HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04456
I
I'
, ;1
'1 ,/
",
1-, ,I
'I
lh
It,
I'
"'1
j!
i ~
, ,
~
q
q
"
"
,1,!I"
!)
/
'I'"
!i/i
,/
"
li.,I,
, ,
III
,',
.
J; "
~,
~
~
~
,
I i! ~ ,I
1'1
i'l
.,
'\I
i'
,
,
,
, I
111
'I'
" '1\
,
'I"",
'ii'I'i';'
, ,
'I,-j:
I
I
Il, -!),
'1\
"
"
"
/' ['
1"
/
'I
,I
,
'h
~
,i'
, ,
I'
_;,1,
"I
.I
"
I ~ ,I '1 '
,..,
''"''
:~
"I
,
"
'.1,/
Ii
I
I
",
!,
, ~
"
ii
"
/; 'I'
,
,
I'
;)"
',I I
",
,'1
'II,
'I
I
,
"
,
I
I
i/"
i '
"
,
i,
.I,
'II
,/"
,
"
, ,
,.'1
}
I
'I
, '"'I
,I"
I')"
,
I
I
I
I q
'I ",II, '
, '111
'I'"~
:(.1'
"
,
'I.
"
,
"
!
"
I' 'I
,
,
I
,
, ,I
I
,'I
I,
"
'Ii
,
" '
, I
'I",
"
ill
I
I
.,
"
,
",
I
,
,I ,
I'
t
,,~
~
,d'
,
',II'
,
'I:
I
\11"
,I
'I,
i
I
:r-
.
I:)
,..
''t)
, ,
,I
;!I
,
,
"
"
, '
I
"
,
'I
I
>iI'
','
I
"
,
.',
,
,
',\1
~I\" ,
-~il I
':1,':'
',~
, I
"
'/"1,"
I
'"
1.,1 I;
,
",
.\.'1
',' , I
,
, ,
"
-,I ',/ ;.i'! "l'j'
_ L "
IL.,f'j'q
!lll ",
I ,Hi!' ';
IJ}" J jl
I, ~'I i I'
~.!i!-/\,' il '0,/'; I
. . . > ;'j!rl';"i';' ;
"If' '/;1. \, il'_' ,
, j ,II ---,-
" ll' ~ 1
" ,
d:'I' ,I
,I ;/1
1-,,:1 t/
,
, ,,,II '
; . -I; \, I, '~ } i)' : II" " " i"'
. -;;1
1\/':"
(.',;1' "
" '
I,\/'!,
'I" J)i
',,'j I;
", 1 ~'
I, '",,'
-I' J; Ii
I
,I
,I
,I
"I
" ,I 'fl
1.;-1 '
," q"
I), ,
I.' -li-
'/'1'
,
"
"
I'!
,,!
'I
!','
HI, "I
, I ~ 1 - 1_ , I
iVHif',
II" ,
'II ),
, ',!
I,!';
'J
,!I
\)'
','
I
I
J.I
, ,I'
11'1
'.i,l
,I'
,-
,
"
,,:1,
"'il
, 1'1:
II, ,
111 '
) .') I'
"
111'
,', 'I
1-' ,I
"
','
(I '.1.1'
,II' ,I
"!;)
. 'I
"
,
':i!
[, ),
:,' " {H
';, 11'~'\i\'
I j'_
,
I,
illl (,
"I, !
"i .Y'
'I
.II L
1 I",
I
, '
'_i.lll
I'il,l,
.'.1
"
I
"
li,\1
I,
/:1,'1'
i,l
,
d-
1'1: \ I'
'1'1,,1,
Ii
.'i.'
; i:'(, .
1'1:
J
If I
I'
I
"
"
I
.J"
/1
I
'1'-
, ~ !
,I
,I
111
,
,
,
'It
I'
"
il
II:
I
'11,1,
'I q
('
,
'I'll
,
\
"
J.I:il
I
I,
"
,'I
"
,
"I
,I'
,
1;
;I' '" ~
"
"
I,
'II
I
,/
I'
Ii
<,I'
I
I
"
!Ii!
I'
"
I i!
"I I
j'l
,
'I
I'
d
,
,',
,
:1;
II'
I
"
I
il,
I
Ii
,
,1,1,
"
l ", I
',1-
'I'!'
'1.1
,
,JI'I
,,'JII
:,
"
\'1
,
'If I
,I
'''I
I'
,I'
I'
"
,
,
I j;!'
d ,"
I III
,I Ii'
1''1
_'I'
I
I,
'ill)
,I I
,1,1
"I
'11'1
:""
"
I
"
"
1'1
"
/;
'I
I't/';
; I'
'I li
,e
tl'l
,
,
I
!
