The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About96-04081 ., " -jll ol! ,I ., " II' IIi \" ", , , ' , t"" , ,\ i) , )1 I'll "1".1 'I"l_> ' 'I ;!:rll;: I~ I, q ilJ' t,',',' Ii' " , ../ ,,' ., ,! , . , :',1' ',Ii' , 'j,1 '1'1 'Ii , ,', I' i,1 ., " , /J fI'I'I: ",I 'i " ,I '\1 ',:.',\ , ',. " . " \I , , I, 'I, I II }/.: '. ., A , " , , " , , , " , ',' " " 'I .1', " .t r J ," - (X) ~ , , ,. d'l I ..9 cr . , , ll,) , 1"\ , f' "", ., " ., " " ., " , ., ., ,,, Iii , ,I ') 'Ii) " IY i I 1,li ,,;1'1 '1'\ JII'I , -I I,j 1,11 . il' ;1.,'11 'ii,' , "il , ., ." , , j', .' ': " " ,., , , .' , , , I '1'" Uq ."'1 i" , I " '. ii' I i',I; ',; j'. I I"l , , , I " " 'Ii ,. .', , ' " 1;\ " , I', ' I, , " ,-Ii " 'f',I., i1\, .1 \I,I'I! , I: I';~jll' .'.1 , , ,"f, ',i :_'\\1! "- (I .Id;,: "J) '")"11,111 . -, .\1,. _'!__, y"a: II, ," I'~, I;, I ',II' ',,1,1.,' _" " )1I,';'L,jl ' illl""']"1 " ", , , 'd'- ;\ ",1 If !;{ ill';'!; ;. I" I , i,'ii,I'); " 'I , " " d" ,! , ,j: i_'ll .,.".1'11 11"1. , ~ I 0)' ! II i - "Ii "'1-"1" 'I '11,r,' i' I Ut 111,fl',' 1,"11' I", ',:,', ,. ''If ., 'I!' I' '" " , ' " " . , II' I,I!/!' ,I" " " Ii':"~ ;1"11'1 I'. Ut ' ,,,Ji'\ '1 ,I"J) , I', '1'1111' , id " .' ,'. ".., " r; , 1.', " ;'1\ 'l, ,,' Id;, ',( ., " "I , '" , ;1 ./ " , , Ii',',! II, . 'If ,il , " II, , , 'il " " ,. 'I " ,Ii 'I' 1\ !. ,I ;01, " 'It, , " 'Ii " L !I I" 0'". " , " I' H .'1' , ." , ! "1 'il:1 I" Ii ".. 'UI 11 ',ii, ,. I- J,1t (I' , I, , '.;1 I, , , ' , ., ,'I Ji' 'I'" " "I" I,: , " " " , , ., ;;1'r " .,', .q I, it.. ',' '11'1 I' " I ,il " " '" ., " . ., II" . " , ,'1 ., , , " ,,' " , , '>11 "I I;' " " ;,11:'1 )1\)' " " d, " I. 'I, 1" , , " " , " " " ., I' , , " , ;1 ,,' , I, '. ,I', , ,1" .", , .' " (j " " " ,', " , - " " .d ,J ., .j ',;'I,',J".,....I ,i, , ", ,. ,\ , , 'Ii . " , 'j' .1' " " ,/ I, " , , ,_I, '\ ., I' ,', d " ':1' , I , , ., , it I' " \' ',Il ,'1" , " , 'I ",' "I, '1'/1' ,.J 'I <~I .V.J.. ",I,if,':-'j', ~'~1-'illl'i,(fA , i,~':'ji:t'\"':il, I I '-'-"..., '0).,,\ I i;'I"'\ l_i,1 ',' " 1'" I) ./ , 7tj!\~"kt.i;1 'It~,,,,.~,,,, ,,'.)lI.:l/~l: p 1-;.oJ _',',j" , " I ,I \- " , , ,'1;1' il"l , " I, " '" I ,,~ I j .j -': ,., '11'1 , , "1':,1 " ., , , '\ .1' " , ':"oj, 11,'1' 't, ,! I "j:, >\ ->\ 'JI;I '''',f 'I jl il'! iI- d ',- I, , , i\\\ ') '" ir- '~ LAW OI't"CI,' 6NILB^KIER & BIUNrUMArl .. . a Pennsylvania business corporation with ~ prinoipal place of business located at 12 stover Drive, carlisle, cumberland county, Pennsylvania. 5. Defendant Herman & shenk, Inc. ("Herman & Shenk") is a Pennsylvania business corporation with a prinoipal place of business located at 601 N. Baltimore Avenue, Mount Holly Springs, Cumberland county, Pennsylvania. 6. On or about May 14, 1993, Plaintiffs entered into a written oontract with Defendant Lehman whereby Lehman agreed, inter AliA, to construct a two story residential house with a two car garage for Plaintiffs on a tract of land that became commonly known as 1410 Cranes Gap Road, Carlisle. A true and correct copy of the aforementioned contract is attached hereto and incorporated her~in by reference as "EXhibit AU. 7. In accordance with the terms of the written contract between Plaintiffs and Defendant Lehman, the contract price to be paid by Plaintiffs included an allowance of $3,000.00 for a zero clearance direct vent fireplace. 8. At all times relevant hereto, it was Plaintiffs' belief and understanding that a vented fireplace would be installed in the houee to be constructed by Defendant Lehman. 9. On or about May 25, 1994, Defendant Lehman completed the -2- LIIW 0''''0:11'' SNnllAKIi.R . BA(tjNI[MAf~ .. construotion of Plaintiffs' residential house and garage, at which time Defendant Lehman was paid in full by Plaintiffs for all amounts owed him for material and labor associated with the oonstruotion of the house and garage. 10. On or about May 26, 1994, Defendant Lehman, in oonsideration of the final payment made by Plaintiffs for material and labor associated with the construction of their house and garage, gave PlaJ.ntiffs a one year written warranty pertaining to the house Defendant Lehman constructed. A true and correct copy of the final statement of Defendant Lehman which was paid by Plaintiffs May 25, 1994 ~s well as the aforementioned written warranty are attaohed hereto and incorporated by reference herein as "Exhibit B" and "Exhibit C", respectively. 11. In the Spring of 1994, prior to May 25, 1994, Defendant Lehman installed a fireplace during the course of constructing the house for PlaintLffs. 12. In the Spring of 1994, prior to May 25, 1994, Defendants Lehman and DraWbaugh installed ceramic logs in the fireplace as well as a 3/ R inch gas 1 ine which ran from the fireplaoe into and through the basement of the house. 13. On or about September 16, 1994, Defendant Herman and Shenk, at Plaintiffs' request, completed installation of the gas line by extending the 3/8 inch line through the foundation wall -3- Electric Kitchen Venit les Sept i c Excavat 1 ng TOTAL EXTRAS COMPLETED TO HOUSEl Russel J. stone and Donna Barkley 1410 Crulns Gap Road Carlisle, PA 17013 Amnunt A 11 owed $6,800.00 $6,800.00 $1,600.00 $6,000.00 $1,600.00 Actual l3ill $6, 641. 00 $6,400.00 $1,838,00 $9,495.13 $2,836.43 fireplace gas line stereo oak bath door she 1 f materi a 1 outside water hydrant plumbing 1 3046 tilt window 9 extra tilt windows 3 byfold units 6 x 6 2 casement windows and jambs 1 pair of shutters extra drywa 11 paint base trim handral1 - main stairs basement door and trim framing - closets, kitchen bulk head and windows window trims labor for ex tras TOTAL TOTAL OWED CRED ITS I Well Carpet Li ght i ng Central Vac Septic System TOTAL TOTAL AMOUNT OIlED $ 62.00 220.00 40.00 221.00 366.00 661 .00 260.00 226.00 762.00 360.00 27.00 126.00 18.00 30.00 26.00 176.00 629.00 76.00 841.50 'l~ful..4 ~ ~' 'l '-, 1- \ S 0 \1 ~o\f'" C\vV 'I' r\~~ ~~X- 'U1l",~ ~J/ K & R Lehman Contracting ~ Amount Owed $ 741.00 $ 600.00 $ 338.00 $ 3,495,13 $ 1,335.43 $ 6,509.56 $'4,972.50 $11,482.06 ($ 1,107.90 $ 491.00 $ 1,500.00 $ 575.00 $ 1 747.57 ($ 5,421.47) S 6,060.59 --4?~IJ-~lFV<-- -~. St e rr. j 1~.. YLA---i3~~li4 _ Uo~y -7 EXlIlIllT 1\ 11ft , ~) ., I~c. . . t.:O "",11 't , Fa(. '$ ., , , II , , '11"1 , " . ~~td )),1 , " ' , , " , '" 1 ! " , , " " I I, " , , , " ! 1 " 'i , , " " , , , ! I , , , , , , , , I' " , " , I , I EXHIBIT C " t;pl'rtftl'uthllUI POU. N. 'J , ...01 pag.. 30' xJfI' TWI) Story With 26' x30' Two Cilr Garage b~d'I"~"IV /ll1')Whnc". S'I,:j(ltJ.ll) ..A,:y ,:xtl',j co~t,~ 0vl,r 111m t" ru~Ks ("~'llil',lill:), It';.HI11 ~tl .liI "d,11\;'1rI4i Ct'~t r,"rl~r'lt'Jly, OI9!l1t'~ ,lJ'.l'r lillI' ,)Ild ,)Iw:trk 11111) ullly. tlilckfi 11 ,jM "il\o1" J",\O" h)' ,)t'''lr''i, ~I1U hbr,v1 ill',I,IJ\/ 'Ji",.;, II)1J will b,) w111.,o 1l~,"IIIQn\ ~XCJVojt irlll, ~l!ll ,lllI.JW,i,:r:l. . SJ,"',,(jt$li ..~ ,\riY l:Xl:i'l I:V.~t~ ()l/l~t' ,1flJ ,jbrJ\'.; 11:,),Mnl.l1 .'JU~ el) r'Jr.k\. 7t~. 111'1111' 1/1 ~tJtJll.I'.'1~1 '.051. ,1I1C,W111 Lm ~Jtl1111J S\lJJilrHlJl,~. .i~)J~i.; ,Ul'J~lollJ~l' - ',u,;'.JU.I') .- /Iii} ,'~tr" ':lIHS 'lYr,r illle aIN"'! .~ll,)WII'KO '1/1)1 I" III ildelr.III'lid CIL,l. 1,1; ,Vi'; ,I~ ~j'I,'ll ii~pJI',ltl!l'I' CONT/lACT I'RICE INCLUDESl' ::"" II" "i,J III'J Split 1 '1.: It f,'n~ ;in :~t. f')r ',;'11 ,:xt,'rior ']II;j InLrl,)r" 1111 :c.lril~' ... "ll,tI lJI~. .IOI/,\ll i :l}t'jq,' rl'll~"1 ':"'pqt. [l'ltJ(jl11!l. I'llIyl jllll:'!I',JI/f, ~.II~ ,l(~"'I'ln'.l tn 1J\.1II~,;1!11;110S'; ~pl;1Itll1q. llll'lbjEl,Tr J" Clm~I''lt('' tiJ<lt,,,n, i:)" pllllr~,j <::on~rl'tl) w~lls; Ii' In i1elgllt, 'I'" tii .lOW 1~, ',~/I';rl!tl; '111.11 tlINrlijl;~')', ,l .A~o(!r~9" 1).d~flil~Il~ 1I11111gWS. 1';:I{~I:r. P/\uI)INr~. VI~IYL "I r,;:,;,,,W; rILe, tcj bp. r:u~t!lm~r.'~ ~h\ll.~~ '.litt1an._. .. .1111;wdnc~ '.:f ~l.u".)lJ :lflr ,UlI,lI'l! .luro rur ':,lrrllll, ,addln<J, 'ilil,~'l ;!n<J jl,n~) J un,li. P ..N ,)o;I'i'~II:)l"! r',.-\lt. "Ir,; -.r,lIjl;~.t j)~ 1)ld. 1~~J.'1.ll '1~ j,..",. :;t'lec'.I,me I.J ~I 0,1(10 ,ll :ll.:".;rd~lln'~ ::1(/I)r 'JIIO \'/JIl, ,11Jb 'jll'Jt.h f.)~"J.t~~ ,)~r'!~r., ';;ilvIH;n~~'jr<J. Ph I?:.bi. . .....-. ... ...... ... ~/\Hfr /IND. STALHI, "\J.:J'),';Us;'l)llI~r", ~li\ll,;,).. 'Jill! 'C\tH' PillnLlill' ')I/~ C\1!1;[f,J:ll.'J... .. ._ iiLU~l\l ..lll l.u:...l:US:.QI!;Ur'S ;:J\llc ..llld tJas~'JIJIl.j31)(}.v') .!l~r .~I"H'$ar.l'l. .. . i:.HWEl:l . ~U;::tlllO ,;illu;Jlljnel; .Juiit Jc:;~rCln!1 ~":JJ.;nS\'IIt.ll..'.H' .,I)<JW~))(':L~f.....__..u__ S5.,JUu.JIi. : ;rettEI, ,WPU,ni\~E~' "Gr.' .. t:lS:,I_,\flijtit #011" - ;"~~' O:lltllllY5. ,,3'J, 'lnU ~il~IJII1Cll1t ,:";)1119$ - IU9. ., . lJin iE~I\Y I lly 'Jt;l,;r~ :' [litrLI',r;~ I _.__.. ",__. - p' ..... ".,. _H ". Ji l,r,/,jJl:' ,:,' ~3,d[)(),(,U FIJr l'lrli Ci"drGnC~ uircct, l'xw' brtI.....JI1.j.i! .nll 2'I,(j' IllldrCa. .,. .-.-..---........--.- '1,,11 t F i fFoill ,)0. 1.,;.~iirl!...iL ~.J JI..! ..::...:;.l:!.:...et.'~-.:.h.:it..t: -..1:.....l11 ~ll,JwJucu.ur"d;j..I.,:.:JQ.J'~- fr.r.,.:II~cr.t~;..__._._ 1ntJ 1.{~>~t."Jr ll'~ht:" ';C;{rii,~\I. O~I;t v'~,~ ,,'I';~ ~I:J r"!Juljli 'II ..dtll JII -11;rWtlflC'! or :b1,3(;1],.JU. .< ,I, 11 LEhl\AMI :'.l'lTR,'\/:m!O 1("lth '.. '.~h",lIn THIS P~QI8(COMlS '''''T Of AND IN CON'OAMANCI WITH PROPOSAL'Otll 1,1, ~.1 ~', 'r. I r,:I .' I Iii' I :. I I' .- ,}.' " ~ 1 Job Name/No. _--.iJ_~._':.._..._.."-~.._.._l LL___L___ r" . Accepled by _~~~__...J._~______._. DB Ie ___ (INlll,t,ll\l , . ., ..1'_.- _..:.___.= 1G~i'~'_~ . ,. , .1 I Submltled by _--"-__ Dele ._~.~.__ 19__ """'H~. Accepled by . .. IjN.i-I;"~51 Dote .~ .... u. 19-...:__':-_. I: , fJlp ertttruttl11111 rngo N. ~ . _",...0' _ _ .\ "--, ,. p.g.. GARAGE I Ij" footer, 8" Il\!lr.k. 6" 3,500 lb. CUllen't() 'dlUI filll!rI'ICJSI1, ' Y'x/' ~ tut! I rJ 1 sud IJMll! 11 .,d ~arll\le doorSd j tll 2 I;lia i 1 ()Il')I!I" 'JolrolVl! .Iour uper I) tors. PORCHI U" rooters, 13" block, rrl)llt purcll tll hl! brick f,;ce, 4" 3,500 lb. concrot/; with rlbllrlllesh, baij.,"I.!tlt wil1dl1\>/5 tlJ bll boxed w1th stll\!l uroltl!~ 111 Doren flu1Jr. PLUMBlIlGI 1\. 'Jill! (1) Swanston\! Ooulil" I)o',jl k1tclllln Slid; ,lith 'Hie (1) DllltJ OJ41 slnyle lever Witll spr.IY C;lrrJIllr. faucl.lt. U. One (I) I\Quag lass AGOI)Utl '/Illite tUb/~IIO\'II!r <wi t.iI tI1 one (1) Ul!! tol , 4642PB sing!1l laver pollsllud hrass folUCr.t. C. Tllree (3) KOhlllr ffK35:W ',lllll\jOI.ttl '.'Ihite ,!lrJll~;ltl"J 1'/,oltor,clos'lts ,,11;1, :)116 t$. D. Tlirl:\! \3) Dllltil ~5f.,P!l s111i)llJ l~vl!r llull~d'!'J l>rlS~ lavatory faue,lt.. L Two \ 2 Aquag I ass ,;63633 \jll ite SilOI'/l!rS '11 tll t'.to (,) Dlll ta #622PI3 s I n'll oJ Il!ver polislled brass faucets. , F. One (I) Aquag!ass i\G5190 '.mfte garden I:IIIJ \'Iftll .m.: (I) Uelta n7\UP~ po 1 isned brass fauc\!t. li. Une (11 wash 1 nu ;;\3CIIII1<: b,lX. H. One (1 RheeOl enorgy illls~r 52 gallol1!l\!ctrtr.!/i)tcr Ileater. I. Ttwee (3) frostprQof Q/Jtduor hose bibb~. J. Till'~e (3) i/utone full/ll'Jllt outl1r'Jom ullitS. ELfCTiUCI A. lost.lll one (1) 200 l\hP ser'i1Cl! panel, COlllphlt,.: Il1th matar IJOS\!. SE cebl\! and breakers. 13. lost.lll all 1M rl!c\!PtaclllS ilnd swltcllGS :'ih\!r'.: ,'oqulred, tJl(;llldl!.tJ ,1r~ <ill 20A receptac I ')5 dnd liFC1 out 1 ets ,lS reqld r<:lI by the rlat i ~nal Electric Code. . C. I nc 1 uded 1 salle (1) <Ir Jet., rO'lgl!, wa tar ,le.ner ,',11<1 d j sliwa SIH:!r ou t I 0; t. n. IllS tall four ('I) ~honL! Jnd ruur (4) TV Jutlets. E. [nstiJll one (1) stalloilrd rJllorbell syst.m. i'. !.Istilll onCl (I) 1 1 'lilt uutlllt oox pur roolll ~IlU ~ios",t. 1,). Install five (5) r,!eessl)d 11gllt rlouslllYs. :1. Instolll tl'/O (2) outdoor 5G:J watt Quartz, fboel I j,..ltS on hou:l". ;. [nc1uoed ar\! all :l\!cUical IIl5PllctlollS, ',i1I"iny ind connect1<lns. HEAT! :'IGI ,\. [nstall to sille 'Jr reJ!" of IIOllS\!, olle (I) dr/Jnt illyll Erflc1\!nc/, 3 1/2 ~JII !!ololt i.ump lIiOun;;~u .111 .J Clad!!t.J OJ:;... 