Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04110 , , , , , , . " 'I-I '~I i I J' ! -;I.b'I, t,,'lil i' " ,.,'1'1 ',I I " il , ' , 'I I ',',H i. "IJ I" I ,I ~, ! I ~ : )"1 ill' 1\;1;1 I' ,.' " ',j ! , ! , ')'1. i,,/, \"I/l'ir "1",1.11 ,11' /iJ: '_I::, " :', "111 -, ):11,,1\,"'_1 '_II' Ii' '" II> "i'" 'I 'I-I .,,1,\ ':'}'j",l ,If II,i It '1_ ,I II, If" t, ,/:11 i;-'I! ,':-~" ",' 'JI i' (,1 ul',:' .- j-' _<\'-1:"1'.-/ , d ,J,III l'ii' I ~ 'J, 1.'1' , , .'d " , , " " , :"1 )"J" >~ ,(1 ~ " ,oj ,:~,),li[T' , ,II ", ,,( , ,i' ",' " , " , I d' '1 I '-I " _/i\, _ ',if ,,';,11, 0,'1 I 11"1 ;:" I, _jl t'i ", ,1-' t-i " ,( , , " "'I 'Ii; ':,'1 I Iii"" " ''/)"11,, ,', 'It' ' ,_ I. , ' ';i , , \ '" ". " I'" 1'/1'1 "'I J,)I' ',1'1 ,i, )1 I " , 1"li_i ',I , , , " ,: ,,' 1:1 " , " 'It,: II 1',1 " ~I "loJ :'1"1 i',,:'; j/J " , ,I 1',1 " I, " , " II 'j: /-'1, " , q ,I, " I ., I,', ,1-1 )d , "I i ",I ,1,1 I 'I, 'I '1,,;1, ... " '. " ~ " " I, ',I' , ' " II I' , ' ,I ''II, ,',' t':. 1'1 .\';) "I i',1 I' I' I'l 'I"~. '\ " ! I., ,,'r! , ,j'l ,'I: 'Ii '" J'tll),', \; I,' q " 1 1_'-,\ II ',I '\, ,\;,)1 " ' ;, III 'I I ..lit '\:' '11,'1 '",'/", , "'-'1:' " ,,-'I i',', '\'" ~.' "i ll'tl [\1',1 ;', ~'\ /1-'/ ,1\ II J ~ii <I ~ ' , " " ii, " I-I' r'i'jl I' ,',-j ! II,,' q ,\,,) , ::i " '1, I' " , ~ II ' I , , 1'1 11',;1 ',\ , , '" 'i" " , , " , , "I, ,.' , , , , ' IJ" "II '1,'1,1' "', i"1~' ',II' , ! , I" , , 1, " ',' .'j"'" . I " : , / ,,' ! ". , 1"_11 , 'I ',I , ' II" " ";1: " J, " , (,_j,I,I! t" '_1, , i ~ \, " , .11"1' " ". ,.-' , , ,1,1 , " ,!, i' i 'J " "~I " ," "0 '- .-- , " , " , , , , , "1 '" ", !, : I ~ " : \ I I I" ,I' ''',ji' '1'1 " , ", ,.I" " I, " -:r -'\' ,JI ;'-1" ,,' " , , ~ - ! " ,.IJ 11'1 J," t', ;," . -' ttr " , ., I'" 'Iii q il' , ' ',I"',, , ' 1_\1 "ilii', , , . " 'I, ,I, fl I',: 'I' " J 01/'; ',: " "', " i!:l , ,. ,ill' ",'I ',' I"" " " " :'-1'1, ", ' ,,' " " " .' ',;,1 " '1'II\i 'i' , , , , ,. ", " j-I!', 10 ",'_1"1' 1 ',!'il:' "'ilj ;-d, !',J,q,l) ;_,1,. ' ; I 1 .~ r ,;;, I ,i ' , ,!J. ; ,!I,_- '<,'_, II' ',il< I' i: _1-) HI,-:J' ';_1 I :/;)1 f ; V;~I' I): ~!_;;!,(_-_l!_i(~i!'~" I"~ , .. ',J"'II,'~",i"i:,{,_-::,,-,-;,_I!',:,,'~ 'J'~'~,-,,),l-',r ~'.' /(,1 ,111.;.. - - ; _0 -; -;- _-, I, ~ I, ','Ilf:o' -_II '_' I \ ;1; '/ ; H, '-'I I" -, .. ,1'1' -; .'1' -..I ,I-L-', '01 , , _ '~ _ -: _ - 'II'!' 0 - -- J '/ ' , , '\:'.'n,:[ ',- '/If-!, '1\\'_I1:,! 1,/, ',r_, Ir! ,-- "df>i.~(! 1'1 jl,~( i '," ,;1 J ~-_~,,!I' -'I-/-'\!' 1:-1 :,h!tl \:'.'IN'i;\J , 1,,1' ! 1'1/:,:'/": ';:;:;i":I:;'i::,:'i j I"t!:ir I 'IJI 1,1'__: Iii 1 ill, t ,-I ',',1 ,iJiiL' q;, i 1/' I of 'J! '1,'\1. 1\ ~'.Jd , ) I " I ; I J \ I o~', ' 1,1",,';;il:, I,' I 1:-1-"1,\,,1 Ill,! ,q , -J'! - '1 II. t,' '!!' " 'I' ',,I ;} ,_rr; Ji , '111.'" '"", 'II,' I lI'd,;1 '/1;-1 ',)11-/ ,- I " ';\-"- I II, ','I L i:,J,' ,\,! 'JI- ~ "1,1 ',I I _ .-\,I'i'I'I, II ,i 1"_' , 'f ,I I , 'I: [, :i'jl';'_,' ,- ,;'t" h-' I, I , I ,L II 1'1 "!,! ~ ,'-1' 'il'\;}'ilr ljI1,,!} ',11- 'I' '. ;1 I '>I I I,' I \ If_: ,~f!' ,', ~ _ 1'!,1 _ 'l" l-~ If" 1 \, !!;!, I J. '1_'.'_:i,I-,'\'I'-'I',I,'I'/, IJ" t I 1- "I -,,~! --:,:- 1,[ _", d;~ :!_~_,>,;ii,,-,~_:-!;,;, 'J' l 'h~' ,-r: r. 'fJ;i_lj]-l '_1 '-""_'-,/11_,-!')' I" ; 'I I; ,I 'I,' .'j',' _',I,;' ;d),~,!-i:;,i' }!I>)~;:~(':ii "/,~ t!~ ://1' II '1,1 "J '". ,:<'l::,'i; i<r{\-' 'llll, If! I. I' ;'i''! , ',I I i' ~t i! ' _ 'I ' I !