HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-02008
J'
~
J ';~
I
i
!
I
I
J ,
/
,
..
~
"
I,;
I'~
L'~, !
"I'
"
.I,,'rt...
' " ,.~ '
" It"
')
,
,
"
"".
,,;V.
.1.'
,
;1
.'
:,!
,:t
,
0'1'
,
,
<
~~
~
~~ . 3
c..C'i ... e
... . I "
zc.. .... ~.. ~ ~ ~ ~ !
0 ..... I
~ ~. ~ .~ f:ji ,.l ~ . . ~fl~
...
~8 ~.... ~~ ~ t:: ~ f~; ~
<tl .
. ..... !Jl U ~
ou ..,c.. > 2l 1.. ~ e
~ co
~~ ~ 0 ~
~ 0 ~
as '" ~
I
'" U
'"
~~ .
0
z z
...
.
basis, Over the next three years, Mr, Gastrock visited plaintitl's body shop at Icast thirty
times and reviewcd thc progress, During one of the visits in February 1993 and after
discussions of the project, Mr, Gastrock signed an cstimate to allow Plaintiff to purchase
two fenders and a hood for the vehicle, The project was completed in 1995 and plaintiff
requested payment for the work completed, Defendant refused claiming then that he had
not authorilcd the work. Defendant demanded his vehicle and Plaintiff demanded
payment for the work he had completed which totaled $9,047,12.
Since December I, 1995, plaintiff has storcd defendant's vehicle in an
inside heatcd garagc, Typical storage fees for storage by a garage are ten dollars a day for
outside storage and twenty-two dollars a day for inside storage, 1,434 days have elapsed
and the vehicle has been placed in a heated indoor storage spot for this period, At ten
dollars a day defendant would owe $14,340.00 in storage fees and at twenty-two dollars a
day Defendant would owe $31,548,00 in storage fees,
STATEMENT OFTHE LAW
"Whenever a workman or artisan, by his labor or skill, increases the value of personal
property placed in his possession to be improved he has a lien upon it for his proper
charges until paid. but in o~der to charge a chattel with his lien, the labor for which the
lien is claimed mllst have been done at the request of the owner or under circumstances
from w~ich his assent can be reasonably implied." Associates Fillanciell Services v,
O'Dell, 491 Pa, \, 4, 417 A.2d 604, 606 (\980), citing Meyers v, Bratespiece, 174 Pa,
119,121,34 A, 551, 551 (1896).
vehicle's depreciation, insurance and emotional trauma, Runk filed New Mauer to the
Counterclaim seeking 522,00 per day storage fee for the vehicle,
m. STATEMENT AS TO THE PRINCIPAL ISSUES OF LIABILITY AND
DAMAGES
A. What was the contract? Was it a large scale restoration job or was it
merely a rust patching job?
B, Whether the work performed by Runk was good and workmanlike and
whether the charges Runk seeks to collect from Gastrock fair and reasonable for the work he
performed?
IV, LEGAL ISSUES
A. Undenigned counsel does not believe there are any complicated legal
issues, but rather, mainly factual determinations which must be made the Court,
V. IDENTITY OF WITNESSES
A. Marlin Gastrock
B, Ruth Bennett
C, An expert regarding the value of the vehicle
D. An expert to determine the quality of the work performed by Runk and to
determine whether the charges imposed by Runk are fair and reasonable,
VI. LIST OF EXHIBITS
A. All documents appended to the pleadings of record.
,. Photographs of the car.
2
I
i'
~'!
~l
[',
I:
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certifY that on October 13, 1999, I, Michael A, Scherer, Esquire, of O'Brien,
Baric &. Scherer. did serve the Pretrial Memorandum of Marlin Gastrock. via first class U,S, mall,
postage prepaid, to the parties listed below, as follows:
Joseph 0, Buckley, Esquire
1237 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
i
I
I
,
~d
Michael A. Scherer, Esquire
,
I
I
I
'I
I
I
I
I
,
I
,
.t
I
,
I
1
'I
i
,
PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL
(Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate)
ro THE PIUl'OOtDl'ARY OF C\JoIBERr>>V COUNI'Y
Please list the following case.
(Check one)
for JURY trial at the nl1xt term of civil court.
( X
for trial without a jury.
CAPTlOO OF CASE
(entire caption fl1Jst be stated in full)
(check one)
Civil Action - Law
(X) Appeal fran AIbi tration
LARRY J. RUNK, II,
(Plaintiff)
(other)
*TRIAL IN THIS MATTER WILL BE SCHEDULED
AT THE DIRECTION OF THE COURT.
vs.
The trial list will be called on
and
MARLIN GASTROCK
Trials commence on
(Defendant)
Pretrials will be held on
(Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials. )
(The party listing this case for trial ahall
provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to
all counsel, pursuant to local Rule ~14.1.)
vs.
No. 2008 Civil Term
19 96
Indicate ~he attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe.
MICHAEL A. SCHERER, ESQ., 17 WEST SOUTH STRP.P.'I'. CARLI SLE. PA 17013
Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known,
JOSEPH D. BUC~LEY, ESQ.. 1237 HOLLY PIKE, CARLISLE, PA 17013
This case is ready for trial.
~4:~
MICHAEL A, SCHERER, ESQUIRE
Signed,
Print Name.
Date.
~ ,1'3' 11
Attorney for:
DEfENDANT
-,.. C') ~
~~, ,,",
>::': " ?tt".
I.I~\ (~l: C1' ;):t~
(,)1"'-, :<: . "L.
[J.:', ..:J: )~j
'/;)~ /'.~
l' . co") .,
(,I N J~~
d,,' ',h~
-:!. (.~
.'- ;;;J :~
ii:l:
'Iv $
(;>
LARRY J, RUNK
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v,
NO. 96-2008448 CIVIL
MARLIN GASTROCK
OROER OF COURT
AND NOW, January 21, 1999, the appointment of Teresa McCormack,
Esquire, to the arbitration panel in the above-captioned case Is vacated, and
Maura Quinlan, Esquire, Is appointed In her stead.
By the Court,
P.J,
William Sunday, Esquire ,
Chairman
Court Administrator
:ssg
;':, ,
as ..,
as g
= ... <
e ~ ~ ~
c...:> ... ~
~ _ l::; ...,
~ ~ 2 ?
~ i:Q ::l ~
z ;. OJ
"'-l '" ':::l
ii! - at
i:Q <
:, u
. '
vehicle's depreciation. insurance and emotional trauma. Runk tiled New Maller to the
Counterclaim seeking $22.00 per day storage fee for the vehicle,
III. STATEMENT AS TO THE PRINCIPAL ISSl1ES OF LIABILITY AND
DAMAGES
A. What was the contract'1 Was it a large scale restoration job or was it
merely a rust patching job?
B, Whether the work performed by Runk was good and workmanlike and
whether the charges Runk seeks to collect from Gastrock fair and reasonable for the work he
performed?
IV. LEGAL ISSl1ES
A. Undersigned counsel does not believe there are any complicated legal
issues, but rather, mainly factual determinations which must be made the Court,
V. IDENTITY OF WITNESSES
A. Marlin Gastrock
B Ruth Bennell
C. An expert regarding the value of the vehicle
D An expert to determine the quality of the work pertormed by Runk and to
determine whether the charges imposed by Runk are fair and reasonable.
VI. LIST OF EXHIBITS
A. All documents appended to the pleadings of record.
B. Photographs of the car.
2
VII. SETTLEMENT NEGOTIATIONS
Settlement negotiations have occurred but the parties have not been able to resolve this
case,
O'BRIEN, BARIC & SCHERER
/ ()./J.-''''
~t1~
Michae A, Scherer, EsquIre
10# 61974
17 West South Street
Carlisle, P A 17013
(717) 249-6873
Attorney for Marlin Gastrock
"
1\
'.
iJ; N
F; -" ..
hIt' .. "
(.,',= -3 .i
, !..~ .. ,r
4:" -t-... I'
~J'~r'; ~:j.': I,)~;~
II. ,",.'1
.'1" Vol : '"
i'.'" r I' I ' 11.J
J.. ' ;,.. ' , . ~. 1
, . ;;. ;; 'J
q ) ,1..1..
,') -n ~'i-~ '
.. ('" '
", \ ,J
~i
~I .~Id
i. ~
~~ ! . ~
.... .
.... ~
. . ~
ii II i ~ I p :1
e ,~
~~I;lq
~
Ii' I
~
. .
. '
,NoIIn!'!'j""
'i - ...;
. ','f/'tn, ~/ ;(/'
. /I{' /1 ' .
, ",,/4.1 ,( /i:,' /'
. . Nf/~"'.J
LARRY J. RUNK. II.
PLAINTIFF
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
96-2008
MARLIN GASTROCK.
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NOTICE TO DEFEND
You have been sued in court, If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the
following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint, order and
notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing
with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned
that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against
you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other
claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights
important to you,
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER, OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE. GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL
HELP,
Court Administrator
Fourth Floor
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle. Pennsylvania 17013
(717) 240-6200
Dat.: May..L. 1996
Marcus A. McKnilht. III
Attorney 1.0. No. lS476
Carlisle. Pennsylvania 17013
(717) 149-23S3
LARRY J. RUNK, II,
PLAINTIFF
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
96-2008
MARLIN GASTROCK,
DEFENDANT
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
COMlLAINT FOR BREACH OF CONTRACT
AND NOW, this 29th day of May, 1996, comes the plaintiff, LARRY J. RUNK,II, by
his attorneys, IRWIN. McKNIGHT & HUGHES, and makes the following complaint against
the defendant, MARLIN GASTROCK, as follows:
1.
The plaintiff is Larry ], Runk, II, an adult individual residing at R, 0, #1, Box 484.
Millersburg, Pennsylvania 17062, The plaintiff also conducts a welding and automobile repair
business known as Bill's Welding situate at his home as well as 254 East North Street, Carlisle,
Pennsylvania 17013,
2,
The:defendant is Marlin Gastrock, an adult individual residing at p, 0, Box 1043, Camp
I
Hill, Pennsylvania 17011,
3,
On or about October I, 1993, the defendant, Marlin Gastrock, requested that the plaintiff
repair and completely restore the body damage on a 1976 Ford Lincoln Mark IV automobile,
4,
The plaintiff, Larry Runk, agreed to restore said automobile of the defendant, Marlin
Gastrock, except for the vinyl top which needed to be separately restored or replaced by a
specialist. The panies agreed that the plaintiff was to be paid for his ti..te and material required to
restore the automobile and place it in good operational order.
5,
At the time the said automobile was given to the plaintiff, it was severely corroded by rust
at many locations, The plaintiff' agreed to restore the automobile after work and on weekends and
requested that the defendant provide funds for the project as the work was performed.
6,
Despite repeated requests by the plaintiff the defendant refused to provide ongoing funds
for the restoration of the automobile,
7.
The plaintiff was able to complete the restoration of the defendant's automobile ill March
of 1996, The plaintiff has incurred substantial costs which are itemized and are marked as
EMibits A and 8 and are made a part of this complaint,
Exhibit "A"
EMibit "8"
TOTAL
$5,607,86
$3.439,26
$9,047,12
8,
The plaintiff has offered to return the completed automobile upon payment of the
outstanding bills but the defendant has refused to tender any payment.
9.
The plaintiff has been storing the restored automobile of the plaintiff at his home or place
of business since March 19, 1996, The plaintiff is entitled to payment of storage charges at the
rate of$22,00 per day while the defendant pays the outstanding bills and picks up his automobile,
10,
The defendant's failure to pay the plaintiff for the restoration of this bill is a breach of the
contract reached by the panies and the plaintiff is entitled to payment in full of the outstanding
charges owe~ by the defendant in addition to the storage charges.
11.
In the alternative the plaintiff is entitled to his quantum merit costs and time for the work
perfonned on behalf of the defendant required to restore his automobile.
WHEREFORE, the plaintiff requests for judgment against the defendant in the sum of
Nine Thousand Forty-seven and 12/100 ($9,047.12) Dollars with storage costs from April 11,
1996 and the costs of this action with interest as permitted by law,
Respectfully submitted,
By:
NIGHT & HUGHES
25476
Attorney for the plaintiff,
Larry J. Runic, II
Date: May 29th, 1996
OOC5INIOlCOMPrUNK.BIUlACH.cMPL T
....n He
ep
-H.""
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
.,.. -, A;e.... ....
.... ...... , I'U. n,' I LtlU.... ..".... ...L...... ,..,.. "".. ..11I1.......
L,'J(,' ,I -1(:, ,"W- '\-
..Ju,"_ - ....,..11:1.11I
...."... ., '''.N'
"011II'
D.IICR...TIOH UP RIt"A,n. .HD nlE..LACItMENTB PARTB L"'.O" P"'IH~ 1'01''''''
.n. HUM_,,, "'MOUN' AMOUNT AMOUHT ""OUNt'
\, IL, 911... ':\ \\l~"'\- i:-,\, ,\ ,i. ('I'I.tl-. ",' :r
h.. .
