HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-04800
, I ,
.! I'
, i ,,' I I' 'I il"
I , , " "1 "
I '!-. , "I I , ,I "
,I , "
'I, i-, /11' " .,
" " " .,., q 1', ,
L ". I I " ," " ;,,1 ,)'1 "
)Ii
I! " ,I ,I' ,r , l' I 'I
" il11 ,I" " ,I q '-il ,
I "
. I I'
~ ij
~~ ~ ~51
J d ~~ . .I~e ~
I i~ j .
.1 i .. J 5 I
..' t J 3 II ~ ~
,8 ~ J, ~ 'fi
I Id. ~i ~ "~~ ~I
. ~ i!~, @H
... ...
11ItI':I.II'I,'.:i Iii: I'Ilhll
III<I,'II,/.b
'/Iii" III/I l'I'lh~\lHI\"'WI I"
:,:\lm'i~WI'itlll:lh1',II"li\'.~11l\~i'I\.'1 /Ill I /II
Itll!Jh)L I:JIM!,)!;\! .1:: r t\), ~~..
Vii.
1'I.l',!)\.IMfI Ill/HI 1';r..AJ"....
. rl/llJ1'lIt II uaJ'il:, ....._...,' HIIIII'dl or [IIIIHJly \ihOllrlfl, .:,1
(1,1I11H>:1I\./l1I1J 1:01lInl.y, ""nl\l,'/I"lInlll, 1/11'; hN'~nlJ ,jIIIYUII''H1l <1'71:",,0111'1\)
III lilli, 'il'YIlI, thw wl.tlnn WIUJ:.IJI'"..li1lJ1l1JJ/J1j..., , " II 'HI "'''''/lV1.l
"poll JlI';)::~!..JlE':'lJflJllLk.l\!;liJJlilll1'MU:'!~..,. .. 1.11."
oj" i ,mdunl., ~ I; O;J1l11fI1/l Itl.JllI\\~, un 11111 . ![',l,ll dIll' Ii r \JII II I..IJ!IIIl.\lL.... ...,,, " ----............
I ~I',!\, i.jILl.J. UJ:;JI'J:Y.NlltIJ.UJI: .. . ~p , . ....... .....,..-.>+.....' ....-
1,:f\lH,llll.,I';, l'A.17\'llJ.... .,.... ". .,w." .~._"" ~...,...' 1;IJJ1JI)~liJ.M.W,......-_..'
1;'I'JII',y, l'III1I1I11'1L'/IIIlIII. 11'1 lI'IlIdllll.l I.... IUI.IJMW Jjhl';l'.-....-..~...,.._"-_.,...-,,,._.,...'" ......
u l.nlL' and Ill;t.lsiIIl;1l11 l;up>1 ",r UH' "WJllT..I.W .\llH1l11J1l1L, ",'T" ..~..d.w "......,
tllld ul I:lll! 11.,1111.1 \\11I11> dH'IU,;,I;111I.1 HIIJ \II I,lInl,I'JII ,:,', thlll ''''JIII.li/nl;fI.l l;h"rlil':Jf,
Hhl\'rs,O'lll I~OI!J"'iI
IJIII!IIIjIt.ll\li1
!'''I''''Hr.!~
/It f\.,jq'lll;
~'IJI~r.~hlcll.la."
HI:J "n"WIfI~1f Ir&: ~...
'1. I~~' .-!I"'l
.l,;!~~ r" """~ ,,"'
~: ~~ rr;'Tl]o'iij,',jCl' 'HIT,'"i,. "lhL i t cr...'..... ..-...-.-
nl.',;!0"llljAU.15 \11')111.: i"I)IH"li',' " 11'-,(,.,1)1.1'.'(
on'il"/:,'~ril:) J . -- 1.
. III.t11i,id
!~\/"I'n nndl1i'1IHNI'I,\JlildlU 1)11'('"1''' "'"
1.11I,11i "l.~,~. rillY "t. ~(J-'[[,"""'" ,,'
I',) .d'/~d'. /I, P.
. ,i. t,t..... (~...121l!.. .I" " ,JJ.~'T.",.. ~
~, fJr'J ;)IJ~.r~'
I III I"I'-'I-'IH I dId..,. ~hll'~'III-'IM
'1I~1I4 'I~ thl' PI Ill~. lit...
..' I ,/I d 1I~ t ~ ~t. "1 "" '1/' /IotJ
'1,._ ~
('\ IAI~I.l\K ANI) \lAI~\lAI~A Illll\l\I~,
Ilhllllllll'K
IN 'I'll\!. C()Uwr ()If ('OMMON I'I.HAK ()Ii
('llMIll!IU.ANIl ('OUNTY, III'.NNKYI.V MIlA
v
NO l)l)..ulllll ('IVII. THI~M
C'\VIl. ACTIUN ,I,AW
I'\.P.ASANT INNS, SlIIIFI~ K
MOTHI., IN" , 1~1('IIAlm I~PVI) III
i\HSOC'lATFS,I' (' lI11ll AMIIIU
MOUIl.ln' INTP.I~N^TlUN^,., INt',
llufUI\lllllllK
Jl!I~Y TI~IAI. UF TWI'.I,Vl! IlLtMANPl!I)
1'llAl!('I\Il!.
TO TIlE l'IUlTllllN(),\, AI~ Y UF ('lIM\ll\I~\.ANIl COUNTY
[I,lIIur lhu IIPllullnll\l:U llf MAlnSON, IlHMI>OIWI', WIU.IAMK lit OTTO III b~h~lr lll'
l>~Ii:mh\ll1 1~lcllI\I'(ll~uu,1 & A~KlIChlIUK, ,,(' In Ilw IIhllW I\llll\ur l>uli:lldlllll hereby delll~lId~ II
lwelw Imlll' jllry nllllIII lhe IIhllW CII11I\1lIlUlIIICllulI
MAlnSON, m(AlmOI~FF, WII.\.IAMK IlL OTTO
r) I/'J, ')~.
ay -_.-t:~, -'-. /~\---_._---"
(lcurlll!' h Fllller, II' , n. IIIIN
III Nll 0\'11113
TUIIl!IIKlllIl!,h Slruul
ClItllKlc, I' A 170 \ 3
(717) :M3.3HI
A\lllI'llCYK I'llI' IMi.!l\d11ll1
1~lchllrd I~ced IlL AK611c\lIle~. IIC.
Pllled: Sep\oll\bcr ~5. 1996
I h~roby \tlI11\1~ IhRI R ~l)I'Y ll\'lhu lillUIlUIIl~ !'mud\lu WUK KUIWd IhlK dlllU by d~llLlK\lIII~ KRIlIU
IlIlhlt I'"al ()O\~u III ('RrIlKlu.I''\. IIrKI c\uu llIull, \l"~\lII!U \llu\lllhl. IIddlUKKUd ilK 1'lllluWK
Hdw1I1I11 K\\khur, 1:.~l\ullu
IHNH~.IU)M\l., ('l)I\\ISI\" & Mer ,,"I..1W
\ 21111 IlllllI' I'ulln ('Ulllur I'lnfll
I'hlhl,lu\\lhlll, I'" 11)11),\
1'luUMIIIIIIIII~, SU\lur 1\1\I11IL:1, Il\u
\ 1100 I \lIlTl~hUl'~ l'lk\!
('ullI~I\!, 1''' 1701]
,\llIl~l) MllhllllY 11I1\!1'I1111111IlIII, IlIu.
MI"] l)1>;llIllIllhwIIY
al'ld~lIl'11I'I, !\i\ 0\11722
M'\I~'\'~,~J 1~)~^lmOI~Ullr... WII.J.I,\MS & 0'1''1'0
;.~;\ . } 1Z/
n /~ I. ///f~'
Y~~_'___"""___'__ ,-1--"
(lulIr!!1l n 11111111r, Ir. ' 11I11'1l
'\'UIII!II~1 III!!h Sll'eel,!
('lIrll~le. 1''' \ 701]
(717) 2.\].]]0\\
"'\llfllllY~ I~)r Pcli:lldlll\l
1~1c\\Rl'd I~ued 8: "~~llC\IIIl!K. I',C,
Dilled: Selllelllbur ~~; 11196
,'}.
t."i
-
, .,
" -
I! III
I , I -
, '1
I :i
, ,
,I:
I, I '! ' t
I I., ~
, , "
, " , j
It
, I r
q
I,
~ l
Ii
,
,
,[
tl
, , I
r r,J1' 1'1 'I
.I
{J;":: 0/1
rIJ ,Jt"j
f'r
I:, t. "'Ji)
t. .) i~
ql ... '.', , I ,
I' - J~. ,
(I:' t!
I 1(11
I I (I 'J
I
lil '.)
0".
l'1
, ,
t~ I !
Il~~~
~ ti:1
J~ I
to;:;
'II
,
" I
, ,
r.~: il1) :.t ~
..,'t
I r! ~; I \ ,
1"'1,:, ,
'" , , 1.:1
.>1
IiI' ~. 'Ij
",., ,
/, I. [:, Ill!
' ,
..
Li_ lli ,\
r. ) Iii
I Ii
\
"
I:
,',
i'
t':
"
Ill, 1I~~ulI~~ Ill' I'luIIlIII'l', l'hul'k~ IllIh~I"~, ,1Ih1lhllll)', h... I~ CIIIlIlIl~L) hlU \lh~~lchUII' UtH)
1I~~~ U 111111111'1/11,1 IlIl1hllll)' whlcl~ IIIUllllfuCIIII'~LI h)' AIIIII!II I\lllhllll~' IillUI'IIlIII'lIlul, Inc.. which
hUIII'~ II ~~l'lullllllllhul' AI\IIIIIJII7Hcl.
II, 011'11' uhulIl AIII!II~I ,111. 1'/11,1, I'lullllll"', l'hurl\!N Iluh...I', WUN ~xltllll! hlN I'lIIIIlI \\'hllll
JulN mllhlllty curl, 111111 IIpllll 1III'IIIIlH hllhu I'll/hi, Ih... cull Ncul Nlllv\!I...LI hll/W I~n h~CUIIN~ Ill' Ull
IlIlpl'llpCI' Iucllu~ III Ihu hl,lc\\IIII" plnpulllnl,1 him .Inhl Iho: ~1.Ic\\ulk,
12, AI ullllmu~ 1'0:10:\'11111 hO:I'UIU, I 100lim<lulll, I'ku~ulll IIlIIN, SUPUI' H MIII~I, Ille.. ~hllll)<1
hllw ImuII'1l Ill' Ilw 1III11l"IpO:I' Nlupo: .Ii' Ih\! NI')U\IUlli. IIN .1\!vlullllll fl'lIm Ilw lllll<lelln~~ Ill' Ihe
AII1O:l'lcull NUlhllllll SIIIIl.tUI'<IN IIlNlllul~ (ANlil) UIlLllhu 1'l'lIpI!IlNIt)' Ill' Ih~ IIlllhllll)' ~UI'I'i~1' N~ullll
~\\I\'III \\h~1l IIn uu Illdll....,
cu.uJlU
IJ, I'lullIIll1', ('hul'l\!N IIl1h~l'. IWl'uh)' IIlCIII'pnl'llh:N ullel/UllllllN c.mllllll~d III I'hulllrlcul
I'lIrul!l'Uph~ ) Ihl'llUl!h 12 UN If full)' Nul .1111 hUI'~lu,
,.., TIll! ull)l'ulll~llll11nc,1 IlldJunl I'cNIIII~,1 1'1'11111 IllI! llulIlIl!cllc~ Ill' Ih\! Def~ndul1l~, Ihelr
1I1!~1I1N. O:lIlplll)'\!~N ulld/1I1' I'CpI'CNCllhlll\'o.'N. ItIld \IUN IUUll mUIlUCI' WhulNIICWl' .tll~ 10 UIl)' ucl llr
1I11llNNIllll nil Ih... pUl'lllf I'lullnll'l', Chill'lO:N Iluhul',
15, I Mi:nJuul, I'Io:i1sulll lUllS, SlIpUI' H l\tllld, Ill":.. \\UN uUI!III!~lllln Ihul:
u, IIw slLlu\\ulli slllpu \IUS Illll Slcup;
h, 1l1U1'~ \IllS ill) luv\!1 lilllLllulJ. lIulsl,l\! Ih\! LIllOI' 10 I~lllllll 302 und Iher~ IN UIl
cseeNNlwl)' sleup rump whel'l: U i...wlluudllll! UlIlllllulluuwrllllluruu Nhould
hu~ Ulld
3
LJ, Ihl/ wl'llI:n1 ,ll'lIp 1I11h'l ,111111' hI Ilmllll ,102 1I~III1I1L1K Ihl/ 1ll1l~11I1l1I1l II1111Wlld
h~ ANSI KIIIIIIllIl'dK,
1/, Ihl/ Kldl/wlllli IK III \'llIllIlllm 1IIIh IhL! AIIWIII.'IIIIK Wllh I llKllhlllllL!K Acl III'
I 'JIll) AIICL!KKlhllh)' lIlIl,llIlhwK III' lIulI,lIllUh IIl1d FllclIlIll.!h,
Ill, I III I'll II tI II II I , Itlchlll'LlltclILI ,II.:. AhM11.!11I11Ih,1' ,l'" plllPlllll,llhl.! 1'IIIInll If K hpllclllclIll'IIlK
IIl'lhll KltllIWlllk IiII' ilK Illllhl I'IICL!IllIWllllhll'lIclIllll 1II11llitIIUI'L! hi dl.!KIUII h II'lIhlll ANSI Ill' AIM
glll,ldlllllh,
17, IMimLlIIIll. Amll/.Il Mllhllll)' 11I1L!1'II11111l1l1l1, 1111.'" II'IIK 1IL!I/.IIUIIIlIIII Ihllli
II, IhL! 11'1I1'IIII1I/.K 1111 Ihlllll'lhllll)' Ichlck 111'11 \\1'1111111111 hllllllIlL!IlIlI'K IIIlLI pllll/lIll
Ill/III' IIIll 1'L!1Il III Ihll hllKI.! Ill' Ilw hlL!L!l'hll\ clllullllI whlll'll II I/lIlllllll hll hllllll
I\'hllll ,11'1\'1111/. Ihll I/nrl; IIl1d
[" Ill/II hili' IhL! IlIhIIIlI/IIIlIlIIUIIlUIIIIlIII' lhL! 11'111'111111/. IIl1lhl/ I/III'IIIlIlK Ihl/ IIplll'lIllll'
hllw hI dL!llIl'IlIillL! 1\ hllll Ihll hlllpl.! L!SCl/lldK Ihl.! I: I::! 11'111'1I111" III' Ihlll 1111
1'lIlllpK Ill' Kldl.!lI'lIlkK Illll)' 11111 1ll1.!1.!1 li!dl/l'iIl KIIIIl.lllnIK,
I H, AK II dll'l.!l/l IIlld PI'IlSIIllIIII.! II.!KlIII Ill' Ilw Iwglll/.l.!lIllll .11' llw 1J1l1i!lIdlllllh, 1I1lLIIlIICh .11'
lhlllll, 1'IIIIIllllr, t'hllrlllK IIl1hlll', 11'lIh Ihl'llll'lllhll11 hlK Illllhllll)' whlcllllllld kllllclill.IIIIII/.lIlhclllllh,
I'IlKulllllg In Ihll Illllld 1'111' 1ll1l.lIc II 1 111111111111111 II lid U h'II'IIlUS IIslIccl'hlllhlllllr his MlIhlplll Scllll"lhIK,
II), As U rlll'lhlll' dllllel IIl1d pl'lISlllllllL! I'lIhUllllrlhlllll.![lII[lllnl.'l/ IIrlhlllll/l'lllllllllllK,Ulld L!lIl/h
Ill'lhllllt, 1'111111111'1: t'hUl'lIlh Iluhlll"K, 1/1l1ll1 II I 1111 hUK C1I11I11IUI/.IIII dL!llll'llIl'IIlL!, rll'luh'llll/. rllll-Ihllll
hll1l1ll IWllllh 1/111'11,
4
211, AN II l\II'lh~I' dll'~~IIIIILI pl'llShlllll~ I'~~\l1t lll'llw 1l~IlIIU~llw 1I1'lhu I )~lillldlllll~. IIIILI Ulluh
lll'lhum, 11111111111'1', ('hllrl~s II\lh~I', 11II~ Nllllin~LI II IIIN~ III' ~1I1'1111l1l~ IIIlLlltllplllnlllltlllll' his UIII'IIIIIII
ullpllult~, 1111 hI hl~ d~ll'hllUIII 1I1ll1111~S,
WIII;I~I'FOHI:, 1'IIIIIllllf, ('ltlll'luN IIllh~I', IIUllllllld~ .IIlIIUIIWIlI IIUllhlsllhll I )ulimdlllllK, IIl1d
Ulluh Ill' Ihum, lill' 1IIIIl1lll!e III 1111 IIl1luIIIlI IIduLIIIlIlLI III Ullmp~llslllll him IIII' his 11l.l1l1'1~N IIlld 1'111' 1111
IIlh~I' .Iusllllld pl'lIpUl' I'eIILll'11I Ihe IWIIIIN~N,
CilluuJ1
21. 1'IIIIIIIIIf, 1IIII'hlll'll IIllhul', hUI'ull)' hlUlll'pllrlll~K 1l1l~III1IIIlIlK ~lllllllhllld III rhulllrlulIl
l'III'llIlI'lIphs I Ihrllllllh 12 IIN If full)' sullllll hUI'ulll,
22, AIIIIIIIIllUN I'Ulul'II111 hllhu IIlilruSllld IIUllulI, 1'11I11I1I1f, 111II'hlll'lllluhuI', hllK buulllllld
UIlIllhlllU~ hi hu 1ll1l1'r1ud III II lid 111'11111 Illth 1'11I11I111f, l'hllrlus IIl1huI',
2,1, As II dl,wI IIl1d prllslllllllU I'I'SUIt ul' Ihu lIul!II111'I1UU III' Ihe lluli!I\\IIIIIIK, IIlld ullch III'
Ihum, I'llIhllll'f, Ilmhllrll IllIhcl'. hilS hecll deprived III' Ilw ~ul'l'kuN, MllIiul)', IINNI~IIIIIUII, suppllrl,
uumplmlulIship ulld cLlIlsnnlUIll III'hul' hushlllld, 1'llIllllllf,l'hllrlUS Iluhlll',1I1ll1 such duprll'lIllulllllld
11ll1'lllnlllllll will COIIIIIlUU III Ihu 1'lIll1ru. In Ihu dUIl'hnulll IIl1d Inss III' 1'111111111'1', II IIl'bll I'll Hubul',
14, As II Iilrlhul' dll'uUllllld ptllslllllllU I'usult ul'lhu lIugllllllllcU IIl'lhu Ikli!l\llllnls, IIl1d ulluh
nrlhum. 1'111111111"', Illll'hlll'lllluhul'. hilS suni!l'ud IIl1d will CUIIIIIIUU III suni!1' Ihllll 1'111111111'1', Chllrlus
IIl1hul"S, Inss IIr elll'lllllgs ulld/III' UIII'IlIIlII cUPIIUlty, IIl1d 1\'111 ulllllIllIIU hi sllni!I' Ihllll his IIINN III'
UIII'IlIIIIIS IIl1d UlIl'Ilhlll cUPllulty III Ihu I'll IU I'U ,
WIII'IU~FOI~I:, 1'IIIIIIlllf, Illlrhlll'lllluhul', dUlllllllds .IudJ,!IllUIII /I1!II111Sl1lw IluI'ulldlllllS, I\llU
ulluh III' Ihum, IiiI' dllmullu III UII UllllllIlll udullUUlu lu cumpulIslIlU hur IiII' hur IlIjllrluK ulld 1'111' 1111
l\lhUI' .Il1sllIlIll pl'lllwr rullul' III Ihu pl'ullllscs,
~
, 1
t~' III '4- ;1
I; to" "
~jd' 'I.