~I"" r ':,'1 ' , ,;/ -'. r \. 1 i-!J<,i", : - 1'(" ~ ; ,~_11; , II' :",' ,",I-t ,\'_t," 'I" \ '-1/:1'-1- '';1' 111111, " '"j:, }IIPJ/.';1~:_IC ~s:!,_,'"/'_ ,', , \,I,-H, I , '.'I_ll!,; i' I!',.-J_,.,' '( I; , ;' i _ ,~I';i.' < 'I),' - I' i~! , ,ill, 11"- ,'_' il!;'!I, 1~.'._Ji",l ':'jll' ; !I,-'r:lit--;{~/).',.,.\~t , 1.1 '_ _\: _" 'I )/ 'I' '-.', "I" 'If ' '- i ,)':' ~t~I(\; '1-1'1', , " 'I' 1'1\'; 'l" ':I~~,;, I,;il' '] dl I - ~ L' ;'1 :', ,11 "1 ,'I", I , '.' ii 1 , " , , 1-1,1 Ii;', " Ii-, ,'I , ,'1 , " , Ii, III. " , " " , ,,' , , 'I Il,.! (ll'U' ~ J , Ii 'III t_ I {' !' I~ ! I' 1,) -I ' I"" 'I v: '" ';1 I \"f' 't' ",'.l!tl' I '; I, !i ,,-'_"'. " ',n ;,I-j ,Ii 'n ,"I-",_"II! ,I: ,j! !_ ij'_< ,LiI J i'_" '), '11'1' -'I' 1;111-}' il'I'\' , '-'/1 ;1. ! ~ , , I ! \ f;' I , ~ ~ J , .\., 'J , 1 '/l " ',,1 ;: ,\-1 " '" 1\ jt .'l-.:'I' ';1,) ... ;,,1 '. , , )" I' ,iq: - , ,'I i 'I'd 1,1' \:1 'I Ii 'I r ! ,1/',"1 " " , .' , lIl_11 1)1, , I I '. "1.1, (;'1 'I ,i.t J' , ;111' , "I I" I" " 1,,1 1,1 '~_ I I'- II 1 01, " " ,,' .1 1\ :1, 1,'1' ., " I, If, " .' J !I,I 1 ~ I) , , "I. 'I-I 1 1,1.11 , , , IJ'i!1 ',II 1'1 t-! , lill ., d, , /1,-'1 ',' , , , " 1:1;_\ ,,'i " ., , 'ill,'), , , , . " ,r,..,.', " ,II I " " 'I I" " , 'I " , " ;-'( II , , ," i'l "ll 11<\1 ':')1, ';1 , , , I', 11!11(-,';{1 '1'1' 1:1 " , , (10 , ' '1; , 11.1 ':1 , " 'i! III '11 ~ I, " ,\ , i I,} " i' Jlj, , " " ;1 " I II I ", , :1' , ii' " " ,h ',/ " , , " , "II " .. :t .'It , :-1 'J '''1 , pI. I', I! :,1 " " , i'/, I-I i) " , I, '." 'll' I I,lil I " I _ I \ i " ,~ " 'I ;11,) , , , 'I .! , , !,}' , ., , , ",I , '. , " , ,Ill I, '_, I_I, "I ' t f ." ~ I , ,d i-I ,I " ;'1'11 , ., ,,' .1 1",1 I' /,11 , ., " ii! lilT' I , , '.. I' , " " (, , , , 1'1'./ ;1 "L \,' . ,I, I,:,' "" "_"'l \ 'I'I;_!! "1_,:1' , ,I ,'II' j I ,I ~ I ,I , 1" ,I, ,i, , " ,11',,\',:) 'I .' " ,i',' , 'J' ,,,: , J,jil:11 , ,I, 11'1':" , ,!< , , " ,t," 'I )1 ,'I " " I, I ; ~ ' " "\,\ Ii ]>1)'1 I I , " I," , , ,I,' , If' , " , " ,I, \ " l,il 1'1_\':1 "II 11'('1-' " 1.1 L_, ,})I_! 1_' '!,;, I, I -, i .'1(1,1 'I,' ,q'I,-'I_1 i, " ';i'! ~I ,,',I ", '" d'l 'I, I , , " II' , "II I , I,d, r ;< U-:, 'I" 'I; till"" r _'J 'I' , (,1,- , " ',-' !\}" . ,'1'1", 1'-1 , i!,\! 1 ,I,'jl ':-1 ." :I I_i , 'f',,' 'I" ,I' ,., 1,-1 \ I ~, , " III '<' , ,', ,I' ',Ii' ;' :"-,,\!,,,/! Ii'-," 1,-1"1 , I,'; Il'"I,\. 1 'I; j .. ;I;h " "I ,I ( "~I;; jl - 1 .. I: ':j '" , i I!/ .- ,I ,'I I .1 .101 :' ., I' 11' l<~~1.' ~,I \tli,~,k:.f!, I ' ",,~I "I!,; 'I; 11.'1> ':'1 ~, !' I I ',! ,ill 1 1 I ;1,:,-;;'--':" " -, I" "I ill ,I '., :1': \' ':11_-' , -"JF,:; ;"I'I-,"J(,'. ') "I \J 1, I.' I " ,I ~ j -) !J I j r 1:' , ..I ," , , I" )il' '11" ',i';' 'I "I ,.' , ,i) "',1',;"'1' 'I' ,11'-"-" I, ;~t ;<'I'j',1 i' Ii;' 1, ,/ '/)-.,;;' iii" ' ,Ii':, iJ I: d ",I I ,'I , 'I,' i "I, , .'j,,11 tll .I' " '\ ,_ 1 :~>v " I 1,1 \ ~ I;I;.!,' , ," ,I', " '1!j!1 II " 11,)1 '.-( 'I" '," ,I' 'I' , ,[1.",'\1 ,-p ',' ':'-,:1" , ,"1',"-1_1 ,', ,] I" /1,_1, I " ;" \' (- -~, }, ,- 'Ill ,!__\,I,\/ " --,-,1 '1'1,' ,,' ii' )'/ 'I , " :.\~, ': \,:- ,I, " '" "I' ,; ',,' , ., " ' ~Ii 'II ',i' " " '. ".-1 , , 'II ,HI " I' I, /'- It' ,'1/1,I,l ;\';'-1 , , , 'II I rli '\'11 IIi": 1,,"'1-, /',,1\'" :,' '" , ,,' :', \-1' /,1'11 , '\'.,1',-' ,it' " ;v !' ! I, 'I ,ill II,,', '1',1 ','11 , I, ,,' , , " , I !J 1 , , D , .' , , ~II , , ., , 'h , , , , , " , , , , !, ~ I , , , , I " , , ~~f. , , , , , , , , , , , , II , , , , I , ,. , " , , 'q, II \]"1 , 11!' .