Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04107 '\\.'1 I , ,/ 'JJ i.:i ,'!,it 1'1 i" --' ~I ,)\~"-, ,.I 'I ~I'''' I )i~',:::',' " Viii! i" , I~X'(; r~ ,I ',', ' ",/' :/1","\-:,1 ',J" _ lJ"f;\, ' f"' ,.'~ ,I, tt;:/\, ":'I"~el1 r,',' , ,\,,1 l '. ' ',\1 :\/) , , ", , ' ,,' , . 'tit ',7 , ,I (~ , "'-,,, iI'.' ~ ~ ~j', 1'1' ~::J':\; "" "",," ,II' ~J',; .,,' I,ll:!! "j , ~,),H_l;,:, ~j~,i ~), , ' 1.'1", I I IrJ,1' fihtl" l' ~t;.-:-:t' :'/';~ <r" ;::'j'<" . '/ 'I I , 1 " ";lb:'" ,I:, ' ,,- , , ' ,_I, ,. ~I </,,- I~ :I,u , If,' I ,ej' ,I I' " 1,'1 !ll, i/ 'Ij'!:',1 l- 1 'd , ' d'lI :1' III",.' I,' " " 'I: 'I}, I" I ," 'I', , ;I! 'I' !,;, il! ,'V , 1'1, '_I' ii' .,-d -' ; " ! ,il i_I; i-I;)' ,'J,{I, " " I, , I, , , )1' " , ,1,1 , ii' i ;1 I, JI,' ., Ii' .' '-~_ I I' , " '! f ~ !, ' ,f',,\,1 11;1,,L_!I_I,I,ti, I 'I 'j, ' '1"" 'I 1',':-1' 'I, \' "I,,' 'i I" 1'\ I, . 1 ;n', ';; _ .-' \ 'd)"J, JI, I;. "_:,,t H- " ,'1" , (,'," '1 I ';\',-1(; i' !fl_J,fi I' ~'It I "I, ;j " ,I 1.1 I , , , 'I "I " :pl " , ,1'1 -I '" '},'\' ',I' i'l , , , ::_1"1,' , I' /;,11111 (- ,.-,' , " \',/'1" , , I' I !L \ '1I:1'I'!i,-I,it I (", \1, , II! I," ;1, ,'I' I - ,;'! '/d," :-'11 l,II",!,I, "-'111' '-.l II,' /:"! "" ~!'\! ;, ,;j1~: ''I:' '!/\d'/,i,;-! 1,- \/;-.1 I,' I ",' 'I , q' "1 , , , I ',i'l.-l\ , '_If " , '~ I ,ii' '1'1- , I, , , " "I , -' 11 ~' I' jl. , , 1'\ I .I,,! ., , " " I 11',1, , ,I , I " ',I, " Ii , 'II Lj ) , " 'I " ,I '" , 'j,'i\i , " , " ,I I. 'J "11 I' I II' , "I , jh I ',iil II',' , J' 'I , ,;1 , , , " ,i " " ,I .',1., , "I )' ii' I , )1,1 ',I " " , ,,' " " I " n 'Jill" I, " 'I , , 'It, " " " , ',I " r '-, I ,);:,' " " 1'1'1 , " " 'I, -,') I " I' i' I' I ~ ' I ~ I ,'J. ill'( I !' 'J'I " ' , 'II , ii' , , " :",-;'lr " , I; , ' .. 'I' ':1 Ii I' I ',I, 'I., '1,1' c " ,I ;1 ,I, ',I! ,", " ~ :'; I,', 1'1 " ,),1 :11 'I I' ,1 ,'I , " j" "'f 0\ j):'i " " II, '; 11 'j ~ !; 'It!,\ ", " ,-', " , , '", ,I , ",1,',1, ! " " ii' 1. , 'I '1,1,'\ "I' I, I' 'I) :, \'\, I," , , ,I' 1--' " I (',' I 11\,;" , , 111:' , , ,I , , !,l I" , , ',t, " ",' 1'1, '11'1' , I " , ;1 "'1,1.' " " I' " I I) '" " ,I'll ., !';),I;!l , ,t" , 'I I ", "" , , " '';, , , ',I I ~ i 'j)' \'!'!' ,Ii, , ' :;",'1 \",:, ;1',: ;>dl , !' ! I "\, ,,\' "I \_ "I' 'i , I' I" " " , ., I ,,' II 'I iJ, \ I'f t, I~t:,' T;I/,'\ "; '1 i_I j ,/ \ '. ' . , i It! '~- 1': . ,! _I I I t -' , ,_ ) ,_, " I~!. ' ' _ J ) ," ,I,! ,-' " !; r _ ,I: '1-' ," 1'-1"- ',- ,,_to; -'!I ,,(,,1' ' , ~ oj _ 'I-n -.I. 1 -. ',' " 'fl I" ,-, -'-- -, ' .., I" "i',",i,: "" : ',,:, / ;,1:,:", '1 iii, 'f! '~;.. ~I '1':,,~ i';!,-: '/'/-: I; '_'\1'-i'-' ~ l ' -;. I' f ';' - , 1. I' ) l :, ; I (!~ '_'I ", \, ,;!J '1 ',I, F, _11 , I ' '.1 ~L-' ILI;r 1,:_1, ,l J d if q; I ,,', I)' " ' p','II:mr;I\'--, ;-)"1'1' ,_I I ',- 1_, 'r (- oJ I' -' di~ . II j If "' ~,:' - '.-,' . ,- j ""1:':1/1,(,,:,,:,,, ''''I! <" _,' 'J/ "'il,;,.,-,,,;I, r " 1 '_'~I '_ ~ ! I i '_'.lH ,__' ' - I ,i I II ,,:,,_,,----,'1"--,,' , "L - ,,;,:( .' :!):,p_,:j ,:,;!,II i:,o!' ), /il; 'ii, Ii ' II ,I -_: -, 1 /; . "'~ I, 'I 1,.- ( il;-, ) ,'/' I, , , ,I, ",;',) 'I) i H ','/ ,', j ,\-1 ! /. ,I '((j-r; 'd' , 11-_ ,1 ,11, ,t ( ',"'; ',n I--!!l.n 'I 'I'" ".'c"" ': ',I : ',Jr_ __ <.":;' "jl'l ",ie ,';1'1'1" '1111-;' --'I,!~,,;II,)' ;',H'I,' " l' ,,';:',,; ';:,:,::':'," :,,/;:, " 1 ,II, " pd/!r_\,~:1 \I)'n,j i'i;' :';1 ,'I 'i'; ;"/1":';",:', , ;-'"(',,',,,1, ;" ,:" ' " ( I '.,1 i);\, :','~fI-~'- 1_,,1,,:-'1 I!, ,,-I. '1 I;:,', 1,i',""~"1" ','L:;I '" ',,1. I "I , ,,", I .( J ~Lr.- ,l,ft ,I.. '1"/1"1 ""1' ,', 'I -,I f ',',:j" Jj:,,;(;},:-I! :,1 l'i/r;'" (:1 ,_L!\ \:'f!j , 11-' ,,' .11:111, -;:! !" ,1__11 "'1)1 ,1-1:, I " )-;, '1,1, , ! : ~ I, 'j ,I ., '>! ;II' 1'1;'1 'I , '11,1,,\-,1.'" 11,11:-'.11/_ I -.' ~ - ,'I' " '1'1, I" ,ill_ 1, 1" '1_11 'I ''1- .-1 'i l "..-I{ ! ',' "I !I-'~: "';',1- !')-I, , 1" '1'1 ,I ;' ,-, I "\ ': J -I',~ '1]1' ,," 'f'I:-jil' ( , " ! "~I :,1, " 11", ,i,I',/. -- I ,I I' /.' , II , ,/' \ . q, , I' ,', I)'! " Ii 1 i I) , ~ I ,Ill " / jd) I 'lil-' ,1',_lI', 11'!- I" "1','; !'I' k , , "I. :'/, " :,liJ, . 'f' -, II" , " Ili;'1 , I,' d " 'I'" 'i q,' \, :f,1 'IJ"llI ,H' ;'\1' I' " 'I I, \1 I. ..,' ,I ,'",. 'il :~I III' " I', ,II ,I I,''} 'jl, '01 , " I I ", I '/'j .'.;1 " ",III , I,),) " I Ji I I, Ii,' :1 '1' "1 " '1,1" 'I" 1\' , , '.') I ,~ , " ,jl -'I I' ,I , ~ ) , I ,\.! '1_,\-; 11'1 ' ", "~I ,jl' ,,' '1 '/{, ,t ,{ .' I " 'i' , , 1;1 I 'L," '1, 1',1--" " "'f' i " 11)-'11 " I' , f, "~ J ,/', .',; " ;f1ii I" :,/,' ,,'I ; , ' ',: " , if " I ,', ',"I I , ." " 1,1 , , , , , - I "It 1 ", I' " /1'_11 1-,_-,'" j 1" I,' " , , " " I' I I, I " 'I') " j,',,1 II' ,', I 'Ii I"" 'j,,' ',' ',' " il 'II 'f", , I) , ,',1/ ,j,' " ''I , " 'I' , "I" ., ' , ' ," 'I}] , '1 I' - \,: ';-/: ,I, 'I",':' ~ ,I. \i] , ':;i 'I; .' , I i 'I' , I,' I .-1'1" I I, 'II" , id , I'll , " '," .1 ", f" 1\;\ I" ',I ;'1 ",,;t'i , ',I., ',' " 'I', ,I' ",')1,1 ,. , ,,-'I ,,,,,, 'II " " " 'I j' " " .' I , ,I 'I" " , , {,I'I' I,]' " , ,I " " " 1'" "I I';' , I , ,f \'1' " ,I, , ',I 1 ! ' ~ , J" ' 'i"/I;I_ ,II : ,1;\,' ,]1':\ '1,'/: I' " 11 ! 1 \ ~ I I " ,I'! " ,_I it ,'1:f 1)1, ',,,'I', ,. , ;" Ii. , Jf.' 11'\'1" , ,I '.,JI '1-' '/ . I" I' 'fl " , " 'I " ,\:,1 ;,1, Itl.r, , :1, I " '(' I, " " ," ,I " " ,,. -J' I,fl "I' 'I I') Ii 1,,_11' ,'I ., ,',II , " :', ,f! :, 'I , ,I, 't', ,),1' , ' el' ,.. ,) ,-\ f" '" I' f1~ ,/',\ " ,'" " ,11'i '-.1', ; ,,,.!,_-,,, )1 1'\ j'I'" II' :'," .. " , " , '1'1 ,_ ,~i \ '! I r, ''.i " .'f:I'1 irq"~ 1,1,\\' "., ,'I ell ;'1'( ,I it 'II " I I ,I i I " :I',i " ,,-, i\ 1"1 Ii ',i, '_/,,\t' 1"1 " " , , , . I" , , I' i f II, " / ,\ ',J' t,:1 I I' i Ij~);:r'i~' " /" ,/)"'1, -;\ '- ", " ! ;' ~ I I!\," -(-r-J 1 ,~- i -f ~ 11'!'I" "q , i;,I'I'-;;' i'II'_;',I; ',Itf 'f\' -ill.' II I'" I, :1,1,';1" . ';,,', :' ".- ',pl, ;1'" '11j- }}'I'\ II " I' ,I 1',1 'I ,II,},!" , 1,1" ',C-i, , litl' ,1__:!",1{' I d-"'_j , j "I" ,-tn.!.-, 1,:'l\',":31 " , ',-l'I" "'.1" ,-, 'f,J.!