HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-03345
/
I
I
i
j~
j,
.n
~
, a
,0
~
; C
~
~ ..~
:,'8 .
_.
C_NWIALTH 0' 'INNIYLVANIA
COlli' 0' C_, 'L1AI
,
NOTICE 0' APPEAL
fROM
r~
lUDIClAl_TlICT
"
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
"
j,
. ,
COMMON'lIAIN.. Qlo-3345 C../,ITerm
NOTICE OF APPEAL
I :.
Notic. I. giwn that tht appellant has fiI.d in tho obow Cour' of Common Plea. on appeal from tho judgment rendorod by tho Di.'rlet Ju.tic. on ,ho
dot. cn:t In If!t c_ n....Ii....J I>olo.<
:;a=A. Jones
NNWI:::;:'::UAHJ
Route 743, P. Q, Box 982, Hershey
:~~"7;: 1996 IN~~::,,";:j Jones
CV IP. 0000312-95
LT 19
This block wiD be Iignod ONLY-~1en 'hi. nolation i. required under PCL R.cP_JP.
1008&
This Notice of AppooI, when rocol",d by the Di.'rle' Jultic., will oporo'. o. a
SUPfRSlDEAS 10 tho Juc9nont !of pou.ulan In thl. cOla
"lit,
] MAQWr~~NA~cwa~
Susan K. Da I 09-3-03
5 Ii I IPCODI
I>I\ 17033
ILlIIIwlde1tJ
Auto Bod
I appel/ant was CAlMANT (see Pa. R.c.P.J,P. No.
1001(6) In acllon before District Justice, he MUST
FILE A COMPLAINT Within twenty (20) days after
filing his NOTICE 01 APPEAL.
SlgnaILnJ 01 ProIhanoINy or Deputy
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
(This seetlon 0I1onn 10 be used ONLY when appellant was DEFENDANT Isee Po, R,C.P.J,P_ No. 100117) In eel/on belrxe District Justlce_
IF NOT USED, detach /rom c",y 01 notice 01 appeal to be served upon appellee),
PRAECIPE. To Prothonotary
En'" ruIo upon
. oppellee(.). 10 filo a complaint In thl. appeal
_0I_1oo(8}
(Canrnan Pleas fob
) within twenty (20) day. oflw _vic. of rulo or .uffor on'ry of Judgrnont of non prao.
RULE. To
5ir118Iln 01 _ Of his l""""'v Of __
_0I_"}
, oppellee(.).
(1) You ore nolified that a ruIo b hereby onlerod upon you 10 filo a cOfllllain' in this appeal within twenty (20) day. oflw the date of
a.vlc. of thI. rule upon you by penanal servlc. or by certified or rogi.lenld mail
(2) If you do not file a complaint within this limo. a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WIll BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU.
(3) Tho dot. of sorvic:. of thl. ruIo If servlco was by moil i. the date of moiling.
Date:
.19_.
5ir118Iln 01 _.... y a 00IxAy
1lCIPC31:l...
" ,
'-81'-
UO ..Jld.e UQ'''IWWOO AW
"I:JflJOIO 'flfJ..
'P'W "Ail "','PW' WOll'" .JO/.q I'I'WO 10 .Jm.Ua/S
,U_/II'IO eJn"ulJ,S
-S~ ' ~O Alia SIH!