~" . , :,! 'I '" I;:; , Ir~ ". "\"f. ~..~ ~, ~'~ };;) ,:~ s (,jm: '~' . " " ".; t.)' ,l, ~\~ , ~' ,~ "'\5 ," W3, if, . CXI - ;\ ~ ;'1 " 1,11 jJ I'" 'Ii' II, ~ '~'I ,J I Ii) II r,' ~. ~M:~~ 111;~~: ji :1 ~.I'I\1i,\!i'l~l\" .1 111'1 ,jl/fJ , ~"'" ,,IIH I it' '\', \ ';.';10;\\_'''' II t'/I'.'.:l itl\'('I I, , J ., , " ,. 1,1' i' " 1,1 " ,I ~ I II ill " , "I, " 1"1: ,i. 'I L , i, "'N, \N .." "'- .~~,~ ~ ~ Ill!1 ;,'1 I' ( i I' " , . , II "1, , , , , " ,1,1 'I )\1 Ii 1;- Ii" t'f'\ M ... ,..... '0 '- ~ o ~ r:.~ I'()~ ,;1 , ',' II. " " , , ,1,- " " 'I ,'; Ii , 1'1 I, il ,I I~~~ I', " " , I ~ 'J' h i:,l 1';\ " lit , ' " , ,\;, ./ I,: " "I. "I I 'J, " "I '" , , IV li;i ,. , , " , " , ., " , :il, ., " , , I , " , " .; j/"'" ,',-' ;', , " " ., , , , I 1:\' " " , If, '\'i,l). , ' '. LAWOFFIOES . DONALD L. REIHART, ESQ. 'FlN BLVD SUITE 204 ' V~~"i;':J~SVLVANIA 17402.2;04 I I I I I I I I , . .,. SHERIFF'S RETURN - REGULAR CASE NOr 1'39b-(/)4110 P COHHONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA I COUNTY OF CUHBERLAHD ~II.tlJ::..JilJiAllJ;;LA1.__, VS. YATES JAHES HD ET, AL PHI L IUA.U.lilll1A.li._ CUHBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, to law, says, the within WRIT OF upon YATES JAHES HD defendant, at 101~~ HOURS, on the ~ day at.' Julv 1'3'36 at ~IEW AVENUE . CMP HILL. P~ 17011 .___,. . Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff a! who being duly sworn according SUHHONS w.. .erveq the -J CUHBERLAND to ~REA WRIGHT. HEOICAL Caunty, Pennsylvania, by handing ASSISTANT A.....ADJJ!,.LIN ,..QMBQK..,_. . a true and attest~d copy of the WRI1 OF SUHHONS and at the same time directing ~ attention to the contents thereof. Sheriff's CostSI Docketing Service Affidavit Surcharge So answers I ~ . . '7'v' //~,~"",..c< 1t(~ fl. 'I homas KJ.lne, [:lne - 18.00 '3.60 .00 2,00 ''29.60 00",,0 ","ART " 0'71:23/1996 by ~ !p~ erui Sworn and subscribed to before me this JSc- day of ,J I"~ I I 19 ITt,. A. D. ~)~., l~ Q. fILLet..,," u.:t>~ I I I'rothol)otary " . " THOMA', THOMAS a HAFER MY, Barlh W. A,ollll, hqulll IDOlTJICAmfl NO, &8787 '" Nri '''1111III ,.0, .., III HInt...." 1/101..- l7171m7111 AllomeYI 10' D,III1II..,1I SARAH STINE and PENNY TEAL, Plaintifh IN THE COURT OF COMMPN P~EAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 96-4110 CIVI~ JURY TRIAL DEMANDED v. JAMES YATES, M,O, and PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER, LTD., Defendants PRAlCIPI FOR RNTRY OF A~PIARANCI TO THE PROTHONOTARY, Please enter the appearance of the undersigned as attorneys for James A. Yates, M.D. in the above matter. I., " THOMAS, THOMAS r. HAlrIR By. ~~A n..L,.h1IJ.&.d Pet~ J. Curry, Esquire 1.0.#16622 Sarah W. Arosell, Esquire 1.0.#58797 305 North Front Street P.O, Box 999 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0999 (717) 255-7637 Attorneys for Defendant, James A. Yates, M.D. DATE. f/'/'b ~' .I II: ,Ii Complllnt Ire adopted by reference: None, 3B. WENDANT HEA~ TI:I CARE PRQVID.EBa. , " I " " 'I :, It, '\- ~I \, " :,,':j . ".1 "I :.' l' " , ' ",.j ...1 1,.)1. :.1 \., , The following health care providers are named as Defendants: James Yates, M.D, Rldgevlew Medical Building 205 Grandvlew Avenue Camp Hili, PA 17011 Plastic Surgery Centor, LId, Rldgevlew Medical BUilding 205 Grandvlew Avenue Camp Hili, PA 17011 4B. CASE SPECifiC INEORMATI,QM. "1 .'1 " '."