(dCII .; - ~ '; ':'1: :;:' ~!.,"! I ,,'[.:,.. " ;,/11 -_'11,1 ,i) 1 il:,iT\' H,'- ,'-1- , .-,('Id ,1' 1'1 ';j 'II {1,,1-",-I" I ,'j. \1 'I :i ,', ":' " i.- 'j ~-; I ',', f,' (I . " '.i_;',:i ,ni,: -,)." ,I!: ,,1'0 I"" ",---~p'!1 j'} 'I' L:; ',,: t_ i, h': 1,1 '; ~j ',I" ; , f. ' ,'1_1, ,:' --:l.' ,~- . t' H ,;111' I' ", ",'",,1, ,','"I;,j\", .." ,1),1',_1" 1--->11.",,;'1 '"1-''''' , I" ,,:i 1.1_' 1\ ,',\ :~.I~.I;",_ j 'I,' i,' r (r!l ,,') , - --. .i " "J " ,,' If "'1",;' /'11 "'I--j'-,'i:1 .', ' " "I' ) 1" ,I. '_1--1" \1 I ~ ' I' , -I ,- ' I ,/,' ,-; \ '-'..(fir, ""/.,, ' ., .il-" '1Ij' .. 1 ~i: J~ ,l f ,1'-"1",-('," ,i, ~,ILi -' '.;j ',1 I I' " I " I If't_ : ~ {' _ t -It i I lj,i', , , I, I 'ri) ", , , ,,;' 1'_ ,_,,, 'I" r ': ;' 1'1_, II! ,:1, ""1""1.' ,'II ,-,I .',iI, " ,,_,II '\11'" , lid , " \1' '.I: i,I"il I !) i ',:,J-1 , H;l ,} , 1'1_ " ;1'111 '11;,:'1'; ,\, ,; ,1'1 ',--.,' ,:!:I'I , ", , " il'i'! ;,,',II.c I' t' '\, tl i('J "\-1" /' , " ,I ":;1 i 1 :1\; ,,'-.t':t,--:r,'_'<, . '11'1,'1 "_/) L' -I' '_-"1 T,!_',';"_ i ,!:I I t', T- i '1,'1,'- ;i-~'- -"rht.\;;, ,- ,<" 1 -:: 'J! ., 'i -':;1 ;::il/!'~:;'.,.. I, I':' Ii]' ,!\',I_~ 1/ ~ ,i '!;\,:\ " I ,-' Il':n' ' I i \'; 1 i' '~l,".il_"~I_,i, >', ;'I~', ;,i',;; ,'-.'; " :1 If' >;',1,. '-. . I, '1,1;:'1" " II, ';.'1. ',"_1"1' 'I, " ,//'1 1_' _ l. '__, 1':'1"" 'il;"I,':~:-,.':".:,"I:;,,,,<,':,,;,:" I"" " !, JI 1/' \I " , I ' I: ~:! l~ I I, ",," I , I . ,': I, !,'-, ~' -' j't ,.:it ';;';, ' ]I'>I,',':! 11:',: "I", It , -,:,'_::'1 ' 'f ';/l ,1,:_:::",\',:,'11:,;' ' I 1 '1-' -_p. ',,"/1 I, _, ,_ _ _ _ - ~ _ 'i ,I '~-'I >',: "\;';'/_1;' "I-,:::'!-'[J,'/:,'/)I Jd ' ,.-,I_-I-i'_' ',";'_1,--", 'I '1",:"'1 I - I' ',I' j \ .] _; ,,(; 1,\ ~,.' , . ,'1--;' -',:,'I'!';:-\;I!I!,'\'I ' fl'" 1;;11 ,., F!\I;r'i, 1-'1 I,' ',I'll:" I" 1:1 "'II I ;1 .1 , It-'.f , '" I'" 'J I, !I ", 'I '11'1 I" I'., , II\,' I I, 'III' '1_/\',:1" ,\'\1'; I ,!! , , , , , ,,' 'I , ,I,' , I', " '1/" ! I' I !' , , ,,-' '~'"I' j , " " "d , I I , 'I,tl I, I' " , , , , " ,i 'I I 'I" , , , " " 'f II , , , , , ,) , , I ' . ' I " "II,' "~I', ,I ;, I, "'I ,I" I " ". I ~ " " ,i t, 1', , SUMMONS ,IN CIVIL ACTION ',' TO: Semlr J. Sroujl, M.D, Ple,tlo Surgery, P,C. 3438 Trfndle Road Camp Hili, PA 17011 Plastlo Surgery, P.C. 3438 Trlndle Road Camp Hili, PA 17011 , , " " YOU ARE NOTIFIED THAT THE ABOVE.NAMED PLAINTIFFS HAVE COMMENCED AN ACTION AGAINST YOU. ' Date: ~~~LC {!.., )rLL/L,~ Pro honol8ry By~ ,J}~~ , , <~(J I " "I , I' ' II' " , I I ., I ',I, I I " " , " , , , , , I " , ' 1'1 'I , ,i' ,I 'I I " " " " " " I' , I , I I i , , I' " , , ! " ',' I , 1'\ , , ',1 , , I , I, " , !', , , , , , , I " I ':, " , , I I' , , , " ~i " , '- :... ,C: ,-. \~~ , I, .. to. .:r ';p' :IC I)" ',.J",~ a.. ") ~'1 "" ' .";:' ~ ~ 10 ~ I, :,:(1) - ..} ~' g ~ "81 ~~ ~ f'1.. '~ -, 1'Ib)'- '0 ,., '" ~ ~ ~ '<l " "- ~ ~~ 'i, , " II I 'I I' , , , , , I , , , ~Il , , I , ~h , , t mal , ! ~ 'I , , , , ~II I , , , , " " , , " " " , ,'I. , "I' " I I ,-, , , , " iJ' ,:1 ,,' " " , , I I' ..' . ,i I " \ ~, " I ,I " '$llI'li!"f':,J~:,:/J"i ~,t,''!'''''I, ," rnl_?i,;",~"lliJi;," '. '. 11:;(; ~'" ," , " 1.1 .' , } ~-, I r I ~ II :,,',,-1'1-, ,.I,,,,, I i/I,) ~ _I <:, r I I I ,." I, , .... ~ LAW OFFICES DONALD L. REIHART, ESQ. 2800 EASTERN BLVD, SUITE 204 YORK, PENNSYLVANIA 17402,2904 !, (, , ". . ,I 'I , . ~-..... . ...... I'.ot ' I """, ,r't , ' ,", I" !L ltj I', '.f , ' ( " !')I "',li,'1 Ji~~ :'r ~, \tyJ j<,', ,fl': 1_1\ j, {f, ' f\1 'w \'f" " '(I'" o~ 1; i ;,1 'l.h\I, " ;,1 f," 'J'di; I'/''' , I, V,':~ t ,J', '.,,': '1',\'" \'/' -Clj ,Ii" ,),,,j 1,'\ .~" tll' XI~ Ii " :l"I \.!rj ',,1 l"" I~\ , "",' 'AII',J!'IYJltl"'II'1 ',', ",~'n"",,', 1,,'\'" I,II'I!, I ',- " ",' '''''' ~"""''''I"I''.-l' I ,) '" , ",,,,,,l , '~ THOMA'. THOMA' I HAFER IY, Slrlh W. Ala.... hquht IDINTflCAmll IlOJ 18787 .. .... "..1IrIoI ',0. ... lit ~'AI7I~ 17171IK7lI1 . " AItDmIyt tor DtfIIMIInIl PEGGY L. KNOUSE and DONALD KNOUSE, husband and wife, and BUGENIA MILLER and LARRY L. MILLER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO, 96-4107 CIVIL CIVIL ACTION - LAW , P,l.aintiffs v. SAMIR J. SROUJI, M.D. and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C., Defendants JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PRAlCIPS rOR BNTRY or APPIARANCS l/r TO THE PROTHONOTARY, ~lease enter the appearance of the undersigned as attorneys for Samir J. Srouji, M.D. in the above matter. , .' nODS, nODS f& HAPsa By: ~Ch~aa..utL- Sarah W. Arosell, Esquire I.D.1I5B797 305 North Front Street P.O. Box 999 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0999 (717) 255-7637 Attorneys for Defendant, Samir J. Srouji, M.D. DATE. 'i/I'Ij'" '" ! -i'-j:.r I ,Jq ,,11t'iit! WI'" lil,I"'inj;,ltMWHi..lftt.lh'}"'IW*ft(1~,hi " 1 I !I '!,I " " ,. I 'I , Ii I , , , , " , I , , ','1 "I II!, , il , " " I, Iii " I Ii " , -I; , , , , , ,. , I , , , , \1 " ,Ii 'I 1; 'I = !" ".. I , i 0\ f" I' "" , 1 , " , ,(I, I:~ " ,~ r. l.\. Ir I , t, , In ~m , , , ~ - HI \/.1 ~ , I ~: , ~ " " " '!'11 ~ ~. " I Iii , , , " I, I, , , , l! , , I " 'II ,) ii',' , , " il " 'j' '" ," " iI, I 'I i'l , " " " 'I " " I, " , I , , 'i I I ,I " ,,, \I " , " " " d , 'I , ,'\ ,I , , I " , I " , ,', , " ;Iii " , I, lill , " , 1-, " II' I , , I " I, " , ill , " , , , , , I,' , , ... , - ~ hi' , i THOMAS, THOMAS" HAFlR IY, 81/11I W. Arollll, E1qu1ra IlfIITfICATllIIl NO, 88181 101 JlII1fl FIOI1lII1111 p.o."'. HIIII..... PA 17I00.oet1 I7ln HI-Inl AlIoflllYI lOF D,1Ind1ll1 PEGGY L. KNOOSE and DONALD KNOUSE, husband and wife, and EUGENIA MILLER and L~RY L. MILLJi:R, IN T~E COURT OF COMMON PLBAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PIllNNSYLVANIA NO. 96"4107 CIVIL CIVIL ACTION - LAW Plaintiffs v. SAMIR J. SROUJI, M,D. and PLAST1C SURGERY, P.C., Defendants JURY TRIAL DEMANDED PRAICIPI rOR RULI TO rILl A COMPLAINT TO THE PROTHONOTARY I ~indly issue a Rule on Plaintiffs to file a Comclaint in the above case within twenty (20) days of service of said Rule, or suffer a judgment of non pros pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1037(a). THOMAS. THOMAS Ii KArlR , , ,.