HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-03790
'I \' , /'
! I I :1;iJ
1;1 "'I' 'I ,j'l,
" 'I ",' II' 'I L 0'",. '1.1
;, "., J' ;; ,;_!,
.j _ ,hI'" ,I; 1r', J!,'1l !~-, ~ "I
':""\_:_.11 "'1-'1-,'-",
Lt, "L', "r-I, 'P.' -
; fl.'-~l': ';'.-1) " t, 'I HI' ,trjJ
i! '1 '-:.' I" ~_;' ;'j,~1 / I 'l,r 'I f ,', ' ' III
,I --i PI " ,I ': 1_\ _ h , '"
, /1' "I'i,:il' -!Ii/~t\'l"'r-i_r \,);!
I' -, -, -_I \,..1, :
I.i" ;1 ; I ,r, I ~': 'II~ \N, _ '!, i,l ,J I
," \.
! l\_L ,-'!lil',IIIUU,~,-;i;jl '.'
, i JI', 'I.,,! '!q J 'I,. j _ ,;, '
-II 1'.<:"-"'"
J, ~ II I i; (I ~ 'i " F ,_ J _ ' _ ; I 'I"
I.' .J'-"\..11,_,I/l-'
,1.'_ ;<I";,,! i 'I
I;' 'j
I II' ,("r
1'1 'J'/"l--!
1// II' j
, ;1:1""1.,,
"i'-fii'f'_',t
'( )_.;J,',,',1
iii '; ('-_'1
I',' j ',,' ll._~-;'
.
,~.
"
;!t'
"
,
,,'
, ,
"
"
J',
,
,
'iF,':
" i
.,
,
,
,
.
I'
,1_.,,; I !1,'II.-it"!;'I.
t,_""_;':;/";! 'I <, I
. 'I i ~\ , J. -; !
1,-' 1'0 ,_ _~;J- H: 't .!' '_I' il ,I
I,'n:' ,- '01' I II 1- - d '
1'-;;, 'I'll" 1'" " I I I ,,_ I ,- j'\'J
" .I~I \ ,>till!" 'II; i 1\' I ,t,',,,,i;,:,"i,,,,j 'J' ,I,
,-., ;; I-""~j 10<.1_' i I' "r - - - -_-_ ii-: !_:; ~1
( -'/" ;r-'- ,/ 'I I'" ,,:,~II-;jH'
_'_I ': ,..,;;-",-,tl- ;,1,10 'I 'I -- :I'~ - - ___ -
,,1 '/i":-I J-" ',r_t,"I_ I'j 1'\ ;,-;,-
) --, t \,' '/--"-d, )
d :,j ,:;;il!-:~"'i\~j~t:'IHt" ~'I:!-' 'i,'/ j"':I'
" 1"1 / \"--.,J~'):'-'f'jl.J!(t_!" ':!Ifj ',!','-'
I , j: ::_ i " .11.;' i : -- '" I ~' I' f , ,,~ ' '
f,'I.;Lj' 1'.1' '-,I
" - .'''It':,: I
'/ "
'_i,I;',
,')I...'c/.
I ;_Ii,
,~
,
',I
'"
,\1 :,(,-
'It'll/,I
1-'-' ,,! ,
,
,
..
~
-t
"
"
(' I, ,I'
I " l",': ~:: ,\l~ 'I.j \"
- f' " I_~, 'I ',II : "i i' i /1 j -! -I :','!:, J
,q;/!'----'-I"i- -' ':i' ',I 1-'iI
-- ;_'-'-iF,,- \ ':,1 'j;'f'-'
! ~-'I,';\,'" " .'i, I 1
':'1 0 -- - - ':'/:'_1 '-'\ -,
'[11,'\ ,_ II'i\"1 'r
r ." __ " " II t- ."
1 ., L_, i 0' "--, i; \ II i; ~ il'; i' "
_'I' I' ,';' I
',:! -:' J -~-\ t I I" \1,
l!! '( " , 'j' "I
h, -II,'
It': ,it,
,
-J
;-
",~,
~,
'.\~
,t,'
,
II',
" ,'1.
,
",
"
H ;:11'
')\;:/,--'-\'.,"/i, I,
-]11'
I
" .!,
"
I' i "H
1 1-H",
,
,,"
,'I'
"l)'
'I" 'I
,I
t,:
'>/:11"')
,
-t..,_11
, ,
I,;l'
, i-II t'
i
!: /f
'I
'I
i'
,~
i
"
,n
,,',1
'I"
tt,',I:1
_-t II!
",
I. I ~ ,
il
,
,
,
I
,
I__I!'
,-t J"
"
,
,
"
, ,
J;I
d'
"
I
/1
'"
"
"I
1
"
,
'J II
,'1'1
,
,,'
,
I
"
.