3~ 31:l0H8 03811:l::JS8ns ONII (03~1:l1~~1I) NI:lOMS
'010J04 P040BIIB Id,oOBJ 8,JOpU08 'lIew
(poJo'8,BoJ) (PBUIlJOO) ~q 0 001^J081BU08Jod ~q 0 -6~ . UO p0880JppB 8BM olnl:l 041
WOl/M 01 (1)8lIlIodde 841 uodn IBOddll'o BOIlON O^OqB 04IBu'~UBdwOOOB'U'B,dwo::J B 811~ 0lBlnl:l041 PO^J081'B41 J041Jn, pUB 0
'OlaJ04 P840BIIB,d1000J 8,JOpU88 'IIBW (pOJOI8IBoJ) (pOUIlJOO) ~q 0 00,^,08,BU08JBd ~q o--6~ '
Uo' (8WOU) 'OOlloddo 04' uodn puo '0'0'04 p040Bll0 IdlOOOJ
I,JOpU88 '"BW (POJOIS,BoJ) (pOIIIIJOO) ~q 0 801^J08 10UOSJod ~q 0 '-6~ . (801MOS10 olep)
uo U,OJ041 POIBUB'80P 001l8nr '01'18'0 04' uodn ' 'oN sso'd UOWWO::J ',Boddll '0 oOlloN 041'0 ~doo B 0
P"^JOS I 1041 WJ!),B JO JBOMS ~qOJ04 I :~IAVal::l::lV
II ! ~o A!NnOO
YINY^'ASNN3d ~o HllY3MNOWWOO
(88.0q 8/qoo!/ddo ,0040 ',ooddolO 801/0U 841 BUI/I11:l31ilt SA 'to (Ot) N31 N/Hl/M o31/i 38 lsnw 80/MO.10 1001d '/41)
~NIV1dWOO 311::1 O~ 31ml aNV 1V3ddV ::10 301~ON :10 30lAI:I3S ::10 ::IOOl:ld
~ .... ?-
..:1 -~ f
M .;:~
r ,~ ',7' i]' i
@ it u: ';1:
);:l
(~ '" '. ~r.; 'S. ~ 0-
I- "R-t C" (r
(~. lZ
,- t.5 In " LfJ \!) V'
fEU, ~- .It (lI d v
e--
~ ...:) ;;fQ" '" 0 r<"
.., 0 l(\ vi
b ..~ f;
.... ,:> ::r -. ;1
<'''' <.J oJ
,'Ij. .. ~ ,,;;
u
- ,
.,.-
NOTICE OF JUDGMENTITRANSCRIPT
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
.... 0I0L No. ,
PLAINTIFF: ...................
GONES, JAMES A
ROUTE 743, P.O. BOX 982
HERSHEY, PA 17033
L.
VS.
OEFENOANT: NNolE.... ACllIlUlI
rcLARK'S AUTO BODY-OWNER I BARRY
1308 PINE RD.
CARLISLE, PA 17013
L.
Docket No.: CV-0000312-95
Date Flied: 11120/95
09-3-03
DJ.......:Hoft.
SUSAN K. DAY
- 229 MILL S'!'REET, BOX 167
NT. HOLLY SPRINGS, PA
T~,~171 486-7672 17065
JAMES A. JONES
ROUTE 743, P.O. BOX 982
HERSIIEY, PA 17033
TlfIS IS TO NOTiFY YOU TlfAT:
Judgment:
00 Judgment was entered lor: (Name)
l!l Judgment was ontered against: (Name)
In the amount 01 $ .00
D Judgment was entered against
LandlordlTenant action In the amount 01 $ on
The amount of rent per month, as established by the District Justice. Is $
D Damages will be assessed on: (Date & Time)
vnR n~F~NOANT ---
CLARK'S AUTO BODY-OWNER I BARRY CLARK
JONES , JAMES A - FAILED TO APPEAR AT HEARING
on: (Dale 01 Judgment) 5/15/96
Ina
. (Dale of Judgment)
Rent In arrears $
Damages Unjust Detenllon $
Damages to Propertyl
Residential Lease: S
Less Ami Due Delendant - S
Amount 01 Judgment .. S
Judgment Costs $
Interest on Judgment S
Attorney Fees S
D This case dismissed wllhout preJudice.
D possession granted.
D possession granted ~ money judgment Is not
satlslled by lime of eviction.
D possession not granted.
D Levy Is steyed lor days or D generally stayed.
D Objection to levy has been flied and hearing will be held:
Dale: Place:
TOTAL
$
Time:
ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL A JUDGMENT INVOLVING A RESIDENTIAL LEASE AND AFFECTING THE
THE riA TE OF JUDGMENT BY FILING A
RT OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION.
.,," '" '
E T INVOLVING A NONRESIDENTIAL Ll!ASE
A NonCE OF,APPEAL WITH THE
!VISION.
, District Jusllce
eedlngs containing the judgment.