[ " BYI,tltCl t Sara W. Arose re I.D.#58797 305 North Front Street P.O. Box 999 Harrisburg, PA 1'1108-0999 (717) 255-7231 DATE I 'if/N/?6 Attorneys for Defendant, Samir J. Srou.ji, M.D. '. CERTIFICATB OF SERVICE I, SARAH W. AROSELL, of the law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer, do hereby certify that on this day I served a true and correct copy of the foregoing PRAaCIPI 'OR ROLl TO 'ILl A COMPLAINT and ROLl TO 'XLI A COMPLAINT on the following by depositing a true and correet copy in the United States Mail, at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed as followsl 0' 0, Donald L. Re1hart, Esquire 2600 Eastern Boulevard Suite 204 York, PA '17402 Attorneys for Plaintiffs " . o \ I,', ..,' TllOMAS, TllOMAS r. HAPIR 'I' BY'~fahJa~ SaW. Arosell, Esqu re DATE I ~'I /9& ," " " , , j , ' Be Ie evlle que sl no de deflende, el caso puede proceder sin usted y la Corte puede decldlr en8U contra sin mas avlso a notlflcaclon por cualquler dlnero reclamsdo enls demanda 0 por cualquler atra queJa 0 compensaclon reclamados por el Demendante, USTED PUEDE PERDER DINERO, 0 PROPIEDADES U OTROS DERECHOS IMPORTANTES PARA USTED, LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO INMEDIATAMENTE, SI USTED NO TIENE 0 NO CONOCE UN ABOGADO, VAYA 0 LLAME A LA OFICINA EN LA DIRECCION ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE PUEDE OBTENER ASISTENCIA LEGAL. Lawyer Referral Service Court Administrator Cumberland County Courthouse 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 SHORT FORM COMPLAINT AND NOW, TO WIT, this S It, day of jt'rkrr,b((' , 1996, come the Plaintiffs, Peggy and Donald Knouse and Eugenia and Larry Miller, by their attorney, Donald L. Relhart, Esquire, and file (his Complaint, whereof the following Is a statement: Short Form ComDlalnt Part A . Peaav and Donald Knouse 1A. PLAINTIFFS Plaintiff Is Peggy Knouse, Is an adult woman who resides at the following addresl: 805 Copenhaffer Road, York, Pennsylvania 17404, Plaintiff (husband) hi Donald Knouse, Is an adult male, who resides at the above. named address and claims damages as a result of los8 of consortium, but not limited to the following: Arthralgia Myalgia Sleep Disturbances Burning pain In chest, breast, arms or substantial loss of function In breast due to disfigurement or other complications Pigment changes In skin Weight change Chronic bronchitis Prolapsed mitral valve Chest pain Visible Implant outlines Capsular contracture 7A, CAUSES OF ACTIOr-:! On the basis of (he allegations In the Fourth Amended Master Complaint, Plalntlff(s) raise the following claims: X Yes No Yes X No -- X Yes No X Yes No X Yes No X Yes No Count I - Negligence Against Defendant Manufacturers Count III - Strict Product Liability Against Defendant Manufacturers Count IV . Breach of Implied Warranty Against Defendant Manufacturers Count V - Fraud, Deceit and MI!\represenlalion Against Defendant Manufacturers Count VIII - Medical Negligence and Negligent Use of Defective Product Against Defendant Health Care Providers Count IX - Fraud, Deceit and Misrepresentation Against Defendant Health Care Providers X Yes No X Yes No . X Yes No CQunt X . Lsck of Informed Consent Against Defendant Health Care Providers Count XII . Loss of Consortium Against All Defendants Count XIII - Outrageous Conduct Samlr SrouJI, M,D. 3438 Trlndle Road Camp HIli, Pennsylvania 17011 Plastic Surgery, P,C, 3438 Trlndle Road Camp HIli, Pennsylvania 17011 Yes X No Count XIX - Violation of State Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law Against Defendant Manufacturers 8A CLAIMS AGAINST RELATED COMPANIES As to thoBO manufacturers and relElted companies that Plalntlff(s) have named' 8S Defendents, Plalntlff(s) Incorporate any claims for successor liability that are raised In the Fourth Amendod Master Complaint and any amendmants thereto. 9A, ALTERNATIVE Lt8flJLlTY CLAIMS With the permissi 'n of this Court or with the consent of the Defendant manufacturers, Plalntlff(s) may raise a claim for alternative liability ba:;ed on Section 4338(3) of the Restatement (Second) of Torts in a Short Form Complaint. See pp, 20- 29 of this Court's September 7, 1993 Memorandum and Order of Court with respect to 'II j :1 ' , , Defendsnts' Prellmlnsry Objections to Plslntlffs' Second Amended Mester Campisi nt, WHEREFORE, Plalntlff(s) seek recovery from Dofendants as follows: (a) general and compensatory damages In an amount In excess of $50,000,00, exclusive of Interest and costs; (b) punitive damages as allowed by law; (c) costs of this litigation; and (d) such other and flJrthElr damages and relief as this Court may deem appropriate. IDl!2rt Form ComDlalnl Part B - Euaenla and Larrv Miller 18, PLAINTIF~ Plaintiff Is Eugenia Miller, an adult woman who resides at the following address: 544 North Hanover Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013, Plaintiff (husband) Is Larry Miller, an adult male, who resides at the above. captioned address and claims damages as a result of loss of consortium. 