HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-05609
'V'/.,:I;'
I,
, .
'I
(',"
" ,
',!l r
"
"
;1
i' "
",f.
d, ...,
'(,II
1:1'.
l",',"~'
"
,
,:j, ,
1',....
:~~
.'
"
,."
"
,
'I
"
I.
j'I'
"
,
,,;1
."
,
,
",
,
',J_"_III
dd i
, ,
,;
I,'
;',
"
'f"';
'11,
ill r,
~I!
t ,1.1",
1.;j -HI!"
"~,Iii ,-'j
'11;
",/'
"
\", I-~
"J\!,'t,
,!'/ i)'
'l)'
I",' ,:1
. fdl
,
;1
,
,
,
1q, \,
"
J
"
"
. d.
'Ii ,i,
i,
'J'
d - (,
i" "
'I, " I! I - ~ :
" I' '.' 'I!
.,1
,
.,
,
"
'I
"
, I,
,
" '"
.
,;'
" ...
~
"
,
"
I.
')" I.
" 'I!',
,I
"
,J
I'\;
,
q-j
:J,
'~
,)of
~
'..
, ....
~
t
,~
"Iii
.,!;'/{-_"L..
i -;' d"
!' -:,"/
/;1 1/
'-'I' '\
ij J..- "1
I'i"
L "~I
I,iq/,';, t
'j jJ 'II'j
II,
t 1/';
f II
l'l
':
,I
,il',',
"
Ii'
"
,
'I
"I, 'I,
'I, .
,'!'-I ;';;j!
,,'
;'1_11_';
\h
1;,lil
iJ'
II
f ~
I ~ .
",J
, 'I
',(II,'
I,!
,"
'I
,,'
I
"
I"
, 'I.
t- ~ I' !
11'
,
: '
;d,
"1, ',1
II'
'j,r.,
) , j .1,
_il-':'
',Ifi \(
,
,
I,
,
,I'
ii- ','
j ;-)1]
,
"
, ,I'
'"
I
,'1; 'I
Ii
"
',j ,I,
"
.;)
'i
,
':'
" ,
I f Iii
Iii
, ,
"
;j
"
,
,
liT
,')" I
/1,
1,1
t:J
\'
,i
,
,;1
'1,,\
'11
,
"
,
"
,I
"
'I
'It
,"
"
,
",
, ,
"
'" I'
.,,' "I 'F
I,
,
,
"
,\,,_,'
"I
, ',I
,
.,
,
"
1,/1,'1
,I
I, 'II
'II;
,
,1,:,1
,'I,'
'-i 'I'
I'
qll'
, '
"
,
"
,
"
U I
,I':'
"
II ,I
,',
"
"
"
"
,
I,
'11'/
I, I j I ~
'I ,/
"
,
.,! 'I
I L I
'I,
,'i I'
,
,',
, ,
rl :11
, '
"
-i'
'jlj'
.
'IJ
"
,I
,r'11
'I
'"I'
,
Ii
1'1
"
,
',II,
"
1
d
1'1'
';1'
I
nl
,
"
"
"
"1':
,
,
,
"
, ,
"
"
,/
,
~.
"
I ."j
, " i Ii ~;'" ~
'II
"-'"/do' :'1"1.);
,1, "\1;1,::' '1",/
, I ,i I! !. '~I '" .1:_ - ,;: ~
r...ll':"I,," '(;_-JI "~I
-.C ,- - _ ", '. _'\' L.,
"I' ,,'
'd ;1':\ ~,'il . ',/)' 1.1i f', '! ")1 1 ;"; .,
!,dlfj ,', '.:,,,.:'/1';.1;
,,,"'.,:), 'l'li" ' .
!I':;q ,t )-..1 ;,!,
j,
"
,
"
I,'
"
,j ;,:'
,
'f
I
'I,'
,;'!:_', ,Ij
r'll
i-j
"
,
'I,'
i ' ~
"
II'l
I 'J;
1-., "
I, .,', i! ~ , .1 .' - , , ,
if j : .J II_',:! I ,l,-I,~'
',\;, f/- - - ~I_j,
,) I ' i.'h: ~ - ' I "
I.!iift'--}W~-;-r,;'\
I"~: ;"'1, - ,
;.,
'I': ".1
,I,
,; /
,
Ij ;11,
If
"
"
"
,I
,I,
"I ~ J" \:
'j
It II
..
"
-', '",-I
!,j "
I'
'.
'I
,
,
, i:r
:1:1
"J
I!.
.it I.'
