HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04737
l:i
"
it
II
Ii
It
\1
Ii
,
,
Iti "
I
'i
, , , ,
, ,
, I
,
,
, " ,
Iii
'/
II
,
,
"
,
,
I,
"
"
"
..
, ,
, J Ii "
, ,
I' , , ,
I,
I;
,
1 ;I
I , I I,
, ,
,
I
I'
,
,
"
4, Plaintiff thlllrlllln"r filed IJ Complaint aljainl:lt thQ
nomed Oefendants In the above-captioned action on BeptQmbel:' 21,
1997, A trUG Gnd correct ~apy of tho ~oid complolnt il:l attaohed
hereto, markod IJIJ Exh Iblt "c" IInd mllde a part heraoC,
5, 'l'hlt Complaint alllJlll3/1 thlit, on or about AUllllst 7.7, 1!194
ot or about 12126 p.m., fedor S. Safonof waa operatinll 0 1994
Chevrolet Corvetto owned by PlalntifC in a northerly diroctlon on
N. Hanov",r StrlJet 150 foot north of C\I,Iy fltroc;Jt In North
Middleton Township, Cumberland County and come to stop to make II
right turn lnto the Hess \Iaa atation, Complaint, par, 4, fJ.
6, The Compla i nt further ll11ellos that, on or about the
same date ond time Dofondant Comp operated a 1980 Dod\le Omni
automobile owned by DefQndant Balaa in a northerly direction on
N,' Hanover Street behind Plaintiff's vehicle, Complaint, par, 5,
9, l5.
7. The Compla I nt further a lleqes that, at the aCoreBaid
time and placo, Defendant Comp nogligently, caraleBBly and
reckleSSly operated Defendant Salaa' vehicle in such a manner
that he caual3d it to come into contact and collide with the rear
of Plaintlff'B vehicle/ thereby cauBing damage to Plaintiff'a
vehicle in the amount of $4,916,77. Compll.lint/ par, 10, 11, l3.
2
ij, The Compll'.lint further 811"'\11315 thllt, at Illl t1nIIiB
mnt$rial to th~ above-oaptioned ~ctlon, Defendant Comp wall Bctlng
with tho consent Ilnd permlusion of P~fendant Sfl1f11l and as the
fI\Jent of Dofendant Saloa, 'Comp1al.nt, par. 6,
9. 'rho Complaint furthor allolleB thlJt, fit nll times
material to th~ abovo-captLoned action, Defendant Comp was acting
undar the dlroction of and under tho diroct BupervIsion and
control of Defendant SallJa. Complaint, par, 7.
10. '['he complaint further alla\loa thllt, fit all timoa
material to tho abavo-captiolled act Lon, DefondlJnt Comp waB acting
within the cour.ae find acope of hiR agency ralationship with
Defondant 6f11aB during the operation of Defendant Salaa' vehicla,
Complaint, par. 16.
11. 'rhe Complaint further allellea that, th~ accid!lnt and
ra~ultinll damallea were caused by tho careleasnesa, ne\lllllanCe and
recklessneaa of Defondant Salaa in, Inter alia, entrusting her
vehicle to Defendant Camp whsn aha knew or ahould have known that
he Was incompatent to drive a motor vehicla, that hill ability to
oporate a vehicle was impaired, and that the vehicle In question
was not properly reqiaterad, inapected and inaured under
Pennoylvania law. Complaint, par. 19.
3
1~, Plalnt Uf ltJllrvod PehndantlS wi th the Compla lot by
oQ~tLfied mail on or about Octobij~ 14, 1997, undor cover oC
tran9mlttol lettor9 dated October 8, 1997, TrUe end correct
copllls of the trollamittal lettors lInd rl/turn re<;e1ptlS IJrQ
attached hereto, collectively mllrked as Exhibit ~DH and made
parts hereof,
l3, Plaintiff aQrved Defendants with u notice of intention
to take a default judgment by certified mail on or about May 19,
1996. True and correct copies of tho Baid nQtiae, transmittal
letters and certificatoB of mallinll are attached hereto,
colleativoly marked as ~xhLbit "t" ond made parto hereof,
l4, ~laintlff entered default judgment aCJainst the
DeCendants In the above-captioned action on November 16, 1996.
True and correct copiea of the Praecipe for Judgmont, with the
notlceB of intent to enter default judgment, and the Notice of.
Filing Judgment are attached hereto, collectively marked as
txhibit ~1i'1/ and mode parta hereof.
l5, On or about February ll, 1999, the Prothonotary of
Cumberland County returned the foregoing transaction with a nota
requeBting that Plaintiff fila tho proof of aervice Cor the
4
Complaint and reenter thG dQtault. A true ard aorr_at copy of
the said not~ iu attached hereto, marked as tKhlbit, "0" and made
a part herl/of.