1
1,1
~
~
"
.,
1
'~
.s::
"
,
,
"
','i
"
,
,
,
"
,
!
II'
i',rl_,
"
, "I'
'\, I I,
,,'
'1'1
I.'
'"
f_t'
I,tl
,j
'.
,
JII'
,
'.
,
'"
"
:1
",
'II
:t I'
,
./
,
" ,
'1
! f.
! '
"
\!_'I,'
,
"III
,
,II' 'I
"
II
",
"
.,
,
';
)1;[
;,,1
"
,
.,
,
,
, ,
,
,-1\"
, ,
, "
,)'
"
'I
'.',',
,
"
.,'
.,
"
"
'I'
, ,
, "f
,
'I
1:/' j'
"
"
1
,
.,
,,'
I",t
.,
.,
,
,
,
,
",'
,
,',I'
,"
"
"
,I
,
."
,
'-I
\
:,
, i
"
,
"
"
q,l
, ,.
:;1':"
"
"
"I
"
,
"
'I'
, '
,
,
",
.,1',
I,
"
,
"
"
;'1
I,
."
,
"
>)','."
,,)
I'll
I
"
,
"
" ,
"
"
"
" ,
"
,',
Ir, /,
,
','
,:.-/,'
"
"
'I
.' ,I
,I,
"
I ~, Ii' I'
"
."
;\1
"
',/-
"
; ~ i 1 _-
1 -,/ '!
L'\ ' "
\Ii;
'I.
.',
.,'
-,I!,l
JI{
,
"
'i
1\ I'
,
:j-I
~ !
"
'I I,
:' "l
"
"If
"
"
,I
"
I,'
i' ,
I';
I,
,
,
,
,
,
.II',
,
.I:
.,
',d r
, ,
1\'
i J,'
: ' J
I >,'
\1
'J I
,1_,li::'
,
"
'-I,!
'_It")'.'
, ~ 1 .
'II'"
:I,
1
"I" \
,,'
h "
'(,II
,
,
,.
.,.
ill
'I':
\' -I
,
'I
"
; ," ~ ' !', 1
I/.'l,'
i'
t']'1
II,
'I,
"
',I
"
ill,'
"I
,
"
,
,
,
,:" 1'1!
,f I" 'ill/JI
'j:" f
,I.
,I \ I'
"
,
\.,
;,1'1
,
'I'I
,I
,
" ,
, ~ ,
,
"
"
,--,1
"
',,'
J I,'
,
"
,
"
'"
"
, "
"
",
,,:! I
,:
, ,
jl,,.
,
;,'1,
_I',
, ,
i
,
,,' '1,
',1'1
"
,d
"
"
/'11
,
II, ii
H'
, ,
,
"
ii,
,,,
I ,,I
,I
,
,
I' ii,
1,11':1 I;
I; I!
II,/'c,
I" i',"',
,
"
"
I!,
,
"d',' ,
,(I, ,/;,!, :-ti I.i,,,
,I ;01 i i If ',: If I, _, ]
'I ]" '! I'i"f' --':-)'II-:~r(-;I"
) 'i-I,! 1,_. ( '11_ 1_ '-,',' "~ '
'I,\i'; :l~~:fllrlf;/~;l:~r:~'_;~:,,:\J<!,','
I ,iI.,>},l/ n"o,il L.. .
\ :'~ ':: - i 1-"/',"1:'" :\""'I'~rl"1 ',',, ,I ','
'tlfli': :
>;Il,', i; _ {"i\'-:_-,,) ! ,
] ;~,i, ': I;~>-:j;.-L;~ ;:,!, -~"I "I!I'
I"~ 1_'
'1,\Jj-i
-,I) "1:1 ~C}: ,) I,
} ;--'1'
i 1';r:~;!;,I:~I,,: \' )1'" II I,
~ '-',;', I, If,lll '<) t' "",1'
'I I" I W I, I)','
,1 J I', ", ,I,
;1,;;,)'>1 J;;",
'I,',I!;/:" I' ,
I', '_11'11",:1_"1
, _\, _,1,1 ,)tt!) !,i~;;-I '/; '-,\ ,',: I',
.! ' ,,_ ~ ,_ . c i l' ,_ \ 1'''' - i, ,~,
o-dljll :h,- ~-,!It;II- :] ,
,-, Ifl -l"__n,---,i~r-:=--,~,-;:J':d,, 'I
;g",l.~\'1 -'--_-,,'-/1' II, ,'It'
'::i:";i'f't;::J:i,""~,';:;':: ":
,!'-! !'J', , q, i --J"!o ltl-T' t
. ';i{":';i.:,: !/:;':';~,:i(':':'" 'I "
;',\ ! 1_/',
::'[1;' I
-,111'1{;,-,i;,,",[:'( I,,'}-I,,:I
I ~
,
,
I
, ,
11<;,
"
,
,il; "r'
,
, ,
, ,
.1
tl'
,
)1
"
"
I
"II
" 'I
I'-Ijil';"-__-;-.-c),>':
, _ i,' _,!;; _I ,i'~ 1 ~ 1'-1 I -: 1
,/ ~ I'] i i -,. !'-~i,j' r~./ -, I , , I
,"'\',i,'I,!-I:l, .j
- I ~;_ ,1--, I!; .)