\ ";'I"J ,.,,:,11 ,1.1. "I" I ,I ;1, I Describe the specific Implant products used In the Plaintiff's medical treatment, Including the name of the manufacturers, brand numbers, lot numbere and catalog numbers. If known. Surgltok, Medical Engineering CQrporatlon Product No. 13270000S0 Lot No. 5272-83-L, 459_ -83-L 5B. To the elltent reasonably known for each procedure In which an Implant Wlla either Inserted or removed, state the date of the surgery, the name and address of the surgeon. and the name and address of the hospital/clinic where the surgery was performed. Include any agency allegations regarding the health care prOViders that Plalntlff ,. making. Implantation Date: April 16, 1984 Surgeon: Jame. Yat.., M,D, 206 Grandvlew Avenue Camp Hili, PA 17011 I, ,I Hospital: Holy Spirit Hospital 503 North 21st Street Camp Hili, PA 17011 68, It:U.U.B6 Yes X No Have the Implants beell removed or ruptured? X Yes Is Plalnllff raising claims for damages from a disabling disease (as defined In paragraph (3) of Gase Man.gement Order No.7) caused by the use of a silicone brentlmplant? If"Yes," describe the disabling dlsease(s) that have developed. Within the last two years of Instituting this action, Plaintiff has discovered and/or No .', ' " , " developed one or more disabling diseases caused by the use of the Implanllncludlng, but not limited to the following: Difficulty swallowing Arthralgia Myalgia Sensitivity to cold In hands and fingers Rashes Chest pain Muscle weakness Cardiovascular problems " , 'II! '," {,l , ;11 : , , I, i'. II ' 'I' Ji 1,.1. . , 'I 'I P,'l I;' "I" ,rd I" , WHEREFC;>RE, Phllntlff(s) seek recovery from Defendants as follow.: (a) general and compensatory damages In an amount In excess of $60,000.00, exclusive of Interest and costs; I , , 1".1 ' ',j , 'I ,I (b) punitive damages as allowed by law; ,I , ! . (0) colts of this litigation; and (d) such other and further damagos and relief as this Court may deem appropriate. , . :! " , " 'I I 'I ) .,", I;' jI,ll! . II i .. '::.';! "!..!I (,r,d :1",1' ,,;) Respectfully submitted, " ' ~~~ Donald L. Relhart, Esquire Sup. CI. 1.0. #07421 2600 Eastern Boulevard Suite 204 York, Pennsylvania 17402 Telephone (717) 755-2799 Attorney for Plaintiff Dated: 0.,,1,19" , , " , , ,', , 'I , ' , ' ., Ii I' "I .., , " " " " " I' , I " , , , , , , , .. , " " , i' , " /', , i' " II , Ii , i, , " , " , , , , , " , ,,' " ,I I' , " " :i ,/ ;1 , I, li,l' , I " , , , , '. , 'II , " ,. , , , , , " , " ,I 1.' , , I" , , , " " . " , , , .', " , , ,-1 , , 1 " '" \\ ." , 11,1 '\ " " I' ',Ii , " , I "i' "_1'1-\: , " 1;1 , ' " I I'll" , , r, I:' I' " . " .' " I', , ~I~ ~i! i i ~J ! ~ II , ~ I ~ :,1 ]1 ,I, , , ri ',if " , i, , I,! , " ,,1\ " " " ", , , 'I , I " , , II; " " " " " ., ", " , " ,'\'1' I \,'1 "I ,', Iii f /:!'l Ik,': .'l' , ~ \ " i , 'I ,I I ',,'I , " 11, . )l:il , '__i , " ,I'il , 11'1, I' , " , , ,'\ f,r'Jn,' /, li( , if" II' " , ' " , " " d.I., ,/1 " ", '11 I , i ~ , ~ .Ii' ,I, </, , ~ I "I', I "1\,1' , I I ,.,:,,1' II ), 'f,' ;r, ;!, /, "I.!",' If;,\,',:,I' ,~ , .111 , I:! , , II' " I " '/'1 , , " , , ii, , , , ", ,. ., , , , /.,.1 " , " I 'I " .. ',' ~ I !'t '. , , " " " , " " " .,. , , \.'" r,' ,,j" it :,,1,., " " , " , I 'r , " .' ", " " , l'I'I'r'l ti' , /, , , ," I- ," ,. I' " ., /1'1 .., 'j,,'1 . I '(', 'Ji .. , , I", " ., , ,\, , " , , " ,!, , , , , , " " , , I"'!' ., i, , I,; 'I ", ,,' , .', ~~ "!' 