.'1'
ill,
;'1
"
"
I
il.
I, ,,',
I Iii;, ,1-1
1',1 Ii II
I"L !IJ
t' 1'1'
r,l,
I'
\ ,
,
,
/,
II"
"III
,
,
11 ;Ji
'il
I'
"
';I!
L"
.1
'1,';tf,
"
I,
,
,
I
,
111
"
"
'I-I
I'
, '
I
,
!1'I'
,I'
I,')',
,i'1
,;:1
) 'II
'I
,
,
I ,)1
1,1,
'.1
"
'I
I
.1
I,
I'"
"
"
\:\'
. ,
"11'
'I
;\
'I
!I :1"
,
"
II
d
,
,I
"
,
II
,,'
"
, ,
,II,
"
, ,
''''
"
"
I'
I
"
<I'
"
'I
"
"
'"
I,
'"
"
,
"
,
"
"
"I
,'1: '\
'.
"
I
"
,I
,
'\/')'1
,
',,1"1
'1;1
)11'
,
1'),1
"
,
"
,
If!
I"
, ,
-1,1
"
I
I
",-
:,\
I
'111'
/
"
"
,
q .1
,
:,j
II
,
'I
I
"
",.J
"
,
"
"
I
'I
'1'1'1,"1
"
I'
"
','
"
,
" '
"
'"
i
'II
<I
/'1,
"I
,'Ii
I 'I
\11 I.!
"
I,
I
I
"
"
]1111
)',
;I'
,
"
"
i,1!
"
,I
,/ ,
,\1('/;
" ,I
..
('i'
',IF
ii' 'I
iii'
, j I)
lit}JIl '
.,1, i.',
I 'I"
ii'
'ij J ~'," I '
, ,-'
,
I'll
I
II
'\1,1
'II",;
\
"
"d'
,
"
,
"
,
,
,11/'-"1)
-'1'1, 'f J,
,
!"i
"
,
'!
"
'\
;1
'\) !
"
I",
, ' ~lj
_11';1/
";,lill,
-1,/
,
"
i(,-
,,'
,U
I' "it":\.
1-,"' ,il I,,!
I'
, ,
1'1
'\ ~
,
I! '
,i
,
ill
" ,,'l't
'.
',/' ,i'\I'
",' I
~ If : ,'I I
'If
""!','
',fl
'I;'
/"',"1", H
'1'1
'I
I:
, 1'1
;:'';,
'I
I. "
,I',
.,
ii,
"
\1,:)
"
,
'I'
,
, "
ii.f. ',"
,
,1/,'1 >I
'q!
'.11
,;
\
1\
I
,', I:" ,. ~
" I':'"
...\/ tI..,
I ,,!".:\
',::.1'"
II!l,!
~ ,! I '
dj'
I'
,'II,)
! tFt
'I,'" I
1,;'1'
',i ,;I
'\
,I',
'.:11,
1'11'1' '
')1,1' ;1'
'f;'
.i:j.'1
,,-"
I, I'll'
I ' '~jlhl
1'..1"'\.
1 (I<J1:
I'!;;'\~:}J-
'N.
I,) /'I,ll
_,'.It
I . "1{
I/'Jf\
;,1' ".),,1
,( ':';1
\'1, I;' "in.'!..
'1, I. '\I,~"
"I,! I'
,.! ".,
n 11"',1,;
I' ,)
I,
!I-' 1
)1,;
I
,'ill
!
"
, "p
',1;/.1 '
i'l'
'\
,
'1.11
'I')
'!l',
LJ/,
"
,
"
,
" l'
-'1'.)1."
!j ,
,
"
"
",
-.J-f
.;
, ,I
i,'rlll
'I I
,
;,'1,
"
I'
,
"
I
"
- 1 , ~
jl \' ,';!.! r I'll
,)(1'\ ,';)
tl i ,"'.;-', 'I
"I I,ll ,iiiJi'.Ii
-I ..
_1; I,i,",;',
" I,"
"
i,
'i",'
-1',1
I,),
"
"
,'I'
. "
I"i/.
,'1
'I.
',I
I"
"
I
,
'\ ',:J
,"
, ! : ~ '
I. ~
,
,
r:
, .,
'I
'Ill
,',
, 11'
, "
.:,(',
,f: .)'i'
,'I!,t',;
,". ii
\' '
i;l.'1
'n
'I
,"
,!
; 'I fl,
I-I;, ,'1>1 '
.,,'1;11,...'1
'I 'i'.' , 1',
',1, 'I
1""/'.:,11.
