HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04435
"
, I I' : i I _ i J\:.J~i t,_ i. \ .. I
,I '!'_I ,_ ~ :i;i~I' \.\!~;<\I, ,\' :,- i j t. J i-'f '
/' ,,,,,,, "f"'!..'''''''''''' ',.":' I, ,d,.'
dl II '['-~'l \;] t :~ ' , :' I' )_,!',' 1,1 :Ii
,," 'I' ',I ' "'::;,-{>,.\,:;-"r:, -;~ -;
:, ' I,.;i/i"":,,;;,;,:.:':i.-"': ,I'
I I" ."," ....','" . i,', '1':, "",'
'" I',; .",'1,' ,I,,,, "
,\-,
,
,
./
':,1.!
I'
"
,
"
,
I.
,.
;1'
llI1I
" 'l
~'
..
.,'1
,"
,/
,
t!
.,r!
"
,
'PO
"~
11
~"
, '
,
,
,
"
I,
,
11\'
, '
I
I
v
Ii
l;;,I'
,
'I
,
,
..,
I:"
"
'"
,-I'
,
"
"
"
,
"
,
1'1 j
.1,
i
(
'"
:~
',-fl
I
," J.
,1,/,1'1
,
;-..
..
,'~
~
i'l
,
,
"
I
,
,
,1.',
0'\"
"
"
1"'1'
1:':
I
I] ;,1
,
d['l',--__.
, ,
il'l\
,,'J
il
';1
,
,
"
,',
1)1'
,
"
""1,1
! it';j
,
,
"
,-, i
II
"
"
d'l ."
, ,
I,.
"
1\
"
.,
I "
~, l)i J"
, 'I I"
I II i . 'I j, i ~-!
,
,I
q,
j',j 1;'1" I'
'"
,
;/1/
:/
I
"
"
'j.'!rl
, I
"
..'
II. I,
:,1'1,'
1>1'
i ,J. -
,," :
, I
"~,I
fl ~ I :, I ' I
J' I ',I
) j' ,I,
"
_"
n
I.
1
'1- f:-j
1 '."
.;,'I,i:
I' '
, ,;/:.1, i
11 ! 'j;
1'-
"j
,'d
I,
"
~ III
, I
'1)(" ,i
,
','Ii
"
','I
"
"
d ;i'
,
, ,If
,j.
:.1,
I\!
"
'1
I,
111'.1' !
II :'
"
'\-'
"
:!
.,
I' ,J"
,1'
,I
,
I
,"
:1:
I
"
iJ I
!, 'J!
(\,'"
Ii'
\
il'l
1/
I,
,
,,1- d
,
I,' ';!
!li;!;
'j' I,
I
(It!
'il.'
.,
,I!
,','/
"
I',
,1'1'1
IJ;
I.;j
"
:1.
1::1,
J,i I ~
"", 'I
If I
il
ii,
,
I"~
,
\)'1
!i
.,
,
,
1, '
;'
I:!
I::
"
I
"
.,
"
"
",.1. '1
,'1:\';'\ '
"
I
I'
j
.,
, I'
"
,
I
"
I.
I",
II,I!
.,
','
,
',I, '
, '
!I
_jJ
,
"
Ii') j!1
,
J'I,
"
'I'
, I
,I
"~I
;1
,
j \
i',
I'"
.,
/1..1" "
II". "
"
"
"
I"~
,
,
I
"
"
"
I,
"
"
"
Ii
,
,
I
,I'
,I !,
,
I
'\'1',;
I!'
11,'1
"
,
, '
J' ,'),1
H;
"
",'
'\ '
"
I,'
II
, .'
,
,.
, I'll
,
, "
,
III
I
,
"
,I
',il
"
If
"
"
"
,ii!
IIi
I
),] ,
"
I
i
"
;'-
,
"
-,'1'1
I
"
"
,
,'II
"
I,ll
,I
,I
!:
"
"
,Ii,'-,
I':
,
,
,
,
1,1\.:1,/
'"
I,
!i'
"f'I.I"
,
,
"1'
.,il
r
'iI',"
,
"
I,
II.,
"
,I,J
ii,
/1_1 '_I
, '
, "
,II I
, ,
,
"
, 'I
i,
,,1
I.
'I'
I
I.,'
,.
IJ
II,)
:1'
','I
, '
-J I,
"
I
I'
,
"
,
,I
,
"
"
"
"
, I'
',I
,
, '
I'"
,I
"
'i-,
,
,
'I
"
, '
"
, I
"
I,
I'
"
I'
'1\
"
"
I,
;,'1
" .
"
"
'!,
I
,
"
)1,;/IJI
I
"
I
I'
"
I,
.,
Ilpl
,1',
-\f:l:<:;"'.-,"';!' I
__: IH:!;~l;,;
"
'-:,
lil"\
.'
i
,( I
"
I:
I'l.
,I ,,'
,,/
Ii'
"
II
"
,
'I
I
1
I
.1
"
II)' I
II) ,
ii,
,.
,
1/1
II,'
,
II
,.1
,
"
,Ir! I',
I ~'I I
,I
"
;) I, 'I"
,
,;1"
,.
, ,
L i .
I
"I'
;'" , I
)': /l-r
'r!' ;'
!
Ilf\:
1 I;
1./.
I 'Ii,
1"!\ I
',I "Ifl
~ I"" (,1
I ',!~ j' ! /1
,ilil'l't
! ('
Ji'
"'I'
,I
,
1 .,
,1':,1
, "
, ,
,
'n I
P I
1 '!' ,.
'jL
, ,
,',
,.'1,1((
ie'
',III'
: '_I, ~ 1
J-"
I.
, ,f; - ~ I
.,
,
" /1
j,
'I 'j
',,',Ii L
,
"
ii
/,
I
I,,!
" ,
'i/-! -:'d II
, I!'
l'iI _ :/
, "",\","!\
" ;1.'1" I
i)" _-d (j ,~!, ! i'
I' "
'," j JI:'!-'
J.' .,,' 'llj::qll';I.,
II' ]'.1 . i-'i"'"
,Ill ' ! I Ii: j' ::1) ~; 1_,
/'.il' ( ; -, -,
j -; i , I ,- , )! j ~ 1 !
I'l.-I'
JI 'I,
"
,
, I
.i(l:
!L'I
, ,
-,','
Iii'
!'
j,j' ,
'II)
'ill.
