Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04298 " , ( lit .!l ' .. , ., .~ t' l-I ,I , ' , ' ,'" " , " :,'. , , 'I R )~ :1 e i " ", ] 1 ~ . I ./ ,( ~ I ., . li- ' iii,' I" " " , " " ,( ~' ....... - ., .'tj '\ " " , 'I, , ,'I , I. .1 " ;, , II 'Ii " 1'( iI I,' I;; , ,i'li!fl" ;/ 'i, " " 1.'( " , , , , i ",I 'I , ", , , " " 'I t';; t "'I', , ,.!' " , I' ( '1':\ j,\' " ." " , ,Il't' , '. , , , )H;!! I'-I ., , /','P ., ;1,'\ .,' 1'1-" :,11 .I ", I , I" :-, d '; , -f, \1': ;11" , ),;-,1.'. ,.__.--,'-"i,' Ii! ',L', 1:"') 'I,; 'lI !'I ", !' .1 il'i\-I'li tifli,,'t e;hl:i " I) ;I\!: '1,'-' ',Ji ,I, I j-I\', !' tf "', "I' , )' I, "1.1- ., '1'11'.- '. 'I! "~'i' Iii' .'1 ii ',I:; !" " , . " ,'I I ',j-" I' -h ",j , , " ',' ,. '\; I'" .!j II, ,ii, ,I \' ';1 >1 I ',; , , ,h i/ 'I 'I ,J I , 'I " .', , , 'i I , II ;i,J.' ~ ) ~ ,',!. .,; 1 H ". \' L. " , ,,1 " ._ Ii ~i,t , 1,1.1' !' l',: "1,'1 ,', j !! ,; "I, , ,I :1 , ' ')':,: .1 1 J '"~' \ if , -it i"I,1 IJi [It [h' 'I' ., " , , 1]' :1 '1/-' '1'1' ., " 1;11 'I, r q ,'I ',. " " , " , " " " ) il/ , \1,' ',;" " " , ., " , " ." " ., II 1'1 '. '<I Jl", p '" ..",_,"I;l , 'tl lil' !I' 1" , ,. 11' " , , ". I , " ',I , '1\' I' ., , , , ' '~,,~~i.! q' '.' >i ;-,)\, ",';' ! , " ';;,i_ J "1"111".' I' , l,' / . ,'I,' '" ,,' ,', I:,' ',: ,,"','" ; I,lii .j;':\-,:! ',I .' I' ,,"f' If _ _i ' I ' ,- , i 1- '-. ,,', ~ 1'1 ! ' ,; ! . ", '\" i" ,. '.1'1,.': ".1" ',o'i I " ~ " _'j ~ ,,1_ ' 1- ':; ,;, : ,:\' :. ' J ., '. ': :,'j ;: .. Ii' ' " ' ,.. I',:, : ~ ,',- ; i! j I '. ]: _ _ _, ,_ _ '('t--:,""-;-'-""!.: --,--, ,,,,,"\". ",' ,',f' "I' 1"1,,.,,",." .1),'" ' 1'.' I '{)":"": '/.' ';1\" ",i I.... :,'"...,I~,:',":i\)!'.i,': ::./,',;.',': ,,' "',;'\"'" "/<"/""'/.','':'1'1'1 t'l'!' ", " ' .1. . '.'/'" \1."/ ;"i.Ii ';';.""\':':"', '/i'\,:';"/":./,"",, ' ,I I,.}fl. \,<1 ,J! -'ldl'/ ,lJ', ,_;/-I,q 'I" ,. 'II 'f" ,,"l' ,'t'.;".'-',il', '" I i/ , " '" ". ".", ,ill "I '1' ". ", ", ' ,)J, ' 'I' I I' , ,~' ~ ,', ,- _Ii'. ,,"- '_ ,_I'F,!'-t.,_,-!,.,-"I ,'! [I , 'I' i' "'1"',;.,', ,'\1.' i" "c.,'; ., ii, ", '1'.,' '..'-' ',. , f" 11 " ':' ',,J ',' ),'1;!' I~ :::"-',:1, ,; ',,"::\";", 'I"~,,',I' ',:i ;,:,' " Ii > !"Ill/Ii ~!j' "'/";iill.,:,,.;.,,"'C"" !I" ;J //1"1 ')~lt,'-ll,(,"~[iIJ)~\.i_:,-;;;:~if,'d;;!'i~.!/';';. Ili_, ~,;- -,'- I.' !~111 , _/_! _ ,_, I "c-' ,,'j"'__'._' ,--'-"',--, I' ".,'1"" -,,' II L'-', '-",- 1_"_' ,!:' ; ]i,-"';': ;--1'; ,-'-t::;i,l:I'I- .-t' Il""l -, -:dl 1"''-/1/': ,_:: i-_J:i'(-IIIJh:1,;:',":,- ,-,,:q.;\,--,,- -,- ,-; ..-~;-, "O~'_,,, ,)1 "",,_-,-' ,I ,li--" ',', ,,'i' - LJI\_'-:\"" iI-I ,\/-, ,'-I, I',' ,il"!""""!"" ,(',." ,'...~[Ii',!/',.,.I"i..'/'",'t\f )',:(,', ,"," ,',' , "','/\'Ii,"\"'':,.,I, ',l''-'-'-,I':';)/,II 'f ;1'-';." :; , ,', ,".,\ :'.,," : ',",'" ':.I'i',.;,;: ">1' " ".' "',,' ' '-"il"'( ':I:'.j :1,..:.' . ,. 'il.., I" I ' ",:','" ,.'\' . ,., ',.1: "', ',I " III ",,' ;,,;,', ".'" il)':I;'/i":;~I' j;: ," "" " '1' r; "I j- -,I .\1-\, Ifl_!i_';i'P: )lh_'..'.i.dl 1\' I ",)" i'lll- ,'-' ',-1-,1.-' j" ., _ \:;,-: J I\',!-,I ~"-y ,,", 11\;;'- .1t1iJ!f ;';,,, 1,,;\ 'i~r i:.i;II;'t,'i'i1;::ii.~;:r,','!,~':/:': . (IJd>"'i/I;,'--~;;' ,,:,-' :f 'I I I. '; \/11--, d ,_t_ i! - " 1---0- . -., " l::\~.rr/.~:,:' -!:il; , , I I' ; ; I '~-' 1 ';1 "I,' d,- , , 'I "I " ,'II r 'I' )1 .,' " !j'l 'll' ;" ".' oj, '" ., -'I '. :') 'I , " '[ .' ',' , '(r " , ' [I' , ,t.\' ,\ "I '.11. i' , i , " ,', " 'I " I' , , 'I !J L' , \ .' , " " I ,,' ,. , , "\1, 11,,\ , , " ,1 : I ~ ., "1 ), " II' " , \-'1 .' ,II , ,,;, "" , , " , " , i " ;/ J )IF!-. , , 'I ,\-:!!;: Ii\', 1 ~ ' " ' , , ,;;,'.";>: \; JJI "_'1' J' :-!., 'I,-"i 'I'd ., . , I. ., , " 'I ." " ," '_1';-1 ,j l;1 :!"ll;! " I.' " , I,' ;,:, ; " ,1'1" Iii " "I' ',' II I' , " q,' II ,-,I ,II , ,J , , ':'1,' ' __"I , , " ,:-i' '!