:',1 . .'~I
:ll,'I!;
11 f'l_1
I,
_'1\
",
,','1
d ',1
II I
~ , '
I,
,
"I,
,II'
"
-'<)'
, ,
"
,\
, ,
"
I,
,
"
, ,
I
.}';I
'1;\
,I,
"
,
,
"
'"
, I'
,\(.,
I' __,
";\j -
,I
"
, ,
"
i'
,',
,
"
Schmidt and Ronca rc
AII",""," ~. [.O"M''', .. UII
o
I" ""1 ......
H~r' "-/1.- ,,,.,
. III '" ..,..
DONNA
known
STUBBS, formerly
a. DONNA SHOLLY,
Plllintlff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLlAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Del.'l.lndantl
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
NO . ; (p
1;1'.1 f" {lCI)..:{,
v.
H. OLARK STAAB, D.D.S. I and
STAAB , BUDEN ASBOCIA'l'ES I
INC. ,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY 'rRIAL DEMANDED
1f0'fICI
YOU HAV! DIIN 8UID IN OOURT. If you wi.b to defend
a,ain.t tbe alai.. let fortb in the followinq paqel, IOU au.t
taka aatian witbin twenty (20) daYI aftlr thil ooapla nt and
Hotia. are .erv.d, by .nterinq a writt.n .pp.aranae perlanally ar
by attorney and filinq in writinq with the Oourt your deflnle. ar
abjaatianl to the alaim. lit forth aqainlt you. You are warnld
tbat it you tail to do .0 the aa.. .ay proo.ed witbout you and a
jU4qment aay b. .ntered agdnet you by thl Oourt without furtber:
natiae far any money alaim.d in the Oomplaint or tor any other
aldm or reU.f requ..hd by the Plaintiff. You lIay 10.. aoney
ar praperty ar ather riqbt. important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAIl THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYIR AT ONOI. Ir
YOU DO HOT HAV! A LAWYIR OR OANNOT ArrORD ONI, GO TO OR TILIPSOHI
TUI OrrIOI BIT rORTH BILOW TO FIHh OUT WHERI YOU OAN GIT LOOAL
UIU.
Court Administrator
4th Floor, cumberland County Courthouse
carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
DONNA UTUBBS, tor~e~ly known
a. DONNA SHOLLY I
plaintiff
IN TUS COURT or COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLV~NI~
v.
NO. lIt'. '~'I'I-1. ("(, \,1 {:.p..,
H. CLARK ST~B, D.D.S., and
ST~B , SUDEN ~SSOCIATES,
INC. ,
Dehndante
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL PBHANPED
COMPLAINT
AND NOW, come. the Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS, for.~erly known
.. DONNA SHOLLY I by and throu9h their attorney~, sohmidt and
Rono., P.c., and respectfully sets forth ae tollowel
1. The Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS I il an adult individual
ourrently residing at 65 Hummel Avenue, Lemoyne, cumbe~land
County, Pennsylvania 17043.
2. The Detendant, H. CLARK STAAB, D.D.S., i. a dentilt
liaeneed to praotice in the Commonwealth of Penneylvania, with
his prinoipal plaoe of business located at 5229 East Tr.indle
Road, Mechanicsburg, cumberland county, Pennsylvania 17055.
3. The Defendant I
Pennsylvania corporation
STAAB & SUDEN ASSOCIATES, INC., ie a
with its principal place at businees at
~229 East T~indle Road, Mechanicsburg, Cumberland county,
Pennsylvania 17055.
4. At all times relevant to thi. action, Detendant, STAAB,
was en agent, ee~vant, and/or employee, acting within the .eope
at his protessional responsibilities and employment on behalt ot
STAAB & SUDEN ASSOCIATES, INC.
G. At all timae relevant to Plaintiff'. aau.e of aotion,
there .~i.ted a patient/dentiet relationlhip betwe.n Plaintiff
end Detendante.
15. On Dr about september 3 I 1980 I Defendant B'l'MB plaoed
crownl on teeth numbere 2, 3, 8, 9, and 10, in the Plaintiff,
DONNA STUBBS' mouth.
7. On or about september ~, 1980, Defendant STAAB p1aoed
orowns on tneth numberll 11, 12, and 14, in the Plaintiff, DONNA
STUBBS' mouth.
8. On or about Ootober 10, 1980, Defendant STAAB ineerted
two (2) bridges ill Plaintiff, DONNA BTUBUB' mouth at teeth
numbers 3 through 0, and at number. 9 through 11. He al.o p1aoed
a orown at number 2.
9. On or about November 15, 1900, Defendant STMB insu'ted
a bridge at teoth numbere 12 through 14.
10. On or about November 26, 1900, Defendant STMB plaoed
orowns on teeth numbere 22 and 23.
11. On or about December ll, 1980, Defendant STMB placed
orowns on teeth numbere 26 and 27.