13. [lIstall into DS'!i:l.,nt locatiiln, 'Jill! (1) 'ir",~lIt J 1/2 tOil Air IIJllOlor :.Jojt 1;0 lle llnkr:1.l tv thl! \lutllO.;r unit usin<j j':~Ld.ltl.lO t'efrtg~r.lnt 11I:e. I/: ~. I'? LE~M,llN CONTl!AC1'INC1 KIllth L. Lehman THIS PAOE UECOM!6 PART OF AND IN CONfon......NcE WITH PAOPOu'L fOR , I . 1 I . ' '", ,~r1 t ~ ) I~" I III I ' . I" ~ Job Name/No. _"'" l_~.__~_ _ ~ ~ L_r'..:__.. L:". .____ :........__'_.~.;..:':...L.. ",'r I'i!! 19" ." o"-ITI,lI!\1 Dolo Acceptod by J.~. Bubmlllod by " ,I , , >',' 0010_"_ 'U_,"_" "19_ AcccplCd by ""'I";'l'.1 Dnle 19 _ _ " ."P..', \.....'-/'... V!'I .",. UI.Jll-.,UU.."...J..., ,....,. ."&~&"I u...\..." 1l1l1l.IlINli 6P.:CltWATlONH /l.Lt Quut.d /l.Ltu'U.llvo.,y Z - 5TCe~ wi-V\. Ful,.~ z.....''t~ GA'~ Halr,,"t.on ~J' ----..--.-----"--- Ilulld" -----K.L~~jJ .(':2ET~~Tu,d~ Own.'~~J:.. /l.t.ln 'or QuuLt /l.t. 0' S.I. 'Typoo'llulldln, 3.> y. '7,~ '2<" ~ !P . Quol.NlI, _ IJhon,. UUlht.r Phonr. O~'n'r 1~A!e(1\eU\ Au() <Uvlnll Room (rlllht) or <left) facing front of house) NOTE, E."y hum. t.quot.d .ccordln, 1..llulld..'. o,Own,,'lIp.dnullon.. PI.... nil oUllh....p.c..c.,.'ully.l..m. m.,ktd YES WIl.l. II.: llUPPI.JEIl. I...m. mo,kod NO 0' INOT t.ISTE/l) WII.L NOT liE SUPPIJE/l. IlAll.;MENT MATEIlIAI..s AN/l PAN.:l.~' I. ~NO I.llycolumn. 2. YEll NO ,I,d.. (wood only) M,cto LI4rp', a. n:ll NO 2a6buckt'0Ihor 4. @)NO b...m.nlwindow.uyp" ~ r.::;". NO fJ. i.> v I ,. 6 ~ blltm,nt illurior doo,. :J ,. '<f-1 6. YEa @,) b..,m,nt Intlrior dfllltl 7. YES @) bu,m,nt ulIMor Wl)lld pln,l. H. (m.t.ri.lonly)(pan.l.lih."hl YES @J b...m.nl....rio. pon.1 .h"lhln, corn If. 9. VES ~ ba..m.nlln"rio, p.rUllon. (m...ri.l. only) Ipln.I.) (h.l.hl) 10. VES @; n.ld .ppllod wp pl...,o, PAn.l. II. YES @ bo..m.nllumn, .Inp. (....rio,) (In"ri..,) 12. @ NO .11I...I"Un.ul.llon) la. @) NO .111 pl."ln.ul"~1') 21..@..).8 ot.h,r WOOlJ FLOOR SYSn:MS 14 VES @ 1.1 noorlru.... 16. @ NO 2ndn..o'lru.... 16A, <iiB) NO 2. .. noar truII brleln, ~ "'iIO I;Uo,c:.. 16. ~ NO l.lnoo,lol.u '- ..'"' 17. VF.6 tiii.> 20d noo,jol.u 18. @:INO nou, jol.l. bOlin, ~ ~ I C:l 19. YES <f1:g:\ 11l!2nd noo,lol.'.unlll".. 20. YES @ 21 @>NO brid,in. (or noor joi'Ulwoodl (m.t.1) Q Itl nuo, plywood S /'-/ I ~ 6 (~ , 22. YE6 @) con.l,ucllon MI.. 2.1. @ NO 2nd nou, plyw..od 1/'-1. i + ~ A I.J~ 2~ YES ~ con.I,.cllon ,I.. 2.6, ~ NO hatm.nt .tal,. Im...ri.1 only) IP,HUI onIY~I.LtIY pn.bu!!D 26. @NO b...m,nl.III,,.II.ndb,.ck,.. PANf;L tiVSn:M. 27. €)No 26.~NO 29. @ NO 30 (vES) NO 31.~NO 31A. YES NO 32. @I NO 33. @)NO 33A ~ NO 34 ~NO :J6 @NO 30 @} NO 30A @) NO PIIM" t or.. ..t.rio,p.n,l. .I.ln.., ~ 'ioG. " 1(" 6.(.. .."'rio, .hrlhlnK . 1.1 n....' p.n.l. ., 11.0 O':>I~ com,,. '5Al"\e .....rio, p.n.I.. 2nd nour Z. JlG. 1(,," (). (. ..t.rio, ,h..lh1r' 2nd noo, p.",I. ., 1(,. O'::>(!l S fl ~e.. cornu. a' " ..,.,. p.n.l. 12 """I.IMh\( 10 ....rio'.h..lhln'..'... ~IC. 0513 2.yl./ int.trior panel. . lit noar {" II a (.. In"rio, p.n.I.. 2nd nou, '? 'il.( ,"''0 ,. doubl. top piau Inttnor pan,11 '.clo,y.ppll.d _ n.ld .ppll.d .J::::::::: n.ld Ippll,d top pl.l.!--' ..I,nor p.n.II..~ ctllln, n.llrr 2. 6101hrr' 20 pr,<('ut .tud. ror braclnlf, hulkhrad nl.ltn,l .k 1101 2 I ~ . 16' '0' br.r1n,. .k ROIW MYSnM: .-- S-/,Z . wabl. ____ plll'h ____._________ hip __. pH"', _.___ .h.d ,.mb,,1 m.nmd olh" 37. @)NO roon'o.... pH.h _ pll<h pll<h pll<h I 'Z a,c:.. 38, @ NO m.lall,o."p'''rI 39. @) NO l,o..b,.c1n,h4(oLh.. ~:;-, "'/((. 0 ~a 40, ~ NO ,.bl. 1'011 I.h..lhldl _ 41. YES ([j]) ,.bl..nd. (.h..lhldl . 42. YES €E) raft... 43. YES @ e'lIln.lol'la 44. YES @.> brid,ln, (or "iIIn, Jol.la Iwood/m.lAl) 4~. YES lli9> rid,. pol. 46. n:s @ alLie kn..w.lI. 47. ~ NO b..m.,porehorr.rport 48. ~NO ..v.. ov.,h.n, ((rom .Iod IIn.1 1'2./1 49. @) NO ..bl. ov..h.n, cr,om .Iod IIn'l \2-~ YES @) ,abl. ov..han, I.dd... ~1. @)Noov"han'''lornmalfriil(W?''"_ ~ 6':\:l' 01. we".:l 62. ~NO 'DOloh.alhln, r "i 63. @)NO roolplywoodellp. s1H II ~4. @iil NO A1umlnumdsip.d&.~..&&.bl.,u> @ D, 1Ill. ~ NO rDOII.1t 16 lb. 30 lb. 1\8. @> NO 50. roor .hl~lt'I ~"upo.urn brand ll"'tCl ~rl f.~t 'U color other <fiD NO .22S FIG ~7, rDOI n.lI. 1\8. @NO .Iomlnom no.hln, M. @NO prop" y.nt 50. @NO rid.. v.n\ _ brown 61. YES @ louv,.. (wood) Ilze (.Iumlnom) Ilze whit. @> 62 Vt;H 6:> nUlIr l',HltiI.\I.,.uutlltl, l'ov.rinll t.IUlJIlnUm/wIJlIlJ) IJ:I @)NO fl4 @>NO 111I. 6J0 NO Ilfl ns ~ 67 Q> NO 611 nil €V 69 ~NO 70. @> NO 71. vt:lI@ 72, ns @ 73. vt:S @ 74. VES @J 7~. @) NO 76. Q)NO 77, @ NO .lwnlllul1l Illmi '" I..el. .YII.III cnlo, ___. la.d. bOIl,d.I.llI) Z. '1" 'V" " ,.kv huunl. ,.111) wood lumt Dnd ,..do ')'ll.Iln .ornl w h. Vllllod 1/3 _ 2/3 K.. .11 _ .olnl V,"I.lrip only (.1,,1 po",h 0' carport collin. (a~~~:7 t:116" plywood) 101h..1 porth b.om .Iumlnum CQVI,td porch beam wood cov"rd c.rrm" bel8m .Iuminum cQvrred corpurt bum wood cl)\"nd .,eh bOil rd. II or 2.ld..) po,ch POI" wood or ~ Ill' 11)14 So.vrtlo-c.. porch POlt. lupport .lructurol bum. 77A. YES @ lamlna~db..ml.} WINDOWS AND EXTERIOn DOORS AND GARAGE DOORS: 78. @>O overhead pr'8' doors, Inlul.led@:NO Ilyl. 'I 'JC 1 ~T( c t b..nd Co /U,I(,Jt"l- no. and .1" _ z.. - '1 '1-1 z. z.. 79. @JNO 00. @NO 81. @NO 81A@ NO 82 YES NO 11.1. @NO PUWt' 2 Ilr ~ no. orl!llctric op,rator. no, DC t.ronlmIU"1 ov..h.ad ,..a,. doon.} In.tall.d '0'0" doo, I,ack, nallrr, jombo, ond brickmold otenor ,ntranc, doo,. lllttll (wood) b,and ~/oJLE'f lronldllorolyl. ~<'l ,..s. 2 510e(,~t..Ir ,..,doorolyl. _~ - l.( hOUllf to lorol' .l)'11 ~ olh.. 6~ \(. l.{ Jambwldlh (;, 9/1", "lfriur dou, .ld.liI,hl'll) u,~ \ Ii II )OCkll't, . hanlllr .tyl., .1itL>, ' C,ont only #Jet f"\4<<C'1 ?-l<1 /~ I13A. @ NO lod..t. . ..IMMo" koy In knoh 838. YE~S @. d..dholu,' ut",lo, dom L~u~." S T II /(.. 83C.~ NO lock..u, .Inu-Mo',' b,.nd -5.!.h.l..e.d f ~ 04A.~) NO woud .hlm. . R.....~ . I 84. ES NO oIWIAcll...doon.l!Qcllumlo...",IUu.L'f.,J INnll101I TIIIMB. noolls. SIIEI.VINO, t;'J'C. /,. r 11 .1.. l<l )( G, b,.nd ..tJJ) O~(JtJ j.J O^. @.> NO 86. 6Bl)NO 86A. YES @> window.: lei ",I. d..lredl @m;llSl:9lTl1ER ,In&le &I... 1n1U1.led &I... multJ.II1 ~ perf. &I~ low E &I... @ primed lena-tone unfinl,hed .kyllu-. leln:l. d..I",d) b,.nd: n..d ope,aUnl dome- net 86B. YES @> In.ul.u-d n..d II... trapoJold, _ octoi'on _ oth.r _ 86e. YES ~ window p.n.l. EXTERIOR TRIM, SIOINOS, ETC. 86. YES ~ (ri... bo.nI. C.I..) 87. YES (filil comic. trim 86. YES @ ml"'.II.n.ou. uu-rio, moldlnl' 811. ~NO 90. YES 6W 91. YES @ 92. ~ NO 92A. window .hutten (drde dt!lired) louYered~ door .hutt.en (circle desired) louvered. pan,l decorative front door trim and head wood style (ypon .Iyl. Ildin" and flccelloriea WO\-O t..,.., ~ 106, ~ l., 111,1 U r j..J'f I ,',1 i:l~ es'4T~ 107. brick Iby bollder) Cei",l. whore brick) (ront rilhl .nd l.(t.nd other fA<L. o~ (hu t... ..., I.bl.. 93. 114. YES liSl> cupola and weRthervn", (hotB.lchick"n) YES @ Ullrio, d",k .1.. leln:l. d..i"dl ltal" hori.ontol ,.11 picket rail other Ir.r.aln Indic8~ height ",1rode llldl'ck" _ 112, POKI :lllr 4 wood ,III. 1028. YES (fg) window lrim drywoll "lorn. . .pron &. .I~I rlY I " b...ho.rd to mlll.ch C.I,,)( ~ 00. dWNO 07. YES @J 97A.@ NO 118. @NO 00. @.> NO 100. ~ NO 101. VES @ 102. ~O 102A. (fj3) NO 103. @NO YES @l:> @;~ NO YES Qv YES@ 104. 105. l.lucrrE NO. Ir IUllt. tWI) (2) .trill"" lhrl'l 13) .Innl'" .111__. m.ln .tol,.: width _____~. ho..d pine and pine w/pln. Itrinllft. __ olk Inlt oak w/olk .trin,.,. _~_ oak and ollk w/plne.trinll.n m.ln .ul, ,.111111 . ..k l.C... bl",h _ w.llo,b.lcolly,.lIlnl p".....nlbl.d 'Ialr r.1I trimmed opentnr' pt1!.hunlllnlenor door. (drcl.duired) .pIlIJamb. QI'C Jamh, ") c..InS applied F/JJ.mb, clo..t door (hlnl.d/bl.(old IIdlnl) pocket door. Inlenor window Rnd door('..ln .h.;rcl,dull1!d) 2,' /I ranch. @Qntoi).ll' nnl" joint 6 window .111. CeI",I. d..l"d) Tt./f\'\. KIT) plctur, (ram, b8lluho, mewl c10let rod. lInd .heh'eo wood ahelvu and m'lal rod. oak noonnll' (prefln.lunnn.) 108. (wh...7) YES G) .~ " ply",o" (wh...?1 109. YES G; a,.\" parllcle boord (wht',e?) I09A. GliJ NO HARllWARI;' tl0. III. ....I.u.nplyCwh.,.?I_~\-k"'~.:s Fo<t#"'. ~(ot"~l',.".../..Wk (~,,(J"'t cooled n.l15 undiUJ8)'ml'nt nail. nnlllhlni nnll, LAW o"u:~.. SNIIL.IJAKER . BR!NNUMN and that it wou~d be fit for habitation as a residential dwelling. 22. Subsequent to Plaintiffs taking possession of the house constructed by Defendant Lehman and beginning on and atter september 16, 1994, the following defects and deficiencies arose or were discovored by the Plaintiffs in the house constructed for them by Defendant Lehman: a. the gas fireplace installed in the house by Defendant Lehman emitted an offensive odor; b. the gas fireplace whon in oper.ation caused a black sooty residue to form and become deposited on all surfaces and furnishings inside the house; c. the ceramic logs in the fireplace had been installed improperly, causing them to char and/or burn; and d. the gas fireplace was serviced with propane fuel by a 3/8 inch pipe, which pipe was of insufficient diameter to ensure proper combustion of fuel. 23. Subsequent to Plaintiffs taking possession of the house constructed by Defendant Lehman, in the Winter of 1995, Plaintiffs discovered nails attaching shingles to the house, porch end garage roofs were rising out of the roofs, raising the shingles and breaking the seals between the shingles, due to Defendant Lehman's improper installation of shingles when the roofs' decking was wet. 24. Due to the existence of the deficiencies and defects noted in Paragraphs 22 and 23, above, the house constructed by -6- LAW C'J"'IC... SNItLOAKIR . BRENNEMAN .. . Defendant Lehman for Plaintiffs had not been oonstructed in a reasonable workmanlike manner and was not fit for habitation as a residential dwelling. 25. By reason of the defects and deficienoies noted in Paragraphs 22 and 23, above, Plaintiffs are required to expend the tollowing sums in order to remedy same. a. Cost to clean interior of house, inclUding contents I $4,452.93 b. Cost t~ paint walls and ceilings of interior of housel 6,704.00 c. Costs for hotel accommodations while painting and Cleaning take placel 2,003.40 d. Cost to replace carpet: 5,657.38 e. Cost to replace soot damaged personal property 897.24 f. Cost to readjust the gas line after installation of 1/2 inch gas linel 79.50 g. Cost to renail and reseal shingles on porch, house and garage roofsl 300.00 WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand jUdgmpnt against Defendant Lehman in the amount of $20,094.45 together with interest and costs of this action. -7- LAW O""CIl' SNILDAKER . BRINNIMAN . . I . I , I II . 32. A. a direct, proximate and factual result of the neqligenoe, oar.le..ne.. and/or reckle..ne.. of Detendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, a black sooty residue wa. emitted from the fireplace during its operation, causing Plaintiff. to sustain the losses and damages set forth in Paragraph 25, above (excluding the damages set forth in Paragraph 25(g)). WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs demand judgment against Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, jointly and/or severally, in the amount of $19,794.45 together with interest and costs of this action. COUNT V. Plaintiffs Russel J. stone and Donna M. Barkley v. Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. Noal1aence 33. The averments of Paragraphs 1 through 14, inclusive, are incorporated in this Paragraph as if fully set forth herein in their entirety. 34. At all times relevant hereto Defendant Drawbaugh was an agent and/or employee of Defendant Tuckey. 35. At all times relevant hereto, Defendant Drawbaugh acted within the scope of his authority and employment as an agent and/or employee of Defendant Tuckey. -10- . . 11. Denied as stated. Detendant Lehman installed a hearth with mantel in Which the fireplace unit was set by Defendant Drawbaugh, 12. Admitted in part. It is specifically denied that Detendant Lehman installed the ceramic logs in the fireplaoe and further denied that Defendant Lehman installed the 3/8" gas line. It is admitted that Defendant Drawbaugh installed the ceramic logs and ran the gas line from the fireplace into and through the basement of the house. 