, District Jusllce
SEAL
AOPC 3' S-1l6
..,
-'
CLAR~
-'
.00
.00
.00
.00
.00
_4>
C_IAUlfOl 'INNlYLVAHIA
cOllin 01 COMMoH 'LIAS
NOTICE OF APPEAL
fROM
IUOIeIAL DIIII'CT
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMON'LlAIN.. Q(o-3345 G,,', ITer""
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice It g/wn that the oppellcn' h," filed in ,he aboYe CaLKt of Cammon Pleas an appeal from ,he judgment rendotwd by ,he Di.trlcl Justlc. an the
.... and In the COle _lIiaoltd ~
NAMlQII"""'-LANT
J.. A. Jon..
"lwaue. ~
Route 7.3, P. O. Box 982, Hershey
I
"l:II'Y'-
rMJD. "".HO 01 ""... '" OJ
BUlan K. D~YI 09-3-03
TlTl ,. COOl
M 17033
fLWlrtdlrfJ
Clark's Auto Bod
.
May 15, 1996
Jll/IIes A. Jones
'"
IlONA 1
tv [/tt#(
CV II! 0000312-95
LT 19
ThI& blade wiI be olgnod ONlY when this notation i. required undo. Po. R-CP JP_ No\.
10088.
ThI& Nolle. of Appoal, when rocoiYOd by the Oiotrict .N.tie.. will aptRlt. as a
suPERSEDEAS ta the judgment fat pauo"ian In this c.....
SigJaIllo 01 Prothonotary ex Deputy
appellant was CAlMANT (see Pa. R.c.P.J.P. No.
tOOt (6) In action before DIstrict Justice, he MUST
FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after
filing his NOTICE of APPEAL.
(ThIs 68etlon of fonn to be used ONLY when appellant was DEFENDANT Isee Pa. R,C,P_J,P, No. 1001f7) in action beloro District Justice.
IF NOT USED. c/etach from cqlY 0/ notice 0/ appeal to be served /JfJOfI appellee).
PRAECIPE, To Prothcnalary
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
"
EnIor rule upon
:., ---.. "-j,oppolfee(,),to IiIe 0 Cl1"1PIainlln this appeal
Nlme oIlJf:JJ811oo(s} / :"'A."i,~'Qj(~ .~~{. :"fl:i.tN. ,.,t;:';~'j'! I '
) within twenty (20) days ~:~~e? ~'Q,' W!f!i{'P?krajiudgmont of non ""'"
(Cammon PIeos No.
RULE, To
SigI8IIIt 01 -., 01 ",. BIi>mey 01 _
-oI~sJ
. appe/lee(s).
III You ant noflfitd that a rule It "-by enlerod upon you to file a complaint in this appeal within twenty (20) days aflor the date of
IIrVice of this rule '''''" you by penanal service or by clftifitd or registered maiL
(3) Tho date of sorvlce of this rule if ."vice was by mGills the dolt of mailing.
(2) If you do not file a complaint within this time, a JUDGMeNT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINsrt~OU.;.:j
.19_.
~..","'u
!:i
_, ":i'\
~oI_""'r Ot Deputy
-; ,j
i:l]
I
.'J
ICfIC Jt,...
.. ,
;,""'.' .':,
,,\.. i
~. ,,",.' ",
"
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
(Thl' proof o( ..,vlc. MUST BE FILED WITHIN TEN r 10) VA YS AFTER IiIlIIg '110 II0"CO 01 oppo.'. Ch.ck .pplicab/o bO..')
, ~.
CO....ONWIAL7t' PINNSYLVANIA" , :\
COUNTY 0' tl hi # 1!..L !l-fU..J.J
;11
AFFI DAVIT: I hereby Iweer or .lIlrm that I lerved _ /J
I:i:Va copy at the Notice 01 Appeal. ,C9mmon ,gle.s No, 9~-, ~3!1-!:r( LI~on the Dlslrlcl JUltlce dellgnated thareln on
Id",olurVlc'I'/'A.JLI 1':::1- ,19..!'tt-, 0 b esono!"ervlce (cerlllled}(r gllter~~)m~II, ander'l'
receipt altlched hqreto, a~t UMlO thOlppellee, (nama)'" ,'; on,
r.'.,," ',,' - \J.u"... ,<,,;' ,19 by p.rsonallervIC~bY (certified) (regletered) mall. lender'l r8celpt."t1ached'~,ere,o,
o Ind further l/1aU lerved the Rule to File e Complaint eccompenylng Ihe above Notice of Appeal upon the'appellee(l) to whom,
the Rule w8IaddrOlled 00_ , 19~ 0 by personallervlce 0 by (certified) (reglltered)
mall. lendar', recelptaltached hereto_
c,,'
\,\\'.,'
SWORN (AFFI MED) AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME
THIS ~, DAY' -()[.Ur.)"', lli%
, .