12. On or about April 27, 1981, teeth numbers 10 and 11
started to abscess.
13. On or about November 29, 1982, Defendant STMB removed
the bridge at teeth numbers 3 through B from the Plaintiff, DONNA
STUBBS' mouth.
14. On or about December 24, 1982, Defendant STMB ine.rted
a bridge in the Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS' mouth at teeth numbers 2
through 8.
us, on Ol' about Deoembel' ';I." I 1902, Oefendant B'l'AAB removed
a .i~ (6) bl'idQI unit from the P1aintiff, DONNA STUBBS' mouth.
10. On or about l'obl'uary ';1.2, Hill3, Detondant S'l'AAB inserted
a .ix (6) unit mandibular bridge over the anterior portion of the
Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS' mcuth.
11. On or about Juno J, 1985, Defondant STAAB observed
ewe11ing and infla~nation of l'laintiff, DONNA STUBBS' gums and
recommended a gingivectomy at numbers 2 and 3.
18. On or about l"ebrulIry 1.3, 1986, Defendant S'rAAB
reoemented a bridge.
19. On or about May 12, 1987, Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS
repo~ted to Defendant STAAU a bad odo~ from her mouth.
20. On or about April 20, 1900, Defendant: S'l'AAB obeerved
Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS' bridge loose.
21. On or about April 25, 1908, Defendant STAAB removed the
bridge at numbers 22 through 27, Bnd recementud them baok in
pllloe.
22. On or about Septembor 21, 1988, the Plaintiff, DONNA
STUBBS' gum had reoeded around 11 and 12 of the bridge.
23. On or about November 8, 1988, the plaintiff, DONNA
STUBBS, reported to Defendant STAAB bleeding and inflammation.
24. On Qr about August 31, 1989, Defendant STAAB ineerted a
new bridge on teeth numbers 9 through 11.
25. On or about September 4, 1990, Defendant STAAB observed
in Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS' mouth a one (1) to two (2) millimeter
pooket between the teeth.
36. on o~ about Maroh ~, 1~91, the Plaintitf, PONN^ STUBBS,
reported pain at tooth numbar 37.
37. On or about Maroh 14, 1991, the Plaintitf, PONN^
STUBBS, reported pain in her mouth at teeth numbere 36 and 27.
38. On or about Maroh 10, 1992, the P1aintitt, DONN^
STUBBS, ruported an abscessed tooth and boil at tooth number 3,
39. On or about February B, 1993, Plaintiff, DONNA STUnBS/
reported to DetendAnt S'l'AAIl heavy b11ledinq and pain in her mouth.
30. On or about August 3, 1993, Defendant STAAB oblerved in
Plaintitf, DONNA S'l'UIlIlS, a three (J) n1illimetel' pocket between
numbers 2 and 3.
31. On or about December 7, 1993, Defendant STAAIl observed
in Plaintitf, DONNA STUBIlS, a dissolving abloe~e in number 2
orown.
32. On or about March 15, 1994, Detendant STAAB observed in
Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS, a boil around numb~r 3.
33. on or about March 31, 1995, Dofendant STAAB obse~vad
general bleeding, which was reported to him by tho Plaintift,
DONNA STUBBS.
34. On or about Octobor 13, 1995, Detendant STAAB noted
that the Plaintift, DONNA STUBBS, was in good health.
35. The Plaintiff, DONNA STUIlBB, has not seen Detendant
STAAB mince her last appoJ.ntment on October 13, 1995, but linoa
that last appointment, she has discovered that she has sUltained
injuries tram her treatments with Defendant STAAB.
36. Thl Pllintiff, DONN~ STUBBS' injurie. includl the
fcllodnVI
(I) ~dyanced p.r,iodontal di.ea.e,
(b) DlfeotiVI bridge work,
(0) Thl lOll of two (2) teeth,
(d) Poorly fitted orownl'
(I) spacing between her teeth Ind margin.,
(f) I~properly fitted orown., and
(g) cOlmetio injurie. due to un.ightly dilfivurl=lnt.
37. The Plaintitt, DONNA STUBBS, oontinue. to haVe
co=plication. from her treatmunt. with Defendant STAAB.
38. It i. believed end aVerred that Plaintiff, DONNA
STUBBS, will continue to experience pain, Ind will allo rlquire
treatmlntl to repair the injurie. created by the negligence of
the Oehndant Ie\: forth above I inclUding .urge,..y and the
replacement of eeveral bridge..
39. The Plaintiff, DONNA STUBBS' injurie. were oau.ed by
realon of the Defendant'. negligence, ae Bet forth below, and wa.
not cau.ed or cont,..ibuted to by an conduct on the part of the
Plaintiff., beoauB' they were not contributorily and/or
oo~paratively negligent at any ti=e rellvant to thil cau.e of
action.
ggj/Jf!Ll
DO~' .~UDBB. for.lIly known a'-DOKHA .QOL~~,
v.
