HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04304
,
,i'
"
I,'
I,
:1-\
, I
, ,
,
::'1'
:~
, ,
\l
,',',1'
",
~'
1['
:"~' ,)
, I
.j
I
,.1"
, ,Il'
"
,
, '
I'"
I'I'
J/,) 1
~I'
"
I'
,
I'
"l
,',~"~'
"
. ,
,
'I
i;
,1'1-' ')"
1\,-"):,
1.1-'1
-
. .
'. :)
~-
<tJ
,,,
,"
II
"
::r-
Q
,~
',I/,ill \'
'I"', ',/1
I"
",
'II
'j II,
,
,
i
"
,li'l
/
!,
i
,
'tI!
",'
, '
l;i,I-'
;1
i,;!1
'I'
I
"
i ;1
) , Ii
'1- I
,
IJ,
I
,'J
,
, '
01 "
,I '\
q'
,I"
"
q I ,I ~, r I .
i)'
i.
{I J
n'll'
,:\'
,
,
:q'
,,",' ,
; .j
']i ,1_1,1 "'i
,I
,old
"
,,'
I
,,'
Ii '/
i,
, I
"I
,
"
"
,
I,
",
,f
"
,
"
,,!'i
'J,
"
'I, 'Id
':1
\-1]
,',
"
, "
.1
"
"
II
1'1'
,"
,!
I'_Ii,! I'
I" 1",11
II; !,_, ,II,'
I'''' I', -""
I" ,L'I;
'11,:I,:i
'I.__j", I
';
,"
,
"
il
I
Ie
:'1
il..!
I
, I
I!'.. t'
,j ,I;
,,'I
I
','I'
'lI,i
'i,!
'~JJ 'i,
, iJiV"
,"
/,
'I"
.,'I"H_I))i ")I~
11 1i,,1 '
'n:1I '
,
t,,1
,I
q'i_
:'
"
'-,'t
Ii'
"
" \
I I
,
"
II ;/1
If
,I"~
:1
'J'
,
..,
,
"
'I';)
jd-,!.I,
.,1
I'
1.,1
'I,
(1)
,,1,,1
:j
')
\
"I,
'\,
,
1'-""
',Ii
,(,
" '
, , '
,_ .'1 i ., ,J,t
1",i,'I';I,,/il;!-
'!Ii It ',:
'I'
,'! "
'''J{ ~I
'1 __;1,-1'1,
/,
'f'l.q'j,i/;;!;
)
'1_'1] J) i
I
"
,I
'f\l
, i
, '
.',-j_1
"
i_t','
01' ;
,
,
, '
,I.I I
,11
,I
\1',)
,"
, '
,
'I'
,
,I
,
"
,
I ii
,
"
',ill
Ii,'
',~
,
I,,'
,\
",
,
,
"I
'I'
"
:1
':1,
Iii
,
"
f
,,'-I"~
,_II
, '
'1,1
I, tl
,j'J
;,}!
"
,
,,'
,
, '
,)
'i'
II," "
/1'
I
,
,-,!'
II"
,I,
;I!
"
\I""i !'
1'1"
:rd: I
"
!
I'!
I
'\
I.
i'll)
,
'I' '\
:\ I,J
'I"~
"
'i I'
"
"
,/,
I
"I
ii'
, ,';'1,
" !j
,1,"
,I, f-,l
. !"!l-~ 1/
'I '
.(i' '
I"
,IJ
I
II' ~ ,I
il I
I')' .q
. "I
"
I'
"
,1'1
, ,
'._1)/.)1
,
"
"
'\1'1 '
,
"
,Ii.
"
"
"
'j'
"
\ 1 '\__'1
I
/11\"
I,
"
"
,'I
"
'"
"
\'
, '
i,j
,1/,
,,'
,
1;/',
:,
,
" ,
,
L'j'--I:j"II,>I_;'1
i:l<r,?l,-.l-
,,;-1,
,-) I, ~ I
1'1. ,I
J
(i/ i. ;t \'i' ~ \; i
; _, ,-dd-'
~ "',:',',::1,';'';' :\,,'/:,," I!
i '.ili ,p
'I ,'I. J;;"
,I 1'-'
,I 'I!
, ,
,I
"I' I
I: j! Iii
a' ,II,"
, "
'I
"
"
',I,',
" '
,
,
1
'I
l-i!
i.