,[,If\ \>.1. "" 'C"lllil.l~, t \,~," i\ ~ NII\.L )J\\(, - -
- -
(J., " I. \ "'+'
K ~, . ~ \~" '.tJ:: - ...... '\I~\~ (~'~ fb~l:
, .- ." < tit." -
- - - - - -
'" k( "M'\... \.:Ito. - ~I~ olJ.D",~ \Y\illl:-\'L.Q'd
..) or-
- - -
~'N\~ v-. "..KIt'.:. \: \)(j II\IL \(j~ ~ - - 1-- - -
'\-' \. ~.- ~,~ Uv';'1:. ~~\,.. ,.-\:.\, l"t'll"~(.II'k \I~ \\'l:.~
- , --
- ~ tx.oc- Aro .:.c \11 ,"'.,.
'J "flPIQ. 1\'
D. ~~~,~ ,-,,'1:<,1, u,'''1''!M~', I-Ifll"'-"...... 11~"V ........ ..-
k ,-,. ;. \111..' ,I \<..1: 'C'\I'<- . \(1"'" 8\\") l,)\".d, r: I',C" - - - -
-\-u ~~\,R. ~~ ~ \I ;v\ \ "",~,\,r- ~ N~i...~ -- -
-- - - >-- --
- -
"\ \..~<..- ~~AII<. ~ ~\"'\' h .. P.l..lj",,-- '::)\..l,.c:, '-
- - - -
Cl, ~ w.~v ~I\\-) ~I\t.-€..\.. ,\>.Q.'O . ~\\'..J\'.h ~ ptlrou. _I
.:~~I~ 1--
- -
0. tm.l.t \-~tl~, l. ~t-ol\>l.., ~ \?(,tv!:U, \-\,y,1')
- - ~
'\)Qjl ~) \;,1. \l'~l\J- , \' tll^t. .. I-tl\~\i r..\~\\\ \
" - - -
\..J 11.,',...-,.'" mk\ ~~",rY'<.,ot'^'I'"' .h.)",~t", -
.. I \
\ t_'d':/""~~": ~.~\.,~ v"',", /;:'Ir ..,<..1,-\ k~j ,
\..)i\I'I"...l5l 'W'I'11... \.1", \',,;:, ..~ '1\ll~ N.:'"" . ~:fV-~
~'Jt-._ '{)l-"'f' I.cZ \)\1'\ 'Tt'-j (f1 ~"'-' ) -
:!'- r ~(, <""":.,,,,,,,-1/.
-
\0 i1~\It. h.... K. i/..,;\- \,I\Il'<' ,.r+,,1.fl1 \1~.f\r:QA (e'" I-'l I- .- -
\ \, ~\Yld Q..~, \ \1I\f~tQ " b~h'\l-"Ii.. I, \-Ic
~ 'K\(
INSUUD 'AYS I I~S. co. PAYS .. O. N._ TOTALS
INS. CHICIt PAVAILI 10 t..
~'"lr;. ""ii' ....~ .. ..< ..,...... ..~ ~... "' ..... .~dlll...1 ..." ., I.h. wI.e...
.., ,:1, .. ':t: ..,11I h. .. ...,1.". All., .,', ..., .t....~. ..., ."'. .,.h.~
.. .. ~. .., III "''lI.,.4 .... .,. ... ",I"..... III' I....,' ... .. "...... 1112 "IWIC'
'~ .." ........ ., ,..... ....... ~' '.1. .... ...... ~It.. .,. ... ...,..,"" ..
t .......... M',,".' .It. AM ...... ... ... ..,.. '1. ....., .,. ..,.... ... ..\tl'" -
nol.\.' eH.'.
Ut, WADI IV - TOT"L 0'
IITI"""
Ii........"..... _All. I_ _..... ........... tire.................... -.......--
II.NID
DAt'
......, He
OP
-M.n-e
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
..... I a;-.... ..,.
..... .. ..... F n.. I..'...... ."..... .......... ta...... -
............
iii'iiiiii.. ..JU'"'' u....n~.. PHa,..
H.....
Dlecll...T.ON OP ".",.Ins ONO nEPLACEMENTS PAnTS La.a.. ""IHY 'tOY,,\.
-". HUM.." AMOUNT "MOUNT AMOUN' ""OU,"
) ,
\ 1., \ ' ," .' Y.9\;\ .'. ... \'~ I\\\. R.- ~~ ' W'lI'llL " toH,(
.. 'II \-
~.
\ ':'" 1(-(,\." \' . rt.\~. \,....~ ':,r ,Q ,.,.\\'. ~
t, ',-,' -, ,'IlL -
, " .
\ .J - - -
\I. ~" .l . \i<\,\\ .''\. i'llIa t\ .... , .,,)Yo 9 V In-H HilI'- /"n - -
- - -
\"\\I~ \f\,......\'-.\,,-;.... c... ,',,'. ri. \. t ' \ ~t\'. '- \'110.'+' It ,,-, h i'II"\' ....
il'.1 -~
- - -
I \' I"~ ", \ ' , I.':, ~ (1,'.,-,,,_ Y -'-(.\'I',u.. ,(\Il \~A.\l\..t\l"l. II \It,
, -. -
\.Jq r \; .. I, " \ \\. Ii"}' ,,1\ 'h",'. \- ( 1,'\l-lQ ,-"- II, r('.oD~(lr \,....
- - --
+c- " '......tl. II \'~\-t, I... \')n1t.J\1 .\ 4"""
'1....
, - - - -.-. ..-
'f'\\~(' ", ~\t
, Ili~ -- - - -- f-- - - -- -
HI \ I ...,'ir','jc.. -;'.. 11-,,'<- 11 "'q:' CC ",.L"l
-- I'"'' A. ,
- - ; -.-....
0~,1"'\ .. ~~\J_ w,li\"!.t!.\~-:' 1,,- "" - . --' A~
. ~-
-' 'J
<,', - \~ 1 i"l '.....'A\',-\\UN \1;.,1-1, (:h lOb
- ",'" ~ a.>
-
nIl", Iv v- \, ,,-;r \<. {1..oI'.1 "'i:~,., \ .~,.I \.,.0 \r I Al'Itll/o.q t
, - - -
I '\~~,J ',\\~*v,..".3';., W'.\\\'.I'('~ ' 'v"",I", (_ -r, r"'\l' ,. r \-,., \ I-
, -
, \~~.) . ",H"" T~ \ ' \\,l.. ' . ( \-,
, .. \ , . I' 1..\(1,'1('
, ,
-
"';'~:1l)~
-:Oil -f'\ -
1II1
------... '-
'S (,U1,1-<.:,
INIUIID 'AYS , ,JS. co. '^ YS I. O. No_ 'O'ALS
INL CHICle '^ Y AILI to ...
::;:41:;' ..t1..".~..4 .. ... ,........ ,.4 4... .., ..... .4411I..., ..... .. r.~.. f-.
.. ..., ''''''N ~ ..,ll ... !Me. ,..,..4. All" ..,. III.. 11.,t.~. I., ..... ..,.h.. wile...
..,.. . .... ~ ....r... ,1Nt I" H' ..Ie...' .. Il,d 1.....11... .. ,....... Ih~ ''''fle.
I~~ .... ..,....... ~ ...... ....... ~I '"l. Ill' ...... ,rllU I"~ .._ ,""IlI,..1f ... - -
t .......... .....1.... .t,. All ...,"'" .. ..rt. ... I.~, I"~ ...,..... ... ..~l." nOIA.' CH.'.
m. WADI n to'Al 0'
IS""A"
........".......AII. 1. _........... It.... .............,...,.".. -...........
UNID
DA"
"
"
Exhibit "8"
lNt.n H.
\ ..).
. .
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
,HI""
.... tv\. , (." - I A;G"'" ....
. . ~\I'Ln
.............. .~ '9, .... I Lie...... ..II.... ........... I..'.. ..... ""'AL ....
\"l~ca t.J '" Mtr..4-
_N.UII'. .t' ..JUUUI ,......C1'.. ........
MOM'
= -
D.~AI'TlOH .. nE'AInIl .ND REPLACE"'!!NT" PAnTII LA"O" ""IN" YOT"',-
.....
HUM.." AJl40UNT A"OUNT AMOUNT AMOUNY
K\ C.l Rv\. I VDn" - 4-\ ~f<..,
\ ~~\.lp.."
r......".. Opal) .... \ <It.," \- Tll. r ~ -
'\'I\ \ Nt\tJc;J.. -- - - - - -- -
.. q~Wl".>.
.. - - - - -
\ , - . -. \ k. UI<" .
" - - -
~J.\ ........ l1. ,\~~M..'T(. "\- \'Q.Q --1 C{ l, III 15.
'f ~ .~ '-
:5S ~ -- - ~ Q-
c., \.. WIn. if'} ~"""\":>T\
-- ...,-~ .,-
.....-..> t:h .ll\ A- In'
- I- - - -- -
, _t:t.\Q.. f-\ mil \ \ ill.
- - - -
c.y\u, ~\, f:>l'\il'v\ L, Ir~: ~
- - -
~-A:a ).. ~~. ~l'v(oQ u.. I {It'
\ "'itl, ~~1."1. "'"dlll'",,4- \Q ~( -
~
V 'N'$tR..\~ 1::6 (.X.:. -
1~ ~A\-; c ~ ~\.l .~ .~\~;- Il. 'U
IK. \ -
-li1r c: 0 t" c ~ 'f..(
-
~ ~~".), "unr~~""" 11..1 ""lL
\~ 9\N~ \,\f\f~ Q I .,0 '""
, ~Cl X ~\~ 0\ Ie
IHSUIID 'AYS , IHS. co. 'A YI I. O. N.__ TOTALS -( br-- ,.
INS. CHIC~ 'AYAILllO . t.. r.. ~ "',/' ~
l::.1 l- ~.. """"', ...04..... ,.....-.. ..4 4... .., ..... .4dlllm' ....... ,.~.. ,a -
~ ...., "..1,:;;1.' ,., ~ .." II.. ..... tflll,.I. An" ..." lIu .1.",,,. '"' ."., lu.h"~ Wile...
.. ...... .'.....11 .. .r. .. .....,... .... Ite .., ..14... 1M II,.. I.....tl.., .. ,...,.,. Ih~ '''TlC.
~~1f:::.~I"h1 ..-....... ... ....... ...... T' 1111. Ill. ....,. ',lu, 't. ..t ''''''.'''''.. ..
..: ... ........... ...,. All ...,.t ... II ..". .... I.Mr .'. .."rut .." .. I." -
"0...... e...',
1ST. WADI rt TOTAlO'
IS""'AU
'~.'n..", ....... 1.......,....... ...... 1M ........................ -........... -
o
SI.HID
DAti
..t." N.
~ ...1.
.HI.....
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
V)~l f~ to ,"\
....... . '01 ...:-.... ..n
.,UI ., eAII ,....." "'. L...... Mn....... 1...''''''.... .......,.,.....
I...."...." ...."'.u. I~.".,"O. ~~....
NO'"
D..CIlIPTION .r nEPA,n. .... REPLACEMENT. PAnT. LA.a.. PAINT
art. TO'Al.
HU....... AMOUN!' ANOUN' ANOUH!' AMOUNt
a~j \&:. '''''"
~ ~\ ~\~I- ~ ill.
- - ~
&:....,'~.lt:\ \,~.D .-k & -
- - -
~ Mlfo.ii ~ i=1 LTfL"':> ...1S ~Q!,.
J ~Q"!li"J c::\\I ,.~ \<;( 11'\1.
\ l'",\- , floM~ ..(\\ \ -
-3 I~
C_ - . --
<' ".... 1\-", ~ b:
- --,.~ ..-
11 ~\~ . \
. l,bD<. I~
J. (').\<; I ....t-". . ,,\ - f-- - - --
A h,-
..
~ ..
~Uf'{> 1~4 fd:>
- f.- .-
\" ~A \ dr ~ 'lil'-A t\AT '. .~~
~ ~~\~ ~AJksL"VI\l'.J'>~")~~
- - -
I I..., M ;1/1.. ,,- 4-~:'" +r-. \ ,-<I l\ .. ::}.')~ ~ ~ -
. --
~\~I~ \\Cf ry)
~) ~\~ ~j'.!qE: '. ).~6
~ ~-Iq-~ ~O 4::l \-"iG 't-')Hl ~O't~ -
\UJ'm,.. 9F\11) \I'J EA\ - )..+~ ~~)FA~ 'I"" -
-- r...,
I B~'
INIUllO ,...YS I INS. CO. 'MS R. O. N._ TOTALS <.0
INS. CHICK 'AY...IU '0 - lA' m"I.,w ....J ( ISg- 06
'~~ C- ~.. """"', ~..~.. ,.. I........ ..~ ~....., .-. ,ddlll"" ...10 .. I.~..
. ~ "'., '"'h~. .., ~ ...11 h. ..." ....1.4, All.. ...11 ~.. "..1,4, .., ...... ".....,. Wile...
......-:-.. .......~ "..." ......f.' ..... ". ..1 ...ld.,,1 '" 11111 1...."1... ... ,...rn Ih~ "ule.
, ~....tt ..1....... "" ._1. ..... r' t~l. .11I II",,' _due "1 .., ...,..t.... I'
~. .......~I... .....,.... ..t,. All ...t.. ... .. ..rt. .".. 111M. .r. ......". '"" ..~I... -
no...... c...',
UJ, 1.1...01 IY - 'O'ALO' ~ l4~~ ~,
III1"A1I
''''''...11.. ft. "ill. ,........ ................ 1M..................... -...........
