HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-03678
I " ,I,t
,
"
"
II I I' -'/1
I
'I 'I ,
I
,I ,I
,
, i',
, "
!, I'
, ,
,
" ,
'I, (I , , I,
.':1 'j
, ,
, if I 'I
"
1 "
,
" ,I ,
"
,
'I ,
" ,;..11"
, "
, ,
, , " 'I
di j"
"
,
/'
I,'
"
1
1
fl,
'jl
,
,I
',-II
"
,
"
,
'I-_f
, !
"
;1
!
,'/1 I
" "
I
I
, , ,
, "
,
1', "
I ,
,
'I
'I
" ,
,
'I
"1 ,
"
-I'
/,1
il.
"
,
I
,
, '
\"
"
I'
"
,
,
,
"
t;'
'"
"1,
"
,
"
,.1, 'J
','
, ,
, I
I'
r'
"
,
,
"~'I
;\'
'"
" ,
"
"
"
, '
"
"I',
1"
, ,
"
"
,I
';1'
",
'I
I'
"
,
"
I,I!'
,I
"
"
I
,
"
,I
I
I,'"
"
,
II,
'i
,I,i
"
"
I
,
'. i
'i
'I
"
,
I"
,
,'"
, ,
, "",
, ,
"
','oj
I,
"
'"
,:'
"
I"'t
,-,;ji
."~
'I _;:~
, ,~. . ',,: -,If}'1
Ij :!,r,'H
",I':', :,,'-l"~ij '1
I?':' ~",I;-;.\!t:;;j~,
. l'iip4.
",<1; ,~,r>:I})~tlr~
\ !ii",/:',-k'"
, I' "'II'I.'lt\,
'f"'I.:.")'!,,
j.(,,:,.W~\
,rl,' ;:\I';!t'W"
'i 1',jl'_'j!].',',I,
I'I--;"~ -'~t
,I 't ;';',."\';;I~H~
. ,',.",\i?,'iN
, :",,':il'
I"' i' ll_~::.\,.!~:.\?;~~.:
I
'I'
"
'II,
.' .\',1'>'1'
,l!IL"'\~}
~,.,,-t;i:~'J,ft
\I.-."..p'
','i)-\
" \':.'~,l:{/i
:{i'.'i';
,
,
"
"
"
.ft,
"
"
,
!' "
I\';!
','
\ I ,j,
,I
",
1,11
li'l
,
,
, "
",
I;
, ,
I'
,
;!
,
I
II
I
'II,/
,'! 'I
"
",
"
,
,
"
,
,t"
,
'1,1
I"
'I)
,I
"
II
"
t',,:.\'
I' "1
,
i
I
"
,
:.J!
i"
'~, ,
,I;
"
I,.t
"
"
,
/,;1'
, ,
II,
"
"
',I
,I
, ,
.",
"1
'I.i',
],J
I
!
dj
11'1,
Ii
)'.
I:"~
,':
I,
I
,,,
"
, ,I
,
, ,
"i,
,
"
"
"
,
,
"
"
;1,
, ,
i
"
,
"
"
"
,
,
I'
it,
"
"
"
,
"
,
I"
",
'l';J
1'.\
,I
;1.,
,lIt
I"', ".'
i/ 01','-1:
I
I
"Ij
.;"
',j
,
,
"
"
I';
t."
"
i'
'"
"
,,",,,
"
"
"
1"'1
'I,
.. ....
SHAULL EQUIPMENT AND SUPPLY
COMPANY,
Plaintiff
IN '!lIE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. (1 (r j (,. I j (I ( ,If ~ (u
CIVIL ACTION-LAW
vs.
H & H EXCAVATING COMPANY,
D~f~ndant
NOTICE
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend lIgainsl the claims sel forth in lhe following
pages, you must take action Wilhin twenlY (20) dllYs after this complalnl and notice have been
served. To defend agnlnslthe nforemenlioned claims. a written lIppearance slaling your defenses
and objections must be entered and filed in writing by you. the defendant. or by an allorney, You
are warned that if you fail to lake action against lhese claims, the court may proceed wilhout you
and a Judgement for any money claimed in the complaint or for any olher claim required by the
plaintiff may be entered against you by the court wilhout further nmice, You may lose money.
property or other rights importanl to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT
HA VE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE
SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP,
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
Court Admlnislrator. Cumberland Counly Courthouse
Carlisle, Pa. 17013 -- (717) 240-6200
NOTICIA
Le han demandado a usled en la corte, Si usted quiere defenderse de estas damandas expuastas
en las paglnas siguientes. usted liene vienle (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la demanda y
la notificacion, Usted debe presenlar una apariencia escrila 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar
en la corte en fonna escrila sus defensas 0 sus objeciones alas demandas en contra de su persona.