'1' ",jl
I.r "qi,
<,
i.:(f:
I'
111-,' )'/
"
d
.,
'1,'(;
, '
,
I"
'Ii' I'
I,li:' ,1'1:
-'L ;r"
:i I"i_
, !/ JI
, '.
'/1'
I,
"
,J,I
'_dn'-l'
,-, ,
I/;
"
"
'-(,,'
I,' .
'"I,
,
,:1
"
('
:1,',
"
.1
; il
.1
"
I' ,
,
,"I'
,
I
"
,
t-'
, f,l '
;lj, ,11.1,
, II ;:':' 'fil
(1)
,
jl
,
Y I,
,
1',1
,
'.-1
'I: III; ,I /j
,11.'''1
l'
)' ,i_,
ill;,'!-'
'1'1
!"
I
,I,I!
.1
, ,
'1\')'
U'I,i
'I
iI'l
I
I,'
, "
1;"/
.,
I, I.
"
:'.
\' 1'- 1_'
.l;j[
,
I"" 1
"11 1
r: \ ,
j
"
['
'"
"I,'
"
\Jj'll
."
,1-'
.,
!'Ii';
""j" i,t
,.1..
,'!I\
'"
"
,
,',
'1,- L
pI!
'J:'
d'
,
.1
I-I
"Ill, J
.')i"" "I,
I
.'
,
,I
d'
, ,
"
','ii
I
"
;1
'!,
:,
"
I, "
';I i 1:1 q "
.;/ ,I",""
,I t'
I-H I\,
, I !Il'
'{'!,_ 'II;,'
,.!I"i" ,-,',
II ,II i I;,
,
, .
II' t"f:' I
,J, I') -I,J" ,
,,' \-',:1
"
"
,
1,:11
!r
,
,
,
.,')
"
'I
'\f
:,' ""I
" ,,-1
, _JIII1
l'li;; 'J
"1,' 'I
'I
"
',J
,
11
,
,I
.IJ,.'
!
"
I
;
,
, '
" ,
I il
I,
,,"',
"
I-i,"
Ij'li
i,
II-i
\ I
"'!'(
,
" ,
'I"
'I'
,I, '
'I)'
"
.,
,,'
:1,
,
/1' I
" If, I I
,I,.', 1/-\ 1
'1-1' : 1 - , - I, i ~ I ' I,'
"ll,'1 I",
, ,
,
"
,.'1' ,
,r.,
:'i,J,
,
I'
!I,tl
,
I,:
.,
I,
I
, '
"
'I
I
,
,r. If!, _, ;;:
\. ,\'
,,'
;)iI
'r !
,
'Ii
p,'
"
,I',i'
,I
'rd,
I.li
.' ,
''i!
jl ,-_I itf
,I q H j'l
I . 1- -I"
., '/_,/1(".'1 hI
,I _ I, q ~i ~. \1 I)~!'";'
'\)' ',; 'I',-Ifl,
I"
"
,
"
I, "
"
,
"
"
1",.;1
, \ - ., Ix ~ ~,I
, 'I
.,
,
,
"
iii' 'iI
iI '
.'1,_(, I
"
'III'
~ i '!
.,
I,'
/1
"
!
'I'
.,-,'11,,)
,',.1' '1 \
'1"_\"1:
I,
,
,
"
,;l
,
\ I , '(,\f'
I'l'" ,-}
'I"f'
~ ,JI, _ j
, '"~I
,I I ,~_I!'~"
, 111'1
r'J:,_t
( 'l'~
',)
Ir ,'r',
,(f.
'ij
"
:,
"
'/
"
;'1
'il
\1,',1
:,1 J'
, "
"
Jr' ".
I,"'!
I,'
tl!
.1
,"
"
{I,
,
I,ll
;-J
tJI't
,
11'1.'lt
"I_I}' ':1
'( "I
'"
"
/(
,
,
"
"
,
"
, I;
"
,.\
"1-'/'
'I'i
"I,
.'
'11_,!
,
d'\
rli
",
"~I
,I
,
"/_!
.i'
,
~ I I ~
li!il
"
...
i,-
/I' ,q
"
,Iii-'
'1'11
:il';':'
,'I';lt.'
,I. !1'),:!!I'
,,' ,,_I,!'"
'., :;l'I~)'j\;(t
II "..
"
1 !'
.i:(1
.1
'-' ,
'JI
H'
,
I;'
'1''1
"
,
:,
, ,
, ,
",
'I,
,1,1
9. Thl,/ IlufulILJanl IN un ullUllud narrlllkN uhuNl,/r h)' hl,/arNu)' InfornlUllon,
10, Thl,/ PluhllllT dnuN rurllllnl~1J crlmlnul Informullon h)' thl! fllrl!MohlK
wllhout prujudll'\!,
11. Thl! f(ll111WlllM url'usutlclflN urll Nlulldl!rOllN hy nulurl!.
12, Thl! Plulntlff IN u o'lmlllul without Ilrdul' III nJu thl! rUNllluthm In nvu
yeurs.
13.
14.
Yl!urs,
15.
16,
Thl! Plulntlff dOUN not rUNldll ut South WUNt Struul,
The Plulntlff IN lIot cIJl1\'I,.tl!d of u vlohmt rrlmu wilhln thl! IUllt nvu
Nun'lllll'N IN un INNUll,
Till! Plulntlff IN not Involved III thl! lIouNlnll Authorlt)' und IN Ul'CUNUd
without prejudlclI,
17, Thl! Plulntlff hUN nllltrlbuled mlmll!N to thl! purty In dlNputu without
preJudice.
18. Thl,! l.)uflJndulll dIH!N not pruNllnl un ISNuu thutl~ prorueded In responNeto
the foregolllll,
19, The Defendunt docs not suggeM thut thlJ Plutntlff flll out lln llppllcatlon,
:W, Thl,! Defundllllt does not require monleN,
21. The Oefenduntl~ not dl~ubll!d,
22. Thl! Defendllllt Clin ullow u reNolutlon upon vlNltutlon llnd the outcome of
the relutlollNhlp cOllcernlng the purt)' Involved,
23, The Defendllllt Is dlscrtmlnullnll with prejudice.