16, Thor~after, Plaintiff inadvertently failed to fila tho
Bald proof of aervice,
17, In spite or tho BB1d failure, Plaintlf.C had tal<en every
other atop necessary too the entry of a valid dofault judgment.
19. On or about October 3l, 2000, the above-captioned
a~tion came before tho court os one of the CBses listed on the
purge Hat,
19. For r~asons unknown to Plaintiff and his attorneYB,
Plaintiff's attorney did not receive a copy of the pUrl/e list or
notice of the hearing until November 2, 2000 and therefore did
not attend the hearinCJ.
20. Plaintiff's couns~l waited to receive a termination
order BO that they could then proceed to open the jUdgment, but
never received one.
2l, In December, 2000, Plaintiff's counsel contacted the
Prothonotary of Cumberland County to inquire whether the above-
captioned action had been terminated and learned that it had been
5
In THB COURT or COHMON PLBAS or CUMBeRLAND coUnTY, PBnnSYLVANIA
CIVIL DIVISION - LAW
KATAR.ynA SArono,
1194 Hope Sl:r..1:
Vine land, New Jer.ey 083GO
AND
reOOR B. BAFono,
1194 Hop.. Strut
Vineland, New J_rNey OB360
Plaintith
VII,
Rosa SALAS
37BO Lot 12, Sprinq Road
Carli.le, Pa. 17013
Ilnd
BRYAN KlUTH COMP
3780 Lot l2, Bprinq Road
Carl1ul., P4, l7013
Oehndanl:.
,
,
I
,
I
,
,
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
.'
n ~ c[ I VE 0 AUO 2 8 1996
tift, II 707 (l; I,;l L.
No. 11
.fJ "1 ~(~ ..')
!' d I
, '1': ,
, : "1
.,." d
11' ,.
1/:, ,) . ':9
.~
I.. oJ' "
", .~~
r~ "..
i/..'" h
'. " - ~,
,1-.1
i' -
" ..:J
'I ~
. I N
th,
PlUUfaIPB rOR IIQHHmfa
I
TO THI PROTHONOTARY,
II IBIIUI A WRIT or SUHNON/J
II HBIRlBY PLAINTIVP(S) IS/ARB
I
IN CIVIL ACTION,
K.tarzvna Sa'ono'\ II91-"oDe Street
(NllIIIe and ailare".)
11D.!.lllnd. ~I:W Jersllv 08360 and Fltdor 5. 5a'ono'. 11941/0011 Strllllt. Vinllhnd
Nl:W Jersev 00360
AltD THB DEPENDANT/J IB/ARB RoslI :i.lu. 371lQ l.D.L12. Sotina Road. C."I hill
(N.._ .nlflUfcrre..)
I
I Pa. 170p. and Brvan Keith COIIII. 3780 Lot 12. SarI no Road. Carlf~llI. Pa.
.llQJ 3
DATil 8/21/96
I
I
EXHIBIT
I ~/1'1
ATTORN.t'a SIQHATURI
G. ChrfstoDhllr P.rrf5~. E~aufrll
PRINT NAMI: AND ADllRl/J/J
1.0. '62609
Attorney far Plafntfffs
264 E. Draad Street
PO Box 589
Dethlehl!lll. Pa. 18016
(610) 866-0973
RECEIVED SEP 19 \991
IN TIIS COURT 011' COMMON PLI!AS 011' CUMBIBRLMIO COUNTY I
CIVIL DIVISION-LAW
KI\TARMYNI\ SAFONOI1'
Phintitt
NQ, 96-4737 Civil
PI!NNSYLVANIA
g -', ')
.., 'I
'f' rn .1
~ ; ~: ' " \ '-I
f"l'Jj - ,I"
,")~ .' I .r, ~. J
., ' ,.1",)
l,~.." , '" ':,',
. " ~ J' 1,lll
~ ~'I '(,t
I' "
'~, ~ ,~
,< rd ",
VB,
ROSIS SALAS IInd
BRYAN KEITH CaMP
Ddendant/l
NOTICB
YOU ItJWB BEEN SUED IN COURT. III' YOU WIS/I 'l'0 OBII'BND MAINS'l'
THE CLAIMS SB'1' FORTH IN '1'1113 JrOLLOWING PACJES, YOU MUS'l' '1'I\KB
ACTION WI'l'HIM 'l'WP.N'l'Y (20 I DAYS AI1"1'ER '1'HIS COMPLJ\IN'1' AND NOTICE
ARB SBRVEO, BY ENTERING A WRITTEN APPBARANCB PERSONALLY OR
BY A'l'TORNEY AND JrILING IN WRITING WI'l'H '1'H1~ COUR'1' YOUR DEI1'ENSI!S
OR OBJECTIONS '1'0 'l'HE CLAnlS SE'l' FOR'l'H AGAINST YOU, YOU ARI! WARNUD
THJ\'l' IF YOU FAIL '1'0 DO SO 'l'IIE CASE MAY PROCEED WI'l'IIOU'l' YOU AND
A JUDGMEN'l' MAY ElE EN'l'ERED MAINST YOU 13'1 'l'IIE COURT WI'1'1I0U'l'
FUR'rIlER NonCE FOR ANY MONEY CLAIMI!:U IN 'rllll COMPIJ\IN'l' on
FOR ANY OTllER CLAIM OR IlBLII!:F REQUEs'rED 13'1 'rilE COMPLIAN'1' YOU
MAY LOSE MONEY 01\ PROPER'ry OR o'rllER RIGlI'rS IMPORTJ\N'l' '1'0 YOU.