Sea avisado que si usled no se defiende. la corte tomara medidas y puede enlrar una orden contra
usted sin previo aviso 0 notificacion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido en la peticion de
demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 sus propiedades 0 Olros derechos importanles para usted.
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO IMMEDlATAMENTE. SI NO TlENNE
ABOGAD 0 SI NO TlENE EL D1NERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO. VAYA
EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONE A LA OFlCINA CUY A D1RECCION SE
ENCUENTRA ESCRIDA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGtJlR
ASSISTENCIA LEGAL:
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
Court Administrator, Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle, Pa, 17013 -- (717) 240-6200
COUNT II . OUANTUM MERUIT
15. Paragraph 1 through 14 are incorporated herein by reference as if set forti'l at length.
16, As a result of the unlawful retention of the equipment and appropriation of the fair
value of its use, without having paid for It, Defendant has been enriched in the amount of
$13,163.86, to the detriment of Plaintiff.
17. To allow Defendant to derive the benefit of the use of the machinery provided by
Plaintiff, without payment would be unjust.
WHEREFORE, Defendant requests this Honorable Court to enter judgment in favor of .
the Plaintiff and against the Defendant in the amount of $13.163.86 plus interest and cost of suit.
Respectfully submitted,
PURCELL, KRUG & HALLER
BY
I n W, Purcell, Ir,
,D. 29955
1719 North Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17102
(717) 234-4178
~
SHAULL EQUIPMENT & SUPPLY CO., LEMOYNE, PA.
CUSTOMERS
~
ORDER
.. !JOl.:1 - ;1 (
1Id't'
The uh4~"htlll'd B,Hl'L'1I tu ~lurl.:bllll' Irum )'uu tbo rolluwIIJH:-
j.k 1rk~--Jt-ll~-I/s=---:::---ct/j--1~~.p-d .i" 7
~ -----1~-J,_I!.l2 ~",----.re;. -,--e---::..'----y.J. --:-.:... 'l-T-;-~.-;lT
___' ~..:I..J~ ..'.'L__2.A.1ILi. __ __ _,~.J::.J___~
lJ.)~--.L3 .r, ~~ .tt:. -dr.~ ------It'lIV/.!!'- -clifT
,.., s-tL.. f' ~ . (~ ._-J- ,
...... - ..,..,.... =tJ...fL!!. v yl-I' )
~_._--~ '~(',N~ (,(../.)
_ :: J/J
for wblcb lllll U denlgned IUUl,llJK lQ pa)' tho .~rn of ___..{~
,l' / ~ I 'Cl
t. t ~-tJ G JJf~'~'"
J. r. ~" -
-.&-
-p:;
v
r /'Ix,'
dolla..
) on lb. 10llowlDS lerm.,
IDd
I
.. (3, u- t.------:-l- ;V{,e.,.
-
1<"', O. U. Can at Oellvered ilL
lDvol,. !:!.fi j;J Ol! ~l./~ / ""....... Ib "'.
Al
Sblp via. t1.. { r-u ,1)o!- /' '0
All drarh or Dotll to be HDt to
DaDk
Tbll order II made lubJect to tbo tollowlUB Lorma Bud cUlu.lltlonl:
1. Tbe ..Uer nllrYeI tb,. rllM to a~c:ept or reject tbll order ilL III homo offico Dnd ,ball Dol be
required to live aD)' r.alOD tor Don-acceptance.