-'I I-d,-', i;J:i , r) 1;'1] ,', , , " ''I,. 11 I d, II " :lJ'l "I: :ltl: I I' -, il- !I, JI , " " ,. , ,. 11'- ! II . , , _,f -J ,. \',' I " " , ',I, " I., -I ),' " jli i'l " . , I' .1 " , 1\ , ,/ , ,:1'1!] '1'1 ,Ii!", d i,l ,'( ,1: di !jl ., "J Ij! q, ,1"1 , ,:il')!.. " 'I, " ,,'\1'. 1/-1" "I ',I , '" " , " ., \, ., ," :!,!:-II " " \:\, ":[1 '!; " ',!I ,'I " " I " 10' " '1'1,1 [,; I: " '! it.',;!:,j .;,I,fl " , ,\ " II \ " " , , 'f: .\, " , ,I '. ~ ;,11, ... , " ;11.,1, ",111- , '1,I_i;I,-I" ';lil; " if 1 i '1..:\ ., i'l " , I , , , ",t " '" " 11 I!, ., " ,I ;f 'II: Ii' , '!,,:,'. , ',l I " , i-I CUMIUllRLAtID MASONRY I INC. I I IN TIIIll COURT OF COMMON PLIllAS Pl.in~iff OF CUMBIllRLAND COUNTY VI. CIVIL AC'l'ION - LAW RONALD W. KIPPS and MARGARIllT W. KIPPS, Defendants NO. 96-4298 CIVIL ANSWIllR TO MOTION FOR JUDGMENT ON TIIIll PLIllADINGS 1. Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Admi t ted. 4. Admit ted. 5. Admitted. 6. Admitted. 7. Denied. At the time I was preparing my answer, I never thought that an answer of "denied" oould ever be rationally interpreted as meaning "sdmitted". I am a layman, and use words in their ordinary sense. If T say blaok I do not mean white. I keep hearing how legalese is supposed to be discouraged and that legal documents are now supposed to oonform to ordinary usage. If that is true, then in the interest of fsirness the Court should permit me to file an amended answer whioh is more "artfully" drawn. . 8. Denied. There very much 1ft a triabl. illue ot tact and that fact il whether Ifter I still owe Plaintiff Gny money. 9. Denied. We have defenees to assert, suoh as the fact that Margaret W. Kipps is not a titled owner of the property et iISUO, and that I have paid the Plaintiff more than he said I did in his Complaint. 10. That may be true but we are asking the Court not to consider the pleadings closed and to allow us to file an Imended answer. 11. IIgain, that may be true but: \lie do have disputed issues of fact here. 12. IIdmitted. However, \lie have never consciously admitted the essential elements of Plaintiff's case, we have consistently denied them. We did not know then that to deny means to admit. 13. Plaintiff should never be entitled to JUdgment on the Pleadings under an argument as devoid of common sense and as contrary to intelligent language usage as the one presented by Plaintiff. 14. WHEREFORE, Defendants respeotfully pray this Honorable Court to deny Plaintiff's Motion for JUdgment on the Pleadings, and to permit them to file an amended answer that is more consistent with the diotional peculiarities contained in the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. I '" , I I I I " I I I 'I I I , I, I I I' I I " I " " , I I' " " " I" " , I I , 1; 'I , , I I.' ).; ,I" , I , ~: f.~ " I I' ... , c.:i , f', ":1... , , , .. I I , ~. .7 I,J~(1 /I , " , , r. 'I,; _.'r,.," , I "j ;; I I.),. , )r;.. G' ..., . :'f/J r , 1 f. .... "'1111 I I" " P'I 'I~ , , '-, c.:-' 'I I t.,:; "l " 'rI ., Jij " tJ <.>, 'k 'I, , I) , , " , , " I, , 'i , , ,I , ill , , , II, , . " ~"l!nICM.'T.ON I ver1fy that the statementa made in th1s Motion for Le~V. to ,il. Amended Answer are true and correct to the belt of my knowl,edge, information and belief. I understand that false statementa herein are made subjeot to the penaltiEs of 18 Pa.C.B.II. ~4904 relating to unsworn falsification to a"thorities. Patel II) )1I)~ ( 1;./ ,;;:"'''-<. ROl'lW. KIPPS . --> ~T , , , , " , , " it , " ., , , , , , , ' CUMlU!RLANJ) MASONIW, I)IIC., I'luhulll' vs. :IN TIlE COl.lltT OF COMMON IlLEM; I CLJMnEl~I.ANL> COUNTY : CIVIL ACTION -LAW 'RONALD W, KlI'l'S un~ MAR(JARHr W. Kll)PS, : NO, 9CJ-42I)K CIVIL Deli:n~l\nls OlmER ANI) NOW, Ihls dllY ul' ________, 1'11)(\, Plnhlllll's MOllon lilr Judgl11enl olllhe I'leudlnlls Is hereby I!rlInled, Judl!lllenlllllhls ucllon Is enlered In lilvor 01' I'lullllll1', CUl11berlund MlIsunry, IlIe. lIlId lIl!ulllllll>elimdulIls Murl!urel W. Klpps Ulld Ronul~ W. Klpps IlIlhe Ul110UIII 01'$2,350.75 plus Inleresl I'rul11 July 24, 11)<}(j ullhe eOlllruel rule ulld cOSIOI' sui I. J. , , ~ . .,1,::11 ,,,-I,:.!I;(, ;O'II't.