YOU SIIOULD 'rAKE 'l'IIIS P}\PER TO YOUR LAWYER 1\'1' ONCE,
IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LJ\WYER OR CANNOT AJrJrORD ONE, GO ToO OR
'rELBPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTII BELOW '1'0 FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN
GET LI!GAL HBLI?,
LAWYER RBFERRAL SERVICE
Cumberlnnd County Courthouae
Court Administrator
Fourth FLoor
Carlisle, Pa, l7013
(7l71 240-6200
G. chri/ltopher Parrish, I!squire
I,D. '62609
Attorney for Plaintiff
EXHIBIT
I I'l"
IN 'l'lIJ! COURT 011' COMMON llLI!AIl 011' CUMBIBRLAND COUNTY, UNliSYLVANIA
CIVIL OIVISION~LAW
KATAR~YNA SAII'ONOII'
P],aintiff
No. 96~4?3? Civil
VS.
Rosm SALAS and
BRYAN KIUOVII COM1'
Defendllntll
COMPLl\IltT
l, Plaintiff Katarzyna Bafonof is an adult individual
residing at ll94 lIope Btceet, Vineland/ New Jer.ey 08360.
2. Defendant ROle SalaB is an adult individual reliding at
3780 Lot l2/ spring Road, Cllrl1BlII/ Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania 17013.
3, Defendant Bryan Keith Comp is an adult individual
residing at 3700 Lot 12, Spring Road, Carlisle, Cumberland
County, Pennsylvania 17013,
4, At the time of the aooident that occurred on or about
August 27, 1994/ Plaintiff Katarzyna Safonof was the owner of a
1994 Chevrolet Corvette being operated by Fedor S. Safonof,
5. At all timel relevant hereto, Defendant ROle Salal was
the owner of a 1980 Dodge Omni automobile that Wal being operated
by Defendant Bryan Keith Compo
6. At all timel relevant hereto, Defendant Bryan Keith Comp
was operating Defendant ROle Salas' automobilo with the conlent
and permission of Defendant ROle Salas and was acting as the
.'iI'ne, ..rv/tne, workman, IImploYlIe and/or uprulIntaHvll of the
Baid Defendant: Rose Salas in the furtheranue of their Interelltll,
7. Irurthn, Odendllnt Bryan Keith 00lllt3 WISB aotinl/ under the
direotion of and undar the direot lIupervision and oontrol of
Oefendant ROlle aalas.
a. On or about August 27, 1994 at or about l2128 p.m"
Fedor S. Safonof waD operating Plaintiff'lI lIIotor vehiole in a
northerly direotion on N. "anover Street 150 feet north of Clay
Street in cuml:16rland County, North Middleton 'l'oWllllhip,
Pennllylvania and oame to a stop to make a right turn into the
Hell gall IItation.
9. On or about the sarno date and time, Defendant Bryan
Keith Comp was operating Oefendant ROle Salas' motor vehiole in a
northerly direction on N. "anover street behind Plaintiff'l motor
vehicle,
lO. At the aforelAid time and plAoe, al the motor vehicles
were pOllitioned al afore laid, Defendant Bryan Keith Camp
negligently, carelellll.y, r.eckleuly operated the motor vehicle
that he cauled it to oome into oontaot and oollide with tlllll
rear of Plaintiffls vehicle operated by Bryan Keith Camp thereby
causing damage I to Plaintiff'l motor vehicle as hereinaCter let
forth.