13. Admitted. 14. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the answering Detendants are without knowledge or information sufficient to form a beliet as to the truth of the averments of paragraph fourteen (14) and strict proof of the same is demanded at trial. COUNT I 'laintiffe Ru.eel J. otone and Donna K. Barkley v. Defendant Keith L. Lehman, individually and doing bu. in... a. K , R Lehman contracting BREACH or CON'l'RACT 15. The answers in paragraphs one (1) thorough fourteen (14) are incorporated herein by reference. 16. Admitted in part. It is admitted that Defendant Lehman undertook construction of the dwelling in accord with the contract attached to the plaintiffs' Complaint as Exhibit "A", with the exception that as set forth in paragraph eight (8) above, at the ~ . I request of the Plaintiffs a ventless fireplaoe unit Wall inoorporated il~to the dwelling. 17. Admitted in part. As set forth in paragraph sixteen (16) above, while the original contract provided for a direct vent fJ.replace, at the request of the Plaintiffs, in or about November of 1993, the Defendant Lehman provided for a ventless fireplace in the unit. 18. Denied. 'I'he averments in paragraph eighteen (lB) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. To the extent that a response is deemed necessary, Defendant Lehman provided for a ventless fireplace at the Plaintiffs' request for reasons set forth in paragraph eight (B) above. 19. Denied. The averments as to liability and causation in paragraph nineteen (19) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. Further, after reasonable investigation, at this point in time the answering Defendants are unable to verify the averments contained in paragraph nineteen (19) and strict proof of the same is demanded at trial. WHEREFORE, Defendants Keith Lehman, individually and d/b/a K & R Lehman contracting, and Timothy S. Drawbaugh, respectfully request judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiffs, together with cORtS. ... . COUNT II 'lalbtiffl aU...l J. Btone and Donna K. Barkley v. Defendant Keith L. L.hman, individually and doinq busln... as K , R Lehman contraoting BRIACH or IKfLIID WARRANTY 20. The answers in paragraphs one (1) through nineteen (19) are incorporated herein by reference. 21. Denied. The averments in paragraph twenty-one (21) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 22. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Def.endant Lehman cannot verify that the fireplace installed emitted an offensive odor or a black sooty residue as such is averred, and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. It is specifically denied that the ceramic logs were installed improperly or that the 3/8" propane fuel line was insufficient to ensure proper combustion and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 23. Denied. It is specifically denied that the roof's dllcking was wet and that such caused the damages alleged, and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 24. Denied. The averments in paragraph twenty-four (24) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 25. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the answering Defendants are not able to verify the damages alleged and strict proof of the same is demanded at trial. ,. . WHEREFORE, DetendantB Keith Lehman, individually and d/b/a K , R r.ehman Contracting, and Timothy s. Drawbaugh, reBpecttully request judgment in their favor and against the Plaintiffs, together with oosts. COUNT III 'laiDtitt. Rus.el J. stone and Donna K. Barkley v. DeteDdant Keith L. Lehman, individually and doing bu.ine.. a. K , R Lehman contracting BR!ACH OP !XPR!SS WARRANTY 26. The answers in paragraphs one (1) through twenty-tive (25) are incorporated herein by reference. 27. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the answering Defendants are not able to determine how the Plaintiff.s interpreted the expresmed home warranty and to the extent that this warranty speaks for itself, any attempt to interpret or characterize the terms thereof are specifically denied and strict proof of the same is demanded at trial. 28. Denied. The averments in paragraph twenty-eight (28) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proot thereof is demanded at trial. 29. Denied. The averments in paragraph twenty-nine (29) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. WHEREFORE, Defendants Keith Lehman, individually and d/b/a K , R Lehman contracting, and Timothy s. Drawbaugh, respectfully , . . request judgment in their favor and aqainet the Plaintitfs/ toqeth.r with costs. COUIfT IV plaintiff. Ru..el J. stone end Donna K. Barkl.y v. Defendant leith L. Lehmen, individually and doing bu.in... a. I i R Lehman contraoting, and Timothy s. Dravbauqh NIOLIOIlNCIl 30. The answers in paragraphs one (1) through twenty-nine (29) are incorporated herein by reference. 31. Denied. The averments in paragraph thirty-one (31) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. To the extent that an answer is deemed necessary, Defendant Drawbaugh properly installed the ceramic fireplace logs and 3/d" fuel l1ne which servfld the th'eplace unit. Further, ensuring that the propane fuel tanks provided sufficient volume of gas to provide proper combustion was not within the scope of the answering Defendants' contract. See New Matter and Crossclairn below. The fireplace was installed in accord with the manufacturer's specifications. 32. Denied. The averments in paragraph thirty-two (32) as to J.iability and causation are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. . . . WHEREFORE, Defendants Keith Lehman, individually and d/b/a K , R Lehman contracting, and Timothy s. Drewbauqh, respectfully request jUdqlDent in their favor and against the Plaintiffs, toqether with costs. gQYJfT VII Plaintiff Ru..el J. stone v. Defendant Keith L. Lehman, individually and doinq busine.. as K , R Lehmen contraotinq, Timothy s. DraWbaugh, Tuokey .eohanioal servioe., Ino. and Herman , Shenk, Ino. lfllOLIOIlNCIl 39. Thll answers in paragraphs one (1) through thirty-eight (38) are incorporated herein by reference. 40. Denied. The averments in paragraph forty (40) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof ther~of is demanded at trial. 41. Admitted. 42. Denied. The averments in paragraph forty-two (42) as to liability and causation are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 43. Denied. After reasonable investigation, the answering Detendants are unable to verify the averments contained in paragraph torty-three (43) and strict proof of the same is demanded at trial. .. . WHEREFORE, Defendants Keith Lehman, individually and d/b/a K , R Lehman contracting, and Timothy s. Drawbaugh, respectfully request jUdgment in their favor and against the Plaintiffs, toqether with costs. COUtIT VI II 'laintiffs Ru..el J. stone and Donns K. Barkley v. Defendant Keith L. Lebaan, individually and doing bu.ine.. s. K , R Lehman contraoting NI!GLIGI!NCIl 44. The answers in paragraphs one (1) through forty-three (43) are incorporated herein by reference. 45. Denied. The averments in paragraph forty-five (45) as to Defendant Lehman's negligence is are conclusions of law to which no r~sponsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. To the extent that an answer is deemed necessary, the roof's shingles were installed when the roof's decking was dry. 46. Denied. The averments in paragraph forty-six (46) as to liability and causation are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 47. Denied. The averments in paragraph forty-seven (47) as to liability and causation are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereat is demanded at trial. "'. WHBRBFORB, Defendants Keith Lehman, individually and d/b/a K , R Lehman contracting, and Timothy s. Draw):lauqh, respectfully request jUdlJlllent in their favor and aqainst the Plaintiffs, I toqether with costs. Nil" NATTIIR 48. The answers in paragraphs one (1) throuqh forty-seven (47) are incorporated herein by reference. 49. For aesthetic reasons and as they deemed the direct vent would interfere with their use of the wraparound porch, the Plaintiffs requested that the Defendant Lehman construct a house so as to incorporate a vent less gas fireplace. 50. Defendant Lehman presented Plaintiffs with a brochur.e from which they selected a ventless gas fireplace in l1eu of a direct vent fireplace as originally called for in the specifications incorporated into tho parties' agreement. 51. The Plaintiffs informed the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh that they would locate the propane tanks to serve the fireplace at a point within 80 feet of the fireplace unit. 52. Defendant Drawbaugh installed the fireplace and gas line in accordance with the National Fuel Gas Code. 53. After the fireplace and gas line had been installed by Defendant Drawbaugh, and before same was connected to the propane tanks which Plaintiff provided, the answering Defendants provided plaintiffs with the installation and operating instructions for ~ unvented fireplace heaters, a copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibit "A". 54. After Defendant Drawbaugh ran the 3/8" gas line from the fireplace unit through the basement to the point in the foundation wall at which Plaintiffs had indicated the propane tanks would be located, the answering Defendants retained Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. to run an additional gas line through the foundation wall to two 100"pound propane tanks provided by the Plaintiffs. 55. Defendant Herman & Shenk did hook up the 3/8-inch gas l1ne it had extended through the foundation wall to the two 100- pound propane tanks which Plaintiff lccated next to the air conditioning unit. 56. Plaintiffs changed the location of the propane tanks in excess of 20 feet from the location they had indicated to answering Defendants that such would be situate, after Defendant Drawbaugh had installed the gas line from the unit to the foundation wall and after Defendant Herman & Shenk extended the line to the two 100- pound propane tanks. 57. Plaintiffs notified neither Defendant Lehman nor Defendant Drawbaugh that they had changed the location of the tanks before Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Servicee, Inc. extended the gas line, hooked up the system and operated the fireplace unit. 58. Plaintiffs continued to use the gas fireplace after they discovered such allegedly emitted an odor and discharged soot into the living space of the dwelling. 59. Plaintiffs have failed to mitigate their damages. . 60. At all timos relevant, the Defendants Lehman and Orawbaugh aoted and performed their work in a proper and safe manner. 61. The Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh did not act in a careless or negligent manner, nor did they fail to exercise due care in their activities. 62. The Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh performed their duties as instructed and pursuant to their contractual obligations. 63. Any damages Plaintiffs may have sustained were not proximately caused by the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, but were caused in whole or in part by the negligence of parties other than the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, whose conduct the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh had no control over or reason to foresee. 64. plaintiffs fail to state a val1d claim against the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh upon which reliet can be granted. 65. The Defendantb Lehman and Drawbaugh join Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. and Defendant Tuckey Mechanical services, Inc. to preserve their right of contribution or indemnification. 