Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-05608 , , , 11,1': , I iJ ,) 'II' Ii ,/ I I' 1: ,. I. if II " , " , I " :;'_! 't ,; I, , ," ,. II ilt/'J! " I , ! " , " ","1, ,'I:,/P ,q\, " I, II, I , d ~ II r " I I, " , " ,1/ )'_1 ! 'I' ",' '1"'11 " 1'.[ ),/ . ',I i I \ ~ . , I: " ! 1'" lill t' o il '~' ,i"i'! Ii ,It ~-i!" :1,1 ~. ~ ,",~ ," ,t- ~, , ~ ~ l~ ~ ',~ ',~ " \ "I "'1,'- I ;:'{- ,Ii .) "I:r ill!; ;l , , ,', , " I; " " Ii' J P Ii "I ;)l,j , )1, 'I, I f,<I i_ \" 'lIt I:" I ';J,' , , , ' ,,"tI' i ), I ~ " , 'jr,'I,';; , " , , i " , , " I , , _"It, '_I' , " , , , ;, ,I " I '( 1)1 " ,_, " ,,' " r., , " :1 " ifl;,' '," q '1/1 I"jll , :1,)" ,I", "I" ' , ,'J, "',1 " j:" '1-,' " " , 'j!] , , "~'I , II ',', '," I') " 'i ' " , ,II' ',i' , , " ) II, ',I " i'J " "'Ii , ." " \ " , \) , 1i h J' Ii, ,I, , 't;li' " ;1-, 'I "'-I , " ""I, ! " , 1,;1 , '" " I ','1 ,\ ,i1 11 ~: I' I" , " ;)- , ' " , ' , , >,11 "I " , , 1/: 1,1- , ,( ~' ~' , , " "!'IiI , ,q " I ~ ; .. I l' , ' ,,' , " , " ," lill ) " '" , , ) rI' I, ,':-," j ;1 ,1-, , , - . . .~ - <:J " HII -11 , " ,;' " " ' ; t , I ) I' ~ I Iii , ' " il,l .),1 1:''1 11,,1 " 111,: 11:1 " !!li 'U I)'i , , ,,' , '-" " , , ,'J "'1 '/tl' -1,1 " , , , ('r' " " bo ~ ~, ."1 " " , , , L III 11,'1 " " "J,' , ,: 1,:'t',:,I'.','I"",i": I 'I'I -'l' d ':\ IJ :1 \ , ,,' 1.1',,'1 , I, II,! , , 'I :1, I"fll , I' ,,~ , 1 , I"'" '[ ll'fl' I ",",' c:ti ,j I' 1'-,1 , d i' , " " ) " " , ' " , , , 'I I' , , "~~.' " " I' " , " " ,'", ,Ii " , , "~I ,ti'l, " , ~ ,I 1/" ;11 I, ,) ,( ;, 1,1 , , " " it 'II \1,' , IJ -'-' " I" " ii, I' , II I'; 11'1,1, , .I, ' ! ;'"111 I ," 'III ','1;1 ! jI ,'; ,j ,I, 11'1 i 1/, \,11" JI"; .. ,,1' , 1'1' ":":, ,II, , ''I''', 'I' """"I!, , '( I") I, ,I;,;; I 'J - ,/1 ',I" 1 i'; fl, ; ':(, .,,,,' 1,:\1 /-! ,ill;,,' I' il ;'[' ;;1 j,! ;'Pi' "1:__//,, '/f)~,(!" '",1 ,I :',/,1" "" , Ii,' :,h!'q~ ,,; ",;, L,"Ii,\I\)IJ,d'I',.' I: '-I,', III:, I Ii '"'I,, '.j,r-'-'/ ,,;,,; .__rl,I!,,~ /1, ,! ;', ,I'" ;1f'. ,Y,', ,';I;'j:;, ;,;'}WI~; ''/'1,'1-': ': ';1: 'i/' ')'-,' IJ/ I,'; It ".J",,/I , ;'::,1::" ,:",,\I,:,(j/;,,:,I,:::';':' ,~:' 'i ",:'" 1, ('," I, " )i ,"I iJ":: ""I,!;I ',Ii ; , ',\1',1',',"'""),,.-1,; 1,1, , !! I"?' rn -, iI;",',d"j,-'" ,,11,11'1 I" I") jl ',! "I !,I,I ,~," i'!"lj'W-~)1 Ir,'l j - I / ; i ,,:,,\, \ I !, d', , ,Ii,'!" :1 J ;-.-: j : ,;!i 11:( ~; , f ... ~ I' !," , '"I, ',-' II'" I 'c' i~ :J: I " ,I :r", '" I','" 'Jl ',', '] i; 't! ;/'1}'" \i Ii!' I .!,;"i/fS:>D I', ;1, 1 ' ' ;} ;i:~.' I, / "I 1,Jl'r",~ \ . ,,' ! !;" ': it ',: :,~ t ,Ii -;\1 l! '- ,"," '1 ,f! 'l; \q::';', , /" I,:]", ':- ';,,11'1" ,','i:l( J' ,'/ "I).',!; 'I' "I}f, 1',1], 'l" "II! H, f ,j' ! 'I ,,_Il ' "iI, ,t/:";i :-)'.,' ':) r "J " 'I 'I J' "/,_Ii , ',I Iii}, r !I'!J ~,' r' ,I] '.1' 'Jl," I i '[ 'I if '/-'ij "I' , ',' IJ II-! I,' ',I'! ")it " 'rl,t I" 1'\ Ii 'Ii ,l"li , I, '1]./' I') ;1,( 1,1" " ri I' .)'1 ! I ! ~ J , , ','I " i;I'/:' , !'k, ,1'1 " , ',' I,' " !, ," i'I,' !: " " ;,1 'I " I'i " ,I' " " ,},) J " " , , !,j I,i ;! f,l I -'i) ,I' Il' 1(' , l'il: ii Ii",: " !' "! 