HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-05705
,
>- 1'""
rr.
~ C'..~
y
~c c;; ,.~
ffi _!t.'
..... ,.:(
~r. .;>.
(. 4~
L. ..v "
,L>. )~
.....
o:~' ' 1- '\~ ...
~ u ;.~Iill
CJ ;':710..
~ _0 ~:
:;)
CJ' U
~ '
~~~
~
~
'-
~
~,;; -
... 0
~/ ;:..~, J
~~
~
. 0
.
:>> <II Z ~
j .., - .... ..
OW ! 1 1r~"C
, :i OW , !& 0( 11-
.: > .... . z
~ = .. ... ~ ~
II B
z .. o ~ 0 i!
.. .
..c ... E & z . & ·
... C)o II Z
! Ir .. II Z
i Z · ..
.... L
i z II: Z .
~ :II: e ; ~
o .. 0 ;)
.., .... C z .
..J -.
o "i
i
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLANO COUNTY, PENNA
NO. l)(,. !>'70~; c..uJ ,...........
ROBERT A. NEILL, JR.,
Plaintiff
JENNIFER PHELABAUM,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
AND NOW. comes the Plaintiff, by and through his attorneys, Cleckner and
Fearen, and in support of the within Complaint, alleges as follows:
1. Plaintiff is Robert A. Neill. Jr., an adult individual who resides at 3617 North
Sixth Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110.
2. Defendant is Jennifer Phelabaum. an adult individual who resides at 841
Erford Road. Camp Hill, Pennsylvania 17011.
3. The event upon which this action is based is an automobile collision which
occurred on January 13, 1996. at or about 1 1 :38 P.M. on Valley Road, approximately
200 feet south of its intersection with Earth Road, in the Township of Hampden.
County of Cumberland. Commonwealth of Pennsylvania.
4. At the time and place aforesaid, Plaintiff was operating a 1985 Dodge
Aries. owned by him, and bearing registration plate number AVS 0648.
5. At the time and place aforesaid. Defendant was operating 81981 Toyota
Corona, owned by Sharon F. Fox. and bearing Pennsylvania registration plate number
ALE 3400.
. 1 .
6. At the time and place aforesaid, the vehicle operated by Defendant
proceeded across the center line and collided head on with the vehicle operated by
Plaintiff .
7. The aforesaid collision was a direct and proximate result of Defendant's
careless, reckless and negligent operation of her vehicle, as follows:
lal in failing to keep her vehicle under proper and adequate control;
lbl in failing to operate her vehicle in accordance with existing traffic conditions
and circumstances;
lc) in crossing the center line and proceeding in the wrong lane of travel;
ld) in operating her vehicle at a speed greater than reasonably prudent under
the circumstances, and at a speed greater than would permit her to stop within
the assured clear distance ahead;
lei in violating the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Code, 75 P.S., Sections 3301,
3309 and 3361.
8. As a direct and proximate result of the aforesaid negligence of Defendant,
Plaintiff's vehicle was damaged beyond repair.
9. Plaintiff purchased the aforesaid vehicle on March 23, 1995 for the sum of
$3.495.00.
10. Plaintiff's vehicle suffered no damage between the date of purchase and
the date of the aforesaid collision, except normal wear and tear.
.2.
11. Plaintiff's vehicle had a fair market value at the time of the collision of
$3.000.00.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant in the amount of
$3,000.00, less sblvage value, which does not exceed the jurisdictional amount
requiring arbitration referral under local rules of court.
CLECKNER AND FEAREN
By:
lOILAlil;)
I 08nnis J. Shatto. Esquire
Attorney 1.0. No. 25675
31 North Second Street
P. O. Box 11847
Harrisburg PA 17108.1847
(7171238-1731
.3-
'".
.-
BAIIRX A. 1lJIOIftIIAL. &SQOIU
'a. Sup~ Court I.D. Ro. 55172
UnlOLDI 5 HAVAS
101 'ine Itnet
'oat Office Box e32
Rarriaburg. Pannaylvania 17108-0e32
o:a1-smo",:
r...:
17171 231-3200
17171 231-Un
Attorney for Defendant:
JDIIfII'&Jl, ,..... 'IBAUN
ROBERT A. NEILL, JR., . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
.
Plaintiff . CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
.
.
v. . NO. 96-5705 CIVIL
.
. CIVIL ACTION - LAW
.
JENNIFER PHELABAUM, .
.
Defendant . JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
.
Harrell '1'0 PLw:r.n
TO: ROBERT A. NEILL, JR.
c/o Dennis Shatto, Esquire
Cleckner and Fearen
31 North Second Street
Post Office Box 11847
Harrisburq, PA 17108-1847
You are hereby notified to file a written response to
the enclosed New Matter within twenty (20) days from service
hereof or a default judqment may be entered aqalnst you.
,~
:>
DATE: i~!19'7
By:
NT
AttorneY I.D. 155672
Attorneys for Defendant,
JENNIFER PHELABAUM
101 plne Street
Poat Office Box 932
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0932
(717) 236-JlOO
UNlI ll.. ~, .'QVIU
... .~ court 1.0. Wo. 55.72
UDlOUl. , Ill.VJoa
101 .iDe .u.et
Poat Office Box .32
~xi&buzv, ~y1Y&D1. 17101-0'32
~l"P"<>lle:
1'&&:
In'l 231-3200
17111 231-1113
ll.tto..-y fox DefeadaDt:
.J_.l..~ .....~..tM
ROBERT A. NEILL, JR.,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 96-5705 CIVIL
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
.
.
v.
JENNIFER PHELABAUM,
Defendant
USWD WI'rB ... D'1"1'D 01' DBI'lDlDAJI'l'. JB1OfII'D PBIJ,aJla.1l1I
If'O ~JOL~rll'f o. PL~TII'l'Y". RQRnlfl a.. nYLL. JR.
AND NOW, comes Defendant, Jennifer Phelabaum ('Ms.
Pbelabaum"), by and through her counsel, Reynolds' Havas, a
Professional Corporation, and hereby files this Answer with New
Matter to the Complaint of Plaintiff, Robert A. Neill, Jr.
C"Plaintiff"), averring tbe following in support thereof:
U'WD
1. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Ms,
Pbelabaum is without knowledge or information sufficient to fora
a belief as to the truth of the averaents of this paragraph and
they are, therefore, denied,
2. Denied. Ms. Phelabaua'. current address is 1329A
South Rolle.ton Street, Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, 17104.
3. Denied. After reasonable investigation, Ms.
Phelabaua is without knowledge or inforaation sufficient to fora
a belief as to the truth of the averaent. of thi. paraqraph and
they are, therefore, denied.
4. - 11. Denied.
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Jennifer Phelabaum demands
jUdgm.nt in her favor and against plaintiff, Robert A. Neill,
Jr., with co.ts a.....ed to Plaintiff.
lID IO.'f'1'D
12. The answ.rs contain.d in Paragraphs 1 through 11
inclu.ive h.reof are incorporat.d by r.f.r.nce h.r.in as if set
forth in their .ntirety,
13. Plaintiff's claims, if any, are barred by the
applicable statute of limitations.
14. Th. subject collision and Plaintiff's alleged
daaages and/or injurie., if any, w.re .olely, directly and
proximately caused by Plaintiff's own negligent, reckless, and/or
careless conduct.
15. Plaintiff's clai.., if any, are barred by the
doctrine. of contributory and co.parative neglig.nce and
a..uaption of the ri.k.
16. Plaintiff has failed to .tate a clai. upon vhich
relief can be qranted,
17. Plaintiff'. clai.., if any, are barred by their
failure to .itiqate their damage..
18. At all ti.e. relevant her.to, Ms. Pbelabaua va.
reapondin; appropriately under the circuastance. than axi.tin; to
. .udden ...rgency.
vn:rP:rCAT:rOIl
I, JENNIFER PHELABAUM, hereby acknowledge that I all the
Defendant in this action; that I have read the foregoing
document; and that the facts stated therein are true and correct
to the best of IIY knowledge, information and belief.
I understand that any false statellents herein are made
subject to penalties of 18 Pa.C,S.A, section 4904, relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities,
DATE:
12/3/97
. .'
eWR~I.I~a~. O~ RRRVrCR
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have served a true and correct
copy of the foregoing document upon all counsel
record this ~ day of 'l)eL . ,
and partie. of
1997, by placing
the sa.e in the United states First Class Mail, postage prepaid,
at Harri.burg, penn.ylvania, addr....d a. follow.:
Denni. Shatto, E.quire
Cl.ckner and F.aren
31 North S.cond Street
Post Office Box 11847
Harrisburg, PA 1710S-1847
"
~-PO
ra L. Haaa
.- - '~
""'CLECKNER ANI, FEAijEiN";
ROBERT A. DILL, JR., I IN TBB COURT 01' COIOlON PLEAS
Plaintiff I cmmBRLAHD COUNTY, PBHHSYLVAHIA
I
v. I NO. 96-5705 CIVIL
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JBHHII'BJl pR'RT.IlJSAUJI, I
Defendant I JURY TRIAL DBllAHDBD
REPLY TO ow MATTER
AND NOW comes Plaintiff, Robert A. Neill, Jr., ("Mr. Neill"),
by and through his counsel, Cleckner and Fearen, and hereby files
this Reply to New Matter as follows:
12. No answer required.
13. Denied, as a conclusion of law.
14. Denied, as a conclusion of law. Moreover, Plaintiff did
not engage in any negligent, recklessness and/or careless
conduct.
111e averments of the Complaint are incorporated
herein by reference.
15. Denied, as a conclusion of law. Moreover, Plaintiff was
not contributorily or comparatively negligent, and did not
assume any risk.
111e averments of the Complaint are
incorporated herein by reference.
16. Denied, as a conclusion of law.
17. Denied. as a conclusion of law.
18. Denied as a conclusion of law. Moreover, there was no
sudden emergency, other than the one created by Defendant's
conduct.
111e aveI1llents of the Complaint are incorporated
herein by reference.
ROBERT A. DILL, JR., I IN TBB COURT 01' COIOlON PLEAS
Plaintiff I CtJIIBDLD1D CotlHTY, PBHHSYLVAHIA
I
v. I NO. 96-5705 CIVIL
I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JBHHII'BJl PIIBLABAUJI, I
Defendant I JURY TRIAL DBllAHDBD
CBRTII'ICATB 01' SERVICE
I, Dennis J. Shatto, Esquire, hereby certify that I, on this
q~ day of ~~~.~ ,1997, served a true and correct copy
of the foregoing Reply to New Matter upon the following counsel of
record by depositing the same in the United States mail, postage
prepaid, addressed as follows:
Barry A. Kroothal
101 Pine Street
P.O. Box 932
Harrisburg, PA 17108-0932
..
~.. .... AIID pa....
By
i. nA A A J / J I
De~~ Y~~~squire
PO Box 11847
31 N. Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1847
(717) :238-1731
RrCHARnS,JUDY / SPFD/16 - openDesk print.
-----------------------------------------
Subject: 45-144
Creator: Monica J WAREHAM / SPFD/48
Dated: 01/16/96 at 1444.
Valuation Report
STATE FARM INSURANCE
115 LIMEKILN, NEW CUMBERLAND PA 17070
717-774-9074
,~
Date: 1/16/96 J~?
Claim: 38-7145-~
Policy:
CUstomer: ROBERT NEILL JR.
Loss Date: 1/13/96
Deductible: $500
Payer Code:
Valuation 10:
Type of Loss:
Classification:
Assessor:
Assessor 10:
Profile:
State:
1678
Collision
Total Loss
BOND
3001731
YORK
PA
~---------------------------------------------------------------------
Vehicle: 1985 Dodge Aries
VIN: IB3BD21COFG269294
Mileage: 163,304
Condition:
20 Sed 4 Cyl
Type: Auto
License: PA
Color:
----------------------------------------------------------------------
N.A.D.A.c, OLDER VEHICLE VALUES
021 ARIES SEDAN 20
Base Value
Mileage Adjustment
Air Condo
Stereo
$1,625
<$230>
Standard
:10 .\djustr.:ent
REO BOOKc, OLDER VEHICLE VALUES
B~21C 2dr Sedan-4
Base Value
:.Ii leage Adjust:.-.er.t.
Air Condo
A.~I-FM Stereo
$925
::0 Adjustnent
$75
$25
-----------
Total Retail Value
$1,395
Total High Value
$1,025
Mitchell International, a Division of Thomson Publishin9 Corporation
warrants that this valuation is an accurate representatlon of the
N.A.D.A.c and the Red Bookc value guides.
Older vehicle average values are not supplied by Red Bookc, but are
calculated by avera9ing Older Car Red Bookc Average High and Average
Low values. The cholce of Average High, Average Low or averaged values
is at the assessor's discretion based on vehicle condition.
----------------------------------------------------------------------
AVERAGE BOOK VALUE (Taxable)
Taxable Adjustments
Taxable Adjustments Total
Pre-Tax Subtotd
State Tax 6.00\
$1,210.00
$0.00
$1,210.00
$72.60
.----------
Post-Tax Subtotal
Non-Taxable Adjustnents
TITLE TRANSFER FEE
Deductible
Non-Taxable Ad;ustments Tetal
$1,282.60
$25.00
<$SOO.OO>
<$0415.00>
Nt'T TotAL
I: t ".., t .,--"
,.,t" . e1l"
--------_.----------------~*---~~---------~~------*-------------------
Pe:""arks I
C,/R J~'-tr~ R~~,'::~rY "~~-:1'J-".~
t BRI:'.'~I~~'"
"t~ CADILLAC . OLOSMOB'L,~
~ 2222 PAXTON STREET HARRISBURG. PA 238,2552
'Z'!"
,J..I'
~
'0'0 .1QV....h.ItWT" llOOt"':
._..0<'0"10 u~ .
McKEE /WieRS
",N1..t.~' A, ~t .
!>I~i1
:..
"...... .... . .- ....." ..... ...",-.. .'" .-~._.. ..... ...- . - -.
cWt tI ,~'. \ ~.~,.. P'l_..,~'WOl'\-" ,...'" ,1I"'~ ",",_1'1\.," * "",""I "':11I'''''''''.''' l.,....,'''''
.-." ......-.. -... - -......--
:!Jjlfl#lr."~, ",I'\\'~ ~',~r. _ ~.~ ,nun
.,,,.,>,n'''' OOO"I"'"t<,...st~.''''~'.o. .1 ... ....,,,.. · ..".... .... ..,.-....," ...,.
.".._ _---.. ..._ .._ .00 "'00""'-'--
-.- ...-....-..oo .oo ."........- ..".--'"
..,,,..,. U" ~..... .,."'... .n... ...... ,," IT. ""
"'-'" -oo..." -...-...... .". ....... .....,
",,,"", ......-..".-. ..- ..--"- ,..<-.,,,,,,,.-.
;-~...,"'" ~ ..""",,,.... SPANKEV'S ,.....O~~O~.N.E,~.~........,
"'...." ..~- ...... ...-.- -.=--
.,"'..,I.:!......I'-.-. '.. .......,_,,_._ ,..."."............., .....~,~...u......"""
_ _ ~ .......,....ltlf,.II..""'I".... '....Il.~....-.-
.."'....._ ..""~...,,,.....,_ I -.-
.- - - ... ..--.- -' - ...... -. - "" "-". ....
