HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-03536
,
~
,
,
I
,
/
,;/
I"' '
.~
\-..
J
her if he found her with someone el~e, When the defendllnt let her
go /lnd wunt uplltlllnl. the plllintiff fellrml hu WII/l !!oin!! tn get hill
gun /lml shu therefnru c:ullucted hur chi Idrcn IInd luft thu hume to
avnid furthul' IIhuse, Thu pl/lintiff filud IIn illcidunt ruporl with
the I'llI'I islu I'ul i,,!, IInd the defcndllnt WIIS IIrrested, ehllrged with
/Iimple 1lI1HIIUlt, IIn<l rutullsud Oil his re'Ol.\1IiZlln'e, A pn!llminllry
hellring is schedulurl hcfor~ District Justice I'urrenl on July 10,
1'1<)6, III 'l:.10 lI,m,
hI On or IIhout M'lY ~, 1'1'16, lifter thu plllint i ff told the
defendllnt to I~/Ivc the home, hc first Hlllmmud the telephonll down IInrl
then thruw It lit her. Thu plllintiff dodged the tclephone tu IIvold
being Htl"u,k, Thu defendllllt left the mnritnl reHidun,e on thiH d/Ile
IInel hns beun residing with his mothur lit her I'eHidcncu sin,c then,
See Exhibit A, ill,orpol'lltud hy referellce,
c) In or Ilhollt ApI'i I, 19%, the defendnnt threlltened to throw the
telephone lit the plllintiff lI"rI then did throw it lit her, The
plaintiff dod!!l'd the telephone to nvnid heing strllek,
dl In or lIJ'l)und Septumhel', l'l'l~, thc dcfendnnt tried to keep the
plaintiff from lellving th~ homl' hy pllll ing her enr keys out of the
ignition IInd slllpping lieI' nn the tirOl,
e) In or IIrnund July, 1992, the defendllnt pushed nnd shoved the
pluintiff nhoul. The plllinliff telephoned the CllrliHle Police,
5. On or nhout June 18, l'l'lh, the plllintiff /lOd the three minor chi Idren
left their residen,e lit 148 ^ Street, I'tlrlhle, Cumherlllnd County, Pennsylvllnill,
in order to Rvoid further IIbuse,
2
II, Thl! pllllnt i,.,. bl!1 Il!Yl!N IIntl thl!rl!fol'l! IlYl!rH thllt Hhl! l!l In Immeelllltl!
IUtd prl!Hl!lIt e1l1n~er of IIhuHe frum the defclldllnt Nh~lUld Nhe l'eturn tu the homl!
without the dl!fl!lIdllnt'N ex,luHlunllnd thllt Nhl! III In neeel of prutl!ctlun fl'OIn such
IIhUNl! ,
7, Thl! plllintlff IIl!slres thill, ttll! dl!fl!II<llIlIt he prohibited frum hllvlng
IIny llirect or Imlirl!ct ,untllct with the plalntll'f Induding, hut not Illnitl!d to,
telellhonl! 'Inel writtl!n ClllnlllUnklltillllS, except fur the Ilmitl!e1 purpose of
file i I i tot ing cUHtody IIl'l"IIJI-!,!mentN,
8, The pl/llntiff desircN thlll tbe defl!ndllnl be enjoined from hllrllssing
IInd Ntlllking the plointlff, IInd from hllrllsHing her \'ellltivl!1l IInd thl! minor
chi Idrell,
I), The plointiff desirl!N thllt the e1efcndllnt he enjoined from removing,
dllmnglng, deNtroylng or Hell illg IIny pruperty owned joint ly by the part les or
owncd by the plaint I 1'1',
10. The plllintiff desircs thllt the rifle thllt the dcfendant owns be
confiscated by the Sheriff's Ilcpllrlment.