2. Tbl. order wben acc.pted Iball be como a IJlndlDA' contrnct hetwccn lite pllrllclI, but .hall be subject to strikes, lockoutl,
accldenta, 4r., dela)'a la maautacturc. traDlportatlon or dellvory ot malerlalll, acta ot Clod, action of tho Oovernmentl aDd aD)'
other eauII. b')'ODd coatrol of the aeller. and tbe eellcr aball not undor any clrcumstllDcel be liable tor an)' real or luppoHd
dltnlle. oa account of d.la, 10 IIlIlnl tbl. ord.r.
J. TIUe to IDd rl.bt or pO.I.llloD at llald oqulpment _ball remain velted In tho .eller until all Indeblednell and III .um.
due or to become due trom tbe purcb..er, wbetber evidenced by nato, book account, Judlment. or otherwise, Ihall hlv" beea
rull)' paid. at whlcb lime oWDenblp Iball pan to lb4t purcbaser.
of. Claim, tor .bortaltlln shipment. mu.l be made wltbln nve (6) da)'1I from recelpl of eblpment. Tho aeller', relpon.l~
bllll)' for .blpmenl eeaH. upon delivery to tflnsportatlon company, and all clo.lml tor Ibortalee or damages accruing tbere-
aller mUlt b. IDlde by tb. pur.bal.. dlre,"y to lb. IraDlporlallon ,0mpaDY,
&. The ..lIer .ban not be liable or relponllble for Bny damagos, whetber on account at peraono.t InJuries, or otberwllB,
luaeroJd or IUltalaed ID thl operatloD of aald equipment, nor tor Bny Implied warranties, nor for IlDY dllmagel relultlnK to tbe
uDderallDed by realon at aD7 delaya or aD)' alleged fllllure of .ald oqulpment to operate, aDd tbe liability or laid Hiler Iban be
IIlDltecl 10 tbe ItlDdard wlrraDt, 01 tbe IDIDulaclunr,
No warranty of aD)' equipment II made, or autborlied to lie made. by tbe seller other than tho Itandard warrant)' of tbe
m.o.nufaclurer. The aeller makes DO warrant)' wbotlner In regard to tro.de accellsorlell nol dellcrlbed bereon. .uch lMlD' lubJect
to tbe .arnnt, of tbelr relpecllvo manutl(torQfI. aDd thQ aeller'a warronty doea not obligate It to bOlr tbe coat or tabor In
repllcement or defective part..
e. The purcblllr ogre.. thot tbls order sho.lI Dot bo countt'rmnnded hy him. ond thlll WhOD It III llcceflled It will ('over all
_.reemeDtl between the pllrtlea rolatlvo to tbla transnctlon. anll thlit the Heller Is not bound b)' Any repreaenld,tloDII or terms
mado b)' aD)' aglot relallve to tbll traolO,c1oD which lire Dot embodied herelo.
SHAULL EQUIPMENT & SUPPLY CO, hI +
~':
1:1 _
IIU C.....
Wltntlll
~.
..
Arr.epted thll
da)' or
19
urc IMr
:s~
~~
Addr... ..s=R \:)-11' ..3 Blreel
- ~~'I'" 7 ~ Ie) II( ell,
l / d tl/~
..
SHAULL EQUIPMENT & SUPPLY CO., LEMOYNE, PA.
CUSTOMERS OR~,:R 1_
r'
~Y
./.~)
___ uJ J'
The und.,.IHllud ButL'l'ft III lIurdulIlI' HUIlI
--..Ll~
)'lIU tll., fulhlWIIl"
....U PI) ,,/,; I..
__~_~t,.,QQl> lJ!'-'S 71 i.
_____.._;2--='...Q.J2 v_____.CJ.:,~._Ji r ___.',u r..l , l.,
((. q 2 I
(~. ,
.;k "
1"
~/7('
Jf. l-
i.c~
f' It> f
, .
.1'1,' IJI.~.._._
-
_m_"';7', '601,,)
________.~__L-_ ___ ...
fur wbil'h lhu IllldlPral~II"'ll a_rill!" It) I"'>' tht\ II\JIII III
(.I'T- - " n "
I' ,~LL-!.,!:"__
,
Flu" I.. I-
;;;'f-J'1~ J ~,(I AJ~ J, ~
r:, Jo!. r., ,1"'>;'':
(~,vr l"
ql_-_~-r:-':._~-=
-,f,~ .,,'.. ...,/
, ~
-:;-G'",+>" r '<'\--"S" -L)n
_.:l,_.,___,_-M'l O/n.Q", ,
-~-PO"~"'b~ ~..