"
)J;J'
, ~,!
"
"
,
I:)
"
"
',{
,(I
'i
'I
,
II,
'1'
"
"
ill
!jl
:'1 I'
,I
"
,I,
j; ,I'i,
11 i,
, , ~ i' I
"rl,I'\
,
t'j'
,
'-HII!;
~',-~W'
I 1 I J i j'l' ~ - I I
,I 1",/' ,: _! '- 0 ,',
" I '.'1" >' _:J,-J-.tU:"/ ! ~il' -'
y i~(:' i j ,\ I !L__ j',\f th-- ) I J, -ii' I,'
t ,11:1__'1(1.1.'.,1;1>--1-".--\1_..-".1
ii_ " _, -' __!"f",~,-,()HitJl" '1 \
,'1/ ' ,'" ",I" "",,' I"" II'
,j' /1',' ,;,;:;\:,;i:!\::!;)rf::?,i?!Ji;~~~;i:" IV",
" ,,", ':,:, ",;,"i'(t" ,,,1','),\1" \"
"", ,1,,1, :,;1:1-,11"':""':.'," ',: ',:1'\11"1';" " "
,I' !' ,"~I 'I"'"'''''''' I'"~ ""." ,1,1,
" ".: i:)~:::" i~ ;::t1.~:,;:~;:~~~;~'i1i);{j~;;/;,:,:1 '
", ,,' ,,"'" ,,' "",' ,I','" 'I ," "
" I' 11,,.,,,',1 '1\ I,' ",I,'" ,,'
; I ,I o! '_ 7.i H('J, o'/, - ,- '_, i'~II\' ,',' ,,1 I
J '.' I __,' _,; , -" 1111 i ;' '" ,- ~ ~ , ' - "', t
"~I, 1'( __/1-,1- _",,0 I I ';},-, i ,",
) , Ii" ; 0, _, '~"I-~' _', - ; \ I,. ,,, 0 1 ,
/,' "I"',' ", \';', ""',." ,'q,
, , , ' 1/'1' ",,"",;'
" I I;.' 1-- _'I J ,I
, d' I' '1I_'_,J 'j J .,"'{
,,', ,I" "I, "I' IJ
,; 0' itJi\"I:-,I.L_'J1;1--':__,I_'
!',.-,!.1' 'J:_~Li.'jl,~IIJ{J':' -"~I
',I t I -'II; I,_b' ,1 h.~__1 'I
I _,nl'-/ 1- ""II. .I
I" _j \f :'fl - r,.',!ql.~ '-'
!J. 'J i I !: I' ,;, 11','1; I-'.d 0 :!~.- ,
JI" " I
:,' ""1'1 J ,"'\'::~'r..."'I",i,',,::\
L ',: Ih -_l'''f~(ff' ':_1 ;,-.,," " }
);-_1/1' "_ /,_1'. ,,_;,,\,1- A" I
,11'," ,''," "', ''J' i,"" ,i',
! II.. 'I"" ),-1: ; \--i~_I(; . '
r--I,/I II ,:",,';-'l!-:-':
I ',,_ ':'1-\-,,'1,- -,I "II'
r i: _ ,'!' '\ I l;j, ~ I , -. I
'0.'; ',i'j",1 i, 1,;1.-,' 11 ,.
-I .'1, " "
. ,: ",;; :i'
_ 1_' " ,-I '\i{,;-!'-': _ \1 I .'
I '" ' " 'I' "
"'1'1' ","':,,'11" ,
_1,1- I ",-,-,:--" i'
..;1::y:'!;::I,,,,;,r',i I;",
..'" ,,' '" I, ,:, ,'",
" 1,"'1 ,_ > 1:.J;;j \:!' I:' II - "I),' "
, I ',' ,')' ,',;,1,: ,,' ','
" ' "{",,, ,'"' L '
\1 :n, 1 ,jl__\ ;['I/ll' '" "
I,-I',j 1,\'\'1,':';1' ;
1"-; ;.\',:, to
I;'!;' .-/;' '" "1'/
q,\,;i I
'}-11
"
'I
,Iii
III
it
Jnn'
, I,'
iI
"
11 II
;II
,
,
!p
,I
"
'1'
I
,I I
,:--1
I'j'i
"
i ;';1
"
,
"
d
I
,
"
I'
'"
1,\ !' I,
:j '!