--~' ..-..-...... --....-"" ---~-
._.... :;:.::::'-'= ,:::0'; -..... -. .::::..-....-. ."',,,""=
_'_'- ... ........ ,." ....."...., .._' ......" " oI'. .,,, _' _..- -- mu"
.__..''''- --............-.'''''' ~...,,'- ....",............ -,.-,'~--
..",.... _ "........... ......._.... "......',... SpH1VEY'S IO.D"......',.~....
- - <0. ~- -" .....- ._- .,,. --. ...---
..-":.-.. . _ -",.",-
",,,,,," _ ":;:.:;;:a-s ,.,,,?,?" .,..... ... :.::::;::::.. 'EO-a.;:r.':?'
.- ",."., .... .. ,..,... .-..... =-"':':..::~,:;. ... ,.,,,...',
~ ~,\.. ..-" .-' -" ." - .,,,. -.. ...."..,
QJlo, .",,,.-,,,= ...- - -..' ......,.,....'- .-..---'-'
- .-.-- ..-." -.... ..... .......-... - - "" "'.,......,.. -
_ .... .."_ .,~""".::;:", :::> "'".:"".,,~ 'CO'",,
,...".. ..... ........_._- _....."..~.._.. .lL~' .".................
-'" ...-.-..- -"'....... --....-..-.. .....-..........
...""",,- .".. ......................-. "...,...,.....- ~
...,_.Il"'''' MC"EEMOiORS _..,,,_._~- .....".....,,'~..........
...~. ...~.. ,...~" .'..... ,...."... ",.. ...,.,.,,,.., -...
..-"...-' ..-'-' -..-'-- --_...,,-- .,,'" .-.....
..... ~... .,,'" .- -... ~". .- - ..-'"
...I.'_...-_....~-.., ...-.-..-. ......._~.- - ..- ..".,,-
.-".- -.-.-- ------ .-...-'- :-_-..::"".;:.-
_D>"" ::::;~:~. SpHIVEY'S :.::"..:::::::".::: ,OI..,...,.,...I~............
...--'- -' ..,,-. .." -.---- -' ..- ..... ...~' .-....... \.';;
.._..- _._-.-- ._..-.- __....-- _....._. _',. t"C\.l.....
. ---. -..."...-.- .- ----' -'-" .... "...-"..- -;
.....".........._ _....."....._- ..._ _'_ ~.. ....._.nltt,.",..~.
..___ _...._.-. r._'::--" .....-...-- --"-. .....---
.-"-.- ..- .....--.- ----- - ---'- ---.,."
--.- .. "... -" - ...--" .-- .... - ...." ---.--- ---...--
........'-- ""'<:",,"""'-- -- ,~- .~ ----- "..
".:'" .:r.':-=' =.r.;=-:: -....-...- .....~.::":~"':.:. ~""=.::=
,.. _ ............_..... ~ SpHllIEYS ~....,,,,,.....,,,,
.......- ...... ~.-'" -- ....--",,_. .",,'-
. .....,u..- ,... tall . <~'...... ~ ---..... elf.....
.---.. .".. ' . .-.......-- ,,-.-'.'" .---.- .-,. .--
...--- - ..-.--". -' -" .... ..- -"--'
-.- ._- ..".- - - - . ..".-.- - ..-..-OO" .... ...... ...... ......... -- ..
..- ~..- _.-"~ --~.-- -..---"- -.-........ .. ...
~. ,,_ ." .... .._ .. _._- '00'-' ,---...... .. ..---'
-. - - - -_.- - .". - .-' ".... .. - ....".....- -- - .-- .
. - .-'" ::::::.-..:"..::= .,~.;:;::,::;."'" - ::::-,"::,-::';"'''''- --
, .::. ......_._.- ,;,. ,....'". SPHIVEY S ..... ........,.....- ,.. -::--......
_ =-:.:....".= o CO",," .",,' ......-. - - ...--...
.-" --.- .-.---- ....-.- -. -----
.. .._....~. I'. c."'" ,...~' ._"......_ ,.....'_ _"'.::.--..............CJIl1 .... ..<<,...... ... I.
- ..-' ".......-- ,...." ~ .
....,,_.'. _.....----... ,..... ~ ,...........,..,..v.-~ ..... .,.."",1.19'---'
__"",-, c.......~......-... ~I- .-...--........ I
........""".. -....-....., . a -..-....-...... *
t::O"" ---.....-- ...-..-- ....-.--
. ' ,....:- .-.--.-- .....-...-.....\
\....-.-... -,=~ ...-- oo.-"'-
."''''''',,,,, =.",.-;:_"",,~.-. .._ .".':':":"'""_ M(K.EE MOiORS ~~~~:::.':
-,,- -. -.. -" . '.-;:';." -' ...-.-' .. ..- ..'"
C'~ ,- "..- .,.......... \ ......... ""... \ ,.....(.......... .--p.
,.. .~.'_ _, ....... ,... _ ....., .u.......... ~ Oc~~h~ \ )I4.T ... ..... .........,..,.,.....~
..'-,'0......... \......-...............:-. .... - ......._~-_\\~--- -~~~\.I).,.. .-
.-..-.... . .... --- " - -- --' ..
"",,"~" -",,,,, .", " ''''':~'''.:-; ....oo.. - \ ",.:'::: -"" -'~ "::-=-. - ....
......__.,......,.~',.._ ...~.~,..__..., PIJGIIEtE \-11'........ -
~.." .._."'__ M- ,,,.__,' _ ._ .. J ......, ...-'-
~.,'" .... ...... .. _ .....-... _,_ .-"",".~' -_.:.. - ...-"
.....--" .;:;,....;;-~"-.;-.;;:; ".... ..... . -. ".., .><~.' -.... ... - -..... .....
_......_ .. w"..~_...'- .,-"-'- -..;.-....-....-
." .......- ....." ....- - ~......
...~~~c~.~'-~~~....._.-. l,l.t"EE rAOiO!(5 ;;;.~.- ,";;;-; ;;;;.
.- ,.",..... - ~- "". .-........,.- ._~,......-. ....
.... ...~...'.... ._._'-' ._~.._ ~_... _" d
._' . .... ._ ,.. ..'. ..._' U~... ..--......."-'
,....-.,;.. ,,",," '-'~-
,
.010 11 [,I' ~., ~ ::. ,
.."..o,O,,'ltff(l~"""'"
-"
'0'0 "M~~" : 1'11I
1"""''''.0111."..'0,",'''''''
,.. uU'u" ""t' ,,,,,,,.
bfO""""C"(04I"""'-'
...."'........ .....f'IOw\,ll.l
....', ",11'1 _If "It," "'"
'l'fl...,.,","'111""'"''
...""
iOlD 1t,.."V'l'I'tfll..,...,Of'M
.."...0l0I"'.............1fI.
""_.ll('\V'C.~o(."""l
......,..110I a.~ ~..1'21
;010 M[J." ~L'__
..." ,,,",,,,t'O"\"" "..
......""fwtf"..~\lTl.""
'U.'OIl~
iOta ..t..L1."""....eCI.
eIl1.ltlOh'. --" ,,..-,,., ..
..........,......11II:"........,
011I'o\,."....\1"'...-...
...~.,..,...."
JOID "'....,...1....~
~I'.... ...1"'" ,''' ...-
""" .I.UIl ,,,, """ (Ot'
~,.,.........
.010 .. .... ,,,... ..... -
tw"-. -.... ~\~...
......-....
.010 0...." 1M..... .........
...,-..caft*'S"t........,
_.
PUGLIESE
..'....
~t.........-.,.,.,.."..
~
~"""" .......~..
~ ~SJ.. _!~~
t
':) ~ei '--".-':'
h~
..".
lftt
Ih
~I\ It j \tl~'
.
COPR. ~ WEST 1999 NO CLAIM TO ORIG. U.3. GOVT. WORKS
31 PA ADC s 62.3
31 Pa. Code S 62.3
PENNSYLVANIA ADMINISTRATIVE CODE
TITLE 31. INSURANCE
PART II. AUTOMOBILE INSURANCE
CHAPTER 62. MOTOR VEHICLE PHYSICAL DAMAGE APPRAISERS
current through supp. 297 (August, 1999)
S 62.3. Applicable standards for appraisal.
(a) The appraisal statement shall adhere to the following form:
(1) An appraisal shall state the name of the insurance
company, the insurance file number, the number of the appraiser's
license and the proper identification number of the vehicle being
inspected.
(2) An appraisal shall be signed by the appraiser before the
appraisal is submitted to the insurer, the consumer or another
involved party.
(3) An appraisal may not maKe use of abbreviations or symbols
to describe work to be done or parts to be repaired or replaced
unless an explanation of the abbreviations and symbols is
included.
(b) The appraisal statement shall contain the following:
(1) Items necessary to return the vehicle to its condition
prior to the damage in question, including, but not necessarily
limited to labor involved; necessary painting or refinishing, and
all sublet work to be done. Furthermore, there shall be a
specification of charges relating to towing, protective care,
custody, storage, depreciation, including but not limited to new
battery and tire replacement, applicable sales tax payable on the
total dollar amount of the appraisal, and all other matters
incidental to repair of the incurred damage.
(~) A clear indication of the cost or dollar amount value of
specified items.
(1) A clear indication of unrelated or old damage.
(4) If there is a date after which an insurer will not be
responsible for a related towing services or storage charges, or
both. and after which the charges will be the responsibility of
the consuaer, the appraisal shall clearly indl~~~e that date.
(C) In the specification of new or used parts, the following
standards shall be used for the appraisal statement:
(1) The operational safety of the motor vehicle dhall be
paramount especially when the parts involved pertain to the drive
train, steering gear, suspension units, brake system or tires.
(2) If used parts are specified in the appraisal, the
appraiser shall have certain knowledge of one or more
relatively convenient locations where the particular used parts
are actually and reasonably available in usable condition
equivalent to or better than the condition of the damaged parts
prior to the accident. The appraiser shall specify the locations
where such used parts are in fact available.
(d) In the appraisal of salvage value, the following standards
shall be used:
(1) If the salvage value of the vehicle being appraised is
known or could reasonably be found out, the appraiser shall
inform the consumer of the salvage value and additional charges
for towing services or storage chargeable against the motor
vehicle as of the date of the appraisal.
(2) For a salvage value listed, the appraiser shall inform the
consumer of name and address of salvage buyer, and the amount and
expiration date of each salvage bid known.
(3) If the ownership and possession of the damaged motor
vehicle is not retained by the owner or his representative, this
subsection dealing with salvage value need not be complied with.
(e) The following standards shall be used regarding the
betterment of the vehicle:
(1) An appraisal for the repair of the motor vehicle will be
made in the amount necessary to return the motor vehicle to its
same condition just prior to the damage in question being
incurred.
(2) If the consumer is insistent upon the use of new parts
rather than repair, or otherwise wishes to repair the motor
vehicle to a condition better than that existing prior to the
damage incurred, the appraisal need only specify the cost of
repairing the vehicle to its condition just prior to the time the
damage was incurred.
(f) The following standards shall be used to determine
replacement value under policy provisions covering the total loss
of a motor vehicle including an uncovered motor vehicle:
(1) If the costs of repair of a motor vehicle exceed its
appralsed value, less salvage value or the motor vehicle canno~
be satisfactorily or reasonably repaired to its condition just
pnor to the damage in question being incurred. the appraised
V.l lue of the loss aha 11 be the replace\llent v.l.lue of the lIlOtor
vehicle.
(2) The replacement value of a motor vehicle shall be
calculated by use of the one of the following methods:
(i) Guide source method . The appraiser shall calculate the
average of two figures reflecting the retail book value of a
vehicle of like kind and condition, as stated in the corrected
edition of the Red Book (National Market Reports, Inc.,
Circulation Department, 300 West Adams Street, Chicago,
Illinois 60606, telephone (800) 671-9907), the NADA Book
(Subscription Department, Post Office Box 7800, Costa Mesa,
California 92628, telephone (800) 622-6232), or any similar
source of information approved by the Commissioner, adjusted for
equipment and mileage, less the cost of repair of damage which
preexisted the accident in question. There may be no other
deductions except for salvage and then only if the owner elects
to retain the vehicle.
(ii) Actual cost method . The appraiser shall determine the
actual cost of purchase of an available motor vehicle of like
kind and quality in condition similar to or better than the motor
vehicle being appraised just prior to the damage in question
being incurred.
(iii) Dealer quotation method . The appraiser shall consult
with dealers or other persons knowledgeable in the field to
secure quotations as to the value of the motor vehicle being
appraised. At least two quotations shall be secured. The figures
thus secured shall be averaged.
(3) If the motor vehicle is listed in any two of the sources
authorized by paragraph (2) (i), including older car publications,
the replacement value shall be calculated by the guide source
method or by the actual cost method, as described in paragraph
(2). If the actual cost method is used, and the owner of the
damaged vehicle shows that the replacement vehicle is not of the
same kind and quality, both calculations referenced in this
paragraph shall be made, and the higher of the values obtained
shall be offered in settlement.
(4) If the motor vehicle is not listed in any two of the
sources authorized by paragraph (2)(i), including older car
publications, or if the vehicle differs materially from the
average vehicle because of factors not considered in guide
sources, for example, antique or classic cars, vehicles no longer
manufactured and unique vehicles, the replacement value shall be
calculated by the actual cost method or by the dealer quotation
method, as described in paragraph (2). If the dealer quotation
method is used, ooth calculations referenced in this paragraph
shall be made. and tt.e nigher of the value5 obtained 5hall be
offered in settlement.
(5) Applicable sales tax on the replacement cost of a motor
vPhicle shall be included ~s p3rt ot the replacement value.
(6) The licensed appraiser's Total Loss Evaluation Report
shall contain the names and addresses of those persons from whom
quotations were secured, the date secured, and whether or not a
similar vehicle was available.
(7) The licensed appraiser's file shall show the method used
to determine the more accurate replacement value in a given
locality.
(8) A copy of the total loss evaluation sheet shall be given
to the consumer by the appraiser or by the insurer within 5
working days after the appraisal is completed. If an offer of
settlement is made before the consumer receives the total loss
evaluation sheet, the consumer shall be verbally advised of the
contents thereof and of his right to receive a copy within 5 days
after its completion.
(g) The general standards of behavior of an appraiser shall
include the following:
(1) Conduct to inspire public confidence by fair and honorable
dealings.
(2) Appraisals of damaged property done without prejudice
against, or favoritism toward, any party involved.
(3) Disregard of attempts of others to influence his judgment
in the interest of the parties involved.
(4) Preparation of an independent appraisal of damage.
(5) Inspection of a vehicle within 6 working days of
assignment to the appraiser unless intervening circumstances (for
example catastrophe, death, failure of the parties to cooperate)
render the inspection impossible.
(6) An appraiser may not receive directly or indirectly a
gratuity or other consideration in connection with his appraisal
services from a person except his employer or, if self-employed,
his customer.
(7) An appraiser may not traffic in automobile salvage if the
salvage is obtained as a result of appraisal services rendered
by him for his own benefit.
(8) An appraiser or his employer may not recommend or require
that repairs be made at a particular place or by a particular
individual.
(9) An appraiser may not have a direct or indirect conflict of
interest in the makinq of an appraisal. This chapter and the act,
and this section in partlcular. shall be strictly interpreted to
protect the lnterest of the consumer .lnd place the burden upon
the appraiser to fully eliminate conflict of inttlrest in the
making of an appraisal. Unless as otherwise specified in this
chapter or act, a licensed appraiser may not attempt to directly
or indirectly coerce, persuade, induce or advise the consumer
that appraised motor vehicle physical damage must be, should be
or could be repaired at a particular location or by a particular
individual or business.