66. If liability is found on the part of the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, such liability being specifically denied, th3n Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. and Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. are solely or jointly liable, or liable over to the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, for contribution, indemnification, or both. WHEREFORE, the they be dismissed Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh request that from this suit with prejudice. In the alternative, it is requested that Defendant Herman , Shenk, Inc. and Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. be found solely or jointly liable to Plaintiffs, or Liable ovel.' to the Defendants Lehman and DraWbaugh, for contribution, indemnification or both, plus costs. NIW HATTIR IN THB NATURB or A CROSS-OLAIM PURSUANT TO PA.R.C.P. 2252141 Defen4ant. Xeith Lehman, individually and doing business a. X , R oontraatinq, Inc., and Timothy s. Drawbaugh v. Kerman' Shenk, Inc. 67. The averments in paragraphs forty-eight (48) through sixty-siK (66) are incorporated herein by reference. 68. If Plaintiffs sustained damages, said damages ~ere caused in whole or in part by the negligence of Dafendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. 69. The Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh join Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. to preserve their right of contribution or indemnification. 70. If l1abil1ty is found on the part of the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, such l1abil1ty being specifically denied, then Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. is solely or jointly liable, or l1able over to the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh for contribution, indemnification or both, plus costs. WHEREFORE, the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh request that they be dismi..ed from this .uit with vrejudice. In the alternative, it is requested that Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. be tound solely or jointly liable to Plaintiffs, or liable over to the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, for contribution, indemnification or both, plus costs. HI. MATTIR IH THI NATURI OF A CROBB-~ iYRaUANT TO PA.R.C.P. 22521dl Defendant. Keith Lehman, individually and doing busine.. a. K , R contracting, Inc., and Timothy s. Drawbaugh v. Tuckey Mechanical services, Inc. 71. ThE! averments in paragraphs forty-eight (48) through sixty-six (66) ar.e incorporated herein by reference. 72. If Plaintiffs sustained damages, said damages were caused in whole or in part by the lIegl1gence of Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. 73. The Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh join Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. to preserve their right of contribution or indemnification. 70. If liability is found on the part of the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh, such liability being specifically denied, then Detendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. is solely or jointly l1able, or liable over to the Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh for contribution, indemnification or both, plus costs. This book contains your Inslallallon Inslrucllons and should be kepI In a sole place. It will be a handy reference guide to operallng your IIreplaclI alter Installallon. For you to realize 1111 the advantages and use of your IIrllplace, you must carefully follow all the Instrucllons contained In Ihe book regardlnQ Inslalla. lion and operallon of Ihe fireplace. These Instrucllons should be read carefully In Ihelr enllrety before beginning Ihe Installallon of the IIreplace. It Is suggesled Ihal you wear wor!< gloves and safety glasses 10 protect your hands and eyes when Inslall. Ing your IIreplace. NOTE: Authorities having jurisdiction (I.e., building Inspectors, tire marshals, elc.) should be oonsulled before Installation to Cletermlne Ihe need to obtain a permit. Whon Instaltlng a fan kit, on louverod modols (See charI, p. 3,), It Is necessllry to bring a power sourCe 10 .Ihe "replacll before walls are enclosed. See Ian kil Instrucllons. Tho following optional accessorlas ore available for use with your tlreplace: Decorative Lcuver Trim Kltl lPB:l6 and lPB42 (polished brass IInlsh), lPSG36 and lPSS42 (polished stainless steel) Decorative Surrounds SPB36 and SPB42 (polished brass IInlsh), SPSS36 and SPSS42 (polished 51alnless steel) Fan Kit FAN.5 and JB.2junctlon box (louvered models only) Fine Furniture Cablnell. specially designed 10 enclose these lire place heaters are also available In a variety of slyles. t CONTENTS Importantlnformallon. . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . .. . . . .. . . . . . .. .. . . . . .. .. . . . . . .. .. Page 2 Planning Ahead. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4-6 Choosing a locallon .... . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . 4 Gas line. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Dralts . . . . . . . . . . . , . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Firebox Clearances .... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 4 Installing the FIrebox. . . , . , . . , . , . . . I . . , . . I , . . . . . . , I . . I . . . , . . . , . I , . . . , . . , . . I . . . . . . I , . . 5-7 Framing the Firebox. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 5 Installing the Firebox . . . . . . . . , . . . . . . . . I . . . , . I , , . . , , . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . I . . I . . . I . . . . 6 lSevelrflng tthhe FFlr,ebobox. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 55 ~ ecu ng e ra x ...............................,............................".. " Gas Piping and Connection. . . . . . . . , . , . . . . . . , . . . . . . . , . I . , . . . . . . , , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 6 Gas Pressure Check . . . . . I . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . , . . I . I . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I I . I I . . . 7 Unpacking Logs . . . . . . I . I . . . I I . I . . . I . . . . . I I . I I . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . I . I . . . . . . . 7 Posillonlng Logs. . . . . I . . . . . . . I . . I . . . . I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . 7 Installing the Canopy. . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . , . . I . . . . . . . . 7 Fireplace screen ................ I . . . . . . . . . . I . . . I . . . I . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . 7 Oecorallve Volcanic Ash ......... I . I . . I I . . . . . . I I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . t . . . 5 Finishing tha Fireplace .. I I . . . . I . . I . . I . . . . . . I . . . . I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . 8 Clearances. . . . . . . . . . . I I . . . I . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . I . . . . t . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . 8 Safely Instructions. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . I . . . . . I . . . . I . . . . . . . I I . . I . . . . . . . . 9 llghUng Instructions ...................... . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 9 Match Lighllng. , . . . . . . . . . . . I . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . I . I . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . I I I . I . . . I I . . . . . 10 Flame Check... . . ..... . . I ... . I.... . ..... ... ... I.... ...... . .... " .. ........ . I I.... I . 10 Turning Off Gas Appliances. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . , . . . , . . . . . . . . 10 Importanl Safeguards . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . , , I . . . . . . . . . . 10 Cleaning , . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . - . . t . I . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . .. . I . . . . . . .. ,,' I . . . . 11 Servicing . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . I . . . . . . I . . . . . . . . . I I . . . . . . . . . . . . I I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I . " Repair Parts ............ I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . I I . . . . . . . I . . , . . I . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . 11 Parts List. . .... I . . . . .. ... ..... I .... . ",. I . .. I..... . I .... . I ..... ...... " "" .. ..... . 12. 16 Exploded View.. . . I.... I.. .... ... I .. "," "". ........ I I.. I . I ,.... ... . .... . .. 1:~ '1/~1 1& 17 Limited Warranly Policy. . . . . . . . . . . . I . . . . I . . I . . I . . I . , . . . . I I . I . I I . I . . . I I I . . . . . . . I I . . . I . I 20 2 l~' ~ . nda:&lMpl'UIIC' Q1~.r"rul' ADL35N ADL35P ADL3529N ADL3023P ADL42N ADL42P ADF30N ADF35P AClF3529N- -~ ADF3523P . I . . -r;- -;- - -;- 39 31 -- ---- -.- ._- - 29 23 ----- --'- . 39 -;- -- '---;- -;- -- 31 - . I 311 ---. . 31 . 29 . 23 . . ~QUI" prtMra llI~t"'M. ADF42N . k . . 39 -:~:;::N --:=r~-~ --;- --;: --; -~ ~~~ -_. FP2023P FP4000N FP4000P FR2529N FR2523P FR4500N FR4500P .'C::= --;- -_'::::--'. . I .. -r-;- - .----. . ---- 23 39 31 29 23 39 -- 31 I . . I ~--;- IMPORTANT INFORMATION ~ INSTALLER: Plba.. loov. Iho.o Instructiors wilh th. owner, OWNER: Ploas. rolaln Ihoso Inslrucllons 10' luIura r.'or. enca, WARNING: ANY CHANGE TO THIS HEATER OR ITS CONTROLS CAN BE DANGEROllS. IMPORTANT: READ THESE INSTRUCTIONS CARE. FULLY BEFORE INSTALLING. .Th. appllanco araa must b. k.pl claar and Iraotrom combusliblo maloriala, ga.olino .nd othor lIammablo vapors and liquids. 'Duo 10 high lomporalur.s. tho applianco should bo localed oul 01 trafllc and away Irom IUlOlturo aod d,apories. .Young children should be caroluliy suparvisad when thoy ora in Iho soma room os tho applianco. . Tho appilanc. should b. Insp. clod bolo,o uao and .lloasl annuaily by a prolosslonal sorvlco parson. Mora Iroquonl cloanlng may bo roqulrod duo to oxcosslve Iinllrom carpollng. boddlng ma'orlal. otc. ~ Is Importanllhal oontrol compartmenl, bulOors, and clrculallng air passagoways 01 tho opplianco be kopl ciao,. .Chlidron nnd aduns should bo aJortad 10 the hazard 01 high surlacolomporalures and should st.y away 10 ovoid bulOs or clothing Ignlllon. .DO NOT place clothing 0' other lIammable ma'erlal on 0' noar the applianco. .This applianco musl only b. usad with pr...u,os allhe Inial as shown In labl. 1. .The Inslailallon musl conlorm wllh local cod.s or. in Ih. abunc. 01 local cod.s, with Iho NATIONAL FUEL GAS CODE, ANSI 2223.1.1992. 'Tho applianco and ils Individual shul-<lff valve must be dlsconnoctod Irom Ihe gas supply piping syslom during any prosauro I.sllng 01 that syalom alios' prossuros In uco.. 01 l'l PSIG (3.5 kPa). .Tho appllanc. must b. isolatod Irom Iho gas supply piping system by closing ils Individual manual shul.oH valvo during any 'esllng 01 the gas supply piping systom 01 tost prossuros oquolto or less Ihan 17 PSIG. l. .00 NOT usa this hoalor In sleeping quarters, mobile homos or rocroallonal vohiclos. .Inslaliallon and ropall should be done by 0 qualifiod servlco porson. .00 NOT uae this heale' ~ any port 0111 has been sub. merged undo, water. Immodlalely cllll a qullllfled I.chnl. cion 10 Inspect the oppliance and replace any part 01 Iho conlrol systom and any gas conlrol which has boon undor walar. 'Always ensuro Ihatthere is adequale venlllallon f,om th. room whare Iha appliance Is operoling. This sppilance Is equlppad with an ODS (Oxygen Oeplellort Sensa,) pliOI Iighl salery syslam doslgned 10 shul itseH off ~ nol ana ugh fresh air Is available. Addilional venlllallon may be ob. lalned by oponlng a doo, to en anothe, room. opening a window. or operallng a central furnace blower, uhausl fan, 0' maka up air blowo,. .ALWAYS OPERATE THE APPLIANCE AT THE LOW, MEDIUM. OR HIGH CONTROL POSITIONS. NEVER USE THE HEATER AT A SETTING AETWEEN THESE POSITIONS AS THIS CAN RESULT IN IMPROPER COMBUSTION AND EXCESSIVE CAn RON MONOXIDE EMISSIONS. .THIS APPLIANCE MUST NOT 11E' U~".fJ Vii /11 GLASS DOORS. 