I ,.-'f/'
,
,
"
1 . L ~ I
I'
'Iii
i.'j
jl!"l
('I
';'
/
;;;
'I II'
,
,
'oj,
I,
,
\",
,,',
,
I
II'
'I",
'\Iil
, ,
j-I
;i
'11-'1'
I,
:i',
il
,
"
, ,
H.
I,~
,
II'
" j'
,I,
I' '
I';
','-\,
'Ii
-.il
,
!!'I> ,\
, i'
{
Jj!-;I
!I,
11"1'
,
[i
, '
',,-;) i"
;1
"
I
"i
"
,
,';':f
"
"
01,,1,"
,
"
'"
'i""
"
"
; ~ I ,
II""
, '
"
:11
'I
,'j.
t"II.-}
,
I'
1_-1
!
,I' ;-:1\1'
\ ' "1,'/ I ~
"'1',11'
,,-1-;':\
;11 I
, I
"
\I
, !'
"
,
,
',I
,
',',lj
,-01
"
'I
I,
Ii
"
ii.
",
"
"
"
"
, '
" I
"
,
"
,t
"
,
ill
I"~
I"
II'J
I,
"
,
"
i!
"
"
\,t'
"
,,,
"
1;1
oJ
..
(c) Dclimdunllilllcd III glw wllrnlll~ llfllw dUnl!CrllU~ clIndllllln, crcct hurrlcudes, or
lukllUII~ llthel' KllfelY J1rccllullllnK tll prewlltllllury III Ihe I'lulnllll'llr llthcr husllle~~
vl~lh)rs;
(d) !JelimdulIl litllcd tll rellllll'C Ilr rCllledy the dllllHcrllllK cllndlllllll which cxlNled
Ilnlhe I1Il11r,
6, Hillel)' UN U rCNlIlI Ilrlkl~ndlll1l's ncgllgcncc, curelCNsncNS ulld rccklcNSIICSN, 1'1111111111'
sufferud Injuries III her r1l!htlcl!.lInklc und lillll,llIdndhlg NJ1l'11lnllnd Icndcl'l1css Ilrlhe mcdlul unklc,
brul~llI~ und lendcrncsN Ill' Ihc IInklc ullllr which Inlllrlcs huI'C clIllscd Plulllllll' I!rcUl plllll und
sun~rlll~ und huI'C cllntlnucd III CUllSC Pluhulrr pulll IInd slIll~r1n[l. und wry contlnllllus IiII' un
Indel1lllle lime Inthc flllurc und lIluy hc pCrl11UnClI1.
7, Slllcl)' us u rcslIlI Ilrllcl~nduJ1l'S ncgllgcllcc, cllrclcssllcSN IInd rccklc~NncNs, 1)lulnllll'
bll5 IIl1d wllllnlhc rlllUre be IIhllg~d tll expcnd l110nlcs lilr l11edlclnc und Illcdlclll curc Is Ilrdcr tlltrcut
ulld help cure her InJlIrles liS well liS IllullevllllC llle conllnllllllS plllnllnd slIn~rlnl! Nhe expcrlence,
H, Slllel)' us u resultorllcl~ndlllJl'S ncglll!cncc. curcleNsncNs und recklc~~nesN, 1'I1IInlll1'
hus und will Inlhc rlllllrc he IInllhle hI lI11cnd III hcr Ilsuul und dlllly dlltlcs und uCllvlllc~ III hcr
delrlmenlund Illss,
WIIJi.REFOI{E, I'lulnllll'prnys Yllur I hlllllruble ('llurltll cnler JlIdl!lllcntln her li\Vllr und
ugulnslthe !Jelcndunlln unlUlllllll1lln eXl:CNS llf$25,000,00 tllgcther willi Cllsls IlrslIllund Inleresl.
DATE:_ ..3-~~~_
. ~-*"""A-
-- F(Jr{ES~I~:MYI~RS
10000 Mlllly Pllchcr 11il!hwuy
Shlppcnshllrg. P^ 17257
^Ihll'ncy 1.1), I HOM
I verll)' thntthe stnlell1ents Illude IlIlhl~ COlllplulnlure trlle lInd corrCCl. 11Inderstlllld thul
fulse stutemenls beruluure sllbJecllo Ihe pcnulllcs of I H I'u, c'S, Secllon 4904 rcllltlnH tll un~worn
Iblslllcutlolllll uUlhorlllcs,
DATE: 1<,}'1,-'1e.