I J il
II ',,',', I"'! '
'- I',
i! ",'1,,11
! . -'r""
1'1
,,'
"
,
" ,/
It' 1/1
J "11- "',,'
fl'
"
./
"
"
II
"
"
"I
,
,
j')
'Ii
'11
I' "
, - ! _\.1 d
,fI-1 ,!
, I
.H II
"~I
'f
'"
",
,
1'1
'f;f'I'
,; ,;
"-tOI
1.;fI'.;',1
';1' ;1'
',"
Ij
'Ii
--ii
"
II
, I,
;// '
,
\,,'-j;,
, ,
\
,
'I
I,;'
"
"
"
j:'
., I
j I
-l.!
'1/1.;'11_1' II
,1:1' -
'1,llll
'I't.;i
1,,1,
,
I!:
'J"
,~ ' , !
/
,11
r'
, _ i , j I ~ I.,
1,11' Ii
,I
,
','
"
"
,
J i~JI',
,
"
,
"
;/
I'
'I!
,I
"
I"
'.1
"
"
"
'/1
"
, ,
I
'I
11\
'/J
1<1
'II'
l';
,
'.1 I
"
'I ~ '
"
'1,1' I
"
""'V
,
I-I'
,
'IJ'
,
I,' I
"
:1,1
',11';
'.'
.\
,!-1
-lj'
'I,
,
I'
I,
I"
-',I;,
"
,')
'I
,/
!
I"~
, '
,
,
"
"
, "
il",1
d ,;
']', ':
,
'I :1.'
"
i"
,
,
,,'
'j I' ,>I
I'll
,- 'j
"
,,'1.'/
'1'1'
"'II
I "
,
"
','
I:' ,I I
,',
jl
"
/'
1,-,
(I';
"
,
, 'I
,
"
"
"i'l
'j,
'"
,
'I.'
"
"
! I
,
"
,
,I,
,;1
.,
','
,
i:1
,
"
"
.,
,
, I
, ,
,
,
'II'
'I
'"
,
\/,
"
"
,! .,
"
"
,
"
"
1
.,
"
"
,
1'1'
"
,
"
;) ,
:,/
I:.
"
, ,
'j!,
,
j'
,
I "
I,j;'
rI:
Ij,
J.'r
. i
"
,\, "
j,I'i.
,f/oi'
"
dll' ;
;;'11:1 .
, 'I
',1 ,
:'J
Jr
,
'I
..;,
'Ii
I'I!
'f,
JI,
,
"
,
,il
, ~,
,I I,)
"
,
,
'1/1',
d,
',!)I;
'-J'
1,-: I
"
",
i
"
,PI
'I"~
,
I
"~I'
'1/,
"
,
r'ill
"
'/
~ 1 '. II '
'_J,I_,-, f"
Ii' I
'_:,I;j'L _;!I
,/I, ''I r
'-',,'"
',[;\1' ,if-"
1'/'loi,l;
t_"./ .
"1:',,-",
'I ' , ~,
I 'i:'_1
'H
'111
"
, ,
'I
;1
,-I'
,
"
';11.-'1
:'! '1-'
I'--!I
,I :,\.\!" ~\,
{Vi I 01')'
, I, -! - ~ '1- 1 ~ - 'I': ,-1_1- '1]; "
1_1;\1. 'h--Itit
1.'11 ".:J I' I,";
"~I ,,' ,I I, .
j "'- 'i'" _1'_i'l 'I,'
'I, ~ tl_l, -- ! "_ .d fll'- 1'. "I
1_,;oIPI ;';"i'I';,i---,! ,:i;i
~ p_ ~ ' _ 1_ '_' - - i' t- 7," _ ._1 ,
,_I -lii/lllli'_ 11.1'
II;) . ,,1 I _I: II, ':1
1_. '1\, _'l,(i,-ll', \t-lJC::
;' I; \: "/ '1--1 'l{' 'I' "L ,
" '1-;\ 1- '-.' -j)'.'( I
, JlI, \," ~i ,
,I J l'i,l 'il,
i';'!':"
'I",' '
"
I"
"I
'1)
,
i"': ,\
'II
';iI
It.I],'
"~I
'I
I;"
! II!
',I
,
LI
,III
"
,!
"
"
"
I'
'J, \\
,'\,
I"p
"
,
I,;;
"
',],1
",
;\1
,
,
",
II'
'i 'fl
,
'/
itj"i
II,
, ,
i, il '\
;, ,1\
,
':11
(i
,'I
'/' ill
,
"
I' 'II 1..'
