HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-05644
J,
~'l r,
n1!,
"
~f'
~X:,,;
,- I'
I;'
id
'I'
,
!;)
'I
,II
'I
q
,
I, "
I
"
,I
:1)"
'"
',~
,
I."
I
,
I,
'I,
'I
,; I
"'I ,Ii
, '
11 'I j
i'l
."
'I'
1':;1'1
,
~
~
~
tJ I,
, ,11
"JII,'
',,'
I " !'.' II
\L,i,.--,\i
,I, ,,:iili'"
; I" i[ I ", I J \ '-" , ", '1, ! ~ ~ 'I
"I, :.! Ii ,';', ",/ ",',
I.
"
Y'II
I'll
,
,
J'
;1
"
I,
'i/.',' "
;1: "I
'1- '-I Ii
"I,
"
'!,li!
,I
I'
~
I
.,
I
"./
,
I
"
'I"t/,
" '.\
ii,
, '
I 't:
f ii' II,
'I, I,i'
t,'
"
I
,
,I
~
\,
...
.~
~"
3
~
')'
. "'~! I J
,"
"
q
""
"
"
I
",
1/
I'.
",
,
I,
"
I
I
\,
, 'i
,1'1
,I
'I' ':]
IIi
I
,
".,
,
,Ii,t
'I
,
:'\,
,
"
"
,
, '
1. 'I
,I It
1;1,
,
, ..
I' ,
'"
"
,r'l
Ill'
.,
,I
.,
'".' )
,d
, ,
,',
,
'I,
,',
" ,
I
,
'I
I,
!I'
n I"
I
"
'f')
"
'I
':1'
I,
,"
F
"
"
,
-t'IJI, t-,
I
I,
,
I
:!J
"
II,l
;Ii' )
"
II:
\:~
'~
/'
"
,
"
,
If I
'I',
"
,
"
!;,
'. '
I"
,
,
.......
.
!
"
'II
'Ii
"'d'
" ,
.
":),
. '
.,..
~
1
"
'1'1
"
I,
I 1;11,
I
"
1
,
'Ii
'I
I,
\ ,
1;1;
.Ij
, ,
" ,
; ) . ~ I
,II
"J I,
, "
I"
I,
,
I, -I,
'1'-
"
,
';./ " l,i
H 'J "
'1/ 'l)' I]';'! I (I' ,llr,":/",~
i -t'll Ii ,,1 ,
"~!Ii I' ,i _.,.1' ';! i .in{-I 1,
'I j , L 1/ ~'-', -1 J'
}!,i,',_::, lil\~,,;_:,;-.:- (-I_~ j;!,t}:l;-';
',']:_1\ ,1.1""'1;-' ,'1 'J-__'!,,/,;, I ;!"__II
:'-1 -I!, 11,/-"',-)_;'r, (,-1-','> -r', '_'-J,il '1/,1,. ,if
"-1 jl'l.-; --, -- - -_- 1
I." ',; ,( ",.', 1:_/_1-,111,_11' I~ ;i' ,,'1:1 "),
, " 'p j , , -. d ,:i;. 'I'
r.I'I~'1 '!,11\\J.:~I'/I'n-.r.~--_,':-i_l, II ,:'n"i'
,11;1,,1.,; "-i'I-LL:t, :1'; d, I;. -"i
I:,:' I.' li_- '~I' - ,.!- 1-1 -I-Ii ,. J ,-, - _ 1_ ' /')f
"-.1',' '("-j - d-'__ --,' ,.;/., I,_j' ,',
!;i', - ,',>/1:\;1"':''; ';~'t~,h ~ :\jl{' ':"1) ~'l
!,;i, ,'f' il!f/r _-.I:'; <-'Ii' ~ "illi.' "1 'I' '-" ;1
!, l'il~,"fj _ -'~'l-','-~:i :~?'I\I;UI ':~:-,__jl'-< ._i";l /- ,J I '
"I ' " I, , .1 ~'_l !,':jl, :_, ~J';,:ll ' ;) \
\"",1...- "1"-' _,__rl,'" I" " '
'L,I :-,-";; ',_I .:; ,Lhq-.J ': ,'1.'_1'" :1- , ,'-',
, j' "I I; ,'Inr I,' - ,L-.t, , I
' fJl>:, ." >i~ i, -'! ii"~ '/\,]'" I.. I':i'"l)"_'_ I 1[;,
, "'II .,q ,'') ,'I' 'I' '1'\ 'i '1"" "'," i,
I j,i,,;!-- I 'TA~I: ! ,-,11]_ -I"-II':c',-'1 ' .
'j' ---I' 1:"1'1:,,1'\'" -'1'.1; PI' I 'I
,-'I (,_,11/:',1' '-'IIf!. " j ,<
,d "i_" '!II'; -, _,\, I !
','1' ,'- ,I_;!-'__,II' '\"_1'[1 l'i'-I,'I'i'
>'I,_,d;',-,!]}II ';1,,_,_'1. ,';._",
;'1, -" lL- '-_'I I,.I!, ' ',\:i I'J ,_ III', ; il - Itl \ ,I
'J, l--,_l'I,\'I-'J'i."J__lr ".") ,J"'I )'l
i.d,,\'i_j\:L'H_t:!.~I-',; .'n ;;-__'Ii;_-;-~]_ :~-; " !_I,: "l
'i~I'l,H I. ,Ij:~ 11 :,1, HI"_;'!l/i ,I,nl'lj~h. "'!'I:'-
n(' ;'_i,: ~)}; i. !I;_;, 1;_;)' ~~ i!!-';l-;__;~,I~I'-"-'!i '" _, -'!"
I ! " 1 ,1"~,,,-,"'!)id'!Lil) ,[I,' ,01 i
Ji II"., I III ' ,/1 ,':"1/."",",,;,., "_"
\{I_\r-!j:;i:.\. ,'\~ ,1,:.f"II]:;_{i'~'~'T;"/fi:'~::;,-I~ '11'\, I 1!