IJ L_BK~J,!111!YfL !.~I)I!l~'lJ'HOO
II, The home from which Ihe pl"jnt I ff is liNking the Court to exclude the
defcndant ill rented in the nllm"s of ll<lIlnll Mile Engle IInd .Jerry Alan Engle. Thc
plaint i 1'1' is not seeking the evict iun of the defendant frum his eurnmt
residence, wherc he hilS h~en I ivIng with his mother since Ilpproximlltely May 8,
1996,
12. The plllint iff ellncnt Iy hllN no plllce to stllY wi th her chi Ielren eXccllt
the mad till home,
.1
H/lIIII
Und i Ilel osed
Plalntlfr, Melnnlc,
'Nhl tney, IInd Ilrnndon Mllrl In,
pluintirf'H son
Pllllnt I 1'1', dcfendllnt,
Me I nn Ie, Whl tney, Jlmnd\lII,
ChI' lilt I rill I.ynll, pili I lit i fr'/i
ndlJ 1 t dnughlcr
pl'llnllrf, r1efendallt,
Mellin I Il, Wh I tiley, Brnnrloll
8/1l1 chI' I sl I n'l
Pllllnt Irf, derendllnl,
Mellin Ie, Wh I tney, Jll'Ilndon,
(~rIHtlnll, and defcndllnt's
(lllrenls, Almll IInd (icorge Engle
Plulnt iff, derendnnt,
Melunie, Whllney, Brandon,
nnd Christina
pluintlfr, defendllnt,
Melanie, Jlrandon, and
Christina
plllintlrf, defendant,
Melanill, IImndon, und
ChI' I st inll
Nl!Jnmllllll IJIIllH:I
und I Ill; IllHlId Junll IH, 19'1b
to thl! prllHlInt
I..H A Slrllllt MIlY H, 1 'I'll>
Cur I Is Ic, PA to Junc Ill, 1'I'Ib
I..H A S t rllll t DtlclImber, 1995
Carllslc, PA to ~IIY H, 1'196
2056 Spr i ng Illllld
Cllrllslll, I'A
September. 1995
to Decembcr, 1995
205t> Spr I ng ROllll
CllrllHlc, PA
Murch, 1995
to Oecember. 1995
1356 Grundv I cw court
Cllrllslc, PA
,June 15, 1992
to Murch. 1995
Mllrch, 1991
to Junll 14, 19'12
September 4, 1990
to Murch, 1991
1356 Grnndvlew Court
Carllslc, I'A
2BI East Pomfret Street
Curllsle, pA
Thc plnintlff, the mother of the children, is Donna Mne Engle, currently
nhus~.
residing III lln undischmed IOl'lltion 1'01' her protection 1111<1 to avoid further
She Is mllfr lcd,
undisclosed to protect hilI' safety.
The Identity of tbe perS(lns the plaintiff is temporarily re~ilcllng wl.th is
5
The dufendnnt, lhu fathur of the chlldrun, III Jerry Allin li/lglll, c:ul'I"llntly
rllsidlng lit I WUllt I'enn IHrullt, Apl. 52, I:llrll/lle, CumlJerland County,
(lennllY I vlln I /I.
lhl 1/1 m/ll'l"led.
The dufundllnt currently re/iidulI with hili mOlher, Almll Engle,
17, The plflintHf hllll lIot preVluusly pllrlidllllted in /lny litiglllion
c:onct!rnlnl! ClI/ito,'y of the IIhovt.! mentioned chlldnHl in thlll or /lny other Court,
IH, The (lllIint I ff hils nil knowl~dl!e of IIny l'u/itody pro,ueding/i concerning
thest! children pending Iwforu II 'OUft in thl.~ Of Hny other jurisdictl<m,
"}, TIll: pllllnll 1'1' c/IlCH JIllt know Ill' IIny (lerson l10t Ii pllrly to this fiction
who has physicnl ~ustody of tlw dilldr~l1or cllll,"s to hllvt.! cUlltoc/y or vlsitlltion
rights with rUllpe,t to tile ,hi "'ren,
20, The hu,'l int<)J'ustll 11IId pennllnent wel fllre of the minor chi Idren wi II
he'llet If cUlitudy Is tem(Xlrllrlly grnnlec/ to the plllintlff pending II hellring In
this matter for re/lS0/15 inclUding:
II. The pllllntiff Is 1I responsible parent who can he5t
tuke efire of the minor ,hi Idrun, und has provided for
the emotionlll IInd phYIlICIII needs of the children since
their bl rtbs,
h, The de fefJllllnt hllli shown by his IIhuse of the