~Jj
'"
~.I! I
II ..,
hi,' ~I', "
"", ( 'II
".,' I '
r .': : . , ,
I!J 1',1 t,'
<.II tJ
. .
:t
I
I
II
1 1111 h 1,0\1 "'111 ' I 1,1 ~ I' ~'Il ......1.1> I Ill!
, ..,.11,1 ,'I "~ ~, lilli' AM
till III ,I t'j I', ~'I" II... '" tJ
I".~ ..
C1IAI~1 mi IIl1lt II^,~IIAI~A 1II/IIHIl,
!'llIlmlnk
IN TIIH ('()llln 011 ('OMMON I'WAIl cur
ClIMllI!Ill.ANI> ('OIINTY, I'HNNIiYI,VANIA
v
I'IJ!A/iANT INNS, SLJ!'E1l Ii
MOTEL, 11'1(' , Illl'lIMI> IlHlI1> 11/
ASSO('IA'I'I~S. I'c' 1111I1 AMle,o
MOIIIl.rn' INTHllNATIONAl., 11'1(' ,
IM~I1Ltlll1li
('IVII. ACTION . LAW
NO %.,Ilillll
HIllY TI~IAI. OF TWHI.VE I>HMANUHIl
AlS~FIl Wlnl.lS~MATTEJUJ.llI!J.:LSJJ.ANr IUe'IlAIU> 'lEED & ASti.u.aA'JJi.ti..J!.C.
'I'l): CIIAHLI':H ANll IIAIUlAIU\ lllllllm, 1'11I11l111l'K, IIlld I hUll' 1I11111'IlUY ,/OHIWll ,/.
1U,:rHWlmCl, li:HC/llIlUo:
YOll Aim JUo:lUmy NO'I'WlI':1l '1'0 1"11,1': A WIU'lvn:N IlJo:H 1'01'1 Ii Joi '1'0 '1'1 IIi:
Ir.NCI.OHJo:D ANHWlm WI'I'1l Nlj:W MNlYI'lm m:FI':NllAN'I' IUCllAllll rmlr.ll &
AHHOCJA'I'mH, I',C, WI'I'IIIN 'I'WI~N'I'Y I:lOI llAYH I"IIOM HJo:ttvICI'; 11I':IUi!ew elH A
,JLmClMI~N'I' MAY III': J':N'I'lmlm ACIAINH'I' YOll,
1.,\ AllcI' rClliullllhlc II1WillHllllul1, thc 1IIIIIVCdl1/!. I M~l1dlll1l II IVlthlllll kl1LlIVlcduc Lll'
1I11'lIlllllllLll1 illl1klC'lIlLllilllllll hcllcl'lIK III Ihc 1I'lIlh ur li,lhlly Lll'thc IIVCl'll1Cmi Il1lhcic plll'lll/.rIIphh
Thc IIvcnllcnu II1'C IhcI'cl,'rC declllcd dCl1lcd IIl1d pI''''''' II dCl1l1l1llled
01 Adllllttcd
s. Aller I'CIIKUl1l1hlc II1VCIlll/.lIllul1, the IIl1hIVCI'II1U IMimdlll1tlh wlthulll kl1Llwlcduc UI'
Inlill'lllllllllll hutlldcllllll I.mllll hellcl'lIK ILl Ihe tl'Ulh UI' lillill)' ul' Ihc IIWl'IllCI11i II11hlK IlllrllUrIIllh
Thl! IIVCl'lllelllK IIrl! thcrcl,'rc decllled dCl1lcd IIl1d Ilrlllll'lK dCllllll1dcd
(1.12 Dcnlcd IlllrMlllllltu I'll Il (' I' I02'/le)
LOLJNTl
1.1 Thl! IIWnllCl1ti ul'llllrlll/.r11llhh 1.12 "I' lhlK AI1KIVCr IIru hCI'chy Il1cuI'llul'Illed hy
I'elerence.
101. DCI11ed IlllrKlllll1ltu I'll I~ (' I' I02'/IIl)
I S The IIWI'Ill11l1th "I'thli Illlrlll!rllllh reler tu ulllIl'ty ulhel' llllll1lhu uluwcrlni Dulendnlll
und thcruliJrl! I1U rCillUI1KC Ii rClllIlrclt Tu thc CXICllI U I'I!KllunKI! limy hI! dUl!llled rellulrlld, lhlK
Ilvcrlllelllls dl!nll!d
16 Denied 1111 I'KIlII II I III I'u I~ (' I' 11l2'/le).
17 Thu IIVlllllIUIllH ul'lhlH 111II'II/lrllflh I'utilr III II fllllW lllhur 1IIIIIIIhu llllHWUl'llI1I Dulimdlllll
1IIllllhul'ulill'U 1I11 rUKl'ulIHU IH I'UlIllhul1 'I'll Ihll ~NlulIl II I'UHflllllHU 1I111Y hll duullwd l'u1lulrud, IhlK
IIwrnl~IIIIH lIulllu\1.
I K.211 l>ulllutl pll 1'N11 II II I 10 I'll I~ [' I' I O~lj(U)
Wlll:'~I~I'lIl(I', IluI~ntllllllltkhnlllltuutl &. ^KMI~IIIIUH, I' C' r.lUlIllllldH JUd/llllUlllllllrH n'Yllr
1\1111 r.lIKIIlIKKllluI'PlllhIlIWs ('olllplllllll wllh plujlltlku
L:illJNLll
21 Thu IIVUllllunl~ III' Pllllllllllphs '.1201' IhlK ^"HWUI' 111'11 huruby 11I~lll'fllll'lllud by
rlltill'UIICU.
22.2,' l>ulllutI plll'KlIlIl1I hi PII It [' P 1I)2'1(e)
Wlll.!lU~FOltE, Ilelcntlllnlltkhllllllteetl &. ^SMlcllllUK, I'C, dUlI1l1ndK JudlllllUlIIllllrH nlYUI'
111111 IIIHlI1lUlIlul'PllIhlllWs ('olllpllIllI1 wllh PluJlldku
t:/~W.MATTUt
25. 1'llIlnllWK ('olllplllltllls hllnd hI' Pl'llnllll's ~llIlll'lhlllUI'Y 'II' clllllpllrnllw llul!lIlluncu
2cJ, 1'IIIInlllr IIsMlllled Ihc II~I, III' his inJlIl'lcs
27. PlllhlllWK ('Illllpllllllllillls III slllle ClIlI~C ol'lI~llollllpOI1 which I'ullul'wllllld bUl!l'Ill1lud
lIl!lIlnHt RIlHwurll1l! l>elcl1dlll1l.
2N PllIlllIlll's ('ulllpllllll1 Is hlllled hI' the ~11I1111e ol'lIl11ltllllollK
NEW MATTER PURSUANT TO PA R (' J!....22.llidl
rhllrluK 1I1JJJ..lliu.llJlJJLlJ.ulli:1 v Pluu~'iJ1iJJuJJ;~lIlJpur Il Molcl. lll~ ,
Rlchurd Ruud &. ASjll.\JJll.l:1i, P C uluJ.AJIlJU1l.M.obJJil,y.Jmclllullollul. lll~,
21) The 11Vl!III1CI1I~ Ilfl'llIlnllll's ('llll1pllllnl. \vhich IIvcnncnls hllvu hucn spucll1ulllly
del1led,lIl'e hurehy In~lllpllrnlcd 1<11' Ihc Inllllcd pllrpllSC Ilflhls cIlls~c111111l
30, 1I'I'IIIII1111rls elllillcd 1'1 ICl'lIVCr lillll1l1ny P"IlY, whkh is cxplus~ly dun Iud, Ihelllhe
llther Pclcl1dul1ls IIIC ullll1u lIuhlc h) 1'llIlnlll1'lIr Iluhlu ,Ivcr Illllufundlllllltlcllllld Ruutl &. ^sKoclulUK,
I'.e. by WilY of conllihlllllln und/1I1 Indulllnlly Ill' Ine Jlllnlly und/Ilr scvcrnlly lIublu to Dufcl1dul11
Rlchllrd Ruud &. ^~M)cilll~s, P (' 1111 IICCllllnl of their Ilwn l1ugllgullcu 01' Illhul' IIl1hlllty produclnll
conducllls IIllullUd Inlhu pluudlngK
'"
II ....
tl'{' ,..:j t'j
"" ')
1;/ ',' 1,'11
II: '/;';1
"J
~III' ,II' I: "
hI "''1
1',.1' t /,'
I' ;,'11
1\ / , 1,1
[./; I
,)
I )
I,
tl
J~ I d
"
, !
'i ,
, I
"
.
>4, AIlur rmn/luhlu hwuillyulln/l, IMu/ll/ullI I'IUUbu/l1 III/li Ii wlthoul k/lowlul/yu or
I/lIim/llllllll bUrn~IUlllln "nrlll U hullu" IIi In Ihu Irlllh nt Ihu ulluli"llnJli ~llIIlulllul/ 1/ll'urullrullh >4, u/ll/
l!rIlIlt Ihurunf Ii l/ulllulIl/el/,
5, Aller rmnlluhlu IlIveillyulln/l, IMuIII/1I11! I'lullblllll hlllb Ii wllhllllt klluwlul/llu ur
IIIIim/lullnll bllm~lulll In "nrlll II hullur Ui III Ihu trlllh n" Ihu UIIU/lUlhlllb ~nlllulllul/ 1/1 l'uruyrul,h 5, 0111/
prout Ihuruo,.li I/rlllullllel/,
1\, IJu/llel/ Ui bllllel/, Allhnll/lh II Ii 1I1/III111ul/ Ihllll'IIIIIIII"" Churleb lIuher ~hu~kel/ 111I0 iull/
Mnlel, II Ii uverrel/ 11M Mlllellb 1/ll/upulIl/uIIII~ nWllul/ U/I~ nllerulel/ h~ IMelll/ullll'IeUbUIlIIII/li u/ll/er
Ihu 1I0lllu "Sul,ur H Mnlu!."
7, Pe/llud IlUrillllllllnl'lI,Il.C,I', IU21)(u),
K. Pe/lled Illlnlllllll hI 1'1I,Il.C,I', IU29(u),
y, Pellled Ui bllllud, II~ WU~ n" unbwur, IIlb ul/lllll1el/ Ihll Puflllll/ulllltllllll ,\\ AnllelulCl
L111/ I/eilllll ullarullo/li IOlhu 1i1~lIlllui,
10. Pallled pUriUU/l1 10 1'1I,Il.C, I'. I(21)(u),
II, Pelllel/ IMillnllllol'll,ltC,I'. 1ll29(u),
12, Pelllel/ pUriUu/lIIO l'u,ltC,ll. 1029(q).
COUN1' I
13, By WII~ or u/liWer, IJufe/ld1l1ll l'lrllaulll 1/llli hltorpOl'1I11l. herrl/l by rUrlll'll/lta, Ihll
nvcrlllelll. 1I11L1l/cllllIl. tolllnl/lel/ III "ornyrnphu Ilhrollyh 12 or Ihl. A/liWllr IIl1d Naw Mllllllr,
14, Pellled purliuollllo "o.ltC,", I021J(e),
15. Pllnlllll PUrJiuu/lllo "",ItC,". 1 02Y(II) ,
-2-
ItH7, Thu /lVatIJlUllli iallimh IIII'/lr/lyruphl Ih 1I11~ 17 111'1'1/111111"'1' t'lIl11pl/l11ll ~1I11111 putl/llll
10 llerall~/lIIII'le/lI/l1l111l1l1 NII~ 1111 /lmwur II rallllltad ulI~ur Iha /lllpllc/lhlu rlllub ul' CIVlllltUC'~Ut/l, To
111/1 /I~I'1Il /III /llIllVer II rellulte~, Ihay /lte dUlllulll'UtIU/lIIIIUI'/I,ll,C,I', 11I~lJlu),
Ill. I.lulllud purlulIllIllIl'lI,ll,C,I', 11I2'}lu),
III. l)ellled purlulIlIllul'/I,ll.C,I', 1U2')la),
~1I. I.lelllu~ purlUlIlI1III 1'11,11.C,I', 11I21)(u),
WllIlltl!JlOllJ!, lJulilll~lIlIll'lallblllllllllll 1)1' Alllurlu/I, IlIe, tQIPQutf\JIl~ t.quuI'1 ~llur Ilollorllblu
CllUtllo dllllllu 1'1/1111111'1'.' ClllIIl'I/l11II whhuuI (lIilur JUdYlllullt hili,
CnUN'1' II
~ I. lly W/l~ III' IIl1iwUr, I)u"ulldlllll PIUllillll1 hllli IIIUlltPllrulUN hurullI hy rel'eralluu, Iha
/lVermellll IIl1ddelll/lli (1I11111111Ud III I'lIrllyrllphl Ilhrlluyh 211 Ill' Ihll Alliwur IIlId Nuw Mllllur,
22, Aller rmlllluhlu IIIYUilIYlIlllIlI, J}ul'ulldlllll I'lumlll IlIIu II wllhllul kllowludyu ur
IlIrurm/lllllll IUrnUIUlI1 hI I'll rill /I hullel' III III Ihe IrUlh 01' Ihu IIverlllulIli uUlllulllu\I 11I1'/lr/lyrul,1I 22. Alld
pt/lof Ihureor II delllulldud,
~3. I.lullled pUrlU/l1I111l 1'1I,ltC,I', 1(21)(u),
~4. Punlud pUtiUUlI1 III 1'1I,11.C, 1', 1021)(u).
WIIHI1l!1l01ll\, Ourulldllllll'lulIl/llIl IIlIIi III' AlllurlulI, IIIU" rUil'UClrulI~ requelll ~our HOllorAblu
COUrllQ dllllll.. I'IAII,lIrrl' Clllllplllllll whhllUI Cllblllr JUdYlllU1II11I11.
NEW MA'I"I'Elt
25, 1'llIlIulrr'l IIIJurlul IlIldd/llllllllUi, which IIru fipuclllulllly delllud, weru 11111 QAuled by /IllY
/lCII, ollllullllll, 01' hrullchul 01' dUlY 01' Purundlllll PIUIIIIIIIIIIIIII bUI wure ulluled III wholu or III purl, or
\Vera cOlllrlbulud 10 by Ihe lIellllYI!IICe, rllulI, or WIIIII of c/lru or 1'111111111'1'.
.3.
21\, l'lullllllh' ~IIIIIIII uru hllnelllll whulu <II' III pili I h)' 1'111111111'1'1 cUll1pul'ulIYU lIuyllyullce,
27, Nu dllllYUI'IIUi ,)1' IImlll'u cUlllllllulI ublblulIllI IlIhlllll1u 1I1111 plucu,
;IN. 11'1111)' dUllyurllul Ul' III1MII'U cUlllllllulI ulblell, which II Il'uclflclIlI)' IIUlllull, /)U""l1l1l1l11
I'llIuIUIIIIIIII. hud IIU uClulllur cUllllrUcllYlIlIUllcu U,. Iuch cUlIlIlllulI ublblllly III Ihlllllmll,
2'/, lJlIl'lIl1l1l1l1l PIUIIIIIIIIIIIIII' cUlIlIuCI Will lIullI IUhblllllllllll'lIclur III CIIIIIIIIII PIIIIIlIlIl'1 IlIjurlul
IIl1d dllmIlYII., 11'1111)',
WlmlU!I'(lIlH, I>U'~lIl1l1ll1 PIUIIIIIIIIIIIIII U,. AlllcrlclI, IIIC, rUlpecl,.ull)' rUlIullbll )'uur lIulluruhlll
CUUtl hI dllllllll 1'111111111"'1' (\1111111111111 Wllhlllll wllur JUll~lllClIl "1 II.
NI~W I\IA'I"I'I\lt IN TIm NATUlm (W A cltoliSCl.A1I\1 AGAINST
UJW~NI)i\NTIi ItIcIIAItJ> lumn III AIiIi()CIATI~1i ANI) AI\IJ(j() 1\I01llU'I'Y IN'I"l., INc.
30, 1)111'1111,111111 Plcllllllll 111111 IlIcuIl'urllfll1 herelll h)' re"erellce Ihll lIyunnUIIII cUIlIlIllICll III
PIIIIIIIII'''I' CUIIIIII II 1111 IIY II I Ilil I lc"ClIlIlIlII I Itlchllrd IlclIlI & AlblldlllCI 1I1111 AIIIIHU Muhllll)' IlIlCl'I1l1l1ulIUl,
IIIC, IlIlhll IICllulI, IlC"Clldlllll PI CII 111111 111111 1I11CI 1I11111dllllt Ihc IIwnllcllIl "" PIIIIIIIII"'I' CUlllplllllll, hUI
IlIcorpurnle Ihelll lulcl)' "II' purpolCI o"lhll ~r'lllcllIllII,
31. All)' IIl1hllll)' UII Ihc pllnol' IlCrClIlI1I1II I'lc11I1I1II Inlll whkh II IpcclflclIlI)' 1Il1nled, WII6
wholl)' 6ucolldur)' IInll plIIIIYe IIl1d fhc IIl1hllll)' 0" !Jc"clldrlllll 1~lchlll'lIllcclI & A660cIIIICI IInll AlI1lgo
Mohllh)' hllCl'lllIllolIlIl, Inc, Will pl'llI1l1r)' IInllllcllw,
32. If It II Ilclurllllncd lhlll 1'11I1nlll"'l lire clllltlclIl') I'ccuycr 1111)' or III'ur Ihc dllll111ge6 lei fonh
IlIlhlllr CUll1plllllll, which II IpcclllclIlI)' denlcd, IhclIlJelcnllllllll Illdlilrll Ilcell & AI611cllllc6 1I1111 AII1I110
Mohllll)' IIIICl'I1l1llulIIIl, Inc, IIrc cllch Iulcly ur jullllly IIl1hle IU Plllltllll"'llInllllr<: CII.;I,lIlollc IIl1hlc, jolllll)'
IIl1hlll, or IIl1hle OWl' hI IJcrcndlllll Plclllllnl IIIn6 fill' c'lIIlrlhullolI, InllClI1l1lflcllllullor b,lIh.