/7:;- I ,-j
,/ / /l{'1,>'''q.4>''~' ~ !-'r ,
(f
. J -
11"- '7?"'-",t" (.t..,t-~).'C,J
'I'
.1,
','.!'
Ii,
'I"li
I
,,'
"
;1
,
"
"
J ~ I
" ,
"
"
'i
\1,
I
I)'
"
" ,
11
'_'I'
i',
,,"i'i";I,,;"II'
. "I';;,
I fl,,;
,I
If!
,I
, ,
"
" "
, ,"
"
"
, "
" "
"
)1
,I ,
" "
"
" " ,
" :11 \, .;1 \
I ;',"I( "
,If
""d \
-'\1 ,
, , , ,
"
,j'l
r,\._ ,
//Il*,',\"ftj' ".
r'l .
j'i'
,
'I,
"
{',;;,
"1"'1
I ~
,ii,'
,-,r'
"
"
,..
~..
"l'
"1
,
"
"
II,'
+,
;
;,\,';
,
"i
,'J
"
,,'
;1'
i'
, ,
I
"
"
"
_',I
!'I,J
,1
r
;1,
"
'Il
I ~k\ ~ 11
, ,1_.' _ . I.l,l"~ ! \
1!!I\t ';",11,\-
;'/;',Ii' ;,,',"
(.','
lid"
"
"
"
,
'I. J
" ',.
"
"
, ,
I
"
:1 !
h'
,
,,'1
'"
")1
',,_,
"1";11)
1','1;
,I 'r,
I'TI,
)1
..I., 'j
i/,f .:,f
"
./,
".
I
il
':.-1
I'
:1,'
;,
"
-/'-,
,
"'I-
h>,t,
,
I
" ,
, , IJ
I,
" .-1
", ,
, . I'! ,
) ! I. ,(' ',l " ,
, ,"
,"
,
" ,I " ,
1 " ,
, r
I , ,
'1;' "
, I'
'I' ;11:, ,<
.',',j
I
,IJ n'
,
',II
I~
If !,-I
iI-'j'"
"
,
I
',\
(;,
J,,""'i(".
\,.-.f, "
1'-'
,I: r>'
I,'
''Po't'l rj
I,
, I
\. ,r
"
,
0,1
..
'I
"
,
, I'
,
1'_1
t.,
"
'-1
';,
,', i'
,>.1
,ill,il!' ,I
"
1,1
,\1'_':'1 ':1
\;,,\/,>,: .I'
'J~}'; ~I-~{,.., ,-
df,_~!,.l;/ , j'/
'II I
I.'
I"
',1,
:,'1
"
" ;11
I, ';:,1',11
, ")
, I
,
"
"
I'
; I ,~ 1 '
1
"
'II'
,
,
,
','r/,
;'i',
I'
"-,'..-, '
, ii. 1 . ,i' -,' .~, 'I
I, "1'1
'I
,
"
I'
'!+I
i,'
'JI I
,
,
,,'
,
J;i, L
I, "
'li'
',-1' :d-,' I,
':I.jI'I;
!.:', "
t,,'
"
I,
"\,1
',I
lir" 1\':1)
l . ..,' j
(,'I:'."I'i.\L\:'iHI1
"i'-"" e" .,...
,'''. "i,-i,t,UI
'. .,,1 i :,1 d. {I :~...-,
. t,,; !~,' -",r.-,;
t' ll"ii, 'J!,;~
"
MARGARBT A, PATrON,
. Pllllntlff
IN THB COURT OF COMMON PJ..W
CUMBBRlAND COUNTY, PA
NO, 4304 CIVIL 1996
v,
BOB EVANS FARMS. INC,.
Defendllnts
TRESllASS
DEFENDANT, BOB EVANS FARMS, INCJ.'S
AIUWIB.. '
r , '"
,
l
I
I
,
'I
I \
.'
I I
.., .
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted.
4. Denied. The lIverments contlllned In this parngraph are denied generally
In accordance with PlI.R.C.P. 1029(e) liS amended June 16. 1994.
,5, Denied. The lIvermenls contlllned In this pllrngrllph are denied generally
In accordance with Pa.R.C.P. 1029(e) liS amended June 16. 1994.