\, ~.' f !1"'\l';i'l!l~ .1"\11(1',;1: j/,"Jh', ": i",l'~~'Ii(\ :1)...1, Il_I' I, (\',j,'J'I-h"-"'/'L',,!,,,, It:\,.JiH,v,'JI;"'I'lqll;l'i~I'1 ,I \;,,/_1_"\' '\1'" -lr" di'J"-r~l,,'l-JJ;,\!;..,-,-, ii \'h!!fl.',l~n"It',:;~r' :'}'.It-;-ll (i;}i-'lil,~\,,;,~llt ~!I'I Ie ,'I.'," J" '"' ,I . [Ir' ::"1"'''''!' t, -'. ~i\!_,; H "~ ',,-> ''':lIdh,,: -,' 'jI Jj!;, il_j,~ i' 1(,,;; 11i>1";~, ~1.~L:'/'I'"' li/U:il' '.,1 ;,'i 1,J:".Ji!' ;,:,',-i:ijiJ J}/;',-\/;:","! .'.'1\ ",r I'"", -:111 -;:'/::; :>:\;,,// '::,:,;',(:,:~:" !,_'j L,il' Ij> ._;k;,.)!,I', 1\;, \F.'-'i~,;'-(,i~'i ,!,\I' ~;-, I' i d!' II /1, , " , , , " :1 , , r, , " , , ,i' \ ) " , CUMBERLAND MABONHY, INO" Plolnun' : IN 'fHE COURT OF OOMMON PLEAS : OUMBERLAND OOUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA VB, : OlVIL AO'fION.LAW RONALD W, K1PPS AND MARGARET W, K1PPS, Dafant\ntB : NO. r;f" 1 lit (l'll,e NOTIOE You hova boan Bued in court. II you wish to defoncl allalnst the olalms sot forth In tha following pagos, you must tal\a netlon within twenty (20) cloys tlnor this cOll1plaint and notlco have beon sorved, To defond llllulnst tho nfotoment.lollad clnhnll, II written nppaarance statlll{J your dolonllOS und objoct.lOll1l Il1llflt bo olltorod and 1II0d III writing by you, the dOfonclnnt, or by 011 attorlloy, YOUllro wOrllod thnt If you futl to tnl\o action against thase c101ms, tho court may procood without you lllld u jud\Jolllont for IJIlY 1Il0noy clalmod In tho complaint or for uuy othor c1ohllll!CjllilOd by tho plullltlH muy 1.10 lllltorod IIgalnst YOll by tho COlllt without hllthor nolleo, YoulIloy loso 1Il01lllY, proporty or othor rluhts important to you, YOU SHOULD TAlm THIS PAPER TO YOun LAWYE:n AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHOm~ THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP, CUMBERLAND COUNTY Court Admlnllltrutor, Cumborland County Courthouso CarHllla, Pu. 17013.. (717) 240.62QO NQ.TK;1A La han domundado oustod on la corto, SllIstod quiero clefendorsa de astas damandas expuastas en las pnglnns slgulontos, usted lleno viento (20) cllas (Ie plazo 01 partir de In fecha de 10 domandn y la notirtcocioll, Ustocl c1obo prosontar una aparloncla escrlta 0 en persona 0 por aboguclo y orchlvflr on In corte on forma (lScrita sUS defensfls 0 sus objeclonea alas demandas en eontrn de su porsona. Son nvisaclo que si usted no so def1endo, la corte tomora Illecllclns y pUllc1e ontrar unll ordon contra ustod sin previa avisa 0 notlficacion y por cuolquier queja a olivia que es podido on la poUc1on clo delllonda. Usted puodo perder dinoro 0 sus prapledaclos 0 otros derochas impartlllltas para usted. LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO IMMEDlATAMENTE. Sl NO TIENNE ABOGAD 0 Sl NO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME paR TELEFONE A LA OFICINA CUY A DIRECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRlDA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUlR ASSISTENCIA LEGAL: CUMBERLAND COUNTY Court Administrator, CUlllborlllllcl County Courthouse ..,. ~b.42l)H CIVIL Tl!l\M IIh~rnllllluwll/lec uf IlIllClldIllCIII~ IN 1II~IIIJllu prulllule Ilw dlNfluNltlulluf cllNe~ ulllh~lr IIIcrllH Illld /lul U/I pruecdurlll d~fceIH. 