,/'\1 - '-,J\' L-,,! _1l'1' _,' ,', -,''If'crL- '-.lII'I~ I d .1-,
t';" I; " ,- f, -" _' ., ' 'jl' !i': ~ _': r- -- , II' - ,11' " ,
'I' il I: ;-,1; 'L_ ,'.ql_iL';ll f :-"111'] , I
II j - 'I, t-C ",_ 'rjl'<dl:,j~'i-"__"/,\ -, "I IIi! i
Ii f: : I ," '- ' I, _..; ,_ ~, -. 'f'; I, ',_'
,'''i--I-.___' -,_
-('>(j -~.-I,-~' ~d~ij,iiJ
'TI - !'i -,~ "'-' I
d' I I~I'- '-;j ,-i' ", ','
'j ;1, ,., ',r, _l ,
'1'-VII'I,:,:ll iI', j' -j"
: - ';::i 111-1- __." ,,",
'rill ::'1)11 _1-1,'"
"-'\ 'I! r _,,' ,/, ,'.".':11'
11.' - I I --I' I, 'iii ,I , J"
','"
'/!\-J';'I,l:,'li-'[-' 1'1"'_,
~-- :~" ,'-I ",",;'\1: ,!i ,; _,",;, 'l,;1 i ,,I,: \ I
.. -.. - - ;: '/ I ~ " y/, "
"II 'II II L ~ _', '-' I '_L' \_ -'u "I
, I'll I j,1 _'!' I,! j 1,-, t ,I; ~,,'
;1;,1 '1'/ ,'I,d ,',- 'II "
; I - ~ ','", ',I;" I, ,- - -
. -,,_ ,_ - I ,
'1,\1 -'ilL!:.".: ."If'- '{,'_I'):,' 'j
"'\' " .. '1'111 I ,,;'
I J ;:~',~/ " ,}; l'llr?,t.~l' 1:1;:bi_.(J/lli\~~:i:'I_!'I_ i i
,'II 'I-I,,! f /Jj ,'I,ll :,- : ~\\.,!tl;:]h- I,',; 'r"', ;1, '
"fl:1 ',-I 1 j "n :'--J '" LI;';_l' -I" ,-', tl,
,l, ,of' ;'I;,-dl';l i" ,i,
I' j" ;Ii,
,I ;-,1' "I!:,
, ;"--I';!, ,1.1:-,;1.\ ;!i', ,',' ~1 I j~_j_J}'l~ ';1'
)1 'I' fl', "." ,i',i:'ii,,:,:..:'!":r'
. ~, , .-: I ; i I -' I 'I I _ - _ , i
,f I I' I l~ / !,j-_!, ! "I 1:- hI -, II '!:' i '
" ",1'-:" ,"JI '-, "-j-- I !I'II,;- -,'
- u ,_ r ;1'-:' /1",1-'
I , '"-j/:> 'I,fl" -
'i il I 1:1;; ;:', 'I 'III d
,'1'1 1'-1 .-'1' /ii,
I '1, \':iJ I
jl'
,
1':1'),'
, '
,
ill, ,
(',I'
!
"
'1'P!
" I
"
"
'/I,i
I
"1','
'j
"
,
i'
,H ~l
,
, ,
'f'I'
;-'h
,/," "' ,'I
,\
,
II:
Ii"
'/1,
,\
111(
,
"
'I
,,'
''t,
"
,1'1
'II
,I)
,::/,'!
:JJJ)"\
I! ,/ ,,\ ,I
I"~
,
,
II;,)!'
/()'
"
,
"
'I
"'\_1
'rl'
'"
;/1,'
!l
;,1
"
Illil
/
Iii
,I i"',
," 1,;'1'
'I " , I
'!I 'i!)"j'!!:,-.
i-;,,_,i'!II',:.-'1
1 ,: -\ r '.'f'
'I ','"
,
;1(\"1' 'iI,
","1,:'1, I'-I!" ,
I; _ ,\.:/,
,.I'l"
lr(, II
,
,
""
'ili
."
11
:,
ii'
iJl.'!
, ,
'.i.'
I
'il'l
, ,
,
') I'
I
\:
"
,"
'_'IIi!
l !,
.1_. I'
11 il':,"i;:,I)
I',
'"
'J
,I I'
q'!
,
"
"
" i','"I,'
I'
,i
i 'd'
I
1(,
I
,
, \ ~ I ;
, ,
';'i ,I,
':1;
,
j'l
,
1 '
"'I
:;J:
"
, ,
'I'
!l'l'
I
1.1'11
"
!!,
'1,'1
,
.,
11,
1'-
J J 1, I
,
',-ii/
Jill,
II
"
, ,
"
II,'
" ,
d fl- I
j-i
'"
'1'1
"
"
I -I I
"
11
,:1
"
, ,,I ~ 1" 1- ,
d'
, ,
I
!
.,'
,
,I ;/ 'I
1 n', I'
"I
'I
";'1" i,1
, ',I
I
',Ii I'
" 1,1
,! I,
ii,
,
,
,
1,1-11'"
"
,
,
,
"
Iii
I: 11
'IIi'
"
I;)
,
"
,/
'"
I',
'II
,11'
,\-
"
,
d
,
,',
1 \ il
':__, 'I
, '1'"
"
,',
.!'I
I'll
I" ',-,/
"
,
,
, i
.-\'
,
1.1,
"
,
,
,
, '
"
,
,
,
,
"
I;'
"
\,
"
.,,'
!fI
"I
,
"
'1,1"
"
,
,-II
"
"
HI
,'I,!,
'J ,I
,1:/
ji-,
n
\
n ' ,
,II'J 1'1,
'ijjl,
,
,,'"
,I'
"
','
h
"
,L',!"
I "I'
<II I
1'.1 i (
,I},"\ I;
, '
"
:,1
"
';',1 :\
"
"
,'I
'j,
, 'ill
11-,
"
'\
"
',:,
"
'/'
d"j')'
'I
Ij'
!!fl'
1.'.1.
I,ll,
;1
,\i!
H' !
"
,
)1-\"'
>I'
'I
,
,
" .
,
,'-1,)1,:,\1',--
1:1
II, J I'
, ,
"
'lit
',II"/I,)!I
"
'"
1 ) 1 '1;1
,1, I
, \
,i \
,
"
,(I,
,'I"
, I
1 /' .,' ,1"_ ,J
\ ,"" I, ",' I ; ; I, I~": ,/1111 :11 f
I 'f "!>;I; -"jut'_!
, . .. ~ - " . , Ii' ," _ -' - II i I
I:Hl_'_,' "',<1'1"'- 'Ii,',
'i; , -- d -," '/ .,'
; ~ I -I ' /,,- j II r ' II )
ili'l j - ,-' "~'I I
"i,d,',,; )1.' I ;:i' .":
i, ,
"
I'.
"
''I i ,ill
Ii;"
,
.,
'.1
'"
"
"
)'1, "'I"
dl--~ I
f ---I' ,\
'1 -; q'j I
'j I _";il 'I.