WIIElWFOIU:, IJcrendlllll Plelllllllllnlll 'If AlllerlclI, Inc, rClpeclflllly reljucbll )'our 1I01l11rublc
COUI'I 10 1I1illllll PIIIIIIIIIJI' Complllllll 1I1I1I IInler judl!II1CIII III hi fllYur, III Ihll IIhcl'l1I1IIYC, II' II 16
lIelcrmllled Ihllt PI 11111I I I'l'l lire clllhlcd III rccoycr, IhclIlJcrclIlllIlll PICllKIIIIllnn6 nf AmerlclI, IIIC" dCllllllld!
.4.
fOL11l an opinion 4B to the truth Or talrJity ot the aVlIrmentll
Clolltained in parllguph :2 of plaintiffs' Compl4int 4nd, it
appHoable, lit riot prQot is demande1 at the time ot tdal,
J, 'l'he allllgationB llet forth in lJl1ragraph :) o~
pldntith' Complllint ill not direotQd to the IInBwering
defendant and, therefore, no answer if! re(luired under the
P~nnBylvanill Rulell of civil Procedure.
4, The allegationll lIet forth in paragraph 4 of
pldntiff/l' complaint is not directed to the I.InBwel."ing
defendant nnd, theref()re, no IInawer h raquired under the
Penn/lylvania Rulell of Civil Procedure,
5, Admitted,
6, 'l'he answedng defendant' B Urllt notice of all
alleged incident involving the plaintiff, Charles Huber, was
thll receipt or. II Summonll, After rllllllonable investigation,
the answering der.endant is without /luff icient information or
bl\llief to fOL1n nn opinion all to the truth or falsity of the
averment/l contained in paragraph 6 of plaintiff/l' Complaint
and, if J:elevant, strict proof thereof is demanded at the
time of trial.
7. The allegationll set fOJ:th in pllragJ:aph 7 of
plaintiffll' Complaint is directed to a party other than the
answering defendant and, ther.efoJ:e, no answer is required
under the Penn/lylvania Rules of Civil ProcedUre,
B, The allegations set fOJ:th in paragraph B of
plaintiffll' Complaint is diJ:ected to a party other than the
answering defendant and, therefore, no answer ill required
und,~ the Penn~ylvRni8 ~ule~ ot Civil ~~oqedu~e,
I 9, 'l'hlt allelJation~ Qet fo~l;h in pal.'lIlJl.'lIph Q of
pl"i'ltHf~' Complaint ill dil.'eutltd to 4 lJlI~ty other than the
,
IIn~wel~inlJ dllflmdftnt "nd, thet:lIfQl'Il, no tlIllIWIlt: ilJ ~lIl1ull.'ed
under the Pltnnllylvllnill Ilulllll <If civil JlroCll.du/."ll,
10, Admitted in .1111:t I rllln.lltd in I)IIl.'t, MtQI.'
.....,1I11olltlble invelltiU6ti(n, /lJHIWedng dllfllndllnt ill without
llufficient infoJ:maticm or lllJUI'lr to form nn opinion 1111 to
whether the plaint i H, CharJ,ell lIublll.', WIIIJ disRblltd and
confined to a whelll chai/: nnd wall ulling II mobility vehicle
lIlanufllctul'ed by the IInllwedng rlefllndllnt, It ill admitted
thllt dllfendllnt, Amigo Mobility Int'l, Inc" W61l the
mllnuf4cturer of motoriud mobility cartll,
11, TIlIl 6nllwedng defendnJ1t'l3 first notic, of 4n
1I11eged incident involving the plaintiff, CharlelJ Huber, Willi
the receipt of a Summorn, Ar.ter realJonllble invel3tigntion,
the IInlJwering defendant ill without sufficient information ot:
belief to form an opinion al3 to the truth or falsity of the
averments contained in paragraph iI, of plaintiffs' Complaint
and, if rlJlevant, lItrict proof thereof is demonded at the
time of tdal,
12, The allegationB set forth in pllrograph 12 of
plaintiffB' Complaint is directed to a paJ:ty other than the
anllwering defendant and, therefore, no anl3wer is required
under the Pennl3ylvani~ Rulell of Civil Procedure,
i
i!
COtm'l' I
!I
1], An~we~in9 de~end4nt incorpo~ateu by re~erenCQ each
and every 411e91lt ion (Jonta Ollld ill the i r 1l/HIWeru to
paragraphp 1 through l~ au 1~ ~ully Qet forth herein,
14, nenied, It iu denied thllt the IllllllwQ~ing detl!llldllllt
W4ll negllgent find it ill further di/lnitld th4t the inoident wall
in no manner whlltlloever du~ to nny acta or omi~llionu on the
part of plaint it t, Chnrlell Huber. '['he lI11ugnt ions /lQt fo~th
in the plaintiffs' COlllplaJ.nt. lllnint.ift, Charlell lluplIL' , Willi
negligent in the operation of Il mobility cart,
15, Denied, The firllt notice of the incident
involving tho plaintiff wnll the receipt of a BUI1"'lonQ, AfteJ:
~eaaonable investigation, th" anllwering defendant is without
/IufHcient info1111ation OJ: beliaf to form 8n opinion au to
whether or not their pJ:oduct Wall involved in the incident,
III the event it is judicially dl'lterlllined that the product
lllanuf8ctuJ:ed by the answering defendant wall involved in the
incident, then the anBweJ:ing defendant denies any negligence
on their part,
1.6,
17,
la) The allegations set forth in paragraph 17(a)
o~ the plaintiffs' complaint are mixed conclusions of law
and alleged facts and, therefore, are specifically denied,
Ipl The allegations /let forth in pnragJ:aph 17(al
o~ the plaintiffll' Complaint are mixed concluaiona o~ law
and alleged facts and, therefore, are specifically denied,
18, The anawering defendant's first notice of an
11
alleged inddent involving the plaint i H, Charlu Hubn, wall
the receipt o~ a IIUmmOI1l1, At ter rll8~onable invQI!It J,gat ion,
the anllwe....ing de~endant ill without uu~ticient info~"atian or
belief to ~orm IIn opinion 41l to the truth or falQlty of the
,
averl1lllntfl oonta,inecl in pllrllgrAph 1U of pla int if f Il' Compl/l illt
and, if rllli'lvant, atJ:ict pI:OO~ thel:lIlof is dlJl1landed at the
time of trilll,
19, 'l'he anaweJ:ing defend4nt'lI Urllt notice o~ IIn
alleged incident involving the plainti~~, Chal:lell Hube~, wall
the J:eclllipt o~ a OU"U1\ons, After I:eallonable invesl;igation,
the anllwedng defendant il3 without I!lUC ~ icicnt informnt ion 01:
belief to form an opinion as to the tJ:uth or falsity of the
Ave~lIents contained in para(JraLJh 19 of plaintir.ffl' complaint
Ilnd, if relevant, stl:iet proof thereof is demanded at the
time of trial.
20, The answering defendant'll first notice of an
alleged incident involving the plaintiff, Charlea Huber, waa
the receipt of n Summons, I\fter reallollllble investigation,
the answering defendant is without llufUcient information OJ:
belief to form an opinion as to the tJ:uth or falsity of the
averments contained in paJ:Aqraph ~O of plaintiffs' complaint
and, if relevant, atrict proof thereof is demanded at the
timll of trial,
WHmREFORE, the answering def.endant, Amigo Mobility
Int'l, Inc" demands thllt judgment be entered in its favol:' ,
COUNT XX
;ll, ~nl3wllrinij ddendlll1t inoorj;l"'~'lltel3 by rehrellolll elloh
and every ~lL.glltiQn contained 111 their an~wer~ to
pili t:llSraplllf 1 through ~l IHI.it tully r,lllt fClrth herei'l,
:2:2, 'l'he IlJll3wedl1g defendant' /J nrllt notioe or. lln
llLleged incident involving the plaintiff, Charles lJup",r, WIUI
thlt rer.:eij;lt of n /:Iul1\monl3, Ar.tl!lJ: rlllHIIJl)lIbJ,ll invl!llJtigation,
thll IUll3wllring defl!lndant is without /Juffi.cient information or
belier. to form nn opinion nil to thl'l truth Ol~ fnll3ity of tIll!!
4vermenr,13 oontl'lined in l~I.tI:lIgrlll~h n of LJla int if f ~, COl11l?lllint
/Uld, if reLevllnt, ",triot proof thereof il3 dl!ll11lHlded at thl!
time of trial,
:23, The llnlJwering defondllnt'l3 firr,lt notice or. an
alloged incident involving the plaintiff, Charleu lJuber, wal3
the reoeipt of II /:IUl1\l1\o'H.I, lifter renllonllhle invQstigation,
the answering defendant il3 without /Jufficiellt ,inr.orl1\ation or
belief to form an opinion all to the truth 0); falsity of the
llvel-ment/J contained in purlJgraph 23 of plaintiffs' COl11plaint
and, it J:elevant, atrict prooC the....eof iB del11nnderj at the
time of trial,
24, The anawering dofendant's fi....at notice of an
alleged incident involving the plBintif f, Chat'lea HUber, Wlla
the receipt of a Su"~ons, After real30nable investigation,
the llnllwering defendant ia without /Juffioient information 0....
belief to form an opinion a/J to the tJ:uth or falsity of the
averment/J contained in paragraph 24 of plllintiffl3' complaint
and, if relevant, 13trict pJ:oof theJ:eof is demllnded at thl!l
til1\e of trial.
WBIlRIIVOJ~IE, judgment ill demanded in tavor ot the
.nl3wu'~ng de/:endant, Amigo Mobi l ity Int' l, tno,
&fJ)LJIh.1'1'1l
~5, PlftintiCfs' olaims are barred by the applicable
statute ot LimitationB,
~6, P14intiffa' claima are barred by the dootJ:ine of
laohes ,
27, PlaintUfB' claims are barred or modified by the
comparative Negligence Aot of Pennaylvania,
28. PlaintUfa' injurl,l!ls, it any, were due to the
actionl3 of third parties over whom anaweJ:ing defendant had
no control.
29, plaintifts assumed the riak,
30, It it is judicially proven at the timo of the
trial that the product i.n question was manutactured by the
answering defendant which was involved in the incident which
is the subject matter of this suit, said allegation being
specifically denied, tha pJ:oduct was subject to improper,
abnormal, unforeseen or unattended use or misuse to the
product after it left the care, custody and contJ:ol of the
answering defendant,
WHEREFORE, answeJ:ing defendant, Amigo Mobility Xnt'l,
Inc" denies any liability and demands judgment in their
favor and demands that the Complaint be dismissed with
preju,1ice and that the answering def'illldant be awuded costs
of this action, J:easonable attoJ:ney's fees and suc~ other
I
Ii
~&liet au the oou....t deems pquitnble nnd jUst.
lflW NA'l''l'lR UNDIR
n t a, Q ,L-a.aUldLllLTJI.DU"OJUj...J)LA....r;ROSSCL~J:H
11, It the plaintiff ~ulltnined t~a accident o~
illju~ieli avened in the ComplnInt, which ia exprerHJly
denied, IIl1n1e were cf\ullad OJ;' contributed to by the negligenoe
on the part of the co-dafend,\ntl'l, Pleasant Inn, Super Motor
8, 1M, and IHchard Heed nnd ABsociates.
1;!. The neglJ.gence of the nforosllid co-defendants
oonaiated of the particulnrn Bet forth in the plaintiffs'
Complaint, Said Complaint is incoJ:porated herein by
reference without admission or adoption and solely fOJ: the
purpoBe of this New Matter purauant to Pa, R,C,P, ;!25;!(d)
and only those allegations of the Complaint; which J:eter to
the co-defendants. By vIrtue of the afoJ:esaid, the
anawering defendant avers th~t the aforeaaid co-defendantB
are liable, or linble over to it on the cause of action
declared upon by the plaintiffa, or are jointly and
severally liable thereon with the anawering defendant by way
of contJ:ibution andlor indemnity, any liability on the part
of the answering defendant being specifically denied,
WHEREFORE, al1sweJ:ing defendant, Amigo Mobility Int'l,
Inc. praya that in the event that a judgment is enteJ:ed in
favor of the plaintiffs and that said judgment is entered
against any or all defendantij that said defendanta are
liable over to the defendant, Amigo Mobility Int'l, Inc. for
indemnification or contribution together with all attorney's
I.
, ..,
I .-.
" II
\,1\ .'
" I I 'I
I. I " "
.'1', , ,
II , , " ,
I ) I
,
I, , ,
I ."1,
I .1
, ~ ,I
" "
)1
,
,I,
I_!
'I
,j,
,
il
t hath
..." j~f )
I ,,'1 I
I ~,I. ,
F', , Ii
,
'; I
')' ,->-, I
' I
1'1' , ",
......
')' ql',
t \ t, ; 11,\,
l-
I L_
,
1/. I'j .1
'., ~-~ I
"
"
I'
.,
, '
'}I
.'1,..
"
~ m ).
. IrJ
" 1"
-
- '.
~' ei '.
. t( II: , i,
v
~li N ' 'Il
- ~
W ~
16 Gi
, '
, ..
, "
, ,
'i
i'
. , .
,I
'~
J.~ ~II"
"ID~
t i : I
J~ I
"
. .
CHARl.IIS and Il~RaMA HUalEl\,
Plaintiff"
v,
I N 'rillE COUR'I' 01' COMMOt/ Pf_IIAS
CUMIl Ii: 1\ liMP COUt/'I'\' I PIIJt/NSYl.VI\l'lI~
NO, PG-4800 CIVIL TmRM
CIVIL ~C'rIOt/ - L~W
PL..ll:I\SI\l'l1' It/NS, GUPIER 8 MO'I'IEL,
INC" RICIIARP RlEmO &
~BSOCIATES, p,C" snd AMIGO
MOQIL..I'r'i INTlERNI\1'IONAL, INC"
Oer.el1dBnta
It_PLY 0' D'~=M= ~
TO NlW MATTIl!. 0' DlrlNDANT 0
MIJ NOW, Defendant Plel1/i14nt Inns or. Alnedo4, Inc, ,
(incol:'reotly deaignated as Pleasant Inna, Super 8 Motel, Inc,), by
its attorlleys, 'l'homl1a, Thoma a & lIaf11lr, filell its Reply to New
Matter of Oefandsnt Amigo Mobility as follows I
31, Denied, Defendant Pleasant Innll specifically denies th4t
it was negligent or csuaed or contributed to Plaintiff/il' injuries,
By way of anawer, Defendant Pleasant Inns incorporates herein by
reference the aVElL"menta and deniala containlJd in ita Anl!lWlJt' and New
Matter to Plaintiffa' Complaint.
3:l, The IIveJ:tn"1nte 'if I?Elrag);aph 3:2 stntlil conclu,Iions of law to
which no answer iB requir.ed under the applicable Rules of Civil
Procedure. To the extent an answer ill required, Defendant Ploasant
Inns specifically denies that it is liable to Plaintiffs or liable
OVllr to Defendant Amigo Mobility in thil3 matter, By way of further
answer, Defendant Pleal3ant Innl3 incorporatel3 herein by reference
-1-
"
"
~ .,..
I'~
'I
P'J 'll
C;!
'\r.~" II
,0/1'
- Ill;'
ttl ~
Si
,
,
I
'I
,
"
, I
III
Ii
"
,I
,I
I
,
"
,
I
~T ~l ,,," ' ?-'
~ f~ .!1
~:)I {~ ;fl
' ~, II', " .~
',i I. I'
) ~, , ' .
f'(' HI I
I I' ... J,I, " ,1
r. ." t:' Itl' "
, " f~
" ~" '. "
0 ~. I,J
~
~
~,
1..\111
~ ~ hi
II'I
I,
, I
"
,
I
"
,
I
!I
,I
"
,I,.
,
.
"
. .
APR 1 7 1997 tf./
.
cHARLa. HUBI,. AND BARBARA
HUBER,
IN THI COURT 0" COMMON PLIA8
CUMBIRLAND COUNTY, PINNA,
NO, 88.4800
olVIL ACTION. LAW
PI.lntl".
v,
PleASANT INNS, SUPER B MOTEL,
INC,. RICHARD REED III ASSOCIATES,
P,C, AND AMIGO MOBII.ITY
INTERNATIONAL,INO"
D.fend,"t.