(10) Before an appraiser authorizes the removal of a motor
vehicle from one location to another, the consent of the consumer
shall be obtained.
(i) The need for consent of the consumer may not be necessary
for initial removal of the motor vehicle from the scene of an
accident.
(ii) An appraiser authorizing removal of a motor vehicle to a
salvage yard shall inform the salvor in writing that possession
is merely for safekeeping purposes and that the salvor does not
have an ownership right to themotor vehicle, its parts or
accessories, until a certificate of title is received indicating
that ownership has been transferred.
(11) Personal inspection of damaged property by the appraiser
is required as follows:
(i) An appraiser may not secure or use repair estimates that
have been obtained by the use of photographs, telephone calls or
in a manner other than personal inspection.
(ii) If a damaged motor vehicle is in the custody of a repair
shop, an appraiser may not take photographs of the damaged motor
vehicle until after a legible copy of his appraisal is left with
the repair shop although the appraisal may contain certain open
items.
(12) The responsibility of the appraiser shall include
delivery and explanation of the appraisal as follows:
(i) The appraiser shall provide a legible copy of the
appraisal to the consumer.
(ii) At the request of an involved party or as is otherwise
necessary, the appraiser shall leave a copy of the appraisal with
the selected repair shop. The appraiser shall discuss the
appraisal with the selected repair shop oliner. its authorized
representative or any other parties as is reasonably necessary to
insure that the actual costs of repairs are adequately covered
in the appralsal.
(iil) Upon the unsolicited request of the consuaer. an
appraiser shall provide names and addresses of auto body shops,
garages or repair shops ~ithin a reasonable distance of vhere the
motor vehicle is locatod and where work will be done in accord
, .
,
Page
1
,.
(111
.,
CLAIM# 38-7145-14401
COMPANY
INSURED NEILL
LOSS DATE 01/13/96
INSP DATE 01/16/96
APPRAISER RAY BOND
LICENSE # 3001731
SHOP UNKNOWN
STATE FARl-l MUTUAL INSURANCE COMPANY
HARRISBURG CLAIM OFFICE
115 LIMEKILN ROAD - P.O. BOX 257
NEW CUMBERLAND. PA 17070-0257
(71'lJ 774-9007
CD LOG NO 0000261 DATE 01/16/96
POLICn
CLAIM REP JAMES RAMSEY 774-9074
CLAIMANT
TYPE OF LOSS COLL/FLD
LOCATION MAGAROS AUTO SALES
COMPANY
.,
"
ATTtl OF
NAME ROBERT NEILL
ADDRESS 3617 N 6TH STREET
CITY STATE HARRISBURG
ZIP 17110-1517
PA
PHONE
(717)236-0060
LIC# AVS-0684PA
ENG/COLOR BROWN
VIN IB3BD21COFG269294
MILEAGE 163304
. E=NEW PART EC=QUALITY REPLACEMENT PART
EU=QUALITY RECYCLED PARTS EP=SEE PX REPORT P=CHECK
I=REPAIR/ALIGN/SUBLET L=REFINISH N=ADDITIONAL OPERATION
. TE=PART/PARTIAL REPLACE ET=LABOR/PARTIAL REPLACE
IT=LABOR/PARTIAL REPAIR AA=APPEARANCE ALLOWANCE
. RP=HELATED PRIOR DAMAGE UP=UNRELATED PRIOR DAMAGE
2-A
QRP PARTS AVAILABLE AT NEWBERRYTOWN AUTO PARTS 938-8211
DAMAGE IS MORE SEVERE ESTIMATE CONFIRMS TOTAL LOSS.
LT 3/4 FRT IS TO SECTION AS NEEDED.
19B5 DODGE ARIES 2 DOOR SEDAN
OPTIONS: TINTED WINDSHIELD
POWER STEERING
AUTOHATIC TRANS
OP GDE HC DESCRIPTION
EU 618 07 SE~~ION.3/4 FRONT
L 618 SECTION,3/4 FRONT
2 ITEMS
N1512A/E OPTNS D/GHOPQZ
TINTED SIDE AND BACK GLASS
AIR CONDITIONING
HEATED BACK GLASS
I,
,
MFU. PART NO.
PRICE AJ~ HOURS R
LT uQLTY RECYCLED PART WO. 00. +25
LT REFINISH
l~.O.l
10.2 4
He MESSAGE
07 STRUCT\JRAL PART AS I [lEtrr H'[ ED BY I. CAR
DODGE ARIES 2 DOOR SEDAN
CD LOG NO 0000261
FINAL CALCULATIONS & ENTRIES
GROSS PARTS
OTHER PARTS
MARKUP
PAINT MATERIAL
PARTS TOTAL
TAX ON PARTS & MATERIAL
LABOR
1-SHEET METAL
2-MECH/ELEC
3-FRAME
4-REFINISH
5-PAINT MATERIAL
LABOR TOTAL
TAX ON LABOR
SUBLET REPAIRS
TAX ON SUBLET
TOWING to STORAGE
GROSS TOTAL
LESS: DEDUCTIBLE
RATE
30.00
30.00
32.00
30.00
15.00
Page 2
Date 01/16/96
500.00
125.00
153.00
'778.00
@ 6.000% 46.68
REPLACE HRS REPAIR HRS
12.0 360.00
10.2 306.00
666.00
@ 6.000% 39.96
@ 6.000%
130.00
1,660.64
500.00-
1,160.64
,,,',.:
.., ."'
.~ "; '; .
PXN:YY/OO/OO/OO/OO SEARCH AREA: DAUPHIN COUNTY
DEVICE .76755-003
'ADP AUDAPOINT U ES LOG 0000261 DATE 01/16/96 10:36:26 CD 12/95
Copyrisht. 1994 Automatic Data Processing
'"NOTICE - REPAIRS TO THIS VEHICLE MAY REQUIRE SPECIFIC
WELDING EQUIPMENT AS RECOMMENDED BY THE MANUFACTURER"
ANY SUPPLEMENT TO THIS ESTIMATE MUST BE AUTHORIZED BY A STATE FARM CLAIM
REPRESENTATIVE. FOR ANY QUESTIOtIS, PLEASE CONTACT THE INDICATED CLAIMS
HANDLER. FAILING TO PRESENT THIS ESTIMATE TO A REPAIR GARAGE FOR REPAIR HAY
RESULT IN ADDITIONAL EXPENSE TO YOU.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
;OMPANIES
OFFICE
- ---- -...--.,.
,.~tCe ~ed
.\CO"Jl5Cf'"
sJr".ox;c r,oe:
c...ncr
,.\tXress
t:ll',~\ ;
( -\
Uab Carp
+
...,....,
,
f~i..
\. -,' 'I
WORKSHEET 6-30-95A
O<1ln. er:SS -71
C/R & Phone --"..... .......
(Crde~usecr/y): 200 3" 'J:J, 390 400
Ptone {. , \ I J :J> i I - ('( I J l..'
Plinnssion to 1TlOII8 salvage g-anI8d by:
Naml OBIe
-oj
FrO!
F"codN/JIe<
Varo
",po
.,)
'~~e'~lfC1'a1No, CD i'3J [];] [[] [)J [D ~ [ill [] ~ 5l rB ~ [J [] 0
SIJte;":' Loss Da,e: ,.\ - \. ~ Vehdel:e, II 11" ,'CIJi ,",'I IV, MILEAGE =tl,n" (II ~ enter'TM
.\ \ e.. """ .^ _ . .
Year ,,;>..:.... Make:.... /oIodef: t"""W<' ') Sub M:xleI:
BOOY STYlE; (CI'COO ~ _, ~ '":OR ~rvHalcttlaC:l< Corl'iert.tle Wat:p1 Van Wity
Pd<up 1/2 Ion 4-lon , ton Stcrtb8d l..cr9lEId Crew Cab Cab & Chassis
ENGINE OET All.; SIZE \. \ \-of CYUNOEflS: 3 4-' 5 6 8 12 TurtlO DeseI (iN
.~-r
,.., Il. - \ ~ I
0Iher
Ferder
WB
Fenler10
0":011I1 (0111:I: AU. '!'KAT u.LtJ
)COT 1TTU/T'UX/DlClDa COWD:Dn antD orrrClllJ a.ICnlllItC fOVD/ DIem
:::J C'Oftl'::IR ,UJrf Cl Ala lAG CJ ...,,1lIoCl 0 AX IADtCl CD AU'l'ClGnc: ftU,a.
CJ OCIJ. ,.t.c:"tJIl: u.u IEA1' Ii1 ua ~rrtow1llG Cl a&AI JTU ....0 j!( M/FW u.azo !SI --
:J WCCAGI u.a: Cl A.I.tOl waLl Cl It:otJIG aua wun;x:III Cl CAI.C"I'n 1'.u1 f'U,1D Cl -.. DDOII lDCU
:::J lID SU'!' Cl Cn.t.LI'UJI: '**1 0 Antu..a.a1 rva. T~ Cl COlOACT otic 'l,A'Ia Sl _ ITIIllI>G
....J llICCo:a.u. Cl Ot,."tU C'C~L 0 TU.:t.D111G 'A.atAl:l 0 DIUO,.,., STI:ID J'U. d I'WII '&AT (Duna :
:J :";"Tw"'! IftD.IOa ~ CtP't'CC:D a&Ul 0 liteM ua:: IUCI2T IU::S 0 IUcrJUC """" 0 pVI IIAT ('~' S.
~ :'.:s~ :~D.:e. 0 u..a.nfl::Jt Jun 0 lie&.:. u.a Cl IQC:ALUD: 0 """"''''-
--'
-...:cr 0 S?D::c.. WNL.I/C'I1I 0 C n:r 11 Jrr"C c;u.s J 0 Intwl':'Y STDIIO 11' J. CJ M.URZaL ftUI.~
~ c.zt:':"Uc ;-...ua -.a, 0 TILl' I':TDltc Wl. 0 at.'Wt1lC; eaAES CJ n&. ftDD ITI. 0 '/6 ..1:1:I ftlAI'S.
~ ~'AL ,u.s. 0 wtJ.l WIlL CiIft'II:I CJ ICl""'" 0 11JI.MICK: STDID 0 1/' "aD ftU..
~ !:-~: J':'m. IOCr 0 , ,... Cl ....... ..... WUIU Cl ru:K:t1I S':'DJD 0 ---
AAl't.~ ~ ace, C . IUSIIIl:D C A:.:X::!ftJII~ 0 Inl.In I":'I:IJD Cl _ _ earn
::J UAD Te' IDO, 0 U'unllGD 0 ~Jfta w:u WIZU 0 l.u.uaar: ftDJD CJ CCIOI.C"r .. IIIIDZ. IlJ
:J ~AI. Cit.AJJ MIa, 0 U '~DCa 0 C"J'S':'CN V'IIn::.I 0 c..a ....,.,. Cl ".:;.. TlWlSllZutCf
~ scr: T'C' JiOO, 0 .u.sIlCD U. MG 0 svrva. ~Ult a&AD:S 0 ftACn.. -..
.....
:J T~u.a 11)0' a ftU'T DI':'DaDI'r 0 "''''''' o ...... DWlC..
:J .~ JIX\' 0 "JaIL IIfrQ C'DfI'D 0 SICtAL. CAlltD "G Cl GUA4 4 DOtn
CJ 1:.u..U.~' 11)0' 0 IfUAI W .tD\AI 0 ...,. """" .~. 0 ,.,....
::J c:c.AaI KlO, Cl --,,-- ~ a .-zslOll YU Cl 0._
::J c.uJ.1our .:>>r 0 fOWD: ILUDI __ 0 ......... - -
0 IIJIIa'W'tAaU_' Cl IGAI. &lIl ~I 0 ---
::J ......-. CJ " a_a.
~ 'I":'f'Tt. .."
,..~, 1llClC. ,""D I"UC 1iDoZ. roe. I
...ua ~.
~ ......1":'01I JIDC'
...~,~ ~ PAIOA CAMlGE (II rent. .."I'CfoE1 n-iro ........, S .'^~ 4J ~'..._~ G C'.crdtDl
....t~ ~,...L r~ Add S ~~ S ~'-' s.r..g.
s-r~ f": ... 5"c' . I. Fttrt , AII:ilAl
""JIl w ~ CEIlI..Cnll!.1f ~~ n.... ~ S--~"" 2.Sido 2. SllId Iq .-u
s .,..-../ 3. "-
""JIlw~ one ~'J Add S l~ 'w ,............., 4 loA 0\Iw 3. Sa~
'...........
',-...w" S S~T'UlU 1..a:ssE 'UelJl ~:"'" 9 -fU'
\ TC'V :f n ~ "_0'''''' ""'9W"!'ll N ~ iY'
. .....; ! ~\ <; C t! St~ S I or; " ;:>t'r.:.rv .,.,... I - / :s
fC' ., 'l.
'0
r CU t!Cf'3QII S
'l,uuH"..""
lOIOR VlIlIClIINSIAllllNI SA,. CUNINACI,
'"
u4:fl
'"
A,(u~nl'
ANNUAL
PERCENTAGE RAIE
IhttO'olol,Oultftthln
.,u.I".1t
AlllUU1l1 Fll1illcell
I". .mol,lIIlolr'ld,t ~llh"Jrd
10rauOf":lroulbrh.ll
101,,1 oll'''rltl~lIls
lhf'lmou'll fr,u""hhl.~lu'IJ'll'l,uu
hhtm.dtfl!Hh'dulfdp.,lh'tll'
FINANCE
CHARGE
lh,dlrllll.moultlU"
tlldll.,lI c'J~l!GIl
;la. 9 \
5.. ~,- -J/C,,--'"'
1,/-(.7_).
I _:'3;2(' :n
I
lotlll 5ile Pllee
1""Iol.lco'Iol,oUI pUl(hlilGn
ufdll,mdiidmIJOU'do"nPlr""nl
01' ..:..(~t:_~"'.:._~J_
":"-'_-r.;'G /:/
1 . ~ . ",
y_,.yMIfIlSclltdlllt"lll.
Nt "',,1JIrfftb AIIlOVflIlihj;;"- .~'~;;;niiA;.ij-';
I .<:$..5S'" "".,
S
'....,...:1_______.:..._ _
UtI c..p 11.",."*"",,,,,. ",...flt t""l'lIl'''ltw~ oIlht PlrMfnl.lw:h '" Ilk' '" 'MII-,tI. Ifp,rt'" .llIllrIthI'UII'I IIIMlIO.u".~ 1t'_1lln lIIIPd
SIt """' .. tIl, .'-t "'*Id ':'(1,_ub '- III' tdlM.-I derlllllllln .tIalll llUItW,1Ilffll dttHl. "'1, tl'QUlfN ",'."""1111I'.,11 bot'-t U.. whNulrd d.tt _ pltpf,1lItIIl 'fflllldl JfI4
........... ............
~..r',. ~ Stc,UI, 'OII11'I'IIIII.W(IIlIt,lIlmntIflItlfMlI...lIIlltflnnl,M'ft"'Ift
/. /' ..2.~~j. ,,,,.,..~: Il,CIlI,.,'off.fll'_.......lltthll'Io04l'.fIt"Ill'
tr YOU tIO HOI MUl 'OUR CONIIICf
~ll OBlIGATIONS '00 MI' IOS( IHI IIlOIOR
t-:...." ......f'~ ~./ :r.",./ /~;.ot~'" ,-tJ YflflUfAHDI'ftOPIRIYIHAI'I'OUlIOUGtIf
-.. . -_.._....(,,~ .-- ~________I.... ,..--.. 'WIIHIHJStoHIRAtI,JNl)/ORMOHl'ON
llfJClIlIt Ot.NSIIW1'M'HlASSlGHll
1M Conb.l II bfI..." St4frtnd.... ..