1kJ1l1l1 v. ClH'H[Hl. Mltehcll, Tlllllhllw & McKllllcy. ~,IJ"~. III~.. "4~ I'Il.Supcr. .127, 4.12, M~ A,2d J Jl}H, J200 (l1)Lj~). AIII~lIdllleIlIH. ufeullrHl~, Hhullld lIul h~ Illluw~d wh~rc lhey wuuldlllll'lllluee 1111 ellllrely lIew ClIlISl' uf Iletlullul' wher~ the 1l1ll~lIlJIlI~/l1 wuuld IIl1flllrly ~ul'llrlHe Ul' prejudice the llfllHIS11I1l flllny. 14 Thc plllhlllll rcllcb IIflllll llillllcy, 1IIIIIIull.1UicCHC. JIIC, Y. Stllllrl, II I'll, D. & (,,3d 303 (Chc5lcr Cuunly J n'i). 1l11' the fllllflllSltlllll Ihlll "II hllld, Ilcllcl'lll d~lIllll, hcrcfl llf IlIlY dCllIlllld fur pl'uof, ur IlVCl'mCIIIllf rellhOllIlhlc IIIVCillllllllllll, lll' pusscsslulluf knllwlcdllc hy Ihc IldVCrNC flllrly . , . C<lIl~IIIUICINIIIII IIdmlNslllll," Thill prupusltlull, wc IIrc sllllsflcd. Is II corrccl sllllelllerll uf Ihe IIlW, ~ I'II.R.C.I', I02'1(h), JnllvllLu. huwevel'. Ihe ddelldlllllN Ilcvcr IISkl~d lu lII11end Ihell' lIIl5wcr, Rlllhel'. Ihcy IllslNlcd thlllthc gCllcl'lI1 llcllflllN Mlpplicd hy thcm WCI'C hllflklcllllU ovcrCl.Jmc lhc mot lUll Illl' judgmcllllln thc plClldlllllN. llerc II vcl'Y dlffcrcnt NItUlllfllll Ih pl'CNClllcd. Wc IIrc NlltfNflcd. In this CIINC. thlllllo pl'cJudlcc will I'cNult Illlhc pllllntlff 1IIIllluwllllllhc d~l'elldllnI5' mollon III IImcnd Ihell' IlnNWCr, Thc pllllnlllfs llI11tflln I'llI' judllmcnl onthc plcll;IlIlIlN reils, IItthl5 juncturc. purely on II proccdulnl defcct. Whcrc Nuch II dcfect could hc curcd hy 1l00cndlllcnl. judgmcnt hhould nol hc cnlcrcd wllh'lulllllllwlng IIn llPPllrlUnlty 10 IImend Ihc dcfecllvc plclldlng. 11llli!.li.ILL!illrl'ihlllwn. 2lJ2I'II.Supcr, 416.420.4.17 A.2d 45.1. 4~S (I~HI); Pulco v, arond SlrcctllllSpltnl. 2671'1I.Sup,:r. Slil. :'IH(l. 407 A.2d .1'i4. .llJ6 (I'17'i); Lehncr v. Monhl.omcry. IHO I'II,Supcr, 4l}.l. SOl, II') A,2d 626, (1.10 (I'IS6), Thc dcfcClivc 11115wcr herc clln h~ curcd hy pruvidlng morc hpccllk dCIIIllI, Thc Ilrnlllllf IcIlVC II) IIll1cnd 15 wllhln Ihe dl5crctloll ul'lhe trllll cuurt. Ilnd Is, In thl5 CIlNC, gruntcd, Thc pllllnllft\ motl'lJlliJr judgmcllt ollthc plelldlnlll' will hc dCllled. cunultlolllllly, .I . ..., ~^.42~K CIVIL Tl!RM :1 , PRDJ!I\ , 'I ~ dllY III' Jllllullry, 1~~7, lh~ IIlullulluf lhl! pllllllllll' I'ur .,\1: ANI) NOW, IhlN Judlllllunl un Ih~ plllllllhlllN la DIlNlm). 'nlll 11IUIlUIIUI' Ihll 1I111'1I11dlllllN lu 11111 1llllU1IUlldcll IlnaWllr IN ORANTED uIIlI lhcy Ilru Illycn 1~IlYC hI filII NIIIllC wllhllllwlIllly (211) dnya hcrlluf, III lhc cycnl NlllllllOluIIlIIIlIllnKwllr la lIulllllld wllhlll IWIIIII)' (211) dllYK, till! pllllllllll' IIlIlY NubllllllU thu court un urdur Ilrlltltlnll Julllllllllllt un lhll pllllllllllllJi which Khllll hClllllllrcd ilK uf Cllurau. BY TIlE COUIrt', John W. Purllllll, Jr" EH1lulru Por Ihu Plnlntlff Ronalll W. Kll'fla nnll Marllaret W. Klppa, Pru So Defenllant. Irlm .1 I I , , , , ' 4 , t .... " I,; Ii'," '~ Jlt ': {I!-' "J t.:', ' i' l:; L'J " , "~ "'II .. o.li" ; ':~.. 1 d '. :1' I. I. I, , I . , ~ ~ I ~ . ~ ~~ ~ j Vv 1~ ~e ~ ~ 'i ~ ! V B ~~< ~ ~~ ~~ ~ ~ -I WH o :> ! ~~g ~ij ~:J. I~ ~~~ p ~ ~CJ f z ~i <~ , ' , , , , " I , ' . . vehh:h: uccldenl. 'l'hll ~lIcond lIgl'lIlIllIlIlll W1I8 IlIthll umount of $12,032,00 for the III~tullutlon of Ihe ~tlme venellr on the propllrty, In order 10 re~lol'lllllellXlllrlor of the 81ructUrelo h~ orlglnul stute. It Is denied 111111 Defenllunl Ronuld Klpps negotluted or elllerell 111I0 In un ugreement rel!urdlng Ihe In811llhlllon of Ihe Nlone veneer on behlllf of hlN wife. Oeti:ndulII Murgurel Klpps, 5, Denied. The lerms of pllymenl helwecn Defenlllllll MI', KlppN IInd lhe PllIlllllff werc for IWo jOhN. one conll'lIel for $4,830.00 IInd onc COllll'acl for $12.032,00. for II lOlal pUYlllelll due of $16.862,00, 6, Denied, Defendlllll. Rllllllld Kipps. did notl'eceiw the involcc dlllCd OClober 19, 1996 III lIny lime prior 10 Iitlglltlon, Defcl'dlllll Ronllld Klpps WIIS to he provided with pholllgrllphs of lhe work progl'css hy 1'IIIII1IIfI. 1'111111111'1' flllled 10 provllle such phologrnphs al any time 10 Mr. Klpps, The work performed hy 1'IlIInllff WIIS nOI done In a workll1anlike Il1l1nner, PllIinllff fllllcd 10 SClIllhc flllshlng IInl! Ihe Slone veneer. This cauNed WaleI' leakoge al Nald property. 