24. Thl! Defendunl doeN not ucknowllJdge the llliNoclute of the afore,
25, She Is follOWing u codl! of ethlc'N whhout ucknowledguml!nt to the fuets
In dlNpute,
26,
27,
follOWing.
28.
Shl,! hus not Investlgutud the criminal mutter,
She hus mude u requlslle for un)' InNthutlon ouulde of lluthorlty to the
She IN slunderous and prlljudku,
2'). Shll hu~ Ilunll/d Ihu I'luhllllT ~J1udlkull)' rCNldhlK In U ru~ldllll~U hll dl)Lt~
ne)I,
30, Shll I~ 1101 wllhoul prc::ludkll UIIJ ~llllkN rlllrlbullelll le) Ull IIYOIlI of lion-
IIlKhhnul1l J1urpo~ll for f1l1undul Kulll,
31. She ~<lllkN no l'Olll'<lrll for UII)' of Ih<l purtl<lN hwoIY<ld.
32, Sh<l hu~ no rllllllzullolI 1'01' Ih<l uUlhorll)' of or Ih<l fUl'u ul hUlld.
33. Thll I'lulllllff I~ wllhout uUlhorll)' to Ihll 6uperdlldhlK 1~6u<l5.
34. WIlr:lWFOIW Ihu I'lulnllff Cl1l'>' CormulI)' 6euk~ ~olllpletu ru~e)lutlon frolll
prujudlcll u.nd dl6crlmlnulloII,
3~. WIlf:l~EFolU: thu Plulllllff Cor)' COl'llluny 611Uk5 Ten Thousund PoiluI'!
(IO.OOO,QO) for uccuNullon elf ~IUllmlUIII wllhout pruludkll,
36. WHElH:FOIU: he UCCU~Il~ Ihe followlnlll
pENNSYI.VANIA CRIMES COQL;
CIUMINAL SOI.lCITATION 902
37, The Pefundant wu~ Inyolved In heul'5uy IlIforma.tloll.
38, The Ph>.llltlff hu~ nllver Indullled In Illegal nurcotlc:s.
,19, The Plwntlff I~ u criminal by filII after the statutory Issue.
40, Thll Plaintiff has rllCOllnl1.ed probuble c:ause by reslsta.nce for the
c:rlmlnal 156ue.
41, The Defendant Is not Informatlvll,
42, The Defendant I~ not authorhatlve.
43, The Dllfllndant 16 prejudiced,
44. The muttllrs at hand are pursonal to the Issue Involyed.
45, The matter at hand Is criminal from the foregoing and hereafter.
46, The mattllr Is not factuw,
47, The matter Is new for the r.omph>.lnt In c:ommon,
48. The matter Is discriminatory.
"
YI1RIIlICATION
I
'i
,
rill
I, COl')' Conlll1ny, Plulnll'-f In Ihu ubllYU cupllollUd UCII'lIl, huruby Yurtfy und NIUlu Ihul
Iha fllCu NIlI forlh In lhu Cllmpluhll Ulluhul KUlhy Lun~flJrd uru Iruu ulld cl.'lrruCI 10
lhe bllll of illY Inforrnull'lIl, knowludllu, und bulluf, I undur5lunrJ Ihul fl1lNu Ul1tcmlunlN
herein nre Illude 5ubjl!Cl III lhl! pUlll1hll!5 of III Pu, C.S.A. Seclloll 4'J04 rulullnll III
Un5WOrrl yerllkullon 10 uUlhorlllen.
....,0 d" "* c;) I "I'll. "
I,
"
"
"
I'
, ,
I \
, ,
"072"
IR.. 8/821
~,~~ c.
IN THE lJNITltp STAnS DISTRICT C:OtTR'r
FOR THE MIDDLE pIS'rIHCT OF PltmrmNANIA
I
,
I
CV.IIS.08H
,
CORY A. CORMANY,
Pldnt.l.U
,axvn. ACITXON NO. 2. I
v.
FILeD
HAI:lI:lII:lP'III:l~ ,,^
APR 2:1, 199b
UI~t:iI\, ~~I:flK
Y "
KARIN rXNJtINBXNPIR, aJ& aL.,
Oehndantl
o It D II ,
Before the court is a l:'llport of thll magistratlil judglil
reconlmending that thlil complair.t in the captioned action be
dismissed for failurlil to file an amended complaint and for failure
to comply with an order uf the court, No objections havIiI been
filed, Therefore, upon independent revillw of the entire record
the applicable law, IT IS HEREBY ORDERED THAT I
1) The court adopts in full the report and
recommendation of Magistrate Judge Blewitt,
2) The captioned action is dismissed for failure to fil~
and:
I
I
an alnendl!d complaint and pursuant to Federal Rule of Civil
Procedure 41 (bl for failure to comply with a court order,
3) It is certified that any appeal from this order will
be deemed frivolous and not taken in good faith,
,,) The Clerk of Court shall clollle the file,
Dated, April ~~, 1996,
H. RAMBO, Chief Judge
Diatrict of Pennsylvania
1 '
,I'
,. ,~ ~
.
I~
C'II f':; \\ ~
.,.
,
.. ",' ~
r ...
1.,< _. "i
:,... ' '
r. "": " r \
h) 1,1,) ',t\ ~
,.,
Ij" , ;t,yj
..!~ r ~~
., Id~
<+.. lJ ... 1.11
I~ ~ d
..
.,1
I
,
"
.
, '
,!
"
,.
'I
jl,
I'
,
CORY A, CORMANY,
Pldntiff
v
IN 'l'IlB COUl\'l' OF COMMON PLBAS OF
CUMIlIH\LIINP Cl)UN'I'Y, PBNNSYLVANIA
NO. 96-4435 CIVIL TBnM
CIVIL I\CTION - LI\W
Juny TRIAL OBMANOBO
KATllY ,"UNSII'ORO,
Defendant
HOTICI
TOI
Oory A. Cormany
1883 00u91al Drive
Cllrlillul pA 17013
I.
are hereby notified to file a written relponle tal
Preliminary Objection I Leok of Pereonal Juriediotion, and
Preliminary objeotionl Attaoking Servioe of Complaint, of the
You
II.
enoloead Preliminary Objeotione
eervioe hereof or judgment may be
wJ.thin twenty
(20 )
daye from
en t;P-
/
./':
//)
r etop er C. Houston, Bequ re
Attorney for Defendant
Broujos, Gilr.oy & Houeton, P,C.