1)1 " \ '11 ,II) , M.A.""UA",., & ('ARH81.1., p,<:. ~TlIlIM, ".,r ""trll WIIU.ntH.. 111'"110"" "'~;'M&a.. ItIMAr , ' """' rnu.. ...,,,u f'I~1 'It,".."., , , " '.1',,; , , , ,. , , " 'I ,il/ I' " ", .' , , I , 1,1" ) , " , " , , " " , )' '\,1,:/,1.'1 " 1. I "Ii "~,I .I'!, 01'\' ", :1 ., , " " '_'[11'1, 'II ii' ' ,I , , I. iI, . "'I' ,.. J~'I' ,;,.r tt'lft if. "+t,lt, ~ttlfl'j ,," , -/1) " ',;,' ' 1.', : "',f" ,';'~,: ~ rir,~, - II 't "h" Ill" 'Jl' II 'I', I, j I ,If, l.!i,ll ~t& II r 1,li , I' ,'" .' ,), I' ,'J Jol.fl'",I'1" i' t~., I'" "I .\. )" I); 1'1,;+ ',' I', }l,d '.jl,,~J! i ,,. It, ,rl....- r ,0',Q/(\ ~,I;:, , 'I I j _;,' 'I" If I "T' \t 1~\':l,;.\t~[:!I' I' 0 ';;ll" " nl' \, . ,", ij "'/ilflt. ,,',:(, : ',I ' ':;"!' '1';::I):I;lI.'6;{i1 , " .,' , , ,. "II"f '!I.!\lJlj , "f" II ,;' I' ,01\'1" '. ~ .! -~lr/'I1:\\';;.tl 'II' "" "." ,,(,,' "'" 'I'I:;! '. I II . 1/, \ 1,1 tl,'~.. ~',;;Jtt~m'ln I I II II . 'i ) l-fj."f,liP}if1P'~ I ' ,r!' \ 0 ~ . dr,fJ"IiI/l'.", I 1 i ,0..1 11~.()''''JRI' ~ ,:j fl'l,t. ~ld /'! n J1tt '\~jl(l) > ":1' I ",' ".:1/"','1'1, 1\/" ,'tli"~'i I t 'I ,~" \ 'I 1,1' 1 ~l " lj\l'+,~ ,.' I ,I,:..,! I . "'1111"~1.1t~'1 d~')I'I~ ,},I;I_'f" " !il',! hll:IfIJ~~ l '1,.I,.;y" .t.!t, !'l~' f ) ," j lid III It\"'~,', ,',I \' q"t ,,fr'J'1 !'o'.lltj \""i~ ,!lIF/i" ,: 'f.'Uo ~Jjll\.~I':'jf.' I ,f!! " -' .,1. ,I, "j"'i~'l';I..jr,."o , .-i",I"'l_:J,'.if;;"'Jjlfi~'i{m:~ , 'I.,...:!,.'..:"...,__"..'.-,;__l"'!".l ,{,' . "'l'i;'-::f{f'{'l '}J~{1!1)!ltl '.'- :.~\,,..:!I,~ \):I":il\;t!,',:(.~,II',~t~.1' 11'1'" ~, h.-,!;~_' ,; :;i\tllt:'''YJ'~t?!j:!b';fl , I, .I , !.'!, ~ " ., l j.~, , ;',.- 1~ II, ' 1:1.,\(',5):':' I ;Ii I , , " , ", , I ,';,; " , , " ;,1 , \ , ! , , , , !: " ~ , ,\ , ' Ii' " , , " " , , , , " , 'Iif I, , ! 'Iii , , , " I', " , I'" " , 'II ,I , , " ", , , , , I' , , , , , , , 1..1 " , , 'I, , ,1,.1, " " I , , " , , , , " ,. ',I iI!' 1,','-;,:_,:' I ,;;~.: I',' H' ::,'1' I:; '1:1\, /1,,1"1' .. " i f ~/'I' " , ., 'I' Ii , , u ~ i :;;; '" "'........ :I:<lJ..... ciJ~~ .<::Vl..... ,,01 -5 -< 'e -c Po V)M.-: :;iEj!E .<:: 0 Po ~ ~ 5 ::EC'lU " , , , " ill , , , , ", ,,, , " " i " r:" ;')1;." "" ',11,; ;!' \I, .IL "I , , , , :1' " ., 1";11 il\\ t'I' ,. I,'! '1 I, II,' ):,\i ", ' ;\( ,I" "II , ,,1',1 ';,',::t i;,ir;I/'i";,l-,\1 '::i "'1":,;,1'1' 'I" " i \ r ",,;;'~',\, 1,"-'-,;' ~ I.AW IlFFICI'S .--. DONALD-L-~~(B~R:r,_ESQulRE' - lllOO~^SnIIN 1~)IIl.liV/\I\I" !'111ff. 1114 \l)II~. Pf.NNi'\'LVANIA I 7401,1'lll1 I)JNALll L, IlflllAAT ~ IMIltIU.~ nu;I~tONE 17171 71\.1799 UIOO)Ill.7Y71 FAX171717!1.111O E'M,i1 ,.i1l11li....lb<~"".. October 9, 2000 . Curt Long, Prothonotary Cumberland County Courthouse 1 Courthouse Square Carlisle, PA 17013 Re: 96-4110 Sarah Stine, et al. v. Yates, M.D., et al. Objections to Pa.R.JA 1901 and Cumberlend County Rule 1 of Judicial Administration Dear Mr. Long: Enclosed plea lie find two copies of my Objections to Pa.R.J.A. 1901 and Cumberland County Rule 1 of Judicial Administration for filing, The original has been forwarded to Richard J. Pierce for the hearing of October 31". Please time stamp both copies, keeping one for your file and returning the other to me In the enclosed self-addressed stamped envelope. Thank you. Sincerely, -;c. Donald L. Relhart DLRldck ene, The fOllowing counsel