!IrK__" "'... "'"' "'Dr s.. StIlI
.-..n....."'" IlIrs c..trad.. ""-'"
.!!..iiil~ionof Amovntfinlnctd
t:m'"C:I
s!f"'1. .....,--
c.m~PI,lIItnt
---'.L'Cc:&
Met hldt III
lit 1M t.III.ltl
:~w'_A:abeL.L'('<.
-- '
;:;_tf. ,
.7.c
~n5
:h~lIlSI. L~~!..LL-"//I _":':?:(t~_ ~_{ ,n. :'/.""'.('-L:~!!!.~~jL
~ fO:IltutnI
J
Ld/Z-.!-fJ ..
1.-'
""""" -. ........hJf'...1l PlWMn. ~""' H\IS tt>crl"". tolle, It ~ 6., VI ....lti'ftl\lllllr tIl,.,f't1t1I/f>t5 11'I11101 C-'*Kt
lIAOHI:
""'"""Iil",,,
"'--
~-
I
I -S- I
lui...cI..-Slii41 ~eu-....;.-~o;.ftI.-NdlI44i1it
M....."~........Iht....If,..ha...".,,'" ....s.........'offM~OII""'~ 'OII..flantandlt,,~lolf\thIt"',
t~.,","__I""~Mlttllf W{~IIltr:'_'.!!:.!-ttpt""""'."""ttJf 1IIItlIftl_~_~~~____.._".__.__
PIOPlIIf IIWIUCI: 'o. Mar tIIooW.. ",..IItt..p."- rMIIl...." tliIliIIW'4 II-' l8\1.......". te... ,~'" W IpIl~ ~IJ
......tllM.....""'...IfIt.,...1I kI fMCen.t'kt. rw lit "tIIIlWlI 10 """'" tit ~tI'.It""'.lI ""WI~_________
CIlDll NmlUKI tS "I IlQUIIII: CINt4I0tf0 1ffl.1fI1Oll:<! aNI CI"," lMitlQ,1, Imw_. aI. "'" .....""N hi abl_ r~ ....,.... rr<< lit
..... ~,..................It IlIllt1rt 1IHrt000000lWt~ I'INw INlI Urf 11011({ 0.- NUN'dUtll'OIf INSUIWtCt ""...,""""
=c.::- rMlfIlMt~Moc."llI'-":''''~ ...""IIIAIIIIUIL......III__...at AwIllWlJlUDWthntd ......lIlt__.
e,..-& .,.. wtKl-" "trbl bit Iftwr-.r_ WNlII t8IJI ' lit 1li""'I. ,W K!WI(.1 ~ I.Itl$rI-'todrnf' ....." I'N
....cM1..__~____ .J__._ lNl'~ HubImlM__...""liIl."OZS 1C't'. _,_ '""
~-.; a;.;; iibi;,;,;;.;.b-...v...... t,1t ~_~
~"Bv,M III lit..... s......uw.k, .", l Nt__ ""-__
" .... ,........ ...
CIIdlIl... ........ .-. c:wsh S .
IhSftl""il...W11Il!llo.1..tnOl
~'HNI\II""'."lrwbl .
_..
fWlIft'
M\iIl.. ,.....-.
__'ebf
-..
1
~.i_e;.n-...-.-....- ...c.e..l.-ellowrttQ
I ~":M..j,"fIf!AWlflf""!bItIt
(INrlkt""ttullllilIwlQl.-.
.. -..-----.-.-- . ..-......
MMClI: ............. II......... __ ftII ictlIOS I!J "" t.."t. "" ""--'t .. .....!P ... ... Vb.~, .... II (..... ~
."..."....c:.._ .
.!!!J!..
U
......-
Im.~
-
,T'IfI.'
~~J!t
It:..f'
.,,-
-'1-
h'cll"'~~ .~_~_~_"'"
. IIJN'.l~ft7
~ kif '1 Mf_s.. 'lied
... At'. .... '-' Vlo'flIQf
__f-.........-.;.~...\,....~"~~-..._.;,,,.....~.IbI1~....fr,..~ A~,,<<,,", 11_...,.......
QIIIlIl:tt...~......._'*-~......... ~ 16ot1lrt*~~.._flliUwo... ....h..............'''''''...~
.""........~NIlIl...S<<.~........."""'........"'.....-I....wtt'.-....~ !Ilta~_~
'-
W1IIlIlClI1lWlCl alIIrAIlf
ct....... ......""""-..b~'....--.............. ~~"'~"'''''''~N''''''''''''~lIJ .,.,.....-t
...... ...........--.... Qllltrtrl b-............... lit........ S
ct........ .............(:..u.. ~...........- ___.....,. ool....,1IfO'It ......."..... ~.... __ ,..'..~..., ~
_ .QIc.....tII_~ ............-.. ~ If.ot_~ ..........._..""""" _a"'lba~i__""'~ ."'-'<<_ "*'
-
It. ................... .........'.....1;...0><<1
ltJ
,
-L-.
IlIIM~,~"
~f!.!~..
~tftltf'l1(.8alIIlr"
-~I('~.
l.tlNl~IIIU~,
-1_.
!!~-~~~-- ~.
l..MW. le"lf RqWr..
Ly.X____
l..,.ftl
S~-
I, __.~.4-~ /!'!_,~__
S ..2"'. ~.~.
..__L.,:.!_~.{i!,,___
.;~,- "
f.~."_ ._.._.____~^__
S
I, .~._._.__.__
,
._1.-.._
-'-
-y ..
:-;:U,r. y~~
,............. ,r-........
-,.15'~ ;of
,.,.... lc..... I" atl" II: '"
.......,........................
,;:. 'I -'1"-
,"",:"0I1/J8,/
ue' "'.., h.,1 ,...t.' .t
,.."'"
..........WilW..
11 ............-.,.
_tlt........\fMlr.....Il.....
~. ~..,
,.... ...-............_.....~""'l.._..........."....,.... ~....li.... .:~ A(;IIUIt.. I" '~*~".....-.a tI-.. _......, er., .-__....
~ . . "............t....."'*"'-~~..-....~Iof'I~t ~'"""'"....~1l1,........'"___..........,'"""".._....._...
.~............k__,........"______.........tI'.f_ ...... .....,""-.-,.,u,....."...w.Ilot......t "- ....,..
.. . ._.,....,.. ......M.4_....."'IIW....,. \....~,...IIIt~...~...........
..._..................,....... .........*~ ",'*""*""'-'""'''' ~ ......"i.;lll<l'+'~~"'..,. -.....~il....\lfI'II* U.,.~...-...
--...... ~.....e1...... ~.1 .......... _IM~" .,.,...... ,..u.. '" .'...... _... '-\ '" "'-,... \If ~.,\Ii ~-. ~ au.;;....!Ut.....
...".........lliII~.___"~#I~~*IfW-...i11 ~~"'.."<M"'*",.~l\"OI .."". .."
~................~~.It...'"..:J.~...,.~-~~.~... ~.,.,........ 1rDttt..... ""'...~'IOIU 4W\n!fiI~!I'J.llJIl1f\,*"lIl Jltnl'Sl \it4
-.. ___. -,..".....~....... ~r.:o~" """ 4-.".~ ....,1 f,.lE~ lftllAltU ft.'''-Il'-: a...Ut I'" ~\Pllt_l~tllf"l'\lIUIlIlIt: ."'1_
_~,.._~8tJ......~.._. ..all':'.1',;ilf";
"''"''""''..,. _..,.",....... .-....lJ;n"'~ ..% "'........t:.".'... .",.tc...'
1oil1~'1 hl8i1I1R -0010<" Sltli H"srtlltl"'llItlllAtCIi IOOAfi(
1~"tllD W A~ IlAfIl1U'Y,~ IHI UllSl~ACl Y\lU SIGII ~HP II IU
~i!lU HftiM tU,Jti RItJH~
'I'.\'oi ~....; /.. .r,,/ .... to:-..'
.. -- .,1"-'"
~\'-"'''I'( ,..
-..(,,'"
..... ..
".
-,._~
,.-.....,.,. .r"".-
"..' N
.'" -,.J
--
.!t- ';'J\ 1""""
,,~
,'I' ".""~1..".1I ~ltl'IIIl"~H\" ,.....'_'\f" '.... \'-lr\liI'HI1.~"lI"
i\~
"
,\, \ \ .t'1I"!
t.-
j-lt!,
~V~v~"~.n V~ r~A~~~~W8U~Lft
DEPARTMENT' OF TRANSPORTATION
BUREAU OF DRIVER LICENSING
HARRISBURG, PA l7123
09/20/99
DENNIS SHATTO
III LOCUST STREET
HARRISBURG PA 17101
992636051735094 001
CERTIFICATION OF ATTESTATION
I hereby certify that William A. Woodward, Manager,
Receiving Section of the Bureau of Motor Vehicles of the
Pennsylvania Department of Transportation, is the legal
custodian of the Motor Vehicle records of the Pennsylvania
Department of Transportation.
IN TESTIMONY WHEREOF, I HAVE HEREUNTO SET MY BAND AND
SEAL OF THIS DEPARTMENT ON THE ABOVE DATE IN ACCORDANCE WITH
SECTION 6103 OF THE JUDICIAL CODE, TITLE 42, Pa. Consol-
idated Statutes.
i.-
SECRETARY OF TRANSPORTATION
I hereby attest that the document or documents listed
below and attached hereto are full, true and correct
photostatic and/or microfilm copies of documents of which I
have legal custody, and that the copies conform to the re-
quirements of Section 6109 of the Judicial Code.
VINI IB3BD21COFG269294 TITLE I 37251711 MAKE I DODGE YEAR I 1985
APPLICANT MAKE AND ADDRESSI ROBERT NEILL, 3617 N 6TH STREET,
BARRISBORG, PA, 17110.
TlWlSAC'rION TYPEI UASSIGHMENT OF TITLEAHO ASSIGHMENT OF TAG AS
PER A'l"I'AMrI'n MICROFILM COPY OF ORIGINAL.
PROCESS DATE I APRIL 25, 1995.
IN TESTIMONY WBElUX)F, I HAVE BJ:IlEUNTO SET MY HAND AND
SEAL ON THE ABOVE DATE, 1M ACCORDANCE WITH SECTION 6103 or
THE JUDICIAL CODE.
;W:N.-. a .;!'~........(i
','j.
,
,t.:," I.
'.' !:".'.:..,-\;
',.
".
. -'-fln~(jS::.::'" .
t ..... L. 'i:.
",---". '~jyp:. ~r, j '1'.:'... I. .
':~""...'" ~,,~~--~_.
)-"-1'. I ",..._ ~ ~~.,_ "'_"
~":.i^'~t(.t~..~ :"~~_'~. '-; ~-::: _':: ." -___-~
."""1.".. :
it'....T".,.._. .'i, ., ...'::'
. 1iS-'~!i. "';.,\:1 --
'f.. ..
..,," '.,
7.~~1~'; i.~:~
'~r:~',..,'-:..:. I"'" '. ..' _ _..'-::'.'.~~,'.'.
' IT.;\ ~..,.:!!;'''-'~' I'"
,lht..~-.._... ~-:- _.... ...:....._.. _.
/j!J!.f!if/~j' ~''';l,-,-:....L:..:. ~1.....:..:2;:...::_.:.:,._ "
:f-.,:~i[!~.'!~-:}~' 'I ::.~/ ~~~~~~~~==.-_..~~.:~ '-;;-;S/~~;tj= ~
!~~/l:i;~. .. ~,~{':- ~ ,'.
....htt:.....~,~.,' I. ~1lI.M'~_ .t....: .....",..... .,
"I'1~'-':'v ~I I . ~~:."""'.>r...='Y..== ;.~.~:___,:,:.'.-'-.-'-'-',:_C._....",____
:~.}~;;y J~, . .".........~..b.... k..--::, .;,'" ~ "
:;.'r'f';'';'~3);:- ILl! "~.C.~''''''~''''Plt''''frl''':Iil.:.'',,' "':'~ :. .... ..~. /1 .-:':.~__ :-
...\ ~ I '-::.~~- --.. - ".-.----.--. '~.- '-... , _ '.' ,
..;~:~':}':::-;::~'."': I ""'.-' -.,,'" . \0 '\';'\;a - . . I'.".
. .'''" -1' .. . - "'_":-.._,1,; I,. "''':. "'" _ ...., -:,~',~.,...",,... .,..... \'\.\.' "1'.; . I;/"l> .,4'
,;:.:.l.;.._j;:~:_: ;... . _ ~_, l"l-" _ . _,. _ .----........ ~~....--- . .... " I
. .1 ~:,lP, .t .L~: - .. .' . 'J " ...., .;-. .' .,. " . . . r~"::.-....__,_: '~'__.:"'_'~_'~~'-:";'. "
:l'~l:t-': ~,~;';'ll _,,i. ('.,.
1,...,.:\:;.1',...., _~4~ .:.&'/~: .. _,_ ..,
~i~l,r...t.....~.~.-{.I ..... __._.__-1:.:.:.'_~_:\.J
..,~~:-.~~~t:..:.....::.~.'::l -.. . ~._..:-.::~:-_--:----
.. ,~ . .-...--.1,.,.-.....------.----
.~j;,<::.:-::~l c:-, '.:" '':'..:.c._ -i I'~- '::~'=-'''~':''~''--.__. .
,.,\ - , t t I ...... ";.......__,.,._.__ ._'.-_'.,',
:'~~~:~~~i~~;~~; " ,~. -,' -_._-~'/';"'._- , -. ~ _
'~:~:.::>-.":;;II: t.!I,.'.t../: III r:::;:.-..-:r.;.:".,:' .' --:=: _.-: ~-:--:;--=:_
--'... ,'-:;. --- JJ . -. -...,--.t-T_'~ "----,----
. ."J r:.-, .. I, .' .. ;:.-;.-
.'. - -~". "~l aa.. .__L.:~:':!w:.' .
,. '" "'......~ ~_.~ '.:Jc
Ij 1_! . ~--'~<..~~
" .....~!,-='l1l.",...,. ~t;;-
" ,..
_.',. . . ~....'.:"\t:..,;.:..."'=....::.::...~.;:rc:....~.
':' ..1 t..... . . .....~-....: ",,-.' .'Wo. ;",,,::-~:~\r..~~
'.~j~. :~";j i -'~.:.' - ~:
..<>;~; I r::
~:"2;:D\~:J ::.-..:..,-:--..
.'. . ..-L,. I... '
.-:::',' .>:-~ ---_...._._~ -.. ... ".-..
)'\<';.''''':'''I'~ .. .. ";'/ -:'. J.::Zi-:-:.-.:_-..,,__'r..-._..,..,
.~ I . . ___ _.......:J..,,,_._~ _ _ . _
\.. .....: ..:. 'J I -:-~.: . .
1- . ,. - -...., ,. t". . ..,.. .i
. '-!':;'-~~;:~; I !. .'\~..~. .f-.-.. l .-r!~J;.~' t
" -) . ....;, ~I'.' .' ~.j~.ll';.. ;::~::'~...~~,I --
~ \'~:\-~\1"',..'~ri ~I ~-..:..._. ' ._....-__
.~'~.n;I.I;1 . .'
",-".':l~.1 !'!t!.=,,;" ::'l.;, !n:....II.lI..~H.;.1.;. "'--;II",~;~~
,.;',' ..,~,.w ~J
, ..;..!
f. '. .