'Keep burne, and conl,ol compoli/"enl r1n.n ~{'p' Installa. tlon and operating InstructIons \l("('Oflll "'Iyli"jll,u heater. 'WARNING: Dunng manutactunnV.lar.". ..11",,' '.'101 shipping, various componenls or this appliance ;,11/ 1'l'...II~ with certain oils, IIlms. or bonding agenl5. T hesa chomlcals ora nOI hArmlul but may produce annoylnp .mo.. and smells as Ihey ar. burned olf dunng Ihelnillal or".' .;IIt." (,r tr,a appliance, possibly causing hon,I;'cha. 01 'y' "I lung Irrllallon. This Is a normal and I.n,porary occulle'lCe. Thalnlllal broak.ln oporation should 1000t 2.3 hours wlih Ihe burner allhe hlghesl sonlng. ProvldO maximum vonlllallon Ily opening windows or doors 10 ellow odors 10 dlsnlpala. Any odors remaining a~er Ihls Inlllol b,aak.ln will bo sllghl and Will dlaappear WIth conllnued use. 3 PLANNING AHEAD CHOOSING THE LOCATION FOR YOUR FIREPLACE: Flgutl 1 ohowo 00"'0 ollh. ",any way. you, fl,oplat" may bo Inalallod, Conaldo, Iho I,alllc pallo'" In you, room and Iho Iocallon 01 dooro and window.. Moving air from Clllllng Ian.. opo" dOo,o, and hol ai, grill. may couu Iho lIamo. 10 Figure 1 Nltfl"I.~ ~J.C'T101l /lk)QMOIYIOIII co""u ...,.. Figure 2: Fireplace and Framing Dimensions (Ins.) ...... A ----- I C '1 A o C 0001. " a dlalu,bance 10 lound Ihol olloCla Ih. lIamoo, " muol bo ollmlnalod by lu,ning Olllho c.,llng lan, c1o6lng Iho doo,. or clooing 0' moving Iho hol ai, roglsl.'. A corn.r loco lion /nOY b, bQst whut., "pace hi Il/lll"H~, You, 11,0place woigho no mo,o Ihon sOmo 01 you, Iin. "uniluro. IIlho 11,0placo 10 local ad no 0' a load boo,ing wall. addilianal ouppo,t. 10 Iholaundallon will nol bo noco.oary, HEAVY FACINGS SUCH AS BRICK. STONE. ETC.. MAY REQUIRE ADDITIONAL FOUNDATION SUPPORT. ALTHOUGH THIS UNIT MAYBE INSTALLED ON COM- BUSTIBLE SURFACES, IT MUST NOT BE INSTALLED ON CARPET OR VINYL I ! i GAS LINE Tho goo IIn. muol bo In"ollod bola,ol,ami"g I",h. IIIoplac. by a Ilcon..d gao 11"0 Inalallo" DRAFTS Do nOllocalolho 11,0placo i" high "allle .'.00 0' .,.oo ..poood 10 high dralto and wlndo, LOCOlo Ih.liroploce .way Iram IU'l1/lu,. and d,opll"", f t\ 1:=, r"1 . 0 T ',H 1 K ~ -~c ... ~ _J 01 A B C E F a H I J K N 0 Q n s 36" louvered' 36 22 39 31Y2 35 38 2 9 21 80A 22 21 65 3?'Y' 46 ..-..- 36" IIush' 36 22 39 7 35 36 9 21 80/0 22 21 65 32V. 46 ---._-- l' 42" louvered' 42 22 45 31 34Y. 39 11 23'1. 6'A 29'A 23'1. 77'A 3B';" 54V. 42" IIush' 42 22 45 5'1. 34Y. 39 11 23'1. 6% 29'11I 23'1. 77'A 38';" 54 V. 'S.o chart. p. J, lor modol numbo,., 4 c -~'--~ ..... 1I a ----- ...... - t4 ..-., . AREPLACECLEARANCES Th~ flfoploco may bo plocod directly on a combuSI,bl. 1I00r, agolnol a combusllblo wall 01 mo",od cl.aranc... 0' on a ,alnd wood.n plallo,m. IIlh. flr.ploc. Is 10 b. Inslull.d on a ,.Iud woodon plollorm. Ih. plollorm musl b. a corlllnuous l.v.lsurfoC1l. Tho Ilreplaco musl bo sor,uI.d In plBC. so II cannol ,h,1I poalllons. Th. nailing 1I0ng.. on Ih. ,Id., of Ih. 1I,.box make ucurlng 1110 Ih. Iram,ng ...y. Th.y w.re deslgn.d 10 allow Ih. Inslallallon 01 ~. wallboard 0' plYWOOd lIush wllh Ih. foc. of Ih. IIrO)l'oc.. Only Ih. hood.r (50. FlguI. I) may I.sI on Ih. slandoNs on lop Ollh. IIr.box. Wh.n 1110 IIr.plac. Is Inalall.d OVOl corp.llng, vinyl 1,1.. 0' any combuallbl. mal.,ioJ olh.r Iha" wood 1I00llng. 'I musl bft Inslall.d on a m.lal or wo09 pan.1 ,,'.ndlng lis lull wldlh end d.plh. AII.rnallv.ly. Ih. carp. ling, vinyl III., .Ie. may b. rlmoved b.noolh 111. IIr.placo bulmu In'lolllng. COMBUSTIBLE MATERIALS MUST NOT BE INSTALLED OVER OR TOUCH ANY BLACK PAINTED SURFACE. 00 NOT BLOCK HEAT CIRCULA TlNG AIR OUTLETS. OOING SO MAY RESULT IN POTENTIAL FIRE HAZARD. Framing musl resl on lop 01 slondo"s. I. Sldowsll CI..,ancu: Cloorancos from Ihe sldo ollho IIreplac. opening 10 any combusllble wall ahould nol be I.u Ihan 151'1'. S.. Figure 4A. 2. Colllnp Cloarancur Th. c.,lIng halghl should nol bo 1.51 Ihan 42" Irom Iho lop ollh. fireplace opening. INSTALLING THE FIREBOX Thle IIsl of sp.cillc Inalruelions w,lI h.lp you mak. cunoln Ihal.v.ry Inslollallon oporolion 's don. corr.ctly. Complel. Ih. Inslallallon Slopa In Iho uquonc. shown. LOCAL BUILDING COOES SHOULD BE CONSULTED IN ALL CASES AS TO THE PARTICULAR REOUIREMENTS CONCERNING THE INSTALLATION OF FACTORY BUlL T FIREPLACES. S.IOC1lhe Iocallon lor Ih. Iireplaco by laking Inlo conslde,ollon Ih. 10elO's p,.vlously oulllnod In Ihe Planning Ahead slellon ollhe manual. ~ Step 1: Framing the Firebox The wldlh 01111. Iram.d opIning musl b. 39" for 36" mod.I., 45" lor 42' mod.ls. S.o Figure 3. Th. enllre flreplac. con bo Illvol.d above Ih. 1I00r 10 achl.vo a roiS.d hlanh ."oct. This can be don. by adding a small pla"orm 10 acl1i.v. Ih. doslr.d h.'ghl. NOTE: IIlnaloJllng a Ion kll on Ihe IIr.placo, Ih. Iow.r grrll must bo ov.n wilh Ih. Iloor. Th. Wiling r.quir.d lor Ihe low., blow., musl be Inslalled durrng Ih. framing slaga. S.. fan killnslallalion InSlruct,ons lor wl,ing r.qulrlm.nls. The nailing lIang.. on bolh s,dos W.r. d.slgn.d 10 allow Ihe inslallaflon of ~"wallboard or plywood lIush Wllh Ih. lac. of Ih. flr.plac.. Wh.n Ih.',amlng Is Insid.. Ih. OUlsld. wall will b.lnsu- laled. If Ih. framing or chas. is oUls,d.. Ihin ins'Jlalion should b. used In Ih. fram,ng on Iho back. s'd.s. and lop. The bonom should b. Insulalld with a hord Insulaling board. Th,a will prov.nl cold Irom going inlo Ih. chas. Ihrough Ih. f1r.plac. 10 Ih. !rvli'g spaco. Step 2: Install the Firebox InSlall flr.box 'nlo Ih. Iram.d oponing by s.II'ng II dlrOC1ly in I,onl of Ih. opening and sliding "'nlo Ih. prop.r position. Step 3: Level the Firebox Ch.ck Ihe l.v.1 of Ih. flr.box on Ih. lop odg. ollh. 1I,.plac. face. Shim ~ necossary. l Step 4: Secure the Firebox Secure Ih. 1I,.plac. 10 Iho fram,ng. The nailing Ilanges on Ihe IIr.box will make securrng Ih. IIr.box 10 Ihe frame qu,ck and uosy. Use approp,lal. SIZ. na,ls or scr.ws 10 ..cure Ihe IIrebox. Flguro 3: Fromlng Dlmenslcns (Ins,) I+-- 0 -.. \r c 1 USU,-mln. -A "'1"- It.dMNnC'nof~ teqult.dlll Ulllpolnl. t+-- c ~ B r1 R 1 - 0;:0":"_ A 36" modal. 42" modola A 39 45 ~: "2~/,~L~A - 5 FOR YOUR SAFETY READ BEFORE LIGHTING {I. WARNING: II you do nOllollow Ihu. Inllluellonl ulelly, . 1111 OIUplollon mlY ,uull eaullng prop.'lY dlmlg., PI'IO"lllnlury, 01 Iou 01 1111. A. Thll appllanell. .qulpp.d wilh an "nlcon dIVI," (plol"l ",hlch IUlol1101lcollV IIglll' Ih. 1>101. IIlho pl.,O 1011.. Ih.n IIghllh. pllol ""1J1 mOlchn nulla, 10 malch llQ/lUnO InIIlUCUO"I. ~ B. BEFORE OPERATION .mull all 0 arounu Ihll appliRnc. B1U lor gOI. J a. lur. to 11111111 m.).1 II,) lhu lloor , - bttc.u.. &om. 'Jill II huo""", lhan Ill, ,.... and will ..1111 on th,lIoor, WHA T TO 00 IF YOlJ SMELL GAS: Flgur. A.l ,Do nol try 10 IIghl any appllanco. -Do nol "'ueh any .11ICt,lcal ."'IId1: dO nol u.. any phon. In you, bUilding. -lmm.dlolOly call yo", uo. .upplll' 110m a n.lghboll phon.. 'Follow tho QDS auppllur'llnSUUl.'uone. ,II you ca"nol roach VOU, gBl,upplll'. clllllh. fI'l dlpo", menl, C. U.. only vour hand 10 po.h on orlum U" ga. <'Onllol knob. NlfV'U u..loole. If thl knob '/tIll nol push 111 or turn by hW1d, dOff! try 10 'upolr II. ClIIl a qulllllllld Uf\'IC1IIOd1n1"on. Fo,c, or CLOCKWISE o".mplOd "pwr may Flgu," A.2 ~'--' cau.. 11 Ii,. or I1n Q)lplo, OFF 1 lion. @G.~ ,., 0.00 nOI un Ihl. oppUan<"II any ( pOlt uf It hOI bllu" undo, woler. hnmodallliy 0411 0 qullllllad 1if'llc. 2 "cI1nletan 10 In.pllct 111. appllanc. - kNOB and 10 Ilplac. any pa" ollh. cen\lol 4 3 'YlIl.m or gOI conuol which hili bue" unuor Wllhu. LIGHTING INSTRUCTIONS I,. I. STOPI R.ad "'1/lV Inlormanon ollova bolo," pll:x:1MJing. 2. R.,., 10 Agu," ,0\.2. To Mn oil Ih. gBl ,upply. d.pra.. the knob ~jghtlV and turn dock-wlU 10 Ihll OFF P08111Qn. 3. Wntl flvo minuted 10 ctUQI out anv gBI, II you then IIlnell gos, STOP! Follow 'B.~ in the 15ulIlIV Inlorml1110n 1100"'11. II you don' Ilnlilll gal, go on to the nU.llll1lJp, 04. R.,., to FlgurI B. l.OCBtllhlt pilOI, It II In Irani of thl bonom nght hWld Ilde ol1t11 Ironll09 In Ircnt 0' thl mom burnur, ~. R.,., to ~1gu," C. Pu.h In Ih. conllol _neb and Mn counlerctockwillllO the lllNG p06111on. Held the oontrcl knob In lor n lew lI8COndl, 6. While lull holcmg in '''II conlrol knlJb. preu the Ignllor pu.h.bunon ..v.,.1 tlm... Thla Will c.u.. 0 spo,k.1 111. pllOI ",hleh "'lIIlgnU. Ih. pliO I g... 7. R.,., 10 Agu," C. Hold 111. control knob lor 10 secondllO prevent the lIame 'adult dlllGClor 'rom Ihunlng on Ih. g.. whlloll. probe III warmng up, 6. R.I...alh. control knob. Q. " 111. knob do.. not pop up wh.n 'Ili....d. .IOp and Imm.d1.,oly call you, ..",c.l.chnIClan. 10. " 111. pllol ",III nOlllay III an., ..v.,al III". lum Ih. 00. conlrol knob 10 OFF and e.1I you, .o"'co led1nlclon or gos supplier. II. To turn 111. go. .upply on. dopr... Ih. _nab .lightly and lurn 10 tho ..lUng you p,ol.r. ~ Figure B . '2. Th. .."ln9 po.IUon. lor rmdol. AOL..:lGN, ADL:J6P, ADL42N, ADL42P, ADF'36N, ADF'36P, AOF4:!N. AOF42P, FP4000N, FP4000P, FR4IiOON, M<J FR4500P a..: Nllufll Plop.n. BTUH BTUH Pllol only Mwn burner (low rAIl I MlIIn bu,n., (lull "") All bum.,. (m.ln burn.' lull rol. and reor Ilamsll Tho ..nlng po.ltlona lor mod.l. AOL362gN, ADL3B23P, AOF362QN, AOF3623P, FP202QN, FP2023P, FA262QN, .nd FR2~23P aral \lING 2 3 4 12.000 10.000 24.600 20.000 30.000 31.000 N.IUfll prop.n. BTUH BTUH ""I Pllolonly MlIIn burn., (low "I.) MlIIn bu,n., (lull III.) All bum.ra (malo burnor lull ,ulo and ,.ar f1,mo.) 13. Thll appllll1cola IIn.d ","h 'Ou",lo", pllr'II"Hnnr 10' lhe lole purpou of laf., momllnlntt Ignition 01 1110 moln COUNTER. ~~{~~~:;":C0@1,lz. \~C;~I~~E Ihl blllle hill 'Itease _II~~~~ 4 turning the control knob KtI(lIJ . . 10 I~. OFF po~tlon. 14. Th. conllol knob Ihould nol b.l.n 611h. Ignltl'" ..nlng on.. 111. pllOI h.. b.on ignll.d. IIING 2 3 4 B~OO Ig.OOO ~g.OOO e~oo 14,000 23.000 TO TURN OFF GAS TO THE APPLIANCE O.pr... Ih. oonllol knob .llghlly and Mn II to Ih. OFF poslUon. RG,..to Flgult C. 9 PARTS LIST Modell ADL36N. ADL36P, AI)L42N, ADL42P, ADF36N, ADF36P, ADF42N, ADF42P, FP4000N, FP4000P,FR4500N,FR4500P e OAS LOa PARTS RI" Oucrlpllon Pltit Oly, RI" Oucrlpllon Plrt' OIy. , waldad grata any" Irani ~089305 ~B knob aupport brackal 2069247.8 , 2 waldad grata any" ra.r ~06932 , , 49 control knob Wi clip 1 C6g208 , 3 basa plaia ~069227-F , 60 right burner luba, nal. 1069260 , 4 main burnar, nal. ~C69210 , 50 right burnar lubl, LP 1069349 , 4 main burnar, LP I C69340 1 61 Ilr shunar 1869261 2 5 main burnat Injlctor, nal. 'C69221 1 62 luba clamp lA69262 2 5 main bumar In/lctor, LP lC69341 I 63 I,ft burner luba I A69268 1 6 main burnar bracht 1869329 I 64 dall platl, nal. 7C69264.N 1 7 plaza brackot lC69230 1 64 dala pima, LP 7C69264.P 1 8 piela WI nut 1886180 I 65 Ilghllng Instructions plate 7C68265 1 9 ODS pilol any., nal. 4C691l<49 1 68 salaty Inslructlons plall 7C69268 I 9 ODS pllol any., lP 4C69960 , 67 blad chlln coupling 1A89221 1 I " wlra any. lA69302 1 68 blad chain 3A89387 1 '2 9as lap brackat 1 C69238 , 59 bonom Irontlog 1069260 1 '3 gas lap wi nul and plug I C69233 , 60 lop lrontlog 1089~81.C 1 ,~ sl,aalalbow, Y..27 NPTF lA89287 , 8' roar log 1089262 1 '5 'agulalor~ap luta I C69240 , 62 lOp log 1089263 1 '8 'Y.o' zouns nul (YI' dla, tuba, ,A69238 2 63 hardwara bag any. 12 'hold down' '7 la"ula (YI' dla.luba) , A69237 2 Icraw.) 4N69300 1 '8 laplpilot ragulalor luba, nal. '889239 1 64 match holder 1A69297 1 '9 'A' nut-24 UNF (',\0' dla. tuba) 'A69212 2 65 volcanic rock any. 4A68688 , 20 lo"ull (',\0' dla.lubo) 'A692'3 2 65 "0 24 ho. nul 1A69218 2 21 pilot regulator, nil. , C69225 I 67 l'o' dla. pop rlvat 1 A59202 6 22 mala Ilbow ',\0' dla. tubl), nal. 1869226 2 68 .8 32." Ph. hex screw, washar 23 piloUrogulator lubl, not. , A69282 I hlOd tyPI'" lA69313 2 . 