1'1 , p, , j' ]i "1 ", I -f" 'i " II,) , I' i' t' ,,' ,-,I J,I": 'I' 1 " !j' " , , , ,'I'" ',' :,1. 'I, .i'i'il' , \ \--, n,tJ.'1 , , , 'I" lilli' 1, 'I' :' " 'fll!, J " i', " " ", -',:fl, "''''1' I " " , l!;".il ,'/1)1"1 I" I'll If !'I',III t ; If ~ ;! t" _" .' , I, " -"-1 ,I' f; -',',1 '1',1 " 'I ,1.1.,; -,I, ;'1; il'p" '1< I "lI,i :('I'i';' 'I'!;' ',jlIL I d ' -"1'" ;i, ,', . lI'r:'fjHf "'I'.i , '! ~ ,\' '; -, I J Ii t , ,'"" '\:l', '1', \!;I/\>lII'I__','",.I : ",',II" '.11'1 I ;! ;"I.-H, 'I' . ,'I "!, ,', I:" 1--' i ',;:;(, i':) , f I i',,1 ,,1,l.r,I'; ; ! ' ~'11' 1, ,',',"1 'I';','.' .f,f'" , 1" d )1 '1'" ',I,' 'it, 'I , 'I , , dl " 'I " 1--- I' . , I ~ \ ; I " , "~'I .ill, ,'j'\J) 'II i,l,'1 ., ,\ .1/ " ~ /1 'I :, '1,1. ' ,,' I! , '" .. , "'-j It),' , ',;' '\", 'L, IJ , '1;.J.'-jl'!!,t, '\"1 ",!' 'j' ' r ,1;1; 1'1 ;..~ ,I \ /! , 'II' tl,: I : I;, ' ;] II ',I iii, 'n' I,!il,o i ,'i,;' F;' 1:,1 11\ ""! II) il! 'II'" ,/ !'I ,I I; ,;1:/'1 i' " ",""fi \'j \1, ", , , , ,iril ';1'1 "I' " , ,'I, 'I '1,' ,,,/' , , " I',' , II) " ,', fI, I " , " 1, " " , ;)'1 \;ji ,')1 "I :1 q "I"! 'I I Ii ,11 I,ll I ':1, ' I' '1'1 1 ,:',;_;j-"'", " "II;")"" i'l ,I' 'l'ii 11 I> f 1(',"1 / " '''\,11,.([,1;1 ,jJ""I,II;'!'fll '\/; J,' 'I ,,/,' '" ,11,1 :":')1 II " J1, II!",,'II' " 'j ,J! '0,,1 , /' " , I' " ," if I " " -",',11'!' , "~I' " , " ',I> , I,i , , " :/ " '" 1,,1 ,j, , .,"1 , ' i, " I ,,,, " " I. " ,I, " " , , r' 'II' ,\,(1 i'i , ',-;1';:,\ " , Ii , , I ~! 1 I " I i, " I '1,1' \:!;:~\r"', 'il III \\'111,1 1_ " ,:11:'<1;/' L:,' I , II'" ! '1,1 I' ,.I 'Ii " , "'I , q' , " , I,! , II'," , , ,_1 " 1'1; J!'I,lj , , , ,'III' " ,,' ',i I ," ,'It :,J " ,I,' :11 ';/ , 'II ),1 " ;, Iii , " ,"',/"'1,"'1 ;"/ , ' , ' ) 'I.' , , I I" , , " " Ii !' 'I), " " " 'fli , II ,J , , " .., ! !t' , " " IfJ,111 , " " , " I \ ,I', " ' I, ,,' , " I, ", ii,'I,! " ';I \1 ji' \: "i: " '1'\' , " " ,;- " , \ ~', , ,,! ~ II ",1,:1 ;f " '1\, ' I III' 11d{ , '1 ",Ii ;"1,1,_ ,Ill, ",1.',1"1' ,;1 ii'l, in "I' \11' ,', lVI' " " 1;11 'I, , ;1'11; , l'! '.,-1\ ) IlL' , , " I" ", , " '1111 'il ',Id " :1'11 ," " " , , ,/t1', I " I" " " , "I I" " "I " , Ii ,'" , , , i , .-1,' ,;,1 '! I',' ,1.1 rl U , 't1 " :'t' II 'f ,.)1"1 . " " "I " I , " 'Id " " , ,,' i' " " ,.(" "II' " , " " " 'I> d. " , q,\, " ~ ...".. '- ~ , ~.p.~ I ()'/'-('((' CONNOLLY EPSTEIN CHICCO rOXMAN ENGELHYER .. EWING BYI Le.lie A., Hay.., Eequin Attorney I.D. No.1 3'975 st.phanie Philipe BerqRan, Esquire Attorney 1.0. No.1 76614 Mandana Shahvari, Esquire Attorney I,D. No.1 74123 1515 Market street, 9th Flollr Attorney. tor Petltioner Philadelphia, PA 19102 aelilnce IneUrance Clo. Tel No. (2115) 851-8400 - I WHX TECHNOLOGIES, INC. / I CUMBERLAND COUNT V et al., I COURT OF COHMON PLEAS I {~/)o,/l Plaintith/ I it:. I , . ft(J.