plaint iff thllt he ill not 1111 lIpproprlllte role model for
the minor ,hi Idrun,
c, The dufendllllt'lI beh/wior hilS ndverseJy affected
the chi Idren,
6
II'JIERI'.I'llRE. llurllulUlt to tho prllvlslons of tho "Protect Illn frllm Ahulle Act"
of October 7,1'1711,2.1 II,S, ~f"OI 111 ~,I!!l,. "" IIm(!,uled, the llllllntlff prays this
1I0nol'/lble ('ourt tlllll'll/It the follllwlnH rellefr
^, Ol'llnl II 'J'empllrllry Order purllllllnt to the "PnHed ion fmm Abuse
Ad:"
t. Ordering the defel/dllnt to refrllln fmlll IIhulling the
pllllnt Iff or plllclnl! her In fCllr of nhllse~
2, Onlerlnl! the defcndllnt to refrnin frllll1 hllving nny direct
or Indirect contncl with the lllllinUff InclUding. hut not
Ilmltcd to, telellholll' nnd wrlttcn communiclltions, exc:ept to
flld I i tllte ,uHtody IIITllnl!clllentll1
3. Ordering the defendllnt tll refrnin frolll hnraslllng nnd
Iltlllklng the plllilltiff IIl1d from hllrllslllng her rolntlves and
the lIIinor children;
4, Prohlhltlng the def~ndllnt from removing. damnging,
delltrllyinll or 11011 ing properly jointly OWOt!l1 hy the partieI'> or
owned by the plaintiff;
5. Grnntlng [Xlssesllion of the home located lit 148 A Street,
Cllrlillle, C'umherlnnd County, Permsylvllnill, to the plllintiff to
the exclusion of the defendant, IInd ordering the defendant to
stllY /lwny from /lny residence the plaintiff mny establish for
hersel f pending 11 flnlll order III this mlltter;
6, Ordering the defendant to provide I'>uitnhle alternate
housin!! I'm the pllllntiff IInd the mlnm children;
7
7, Ol"lIlltlllll tcmpornry custody of the Pllrtles' mlnol"
children, Melllnie Jellll Engle IInd Whltll~y Nicoll! hng)u, to the
pllllr,tlff,lInd
1\, onlurlllll till! dl!fl!wlllnt tu rellnqul/;h to the sheriff's
dep/lrtmcnt his r I fll.', 1I1le! prllhllli t inl! the defendllnt from
/l(;quiring or posscsllillllllny othur wellpons for the duration of
the order.
Il. Schedulu n hCllring In ncconlnncu with the provisions of the
"Protect Ion from ^bus~ Act," IllId, nfLur such hunring, cntel' nn order to be In
effect for n p~rlod of une yellr:
(, Ordering the dcfenrlllnt to refr/lln fl'om abusing the
pl/lllltiff or plnelnl! h~r In fellr of nllusu,
2, Ordering t.hu ddundllnt to refruin from hnvlng IIny dircct
or indlred cOlltnd with the plrlintiff inclUding, but Ill)t
limited to, tulepholle IInd wri tLun comlllunicnt ions, except to
fllcilltlltu custudy IIrmnguments,
;1, Ordering the dcfcndnnt to refrain from hnJ'fislling Ilnd
stnlklng thl.' plnint i fr IInd from hlll'llssing her relat lves and
the minor chi Idnm,
4, Prohibiting tb.! defendnnt from removing, damaging,
destroying or sui I ing pf'llperty juintly owned by the pllrties or
owned by thl.' plaint i ff,
5. llrnnt illg possession of the home IO~lItetl at 148 ^ Street,
Cllrlisle, CUlllhurI ane! County, Pennsylvania, to the plaintiff to
thc cxc:lu:;ion uf the d~rcndunt, und urdcrlng the defendnnt to
Il
IItny nwny from /lny ,.c~ldcnce the plllllltlff mllY Illltnbllsh for
hers.!! f pClIlljng Il flnnl ordcr In thili mnttcl' ,
6. Clnlering the defendllnl to relinquish to the nheriff'li
dtll'nl'tmcnt his rifle, IInd l'rohihiling the defondnnt from
Ilc'lulrlng or poslielisingllllY olhcr wClIl'ons for lh" durution of