~
AND NOW, thla ').1 d.y of -1~ _,1997, upon oonaldarlltlon of
the Petition of Defendent Pleelllnt ",ns of America, Inc, Icr Lellv. to Join Addltlon.1
Oelllndont Pur.uant to Po,R,C.P, 2263, IT IS HEREBY ORDEREO thllt D.flndant
PleolllJnt Innll of Amerlco sholl hove en extension 01 time until April 30, 199?, to Join
Lober Inc. 011 on Additional Oelendont,
BY THE COURTI
Exhibit A
7, 011 ur ubuUI AUHUM JIJ, I'Jll04, III Iho 1111I0 u/ld plu~o ulleyed III 1'lulllll""I' CUIIlllluIIII,
1'luhlllfrluIIIYI'hull'lul/lllfl' Churln Iluher WUI IIIJurad hU~UllbO:
U, Th, Ildowulk IluJlo WUI 1"',1 Maall,
1'1, Thore WUI 1111 lawl III/ldl/lY IIUllldo Ihu dllllr hI ItllUIIl ltJ2 UlIll lhora II Ull
u~~obblvoly Ileoll nUll II whore IllovellllllLlI/lIIIl/ld 1II11/lluvarl/lY IIrell IhllUld hll
~, The wl'Il~1l1 drull ul Ihv dUllr hI ItuIIIII ~l)2 a~~aedoLllhe 1Il0~lIllUIll ulluwoLl by
ANSIIIIIIldurLllllllld
d, Tho IILluWlllk WUI III vlolullu/l willi Ihe ^llIorl~u/l1 Wllh Ollllblllllol AClur 1990
AccuulbllllY C1ulLlolIllUlllr lJulldl/lYI III1Lll'uclllllol,
K, f)are/ldlllll PlolIIIIlII hllll cOlllrllcluLl wllh Addlllullol l)erullLlullI Luhur 10 CUllblrUCI Ihe
udLlllloll alld rdllovullonof ruclllllul uI1I1 promllol,
9, If Ihe I"opony wua dorucllve IInd ullruulollnbly dBllyuroUI, which II lllUclllcally LlonleLl,
Ihon AdLllllonllll)orolldll1ll Lohor II Iululy, johllly or Ivvorlllly IIl1hluo or lIuhluovor 10 IJorcndallll'leuaulll
Illnl ror /IllIllIllrrl Injurlol ullLl domllsul,
10, ALlLl1l101l1I10orUlld1l1l1 Lobllr Will noSllllulI1 and cllrolm In IhuIII rlllleLl:
II, To cOllmucllho premllu III roqulrod hy Iho colllrucl ulld Ipoclllclllhllll.
b, To COflblf1lcl Ihe premlau III Rccordllllco wllh IIppllcllblo J,NSI alld ADA
alandardll
c. To properly h.lpccllhe aldowlllk, Iundlns und venlcul drop IIllho cOllclullOII or
COnalf1lcllolll
d, To warn Dure/ldllnl PIOlllllnlllllllOr IIlIlnudoquate Ildewulk, landlllS and vertlclIl
drop. und
Co To ucrclle reasonllble cure In Ihe conalf1lcllon of Ihe Ildawlllk, landlns and
vurtlclIl drop,
.2.
II, ALlLllllullullJvf'ollLlulII hrmh~lllll wurrullIY IhOllho wurk wuuld he ut' yuuLl1lunllly, Ihul
Ihu wurk wuuld hu "rue Ihllll Llu'i:~11 Alld Ihul Ihe wurk WUllld ~IIII"'II'III wllh Ih" rCllulro",ulIlI ur Ihu
Nro~lfI~nllulIl,
12, ALlLlill'lllllll)ufeIlLlAIlI I.llhllr hrell~hulllll ~UllltuclUlllllhllYllllulIlll purrllrmlhu wllrk t'ree
I'm", dUrUC111l1ld11l Cllllt"ltmAllcu wllh Ihe ClllllrU~1.
13, All)' Ihlhllll)' 1111 Ihc pArlllt' Iloli:lldolll I'lmlllll 111111 WOI Whllll)' mUlldur)' ulld,lmlvu
IlIlLllhe lIohllll)' ..,. At/dlllllllallJ"lillldAIIII_'lhur wa. prllllllr)' Alld 1I~llvu,
14, If II II dOlurmllluLllhAll'lulllllfTllltu ellllllud II' rUCllvur III1Y llr ullo"lho dUlllnlloK Icl rOrlh
III Ihulr Cllmplllllll, Which II Ipocln~ully llulllod, IhulI AdLlllllllIAllJvrullllalll tohur II lululy IIl1blo III
l'lulllllffl, jolllll)' lIuhlu hI I'luhllllll, llr lIohle IIVOr OorulldplIl I'lmum 1I111N rllr cOlllrlbulllllI,
IlIdolllllll1cullolI, or bOlh,
WlIl!:ItEFORE, /)01i:llduIIIPlmAIllIt1ll1 tubpUClIilll)' rOllucbll )'llllr 'hmornhlo Courl hI dllmln
I'lulllllrr.' Cumplnlllllllld OIlier judYIIIU1I1 hI III rpvur, IlIlho IIl1umllll',u, 1f'1I11 dOlermllloLllhull'lnlllllfr.
lire: ulllhluLl 10 rOCllvor, Iholl IJofulldulII I'luBIIlIII 111111 rUllIIOMI Ihal judymolll ho "llurod lole:ly UYllllllil
ALldlllollal /)ofulILlanl tobllr IIIC, IlIlho tlJnhor ullomnllvo, If Ills dOlorllllllodlllUl Plalnllfrs uru ulllllleLl
III recover uynltlAI OOfOlld1l1l1 I'loUIIIIIIIIIIII, which II 'pucll1cull)' dOllloLl, IhulI /),J'elldlllll JlIUJPIllIIIIII
ruspuclI\lll)' roquulll )'uur HOllorllblo COUrl hI clllor judymolll aYAhllil Addlllollul oorulldUIlII.obur IIIC,
for jollll and lavernlllllbllhy, conlrlbulloll, IIILlollllllncnlloll, or hOlh,
TIIOMAS, TIIOMAS III lIAFER
DATEDI
iMVlD L, SCIIWALM, ESQUIRE
30~ NOIl1'1I FltoNT STREET
P.O. nox 999
IIARRJSnURG, I'A 17108.&)99
(717) 2~s.?G43
A'M'ORNEV FOR DEni:NDANT
PLEASANT INNS ()It" AMERICA. INC,
.).
'~t
"
::'
m}:
61 \.
tfl~
I,
~)
1:1
""
SJ
~-';
nj,s.
,I'tr.,
'g
',,~
I,;"
," ill!
':..1
a
, "
I I
, , "
" ,
, "
, , " 'Ii
" ,
i,
'I,
.,
,
"
'i.l!
t~ld
J II q
J~ I
~
"
i'
., i,'1
, I
,I , , , , "
'I
, , , "
, ,
" I , I,
.1 ,
, 'Ji , , , 'II
iI
, " "
,
., . "
I' I .
" . I
, , 1,1
'~
H.
~t'l
,>,J
r..'
~a
\)i
"
7, Clnur phnUI AUYUII 2'/, 199,1, ullhu 1111I0 Plld I'lu\'u Illlu"eLlIIII'lvlnllrr.' Cnllllllphll,
1'lpllllllTI vlla"v Ihull'lnlllllrr Chllrlvlllllhur Will IIIJllrud hUCIlUIUI
v, Thv Ilduwulk Ilnpu WUN lUll Muul'l
h, Thuru WIIN IIn Iyvul 1111\1111111 llUlaldu Ihu dllllr III ItnlllU JlJ2 und thvrn II un
u~l;ol.lvuly IIUVII rlllUll whuru II l~vul IlllldlllY Illld IUllllullY~rhlH IIrUIl IhllulLl hu;
c, 'rhu vurtlcll Llrul' IIllhu dllnr hI 111I1I1U Jill u~~uuLluLllllo IIIU~IIUUIII ullnwud hy
ANIlI i1l1l1daldNI alld
Ll, Tho sldowlllk Will III VI'IIIIIIIIII with Iho Alllurl~III1' Willi 0lsIlhlllllu5 AcinI' 199U
Acmllhlllly OlllLlolIlIUI nr lIulldhll!' Illld I'lIclllllul,
K, IJurelldoll1 Plulllulll 11U15 ~lIl11rllclud wllh Addllllllllll IJollmdlllll Lllhllr In Cnll511'1M thv
IIdLllllnll ulld rUllllvllllnll IIr 'ilclllllol 111111 prulUllul,
9, If Iho Iltnl'urty Will Llerucllvu IIl1d 1I11rUIIIllllllhly LllIlll!oru1l5, wlllch I, 5puuIIlcIllty dUlllod.
Iholl AddhlollullJurulldlllll Lllhllr I. s.Mly, JlIlIlIly III' luvurlllly IIQhlu, III' lIuhlu over III J)orolldulll Pluullllll
111111 for 1'lQlllllrralllJllrloN IIlld LlIlIIIIIYUI,
.
10, Addll,'lIlul J)UrUlldUIU l.ohar WUI IIUlIlIHCllllllld curulm III Ihlllll I'llltod:
Q, Tn COllllrUCllhu prvmllcl liS rClllllrud hy IlIu cnlllrll~llllld spo~lIkllllollll
b, ' Tn CIIIlIII'Ucl Ihu prumllus III IIwlrLlllllcu wllh nl1l1lkllhlu ANSI IIl1d APA
IllllldllrLls;
c, To properly hllpUCI lhu IILluWlllk, IIlIILlIIIY ulld vurtlclIl LlruPllllho clIllclualoll of
ClllIslruClhlll;
d, Tn wnrn Ourclldlllll PIUII51lllllll1l1 111'1111 Illlldo'lulltu Ilduwulk. Illlldllll! Qlld vurtlcQI
Llrop; nllLl
u, Tn u~ercl,o rYIIIIIIlQhlu cllru III Ihu clIlISlruc.11l1I nr Ihu sldvwulk. IQlld11l1l ulld
vurllclll Llrllp,
.2.
,
II, AtldlllollullJurvlldulll hrmhuLlllI wllrrllllly Ihllllhu work wlluld hu lll'lI1111LlljLlUllly, Ihlll
Ihl! wllrk wllulLl hu froll rrlllll LloruclI III1Lllhll1 Iho wllrk Willi III ~1l1ll'1lI'111 wllh Ihu rUljUlrOllllllll1 Ill' Ihu
Illvc1flclIlIlllIl,
It AddlllllllllllMelldulIll.llhllr hrmhuLllI1 ~lllllrU~IUulllhlllllllhlll hlllCrlimll thu wllrk rrlll!
'hllll defucll Illld III clllIl'llrnlllll~e wllh Ihe ~lllllrll~1.
J 3, AllY IIllhlllly lllllhu pPrlllflM~IILlulIll'lumlll 111111 Will whlllly Iuclllldury "lid 1'0nlvlI
ulld lhu lI"hlllly III' ALlLlIIIIIIIIII lJofulldlllll I.llhllr lVull'rlllJllry ulld 1I~llvu,
14, If 1111 LlulllrllllllllLllhllll'llIllIlIlI1 Ilru ulIllll~11 hI rU~llvvr IlIlY llr 1111 "flhe LlUIIlUIIIlI ~el forth
III thulr COlJlplullIl, which II ~pudll~lIl1y IIUlllud, Iholl ^ddlllll/lIlllJufolldlllll 1.1Ihur II lolllly lIuhlo 10
1'llIllIllrrN, jllll1lly lIuhlv III Pllllllltrlil, llr lIuhlo lIvur J)orlllldlllll Plrmlll JIII1N fill cOlIll'lhullOII,
IIILlolllllll1cullolI, or hOlh,
WIlElU!.JlO/tE, lJurelldllllll'ImuIIII1II11 1'0Ip~~lrully rOtjucIII your ""II11l'llhlo COUl'llll dllllllNI
I'lolllllrrl' ClllIIl'lullIl "lid ulller jlldYIIIUlllltlll1 I'ovllr, IlIlhu IlIlUrllUllvu. 11'1111 LlUIUl'lIllllULllhul Plllltlllrra
uro ulllllloLl tll recovur, IhcII lJorolldulIl Plemlll 11111I re'l"eMI IhuI jllLlIIIII~1Il ho uIllurod Illlely UIIIlIIIII
AddlllollullJoro/ldulIIl.llhllr IIIC, IlIlhu futlhur 1l110rllllllvu, 11'1111 dUlurlllll1cd thut PIIlIIIIIl'rl orv ullllllod
10 rucowr UI\UIIINI lJurCl1dUIIl PIOOIIIIII IIml, which II Il'uclllcully dUlllod. Iholl IJurulILlulII "Imlllll limN
rulllCelrull)' roquulll your Ilolloruhlu COUrllo ulller JudlllllUlIllIl!olll1l AddlllllllllllJurollLlulIIl.obur IlIe,
ror JOIIII Ulld levorllllluhlllly, tlllllrlhllllOIl, Itlllullmlllclllhlll, llr hOlh,
D^TED~ '41,ul'\7
,.I/0MAIi, .,.I/0MAIi & I/AJlE/t
'. I \. I
\ ~~" .:,,), ,t.. l
D,W(i> I.. StIlWAI.M, 1~IiQUlltE
30S NOIl'/'1I t'ltON" S'l'llE/~'"
1'.0, JlOX 999
I/AltRIIiIlU/W, IIA 17I01t.0999
(717) 255.7643
A'M'OltNIW .-em m~n:NJ)AN'I'
PLEAIiANT INNS OJ! AMERICA, INC.
.3.
E'llhlblt A
, ' ( (' ",'
,
, , ,
JUHflllh J. IlclulVurll AIIOr/IlIY~ fur Plull)\ltr~,
MANml., COIIHN, OAltEl.ICK, r.huthlH UI1~ Ilutburll Hub"
RlmlWEllCl & FI~IIMAN
HHHIl KeYHI0I111 crouh'll
Bullo HOO
IlIdllllllpolls, IlIdlllllll 411240
(317) 57).HIlIlIl
___t )
CIIAltl.ES DII~ IJAllUAM HUlleR. )
577 Porlcl Ilouluvutd ~
Cllm,,,I, IN 46032, C()URT O~ COMMON IILl!AS
) PilLA W Aim Cl1UN I' y
1'llIhllll1'l, )
)
v. )
) NO, 9tl.t1HOO civil Torm
PLEASANT INNS, )
SUPER H MOTEL, INC,. )
I HOO Borrlsbul'Q Plku )
Cllrlllle, I'A 170131 ) CIVIL ACTION
11IClIAltD Rmm & ASSOCIATES, PC, )
" L1borty Avolluo )
Cnrllll~, I' A I?O J 3: nlld )
AMI(lO MOUltlTY 11'1'1"1., INC" ) JlIR Y TRIAL DEMANDED
6tl'13 Plxl~ HlllhwllY )
DrldQoJlorl, MI t1H?22, )
)
PllfendD",~, )
)
<::IVIL ACTION. COMI'LAIN:J:
Plnhlllffs, Chnl'le~ IInd OorbnrD Buber, by coullsel, nlld for lhclr Compllllnl nQnlnsl
Dcfelldnnls, I'lenllll1l lilliS, Super 8 MOIUI. IIlC" Rlehnrd RUlId & Assocllltcs, p,C, Ind Amlllo
MobllllY lnternnllonnl, IlIe" do sny IlI1d nllolle us rOIlOIVI:
I
J!Ju:llu
I, Plnhlllff. Chllrlu~ Huber, I~ IIn IIdllll Illlllvldulll uurrullll~ l'u5ldlll~ IlIlhunlhlllll\IUlllY,
IIILlllIllU,
2, Plllhulff, Ilurbllrll lIuhur, In lhu wlfu ul' fllulllllfl', Churl us lIuhllr, rllnlLlllI1I wllh hlmllN
hl5 wll'u III Ilul1llllol1 CIlIlIllY, 111111111111,
), Uufullllull\, fllullijUIl\ 111115, Supur 8 Molol, 111u" 15 U PUIIIl~ylvUllhl uorpurulloll, dt3lnu
bUijh,Uijllll 1800 IlllrrlijburlJ Plku, (urllllv, PU'lllij~lvunlll,
.1. lJllfolldllnl, Rlchord Ituud & AS61lullllun, fI,C" Is 111111/\11' WUSII Jlrulclnlonlll corporllllon,
wllh lIu I'rlllulpull'llIce Ill' bUijlllU55 III 4 Uberty Awnue, Cul'llijlu, I'unllsylvunlll,
S, Dlllill1dllll\, Amll!o MubllllY 11110rl1l1llulIlIl, Inu" lij II lV*hlUIII1 corporlllloll, willi hs
prlllclplIl plllce of buslnm ul 6693 PI)(le IlIllhWIIY, Ilrldl!uporl, MlchlIlUI1,
fWI
6. On or lIbout AUllUSI 29, 1994, PlulrlllO', Chllrlu5 Hub"r, while on II buslnllss trip,
chl!c~ed Inlo thl! Supur 8 Molul III 1800 Ilurrllbllrl! I'lku, Cllrlllle. PellnsylvlIllllI. wllh Ihe
IlIlellllcn of IllIylnB ullllllhe l11omll1l! of AUl!UNI 30, 1994,
7, The Super 8 Molel hud 5Jleull1c ucuol1ullodullol1s lor dlsubled illdlvldulll~1 nnd such
IIllCOml11odllllol1s were provldud 10 Plullllllr, ChllrluK Hub,:r,
8, Plalrlllff, Chllrlu5 Hubur, Wllij In need or dlijllbleLlllcconlllloLlallons for Ihe rualOl\ IhuI
he wffers from Mulliplu Sderolls lllld lij wheelchlllr bOUl1d,
9, Dllfendllnt. PleuNall\ll1115, Super Ii MOIUI, Inc,. had I11l1dellllerll\lonn tolln facllltlen 10
accommodale dlslIblod Indlvldual~, with Ihoiju ulrurallonn holnllllosll!nuLl by Dofendanl, Rlchllrd
Reed & AS50claleij, (I,C,
2
10, Ll~cnu~1: uJ'l'lnlllllff, t:hnrlc~ Iluhl:r'~, lilbllhlllly, hI: I~ Cllllllllud III n whcl:lchnlr nllL!
u~u~ n llIolorl~.uu mohllllY vuhlclc IllllllufllclllrcLl hy I\mll&ll Mohllll~ IlIlul'Ilnllllllnl, Inc" whlllh
bUiltH II mlulllumbur AM I lll)l)7SJ6,
II, 011111' UhllUt AlltlUM 30, 1')1).1. PIIIlllll/r, ('hurlu~ Iluhur, \Vu~ I!sllllll& hl~ roolll whllc
hll~ Illoblllty CIII'I, III1Ll UpOIl lUI'IlIIIY IOlhe rlllhl, Ihu Ilurl ~I!nl ~wlwlud lolhu lun hUl!uu~u lie un
IlIlpl'upc:r Illullllu III Ihu Nldewlllk, propolllllll him III1Iu lhu ~ILlu\Vlllk,
12. AIllllllmo~ ruluvul1l hurl!lo, iJul\:II,lulll, I'luII~III11IIlIl~, Stlpor K Molel, lilli" ~hould
l\IIve klloWII of Ihe ImpruJll!r II0pl! of Ihu ~lde\Vlllk. II~ Lluvltnloll frum Ihe tllllLlllllnl!~ of lhu
AlIlurlclIlI NnllulIlIl SlllnullrLls 1I1~IIlUle (ANSI) unu the Jlropenslty uf IhclllllhllllY currier 1011110
swivel whe'1 on UII Incline.