1_, qt,l, ,
"']
"
Irl
,);11
,,1_ I
",I,ll}
;:11
.:.,IJ,',
'I '1-'
",\1
'--I"
'I'
,_'I 1111 '1/'"
q, i_I '_ '\___
",1-_ \,') Ill",;,'
: do: I-:! i ' ,I"
I" \'1\' ,_I
i ' pI'
I' ,
",\
"1,
, ,
:11,'
",I
,I'
, ,I
:,',1,111
,,' 'I, '1),
\'1
"
"
I
! ,I" -.' ;~; 1--
,
~ ! I
,_ I
, ,
,II,
"
',;),
I
I
\"1'1'1
f '(
"'-,1
,'I
L,"I_I
j,-,I
oil
1'1
"
I,!"
lii!1
,,)
'."
',11'
I
,-II'"
d'-r,'
I I!
,::1, '1,,\
lll.,;1
,
,.
\'11)
,
, ,
:Ii
,
"
,,'
'-1,1
, ,
'H 'I 1
", I i_',
1'1)' ,
'I , :;1 ,ill"
,I' , .- '_ ,'I 'I"
\J_ lil!I'lf,.-,
'li- /,,,,1'_':1';_
:":1'1'1',\_'11,,1,
" ,/
I I')' /,
I j'
'"
; ',i1
,
','
'I ,) :11 \'
",:'i i
I .j"1
,11,1 ..
i'
,! ;,
,
11,1
II,
!i.).
,
"
"
"
"
.,
,
'"
,
,
11'1 I
,
,
y,
"
"
"
"
,
,
"
,
.-J'
'I
,
"
,
1
,
I
!I
]1
"
,i
'I
I,fl
"
"
1,\
I'
"
,I
;)ll 1'1\
,II
"
','
" \
II,
"
,
"
"
, '
"
,
"
JACQUIEJ:.XNE 0, SCHWIi:IOfIR'l',
Plaintiff
11:14
IN 'l'HIil COUI\'l' Olr COMMON PLlEAS Of'
ClJMQIERLANP COUN'l'Y, PIE~NfJYLVAN IA
v,
WILLIAM II. CRESSt.IER,
individually, and
WILLIAM H, CRESSLER
t/d/b/a CRESSLIER'S f'RUI'l'
M^I~KE'r I WILLIAM H,
CRESSLIER t/d/b/a
CRESSLIER'B ~OOP MARKET
and CRIEBBLSR'S f'OOP
MARKET, INe"
Defendants NO, P6.~644 CIVIL TlERM
IN R~l PR~TRIAL CONFERENCm
A pretrial conference was held in the chambers
of Judge Oler in the above-captiol1lld matter on Wednesday, June
21, 2000, Pres~nt on behalf of the Plaintiff was William A.
Hebe, Esquire. Present on behalf of Pefendants was Todd ~,
Narvol, ESQui re.
This is b negligence action for personal
injuries to a business invitee arising oul; of a slip and fall on
,
October 15, 1994, on water allegedly on the floor of P~fendants'
premises, Pefenses include a lack of notice, an absence of a
dangerous condition, contributory negligence, and lack of
causation.
This will be a jury trial in whic~ each side
will have four peremptory challenges, for a total of eight, The
estimated duration of trial is two days,
To the extent that any deposition testimony will
be shown or read to the jury and contains objections being
pursued by counsel, counsel are directed to furnish to the
Court, at least five days prior to commencement of the trial
term at which this case is tried, a copy of the deposition
testimony in question with the areas of objectJ.on highlighted
It"'.'
(,::-,,'~
I i
,.
'.'" ,
'RB~RtAL qONFBRQNCB O~DBn
01181 NNIIII ;' (j /.IH I i (' k 1 ':. "L ~ j! - '/ l, .- I; (.Ift 0' V&-1
x.
1
,
u.
tIt.'
IV.
I1t8tdal contlttena' pA.ta '1"1 <) '."\ ,)
A. Pate _ IJJ,"l" ">1/,<", I
B. JUd90" I) I rJ,\ (( 11\ l~' ~ I ~.;
C. l\.tto):oeys /Plll:tios I I IN \ , I "''': ~. ~ "~'I (( G I
\),\~,' TIP!,l b. Ni!f''1J , ~ ~I,
. ,
lIlltu):e ot Callo \ - I\", ( ,
A. CaUso of l\.attoo \\';""~ "',"11"(., ,11.\1"11 "'I)I''":('J.'o)'" f;J"~lr,'l J
.\., rf ,,', '1)' \'7\,,1. (, ./J' '..1. ~., ~ '1 ~\If "
0, J!lIl1iq-r;.~dhl1"/)f.._ '(:;J I'>, \'l~i I ~~\ v,A...",\! "J?(I)
"" It '_ r I".r '1'" t;,..\r/l,l,'it, 'r 'r'" ',r ,~, ,
a. Pefooso Y()'~I..(,~~ l'1l,,,L... 2. 1.If" 0 ,,~\,r'....
v,..L f\-,O':I,l) "r, ;;'~l:.rJJ'C ..l ~'~y)"J!.
(' 0 f' t, 1 m I ItFt;:f::~~
'1!' f!i== ~I
Td.e.l ,,'
A. ,J~~~/NanjUl:Y - {
13. 'PG):omptol:ios - 'of ,( \. .. .
c. Estimate of DUl:ation - '1~ ""l 1,...
D. Mal.lability af coun.el .. ,
I '
IssUes
V t J /, ,11ft ,t f""~' ')
"
, ,
v.