28, DEFENDANT MANUFACTURERS AND RELATED COMPANIES The following entities Identified In Plaintiffs' Fourth Amended Master Complaint are named as Defendants and the allegations with regard to these entities In the Master Complaint are adopted by reference: I !'i .II I h I'" " II Implantation Date: , June 28, 1982 Samlr SrouJl, M.D. Holy Spirit Hospital 503 North 21 st Street Camp Hili, Pennsylvania 17011 6B, "/1 , I, Surgeon; Hospital; INJURIE~ -- Yes X No Have the Implants been removed or ruptured? X Yes Is Plaintiff raising claims for damages from a disabling disease (as defined In paragraph (3) of Gase Management Order No, 7) caused by the use of a silicone breast Implant? If "Yes," describe the disabling dlllease(s) that have developed, Within the last two years of Instituting this action, Plaintiff has discovered and/or No developed one or more disabling diseases caused by the use of the Implant Including, but not limited to the following: Arthralglas In ankle, knees, hips, hands, wrists, shoulders and elbow Myalglas Chronic Fatigue Sleep Disturbances Lymphadenopathy Photosensitivity Dry eyes and mouth Dysphagia Alopecia Easy brulsablllty Balance disturbances Bladder Irritability Chest Wall Pain 7B, CAUSES OF ACTlQM, On the basis of the allegations In the Fourth Amended Master Complaint, Plalntlff(s) raise the following claims: X Count I . Negligence Against Defendant Manufacturers Yes No X Count III . Strict Product Liability Against Defendant Yes No Manufacturers X Count IV . Breach of Implied Warranty Against Defendant Yes No Manufacturers X Count V . Fraud, Deceit and Misrepresentation Against Yes No Defendant Manufacturers X - Count VIII . Medical Negligence and Negligent Use of Yes No Defective Product Against Defendant Health Care Providers X Count IX - Fraud, Deceit and Misrepresentation Against Yes No Defendant Health Care Providers X Count X - Lack of Informed Consent Against Defendant Yes No Health Care Providers X Count XII - Loss of Consortium Against All Defendants Yes No X Count XIII - Outrageous Conduct Yes No Samlr SrouJI, M.D. 3438 Trlndle Road Camp Hili, Pennsylvania 17011 Plastic Surgery, P,C, 3438 Trlndle Road Camp Hili, Pennsylvania 17011 Yes X No Count XIX . Violation of State Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law Against Defendant Msnufacturers BB, ~LAIMS AGAINST Re~TED CQM~JES As to those manufacturers and related companies (hat Plalntlff(s) have named as Defendants, Plalntlff(s) Incorporate any claims for successor liability that are raised In the Fourth Amended Master Complaint and any amendments thereto. 9B, ALTERNATIVE ~1"BILlTY CL.AIM~ With the permission of this Court or with the consent of the Defendent manufacturers, Plalntlff(s) may raise a claim for alternative liability based on Section 433B(3) of the Restatement (Second) of Torts In a Short Form Complaint. See pp. 26- 29 of this Court's September 7, 1993 Memorandum and Order of Court with respect to Defendants' Preliminary Objections to Plalnliffs' Second Amended Master Complaint. WHEREFORE, Plalntlff(s) seek recovery from Defendants as follows: (a) general and compensatory damages In an amount In excess of $50,000,00, exclusive of Interest and costs; (b) punitive damages as allowed by law; (c) costs of this litigation; and (d) such other and further damages and rellaf 8S this Court may deem , " ,I '11 'I \, I' I , 'I, I 'I " IL ,i.11 '.1 , " , I 'I I[ 'I i'll' , " ., I, I I 'ii Ii' .'1 I I " ;' t, I' at) .IS .. ~ ,c:. ~ '" I ,j'::: f.~i "~ ,I, , ' , , I,LJ I' I '1-' d ilf ;'.1 !j " " I il " jl J-lei:' , ,', ,I " , I, I, I' '," , , ~ I' , I "I , 'I I ill , I, , , , I ' ~i! I , , ,I i ~i , , , , , ' " , !~ 'I , I I " , , , I ~ll , , , I , " ,,' " I " I, 'I' I " ':\ i,',' d ,', 1,1:1 '11 I" !] , I' II,',' "I' 'l-II LAW OFFIC~S UONALD L. REIlIART. ESQ, 2600 EASTERN SLVD SUITE 20~ YORK, PENNSYLVANIA 17402,2004 , , , 'I ,I I I' \ '1,1 II} I" I I , lit 1'1 -I:' FJ,~'i~I'i.t{i1_, ;,'1://'" ~'_<i';I.I~'I'" ,[ ~fl!.:_I'I!.:',\,\I/<'; ~'')~--iXj',r\ --'i,>I'I,', ,11/1111:;_:: '1/ ~'_fi_);,i 'I, r'~!.il'-~);rlt\!{~~/--_, ii/: 1\ '-'I ' iI i~, -" : -: ~-', -11,:'-..' 'i ,'I ~;1'.t~I'\: '-', ,I J'~_\;(:l'\;:lj' 'jl" \'''\\I,(;'.Nt;',I'' ' 19-t?J'I; ;' ',:r,l\\."'-\n' ,_ .,'- tr1;.I;t"j ,,,1__,': lit!";",.!,!;!",,! ;':.\~)f\~;_;i:',I_:'I):,,;t., YJ~,tV'r"" 'j" , - ,(,'! :l,lI)',I)lf\ l".: ' 1JJi'':; , '(\;'.;.,\;',,' 'I'~!lt jl~ -~' ;- I ,U;'~(~,;,;it :.' "', '" ;"ki1\'.l'JI.,.' !, ~! ~~;(i;;"I<).;;;i>:;;;' 'I \,.',- I, "I " , H " d ,I "I 'il,' , ,,' , , ,I; ':11 I,'. ,!) it,' , Ii ,I ..1'., 1(1 'i'; "if, '"i;i, ill ",' '. /'< " I, ,I " 'I ," '1" " " 'i,- " 1-1 \, 'i I'j 1'1' !. ',I ,I I , " !I, ',' , , I I, , ",)1 '.\ .1'1 .,', I,. " \'\: II' ,,' " '''I , 'I , i:;l'" , :11' , " , I, , , I: , " " II" [I , ,'1 , ,I " , , ,I /I! 'i,1 , " \'i 'J"! i." I . ,:. ~', J ,;Ii " " " 1 ',I',;': I ",;1,','.. ,,' ',,' :;,>,';'):~;Ii'i ;'.i~' , . ~ ,. AND NOW, this -/12.-- doy Of~/1J/~ 19971, flmncls E. MOl'Iiholl, Jr., Esquire, hereby centfy thot I served n lrue nnd correct copy of the foregoing document on 011 parties by depositing II copy of slime In the Unltl'<l Stlltes 111011, reglllor delivery, postage prepold 01 Camp Hili, Pennsylvanlo, oddressed 05 follows: Donald L. Relhart, Esquire 2600 E05tem Boulevard Suite 204 York, PA 17402 Frimcl$ E. II, Jr. , I"~ , ' , I, , ' t' " , " , , , " , , , , ., , , , , , , , , , , I , " " ,1', ,I I I I;' ' , '\'J 1" '1""" I, " , ill, , II' I',' , I I; 'I I"''!. " i.' ,1 " ....1 " 'Ii, !':' " ;, " " ',"( "I ! I-I '11"1 , I " , 1'll"'Ji". ',', i,lIl'.:1 '.!i , ,I I' Itl' !; " 1',I,I"li ! 'il " , , 'I: , , , " , , ,1, 'I ,) .1"1, I li'I' ,,' '" I,' li"II'.I. ,: ~ ' ,",'-:' ,1:"/ '" I 'i ""l '~ I" I,' ,Ij I,', 'I" 'I ," , , ) I ~ ", 'il " " " 'I' , I, , ,I 'I 'I , ,II " '.,,' 'I , It '.\~ ~i,/"j I ~"}"I;'i.1 II I;: I, j',.,'M,I::'X':,:'t',~,',:' "JJ"i~"':'" '.~,' in1,:(; 1:1"',1'.1,'" I, , l"t ,I,' II :'i,I;:~":'\:'i! ',:' .1i"II"'.';'- ,,,11.,,,,-1.\',, \'h'l '.'lnj "i ','j':,' ~i ~~/.' l::y,i<'\': ' ~:(f; l~i(i:j\J ;;:',:' 'I,. 1< i:l~,J\':/'.,',I;_-.'i'..,I' ,01 ",'.I"I\'I"I'-""""'}" ,.1",'lI'.li,:>I,:'lj, l' " ~ "" . m:~;,,1 \1.:11;,'11., "~'::;",' X;~\'I:\' j. 'I',~ ; I ' "1"\ :-~ .t_,! I ~ ' I,', _ ''J 1,I'i \~\f.,j\\"-!:'-,,,{: .:\',III,,'l' '/II_I;;'i'i",; 'I,; ,I.' t 1.' " ., \ , ~, , , t ;, i ;; I ~ ',':;' '~ \;_; ,.J.'. ' " , \ lJ,.\"',\/""" rJ;'\i. !'\',I il,! I l)t:ill ';' ;"/l~. _II ~j-'~;""~'Yl' i''-<j . ~..;~., I'",', ," ~ Ii' '1:~11".. ~ ',':, '," I' j I, i,i,1t,;:I~.:;,J,I, .' I' , , , " "I, " I., , , I' II' " ,I , " , ,': , " 'I , II " ,I :1 I , '1,'1 If, , ,~ ' 'I I Ii, ',', " " " " " HI ;:J'''I " , , ",I' I .1 , , 'I I \\': " , ..-.111 d. " , "'\ " , ',I , "III , , 'I. 'I " " ',I. , " ,', ','II " , .