7, Admlllcd in plll'l. dcnled in plll'l. Defendllnt Ronllld W. Klpps pllll! $5.000,00 from lhe Elk Trull Ranch husiness IICCoUl1lllS plll'lia! pllymcl1lof lhc invoicc dilled October 19, 1995, leaving II balllncc of $1.447.00. 8, Admlllcd, Defcndllnlll1l1dc IIn IIddillonlll pllymenl in Ihe IImount of $500,00 by check in February 1996. lellvlng II bolllnec of $947,00, 9. Denied, Proposals dalcd August 29. 1995 and September 9, 1995 do not indh:ate 2 1I finance charllllln allY rclsptClfor Ihe lIcerual of Inluresllnlho lIl1loUnl of $295.75 Ihroullh JUly 24, 1996. 10. Denied. 1)llllnUff was required 10 ohlUlnthe hulldlng permit, the cost of which Is unknown to Defendant Ronald Klpps, In order to proceed Wllh thu projects In the August 29 and September 9, A995 proposllls, Defendanl Ronllld Klpps did not rulilse to pay the balllnce of his bill until a building pennlt was secured, 11. Denied. Defendllnt Ronllld Klpps acknowledges the outstllndlng balance due and OWing to the Plaintiff onlhu conlract Is $947.00, 12. Denied. Dufendlllll Mr, Klpps has been prepared to pay $947.00 10 satisfy Ihls claim. l20lJNT I JJrellch of Contract 13, This paragraph states II conclusion of law which requires no reliponse, In the event a l'Csponslve pleading is necessary, lhenlt 15 denied, 14. Denied. Defendant Ronald W, Klpps is not In breach of the contract and does not owe the Plaintiff the anlount of $2.350.75. COUNT II Qualltunl Meruit 15. This paragraph states a conclusion of law which requires no response. In the 3 eVC:/Il a n:sponslvCl pleading Is I\l:ceuary, Ihell II Is Ihmled, 16, Alhllhlcd III pari, dCllled III purl. II IH IIdlllhled Ihlll PllIlllllff pnrftirllled work applylnll u 51U/le VIllleer 10 Ihe properly locllled III 4904 ElI51 Trlndle I{UlId, Mcchll/llc5burg, Cumberlu/ld CUUIllY, 1>e/ln5ylvanlu. 1115 de/lled lhllllhe propcrlY 15 owneu hy bUlh Defendunl5. 17, Adlllllled, Ill. De/lled, Defendllnl l~onllh.1 KlppH hUH nut hecn cnrlched hy the u/lpuld bulllnce chorged for services performed hy Ihe PIlIlmllT Inlhe IImounlof $2.350.00. 19. Admllled hI pun, denied 1/1 purl. J)efe/ldllnl RO/lllld KlppH tldml15 Ihere 15 tin allloulll oU15lanJlng Which Is $947,00, tlnd dlspules lhe tI/I\lJUIII of $2.350.00 cluhlled by Defendll/ll, WHEREFORE, DefendllJll Ronllld Klpps respeclfully requesls lhullhl5 Honorable Court provide him wllh 7 dUYH In which 10 ptly Plul/lllff Ihe IImounlof $947.00. In full selllemelll of all claims agalnsl him. u/ld dlHllllsH Ihe rcmol/llng charlleH agalnsl hilll. NEW MATTER I. Defendtlnl MlIrlluret W. Klpps IH 11/1 adult individual reHldlng at R.R, I, Box SOK, Owego Pike, Uniondale, Pcnnsylvunlll 11l470. 2, Defendanl MlIrgurel Klpps Is nUl II 1IIIc oW/ler lOthe rellleslule loculed al 4094 East Trlndle ROlld, MechanlcHburg. Cumberland Coumy. Pennsylvunltl. 3. At /10 time did Dcfe/ldllnl MlIrgllrel Klpps emcr Imo tin ullreelllelll wllh Cumberlond Muso/lry. lite, Wllh regllrd 10 certllln ImproVllmems lind/or 1/l51allallon of slone 4 FII.C/J.orrlcr; OF i', " ,n"~I",j{ifiY 97,!IJN I 7 Plf 2104 CUMCIDI/j.., ,/) (; lAIN1Y , peNI\~~'l.V\1110 , , , , i I" [ I lId 0-. ~ ~ .J .~ ,... ';~ q , [t. N D.; r" ~,~ ;1.,. "" It ' .1 .., '0 ( , ... - il'l h;r Il. ,".-.. 0 ':ll ~ ~' -. ~d . c1 (')/. 