2
11. The dO/:Quid aoold"ll: and /:..ultinq damage. 1:0
Plaintiff '. motor vehiole weu diuotly and Jjlroximately oau..d by
the n.gligeno., oarole..ne.. and reokl...n... ot Oefendant Bryan
Keith Comp that o~n.iut.d ot the following.
a, railing to op.~ate the laid motor vehiule in a eare and
prudant manne~1
b. l."ailinq to have the Illata/:' vehiole unde/:' p/:'oper und
adequate oont/:'ol,
0, Opent:ing the lS8id Illata/:' vehJ,01e at a .peed whioh Wall
high and exaee.lve for the oonditions then and the/:'e exietingl
d. Failing to apply the brake. in o/:'de/:' to avoid a
oollidonl
e, Failing to keep a reasonable lookout for othe/:'I on the
/:'oadl
t, Failing to keep a rea.onable lookout fa/:' othe/:' vehioles
lawfully using the /:'oadwaYI
g. railing to stop in the assu/:'ed ale4/:' diatanoe behind
Plaintiff's moto/:' vehiale,
h. Ope/:'4ting the aaid vehiole without due /:'ega/:'d to the
right., aafety and po.ition of other motor vehiale. upon the
roadway,
3
.t.. Violating thlt Itt.tutu of th. Clol1U1lonwulth of
hnnltylvania p.tt:ainin'il to t:h. op.....l:.Lon of motor v.hiol... under
the airoum.tAnoe. here in que.tion.
COUNT I
lWlf'l'IPP VI$ .....DJlL\LJSIUJI...GmU!
12, Plaintiff inQorporates herein by referenoe the
allegations ~et forth in paragraphlt 1 through II Above alt though
the Itame were mon fully lilt forth At length pelow.
13. As direot and proximate result of Defendant'lt
ne9ligenoe, oarelesltness and reoklesltne.., Plaintiff .ustained
propet'ty damAga to hill' vehiole in the amount of Four Thousand,
Nine Hundred, Sixteen and 77/l00 ($4,916.77) Dollar..
WHBREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment in her favor And
Againltt the Defendant. in an amount: of $4,916,77, together with
the ooets of these prooeedings and legal intere.t.
COUNT II
~INTIFF VB. ROBE SALAB
AGINCY
14. Plaintiff inoorporateo herein by referenoe the
AllegAtions set forth in paragraphs 1 through l3 hereinabove as
if the Itame were more fully set forth at length below.
l5. At All times relevant to the within oaUlte of aotion,
Defendant ROIt. Salas was the owner and maintainer of the 1980
4
ood9' OmnJ. aul:omobJ,le b.ln9 opel:lll:ed by Oefendant "ryan K,.l.I:h
Camp,
1/ lIS, At 411 timeQ rlllllvAnt to the within OllUlle of aotlr,lIl,
Pehndllnt Ilryan KeHh Comp WIlli lIot:i/l1J wi!;hin the oouru Ilnd QUOpl!
of hi~ ago/loy relatio/lQhip with Pqfo/ldant ROlle aaL4Q during the
operAtion of the aforeBllid vehicle,
l7. The aforeQaid IIccide/lt And reQulting dllmaljel and
injuriee of Plaintiff were directly II/ld proximAtely olluQed by the
ne'illigenoe, careleQQneQQ Ilnd reoklesQneQs of Defendant ROQe SALae
by And throu'ilh her agent, IIQrvant lind/or elnployee Pefo/ldllnt IlrYftn
Keith Comp ae eet forth above,
W"BREFOR~, Plaintlff demandQ judgment in her favor and
lI'i1ainst the DefendantB in an amount of ~4,9l6.77 together with
the coetQ of thue prooQedill'lll and hgal lnterellt,
COUIfT II
PLAIIfTIPF VB. ROBe B~
~BOLIGK~BIfTRUBTMEIfT
18. plaintiff incorporllteQ herein by referenoe the
allegationB Bet forth in parAgraphB 1 throu'ilh 17 hereinabove ae
if the eAme were more fully lIet forth at len'ilth below.
19. The aocident and dama'iles rellulting from the
aforementioned collision occurred all a reBult of the
careleBeneBe, recklesBnellB and ne'illigencQ of Oefendant ROle Salae
and conllillted of the followin'ill
s
a, Bntruetinq he~ motor yehiole to perendant Elryan Keith
Camp when ehe knew or ehould have known that he WAg incompetent
to drive a motor vehicle,
b. Bntrullt her m'lt'lr vehicle to Oetend"nt aryan Keith Comp
when ehe knew or ehould have known that hi. ability to operate "
motor vehJ.o le wae impaired /
c. Entrust her motor vehiole to Oefendant arYlln Kelth Comp
when shill knew or should have known that the odd motor vehicle
was not properly registered with the C'll1ul\'lnwealth of
Pennsylvania, not properly inopeoted and ineured all required by
the provi.lons of Pennsylvania Law/
d. aeing otherwiPe negligent, oarelesll and reoklellll under
the oiroumstanoes aa will be ahown at trial.