\',' , " " I" / 'f I,' , , , ' '\1, ,0' '\. .. ! I' I,' .'.,1 'I' ,1, I I " ,i\;"i'{' " t, ~ ill If1," 11 I) I:I}, f'ltt ~"j' j;~' " li~: \'11 ,-.(1 ~ h' (~~J /J II ;\J:'~'~' :); .11;'I>\\V':({;l~~~~ ,,)11 ,I, \ "lll:\\,l!r\,1 !!:\"n,;i'~~ II 11.'" 'll,ll"r Ij\.~JI~!\H: 't~\~I.IMh~ , , ',' "H Y''l\ "'''"'I'!I~1 , '{I Ill' ,,~,~,,\ I jl }'\ '~I,t::\J;,';;.;1\~fJ~J,~11 I 'I l"'::~'~' "(III~I '...,,;ji.....Piil'f'~1 'II .,' Il',' 1 :11:"/' Ii 'I l~r\:I~.II! i i}IK1/,lli' , 'I , Ill'" Ilhold ."'f .... ..' tjtrl I ,. ~ 1 "'l \~"'I '/"; i1i.'!IIJ,t'tol( i \ ,'I' I" ,\fl.ll'.\\,\, j,.ti!I"6' U~ ',t.ki , 'I' '\ lit-,I ~ , ""j I ,iltl' /. I, .t. j l'II'~1 t 'd' ,', 1,,1 ,II. :\'1" ,I' ,', ""1 :'''1'' ;1\111'1';':'" ril'.',lll~lllli ' I!., I, \,\\ 'VI I ~ ,Iff ~ l'li' fl', !I, . 1~1,II.J"li'" 1":,~I\""1 JI1IA:NIf! r}- ,',>" I ,I,', I 1III'\j'I\'",1,'ic'.\n/.. (J )1' )\ Il II I'J'':(;I~\rl' "''*\iII'J'i''~11 " I'! II ,l?l, tl',,:'I": ~,.,'lm~I.~ l,,:i 'J I, \ \. I I, , ' 'b l,~ I~ ",r,,' 11'11(' '1 1 "1\' ) . "" \, Ii~ Il\'~! l \ II; I : " I 1,11 I \ ~!. ',I~.\l 1.\'j1nill1f'~!1 'i' II ,\" . ,:1 I' ',A 1)\\ ',),'l"'l' ~~~, '" ' 'I" r' I ,I), , ,\, ',, 11 \ IJiIC~ \:" 1', I ,I J" 'I" 1,'1'" II I)lll ~,~ , ,I '. ,I \ ,,' -'II j'\ I,' P 11,if~! J 1 '! 'I \ ,l, ,';:,>,~ /- 'I'" ',t., :"f ': ,~, "\' I' ;!, I' "l:'."l':':\I;U,~i,~\ljm~I' I,':' .1, '{',' ,ill\-,:~.< :.:\ 'f,,! -,/"'._"1,',,1,1\'" . ;i' I,' ot~,:; "" ,rt'" \1 I' '~ I," -,'d :",-,,, "1.11 "11.'." \':'''\'~HI-'l~[\' :: , ,,;':'\H1>>,.Il,j\' ,,'-1 " ' "-A'~;~~~~' ','.,,' I ',I' '>1' .(i;~Ii'/\V~ll : ''-':'l,,\':;';,II-;''\:,'d " I'-I '1:, " , ","Hi "I"il' ,I 'I i', I, '/ I, I, ",! " " , I, j, " , i ).' 'i I , , I ;.1 I,' 1,'1 \ 'II ,Ill "I " " ,! \'\'" I, I ,il 'I 1'.1 'I,'" ,.," , , 1.3 p; "6 :a 'Cl "'....... :I: V"" o'Il~g V).... -5 's ~ V) M . =.s~ "' ::l ,J:: 0 Po ~ V) E ~~l3 -< p.. ',:,1 $ LAW ()FI'I(:ES _____.___._..~__,_...____.____. . ___ ....,.,..~_..H.__..._.___. OON ALl2J~J{~lJ:!~J~'I!J~~QUIRE 160J ~^SnIIN l~lUUV^ltll' SUI n: 104 Y()IIK, I'I:NNSYlV^NI^ 174~/.l'l\l4 llONALlIl- ~I!JItAAT ~:a JIIIUlI.QIIrJ\ nLEl'tlONE (717) 7lI,179'1 lllOOlllI,7'l74 FAll17l717l1,1l1O !.M,i1 ~ihonJ...""",.""" October 9, 2000 Curt Long, Prothonotary Cumberland County Courthouse 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 Re: 96-4107 Knouse, et al. v. SrouJI, M.D., et al. Objections to Pa.R.J.A. 1901 and Cumberland County Rule 1 at Judicial Administration Dear Mr, Long: Enclosed please find two caples at my Objections to Pa.R.J.A. 1901 and Cumberland County Rule 1 at Judicial Administration tor filing. The original has been torwarded to Richard J. Pierce tor the hearing ot October 31", Please time stamp both caples, k~eplng one tor your file and returning the other to me In the enclosed selt.addressed stamped envelope. Thenk you. Sincerely, -:e- Donald L. Relhart DLR/dck enc. i.' .. -, " Richard J, Pierce October 9, 2000 Page Two Plaintiffs In the above-reterenced breast Implant case request that their case not be dismissed tor Inactivity all their case Is covered by a Stay Order, precluding prosecution at their claims, Plalnllffs certlty that they have served all known parties, or their counsel, with this letter and a copy at this letter has been tiled with the Prothonotary'il office. A list ot those who have been served Is attached hereto, ,', I,' Please call It you have any quesllons, I . , Sincerely, ..... - ,:::( Donald L. Relhart DLRldc,k eno, co: 'Franols E. Marshall, Jr., Esquire Kerry VOIlS Smith, Esquire I Prothonotary t s Office " , , ' , " , I , , 'I " ", I, " ," The following counsel ot record have been served with the LeUer of Obleotlon In reterenceto Pa, R.J,A, 1901 and Cumberland County Rule 1 of Judicial Admlnlstrellor In Case No. 96-4107: Francis E. Marshall, Jr., Esquire Kerry Voss Smith, Ellqulre Marshall, Smith & Haddlck, P.C. 20 South 36111 Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 " , , I' I , , . " , ," I I' , , " I " I , , I, I , 'I , 'I , , I , I, , , I , I " I , , I " I , I , I, 'II' " , , , 'I " I " , I'! " ," " , I , , , , I , I i , I' 1,1 I , ," I , I I I , , " PEGGY ~, and DONALD KNOUSE, EUGENIA and LARRY L. MILLER, PLAINTIFFS IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. CIVIL ACT tON - LAW SAMIR J. SROUJI, MD, PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C., DEFENDANTS 96-4107 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 30th day of October, 2001, in the case of Knouse versus Srouji at No. 96..4107 Civil Term, and it appearing that Plaintiffs' counsel has requested that the case be removed from the purge list because of tha existence of a stay in the case, the case is stricken from the purge list and shall remain active. By thE! Court, Donald L. Reihart, Esquire 2600 Eastern Blvd. York, PA 17402-2904 For the Plaintiff. Francis E. Marshall, 20 South 36th Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 For the Defendant Jr., ~SqUir~ a~,~ I bj~ C;l (') -. "" '".. j I c.':) ~f' ....:,: I .i'; \J:) Ie ~(, ~ ,;/.:') to.,(') ... ,.1;,:')1 ''''p ,'. I; ~, ~"- c.~ t-,'ll , ~ .' ;:,<( 0 :ii ';:) ... pcb r' : , I :;: 'I " " ;,I",! LlI',I , I! , " , , , " " 'II' , " .1',": 1,1 " , I ~ : , ,,'-Ji.' 1\1 ,'I, " , 1,1 " 'il ,Ol'!lf:ll ".'1' ~,; i, ' I',' , , ,,::/.i'. ':1' , ,I" i' !- I~: '-" "I " I:.', \ I': " , ' I' , ", " ,I i"I" ,1'1" I', I,' 'I " ,'il.' ".1', '1'" .,>1 ., " ,', , , ,i .' I,i ,,;,', ,~ ' .' '~ I >,: ' " "'f','" , I, ,\1; "I " , H " ., , . " " " I I . , , : I ,Iii , I' , , , ,'.\ " I I I , "I 11(, , ','I!' i I, ,'11' I' '" I' II' , " I, " 'I", \, " .'. " ',;'f " ,:1 ," '" f " !,l 'I:i,'.. II" ~ ;, I , , " " ;,(1 "~'I ", 'I " ' ",,1 , ..'r ,I,',:'" " , " ! " i i,,/ " I " , " I " .. , I , , !, , , , '\ I, , , , , , , , , , i' .'i " , "I" !,,:,-' I, ',i, (' 1<,,1,, ,I. ]",1';, 1,-'.\ ,,' '\' , " 'I :,"', ~ . /q , ,:" ~ \ (!;: ".(, I,"':,"':""J'[ "" 1\'1 '.'1. , " ,', 'I" 'I"~ I' , " 'i ',.'