({_ Term, 11'_,.. v. I I No. THE ADMIRAL INSURANCE CO. / I et al., I I Defendants. I -- I Dlr.WDAMT RILIAMal IH8URAHal OONPAHY'I PITITIOW rOR IIIUANOI or 8UBPOIWA DUOII TIOUK ~AlI D.P08ITION or THl~PARTY WITH.II DONALD A. LA.AROIIE Petitioner, Reliance Insurance company (heroinafter, "Petitioner"), through undersigned counsel, respeottully petitions this Court tor an Order allowing it to take the deposition ot a non-party witness tor use in pending litigation in another state. Pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 4018 and 42 Pa.C.S.A. 5 15326, the illsuanoe at a subpoena duces tecum is requested on the following groundsl 1. Petitioner is Reli~nce Insuranoe company, detendant in the above named civil action, currently pending in the Superior Court ot New Jersey, Law Divisionl HUdeon County (No. HUD-L-931-92). " ~. ........ "- , a. Petitioner, by it. New Jer.ey ooun.el/ ha. i..ued and .erv.d on all part i.. in thi. matt.r I Notioe to takl thl dlpo.ition ot the tollowino p.r.on It a looation to be det.rmined, at the time and date .et torth blloWI DEPONENT Dnnald A. Lalarohik 338 N. 29th st. clmp Hill, PA 17011 pAIllE AND TIME Novamblr 8/ 1996 10100 I.m. A true and oorreot oopy of Petitioner'. Notioe ot Depo.ition, inoludinq a list ot the dooument. who.e produotion i. reque.ted, is attaohed hereto IS Ellhibit "1.." 3. A commillsion was issued by the superior Court ot New Jeraey tor the takinq 9t thill deposition on september 6, 1996. A true and oorreot oopy ot this commission is attaohld hereto as Ellhibit "B." 4. Petitioner requires the issuanoe ot a .ubpoena duces teoum by this Court to oompel the attendanoe and produotion at doouments ot the deponent as set torth in lIaid Notioe. A copy ot a propolled torm ot subpoena duces teoum is attaohed hereto a. l:xhibit "C." WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays that the Court direot the issuanoe at a subpoena duces tecum in the torm annexed hereto as 2 . CONNOLLY EPS'rEIN CHICcO FOXHAN ENGELMYER , EWING BYI Leslie A. Haye., Esquire Attorney 1.0. No.1 3~97~ stephanie Philips Bergman Attorney 1.0. No.1 115614 Mandana Shahvari, Esquire Attorney 1.0. No.1 74123 1~t5 Market Btreot, 9th Floor Philadelphia, PA 19102 Tel No. (215) 651-0400 Attorney. tor Defendant Reliano. Insur.nc. Co. WHX 'rECHNOLOGIES, INC., at aL, I I I I I I I I I I I I I No. cUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS plaintiffs, _ Term, 19_ -- v. THIE AOHlRAL INSURANCE CO./ at al., Detendants. ORDIIR AND NOW, this I~-' day of ",~"A. I1t"upon consideration of the annexed Petition for Issuanoe of Subpoena Duoee Teoum to Take oepoaition and upon Hotion of oounsel for Petitioner, it J.s hereby ORDERED that the Prothonotary ot Cumberland county isaue B subpoena ~ tecum directed to the person named below, directing his attendance and produotion of doouments at a deposition to be oonducted under the New Jersey RUles of civil Prooedure and to be held at a location to ba determined, at the time and dates aet forth belowl " " . ...."