of record have been served with the Letter of Objection In reference to Pa. R.J,A. 1901 and Cumberland County Rule 1 of Judicial Administration In Case No, 96.4110: Francis E. Marshall, Jr" Esquire Kerry Voss Smith, Esquire Marshall, Smith & Haddlck, P,C, 20 South 36'" Street Camp Hili, PA '17011 . , , ' " II ", " I, , " , 'I " " , , I, , , " ., , , , , " " , ' " , , , , " " , , Ii! , , , , , , , , , " " " " , , , " . , , " , " \",'/ , , " " " ) I, ! , , " " I, :' , , " ,I " , , , I I , , ,j " :1 , , , " , The following counsel of record have been served with the Leller of ObJecllon In reference to Pa. R.J,A. 1901 and Cumberland County Rule 1 of Judicial Admlnlstrallon In Case No, 96.4110: Francis E. Marshall, Jr., Esqulra Kerry Voss Smith, Esquire Marshall, Smith & Haddlck, P.C. 20 South 361h Street Camp Hili, PA 17011 " " 'I ," II I' " " ,I, , , " " I ' , I ,I 'I' , , ,I 'II' " I, , 11 1'1, , I, I, I I' , I, 'I , , , , " , , , , , " , " , II; , ' ! ' " " , , , ")1, , " SARAH STINE and PENN'l TEAL, PLAINTIFFS v. I I I I I I LTD., I I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COm~T'l, PENNS'lLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW JAMES 'lATES, M.D. , PLASTIC SURGER'l CENTER, DEFENDANTS 96-4110 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COUR'l,', AND NOW, this 30th day of October, 2001, in the c~se of Stine versus 'lates at No. 96-4110 Civil Term, and it appearing that Plaintiffs' counsel has submitted a letter requesting that the case remain active because of the existence of a stay order, the case ia stricken from the purge list and sh~ll remain active. By the Court, J. Karen L. Saxton, Esquire 2600 Easter.n Bculevard, STE 'lork, PA 17402-2904 For the Plaintiffs 204 1'~1~ (JJ ':J.~'OI R~S Jr., Esquire Francis E. Marshall, 20 South 36th Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 For the Defendants pcb ~ffi 0 q ~ ,.../ I'; " '1~ ~~ , , " 0.,,- It I ';::.1 r;l" , ...., ,r-' ~n . . '-.\'.U ,..'. " ) W ' on, ~i .;,t ~ :7) r::> :Jl ... Defenllnnt: Clnlm(s): - , B, Are you clnlmlnlllocullnJury'! X Yes No C. Are you clullllh1llsY5lcmle Injury! Yes X No D. Are you clulmln~ lo~~ of con~ortlulll'! __Yes X No E. Are you clnhnlng wugc lo~s, lo~s of eumlnl! capacity Qr loss of future enrnlnl! cupuclty'! Yes X No If so, Identify your clllploycl1l limn the S yeul1l precedlnl!lmplwltntlon to the present. Employer: Address: Employer: Address: Employer: Address: Employer: Address: IV. JMPLANl' JNFQHMATI()~ For ench implnnt nnd/or sel of Implunt~ you were Implanted wllh Identify (nttach extra sheets, Ifneces~nry): I. Mnnufncturer/Brnnd: Drlstol/Surultek III 3270000S0 2. Identlficntlon ofimpluntlnll phy~leiun: Jmlles YUles. M.D, 3. Jlospitnlllocutlon oflmpluntalion: HQly Spirit Hospltnl. Cwnp HilI. PA_ 4. If removed, Identificulion of explunling surgeon: 2 , ' " '1, " "" 'II " '. " ,,' " , " ,) ,i' I ,p'! , , " 'I', 'I" " " ", , I :'l I I, :, I,. i,I'\i, " , , iI. ',' -j'l " , " " , , 'I , I, "1' ',I 'I " " I 1,1, I, '1 , , -I ;i I", ,i' , " 'I, 'i",) , , ,'I, ;, " ", , , "1 ", ,I' " ," " I, , I' 'I " , , " ,," . "1""'" ,L,;,~,;" ,,' ,I' :'~' _ ' "_'(",. ,;.: __~:'-j("<\'~i:<I:r.i/' ;'I:/_~'-'_'/j _ ,,'iM/ll'W'iOiI/..<y{:',r(,;:: :I"ii':,:,,~rt!';:' L' , }~lAi~,'~Ht"r.