:\1 \, ,1'_'-' ,I
I/!I\
I'),,'
\,-:111 ;j
i,t,II'
",'1
,
"
"
1"1
I :\'1
"
,
j\/I,,'I'
, "
'lIt: ,'",
"
,
,
I (I
'.'
"
:1"
'dli'
, ~ l' \ ':, ,\; lL ;
',I
"
,11'1
, I' ,I ~
, ? '-'I
I'll
,
,
,
"
"
,
,
,
'.'
,
'I',),',
,
J
,
.,:
" ,
"
"
!
,
.,
11 d
il,l
,
"
I'
,
,
1.'1
"
,I
"
,
,
'I;
,',
~
,
.
2. Petitioner, by ita New Je~.ey counael, haa iaaued
and Merved on ,11 parties i" this matter a Notioe to take the
depoaition ot the tollowing pencn at a looation to be
determined, at the time and dates set forth belowl
DIi}?ONEN'r
Edward R. 6immons
1120 Columbus Ave.
Lemoyne, PA
DA'l'EB AN/) TIM/!
November 20-22/ 1996
10100 a.m.
A true and oorrect oopy of Petitioner's Notice or
Pepoaition, inoluding a list or the document. whcse produotion i.
requested, is attached heretc os Euhibit "A,"
3. A Commi~sion was issued by the Superior Court at
New Jersey tor the taking or this depoBiHon on September 6/
1996. A true and correct copy of thi. commission is attaohed
hereto ftS Exhibit "B."
4. Petitioner requires the 11lsllance ot a subpoQna
duces tecum by this Court to compel the attendancIJ and produotion
or documents of the deponent uS Bet forth in SlIid Notioe. A oopy
ot a propoaed form of subpoena ducea tecum ia attached hereto as
Exhibi t "c."
WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays that the Court direct the
issuanoe ot a subpoena duces ~~ in the term annexed hereto a8
2
,
"
,I
'I
,
"
i
,
!i
Ii
r' ,
t/r'n (\"/'1.''''
I Or r /':, I, /',1 t:1
l~lj/i 1
II' '" ", I ,
h.' H 'o..JIL"lj /.1\
' "
"I)
"
, ,
, ,
" d
,I
1 'I
" " ,
,
, ,
,
" Ii
"
"
,
H
I,
i
I,'
,
,
,
,
"
"
"
,
\,'
,I
, '
),11
,
",
It!
,
Iii
! Ii
,
,I'
"
f I,)
,
;[ ,
"
il
Ii
L I
,
il
, ,
'I
,
"
I,
I
,
II [
'I
,
"
I,
"
,
I
"
'I
L I
,
" ,
, , ,
,
,
, ,
;-!
'I
;)
I
II
Ii
"
I,
1:1
, ,
I"
L
,I:
"
, ,
.,.~....,.
..
,.
i
)
I I' I ,
, ,
, \,
,I
I "
)t I
" ,I
,ti,
'I ,
,
,
"
, "
I
, j
" "
I,
~ I ,
, " 'I
"
,I
'I"~
@ , , 'I
" " , 'i
I " j'
, i ,
'.1 ,
K
"
! ' I ,I ' ,
, ,
I "
i "
,;
I
" "
I I , ", ,
I '.1
,
, "
"
TANSEY FANtlItlG lIMOERTY
1<l~LLY CONVERY , MURRA V.
BYI Edward J. Fanninq
V.o. Bo)( 5filHl
1521 or...n street
Woodbridqlll, NJ 070915
(900) 634-7080
and
COt/JiOLLY EPS'l'I;;IN CHICCO
FOllMAN ENGELMYER , EWING
a'll r"elSl1e A. Hayes
Carol L. Press
stephanio Philips Bergman
Ml\ndal1a Shahvar i
11515 Market street, 9th Floor
PhiladelphiB, PA 19102-1909
,I
WASTE MAtlAGEMENT, INC., et a1.,
Plaintiff. ,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
DOCKET NO. HUD-L-931-92
CIVIL ACTION
SUPEIUOR COURT OF NEW JBRSBY
LAW DIVXSJ;ON I
HUDSON COUN'rY
VB.
THE ADMIRAL INSURANCE COMPANY,
et al.,
Defendants.
HOTzoe or VIDeOTAPBD ORA~ DBPOSITIONS or THIRD-PARTY .I'MISS.,
TOI ALL PARTIES AND THEIR COUNSELl
PLEASE TARE NOTICE THAT Defendant Relianoe Insurance
company, by and through its couns~l, will take the fol10winq
videotaped depositions purauant to B... 4114-2 (a) I
1. Ildverd R. B ilDlllonB
DATES I October 29"'31, 1996, and continuing day-to-
day until complete
TIMEI 10100 a.m.