Cllunll
I J, Pluhlllff, ChllrhlH Huber, horeby IlIcurpornles Ulleltllllolls cOlllllllIOd III rhelorlclIl
porllsrllphl I lhrough 12 us If fully ~ut OUI herllln,
14. The I1fc~omunlll)ncd Incldelll rClultou n'om lho Ileglllll!nce of Ihe poronuullls, Ihelr
IIgenls, employees nllu/or rcprc~enlllllvu~, onLl Will 111 110 mllllller Whnlsol!vcr duo 10 UIlY ncl or
omls~lon 011 the port of I'lolllllff, Chorlus Huber,
15, Petimunnt, I'lcIIsIIIIIII1I1S, Supor K MUlel, IIlC,. wns lIeBII~olltllllhnl:
II. Ihe slLlewlllk slopu WII~ 100 ~leuPin
b. there WI1ll no level IUI1LlIIIII outslLle the door 10 Room 302 nnulhcrc Is nn
e>lcesslvely ~teep rump where nlcvel hlllulng Ulld mnneuverlns 01'1111 ~hould
be; ond
3
~, Ih,,' \'mIIlUlllruflllllhll ~Illlr III Itllum JOJ ll~wullK Ihu mu~lmumullll\wLI
by I\NSI MUlldurdi,
II, lhu Klduwulk Ii III \'llllnllalfl whh Ihu 1\/lIul'kllllK Whh Dllllbllhlo~ Alii Ill'
I'}l)l) 1\""llKilbllll~ "lIldlllll1u~ Ill' 1l1lllLIIIllls 1111<1 Fu"llhlu~,
Ill, Illllil'hlmll, Rlchu!'d ItuuLl & AKKuclulUi, p,c" pruflllrud thu Plnll1lll'l'K Kfleclfl"llllollS
Ill' Iho ilduwulk fUI' hs mllil rucullllWIlIl\lrllllllul1 nmllillluru III dUKlll1l II whhlll ANSI or ADA
Il,UI~lllhIU~,
17, Dllfoll~nlll. l\mll!lI Mobllh)' 1111111'lInllolllll. IIIC" Will 1I01l1l1!0tll IlIlhlll:
II, Iho wllrnhllli ollthu ll111hlllly whlclu IIrll wrillullllI ~Il1I1I1IUl\ura Ilnd plllcud
llUllr Ihll feol III the bllsu uI' Ihu sluerlllll 1I0lUlllII WhOI'll Illlanllul bc ICUll
whllu drlvllllllhu CllrI; IIml
b, nullhor Ihe Itlslrllllllullll1l1l1UlIlnur Ihe WOrnhlll olllhc carllall~ lhe opernlor
hllW 10 detllrmllll! whon Ihe slopu uxcecd~ Ihu I: 12 warn hIli or lhot 011
rllmps or slduwnlk~ ll1aYllolmelll federal slllndards,
I S. Ai n dlrecl und proxlmale rusult of lhl! nellllllellcr: lIf thl! DofellLlllJ115, and each of
lhum, Plolllllft: Charles Hubl!r, WOi IhrowII from his mobllllY vohlclu anLl knockcLlllllCOll5CloU5,
resullhllllll Ihc nlled fur ml!dlcal lroalmelll ollLlIl sl!rlou5 exacerballoll of his Multiple Scll!rolls,
19, A~ II furlher dlrecl and proxhlloll! rUKu11 of Ihe nellllgence orlha Dol'endonls, lIJ1d each
or Ih"I1, Plaintiff, Chllrlus Bubur'l, condition hlL'l lI11nllnuod 10 dlllerlorule, requlrlnll full.lIme
home health core,
4
~(), I\~ II I'urlhcr .lIrccllllld proslllllllU rc~ulllll'lhv IIcllllyulI~c Ill' Ihu Dclilll.IIIIII~, UII.' cllch
ol'lhclII, Pluhllll'I', C/lilr'u~ 1 IUhvr, hll~ ~UfliJl'ULIII "'NN Ll/' ullmlllYN 1111.1 IIIIJluh'lIIClI1 of' hlN UlltrlIIIII
~upnllll)', 111110 hl~ LlulrllllclIllllld Ill~N,
WIIFREFO/tJ:, 1'111111111,., C/IllrIIlN I'uhur, lllllllllllllN JUl'1l1ll0lllUllulllNllhll /)Ul'ulld/llllS, IUlLl
Ulluh ol'lhUIII, "ll' dlllllllYII 1111111 1I1111IUIII IIdvLlunl1l III cOlllpllllNlIll1 hIm /,'r ;,Is IIIJurlcs ulld Illr Ill/
lllhur JU~IIl'lll Jlmpur I'uliul' 111 Ihll flruIIII~ul,
1::u.uIllJJ
~ I, PllllllllfI; IIlIrburll Ifubur, hllrub)' IlIcllrpurllllls Illlullnlhms cOlllnlllltd III rhltlorlcnl
Jlllrullrllphs I Ihrollllh 12 liS If' 1\111)' ~ul ()Ul hllro/ll,
22, AI III/ IIIIIU6 releYlI1lI III Ihu IIforosllld IICIIlJlI, Pllllnlln; 13l1rbuI'U "luber, hns buon nnd
<:o'lllnuo~ III be mllrrled III IIIlLlllvlny wllh Pllllnlll'l: Chllrl06 "ubur,
23, I\~ II LllrucllIl1d proslmlllu rUlulI o"lhe neyllgul1clI of' thu DulimLllIlIlS, IInd llllCh u,.
1/1011I. PllllnUn; I1l1tbllrll "uber. hll~ hoon deptlvoLllJ/' Ihe Hurvleus, suduly, lI~slsIIlI1CO, ~uflport,
cOIIIJlllnlol1lhlp IIl1d ~on~orlhllllo"her hushllllLl, Plull1ll,.,., Chlltles Ilubur, IIl1d such deprlvullol1l1l1Ll
hllpllltll111nl wI/I COl1lll1Ue 111 Ihe IlUute, to the detrlmelH IIl1d loss 0" Pllllmll1', I1lltblltll "uber,
24, As n "Utlher direct IIl1d ptlJS.lfIlllle resUIII)flhe l1uylillel1cullfthe lJe/imdoms,ul1d ench
Oflhc,l1. PllIll1Ilff, I1l1rbnrn /'lubel', hilS suf"ered IIl1d WliI ,'JllIll1ue 10 sUIT,r Ir..m PldlUlff, Clnrles
Hubur's, loss of ellmll1gs lind/ill' elll'l1inll Cllpllchy, IIl1d will cOllllnue 10 su""or 1'1'011I his loss of
Olltl1ln!!s IInd ellrnll1g Cllpllclty In the tlJlUro,
WHEREFORE, 1'111111111'1', IJlltbuCII "ubor, dCfIlonLls Judllll1CIlIII!!IIII1Sllhu Detendwlls, IInd
ullch of them, tor dllnHlg(~ 111 1111 IIf1llJUl1tllduqullle 10 compenslllll her lor her Injuries IIl1d lor 1111
lJlhot JUSI I1lld 1'1'01'01' rulief III the prull1lsos,
5
I' ,
I;
Exhibit B
.., Mer rmllllllhle IlIvUltlYIIIIIlIl, DCrCIILlal1l Illmalll 111111 II wllhoul kllowlllllua or
IlIforrnallolllurncl.1IIIII ron" " bailer UI 10 Iha 1I'11lh of Ih. 1111'1/."110111 clllllalllllll III Pmllraph 04, IInd
proor lharror II delllolldud,
5, Mer rmollablc IIlVClIIUOIIIlII, DerellLlll11l 1'lmlll1l hUlli II wllhoUI ktlowledue or
IlIformallulI lul'Ocl.1I110 rorm a beller UI to Ihe lruth ur Ihe olleYAllolI1 ClllII.lllcclllll'ArAllrAph 5, And
proor thereor II LlemAncled,
Ij, Dellled IIJ 11.led, AllhouUh Illl ndlllllllllllhllll'llIlIlIlrr Chllrlcllluber chllCkcd Into IlIld
MOlel, IIll averruLllhll1 MOle111 IlIdeJlellclel1lly oWllecl alld opurulecl by DerOllclel1ll'leaulIlllI1lI undar
Iho nlllllO "Super 8 MOle/' "
7, DCllled PUUUUIIIIO l'u,lt.C,I', IO~9Ie),
K, DOllied PUt5UlIl1IlO l'a,It.C,P, IOme),
9, DenlucJ III ItUIOd, By WAY or IInlwer, II II Admllled lh.1 Defend.1Il R.IIS It Aaaoclal'l
did dulllll ollerllllollllO Iho fllcllllte.,
10, Denl.d purlUllnllo PII,R,C,P, 1029(0),
II. DenlucJ pUrlUlIllIlO PII,R,C,P, 10~9(.),
12, DOllied PUUUlIlIIlo Pa,R,C,P, 1029(0).
COUNT I
13, By w,y of Anlwer, Dorendanl Pllllanl 111lll Incorpor.I.. h.r.ln by referenc., Ihe
Avermenll .nd denl.11 conlalnucJ In Panuraph.s Ilhroush 12 of Ihll Amw.r and New Miller,
14, DenlucJ puuuonllo p.,R,C,P, 1029(.),
15. Denied puuuanllo Pa.R.C,P, 1029(.),
-1-
11\.17, The mrfllenli lul rOl1h In "uruyrllpha 16 und I7l1r 1'1~lnllrra' COflllll.IJlI do 1101 r"l1l1ln
10 Parflldlllll Plflllllllllnnl Alld no IInswur I~ tu~ulreLl unLlur Ihf Ullllllc~hlo I1llu ul' civil rroctduru, To
Ihe Ulellllln A1I1Wer Ii roqulred, Ihu~ ure Llunlcd rUtIUullllul'lI.r\,C,I', I021J(f),
18, Penlud rUrlUUllllo 1'"It.C,", 1029(,),
19, Denied pur~ulIllllo l'II,R,C,r, 1029(1),
20, Denlld l'uraullnlllJ l'u,It.C,r, 1029(u),
WBl:Rl!FORE, Dfrundllllll'lclIllAnl Irml lJr Afllerlell, Ine, r.apcclfIJIly raquem your Honor.bl.
CourtllJ dllfllln 1'11I1I1I1O'a' COlllr11l11ll wllhoUI cOil or JuLll!fllelllto It.
COUNT II
21, By WilY of unswur, Dorendllnl rlm'lII Irllll Ineorporlllu heraln by "rarenee, lhe
IIvennellla IIl1d denl.la cOllllllnud In rnrllllrllpha 1 Ihroullh 21) or Ihll AllIwer .nd New MAllcr,
22, Mer rmonllblo Inve5lIg~llon, DerunLllI1ll rlm'lII Inn. la wllhoul kllcwlcdlle Ilr
Inroml.llon Iurnelentlo rOml U bolioI' lIli 10 Ihe Il1llh of Iho IIvennellll eonlAllled In PBrAllreph 22, IIl1d
proor Iherecr II Llefllllndcd,
23, DOlllod pUtiUllnllO I'II,R,c,r, 1!129(e),
24, Donled pUnUIIl1II? l'II,R,C.r, 1029(1),
WHEREFORE, Durendllnt Plulllillllllnlll or AllIorlell, Jne" rclpecUlllly requem your Hcnoreble
COUrt to dllmlu Plllnllrrl' Complllnt wllhoUI COlt or Judglllentlo It,
NEW MAT'l'ER
25, pl.lnllrrs InJurlea Ind dlll1llIlU, wblch Irc ipeelOeally denied, were not cau.ed by IIIlY
lell, omlnlo/l.5, or brelchu of dUlY or Defendllll plWlIIl1 1111\I but were UlIIed III whole or In petl, or
were eontrlbuled 10 by lhe negligence, rllull, or Wlll1t of me of plllntlff,
.J.
J(), 1'111111111'''6' clullm ur~ hurrod III wholv Lit ill pllrl h)' IIlulllllll'l cLllllpmllve lIel/IIYUIi~u,
27, No dAIlNerllul or UIIIOrU ~olldlllllll v~IMe~ ul lul,llllIIe ulILl plu~e,
211, If 1111)' dUIIl/eroU6 IIr UlltiUlCt ~Lllldlllllll uxlbluLl, \\,I*h 16 6f1UCln~III1)' d~lIl~d, lJorelldUlI1
I'laUIIJ\l11l1l1 hALlllu oCluAl'Jr COllbll1JCllvu 1I1111~0 Llf such Clllldlllllll eKIIIIIIII"IIIIIII 1111I0,
J9, CerelldoJ\l "'umlll hills' cllnduCI WU5 1101 0 lulmUlIIllI1 rllc\llr in ~uullny PlulnllrrllnJurlel
IInd Lllllllnyol, If IIny,
WUJlIU:rOIU:, IJ~follullnll'lollbUllllnns 01 Alllurl~o, III~, rUspu~lh'lI)' r~4uom your lIonorAble
COUr\ hI LlIIIIIIIS 1'111111111"6' CLllllpllll11l wllhLlUllllbl lIr JllLllllllUl1l III II.
Nlm' 1\J,\,rnm IN TIlE NATLJItE or A CIH>SSC/.,.\II\J AGAINST
OEIIJo;NJ>ANTIS IUCI/AIUlItElm III ASSOCIATES AN/) AMIGO I\JOIIILITV INT'I., INC,
30, lJofunLlllnl I'lull6l1nl Inn6 IIIILlrpllrlll'!6 herein hy rureron" Iho IIVtrmOnu CllIIIUlllud III
PluIl1lIr(l' CIIIllf1llllnllllllllllbl lJ~rr.lIL1ulIIs Illdlllru IluCll & A6SlIcllllCI IIIIU ,AlIIllIlI MohllllY IlIIernullonlll,
Jnc, Inlhll 1I"lon, lJerellUll11l I'lmlllll Inlls dllel 1101 lIullllllhu IIvenllollll lIr 1'1111111111'1' CllIllplall1l, but
IlIcorporalo Iholll 6l11uly ror Jlul'JIlIm ol'lhll crnuclallll,
31, Any IIl1bllll)' 011 Ihe pllrt or PerelldullI I'lmulll 111111 which II Ipecll1clllly ~ollle~, Will
wholl)' 60colldllry alld pllnl"~ alld Ihu IIl1blllly Ill' Corolldll11l1 RlchurLl Reed & Anocllllel unLl Amigo
Mobllll)' 1l1Iurllllllolllll, Inc, wal prlmllr)' IIl1d IIcllve,
32, If 1111 delurmllled Ihllll'llIlI1llrr, IIro ul1lllled 10 rucover 1111)' or all orlhe dlll11118e6 601 rorth
IlIlholr Compllllm, which 16 6peclllclllly ~ulllcd, Ihell /.lerelldll1ll6 Ilkhllrd Ilel~ & Allocllllti IIlld Amigo
Moblllly Illlornlllilllllll, 1111 lire elllh s'llel)' llr JLlillll)' Iluhlc 10 1'11111111116 1I1ld IIru ealh ulLllle Iillbl~, Joll1ll)'
IIl1ble, llr lIuble over 10 Perelldlll11l'leuSllnI IIIIIS 1'01' 10l11rlhulloll, IlIdel1111lllcalloll or bOlh,
WHEREFORE, POrel1dlll1ll'lellSlIl1Ill1l1S or Al11erlca, IlIc. reipeclf1llly requelll your Honorablo
COUrt 10 Lll61111u PllIll1Ilrr6' Complllll1l IIlld Ulller Jod8111elll III lis rllVOr, In Iho ullernallve, Ir II 16
dcronl1lnod Ihal PI 11111I I 1'1'6 lire ollllllod 10 recover, Ihell Pofol1dlll1l PICIISlIl1l/nllS of AmerlclI, Inc" demands
-4-
'Ii
Ellhlblt 0
form an opinion ae to the truth or fal.ity of the .vermente
contained in paragraph 2 of ~laintift.' Complaint ~nd, if
applicable, etrict pr.oof ie demand,d at the time of trial,
), The allegatione eet forth in paragraph J of
plaintiffe' complaint ie no~ directad to the anewering
defendant and, the~efore, no anewer i. required under thl
Pennllylvania Rulee of Civil Procedure.
4, The allegation. eet forth in paragraph 4 of
plaintiffe' Complaint is not directed to the anewering
defendant and, therefore, no anlwer iD required under tho
Penneylvania Rulee ot Civil Procedure.
6. Admitted.
6. The answering defendant's tiret notice of an
alleged incident involving the plaintiff, Charles Huber, was
the receipt of a Summons. After reasonable invelltigatiol\,
the answering defendant is without sufficient information or
belief to form an opinion as to the truth or faleity ot the
averments contained in paragraph 6 of plaintiffe' complaint
and, if relev$nt, strict proof thereof is demanded at the
time of trial.
7. The allegatione aet forth in paragraph 7 of
plaintiffs' Complaint ia directed to a party other than t.he
answering defendant and, thereCore, no anewer ie required
under the Penneylvania Ruleo of Civil Procedure.
B. The allegationo eet forth in paragraph B of
plaintiffs' Complaint is directed to a party other than the
answering defendant and, therefore, no anewer il required
unde~ the Pennsylvania ~ulll o~ Civil Prunldu~l,
fl, The allegationl ut f'orth in paragnph 8 of
plaintltt~' complaint il di~lctld to a pa~ty other than the
,
anlwlring dlfendant and, thl~Qfo~l, no answer il requirld
undl~ thl Plnnllylvania RUles ot Civil p~o~ldurft,
10. Admlttld in part I den,l.ld in part. After
rlasonabll inve.t~gBtion, answeling detendant is without
autrident information or belillt to torm sn opinion 51 to
whether the plaintiff, charllll Huber, wa~ dl.abled and
confined to a wheel chair and wae using a mobility vehicle
msnutactured by thu an.wering defendant. It is admitted
that detendant, Amigo Mobility Int'l, Inc., was the
manufacturer of motorirted 11\obl1 ity carte.
11. The answering defendant's first notice ot an
alleged incident involving the plaintift, Charles Hublr. was
the receipt of a Bummo~s, After rea.onable inve.tigation,
the an.wering detendant. is without sufficient information or
beliet to torm an opinion a. to the truth or tal.ity of the
averment. contained in paragraph 11 ot plaintitt.' Complaint
and, it relevant, IItrict p~oof thereot is demanded at the
time ot trial.
12. The allegations set forth in paragraph 12 ot
plaintiffe' Complaint is directed to a party other than the
answering defendant and, therefore, no answer i. required
under the Penn.ylvania Rule. of Civil procedure,
cotnn' X
11, Anlwering detendant incorporatl' by reterlnce each
and ev.~ allegation containQd in their anaWlrl to
paragraphl 1 through 12 ae it tully lit torth herein,
14 , Denied. It i. denied that the anlwlring defendant
waa negliglnt and it is further denied thot thl incident was
in no manner what sOlver due, to any act, or omi/llion, on the
part of plaintiff, Charlea Huber. The allegation, ,et forth
in the plaintiffs' Complaint, Plaint if f, charle, Huber, was
negligent in the op.ration of a mobility cart,
15. Denied, The first notice of the incident
involving the plaintiff WaB the receipt of /I SUnU1\OnO, After
reasonable investigation. th~ anlwering defendant is without
,ufficient information or belief to fOl~ an opinion aa to
whether or not their product waR involved in the incident,
In the event it is judicial.ly determined that t.he product
manufactured by the answering defendant was involved in the
incident, then the anawering defendant deniell any negligence
on their part.