I,), ~\O:n,,'H~
),,)U ,\111. II' ",', ,'!li I" !:!) I') I I ,,'j
10 11I1.__N.f.W P'o.t+e.r.
,!itlll 20 "",.,' ''',
,1HI'1 or :~r ,,1,'1''1:" (\ .\ " ,I: I
'1'1'11',1: ",Ilill:,' " '" I "i, ,
r0tJ(~HJ0:~_g~/. f~/"" e
,\fln:I\!YiuI\ (J&~ E.\X:.o.t\S
6. Denied. The a'lertncmtIJ contained In this paragraph are denied generally
In accordance with Pa,R,C,P, 1029(e) as amended June 16, 1994,
7, Denied, The avermcnlS contained In this pnrngraph arc denied generally
In accordance with Pa,R,C.P. 1029(c) liS IIl1lcnded June 16, 1994.
8. Denied, The averments conullned In this pllrBgroph are denied generally
In accordance with Pa,R.C.P. 1029(c) liS IIntended June 16, 1994.
NUW MATTER
9. The plaintiffs claims arc bllITed by the applicable Statute of UmltBtions.
10. Plaintiff has flllled to sUlle a claim IIgalnst Answering Defendant upon which
relief can be granted,
11. The alleged negligence of Answering Defendant. same being specifically and
unequivocally denied, was not the proxlmlltc cause of the alleged acddent and Injuries to
the plaintiff, If any.
12. The IIl1eged accident and injuries to the Plaintiff. If any, were proximately
caused by parties other than the Answering Defendant. Including both parties and non-
parties to this litigation over which Answering Defendant had no control or right to
control.
13, ' Plulnllff, ut ulltlmes muterlul hereto, wus guilty of contributory negligence,
such nllgllgencll blllng thc proxlmatll causc of thc IIccldent und Injuries to the Plnlntlffl
therefol'c. Plulntifl's clulms lire ban'ed or In the ultemutlve diminished In uccm'daJlce with
the Pennsylvunlu Compurnllve Negllgcncc Act. 42 I>u, C,S.A, ~ 7102.
14, Plaintiff fulll!d, lit all tllncs muteliul hcrcto, to keep II proper look.out while
proccedlng upon Ihe property of Answering Defcndunt.
15, Atlllltlmcs 1l11llerlul herelo, Answcrlng Defendant ucted reasonably. properly
Ilnd prudently and wus at no lime negllgCllL,
16. In the ultemllllvc If Ilny negligence on the part of Answering Defendant Is
found to exist. same Is specifically and unequivocally denied. such negligence was not the
proximate causc of thc Plalntlfl's InJuries,
17. At no time muterlal hercto did Answering Defendant have either actual or
constructive nOllce of the alleged condition thllt Plaintiff claims to have caused her hann.
18, Plaintiff's physical und cmotlonlll Injuries, sume being spec:l/1cally and
unequivocally denied, were the sole und proxlmtltl! l'esult of II pre.exlsting condition. not
related In any manner whut50ever to llny uct or omission of Answcrlng Defendant,
19. It is belicved and thercfore aVC!ITed that discovery will show that the Plalnt/ff
voluntarily assumed a known risk thereby barring recovery by the Opel'at/on of the
Docn1ne of Assumption of risk.