1..' ~ , N ',.1 '- ','i,l) ~ u.:' :'\ /'11.1.. ,.. r' ::l.: ~'i t, ,- 0 "., , , In Tb!;j Court d C.:mmcn Fle::s ci C::.Jr.~:':~~IC';=nd \.:.::w:-;.,''II PSrlnsylvc::r.!c Clluoor l11nd Mllaonry, Inc. 'IS. Mftrgftrat W, ~ipps ~o. llfh."''Jnli Ciu41 'l'dYlIl ......----, ~9~ ;-{QW, JUlv J 1. 1996 :9_ X. 5:1tt~'F OF c~r:n:a!.,A..:m cot.i'f':'''t', PA.., eo h=--'; c!q:u= t!:.a !i:.=I.H 01 Susauehnnn" , . . C:u.:.q 10 c=mr.t.I t.!:!s 'oVrl:, :!:!.s c!:ruc::==u h=i::f =4.t " t!ur ~ I::d ~.tk ef t!:c l'W::!5. r~-"'<~ ' f:4tl".t! at Ctdu'.4.I:v, C:u:rr. Pa. . .A.5d,..rlt Qr Sem= ~ow, AUJlust 6. ~9 96 . ~t 6168 , ' Q' :lea .L~,[, 1c:""0::I. :::c ';"'i.~l. COMPLAINT MARGARET KIl'PS '~~a . , u HER RESIDENCE IN CLlnORD TOWNSHIP '::y b::~t-! t:J HER PERSONALL V , TRUE AND CORRECT ~ af C: arl-i'--I COMI'LAINT .. :c:r: -"!":. Ccw-:1 '::) HER r.:.r: ::nt:e:: th.c::":t. !o c.:::w~_ Ir:. / ! -A I: t . , I ,/ ' II , .1:' i. ((I t!.L-. !4d ,I SUSQUEHANNA ( COIUJ.rf( ~::. SWl:~ l:::<! r.:=rc.d e.:<::1: =0 :!:!: ~ C:.,! af (J.t, J " l~-U [J fr'-", H "--- f.i ") 1 ~ . J;/, n~ PROTHONOTAIY , rr)MMfSSfON F.XPIRES 1- '-::: 'D" Y C'f ,., IlJARY /J.!. r cern 9.00 15.00 I ::.c....,..,~1CZ S ~C!:..!.1...:i Z 35.611 .~:I-'.J....,~ 10.00 $69:64---' ..... , I " " , I I i) , I " I , I' ,I .... i .1. I Cr; i-.~ ~ '. , .j~ )"1 -f; ~: .' "I t;I.. j;'~ C ~.., 'I,a I. I ;-Jr.!J I, - L!.' ~ om r. .."! _1 ~ t4? d I , ,I I I I .i _.- ,I I' I, ,I I " II , , , I , I) \t 'I , , , , ~~ PI .. . Ln . r:J "l:,n I ' 'I I~ ~.. ' jf~ " .... )~ ,,\ L 'I r .,1>' fl, I IIp fll' r~ " " .,1 'I,; I ;;' F,. , ~ b~ I.} , !I 'I I' .. " i\ 1 \. , , 1,1 " II i: , I' , , " " , i) " " I , ! I , , , .J~ I I I I '~.,. I l, .. t, I,;, "'11"1' 'I " FII.FO-oFFICr: O~ TH"I"','\,":nmNW '. 97 S[P ~~ fill 1I!1 Fi3 C~M~li.I.:I,\~. ,;1, 1[1 jiMTY , I~ENN~YI!h\j1!/\ 'I' " I' t l' ~_ I' l~- , \', '11 -'-'II 1111 , 'i I' ., ., " " , , ,I " , , 'I , , " , ' " , , " " ., , '"I i , I-I " '1>' " i, " , , ' " ,II i' " , I' " , III " 01 , It , iJ , " ,I " I' , , , , , ! , " ., I" " " " " , ' ,,' il ,'I I L I . , .... .... "I.H~. ~!l '1,' I)/.~~'-" I-II ,'..1'-,"1.'" '-"I,',' I,,' ," ,','.,t"I, ",' " II. /WIllvor lI\.rllOt llllllilll~, "II "10111 (7171 2~Q.oo'1I TUtllJ.W OI'I'Il.W.tl (W I'A'I'IUl1K 1", LAUER, .m. ~1U8 MM~I(Wl' 1f1'IUWI', /lY.'I'Ir,t: IlUtLDINO CAMP HlJ,1. rf:NNIlYI,VANlA 17011 I'll'/) '/IWIIIIOO !"IIX ('II'1l 'IOJ ~:M'I H\lJOII:I.~ ~ I,^W 481l, 1)1111. IlLnttll 'fijrl>. I'h 17in I 171'1)H-III-I'MI O~~ N, /'140011I" fll",.,l llllrrlnlllll1r, 1'/\ 171U:l 17171 :1.lI~""14'1 ^,\IlOlIWlu C....Ulllllll MntUUlW ,I. ~~lhllhIlUHI 1':1"'1' ,100111111\ II. W\j~Jd", I':"'. m"I'1,y W l';uuI' 11I1I1I.Iolr.'."> ~ In N, "ifil' HLrtttlL 1)111111111111111I, 1'/1 1711211 (717) 1\II~,~O,1n r~\I.1':Jo'A)( 111)('lIMht!:J'II'IV(1IIMNI'IOI'I flJ1_ '1'0' ItnNOllAOt.11. ,Jllnm: ItAIlOl.lllllll':I':J.Y 'l'l'll.l"~")( NUMIII-:tl. :I.~(HI.III~ ~.It()M: rA'rmCI()o', l.AIII.:ll ,lit" 1':t;'1UltU': DATE: AllOW"I' ?7, 100'/ Ill':: C:UMIIL':IU,AI'IIl MN\OI'lIIY v 1l0l'lAI.f) W, & MAIWAIll':'I' W 1(11'1'0 Nn. 01" l'Alll~' IINcl.unu>/o CLlVlm tII"':~;'I'1 :I. w yOU HAvtr. NOT nl':t':J':JVI':1l Al.l. l'llCllm CON'I'AC"r, I.lr.sr.m IlI'J'I'/NII AnUI'I'IONAl. cOM~mN'I'R: WII.I. YOU I'l.~:MlI': Vi\.'> UACI( A SJ(JI'/I':O CoOl'Y, 'l'llANI( you VI-:rtY Mucll 1,1,:!".tl'; NO'I'ICB: 'I'm: INI'OI\MNI'ION ('()N'I'A1NI':1I IN 'I'1IH1 "'A'.:iiIMII.I': 'l'IIANIiMlI111l0N W NIYI'O ltN \0:\' rIllVJLI:)l'II:lP Mill CIINl"lIJ1';N'I'IAI. INr'lIlIMA'I'ION IN'I'l":NIII.:1l ONI.\' VOlt '1'111'; LIlli'; 01' "111'; AnOV~}N^~Il':" ADlIIU'~HI1I';)':, II" 'rill': IU':A/II,:lt III NO'I' 'I'm: IN'I'I':NIl\':lllmCII'I~:I'I'" YO" AnI': IUmr.jll\' NO'I'IFlIm '1'1111'1' ,\NY IlIWmMINNI'lotl, 1lI0'l'nrnllTION I1R CIWY or.' 