status of s~ttlement Nego~iatio,ns
~ \'<', ,~~l If' < I, ".'.11 r ;\.> r~ ~
II.., I)()')
~ \I I li,"S ,'}..:: 6 ,
"I '::"y.'o(rl f~
,
. ,~-
Ublllll prublufll~ with Iwr lul\ hip unlll AUgll~1 I (I, IIJI}S, murl! Ihun III mU/1lh~ IIl\l!r Hhl! IIl1u~I!,jI~
1i:llln ('rI!H~lur'~ Murkul,
Atlhu IIml! llflhu IIccldl!nt, Pllllnlln'wu~ rl!cl!lvhlH Sudlll Sl!cllrlt~ bunl!lllH U~ U rl!HlIlt ufu
clo~I!,j.I\l:ud Injur)' Ihal shl! rl!culved dlll'lnH ullIulur-whlcle ul!cldetllln I '18C" l'lulnllll'l~ nut
maklnlJ II c1l1lmlor lu~llnuullle ur IllIplllrl!d eurnlnl& cupueh~,
Plulnllll'hulI u long hlslur)' ufllucldenl~ bulh pre-dullng 1Illllpusl-dallng Ihe ullulled
Incident In Cresfller's Markel. hI I 98(J, she wusln u molor ~dllcle uccldl!tllln Nllrth C:amllnu,
She WUIl fll!verel)' Injured, und hUll been culleullnll fedl!ral dlflubllh~ benl!lltN uwr fllnue, lieI'
mahllnllblemlfl wllh her short-ll!rm mumur~, In 1989, flhu hud IInulhl!r motuI' vehicle aueldelll,
where flhe hll u lice or an embankmenl, and wns knuekud unuunsduulI, In 191}2, IIhe: had nel!k
lIurllcr)',
In 1991 I the:re waflullre Inlhu Plalnllll'fI hume:, Shc fell while Ir~lnlllo ufleuI,e und
injured her rlllht hip, In 191)3, flhe wuslnjured when u llIun reuuhed In hcr ullr III grub upurHe: und
I{l'abbed lhe l'lulntifrhlslead. In Fcbrullr)' uf 1994, Ihc Plalnllfl'had unuther motor.whlcle:
accident, While Hhe was drlvlng, u piece of lumber lell 011' u lruuk IInd wenllhrough her
wlndflhle:ld. II slruek her Inlhe fuee, She: hud resulllng jaw problems, Sometime: Inlhe monlhs
fulluwll1g lhe February 1994 mOlur.vehlcle acddenl, flhe 1i:1I on Ice und had contlnulnll
complalnls of pain In her 1e:lls, In AUllust uf 1994, she floullhllrealme:nt us a re:flult of u 1Ivc:.ln
bo~friend who waH verbally und ph~~lcull)' abusive,
On OClober 15, 1994, Plulnllfl- had her alleged fall al Crmlcr'lI Markel, rhrel! da)'flluler,
on October 18, 1994, sbu had TMJ surgery relaled 10 Ihe February 1994 mutur,vl!hlele aucidl!tll,
In December of 1994, Plainlltrhad problemfl wllh a pruballon ufllccr comlulllo her huuflu and
haraHfllnll her, In April of 1995,I'Iulnllfl'had prublums allulludly relaled lu beingli.lI\dll!d b~ u
2
1'~IlIlS>,I"'"lllullll\l~ Tl'llOp~r, III JUIlU ut' 11/1)5, 1'lullllll1' wus I"jur~d wh~n sh~ wus Inlh~ wurd~n
d~pl\rtlll~nl ol'u slor~ u/lllllllIl~rlllls 1\:lIulru Nh~ll'u"IU hur,
As llI~nllulI~d uhuw, un AU!!Usl I (I, 11)1/~, Nh~ sUll!!hlll'~UIIll~1\I Ii.II' ull~!!~d InJurluN IhuI
Nhl! /"I:c~lwd Inlh~ Ihllull'l'l:ssh:r'N MUlk~ll~nllll)nlhs ~urll~r,
In Nuv~mbl!r ul'11/1/7, Plulnllll' hu.! ullulh~r mUlur-whlcl~ ucdd~nt In which IIlur!!l! hUll
rUllllcruss Ihl! mad IInd NIlIIISlll:d Inlu lhl! pIlSN~nl!~r sld~ ufPllIlnllll'N cur, iiI Jul)' uf 11/1/1),
Plulntltl' ulld~rwl!nt low-buck sllr!!~r)'. IIppur~llll>, Ullrl!IUI~d 10 h~r ull~l!~d IlIjurl~s Inlhls I\llS~,
III. ISTATEMI!:NT ()J. 1>>IUNCJlIAL. 11l1SU.:/i AI; TO LIAlllJ...1'l'V AND UAMACmS
A, LIAlJIUTV
As to Ihl! ull~l!ed dungerous condllloll/,~" the INNU~ of wuter onlhe Ihlor-ussullIhl!! Ihul
Ihere II'tl.l' wul~r WIIS onlhe Iluur--there Is u quesllon us 10 where olllhe floor the WilIer wos
locllled. where Ih~ Plullllll1' ullel!edl)' 1\:11; how Ihe Wilier !!olthere: how IUIII! Ihe WilIer WIIS lher~t
IInd whl!lh~r thc wul~r WIIS Ihere long enough 101' th~ slure clllplo)'e~N, Ihruul!h Ihe c"er~INc 01'
rellNollllble cure, 10 dlNcowr It und clellnll up belore the 1'1111111111' ellcounlered II,
lJ, IMMAGES
There IN u qucNllolI t1.~ to whether Plulntlff sutlered un)' IlIjUI')' lit 1111 UN II rCNult 01' Ihe
ullcged lhlllll Cr~Nsl~r's Mllrket on October 15, 1994, '[ll&: Plullltlll'hud nUlllerous doctor vlslls
In the 11I0llths fi.lllowhll! the Incident lit ('ressler's Mllrket, buill wus nut umlll 0 months uncI' Ihe
IlIcldcnt lhul PllIllltll1'lllelllloned ulI)'lhlnl! to herdoclorN ubOUI UII)' IIIJur)' to her len hip,
Although lIuppeurs thut the PIIIIIIIIIl' hils ollgolllg medlcul problelllN, lIone ortheNC problellls Is
elluNlIlI)' relulcd to the ullegcd fhlllll Cressler's Murket on Oclober 15, 1994,
3
, , ,
I,
I,
, ,
i I I II
'I
, .
:
I ,
"
"
I
, I , II
I, !
,I
,
ln~ y,
k~ f ~
J ~
' ~~J.
f ' ~.e. ii ~
j)~ . ..
~ III
. .
-UB J i I
liI~~
cl ~
i · · 'i
lI:ll:ll: i mn
, ~~~I
u
.
, ,
, " ' '
,
, , ,
, , ,
, '
,
" ,
i I I
, . " ,
,
J
~
e ~ ~
0 \Ji ""
.,.. :r
'" ..
tf
o.~
'I-
,'"'
'\[\\
~
,I
',-
ll..
i.
1.11'
~ '~
B- ~)'
d\'
t!~:
IJJ'
rk
I
\,1
l...'..'
""
,.I)'
.f
"
"..
~..f
.
p'
,
,
,
I If,
II
"
,
",
, I
q
./
r I
,
,
, ,
Ii
"
,
, II
!
,
1';1 , I
, , \ ,
" II
, ,
(
'\
J,
, ,,~'
II'r'
i _~il
1";,\
, :'Iiiij
J. '-1
, or;)
, ",i~.
,
<~
"
.,
'I. '
....
11'1
..;'l
i I
I'
,'"
1';
II
"
I"
"
"
,/ ,
"
I"
Ii'
, '
Ii' Ii
, '
, ,
'I
J '.
d
I"
( I,
Ii
II
"
:,1'
;;1
;11
I
i'lf
)1
!I
il
, ,
,
,
"
I'
i'
'II
"
'.I
,
SHERIFF'S RlTURN - RIDULAR
OAS! NO. 191J6-18/5644 P
88Da~~W8~t.~U"i'Rrfa~BYLVANiA'
IlWiJtIIOART JMllilUICLINf: O.