? ~,.:L_,q
.. tiff.,
-_!:.,"-../t!. "
t>/i~ ~
l'}yi-( ,
II", I ~ I'
I 4,_ .: , J.-'
,j..:b _ h
_I,;j,' ,qaU::_____
.111 lhu
-q"--dollm
lollowloK lorm"
AUe)
l'ltlltn I' Y I., L) t.' ,.
.', O. 11. Car. .t 1),IIYeHe,d at
......._n...
10';"'. 10 l!.h1iUJ."IJj;,;';';; ;;,;- n /1." II L,l.I.,,_I-Jf..J c... '
Al
5hlp YI.'--lt:;'i.:;;~~~:I: 10
~~~~!_~~_!.~~.~. ~o
O..k
Tbl. order I. blad. lIuIJJ"~l In tilt! '1ll1uwlllll lttrlllll 1111d l:1I11111t1onl:
1. Tbe ..1Ier ro.,n.. lh. ".ht to ""'~'Lil I)' r.JIH'1 thl. .mlltr ilt II" huma IIln!:", ond aball not be
required to ,he aay r...ou tor .JlUI-I,,:c'IJlIQI'e,
2. Tbl. order "baD acclpt.d IIhall h'I~l)mlJ " 111111111111 wlltrud Imlwl'"n Ihll IIMIIIl". hilt IIhllll II" ItllhJlId II) .trlko., InckoulI,
accldlnl., I1r., dell)" II) mlDuIlClIult, IrlUlm,tathm lit dulhltr)l ul 1I1I1tnrl"ll, Ild. ut (ltul, "dllln of Iho lIuVerUInOllt, aud 10)'
othar CIU", beyond control 01 tb, .ulht" "1111 thl) 1IIIIIIIr .h,,1I 11111 ulI,I" rall1 dl'CUIIIII.lJCll. II. lIablo rllr un)' roal or luppoMd
dim I'" on account of dill)' In nUIII' Ihl. urd.r
3. Till. to IDd rllbt or pUIII...Jun 01 ..hl 1111111111111'"1 .hall rUllwln Ylt.lfld In tho lellllr ulIlIl all Indobtodnllu and all .uml
due or to blcom. due from Ibo purl:hAHer, whelhllr '#Yhh'lll'ld lIy nult', IlImk "rt'nllnl, Judam8nt, IIr ulhllrwls41, shall have bHD
full)' paid, It whlcb lima aWDersblp Ihlll J'1It1 In lhn IIUHh",or
f, Clalml for .borta'"ln .blpmpnlll IIIlJoIIt II., HIall. ,,1111111 11\'11 f~) dAYI 'rulU rocollllnf IIhllllllt!f1I, '1'1Il! "oller'" rellpoDsl-
bUlty for ,hlplUlnt c....n ullon dollnr)' III ttlllhlllHlnlllll1 1'lml~lIUlr, nnd all l'Iulllll fl)r "horla..,,, ur dIUIIRKO. Q,ccrulng tblre.
aUllr Dhl,t be mad. by lb. purcblnllr dlrlH~lIy In Hut trtUUauulallll1l I'IllllPIllY,
6, The ..Ilir .ball Dol b. lIahle IIr r"II'UUlhlll fllr IWy d.. "HI II IlH, whltlher tHl '":CIlUllt uf 11IIrllllnnl InJuries, or otherwise,
lunl!red or Iu.I"'ud 10 lbe operaUon or Inld 11IIUlJIIIlIwt, 110' tllr AII,V IlIIplhul wo."lInllol, IIllr fur an)' dllllllll:llll rlllulllnK to the
\,Indent.Dld by r.a.on or an, d.la)', or any ..lhtNUd hlllur4J IIf uld 1'II1I11IlnltDt tll ullllrato, nntl Ibo IIllbllll, ot IBid IOlIor .hall bo
limited 10 tb. .t.ndard warrant, of tb, manurll('IUr.,.