4 North Hanover Struat
Carlisle, PI\ 17013
717 - 243-4574
Oatel
fl/rf;f
conncnv,po
CORY A. CORMANYt
J'lainl:.ut
v
IN '1'IIB COURT 01" COHtolON Pl-BAS Oil'
CUHBBRl-I\NO COUN~Y' PBNNSYl-VANIA
NO. 96-4435 CIVIl, 'l'BnM
KATHY l-UNSFORD,
Dehndant
CIVIl. AC'I'ION '. LI\W
JUllY 'l'JUAr, PEMIINI.llm
I!BILDWfARY OBJIC.UOJfJ-.!2l"..Jl1lJIfDAHl'
AltO NOW, oomell the Oefend"n!:, Kathy LUllutol:d, who tileu the within
Preliminary Objeotions.
I. PRILIMINARY OBJECl'lONI LACK-Q[ VIRSONAL JURISDICTION
1
The Detendnnt, Kathy Lunlltord, irJ a resident ot Cumberland County,
penneylvania.
2
The Complaint in the above-oaptioned matter wall filed on Auguet 6,
1996.
3
Pa.R.C.P. 402(a) provides that original prooess is to be lerved by
personal servioe.
4
Attaohed to the Complaint is a Certifioate of Servioe ligned by the
Plaintiff indicating that the Complaint Wal lerved upon the
Oefendant by United statee mail.
5
By leparate Affidavit filed in oonjunction with these J'reliminary
Objections, the Defendant affirml that a Complaint was served upon
"
I
j ~
jl
"
the Vefendant by oertified InAil on or about Augu.t 7, 1996, in
violation of the Penn.ylvania nule. of Civil Procedure.
WH2RBFons, th$ Oefendant reque.ta thi. Honorable Court to enter
jUdgment in hvor of thlt Oefendllnt and againllt the Plaintiff
beoaulle thl.1I Court lIlokll jud.adiotion over the penon of the
Defendant,
II . l.8II.lH~1QN I ATTACKING lII:l\VICI or COMPLAINT
6
Paragraph 1 thr.ough 5 of the.e Pr.uliminary Objeotionll an
inoorporated herein a. if aet forth in their entirety.
7
The .ervioe made upon the Defendant i. in violation of Pa.R,C.P.
402.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requltBt. thi. Court to ent$r jUdgment in
favor of the Defendant and againBt the Pl.aintiff, in that Plaintiff
improperly .erved Defendant.
III. P~LIMINARY OBJECTION I MOTION ~2-BTRIKI. rAILURI
or PLEADING TO CONr08tiL~ LAW OR RULE or C9YRl
B
Plaintiff'. Complaint iB oumberBome and unintelligible I in
violation of Pa.n.C.P. 1019(a).
9
The Complaint failB to comply with Pa.R.C.P.. 1020(al in .etting
forth what appear to be oau.eB of aotion for defamation of
14
Plaintil! f I I pleAding fdb to ut fo/:th . oau.. of aotion upon
whioh /:81i.f oan bl g/:anted fo/: an lotion in defamation, for th.
following /:ealonll
A. Plaintiff'. pleading faill to aVI/: th. defamatory cha/:aotu/: of
any communioation,
B. Plaintiff fail. to aV8/: any publication of any defamato/:y
oommunioation,
c. Plaintiff tail. to aV8/: the applicaHon of any defamatory
communication to the Plaintiff,
D. Plaintiff hill to aver any third party'. undentanding of the
communication'. defamatory character and of it. applioation to the
Plaintiff, and
E. Plaintiff fails to aver any injuries suffe/:ed by the Plaintiff
as the result of any defamatory communication.
15
Plaintiff's pleading f4il. to set forth a caule of aotion upon
which relief can be granted for an aotion of dilor.imination,
WHERBFORE, Defendant reql)ests that judgment be entered in favor of
the D~fendant and again.t the Plaint\ff for failure of Plaintiff to
let fo/:th a caule of aotion or claim upon whioh relief oan be
granted.
CORY A. CORMANY,
PlllintUt
v
I IN THB COURT OF COMMON P~HA8 OF
I CUMIlBIlLAND COUNTY, PBNNBY~VANXA
I
I NO. 96-4435 CIVI~ TBRM
I
J CIVI~ ACTION - LAW
I
, Juny TnIAL DEMANDED
KATlfY LUNSFORO,
Dehndant
ArrIDA.VIT
I, Kathy Lunsford, of 114 North Hanover Street, Carli.le,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, the above-named Defendant, Itate
the following,
1. I am a re.ident of Cumberland County, Pennsylvania,
2. On or about August 7, 1996, I reoeived by oertified mail,
return reoeipt requested, the Complaint filed by the Plaintiff in
the above-oaptioned matter.
3. Prior to the afore.aid date, no Complaint has been served upon
me by personal servioe or by mail.
);i'f/u ./ ~c1
KATH'i Lu~rOR~ ( If ~
COMMONWBALTH OF PBNNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBBRLANO
,
, es
,
~JI L1 ~
On thie, the J- day of rr1..t,!iUJ' , 1996, before mel the
undersigned of oer, pereonally ~ppe4red Kathy Lunsford, known to
me (or satisfaotorily proven) to be the person who",e nAllle is
subBoribed to the with!,n inBtrument, and aoknowledged that she
exeouted the Bame for the purpOBe therein oontained.
IN WITNBSS WHEREOF, I have hereunto Bet my hand and notarial seal.
'-f.d. h 0.... J \~ ~~....
~blio
I'lllm,,'1 '~IH11
I<nrml r IIYI!l:'.. NGlnry Publlo
r:n';I~.LI) HlHll. '_:111';. 1,;r(,lI'd COlJnry
11,. i ,I' III :IF.I'~n I 111-' rl'.11(1110, IOf!)
L
" t: , ,
ut i':':
r~ ..'
& 'I
r ) ~G
"If :t -,~ ,~,
!J.t I'
,
IJ')
11 ': ~.
~II tfi !;
~c
~ ' U~ iJ
I';
" ,
I,
'I
I):
'., j
I'
, ,
"
I
I I'
'I.