20. Aa a direot and proximate rasult of the oareleaaneaa,
reoklellllneea and negligenoe of Defendant Roae Salaa, Plaintiff
auatained injuriea and damages aa aet torth in Count I,
paragraphe l3 hereinabove,
WHEREFORE, Plaintift demanda jUdgment in her favor and
agalnet the Defendanta in an amount of $4,916.77, togrther with
the ooate of these pr'loeedings and legal interest,
ROSS, NEGRETE' SCHWARTZ, P.C.
BYI
G. Chriat'lpher parrish, Require
I,D. 162609
Att'lrney for Plaintiff
6
, ,
IN THE COURT or COMMON PLEAS or ~UMSERLAND COUNTV, PENNSVLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
~TARZYNA SArONor,
': PlaLntiCf
No. 94-4737 Civil
VI.
ROS&: SALAS Ind
,; SR'iAN K&:ITH COMP,
Oefendant
I TOI
I'
II
Oat. ot NoHcel
Bryan Keith Comp
3780 Lot 12
Sprinq Road
Carlisle, PA 17013
May l8, 1998
IMPORTANT NOTICE
'tOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAUSE 'tOU HAVE FAILED TO ENTER A WRITTEN
APPEARANCE PERSONALL't OR B't ATTORNE't AND FILE IN WRITING WITH THE
COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET FORTH AGAINST
" 'tOU. UNLESS 'tOU ACT WITHIN TEN DA'{S FROM THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE'
:: A JUDGMENT MA'{ BE ENTERED AGAINST 'tOU WITHOUT A HEARING AND '{OU MA't 1
I LOSE 'tOUR PROPERT't OR OTHER IMPORTANT RIGHTS, '{OU SHOULD TAKE THIS
NOTICE TO A LAWYER AT ONCE, Iii' 'tOU DO NOT HAVE A LAW'{ER OR CANNO'f
AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE 1i'0LLOWING OfFICE TO FIND OUT
WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Ii
II
'i
LAW'tER REfERRAL SERVICE
Cumberlond County Courthouse
Court Administrator
Fourth Flc,)or
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
,
I
II
/,
II
"
I
II
!I
1
l80l6
'I
j'i;:
',' I
'I,
, 1
;\
,,' I,~ ~.
(~'.~ ~
, .11 ~\l 'fJ ~~
\?.~ fo, ~y.
"" .f"
,~, Q
,
I
"
., II'I!,
I I
1
, I .. /
,
,
,"
'/ 1 , i ,.
!
1
, 1
,
I ,
'n
':
i I,
, i' I "
,I,
I I
,
':' 'I 1
,
I I' I I
1
Ii , ,
"
, ~
ft
1"1 ,;
;
ra
I ," ~I I
"
;1 n ~
" , .
IJl
f ~ .
-I ; II
I
as
II II
"
1./\ \\' OI'IKI. 01,
~l/\RVI~ 0, S<;II\\'AI\I /. 1',(',
1', 0, BOX ~Hl)
1111I1I1.1I1.~I.I'A 1~()lh
'I
, ,
,
'.
I
,
"
I"
I
, "
I'
it
.1
"
I
I,
,
I,
.,
Ii'
,
Ii
.rl I
Fr
Jo(!
,
,<'~\Hu;',I!'<'ri:: "I .' I
,,.,; ,>...' ,~),;l~"t:' ~j <II 41..:'1,(1...,.___
'ik!'I" of., t~ ,; 1'(
",
.
" r;
"
"
I Ii
'1 i
I
I
Ii
"
I,
HI
of \,
"
,
.
...,-1.. ...
"
~ I
,
,',
"I'
,"
II'
','1 ,;'(t
Ii ~
,! I _, Il~
1"\/
;1 i"/'ll1
'I , I,' .', ;'. I~
i.\, ,:ql
,,":1,1'
. \,
"
"
il
:'!I
tI
:,'111
,:\
"
,'i
"I
1
q'l .'
i'I,,'I:!
ji '!1
,I .1
, I
'I
"
Ji
I
~
,I' ~ ~
, , "
, , &
J,1. I-
" I c ~ 0'
e; ~ 0< ...
, , i': ~ 'f, r:.:
I [E ~ ..,J
., , C ~ ...
, C if. I:::
I ~ ,~ t'~ -
'r, ~ u.;
I -
I ~ ~ r": I:;:
If 'I - E
'il,', !.I ,II ...
, ~
, I ... a::
"
-
i ....
II Ii I"
, "
II
Iii , ;11' ,
, .~ I; "
,,:
;;j
;-1, '~r ~ .~
'i't,.".