(l,~-"-~,, .,01.,,.. , , ',II" ':'\> ,~};~I"i::'?I"ti"'hl'''(OIo'; " , ,I," -'I' ,',1 i(1 ;11' " , , ,JI' , \.' li'I,,1 , " , lAW OFFICII DoNALp L; REDlART~ ESQ. 301e IA8TIAfoiIOULallAIlD ' 'YORK, PlNN8VLV,,"1A 174011 . IN ItEr SILICONE IM1'LANT LITIGATION pLAINTln"S U'WOHMATION SIIF.ET I. CASE I~F9RMATrON A. PleDllll stole the following lor th~ civil uelion which you flied: I. Cuse cnpllon: Samh Stine und I'enny TCIII v. James Ynles. M.D.. nn4 l'lustic Surl,lerv Center. LTO. 2. County(les) in which cuse mcd: Cumbcrland.Qlllnty 3. Cuse docket no: 96-411 () 4. Noone, Address. Phone, Fux of the Allorney Representing you Donuld L. Reihurt. Esqlllre 3015 Eustcm BOlllevurd. York. Pcnu~ylvanlu 17402 ,Phone: (7\7) 755-2799.Blx;lZllJ..lli:2S30 II. '.ERSONA~ rNFOI~MA TION A. Fullnoone: Sarah A. Stine B. Maiden or olher numes known by: Sarah A. Roberts C. Present ~lreel uddrcs~: 748 1-llllcresl Drive. Abbollstown. PA 17301 D. Social securily number: 170-44- 7457 E. Date of birth: 12/07/195S III. CLAIM AND DAMAGE INFORMATION A. Idenlify the exuclnature oflhe claims thut you ore pursuing ugulnst ench defendnnt (I.e. negligence, fililure 10 obtuinlnfonned consent, negligent seleclion of a defecllve product, fruodJmisreprcsentulion, loss of consortium, product lIabillty/fuilure to wurn. etc.) (Allueh extra sheets,lfnecessary): Defendant: James Votes. M.D Claim(s): Mcdlcal Nerzliucnce. Neuliuent Use of Defcctive Product. Fraud. Deceit. Mlsreprcsentation. Infonned Consent. Outruueous Conduct. Los~ of Consortium Defendwlt: Plastic Sumerv Ccnter. I.TD" Clalm(s): Vicarious :tnd Indcl1cndent Liability for Medical Nellllgence. Nel,llluent Use of Defcetive Producl. Fraud. Dcccil. Misrel1resentatlon. Infonned Consent. Olltraueous Conduct. Loss of Consortium Defendnnt: Claim(s): B. Defcndnnu Clalm(s): Are you clnlmlngloeallnjur)"! X Yes No Are you claiming syatemlc Injury? Ye9 X No Are you claiming loss of consortium" X Yes No c. D. E. Are yllu claiming wage loss. loss of enrnlng capncllY or losa of fUlure eumlng cnpacityl Yea X No If so, Idenllfy your employers fomllhe S yeara preceding implnntotlon to the present. Employer: Address: _ Employer: Address: Employer: Address: Employer: Address: IV. I.MPLA~T INFQRMATION For ench Implnnt nnd/or sel of implnnls you were Implnntcd with Identify (attach extra sheets,lfnecessory): I. MnnufaclurerlDrnnd: Brislol/8uruilek # 132808 Lot 170S2.84F & l70S3.8~F 2. Identification oflmplnnting physicinn: James Yates. M.D. 3. Hospltol/loclltion of hnplnntntlon: J:.!QIy 811irlt Hospltnl. Cnmo Hili. PA 4. If removed, Identification of exp1nntlnll surlleon: 2 V. A. Identify each nnd every Illcdlcal provider frolll who III you Soullbttrelltlllent !'rom or IIIly Injury, IIIne~s, dl~ense, symplolll or condlllonthat you clahllls related to the hllplantntlon of silicone Illlplants. (Altnch extra shcels Ifnecessnry) Nwne: Judith Diffenderfer. M.D. Address: Unknown Nwne: Address: Nwne: Address: -- Nwne: Address: Nnnle: Address: Nnnle: Address: Nwne: Address: B. IdenUfy with nnnle, oddress and phone number your currenl fwnily physician nnd your fwnily physlcinn at the time of the implanlatlon of the silicone lmplnnts: Current: Lindo Tavlor. M.D.. 430 N. Moln Street. Sllnnll Grove. PA 17362 (717) 22S-48R4 AtUme of implantation: Judith DlI1enderter. M,D.. Pennsvlvanla Jomes Miller M.D.. Deccased VI. j\fANVFA<'''TVRER SE:rr~F:MF:NTS A. Hove you seUled any claims related 10 silicone brenstlmplanls with a Illnnufaclurer? X Yes No