'1r:~~"~~'lw:ItJ~' ''','' I',' , I""\,, l'Il'I' ':' 'I' 'I ') P'''''',', '1'1 \,'1,,''''''
m~\~~~~'J"r~I',IIJ\" I'" I",lll" /I',J' 'l')"t'~' l'f 'If'" ~'JI
'1\IJ',~'j ifl/'!,l ll"", fll 1,'1' 1/"'1' '~'I '1' 1 ,)<1.,,,11
, "I" I' 1'lfl1llf, j "j' I ' "1 '/iI I I' ,
illf'(~'llj.J:t,.Jj~"I.' !~,J!'I 'I! Ili \:'I! IT) .II'JI 1,';,' I:q',/I,'.,,\ '1111~'f
) f! AI (, III I I f I I ,. I \, I" I" ,~ <I I . \1/, j I) ., 1 'i~"
l '1~"I" I" . i't':' I Ilill\~ 'e~ II I " J l) -", J', I r " r II iI' I ) \ \,. ,'I l-h1r '('I
"/"11\,','1. \ ~t' I, ,J,i, r I ," \ I. "I,'" './' 'I "llll . fl';./J' '
lJ:' .1'1'" 'II I' , I')', '11)":1 I ,I JI, I' , /'), .. ," I. I"j" "I 1\,
'il ,,-.' r - ,". _.. 'j-. !.l'.'." '" )1), I' , ", i' , , " 1"\ j ,,'t d 1 ,'f II', ',\ 'j: 1",:1,"""
l.l 11"f'v"II,I'JI" i_l"i,,!<1 I'll .II 1 (, 1,'1"" [JI ' ' IIf1tl '11,1' 1
;;,~rll','V".I'd':lr':'"\<,,,~-,\,/' /: " Ii ,ft '1,',< ,~:Il,",~,\ .' 'I,' .J,i't'r~i.. ~
;i!/ . '('i-'!~' 1):1 ,. ~II j", !I ,II,;' , !: l ,'),.! i..,' I ',;, , Y " i!'/' J '1.1 I J J, I ,) " I ~ O'\~~' .1/ I ',\~ ~jll' I(~
jlll',.?!f"'I""."I/" 1 ,','I /i\ Itl,,' ,I \,' III"'JI~}!I~t,.(~k\J,
11" ,'--',I.",.' '. " "','" '\,!'II' I' I I' 11\ I t.~, '~'
A!:!,id,'./JJ;,,"!;jl'ii" ;,' '1', l' 11 :;,; j ',,', ;'I\lld 1 r.~ 1.
"'-,II,i,I,II,"',,""j,;I', f" I "I' '" ~'I"I " I' I'~' Itt~I..i, 'i'!!~
'(,",' ": i''' "', ",,,,,. ,j '"I,' .,1 ""1 I \I!' i I." 'itl 1i,' .~~ .~, "
. .rill~II'!, 1'1: .)1,,' '011 I j , ~II! ~,j' i,l' f. J',J1t;lH
III ,,',':""1',," ,,"" , ""),, ""'~~"1~11"
I',!, I,'" " I..,)",' ",'J!! ,', 1,'1lI
/ II '"r'.)', '" 'I j,l l r ')1 p l' '( r'll\';'
\" ""., 'I ',,' ,', ',1'- , I ,,' ! 1 ' ~ "r, \ ' . f 'I HI' ~ f
,,;',~.-t';l!IC!~"ii' )'i 1 'I '1>")' 11{!'J',.l!{ 'J~1(
\tl~i~il' !~,;'" ,':'1'.'"" ~ !"f ,1/ JI ~ 11 l:tlf~'li'\.-' I!
, nIt !;J('J, II" ,):.;',!, f.'" 1,,; I, I' J I \ I , 1" '~ t f '!. jf I'
~1111!t!I"~:f; I-;;..I'i' .1,. j, I'.' ,I 1~",'"Jt)1i
1'1' j'j1\'f!.'!lr--r'f:l!';",i," 'I;' ; ,I " '1; ,; ',\' :'t I, If il,),
( f, ~~'"I''' '" ','1", I ri " I "'II ".Jl J"",
"~\~I!I,tY;i"J;~'--":':!"!""";XI[(';" 'I), ',; :;,;_);'V}lI'I..:--,::'H;;~,jl"
'i .'.i~IJ 'f.'i,\"~'L -j,II, ,: ,',,}.-- (.1'.1;') ',j !;~; 'II' ~--- \:.t
'J;' __,L 'tLI,I.,J -- '''', I!\' ,_ "'\V I.".., ".,. --
, "~,.""",, '. ','11 P. """,.., c,' ["'I""\J l I'
I " 1\ ~ .,.. , 'I -' j: " " 'I" I " . " "I' ,t.-.\ t I .! "," . ,"
~t rtt.'!':! _1;-": .11."1, '1' ", . II lit;!, _IN_-'':l~-'
''k)~.' r~tt\l::___\~',':; ~I}.';; i,-l ;;:"IL:'!{ti'v\G~'hi3~'
l~lrli~tj"iA'I!;r;I~:~f(:l~,~{I"I';?:(j, Ii "ii:' ''I !, ;<.,1,-" :~''--\;~l:-.I{'\\I/'}'{\I~I1~
'(1".':-0 ,-'i"',' "',I II I "I J' '1)1' ",
'\i,j'f{'il" :; ",,1.',,',':[ '1' 'i ' I h " fl I, IJf --
'll/iJ~-;;II\\; 'I,"; i".I':." ,/ i I ! ~,' /" ___,,i' HI 'f' Ij: '
~~,f~~',~N!:'\'~;.j,jli' j:'!'-~ II 1::1' '..'.""'.i'~;}".'I'~C'"
"
1'""
, II
I,
"
:,
"
,)
1 , ",
"
" I "
..