2C>
h
S16NIO
_MI'
VERIFJCATION
The foregoing Complaint is based upon information which has been gathered by my
counsel and myself in the preparation of this document, The language of the document may in
part be the language of my counsel and not my own. I have read the statements made in this
document and to the extent that they are based upon information which I have given to my
counsel, they are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. To the
extent that the contents of the statements are that of counsel, I have relied upon counsel in making
this verification, I understand that false statements herein made are subject to the penalties of 18
Pa,C.S,A, Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities,
~
Date: May 1., . 1996
, ,
I, Marcus A. McKnight, III, Esquire, hereby certify that on this date a true and correct
copy of this Complaint, was served by fir$t class United States mail, postage paid in Carlisle,
PeMsylvania 17013, upon the following:
Marlin Gastrock
P. 0, Box 1043
Camp Hill, Pennsylvania 17011
Arthur T, McDermott, Esquire
SO East High Street
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013
By:
Dated: lune 6, 1996
LARRY J. RUNK, 11,_
Plaintiff
In Thu Court of Conunlln Pleaa of
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
)
)
)
)
) I!/
)
)
CUUlhul'Lalld County. Pennsylvania
No '.-36_..___2QQ~L
1996
,WI'II
./
t~e do solemnly, swear (or afflrm) thnt 1m will support, obey and defend
the Constitution of the Unlted States 1I11l1 th" Clllllltitutlon of this ComMon-
wealth and that we wlll ,l1scharge the ,tutll'S of our off tee with fidelity.
,1"'/.,4/ /
_.Lfd'tf""4t: _~. ~ < ,
I '<
_-:~ill;:.""'" .
. )J. /~ .. '::> .
, IZ!!!:"oIt,~Z)_ .c::;;?~('~--<.~
AllARD
We, the unders 19ned arbitrators, hav tug been duly appo lnted uud sworn
(or affirmed), make the following a..ard:
(Note: If dRmages for delay lire "wantu,l, they shall be
separately stated.)
We find in favor of Plaintif!_f1nd aqainst the Defel1dant in the amount of
510743.12. wJ..tl1..J.nUrest from Maill_2.L,..1!t!t9..L and __.___.
We find in favor of Plaintiff and aqain,st the Defendant Qn Defendant's
Counterclaim.
Maura Quinlan, Esquire
applicable. )
with respect to the amount of the
Arbitrator, d lssents" (Insert name if award.
Date of lIear ing: March 5, 1999
~ ~.K ,y',' c:.I:",~4./
! <,.. ~'/ c.t<;~irman
! (I/l0, .rrl '
. )- / ..)..:> . .
~ Jlr.:!.,. .c /) _-~. ,~~#-"'-'
NonCE Oil ENTRY OF AWARD
Date of Award: March 5, 1999
Now, the S (L day of '/It", C ,^..' , 19 -) -i . at '1:/ / , f' .11., the above
award was entered upon the ,locket and notice ther-eof glve" byinall to the
parties or thelr attorneys.
Arbitrators' compensatton to be
paid upon appeal:
$ ,Jqf), i.n)
)j'
"
LL~.h.1,",) A'- ~~1::=...:...
--- F-tqthonotary
, ..
By: ~~LL.._7J,'-((L'~:.._
, rJeputy
I ( -
. ~L.ll,-~.-
'(' ( ,
/.. U< 0,""", (~c
C 'V I ,l,. ."i.;.., / lit.
/)' P
/htt....t.4... LV/,..lt,...~.-, .4J/ .
), I
f
t
"-
/1,
'" ~))';1 iJ.(t~.J.... Leo
...
...
(') '..1:'1
,... t...LJ ~ "',
:": ..
--n ,
fill
(;1 " .I 'I
,
'. ,.,;"1
" ' ...~. "
,.
, , /:1
., 1
i :
,-
c' , ,
, , , ,
,
.-J .~!
COM_NWIAUH or "NNlnYANIA
.--...-COUI,-o,.cOiilMON 'IIA'
NOTICI OF APPIAL
JI'DICIAL Di.f.'Cl
FROM 10/ II ~.I cl....
DISTRICT JUSTICI JUDGMINT
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COMMON 'LIAS No.
Qt- - .,).'OJ CLv<-i r..u-.
NOTlCI 0' APPIAL
Notic. il giwn thot the opptollont hm filed i" the oboy. Court 0' Common PI~u.. un oppt>al from the judgment rendered by the Di,trid Justice Ofl the
do,. and In tho co.. mennanod bel"",
LARRY J. RUNK. II
AIIllmJCll-.;;w.AH,-.."-. - . r
CITY
. rp~U~l:~Nb~~N;~~::~ .-~,~.-- 09-2-0 1
!lIAr! . . "'-'~~ .__._.~-- III' COOl
NAMI 01 AmLLA"'l'IT-- -.--.-.--.--
254 EAST NORTH STREET CARLISLE PA 17013
"'MA"RO#C"-"""'H 18N.r-199.-6....-'.....[rNTHlC.1[61-,;',,;;i,i~ . r~M~.(\)G{I." "'~~c..k. v.. 2 A~lil<?", ~~';;,.,,;...-..---------
~_m -"'00,06"-- "''''' ". r~'~'" ,,'~.. ~"M'".'" ~~:\.o',a~, 'ib:t......
.. ...,;0 ~ ~:~:.::,." .","'" ,..." .~; ~ C,i Z'd:;1l::oo-,. R.CNP ..-
10088.
Thl. Notice of Appeal. when received by the Di.trict Ju.tice, will operate o. 0 '001 (6) m acllon before District Jusllce, he MUST
SUPERSEDEAS to tho judgmeot far possession in this co.e. FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after
filing hiS NOTICE of APPEAL.
...--------u.-.--S;griij"ftj;c (),"p;iJihOf1l11<lry 1)( O"t'll/Iy
U. 'RAi-cIPETO niTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAiNT AND RULE TO FILi
!This seetlon 01 101m to be used ONLY wholl .1ppol/a/1/ WilS DEFENDANT (5'.'0 Pa RCPJP No, 1001(7) In actloll belore District Jus/lce,
IF NOT USED, dotach 'rom c~y 01 notlco 01 appeal 10 be sm",,! upcm ill~)el/e")
PIAICIPI. To Prothonotary
Ent... rvle upon ___~_____________~______~_______
Nll/tlt! <.1/ .11J1.}t'III".1-~J
, appellee(.}, to file 0 camplaint in tN. appeal
(Cammon Plea. No. ___.__.__.___._.______..____.______) within twenty (201 doy. ofter .ervice of rule or .uffer entry of judgment of non '"""'
S'rlf1ulUltJ 01 iJ/JPfJ/farlt Of hIS anom.y 01 aqent
lULl. To .._______.~________
Nllmr)0' iI/.lX'llfW('.)
.. , oppellee(.},
(11 You are notified that a rule i. hereby entered upan you to file a complaint in thl. oppeol witl1in twenty (20) day. afler tho do,. of
service of thia rule UpQn you by personal service or by certified or rE'gistered moil.
12) If you do not file a camplaint within this Ii""" 0 JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(3) Tho do,. 01 ...rv~e of this rule if .ervice woo by moil i. the date of mailing,
,
Datw:
,19_.
,,_ 01-......., '" ~
.IDfC J' J. 1M
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FII,.E COMPLAINT
(ThiS proal 01 SO'VICO MlIS r BE' FILE'D WI f1/1N rEN, /OJ OA YS Afffl/ IIIIIIY III" no/lCO 01 "PPOIlI Chock appllCoblo bO'.s)
COMMONWEALTH 0' PENNSVLYAN'A
COUNTY OF ______~_~-_____._..~...._._.. .._ :..
~~F'IDAVIT:
I t14_lrnby swear or affIrm that I sQrlJed
[J il copy ot the Notice 01 Appeul, Cornm0l1 Plell::> No ____.________ . upon the District Justice desIgnated therein on
((Iale 01 se,vlco) ..._____.____, 19____, [] by p."onai service 0 by (ce,lIfIed) (reglstoredl m.,I, sonde,'.
fftceipt attached ~lerelo, und upon the nppellee. (rJiJfne) ______~_......____.___________. ..______, on
,19_.0 by personul ser....lce [j by (cor'lfled) (registered) mall, sender's r~ceipt attached hereto
[] and lu,ther /hall se,ved tha Rilla to File u Complaint accompanYing tho above NotlceDf Appeal lIpon lha appellee(.) 'I) whom
the Rille was addressed on ______, 19__ 0 by p.r~onal service [] by (certllled) (reglsfered)
mail, sender's roceipt attached herelo
SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME
THIS __.__...___.___DAY OF._______ , 19_
Signature of smant
S/(}na/lJf& 01 0"'1:1111 bulOfH whom ;lff,rliJl.'II WII" mllrJr1
T,II,. o,,,t/,e'/ll
My commis510n ft.llpireS on
,19_,
~
J
~
('
., .f
I
r' .,
'.., J \"
I
-;1
.,)
,.. .~. ) ..
,11 -f' 01-
", ,-,\C
'-_'I \j ~ ,
C
f
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
~<2.u..Nn:_Q!,-,- CY~!.l!=~~~~R. - .__"=~
NOTICE OF JUDGMENT/TRANSCRIPT
DJIIl.,,,.I,,,n
PLAIN TIFF NA~I .M AIIII'" :,,,
~ASTROCK, MARLIN
P,O. BOX 1043
CAMP HILL, PA 17011
L
.J
U.g 0,,1 Ill.,
-1
09-2-01
PAULA P. CORREAL
...,,,.. EAST WING - COURTHOUSE
1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE
CARLISLE, PA
''''ph,,", 1717) 240-6564 17013-0000
VS.
ATTORNEY DEF PRIVATE :
DEFENOANT
!RUNK, LARRY
254 E. NORTH ST
CARLISLE, pA 17013
L
NAME .rHi ADom 6fi
-,
.J
MARCUS A. MCKNIGHT, III
60 W. POMFRET ST.
CARLISLE, PA 17013
Docket No,: CV-0000613-95
Date Flied: 12/05/95
THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT:
Judgment:
~ Judgment was entered for: (Name)
~ Judgment was entered against: (Name)
FOR DEFENDANT
RUNl<. LARRY
GASTROCK. MARLIN
In the amount or $
.00
(Date) 3/18/96
on:
o Damages wiTn58 assessed on:
(Date & Time)
o This case dismissed without prejudice,
o
o
o
o
o Objection to levy has been filed and hearing will be held:
I Date:
L
Amount of Judgment
Judgment Costs
Interest on Judgment
Attorney Fees
$.00
$.00
$.00
$.00
$.00
Possession granted,
Possession granted if money judgment is no!
satisfied withIn thirty days,
Possession not granted.
Levy is stayed for _ days or 0 generally stayed,
TOTAL
r
ANY PARTY H~S THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN, 30 DAYS O~ THE D~TE OF J~GMENT BY FI,LING A NOTICE
OF APPEAL WI~H THE PROTHONOTARYfplERK OF TH~-'=O!JRT)'F COMMc?N PLEAS. CIVIL r;>IVISION,
.~-'- ,,;.'/, Date __~.i1' i-. .L..-.f-' / .(.f, /1-",' ,DlstrlclJuslice
, --" . ... "
I certify that this is a Huo an(fcorrect Q6py of the record or the proceedings containing the judgment.
,,' . .
,. I .'
, ;/ 'J.''; Date ~___----L' ..../ ( ,. ! . ' DisHict Justice
.' \. .
My commlsg,on expires first Monday of January, 2000
SEAL
AUPC J1'19-,
LARRY J. RUNK,II
Plaintilf
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYL VANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
NO. 96-2008 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COllRT
AND NOW, this 1.,rl'day of Augllst. 1999. a pretrial conference in the above matter
is SCHEDULED for Monday, October 18, 1999, at 11:00 a,m, in Chambers of the
undersigned judge, Cumberland County Courthouse. Carlisle, Pennsylvania, Pretrial
memoranda shall be submitted by counsel in accordance with C.C.R.P. 212-4, at least five
days prior to the pretrial conference.
A NONJURY TRIAL in the above matter is SCHEDULED lor Thursday. November
4, 1999, at I :30 p.m., in COllrtroom No. I, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle.
Pennsylvania.
BY THE COURT.
J.
I
Joseph D. Buckley. Esq.
1237 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
Attorney for Plaintiff
c...,..., 1)1.<"-<..i,;" r 3' - 'I ?
r
("
t,'
"
f"'ll" r..;' <I ;,:~:
"" .
FiR',
~(J rll~ :11 t.,;; 'j: Ie
l;Lill" ,
I,'.;
I! ,,;; ~r{
',.'
Ii)
!,
"
,
I
,
','
-
Michael A. Scherer, Esq.
17 West South Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Attorney for Defendant
~I~(
~. 11.'1'
J""'"
Court Administrator
I ,'. ,-'/' I' J
I., ' .,.,...., '-"~ u_ . I ,/, '/
- I " 'J" , )!~.J
:rc
'I,
(' I
,.-.
'..
....
it",
i;'
11"
I):
i:',
\,
'f'.
I'
\1\'
L:_l
I
I.
1.I
i':
..
,.-
-..
, I
. ,
..")
l,,';
c.
\.
"
(-..
...,
I ..
~ii !
~ >~Ii
~ f ~~ [
't -~
~
,-. .