'l'UlIll"ACllIMII.I': ltHmU<.:'I'IS I'ltOHlIlI'n:1l II-' ,'Oll nAVI': nI':C~;)VJo:ll'I'IIIWI'l!/\N:;MIH::SI()N IN I.;I\1I011, 1'I,I':l\I.lJo: NO'I'W\' vu IMMI~r)IAn:I.Y 11\' 'I'1':J.I':I'II')NI'; ANIlIU':'l'UlIN '1'111:) OlU<lINAI, M l':mw:! I': '1'0 I'll 1\'1' 'I'm: Alllllmrm 111':'1' I'IlJ,'I'II A'I' '1'111'; '1'01' 01" '1'111::\ IWIl:; , .111 , , :' " t I ~ 'I ~. ~ f' ~ " ,.) ( " I:;, ~ 'I .. . ,,, , '- ~ \n .'.,; ~ " 1 '. ~ ~ ~ " 1 I- 'I 1'1 , " I ~ ~ . \.. .' r... '. I I) "1' , , I I , , ~UMlll~IlLMm MMllNltY, 1 Ne" l'l111n t 11' f ) ) ) ) ~U l 111 '~hl.l CI.IU~t IIC ";UUUI\LJIl l'lllUB (If CI.IU\UI.I~lllll<1 Cuullty, ~I.IIHlByl'lUII.l.U nlJ~ 96..142"8 PIVll. '1'1mN '*R 1l0SAI.ll II, K lI'l'S ANP MAll<JAlmT 1/. Kll'I'S, Pufondlll1to CIVil. AC'l'lllN ~ LAW tJ'\'rH lIe <10 5olo1umly 5wuur (lJr uH.l.rlu) thll GOIlBtitut.l.on of thll IJII.l.tu<1 ~tAtUB '~Illllth 1111<1 chllt WI1 '~ill oji5&;hl1~all thl.l chut wu will GupPQrt, obllY ulld defend IIIld thl! GoJlIB titu t.l.Ul\ lJl! th.l.is CUUIJI\OI\- ojUC.l.UII of uur lJl!ficlI with fidelity. , -1'" 1~ ' ;I (.- //. ,,~, /t~t'~~ "J ,.... t;hli 1:1l1lm ( . .' J . (iJ./.., 1\ / (), (I I l'j' "'~"-(~ N t,j p,' 711 t' -J /111- ',I )It- I" I;;J il /' ,) I -J lJl,( j ~,;)r I-' h t /)(,'/ -I),~ hf?(11:5' /p).S tit{e..f /h 1,(1/' ".)11'5 l)i,j,.h'J/I'~( I . .' ( 'A 1/ ,\HtJ\J). " '/ I,' /' , ' ttjftfi /.1,//1)0.. "1' 7f( (.1') }"// 7/'0)"/11/ /;.II//I}),( ( /i )I)I{' / ,.I;:(jt/( ,J"J 1~1l, the undllrGigl\l1d I1rbitJ:l1tUJ:S, hU'Ilnl.l bllllll dull applJ lJItiir'al\ilil"'''w'- ;...r- . (or I1ffirUled), UlI1Ke thl! folloJwln8 I1ward J lJ 1..1.1' .'!.-tLW.?!.~ ..:!S ;':l7i A'i/"r/;T(L (t1oJtel If ojWJ1411UO for ojuLI:' urn IIWIl~dlld, thaI Ghall-lle ". ". Bupurl1tB1I stlltuJ.) ih /'",',} {I/: );,+ //JIIII,I/ 1;)^J );,';1;1;,,1- j/,J(:' . /;e'II.)/,} 7(:: ;, '/11" /A I) )J., f Ph /7 1'-/- 'A I'/.!. f ;; ~ ~./; II cf Ili / 9 t; /, (7~ ~ !t/(} ~ 4 ~ I )1}j)):C! Jill ,hL~)t J ,JI) 'J/;)~ f J'l.ll t. JI (.j It/ Plp"lr '/ ,7~ ~ . ,\ruitJ:lltor, dinnllntu, (Insurt nBme if applicable. ) Oace of lleBrinll1 '} /" '11r.; f '1"'/~f / If ~1,;,f.t,-}~ ;) j/;.-;, ~ .. . Chili 11 ," / / . " (5/tl ,lcf\.t I) / {'At' 0... (,) , Oate of Award I :IO'tIGE or Imm'{ O~. AI/NUl "f ,,' Now, chn.J'I' Jnl 0';(('" "" awnrd wan l\otllnu upon thl! d6<:knt partillo or thn1.r llctornu:'n. . l:1"ZL. 'It L..!l., L..a, , thG BUlJVe aud notien thllrco~ lliv'llI by ul.llil to the Arbitratorn' compcllaacion to bG paid upon a\1pllal: $ .)>11) 011.. ,1. /'~... . \... ...... '0 t Iv. d,'.., ~ Prothond ary U/I I ff--t.. . ''))llltiL Caputy )7)/1' A~~^ll ;;'/ If/f)~) .I 'jJ. I I I I- 1//)/ ". (. 1,1 (I /1/' I (I) r It I I I ( . " to I)'j I ./ II ( ',' , )j .) I' /iI' f t'/,/ ('/'J",-" \ '/~ ;/ ,'" J'III ;JY(lr:;; J.llcl /51 f (. I( }'I ) )" A ( J. J (/11 hiI' J); fi; J J'I /O~'... ''-:--7 Ti'-----~ . _...- f .'( II ) ,. jl.~:4.'(..L~~~~'7':z.., -- ;1...# '.n... .-".. '2)".?I,;--j);./;;-:t.-;;r---- $~':..l/:!r-.t':!n.. ---. .--..------- .---..-- .--. 'f' N ... " ..J ,.. 1 t ... '" ~ i. . \ :... ! . .l ~... I I 'n~" r) .( '1" I) . ' . ~4i:::/" .If . '!"'~__4.~ _' to. ~~ ( r{,'~II"~1 ~;, 'rhl ;'p:. -- --~ , IVI ) /1 ;J~' II I Yt1 [II li 'J () (1/ )-))t"f ~ j t;IJ If" /- C7P! 1/;/1/ /~ ) ')(1/1 / If t;.. ,,2;" - ~ l/ /Ii I . d ff'Z (/.:5 )J'?I?/r?/ )')111". c):. ;JI, /J I- Ii ~ II .; 7e I- 'Y(/Jtll f:J !v'1be.(s" ,1 (ili (/! III h {J'; )'r/, (ii/tip lit 1(( (/61 I (a 1/ /qr 6 C/. (l:>[I, 7 ~.. '? ({ I ,r ct /j(J, ~ b 7 ~ 5 I , J 1 ',) IIp I ~ !Jt;/I (" I/.-'/P .15' ,J; ri..u;.,l C '\) J.... I '\1 I , I I ' r:<~ "') t.~ ......t I~) ...!', I.... fl , ~1 ~ ; i'-'l' . , , . "[:rr (I! ~~J i'I'l ',.i ;I! -;\,1 1'''' I ~~. J:" "., J) 'J ..} ell 'I " r.