,
,I
,I
,
,
,
,
"
I
,
,
,
,
I
"
,
{I
I
"
, I
I I
,
I
,
,
"
, '
1'J,AfN'I'1Jl11
GollY A, l:OIWANY
11'1'1'11 UGOllllT (W COMMON I'Ll Wi OJl
c;UMIIUlUANIl COUNTY, I'IiNNIiYI,VANJ^
V.
(:lVII. 'I'l1ltM
m~illNDANT .
KATHY l.UN/woltO.
CIVIL NUM\J~lt 1)6-4435
, ,
./lJllY 'J'IUA1,
MOTION ':()R IUlX,MllN'I'ONT1IL1PU1ADlNGS
AND NOW, romes I'lullllll'f, Cory A. Cormuny, who resperlfully submits the
Molton for Judgment on Ihe Pleadings und 11)1:1 respOllse wllh urgumenl, This Is
pursuant 10 I'.S,A, ltule 1034 and Itule 40llt,C,I'. The following Is of ('oune fIll' the
aCllon.
I. I'IUil.lMINMY OUJECTION IN TilE NATlJlW OF CIUMI1
1. The Oefendant Kalhy Lunsford acknowledges the criminal Issue with
demUI'rer.
a. The defendanl has not been uccused of Ii rrlme except for the
circumstance providing the Inslunt complalnl,
b. I The llllegatlon pursuant the I'ennsylvanla Crimes Code docs not violate
JlI.t\IN'IWII
COI\V ^' COIlMt\NV
IN Tllll(;OlJl\T ()II (;OMMON l'I,I!t\H (>I'
CLlMllUlUANLJ COLlN'I'V, 1'1INNSVI,Vt\NIA
v,
CIVil, 'l'lll\M
m~ll!Nl>,wI'
KA'l'lIVl.UNljI1OI\JJ.
eN". NLlMlllll\ ~)(1."435
'JlJl\V TIMI,
1l11l11ll1N SlJI'I'OIl'I' ()II TI1Il1'IAIN'I'lJlI1'/l MOTioN )lOI\ IULXIMUN'I' ON 'l'1IL1IILllAPINOS
I
I. JlltOCI!DUIlJ\L llls'J'OltY/Ft\GTUt\I. /lTATL!MllNT
I
In or Ilboulthe month of t\UKu~t, of the )'ellr 1996, on or Ilboutthe 7th dl1)', lhe
I'll1Imlff Cor)' t\. Gormlln)' did file thl! cumpllllnt Ilbove cllptloned. Tbe servka Is In
recognition following thl! subml~slun theralo. The Defendllnt Klllh)' Lunsford hili
followed wilh the rl!sponSl! Ilnd her IlUurnl!)'. The mOllon herein follows the l1ctlon
I1/1d the relllon for Ihl! Illlernllllve.
~
/1
, ,
II. clJ,miTIONlIl'llIfiIlN'I'Il11 FClIt 11lrvthW
"
I. POIII thll civil nlllllur Involvu lhu l'rlmlnllllllUII7
2. lJo1l1 thu crhnlnull..uu connhUlll u vlolutlon llf lhll civil procllduro7'
"
3.
nOli. lhu civil prol'utlurll nluku u vloluUnn7
4. bOils lhlll15lulI of Illrt mllkl! u vurlllUllll for thll civil mlluer7
5. Is lhurll nol un u"('lIpllon tel lhll civil pro('udurl! conclIrnlnB the
c:rlmlnul nlUller?
6. Cll/1lhlljudllmenl ortlor bu followcd u. a rcason?
7. Is thll CUUHfl of ucUon madll III be dl5ruPllvu the PIBlnUfn
,
"
III, AIUILJMliNT
A, l.ul'k or PllrHonul IUl'IHd\l'lIon
lillhlbllll doeH l1urHull Ihll Cerlllklllll or Sllrvll'll rolll/wlllK Ihe Pu, ltC, I', 411;t(u),
II I" notlld 10 bll IIIrlhllllhl1l u 111'0 Hll 1IIIIlUlhlll I'or thll 1'UI'11OHll 01' rllvlllW ulld I"
110rllnllllt '" lhll IIPl1oHltloll, C;o II 11 1<'1 01' IntllreM I'ould hit ulld IH ImporlulIl leI Ihu IHHue,
Pu, II,C,I', ;tll') In 11UI'II (,,,111 whldl UVlllI1 ull UVlJrmlllllH 01' I'ul'l rUHl10nHlvll III Ihe
l111tltloll und I1ro\lurly I1IUUIIlJd III Ihu UIIHWIlJ' Nhull hlJ dUllmud udmllllld I'IW thll pllrl10Nll
01' Ihu rulu,l, Fur l1ullllolIlll' 10 he rUljulrlld 10 Iuku dlll1oNlllon Ill' IWdUl' Ihe l'UlIie I'llI'
urllunllmt Oil l1ulllloll In 11l1un dlll'lIull judllJ1lunl thuru mUHl u"INI dlHI1Ulud rUI'luul
IHNuei, lllnurdo v, Cllntrull'ulln AII' SllrvkeH1 Inl'" 51 II A,;td II K7, SUl1cr, 1')lIfJ,
WIWllEl'OIll!, Ihu 1'1111111"'1' rllHl1el'lrully reljuuNIH Ihut Ihe I>>ollull bll Ill'lllllud fur
thll purl1llHll ul' rllllllr,
II, Attul'kh11l Survke of Coml1hlllll
Thll vlohlllon of thl! rule I1rllHUlbed IN wllh Ihu ul....,rdul1l'Uul' thu Po, 11,(;,1', 40;t,
IlIduHtrlul duvulopJ1lulll uUlhorlllus wuru nol "spudul l'o,"mlsslons." lIuHuhoru v.