,. ,
LARRY J, RUNK,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
lJI.- .J(}oi'
NO.:Jll l.l.",8 CIVIL 1996
v.
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBI'fRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Joseph D, Buckley, Esquire, counsel for the plaintiffs in the above action, respectfully
represents thaI:
I. The above-captioned action is at issue.
2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is $24,000.00,
The claim of the defendant in the action is $13,539.50,
The following attomeys are intcrestcd in the case or are otherwise disqualified to sit as
arbitrators: Marcus A, McKnight, III. William C, Vohs, Arthllr McDermott, and Michael
A. Scherer.
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3)
arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted.
Date: Jr--I.1'+~.J 0 / /y<;1
~esp tfully submitted,
j 'Ii 111"tt,
ph D,'B~~ESqu1e
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, (}(r& dtt 1_., )998, in consid.era~on of the foregoing
L. .~. 'j)' ~ "~)C'.>(t<<-"A, ,J~k
petition,/tY-ti:t"m~~l{ddoESqUire, .. _ ~~~ft!UJJC,
and (/ !l..1.;..{.. ,~x.. -) LL , Esquire, are appointed arbitrators in the above
captioned action as prayed for, ~
PJ.
I.!' ':1'/ ,I~ I
I 1-,:',: rt
( ,:
I)~~ en
iii: !il.)
C'",'
, ',..IJ!',IY
1:'\: , . 'II \.
"
..
~
,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
It is hereby certified that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Petition was
served via first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
Miehael J. Scherer, Esquire
17 W, South Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(Attomey for Defendant)
Date; Stp~~ WfJ<ifP \
Joseph D. u kl
Attomey for Plaintiff
Supreme Court I.D. #38444
1237 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-2448
.
'"
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certifY that a true and correct copy of the foregoing
EntrylWithdraw of Appearance was duly ~erved via United States First Class Mail,
postage prepaid upon the Ibllowing person:
William C, Vohs, Esquire
Hanft & Vohs
11 West Pomfret Street, Suite 2
Carlisle, P A 170 \3
Dale: i/- t -97
, ,
I
~ r- .~
~ l-
.'
I~ M 'I....
~"39
.~ :c " .J.
0- ~-.~
<:;;, \D ~...
k ''"If)
I r',~ ~,;
~" :;> , l)(il
~ ~ .. f.\ a..
5
~ ~ u
,
>- ...,
u,; E
~ ''J
LU(l N '-
t.J ..... .). .
r' ,,: ,,1t.
f:;'j' '. 'j ;_:~
']-" . l.L {,:.::
"
f-' <.. U') ...J
:;"-:-;
.':' . .,>
... I,ll ! t~ ~:'11>;
!' 'i -t!
'I .... ..',l
C. ,- ::3
<'1' U
'.. <(
01-<
~~
'>'l
i~ ~ '"
tn ~
~: ''-' '" iil
E~ 1'-' ::t
..J I-< F,-o 0;:; t;; ~
",rz I-< H >~~~ ~!
>- ... ~
~~ .
I-< ..... 8~
u ~~ ~'" eII~g~l~ct
0>: "" ~.... ~
I:> G . .., ~g
0 '>:c:: I-~~~ "'E'
~~ 0 .... g u'o ~ E't:.
'" . III
, .., ~. t, .e Z I:; t:. ~
<0 0., . z~ ')0< C C In u:
en >< > .1
'7 ~ ~ ... (l. ::t ~
g ~ r,-,
.:l1:J '" -
-
..;. '..
.
~
..
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
LARRY J. RUNK, II,
Plaintiff
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
NO. 96-2008
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
REPLY TO NEW MATTER
AND NOW, comes the Defendant, Marlin Gastrock, by and
through his attorneys, Hanft & Vohs, and replies to Plaintiff's
New Matter as follows I
22. The averments of paragraph 22 of Plaintiff's New Matter
are concluslons of law to which no answer is required.
23. The averments of paragraph 22 of Plaintiff's New Matter
are conclusions of law to which no answer is required.
24. The averments of Paragraph 22 of Plaintiff's New Matter
are conclusions of law to which no answer is required.
25. Denied. Defendant is wlthout information or belief
that the Plaintiff has had the automobile inside storage since
April 11, 1996. Defendant has specifically requested the return
of his vehicle and confirmation that Plaintiff was still in
possession of Defendant's vehicle, however, Plaintiff has refused
!
to provide such confirmation. In addition, Defendant denies that
Plaintiff is entitled to any storage fee or any f.urther payment
for the repair requested by Defendant.
,,~oca"""Vl<tW
-'
.
.
WHBRBFORB, Defendant demands judgment against Plaintiff.
Respectfully submitted,
HANFT , VORS
t UL~-
iam C. Vo s, Esqu re
Attorney ID No. 65208
11 West Pomfret Street, Suite 2
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-5373
, '
~"..
.
VBRIPICATION
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Reply to
New Matter are true and correct to the best of my knowledge,
information and belief. This Verification is made only as to the
factual averments contained herein, and not to legal conclusions
and averments authored by counsel in his capacity as attorney for
the party or parties hereto I understand that false statements
herein are made subject to ~he penalties of 18 Pa. C. S. Section
4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
~~~;~
in Gastroc
L~Y*
'"
U{ '-0'
11--'
, ,.
~I' I, ,. _.
, .
I.:' ,
I' ~ .
~.
II t-
(.' (,' ,\.'
;t i!! ~ld
~
~~
i~~ .
,...
,... . i ~ I i Hl
. i ;h
!
~~~I ~ J i !~
.t; gl ~ ~ i t; ~ ~~
If ~~ ~~~ . . ..
; :l ~
. i~ 'i I ~
B 0 ~ t~
==
I!!l ~
. ..
. .
L....W U~'Ir:l:'l
of' // " 'Z/' , ~. 'J/:'. /.
. 4"~'1I, . I;'., /I"~?,(~ a.: ", "~~?"e.J
. ,
Runk, II, at his home in Perry County, Pennsylvania, and not at Bill's Welding located in Carlisle,
Pennsylvania,
15.
The averments of paragraph fifteen (15) of the New Matter are conclusions of law to
which no answer is required.
ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM
AND NOW, this 7th day of August, 1997, comes the plaintiff, Larry J. Runk, II, and
makes the following Answer to the Counterclaim of the defendant:
16,
The averments of paragraph one (1) through sixteen (16) of the Complaint and the
Answer to New Matter are incorporated herein and made a part of this Answer,
17.
The averments of paragraph seventeen ( 17) are admitted in part and denied in part, It is
admitted that on or about October I, 1993, the parties agreed that Mr. Runk would perform work
on behalf ofMr, Gastrock. It is denied that only a few rust spots were to be repaired. On the
contrary, the defendant requested that his automobile be restored which required significant body
restoration as well as new parts and mechanical repairs. The defendant would be billed on a time
and material rasis.
2
18,
The averments of paragraph eighteen (18) are admitted in part and denied in part, It is
admitted that Mr, Runk did the work at his home as he was able, Mr, Runk did attempt to secure
funds from Mr, Gastrock as the work progressed. It is denied that Mr, Gastrock ever provided
progress payments to Mr, Runk as the work progressed,
19,
The averments of fact contained in paragraph nineteen (19) of the Counterclaim are
specifically denied, On the contrary, when the automobile was delivered to the plaintiff by the
defendant, it was not inspected, The plaintiff never agreed to have the automobile inspected and
that is not-part of their agreement.
20,
The averments offact contained in paragraph twenty (20) of the Complaint are denied. It
is specifically denied that the defendant paid in excess of One Thousand Two Hundred and no/100
($1,200,00) Dollars and proofthereot'is demanded, It is specifically denied that the defendant
ever paid the plaintiff in cash for the plaintift's work on his automobile,
21.
The averments offact contained in paragraph twenty-one (21) of this Counterclaim are
denied. On the contrary, the defendant is not entitled to the relief he seeks in this Court because
this Court I has no authority to return an automobile, The defendant is not entitled by law to
damages for emotional distress. The value of the automobile restored by the plaintiff is far less
than Ten Thousand and no/100 ($10,000,00) Dollars. The averments off act are therefore denied,
3
WHEREFORE, the plaintiff demands judgment against the defendant in a sum in excess
of Twenty Two Thousand and no/100 (522,000.00) Dollars and the di$missal of this
Counterclaim
NEW MATTER
AND NOW, this 7th day of August, 1997, the plaintiff names the following defenses by
New Matter,
22,
The defendant is estopped from the applicable statute of limitations and by his lack of
activity by law from bringing this action,
23,
The defendant fails to state any basis upon which a claim can be made within this
Counterclaim,
24,
The defendant is barred by bringing this action at law from the relief suggested, No action
for emotional distress or specific performance is permitted by law under the facts of this case or
the forum ehosen by the defendant.
4
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
LARRY J. RUNK, II,
Plaintiff
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
V.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
NO. 96-2008
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
IHPORTAN'l' NOTICB
TO. l,arry J. Runk, II
c/o Marcus A. McKnight, Esquire
Irwin, McKnight & Hughes
60 West Pomfret Street
Carllsle, PA 17013
DATE OF NOTICE. July 30, 1997
YOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAUSE YOU HAVE FAILED TO TAKE ACTION
REQUIRED OF YOU IN THIS CASE. UNLESS YOU ACT WITHIN TEN (10)
DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE, A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED
AGAINST YOU WITHOUT A HEARING, AND YOU MAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR
OTHER IMPORTANT RIGHTS. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR
LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD
ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT
WHERE YOU CAN GET HELP.
Court Administrator
Cumberland County Courthouse
Fourth Floor
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
BY.
v4\ ~..
William C. Vohs, Esquire
Attorney 10 No. 65208
11 W. Pomfret Street, Suite 2
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-5373
~ ,... 4-
I'~ LI.
ll",. '(.:.1
C.J ~ "
lr" .
~~~ (I.
"
{. , ".)
W: I.' ('; "
,
n:~:. :;::1 :-1{ Ll
....1 le,-
1- .-, "
ll. r- ,',:')
0 cP U
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
,
I
I
I
I
,
I
CIVIL ACTION - LAW ,
NO. 96-2008
LARRY J. RUNK, II,
Plaintiff
V.
IMPORTANT IIOTICE
TOI Larry J. Runk, II
R. D. * 1, Box 484
Millersburg, PA 17062
DATE OF NOTICEI July 30, 1997
YOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAUSE YOU HAVE FAILED TO TAKE ACTION
REQUIRED OF YOU IN THIS CASE. UNLESS YOU ACT WITHIN TEN (10)
DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE, A JUDGMeNT MAY BE ENTERED
AGAINST YOU WITHOUT A HEARING, AND YOU MAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR
OTHER IMPORTANT RIGHTS. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR
LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD
ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT
WHERE YOU CAN GET HELP.
Court Administrator
Cumberland County Courthouse
Fourth Floor
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
BY'
wJv ~jlr
William C. Vohs, Esquire
Attorney 10 No. 65208
11 W. Pomfret Street, Suite 2
Carllsle, PA 17013
(717) 249-5373
:>-> .... 'I'" --
rr, v: ,..
i~~: ~. ".
.. .'-).
lUl..,'.~ ~~~ ..;';"
( j"
.~-I
l". L.\..
, .
,;'
( ,
C':: C"l
"-j
~ c. I ' , ~i I 'j
(L. . .....
f'. ='j ,!_lk
,.
IJ. r- '~J
Q 0' U
,'-I I
l,
I'
"
,
I"
c.,<
~~
~~ ~
~~ ~ OJ
~ tn I!!
. 'i: ::z: Ii!
~~ ... H ~ O;!; ...,
.~ H >~i~ ~~
.
... ..... i~ 2
~u u ~.~ "'i~<f'I~~
00
8 c>:~ ~ t- ~ OJ r::-
i N ... La. ~ r::- -
. rtl c,,~ Z~ ~ E~
~ ~..... .
~~ ~~ > z2l ~ cc " >- ..
H % :il
~ ~ ;!;
::
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
LARRY J. RUNK, II,
plaintiff
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
V.
.
.
.
.
.
.
.
NO. 96-2008
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
ANSWER AND NEW MATTBR
AND NOW, comes the Defendant, Marlin Gastrock, by and
through his attorneys, Hanft & Vohs, and files the following
Answer and New Matter and in support thereof avers the following.
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3. Denied. Defendant's only request was that Plaintiff
paint the body of the automobile white and repair the rust spots
on the body of the automobile, Several months after agreeing to
do so, Plaintiff stated he felt the vinyl top should also be
replaced with a new white vinyl top for a better appearance.
Plaintiff never. mentioned a specialist, and implied he would take
care of replacing the top and was merely seeking permission or
additional funds to do so.
4. Denied as stated. Further, the Defendant did pay the
Plaintiff for the work and materials as demanded.
!
5. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted
that the automobile was corroded and that the Defendant requested
that the Plaintiff paint it and repair any rust spots on the body
a.~~..
of the automobile. It ls denied that the Plaintiff was to
completely restore the automobile. The automobile was released
to the care of the Plaintiff for a normal repainting and removal
of rust spots.
6. Denied. Despite the Defendant's supplying payment in
excess of $1,200.00, the agreed upon services were not performed,
nor was the automobile delivered to the Defendant.