thc Ordur,
7, Ordering tbe lldcndnnt to reimbursc the (lllllntlff'n out-
of-pocket 10lisCIi suffercd liS II rc.~ult of the IlbuliC inclUding
but not I Iml ted to th.. losscs Illitcd on the nttnched sheet
mnrked Exhlbl t A,
R. Ordcring thc ddendnnt to PIlY $250.00 to Cumberlnod
County, one of Lcg/Ii Servicc:;, Inc, 'Ii funding sour,cs, In 1 leu
of nttol'l1l.'Ys' fees, liS rcimburscmcnt for the cost of
litigating this <:nli~, the $25,00 liurchnrgc, nnd nny court
,osts If the cllse goes to hCllring,
Thc plnint i ff further IIsks thnt this Pet i t ion be filed lind scrved without
pnyment of fecli and COlitli hy the plnlntiff, pcnding II further order nt the
hellring, Ilnd thllt n (ertlfled copy of this Petition IInd ardor be delivered to the
Cllrlislc Policc Oepnrtmcnt whic:h hilS jllrisdictioll to cnfor,c this Order,
The plninti ff (ll'/lYS for slll:h oth~r rcl IeI' liS mllY be just and proper.
CXlI1NT II
ClISTQJ>Y ,1JM2F!LPfl!NIiYJLV~l1\u_ClJl>'1'01!UAW
21. The nl legations of Count I libovc lire Incorporated herein ns if fUlly
set forth,
'l
\
-
~~
~\
t--"
~
'-l.I
fl
il-!
J1
~
"
~: r-. ..
...'.
~lt l.h '. -
(SP,-~ ..... )':
~~ I:"
~ ~L' " i
1.';>
J' ('.1 ..If}
G: t' . '::1
, 'Ill
, ..'
" J ;u.
U '" ,)
C'\ ,.>
"mount of t.he plnlntlff's 111ss~s nf $50,1)1) In full, In th~ 1'01'11I of II chc.:k or
monlJY order sent tll the pllllntlff's leslden~e within 14 dllYs of the lJntry of this
Order, An IIwllrdundt'r this dlllpler ,sllllilnolcolIslllute II hilI' to Illll1/1tlon for
dvl J dllmllges for IlIjllril'S sustllined 1'1011I lhe IIcls of IIhuse giving rise to the
IIwnnl or n fln,llng nf l'tll1telllpl under thls dlllptc'r,
7. Court Ctl~lK ItIIlI fl'eK Ill'l' wl\ived.
ll, This On"'r sllllll r\'lIIl1ln III t'ffect for II perind Ill' onc (I) ycnl' nnd
,"n he extt!rllled he yond lhllt t illle I I' the ('Ollrl finds thlll the defellllnnt hilS
cOlllllllttl~d IIn IICt nf IIhuSl' nl' hns cnl1agcd In" pnttl'J'II Ill' pr"cllcc thnt Indkntcs
risk of h'll'lII to the plnlllt i rr, Thh Onll'r Shill I h,' l!lIforLcnhlc In the snmc
mllrltlln' ns the COllrl's prior T~IIII~lI'nry Protect Ion Onll!r l!lItcred In this ,nsc,
q. This Onler IIIny suhjecl. the defellllllnt tn: I) IInest undl!1' 2,) P'I,(',:;,
~til J.l1 II) II prlvllte crilllinlll C'"l1plllillt under 21 I'II,C.S, ~611J, I; I i I) I\. chnl'!!e
of indlrec:t cr 111I1 11111 conlelllpt lllldl!1' 2,1 PII.(',S, ~(>114, punlshllhlc by Imprisonment
up tll six lIIonths nnd II fille of ,$IOI),l)O-$I,OOO,OO; /11111 Iv) civl I cOlltcmpt under
n I'n,C,S, ~('114, I,
10, The Cnrllsle I'olke Ilepllrllllcnt shnll he provldcd with n certified
copy of ttds Order hy the pllllntlff','i nttorney IInd mllY enforce this Ordcr by
nrrest for Indirect crimlnlll contempt without Wllrrllnt U(lIl11 pl'obilblt' CIIUSC th'lt
this Ordt',r hilS heclI violnted, whettwr or not the viollltlon is committed In the
presence of the 1'01 ice officer, In the ev~nt that /11I nrrest h mnde lIT1<\(lr this
sed ion, the defendant ,'ihall he (lIkcn wi tholll. llllllccessnry delny before the ,ourt
that Issucd the oldcr, When thllt <,nurt is unllvlli IlIhk, the defendant shnll hc
-,'
(11.1'() cm:r:
(); "'t" I )' 'i '" .,';:.','i'~
(' '., '111 .