- ,( ''I
'\\:,f,I""lJI
,
1,,!
"
,
,'-III
, ,
."
"
"
II)'
':1_\.1 '
,
,
,
'(
,II !I
,
','
"
"
"\;.'
'.1
"
,
,
"
"
,
"
"
,
,,'dJ
~ !_, '
'Ie'-')'
, "
"
II
"
I:"
'1
,
,
" ',I"
': ;~ I r'
"
" ,
"
(,I
"
,-'II
>1
,
"
,
"
"
"
Ijll;
]',',
"
i:-!'1"'\l' :,1,,;;;
I ' ,'J t
:rd
,-- ,
, " ,
! ill'! ';:,0
1'('1
!II
,
,
,
i'~': 1 ' t:
,
"
i',
,i-1
,
'I".
I, (;
',)
,;,'1'
I
"
I"
'I,
"
ii
\;-',1,
! i,-:li',:'IJ,j IIJ
";->\'-1;\__ 1..'1
,i,'I''II:1 'I
,--. I"
,
"
l\~
,
,
"
,,_-I'
--l-j
, I
./ '
,
II'
1.1,'
II;
;.1;,;
,1.1
, ,
"
1- 'I'
,
,
,
,
ii,
',I'
,
,
"1\
, I,
jll'
,
"
, "
"
"
"
',',
"
"f
"
1,1 II \, \-,
j \,"1_ !ll
I" I', 'I
",
, ,H-;,' i
." I ,;1 'I
:[1', .. 'I
'!,'I' ,', 'j \Ii
'"
;1'
"
I,'j
"
"
,
,I
"
,
,
"
'I'
~
y,
-
II
i
~
.~ ~Il ",.
Ii; ';"', f
..C (;..,'
I. ':,.,
~\I: 1 l. ) ,_I
.., ~r.~ ; ,:'
\,-., 1.:),.. .',
,-)1: , ,-
(I~', I") i (~
-!;j" C'..I L
(i:" r..'J ' 1;1(1~1
'I e.: q~
I..
\j ~'\ ~~ "
I'
,
I I 'j
, ,
i!
o
'/I
.....
...
"
"
MARY ANN VANDULEK and
PAUL VANDULEK,
Plaintifts
IN TijE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 96- -'/'10 CIVIL TERM
INTERSTATE MOTOR LODGE, INC.,
tla HOWARD JOHNSON'S MOTOR
LODGE,
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
AND NOW, come the Plaintiffs, Mary Ann Vandulek and Paul
Vandulek, by their attorneys, Fowler, Addams, Shughart & Rundle,
and make the following complaint:
1. The Plaintiffs are Mary Ann Vandulek and Paul Vandulek,
adult individuals residing at 190 Lisbon Avenue, S.E., Rio
Rancho, NY 87124.
2. The Defendant is Interstate Motor Lodge, Inc., trading
as Howard Johnson's Motor Lodge, 1255 Harrisburg Pike, Carlisle,
Cumberland county, PA 17013.
3. Over the night of August 18, 1995 the Plaintiff,
Mary Ann Vandulek, was a guest at the Defendant's motel.
4. As she was leaving the motel on August 19, 1995 through
the rear door marked "E" to the parking lot, she fell and
sustained the injuries hereinafter set forth.
5. The Plaintiff's fall was caused by the negligence and
carelessness of the Defendant in:
A. Maintaining the exit with a step down at the door.
B. Failing to adequately warn or alert invitees of
this unusual and dangerous condition.
COUNT I
MARY ANN VANDULEK v. DEFENDANT
6. Due to the negligence and carolessness of the Defendant,
the Plaintiff sustained 4 contusion of her back, and a sprain and
strain of her back, which caused her to develop pneumonia which
resulted in her hospitalization from September 1 through
September 3, 1995 in Olean, New York.
7. The Plaintiff continues to receive medical and
chiropractic care as a result of her injuries and will need said
care in the future.
8. The Plal.ntiff was unable to work and absent from her
employment from September 4 to september 25, 1995 reSUlting in a
10S8 of wages in the amount of $533.55.