..., DIt:POlf1t''l' DA'f.. pD '!tINIJ Don.ld A. L...rohi~ :138 If. nl:h II:. c..p Kill, PA 17011 "ov.~,r 8, 1"6 10100 .... Dated 1 ootober 1.1.:.., isles BY THI COUl''1' I 1~' iT. tfI. ~.; " , , , , , : I ,I. , , 1'1 I I I :, , : , , I , " , , , I ,,' , , I :1 , 'j 'IJ :'1 ilt: ;I.'; j;ill (/1 ;1 i! I' II! '/; ,\,j to:, l' " , ' , , " 11 i ,,' . , " " iJ , , " , , 2 I! ., I , 1",-, . ; ; ,-,( "J'~Ir:.1 I ". ',.",1 I}., " :;,'Jt(i" I 'J' " \ "/'IU (l/'I , ~,j.IJ' j:;I,. 'II..' I JI f 'I " I.:'YI\':'I/I".""I" It t 'j'lj,W, 'I " ,'I' -, , Ii 'I " " " :1 , I, 1 / ;1' I ii, , ,I I , , '>. "; , " , \, ,'I , I , " " , " , I, " , " , /'1 , , , 1 I' , , '1' 1 'j I: ,I' " I , 1 " , " I!j I', I, I, ill , , II }.I , , , " , , , , , " , , " , II; " " " , )',1 ii , ' " , " I , " '\ " , ,I, 'I il I I 'j I "I ,- Ii , " , -, , , ,- j't , , " il I , II , , J' , . 1 " I , , , , . , . I , , 'I Ii I' , " . , 'I iI/I i,l , , , , . , " I " , I , , " . I " " ' ' !I I " ,i! I' " , , , , I , @ " II I! . , , , . , I , I", " , , I , " , , , , !I I , , I" J J} ,I, " " " -, I i', , , 1:1 " " , , I' " I , " . , , ,I " , " " , " I, , J , , , , . , I , , ....... '.. "laH.DULI l" DarIIIXTXOIII 1. The tn.. "Modern Landfill" "Modern sanitary Landfill" and "Jon....H.ind.l Landfill" OJ.' the "Hodern Tralh R.llloval Landfill" ..an the Landfill looated one-halt lllile louth of Route 1:14 on York.na Road in the Townships of Windlor and Lower Windlol:' end approximately eiqht (8) miles welt of the city of Yot:k. :I. Th. terme "Modern Trash Removal" or "Modern Trash Removal at York, 1.rlo." mean the el~tity or entities that operated the Modern Landfill. -3-0- Tha term- ,I PAOER" means thll Penn.y 1 van ia Ooipat tlboiht ut Bnvironmental Proteotion. .... The term "EPA" means the United stat.. J::nvironmental Proteotion Aqency. 15. The term "dooument" shall inolude, but is not limitAd to the following items, whether printed or reoorded, or reproduoed by any other meohanioal or teohnioal prooess, or written or produoed by hand and ahall include all drafts and non- identical oopies, namelYl agJ.'eements, communioations, including inter-oompany oommunioations, oorrespondence, telegramst memorandat inclUding internal memorandat reportst summaries, transcriptst reviewst analysist studiest reoordst bOOKSt summariest notes or reoords of telephone oonversations or interviewst diariest forecastst statistical statementst graphst chartst applioations for inaurancet endorsementst minutest notes or reoords of meetings, oonferences or oommunioationst minutes, notes or records of board meetingst opinion or reports of """.. '- . aon.ultant., apprai.al., broohur.., pa~phl.t., ciroUlar., trade