\.. '. ".~. j'
"..' .....
.,-"~:I __ .
., :\. ~.~ - _._---
'i'.' 'H .. .
I ~ - .---.-
r- -.--.-0..- -~-
i. .
ILi
., . '0;'
!'-
...----- ---.-,....- -.-
-----.-------
'.."~ ........ I
........,., .....,..
..'.--.-----
, ~ ._;- :-:-=-:.--,..:.:;.' "'"
...'.......
;~"70:.U~.U3 ,..,.AA~!S~:.JR~ Fi'-l:=
- '" l-L"-";':''''':7:"=:\~L;'-;-;-;:;':---II' ".--
. -..J 001 .""'...-....t.,_ry___.-2..:.y.........__
' . ../.-.;..-,c;....,....- -,. ~,,:"...
. .~... ~......._~tol~-.:..::'I'
'--.---~--.-..- ----.---------...
------. ---...-- ~_;;.:'c:.:k.~~,~
...,' ":'-',. I/.
"--~ .;...Z"__..;7......:...!:..~ ..":":1";;':-'
".:'
. -~__.....r_
f~ --
._<~..~..- .~:'::'. :::::=-'
--
....---------.
_-r""...;.:,;'~,-.;'-....1"~~..;.......,_-~~..
," ..' ".. I
~----/~_:~-./....;..:.."="~~--
--'-------_._----~ -
- -- ~'......~..~'....._._--+-'=--.:.~~.-
..... r' ___ ~ .... _~_~.... ~.~ _.__.___
.. . :'..,:; ,.-......
~-_... -- --------
-'~~ :"..~ --_"~.~:~~~~-~",
------.--
..' -., .. ~ ,+' .. .' - t'
-=-,~_L'...i.:2<:~... ..~._,;....
t. ~----,
I) ___ ~
~r;'
~ .. .~.
.",.,..,. "r.../ /"'..,........
-~~~4~
I
I
lILu
.------
--.
I
\
,
..~.:.....-
.
,
-..
-1
I
__...:--'-'-'...t..:___---,
,
,
:..'!'--------i
-_.__._--~..._----~
.~
'. . ;
\ w .
~:..I:.:y
..~~---:---- ----
11
r-=-~ ,_ ~..
............ _I....
~
--._.~---_._..--
-J
--..-----
,(: " ~r~j1I~Cft:-t..:...t:: ...~! ."') :..~.J:.&: ~t~~:lI:'" ~~'''~''U.
,_.
...
..."
"i",.
~... ~. -., ~',~"'-
, .
.....,...
,
..
,
~
;
.. ,.
.. L
" , .' ~
..
.
!.
,.
.
. ,
t..
,
I
I
,
I
,
I
,
. I
. r
"
, L
.. i
.
.:
".'''
"
.'
,-
/
I
I
t
I
....
'":..:=-
, .- ,-'"
I- 'e.""
or ;; I1!!J ~3':' ~ ~
.. . Cl.IJ !'
U ..
.' ~ctl -0;: 0 .... '"
0 .: : I "'.1 I , .x w
0 y, "'''' '"
" U _..J a:
'" ~:> ;;; %0 w
"'
'J u w.., f." z ... '"
.. ::: .. j 11::> ... w
" "'''' '" a:
% ~'?i -, ... on a
w
.. e ~.D.. l on ...
, i:. z ::li 2 =,~ "
_ 0 '"
~- :J "' u :!!on ,. "'1"'" ::l
:-'-" ,. ..
i ii ..J .. "'00 ... t ':>r w
;;; iii ~ o , on .... .. :I
~. x 0 0100 .. i 2 Z ... ~
0 :< '" ~o .. 0# X
:> , .
,..'1:' Go 0 .. .. I 0 t ..J ... '"
J~~: .. .. :':z ... 1Il ..
"' :> c ... II:
II: U ..C '" ... to!~ ~
;S '" ,~ ::;.. .. ...
..J Z .. .. ~ Do>... !
~.": oJ ... C >< ..
~ :> "'
.It." : .. OJ ..
.. :> a: .. ....c
~;<' .. 2 ii: WI 1Il "''''0. N
'" :I 2 ... ... ..
~";.." S! '" co ""'"'' ...
~'. . II: II:
'" '" 0( '" ... 0.... ...
.,~ ~ ... .. "" .... .....:>
~L:. . .. .. OJ I '"
~ t- .. ::c,.. .z'"
.. < &:t:lo oJ - w
Z .. .. :'):1 -c ........ ~! J
w .. ..
\:'. Go ::::> , -.... J8ll:
DB "'1'\ ..........
" "i~ Z"'2.- r!i:
.
""go" =: .. ... r~;f; - I
. ..
c .. .. z
. ~ . . ... ... : i ; '~l~ t
0 co ...
u '" 'n ~ t,,~ '. ..
,- licp .. !Oz:-.
.. ~!l' ~ Hr aH
..
.' :J f,f'"' l lioi:
ii .;.-::1 a"g :.-~:i
-0 ..
~I< ~- ; - ~~ .. :..1_ :10
,t~ ~ -'" nat.' '1.... r' !:;I<
~u " .., "
t .. ;., "-f6 '1'.. r. ~ :;15
' .,.
..- '1:.... ~ ... '1 io:!) a.
wo _ 0::" ' .- 0",
=- ....- F. ~Q on - ~x
.. .::':1: lo_ -....
,- ...'" !~- .. ..-
,,:r'~C .. n! iot':o .. u"
n~ ...
-;';.85 ~ ...:-. .,!!. ~ g~
,,~ ~. l it -- r",~&
'. "'!; t;;!] - in E ~:; f~!~ ~~
.- .,..
- '" c..!.to U ,..4.r n;.-li we
.0 ~ jf- 1r0
,,;; lir~ i ~P':: !';...
..~ ~ ,"
Bu i 1ff u' ~ .~ U~
.," Go '
..Z >'0<1 lrO
.. \'lIt' ~ 'J 1:! '" ~.r.
01< 0." ~ .. 1,.- . "...
",:,!:a lilt; ., 0"
z:> 'I ... l ~ \.
- .. .. I k U uH.. > "
0_ ~!l"- l 3'" " ,,,lit ...
11::: -.. - .. ~ \-J. . ..
- e.. ~ -. - I;'t~ - ,- "'x
... ~~!~ S a~. . .., ~..
... .."tn
Ie 1l!I.' I: :rs _..~ . .
.''''\ -'~' :;.. It~'li
r-o.,) >-a 1~\1l ~n"
1J)_~!'L!'''''!l'~' -!:.
.. ,
fllt/uti'MIII"
MOTOI VEHICLE INSTAllMINI SA" CONIIACI.
....
liflt,J
"
ANNUAL
PERCENIAGE RAIE
lt1ttO\lol,OItl(ltdtln
I,..rlfllll
AlIluun!'lIldI1Cel!
Ih"IT14lJllIOlr'fIMp'o.'l!td
IO,I,I11Offt:/,ou,bt","
FINANCE
CHARGE
IlItdo!lll.lIIOIlflllll,
(litdll.~l t1~' 10\1
JolJj 01 PJymel1l$
'hfolfl'iOl,lflllnl,l'"llhh'Il.~I.lI" ,QU
Ilhem'de'~I~tItd\llrdp.,lIl'1l1'
;l(), 9 ,.
5": y.-
-J / r;.,.- ...
1/-0/_),
:3 7,7-[: :-1"
I
,,,,,,,,MflltSc~"be
No"'.,1IlIIIh lMIUfIt"',,~
I . 55"'
I
.,..or,"
WfIp',,-.nll AI, Out
1Itnl1ll"btt-.
AUOllnl'
lolal Sale Pllce
1"'IDI"to~lal,aur pu'chu.OfI
tIld4.mthlllllllrallldownp,lJtlItnl
. LO 7,J
111$",'( rr.
/"~~"f7n /.:/
$ . ... (- ...-.
1'.~1
SIC""" ,.. It. l"IIl.' Sf(",,"IlIt"t$l..lht........,... bttrraputuated
"'JI,IltIll: II pOlt",1l1""',rIIl..""-"Ie"",."""
f~'
...../~"l-
'''''ttt:'
LIltQa,p:' ,,.,...,,Wt. ,....... tlUlltll1\;"IMPIl""''' thI p',1lIIIIt .hdlllltttilr .<<ItlItIIIllh.II PM''''''''''"' II'''" ItItA IOdlf1.ht.,flllIllllWflPlld
SIt ... .... Ill, 11M t.Illd ,.1IIIltflU '" tn, lddIIlaNl...lRtl.II\ tbowllllnP'JIIWl tiff_ III' 'tQIIIN "IN,"""' Ill'''' btIIf, U. ....... dllt ..... plflNflIIMl'....... ....
........ ..........
If TOU DO NOI MUI TOUl tONlllCI
- . ~! I OIUCAIIONS 'OU It..o 10Sl1N( MO'OI
Z. t::.,,;~t1 ......" ./ J;....../ /~.,r:~<.. ....tf vr..'CUAMDP9IOPlltlTtHAlrou.ol....n
';",mc_n-- ---~,\ ..-----~-----.'J,Ceot..- ':~~~::::~?'lOt(rOll
- '" I. / 1""c.nutct......SrIIf.....,...
(.l' ..J,"'/~~.,' ':/L.-L.<iLZ~,fJ . "".............._..__
AiN'"*" III tGlMt" ........... '-ad.......
If'mlllftono; Amount riMAe"
W'"c,
I .:r~ .....,- -
""--
I~
MIl "..t/I
I
1.w.."fW,..... ",
, /'"a,
.... CasIt rru IIitIu
....a~.
I. """ -.__ c.,..,
I
l.f'lIIIkOl'llNl!"
\1:11III. ,"'...............
I Y7
l...f.
, ~-.
......c.....
:~WI. ~/~d/!. ;;;.~,
- .
, U,,// '-,'/-/.7 ,t'
,...... ,JI
..aunItSI. L~'L!." ,
--
UtNI.__...._ h"'_uctl,,1MlW\ ltp.llalfol,.... ~.I'IJII" '\V1lI1 dllt _,1/01I" 1Ief'lIIIIl III l(I~h III "'" CoIlll.ad
lUOI.11
,..Itttt"~1l
........--
~-
I . -I' .1
r........ s.", "..4"'II'I~o-a Nttl,.lft
.'~"........IIII....d.,..""'h.d'" IfltStleJ..", ...""'........IflJOllbrhtll 'OU..f1J11taMltpfnenllll1thttlflJ
".... ""........~ 1IltlIMtII1llt.... '0<<.., ......nt. h<...." """ IIMt 15 DIf..... .,.. O-a.
","In 11SVlAlCl: T..... <'-"11I..._............ """'1IltI" *-d..-st "',. d.Mqp II "" YfIIc1t....,... ~t,
............... ...""'tllht VtfIlI.It ... ""'**<<t. loti'" ,,~ 101llWf.... Vtfotll'lnlI.,ot "Wltd
CIlDtl IISUIQCI II 10' lIQUIUO: CttdIt I." ~_. fl'lII Clfldlt ~ 1IIwI~ to, "'" .....f'd '" *- f,",1 ..... .. .... bI
~ flIllm,............... 'If" ....,lM Idlhl-.t mil" Ptmt f'M1ItI NIJIIlf.,Of PlWl'UYO UIIOlIIltSUtWltl_IIlt~1t
WI: 'f.., _1lIA",**. """, ..... JIIIIIbI MtAIJIWM............... :1:UlflWMt, ,.c.... "llItw "" ~ II
....... .
.,.....,...., "'-""'l'" la\lIIlil\:t, .~..t'*' 8t"4""JOll~1 ClNl Auodenl & WIWilIl,oul
....~I "",__,,,,, ltulJtllllul.......fllC.~_'__~.___~__ .'_'NlI
.....i.,.."..-.."'s...-~l.....w_.
~ti.....__.. ~'"*"<"""'HNIh lIW-e
1y1llfWll.,......wtIct....
~ lilt.............,
It -.... ,........_CIftM
tcodrfII& HuIlt.........l.aI__._ ~
... ..
-..'
....... -
"'.' II.
-
I_~____--_.
,--~----_...- -
............IIIywtIt........ c,. birr..........
1 _.. _, __ t _
~"afllolllhIN...,."..fII.. J\o;III
UIlIlI:k~&.......1IQ
..... . .-..------
ftIICU: ,..........It ........_ ~ ......... II ""' C....l a-. ....". .... .-k!JI ..... ~ ",'" ~ ~ ..~.... ....
~....c..1Ct .
.!!!!!..
U
,...... ..,
/fTf" ~ I"'"
~
~f'
.. ,..
'T
1,..'1_'-"'" s....~
IIJ]iij.~'it1
l...... k'l _" ..I..... _Ss.. '*""__._..______
.. 101: ,. .'11I1., ..,.ao,.,
&SSICIU .........,~~.;;....~.-..~~-_.""'... ..~.... au.,.... _....."""
0-.. ".. '--at...." CWat...... ~ .... ""'- -.. '"'" ~............... "'"... ""~ ..,.,.,..........
,,!ltISIIIt ...c..at ...... s....,.................." taII..~., 1ht~ ,.. ~""*'''
1I[1IAlI:t F1lWI:I aIIIfMY
Cf.-llCIIt '"'........h(.s....I~~..-"""".... ..,torforo......;A~I>ol....~I.w "Ilk" WlM
.........................c..Jt1 tt.................. ...........
tt..... "'" ........... ..t:.O"", SR~",__ __..-", ''M~ .......,.....""'-1Ir......._ ....'~......,......
-..c..o-to\tl_~.. ............~...'-~"''''l'c'~.....IIfbpc''"''III~\~..!"''1f~ f'l~",...
-
"_ "'lIr..............__JIII1.....~.,
-
..
7"
\
It .~...~.. _' ....
, ,71". ;0,'
N-_ '.,:!_'~_/~!
, ;t.,~"
\
I.
I,
-,-
I 'S."
I_a... t'''r
'-',217
.......'-'-If.........
I J'3"~ ",,-
..,.... k..... . ,.. 11''' ....,
.ld..~'...tf,........
,:. 'I -.--
_.I/~/r
tit" ,., . ".,1 ......f "
, 'fltltnl
...........lIt......
I' .......,.........
....................,....-
~ ---- --~.-..
~ii",:.t;.-..-.,,-.;.1IlI-_-'*SM..;,.....1!lrt ........-..;~... '....-~(...it ""1"'1 Ie ..."".s....-.......,._.. Pf'<.....-p....
...................-..... '--" '_H fIof!I"""~ .....- '-..... --.." '~.................... (-_. -... . -............. ""........ ... II 1:
.~.""'''''''k''''''' ,.""....".............-. ......__ (i'..... .....,_, ,...__Ir....~........_..... ........ ......t\ ..
.........~,...._,..........I1lttt."'""........""'.,........._.....
."Nr\.......""t~..... ,,,....."'tIil..~-..,,... hi_ ~~...fII_~"""""'''''-'''' '..._*"".".-.
........... ...~...=-..t '-...........1........... a,....-,.....,,.! ---=:... __.._,."", ......~ ..~~,...................