VB,
llWIJdJl,I1.IJ..1UJLJi..ET AI.
ROBERT L,-DHK. SR. .. Sh.riff or D.plAty Sh...iff ot
OU"BERLAND County, Penn.ylvania, who b.ing duly .worn acoording
to ln, a.y., the within It!IT OF SUIIIIONS ___ va. ..rv.d
upon ..QJII.U.l.M..JUJ..L.lAII.Jf T IDW.LQBES6LER' S FOOO.J!ARKET _ the
defendant, .t .l1.iIJ.JI. HOURS, on th.. iill.i. d.y of Detoll.r .
19116...t 2l/191.U.'Lll1Jm STREET
IlHIPPE.IlIiJllllmL-lA. 1 ?2l'J? -...--_. _-.J ItUJlBERLANO .
OOllnty, Pann.ylvanh, by handing to U'U...JlI.lJL\JL....JlMIADER ANO
AD.ln...I...lILl1IfABOl.._______._.
a true and aU..t.d ooPY of th", _10U,T 01" W1lJlQIfL .
and .t the .... ti.. direoting U~I .ttention to the oontant. thar.of.
She['iff'. Ooabl
Docklung
S.r oe
A:ffr nit
Surcharg.
6:1'
2: I
, ./ ~,'
So an.w.._~-O.....' '. /,~-;;:;-:
..,' ~_,""'_.r.(. -r-".~
H. ThOMa. KIln., 5h.tll1
ee. 11111 SPENCER GLEAFJON HEBE l RAGUE
11/23/199& ~
byG~~ ,./4J,-e
, . lapu( .r1l;( G/ c'
Sworn and aUb.orib.d to ".for. ",e
thi. ~ J '...- d.y of CDtLL_.
19 'll, A.D.
(-\'I!.!a: () 11.,-, ~lI.-, .. or.."
i pronionotn)l' , ,
.
\,
JACQVS~INB P, SCHWEIQART,
Plaintiff
v,
IN THE COUR'l' OF COMMON 1i'~I!lAS
CUMBERLANP COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
No, 96-5644 civil Term
WIL~IAM H. CRmSB~ER,
individually and WIL~IAM H, civil Aotion . Law
CRBSSL~R t/d/b/a CRESSLER'B
FRUIT MARKET I WtI,LIAM H,
CRESS~ER t/d/b/a CRESSLER'S
l"OOP MAAKE'r Ilnd CRESS~ER' S
FOOP MARKET, INC,
Pefendanta
L;'
J.,'
PRAICIPI 'OR RULI ~o 'ILl COMPLAINT
TO THB PROTHONotARY I
Plealfe iaDue 11 Rule on PlaJ_ntiff to file a Complaint in the
above oale within twenty days after servioe oC th~ Rul~ or suffer
a judgment of non proa,
"
I
,
'"
by
Datel q/~J{11
AND NOW, thiB ut1-(~ day of
ISSUI!lD AS ABOVB.
ReBpeotfully submitted,
~~~~ -
Todd a. Narvol, I,P, No, 42136
305 N, f'ront Street
P,O, Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 171013-0999
,A fl' 'I (
, 1997, Rl1~B
By
l~
I'l
l-.,t
"."!'2:aAT. O' SlaVIC.
'I
,
I, Tmld I, NIU:vol, of the law firm of THOMAS, THOMAS, & HAfER, do cntify
that I .erved tha foregoing document on the foregoing per.on. by Fir.t
,
Clu., United Stlt.S Mail, postage prepaid at Harrilburw, Pennsylvania,
addru.ed II follow. I
"
William A. Hebe, m.quire
17 Cent ral, I\.venue
Wellnboro, Pa 16901
"
Datel ~/Z}/'f'1'
.~\~:::z
Todd B, Narvol
, ,
,
,
, ,
, I , ,
, , ,
, "
" ,
, ,
, , , ,
, I ,
I. "
, I'
, ,
IPIN([~Qlr"ION,
IHUE &.llAOIJE, P,(,
A"C~IHY5.A'UW
""rUIOCIW,'A.
JACOUELIN~ 0, SCliWEIOAR'l',
Plllint1 rr
IN 'l'1l1': COUR'l' Of' COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBIlRLANP COUNTY, VENNSYLVANIA
1'10. 96-6644 CIVU" 'l'EnH
V.
WU,l/IAM Ii, CRE/lBLER,
indiv idullll y, and WILLIAM II,
CREssL~m t/d/l:l/11 CRIUJBLEI~/13
FRUI'l' MARKE'!" WILL/lAM II,
CRESSLIlR t/d/b/ll CRESSLER/S
FOOD HARKE'1' IInd CRES/lU;JV S
FOOD HARI<E'I', r NC, ,
Pofondanh
CIVIL AC'l'ION - L1IW
JURY TRIAl. PIlMM'OED
NOTICE
You haVe! beon sued in Court. If you wish to detend against
the olaJ.ms set forth in tho following pages, you may take action
within twenty (20) days lifter this complaint and Notioe are
served, by entering a writtan appearanoe personally or by
attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defensam or
objections to the olaims set forth against you. You are warned
that if you fail to do so, the oase may proceed without you and
a judgment may be entE1red againl3t you by the Court without
further notice for any money claimed in the complail,t or for any
other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose
money or property or other rights important to you,
YOU SHOULD TAKE '1'IIIS PAPER '1'0 YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NO'l' HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNO'1' AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
TilE of'FICE ::lET FOR'l'1I BELOW '1'0 FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET I"EGAL
HELP,
Hr, Thomas E. Cheffins, Court Administrator
4th Floor, Cumberland County Courthouse
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013
(717) 240-6200
JACQUBLIN2 0, SOHWBIOART,
plaintiff
v.
WILLIAM H. CRESSLER,
individually, and WILLIAM H.
CRESSLER t/d/b/a CRESSLER'S
FRUIT MARKE'l', WILLII\tI It.
CRESSLER t/d/b/a CRESSLER'S
FOOO MARKET and CRESSLER'S
FOOP MARKI!:T, INC.,
Dehndants
.
I IN TH2 COURT OF COMMON PLI!:AS
I CUHlIBRLANO COUNT V , PBNNSYLVANIA
,
I NO. 915~15644 CIVIL TERM
I
I CIVIL ACTION " LAW
I JURV 'l'RIAL OEMANDElP
I
I
I
I
I
I
COMPIAINT
1. Plaintiff, Jaoqueline 0, Bohwei9a~t, i. an adult
indiv idual who redElell at One B idney Lane, P,o. BOle 428,
Dhippensburq, cumberland County, Pennsylvania 172157.