lett.r., pr... r.l.....' contraot., not.., proj.ction., dr.tt. ot Any dooum.nt., workinq papers, copi.., m~rqinftl not.tion., photoqr.ph., dr.winql, Alid.s, lampl.. .nd other .peoim.n., oomput.r t.p.. and printouts and other data compilation. ot any nature what.oevlr, and any oth.r dooument., t.p.. or writinq. ot whatev.r desoription. Il. IIcommunicationll means any oral or written oQmmunioation ot any kind or oharaoter, inoludinq, by way ot example and without limitation, personal oonversation., tel.phone oonversations, letters, meetinqs, memoranda or transmittal ot doouments. It inoludes a review, by any person, of document. under the po.session, oustody or control ot another per.on. 7. IIPersonll moans a natural person, or a oorporation, assooiation, partnership or any other entity, enterprise or organization. 8. IIRepresentative" or IIrepresentative(ll) II used with referenoe to a person means (a) offioers, directors, partner., aSllooiates, employees, servants, agents', SUbsidiaries, and atfiliates, aSllooiates, employees, servants, agents, sUbaidiaries, and affiliates of such person and (b) other persons acting on behalf at, or in ooncert with, suoh person. GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS 1. This subpoena aeeka testimony and the produotion at doouments conoerning the Modern Landfill. 2 ~. Whenever in tho followin9 para9raphe there i. a requeet to produoe douumen\:e/ you are requu.ted to produCle all dooulllenl:l deeoribed in tho reque.t that are your pO.lleaaion/ ouatody or control, or in or under the po..... iun, ou.tody or oontrol ot your agent/ ..rvant, umployee, aooountant attornoy or other repreaentative. It any dooument reepondin9 to all or any part ot any r.equeet tor dooumente wa. at one time, but ia no 10nger in your poasossion, oustody or oontrol/ or is otherwise not ourrently available, inolude e statement to that etfect and turnieh whatever dooumenta are available. Inoludo in your statement when suoh doouments were most recently in your possession or subjeot to your oont~ol and what disposition Wea mad II ot them, and identity by name, job title /lnd the llllt known businees and home addressee of eooh person currently in possession or oontrol of suoh doouments. 3. It any suoh documente have been destroyed/ state when and where euoh document. Were destroyed, identity by name, job title and the La at known buainess Bnd home addresaes eaoh person who direoted that the dooumenta be deBtroyed, and state the reaeons said document a were destroyed" It any dOQument requested herein is aubjeot to destruction under any document destruction sohedule, ouoh doouments shouLd be exempted from soheduled deetruction until the Court order. otherwise. 4. These demands are oontinuing, and seek all dool!mente that are now or may later come into your possession, oontrol or oustody. 3 " ~...." .... 