.. .,.-.................~ ,""..\Irairt.tu+---'.~....1It :....."..............,.. _
CIa(1........... ~c.r..1.1Ii"~1. ........."""""''''''....... 11hl..... UltfM'tf..' ...tIItOf'JIIt, I~ tt""l.' tl~lIli.!tllJlf IHt ...... \Ill
II.... ~ .8II~. .....~ '" _ ....._....,.,...~ ~ .~_ ottI:tAlttlll''"11Ml It_UI ~ l\JIII",'~""".\III1Ml'eg!ltt_
............................ ....Il"i \~'li\
..........-.. -...."'....P;,,\liIIIlo..~....~It,.~._..~"l.#>f...1
"'\lit! hJ Rl" I ij -- UO!l<" \~;lI ""S nllll~AlIlIl8\A... 'IQ\/ ARf
I~"'I( 0 ""~ (...111'" '" It<! UlIITMACI rou SIQI ~II' II 10
PiWHU hlliH ll~i RRtHI:)
.'
~\d..,/ ~; "5r'/ ; '"' ..,~,
--~.-~ --"--'.-..,1
'Y -- ;,_.--.
tHfI/'< /
..:....(!.
>
Ca....
--~
.!t. .i"
.'''-
..,''1_
1'1.1 "10."'11 1 "I _11.11 ..,... 1,11!;1 ",,1,. I 1;/'.. "" "III
In..'"'lI-.... 41 ."""'0(:1
/
.. \.
.\"io....,
-
;..Hi:
~,~
MV-4ST 18/93' II TAX """!'~:"'1Il' /I,,<;,l;:t,..,
.
i
.
~
A. :v. llTU. ~.UMBE.FlI"..'i ~HUWN U'j AT TACt.( 0 TITlt., IlMo~'l. ~'~~~.'~
=; !-~"'''-.I7,'//,,,,, ... /)/;/ ,,~~':.;.
~~ :\lE,.r.;lf lOfNTIfICATlONNUU9E1-I ICLIol....llUN .,..
'rll'/".""n.0'7/r.._~L"'t7~~4 o ',f)()f) 41'fAI~
LA:JI '-lAME.,~ fUlL. bU~4:~ NAMl;j fRiT NAMI;
.-,. 1 f
.--: ._. /7'" ~.'. .;,'
CU-M.Llfa-'
B.
"'-:/.:", ;~..
_, .~'c..
PI.!""."":.l ,
PR,((; ! - '/~(-. -
1~""'.ll."tl'_'''''1 I .
-
l[S5 I ,
o POOR 'FlAD(1N . .
Mll..IOl.i.INITIAi.. '......Bl[
~
AMOUNT <....r#-. .
.
;
I
I <i.... f.u D:.
.tl't06ls..tr... :-'"
'~"'IOll~AM ~/1t; .~V .
..s..lUI~__' ,-y"
~=: .....: :.... : .~.~
... ,.. '"~~:-ri~~":
. 1 '\o-:"'''f',Ior~' '
1'. ~~... ".". '~1'1';.11 ,.. _ "-loll
P'"..~.._./C...,.... ..,tr _: ~... ..._... .: ~~
c.
w.. ":i/;~i "/_ss 7l ;'c ~;sr.....,
co. A
I
T_F.
MlOOlf. NTW.
DATE ACQUIRED'
~9<'"
Ii
STAlfT
~/..17 AI l~ '\;-
CITYM
.
D. lA5T NAME tOA Fl.I..L IIJSIES$ frWIIEl
IroCIDLE NllM. DM'E ~DI
"""""""D
J{'"' .-
~.
=: 2l/. .
~r~"~ l;~.a~~'i
.... ..~.~1i!~.4
-....
.. f..
-..""'"
.
SWE
~
" too(
I -'7 .n"
IIt~HO
,,- !l?1
'-
f..
fRlf_
i .
i I
i
co.NlCHA&A
STRUT
..
.
CITY
s..1t
" COlJ(
IfElfPHUNE NO
, I
''''- ...
E.
lrMKl Of VEHlCU
'-'"
YEHlCU IJEHTlF&UIJN.......R
..
n MOOU ....
IIIOO't TY.PE ICP Tk.ETCI
I'UJOoOII....
oc.ooo
-
...
-~
Of'"
n""""
F.
................ ~
o PLAT( TO BE ISSlIO BY
8lJP(~ IPROOf OF ...
SLfW<<:[ MUST. AT.
_.,
o E~purtTOBi.
I ~ ~D flY BlfV,U
~~~~Pl..A1"(
I ~D 8Y FlU AGENT
.... ()w
~~
n.."....
ro..._
;,;;,;,-; """"'
I
~-S~
-.' ~: . ""f:....~~:t1: -. ~ do
.4!t:r./14.fwL~
...~......1'Ulb<r .
o T'fUHSFEN OF PAEW.lU5lY ISSW.D PlATE
o TRANSFER. REP€'M&. c:s Pu.TE
o fMNSftA. A(f"lAC(",HT Of JUTE
O II 11GRNC>T'Ow'
tRANSFtfil C# PLATE I REP\..Jl(.(liEJ(T Of !.TICkEA 'a:,;'.. 101
.....-:..I_..-J(~.I1. . ........'OAAEI'UlClM<.,
.... -.~. OUllT 0 OlfW;;LD
(I=,S __ O~~~~~~~E:lrhk1O.~
~5fERAED fAUM TlTU -.J - WI
Ii
(I
=~"lf"1S~~,;';:":>QII'tJt. IRELA~ro"""'lCAHT
''EFlf.IfOltl\lIHflAh''''''''''''U.>>iT'. 1
.l.HU!flURl.~O.......IIWM HtQ.AfliiAJS,Swl HEiJAl:GtAJ.SSt;Oll.8
,~f~g~[, ". ~l(W) .T i. a.Pf'U:.MLf1
i~ft.:~'~ IPlJ"C"-flIl.l'OR _' . _ . . "'-"'t""'(FffC~_ _ ;pr:''-'..''f.ll~I"""
!_<;.,. ~. Al.....H""""HIS71-'-/.?f.,J;t7.n"'i"'" j.q.g< ;""0_-7,':..-
['''-:'lft,j IIC[R"fW'l' r....'l.:fol.....''''.__........:r,.._._ DAy .,a.--'._YEAA _ <"'-_IJSSUN::i.lrlj["'~I""'~I__ ,.tr.:.E""trU
~~';P~T ''"'IAIIflH(-CllfO'.~~C'f.,~.~I!HI_'t-l:...:E~~HD~ -l~"'l.:.,./_..../ ~_~ ~ :...- / "',....::-4I'~1
,hfC-R- i GSLEOf[..-IfWf'I'RtlJ51IUfll'INT;..,'.....8U.'f.~'... T~""""'f~T\JAf jTW.~1iIIU
;-......rON t ~~=~~~~il~~~PAr.,,~,.I ~I-€YU<<:U;';(u ~ ;, Ynltt"d.-./ 'AI'
G.
"lit! \.l..'lJy '......, i ..... .......-t ~ _""""* l' UoItl ..........~) T......"., """ AflI:R.rs, u....... U" "Ill ......u ".-1'" . ,'.-"lWII1,'ltrf l.iIVf~ l..'" '.....;t .toNO i..,.)H"*;.1 . ....... i .flwlP!ll....
.', Il"""'D ... 1l\A(........qQ I, R'f)<f:R \ f Q~If.'> 'hAT..,. "'~ ...; ..1'....lHlLtO 'U ~4."'" 1~ (;.ft,lPT'l.... ; M ..(~...'WU~ '."" , *f....., ,.:::st "'" 'I..oR CI'{'lA.T""'i
."'Q.I\,t;-:;.(;c" ,'!R ..t,.'lf r.,..>l.."if'ta'lO;....'-:" '('oR 1..1_'" T,) ...-..'.... f~WIlt "*~..........If, '-* '.ot ,uRA(,.,I~. RtlJ6!lqf-D '.1.t<ll(ll _.R """ r'f"-'O {"
:~("~!lUl''''''' Wf ............lWI.H"~ ~I...' . ~ ~Y ~ -....4l.jh1 ro _ fp.;f -.u' (ltt.U~ '!:!-;\1;'! AN[l"~"""",,, ..:1 "<<}' --...... .h...... T'M.:)'(A.HS lvA...,...
'..'.;f<rt.'f~!--'..~t"yl.....'..':!'.~ _. _.
'''IT ~'~~":~.'~ -.~ ~?--- ~"~~:_~e-l ~- . . t:~:..-~ ~
""""."'01 t-- ~ .. . - __~__.__..;.L~ __ ,..~_.'"._
.......: ~ '''c..~_ ".'~'~"<.l..s'.,.. ::3.y_""'-'
5
.
W
.
;
~
tiy--'.... ,;---"'., ~ "-' .. ................ '....
.).-~:...,
"'fi.\
a.",".t.J\t
",..,
i
.-..--- ---.----....-- .._._.~----
.~~~\..-
I- ,,--- .----.--.-. '--. ........-....
~ ,. ,.. .~~ '--... ........".... "....
...------..-....-.--.--..-
H
.. ~ ........- ,,,,,-,.. lot '... '......, ut.; ,,~.:..., .,1 '.> .~:_'l~ ....hol ;...,.. ,... ,# .,-it.. t"lt.c'.J\.:.l. ~ .... ~,~.". ,>..~ ...tiJ ,t ,..."'" ut. ';'.;oi..<t" ....
~":'!o.~~.~:~.~ . .'Ir,,~ ~....__._ ._____.. _ .'_ . ___._._ .. .... _,__.. ...__...._. '. _ . __ -. _-: . .~.__~__,~___. __~_.____.______ ._,,_______._
,A _' .!(,:'lffIIo! 'l~~ ""'!'H~~:~!f '',l..,~1\,,:.,;~it'' -l~utA!~"i.'f" ,-N \_~....-q ~'!1..f \u"' Tn SI.Jf\-1W<<:iC~q
; n ~: ~,[~TS f4CCWUJftt - i.:)NC€J,fH l..:f c....c.oo~q,...~tF4SJ <::# It.ct:.A;-.co (>>t<<R ~s mHS(Yl~R."RS ~lStl.l(
~"')T[ :f H€ \-{H(LI: is &if\.k.i L!A..,,)(O (j;((:K 'HIS AlL":' C If Rli."\.:A 1:3 CHECKED Li.:..,..ETE AN) &f"tJ(;Hh~'" ii
'....~.................... MlSSlIllIGI"~'"
..-. foit 4W' ... ,;atlUlit~!"l
.
'-I'
1<
ri
J Apftt!CI,.T""il"Pt., . r...,.o.'1,..,. RtG15r~Ar'f''''I\ALJOf()~''{)O'''.~;
::::'::.',
;::;;:.
.::,.
...
USED VEHICLE ORDER
DEALER:
"
,
DATE
i .,- /:
-
-
. ,
19 .2..::-
.
,
.c
"" r
,~
',' :
;
PURCHASER:
ADDRESS: -..,
. '-
.'"
.,. ,;I. ~t
, ,
.;/ /'. /1
-
~'
'.. . - ""
" -'
,...
,..-
r.
~ , ,
PHON""- ','
7~1,r-:
,
EHlER MY ORDER FOR ONE
STATE ,-(..
o CAR 0 TRUCK OR
Z ,-, "I'
IP -. , _'
AS FOLLOWS:
CITY: ~"--f'
,
YEAR MAKE
19 j:" 17.~ ~
,~...""
~,. .,' ,~:?'
OIOOEL
,'1
...... ,.
....... NO
II"....')}.,. ,/'-' ,
T .,....f__ ..)-
800'
UC.HP
COUl"
STOCK NO
"
S .. .. TOTAL PURCHASE PRICE S-:-- :t)
DEPOSIT ,f?,
, ... USED CAR AlLOWoIHCE S
LESS UEN S
" HELD BY
. , EaUITY
, CASH ON OEUVERY
r
CAR SAlES PRICE
OEU\IERY & HANOUNG
TAX
FlUNG
uc:. PlATES '
-.
"
The lI'lformatlOO you see an "". Wfndow form tor thtt
..ehICMt 1$ paf1 of thIS contract tntormatton an the
wU'lOOW form o~emdes any contrary prtNtSIOM k)
me contr ac1 of sale
TOTAL PUAClIASl PlIICE
1100..
olS .ac" 1~ -""'"
lIL>O'f UllOA
.,
'"" HP
Conract III be
-.
"
fIT\.E!r'IO
S1'OC" NO
l~
1",,,*,,,,,~~1rlIhouI""'t9~"" 'qJI'HMdOtIft'lC*ellD.-I\taQUtlt'Othll~
~.s..-
--.---.-. ---,-.--.
~ WIN..,................. .r(' ,r-y...~Dl'\. =..-rr..........GllOIftI
. LD WITH ..., '*" uIMI f()IIMr ~ ,-;:- ..", 1W'd....... ... .-.... ~........ =-."....
W'& ftft &UTV .......- .......".ft'lUltoe~ M"ICt.,..OI ~....,..".,.",_~n.,..;
",IWV'A' t. __ dD nail............ ~- 11IM cu:t. .... Of '..
--~
0..., s..~. -'~---
'...........-.......flllI04.. ........... ...""'~.........,....~... ..1....._......
~NCM"OJ &C(JilIIlIi\flIC~OJ TMS~QfIlfHlD&tt ~JoIOVf: '"'-.......-..,--_..-.~~
_.........tfIlI...(~.......-...'-.......... __.....-c.IIIl.~..tuOIIICI.~~._...............~
....................... ,.. __.......,........ lit _ ~........."...... ...... Nt'" !11IM ~......
I .... . ItUII:J ......"
_.s.-w.'-:
-
"_55....
--.
,.... OR_ ,. N01' waUO utAA" ....... ..- ACes..,... .. D8A~"
. ~ - .,"
,
-_It
~..~~
'-
.J;~,.~,._..._..-
.~
/"
r .
.
CRR~r~tcA~B OY RWRVIC.
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have served a true and correct
copy ot the foregoing document upon all counsel and part i.. of
record this -'~~day of ~. , 1998, by plaoing
the same in the United states First Class Mail, postage prepaid,
at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed as follows:
,
Dennis Shatto, Esquire
Cleckner and Fearen
31 North second street
Post Office Box 11847
HarriSburg, PA 17108-1847
r-~Y' <:U.-r-.
Debora L. Hua
- - .
r' .
;,.. r" - ,.. .,.
. .
. .
. ..
.~
\ .
-0
..........
,
~-
.......
~
-0 ~
'd---.:)~ f'
-...> ~ ~ i
"-' '-
d ~\1J
.;.
"
t..'-
.
.-
....
FilE COpy
LA II' OFFICES
FLOWER. "'LOWER & LINDSAY
A PROFESSIONAL CORPORA nON
II EAST HIGH STREET
CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA 1701),)016
JAMES D. FLOWER
JAMES D. FLOWER. JR.
CAROL). LINDSAY
(717) 24H5IJ
FAX, (717) 24J.6510
I'FI.EsqOaoI.com
June 8, 1999
Curtis R. Long, Prothonotary
Cumberland County Court House
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle, PA 17013
RE: NEILL Y. PHELABAUM
NO. 96-6705 CML TERM
Dear Curt:
In response to your inquiry conceming the status of the above referenced case, enclosed
please find a copy of a letter from Dennis J. Shatto. Esquire, rescheduling the arbitration
hearing for August 3, 1999.
Very truly yours,
FLOWER, FLOWER & LINDSAY
James D. Flower, Jr.