9. The Plaintiff sustained severe mental and physical pain
and SUffering and will continue to undergo same in the future.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff demands judgment against the
Defendant for an amount in excess of $25,000 plus interest and
costs of Buit.
COUNT II
PAUL VANDULEK v. DEFENDANT
10. Paragraphs 1-9 are incorpurated herein by reference.
11. Plaintiff Paul Vandulek is the husband of the Plaintiff,
Mary Ann Vandulek.
'.
"
"
V' 't'
.,
~z ") ~ f\
j: .- .' \:). ','1
~( .. ~\ Cl '" "
...., .., '~
rji~ 00' ,,'j
, . " ~
Mo':
~; Ul . ;'j ~'\
, 1"/1 ,"
cC' ~I ~~ ~~
I ..' 'f)
~~ ') ir~ ~ ' '
,,~ '\
:.~ fn '.)
, "
, ,
"
,
"
, I
,
'I
,\
.
MARY ANN VANDULEK and
PAUL VANDULEK,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintif fa
v.
NO. 96-3790 CIVIL TERM
H & D MANAGEMENT CORP. tla
HOWARD JOHNSON'S MOTOR LODGE,
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
~NDED COMPLAINT
AND NOW, come the Plaintiffs, Mary Ann Vandulek and Paul
Vandulek, by their attorneys, Fowler, Addams, Shughart & Rundle,
and file the following amended complaintt
1. The Plaintiffs are Ma~y Ann Vandulek and Paul Vandulek,
adult individuals residing at 190 Lisbon Avenue, S.E., Rio
Rancho, NM 87124.
2. The Defendant is H & D Management Corp., trading as
Howard Johnson's Motor Lodge, 1255 Harrisburg Pike, Carlisle,
Cumberland County, PA 17013.
3. Over the night of August 18, 1995 the Plaintiff,
Mary Ann Vandulek, was a guest at the Defendant's motel.
4. As she was leaving the motel on August 19, 1995 through
the rear door marked "E" to the parking lot, she fell and
sustained the injuries hereinafter set forth.
5. The Plaintiff's fall was caused by the negligence and
carelessness of the Defendant in:
A. Maintaining the exit with a step down at the door.
B. Failing to adequately warn or alert invitees of
this unusual and dangerous condition.
COUNT I
MARY ANN VANDULEK v. DEFENDANT
6. Due to the negligence and carelessness of the Defendant,
the Plaintiff s\lstained a contusion of her back, and a sprain and
strain of her back, which caused her to develop pneumonia which
resulted in her hospitali~ation from September 1 through
September 3, 1995 in Olean, New York.
7. 'l'he Plaintiff continues to receive medical and
chiropractic care as a result of her injuries and will need ~aid
care in the future.
8. The Plainti f f was unable to work and absen.t from her
employment from September 4 to September 25, 1995 resulting in a
loss of wages in the amount of $533.55.
9. The Plainti ff sustained severe mental and physical pain
and suffering and will continue to undergo same in the future.
WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff demands judgment against the
Defendant for an amount in excess of $25,000 plus interest and
costs of suit.
COUNT I I
PAUL VANDULEK v. DEFENDAN~
10. Paragraphs 1- 9 are incorporated herein by reference.
11. Plaintiff Paul Vandulek is the husband of the Plaintiff,
Mary Ann Vandulek,
~
I~i
~i
r.
fr..
fell'
~;
~.
-
N
M
'..
,-.
...
";}
,") :'$
"IJ~'
()~
: :(.1)
1;1~
~,
"
"
'I
,
,
,
"
"
"
,
"
, .
" ,
, "
, "
" , ,
L.
, ,
,I "
q , , ",
,
"
:r.:
u.
In
N
....
t_.
c;;
.n
0'
,
,
,
,
"
, ,
"
,
,
",
.'
" J.
" l
, ,
,'"t\j; ~
re- -JR
'I~l ~'
~i
.....~. ~
"'l"'~ '~,1iW
t-'ta,....~,I"
,
,
l~
! i;:.t
'rlo-' .'
')rl:!
I<;-'I.~,
)~~
"l:;~
~
. ,;':,!2'
:""~
. ''1 "'J
;~,
1.f. "1
I'
,
~
't
,
,
/1
, "
"
,
,
,
"
)
II ! ,
,
"
"
, I
"
\ I'
,
,
,
"
,',
,
,
I ',I
I);
, '
,
iI
,
I,ll
"
il
t
~8
~~EI~
J';li~
~ t i ~ i
j ~ I I
~
,
,
"
, ,
, ,
,
,
"
"'I
.'
,
),1
,
,
,
"
;'.\
il-"
"
Hi" I,
'.
I"
,,'
,d
,
,
,
.
.
t