24 pilolAap luba, LP '069344 I 69 .832 X l'o' Ph. pan hex screw, 25 lap/rlSlrlctor tubl , A89283 , wash or hud typa ',' 1A89203 22 26 ',10' nut-24 USN (V.' dla. lubl) 'A692'4 6 70 .540. \10' Ph. pan hex screw, 27 larrulo (Y.' dla.lubo) , A69215 6 hlOd typo ." ,A69249 2 28 .51 rlStrlctor, nal. '869280 71 16 X ',\0' Ph. and slid. pan ha. t scraw, washor haad typa '25' lA69469 2 28 .61 rulrlctor, LP '869345 I 72 18 x ~. Ph pan haad typa 'A' tA69205 4 29 ,oslrlctor union Too tuba , A89284 1 73 18 x lJ.' Ph pan hoad typa 'A' tA69206 1 30 II laplunlon Tee tuba '869285 I 74 '1\' 00, .19" 10, .032 THK wash or lA69204 1 31 union Taa wi nuls and larrulas '86928 I 2 75 pilol shlald 2A70105 t 32 union Toa/maln burnar luba '889241 I 33 tap union Too .2 tuba t A69286 I nal. . natural gas modal. 34 union Too rl9hl burna, luba 1 C69242 , lP . propano gas modal, 35 153lnjactor. nal. 1869244 , NOTE: All 'gas ilna tubes' will ba suppllud with Iha approprl. 35 867 Injoctor. LP 1869348 , all nUls and flrrulos. 36 union TII~lft burnor tubl I C68243 I 37 854 Injlctor, nal. 1869276 I FIREPLACE PARTS 38" modala 42" mOdll1 37 868 Injlctor, LP 1869347 I Plrt' OIy, PIIIN Qly. 38 ragulator, not. . 1869326 I llrescreln rod 3T68403 2 :1T65864 2 38 ,agulalor, LP . ,C69331 I screw lor lire. ,A63188 2 ,A6:1188 2 39 mall conn actor wi nul and flrrula . '869209 I ,creln rod 40 ,agulalor b,ac:kat 1869277 I llrescreln Wi rings 1T861 ~6 2 , T62' 97 2 ~1 burner cover I A69278 I screln rotalnll 'A62222 4 lP,6~;'/) 4 42 caution plato (Hot) 1869288 I refractory ralalner 2C68n4 1 ~1J69&~'1 1 43 air dlllactor platl 1 C69279 1 IcraWI lor ,afrae. 'A68188 2 IAbOlllU 2 44 shalt Ixtander auy. 4889289 1 tory ratalna, 45 'A.' c:ottlr pin 1 A89293 I rig hI sid a relractory 2088520 2068967 46 caramlc IIbar basa 1089231 I lilt ,Ida relraClory 2068519 2088906 . 47 gas tap shlold I C89246 I bad< relractory 2066993 2067130 bonom ra',actory 2068336 4C69553 canopy 2068n9 2D69554 12 PARTS LIST Models AOL31129N, AOL:\1l23P, AOF31129N. ADF31123P. FP2029N, FP2023P. FR21529N, FR21523P 4 GAS LOG PARTS R." Ollcrlptlan Part. Oty. RoI' Oucrlpllon P.rt. Oly. , w.ld.d oral. any" IranI ~069649 1 81 air Ihuner 1 B69281 2 2 welded o'ale any., rear 4069681 1 82 lub. clamp 1 A69282 2 3 bon plale 4D69687.F I 84 dala plate, nat. 7C69674 1 4 main burner, nat. 4C696011 1 84 dala plate, LP 7C69731 1 4 main burner, LP I C69720 1 88 1I0hllno Inllructlon. plata 7C66741 1 8 m~ln burner Inj.ctor, nel. 1 C69660 1 86 amfety Inllructlonl plat. 7C69266 1 8 main burn.r Inj.ctor, LP 1 C69724 1 87 b..d chain coupllno 1,1.69221 1 6 main burn.r brachl 1869229 1 88 b..d chain 3,1.69119 1 7 pilla brackel I C69230 1 60 lop fronllog 1069f3.48.A 1 8 pilla WI nul 1868423 1 81 raar log . 10696014 1 _ 9 ODS pilot a..y., not. 4C69949 1 62 lop 100 lD696016 1 9 ODS pilot .say., LP 4C69050 1 63 hardwall baO asay. (2 'hold down' 11 will osay. I A69302 I ocrewl) 4N69300 1 12 0" lap b,ack., 1 C69238 I 64 malch hold.r 1,1.69297 1 13 0" lap WI nUl and pluO 1 C69233 I 68 volcanic rock asay. 4,1.68688 1 14 Ilreel .Ibow, II .27 NPTF I A60287 1 66 .1024 hex nUl 1 A6921B 2 18 reoulalo'~ap lube I C69262 1 67 Yo' dla. pop rivet 1,1.69202 6 16 '>\0' zouns nUl (II' dla.lub.) I A69236 2 68 .832.1' Ph. hoax Icrew, weiher 17 ferrule (l\' dla. lube) 1 A69237 2 head Iype '1' lA69313 2 18 lap/pllollloulalor lube, nal. 1 B69282 1 69 18 32 X Yo' Ph. pan hex screw, 19 '/0' nut-24 UNF ('~.' dla.lube) IA69212 2 walher head type'I' 1 A69203 22 20 ferrule (',\0' dla. lube) 1,1.69213 2 70 .6 ~O x ~' Ph. pan hex Icrew, 21 pllollloulnlor, net. I C69225 1 h..d type' I . 1,1.69249 2 22 male elbow 'Ao' dla. lubel, nal. I B69226 2 71 .6 x .~,' Ph. and Iltd. pan hex 23 plloVreoulator tube. nOI. 1 A69282 1 ocrew, wsaher head type '28' 1 A69338 2 C 2~ pllolllap lube, LP 1 D69344 1 72 .8 x "'. Ph pan head type ',1.' 1 A69208 ~ 25 top/rellllctor lube IM9283 1 73 .8 x 'I,' Ph pan head type 'A' lA60206 1 26 7,\0' nut-2~ USN (V,' dlo.lube) IA6921~ 6 7~ '/0' OD, .191' ID, .032 THK wuh.r 1 A69204 1 27 lerrule (V,' dla.lube) 1,1.69215 6 78 pllol Ihleld 2,1.70108 1 28 .88 reltrlctor, nolo 1 B69662 1 28 .67 rOllrlctor, LP 1869722 1 not. . nalurol 000 model. 29 ,..I,lclor union Tee tube lA69662 1 LP . propane 001 model I 30 .1 laplunlon Tee luba 1 B69285 1 NOTE: All '001 IIna lubal' will be lupplled with the appropri. 31 union Ta. wi nUlo and ferrul.. 1 B69281 2 ala nul a and ferrulel. 32 union Teelmlln burnlllube 1 B6924 I I 34 union Te. ,Ighl burnlllubo 1 B69667 I FIREPLACE PARTS 35" mod.la 42" modala 35 .82 Injector, not. 1 B69663 1 Part. Oty. Parll Oty, 35 .68 Injecto" LP 1 B69723 I lire screen rod 3T6840:l ~ aT65864 2 38 reoulotor, nat. 1869326 1 ICIIW for fir.. 1,1.63186 ~ lJ1,~~186 2 38 r'oulalor. LP lC69331 1 sCllen rod 39 mal. connaclo, wi nUl and fe"ul. 1 869209 1 IllIscroon wi rin9s 1T66U6 2 1T62197 2 40 reoulalor brocket 1869277 1 ICllen rololnll 1 A62222 4 1 A6?222 4 41 burnll cavil 1,1.69664 1 relraclory relaln., 2C88774 , 2(J696017 1 42 caution plale (Hol) 1 B69463 1 SCIIWS fa, IIlrac. lA68160 ~ lM8108 2 43 air deflllC10r plale 1 C69665 1 lOry ilIa In., 44 Ihalt extend" a..y. 4869269 1 rlOht side relractory 2068520 1 2D68967 1 ~5 %,. collll pin 1,1.69203 1 lelt side ralractory 2066519 1 ,n68966 1 ~6 c.,amlc fib., bas. 1069843 1 back refllctory 2066001 I .!IU.,130 1 47 oas lap shield lC69246 1 bonom IIfractary 2D69:J:l6 1 4C695~3 I ~8 knob support bracket 2069247.B 1 canopy 2D68719 1 2069554 1 49 control knob wi clip 1 C59208 1 ,. 50 riOht burner tuba, not. 1 D69840 1 50 right burner tuba, LP 1069640 1 15 One Year Limited Warranty This warranty Isllmltsd to gas IIreplace healers manufactured and assembled by Temtex Products, Inc. (henceforth, Temlex). Warranty Coverage II any component 01 0 IIreplace covered under lhls warranty Is lound by Temtex to be defective within one year from the dole 01 Installation. Temtex will, at Its option, repair or repface the de'ecllve compo. nent at no charge and will pay reasonable labor costs Incurred In repairing or repfaclng such compo. nents. II replacement 01 repair Is not economlcatly practical, Temtex will. at Its opllon. refund the pur. chase price 01 lhe IIrepface. Dote 01 Install 011 on and purchase poce must be verllled by acceptable prool 01 purchase. This warranty covers only ports and labor as prOVided above. In no case shall Temtex be responsible lor materials. components. or construcllon which are not manufactured or supplied by Temtex. or the labor necessary to Inslall, repair, or remove such materials, compononts. or construction. Quallflcallon The IIreplace must be Installed In accordance with Temtex Installallon Instructions and local codes. The fireplace must be Installed by a qualified Installar and must be operaled according to the opera- lion Instructions furnished. This IImlled warranty applies only to Ihe orlglnel owner 01 the IIreplace or the original owner of the dwelling In which the IIreplace was Installed. Limitations Temtex Is not responsible lor any Incidental or consequenllal damages caused by poSSible defects In the product. The durallon o. any Implied warranty wlfh respect to Ihls IIreplace Is limited to Ihe durallon 01 the loregolng warranty. Some states do not alfow exclusion of Incidental or consequential damages or limits on the durallon 01 Implied warranlles 50 these limitations may not apply to you. Warranty Full/llment Temtex reserves Ihe right to Investigate any and all claims against this warranly and to decide on the melhod 01 settlement. Temtex Is not responsible forwarranly work completed without obtaining Temtex's consent. Terntex employees and dealel's have no right to alter this written warranty. This limited warranty Is given In lieu 01 any other expressed and Implied warranty. TEMTEX PRODUCTS. Inc. P. O. Box 1348 Manch.Il8r. TN 3735S (S15) 72e~OOI FAX (SIS) 728-1215 P.O. Box 1148 Pernl. CA 82572 (714) 857.731 1 FAX (714) 843-1841 A aublldl.'Y 01 TemloxlndulbiBl.lnc. 20 ( f (./' LAW U'''H.~.. SNILnAKEA o BRItNNItMAN roasonable workmanlike manner for the reasons set forth in the Complaint, the averments of which are incorporated by reference herein. 46. Paragraph 46 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. l029(d); thereforo, same is deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that Plaintiffs failed to mitigate their damages. 47. Denied. It is denied that Plaintiffs may have caused or contr ibuted to their injuries and damages. To the contrary, Plaintiffs' injuries and damages where caused by the Defendants as more fully described in the Complaint, the averments of which are incorporated by reference herein. 48. Paragraph 48 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.p. 1029(d); therefore, same is deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that Plaintiffs failed to state a cause of action upon which relief can be granted. 49. Paragraph 49 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is -2- LAW O"-"'C.. SNll.IIAKE!R . BRENNEMAN deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is neoessary, it ls denied that any statute of limitations applicable to Plaintitfs' claims expired prior to the institution of this action. 50. Paragraph 50 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that the acts of Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. were not substantial causes or factors of the incident and did not result in the injuries or losses claimed by Plaintiffs. 51. Paragraph 51 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that the incident or damages described in Plaintiffs' Complaint were caused or contributed to by Plaintiffs. 52. Paragraph 52 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by his party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is eerned to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that the incident or damages described in Plaintiffs' omplaint were caused or contributed to by Plaintiffs. -3- LAW O'''IC.. SNILOAKER '" BRl(NNEMAN 53. Paragraph 53 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that Plaintiffs assumed the risk of any injury, loss or damage. 54. Paragraph 54 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that Plaintiffs were contributorily negligent. 55. Paragraph 55 of Defendant's New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no relllponse is required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is deemed to be denied. To the extent a response is necessary, it is denied that the incident, injuries and/or damages sustained by Plaintiffs were not proximately caused by Defendant Herman & Shenk, Inc. 56. Paragraph 56 of Defendant's New Matter contains a series of unwarranted conclusions of law to which no response is. required by this party pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d); therefore, same is deemed to be denied. -4- , ... .... -" If) I , I " .'1 - I II' , .;/ ; 11,1. . Ii d. '\ I I h. "};; ;" ,:...} I II I .':.'i [,;", I" ' ,tjl - , .-.' 14 " I .. " ! " It) I.. I I l , <.) ~ ; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ .. i ;. ~i ~ 0 ~ .: ~ I' ~ I < ... 'II . . .. ~ SHERIFF'S R~TURN . REGULAR ~AHK NUl 1~~6'~4081 P CIJMl1llNW~:Al..'rll IW PI';NNijYLVANIA I CIJIJNTY IJF ~ H1l1lmLAND ' :"J'IJNI:; RW;H~;L J ":T AL VS. L~:Ill1AN K~; ITH l. ";T AL KI':NNI';TH ~;. IjlJm;l';RT CUMBEIlLANU County, P~nn8ylvani8, who t.o lew, 8ays. the w lthin ~UMI".A tNT uplJn LI';IlMAN KI.:nH l. tNPlVIP & D/II/A dE'to?ndant. at 20llll I 01/1. HIJlm::;. on thrr lY'}'" at ?llll'l WAI.NIJT OUTTUM IIIIAD CAIII.lHL~;, I'A ['/1/11:.1 --,1<.!11Ull::RJ.AND ClJllnty. I'lI'nnsylvenlli, by handing to KlUTH L. l.r':IlMAN a true and lit tested copy of the ~UMI'LAtNT tlJgether with NUTICK and et the S8me time directing tllA attention to the contents thereof. , Hheriff or Deputy ijheriff of belng duly sw"rn ~ccording wa. .erved K & R LIWMAN 1;IJNTRACTINll 2Yth. day of JUlY the J .