5. .Ich requI.t herein for a document or document. to be prcduced, of Iny de.cription, require. tho produotion ot the dOCUlIIel1t in it" entirety/ without redaction or elCpur9ltion. It you delete anythinq produoed in responae to a roquest for production/ .tat. in full the lubj.ot matter of said deletion and the rea. on therefor. G. If any dooument oovered by the.e requests is withheld from produotion, furnil\h a Ust ide.,tityinq elloh suoh document, and provide the following information with reapect to eaoh suoh document I (a) the nature of the privilege asserted I (b) the date(s) on whioh it wes tranemitted, diltributed, or otherwise provided to Bach person to whom it wa. transmitted, distributed or otherwise providedl (0) identifioetion by name, job title and the la.t known business and home address of each person who wrote, drafted, or assisted in the preparation of the dooumQntl (d) identifioation by name, job title and the least known business and home addreaaes of each peraon who reoeived or haa custody of the dooument or copies thereOf, inclUding those who reoeived "blind" oopieBI (e) the title of the dooumentl if anYI (f) a brief descriptionB of the nature and subjeot matter of the document I (9) a .tatement as to the basie for any claim of privilege, work produot or other grounds of non-disclosure I and 4 ;.', ,j' " ,;! I, , , " r " f f I I ~ , , I' " i\ , , , " " " I i'l , '" , !i;I!'! , " " I ','f 'II , , J,IIJ ,I I , , , 'I, , " , , , " II' 'I I " , , " ,', It' " I , " ~ , "r! " 1'1 , IIi Ii , , " " , , , , , , " .' .. """J- .~ , " , ,I fJ .. ohlin I. lI.nloh DATIl Qotob.r 10, 1886, Ind oont!nu!nv ~ro. dl~.to-day until complete TI III 10100 1.11I. LOCATION I TIJA I. Illith Knnl DATE 1 Ootober 15, 1986, Ind oonUnuinv trolll , , " d.~-tO-d.y until oomplete , TI Er 10100 a.m. LOCATION I TnA 4. DOhftld A. Lalarohik DATHI Ootober 18/ 1996, and oontinuinq tl:'om darto-day until complete '1'1 HI 10100 a.m. LOCATION I '1'1IA , I. JIIIlIII P. Bnyder OATEl Ootobor 23/ 1996, and oontinuinq tl:'om day-to-day until oomplete TIMEl 10100 a.ln. LOCATION 1 TnA are material witneas in the above-oaptionad aotion, we l:'equ..t that you iasue Subpoonas Duoes Teoum to the above-noted individuala to appear for depoaitiona, and to produoe l:'elevant dooumentB tor inlpeotion aa aut forth in Sohedule "A" of the Notioe ot Oral Depositiona annexed hereto. The depoaitions are to take plaoe before a oel:'titied oourt reporter on the above-referenoed dates, or on any later date to which the depositions have been adjourned by the notioin9 party. Dated thia ~ day of SrI , 199C5 2 I, I; ,Ij ,'I " I, , , , " '1 ; ! ~ , , (" I .,. '" '.,. '~'''I ." IV) ,~ ~/! 11 ).':.,. LI , I ~ '~ " J.f ",1,1 "j ~ , , It.' 1\ jl' -. , I 11 I " , 'I' .... . "+"1' ,,,, l ~ J, 1'- II..,. I' .... '1 ~ ~j . '11 , '" , i.) " " " '" ;! , " " " Iii , I , I, " " '1;1 '1 , , I , " II: , , 'I , , . .