\ I, 'i':';"'" '{,i: ' ~r"'i I ,1, " ','I' ,I , " 0' I,. " i ",' 'I,' , "I' o'C '"' \ ,0" ' ,I " " ,,'J ,'/,'!:I' I 'I ' J ' i",' '-f'~ I, Manufacturcr: McGhnn Mcdllall 2. Whethcr you recclvcd pnymcnt or cxpcctto receive payment In the future: --K._ Ycs No 3. Whcthcr you slgncd n rclcllSc lllld!or scttlcment agreemelll'7 X Ycs ____No B. Hove you submittcd n proof of claim or othcr document tor pnrticipatlon in the Dow Coming Bankruptcy'? -L Ycs No VII. DOCUMENT1i You ore requlrcd to sign TEN OIUGINAL slgncd authorizations In the fonus appended hereto. Sign only thc rdcnsc fOI' cmploymcnt/uncmploymcnt rccords If you claim wagc loss, loss of comings. loss of camlng copuclty, The following proccdure hns been ngrced upon by which rccords shull be obtulned, l11e authorizations will be scnt by defcnsc counsel to RccordTruk under cover lettcr with copies to all counsel. The plaintifl' agrecs to wolve any notice rcqulrcmcnts and the lIuthori7.l1tlons shall be immedlutcly sent by RecordTl'Uk to the person and/or entity nOled on the authorization, 'nIC records shall be produccd to RccordTruk. Oncc thc rccords huve becn obtuined, RecordTruk will provide thcm to pllllntifl's counsel only, The plulntifl' will huvc live (5) buslncss duys to review them. The records shull lhen be dlslribuled to ull counsel unless the pluintlff obJccts in writing to nil counscl und RecordTruk. j ," , " " , 'I I', , , 4 'I . YF IlIFI I:AI.lQ.'.i " I' I J('d3rC under penn:IY (Ie pe,:"!)' sub;ct'tIQ 18 Pn,C,5, ~ ,190-llhnt nil of the inf\lrmBtlon prvvlJed Itlthis PIDlntlfl"s I'M'I Sheet i~ Ul1e and COITe~llo the be~l of my knowl,edj!e, InfomlDtion nnd belief nnd thllt I have supplied nil the documents rl:qll~W:d to the extent th.lt nny of the documents arc In my or my ID\\')'cr's possession, Dlltc: 1- 1- q If Signature: QtJ~~.Q.i- PrlnIName:. 1.... " , , I ',1 , , , ' " , , ' f! ' " " i i , I , , , , , " I' , " , , , I, I " , " I , , , , , ,~ ... ,. .. , 1 " I' ':'-11 I J: " , , , . " I " , , ". I " 1,1" I I' I r. , " I , " 'I 'I ['Il(" , 'I I .L._ " ,,, , " I j..: I'-I .~ II, r~ I " U I " , , .... (.l , , " i ,,' I I ,.J I , , >1.; ,I i , , I I , I I " '," " , , , , " , , " ',I" i, I, 'I , " " " I, , , , " , , , I' I I, " 'ji , " , , " I , , I, , , , " , , , I ," , , , , " " , , " , I,' " . " " " I' , . ..' I; I ;-, ,I I' " , , , I . , , , , . " , I' " , " , ';1 " , " ,.' \ ' ,\1. , , , , , ,,' , " './'i I , i ~ I , , " , I " "i " i' . , "f") ',1/ , " d' , , ,\ " II' " " !' ,\ 'I, " " .i" 'il \, " ,i/(. :',,-.' ,I, " 1" ."J't 1 '. ," :~\ .;. '11 'I 1\ , " ,of, , " " ": , '~ 1'-" ",1/ .", .' '~ " 1'1' " " I ;. I': '~I 'I, , ,11'.'11'.1,_.' I J ""I I !'q I ,,_, ,,-~,I:u(::,h'j ';~" .'" 1',' j \ I'.., ',-I, 'I'" ;~'il,l... 'Iv/,l" 1,:,)1.: 'I,'; I J"l' , . 'II, ''<;It:''\'ff:,'t~,;..t-~III';~ I ,I', '\'1:," ,i '_, I. -'., "l-~':i 1 fl'~." .' . ",I' 1- J I ,:.;' 1; ~Ji\"\",'il,'fl/l' ;'. '. ,'tI ,,'I 'I': "I ,(r,il-'! If I' ';i:~'/i.\\,: I.! , '.j,l,' I ';: ],:.1\':(:';)<(: :~li::\; ", 1 ;! ;:';"":-1 ~'-'i ~, _"': ":",~~ <,~\~,l'::I"'_ '.: _'::< 1_.',,'1_," ..' "'"i.-:_ "<i,~!:! ,J,:_< i, ;'j \'r':'J\,!:,t'~:'::"1','i,! 11'11',-;,,1~; J.i"ijI':t'\I"':'- \-~.\':'; ')"it -,/ ',,':",'. -: ",I''i ;.- II..-!.. ,'11 "'("'I'.'-'-'J" .t",'!..:! ;\.l'i',.~!j,;..r~{;:'I\;i!'ki.'V; ! 1'( " '1,' ~jll; '~(~iAr~~W{lK1':\J~1~tlf~~~'~~'~'~I)I;(J\j*;'~i'~~~Wt~f;:;'i;i)j~r\!/(;Jrl;Wi~/~?)'I~*!~I:,~Y~I_~ . I "t' ._\J,\' ._I"i ,_~,,,'~II\'''l'\f,ii.t~l(I,'.'~)~?''L'\l'\\~' ,.11,'1"/""\'" ,. ",' \""'1''''1,1",.,.".", I" ," '. , .j' ;1. 'tij' ".'1 ,L 1,1 1 ," , , , , ,"' ~ ' " " , " I'i-.""I'" i., i) i" ."\ ",' ":,'" " " , LAW OFFlcea DONALD I., REIHART, ESQ. . 301 & EASTERN BOULEVARD V~K. PENNSYLVANIA t70402 " I, I'i " II iil " " III I, 'I , " I, , " , I , t;; .'1' '>+ '1, N f" , I '. .'!t "I t".' "II;! I\'r, _'i :t: (~, ;:~ " ~I";,'J <l. 'I" )~'l 'f,' j J~' II (Ill;.! .C1\ 'Ii/ " (~", t'" 'J ~~- i- ' u_ 'I, -.1 :: Ill! , [f; ~p i::~ "' 'I I ~-: ), .... F;; d ," I L.. ,', ,0 ~..a 'I 'I' " I' '" , 'I I " I' i , ,I' J " , ", II ,', 'I' 'I, I, , I, I';j :1 " " ',I d-l t;~:,,'i;'.F '.1 't.. ';' ~'I'{ \ , ' (' ,',!,I I, " " , , I , I ,,'I ,I'i .' I 1 , , 'I' " ,I I , , "j " I ~ i E' , I I " , 'I', , ; I,i' , " J I I,ll , J I , I , I , 0' (f,',", /\' -"/' '1,1 1;"1,,1 : ~ I : I 'I ,III',' '", " "'i I' '\,1 ",/,_,,1 J,')II'\ " 1\1 ,I, I" 'If' .,1 " ,,' 'I ~ I I I I,,) , ' " . , " 'l , It , ,I " '." i,' , " " , " " I I") " " , ',' , I ''I , , " " , " ,\'0' I , H ;i ';1' ".i ,I, , ' 1,1," { I',il!) /' , . ."; " , " " " ,( , ' , " ' , , " ',f , .... " I ',I " ,1,,1 " " I' " '" , "I ., -'III. Ii' ," ,j I " , I AUTHORIZATION FOR RELEAS! OF INFORMATION MClW,.:_ Nama: J14-tt-LJfJ1 \( II 't " . Address: ',)(") (' ( I h II Ii Ii k'l ~Jiu~- 5SN: J~ (: 00ll: . i I / ) i.L.t.l:fJ_ City: ...!.)LLLJ _Slllte: .J.Jl_ ZlpCoou: __~L ..- --_._~_.~-.._--~-- I. Gonersl RI/loase. I hereby oulhollze ._., .._.__... ,__Iodlsdos. tho II110rmotlcn &81 forth In SlctlonlV 01 INan'" ">I.d~" ~ IllOlI\l UlUOIJ/, ',g.. !mp.I.lIj thlB Authorlzellol1 lor ~le period Irol11.'________' ____ _. t~,__,....,_, ....._,.' TIll rlloosnd InlOllIlBtlon Is ruqullod lor 111l~81101l, Ilul1hor au1hollze TIm MeS Group, Inc" e plNole rooord reprodu<;lIon oompnny. upon prossnllUon of IIlli BUlhorlzallcn or ~ oopy IIloreol, 10 pholo~opy oucl1 reCXlrdo os ore reBlo,,~bly necossary lor tho Bbov&-sloto purposoB, . . _., ____.______.._ _.._--~-~.._--_.~.__..-_._._----~--_.._--._..- -......-- -."--. -.- II. Heolth Information Ralsese, I haroby authOlI?e the dlGcioBure 01 lilY heehh InlormaUoI1, 0' d~cribod In Ihla alJlhoriUlllon: 0,) Person(11 BUlhollled 10 dlsclolo Ihe InlollnBllon: . - INlllN iiiij,fl Ptl1l'~W: 11o$plw.