~ I '{~ 'i'-, PllEI).OfHCr: OF nil: 11'11f1'n:'(jl;\I1Y \, I g7,11I1?9 MIIII no CUIII' ,J.! ;,/ :1 I \ \ )IJN) Y 1'~NI'f,\I,V:NII\ "1 1 , " II , 'I I' " I, ..I II " " I ,I , ,I Ii, , I' , , Ii ii' ,I 'I' , I '1 ,I " ." , I I" " , , , , , , i 'I , " " ?,; 1"" ~ f'iP c..., " .. o!, "I"~ , I,. fjJ ~~',; ::a.: . ~t , 'if:, f).. , '",.J I') " (IF' ,.... ,'. 'r; - ilL, fL'i l~ " Itjl I';:' ,;./, . 'i' t5 ffi 8 ,. 'I , I I 'I " i' I ~ " I , , ;, I, " , I, " " "I " . , , " ,. , , , " " 'I ,I , l-;t-. In 'h 1 , Il-; t,l, 1,1;, h. , , "1 t,', f),1 ),H 1.1- I"... ,';.11 ., 1/" I,;! ' ", ',j ~j,; I'P.::i (i1jl a~ '-');'~J I h.I" ,'. I"W I " ',I ' I" , -~~ < ,,~ I , 1';".' r,T I,.r ,,:\ t ) .J ,/ , Ijl ,. , " 1\ I , , I , , " " I, , " " , q: , , I " , " Cumb.rl.nd Mllonry v. Klpp. Today', Dall March G, 1998 , . ' __ ,J, III ~~JJj'cl , -,. ..,~iI\, , . Ocloblr 19, 1995 $1,947.00 128853 $2,215.53 Sub TolI11 $1,1l47,OO 1288,53 '2,215.83 COlli '280.118 prOlhO"Ola~ 180.110 Sheri 1108,84 Judgm."1 '9,00 Sllll'lcllo" '8,00 Sheriff e~lcullon .110,.... Judgm.nl on Garnllh.. '11,00 "oltll '- ,IM8IM~ 'Dally Inlernl al G% ulcula\ad 30 daya from Invole. date , I Iii , I 'Ji )! , .' " " " , " 'I I,ll , I I' 1'1 I I SIIIIII'" S III1'!'UJUf oon.1f . .-98 Plllsolf~L PIIOPIIII'!'Y WJ\l'r 0' IIltllcU'rION CUMPIIRL~D MASONIIY INC, VII KIPPB JlONAI,P W, I\lld If 01'11 January I, 1$98 Ill: 2 122 P,M. IlIICIIIVIID FROM PJlO'!'JlOIfOTMY /\lid NOWI Jllnuu'y I, UIld Ill: 2126 P,M, PAYMII~r IlIICIIIVllc 106673 And If 01'11 Jllnullry 9, 1998 Ill: 3104 P,M. It/I'!' 11\1. BIIIWICIl And Nowl JanuII"Y 22, 1998 at 4 120 P,M. IiIlRVED GMNIBlIlIIIIS) Mil 1MB ~ld Now, January ~2, 1998 at 4.20 V.M, /UI COMMANUIID DID ATTACII ALL MONIIIS. OIlIl'I'S, C1UIPITS, RIGIITS, IN'l'ERlIB'!', III1AL , PERSONAL PROPER1'Y OF RONALD KIPPS, DIIFT It/ llANOS OF CORIIS'!'l\'rIlS BlINK, GI\lUf BY IIANDING TO PAUL Fllt/TOIf, QUALI'rY SRV SUP, TRUE I\'rTESTIlO COpy 0' WIllI'!' ,. MAKING KNO~IN TO 111M 1\'1' TIIEIR OFFICE 30 N. lRD S'l'. IIIlG, ALSJ LE1'"l' WITII GM1USHEII A COpy OF wlu'r FOR WI'rIIIN N/\MIIO Dill''!'. Shariff's Costs Stata!P"othonotary Fila Poundaga $42.00 $9,60 $J8.94 So An.W....., $90... J, II. t.ol:wio~, BheriU " , , " , " 02/12/98 PAG&: 1 CUHBIlRLAND HASONRY1 XNC. , I VI. , , RONALD W. KIP'S , , and , , CORBSTATBS BAHKI N,A'I , OARNISHBII , COURT or COHHON 'LIlAS COU.TY or DAU'HXN NO. U~4298 ATTORNBY I.D.'17498 ~~SNIR8 TO IMTIRROOATORII8 1M A'TACHijBMT TO. CUHBBRLANO HASONRY, INC,. Plaintitt 1. No. 2. No, axcept tor an acccunt titlad Ronald N. KippI dba Ilk Trail.1 Bilon Ranch. Th" aUI ot f3, 300,00 hu bun rutri/'Jted purluant to thil Writ. 3. - 6. No. ,/ ","'." /. "'-- Dated. ) (/~ C. RLIN & ASBOCIATtlS 15 9 alnut Btr"et Six h Floor Philadelphia, 'A 19102 (2151 864-9700 'I I ~. o..tl >. I ,; V'; [., 'I . r.' ,1,1; r_) "l' ,I (, II ~ ;, -" I, ." \,.. . \}.: ' . t..' .. t -., . 'I " '!' ..""J .\ '1) Ci.\j 0; , ~ 11J . fJ II).. I :I: ", b ~ ~ I' ,; " ClJM II 1':tll.r\N II M....IiONIIY I INU, I 1:lllJll'I' OF 1'(IMMl)/'I "',BM; I I:OlJN'I"1' l)Jo' l'lJMIII.;JlI.....NIl v, I I 1 ~ - 42?f 11ONAI.Il W. KI PI'S I I NI),~I~-n1r" 1111,1 I I 1'011 I':S 'I'.....n:s II....NK, 1'1..... " I 1,Il,H:J9'fS..r- (IAIIN 1lillJo:B I .\'1"1'0111'11>:\' Q.RDI!8 TO SAT Ul.E.LIlUDOMI!N'I' ....OAINIiT (IAJUillillEI! '1'0 '1'111>: 1'1l0'1'lIllNO'I'AIl\', KIII.II)' 1II111'k Ih.' JlloI"III""1 ..111"1'...1 ""'IIII1HI Ih.. 11111'111 Mhnn, l'1l....StlllllH Illlllk, N.A.. ill Ih" II hll v.. 1III1IInl', MIIIIHI",," 11111I11 1lll,YINnul IlJ' )'11111' HOIIIH nlll)'. ~~ Illlludl '3. '1.,.1,1 , , , , I , I' iI I, , , ,. " t ~ r- ~ ~G ,I, L4~ ~~ if .~~ , ' I, ., ~~~ .n .1 N ~~ ~ 8: ~~ ~ ~ ~ ~ I, 1'1 ,I " I, I" 'tl ., I'l' , , " I' , , " " , II 'I I , , , , " , ;,