16.
17.
(a) The allegation, set forth in paragreph 17(a)
of the plaintiffa' Complaint are mixed conclu,ions of law
and alleged facts and, therefore, are apecifically denied.
(b) The allegations set forth in paragraph 17(a)
of the plaintiffs' complaint are mixed conclusions of law
and alleged facts and, therefore, are apecifically denied,
18. The answering def_ndant'a firat notice of an
all.sed 1ncidMnt involving the plaintiff, Charl'l HU~er, wa.
the r.ceipt of a SummOIl., Mt.1:' reuonabl. inv.ltisation,
the aneW' ring d.fendant h without uuffic1ent inform.tion or
belief to fOl:'m an opinion IlII to the tl:'Uth 01:' hleity of the
,
aV'J:'menta contain.d in pmragraph 18 of plaintiff., complaint
and, if relevent, Ir.rict proof ther.of is demanded at the
time of t,rial,
19, The answering ~efendant'l fil:'st notice of an
slleged incident involving the plaint iff, Charl.. >>ubel:', was
the I:'eceipt of a Sun~ons, Aftel:' reasonable investigation,
the answering defendant ia without lur.ficient infoJ:'mation or
belief to foJ:'m an opinion aa to the tl:'Uth 01:' fal.ity of the
aVlIJ:'menta contained in parDgnph 19 of plaintiU., complaint
and, if relevant, atrict proof thereof il demandod at the
time of trial,
20, The answering dofendant's first notice of an
alleged incident invQlving the plaint1ff, Charles Huber, was
the I:'eceipt of a Summons, After rea.onable investigation,
the enlwering defllndant h without .ufficient infoJ:'mation or
belief to foJ:'m an opinion as to the tl:'Uth or fallity of the
aveJ:'ment. contained in paragl:'aph 20 of plaintiff., Complaint
and, if relevant, atrict proof thereof is demanded at the
time of tdal,
WHEREVORE, the answering defendant, Amigo Mobility
Int'l, Inc., demandl that judgment be entel:'ed in it. favol:',
CotmT n
a, M.wer:ing dehrldant i"cor-pontu by nflll.'llnce each
,
and .vlry allegation contained in th.ir an.wers tQ
paragraph. 1 through ~1 as ~f fully aet forth herdin,
~2, The anawering defendant'. fir.t notic. of an
allegld incident involving the plaintiff, charlea Huber, wa.
the receipt of a Summona, Atter reuonable irlvut.igation,
the answering dehndant ill without .ufficllnt infortnation or
belief to fonn an opinion ae to the truth or falait>, of the
averment II contaiMd in paragraph ~~ of plaintiff.' Complaint
and, if relevant, lltrict proof thereof il demanded at the
time of trial,
23, The answering defendant'. fir.t notice of an
alleged incident involving the plaintiff, Charles Huber, wa.
I the receipt of a Summons, Atter flIl\llonablu inveatigation,
the answering defendant is without lIufticlent information or
belief to fOl;11l an opinion u to the truth or falsity of the
avermento contained in paragraph 23 of plaintiff.' Complaint
and, if relevant, lIt-rict proof thereof ie demanded at the
time of trial,
24, The answering defendant's first notin. of an
alleged innident involving the plaintiff, Charl.. Huber, was
the receipt of a Summons, After reasonable investigation,
the answering defendant is without sufficient information or
belief to form an opinion a. to the truth or falsity of the
avermentB contained in paragraph 24 of plaintiff., complaint
and, if relevant, strict proof thereof ia demanded at the
time of trial,
WHaRIFORa. judgment ie demllnd.d in ~avor o~ th.
.
anewering dl~endant, Amigo Mobility Int'l, Xnc,
lfJJf ~IR
~~, Plaintit~e' claime are barr.d by thl applicable
etatute o~ limitation..
~6. P1Aintif~s' olaimB ar. barred by the doctrinl of
lachee .
~7. PlaintiUs' claime are barred or modUied by the
ccmparativ. N.glig.nce A~t or Penn.ylvania,
28. Plaintit~s' injuries, it any, wore due to the
action. of. third parti~s ov.r whom answering detendant had
no \lontrul.
~9. Plaintit~B aBsumed the risk.
30, If it is judicially proven at the time o~ the
trial that the ~roduct in question was manu~actured by the
an.wering defendant which waa involved in the inoid.nt which
is the subject matter of this suit, said allegation being
Ipacifically denied, the product was subject to impropar,
abnormal, unfor....n or unattended ule or misu.e to the
product a~ter it lert the oare, au.tody and control of the
answering defendant.
WHBREFORE. answering de~.ndant, Amigo Mobility Int'l,
Inc., denies any liability and demands judgment in their
taVer and demands that the Complaint be dismis.ed with
prejUdice and that the answering defendant be awarded costB
of this action, reasonable attorney/s tees an~ Buch ether
....Her aD the COUl.'t d..ms equitable and just.,
lfIW MA TTlI\ l1JfJ) 11\
IA. ., a ..L-_U U tdU)L'I'ILI.oNLO'-..A.-CJ\OJJ~LADI
3:L. If the plaint. i U 'suBtaiOf,ld the accident or
1njul:'ie" averred in the COlllplllint, which is expnuly
denied, ".me werQ cBused or uontributQd to by the negligenca
on the pal:'t of the co-defendant", rleasant Inn, Supel.' Motor
8, Inc, and Richard Reed an~ Associates,
l2, The negligence ot the afo~esaid co.defendants
consisted of the partiGularll oet forth in the plaintiffs'
Complaint, Said Complaint is incorporated herein by
l.'eference without admission or adoption and solely for the
purpt)u of this New Matter Plu:suant to Pa. R,C.P. 2262(d)
and only those allegations of the Complaint which refer to
the co-defendants. sy virtue of the aforesaid, the
answering defendant avers that the afore~aid co-defendants
are liable, or liable OVer to it on the cause of action
declared upon by the plaintiffs, or are jointly and
severally liable thereon with the answering defendant by way
of contribution and/or indemnity, any ll.ability on the part
of the answering defendant being specifically denied,
WHEREFORE, answering dotendant, Amigo Mobility Int' 1,
Inc. prays that in the event that a judgment is entered in
favor of the plaintiffs and that said judgment is entered
against any or all defendants that said defendants are
liable OVQr to the defendant, Amigo Mobility Int'l, Inc, for
indemnification or contribution together with all attorney's
,.
CHMLIES and IIMBMA HOllIER,
Plaint-Hfl
v.
XN TBlE COURT OF COMMON PLJAS
CUMBlERLAND COUNTY, PlENNSYLVANXA
NO, 06-4BOO CIVIL TlERM
CIVIL ACTION . LAW
1l1.IEASAN'f INNS, SUPIER Il MO'fIEL,
INC" RICHARD REIEP &.
ASSOCIATES, p,C" Rnd AMIGO
MOIHLI'rY IN'l'U:IUINI'IONM" INC"
Pefendant-I
~IPLY 0' DI,IHDANT PLIAI~ lUUJ,
~ ~TT.~ 0' DI'.ND~IaO ~011LIT1
AND NOW, Defendant PleBlilent InnlJ of Amerioa, Ino.,
(1noorl:llotly duignated lU Pleasant Inns. SupaI." 6 Motel, Ino.l, by
its attorneys, ThomBlil, 'fhol1lall &. Hafel.", files its Reply to New
Matter of Defendant Amigo Mobility os follows I
31, DlIInied, Defendant PleaUl\t Inns IiIplloifically denies th.at
it was negligent or caused or contributed to Plaintiffs' injul."iell.
By way of answer, Pefendant Pleellant Inns incol."poratell herein by
reference the averments and donials contained in its ArUIWel." and New
I
Matter to Plaintiffs' Complaint,
3;1, The averments of ParRgl."aph 3;1 state condulIions of law to
which no answel." is required under the applicable Rules of civil
Procedure. To the extent an anSWer is required, Defendant Pleallant
Inns specifically deniea that it ill liable to Plaintiffs 01." liable
over to Defendant Amigo Mobility in this matter, By way of fUl."ther
answer, Defendant Pleall8nt Inns incorpol:lltes herein by reference
-1-
~, Vi .a,aJ
rr IE ~
~,:: ~~
1,/1 fiI
\0 :'J:~
,l~ 1:;1 -
'~\J.I i '.
, ..
.l.) Ii9 "'0
~ ,:.:j ~..
.I I...~
t"'_)
"
.,
;)
,.
Ii
I:
,II
"
tr: '1/ ~
rl ,;i '.. Ii.
~~ : It'i
13, ' r.l' ~ ; t '~
.'..1
(.1, r~.
bf ,"
.. I, \
III: ~~ ,,: ~a,
I
I' ~ l~
u
! I I ,
~ I Ii I
dlq~R
Udl
I,
CIIAIU.ltS HUnltl~ Mil) n!\lUlAM
II ur3ltI\,
IN TIIH COlll\'\' liP ('()MMMON IlI,lli\K
()II CllMIlHl~\.AN\l cmINTY,
IlHNNIiY\.VANIA
NO, 1)l\.,tt\IlO
CIVil. ACTION. I.AW
1l1~lnlll'l'll
v,
IlLlWiANT INNS, IilIIlHl~ K MOTI!l.
11ICIIAlm lump & MiSOCIA'l'I!li, ".C,
AND AMIGO MOlllI.l'J'V
INTI!I\NATIONAL, INC.,
JJurun~III\l1
v.
LOBAI\,INC"
A~~llll1IlIIl IMun~~nl
lS~
TO: AlIIlKo MohllllY Inlurnlllllllllll. Inl:.
C/ll thulr I:llunlel
Gernl~ I, Cllhun, E~qulre
Gerlll~ I, Cuhen J.IIW A~~udllle~
1I LelllllY lIuu~u
115 ItuullIfllrlltlllld
Phllll~elphlil, l't\ 1'111'1
you Al\E llEl\EBY NOTlrmp 10 llIc 1\ wrlncn I'espons~ 10 Ihe encloscd AIIswer
wllh New MillieI' wllhlnlwenly (20) dllYs or 1\ JUd811l11nl 1I11lY bllllnlcred 1l111lh\SI you.
I I
/1,./'/1
DIlICd: (" "
\
i, y.!
PETERS & WASIL, .J1SKI
/ '
BY: ( . ,t,'/)!
, el\nl~ l. Bunelll, Esqulru
1.0, Nu,: 3432'1
2/)31 Nurlh Frunt sncel
IllIrrl~hul'l~, I't\ 17110
(717) 238-7555
Allurney for Defen~l\nl
4, lJunluLl, I.llhlll' IN mlvlNud hy coum~'1 1I1llllhUI'ulill'U IIVUI'N Ihlll lhu IllIulllUhlllH
Cllllllllllud III fllll'lIl1rllph 4 flU1'l1l11l III II plll'ly lIIhu,' Ihllll I.ohlll' 11I1LI, llwlUrol'U, 110 IIIIHwur IN
1'1J~lulrud, 'I'u Ihu U~IUIU 1111 III1HWUI' IH I'ULlull'uLI. Ihu IlVUl'nlUlIlH cUlllUlIlULI III plll'lIlll'llph 3 IIru
dUllh:d PUI'HlIll1U lu PII,IU',", Ill21J (U),
~, Ilulllul!. I.uhlll' IH 1I1lvllUlI hy ~oulIHul IIl1d Ihul'ullll'U IIVIII'N Ihlll lhu IIlIulIlIIIllIlN
CllIIIIIIIIUd 111 11ll1'IIj,1rllph ~ flul'lUllI III II pliny lllhul' Ihllll I.llhlll' IIml, lhul'uI'oI'U, IIIl 1I11NWUr IN
I'Ullull'ud, 'I'll Ihu UHIUIU 1111 III1NWUI' IH I'UIIIII I'ud, Ihu IlVUl'nllJllIH cUlllUllI~d 111 plll'lIllrllph 3 1I1'U
dUll Iud plll'HIIlI1II hI PII,IU',I', 11I21) (II),
6, Ilulllul!. Mlul' rUIIHLl/H1hlu IIIVUNlllllllloll, I.uhllr IN wllhmll kllowluLlIlU Ill'
1111'01'11I1111011 Mlfl1cllIllllll IiI 1'11I II hllllur IIN hI Ihllll'Ulh llrlhu IlVUl'lllulIlH ClIllIllllluLl 111 plll'lIl:1l'IIJlh 6
IIl1d lhll HIIIIIU IH IhuMilrll LlII II lull , fly WilY or ,Imhul' III1NWUI', 11111 IlVlIl'IllUlIlH COlllllllluLl III
pllrlllll'lIph 6 111'11 dllllluLl JlllI'NUIIIII lu 1'1I,IU'P, lOll} (II),
7, l>1:nled, I.uhllr Is IIdvlsud h)' cllulIsul IIl1d Ihllrllllll'lI IIwrs Ihlll Ihu 1I11UIIIIIIllIIH
CUlIllIllIUd 111 Jl"r"j,ll'llph 7, IlIcllldlllj,l HlIhpllrlll!l'IIphH w) IhrlllJllh (Ll), III1Ulllrl hI plll'lIphrllNU Ihll
1I11111111111lllS cUllliIllIUd 111 PllIllIlllTs' ('ulllplllllll IIl1d 111'11 Iherur'lrll LlUlllud, By WilY lll' flJrlher
II II SWill' , Ihe IIWl'Illellls Clllllllllled 111 Plll'lllll'llph 7, IlIchullllll slIhJlllrllllrllphs (II) Ihrllugh (Ll), 111'11
dUllleLl plJl'SUIIIII III 1'1I,It.C,P, 102l) (e), By WilY or rllnhllr II IISWIl I' , II fill r I'lIl1HOllllhlu
IIIWHlll:llllloll, I.uhllr Is wllhlllll kllowluLlllu 01' IlIrlll'lllllllllll sunlclelll III rlll'lll II hllllur liS hI lhu
II'Ulh Ill' Ihu IIWl'lllllllls ~IlIlIIlIIlULl 111 plll'lIl!l'lIph 7, IlIcluLlllI1! SUhPIII'III.U'lIphH (II) Ihl'llUllh (Ll), 111
the HIIIllU Is Ihlll'ururU LlullleLl,
8, l>lIl1led,
I'Il,R,C,P, 1029 (II),
Thu IlVllrlllulUH clllUllllleLl III plll'lllll'lIph 8 III'U Llullllld purHIIll1II III
By WilY ul' rUl'lhel' III1SWUI', 111'1111' I'IlIIHllllllhlu IIIVUHlllIlIllolI, 1.(1hlll' Is
WllhLlUl kllllWluLlNIl Ill' IIll'Llrllllllhlll bufflulclll III lill'lll U helllll' Ub hI 11111 II'lllh Ill' Ihu UVUI'lIIulll~
UIIllIlIlllUdll1 fluru~rurh K Wllh rU/,IUI'lIILl Ihu bfluulllc ILlUUIILlIl Ill' ILlUUllLlllb Ill' IlIu flrellllbub uI'
lJefllllLlIIIIl, l'IOUbUlIllllllb Ill' Alllurku, I lie " IIIVLllvullllllhlllllWblll1 flIU11 hy 1'111111111'1',
I), DullleLl, Thu IlvuI'llIulllb ULlllllllllud III l'UJ'IINI'Uflh l} II1'U Lllllllud pursUullI III
1'1I,ltC,l', 11129 (ll), By wuy Ill' l\lI'IhuI' IIIlSIVUI', I.llhur Is IILlvlblld hy ullullsulullLl Ihul'ul',ltU
UVl!I'b lhullllu IIl1uyulllllls ULllllulllUlll1I flUJ'II[lI'lIflh l} sllllll ~LlIlUlubhHlb Lll""W III whl~III1LlIIIIIWUI'
Is rllqulruLl,
10, DUll lull , Thu uvunllulllb UIlIIlullIULll1l PIIJ'll[lJ'llllh 10, 11I~llILlIIl[l bllhfllll'lIlll'UJlhs (u)
lhrLlllllh (e), IIru LlullluLl flUrbllUJ1l11l 1'1I,ltC,I', 1029 (0),
I J. lJellleLl, Thu UVUI'lIlU1l1s ~LllIlulllud III fllll'll[ll'Uflh II 1I1'1,! LlullleL! Ilursunlll 10
ru,I~,C,I', 1021) (e),
12, lJullleLl. Thu lIVl!r1llllllls UllJ1lullled III IlUrulll'llllh I~ uru dUllled PUrbllUll1 III
ru.R,C,r, 1029 (e),
13, lJullluLl, The UVUl'llIeJ1ls cLllllullled III flUrU[lruph 13 ure dUll Iud flursuulIl III
ru.R.C,l', 1029 (u), lIy wuY Ill' furf.hur IlIlSWur, Ltlhur Is luJvlsuLl hy cllullselulILl lhllrel'i.lre
uvers lhllllheullul!lIll11IlS CllJ1lullluLl III flurul!ruflh 13 stule cOllcluslollS ullolluLl which 1I01lllSWer
II requlrud,
14, DellleLl, Thu UvurtlleJ1ls ullIllullled III Jlllrll[lrUflh 14 uru Llulllud flllrsuulll hI
l'u,R,C,I', 1029 (e), lIy wuY or further UIlSWur, Lllhur Is uLlvlbuLl hy coullselUlld Iherel'nre
livers Ihllllhellllul!UllllllS ClllllllllluLlln pUl'IIl!ruflll 14 slule cOllclushlllb ulIlllled whluh 110 II111Wer
Is required,
WlIl!IU!I'OIU!, J.uhllr, IIIC, LIUIllIIIILl~ JULl~IllUUllllll~ rIlVUI' 1IIlLIIIWIIIII~1 ChurluH lfllhur
1I11~ IIl1rhlll'1I lIuhlll', I'lulI~1I111 Itlll~, IlIe.. Itlchlll'Ll ItUULI III1lI A~Mlehllul, 1),(', UII~ AIllIWLl
Mnhlllly JIIIUJ'IIlIlhllllll, IIlC" wllhmll cn~l,
NJ1;WMAU'ml
I~, PIIIIllI"""I1Ullu~ Ihllt hu WII~ Il1juI'ed UI1Ul' 1I11111U AULlU~1 ~1I, 11/1)4, 'I'hu
Cnlllplullll Jull1ll1~ Lnhlll' WII~ 11111 f'IIed ullIlI April 2J, 1'11/7, Thu cllIlll1~ nr I'lulllllff' IIrll hmu~
hy IhllUJlpllcllhh: Sllllllle ul' I ,llIlllllliull~,
16, Plllllllllr~ IIl1el/ud IlIluI'lu~ III1Ll dIlIllIlLle~, If lillY, which 1I1'1l ~pucll1clllIy LlUIIIIILl,
IllIlY hllvu heul1 CIIU~uLlllllhel' III whuh: Ul' III plll'l hy Ihellcl~ III' ull1l~llulI~ llrlhlrLl flllrlluH nlhur
lhllll Luhllr,
17, Plllhlllff'~ IIIJuI'lu~ III1LI LlIIIllII~e~, II' lillY, which 1I1'1l ~flucll1clllly dellled, IllIlY 11IIvu
huulI JlI'I:.c:~I~III111, ullhllr III Whllh: ut' 111 pllrllllld/lll' 1I111 cllu~lIl1y t'ulllluLl hI lhll IIccl~ulll HlvllIg
rl~c: lUlhu pl'ululllllllllIlIIUI1,
III, Plllhllllr~ dllhll~ 1I1'1l rllLlucuLluI' hlll'ruLI hy Ihe ("llll/llll'llllve NUlllIgul1cu Acl.