" , . SIIIIII/ur. olll/l.n/,
; ,\ I '.1.~ ~ <, :,\\i\
",'.,'
rill. ololl1G1.1
P 282 348 824
~ Receipt for
- Certified Mall
'.. l'ou Insuruncc COVOfflllO P,ovidel'
~I'''''''' Dv nol usu lur International MOl
"''''.",...'
ISm! Rtl\lor~ul
.
~~. >en' I: .")-t. -,~, -ii ~ ,-;
0 -
II -~?
.. t>.
.:I ..).~
5")
:!l: -:,:
Q.. ,~
'1'~"I"I'l , " tf'. .:r '(YJ
- . i'!ji
It, "]
.....- "'~
id, "'
1'" "
~l ,.0 '\
"'-. Q
l :"1. ',\ I,
l' ,{, ",!"
j
",' ,.f..
"
m
'"
/, dJ
..,
,
,
"
$ y, :J;?
o "
o
'"
M
.
,-; ,ft{,0~
'Ii
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA 9~ -- 331, ~
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
.... lllol No.'
09-3-03
OJ......:Hol\.
SUSAN 1<. DAY
~. 229 MILL STREET, BOX 167
NT. HOLLY SPRINGS, PA
T_ (717) 486-7672
17065
SUSAN 1<. DAY
229 MILL STREET, BOX 167
MT. HOLLY SPRINGS, PA 17065
COMMON PLEAS NOTIFICATION
PLAltfllFF REQ~:.!:l~RM
GONES, JAMES A I
ROUTE 743, P.o. BOX 982
HERSHEY, PA 17033
L ~
VS.
DEFENOAtfl: ......... AOORE88
I(:LARJ(' S AUTO BODY-OWNER: BARRY CLAR~
1308 PtNE RD.
CARLISLE, PA 17013
L ~
OocketNo,: CV-0000312-95
Osla Flied: 11/20/95
Dlsposnlon Dale: 5/15/9 6
PI.... be a,lvIHd thaI an appa.1 h.. ba.n fII.d In tho abov. capUoned c..., Kindly u,.thl, form to Indlcata Ih. r.,uh,
In Ihlo c.... and rllum 10 Ih.lllulng authority (lI,t.d .bov.).
RESULT OF APPEAL Common PI'.. Judgo
SUMMARY APPEAL
APPEAL STRICKEN. appaal h.. be.n dillllow.d,
_ APPEAL DISCOtfllNUEO -appaal ha' be.n di,conUnu.d by appallant.
DISTRICT JUSTICE OECISION UPHELD - court hll roach.d .aml d.cl,lon a. o~gin.1 dl,~lcl Ju,tlc. d.el,lon,
_ dl,tllot ju,UcI offica 1.10 celllct romllnlng fln.oIco,t"
APPEAL SUCCESSFUL - court hll rlach.d dlcl'lon tlvor.bl.lo dllondant.
tull rolund to be IlIuad by dl,~lot ju'tlca offica,
partlal rolund to be la.uad by dl,trlctju,Uca offlel,
REVISED OISTRIBUTION OF FINES ANO COSTS
tf dlatrlct IUltlc' office I' to '"UI . partial r.fund, plaue Indicate any new diltrlbutlon In the amount(.)
of fin.. and COlta .. . ,"uh of the court', decision.
FINE
COUNTY CRT COST
STATE CRT COST
STATE CST!