, ,
"
I ?G
I
Cl;I,'L ", _ "II'
Pd :1':,/, LVi.~ i\
term nr the Order, Ilnd the dercndllnt IIg/'l'I.'S thllt hI.' will nol II'-'qulrl! or IliISSll/;S
/lny other wellpons durin!! thl! Il:rm of th.' Onlur,
6, The dufclldllllt IIgrl.'l.'S to rullllhurM' tile pllllntlrr's out-or-pockut
losses sufrered liS II result ,II' tll<' IIll1lse I Ill' I udlllll., hul lIot Ilmlllld to, thu
losses listed llll the /lllll,hcd sh"l't /11l1rked I':xhlhlt A. TIll' dd'endllnl IIgrees to
PIlY the loUl1 1l1ll0unt or lhl! 1'IIIIIIt i rr's 10SM'S or $~o,J)o In rull, In lhe ronlJ of
'1 ,heck or /II0ll"y ord,'r S"1I1 10 Ihl' pllllllllrr'>; resldc'fll'l' wlthlll 14 dllYs of the
clIlry nf' the ProteLllou Old.'r,
7, TlI~ derendllnt, nlthough entering Into llil" ^gr~~ment, dl)(" lIot /Illml t
thll nllegnt Ions ml\lle ill the PI! I I I lon,
8, TIll! c1l.'relldllnl understllJil)s Ihllt the Protcct Ion Ordcr cnlered III this
milt tel' wi J I hc ill "rr...ct 1'01' II Ill!rlod of one (I) YCllr nnd Clln be extelldell h~yond
thllt t 111I1.' I r tilt' ('OUrl rinds tllIll the defelldllnl hilS cOlIlJlli tlcd IIn 1Ie1 or /lhuSI! nr
hilS ...ngllged In II pnttern "I' (lI'IICt ICI! thlll Indiclltcs risk or hllrm to lhe
pllllntlrr, The dc,rendllnl undcrstllnds thlll this Onl...r wi 1 J be enrorccllble in the
.'illme mllntlcr llS the Cnurl'~ prior Tempornl'Y I>rot,ect illrl Order entered in this cllse.
'l, Violnt ion or the Protect Ion Ord~r mllY subj,'ct thc derllndllnt to: I)
Ilrrest under 21 I'Il,C,S, ~(ill.li il) n prlvlltl! crimlnlll compllllnt undcr 23 PIl,r:.S,
M61IJ,II I Ii) II ,hllrgc nr illdlrc'ct ,rlminlll contempt undl!r 23 PII,J',S, ~6114,
punlshllhll' hy imprisonmenl up to six lIIonlhs Ilnd II rlne or $IOO.J)O-$I,OOO.OOI IInd
Iv) civil ,on tempt ulld~r 21 PII,(',S, Mhl14,I,
10, Till! derendllnt /lnd the pllllnllfr IIgrel! to thc enlry or nn Order
prOViding I'llI' thc rollowlng custody sdlcdul,' I'llI' thel,. (hi 11Iren, Melllnle Jelln
Engle 1U1Il Whi tlley NI cllle EII!!!e,
n, The lIIother will hllve prllllllry physklll custody of the children
IlIId the Pllrlle:-; will :-;hllre le~1I1 'IHilluly,
h, The fll t hl!r w I II hllve pllrt III I 'lIstody of till! .:hi Idren
IIlterrll1tlnll weekends fl'lllll FridllY lit (1i00 p,tII, urJl I I SlIndllY lit 6,00
P,III, , on IIltenllltlnll wl'ekl-i Ihe fllther will hllve the children on the
weekdllY he hilS on w',rh "lIrly frollll 2:00 p.lII, IIntl I 7,00 p,lII.. IInd lit
other t lilies IIIIJtlllllly IIg"'.'l'd IJI'lI'I by the pllrt ies.