I'lnhlllff'~ cnl1trlhulury I1UlllI!!UIlCU CUI1~IMIILl M, Illlll~ III II IIl1lltuLl Iu:
II, FIIIIIII!! III PIlY IIIIUl1llul1 hl whel'c hc WII~ Llrlvll1!! hl~ lll11hlllty cllrll
h, FIII 1I1111In UIC IIJlprIlJll'IIIIU IllIlIlCUVCl'~ III Llrlvc hl~ ll1uhlllly CUrll
c. FullIl111ln IllUk WhCt'1l he WIl~ dl'ivlllg;
d. FulIllI!! III ~clcct 1111 IIItCI'IIIIII1 plllh whulI UIIC WII~ IIvllllllhlu III hllll, nr
rllquu~IIl~~I~IIIIICC;,
e, FIIIIII1!! III U~ll rellSllllllhlc: CIll'C whclI drlvll1!! hl~ ll111hllllY cllrt;
f. Prlvlll!! hl~ Il1LlhllllY ~1Ir1I1II1I1IIllJlropur ~JlccLl ulldllr Ihll clrculllsllIlICIIS,
II), 1IIIIhlllll'N' ~"IIIIII IIru hllrruLl hy lhu IltihUlllpllUIl ul' lhu rlhk LlU~ll'lllu ulldur lhu
lil~u IlIId ~lrllUIlUlllll~Uh ul' Ihu pruhulllllllhU,
211, AllY wUI'k pcrrul'IlIuLl h~ I.lIhlll' Wllh lllllllpluluLl hcrurll lhu AIM hll~lllllu
ufliMlvll, Thuruliu'u, IIIlY l'u1lulrulllullIl lll' Ihu ADA 111'11 hllll'pllllllhlu IlIlhu wllrk purlimlled hy
I.uhlll' ,
WIIJ!IUwoIW, I.lIhllr, III~, IlulIIlIllLlh JuiJlIlIlulll 1Illlh rllvllr 1I1ll11l1lllhlbl CllIIrlllh Huher
IIlld Illlrhllrll lIuhur, PIUllhlUII IlIllh, lilli" Itlllhllnl Ituud 111111 AhhllClllluh, p,C, IIIlLl AlIllllll
Mllhlllly lllllll'lllllllllllll, lilli" WllhllUllllll1.
l'iEW MA'I"mJUlIlliiUAN'l' TO l'A,BJ:Jl'...J.UZUll
ldIbllr. lnll. v. l'II!IIH~IIIIIlIlH.1Il.AJllirk!I;Jm:,. ItllIllllrd It~1UUll
A.uudJllUd!J.cu.JllUlAmJw..MubillIY IlIlurllllllJJJJ!I1.Jmt.
21. L.uhllr hcrllhy 11I~llrpUrllluh PllIlllllff'h CUllIp11l11ll wllllllUllILllllllhloll or IIdoplloll,
Lllbllr IIlhlllllllllrpurlllllh Illllllhwur III Addllllllllll Dcli:lldlllll ClIlllplllllllllh lhllugh lhe IlIlIle
werc rully hOI rllrlh hurclllllllclll!lh,
22, III Ihu cvullllhlllllllY Ihlhllll~ II lilUIlLl11l UXlhllllllhc pllrl Ill' Ltlhllr, which
IIl1hllll~ Ih hpucln~lllly dClllod' IhuII Puti:lldIlJllh, I'ICllhlllll Inllh Ill' AlIlurlclI, JIlC.. 1~lchllrd Rced
& AhhU~llItllH, Il,C, IIIlLl AIlIII!Il Mllhllll~ IIllCrIllltllllllll, JIlC, IIru IIl1hlcovur llll..ohllr fur
clIlllrlbutlulllIlILl/llr IlIdcllIlllllclIllollllr Ih Jolnlly III1Ll huvurnlly IIl1hlclo PIIIIIllIl'fti,
23, Illlhu cvcllllhllllhc hllnn, IllhhUh Ill' dllllllll!Uh IIllcl!cLl h~ Pllllllllfl'ti lire roulld 10
c"I5I, which III'C HJluclllclIlly dCllluLl, IhCllellhur I'ICIIHIIIll hUlh Ill' AllIurlcll, IIIC" Rlchllrd Reed
"J!lp'lI1IC A'l'~ UII !i1!1l VlC'l!
I hUl'uhy t:llrlll~ Ihnl II t:IlIIY Ill' Ihn 1'11I~1\1l11l1\ ItuKllllll~~ Ill' I Mt:lldlllll I\It:hnl'd Itulld &
AIIIlt:lnllll, I' (' III NilII>' MIIIIl/I' Ill' 1.llhlll, III~ WII~ ~ulwd Ihl~ LIIII~ hy 11~llllKIIIII~ snlllllllllhl/ IIUII
OIl1t:~ III ('nl'lIlll1. IIA, Ih'll dllKK 1Il1l1!. IlL1SIIIl\U pluplll<l, n<l<llmulllls l'II1IlWK
llulIlIls J 1I11llulIl. I'.squllu
1'!'.'I'Il.ltS &. WASII,I'.I'SI,I
2'1.11 NUlth hU1I1 SlIuul
1Il1lTlslllllll, I' A I '/1 III
1'llwIII<l1 SWI~hllr. \'.Mluhu
BLANK, ItOM\'., ('OMISI<' \' & Md'Alll.IW
1200 l'uUll'ulI1I CUlllull'hl711
I'hllll<ldphlll, I' A 1'lIll,1
Jllsuph J Itul~wuIJ:I" I'squllu
MANTEI.. ('OIlFN, (iAltF.l.l<'K
ItEISW!'.IUi &. FlSIIMAN
Sultu 800, l<,uySIUIIU ('Iussllll\ 111117.11
8888 KuySllllIU ('Iushlll!! lIuulevlIl'll
11I<lllIlIlIputls, IN ,\h.I2ll.,lh.1()
Dllvld I. S.-!lwlllm, !'.squilu
TIIOMAS, TIIOMAS &. IIAFElt
JO~ Nullh hU1l1 Sired
1'0 lIux '}')')
1I111r1shlll!!, I' A 17108
(iuIIII<I J ('uhUIl, I'squlle
OEMLlJ J ('OIIEN LAW ^SSO('I^n~S
n.lo Wesl Sdllll)llluuse I.lIl1u
"0 Bux 442,17
I'hllllddphlll, "A 1')\,\4
MAlnSON, llEAIUlORFF, WILl.IAMS & OTTO
BYGc-Ill~ie . 'II ,JI~~a,----
Tun Ellsllli!! \ Sneel (
CIII'tlslu, I' A 17ll 1,1
(717) 24J.,1.14I
AI\Ullleys 1<1I' llell!II<111111
I' r.! ~!
" ,:r.
.. "~r ~l
... 'I
t~ (. ,:,'
k 'U
.,1 i"IIJ "
1'1 ) ,,'J' ,
mil t," 1'1 ill
~,
I. ') ti !I!
15 r; iJ .,
, I
"
t ! !
j~II'
~ ti q
J~l
~
:,
"
,!
"
I III
"
,
,
I
"
"
I:
,
,~
, I
, ,
.
.
and again/lt the additional detendallt, Lob/ll:, Ine" tor CO/lt/l ot
thi" action tor other appl:opriate relief,
HlW NATTIM OHDla PINHSVLVANXA RU~IS 0' axvx~ PROCIDURI 2252(d)
ADWIIIJL.T.Q-AJ2JU.T.lOlfAL.JtIUlWNfJ.wQIAR;-1JU1...
24, If the plaintife /luatained the accident or llljuriel
averr~d in the Complaillt, which itl expnllllly dellied hereill, the
lame were caulled or contributed to by tha n~gligenulI 011 the part
of the additional defendant, Lobar, Inc,
25, '~e negligence of the aforellaid additional defendant
oonBilltll ot the pllrticulull llet forth in the CQmplaint joining
the additional defendant aB a party to thill lluit all well all
8ll~g8tionll contain~d in the plaintiff'll original Complaint,
Said original Complaint ill incorporated herein with reference
without admillllion and adoption and 1I0lely for the purpOlle ot thill
New Matter purlluant to the Pennllylvania Rulell of Civil Procedure
2252(d) and only tholle allegationll of the Complaint ageinBt
additlonal defendant which refer to the additional defendant, By
virtue of the aforeaaid, the defendant, Amigo Mobility
International, Inc" aVers that the aforeaaid additional
defendant is liable or liable over to it in a cause of action
declared upon by the plaintiff or the joining defendant, or are
jointly and lIeverally liable thereon with the answering defendant
by way of contribution and/or indemnity, any liabilit;y on the
part of the anllwering defendant being expreallly denied,
WHEREFORE, anawering defendant, Amigo Mobility
Internat.ional, Inc" prays that in the event that a judgment ia
entered in favor of the plaintiff, that lIaid judgment ia entered
VJ'~r:tc~!o..
QIIM~P J, COItIlN, IItatlll that hll ill the attorney tor
dlhndant, Amigo Mobility International, IllO" in the wil:hin
action, that he ill lIoquainted wiJ:h the taotll IIItt torth in the
tOrllgoing pleading and thllt the /Illl1le al:'l I:rlle and oorreat to the
bellt ot hill Imowllldglt, intol:11\ation and beUer and that thill
statement ill made lIubjeot to the penolties ot 10 Pa, C,S, 14904
relating to unllworn talllitioation to authorities,
"
I:
)!
'., ~'l j ~ ;"
f,: li ~ I
l) " ~ '
"J
)i , , "
t1. ", ,
, .. I
,.. "
,-.. , )
I,; I
II. " (', 11'11
'J
I "l 1//'.1
I' ,.. Ij I,
I. '~ 1,1' ['
"
1 ,
I
"
1 "
" I
, ,.
,
,.
I" ~~,
I; I,
1" c; I.
..
III' , (,'; I
)"
III, ' '
.', ' i '. i
'I' 1:- 11:'\
, ' I'':'
I" . r'
I I
I'll .'J I /
I. , L'; I r'
I ~ ! I r', ~
~J . '
,'. ~!
J ",
~ ~
j/II
"
II' I.'"
I II.
, " ,;
" Pi
Il, I
, II,
,
1'1: II' I ,
II "
,,' !jj , ,
I' [" li'jll
I') C'; I
I, d
!
~ ! ~ ~
~ II >, ~
"till
1111,
,
I
! I
)1
'I
, I
(190U1 I"
U_ll,
.,...,
CIIAI~l.nS IIlJnt!l~ ANDUAIUlAltA
IllJIIJ!lt,
IN Till! COllin ()JI COMMMON JlI,I!AS
()II CllMlllUU,ANI> COllNTY,
JlHNNIlYI.V ANIA
I'IlIlnlll1'K
y,
N(), IIIHHUU
CIVil, M,"I'Ic)N . I.AW
JlI.I!ASANT INNIi, SlIJlI!It K MO'l'IU,
lUCIIAltIJ ltElm Nt ASS()CIA'I'I!Il, 11,(',
AND AM1(lO MOIIIU'I'Y
INTHHNA'I'IONAI.,INC"
JMUlIlhll\l~
v,
I.OIIAlt, JNC"
AddlllulIlIllMcl/ldlllll
J'JC1'I'I'ION {,)Ii' AUJ)J'I'IONAJ. I>IW~J~UPIJAI~, INC. 1~()J\
~A V!~ '1'0 JOJN.AI)JU'I'ION.\L IUWI(.NJ>AN'I'
Addllllllllll Uufu 11I111 III Lllhlll', III~, (hul'I:lnllllul' "lAlhlll"), hy his ullder~lllllr:d euun~lll,
pllllllUllti IhlK ellUl'1 pUI'~UIlI1lIU IIII,ltC,II, 2H3 'ill' IIn Ol'dlll' IIl1uwlnl! Ihll Jlllndllr llf lUel1llrd
QIIIlII~ ilK 1111 AddlllulIlIllMulldll1ll Inlhls 1I~1I11n, IInd in SIII'P'll'llhul'ullf' IIl1ulICS II~ 'illlllWK:
I. 111111111 IIfs , Chlll'lll~ II lid 1I111'hlll'II J Iuhul', 1IlKIIIUIIld suit IIUIIIII~I urllllnlll
lM'endllllls, I'lc1I6111111n1l6, SlIpUI' K MUlul. IIIC" Itlchlll'd Ituud IInd Amlcllllus, II,C" IIl1d AllllUll
MubllllY 1 l1Iu rnlll 101111 1 , lllc.. un lJucclllhur 30, 191)6,
2, 011 ur IIhuUI AUUU61 29, 1994, III Ihu IIIIlU IInd plllce III111Ulld III PI II 1I1III'I's,
CIIlllplllllll, PIIIIIlllffK IIl1euu Ihlll Chlll'lllS lIuhur WIIS IIIJlIl'ud hUCIIUSIl:
II, Tht: ~Iduwlllk slupu WIIS lUll sruup;
\1, Thuru Wllti nil luvullllndlnll llulslclu Ihu donI' In RIIUIll 302 IInd Ihllrllls 1111
UXClItiKIVIlly Kleup rlllllp whul'u II JCVIlI hllldlnu IInd Illllnuuverlnu IIrell 6huuld hCi
l:, Thl/ WI'Ih:1I1 ~I'lll' III Ihe ~lllll' III l{lllll1l ~U2 eXI;uelled Ihl/ II1I1Xhlllltll
III1I1WIIl! hV ANSI NIIIII~IIIlJS: IIn~
~, Thl/ slduwlllk WIIS In vlllllllhlllllflhll AIIIIII'il:1I11S Wllh IllsllhlllllClN Alii III'