2. At all times msterial to this oauBS of aotion,
Defendants, William H. cressler, individually, and William H,
Cressler t/d/b/a Cnllsler's f'ruit Market, William H. Cressler
t/d/b/a CreslllGr's Food Market and Cressler'lI f'ood Market, Inc.,
are to the best of Plaintift'lI in~ormation, knowledge and
belief, the OWlIel:1I of a IItore located at 209 West King Street,
Shippensburg, Cumberland county, Pennsylvania.
3. At a1.1 times ml1tarial to this cause of aotion,
Pefendantll, William H. cressler, individually, nnd William H.
Cressler t/d/b/a Creslller'lI Fruit Market, William H. Cressler
,
t/d/b/a Cressler's Food Market and Cressler's Food Market, Inc.,
are to the best of Plaintiff's information, knowledge and belief
engaged in the business of maintaining, oonduoting and operating
"'NCE., GLEAION,
HUE & JlAQUE, "c.
AT'O~N~'Y'a"r.uw
WUUIORO, 'A,
.,tNCI.,OlEA'ON,
IHII & RAOUI,',C,
AnCANl'YI.A',lAW
"-lHIIO_U,'A,
D, paJ.n and bruilinq of no.. I
8. The aooident, injuri.. and damage. .utter.d and
.u.tained by Plaintifr, Jacqueline 0, lIohweig8l:t, were cau.ed
.olely, .ubatantially and proximately by the negligence ot the
Defendant. in thatl
(a) Oetendante knew, or with the exerobe of
re&lonable diliqence, should have known that: the aille in which
the Plaintiff w~s injured was unsare tor pedeltrian travel dUe
to the danqerous condition,
(b) Defendants tailed to warn PlBintitf and other
invitees of the dangerous oondition of the aisle,
(c) Defendants failed to adequately start its
grooery store with trained and oompetent employses 10 that Bafe
aisles oould be maintained,
(d) Defendants failed to insurs that the aisles
within its grocery store, and the partioular aisle in question,
Were Bafe for invitee., and,
(e) Detendants knew, or with the exercise of
r.easonable diligence, should have known that the unattended
duties of the employees freqUently create dangerous oonditions
providJ.nq the Defendants with aotual notice I
SPtHCt.... GltAlOIt,
InISE" u.(IU~, '-C.
AlIOIlHL'f'I.At.IAW
WULUORO, rA.
COUNT I
Jaoqu.lin. D, schweigart v. william "I cr...l.r,
incu'vidually, and will iam n. cr...ler t/d/b/a
cr...ler'. Fruit Market, William H. Cr...ler
t/d/b/a Cre..ler'. Food Market and
Cre..ler'. Food Market, Inc.
9. The averments ot paragraphs 1 through II are
incorporated herein by reterenoe.
10. As a direot, proximate and substantial result ot
the negligence of Pefendants ato~osaid, Plaintiff experienoes
low back, left hip and lett leg pain whioh renders her unable to
maintain her preinjury level of aotivity and may be permanent.
11. As 8 direot, pr9ximate and sub.tantial reBult ot
the negligenoe of Detendants aforesaid, Plaintiff sutfered pain,
mental. anguish and humiliation, a 1011I of the pleasures of life
and disabilities, all of which she may oontinue to suffer for an
indefinite period of time and may be permanent.
12. As a direct, proximate and subDtantial result of
the negligenoe of Defendants afore.aid, Plaintitf suffered a
loss of earning oapaoity.
WHEREFORE, plaintiff, Jaoqueline D. sOhweigart, denlands
judgment against Pefendants, William H. cresBler, individually,
and William H. Cressler t/d/b/a Cr..sler's Fruit Market, William
"
,
q ,
" ,. ,
" "
d " ,
'! ,
,
, , I
I:
,
I'
" "
,
"
I
"
'.
-. 'I- , ,
~; r,. , ,
C; "
.. \ ( ,'1/ "
t; 11.,1
~I I ~ t' .,
~. ;r~ , :q
.\,
~I., 'J\ '~l
JI:~ "
~" .- 11'e' "
I. ~- , "
[;!I,' I,
I- ~': ;.~
4,. ~ ,J.
Q
"
'; , I :
, ,
, , " "
" I
I, I"
, , ,
q "
, "
Ii ,
, , , I I
' , I ~ ,\ , , Ii ,
"
,
',I
~ NAT1I. DI.IC1~D TO pLAINT!"
13, Pefendallta'incorporate by reference as though fully
.et forth herein the averments snd denials contained in Paragraphs
1-la of thi. AnsWer & New Matter,
14 , Plaint if f' s inj uriu and damages, which are
specifically denied, were not caused by any BctS, omissions, or
breaches of duty by Pefendant, nor by any employee, servllnt or
agent of Pef~ndant acting in the course and scope of their
employment o~ agency, by were caused, in whole or in part, or were
contributed to, by the negligence, f.ault, or want of oare of
Plaintiff.
15, Plaintiff's injuries, if any, were pre-existing, and
were not caused by nor aggravated by any acts, omissions, or
breaches of duty by Pafendantll, nor by Pefendantll' employees,
servants, or agent~, acting within the course and Ilcope of their
employment or agency,
16. Plaintiff's cause of action may be barred in whole
or in part, or reduced by virtue of the Pennsylvania comparative
Negligence statute, 42 Pa,C.S, 67102, or by the Doctrine of
Comparative Negligence.
17, Plaintiff aSllumed the risk of the injuries allegedly
sl)lItained by reallon of her own intentional conduct.
3
18. NQ dangeroulI or un..f.. ccndition exi.ted on I:he
premilel at the said time,
:L9 I I f any danQurous or unsafe condition exhted, which
ill specifically denied, then P~fendant. did not caulle the condition
and had no actullll or constl:uctive notice of any lIuch condil:ion
exiltting Oil the property at tho /lAid time,
20. If any dangel:ous or unsaf) condition existed, which
is specifically denied, ~laintiff had actuel or qonstructive notice
of such a condition,
21, ~laJ.ntiff F.ailed to exercise her last clear ohance
to avoid the reasonably discoverable conditions to whioh she
e:H:posed herself,
22, Pefendants' alleged actions or omissions were not a
substantial factor in causing ~laintiff' s injuries and damages, if
any,
23. Plaintiff's Complaint fails to state a claim upon
which relief could be granted.