,I
,Ill ,'i
I
I
"
"
"i
, "
, "
" )1'
'I
"
'il
I,)
:\"
,
,
11-,1
,,'
,
"
"
;,1
,"
\,1
"
'I
';,1, ,'II Iii
I
II,
" '
I,
I
"
,I
,
I,
"
'\J, ,. I
,
" "
I , "
" , , , , "
I
"
" ~-.'J" I,i,
, , ' ' ~ I ',~
"
1\,
"r'I',
,
,
"
,
"
1'1 I
"
'J;
,
,
1',1
I'
Ii
"
,
1,'1,
,11'1'
"
"
,,'
'Ill" r"
II,
"
",j'"
,
,.1,:',
",
"
,
,
I'
, I
",,'
"
'ii"~
!,';
".,/"
,1'.":1'
,
"
"
I,
,
"
'r'rl)
,.1'1"
,1; 'I 'II
,\,' , '
,
:',
(.1
:;'i'"
"I
1\
/'
: ~ ""'i
",t di
{f' I
d
,;'1
,I,
',~ .','1' il
'II }I
I' ,
,
"I:
';1
',I
,'II'
'1,,':1
I>'
I.'
"
"
,,'
,
" '
"
,
\'1
"
";11", "
I'
iI'
1
,! '1\1'
,
.
..
~
MARGARET A. PATION,
PloIntilf
IN l1IE COllRT 011 COMMON PLEAS
CUMBrnuANDCOU~N,P^
NO. 4304 r:lVIL 1996
v,
BOB EVANS fARMS, INC.,
Defendants
'nmsPASS
INTERROGATORIES OF DEFENDANT,
UNDED UPON PLMNTlFF . ~U.l
Defendant. Bob Evans famu. Inc., by 1\1i IlLLOmcys. Mmh11ll 8. farrell, P.C., requests
PIBlntlff to BIlJlwer. under oath. the following 1l1Lerroglltoric5. In Ilccordance with Pa,R,C.P,
4003.1.4003.3, 4003.4, 4003,5. 4005, and 4006.
The following Interrogatories shall be BIlJlwered by you separately and fully In writing
and shall Include aU Infonnatlon known or available to the Plaintiff Including, but not limited
to, lnConnBtion known or BvaUBble to Plalmlffs attomcy, coll5ultw1t5, agents, servants, and
ameen.
Answen shall be signed by a duly authorized person on behalf of Plalntiff and shall be
served upon the pro(.Vlundlng Defendant wlthln thlrty (30) days after setvlce of the
Intenogatorles.
If the Infr.,nnatlon called for by an Interrogatory Is In whole or In part contained In
documents, the lnConnatlon may be supplied by attaching copies of the relevant documents
to your W15wel'5 to the Interrogatories to the extent that the documents contain the
Infonnatlon requested.
RECEIVED
SEP - 9 1996
LAW OFFICE
FOREST N, MVERS
1
,
.
,
JJEFINJTlO~~
A. The'tenn "documem" as used herein shull mean the original and any copy,
marked-up copy. revision, amendment, modlllcutlon, Ilon.ldentku) copy und/or dmft, of any
written, printed, typed. drown, or other gruphlc IllUller of any kind or naturll. however.
produced or reproduced, whether or not scnt or n:cc1vcd, Includln.g wilhoUl limitation:
memo ronda, reports, cOlllputllllons, CSthlll1lCS, communications, Ilnanclul rCJlorts or
statements, notes. tmnscrlpts, lellcrs, COlTcspondencc, hllm or IllIcr o(llcc
communications. envelopes, lclcgrams, cubics, tclcphonc Illcssugcs, Illcssages, summaries or
records of telephone convcrsmions, sUllllllurlcs or rcconls of personal conversations or
interviews. minutes, notes, notations, tabulations. studlcs. unulyses, reports. evulul1llons,
proJections. work papers, summmies. Joumals. stllllsllcal records, calendars, appolnullent
book~, diaries, plans, drawings. blue prlms, modulcs. specifications, datu, sketches, maps.