7. Denied. That part of the allegations of Paragraph 7 to
the effect that repairs were made thereto etc., is herewith
denied. On the contrary, the Defendant avers that after
reasonable investigatlon, he has no knowledge or information
sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the facts averred
in said paragraph. Therefore, the Defendant denies the averments
of the aforesaid paragraph of the Complaint and, if material,
demands proof thereof on the tr.ial of this cause. The averments
contained in paragraph 7 concerning the costs incurred by the
Plaintiff are denied as stated. On the contrary, the Defendant
avers that a fair and reasonable price in the ordinary market for
said material, work, and repairs is $1,200.00.
8. Denied. Despite the lack of ascertainable physical
progress on the automobile, the Defendant supplied payment of
over $1,200.00 to the Plainti.ff.
9. Denied. The Defendant is without knowledge or
informatipn sufficient to form a bellef as to the truth of the
averments set forth in Paragraph 9 and the averments are
therefore denied.
~urthermore, the Plaintiff has refused to
'~~lOII
,
~
I,
I
allow the Defendant to pick up or even inspect the automobile.
10. The averments contained in Paragraph 10 of Plaintiff's
Complaint are conclusions of law to which no answer is required.
11. The averments contained In Paragraph 11 of Plaintiff's
Complaint are conclusions of law to which no answer is required.
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Marlin Gastrock, demands judgment
against Plaintiff, Larry J. Runk, II.
NBW MATTER
12. Plaintiff's claim is barred by the applicable Statute
of Frauds.
13. Plaintiff's Complaint alleges that Plaintiff is an
adult individual trading and doing business as Bill's Welding.
14. Bill's welding is not a registered fictitious name in
the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
15. Plaintiff's failure to register the fictitious name
violates 54 Pa. C.S.A. Section 331. As such, Plaintiff lacks the
capacity to 'to maintain any action in any tribunal of this
Commonwea 1 th . .
WHEREFORE, Defendant demands judgment against Plaintiff.
COUll'l'ERCLAIM
16. The responses in Paragraphs 1 through 11 and the
averments contained in Paragraphs 12 through 15 of answering
i
Defendant's Answer and New Matter are incorporated by reference
as if set forth herein.
1,'(.'UIJrnWl(iI\I11UlC~NN
17. On or about October 1, 1993, Oefendant, Marlin
aaetrock, formed an agreement with Plaintiff, Larry Runk, wherein
the Plaintiff agreed to paint the body of the Defendant's
automobile white and repair the rust spots on the body of the
automobile.
18. The parties agreed that the Plalntiff would perform
work on the automobile after work and on weekends. The parties
further agreed that the Defendant would provlde funding to the
Plaintiff as work on the automoblle progressed.
19. Despite the terms of the agreement between the
Defendant and the Plalntlff, Plaintiff took it upon himself to
perform work on the automobile above and beyond the nature of the
agreed upon services.
20. Despite the fact that the Defendant tendered payments
by cash and check in excess of $1,200.00, the Plaintiff has
refused to deliver the Defendant's automobile.
21. The Plaintiff's failure to deliver the vehicle to the
Defendant after receiving payment for the agreed upon services is
a breach of the contract formed by the parties. As such, the
Defendant is entitled to the return of hls automobile in normal
operating condition and total costs of $13,539,50. This figure
represents depreciation of the automoblle's value while In the
poesession of the Plaintiff, amounts already paid to the
Plaintiiff, insurance and registration costs, costs incurred while
attempting to ascertain the Plaintiff's progress on the
automobile, and emotional trauma suffered by the Defendant as a
1,\I..'lJDnW~'II\AHIWllaNN
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
LARRY J. RUNK, II, I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff I
I
V. I NO. 96-2008
I
MARLIN GASTROCK, I
Defendant I
CBRTIPlCATB OP SIRVICK
AND NOW, this ~ day of
~ l 1)1
, 1997, I, William
C. Vohs, Esquire, hereby certify that the following persons were
served with a true and correct copy of the Answer And New Matter
by United Statee Mail, First Claee, poetage Prepaid, addreeeed as
follows I
Marcus A. McKnight, III, Eequire
IRWIN McKNIGHT & HUGHES
West Pomfret Profeesional Building
60 W. Pomfret Street
Carliele, PA 17013-3222
HANFT . VOHS
.~.~."i~
Attorney 10 No. 65208
11 West Pomfret Street, Suite 2
Carliele, PA 17013
(717)249-5373
---.-
LARRY J. RUNK, II I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
vs. I 96-2008
I
MARLIN GASTROCK, I
Defendant I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
ANSWER TO PI~INTIPP'S COMPLAINT WITH DBPBNDANT'S NBW MATTBR
COMES NOW, Defendant, Marlin Gastrock, by and through his
attorney, Arthur T. McDermott, and files his answer, new matter
and a counterclaim, and states as follows I
1. Admi t ted .
2 . Admit ted .
3.
Admi t ted in par.t and denied in part.
It is admitted
that Defendant requested the Plaintiff to repaint his 1976
Lincoln Mark IV automobile.
It is denied that Defendant
requested Plaintiff to "repair and completely restore" the
vehicle.
4. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is denied that
anything was to be done to the automobile except to repaint it.
5. It is denied that the autmobile was "severely" corroded
by rust. Proof is demanded that the plaintiff agreed to restore
the automobile after work and on weekends, and that he requested
the defendant provlde funds for the project as the work was
perform~d.
6. It is denied that plaintiff made such requests and
defendant refused to provide on going funds,
7. It is admitted that plaintiff completed work on the
vehicle in March, 1996, but he refused to return the vehicle to
-~
defendant or even to allow defendant to see it.
It is also
deniud that the itemized costs were reasonable and/or necessary.
8. It is denied that plaintiff offered to return the
automobile.
Defendant had paid plaintif f on several occasions
durinq the work In process and disputed the billinqs.
9. It is denied that plaintiff "stored" the car since
Karch 1996. He has hidden the automobile and refuses to allow
plaintiff to even inspect the automobile.
10. This ls a conclusion of law which requires no response.
11. This is an alternative statement of a cause of action
requirinq no response,
WHEREFORE,
Plaintiff demands
that
the
Complaint
be
dismissed, and that the vehicle be returned to the defendant.
NEW MATTBR
12. On March 18, 1996 this same cause of action was
litiqated before the Honorable District Justice, Paula Correal,
who found in favor of the Defendant and aqainst the plaintiff,
and announced her decision In open court and advised the partie.
they had 30 days to appeal her decision.
12. Plaintiff did not appeal the District Justice's
decision.
,
13.1 The District Justice's decision closes this cas. as
"res judicat".
WHBREFORE, the cale mUlt be d1emissed for lack of
jursidiction over a cale previoully decided in a Court of
competent jurisdiction.
Respectfully Iubmitted,
ARTHUR T. MCDERMOTT , ASSOCIATES
/'/ ----~-~' ) / 0 .
( Ar~::-M;D~~~t't~- ES~ire
50 Bast High Street
Carlllle, PA 17013
(717) 243-7807
,
VBRIPlCA'l'IOM
Arthur T. McDermott, E8quire, being duly affirmed according
to law, depo8e8 and 8aY8 that he i8 the attorney for the
Defendant, that 8aid Defendant could not make the verification to
,
the foregoing Answer to Plaintiff'8 Complaint with Defendant'8
New Matter within a rea80nable period of time, and that the
undersigned attorney has Inv88tigatod the factual allegation8 and
that the fact8 set forth in the An8wer to Plaintiff' s Complaint
with Defendant '8 New Matter are true and correct upon hi8
knowledge information and belief.
<:,~.:~:-,_~~~J_:k~~ _S
Arthur T. McDermott, E8quire
Sworn and 8ub8cribed before me thi8 :2.7/J- day of June, 1996.
~1(li
SHELLY D. SEXTON, NOTARY PUBLIC
CAIll.ISlf BORO, CUUIERWID COUNTY
UY COMUISSION EXPIRES Al'RI~ aI, 1 age
Member, "'nnaylYlllI. Auocllllon of NofIuIH
,!
,
,
~, ,
~,I
~ CJ.' ".
~, (
~ , ,,.
~lJ " ~. ~ ...,
-)~ ;~(
p,:' .~ 1: '.
..: ~ :"'..J
l{\ .,...
(0 ' v>
'9~1.. ,'- '2
';7.
'!'JJ
ti~ t. ' ;.\ ,el-
f, ,
" ,C,' ';
Q (j\ '->
JUDICIAL 01"1.'::'
NOTICI 0' APPIAL
fROM '41"i/f~
DISTRICT JUSTICI JUDGMINT
...
C_NWIALYM o. 'INNlnVANIA
--'(ouiTo. C:OMMONioLIAI
,
CUMHt:KI,^"U COUNTY
Cotli\MON 'LIAS No.
C,, -
qt.. _..1Dol ~,-L ,.u.-.
NOTICE 0' APPEAL
Notice i. given tha, the ~tant hen filed in the above Court of Common Pleas on appeal from the judgment rendered by the District Ju,tke on .~
daM and In the co.. montianod bel"""
NANII 01' AmLWlf
-:T~~:~;:~::~~~~o_:__;;Ol
m___m_ PA ____.!..70J2-_
-.-------.,&1j.;j;ir-,;J~--
,I \ I , JI,
I..ARRY J. RUNK '" HARLIN'dASTll.OCK C
95-0000613 [!iGNAl'"'' 0; A"mANI Olt ....IlOii""-(jO-AGlNi - - .
CV 19 _xe,J:nrn1 /' " ~. _
LT 19____.0_._______ ./ L '----
Thi. blo<k will be ~dmciNLY.~.~t.;i;;;.;iali.;;;i;r~q~i;~do-~nJ~; Pa.-R.cI'.J.P No. /I appcllant-,;:,;;~CLAIMANi(see.Pa, Ri5p,J.P, No,
l008B.
Thi. Notie. af App"al, wh.n rec.i.....d by 1M Oi.lricl Ju.lie., will op.ral. a. a 1001 (6)1n action before District Justice, he MUST
SUPERSl:DEAS 10 Iho judgment fa< po.....ion in thi. coo.. FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after
. __,_"_.m' filing hiS NOnCE of APPE:AL.
- SiiJ,iLiii.i,i; '('irAoiiiOrJiii;-y or -b;'1Jufy
." ".-~--- ..
""CITY"
~~~~~"It
254 IW)T NORl'H STR~~t;l'
:;C::: __!_~9~ - "r':::(j''';~d,,-~-~-
QAIM NO
. __CARLISLE
. L. . I
I'"-Il./
,itAICIPITO INTI-. -.ULI TO 'Ill COMPLAiNT AND RULE ToFILI
(ThIS section of larm to be used ONL Y wilen appellant was DEFENDANT (sell Fh R.C PJP No, /00 I (7) ,n action belore D/stllct Justice,
IF NOT USED, detach Irom copy 01 notice of appeal to be s'"rveel upon appel/co).
'RAECIPE. To Prothonotary
Enter rule upon_u
._---_...~"----
Mlllll! of ,In)dll'!.'(,~)
______ . appelleel'), to. fil. a complain\ in tIIi. appoaI
(COIMIOI1 Plea. No.
__ ) within tw.nty 120) day. ofler _vie. 0.1 rulo Of .ull.r .ntry af judgment of non ""'"
Slf]fllltlJ/tJ ot appell/M'lt Of hIS attomey Of IgIt'It
RUllI Ta_._________._._______m.
Name at ~11uL"(,'J)
. , app.II..I'I,
(1) You are notified lhat a rul. i. h.reby entered upon yau to. fil. a camplainl in thi. app.al wllhin tw.nty 1201 day. alto< tho dm. of
service of this rule upon you by pet"tOnol sltrvice or by certified or registt!'red moil.
(2) W you da not lile a complaint within thi. limo, a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU,
(31 The doN 0' ,rvice of this rule if service was by mail is the dote of maiUrg.
Oat.: ___,19__. ____u____._..
Si~oI~or_
'-
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
(Ttll~ pwuf lJ/ :)V'~jC;U MUS' IJI:. fiLED WI r/'/IN TtN (/OJ DA YS AF rr: H !ll1I'f.1 tlll1IW"t'tJ 01 LiP/UMI CflocJ4 iJppllCdbls b01~~)
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF __ J':VM.8I:\\!,ANP_ -----
; ..
AFFIDAVIT:
[)tJ
, herflhy SWeur or affirm thnt I servod
SWOA~ (AFF~ED) AND SUBSCfllBED BEFORE ME
THIS _::~L.::':____DAY OF .__~I'.,il____. 19}6_
iJ copy of Iht~ NolICtJ (JI Appeal, Cummon Pluus No -2.6.':'_2JlO.8-_._______. . upon the District Justice desIgnated therein on
Id"'. olsmvleu) __-1\P.riL..l6----, 19_.9.9._., [J by pO,""'H1150rV'CC I}!J by (certified) (registered) mail, .ender's
receIpt Ilttached hnr~Ir). und upC)n lhl] nppellce, (f1dmO) __ __M6I_l.1.n.J~_4.&.t~~ ,on
April l~___._, 19~.lJ by personal 'mVlcelJll by (corti/led) (rogl5'orodl mall, ,onder's receipt Bllechad hereto
o and lurthor that I servod the Auto to File 11 ClJfl1pl.:ml1 accompany"'!} the above Notice of Appeal upon the 8~pelleo(.) to whom
the Rille was nddre5sed 01'1 .._~._..___._.._._._ ._._..___.___.~._..._. 19._____.0 by personal serYlce 0 by (certIfied) (registered)
4~~/
/ ~; . "~.f1,.nl
f
mall, sendors recoipt attached tlorcto
.. , "
"
,I \\
" ,
) " 'J
\ '.