Ifso, state: I. Manufocturer: Brlslol 2. Whether you received payment or cxpectto receive poyrnentln the future: ---X_Yes No 3 " i 'It " ' IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PE~NSYLVANIA \.i, I SARAH STINE and PENNY TEAL Plaintiffs :No. 96-4110 Civil , , v. JAMES YATES, M,O., and PLASTIC SURGERY CENTER, LTD. Defendants . . :Clvll Action. Law . . :Jury Trial Demanded ~~ I, Donald L. Relhart, Esquire, certify that a true and correct copy of the Plaintiffs Inrormatlon Sheet was ceused to be served on the date shown below by depositing same In the United States mail, flrst.c1ass, postage prepaid thereon, addressed as follows: Sarah W. Arosell, Esquire Thomas, Thomas & Hafer 306 North Front Street P.O. Box 999 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0999 The Honorable Emanuel A. Casslmatls York County Courthouse 28 E. Market Street York, PA 17401 Respectfully submitted, , Dated: 1- / - tJ t./ C \~ BY,~u~'-;:C~ ... J Donald L, Relhart, Esqulra Sup, CI. I.D. 1107421 3015 Eastern Boulevard York, Pennsylvania 17402 Telephone (717) 755.2799 Attorney for Plaintiffs " , ~,~ . ,.J" '" " I,j ,/ ... i' , . , ..' I " " t.":J I'l.!, .,0 I i J ~ ! , , .. ), I:,:l,:. , , ii Iii" I " , , , , , , " l,) ~ I - , ,) " , , ., " 'I, "Jlfl_ I , -It/ , li 1.1, I:j '-'uJ I , I' , lJ'T "'J , ~") 'Ifil -, ( f-: ,. '~i , ! t> .'1 'd ,i , , , }. r'.;j I, ,1,1, , , , I" , I I, I " I, " :, I , , '1'1 i' , i; /, , I \ I i' , , , , " " ;_1 1 " , , , , d,1 1'1 ,I " , , 1 , , , " , Ii I' " " , , , 'i' " ,1-1 " , J:: " " , " " " Ii , " , )','11 , , , " Ii. I " , , , " " , , II ,-I , , !, " , ,: , , " il I, " , , I , , , , I, , , I' I, " ,I , " , , " " " I' J; , , 1 , " . " I " , , , , "I , , " I , , ,;' , , , , , , , , " " '1:1, " , , " , " I , i , ,I , , , I ;-1 " , , jli , I' , , , , i' I , :' " ,I I, I , I'" " III , , " ..;1' -I" , I " , ,I , I ~, lil'i \':\"1\ I , I d ti', ',j.1 " , ;' J' .j,; " , , 'I, " , , " ',' " l>li , ,~ i' , ,: ("1 "J' 'Ii I, ,il'l/ , " 'I I" , I,,' " ') , " , ",'I I:i l;, I' , '.1 rk .r' J, , _ ' ~ l,i--' " " ,I' ,iti, :" 'I', 1.::1 :h,,'" .'..'1' ~ J I . , . . ,- " ,,' " ,I; -j., ;"1 ,1, 'I " ,/ " " oj, ' I\'i ": , '" " 1,'11, '('" , , , " , .'1 "',') " , \.1 " " ," ,hi if~~~;l~~,~;;.: . "'I I!';,_"',',:',I,\I 1',I,.,e'-,,;:\ " , , : ~... ; i_ :,1,' " 'd , ,': ~0fI1IC" ':, ,,:':":'~~4lP J" JlIDWlT, ESO; ,,'I ",~~~AIII,)" ,',:,ll' " , l'<~~V~t'4OI It,;'_-I.'.\-, 1'\1 '1111'11'_- , , "',,-rjll\,_.''-\,; . Jl,1;',"_'<\;','-""_".I'.:'! "1. ,> , , , , , ," 'j:! , 'j /'1 :,);i.i.' 'I ,;', il ,I ( ", " ',' ,. " ~- r ' .. I ",.., 'I ;/"\ ,!i q' , , I,l, ;'1', " " i'I' " '" , , " , I , , , .' 'I;I! , , " ! .' " 1\' I , q- , I " , , '.1 ~!, ,I , , ., \, ','.r i,JI'" i " , ;'J : , ..Ii "I " _,l,"!, '" , " ,,' , , , " 1,'-1 , f, " , , , , " . , 'I , " " I'I'!' :;' " ;!/',' , 01,' JI'I , I' , i" , II.il " , I I , " , ," 1"1 '.1\ l,i,1 . , , , " " , , " , 1.'1 ,"I I iJ' " " ,') '-\ _'! I, '. ',I " i," 'I , " , 'I" , 1 " /'1 !", 'I , '-), , " " , III " I;, , , , " " i , , " " >I, \,' " 'I " , " " " , " ,I " " " , " " , , , 'I.', , I: " , , , I , , " " . . , " ;\'1 , .j I" ~ ' :'i\ i\ ji , " LAW OI'I'ICIS . DONALD'L. ~1IWn', UQ. '3011IMTlAN IIOUI.IVMO ' . VOAl<, I'INN8VLYoYM ,'... ' "\ ' " " I' ,,' ", I", III ,-! " '-'i '.;11 " . " ,J" , ' '(1. ';/"'rl; I, ,I'I! ir II I, , , ., , 1 ", " " , .., .' , " iI, If,