LOCATION I TBA
2. I'renai. P. Feir
DATES I November 5-7, 1996, and continUing day to-
day until complete
TIMEI 10100 a.m.
LOCATION I TBA
"80111DULI AH
DIlFIlfITXOlfB
1. The terms "Moderl' Landfill" "Modern rianitftry Lllndriil"
Ilnd HJones-Heindel Landfl.1l" or the "Hodl.lrn 'l'rash 1~llmoval
[,Ilndtill" mean the Landfill looated one-hlllf mile south or Route
124 on Yorkana Hoad in the 'l'ownahipa of windeol:" and l,ower Windsor
and approximately eight (0) milea west of tho City of YOl:"k.
2. ' 'rho tel~lns "Modo!:n 'l'rash Hel11oval" 01:" "Model:"n 'l'rash
RIJmoval of York, Ino." meBn the entity or entities that operated
the Modern Landfill,
3, 'l'he tel:"m "PAPER" means the Pennsylvania Depal:"tment of
Environmental Proteotion,
4. The tel:"m "EPA" mellns thIJ united states Environmental
Proteotion Agenoy.
5, The term "document" shall inolude, but is not limited
to the fOllowing items, whethor printed or recorded, or
reproduoed by any othel:" mechanioal or technioal prooess, or
written or produced by hand and shall include all drafts and non-
identical copies, namelyt agreements, communications, inoluding
inter-company communications, cOl:"l:"espondence, telegrams,
memoranda, inclUding interna 1 memol:"anda, reports, summaries,
transcripts, reviews, analysis, stUdies, records, books,
sUmIDal:ies, notes or records of telephone conversations or
interviews, dial:"ies, forecastsr statistical statements, graphs,
charts, applications for insurance, endorsement$' minutes, note a
or records of meetings, conferences or communications, minutea,
notes or reoords of board meetingo, opinion or rcporta of
cQn.u1tantQ' apprailall' brochure., pamphlet., cirou1ar., trade
letter., pre.. reles.e., oontraot., note., projection., draft. of
Iny document., working paper., oop!eB, marginal nQtation.,
photograph., drawings, slidel' samples and othar speoimens,
computer tape. and printout. and other data oompilation. ot any
nature what.oevor, ~nd any other documents, tepe. or writinq. ot
whatever de.oription.
IS. "commul,ioation" mean. any cral or written oommunioation
of any kind or oharaoter, 1ncluding, by way of e~ample and
without limitation, personal conver.ation., telephone
oonversations, letters, meetings, memoranda or transmittal of
doouments. It inulude. a review, by any person / of dooument.
under the posses.ion, oustody or oontrol of another porion.
7. "Person" means Il natural per.on, or a oorporation,
8s,ouiation, partnership or any other entity, enterprile or
organization.
s. "Repre.entative" or "repre.entative (15)" used with
referenoe to a person meana (a) ofeiolJrs, directors, partner.,
assooiates, employees, aervants, agents/ sUbsidiaries, and
affi1i~tes, aasociates, employelJS, Bervanta, agenta,
SUbsidiaries, Ilnd affiliates of suoh person and (h) other persons
aoting on behalf of, or in conoert with, suoh person.
OBNIRAL INSTRUOTIONS
1. This subpoena seek. testimony and the production of
documents oonoerning the Modern Landfill.
2
:I, Whenever in the followino paraonph. there i. a requell:
to produ~e document./ you are reque.ted to produo~ all dooument.
de.crlbed in the raquelt that aro your pO.lelvion, oUltody or
control, or in or under tho pOlsosBion, oustody or oontrol of
ycur aoont, BQrVant/ employee, aocountant attorney or other
representative. If any document respondino to all or any part ot
any request for dooumonts was at one time, but iB no lonqBr in
your pOBsession, oUBtody or: oontrol, or ia otherwise not
currently available, include a statement to that offoot and
furnish whatever doouments are available. InolUde in your
statement when Buoh doouments wore mOBt recentiy in your
posaession or BUbjeot to your control and what disposition wall
made of them, and identifY by namIJ, job titlo and the last known
business and home addreasos of eaoh person currently in
posaession or oontrol of such doouments.
3. If any suoh doculllents have been destroyad/ state when
and where such doouments were deatroyed, identify by name, job
title and the last known business ^nd homlJ addr.essea each peraon
who direoted that thIJ documents be destroyed, and state the
reasons said doouments were destroyed. If any dooulllent requeBted
herein is aubject to deatruction under any document destruotion
schedUle, Buch documents should be exempted from sch~du),ed
destruotion until the Court orders otherwise.