e, Tbe motht!r IIIld f'lth"r will ;111"rnllte the following hlllldllY:-;
from '1:00 11,11I, until 7:00 (1,11I.: July 4th, I.llbor IJIlY, New Yellr's IlIlY,
FlIster, IIn,l Memorilll /l1l.Y, n,e mother will hegln tbe sdll!dule with
Ju I y, 01, 1'1'16 .
d, The 1II0ther wld fllth"r wi II shllre th~ Thllnksglvlng /JIIY holldllY,
with the ,"other hllving the children until .1:00 JI,In, Tt1t' fllther wi! I
hllve th" children fl'lllll ,1:00 1',11I, until H:OO JI,In,
e, The I'brl:-;tmlls holidllY will be shllred by t'he pllrtle:-; on un
.l/ternutlng hll:-;l" ~lIdl yenr, with one purent IlIlvlng the children on
Chrlstmns Eve 1'1'1'11I 01:00 JI,III, unt i I Christllllls /lilY 'It 10:00 Il.m, nnd
the other pllrent hllvlng till! lhi Idren on ('hristlnns Ony 1'1'011I 10:00
/I,m. until Ile.:ember 26th /It 10:00 /1,11I.
f. Regnrdl"I-i:-; of the IIlt~l'I1l1ting weekend s~hedlJle, the mother
will hnve the ch Ildren 0/1 Mother', Il/lY frollJ '1:00 II,,", 1111I1 tbe futher
will hllve the chllrlren on Fnther'" IlIlY from 0):00 lI,m, until 7:00
p,m,
g, Fnch pnrty wi i' huve thl' lhi Idren for two w(:eks Vllcut i()n eneh
yenr (fncllllling n IIInxlllllJm of two weekends), Whell the chllrlren hegin
~, ,
,
1';: 1'/\
(.
I.. ., "
~'~, , \\) ;....
"~
n;I., , .,
l._. ':".
('\1 'J
I'
f': , I~) ]
" I
I..', ' I .~
'"
, ,-, ,'\.;
.' I'., I
\, ", J
SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NOI 1996-03~36 P
CO~~ONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA I
COUNTY OF CU~Bl::RI_ANO
ENOL,E DONNA ~AE
VS.
ENGLE JERRY ALAN
PHILIP ~AUGH~AN
. Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
CU~BERLAND County. Pennsylvania, who being duly
to law, says, the within PROTECTION FROM ABUSE
upon -ENGLE JERRY ALAN
dehndant, at 16551U HOURS, on the ~ day of
192,2 at ONE WEST PENN. APT. 521
CARLISLE. PA 17013
County, Pennsylvania, by handing to JERRY ALAN ENGLE
a true and attested copy of the PROTECTION FRO~ ABUSE
together with TEMPORARY PROTECTION ORDER, NOTICE AND PETITION
and at the same time directing ~ attention to the contents thereof.
sworn 1I0oording
was served
the
June
,CU~BERLAND -'
.
Additional Comments I
DEFT ADVISED HE SOLD THE AIR RIFLE <ONLY WEAPON HE OWNED). HIS MOTHER
ADVISED OUR DEPUTIES OF THE SAME.
Sheriff's COStSI
Docketing
Svrvioli'
Affidavit
Suroharge
18,00
2.80
.00
2.00
1322. B0
So a~sw?e\~} ././.4'
L"'~~X'~~"<: ~~
~homae Kline, Sherif!
00/00/00000 '
by I
Sworn and subacribed to before me
thia ..l2 '!:: day of \.1.-'1
,
19 'ie. A.D,
(, ).~I~ C, )it.d;'__ 4~;.
::::;< , protl'iOnota'rY ,