lIull1pdcll InduHlrlul llevulllpmenl AUlhllrhYI :l,.1I A,;td :ll:l, 4;i;1 Pu, 40, I %K, Tho
upplll'utlun rUllllWH the rulu ulld IH eljul\lulelll lu the 4:l I'u, Ite,l', HI), ruspcl'll'ully
Implyltlll und ul'knowledlllllllllullllN v, Illlylu, rd7 A.:ld (dO, 4,11 PII, Super, rlorl, Super,
11)1)4, I'ruJudkc IH Hili rorth III Ihu l'ompluhll I'llI' Ihe reuson relcvullt Ihc cxhlbllS, thc
vlolutloll or thu rulc would dkllllu u dlHmlmll purHuullt I'u, H.C,I', IO!'), CUnlplulnt
HCIIIIlIl rorth l'UUHU llf Ul'tllln 1'01' dvll l'llIlHplrul'y mUHt IIllullu muturlul rUI'IN whkh
will clthcr dlrcl'lly llr Inrcrcnllully eHlubllHh elumclllH or l'lHlsplrUI'y, CUNncr v,
Amerlrull Fedcrullonllr SlllIe, Counly ulld MUllldpull:mployeeH, ()511 A,:ld 1165, Cmwhh,
11)1)5, Thu rCI'ollnlllol1 rur Ihe llppOHlIlllll 10 Htrlku Ihc I'rullmlllury ObJecllon, Iuhclud I
und II, In whole IH l'ompllmcnled wllh Ihu lIuhuncHc v, l.ullor, 41;t A,;td 1111 (I'u,
Commw, 1(1110) und Is Icfl 1'01' Ihul dlHl'l'utlon l'olll'urllllllllrlul,
, '
WIII!Illil'Oltl:, Ihll I'lullIlII'I' 1'1ISpUl'II'IlII>' Mlllusls Ihul Ihl! 11l11llon hll IlI'UIIlIILl rill'
IhlJ l,urlll/HlI or 1'lIl1ul',
(;, Mlllllln III Sll'lkll, I '"II Il I'll Ill' I'lu'ldlnlllo 1'I1111'1l1'l1l III lull' 01' I'ulu or CIIUI'l,
lhu I'lIl'luul Issllu prl!suntud Is dullbl!l'IlIc III Ihu Ill!I'cIIHl!, Thu IHHUC III' Pl'uJudkll
UllullI urlsuH 1'01' Ihu IIhll!L'l III' dl!fUlI1utlll')' HllItl!l11ullt, hOWl!VUI', IH Huhjul'1 IUllullly,
l'urSUUl1tl1l I'u, ItC.l', 101') It IH, III bl!HI, thl! INNUl! IlIvlIlwdlhl! ClIlI1plllhlllll1ll hUH IlllI
hcclI uddl'l!HNl!d hy thl! Ill!rcI1Nl! fill' Ihl! plll'pllNl! 'If I'l!NP'IIIHl!, Thu rllll1pllllnt IN Hhlll'l,
rlll1l'iSl! 'llld fill' 1'l!IIMlIl tll I'l!Npllnd, IllIhl!Ill!Nl! \, I.UIl'I" 11H1)' 11111 'II" IIH1Y Ilpply hut IH
l'Ul11hC,.NIII11l! \II thl! ISHt,ll! III h,lI", ^ pklldlllllll1llSI hl! ,\Illlkil!ntly NJll!"lIk III 01111111' Ihl!
l)c/unlJ.lIl1 tll pl'CpUI'C 1111 IIPJll'lIpI'IIlll! I'l!SllllIlNl!, I.lllll'NCI1 v, (il!lll!nll II IINJlI llIl III'
MOllnll! CIIUl1ly, I.S') 1"1, SUJll!l'. I SO, IS'), ,i'J.i ^,Ld 7111, 71111 (1')71\), Thl! I)crcI1HU'H
rCl'Olll1llloll fill' dl!hlllllllloll Nl!ts flll'lh 1'11"1 1'01' thl! Il1tdlllll!Il"l! III' Ihl! 1I1l11tl!I', Cl'lInllHlI
S"IIl'iHllloll Nll11ply IN IId':l1l1l1'll!dlll!c1 for thl! IHHul! UI hlllld pl!1'l1111l1111l ;tHIIIIl III Ihu
l!xhlhitH, Thl! \'111111111111 III' Ihl! I'll, 1l,C,I', Il)tll IH Ilot \'ulltI fill' Illll 1'l!IISlIn tll l'iIJII11 UI1U
JOl!N full Ihl! ISHIll!, Thl! ahl!l'Ililll\'l! Is 1I1lldu II\'lIl1llhll! CIIllL'l!1'I111l1l II1110UIlts (lIlclIlHUU
IIl1d l11usl hu l'III1Hldl!nIlC lhl! Imrl)' 11l\'lIlvl!d,
WIII:IlIHlIlI:, thl! 1'IIIII1tlIT I'l!spcl'lfully l'l!4UuHtH tlllll lhu MOII'lIl hc IlI'UllIUU rill'
Ihe pUI'J10Sl! of 1'l!lIl!1',
I), Dl!l11url'l!r (fullure \l) SllItl! nIUSl! or union),
In Ihl! l1l!fl!lIsl!'S I'rl!lImll1ury OhJel'lloll luhell!d IV, Ihl! I)ul'ullsu UOCH IlIdudc 0
vurlous lIumhl!r of l'l!USOIIS pl!l'lllll1hlll to Ihl! l'\IUSl! of llCllolI, ullof which upply III Ihe
ohJel'lloll III wholl! 11I1d would Sl!l!m to l'olltrudle'\' hll" l!xlIl11J1Il!: tOJ11c ^ IlIduduH Ihe
ISSUl! or dl!l'u/Ilutory dHll'llrtl!1' which Is 1I,'kullwluullUd 111 11ll! I'rclll11ll1ul'Y OhJCCllolI
labeleu III, Thu \oJ1le's II, C UIlU 11 1111 I'ellerut(! the cuusu of urllOIl UIIUllrl! uJ1plluullI
Ihe l'ompluhll for Ihl! "uSUIlU of rl!spol1se". Thl! I~xhlhll sll(lwd hy thl! l)efundulIl Is lhe
IIhllll'l r'JI' Ihl! l'lIlllplulrll ul1c1l~ clll'l!l'Il!cI rill' IhuI pUl'pll~l!, Thu lllpk luhl!lucl I: wlluld
11111'11111'1 lhl! ull!Illl!1ll Illduclucl, Kl!lIu>, I, 111.'111 1I111'1Il ;loI'I, !II II I'u, !l17, !I,H ^,;.!d 'I.jO
(1'11111), Yl!1 I~ pl'uluclkl! UI1c1WIIUlcl 1'11111111' ~1'111c1l!1' Ullcl/1I1' pul1ll<' IIUllllllulllI1l rill' Ihl!