HEARING COST
OTHER(pl.... ,paclty)
EMS
CAT
JCP
OVC
CNC
CCO
CIVIL - LANDLORDfTENANT APPEAL
APPEAL STRICKEN. appaal hll baln dl,allowad,
APPEAL DISCONTINUED - appaal h.. beon dl,contlnuod by app.llant.
DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION UPHELO . eourt ha' roachod tha 'ama dacl,lon a,tha dl,~lcl Ju,Ucojudgmont,
DISTRICT JUSTICE OECISION OISMISSEO . court ha, roachod I docl,lon Ihat do.. nol concur wllh Iha dl,trlot ju,tlclludgm.nt.
WRIT OF CERTIORARI
WArT STRICKEN. appa.1 ha, boon di,allowld,
WAfT OISCOtflINUEO. wrll ha' bean dl,conUnuod by appall ant,
DISTRICT JUSTICE DECISION SET ABIDE _ tha ca,a will ba rohoard duato Irr.gularlty. lack of jurl,dlcUon, or Improp.r Vlnua,
WRfT DlSMISSEO. di,lrlcllu,Uco docl,lon w., nollound to ba flawod, lacking jurl,dlctlon . or h.ving Impropll vonUl,
BTATEMENT OF OBJECTION (Plaa.. glva a g.noralaummary 01 Ih. r..ulI.)
OBJECTION OISCONTlNUED . objocUon ha' ba.n di,conUnuod by tho .ppoll.nt,
OBJECTION DENIEO . obj.ctlon h., beon doni.d by tho Court 01 Common Pl....
OBJECTION UPUELO . .ppollanl" obj.clion hll boon uphold by Iho Court 01 Common PI....
AOPC 7N."
FORM PRINTED:
6/19/96
8147:50
c:\wpSl\<rlmlnal\jon..,rom me # 4'J.I-I.'Ko-I'1
JAMES A. JONES,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNlY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 96- ,331 IS CIVIL ACTION
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plalnlllt
va.
BARRY CLARK, t/b/d/a,
CLARK'S AUTO BODY,
Defendant
IN ASSUMPSIT
NQ.IlC.E
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth In
the following pages,you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and notice
are served by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing In writing with the
Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you
fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by
the Court without further notice for any money claimed In the Complaint or for any other claim or
relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT
HAVE A LAWVER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP:
COURT ADMINISTRATOR, FOURTH FLOOR
CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT HOUSE
ONE COURTHOUSE SQUARE
CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA 17013
(717) 240-6200
FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY
AUornafor the Plaintiff
I
By U
Carol
ID # 69
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243.5513
VERIFICA lJ.QN
The undersigned, CAROL J. LINDSAY, avers that the facts set forth In the foregoing
Instrument, based upon information and belief, were developed from conversations with Plaintiff and
Information gained In the investigation of this file, and this Verification is made for the reason that
Plaintiff Is outside of the Jurisdiction of the Court, and that his Verification could not be obtained
within the time allowed for the filing of this pleading, and this Verification Is made subject to the
penalties of 18 Pa, C.S. ~4e04, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
FLOWER, MORGENTHAL FLOWER & LINDSAY, PC,
Attorneys for Plaintiff
By:
Carol J, Lindsay, Esquire
ID # 44693
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-5513
Date:
.,
....... -."""""..--......... '-- . .-. .........,... ......
IZ~
Speclallzu IIJ Fiberglass
C)LARK'S A UTO BOD l'
1308 Pine Road
Carlisle, PA 17013
Phone 486-4151
a....A. IJ_ ,_
Co' c::r
ADORESS 1Ji1] 'tr?. I ~ r " I/.'.A / Q J'7, "?,
YEU . MAKE" MOOr(, , c;:mOY
/~ q...::J .l::" ___ '" -r:... - I
,
OWNER
DATE .7 - > 1- rS-
lAJ ..;zY s-- .S""rr 17
~HONE J-/ ~..i'ff': ;'79 -7 J
SERIAL NO,
LICEhSE NO,
IoIILHG[
- -.c.