24, Plaintiff's injuries or dsmages, if any, were not
caused by and acts, omissions, or breaches of duty by Pefendants,
nor by Pefendants' employees, servants, or agents acting within the
course and scope of their employment or agency, but were caused by
others over whom Defendant had no control,
25, Plaintiff's olaims may be barred by the applicable
statutes of limitation,
4
WK..lroa./ DU"nd.ntl denland jut1;m..nt in their favor, together
With all applicable ~ourt cOlt., a;"inlt Plaintiff,
Re.pecr.fully .ubmitted,
THONU, THOMAS " HArlR
~ f)yt~,--
Todd B. Narvol
1,1), No. 42136
306 N. Front Street
1/1,0, Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108"0999
Datel '(~l'n
,
"
, ,
"
,
,
by
,
,
"
,
I'
I
,
, ,
" ,
, I
I'
, ,
, " I'
"
, I
, ,
"
, ,
I
i'
I,'
6
g..,r.rOA'. o. a,lvra.
I, Todd &, N.~vol, oe tho law firm of 'rHOMAS, THOMAS, & HAI1'IIlR, do ClertUy
that I ..X'ved the fongoing (looument on the foregoing penona ,l:ly Fin\;
Clus, United Statu Mail, poetage prepaid at HardabuX'!l, Pennlylv'ania,
addre.~ed ae followel
William A, "epe, msquire
17 central Avenue
Welleporo, PA 16901
'I
Iii
"
"
, '
)i
!,
'nlONAll, THOMAS . HArll
~~~-------
, . ..
Oate, C, { ~ [ ~ J
.
IPfNClI,OllA50H,
IttDE & ~J.QUr, P,C,
",ltlitU,'.Af.I.AW
WtunOIlO, PA.
.
,
. ,
.
JACQUBLI~B D, SCHWBIGART,
Plaint:1tt
I IN THI COURT or COMMoN PLBAS
I
I CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PENNA.
I
I HO, 96-8644 CIVIL T~RH
I
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
I JURY TRIAL DEMANPEP
I
I
I
I
VB.
WILLIAM It. CRBSBI,BR,
individuallYI and WILLIAM H,
CRESSLER, t/d/b/a CRF.BBLBR'B
f'RUIT MARJ<E'fl WILLIAM Ii.
CRESBLER, t/d/b/a CREBBLIER'B
FOOD MARKETI and CRESSLER'S
FOOP MARJ<ET, INC.,
Defendants
IW~DEEEmlAN~
13, Requi~QB no ~QsponQive pleading,
4. The averment. of paragraph 14 lite denied,
Plaintiff's injuries and damages were oaused speoifioally by the
neqUgonoe of the Pefendants and/o~ their agent.., servants or
employee. aoting within the soope of their employment or agenoy.
Plaintiff at all times exeroised due oare.
16, The averments ot paragraph 15 are denied. The
inju~ieB fo~ whioh Plaintiff seeks o~mpens~tion in this lawsuit
were not preexisting and were oausod and/or aggravated by tho
neqligenoe of the Defendants BS desoribed in Plaintiff's
complaint.
16. The aVlllrlnsnts of paragraph 16 are denied.
Plaintitt was guilty ot no oomparative neqligonoe,
17. The averments ot paragraph 17 are denied. At no
time did Plaintift alsume any risk,
SPlHCfIl. GLEASON,
IIUlI RAOUl, ,,C.
~'IO.Jjt"I""'.lAW
WmUOIIO, 'A.
I "
18, Den1ed tor the ......on. ..t torth 1n Pla1nt1tt'lI
ao..pla1nt.
1V. The aver..ent. at paravraph 1V are denied,
pleint1ft believe. and, there tore, aver. that the Defendant. did
have aotual or oon.truot1ve notioe of thlB danverou. oondition
de.oribed in Plaintiff" Oomplaint.
20. The averments of para9raph 20 are denied. It is
denied that Plaintiff had any notioe whatloever of the dangerous
oondltion ddsoribed in Plaintiff's complaint.
21. The avermenta of paragraph 21 are denied.
Plaintiff did not have a last olaar ohanoe to avoid the dangerous
oondltion delcribed in Plaintiff'. Complaint.
22. The aVlrment. of paragraph 22 are denied for the
reaaonl peC forth in Plaintiff'. complaint.
23. The averment. of paragraph 23 are denied for the
reaeon. set forth in Plaintiff'p complaint.
24, The averments of paragraph 24 are denied for the
reasons let forth in Plaintift'p Complaint.
25. Penied. This aotiun was instituted within the
applioable two-year statute of limitations.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demandl judgment as requested in
her Complaint.
SPENCER H~BE & RAGUE, P.c.
BYI William A, Hebe, ::r.~~
Plaintiff
P.o. Box 507
Wellsboro, Pennsylvania 16901
(717) 724-1832
Attorney 1.0. No. 16601
. .....
1\
1
;1
I~ i
'P[HCEIl. Gl!AIIlH,
lUll . ~AGUE, M.
"lTQIlI.'iYl."'.!-AW
WHUnOMO, 'A.
. . I
. ~ .
The undeniqned certifies that II true and ccrrect ccpy ot
the totl\loinq Reply wu rllrved on the tollowinq by United statell
pint: Ola.. HaU, postage pt'.paid, this 7th day ot July, 11197.
Todd B. Narvol, Esquire
THOMAS, 'rlIOMAS " HAFER
P.O. BOI( 999
Harri.burq, PA 11108
ON, HE~E , RAOUl, P.c.
aYI William A, He~~~ tOt'
Plaintitt
p,a, Box 607
Well.bore, Pennsylvania 16901
(71'/) 724-1832
Attorney I.P. No, 16601
i i I
,I ,
I,
, I
,\
\
J^CQUBLINE p, SOHWEIG^RT,
Plaintiff
v.
IN THE COIJRT OF COHHON PLBAS
OUHBER~NO COUNTY, PBNNS'J t,vAlnA
NO. 96-6644 CIVT.L TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL PEMANDEP
WILLIAM H. CREBSl,L1:R,
individually, and WILLIAM H.
CRESt31,ER t/d/b/a CRJUISLER'S
FRUI'l' MARKE'!.', WILJ"IAM II,
CREssr,ER t/d/b/a CRESSLER'S
FOOP MARKE'l' and CRESSUilR't3
FOOP MAltKE'l', WC.,
Oufonl1ants
~EPTANCE OF B~RVICB
I, Todd U. NBrvol, Esquire, horeby aooept servioe of
the complaint oJl, blll,Blf of tl,,, DefellJahts, William H. el'llsBler,
individually, and William H. cressler t/d/b/a CresEller'1!I Fruit
Mar)tet/ William Il. Cressler t/d/b/a Cressler's Food Market and
Cressler's Food Market, Inc., and certify that I am authorized
to do
so.