-' -' Sh.riff'. Costel PO':keUng S.rvice Aff idavit Surcharg. 1/3.00 4.48 .00 2.00 So answeral .~";y,,.-::,:., ~ '1 ,'!':-?f.",,","".-'< _ ~~ Il. Thomas Kll",', She .Z4.48 SN~LBAKER AND BRENNEMAN 07/31/1996 ' by t;wlJrn and 8ub.'~ribed to b.fore me this .1."....,t dey of G..;,AAY 1Y q(, ,A.D. (.) c.c...a)~,~. "-f"'t I'r 0 t 110'0 0 ta I Y SH~:rlI F'F' 5 Jll;TUI1N . Ill;OUL.AI1 CAH~ NUl 1~~~'010ijl P lJlln/lIJNWI':A1:I'U Or,' rl':NNoYI.VANIA I Cll NTY IW C /Ill .:t~LANI) I:iTIJNI'; tlIJHIiI';L J J::'r AL Ys. LI':II/1AN K~;ITH L L::T AL II [CIIAL::L BAI1RICK , Hhniff or Deputy I:>hn1ff of CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania. vho being duly svorn Q~oording to lav, says, the vithin CU/lPLAINT upon IIJ:;RIIAN to SIII':NK INC defendant, lit 1511100 HOURS. on the ~day of lY.ll!- 1':1'22. at ~Lli!J.Il1.lLBALT[IIUJl~; AYE. liT. HU!.!.. V spn INOS. PA 171o?G5 , CIJIIBERLAND Cl'Junty, Pennsylvania, by handi.ng tl'J IW1:iMlTT SItIOLAV. GENERAL IIANAI1"Jl AND ADULT IN CllAtlGE a true and attested copy of the CU/lPLA[NT toqether vith NUT[C~ and at the slime time directinQ ~ attention to the oontents thereof. vas serlled the -' Sheriff's Costsl Dooketing Service Affidavit ~;urcharge ~.l/l0 ".18 .00 2.00 So anevll'r.~, ," , . ,r ~ . ,J~, f'" ~ r ....,4-~1"!.J..;;.' R. Thomas Kline, Sheriff 1J12. 46 SNl::LBAKEH ANO 07/31/1'3'39 ) l:ivorn end subsoribed to before me this ).~ day of ~........ 1':1 l/l, _ A. D. ,'\>-,\,-,- O.~, f\!JfWt. ~ I Prothonotary COUNT I. IU\F.ACII OJI CONTRACT RUHSl!1 J Stone nlld DOllnll M Barkley v Keith 1.. I.ehman. Individually 111111 dolllll busil1l!sS as K & It Lehmall COlllrnclinll I~. The avennenls of pllfllgflll!hs 1 Ihrough 14 of Ihis Answer lire hereby Incorporated by reference, 16-19 The averments of these JHlfIIgfllphs retcr tll II pllrly other thun the answering Delendantund therefore no response is required WHEREFORE, Detcndlll1l Tu~key Me~haniclll Services. Ine demunds judglllentln Its lllvor and dismissal ofllllllnlll11;' Complaint with prejudice COUNT 11 - lIIU:ACII OF 11\1I'I.U:U WAlmANTV Russel J Stone and lJonna M Burkley v Keith L Lehmllll i.wll.\1lWlllly nnll doillll business as K & It I ehmlln COlllrnctill1l 20, The averments of pllfllgfllphs I through 14 of this Answer lire hereby Incorporated by reference. 21-25, Aller reasonllhle investiglllion. Ihe IInswering DetcndlUlt is wllhout knowledge or Inlbnnatlon sullicientlo forma belief i1S to the tmth or titlsity of these IIvennents and strict proof Is demanded. WHEREFORE. lJelcndilllt Tu~key Me~hilnieill Servi~es, In~ demands judgmelllln Its favor and dismissal of Plililll I 111; , Complililll Wilh prejudice. COUNT IIJ - IIIU:ACII OF EXI'IU:SS WARRANTV Russel J Stolle nnd Donna M Barkley v Keith L L ehmlln, iwli.vidunlly and doinll business i1S K & R LehmllllJ.:.w1lraetinll 26, The averments of pllrllgraphs 1 through 14 of this Answer arc hereby incorporated by reference, 27-29, After reasonable Invcsllglltion, the answering Defendant is wit bout knowledge or Information sullicientto form a belief ns tll tbe Imtb or falsity of these averments and strict proof is demanded, WHEREFORE, Defendant Tuckey MechwllCllI Services, Inc. demands judgment In its favor and dismissal of Plalntifts' Complaint with prejudice. COUNT IV - NEGLIGENCE RllM!lel J Slone Bnd Dnnnn M Rnrkley v Keith I. L~hnlBn individuolly Bnd doinll business os K & R Lehl11lll1 COl1troctinll and ThntJlhy S. Drawbaullh 30. The averments of paragraphs I through 14 of this Answer are hereby incorporated by reference. 31-32. Denied pursuant to I'a. ItC I' 1029(e). WHEREFORE, DefendlUlt Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. demands judgment in its favor and dismissal of Plalntil1s' Complaint with prejudice. COUNT V - NEGLIGENCE Russel J Slone and 0011110 M Barkley v Tuckey Mechanical Services. Ine 33. The avennents of paragraph I through \4 of this Answer are hereby Incorporated by reterence. 34-35. Denied. To the contrary, at no time relevont 10 this Complaint was Defendant Drawbaugh acting as the agent, servant or employee of Defendant Tuckey. WHEREFORE, Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services. Inc. demands judgment in it$ favor and dismissal of Plain tilTs' Complaint with prejudice. COIJNT VI- NEGL.lGENCE Russel J Stone and Donna M Barkley v Hermon & Shenk Inc 36. The avennents of paragraph I through 14 of this Answer are hereby incorporated by reference. 37-38. The averments of these paragraphs refer 10 a party other than Ihe answering Defendant and therefore no response is required WHEREFORE, Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. demands judgment in its favor and dismissal of PlaintilTs' Complaint with prejudice. COli NT VII - NEGLIGENCE RUIRI!I J. Stnne And Dnnna M Barkley v Keith L Lehmlln IndlvlduR~ly And dolO" hUldnlHlfl 8M K & R [ ehmnn COlltrBclinw Timothy S Drawbaugh. .I.l.wkey Mechanical Se~lces. Inc. llnd HI!(mnl1 & Shenk Ine 39. The averment6 uf Jllll'Ugl'UJlh I thmugh 14 und 31 throuhlh 38 of this Answer are hereby Incorporated by reference. 40-43. Denied pur6uantto Pa. Rep 1029(e). WHEREFORE, Detimdant Tuckey Mechanical Service6, Inc. demand6 judgment In Its favor and dismissal of Plaint Ills' Complaint with prejudice COllNT VIII. NEGLIGENCE Russel 1. Stone and DOIIIIIl M Barkley v. Keith I.. Lehmall individually and doin~ busilless as K & R Lehman Contraclinll 44. The avennents ofporagraph I through 14 of this An6wer arc hereby incorporated by reference. 45-47. The avennents of these paragraphs refer to a party other than the answering Defendant and therefore no respon6e Is re.quired. WHEREFORE. Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. demands judgment In its favor and dismissal of Plaintiffs' Complaint with prejudice. NEW MATTER 48. Plaintiffs never entered into any wrillen agreement with the Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. for any ot'the mailers complained ofin the Complaint. 49. Plaintiffs never requested scrviccs either orally or in writing of Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. for any of the mailers complained ofin the Complaint. 50. Plaintiffs' claims are barred to the extcntthatthey have failed to reduce or mitigate their damages. COllNTERCLAIM NEW MA1"ER PIJRSlIANT TO PA It.C.!'. 2282(d) Tuckey Ml!chBnlcll1 Services. Inc. v Keith L Lehman Ind'vldul1l1y and dolnll bURlneKK All K &. R l.ehmnn ConlroclhHI. Timothy S. Dcnwbnuuh llud I-Jerman & Shenk. Inc. 51. The avennen13 uf PhlinlilJ's' Complaint, which avcrments have been specll1cally denied. are hereby incurpuratcd for the IImltcd purposc of this cross claim, 52. If 1'lalnlil1's are entitled 10 rel~over Iromllny party, which Is expressly denied, then Ihe other Defendanls are alone IIl1ble to PllIintilJ's or IIl1ble over to Defendant Tuckey by way of contribution Wld/or indemnity or lire jointly and/or severally liable to Defendant Tuckp.y on accounl of their own negligence or olher liability pmduclng conduct as alleged in the pleadings, 53. If Delendant Tuckey is found liable 10 Plaintiffs, which liability Is expressly denied, its liability is secondary and passive to the liability of the other co-Defendants whose liability Is primary and active, WHEREFORE. Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc, demands judgment against DefendWlts Keith L. Lehman, individually and doing business as K & R Lehman Contracting, Timothy S. Drawbaugh and Herml\n & Shenk, Inc. 1'01' all sums that may be adjudged against Defendant Tuckey In favor of Plaintitrs; in the alternative, Defendant Tuckey demands judgment against Defendants Keith L. Lehman, individually and doing business as K & R Lehman Contracting. Timothy S. Drawbaugh and Herman & Shenk, Inc, for contribution and/or indemnity for the appropriate part of the amount of damages and costs awarded to Plaintiffs. if any. MARTSON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & OTTO \, j I I By . \. , If.. I J Ge'orge B, Faller, Jr.. EsqrJre I,D. No. 49813 . Ten East High Street ' Carlisle, P A 170 I 3 (717) 243.3341 Attorneys for Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. Dated: August 27, 1996 i ., i' ,I' ,i " " d i ,\ r,; .4 ... ,. I.i I.." I \J1 i, " ~\\ I ~ :1;p. " i ':1,~ , , u.. . .,::3 .1 ,', ~\- ' ",- i, I' , M /l~ ., - i' i.W,f I, 5:\:' ::'" I I I L.: I ~ a tJ "J1 m i., ,I i, I I I , , " '., , , , , " I' , I , !>- ..:l' .'~ b~ i.. I Ll~ . , f' {.I; '.1.<1'. ~'I ~:: ,'31~, .. ..., ~ .... .!)?i .~ ( ~" :S~7 'J. I.. - "Jffi I ~I " t:I. I . ~~: '-.:.1 ll-l :;!.: d ~ .,) CT' 'I " ,I I, I' 'I .1 ,', I, " " .1 I I I , I I' , I " ., " , . 11 !I . , /! I I" 1'1 " " I , " 6-10. Denied. Aller rea50nabll~ Inve5t1gatlon, An5werlng Defendant lacks Information or knowledge sufficient to form a bU515 10 the belief a5 to the truth of the averments contained In thl5 paragraph and 5ame ure therefore denied, 5trlet proof being demanded at trial, If relevant. By WilY of further eKplanatlon Answering Defendant avers that the attached document5 referenced In these paragraphs speak for themselves. 11-14. Denied. After reasrmable Investigation, answering Defendant lacks Information or knowledge sufficient to form a basis to Ihe belief as to the truth of the averments contained In this paragraph and same are therefore denied, strlet proof being demanded at trial, If relevant. COUNT I, II, III, IV, V Paragraphs which contain averments directed to another party and therefore no response 15 requirEd of this Answering Defendant. COUNT VI 36. Parag-aphs 1 through 14 of Defendant's Answer are Incorporated herein and made a part hereof as If set forth In full. 37-38. legal conclusions which require no Answer. Where an Answer Is deemed to be required, after reasonable Investigation, Answering Defendant lacks Information or knowledge sufflelentto form a belief as 10 the truth of the averments contained In this paragraph and same are therefore denied, strlet proof being demanded at trial, If relevant. COUNT VII 39. Paragraphs 1 through 38 of Defendant's Answer are Incorporated herein and made a part hereof as If set forth In full. 40. Legal conclusions which require no Answer. Where an Answer Is deemed to be required, after reasonable Investigation, Answering Defendant lacks Information or knowledge sufficient to fcrm a bellllf as to the truth of the averments contained In this paragraph and same are therefore denied, strict proof being demanded at trial, If relevant. 41. Denied. Aftpr reasonable Investigation, Answering Defendant lacks Information or knowledge sufficient to form a basis to the belief as to the truth of the averments contained In this paragraph and same are therefore denied, strict proof being demanded at trial, If relevant. 42.43. Legal conclusions which require no Answer. Where an Answer Is deemed to be required, after reasonable Investigation, Answering Defendant lacks Information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained In this paragraph and same are therefore denied, strict proof being demanded at trial, If relevant. COUNT VIII Paragraphs which contain averments directed to another party and therefore no response Is required of this Answering Defendant. NEW MATTER 44. Answering Defendant was not negligent. 45. Answering Defendant preformed all work referenced regarding this Incident In a reasonable and workmanlike manner. 46. Plalntlfls (ailed to mitigate their damages. 47. Plaintiffs may have caused or contributed 10 their Injury and damages. 48. The Plalnllffs may have failed to state a cause of acllon upon which relief can be granted. 49. The applicable Statute of Limitations may have expired prior to the Instltullon of this action. 50. Any acts or omission of Answering Defendants alleged to constitute negligence were not substantial causes or factors of the subject Incident and/or did not result In the Injuries and/or losses alleged by the Plaintiffs. 