No warranl)' of Ilny equlprnullt III ullulu, or alllhllrllllll II) lil! llIiltt" , II)' Ihll alollor nthllr tlllHI tho IItnnflo.rd wllrro.nty of tbe
mallufacturer, Tbe IIlIer mlku DQ warrlln'y whntnvQr In re.arlllu Irllllll 1II'1"'II"url"" IIl1t dll,u~rlhflll '-creon, lIuch beln. .ubJect
IQ the warnDt, of th.lr r4l1p,cUVO IIIl1l1ufacturural, BUct the IIllllr', warr""ty dlllll nnt nllll",nte It 10 bear tho COlt or labor In
replllclment or derectlve PI,t.,
d, Tbl purcballr "l"n Itl..L Ihlll order IIhull nul hl! fllllnll1rllllllldl'.1 IIy hllll, Rnd Ihnl whan It III urcllpted It will cover all
a.reemeDt. betweeD th, partl.,. rlllaUvo 10 Ihl. l'IUllllll'tllJlI, IUllt thllt Ihll .1Il1ur III nut hUllnl1 h)' ally reprolllntlltlonll or lerm.
mlllle by an)' .unt relative 10 thl. IrwDllldulI whkh IIr. lIut 1II1IIJllllhlfl IIlIreln
SH^Ull EQUIPMENT & SUPPl V CO,
jJ1~L_,_.
fi7<c
/4)(1
ACt'upled thl. da, of
It
~Il;'~(';,/~~:,~ ,
Purcb'ltr
All..,,,.. .,~_f- \).# _~
$' I' K./.;1,Ll___.G~ Ii c
_Y.O"!/(
E"lilhll t11:1I _._~_,_ p/J-
5t,..1
OIly
Wlthell
"or
.._~~~if~-jf .
County
'. ,~
, ". '. '.r,. ~'/,. .~.\
' . "'. \ ii6. " I,'"
, '"..~;.. . ~.~ . ~,.,
" \, ,,~'. r C',. "'/.' ",,'\ .' ~\ .~. '
~... 'IEr,G~WjIIP;~~Nir(.~;a~~~'~~:~~tf,,')
,....... , .~. , I
; , 'IO)(II1'.--UMOVNI,IP.A:1104:1-:0112 " IPhOnt-lH~R~~S8,~~Q.(,~~~~~~:~r"":o/"\" ," '
I Ontlruollon:lqlllpm.nl, ,;-,'.. II.'.. (l.rvlot~R.nt.,. .-' 'lUn,~.tla.rrJGIIR.l;~'.;'tm.'II".P'.~,'t'
r '11 · .~".I,~.~/I nO'.,l1 ,~f~~~.,#~", " ,I
, I . ", '. " .,', .' ~
I .. ::l\:H .,',. ;1.O.ri~n', " , . ,,\ :~;'~" ,'J' .':' ,,':?i'f..., ~
.. ., \:':IDlJ 1'-) c:-~. /\';,I:::::/Al;~:rp..:" r
'TO '\';"P~lD, 01'0'","'. 173&:1 /'.' ,,_I l..,:~ cI-,fifJV~' '\
, , ,
....LI
,L
, "
," 'I'
,.....'-
,_.,""
,,_,YO
. ",' . . "
I, ",.,' ,: i' ..:~' /" 'j',-;' ,,~~'~:;~'.'r~,'~ " II
. . _.: .. ': ';. \' .:; ~. .,',J:,; It",:;~'.' .":'- .
i'
.:1
'I L.C"'''''I-:';OMI~cM'''' ':~ \'.. ':~..'I' "
"';""'12/14/15 77'08! I
..1 . : :
.....AII'"': ,OUCI"nON " -/, IlJY,P.lIICI- \ OJ .", ':''1
I l,'l . ~~...\. . "',' .... "'J,"'. '1-', "
: ,.,:,~~ .z,~O.~Cl:I.~9~,: P...~,.AO,~"~~I~T.,.~Z'''':.i LI. ol'H~,fal '~,~~~3' i~t*,!i.l)O ,',',
,', " t v. "'","L '
"",' , ' "'O",,V~!lI:, !)'t"II,JHA,AC,' ,CC10,.IOLLI!l '.5"),..~~~ Flalo, tV ' ) r~? i '" ..1U"..,IlQ... i
I ,\ ~ YO 0--' r . - ....j
I 5/11/88 twolIgb 1217/95 ",,: I ':'iq8.~~~Pi~IJ" 'I
,i ~:";~~ '':;;:-/~/.I:. ,'. :;~,..,. ':I:.