JOF Jr.n1m
I:ildi:lMn
CLECKNER AND FEAREN
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
DENNIS J. SHAnD
ANN E. RHOADS
111 LOCUST STREET
P,O. BOX 11847
HARRISBURG. PENNSYLVANIA 17108.1847
June 3, 1999
James D. Flower, Jr., Esquire, Chairman
11 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Re: Neill v. PhelabalDll
Docket No. 96-6705 Civil Term
Dear Mr. Flower:
DF COUNSEl
RICHARD W. CLECKNER
WIUlAM FEAREN
ROSERT D. HANSON
TtLEPHONE
17171235-1731
FAX
17171235-848'
This will confirm that the arbitration hearing in the above-
referenced matter has been rescheduled for Tuesday, August 3, 1999
at 9:00 a.m. in the Second Floor Hearing Room of the CUmberland
County Courthouse.
Very truly yours,
CLB~ClCNBAND FEAREN
/ jJ,I..lLIJ/
Denni .~tto
DJS : lnm
cc: Mr, Richard Pierce, Court Administrator
Barry A. Itronthal, Esquire
Johnna Deily, hqu1re
Meli... Greevy, Esquire
Hi- i: 1 f'j'
\.. .\-,r ~;t_\: l'f,'!",-~'" 'Ul" f
f:,11I"'lt"';._iNw~...\1. fif LIt' ';".~'PL' 'I! \,' :\N-::";
l.:! I~ IN ry I~'" !_:UM r-\Er~LA Ni.l
w:
"
".
:,!lj..'!,',.,!,
~ .;
,
"
Lu..!::LA~~_A ~~;!-.:!~i;.,!~ N ; :..,~ f:L__
"
.
l. ~\i.
~~,3'f. .;,...
~ : : i.:,; ",:"'; .
L.: r;. f f. wr
"~___1.:r~:_~,~~_1~1_tt~ e_,_"
3'i....~.
. _ w;...~
-. 31.0 un~b .0' ..
j. .-, .~~.~' ",.::9:
~ !"
A}: f:~:,:':. . - ~: " .. ...
c
.:=t,.. ~ "4 ~:' 1'~ .
~""C'; '?I."Tn"~-:l';.
;- '. ...;.,":
~)o? ;:,:jrt-;...t~l'i'~
f1i,l,T.~ ,= {:
\ ~ . ,; , ., " ;
.. .. . . . ..
, .: , A P . " " ,
,
.. , ~ . > " .. . " ':
,.
1 t .
,;j.
r.,::,
~:
',' 1 ~: t::-
: _~"ll ~' 1 .
'-_' J . -::~. l i :~ It"'"
"
,,--- ~
.n.......
q.~ ..
, ((J.d..
;:.)
..L~". }.....,~.
I~ "
.~.
"
,
..'~'
.'11 ~... ," i;" t
.<
.. ,/
~#~~.
.,.,...
::17
, .
,
,
~.~:.1.--' ,lv ~'Io';:'r'n accc'r,jl;i'~
., h~;. \Ii 1. t ~Il f:
:; ",.4
;,,;'"
!' .
~( .....-:-;f'! "'2 !"\?-2r::r
~:.'
.../:r~.'>';,-~
-...~~-~, '-'~i"-;:-
4
I~
1
~ ('I 2:
~ N
. .. .. , ..
r
" .
.. ,
L
,
<...), .
, ,I .
~.' , ~-,;;.
-.;1 " ,. .-l4i
... :~ (....
C --..~
L' ~ d
c
-.
[
p
, t
J:
ill
ij
,
,
"
63~ 1'.
633 .\TLA....TIC IlEPORTER. 2d SERIES
SaJ'f'-f;ld.~...,t/(JII -"'1IfJf' nu.,) , 201 F,~d ~
list Cir.19;..1J; .\'utwl/IJI I.fJhur RrlutuJIIs
Boan! L Cllfrt.qo '-\,,/IfI",'II:4 nJrp.. 116 F.2d
753 (7th Cir.1940)." 1'f'."uyll'fUllrl L.arnJr
Rtlatllms Board I', Sand'~ Rtslo'4nJ"t. 429
Pa. ~.9. ~8-I. 210 A.2d 801. so:! 11968), In so
doing, we "ill employ the definition o( "con.
structi\'e discharge" :1S applied in case. Iiti.
gated punuant to the Penll!yl,,"nia Labor
Relatioll! Act. ~3 Pa.C.s..-\. t 211.1 rl "q,
See. -"apui's. iO/fpm.1
191 In'tantly. appellant h.. alleged that
almo't immediately tollo"'n~ his retu.al to
under." l"'lygraph e..rmnollon, he was de-
moted. hi. hour! reduced (rom (orty to ,Lx-
teen per week. ru. pal' rate reduced (rom
s:;,~ to ~,OO per hour and his Job locatIon
was chane'-'l!. .\lthouJ:h a 1:1 undisputed th;At
~ppl:!'llant J"ll~llitntd (rum hilS poslUon. wt! b@-
lie'-. that the qutts.tion of whether a nearty
71 c;. reductlon In \~..eek1y \\'agf'S l"Onsututes a
-constructlve discharge" ,hould b.. decided
bl' the JUry, rr. ,\10"'001< I', Coole. t>l Md,
App, I. ~9-l A.2d 212 119li51 ,(onn.. employ-
ee. wne "TOngfully. coll!trucU\'.ly <ii.-
charged when. aI'" re(u..ng to .ubmlt to
poll'graph euminatioll!. th.y ....re trans-
fe-rrt"d tu ltist.ant lut"atll.m~ and their huu~
WPI? l"haN!edl,
In l\utn. w@' find that th~ th.1ctnn~ vi ,"'QUat.
era! ..top!"'l IS lOapph<abl. to thll< c.... that
a nUSt' ot acuon (or "TOntlful d..c~ of an
"t.",1I ..mployt'(t \l'l1s.U ~;h~n an Il:'mpllJYff 1$
disrhupd (or ....(U.-101I to s\lbm'l to a he
\1ftf<'ti)r tt'St and that the f'frord rP,...a1.
...mrlfnt (actJI (or the qu..tion o( ..'beth.r
ap\><,Uant ..u "ronalJ'UClluly dit<harpd' hI
i:" to tn.1.
'7 "'r J,~,l r..'tr ::\.11 :~ "n"-'~'l.ll\mt'1"l' ~1'mf't"'1'"
':,'n .'~lI~ll,1ll ,"..J l m:t1."ii"-C'..Ii!h ,,,.11'1 -,1\
~\.tt.-.J
.\ ,;...n:..n~ hl;,"" .:~~!'PI,,-\\ll\~":l " .1<,(-'
\".<lt1!"I~ 't'!"~.flJ\" r. 'l".tl~ 'It&' "UIl}t;:
;'!\t.,.-" .n.., ~...,:'l ','~f!::r,,,,hHtl "'''\ ,",'Ilt ..I~i"'"
" ...r........ oJ:''': . !I';'t"d"~ .;~t\lh: '!".Jo!
, ,-', .It",l..i~~ t., ""'I.~' '~, t .....11 ,,'1'-'
.1.U]I"l. f.t'~..",l\' \~' !~T: '\.'\<H..t' ,,' 1,,"<
,'~.,:,.''''.r'' .:'~,1', ,_,,,.J.,L.~l'-.l'''.j'
';';t. i~ , ., ;t;~:..' .;
''''''r \\ .' " .
"
" ;" ,
. , _I'!',,' Al'" ~... ,.. .,: '
,. ! .....~ ., -....:'..~ ,.,~.'
'. .:1 l ,', ~"
".'.I.-l' .,
Summar)' judll11lenl rl"\"t'r!ied,
manded for trial, ,;i.lr.~dh'~:I,n r~li
.
0'1.'" ..,._\"'...
G.n..;~. R,
\'.
.\I;..,.ed ;:'Pl. 13, 1 m.
riled SO\ l. 1993.
Di\'orce action Wi! brough~
of COllllllOn 1'1... o( Allegh"l' C
ily Di\ision. So, FD ~7-127i.
J., entered final detroe, Husband
Th. Superior Court. So, 1693
1992, ""I""~rh. J. held that 'II
did not frr In adoplU".il miiL"ter',
t.on that :;g \'ehldt.J~ ,,'''T.t''l t-y
l1"\l('iunlt ;lnd traNlp'Jrtahun ~'i)mp&D'
he appnuSt'd at lh.ir "11:,. <luu.- ·
....rdinll ",,(. :.~; ,,( mmt>! pro"'"
di\'urre .-as nllt an ,jb~f A ~
,3\ d.nl'lllt hu.band . ~.tH.hart rl
tal t'!Itatlf upon di"f.'rrf' W~ not ..
~ti!.'('l"fuon,
.\fllnn<>d,
\'1 : l'........H' : .:.-~ _..,.-..t CiI"'WI
A.-'on. 1.'l:PJt!~\..~" :'~ ;~I '...,.
~ \.1.; ......j, (l!~' .L".~'''':
f"~h",,, ''',1...\. ; 11'-
..... . :.1 .,;{ ~. -l \ ,....
t'...... r "11'":"",_
.~\C',.,~ ,h~.. !..;!.....t~. ~.!
\0 .l'~.;J. '\j'h <,"
, .'1 ~\ I, '"t\-.i!!\,' ,;. -, r .I' .-
, ;'-\.'--" ,'~- .,.. ."....>'
..:' .. ' 7,.J. ; ~ ".,~
;....~ "'''
"
638 Pa.
633 ,\TU.'\;TIC REPORTER. 2d SERIES
feet of \"aluin.r thol'lE' a~se~ at 1~!Ol'i than a
fair market \'alue, In arlrl'llan, It woulrl be
incon~istent \\ith the valuation of .\F.-\. as a
going concern, Accomingl,', such an ad.
justment is not appropnate,
Master's Report, pp, U-15. Himllarly, the
~Iaster disallowed an adjustment far the esti.
materl cost of remo\'a1 of fuel storalle tanks:
Fi...t, ~Ir. Walk testified that he would
likely t",at such e.penditure as an operat.
ing e.pen.e, While such an e.pendltu",
would affect the rompany's future opent.
ing l'itatempnt. it would not impaet upon its
September tl. 19~9 'or [)"""mb.r :lI, 19~9)
balanr'! !tohH"t. ~in(,'tl thp bu!tolnt'~~ l~ hein~
\'alu~d on a rpca."t hook "aiup t'asJ~. the
po!li!lolble in~rrenre of futurr "rWrJ.':ln.c E'~'
pt'n~!I li; not Nlt"\'ant.
St"('ondly. no ('\1denC1.' ha~ t4>t-r. ,.ifert'li
which would indicate that the pt"l'~enno ne
the tanks reduCPtt thf \'a!Utl I)f tht' l)ropt>r.
t,', Since the parti.. ha\'. stipulated to
the fair market \'a1ue of Af.\"s r..l e.tate.
the ~Iaster conclude. that any unJl'l<l upon
ill \'alue ",sulti~ from the pre..n.. of the
tanks is aI""dy ",fleeted in tho," .pprats.
a1..
~I..ter"s Report. p, 15. The lo....r ,'Ourt
deternune.t that the Muter ilJlPropnately
prechJdtl\l an aJ,)u:otmf'nt for the aiol'!'m~n~
!loned <0811, Trial llpln"," ;), I', 9~, P ~,
Anir t>xanunuuc the- rpt"Ol'tl. oUld ;n n~'" d'
the lln<&.lpl1S 1}f'tI\1.d~ by our ('uurt In .\lKf'
lait.." .~ If pm. ,,'p find that thE' 1".....' roU" dld
not .must' It.f th.stt'(>uon In IU ,irtf'rnuna.tum.
In tl\'alu:lUnll wh..th.r lh. tturd M,.nl,ntlQn
r&l"fo(j b~. hUliband hu a"~' nwnt. \U lruuail~'
dinaet ",ur aUenllon to tM rollo.'fti .ana1}1';ul
a.." r''tlnd hy llUf t \lUr1 In $n't.fl~'~ ."0"6
,,4. :1:111'. ~1lI"'r l. \I. I~ ,\:,llill~. l,~i;!
'b"I'l ;Tl"ti!;~ >It...,. ';""'li!f.Jj. .,ir.\ 1'... .:~:.:.
~llt! .\ ;':,1 l\~. j l~..
IT:h,,'r!' ,.. t:o ~;n\JI(t" i-'rnt...~.. t \ "hid'! t,
.fIH't.. !""',.tr:h.l l',....f"-.r.\ n-lt' ~,"~'..Ii
,h~tr.!,,'.j.tl,'n ,hn\.... fr:"!!l !~:.. t.&i.'u- . ~!W
:n>.il\'!hu: '_1"'" T1w L..' f fL" -f.. i
U.....,.: '" '. ..("1"'1..... .\" ,to ","'l,li.t..t'rll' ~ r --!,:...,j
t'r;i~i' n. ,..~k'4.:h th.. h~ l~ ~""~~.t'r ."~J;ii'"
as8ume~ rp!'pont.ibilily In rent\~nnL!' :'.~ dp.
cisionl!.
SrI' Strut r. SergI.. :1:)1 Pa.~ut,~r, .....\0. ..,.,~_
1;00. 506 A2d 928, UJ.l1l98til 'while an',th.,
rourt ma). rhoose to give different \\"t'lght to
the facto... of U 350:!la) I, itlS apparpnt thot
the trial court considered th.,. lactl," ,n It!
detennination).
[81 Husband contends that the ~Ia"ter
and lower court erred in awardmg the ",f.
,m of the mariu! property, Hu>hand sug.
geslI that the Master .nd th. court t.low
pre.upposed that a 5lY"oO .pht '..'", n.e""an.
Iy the most equitable and thus ,'r,mmllte,1 an
error of law, ....ppellant's Bn.i, I'p. ::~-"l
St" /'t)wf'll r. Polt'r-1L 395 Pa.~'JIJt'r. :{;-,. ',::
.\.2d S76 t 1990) una! court mu~t n,)t ,:rt-..ume
;",Q-jO dhision and must (lnt Oina.ly:t' ..!.:utu.
ry' U:o.t of facto", to be ('Un!'.dHt:'d :n case
r~lwnnJ<r equl~le distnbut,l'r.' "'_Intrar)'
to husband's asurtion. we fino !r.at th.. ~b.....
ler did not p",sume a :;n:;o ,pitt '" Ius
equitable distribution .nal)',,<. In b R..
port. the ~laster began his <\'olu.con ul eq.
uitable distnbution by /'eCOllllInng the rac.
ton prnmbed in , 3.';02 ,,j the O,,'or,"
Code. The ~I..ter then pro<..edd t" '<!".c.
nu-e the farts or the tL"e 1ft relallor.:ohlP to
tho~e factors and only then ('-'~nduriM '~.at .1
..to.50 di\~lon was th. mo."t p'rlltablt> \t.l....
f('f'iI Rrport. pp. .t!-4ti. \\'" rf'}t't.'t r,u,"~"4!:lf..
C'ontt?ntl\ln that a pnsumpUnn ~n'Jul,i I.. im.
phed Irom the ~I..ter" ron<1u,,"n
ltu~band URrts that the ~b.':'h'r .1:1li ttt
t.J"....r roun t?rTPd tn "'''Ia:hu~1Z ~!".P f.ar!.i"J"l ~t
forth in , ~ or ~ D1\'nn'f' t'l~tt" Tht
l'nu l'C hu,band's UJrUm..nt ;,.; that 1';(1 ,I
<nutled to I l!"'llor share "r the manta!