,'., I i'.,. ,-:',
1-'" .,
'1,1\: I'Y.:~;l
I ,"~I I,' ! ,: i'1 I 'I b;-l\l\'J,",V
,I . ''1/ IIIL , ",1',' , I' f)~ Ii:,
Ii ')" J \ "\ 1 "lJ'l~
il,11, I ,'J',). l,'l"I,,}t,,:'I'lH/ :":'i.'mt'I'"
" ",tl ,,', I ,v,. '"
\ 'I'~:' III 'I d/l " I i~'f '~ ,"
r q I I" ,~J t \ I . I 'I I '~,
, ' I ' "j I' "1 I~ ~,' J \1 ~"I :llf I' .',
.' .,. '.'(', II /, I 1 'I' j \0' '\ ",IJP! Ij I ~ '
1:1/;' . [ PI,' , j I If 1'/" '"I l'.i,.i' ,n;; ,
,,',',,I,;,:,;,;,,ll:~ \{,"';:' :fr:/,I,:'~~,.::i'\:d~J~~i~\ '
'I II' j, "I,j/'t ~I\\f:,!\' ')'~h'/'~J';~llltl.!\\~
I ,) ,II >1'1,' [ ~ J,' 1\1 '11l'.J.{fh,H' .rr.J
:II!" I j -'('I)'?:I\J'\'>'I'lllj \t '~liJllr~t
.') '1 " ' j; I IJ . ~ J < lTj r ,F ,11; JJ~ ,: e
",I I, ' II rr lfl.r~ld)' f' ~ ,'l J;I'F~' ~~,T
"':'\' ~'!l' l!l. I, . IJ ",' :l'r) ,It ';\Ff' ,
il,.", , ' f '1,1 . j1~I' i'"II,11 ),I'II'~' I' ta!~~'
. I' , ~, ' I I 'j ,I. 'I' " 'J 1 J :J1I1 \
! II \ I I. If II ,I j j:'\ r "/" "fir l:)':~i\! 1U
'.1.'1' / tl\ I' JI' l Il "\JJ)t7'CM
',I', "~'I I I 'I j \! ",I f,'''' I ll~ I' r.'lJ:.flJi!l1..
" 'r]' 'I t\J:' I~ I' \. tL~',
I' ,']1111 I II" "'~)qb~~\I;"\()I~\IIAI
I' ,It ( I I , f, r. ? ,,/ "",\t.~J'.~ '
,'11 'I':J.' ,Ii' .: "~I'tLj'I~,J(:'jt:' i;tll ~\1r;v ~'\
jl,1 Ill' 1'!1 ';I;[Jltl\J/tr,.,>l ;1;~I.J",~,
, ", 'I r" ,'.t)\II\'~t I}'!' I{!(' .\I\\.t
I ".I..lll' "' '. \,1..1 , "J'
, f' "''''1/,,1.. , '{I.\c",11lc
j' , -. !. ,:".1 ' ',' I . '/:; I ~ ~l I
qt,,' ,;'( ..f. "'iil ",'IH'::Mlii;,;,','
'1 ,',' >, j",'f f$J
, ,i',
1 f'
,. ,
!/
;1
,I II
',I
"
Ii,
"
'oj
,',
,
s.. 'I
\..
Ji'1 I
"
, ,
J ,
~ .R i
~ II j . M ! ~ I
~
j" ~~
~
. I II ~ ~o ~
tJ Do...
IN '~1I11 aOUIl'l' OF COMMON l'LIIAS or OUMBIIIlr.NiP OOUNT~, PII"NB~LV^NIA
OIVIL DIVISION~L^W
K^TAR~YN^ SAVQNOV
Plaintiff
No, 9ft~47J1 Oivil
VII,
ROBI! SALIIB Ilnd
BRYAN KlH'l'lI COMl'
De fondantll
CONPLA.JIII'l!
l, Plllintiff KIltllrzyna BIlfono~ iQ an Ildult individual
r..iding ftt ll94 Hope Street, vineland/ New Jereoy 00360,
2, Defendollt nOIlO Saloll Ie an odult individual reeiding Ilt
3780 Lot l2/ Spring Hoad/ Carliole, Cumberland County,
Penneylvonio 17013.
3, PefendAnt Uryan Keith Comp il an adult individual
reeiding ot 3700 Lot 12, Spring noad, Carlisle/ Cumberlllnd
County, Pennsylvania 170l3.