\ f- I 1,").
I ."'\
:'
CJ
I:J "iro
1 ,
.. ..I ;.,,:
~.
-
.:r:1L"~'::"
,,, \, 1\, q 'I L '(
Receipt for
Certified Mall
No In'lLJlum,u Ctl\illfllllll ProvIded
00 lIot Wit! for Intmn.lllonol Moil
(~tll' A'JVutIWl
~~.~ASTR~~K__.
j . 'l;~ Box _'-l!.~~__
I
j
le
,,' '.,
CAMP IIIL!'JA....llOIL
~:~:"______~_______ )c. ~____.._
I,.<,j.,."""
Jet
',.",.,.",
-------.-
l'p'Il..'." ',I"
1I"t._" 1<"'1' r,
',',,,,,, 1\1._""
.J
1"'1"" i., ,_,, I,
1\1"- ",)/"'d.,
)'. "I
"11''''
]'d,'; I' ',q,
1',1"
$ i.~)
I', .",1 r" .'.. ~. I "
Mike
04-17-96
Runk
I- . C......... ;.,. ,,,,dlo, 2 for Iddltton.. nrvlu.. I 1110 with CO ,.c..h,. th.
, I' C.......I...... ,,'- .. · b. following .,rlllc.. (for In '.1,. J
. ~ your "_end Iddrll.rm th, rlv,r.. 0' Ihi. for'" .0 tnlt WI un flel:
,1IIfI\Iin tNI a.... to YClU,
:.:.n:: ::,...~m to lto. ',orU 0' the m~lpf'I;'. Of on tn, blck Ir ,glC' 1. [J Addr.".... Add,... J
' . Wrltl.."""'"~ptllt9quelllld'.ontNm..""c.befowth..rtlcf.numbt' 2 [J Restrlct.d D.llv.ry
. The ~ Ittc"Dt will ,how 10 whof'n the Ilrtic'''' w.. lMliv.rld and tt\l dlr.
',.v...... C.o".ul~!~lIr.r fat fe._..
3. ArticM Addr..etct to: .... Artichl Numb.,
IlAlLII GAS'R.OCK I 321 8J4 411 ._)
. 0 lIOlt 1043 4b, S.",lc. Typ.
CNII' HILL 'A 17011 [] A.gl.....d [] IOlured
II Cerllll.d [J COD I
[] Express Mail Aftl,," Rec.ipt '0'
" .-J
.7.
I
roqU"IM J
8,
/
, Dee_, ,.., 8I.\e...... ,---". DOMESTIC TUIlN IIICEI"
) ~
I:..c..,
~''''
1'':'-
"' 3J
') I
s
..
~
~
~
~
J
~ \D ~
M
1- ..
~i.J~'"~) 9
,....J.. ~ 91
r~:: ~~::
~,. In
Ii '.'5
'Ij"' I
t.:tI 0:: ~
L\ '
" ~ c
~..
u.. $ a
0
. ,
4, 1999, at 1t30 p.m. The anticipated duration of trial is
one-half day.
Defendant's counsel has indicated that he
may be supplementing his witness list with an expert on the
subject of the reasonableness of the Plaintiff's charges
and the quality of work done to the vehicle.
With respect to settlement negotiations, it
does appear that there is a reasonable possibility of
settlement in this case.
By the Court,
Joseph D. Buckley, Esquire
For the Plaintiff
~"IOY 01"
_ c.~,." t?',~,Jt.{
H).~'1 Jq~.
~:'IS'.
Michael A. Scherer, Esquire
For the Defendant
wcy
f 'I ~ \' L
"i.','(
,,"
n." , ~ r '~ ",: I,
.,,' ,
r I '~ 1, "
,',
'1'1'
(~I I
"
.
LARRY J. RUNK, II.
Plaintill'
IN THE COliRT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYL VANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTION -- LAW
MARLIN GASTROCK.
Delendant
NO, 96-20011 CIVIL TERM
AND NOW. this
ORDER OF COURT
tt
3 day of November. 1999. upon consideration of Plaintill's
complaint and of Delendant's counterclaim. and fi)lIowing a nonjury trial. the court linds
(I) in favor of Plaintiff Larry Runk, Ii. and against Defendant Marlin Gastrock on the
complaint in the amount of $8.500,00. plus costs of suit and interest see, leg, from March
19, 1996. and (2) in favor of Counterclaim Delendant Larry Runk. II. and against
Counterclaim Plaintiff Marlin Gastrock. on the cOl.mterclaim,
THE 1976 Lincoln Mark IV which is the subject of this action shall be returned to
Plaintiff upon satisfaction of his obligation hereunder, Risk of loss with respect to the
vehicle in the interim shall be upon Dctendant Marlin Gastrock,
BY TIlE COURT.
J
Joseph D. Buckley. Esq.
1237 Holly Pike
Carlisle. PA 17013
Attorney for Plaintiff
~. j : '
,,'" .
,l:.:-,i
- .. .~
.:.. J; -'
.
".
Michael A. Scherer. Esq.
17 West South Street
Carlisle. PA 17013
Attorney for Defendant
:rc
~__ ,,,...t:...t.~ ILia) ~ i'.
,
-- , .
f !~
~ ! ~:I!
~ f~; ~
l. ~ I::.
~
"" ",
r
~
:J
CD
00
r()
-r
(0
r0
" .
v
,_ 0
f..;
""0 11
;.:.: ' :;', <:)..->: :rJ it
';;l,' . 'V') V) J:J '
~,;"i _ d S{
'.:, ;'1. -=a '-l ~ ~
/_~) .:)
:.-
r:;~ 14)
~: .;J
c.~
, ",~
- .
l.ARRY J, RUNK,II.
PluintilT
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON Pl.EAS
CUMBERl.AND cot 'NTY, PENNSYl.V ANIA
v.
CIVIl. ACTION - l.llW
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Delcndanl
NO. <J6-20011
CIVIl. TERM
WRIT 0... EXECUTION
Tolhe SheriffulTumherlund Counly:
To sUlisfy the judgment. inlerests uml costs uguinst MARLIN GASTROCK,
dclcndunt.
(I) You ure direcled 10 le\'y upon Ihe property of the delcndanlund 10 sell his
interesllherein: u I 97Cll.incoln Murk V automohile, presently locuted 1Il
Bill's Welding. 254 I:ust North Slrccl. Curlisk, PA 1701 J.
(2) You arc ulso directed 10 ulluch Ihe property of the delcndunlnot levied upon
in the possessiun of M & T BANK. loc.lled at One Westlligh Strecl. Carlislc.
PA 17013. us gumishee. that heing any ullll ull hunk uccuunls. including but
not limited to chccking und suvings uccounls,
und to nOlify the garnishce thut
(u) An ulluchmenl h.ls heen issued;
(b) The gurnishee is enjoined Irom puying any dehtto or for thc account of
the defcndant und Irom delivering any property of the defendant or
othcrwise disposing thereof;
(3) Ifprupertyof the dctcndunl notle\'ied upon und suhjectto ull.lehment is
lound in the posscssion of uny one other Ihunu n.llned gurnishcc. you are
dirccled to noli fy himth.1l hc hus heelludded us u gurnishee ami is enjoined
us abo\'c stuted,
Amount due
Inlerest frum Mureh II). 1')9(,
Suhtotul
Cosls
Tolul
Seul of the Court
.~ ':") l;
(',~ ~1
I
" ,;, '::i,r;
,J-I
" :\~
~ ~::1
',I r
,:;) : U)
)'"
,,~
, , I(~
l~ ~ ' I,~ L .
c..::.
t.",\ "3
-' l.J G
.. ,
" (') ....
~:'; ." fc'
';..
.. ;n~ ",,-
, , -'1 ....
L! .. .t.... ~ ,<,'
.-.-t '~ ) ;J:
t..l.. .~ ~'.:.j
.....,j " ,.
I " ~:
:~~ --
, '1i'1
.' 'ld'
.,.' ..
, ',....., ..>
(',:> (,,),
..
I..
~ ~li
'~ . ~:II
lhi~
. .'
. ,.
LARRY J. RlJNK.II.
Plaintill'
IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
v,
CIVIL ACTION - LA W
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendunt
NO, 96-2001\ CIVIL TERM
CLAIM FOR EXEMPTION
- .
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 22"d day of January. 2003. upon consideration of the all ached
leller from the Cumberland County Sheriffs Office. the hearing scheduled for March 14,
2003. is cancelled.
BY THE COlJRT.
Joseph Buckley. Esq.
1237 Holly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
Allorney for Plaintiff
l1t/c~ k.~i 4
! Wesley 0111,(. Jr., J.
Marlin L. Gastrock
clo Ruth Irene Bennell. PI A
1052 W, Foxcrolt Drive
Camp Hill. PA 17011
for Defendant. Pro Se
~ ".....t..( I.~J'().J
~.
:rc
I" ~ " .: ,. .' 1 r, .
OF I ' ' : '. ),-;;y
03.JMI2.i M\ II: n~
CUM,;I;I',.! ;;.J ....JUN1Y
PENI\lSYLV!'NlA
, '
"
, ,
, ,
" ,
, '
,"
..
LARRY J. RUNK,II,
Plaintill'
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON I'I.EAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
v,
CIVIl. ACTION-LAW
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Delendant
NO. 96.2008 CIVIl. TERM
Qlmt:J{9Ll~()lJRT
AND NOW. this 21'1 duy of Junual'Y, 2003. upon considerutiol1 of the Claim for
Excmption. a hearing is scheduled tllr Friday. March 14. 2003. at 10:30 n.l11.. in
Courtroom No, 1, Cumberland County Courthouse. Carlisle. Pennsylvania,
BY TilE COURT,
, Joseph Buckley, Esq,
1237 Holly Pike
Carlislc. PA 17013
Attorney for Plaintill'
>
(, C,-r-u.W J..
L (Y).o.:>-
l P\~ S
o I ;).:) . 0 ~
/ Marlin L. Gastrock
clo Ruth Ircnc Bennell. PIA
1052 W, Foxcron Drive
Camp Hill. PA 17011
tor Dctcndant. Pro Sc
c
::J.:
('-' ('"-~
'''It
c. .
()
'rc
!.:~ .
~;:"
I, ,I ('/'./(" (/' .. ,/
I I( f) II.' j " ; I I I,' / I ,I, 'r' , ! ',- (,-, '
_ ... 1, /) _ _
!' ' 'v',it" ',' ,/., ,/, "
, 1.11 r I ". " ",
~,- .. 'I .
-,
-<
~
.' '
JAN " 2003 ~
LARRY J, RUNK, II,
Plainti ff
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CtlMBERLAND COl il'\IY, PFI'\NSYl.VANIA
v,
CIVIL ACTION - I.all
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
CIVIl. TERM
NO, %,2008
WRIT OF EXH'llTlON
To the Sheriff of Cumberland County:
To sallsfy the judgment, interests ami costs against MARLIN GASTROCK,
defendant,
( I) You are directed to levy upon the property of the defendant and to sell his
interest therein: a IlJ76 I.incoln Mark V autoll1obile, presently located at
Bill's Welding, 254 East North Street, Carlisle. PA 170\3,
(2) You an.: also directed to attach the property of the defendant not levied upon
in the possessilll1 of 1\'1 & r BANK. located at One Westlligh Street, Carlisle,
PA 17013, as garnishee, th.ll being any and all bank accounts, including but
not limited to checking and savings accounts.
and to noti fy the gamishee that
(a) An attachment has been issued;
(b) Thc garnishee is enjoined 1i'l11l1 p~,ying any debt to or for the account of
the defendant and li'oll1 delivering .IIlY pmperty of the defendant or
otherwise disposing thereof;
(3) (fpropertyof the defendant not levied upon and subject to attachment is
found in the possession of anyone other than a narn'.:d garnishee, you are
directed to notify him that he has been added as a garnishee and is enjoined
as above slated,
Amount due
Interest from March !lJ, 1'196
I Subtotal
Atty for Plaintiff
JooeP't Ftl:kley
1237 !bUy Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
Costs
Total
$8,500,00
$3.408 14
$ll,lJ08,14
'ISO 25
$12,2583') , , .,
Seal of the Courl
c. other (specify amount ami basis of exemption):
I request a prompt court hearing to determine the exemption,
Notice of the hearing should be given to me at:
.l{-?.'~~/4. ~ ff-; /~ /F
Address
/d.s-~ JtL.EKEr~~r:
(7/7) 71,3-21.3/2-
Telephone Number
I verify that the statements made in this Claim for Exemption are true and correct.
I understand that false statements herein arc made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa, C,S,
4904 relating to unswom falsification to authorities.
Date : ~~:I'/,,:/
I
THIS CLAIM TO BE FILED WITH THE
OFFICE OF THE SHERIFF OF CUMBERLAND
COUNTY:
CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE
CARLISLE. PENNSYLVANIA 17013
(717) 24().6390
POWER OF ATTORNEY
KNOWN ALL MEN BY THESE PRESENTS: That, I, MARLIN L.