'V"f .' .5 'ji
", I',t, ":.' ;1
~:. ~~~v.,.: ::,.' '., r:
.... ''1..,1' ,:', II
I'" " ~
~,
, ..-vOtCI _tIIIl,1
~ "YI, "',,,.
..
,,'-1'
r
, , ......I;'1Jr,.,~,\,/ ,i,':,'
, ~ f,. \ I'
1 'I I ,': I
r",_. ,_,,, I : '...', '
... I
, -
.,;.t
.,
-,
,....
'.
i
'11';' ,
',1':
)
"
'!,:
"
.j'
.
)
1""'"
.;' ... ~ '... .
"''''.
"
," "
I
,
",;.'. '
Exhibit "n"
10', .
, Ii,; ....:.~:~: ';'.': :.
, .
,:~i;:,: '?;:);\',
"
"
",
....
.'
. ,.... ..A"1t ..... ..... ..... ...
Plaintiff,
IN THE COURT Of COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACI10N . LAW
NO. 96-3678
SHAULL EQUIPMENT AND SUPPLY
COMPANY,
VI.
H &. H EXCAVATING COMPANY,
Defendant.
ANSWER AND NEW MA TIER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
AND NOW COMES the Defendant, by and throuah Its counsel, Boyle &. Conner, who
files this Answer and New Matter to Plaintiff's Complaint, and In support thereof, avers the
followlne:
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted.
4. Admitted.
,. Admitted.
6. Denied. It Is specifically denied that Defendant was to bring the roller back to
Plaintiff, and on the contrary, the representation of Plaintiff to Defendant was that the roller
would be picked up from Defendant's place of business in York. Subsequently, Plaintiff's
representative returned to Defendant's place of business twice in order to pick up the remaining
balance due on the larger pieces of equipment which Defendant purchased from Plaintiff, but
Plaintiff did not pick up the smaller roller or make arrangements to have the smaller roller
picked up and returned to Plaintiff's place of business.
7. Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant agreed to or was responsible for
retumine the subject roller to Plaintiff's place of business, and on the contrary, it was the
understanding of Defendant baled upon Plalntlfrs representations, that Plaintiff was 10 arrange
for the pick up of the smaller roller, which Plaintiff failed and forgot 10 do since 1988.
8. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admhted that the smalh:r roller remained
slored at Defendant's place of business since 1988, and it further admitted that during that time
frame Defendant used the roller with Plalntlfrs knowledge and even had the roller repaired and
serviced by Plaintiff at Defendant's expense. Any suuestlon that Defendant was acting contrary
10 an agreement of Plaintiff or intending 10 mislead Plaintiff with regard 10 the smaller roller i~
specifically denied.
9. Admitted. By way of further response, Defendant believes and therefore avers
that the smaller roller had been returned 10 Plalntlfr s place of business for routine service prior
10 1995, and in 1995 when Defendant brought the roller 10 Plaintiff for service, Plaintiff
attempted 10 order a part for the roller, at which point Plaintiff apparently determined Ihat the
roller had been forgotten and in fact belonged 10 Plaintiff; some minor repairs were made 10 the
subject roller at the expense of Defendant and returned 10 Defendant's place of business and
subsequently, Plaintiff, upon determining that the roller belonged 10 Plaintiff did arrange for the
roller 10 be picked up at Defendant's place of business and returned to Plaintifrs place of
business.
10. Denied. It is specifically denied that Defendant used Plaintifrs roller during the
entire period of time, and on the contrary, the roller was being stored at Defendant's place of
business with Plaintlfrs knowledge when Defendant used the smaller roller; and Plalntiffsimply
forgot to malce arrangements to have the smaller roller picked up.
2
11. Denied. It is specifically denied that the parties reached an aarccment, and on
the contrary, Defendant advised Plaintiff that Plaintiff could pick up the smaller roller, which
Plaintiff did; it is specifically denied that ~Ialntifrs ElIhibit D reflects an aarccment of the
parties; Exhibit D Is simply an Invoice prepared solely by Plaintiff and does not reflect an
aareement of the parties.