4. ThesIJ demands are oontinuinq, and seek all doouments
that are now or may later oome into your possession, oontrol or
custody,
3
"
8. Eaoh request herein fo~ a dooument or dooument. to be
produced, of any d..cription, require. the produotion ot the
dooument in it. entirety, without redaotion or e~purgation. It
you delete anything produced in re.ponee to a requeet for
produotion, state in tull the subjeot matter ot said deletion and
the reason theretor.
6. If any dooument oovered by these requesta is withheld
from produotion, turn ish a liat identifying each suoh dooument/
and provide the tollowing intormation with respeot to eaoh suoh
document I
(e) the nature ot the privilege assertedl
(b) the date(s) on whioh it waa transmittA~,
dJ,stributed, or otherwise provided to each person to whom it waB
transmitted, distributed or otherwise provided,
(0) identitication by name, job title and the last
known busineBB and home address of eaoh person who wrote,
drafted, or assisted in tho preparation ot the document I
Cd) identitioation by name, job title and the least
known business and home addreases ot each per.son who reoeived or
has custody at the document or copies thereOf, including those
who rec$ived "blind" oopiea,
Ce) the title of the dooument, if any,
Cf) a brief desoriptiona of the nature and subject
matter ot the dooument,
Cg) a atatement as to the basia for any olaim ot
privilege, work produot or other grounds of non-diBolosure, and
4
.
. I
I
,
,
i
"
Ii
"
,Ii
" I.
.1,
111/
it
,i
1',1
11
I,
,
i'i
,
,
, I
.,
Id
I! t
I . "
" " . ,
,
,
, ,II
I I'
,
II
,
,I'. I'
I
" , "
,
, "
,
I , ,
"
1i
@
t
I
I
I
I
, i'
, , I!.
, 1:1,
. ,
"
,I
, i
, "
,
I
'I
II
! I: r
'I II l'
,
I, 'I
"
,
, , , I
,
. I
',I
I,
h
,
,
il
J.
~ I
.,
I
';1
II , ,
,
,
,
'.
, ,
il
I'"
,
,
,
\, )
ji!
Ii II
Ij I
. I
I,
I
.
.... '
" ,
'l'MfSEY I"MNINO IIMOl!:RTY
XE~~Y CONVl!:RY , MU~~Y
BYI Edward J. Fanning
P.o. Box 551111
11:11 oreen stroot:
WoodbridgG, UJ 07096
(90B) 1134-7800
and
CONNOLLY EPS'l'Eltl CHICCO
FOXMAN ENOELMYER , EWING
BY 1 LusUe A. lIayos
oarol L. Preis
stephaniu Philipo Berqman
Mandana Shahvari
1515 Market stroot, 9th Floor
Philadelphia/ PA 19102-1909
FrLED
SEP OB 1996
JOHN A. MclAUGHLIN, J.s.e.,
'.
I
WASTE MANAGEMENT, INC. , et al., I SUPERIOR COURT or NEW JERSEY
I
Plaintirtll, I LAW DIVIsION I
I HUDSON COUNTY
vs. I
I DOCKET tlo. HUD-L-931-92
THE ADMIRAL INSURANCE COMPANY, I
etlll., I CIVIL ACTION
I
Detendantll. 1
1
COMMISSION TO TAKE VIDBOTAPED
DBPOSITIONS or THIRD-PARTY WITNBSSBS
. To the Judges ot the Commonwt'lalth ot Pennsylvania,
greetings I
WHEREAS, it appears to this the superior Court ot New
JersIJY, LaW Division, Hudson County, that the following
individuals 1
1. B~war4 R. simmons
DATES I Ootober 29'.31, 1996, and oontinuing day-to-
day until oomplete
TIMEI 10100 a.m.
LOCATIOU I TBA
,.
, , , ,
, I 'Ii
! I ,I
"
, ,
,
1>, ,,'t. ~~
l,l'~ LI, ,..,'~
t,'. 'j .
f-, ~i ~~
1'1 ~\ 'I
I i ",J
')1
(: .... , ~ f
J' ... I ~~
If I t, ')
" , "
I 1:., ,
I'i ,n :i ,
I;), I
I,
'I
,
Ii
, I
, ,
II , ,
" :
,
i
" ii, I'
" I
,
" , I I
,II
, Ii ~
,I "
1
Ii i
" ,
'I
fI "
, , I ,
" "
,
'I , , ,
"
'q