J C ~ 1. ;:)":? 1 JIJlJ."'~ ~..,U~
HOURS LAlOR ~ARrS
SUIlLET/NET
I FENS
/,..- .J~ /
V fI' jf~
/~ - ~ A '"Jf ",.IJ. _ _
. 'i.-I..~p/_ ..,.I ..,,2 II u
/
'ilD. frI'" 4( / 'I
'1'10 A.1t.
F!J. S- ./.,
;J u _~,!A-"UJ
7
J .-
-:I.-
..,~ C A..
~ ?\
,
./J .-
~l~.Lr, / y ~7/X~-/
/ -Irljj A~' .;
-, A
e;c ,;o/~
~ , c;: " . lJ .)
Q -./
r ,.
SUB TOTAL
,.. 1Iftt.....,. .. ..... _ _ l._ _._.... ........ ..,.. ....TMMM. PAn. OIl
~ ___ .....y .. ....,.... ..,... nt. ..... .... ....... nAaTtD. ."... TN' ...-.
.... nMna, __ ... ~...... ...1nS ..... .... MeT ........,. _ PI"" I~acn'" .....,
- ..-n:.... ....ftIatoU,y "... unMAn ~ OIIV'" ..... ~_"'I", ...~
....... ~.... .......... ~ ...-nca. lMlI IITI...ua t. ..... .....Ul.". IoOC....,AlCL
LAeoR
PARTS
SUBLETINET
TAX
I,..') t; ..
-'--- -
,I,
ITEMS '( tJrr au
~-a '1'.
~~~ -:"
THI. waNte AUTHO..IUD ay
1ST/MATI SHEIT
~.. ;. ., v
, TOTAL
Q'3 ClUj
(;}
'- ':>,
ft.
,,,:::: -
IJ: I~ ") ..;r
1/' --. '.';
"" '4~. ::,.
'.
r , I =i
. I.:.' C\/ >.
". I '. \'~
Ci:1'! )~
t::J lip;
r-: '-'j'
IJ ".' t.
l') ~,
.-:J
0, ()
6. Denied. All work done by Defendant was performed in a
reasonable workmanlike manner consistent with reasonable standards
and customs for the body repair industry.
7. Denied. Plaintiff made no mention of damages nor did he
make repeated demands for payment until Defendant initiated
proceedings against Plaintiff.
NEW MA~
B. At the initial meeting between Plaintiff and Defendant,
on or about July 31, 1995, Plaintiff requested that Defendant
repair certain front end damage to a 1992 Ford Tempo.
9. Defendant visually inspected the damage to which
Plaintiff referred.
10. At said meeting, Defendant provided Plaintiff a written
estimate based exclusively upon the front end damage apparent on
the vehicle itself.
11. After Defendant prepared the said estimate, Plaintiff
stated that he might also want the entire car repainted and requested
a quote.
12. Defendant quoted a price of $550.00 for said additional
work and noted same upon the estimate.
13. Plaintiff did not agree to or authorize any work at the
time of the presentation of the said estimate.
14. On or about August 3, 1995, plaintiff telephoned
Defendant and stated that he wanted the front end repairs done
and authorized Defendant to order the parts needed.
15. Approximately five days later, Defendant called
Plaintiff on the telephone to advise him that the parts were
delivered.
16. At said time Plaintiff also asked Defendant to inspect
his vehicle.
17. Defendant declined to inspect the vehicle because he is
not licensed for this service.
18. Defendant advised plaintiff that Sam and Jerry's garage
would handle the inspection and service at plaintiff's expense if
he wanted it done.
19. Plaintiff stated that he wanted the inspection done and
that he would take care of the bill.
20. Plaintiff authorized Defendant to pick up the vehicle
and perform the needed repairs and inspection.
21. Defendant's employees picked up the vehicle at the
medical center parking lot.
22. After commencing repairs, Defendant discovered that
additional parts had been damaged.
23. Plaintiff Jones called to inquire as to the status of the
repairs and Defendant told him that additional parts were needed,
which he would provide at cost.
24. plaintiff stated "Ok".
25. At the time Defendant, by his employees, picked up
Plaintiff's vehicle the steering column was in a damaged condition
and the top molded plastic casement was held in place by a large
hose clamp and the lower case was missing.
26. Defendants employee Richard Clark spoke on the telephone
with Plaintiff and mentioned the steering column and hose clamp.