.. OLARK 'T~. D.D....~_I~AlD-' BUD.H A8.00tA~I.. tHO.
lfJlgL1SIJIlf.C11
40. Paragraphe 1 through 39 of P1aintifte' complaint are
incorporated herein by reterenoe and made part there of aa if .et
froth in full.
41. Ae a direct and proximate roeult at the negligence ot
the Defendant, II. CLARI< S'l'AAll/ IJ.O. S. / sot forth below, the
Plaintitf, DONNA STUBBS, sustained sorious and permanent injuries
outlined herein.
4J. Defendant S'l'AAB'S negligence conBlsted of the
followin'iJl
(a) Failing to diagnose periodontal dieeasel
(b) Failiny to properly insert bridges into
Plaint ff'e mouthl
(c) Inserting crowns into tho Plaintiff' :] mouth whioh
Wore not fittod properly I and
(d) Inserting crowno into the P1aintiff's mouth Which
margine were not unifor.m.
43. As a direct and proximate result of the negligenoe of
Defendant STAAB let forth above, the l'laintiff, PONNA srUBBS, hae
been forced to undergo great pain, eUffering, disability, and
inoonvenience associated with the periodontal disease, poor.ly
engineered bridge work, improperly fitted crowns, and the
complications and injuriee which have resulted therefrom I
inoluding additional surgery and bridge work.
44. A. a direot and proKimate relult of the ne\llillenOu of
Defundant STAAB uet forth above, the Plaintiff, DONN~ STUBBS, ha.
beun foroed to under\lo further dlntel treatment and inour duntal
eKpen.e. to datil II . rllult of the damal/e. llau.ed by lJefenda"t
STAAB'S nel/lil/enoe in the approK1mate amount of $26,000, ae let
forth above I and may oontinue to incur duntal eKpen.e. into the
future.
4~. AI a direot and proKimute reeult of the nellligenou of
,
Defendant STAAB uet torth above, the Plaintiff I DONNA STUBBS, ha.
been foroed to mill time from work, Which. mlY re.ult il1 a 10.. of
earning. oapaoity in the future.
46. AI a direot and proximate r.eu1t of the negligenoe of
Defendant STAAB set forth above I the Plaintiff I DONNA S'I.'UBBS, hu
alee incurrad a lce. of life's enjoyment and pleaeure..
WHSREFORE, the plaintiff, DOHNA STUBBS I demand. judgment of
the Defendant, H. CLARK s'rAAB, D.D.S, and STAAB' SI/DEN
ASSOCIATSS, INC., in an amount in eKcee. of Thirty-Five Thou.and
($3~,000) Dollars, and in excese at an amount requiring
oompuleory arbitration.
ly eUbmitted,
(i~CA~ P,C.
...,) .., #__-J
BYI
Charles E. Schmidt, Jr.
Attorney at Law
209 State street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Attorney I.D. 119198
(717) 232-6300
Attorney for th.e Plaintiff
"I
"
"
II.!
,
,
,t
"
! I
I;
"
I
II
.jI ,~ ~
- ~ ~r46
.II ~
I, #J ~~
r.E ~~
l'~ Iii
~ ,
I,Q ~ ." ~~
I III ~
~~ ~ \"f"')
~ ~ "
~ jIiol
~ ~ ~' 'i
~ ~ ~
,
,
\
,I
,
"
,,!
,
IL',i
"
I'
.. I;
"
"
.! l:) ,~
011 ,..,
.
~ I
'I' lE
~; Q
N
,W ~
l;' ~.
I,
I,
"
,1\
I
,
,
\. '\
I
,
.il
1,1
"
,
"
I
,
I
'tl
, '
. ,
"
'I
I
, I
'i:
"I
, ,
1 ,
"
II I
I
"
,
I
Ii
"
"
ill
I) 1'1
i:l,
/,
.'/_11/
:'1
I I
j.J!
'(1
Iii
I.
I ;i
,
'J!!II
,I
I,
ii,
I,
I,
t~ld
J "8 I a I
~ J i ~
J I
'I
I' I
I
" , ,
d ! ,
,I' J.',l
,[' Jr
,
I 'I "
, , , ,II
I
,I I..
. ,
, ,
I
'/
I
I,'
'.
,'I
I,
Ilil
, .