IIhjUl'1 III' cll~ITIrJlIIlUIIIlI1 pUI'~I"ll1l I'll, II.C,I', J.l)'l, llll~ "lIulcI [1l'lIvlclu I'l!U~1I1l hi dullll
1.'1I11"Ul'l1ltll1 Ull\l)unl~ Inducll!c1, llll! IlHllll!1' III' SlIlklllllllll1 111111111 1I1'1~l!~, Tltl! I'ulu 1001,
UIl l!lllplllyul! Ill' 11 IlI...l\ [1l1l1ll...11 'iul1c1I\'I~llIl1 ...111 lInl)' hl! hl!I" lIuhll! wl1ul'l! II I~
judldully "ull!l'Illllll!cl Ihlll UI1 ,h'l lIl' lIlIIl~~llIn lIf llll! l!lIIpl'I)'l!l! ,'ol1~lllllll!cI "II lTIIIll!,
ul'\uul rI'UU", Ul'IUIIllllIllIl'l! lIl' wllll'uIII1IM'llllLlurl," Snlll \" WIIII~, 11111'11, CIIIllIllW, .il7,
!I.j,i ^,l" 1 h!l (I'JliIl), Thl! 1~~Ul! nll1lltllJl!~ IIl1hllll)' tltl! I ldl!llLhlnl I'llI' Ihl! pUl'pll~l!I)I' Ihl!
l'lIlllplullll, lhl~ I~ [1llnlnl!1l1 cld'ul1HllllIn l'lIll"l!rnlllll 1111 1~~Ul! 01' llllllJlIl)11I11 cll~\J'U8S
whlrh Is l'III1~l!qlll!llll)' 11111 1lll!lllllll1l!11111 thl! In~11I111 l'lIlIIplulnl,
Till! 1~~Ul! l'lIlll'l!l'I1ll1l1lhu'l!1I1 \, llilnhd, :lI1 ^,lcl II, :lO~ I'u, Supur, 4.j;,!, 1'lCl!l1
Sl1rUIIUe v, bl~lwlIlIcllleult)' ClI" !I.lll, & C, 2c1,j.jO, 11'11'.1../. ,i'll, 1'171 II1USI, Ullulll bll
l'Ul'lllll1lzecl I'llI' Ihe UPl1llrulllIll rdl!\'11111 tllillllhJl!l'l,
WIIl:IU:l'ClIU:, the I'lultllllT re~pel'lI'ully rU'luuMs Ihe MOllon bll Ilru.nLurJ 1'01' Illu
purpll8u or relief.
I
,
,
,
~ vI : ~. !I
r" \0. "
"r ..,
l'l" j,f,
1:.1, ," ,
:,1
. . ',;1\
'-..1' 'II,
" ,
~n ' ,rj i,
L ~. 11.1
II tl 'J
i"~'l
I ',il'.. " , ,
I,'. H~ ,,'
I...J Ul d
"
" II
"
I,
1
1
"
. ,
I,
I,
, ,
"
;1
'i
"
"
I'
"
cO~Y A. CORMANY I
Plaintiff
I IN TIlB COUR'r or COMMON PLBAS or
I OUHBII\LAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVI\NIA
I
I NO. 96-4435 CIVIL TeRM
I
I JURY TRIAL DBHANDBD
I
v
KATHY LUNSfORD,
Defendant
ORDIR
AltD HOW, this .?Jw ~ day of Sept:ember, 1996, upon
oonsideration of a Motion to Enter Default Judgment Again.1:
Plaintiff, a Rule ie i..ued upon the Plaintiff to .how oau.. if any
there be why the relief ruque.l:Iad in thh Motion Ihould nQt b.
granted.
Rule returnable ~ from lervice.
)
'/
, ,
J.
i,
, <
~. I
,
,
I,
I
4
Said Preliminary Objeotion. were mailed to the Plaintiff on Augult
l~, 1996, being the date of lervioe in aooordanoe with Pa.R.C.P.
440(b), with laid lervioe being certified purluant to an Affidavit
of Servioe attached to t.he l'reliminary Objectionll of the Defendant.
5
On September. 5, 1996, Defendant mailed a Notice of Intention to
Enter Dafault Judgment to the l'laintiff. A copy of .aid notioe i.
attached hereto and incorporated herein.
G
The underlligned certitiel that the written notice of intention to
enter dlBfault judgment wae mailed to the Plaintiff at leut 10 day.
prior to the date of the filing of thi, Motion.
7
On or about September 16, 1996, the Defendant and counlel for the
Defendant received by mail a document entitled "Motion for JUdgment
on the Pleadings" from the Plaintiff.
8
said Motion for Judgment on the Pleadingl hae not been filed with
the Prothonotary.
9
Said Motion for Judgment on the Pleadinge, even if filed, il not
re.pon.ive to the preliminary Objeotion., a. afore.aid.
')1
I:
,
i
I
i
II
10
With no rlllponee havinq been fJ.led to Defendant '. preliminAt'Y
Objeotion. raieinq laok of perlonal jurildiction and attacking the
urvJ.oe of the oomplaint the factual allegationl of the Preliminary
objeot,lonl au admitted, that blling I
A. The oomplaint wal qerved upon the Defendant by oertified
mail on or about Augult 7, 1996, in violation of the penn.ylvania
Rulel of Civil Prooedure.
l'i
f
WHBREFORE, Defendant requeate thh lIonorable Court to enter
jUdgment in favor of the Defendant and againlt the Plaintiff for
want of an nneWer to Preliminary Objeotione of Defendant.
r etop er C. II ueton, Blquir.
Attorn.y for Defendant
Broujoe, Gilroy & HOUlton, P.C.
4 North Hanover Street
Carlille, PA 11013
717 - 243-4574
II
"
CORY A. CO~Y
ha.l.ntiU
I IN 'JIIIB COURT or COllMON PLBAS or
I CUMBIRLAND COUNTY I PINNSYLVAtfI~
I
I NO. P15-443~ CIVIL TIRN
I
I JURY TRIAL DSMANDBD
I
v
KATHY LUNsrORD I
Defendant
CIRTIPICATI 0' BIIVle.
r, chrhtophn c. Houetan, Blquire, hereby certify that on thil,
d/tte I IUVed the foregoing Motion by tint cla.. mo.l.1., PQltag.
prepaid, upon the followingl
Cory, A. Cormony
lBBJ Douglae Drive
Carli.l., PA 17013
P.C.