4. lit the time of the oooident that ooourred on or about
August 27, 1994/ Plaintiff Kntarzyna Safonof was the owner of a
1994 Chevrolet Corvette being operated by redor S, Bafonof.
5. lit all times relevant herato, Defendant ROllt Salas wae
the owner of a 1900 Podge omni automobile that was being operated
by Defendant Bryan Keith Compo
6, lit all times relevant hereto, Defendant Bryan Keith Camp
wae operating Def.endant nose Salas' automobile with the oonsent
and permission of Defendant Rose SalaQ and wa$ aoting as the
. -",
1gent, .e~vlnt, workman, employ.. .nd/o~ ~.p~..entativ" of the
.aid Defendant Ro.e ~als. in tho fu~the~sncB of their inte~..te,
7. li'u~the~, Oetendant B~yan Keith Comp wa. acting unde~ the
di~.ction of and unde~ the direct eupervieion snd oontrol of
Defendant Roe. Bala.,
O. on or about Auguet 27, 1994 at or about 12120 p,m.,
redor B, Satonot wa. operating Plaintift'e motor vehiole in a
no~therly direotion on N, HanoVer street l50 feet north of Clay
Street in Cumberland County, North Middleton Townehip,
Penneylvania and oame to a etop to make a right turn into the
Hee. gal Itation,
9. On or about the lame date and time, Defendant Bryan
Keith Camp wal operating Defendant ROle Salal' motor vehiol. in a
northerly direotion on N. Hanover St~eet behind Plaintiff'l motor
vehiole.
10, At the aforesaid time and plaae, al the motor vehicle"
were positioned ao atorelaid, Defendant Bryan Keith Comp
negligently, oarele"lly, reoklessly opa~ated the motor vehiole
that he oaueed it to oome into oontact and oollide with the
rear ot Plaintiff'. vehiole operated by Bryan Keith Comp thereby
oausing damage. to Plaintiff'. motor vehicle as hereinafter set
forth.
2
11, The dor.lAid Aacidelll: And ruulI:ing damag.. 1:0
Plaintiff I. motor vehicle WItU direcl:ly Alld prollimately cau..,d by
th_ negligence, car.le.enee. And reckle..lle.. of nefendant Bryell
Keith Comp thaI: oOllehted of I:he followilllll
a. Failillg t,cl opllrate the .aid motor vehiole in a IA~" and
prUdent manner,
b. Failing to have the motol:' vehiole unrJel:' proper and
adequate oontrol,
c. OpentJ.lIg the .aid motol:' vehicle at A .peed which WIlQ
high and e~oe..ive for the oondition. then And there e~i.ting,
d. FAiling to Apply the brake. ill ordur to Avoid A
collidon,
e. Failing to keep a ree.onable lookout fol:' othel:'. on the
road,
f. FAiling to keep A reA.onable lookout for othel:' vehioles
lawfully u.ing the roadway,
II. FAlling to stop in the AIIsured cleu distAnce behind
Plaintiff's motol:' vehicle,
h, Operating the said vehicle wJ.thout due J:'8gud to the
I:'ight., SAfety And position of othel:' motol:' vehicles Upoll the
l:'oAdway,
3
1, Violating the .tatute. ot the Commonwealth ot
hnnltylv.l1ia pertaininlJ to the opeution of! motor nhiole. undn
th. oiroumstanoe. here in queution.
gOUIIT I
lLaIIITIPP VB. B'Y~ Kl1%H CONP
l2. Vlaintiff inoorporate~ herein by referenoe the
allegation. aet forth in paragrophs 1 through II above a. though
the aame were more fully /let forth at length below.
l3. 1\11 direot and proximate reault of Defendont' a
negligenoe, careleesness and reokleesne..., Plaintiff sUBtained
property damalJe to her vehicle in the amount of Four ThouBand,
Nine Hundred, Sixteen and 77/100 ($4,9l6,77) DollarB,
WHBRRFORB, Plaintiff demand. judgment in her favor and
aqainBt the Defendants in an amount of $4,916.77, together with
the tlosts of these prooeedingB aud legal interest;.
COUIIT II
fNAIHTIPP VB. ROBI SALAS
lWJ~
l4. Plaintiff inoorporates herein by reference the
allegat10nB Bet forth in paragraphB 1 through l3 hereinabove aB
it the eelne were more fully Bet forth at length below.
l5. At all timeB relevant to the within caUBe of aotion,
Defendant ROBe Salas was the owner an-t maintainer of tho 1980
4
Podge Omn.l. Automobile being "peuted l'Iy Pefendant Il~yan Keith
Cump.
16, At all timee rolevant to tho within oaUle of aotion,
Oefendant llry.u, Keith COlllp wile Ilotlng wlthJ.n the oouree And eoope
ot hI. agency J:olntl.onahJ.ll with Pufl/nrlant Itoae /:lalllO dudng the
operation of the IIfnroalll.d vehJ.olo.
17, The oforuaoid oooJ.dent and roeulting damllgoe and
injurioo of l'l/lilltltf WOJ:U dil:eotly Ilnd proximlltely oaulled by tho
negligenoe, onrolooanono IInd rookleoBneso of Pofundllnt Rooe 8alas
by Ilnd through her a'lont, oervllnt IIl1dlor ulllployee Polendant Dr.yan
Keith Comp aa aut tortll above.
WllnR~PORE, 1'1aJ.ntiff dOlllondo judgmont J.n hor tllvor Ilnd
againet tho lJetondantn in an nmount of 1S4,916.77 together with
the oOlltll of theBo proaeedin'1o and le'101 interellt.