51. The Incident and/or damages described In Plaintiffs' Complaint may' have been caused or contributed to by the Plaintiffs. 52. The negligent acts or omissions of other Individuals and/or entities may have constituted Intervening, superseding causes of the damages and/or Injuries alleged to have been sustained by the Plaintiffs. 53. The Plaintiffs may have assumed the risk. 54. The Plaintiffs may have been contributorily negligent. 55. The Incident, Injuries and/or damages alleged to have been sustained by the Plaintiffs were not proximately caused by Answering Defendant. 56. As to relates to the allegations against Answerlnll Defendant, and If Plaintiffs are able to prove the damages and causes for those damages as alleged, then the Answering Defendant, Herman & Shenk, Inc. In accordance with the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure of 2252(d) hereby loin, as additional defendant, Keith l. Lehman, Individually and doing business as K&R Lehman Contracting, Timothy S. Drawbaugh, and Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc., for the I' " , I " " I' " " , I . " Cl') ~ I/) & ' I !: ~-~I " I, I Y~' - N ~~ ~ F ~ ~ : d ' I .1 I .1 I 'I h , , , II I. I I' I_i I' " , , I' " , , n , ~ , , ' RUSSEL J. STONE and DONNA I IN TUE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS M. BARXLEY, I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiffs I t V. I I NO. 1996-4081 r.ivil Term XEITH L. LEHMAN, individually I and d/b/a K & R LEHMAN t CONTRACTING, TIMOTHY S. t CIVIL ACTION - LAW DRAWBAUGH, TUCKEY MECHANICAL I SERVICES, INC. and HERMAN & t SHENK, INC., t Defendants I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED RBPLY OF DBFENDANTS KBITH ~. LEHMAN. INDIVIDUALLY '-ND d/b/a It , R LElHMA!I CONTRACTING. AND ~9.l:HJ I. DRAWBAUGH ~~HB NEW MATT~D CROSSCLAIM OF DEFENDANT TUClEY MECHANICAL SERVICES. INC. AND NOW, come the Defendants, Keith L. Lehman, individually and d/b/a K & R Lehman contracting, and Timothy s. Drawbaugh, to reply to the New Matter and crossclaim of Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. as followSI 51. Please see Defendants Lehman and DraWbaugh's Answer to Plaintiffs' complaint. 52. Denied. The averments in paragraph fifty-two (52) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. 53. Denied. The aVfflrments in paragraph fifty-three (53) are conclusions of law to which no responsive pleading is required and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. , WHEREFORE, Defendants Keith L. Lehman, individually and d/b/a K & R Lehman contracting, and Timothy s. Drawbaugh respectfully request that this Honorable Court enter judgment in their favor. . - ~I. r ',-; i-' .. - .~ lit' ..:J I I 'j' .": -, I V.~ I',' .1.. t ~ I' t. I 1,11 ('- ,-. 'I- ';'''j , ,i . t;.~ (i' [:, \td I I , 1 :'4 I VI 'If; " , , , ,I l.> ,'.- 1..) ~ i 8 ~ ~ .. i dd !;. :( :;. ;. ~~ i ~ 0 .: ~ i <<( .... :: I, I 1 " 'I . . . LAW OI'JlC". SNELDAKIR II BRENNEMAN RUSSEL J. STONE and DONNA M. BARKLEY, Plaintiffs IN TUE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBER[~ND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA I I I I I XEITH L. LEHMAN, individually l and doing business as K & R l LEHMAN CONTRACTING, TIMOTHY I S. DRAWBAUGH, TUCKEY I MECHANICAL SERVICES, INC. and I HERMAN & SHENK, INC., I Defendants I NO. 1996 - 4081 v. CIVIL TERM CIVIL ACTION - LAW JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PLAINTIFFS' REpLY TO NEW MATTER OF DEFENDANT TUCKEY MECHANICAL SERVICES. INC. Plaintiffs, by their attorneys, Snelbak$r & Brenneman, P. C. submit the below Reply to New Matter of Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. as followsl 48. Admitted, with the qualification that the absence of a written agreement betwe~n the Plaintiffs and Defendant Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. does not absolve Defendant Tuckey for liability of its agent, servant or employee, Defendant Drawbaugh, as averred in Plaintiffs' Complaint. 49. Denied. It is denied that Plaintiffs never orally requested services of Tuckey. To the contrary, Plaintiffs requested Tuckey to look at the gas line. Defendant Drawbaugh, an agent, representative and/or employee of Defendant Tuckey provided services as set forth in Plaintiffs' Complaint and Defendant Tuckey in recognition of the services provided to Plaintiffs' by its agent, representative and/or employee replaced the gas line which is the subject of this proceeding without charge to the Plaintiffs. LAW O"",CUI 6NEL.UAKlR It BnENNIMAN Plaintiffs of Lehman. Defendant Lehman improperly in.talled a vent leas fireplace in Plaintiffs' house contrary to the contract specifications and without any explanation to Plaintiffs as to what a vent leas fireplace was or how it operated. 50. Denied. It is denied that Lehman presented Plaintiffs with a brochure from which Plaintiffs selected a vent less gas fireplace in lieu of a direct vent fireplace. To the contrary, no brochure was ever provided to Plaintiffs and Lehman unilaterally installed a ventless gas fireplace without Plaintiffs knowing what such a fireplace was or how it operated. I 51. Denied. It is denied that Plaintiffs informed Lehman and DraWbaugh that they could locate the propane tanks to serve the fireplace at a location within 80 feet of the fireplace unit. To the contrary, Lehman told Plaintiffs where the tanks would be located, which was originally within ten feet of the heat pump servicing the Plaintiffs' house. Lehman further told Plaintiffs that the concrete pad where the heat pump was located was big enough to accommodate the propane tanks. 52. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiffs are without sufficient information to form a belief as to the truth of the allegations contained in Paragraph 52 of Defendants' New Matter pertaining to installation in accordance with the National Fuel Gas Code; therefore, same are denied ~nd strict proof -2- LAW O"le.. SNELbAKIER a BRENNEMAN thereof dumanded. It is denied that Drawbaugh alone installed the fireplace and gas line. To the contrary, the fireplace and gas line were installed by Lehman with DraWbaugh's assistance. 53. Denied. It is denied that the fireplace and gas line were installed by Drawbaugh. 'ro the contrary, the fireplace and gas line were installed by Lehman with DraWbaugh's assistance. It is further denied that Defendants Lehman and DraWbaugh provided Plaintiffs with the installation and operating instructions for unvented fireplace heaters as identified as Exhibit A in Defendants' Answer with New Matter. To the contrary, no such instructions were provided Plaintiffs. 54. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiffs provided two 100-pound propane tanks. It is denied, for the reasons set forth in Paragraph 51, which Paragraph is incorporated herein, that Plaintiffs indicated where the tanks would be located. It is denied that Defendants retained Herman & Shenk, Inc. to run the additional gas line and make the hook-up to the tanks. To the contrary, Plaintiffs engaged Herman & Shenk, Inc. for those purposes. 55. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that Herman & Shenk, Inc. hooked up the gas line to the two propane tanks. For the reasons set forth in Paragraph 51 of this Reply above, the averments of which are incorporated by reference -3- LAW OI'I'ICU SNELBAKER II BRENNEMAN herein, it is denied that Plaintiffs looated the tanks nftxt to the air oonditioning unit. 56. Admitted in part, denied in part. T.t is admitted only that the location of the propane tanks was changed in excess of twenty feet. It is deniud that the ohange was made or required by Plaintiff. It is further denied that Plaintiff indicated to Defendants the original location of said tanks for the reasons set forth in Paragraph 51 of this Reply, the averments of which Paragraph are lncorporated by reference her~in. It is further denied that DraWbaugh installed the gas line. To the oontrary, the gas line was installed by Lehman with DraWbaugh's assistance. Finally, it is denied that the location of the tanks was changed after Herman & Shenk, Inc. connected the gas line to the tanks. To the contrary, the tanks were moved in excess of twenty feet from the location selacted by Lehman before Herman & Shenk, Inc. made the gas line connection. 57. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted, although not relevant, that Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh were not notified of the change in the location of the tanks. It is denied that Tuckey Mechanical Services, Inc. extended the gas line, hooked up the system and operated the fireplace unit. To the contrary, those actions were accomplished by Herman & Shenk, Inc. -4- ~w Q''''GIlIt 6NII-JJA"-IiH II BR~UNIMAN 58. Denied. It ia denied that Plaintiffs continued to use the gas fireplaca after they disoovered it emitted an odor and disoharged soot into their house. To thv contrary, a soon as it was discovered that Boot was being diScharged into the house from the fireplaoe, Plaintit!s disoontinued the use of the fireplace. 59. Denied. Paragraph 59 of Defendants' New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party; therefore, same is deemed to be denied pursuant to Pa.R.C.p. 1029 (d) . To the extent a response is required, it is denied that Plaintiffs have failed to mitigate or reduce their damages. 60. Denied. It is denied Defendants Lehm~n and Drawbaugh acted and performed their work in a proper and safe manner for the various reaBons set torth in Plaintiffs' Complaint, the averments of which are incorporated by reference herein. 61. Denied. It is denied that Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh did not act in a careless or negligent manner. It is also denied that they exercised due care in their activities. To the contrary, Defendants Lehman and DraWbaugh were careless, negligent and failed to exercise due care as more fully described in Plaintiffs' Complaint, the averments of. which are incorporated by reference herein. -5- LAW O",CK. SNrLBAKI!" II BRENNEMAN 62. Denied. It is denied that Defendants Lehman and Drawbauqh performed their duties as instruoted, requirqd and/or pursuant to their oontractual obligation for the reasonB Bet forth in Plaintiffs' Complaint. 63. Denied. Paragr~ph 63 of Defendants' New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by Chis party I therefore, same is deemed to be denied pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d). To the extent a response is required, it is denied that Plaintiffs' damages were not proximately caused by Defendants Lehman and DraWbaugh. To the contrary, Plaintiffs' losses and damages were caused by said Defendants as alleged in Plaintiffs' complaint, the averments of which are incorporated by reference herein. 64. Deniod. Paragraph 64 of ,Defendants' New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this partYI therefore, same is deemed to be denied pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d). To the extent a responRe is necessary, Plaintiffs' Complaint sets forth valid causes of action against Defendants Lehman and Drawbaugh. 65. Paragraph 65 of Defendants' New Matter contains an unwarranted conclusion of law to which no response is required by this party; therefore, same is deemed to be denied pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1029(d). -6- r: U') I'.: t ..;:.: , ,- II' '. i.~ I"'t )r T )oi;J . '. ' "J ~<l I.. 1: t, .~ ,'ij , 1 - ];,,; ~,. "fl;! [i,'i [\"j '~I .. I "'I '.j " .,., I,.., U' CI " ... . I, , , l' i ~ .... E ~ .. idd !;. :( :;. ~ ~~ i 0 .: ~ . ~ ~ .... II: ,1 j', '1 . -1'1 , 'I ! , 'I q ,! " .1 , , , ~: (O'~ r:; '! Ii .f "" !, r.:; &j It! f?'< IJ~ ~.'~ I, ~ 1:4;: H'.n -(.. ';J ;~t J....., ;.J! ,llf" "]~1 " 1~ ~! . ,. V) 'dO. E: ,', I , 1)r-."j1 (J:qi' ;>. ill (0 ' , . , .., , r.. :;I: t,. 0:: I " ! " l!.I ~~ , , ., I, , " , " ., " " ,. " " , , " , , " , " I;] " " ,', , -