IIJI)l) Al:lIl/hhlhIIlIY CllIldelhlus uf Ilullllllllls IlIId FlIlIlllllus,
1. OI'lyllllll l>ul~lIdlllll PllIlINlIllI IlIns III AIIIUI'ICII, III~, llIulllI ('olllplllllll jllllllnl/.
I.llhlll' IIN 1111 Al!l!1111I1I1I1 nlll~lIdlllll 1111 AI'I'II H, IlIln 1I111111hllllhlll II' PIIIIIlIlffs' lire IInlltllld hI
I'U~llVUr III1Y Ill' 1111 llf Ihu d,lllllllluS sui till'lh III Ihuh' ('1111I1'111111I, Ihell I.llhlll' Is NI1IIIIy IlIlhlu hI
PlllhltlI'I's, jlllntly tlllhlu hi PIIIIIlIllh, lll' 11III11u llWI' III I'IUIINIIIII IIIIlS I'llI' cllnlI'lhlllllln,
IlldulIIlllllclllllln, Ill' hOlh,
,., Lllhlll' hulluws IIl1d Ihul'ufol'u livers Ihllllflhu IIlIu!!IIII'lIlN III' Plllllllllh' Clllllphlhll
III'U I'ruVUIl III 11'1111, Ihun 11111 pl'llpllsed Addllhllllll nlll~1l111l111 1{I~hllnl (JllulIS Is slIlul)' IIl1hlu In
PllIIlIIlITs, Is jnlllll)' Ill' sevcl'IIll)' IllIhlu lit' Pllllllllft's' CIIUSU ot' IIcllnn, III' IN IIl1hle IIWI' In I.llhllr
I'llI' full IIl~utlllllly IInd/lll' ~llllll'lhllllllll for 1111 such hiSS, aJllllllllluS lind/ill' cnUl'1 ~llsls liS tlJhllr
IIlIlY suITer liS II I'usuh llflhls IICllolI,
~. Lnlllll"S Ill'slnlllkc Ilflhls ~11I11ll WIIS viII Ihe JlJln~cl' ClllIIl'llIlnllllt:~ 1I1llllllS1 II
111I April 23, 1997,
6. Lolllll"s IIIVlJlvClIIulll III Ihls ~IIUNU 1It'IICllulI, I.u, lis CIlIl5ll1ll:lhm work III Ihe
pl'ulIIIses, occurl'ud IIPI'I'IlXhl1l1ll:l)' lwulvu YUill'S IIIlU 1111985,
7, Ll.lhlll' PUl'lIl1d 1I11~ duslI'oyud 1111 ot' lis l'ucllrdN clJllCUrnhllllhc CllllNlrucllolI wurk
III Issue Illlhls CIISU III 1992, pur thillI' UNUIII husllluss prllcllcu, COllsuquullll)', Lllllllr hilS heen
lilrcud III I'ul)' on ulher plll'llus III ",:~ulvu Illlillllllltllllllul!lIr~lnll snld CUIlNll1lctlull wllrk,
8, Luhllr WUK fill'Ct:lllll uhllllll CUIlIl/N 1I1'lhu phlllN ulld llruwhlllN ul' tllll CUIINII'lIt:llulI
pI'OJt:I:IIIIIKNUl/ I'l'lIllllht: J}UpIII'lIllUIIIIII'l.lIhul' IIl1d IIILlusrry,
9, SlIld dUClllllUlllij I'1:VL!lIlud Ihlll 1~lchlll'd (luulI~ hlld suhculIIl'lIclud Ihll t:1l1l~lrWlhl/l
1I1'lhu Wlllkwuy ullNMIU llllhlij CUijU,
Ill, This uvlllullcu, fill' Ihu IlI'sl IllI1u IlIlhu hl~hll'~ ul' lhl~ CII~l/, IlUIIIIK III lIu/lII/l1l11I
CllllduCI1111 Ihu plll'IIll'lhe pl'lIpuNell ALlLllllulIlIll>ulLmLlIlIlf, 1~lchlll'd (JUl/II~,
II. I.uhlll' IlIlij llIed Ihlij l'ulllllllI pl'lllllplly IInUI' IlIs~')VL!l'llIlllhu 1i1~1~ IlIdlclltllIlllhe
pUlulIllllllhlhllll~ uI'lhu l'l'upllsud Addlllllllul IJufimdllllL
12, Thu III1IlWIIIl~t: Illlhls l'ulllllIlI will pUl'llllllhu IIl1hllllluij IIlld rlllhlN uI'lhe vllrluuN
pllrlluK 10 he hUlIl'd 111111 dulul'lI1ll1ud III Ihu SIlIl1U Ihnu, Ihuruhy IIVllldlll1! II lI1ulllpllcll~ Ill' CIINU~
IIlId I'oMurlllll judlcllIl U~III1UII1Y,
I J, I.llhlll' will hu IId\'ul'suly pl'u.ludl~ud h~ dUIIIIIIIIl' Ihls l'ulllllllI, IIN h hllN II IIUlld
IIl1d lI1ulhllrluus u~lIl1l1ulllllusllhu Plllpll~ud AddillllulIl Dul'clldlllll which ~1I11 hu hu51lllljudlcltluLI
nllhu SIlIllU IIIIIU IIN PIIIIIIlIl'h' Cllijlllll!lIllIKllhu l>el'ulldlllll~,
14, Thu prupusud Adllhhllllll Dufi:lldlllll wllll1uI hu pl'ujuLlI~cd h~ Ihu Joll1dur IIIIhlN
1111t1Il!l' ijll1cU Ihu lilCIN whl~h I'1l1'1II Ihu hllslij Ilf IIl1hllll~ 1I1!1I111ij! him IIru ~lIl1plu IInLl
sll'llll!hll'urwul'd, 1111111Lllllull, Ill1ly Wl'llIul1 dl~~llvu,'y hllN IlIkUI1 plllcu IlIuN I'llI', Thuru hllvu heen
nil dupu~lIlol1s, Luhlll'. 111 Ilrdul' IU 111111111111.u 1111~ In~UI1VUlllullcu II) Ihu Addlllul1l1l Duli:l1dlll1l,
will pruvlde cuplu~ Iu him ul' 1111 dlij~uVL!r~ IIII1IUI'llIls l!ul1ul'lllud 10 L11t1u,
I ~, Nl:ilhcr JlIIIIIllIl'rs nul' urllllnlll l>urundlllll~ will hu plt:judlcud h~ JulllLlur ur Ihe
prupusud ALlLllllllllllllJlIl'Ulldlllll,
CEll'l'WICA'I'Ir. mr l1E1lVICI~
J mml!lJY cmnWY Ihlll n lI'Ut: Iln~ ~lIl'rl!~1 t:IlIlY o"lhll li)rl!lIolnIlJ'dllJulI rllr 1.IIIlYII
II) JIIIII AddllJulIlllUlIrlllllhlll1 hll~ ht:l!n duly ~lll'Yud uplln 1111 ~uulIsulul' IWlll'~ '1I1d pllrlll!K Ill'
hUllrl!.1 hy ~t:f1o~lIlnll Ihu ~1I11ll! III Ihu lInlt~d SIIlIl!S nlllll, Ill'~l ~hISN, IlllSlIIIll! pl'ul'lIlll, III
IIlIrrllhurll, I'I/IlIl~yIYnlllll, un Ihl~ -1-'- ~IIY lit' -1J.t!.w.i!.t <, , 11)1)7, IIddrml/1l II.
full ow. I
JIlKl!f1h J, Ht:lswl!rlJ, I!~~uh.t:
MuJlll/I, Cuhl/Il, ()lIrutl~k, l~ulhwul'!! & Flshlllllll
/lulll! 800, KuYNlonl! Crussln!! 1'1111.11
8888 KUY~11II1U CrIlSNIIl!! IIl1ull/vllrd
llllllllnllpoll~, IN >16240.463(,
J:!Ilwllr~ I. Ilwl~hllr, l!~~uh'l!
IJIllnk. HOlllll, COIllI~ky & M~Cllult:Y
1200 Four Pl!nll Cul1lur 1'1117.11
Phllllllt:lphlll, PA 19103
Ol!OI'Ilt: II. Fllllul', Jr., E~lJulrl!
10 EIIKlIlI!!h SII'uul
CllrllKlu, PA 17103
Ol!rlllll J. Cuhl!ll, EN~ull'l:
Ol!rnld J, Cohull Lllw Am)clllll!K
II LuIlIllY J Jou~u
lIS J~uullIforll{oll~
PhlllltJc:lphlll, PA 19119
lJllvl~ L, S~hWllhll. l!slluh'u
1',0, Box 1)99
J'lllrrl~hurl!. J'A l7l01l
('
(.1-t-OJ;!1'pli! I. ~~."..(..
EYOllllll K, BooYt:r
!
,..
-.t.
~
-
~r; '" " -1
~, ,.
II t. ,
"
II ~, , "
II" . ~ ';. ,
I.. I -, i' 't
~,d "~I " .
I' , I I,"
. ,
1',1, . v, ' I
'1,\..
I . ,
1', I" d
L'
II ! ,
~liJl
W/l
I,
, ,
, I
,
I
, I
II 1 UEO 0 5 1991
,
2, OI'INIIIIII IMimLllllI1. Ph!lIsUIll IIIII~ II" AIIlUI'I~u, III~, flIuLl II ('lIl11plllllll JIlIIIIIIN
I ~Ihnl' ILK 1111 AdLllllIIlIlI1 I )U"~IIllIIIII 1111 Apl'lI 2), 11)ln IIl1uNIII~ Ihlll I,. 1'llIllIllff~ IIl'u ulIIlllul1 III
IWIIWI' III1Y III' 111111" lhu IIUIIIII~U~ hul 1I11'Ih III Ihuh' ('1I11l1,lullII, IhulI I.uhlll' Is hlllul)' IIl1hlt: hI
Plulllllffs, JIIllllly IIl1hlu hI I'lullllllh, '11' lIuhlu II\'UI' III I'lulIslIlll IIIIIS "111' ~lIl1ll'lhllllllll,
11Il/l/III11IIlt:UIIIlII, Ill' hlllh,
~, 011111' IIlll1ll1 Cklllhul' I~, 1')1)7, l.llhul' pUIllIllIICd Ihl~ 1llllllll'IIhlu CIIIII'I lill' luuVI!
\l111l111 ALldlllllllllllJulimdulll 1~I~hlll'll (hIUII~,
.t 011 ()~llIlwl' 20, 1'11)7, IIpllll ~1I11~ldcl'llllulIlI" 1..lhlll"h Pl!llllulI I'UI' l.uIIW hI 111111
1111 AdLl1l1ll1I1I1 Ilu I'u 111111I II , lhlh I hllllll'lIhll! ('11111'1 hl~IIULlII 1(lIlc hI Sh'IW ('IIUSU Wh)' Ihu I(ullu"
l'uLluuSlud shlluld 1I1l1 he ~l'IIlIll!d, The lhllu WIIS I'cllIrnllhlu wllhllllWUlll)' dll)'~ III' ~cl'vlcu,
5, Thl! Ilmc pel'lllLl hllh pllsSCll 111111 1111 "ul'llu~ hllvc l'espllllLlud III Ihl! 1~lIh! III Shull.'
CIIU~U Why lhu l~ellul' I'cllllUSICl1 ~hllllld 11111 hu ~l'Il1l1cl/,
WIlElmJ:ClJ(E, AdLlltlullllllJulclldllll1. l.'lhlll', I'I!~pl!~II\'CI)' I'CIIUl!hl~ Ihullhls 1IIIIIIll'IIhlu
CIIIII'I Ilrlllll Ihl~ MlllIlllI 111111 IIlllku Ihu 1(lIle IIhslllulu, pU1'1111111111l l.uhlll' hi flIu II CIIlIlp11l11ll
1I1llllllSllhu pl'upllsud AddlllulIlIllJulclldlllll. 1~lchlll'Ll qllulI~,
PETm~S & WASILEFSKI
lJy:
DIIIIH(~ 1'l.Jflt7
3, A CUIlIJ111I11II WIIS flIud h~ PIIIIIIIIITN UII ll~~ulllhur 30, 11l!/6, II ~uJIY ul' whl~h IS
1I1111~ht:1l hUrl/Ill 1I111llllltrkud liS Hxhlhll A,
,~, C:UpIUN ul' 1I11111hur IlIUIILlIlIYs fllcd IlIlhls 1I~lIulIlIl'u 1I1111ChulI ht:rt:111 111111 IlIl1l'kull
liS l!xhlhllll, liS rUlllllrull h)' I'II,JU',I', .W,
~, 011 III IIhuUI AlIYlISI JI), I'J'N, III Ihu IhllU IIl1d plll~u III1Ullull III PIli 111I IfI'b ,
Cumplllhn, PllllllllffK IIl1ullU Ihlll ('hllrllls 1I11hul' WIIN IIIJlIl'lll1 hIlCIIUNU:
II, TI\I! slLluWlllk slllpu WIIS hlu h1IlUP:
h, Thul'll WIIS 1111 luvulllll1ll1l1llllUlshlu Ihu dUlII' hI J{lllllll 302 1Ill1llhul't: IK 1111
uxcUSNlvul)' SluUP I'lIl11p whuru II luvul hlllLlhll\ IIml mlll1uuwl'lllll IIrell
shllu III hu:
Il, '1'111: vul'llclIl dl'llp III Ihu ,j UIl I' III HllUIlI 302 ex~uudud lhu IIII1XIIllUIII
IIl1llwud hy ANSI h1l1l1dlll'dN: IIl1d
d, Thu NlllcWlllk \\'IIS III vlllllllllll1 "I' Ihu AlIlull~III1'b Wllh lllNllbllhluN A~l Lll'
11)1)0 AC~CbKlhllh>, GlIldulhwN ul' lIulldll1Ys IIl1d FII~lIhlus,
6, ^lldhlu.l1I1 llul'ulldllnl 1..lhlll' slIhml1l1'lI~lull Ihu CIlI1Sll'lI~lhlll Ill' lht: rump ur
WlllkwlI~ IIIINSUU IlIlhls CIINU Iu Addltllll1l1ll>ulimdlllll Hldllll'd GUUI1N,
7, ^lldhllll1l1l Ilcli:l1dlllll I~lchllld (JIlCl1b WIIS I'UNPUI1Nlblt: 1'111' Ihu cUlI5tl'Ut:llllllllf Iht:
I'IIlIlp UI' WlllkwlIY,
II, If lhu I'lIll1p .". wlllkwlI~ WIIS dUIl!Cllvc IIl1d Ul1l'UIISUl1l1hly dIlI1IlUI'UUK, which IN
Npuclnt:lIl1~ dUl1lud, lhUI1 Alldhllll1l1l Iluli:ndlllll 1~lchlll'd GUUI1N Is Nlllul~, JIlIIIII~ Ill' NUVCI'IIIl~
IIl1hlu, Ill' IIl1hlu UWI' lu Addllllll1l1l Puft:lldlllll Luhllr fill' Plnltnlffs' InJurluK IInll dllmlllll!K,
,
~
~'v
... ul ~; ~
~I; ~
F,' :!J ~ I , i:..
\,11/ ,,' I,~;;, 1.1
1\:(" LI.: tf.
" 1'" .,
.1. I 'Ii
[I" , I~' ('Ii
" rib"
P,\ N
''1 l "
~ ~l' ~',
, I Jt W~
I" ~
\~j ~~ t:
~ ~
~
! ~
l~ I d
~ If ~
dlq',
Udl
'I
II
I ,
, ,
..HI ~ 1l1'l'JI1f;t?
f\t olt '..
r'r ... 1'.
:,~ '1
r i '"fI
,. i
1" 'If ' I~
;,,,1 10, , ),,1
II' : '11 ./ '
I ,',
I~ , ;1'., ,,' ,,~ .
" ''''II
", l,'..
l'. )~{ n
.'
!
~ I , I
~Jr:
. 'Ill
!II/I
"
\,
~ ,JUN II 9 1998
I'
I,
r;j ~ ~; I, "
rl~ "1
& ; "',
I. 'r.
I.;i ~ '~
j'r '.
'I , 'H~,l
'll!, ,.. ""1
6j!f. IN ','
r.,I~' W fJlm I'
I' ;3
b rr'
L,d
Complaint rlltu to a writing, which 'P"~III tor: Ll:llleU and 1. the
bellt evidence ot all 11; CJontdl'll, Ilnd th....lltor:. no rltlpon" LII
required,
", I\dmittQtl in part and dented in put, It 111 admitted
that oopieB ot other pludingB werl\l provided, 'l'llelul pleadings
being in writing, IIpeakB tor thelllselvel!l IInd h the pel!lt Illvidenae
of all they oontain, and thereforQ no l:'ellpOI'lBe iB required,
5, (a), (el), 'l'hh allegat ion of the f,obar I II Complaint
reten to original Plaintiffs' complaint, which being in writillg
Bpeaks for itself and is the beat evidencQ of all it contains,
and therefor.e no l:'eBpOnee ie required,
6, Denied, This allegation of the Lobar Complaint
cOIlBtituteB a concluBion ot law to which no rellponsive pleading
iB required, and therefore it ie denied,
7, Denied. '1'hie allegation of the Lobar Complaint
conllltitlltel!l a conclul!lion of law to which no rel!lponsive pleadillg
is required, and therefore it 1s denied.
8, Denied. Thie allegation of the Lobar Complaint
conlltitut~1!l a cOl'lcluBion ot law to which no responsivl\l pleading
is required, and therefore it is denied.
9. Denied, Thil!l allegation of the Lobar Complaint
conl!ltitutes a conclueion of law to which no relllponllive pleading
is required, and therefore it ie denied,
-2-
10. oenied, ~hi. allagation of the ~o~~r Compl~int
oon.titute. a o0l101u.iol1 ot law to whioh 110 re.ponNive pl~adi"a
111 requind, and therefore it ill dllniet1.
WBIllRIJPORIll, Additional Defendant Richard Jil. Cloe""
re,peotfully requellt.1!l thaI: thl.l!l Honorable Cou.t dhmil!ll!l the
Complaint of Addit ional Oefendant Lobar, Inc., joining Riohard Ii',
Goen., and entet judgment in favor of Mr. Qoenl!l and again.t
Lobar, Inc,
UII MATT.,
11. Lo~ar hall tailed to I!ltate a claim upon which relief ~an
be granted,
1:l. Lobar'l!l olaiml!l are barred by the dootrinelll of
oontributory and comparative negligence.
13. Lobar'. claims are barred by the dootrine of allll!lumption
ot ril!lk.
14. Lobur'l!l Claim. are barred by the appliaable I!ltatute of
l1mitationl!l ,
WHEREFORE, Additional Defendant Richard P. Goenl!l
reQpectfully reque.tQ that thi. Honorable Court dil!lmilll!l the
Complaint of Additional Defendant l,obar, Inc" joining Richal:'d P.
aoenlil, and enter judgment in favor ot Mr. Qoenlil and againllt
Lobar, Inl:.
-3-
.
NlK MA~1 IUllUA>>T 10 ,~, liQ.P, Wo, ia~~lb)
16, ~lAi~tittll alle9~ that they mUlltAined inju~ie. a"
averred ill JillaintHtll' Complaint, whioh iN inoorlilorated by
reterenoe hereill 1111 it Silt torth in full. "'he existenoe ot said
injuries and/or their oonneotion to the aooident reterred to in
Jillaintitts' comp\alnt iJ!l denied, '1'0 the extent it ill "etormined
that Plaintifts did auatain injuries, thoJ!lu injuries were oauued
or contr.1bllted to by the negli(lenca on the Jilat.t, of co'PetendantJ!l
Ple8eAllt Inns, Super 0 Motel, Inc" Richurd Reed & Aseociates,
P,C., Ami.\)o Mobility International, Inc" and Lobar, Inc.
19. The negligence ot the co-Pefendants consisted of the
particularll set forth in Plaintiff'lI complaint and in the Joindur
Complaints flowing therefrom. Said Complaints are inoorponted
herein by reference without admission o. adoption, and solely tot'
the purpol3e of this New MattI!/: pursuant to Pa. R.C.P. No.
2252(b), and only thoee allegations ot the complainte which reter
to the co,Petendante, By virtue ot the atoroeaid, Mr. Goens
avers that the co-Pefendants are liaple, or are liable over to
hinl on the caueo ot action declared upon by Plaintittll, or are
jointly and eeverally liable thereon with Mr. Goene by way of
contribution and/ot' indemnity. any liability on the part of Mr.
Goena being epecitically denied.
WHEREFORE, Additional Pefendant Richard ~, Goene
reepecttully requests that if judgment is entered in tavor ot
"I
I
,4,
~ "
..v'
-f
-0
3
]
p.: ~
j
~
') 0-.'-
-
jJ
}i; )
"
'I
II
I,'
, "
." In f',; "
I 1'"1 ,
I,~I, , -t..
~.I-~
il
"-1 I
1\' I'" I
I)' I' I
I' '_H , ,
Ir'; I I ~ ,
,
1"1 t; il,1
I'i j'i1h 01
, 1'1'
I " nj "
U ~I i..J
i1
ill
I
,
, I
01
, ,
.
"
'" III I
i' ." '.
i' \'1
Ill'
, " ,.,
Ii ,..
, ,
I "
1"1 ,
!'I
I, I ,
.
" ,
, , I
'eT '-. , - -
.u~ ,._....~:-=-- -~~
~. !
~
~~~ I ~~
~~~ ; ~~1~ ~
~~~ . ~ ~ ~ ~. ~ ~ ~~
~ ~
ot: 1 ~~
i- ' ~~~~ ~ ;,
~i5~ ~ ;r.. of.
~;~I i
g
e
.1
" I
.,
. '
., .
I .
I
, ,
, i
.' '
.' "iii"
.~
I,
,
I
I,
'I
'I'
I,
"
~~ ~ ~.
~
" ,o.jr:?
-
it:- I r' "
'j "':Jm
I}( "' l'
IrJi:, I ~re
If. \/ ~
.1:
~ f$l t ' "
I II;! 'J
..,
"
"
.
.
,
"
"