CmlM....1.l
floAW.ll'F VB..-MJ.I...--ULU
1t6,LI.!iIM-.lMRUUIWf21
lB. Plaintiff inoorporoteo horein by roferenoe the
al1egationo oet forth in parngraphll 1 through 17 hereinabove ao
if the eame were more fully oet forth at length below.
19. The accident and dnmageo reoulting from the
aforementioned oollioJ.on occurred 60 a reoult at the
oareleollneoo, recklollonello and nogligence of Defendant Rose 8alas
and oonsisted of the following I
s
Il, IInt...uetin\l h.... motor vehiol,Q to Perol1dllnt a"'Ylln Keith
Comp when "h_ knew or "hould hIve known that hu wa. inoompetent
to drivlt a motor vuhiole/
b, IIntru.t her motor VQhiolo to Plttendant aryan Keith Comp
whltn "he know or ehould have known that hie ability to operote a
motor vehiole woe impaired/
0, v:ntrulIl; her motor vlIlhiole to Pefendant Ilryan Kl.lith camp
when ehlt knew or lIhould have known that the lIaid motor vlthiole
wa" not pr.operly regieterlld with the Commonwealth of
Penneylvani~, not properly inBpeoted and inllured ae requirod by
the proviBionB of Pennsylvania Low/
d, Ileing otherwioe negligent, oarelesll and reokleltll under
tha oiroumlltanoeB all will be shown at triaL.
20. As a diroot Bnd proximate reoult of the Ol.lrelOllenllllll,
r.eoklllunllllB and nogJ.i'1onoe of Oefendant ROlle Slllall, Plaintiff
eUlltained injuries Bnd damageB aB Bet forth in Count I,
paragraphB 13 hereinabove.
WHV:RErORE, Plaintiff demandB judgment in her favor and
againBt the OofendantB in an Bmount of $4,916.77, together with
the ooatB of theBe prooeedingB and legal intereBt.
ROSS, NJFv"'r~ i S~I~~Jl P. C .
By I '. ( Ji. " ~ .
0.' Chrht<)pller. Parr EBquire
1.0. .62609
Attorney for Plaintiff
6
, I
II
"
!.i
" ,
I' CD ,~. "
''N ; , , I. I"~
~ " " .,
I! , , , , , "
I " ,',' "
E ,/i , ,
I, "
i II 'II " if :.1 'iI
" , i'
In , I ! ,L,!
- " ., , /'
I r II, , " , !
,'I 'I. , . ~ j j
" i ;, "I
~.. - , I
Ii ~I , '"
, " /'
, ,,I " 'I pI,
\1 i ;) ,
I, , 1, ;" It 1.1
I II II
" , , "
'Ii Ii
" I , i
, , I
,
11.'
,;~ "
',/ &,
',I
II ;
!. I
., I
h
;1
' , ~
'I' !;'
I~ .
I' ~
I
,I . I
, '
G
~~
.~
~I-'
C ~ ,~
~ ,.... ~ ~
E~~~~
c~~Q
, ,-
~c-c
~~a.:t:;i
- - -
.... ,...-
~ ~
~ (.t:
-
.....
<;;
-
ri
I:
i'i
'I
,
,'J
l ;1
'I
,
,
,
,
,
'.'t
I'
"
I'"
l'i!
I it!
,
"
1,1
'II
"
'I
I
,
,
, ,
,
,', , "
,r 'I
I, ' ,~ ''I
, 'I
,
,)
,
q
, ')
I;
"
q'l
'\
,
f
"
/
"
"
';'1' ,1]1
,
"
" ,
)'
1'"
'lit
~ 'I}
,
, I
1'1' ,
"
"
.
.,~
, ,
~ "
It',
,r.,f,'
,";" I',
,'t"
.~ ~~ t
I" :J
.'
(,' i~ f.1
" , l~
y~, '."' t,' ft.
'" ,
Ii 1'1, '1.-\
, I ,.
I ..~ , "'J
, - )n
V'
.J:j iJr.
, '1
I' .f." r. '
I.:; I,;.)
,
'.
\-
'-....
','
,I
,/
"
,
,
"
: I
,
,
I!
"'<II
IO::~
,
)
>
',I
, ,
I,
J!
r: ,
"
, ,
," " ,j'l "
, , ,
, ,
, ,
I I
II , , "
"
~.~ "
'II ',J" ,
L, I, ~,
".
". , ~ ~
,
I', I;'
'i, I
,. ~ ::::
1
. , '\ ~ ~.
ili I ~~ t
I" 1,1 ).
!..
"",
"J ~
"~
,
,
, ,
I,
'I'" ,-. ,,'
:j)
"
I, 01
.'v ~
,.
"
li