boring logs. 5011 tests. soUs chans. solis reports, sketch books, quamlty books, material books.
time log sheets, purchase orders, Invoices, checks, rcceipts, payroll records, SUnllllarles or
records of meetings or l'(mferences, minutes or tupe recordings of mcetlngs or conferences,
swnmarles or repons or Investigations, opinions or reports of consultams. questionnaires,
swvcys. charts. gmphs, books. notebooks, note chaltS, articles, magazines. newspapers,
booklets, circulars, bulletins, prcss releases, notlccs, Instructions. manuals, photographs,
schedules, network diagrams. bar. chalts , line-charts, motion picture IUm. mlcro/llms.
photographs, tapes or other recordings. punch card~, computer programs. magnetic tapes,
3
\
.
,
duo. data ceUs. dl'Ums. printout Imd other data compuunlolU frum which lnfomlatlon can bc
obtained, and mlll1llnal commcnll appcarinK on Imy documcnlB. Ilnd all othcr writlnssln thc
polIl!lllon. CUIItody or conll'Ol of Plaintiff or her ugcnlB, officers. employecs or uttomeY$,
D. "OClfendulll" meulU Bob Evans Fnmu. Inc..
C, "Person" or "Persolll" shall mean any IUltural Individual or corporation, finn.
partncrshlp, proprietorshIp. BSsodalion. joint velllure. govcrnmental entlly or llIlY other
buslneu or government ol1llllllzatlon,
D. "Meeting" shnll mellllllllY BSscmbly. convocutlon, encounter or colncldence of two
or more persolU for any purpose, whether or not planned, lIJTB/lged or scheduled In advance.
E, "Communlcation" shllll mellll llIlY utterance made, hwnllll speech heard,
overheard, or Intended to be heard by any purson, whether In person. by telephone, by
means of sound recording. or otherwise.
F. "Identify" means:
(8) When used In reference to a document. dl!lcribe wlth sufficient particularity to
fonn the bBSI.5 for a RequClit for Production under Pa,R.C,P. 4009. Including but not Umlted
to the date It WBS prepared or created. the Identity of Its author or originator, tile type of
document ~ letter. telegram. chart, photograph, sound recordlngs. etc,), the Identlty of Its
addressee. Its present location llIld the Identity of Its prClient custodlan(s). If such document
was, but Is no longer, In your possession or subject to your control, state what disposition
was made of It;
4
'.
"
"
5. EIlalpt BI let folth above, lilt me naml!l and addrellCll of Il11 penolU known or
bClllcved by PlalntUf or anyolUl actin8 on Iulr bClhelf to have ftnlhand knowledse of the
l:Ondlt:lons at me lalne of the lnddent elllltlns prior lO, at, or Immediately I'oUowlns the
Inddent,
AritiYIII
None
, ,
"
,
,
"
'! i I ~
I
,
.
'I!
, '
'I'
,
:,
, '
, ,
,
'I
,
\ II
i'
,d
,
,
10
...
, ,
, -
~
12, Do you c:urrently I1lcelvc lJ'llalmcllt or medication for the lJ\/urICl1 allegedly
IUlta1ned In th1Ilnddent? If 10, pleue IdentiCy the type of l1'eolment and/or medication_
AIUlUllI
Medical:ionl
l:akes Tylenol and Aspirin daily tor pain
, I
I'
,I
, ,
, I ,
I
, ,
, I
, ,
"
, ,
17
,
,I
"1
:;/
I
"
I,
,'1
"
,
"
) I
, I
II
i
,
,
Ii
I,
"
';..
,
"
\
"
I
'{> , 'I:
f "
,-.. j!
l,? - J
it;, "i"t: ,
I1f k~
...,h l .' ~ il
b:!, rt,! '!j
n'- ! ~~. , ,
~~li ~~ '.1
N ..!lw , ,
t-:-t'11 :>" 1.1 ~
I. " "'-1'
r, . -. "
"... d
~ ~ ,
"
'I
'I
,
II
I
)
,I
"
,
I ' ~ I
ql
\1 )
, ,
,
I
,
,
,
,
,
,
.
I
I
I