GASTROCK, of Camp Hill, County of Cumberland. Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania, do make, constitute and appoint RUTH IRENE BEl\'NETl' of
Camp Hill, County of Cumberland. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania, as my true
and lawful attorney for me and in my name,
(a) To ask. demand, sue for. recover, collect and receive all such sums of
money, debts, accounts, rents. interest, dividends, bonds, certificates of stock and
other certificates, stock rights, annuities, liquidations, damages and demands
whatsoever, as now are, or hereafter shall become due, owing or payable to me or
to which I may be entitled; and
(b) To open and close checking and savings accounts, to make draw, sign
execute, endorse, guarantee, seal, acknowledge, join in and deliver all such deeds,
ka~es, assign:nents., p~,~dgC3, elm tracts, chat:el mmtgages, checks. bills of lading,
bonds, promissory notes, evidences of debt, receipts, releases and satisfactions of
record of judgments, mortgages and other debts, and such other instruments of
whatsoeve~ kind and nature as she may deem necessary or proper; and
(c) To make, sign, execute, sell, deliver, endorse, exercise. guarantee, buy,
subscribe lor, and deal in stock or certi licates of stock, stock rights, voting trust
certiticates, bonds, notes and debentures, incluuing United States Savings Bonds,
of any nature entirely at her own discretion; and
(d) To buy and sell motor vehicles in my namc and to make, execute,
endorse and ddiver all applications on or assignments ofcertiticates of title or
other documents in connection with the purchase or sale of motor vehicles; and
(e) To purchasc, lease. repair, insur~, receive and take possession of and to
sell. transfer, convey and mortgage all lands, tenements, interests in lands,
hereditaments, chattels, choses in action and real or personal property upon such
terms and conditions she may think proper; and to buy. sell and mortgage and in
every way deal in and with goods, merchandise and chases in action; and
(I) To initiate, join in, or defend litigation in my name and in my behall~ to
enforce any right, claim or defense I may have and for this purpose to retain,
instruct. discharge and pay from any funds legal counsel of her own choosing, to
control my interest in such litigation and to prosecute the same through final
appellate procedure or to settle it at any stage under such terms and conditions as
to her shall seem proper; and
(g) To act as my attorney in fact and, if qualilied, as my true and lawful
allorney to appear for and represent me before the Treasury Department in
connection with any matter involving federal taxes in which I am a party, The
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW,
of Civil Procedure 3 I 23.l(b), a hearing is set for
pursuant to Pa" Rule
in C;ourt Room No,
Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, The Sheriff of
Cumberland County shall notify the parties of the time and place for the hearing.
By the Court,
},
"
ii'
LARRY J. RUNK. II,
Plllintiff
v.
MARLIN GASTROCK,
Defendant
IN Till: COURT OF COMMON Pl.EAS
CUMBERl.AND CO! JNTY. PENNSYLV ANIA
CIVIl. ACTION. l.aw
NO. l)(,.200S
CIVIl. TERM
WRIT 01' EXECUTION
To satisfy the jlldgl1lcnt, intcrcsts and costs against MARLIN GASTROCK,
defendant,
To thc SheriffofCumberland County:
(I) You arc dircctcd to levy upon the pmpcrly ofthc dcfendant and to scll his
intercst thercin: a 1976 l.incoln Mark V autonlllbi1c, prescntly located at
Bill's Welding. 254 East North Strcct, Carli sic, PA 1701 J.
(2) You arc also dircctcd to attach thc pl'llpcrty of lhc dcli:ndanlnot Ievicd upon
in the posscssionof M & T BANK. localcd at OIlC Wcst High Slrcct, Carlisle,
PA 170IJ, as garnishcc. that bcing any and all bank accounts, including but
not limited to chccking and savings accounts.
and to noti fy thc garnishec that
(a) An attachmcnt has hccn issucd:
(b) The garnishcc is cnjoincd fnlm p.,ying any dchlto or for thc account of
thc defcndant and thlln delivcring any propcrty ot'thc defcndant or
otherwisc disposing thcrcof:
(~) If property of the dcrcndant notlevicd upon and subject to attachment is
Ii.lllnd in the posscssion of anyone othcr than a namcd garnishee, you are
dircclcd III lIotify himlhat he 11:ls hccn added as a garnishcc and is cnjoined
~IS uhovc stat~d,
Amount due
Interest from March I'). 19%
S+btotal
Costs
'I\)tal
Seal of the Court
Atty for Plaintiff
Jasqn F\ckley
l237 fblly Pike
Carlisle, PA 17013
"
,
R. Thomas Klinc, Shcriff, who bcing duly sworn according to law, statcs
this writ is rctumcd STAYED.
Shcrifrs Costs:
Dockcting $
Poundage
Advertising
Law Library
Prothonotary
Mileagc
Misc,
Surchargc
Lcvy
Post Ponc Salc
Garnishec
18.00
2.07
AdvlUIce Costs: 150.00
Shcrifrs Costs: 105.97
44.03
Rcfundcd to Atlyon 1/23/03
6.90
10.00
"0.00
9.00
105.97
-{j
r'
"-
<>
I)
'<l
Sworn and Subscribcd to bcforc mc
Th" t1 d f i
1S.:!.L ay 0 '- <"'L~A'Y
. \ ,
2~A.D. ~t., C. IlJf,,/,~
othonotary
~~~,'
R. Tho as Kline, Sheriff
~~kkA/
By
..~
.~~';~.'.'
"~'il~fJ
'.'iTiJ
-:':;.'':;:''
,""""'-
.. -~ r:!1
',iYiJ
PLAINTIFF'S
EXHIBtT
.HIIT No.
O'
-Hlna
"I'tif'l S- tJ'i
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
.... ~\tJ (;-~ , - ..
I AODIU" J: \ 2,- q 3
:=-~ 1;"b n.. I LIC:lJriIl. ,.u...." WU.LAGIl IWOTD" NO. Dl;NIAl. NO. -
INlIlJIIU),," ADJU.'Ul INI"aC:TUlt I "HONI
...0.....
- -- .. -" ,- - - -, - -..-.--.. -.. on ,- _ D;.IIIIN'''.
DESCRIPTION o. REPAIRS ANO REPLACEMENTS PARTS LADO" PAI,n TOTAL
QTV. ---
NUM8Eft AMOUNT AMOUNT AMOIINT AMOUNT
II ,,f\ r.,... _, ())
LC:.-\+'. ,r,D,;' , ..
- -- - - '- '5('v ~
'?,.L-.+ ...~~ "'YJ ) k!J.
'f .- .- f-
f--
-- --- I-- - - - -
- - -- I---
,- - --
I--- -- - f-- - .
'- -- I-- 1--
1--- I---
---_. -- -- - i--
,- - - -
-
--
-- -
I - - -,
TOTALS II' .... -
INSURED PAYS I I~JS, CO. PAYS R, 0, No_ - -
INS, crlECK PMABLE TO TAX ~ ~
1111 .I:ll)~' it ." ','~mlllll, bOUlli on our ll'llpletion "'lid d,," ",.,r (:,jlll' 1I,"ld"'O",,1 PM" 0' lltbo, - - - -- --
whicll ",,,~ b. ,..,,~...rj .ft" th, lIlIclrk hili b,," ,III,"d. Atts, ....urk lloH Illtrlod. 4n~ .<JIII, brO~lIn WRECKU
or ~.m.ql!d p.,t, .11.(11 .r. di,CQ."'<l 411d I" 1101 '\lid""r Oil fHlt IIIIPO~I'QII, ..II ,.511......., 'h, 5UVICi
"'lltl fa 'h'" Ih,. Ill,mll. by p,ool. e.1~"UI' 01 tl'l,~ II,. IIbQ'11 pfi!:1I If I not QU"f."leod IInd
"'1 '0" 1"'",.dil'l ,~~'plln, _ gill.,. All quotl"Ont Oil ""'1 IlId I.bo' 'fl c.Urf.n, IIn,J Iubi.d
'0 c.hlnQI. SlOlAGI CHG'S
EST. MADE IY TOTAL 0'
ISTlt.tAII ~H6~
AU'IIOIIIA N roa UPAlI, ,".,.. auft, IU~'IA nJI1I1"Ut.I... IbtdlllrllD. -----.
\'GN~~'~P ~~~- ~~----
itlOIlDl1I PIIOM. AUTO AUDIO I ACCISSOIIIES' 120 H.no.., P1k.. LIIUfllown.'A 17340. T,uc_ Phon., 17 17) 17:J.lll4l
PLAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT
....IT "II.
\ 0' ~ ........
. .
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
11/'1/qq d-I4Y
...... Y\.. (~\I I A;e..... ....
.... .. ... L' ~ \r "\l , r~6 nPl ILl"...... ...1.... .IL...... I..'....... ........ ....
MlI.4-
"'."...., ..,,,.,.. 1"'''lIn.. .M....
~D".
DIEKRII'TIOH 0' RlEl'Alnll AND nl!l'u.CI!:MIENT. PART. LAIC" PAINT 'OYA&..
on.
HU....... AMOUNT AWOUNT .IlIIOUNT ."OUNT
~) ~...~\ ~, . V"_iH1 - 4-1 I-tfo:..
\ ~~I.I/)oo,.
^- - 0'01) .... ,..,,~~ ~. "'t1I. r i:.. -
'\'~\N\I.~ - ~~~ll:'>,
... - - - -
\ ,... r--....:, . I -, \ ~_ U'S '
... - .-
'Q\.J:t ~ - --Iff \\~JI""AT(. + \ \ OIl" ~j ~,
'oj -
1C1\.~~.\ ,~~.l ~. I~ .~ ~
ffi T I -
- \.. WI<<,\:, "\{, ~\'lJ(~l\
- -.-. .,-
- , c:,.., '" A- fT'
- - - - -- -
-- ~\~~\\\d.. \ \ .lQ..
-- .
(~tt>. ~ \ ' t'fI i\\;,\ L"""l I,....
- - --
...~,4..,. 'l- ",h. l~n"" ," 0 0 I A ..,
':l,~ T"l - -
~ ,..,11\ """..\., '''~* ~'-l -
,,.'
.... - - -
'? \~'StR.\~ 1.:5 r..x..; -
J.~ G~t..b, r }o h " .9 \Yt\ I\..f-.lj=- It-. 'r\
- -
R" .....l.. Al I\r ~ P tuJC:.. f:' R(;
~ Q\\<:>, ' ' .J'\"-~\<.. 1.1 ~L
~. -
\~ ~\t-J-\ \-\f\t~ Pi .,0 ,<1"
\ ~ClX \b.\.')t:. \S 0.. 1C
INSUllD '.'lVI' INS. CO, 'AYS R. O. No_ TOTALS -(, lli~
INS. CHICK ""YAILI TO lAI r. -f!~Dt S'"
,..~ ..... I. .. ..n",.I. 1N..4., ..' ,,,........ 11I4 ~.... ... c"'" ..,dUI.".1 ..,11 ., I."', W.'CICU
.a ~. ... ... ,.~.I':f.. .1.... 'Il~ "" .... Mil Ilul.d. All., .," II.. 11..t.", '"' ."", -'.....~
If ....,.. .,.....a a,". ......... .... Ir, 11.1 ...1...... " 'l.d 111,..,11.., ... rlO,"'" I"~ unlc.
~.:t: =. la~ ........ ." .-1. ....... f' Ill. ta. .Dew' 'HU' .r. .... .........,,\t I. -- -
~. .. .l... ......... _... All ...1.1... ., .,111 ,.11I I..., .r. ...,...1 .... .. .... nOIA.. eN.',
Uf. "'''DI rt TOTAL 0'
ISTI"'''TI
AU'I'III..t'I'" n, ...ua. ,..II'.... ...... ...... alii ............-.urt. 1M............
o
SIGNID
DAT"
"'.111' Ho.
d... .O' 1..
aMI""
~1 f~, rn ,'t
...... \"1 l~.'" ..,.
..... ... ... I 'u, np, I LII.... .".... .IL....... I..'.. .... ...1.."....
,........... ...,,,.,... I......... .......
......
D..C"I~'IOH Of' nEPAI"S AHD nI!PL.ACI!MIlENT. .."ATS LA.O. PAINT ?O'AI.
.n.
HU....." AMOUN' AMOUNT ....ou..? AMOUNt'
(H..j \&:, ~'"
(:;:,\ f:\~h. f- lu.
&:..,' h~\ \..i~ -k ~ -
- -
4- ~~I\\l i l'l~H':1 \=\ I. "\'"..,~ \'2. ,,,
1 ~Q<:..\)i~;t... ~111.... \<;( rv,
\ ('.~, 'AA._ -~\ l -
.3 .:t:
, --
(' II../J M\ "1I""'~, ~ 1"
11 fl.1~ f"'A__I ,'~v -'- ..-
\ SL I.-
,:1 (,l\<) I...... ....... {'ln1\.nlJ -- - - - -- -
. 1-
tLl.