Dahl
11t'1! If'
I f
,
I "
,
,
"
, ,
j "
, I,
r/ I
,~
,I
I,ll
I';
;f
, ,
, ,
"
"
"
, I
'I' 'I
if '[
, I ~'I'
iil
'"
~
f~
,;
~14)
yI/i'
f".
,',
'4:jl
I',
I.J,
1..1
t,J
"1
(II
'I
"
,~.
L"
,
lt~
'in,
I ~...
,~:
't' ;'
t'\' fr,
l'i'."
,.'.."
,I'
,1,\,,1,'*1
':'1 ,i
I,If'.#,
, "
,/,",j
" '.&..
, '
d
rn
.~
"
d
'I
I,
,I
I,
"
'i
" ,
,
,
,
1
'I'
"
"
,
,
,.1
I'
, '
I
"
I;
I
I
"
'\
q
;,
'Ii
I,
;.1
'01 I
!t
"
iii
I
,jl
" ,I
~
\
! 1 ! j I' , ,I d 1,1 ,
!~lj(tl'l\1hIH~I~'~lll\"ll 111'1",'., ~\,!,IJ\"J;l~''(IH:'I:'" I t, ~'\!~I,;:I;,I/!Il;'~'}(I'k1~ t
',r,''. "IL( II' " '......41...."1., ' , 'I.~ 1".'~lq'I';,'rI '
"f"','\I,I,,'II, '~""1"'" / ,t},;rert1\f'f,I/
f I ' I r, ! I ( , ! ' I, j '. ,0[, I 'f H' ,
;'t':'fJ-'(" MI:llh\;\I",v)::,,:: "I" ."1.~~, .::' i,',I!;III'."~~II\~li'J'
'{jI,"!'III~!.L1 "(~i!;J,I\,i\~,:I,;I"I\II''','I,',,: ,~'''''''~. :"1,tj",,, 'Ifl." 'H(itJd1i
~j 'I'" /1'1 t/ffj,'f._,l, 1,,1(., 'I, I 11""", ! ...,. '4 ~ I, ",,'1111 ~" ~
'I'IJ,I~. '1" .h'f\i~f''fI-r/III~I}!'..Ii,LIII',''jl/iL, ll"/,f ,'I,; 'r, I 'I I, ',,,' '/1 I 1/ ,1!J!I,r:..'...
.jj,.J..~...l...1 r
CORY A. CORMANY I I IN '1mB COURT 011' COMMON VLBAS OF
IHaintiH I CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
I
v I NO. 915-443~ CIVIt TBRM
I
J(A'l'IIY LUNSFORD, I JURY TRIAL OBMANDED
Oefendant I
DROll
AND NOW, thla L day of Ootober, 19915, upon oondderatoion of a
Motion to Make Rule Abeolute, thll Rule previouely heued upon the
Plaintiff ie he~eby made ab.olute and it ie hereby further ordered
and directed that judgment h entered in favor of the Defendant and
again.t the Plaintiff. ,/ ~
"
, I
.y ~~/
J.
h '.\1'
,
"
.,1 .
'1 "I,
",
~ '; I
, ,
, ,
"
'I
"
conn,nvmDVIOUlI
CORY A. CORMANY, .
Plaintiff
v
I I~ THB COURT OF COHHO~ PLBAS or
I CUMBIIRLAtlD COUNTY, PBNNBYLVAtlIA
I
I NO. 96-443~ CIVIL TERM
I
I JURY TRIAL P"MANDBD
I
KATIIY LUNsrrORD I
Defendant:
HQfION TO MAXI RULI AB80LUlI
AND NOW, camel! the Defendant, Kathy Lunsford, by and through her
attorneys, aroujoe, Gilroy & Ilouston, P.c., who 1lI0ve13 the Court, al
folloWI'
1
On September 23, 1996, upon consideration of /I. Motion to Enter
Dlllfault Judgment: 8gainlt Plaintiff, this Honorable Court entered an
Order ilsuing ft Rule upon the l'laintiff to show OIlUle if any there
by why the relief requested in laid Motion should not be granted,
with said Rule returnable seven (7) days from lervioe.
2
Filed simultaneoul1y with this Motion il an Affidavit of Service
whereby the undersigned certified that laid Order wae lerved upon
the Plaintiff by first class mail, postage prepaid, on September
24, 1996.
3
The Plaintiff has failed to file an Answer.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant requests this Honorable Court to enter
default jUdgment against the Plaintiff for want of an AnSWer.
I~
CORY A. CO........Y
.'......, haintiff
v
I IN THill COURT OJ!' COMMON PLBAS or
I CUMB~RLANP COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I NO. 915-443!l CIVIl, TI!RH
I
I JURY 'rlHAL DEMANDED
I
:,
KATHY LUNSIl'ORD,
Defendant
AfFIDAVIT 0' BIRVICB
I, chriltopher C. Houlton, Esquire, hereby oertify that on
September 24, 1996 I lerved by first olass mail, pOltage prepaid,
upon Cory A. cormany an Order dated September 23, 1996, illuing a
Rule upon the Plaintiff to Ihow cauee if any there be why the
relief requested in
be granted.
the Motion to Enter Default Judgment Ihould not
/.
/'
/
"
/
Date I
/o/~;tI
r Itop1er C. HaUl on, Eequ re
~ttorney for Defendant
Broujos, Gilroy & Houuton, P.C.
4 North Hanover street
Carlisle, PA 17013
717 - 243-4574
, '
, i
.'.' I "j.!,.,j
',1
~~ ,~l
f" t;"':
b~' ,:J. J ~ I.
. "
l-.;( " J
i;l; ;:~
5', ". I
[" ,
I ' ,. '"
r.l: I I [q
I,'
,.. "'-"
I . ,i (\1
I', e fl. ..
\,': ,
'"' ';"1 l-j
,"'" ~.~
.-
'"
".
\~
'1
~
\, "
.
,,~ I,
,
.
~ J
lI-
I
..) 'I'
,
iii' .~
-'
of I
'il" '1
..
~
~
~ "
I 'I
, J II
U"'
.. III. "
I,
II
,
".
"
'I
,
I
, ,
,
,
, '
'('I
"
,
,
.1
,
,
,
i II
"I
I,
I,
,
"
.,