12. Denied. Defendant Is without Information or belief 10 respond 10 Plalntifrs
allegation in paraaraph 12, and therefore same is specifically denied and proof is demanded at
the time of trial. By way of further response, It is specifically denied that the resale price of
$l~,OOO, the sum of $13, 163.86 or the cost of $3, 163.86 is in any respect the responsibility of
Defendant; Plalntlfrs cause of action Is based solely on Plalntifrs ~Iegation of Defendant's
aareement 10 pay; otherwise, the cause of action Is barred by the applicable statute of
limitations.
COUNT I . BREACH OF CONTRACT
13. Paragraphs I through 12 arc incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth
herein.
14.[13] Denied. It is specifically denied that the parties had an aarecment, and h
is specifically denied that Defendant is required 10 pay Plaintiff the sum of $8,480.
15.[14] Denied. Plalntifrs allegation in paragraph 14 is a conclusion of law 10
which no responsive pleading is required; 10 the extent the allegation is deemed factual, it is
specifically denied that Plaintiff and Defendant had an aarccment or that Defendant breached
same.
Wherefore, Defendant demands judgment in hs favor.
3
COUNT U . OUANTUM MF.RUlT
16.(15) Parqraphs 1 through 15 are Incorporated herein by reference u If fully
set forth herein.
17.[16) Defendant Is without Information or belief as to the tnlth or source of
Information for Plalntifrs calculation in paragraph 16 and same Is therefore specifically denied
and proof Is demanded at time of trial. By way of further answer, it is specifically denied that
Defendant has been enriched in the amount of $13,163.86, and on the contrary, during the time
frame that Defendant utilized the small roller, repairs and maintenance which were performed
on the smaller roller by Plaintiff were done so at the cost and expense of Defendant.
18.[17] Denied. Plalntifrs allegation in paragraph 16 is a conclusion of law to
which no responsive pleading is required; to the extent the allegation is deemed fact.sa1, it is
specifically denied, and on the contrary, Defendant has incurred the cost of repair of the roller
on those occasions when Defendant has had the subject roller repaired and Plalntlff, through Its
own neglect and forgetfulness, forgot to retrieve the subject roller eight years ago and cannot
now blame Defendant for Plalntifrs inattention to inventory and record keeping.
m
Wherefore, Defendant demands judgment in its favor.
19.[18)
fully set forth.
20.[19)
NEW MAlTER
Paragraphs I through 18 are incorporated herein by reference as through
Plalntifrs Complalnt is barred by the applicable statute of limitations.
4
,
f
~: en
. 1.1: " "
." .. ,,~. ,
~: (.: \ 'J
..... jA,.1
I:.
~f t:.._ '\:1
. '.,
(, I .~J \'11.1
rtl, \ ,~ ,,;
rr::: I f;", II.j.i ,
'IrJ..,.
I OJ; .
" '.n :i
u t;" IJ
,
"
SHAULL EQUIPMENT AND SUPPL Y
COMI'ANY,
: IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERl.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plalntill'
vs.
: CIVIL ACTION-LAW
H & H EXCAVATING COMPANY,
Delendant
: NO. 96-3678
ANSWER TO NEW MATTER
" " , I ')
. , I
"
. ! I
I , , .
I J
, \..' 'I,J)
,.
I, I
,
. )
, ) ,"
:
- , "
. .
In
19.[ 18) No response required.
20.[ 19) Denied os a conclusion of hlW.
21.[20J Denied. To the contrary. it was the Delendant's responsibility to return the roller
to the Plaintin: who "Iorgot" to return the same.
22.[21] Denied. PlaintilJ is without knowledge or inlimnation sufficient to form a belief
lIS to the truth of the averment and strict proof thereofis demanded at trial.
WHEREFORE, PlaintW'requests this lIonorable Court to enter judgment in favor of the
, ,
",. r~' Co
[0 U'; , .
I'.
ro' .. 1'''(, "
II ~ I-'!>~ "
,~j; : ~ . ; .'o/..
ij.\' Q.. , "\:~J
~~. , ~,()
" I. ~
" N . ,l~J
<- , :~\tQ
ti~ " ';,.
t~ ~ :.1
1- ~. .~
u. \f:J d
U ({\
"