Datel
fj 1''1/17
~M bJ1~
Todd B, Narvol, Esquire
THOMAS, 'l'HOMAB & HAFER
306 North f'ront street
sixth Floor
P.O. Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 171013
(717) 237-7105
"
"'HUll. GUAlOI'f,
IlfUI RAOIJf,P.(,
",IUIINe ~i.A'.IAW
WIU,IUOIll), 'It,
VS.
IN ~HE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CIJMIlERloAND COUNTY, PENNSVLVANIA
No. 96-~644 CIVIL TERM
JACQUELINB D, SClfWBIOAI\T,
Plaintift
WILLIAM H, CRESSLBR,
Individually and WILLIAM H,
CRESSLER t/d/b/a CRESSLER'S
~'RUI'l' MARKE'l', WILLIAM II.
CRESflLER t/d/b/a CRESSLEIV S
FOOD MARKE'l' and CRESBI,ER'8
FOOD MARKE'l', INC.,
Defendants
CIV'IL AC'rION - LAW
JURY tRIAL PBMANDED
fj.Q'l'rCE ~E Of' DISCOVERY
The undersigned oertifies that true oopies ot AnSWers
to Detendants' I"t.~I.t0I11itoriGa and Reeponse to Request tor
Production of Documents of Defendants Directed to plaintiff--
tJ yt ( ).
flot I were served on the fo11o\/ing this,..:J I - day of . 'f~u".IA.,/ ,
(/ /
1998, by U,fl, First Class Mail, postage prepaid, addressed as
follows I
Todd a. Narvol, Esquire
TllOKAS, THOMAS & HAFER
305 North Front street
sixth Floor
P.O, Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108
HEBE & RAGUE, P.C.
~~&
-
William A. Hebe - I.P, No. 16601
Attornay for Plaintiff
~PIHCU, GLlAION,
lUll! " kAGU"1',,"
AIIO.Nm,Ar,~w
WlLUIOIlO, PA,
P.O, Box 507, 17 Central Avenue
Wellsboro, PA 16901
(717) 724-1832
, ,
, I
,
" ,
, ,
!)
'I I'
,I
I. I
,
I
, ,
, ,
,
:1 ,
,
, "
~ ,... , II:
.:I , I
, ,
"
"),, - f~~ ~ , I
, p, r. I. r. I'
ri-'I' "..
I :... ';I~~
'tJI': '7\ "
lip I rt.1~
(- ", fq 'I "
"1 ~ Ii
I- I
t~ m " I I "
" ,
, ,
" I
I ,
I, " 'I I I'
,
"
"
, ,
"
, , I " "
, "
,
.I; "
"
, II' :'
11'..1 ,
, ,
I, I
;,
,; I,
" I ,
"
" ,
I I
I' ,I Ii
;11
'I I,
,I
"
'I II ,
'" 1:1 ,
, ,
I
"
I
I.
Ii: ;,
"
" " "
I' ,
~ ~:I' )... " , "
~I ~ l;i , 'I
'':) "I' , ,I' "
r~n {.~ I.!: I! " .
1.1. t". , _il
" .' I
'\", o. ) ~l
'I ';...
I' ' ~. ,'Id "
fi'i ~. /,1tq
T I -
C'I" . t,.. ''''1' "
l., el: ~f . :1
I 11: "
e:. al t:
,I
"
" /,
I' '. ,0;
"
"
,
,I I, ,
" I, ,I "
I , , "
, II ,
Ii I ,
"
, , ,
, I
, /, , , !III, ,I
" "
" , 1
"
\' "
......-.
v,
IN 'l'HI!: COUR'l' Of' COMMOI'I PLli:A/J
cUMalDRLANO COUI'I'l''i, 1)~;NI'ISYLVI\tHA
NO, 9lH5644 CIVIL '1'l':HM
JACQUfJLINI!: P. BCHWI!JIQAR'l',
Plaintitt
WILLIAM H, CRESSLER,
indiviJually, and WILLIAM H,
CRESSLER t./d/b/a CRESSLER'S
FRUIT HARKE'r, WILLIAM H.
CRESSLER t/d/b/a CRESSLER/a
FOOP MJlRKE'l' and CR~~SSLER/S
f'OOP MARKE'l', INC"
lJefendants
CIVIL AC'l'!ON . l..AW
JUR'i TRIAL OI!lMANDElJ
tiPTICB or DBRVIOB or-DliOOVERY
The undersigned certifies that u true uopy 01 Notlc~
of Oral Deposition echeduling Michael C. Gaudioee, M,I)., tor
deposition on June 29, 2000, At 3130 P,I11" at the otfioes of
Cumberland
Valley
family
Physicians,
in
Chambersburg,
Pennsylvania, wa13 served this 16th day of MIIY, 2000, by U,s,
First ClASS Mail, poetage prepaid, addressed as follows:
'l'odd B, Narvol, Esquire
THOMAS, 'l'HOMA6 & HAnm, L. L, p,
305 North front Street
sixth noor
P.O. Box 999
Harrisburg, Ph 17108
lPlHUP,OUA'oN,
IH;1f .. RAGUf. p.e,
AtTOIHn'S....f.lAW
Wf.tUIO~U, ,~.
SPENCER, 'A60N, HEBE & RAGUE, P,C,
By: U'~~ ~.~t~4fj~
William A, Hebe, Esquire
1. P. No. 16601
Attorney for Plaintiff
17 Central Avenue
p.a, Box 507
Welleboro, PA 16901
(670) 724-1812
, ,
, , ,
I,
II II
" "
,
I " 'i II'
I,
'i 'Ii
, I
!'
"
" I'
" "
, ,
,
"
,
"
" I,
"
"
:'1 t.~ f 11 ,
1.li ..
~;;f " "
_j Ii;,
i)J1ti \..~ , I
, , ..H ,IJJi
1" ,." "
,,/ 1,1" " ,,\
t_,'" 1,-.) , "i-~ I ,
'I' ..-,-, ) ",ri" I
1,1" ,11"1,1 I I ,
{I,I, ~ .. , , I ,
f: 1M:, '" t.. , I
\I.; U , "
~i "'J. ,
tl , ,
!! I, , "
,1
,
, H "
"
,
" I
, ,
"
" , "
" I, , I
,
, I
, , 'I 'I
,
, " "
I , 11111 , ,
','I ,
,
" 'i , , ,
, " ,
" , ,
I ,
" ',I
, ,
" , ,