\, D~-illr, In6WlU1l.11 0.:,1 b,l Informallon to bo dllclo~od: The Information lellonh In Section V OIOlls A\nhoriwllon, I ullden;tsnd Ihol illS heullh Inlol1T1ollon may Include Inlormotlon portalnlng to "ealment 01 drug and olrohol obuse, menlul heanh Including wlOlOlJtllmllatlon psychiatric lnlorm~non, 8"1ulrerJ Ir"mul\odolicl~ncy syndrome (AIDS), or hUnlBn Immunodellclency vlrul (HIV), sGXuelly Irunsmlned dlsoBEss, ~Ick ceil anomia Irealrnonl, IIJbarcu~l.llnlorm8ilon or genellc Inform6110l1, THIS INFORMATION WILL SE RELEASEO UNLESS I INDICA TE OTHERWISE BY CHECI<JNG HERE: ____ c,) PSfllon(s) ulfthorlzed to rocelvo tho disclosed Inlormatlon: TIlO MCS GIOIJp, Inc, orl boholl 01' IN'''''' or MCS Clllll'q I furthor Qulhnrlze The MCS Group, IIIC" d privulr. rec.:lrd reproducllon cOl11pany, upon pro~entllion 01lhl5 ulJlhorlwllcn Or 8 copy Ihereof, 10 pholtxopy such rewrus BS are leasonebly nocQssary lor the 8bove.stlle purposes, d,) Purpoeo of Ihlo requr,~t: At my requosl. 0,) E~plratlon Dale: Unloss olherwlso rove ked, lllls authorizallon will o~plre one yoar Ane1 1110 dale 01 Ihls aulholllallon or laler 08 Indicated here -----" f,) Right to ruvoke: I underslAnd thai I have the righllo revoko Ihll authortmtion al any lime by nolllylng In wrlrlng each Porson Idonlified In SOOlon (e), I undOClll3nd lI1al Ihe revor_11lon II only oll.clive nllor ~ II rfoC'llved Bnd logond by !Veh Person, I undersUlnd thai any disclosure made prior 10 lIle r"vocallon UIIdur Ihlo DWoll,nllon will nOI be affectod by the ""o<:allol1, g,) Subsequent Disclosure: IIJI1derltlOd I11nlany dlliClosure olln/ormallon IHIlY be sub/ocllO le-dlsclo!ure by tho reclplenl and may no longer bo prole_10d by ledoral or slele low, h,) Impoct on Medical Treatmenl: lunden;lllnd i11all do nol naed to sign It1IB aU1horlzallon to assure any modlcallroolmenl. I understand Ihal I may inspe_1 ond/or C\?py tho InlonnaOon 10 be disclosed, I undor!land ",al euUlOflzlng \J1ls disclosurQ Is voIunl'uy. I understand Ihal III/laVe any questions about disclosure of lilY health IlIlormallon, I may conlaclthe privacy offrcnr for oach PSl10n Idontifled In Seellcn (a), --~_.__._-~--. ..- --.---.-.- ....-- .-----------------....-.--..--.-- III. Slgnalurll/CcrllflcAtlon. 2 _ l t{:1Q1j;o..':Jj~d,lfJJ.~_, SlgMIlJro 01 pa!sert'idnnlifled Alluve or his or her Aul'lorllad ReprescnlnUvo I Guardian hu.1:1 -(J 'I Dale By signing Ihls authorlmllon, \J1e Aulhorlled R~prC.\ol1lallva endlor Guardian warlllnls thai he or Ihe hOB Ihe aU1l1orily 10 act on bohaU of Iho pereonldonlllled abovo on Ihe bo,ls of: h_, h _.h -' OV: 1P1AJM9J...' (jBQLQlI,DOq IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PEGGY L. KNOUSE and DONALD KNOUSE husband and wife and EUGENIA MILLER and LARRY L. MILLER Plaintiffs, : No. 96-4107 Civil v. . , : Civil Action - Law SAMIR J. SROUJI M,D., and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C. Detendants , . : Jury Trlal Demanded I, Donald L. Relhart, Esquire, certlty that a true and correct copy at tho Plaintiffs Revised Intormatlon Sheet was caulled to be served on the data shown below by deposlllng same In tho United States mall, first-class, postage prepaid thereon, addressed as follows: Thomas M. Chairs, Esq Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. 1200 Camp Hili Bypass, Suite 205 Camp Hili, PA 17011-3700 The Honorable Emanuel A, Casslmatls York County Judicial Center 45N. George Street York, PA 17401 Respectfully submitted, Dated: 1"" .. 10':) y . Q ~D~-:r~ Donald L. Relhart, Esquire Sup. Cl. 1.0. #07421 3015 Eastern Boulevard York, Pennsylvania 17402 Telephone (717) 755-2799 Attorney tor Plaintiffs , ",,,. t:? , I") iiI r.;; . .. 'r " ..f...1 ,,(I ~~I I ,'f. I'. , : "~ .~ 11'/ ". .' , rji -: ,~ ! '<'t~ (I,: , , ':'l I"': " ~I ~;/ I ~ I ~;', , 1"11 fl. V/ 1,1./' -. ~. H "j r; ,',\ I. ..." ~;; .... , , " " , " , , " 1,1 " " " I I I' , '1'1 , , I " I " " " I ,. " I " (',' 'jl ,I " '. 'I i " "I , , I' I' i I III ", .1 ,', ,I " I' I, " ,I 'I , , " ,I ,I i I' " II I' II I, I '01 t,11 1 I , , , " I, , , I " ii , , " , , , 11,1 I, 10 , , , '..' ," ,/,1 ,"" , , " 'I II' "II II, , , I' ',,/, I: ,: I, ,'"I ;,/' " ;! I 'i ,I'l " I I ,,' , " 'I I" I -,'r,'I: 1.)',.1,' " II " , , ,1'1 , , , , " , " , ,', , I , I, I, , , ", 1,1, ','I, 1;-" ,.," I' :,' 1'.."1 II',", I, 'J " " Iii .\,1' 'I', " ,,' " , , 'I, " ,'-, ;.,;,;' " :,1'1" , , , , " , ,,\"1,' , ' " '.' " ," ,', " I , , " ,,, ;'1' , ,,' :\ , , I " ',I "I ") 'I I'll " , , 'I I , , , ," " I I , " , I I I. "I i\ Iti'" '" " , .. II ,~ . I ,( ,I II .. I,,:' I l .,' J l' \ 't '1)1 )'1,.1/,1 II" ..j ",,,\f 'I ",,\i J "', \ I ," .1 ~ ' I) I~ ) '(I ), I,d I \1 I' I" 'I 'Il~Ml~;a~~~~h/;lilf;~ '~:";:~'~I\~I\:" ',( 'JI I"~; .\ " t " , ',I," 'Li.l, r,' ',>;' t, '" " ,'" .!" ", '.'_"~H , " , " . LAW Of'FICIS ~NALD t. REnrART. IsQ, 3ll1SI!A8TflAN IIOULEVAflD VOfU(. PlNH8V\.VAN/A t 740ll , , , 'i'l , " ,,' " ,I " " , , , , " ,1 , " ',I ., " " I , I'll" " I I I , I" " " , II " , \'1 I '" ,'1' r~: I,:' "J i" I;':', ',., ..:,. 11.1' ...,)."t' I.... r I,: " .t; ". I'I,J/ , 1.:\.. " ":':1 1.)1 , ,- " I' 'J.I r L' 1.1. I :", ("\ I" ;1; I.IJ :1., " , " "- ..r'O: I " ~ I,. 1''' " , , _"~ d ". , .0 ,', I:) , ,,~ ,.,.. , , " I "II J,I , , I I , , , , " , , " , , , I ,,\ , ',' '" '" ,I 'I , , " I " " " , !, , , , III I i' , ;1 " , I, , , , , I I, JI,I ,I I, I , " , " , , , , , , , , , " , '" , "I ',' , '" , I' I' I I, " " , , " " I'" ~ ,- ',.'j ~ .', ,\ '~,fJ , , I , , I, i I , , " , I " " \1 " " " , \'11 ", II :1 , , I I II " d II " , ,'l 'I , 1 , , , , , I , , '. " , 01 I , " ',. 'i' I_I " I, I , , , , " " , " " I,' - .... " , , ?r;' <", I,' " r-:', .. 1:;':,,.,., I " ,(I") , I lif), "J4 \f- I, ,I -"\-: ~:i 1 1"'\ , , 1'1' In I, , (t\:~ I " , ~~t w , IlL , , ' .\q, IJ.J " i, ~. F I l:.\ \' ',I " ~'.'"~ 8 ~:5 ,. lti, 1,\ ,~ I " , " I,. 1-) , , r" " ,I' \j , , , , , , , I, , , " ~ -.. , , 1 ,', , , il I , " i' " , , " " , i , .. ,; ,;1 'I I; I I'! ) ',' "/'1' 'i) 'r 1 ',i' " " " q 'H,' I, " " II I, ;1' .: I'j, t:: ,I.' ., I, i"!,. , r' ': 'i I" ","' " I" 'I 1 . "I, \""'1 ;:;:/1. , i'ti'! 'i')' ',I; " ." '!'If''1 'J', " , . , , ,I " ! "I, ,'1 " II I;, 'I " I, 'I 11'1 II . '1"I,II{1 ", ,J, ,-,I' , ',If! , , .1, II \'1 1.,1 ",1 j,j "I 'll I: ;,11' 'I " ., ,il " , .,,1' 'I.; , ' 'I (, ., ',I", " " I;, "~,I .'" , \ . .,1,'1' , \ 'i,1 ." " I II. ,', , '/. '('I, ,I , " , I. I , .' 