CERTIFlCA'rlt or IlERVICE
-
I, KEVIN E, ()IiIlOIlN'~, EIiQUllm Ill' Ihu Inw Ilnll ur'l'1I0MAS, "'1I0MAS, III
nAVER, dl) cerllry thut I Nurv~llhu roregllllll! dllCUIII~lItllJllhe fullowllll! Jl~rtillll('), hy deJlosllllllllhe
SAllIll III the Ulllled Slul~s Mull, JlOllul!~ Jlr~Jluld, ulllurrlsburll, IIclllllylvllllla addremd III rollowsl
CharlCIII!, Schmidt, Jr" Esquire
SCHMIDT &. RONCA, II.C,
209 Slale Street
Harrlsburs. PA 17101
TIlOMAB, THOMAS II nArER
t: C-1
/ -.....,.~.., (' ()".J.J '/-"'--
'KJtVIN E. OSBORNE, ESQUIRE
01101 AU8ua119, 1996
Ii.
I
It.', ,', I
0 Ij, ! qt' I ,
.'i I ,
'! ,... " '1
,.. I
. I ,( Illl
:A n ,\ , II
q
p: II i'
U. I
1,1 'lL I' ,I , !
~ ltI Lf. 'I ',' !'!
J )1 I 'I'
N n! " 1.1' /,1 1
I' I
~ ~ I 'I
\~ I)')
I ,I,
1'( 'I ,
~ ~ 'I , I , " I
, (: ;'I'
I 1 ' !' I,
I I' I ' I d
" '!
I' " "
,
1 I, /,
I
"
1 I' ~, ','
c()~i I
"II~
'I
~
, "
I'
ill
I'
,
I
/'
I
..' ,I I,
1;.1 I I I
, , I'
I' I il 1'1 ,
I , !
, " 1,\
, I
:,1 " I, 'I "
, II
I I, ,I 'I" ,
11\, "
" '1
'I I.', I I
,
I
I ,
, ,
I" I,
"
" I'
I
,
, ,
I
II
! ]j
:,
;1"
,I
,II,
,I
I'
I'
"
II,',
I ., i.1
"
.
.
.'
"
"J-' " t'
"
,
"
,
maMA', mOM^' olltA/'JI1l
-V, I,"" I. "'''''''' ..,,.,,
1011".""'_
,Q, .. '"
II......., 'A 11I11I.."
"'" "Hl'"
A..., ,.,110_
"I, I
I
DONNA STUBBS, foonerly known ..
DONNA SHOLLY,
l'lalntlff
v.
IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBl!RLAND COUNTY, Pl!NNA
NO, 96--4456
CIVIL ACTlON . LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
H, CLARK STAA.B, D.D,S.. and
STAAB & SUDEN ASSOCIATES, INC"
Defendants
ANSWER WITH NEW MA ITER
AND NOW, COIII~ the Defendants, JI, Clark Slaab, O,O.S. and Staab & Suden
Associates, Inc. by rJlelr attorneys, Tholllas, Tholllas & Hafer, and Answer Plalntlfrs Complaint
1\1 follows:
I). After reasonable investigation, the Defendallts ore without knowledge or
information sufflclentto foml a belief as to the truth of the avennents of Paragraph 1 and 38 and
proof thereof 15 demanded at Irlal.
2). The Defendants admit the avennents of Paragraphs 2 and 3. The averment of
Paragraph 5 is admitted In pan and denied In part. It Is admitted that at all times relevant
hereto, there was a patientldl!ntlst relationship between Plaintiff and Dr. Staab. The remaining
aVerment of Paragraph 5 15 denied,
3). The averments of Paragraph 6 . 37 and 39 arc denied In accordance with Rule
1029(e) of the Pa. R.C.P.
4), Tho a'/onnonl# of I'arallraph 4 of Ihe Complalnl nllllO conclunlo/lll of law 10 which
no l/lIIwor II required, '1'0 Ihe elllOnl an alUwer In deemed required, Ihe avennonll arc denied
Ind proof thereof In domanded allrlal.
COUNT I
5), In respolUC 10 Ule avennenla of l'al1lllraph 40 of Ihe Complalnl, Ihe Defcndanll
IncorporalO herein by reference Ulelr OIUWcn 10 Pamllraph I I.hroullh 39 nbove an If sel forth II
lenaUI.
6), The aVenl\lmln of PBr8srophn 411hroullh 46 are denied in oecorllinee with Rulo
1029(e) of tho Pa. R.C.P.
WHEREFORE, Deli:ndonll demond Judllmclllln their favor and oaalnnt Plaintiff.
NEW MATIER
7). Plalntlff'n Complollll foils 10 slllle 0 claim UpOIl which relief can be grallted.
8). Plalnllff's clohns may be harred, In whole. or III part, by the ,ppllcable statute
of IlmillltlrllU.
9). Plainliff'n claims may be barred, III whole or In part, by Plalnllff'n own
~nlribulOry negligence.