27. Plaintiff stated to Richard Clark that the column was
broken and that he, Plaintiff, had put the clamp on it.
28. Upon the commencement of work, Defendant's employees
discovered dAmage which appeared to been previously partially
repaired.
29. Defendant believes and therefore avers that Plaintiff'e
vehicle had been involved in previous collisions and had
sustained prior damage.
30. Defendant properly completed the front end repairs to
Plaintiff's vehicle.
31, Defendant took the vehicle to Sam and Jerry's garage and
it was repaired and inspected as requested by Plaintiff.
32. Defendant delivered the repaired and inspected vehicle
to Plaintiff on August 22, 1995.
33. Plaintiff briefly examined the vehicle and stated that
he was satisfied with the work and the invoice presented.
34. At said time, Plaintiff issued a check for payment
in full without reservation, exception, or condition.
35. The aforeeaid check dated August 22, 1995, was
returned to Defendant as dishonored due to insufficient funds.
36. Defendant advised Plaintiff of the check's dishonor and
Plaintiff initially promised to make the check good and pay the
sum demanded.
37. Plaintiff failed to make payment and after approximately
a week Plaintiff advised that he would not pay the invoice for
the reason that Defendant had replaced the key to the car during
the work.
38. Defendant had in fact replaced the keys at his expense
because he was un3ble to locate Plaintiff's keys.
39. The replacement keys were correct and in no way caused
loss, inconvenience, or damage to the vehicle or Plaintiff.
COUNTERCLAIM
BARRY CLARK t/d/b/a CLARK'S AUTO BODY VS. JAMES A. JONES
40. Paragraphs 1 - 39 are incorporated herein.
41. Defendant believes and therefore avers that Plaintiff
Jones wilfully and intentionally defrauded Defendant as follows:
A. Plaintiff Jones solicited Defendant to estimate
partial repairs to a vehicle known by him to have
additional damage with intent to claim said
additional damage as a means of evading payment.
B. Plaintiff Jones solicited a written estimate then
verbally requested additional work with intent
to evade payment.
C. Plaintiff Jones issued a worthless check to secure
possession of the repaired and inspected vehicle
intending to evade payment later.
D. Plaintiff Jones has made a spurious claim for
damages with intent to carry out his original
scheme to defraud Defendant Clark.
WHEREFORE, Defendant requests jUdgment against Plaintiff as
follows:
A. $1248.28 for services rendered per the contract;
B. Reasonable counsel fees;
C. Punitive damages for intentional fraud.
Date 7 - 2. "Z -cr6
~fU11Y Submitted,
412i.~q&
Attorney for the Defendant
One West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717)243-1083
Supreme Court ID 06362
f1le~
JAMES A. JONES,
Plaintiff
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 96 - 3345 CIVIL ACTION
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
BARRY CLARK Ud/b/a
CLARK'S AUTO BODY,
Defendant
PRAECIPE
TO PROTHONOTARY:
Please mark the captions case settled and discontinued.
FLOWER, FLOWER & LINDSAY, P.C,
Attorneys for Plaintiff
By:
Car J. Indsay, Esquire
ID# 93
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-5513
"
Ir;
If}
'.
1.....
r:
I.
t..
rr,
Cf.
"i
C)
'-
,..
-.
t'f)
lC
f':-
',--.
III
r'/,
~ :.:
,.
~')
i.:
'-.
, ,
, ~ ::J
r
l'
v. .'
11- rr, U
Cl C."
"
JAMES A. JONES,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Vs.
: No, 96-3345 Civil Action
: CIVIL ACTION. LA W
BARRY CLARK tJd/b/a
CLARK'S AUTO BODY
Defendant
PRAECIPE
TO: CURTIS R. LONG, PROTHONOTARY:
Please mark the above case settled and discontinued.
Date: September 14, 1999
Edwar . Harker, Esquire
Atto ey for the Defendant
On West High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
..... '~') I~~
, .. I'.
1 1 , "
, . r
, ";'1
... , r-.'
" '. ,
I.: C. I; ,j
"J l...l_
, Vi ..
IJ ,,, ::j
u oJ' U