- -
~\ ~~ S.1 ~ - - ~-
\" ~ \ ~ ~ 1iil'..A. V\IIT" ~-~
"\0/11.
l~ ~\\'o~ C:Y~kQ...', T{ll~~ ~~ -
I~ , M ;\1aL"'~ - 4.:;:..... ~ \ "Al\ +- ),,).. OQI. ~ I-- -
~\- - - -
~\ ""In<. \ Ict (V)
t.+'\ -C.~. A ~.f4,i?- '. ..,-f r->"'ALA
...:.-
""-' ' \ -
~ ~-lq-~ -\-0 4-\ \-C{G 'l-<.,Jntl Gl.o\~- -
\. ltJ\\L ~f\\\) 1l'J E 1\\ - ).. 4-~:" ~v~ F'At.. "\.1.1'0 Q,;>
I 3~'&'
IN$URlD 'AYS , INS, CO, 'AYI a, 0, No_ TOTALS <0
INS. CHICK 'MAIU TO 'AX ~.CN +- I At .AI> .", I \ "5 g" ~
I~~:.... t:... ..1111II.1., ....... .... ..' hUI"U.' .... 4... ,.f .-, .ddlll.II.1 ,.,h If I..... wile...
. ,.., ,....h:f....... ,..... ..,_... 1M.. .."t.oI. AU., ...'- II.. .t",.... '"' ..... 1I,.h"~
~ :."'::'.... ,,~.II Ill.,. ..1.....,.4 .... II. ,.1 ..1....' .. II.., l....cti... .. rI""" 11Il~ IIUICI
, . ,..... I .. ....... .. ._1. I...... .1 IlIl. .... ..... .,.". .,. 1M' ,.......... ..
:;. J.~~:......." ..c..,.... _I,. All .....11... .. ..rt. .... I.....' .'. ..",... ,"d ,...... -
110.....1 CM."
1ST. "'AD I rt_ TOTAL 0' ": ~4-3q ~,
I"INATI
........11.\""1 ft....ua. 1......, IIIItIrtM ..... alii................" &ail...........
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
~
"
SI6NID
D^"
PLAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT
..tin He.
o.
....n'I
11/'11<11 I
~'1
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
..... ,...:-.... .".,.
.... ., ..... \ [:" n.. I LlC..... .11II"'.... .......... ~...,IJ"..... ".I"'~ .....
L "(,,,II -L ,~,t..ct, '\-
IHIUII'. .., ..'''1''. 1J....t'JOllll 1...0...
NOW'
I ....,....
- .
D..CRI~TION 0," nl!:PAanS AND REPLACEMENTS ""RTII LA.a.. ~AINl' TOT""
Qrt. NU"'_I" .......OUN' "'''0 u... T ..MOUNT ....au""
Il ~) " \Wt,"-\ - \:. \' C)'I,t\-' ",'
\, , \::'~, ~, ,'"\. ,'- : r
I.... ,
\ ,,,,\(\ \'1.\.A.' I t 't,..,Kh" 0l.\I\.C :1\ \\.:",
<;:'ilt.lci<;
~ \. \ - -
c)., \Z, y..c, -~ \~,,\.x - ... i\l\oJi (,-" f.'b, \J:: ~+I
."' .':~k'" - -
- - -
~ ~( ~cf... \.:\l\ - Fn, ~OAI~ \YI~ '<-\'1...('\0. or
'"J ,-
~'N\~\-'o W(~\(, '" \leJ ,\\Q. \()l.:.~
'\-' \.. ~L. - tl'~ u J';'''- \J~\". _":\:. \, ~",''\I\' pt\l~l \\~ I-\"'~l
-- -' --
- ~ \Lot- r.toJt \1l \\I(~
J '\ f.\P"'. I\~ m
II \.:.Ql\x>..k:=::- '-..l~'E<." \).. ,...I):"",~ " I-IE,I"'-'''''-..... ,,~ YJ ,- -.-- ..-
<C. r(f.\\'hl- \1\1..>.1\ 'uj)' ~\\"" . \(\~,\, H\h 0I\l...d~ \: 1",(<' , .- - I-- -
-- -- -
-ru ~\1l\1I.. ~~ ~ \I ; V\" ~~'\'\Y\ ~ {)I.lI'_Q.. -
- -
.... \....~<.- \2Q.~~\1<. ... ,. :;\.16
1 tI.....I''r.1- ()~IMSi...
, , - - - - - -
G, ~, w.tQ.l.. - ~f\b, \ll\t..e\-- ... \J.>QU, ~\,^-,\.,\-, ~ pfJN.. _I
."".. :..\.t<-
. 4-,_ -
ex ~h:U- \- ~p\A:Q.' l.. t-r.:1'v1'\Qt..,R 1?1: ",W, \-\ '.'" I)
- - - -
\W~~, \.,,/.... Or~\\ X , \UI~c... ,.. ~!.C>,~V I,f (.J..~i\\ ,
~* , - - --
1\,,,,,,, ,1'- &W ( , ~
" \ 't~,,-,t)'~{3.\'t~,....:~I'.v.." \ \..),v'.~~(.t~.
. , . \' \ -
\ji\\i ....u.. t~{;\-(:j~ ,....:_~.~~> ......~\-,('~ '--.~t~ €.:..... .i.i:"c.:'......, ,\j \
'~llr,-r_~ '.(r~.. \..\ r.t ..!.."HLJ~ Oi!:..'~ ' :\:. t\P,~
~'Jf:-'_' "'-'X,!" '-'-"'- 1',1) \tv, n, ~-0 ) -
_~f r ~f" lv:.,;U<Q.iL -
\0 f \-..'l-K. i0.~ ,.,\Int'.. ,J+';l, /I-\-J.J-.{'" (c,' 'i 1-'(
tiJt"lt AlCQA - -
-
\ \ () Q~ \ ,"\/\Io.lQ ,., b...h\~~~ I, 'rl e..
'Kt IYtI... E ... \(1(
I
TO'''LS
INSURID 'AYS' IHl, co, 'Ml___ R, 0, Ho_
INS, CHICK 'MAILI TO ,AI
,..~ ...... \:... ..11....1. ........ ..' 1tI,..."" .,,4 4eNI ... .O~t .eldlll..... ...h ., I.~., -
.. ~' .., ,...11:1. .It., I~ .." lit, .... .,.,t.... Alii' ..., II.. .,.rl.... ..." ...., ",.h.~ WUClCll
~' .. ...,.~ ".rt. ,II It If' .. .........1 ..4 .re ..f ..Id..., .. fl,.. II"...U,., ... ...,...... 11t~ IIlYlet
I , , .. ... .. N... ..,.... '" ,~t. ....... t' '"l. fh ..... "\UI .,. .... 9..,ul..", .. -
~. .t:...~..,... .......... ..". All ....., .., M ",., .... I.... I'. ..,..... .... ,.\ti." no..... e.....
lSl. WADI .., TOTAL 0'
ISTlNAII
......lIAn.. ft. "ill. I"....., ..... .. .... ... ..... ..uw,..... . 1M - ....... .... -
SI6NID
D""
....n H.,
o.
-MlaTe
ESTIMATE
OF REPAIRS
liIa.. ,........... .An
_A.' e.. .... 1 YUill .... I ....c..... ,."'.... ..It....... 1_0'.""'.' ...,,,.........,
...."'...... ...JV.". 1...".':'0. I ::::.
NO".
,....
DIEBCAIPTIOH 0' nEPA,ns AHD REPLACEMENT. PAnts LA.O" .....INT fOTAl.
a.....,
HU.....,' AJ040UNT """nUHT "MOUNT "MOUNT
" .
, :..' \'-r "\' < " ',- ;)~,\'\ ~- .... ;-'r\., 11\i.. R'- ~~ ',l'\:,\u: " GHt.'
_,_,,' I 'u' ,
\~ I C-~\ \, ,':' ',-, \ It- ~. I; '~ I L '. '. r: .,4)_ \,_.... R" ~'I ,~ ,~,.\r", lor
. ~ - - -
',', <, '\.. ' ,i( ",',I -" 1\90 t\ ... \ "1v1'Y: ,1 \JI t\'iH 1-1" I.... II/n f-
- - >- - -
\'\I~ \:,~\",tl'.'...<r G,. ,I '.\ !"K ',. . . \~ f\.'",- ~~(v...~:_\'''' I,. \<.\ \-.. \-,\(J~q~+
"~
, I I\\~, ' , ( 2.." \ - ('Ii':')......... '" '""'rl";;;ILc..J.. "'"".'11.. \;A',r-..,hl<-L II \It-
'" - \ ~I, \ " ..L
, , ~ -
\-\ ru;"", -1 \ ;'v \ "~' 1\\ \ -\-tJl"" \, (. ,..,1--101'''- ,., (' IIJD,I€,i Ie,^-,
"
,'" h'~~I' \ I r<\-\-, L -- - , --
-I:r ,,;l' "~it I I '\ 4\1~' -
" - - _._~ .,-
\1\\"'( . ::, 'tit
- - J-- - -- -- -
Ii \ \ , _~::"":')I~ S(., t-,i'<- '1'( (\1" -or' ~: ,,(..( ..,
~ t','" ; -,~ A.
- -
0~\"'\ ... ,\\...1 \Ydlitt' 1\":' I',' 4." - ,--
. -
, (\".. h.', ~\..~\IIN ....
r) -- 1'..., , \-\ H.,,\ '(.0:, 'y, 106 (.X.:J
-
,
'nil' 'i'( f"' ",iji \\, (\.....Nt "":U_' \ ,'1,,1 \ \-,,0 Il' Al'\t\,,,,q t
" ,- - -
'\\v.J ',\\I\tl."-" IJ ',^, W'~',~_\\ QL I ',,,,f', '-Y (',I, r 1 ~\. ..\
, (, '. I', ' ~ -
i,<"',"\\'~:"-" ,;, \" , '1,1.-... ""\(I,H I" ( -1-1
" I'
-
-
'=",':!.<;o+")
-=",\1 -f' -
TJl\
----..-... -- - -
'3 Co () Tf ('"
INSURlD 'AYS . INS. CO, 'AYS R, O. No__ tOtALS
INl CHICK 'AlA'UfO -- I..
I~,....... \:... ..11",.1. 1M"".1lI .._ I.".,W.. .." "... ...1 co~' .dcllll.".1 ,..h ., I.lta, WllelC"
:, ~1iI ...., r..,"::1.. ."., '':f ...,_ ".. !ten ,I., I,d. AU.. ..'.,"" ''',t,d, all, ..rll, ~,.h".
,~...-;:"1 ,.rl_.1Il iii ... ., ......,.., alll" .,. 11.1 ...Id.", ... 'l..' I.....cli.... ... ......... Ih~ IIUIC.
., ~.,.. .... ..,....... '" .~,. ..c.... .1 11Il11 III. .MY. .,.eu .., ..._ ,..,....." ."
N. ""....."... .......... .Iot, All ...1.11.". .. ,.rt. .1" I.M' ... ...,..". .... ,.~I." -
no...... e....
Uf. "'ADI .., tOtAL 0'
- 1S""AlI
IUI'MI."".. n, "All. 1.... .... ...... lit .... 1M ..... ........... .. ... - ...... ......
M
SIGNID
PAil
';'\,', ''T(..;' If\\..:'"'
, \I .,\'...-.
.-:. ~,~~: 1" ~\''fT\l1....
\. :\.~',\~~-i"",
" ;,. ',:'-.J
,
~ '
(\, \" <,\ 'J-,.'. u...
;Uu\k c:^. ,,')")"')
..:\1:.:1 ''"': 4-
II. 10
~
-.
,) ":_~\"L\\ f...,I\--'
{:l~ C\~ 1\(_
1'\"""'" 1,\'IIl':\^-'- \, ~\-:Z.<, ((",1'"",,') -
I )......i" ,
L r, " ' . ..
1_\>\ ',; \", ...,,,1\1:>-\ \.:.. -
\ ""2.':; ,V....
,'0:, (':0'>,,)
4
,
t::,
(,
,;..
.,
,
':\~\~"'~M-'~ \J,."~I.',
'.' \\
.....
_\" 1"', [I';!, ~, . ,\ ,""
- V-, ,.....~I~....
I '(4, , CO
00
\, b ' ,HI '.I (:... -- ,:,,+
\ -, ~,I,'.'"tll ;J. '.),1\\-,
~?, ,\"""'(_ \\,:~I.U(t... -
I CI, =' Ii, -, l~' " ,..,
\ tf-1 rx;
? l ).""
j "
.'""" ,(:1-,
.... ,1_,,'
.10_
~(= ,()..J
~(J "~"I:"'<""'.', p,._.~,~_t_ \ '::' :_i'~-
", ;~i,<:L1( f-,i'.\~<, " ',.Y-,
-I -'. \. \-
~......:..~ (.\-.~~~t fJW'~. \ ::,,/_,
,( -., -:;,\ I:... ,:J\u." - \ 2. rt 1,:0 f ~,-
'-1
I LJ. " '''....I (I (,,, '",:., ,'" .
;-..,,' v \ ~.....l'_ _ 1.,../'-1
I:t
",2.0
'j<:' '\c..Q..+d~l4 ",) (, ':>)0
~'
'1...( (,0', t:-< I. 4-(1\....4 I c. - ,:> ,;.!.-J
r.. .. ~....' .
),1 f); ~~- ( \,0, rL 1u,,~, (~ ~ <;<:;u ::.l..~'lX)
- .-/,.'.\'"
'," ,
)...1- \,1/,<+,( , [I~bet:. \ "..l i'S
)..q, \ \:x. )( 4llu I VApu..
\0 (-r" t)~ ~\"2.U
~ , , c.~!J
-, ( .... r:L~ "/._1 r \1'1.1'.'/..(-, Ibuu
!