10). Plalllllff'n claims may be barred, in whole or In part, by Plaintiff'. anlumpllon
of rink or her acllolU or inacllolU.
2
CKRTUI'ICATI 0" SIRVlCI
I, KEVIN E. OSBORNE, It8QUIRE of Iha law Onn of mOMAS, TIIOMAS, II
IIAFER, do tertiI)> Ihnll aarved Iha forugolllll docul1lalllolllha follllwlnll paraon(I), by dapoahllllllha
lima tnlha United Slalul Mall. Illlltalla prupald. alllmlaburll, Palllllylvalllaaddrmed II followll
Charlelll. Schmldl, Jr., Ilaqulre
SCHMIDT &. RONCA
209 Sllle Slreel
Harrllburg, PA 1710 I
TtlOMAB, TIIOMAB IIl1AnR
m4~"'''~-' ~0~'l-""~.
E. OsnORNE, ESQUIRE
Dalel AUIUI123, 1996
"
,.
Schmidt and Ronca PC
""."'.,. ... r........... '1 1.0.. '
,.. ..... ....
......... '-If..... J 1111 ,
"" IIf:'... ,
,'I; I
----
DoNNA STUBBS, formerly / IN Till COURT 0" CONNON PLEAs
lcnown I. DoNNA SlfOLLV1 / OUMBERLAND COUNTV, PENNSVLVAHIA
Plaint rr /
/
V. I Ho. 91S-441l1S
/
If. CL.\RJ( STAAB, D.D.s., and /
STAAB , SUDEN ASSOCIATES, / CIVrr. AC'l'IOH - LAW
INC., /
Defendants I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
A.PLY TQJHJW ~TT.8
AND HOW, comes the Plaintiff, by her oounsel, and .et. forth
a. fOllows/
"
7. Paragraph 7 of Defendants' New Hatter aontains a
aonalu.ion of law which dODs not require a responsive Pleading.
8. Denied. It is specifically denied the statute of
limitations bara Plaintiff's alaims either in Whole, or in part,
for reasons set forth in Plaintiff's Complaint.
9. Denied. The Plaintiff denies that her claim is barred
either in Whole, or in part, by Virtue of contributory
negligence, far r.easons set forth in Plaintiff's Complaint.
10. Denied. The Plaintiff denies that her alaim is barred
either in Whole, or in part, by Virtue af Plaintiff's assUmption
of ri.le, tor reasons set forth in Plaintiff's Complaint.
11. Paragraph 11 of Defendants' New Hatter contains a
conclusion ot law Whiah does not require a responsive pleading.
. (
!i
I
I
1)1,
'I
"
t! 1"1 ',. ,
Ii
c:; I..
~~ ,
:& "~I , ,
"~~~ I r/
.~~ :r.: "
u., Ilf; r,
:1..: M "~
~(\; I ,'11 "
I,l! ~ ':)ll
oI~' ,"
:3
\b ~ "
" li:1
I,
>, I
I
"
, "
I'
'I
d " "
I ,
I I'
I I
, " 1)
" ,
, " II
, "
i: "
, " ;1
, I,
" ,
" , ,
:I' 'I) " I
'I , I
"
"
1)1
:,1
I I
Ii
,
~: l~' (".
It: N I,
,.~ i') ~
it;
~;: 'J"'..
t' >:I.. ',:J
1'" /'11/;
11 - ,'.r~
(1,1/, ~\ "j4J 'I
,. "-' /1, I,. "
I 8
1I" ~ J "
'.J
,
I
"
"
"
'II
I J:II
, ,
_~'_"U_. ,__
_11"t
- ,.
~"""
5d1mldt and Ronca PC
1M ...f, .....
"on_" ,_~..... "III
""" ,"M
"- .-,
~_..-._'
"...,nlt"n" (D.."..I,,.., J..~ '-. -.,
DONNA STUBBS, fo~~erly
Imown ftB DONNA BHOLLY,
Plaintitf
IN THQ COURT OF COMMON PLIAS
CUMBQRl,AND COUNTV, JilQtmS'iLVANXA
v,
NO, 9li -4466
H, CLARK STAAB, D,D, S" and
STAAB & SUPBN ASBOCIATQS,
INC, ,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Defendanta
JURY TRIAL DEMANDBP
QlBtI'IOATI 0' SlaVICI
AND NOW thia /9/1 day oJ";iJ/,7vlJ, 1996, I, Charlell B.