'Iii; , " " , i' " . , " , " " , , ,II ,',I ,"I 'I '", 1 , , ,,' \, \ , ',I " " " " . " ! . " , , I ': ~' .'1,' i,-' ,"t_' ,II I' "-1 " , , " i-J ,1,' ,TI ,I '\ .] , , , I " ' ,\ " i,t" " 'ji' J:, , " I' " , " ' ,I, i' '" II, '\" " , , , , " I , ;,1 II , 'i , , ,'I, , " , , .' I' I , , il , I 'I ",', I' , , '" :r' ", , " .", , ..J" I ',' I J I I " " ,I' ,~- . '" "I ,I, '! !/l" '1: ,,:1, , , " ,,'II ,'II I, Ii, 1':1 ",:" , " , I " " 'I, "", 'I 0' I ,,", .,,1, ,;1_1'1.\\ . 'I ,j:,. " -,;'-':" ':.. ~ ~:, ':,: ',- 'd, ' , I 'Ie. 1111II1 I i"I.,', >,t',;;:,;!!_ ,1"_,,,_,,,/ I ";,'~'Pj,,tl~',\'~ "'.~II:\ , )1~~I~"'I"i"::-,"(,:-\lf\'~'/:: )1 JH, Jllllt ., I, \I .' > 'l"~ Ii',... ,I-I"" __ ,.1 /" :1' 11\/">,'h'I;.:n,,I' " 1"11! ll,,:'-.-.'i'~i'_-I\/I':~ "l/,.l'j.. l >" 1111 ~ 11~i:~w;'~III' ,,;,.' '\ '.', i 'l.J_l~;~J'f:.',;) ,;H ,Ill . , ',I" ,'" ,', , , ',I "'I:""..' 'I' .",:' '\ ';"'1. LAW orFICES DoNALD L. REIHA.~T, ESQ. 30lS iWlTERH BOULEVAFlD . YORIc.PlNN8YLVANIA 17401l 1>" , " , " ',' IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PEGGY L. KNOUSE and DONALD KNOUSE, husband and wife, and EUGENIA MILLER and LARRY L. MILLER, CIVIL DIVISION NO. 96-4107 Plaintiffs ORDER OF COURT vs. Defendants HON. R. STANTON WETTICK, JR. CHAIRPERSON COORDINATING COURT FOR SILICONE IMPLANT LITIGATION SAMIR J. SROUJI, M.D., and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C., COPIES MAILED TO: Honorable Emanuel A. Cassimatis York County Courthouse 28 East Market Street York, PA '17401 Counsel for Plaintiffs: Donald L. Reihart, Esquire 3015 Easte!rn Boulevard York, PA 17402 Counsel for Defendants: Thomas M. Chairs, Esquire 1200 Camp Hill Bypass Suite 205 Camp Hill, PA 17011-3700 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL DIVISION Defendants ] ] ] ] ] ] ] NO. 96-4107 ] ] ] ] ] ] PEGGY L. KNOUSE and DONALD KNOUSE, husband and wife, and EUGENIA MILLER and LARRY L. MILLER, Plaintiffs vs. SAMIR J. SROUJI, M.D., and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C., ORDER OF COURT On this 1. day of December, 2004, it is ORDERED that Honorable Emanuel E. Cassimatis shall assume responsibility for this litigation, including all pretrial matters and the trial of the case. BY THE COURT: HONORABLE . STANTON WETTICK, JR. CHAIRPERSON, COORDINATING COURT FOR SILICONE IMPLANT LITIGATION to...;J ~ 0 ~ - (":",") "W'. ..t.;- -Ii c:/ :;:-:J t''1''1 C) i: '1:'] / -nrn .,. '0 ('i ) P -.., " ) " " .:"J.l" fS5 .- () ) f"j"J - ./ C) C.' .'. ....\.. / IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PEGGY L. KNOUSE and DONALD KNOUSE, : husband and wife, and EUGENIA MILLER and: LARRY L. MILLER, No. 96-4107 Plaintiffs, v. SAMIR J. SROUJI, M.D. and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C. Defendants APPEARANCES: DONALD L. REIHART, ESQUIRE Attorney for Plaintiffs THOMAS M. CHAIRS Attorney for Defendants ORDER On June 10, 2004, this Court as the Coordinating Court for Silicone Implant Litigation entered an Order severing Plaintiffs from other Plaintiffs in all Silicone Implant Litigation Cases, which severed Plaintiffs' cases from Plaintiffs' cases under each docket number. On December 9. 2004, the above captioned case was assigned to the undersigned judge. Pursuant to Pa. R. C. P. 213 (b), the court, in furtherance of convenience or to avoid prej udice, may, on its own motion or motion of any party, order a separate trial of any cause of action, claim or counter-claim, set-off or cross-suit, or of any separate issue, or of any number of cause:s of action, claims, counterclaims, set-offs, cross-suits or issues. Applying the same reasoning as in our June 10, 2004, we hereby Order that the Plaintiffs Knouse and Miller are hereby severed from each other. We direct the Prothonotary of Cumberland County to reassign a new docket number to each case and to forward a copy of the reassigned cases to the undersigned judge at the York County Judicial Center at 45 North George Street, York, P A, 17401. BY THE COURT: ~~~ Emanuel A. Cassimatis, Senior Judge () l"--.) = 0 c <=::> 11 ..:' .z::- "'D (~:~~" Cj -i ?2 ~i:~' Pi ::r::.." (J n1r= -:7.... . W -om ():, ;':C :06 ~ <:: "'- a C:i_. ~~~'" :b ;]: -H :::J;: ",)-- zc) 70 >e- ont ~I Z i> ~ W :.0 01 , f / ill'" IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PEGGY L. KNOUSE and DONALD KNOUSE, husband and wife and EUGENIA MILLER and LARRY L. MILLER, No. 96.4107 Civil Plaintiffs Civil Action - Law v. SAMIR J. SROUJI, M.D. and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C. Defendants Jury Trial Demanded PRAECIPE TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please mark the above captioned action discontinued. Date: 'i' ...- ~,", ~-- >- ~ - 0 ). '~)~\cJ~ Donald L. Reihart, Esquire Supreme Court I.D. No. 07421 Counsel for Plaintiff Law Offices of Donald L. Reihart, Esq. 3015 Eastern Boulevard York, PA 17402 717.755-2799 IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PEGGY L, KNOUSE and DONALD KNOUSE, husband and wife and EUGENIA MILLER and LARRY L. MILLER, No. 96-4107 Civil Plaintiffs Civil Action - Law v. SAMIR J. SROUJI, M.D. and PLASTIC SURGERY, P.C, Defendants Jury Trial Demanded CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Donald L. Reihart, Esquire, certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing document was caused to be served on the date shown below by depositing same in the United States mail, first-class, postage prepaid thereon, addressed as follows: Thomas Chairs, Esq. Dickie, McCamey & Chilcote, P.C. Suite 205 1200 Camp Hill Bypass Camp Hill, PA 17011-3700 Respectfully submitted, f i - 7- 't - 0 s' / . \ ,', '\) , /',. .. , } By: l~~) -.:1 ~\,,^-.1 Donald L. Reihart, Esquire Sup. Ct. I.D. #07421 3015 Eastern Blvd. York, Pennsylvania 17402 Telephone (717) 755-2799 Attorney for Plaintiffs ~ Date: /. ") ':"n .--' --- f'1. <; \ c.:"\ ,...,..""1 {.2 c"J -'