Sohmidt, Jr" Eaquire, hereby certify that I have thia day lIerved
Plaintiff 'a Obj ectiona to Defendallts' Requllst for Production of
Documenta, by depoaiting a copy of the same in the United States
Mail, pOlltage prepaid, at Harriaburg, Pennaylvania, addrellaed tOI
Kevin E, Oaborne, Eaquire
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER
306 North Front Street
10',0, Box 999
Harriaburg, JilA 17108
By,
/ ~CA(t.P.'C'
/ '
. ,,( . ,'\,( ,
Charles E, Schmidt, Jr,
Attorney at Law
209 Rtate Street
Harriaburg, PA 17101
Attorney I,D. #19198
(717) 232-6300
Attorney for the Plaintiff
..~--
I
,
11
'II, I
'I,
"
'It
"
, :1
"
~. In '..
r I
" ~'I 'i" I
r"- ill , i..~
p~~' , J ~l.,
. ; ,It,.
11:' ~ .:.... I'll
.;;;1 , ,
I'; ~J 'I'J
'I'...
C" ,'I 1(:.
II' [1', ' : 1/') 'I
lL'" ' '/It ,: "
I' , I
I, lj. :tJ , i 'I'
1..1 ~ .) ,
I',
'., rJ I r.J
"
,I
"
, I
,
I
I'
,I
/I
It
I
,
i"
I
'I
'I
'II
,
, '
~.._... ,
~If':?
--
... -
Schmidt and Ronca PC
'ot".I.",...
"..._~, ,_....... I"'.
'" I "'UDe
.'
&..,..., .i... ~
Au"n't. ,nit c.w"uhuI ..lAw.
DONNA STUBBS, formerly
known II DONNA ShOLLY,
plaintiff
IN 'l'lIlii COUR'l' OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMDERLANO COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA
v.
NO. 91S-44tl6
If. CLARK STAAB, D.D.B" and
STAAB , SUD~N ASSOCIATES,
INC. ,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY T.RIAL DEMANDED
Oltsndant.
CIRTIrIQkTIJULIJRVICI
AND NOW this 2 /,~rday or ()c+. , 1991S, I, charl.. B.
Schmidt, Jr., Esquire, hereby oQrtify that I have this day served
Plaintiff's Answers to Defend~nts' Inte~rogatories, along with
Plaintiff's Response to Defendant's Request for Produotion of
Document., by depositing a copy of the same in the United states
, Mail, postage prepaid, at Harrisbur.g, Pennsylvania, addr....d tOI
Kevin E. osborne, Esquire
THOAMS, THOMAS & HAFER
30tl North Front Strset
P.O. BOle 999
HarriSburg, PA 17108
, ~1Jl>j P.C.
. ....Jth
BYI
Charles E. Schmidt, Jr.
Attorney at L~w
209 State Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Attorney I.D. 119198
(717) 232-6300
Attorney for the Plaintiff
',I
",
il
,"
'I
I
ili
II
'I
J, J
I'
,
I
"
"
"
,
"
'I
"
,
"
_._",,,:"!..~.-.
.....,..
"" ,..
1"'\-
Schmidt and Ronca PC
1111_,. .04 CoN"."'... 0.1.010
I" ..... I!rOOI
........" ,....,.... 1""
III III ..,"
o
.
.,
"
'-... ,-....,
-.--
DONNA S'l'USIlS, tormllrly
known as DONNA SHOLLY,
1>laintir.f
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PL~AS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, P~NNBVLVANIA
v,
NO, 91S-44!l1S
H. CLARK STAAB, D.D.S., and
STAAB & BUDEN ASSOCIATES/
INCl, /
Detendantll
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PBAIOIPI rOR DI800NTIHU~cl
TO THE PROTHONOTARY I
Pl.alle disaontinue tho above oaptioned aotion, mark it
settled with prejudice and iseue a certificat. of settlement,
Thank you.
.
SUbmitted,
BYI
SC~H/ 0 RO~CA,
^ ~J ,- I
/'..,,, ( l'V'
Charles E. Schmidt, Jr.
Attorney at Law
209 State street
Harrieburg, PA 17101
Attorney I.D. #1919B
(717) 232-6300
.C,
Attorney for the Plaintift
Dstedl
'"';\
\j0f}'\30, 1"18
"
1
"
,
1
,I
I
I
,
,
"
., <:II ',. ,) ,
fl oU 1", " ,
.
I, ,I I I'
~'.It . ~f "
(J l i I ," ~~', I.
E: , ., ~ 'ii
I.j" ,~ I ; :'j
~l: ~" I,,;,}
(.:i. , , ,L",~" "
..-,JI
LJ, [; l,,(,'j
,', ~U "I.
, III
~. I.'I.~
.I fn '., "
" , I
:.i
"
:,1
",
"
'II
, '
,
,
,,1,"
I,
'"
"
,
,
---,.-..
"'---"'T----.-"-"
,I
, '
"'1
lIDo "..
c.....
00(1)