1!'fUte hftoaU-~ of hiM f'mPicymt'nt .. tTLll"'ll
ThiP I,m'pr l'\lUI1 wat ('\l\!TlIUr.t i ~!1t' !'.k1
that hwc.ha.nd wwkt"'-t !'tf\J'nu"u~;'. ~ I ,h''''I''P
!,he oI.\lC'tt>,~ Hr .\....\. H!Iu't<u.r. ,~.!" :U't
r..1".' al!'>tl rff\~1\l%t."tt lftto ..ut:.. .nt..~. r.~r.
\utll.'n j.t ",ft!' ....~ hf"'Wtt\.ai-..,l" Th: ..,'x~
~l,,*i f'Uf l'h~idNn. "nt" ,,( ~\h. ~-; r:,~q 'i"ii
1., Tlw ;<'''.r ,'.,un i."u.n;l '''',..t 'I~t, .-',',1'"
: 11t'1"" . t .f;llol ""'.1r.-n..: "'it... . .,,'I,t ", ,-'!'
:h ..,t-t,~,'4'L ;htl ,'"urt .,d,,\\ .!.......~'::,~,,'l ';'..\
'\If. ,""fl1f"!hl.!,..t .'\lh~hlt'r;.tj\ '. t";..!",,,".l"
!.'-'" "': 'r "I,..\"!-!l,' l.~ ~, !":t'- "\"',"~' ,h.' l,1"'h.....:,.t;,\i .lr1"t'f' ;'\ '"~:H'.l.~;..'': '"
,,~'.'!'l: ~'y \ "YII"I'" 1..'1,,.. n..i"- '~.,. ,.,~!"" ;:,,'t",~.~ ;..-:.. '''tlr.h'~ ':'1'~':'~ 1 __ ',\.. ....._1
"",.. ;.., ,J ;;.' :-..... ."""1" -,t .~',,~ .
.,.. ,.,
--_.....-,..
,'.;~" ' ~..,rl'.,.". ~,'~. .,.r r"
"
t
01......,' \Jd'.u lr'.SU'-' If"'.
UleSsment of factor!' In thilt ca..~e. ....,.f'f' Ow. :ou(ficll'nt t,) n',iu('(' b:, lJut~tantlmlo! bai.m~,'
:: IIOnd r. V",,,,,,,,ri. :100 p..Super. 101. II~. to SI.UOIl.WO. The 5I.UUU.LMJO .h.llthen b.
619 A.~d 101~. 101~ \ 19bj'l, IJpPnJ[ dt'tllnL pOliti In l'quai ;n~tallment.... at a rate vi ,it(
'. &16 Pa. 633. :>33 ,.\.~d 92 I:~&j) <In ""c.rtam. on the "u~,t.r.d;n~ ral.nce ~h. ",11
IDi .quitabl. di.tnbution Mast.r mu.l I'e be rec.";n~ pnnclp:&! pa)"IIl.nuo of 510U.-
permill.d neXJbilit, In ordor to do .conumlc 000 (lOr )"ur plu. Int.....t in th. ou"'t.nd-
Justice). in~ b:&!anc.
. (Ill Husband a1.0 maintains that h.
. Ibould ...ce,," a great.r .h.... of the mant:&!
_tall on tho J(l'Ound that "if. is now d.-
,eeued. Th. :ow.r court full, e<>n.id....d
husband's argument tn IU determination <)(
equitabl. distnbuuon. Th. ,'Qurt below
lowld that ",r. was .ntltl.d to her .qultable
ebare dunnl!" her hr.time. and. under the
c:irt:uInStances of the ca.toe, l~ ~ntltl~cI t;"1 piL":O
; her sharr to r.er e-state. Tnai rk'lnli.'n
.' 'p
rtl6f~. pp. 1-;;. H..... th. <1"'0""" d,,'re.
WIS entered un July :!t. 1~7 From n...ttl\l~r
29. 1990. throu~h J.nu.r)" \Ii. 1,>91. th. ~1..,.
tar eonducte-d ~I.X days H( heilnnlZ~ tv dt:>h.'f.
mine claims Gf eqwtable dLStnbutlOn. ilhm(}n~"
aDd CtlUnsel r"".. On Dffi'mber ~. 1991. tho
Kuter .ubm.lll'd hIS R.port. On Jun. :::I.
. 1992. ",r. di.d unexp<'ctl'dl,. Cpon n""''''
. III the rec<lrd. w. e<>ndude that th. lo,,'.r
COW't dId not ahu~e Its dl5rntion an rtJf'ctlfl':
a husband's conltlnUOn that he 1f t'nutii'd tll a
,,- I"ater .h.... or th. manu! ulate be<au... of
'a: we's death. .o;ft l\utlu:(k I' [l(I:;h..;d,:,
:"{1 s.&6 Pa.~upt'r. lit}. llJ9 A.~J l(.~9 ll~l~\, ,fl'.
1.-: ptal lIte"If/Hi i H~-";I, \j)n~ ;l ,h\.or~ ,t..crt-'t'
.. has bHn f'ntt'rtl-'i. ~ht n~l (,f th~ :"p~IUH' !,)
;: t;ht d~tnbuuon d marital prtlPtrt~. .and >,:ther
~ ttonoml\' dou.m~ whup tht.l~ matt',... h.a\t:'
bien pr(\f'It'r:~' rut in ItllOue t-...f(1r~ tht' llt'ath
" of
.. t.M ;pnUM' .~ n"!'>tedl Hanntl I'~;nl'iudt'(t
*'. that the I~Ut'!i r:u!'Pd in. hlJ~t'an,i'Ji th~rrt .lr.
. I'DMnt Iltl nut wanant ""',,,,ai, WI altJn-~S
....banQ!I fin~ ~"'nnt.nUoft
"
ro:-;zl \. ro:-;zl
,
,.
,.
...
'..,
,
-,
",\,
~.ll
,.
r'
[101 Hu",hiln(h f,>>.&rth oilf't'ttni'nt ,:hai,
.. Ie., thr \.lwt'r 1.~"lJ.n '!'o tkt..mlnJ.tpn ,I' t~w
-
\. taa ~t lnh'ft"~t \'t't"it'l"qUt'r.N~ J.n;c.;r.tt fr,'m
the "L.." ,,( ,Lo.~r~hib'n :r~~~l"""> "" t.,~..
," ..~
....t ~ht' '1"~',"r J'rq.......,.1 .t ,i\<.:tr:f'ut:f,
Ift\totnp \\~;~I't, !T ,:J.lrt'-it "I,,,'.,n:HI~ ;!'An f'_',..-
bal\41'1,\~!".l !l.i':,!,I."'llil ".'!' ,\! '.~r":,'..l:
~\fl.th "d It H ~.~...~,i (:,',i J.'" '."1 i~, :: '
th. \t....~"f ~ ; d:~! .1"'1':~:..o1. t H .:.:.LI~-l
t'tq'.h'.1fl-'1 '_!'" ~ ".'\"hart:"~f;'.l';' ,. ...t.. ,~..
Hu."L",~~ I '.:~~ ,0, .r..\: ._"".+-
111'11"'1 "."n,
:.\ ",
,"
Pa. 639
Appellant'. Exc.puons to ~Iast.r'. Report. p.
46. The l'Jwer rourt ~usuuned hUl'band'!\
..Ct'ption and pro\"ld.d th. rollo"'n~ distn-
hutinn :t-cheme which IS 51mllar to hU5hand'fIo
fpqut!loted pla.n:
In IlrdE'r to redu('tt the f'Conomic hardshlPs
'\n HU5band and ensun- an equitable distn~
hut10n ..'1' the mantal E'!ltatt. the payment
~('hl'm~ ~hai1 be ('am~d ()ut O\'tr :l period
"r t.n ,\O! :..ar,. Husb.nd shall mak. a
lump ~um .LJ'.tn~u.tion in the amount uf
sa7~+.~~h) \III ~.~ Wlft' ""thln ~lxty ,no'l dayi'o
\)( t~,L'" (h.\'r..t> Th~ ''In reduN' Hus.
hand'~ <lut...tandlni!l halanrf' to J1.UUO.-
tlOO.UlI Th. 'Iul>tandin~ b:&!ance .hall
th.n ~e p..d 10 t.n .qual annual lI\Stall-
menU" \\1th .n inttr~5t nt. of pnm. pl~
OM perrent ,1 'i I on an)' ouulandinf( bal-
anCt'.
~1t>m\lrandum 'J( Final Oecfff ~..::l9'!, pp, ~-
;I. Hu.blft<J h....ln cont.nds that the \owor
.:uurt f..llltJti to l"Jn~ltit'r tht t~, and inttrt'-!'t
ramukau.mJi ,~ ,t~ ,tt'tf>Mnlnatl(}n nf t'qultJ.bl,'
'hHnt'lutl,ln i{u~tlanrl t'nmpi~t~[y ltmC'l'I"-!'i
!ht' told ~:-.....t ~r;e fjlU!"'t t..h.t\llo' .d~l,)tt"d J Ih~tn.
~'Uli.un 'tn.:'tr.t" r..t'ui:: lflenl1c<l1 toJ thlt pi,,"
r"'lut'~H"t I':. ~u~h;ln,l w. find th4lt tht'
lll\\..r t~l"..rt tn'lt'llue:rt!y ;a...,p!<wi thti t'l'onr'm
tC ("<}n~_tul:'r.\t":O A ~hf ,Jultr~hutl(}n ~rhemt..
.nd W@ ~'iln\'iuJe t!-..l the n~rd t'J.Ul!i t\l
rt'nPC1, an. ah\1ti.f Il( rt:~th)n un t he part of
t~ IMal l~".lrt
Tht' f:na.j .~",..f\-'," . f ";'rtt'mNr ~ t:f'..t~ ,"'-
..rt'irnw'l
~._.. ,)
I
,
.
t
\, -
I ). ~:-
:I
636 I'a.
0;33 .\TI..\....nf IIEPORTER. 2d SERIES
\'orl'l'll but :"ub~t''1ut'ntl~' l'ntt'rl'fi anto a ('om-
man law marnal[l;' In Apn!. 19fi:!. whl{'h \\'a~
solemmzf>d in 197-1. In Derember. l~~. the
parti.. ;oparat.d and were di\'orr.d by d.,
e... .nter.d on July 2t. 1987. On Jun. 28.
1990. the lower rourt .nter.d an order ap.
pOinting William L. St.iner, Esquire. Sp.rl.1
~I...ter to ""ndurt h.annl(S and d.termine
daims Cor equiuble distribution. alimony and
""un.el C.... From October :!9. 1990.
through Januar~' 10;. 1991. the ~I..ter ""n.
dueted Sl.'\ day!' of heannp. On December
0;. H/fIl. the ~I""t.r submltt.d hi. Report.
Th.rpafter. hoth part,.s filed timely ..rep.
t1on~ to the :'-Iastt'r-!I Report. On June ~.
t~.r.!. \\lfl! .hed unf:\pt'l'tedly. On July :..~.
199'~. the l.'1)urt bttoillW t'nttred a memoran.
dum and final llfl'rree :;ustalnina- In pan. ..nd
I'bl'mJl'\~in.r In part. toth partJt>s' ex~pu(}ns to
the ~lastPr'. Rpport. Hu.band then :iled a
motion ((if rHOnl'lciflraUon. On September
::I. 199".!. the lo"..r ('(tUn fnterPd a mrmoran.
dum and linal dec.... whirh ,u!ltained f".. oC
h~band'! n.t"epuons and one of ",fe', tlC@p-
lion. and d..mU'!.d the ..maimng ....p-
tion.. The ""urt helow determined that lhe
mantal ..tate to be $l.stS.1 ;':!.OO and award.
ed ",Ce one.half ,hare oC the manta! p.ute
ur Sll'2'!,'\AA.OO. On October ~. 1!l92. hus.
hanrl fil.-d a noul.'t' flf apPf'aJ.l On Snnomber
Itt E~J:!, ~h. l..\\"flt l..~urt rtirpl'tM ht1~i::and t'l
tilt!' a ~'llnl'I:'~ :-tatt'mt'nt uf matteN rom.
rwnt'd i)f "n a.p~it;i. nwnafter. hu..-.;,band
timply m~d hU' l';Jnl'i~t' \"tat.m.nt m al'C'Or.
,Ian.e ,nth r. RAr. l:r.::'hl. On F.l;ruar,
1';'. 19*J3. 1M l\IWt"f L',IUr1: HH;Uf'd an (~lrJl.m in
!ioUPllIJrt ..~f thtl t1n....l ~i~H diltM ~t'ptrmhfr
:::1. 199"!
.-\pptollant rrr....!'tb thp f,-l.Ull\\lr.~ .u'rU-
mt"nt!4. f,lr "ur non.'\\-
I THE: L,'\\Ui ,'''\"IlT E:RRH' I~
I1F.TER~tl\I\I; TIn: \'.\Lt'E HF\D
r"TERI'!;l"r" 1\,' II.,. ()l".\LL. \W
I',; Till: ."" 1'1"t'tll'''T :" Till:
lll.n: I~'\ll\ \. \Ln:.... :~, Hllln.f"
ltH"TH if l' :\ TnI' ro('I:TH ~ \1T
'jl\f\Y I!F \l"ii:tLi:' \~P \'\:. }J.
III !P 'l; \''1\ \T ~~i4t".iiIH
II. THE Ltl\\'EH 'lI!'nT ER
OETER~II\I\I; TIlE \".\1.l:E or.
ESTERI'RISE,.. 1:'\1' IlY DI
ISG THE T1tA:>i>;ACTIO:'\AL
Sl7t.933.00 RELATED TO TllE
OF EQnp~IE:>iT .\:>i0 TllE
ROSME:>iTAL 1.IAIlILlTY or
000.00 FOR RDIO\'AL OF
STORAGE TA.'I;KS 1):'\ AFA
TY.
III. THE LO\\'1:It nWRT E
AWAROI:>iG THE WIfE :.&\ 0
MARITAL PROPERTI" 1:'\ LI
THE Ht"~IlA:>in'~ "\'ERWllt
ASO OI~rRO(~IRTltl:'\.\TE
Bt'T10:>i TOWARD TIlE ACQU
OF SITH PROPEHTI"\:'\D IN
OF WIFE'~ nTl~IELY DEATH
SEQI'E:>iT TO TRIAL
1\". THE LOWER rot'RT E
FAILlSG TO CO:'\SIDER THl
COSSEQl'ESCES Uf THE
D1STRIBt'TIO:>i WHICH R
Ht:SB.\."O'S lOSE Of
DOLLARS TO PAY TO WI
TATE SI.oooJXltllltJ PLt'S I.
IS TES ,101 EQt".\L A.,'I;S
STALL~IE:>iTS
Appellant'. \In.C. "T.I.I,' ..j ("on
Il-Jl In iL.;,llt'....m~ \\h,.t!;pr the
].;w ilpprf'fMJ.tt'l\" ,L:'("f>fU:r:t',i ttlt
dl!tnbuuon ,,( lht' r.unt.;u propfrty,
brlt"f the foH\}\\1rlit il!\a.lY;';I~ ;l! W.
aUf Cvun In .\lH..,);'." .\1:"'1,4" 410
rer 1.16. :>99 A.2J ~~7 1 :",1. .""..
.\30 r. tW3. .itlfi .\.:!,t ~M.r.: 'lm)~
.,,'d, - I'S. - 113 SCL I
L.Ed2d 1:l9 ,1;l!l~'
Our ~\~pt" 'lr rY\'U''' :n t>'>~UI~
H\lft nu.ttt'N :!" t.tt1Itt'it 1. Wulf' ..
&d1 P.l.~~t..r '::"1. .:....;. :,,-.j .\.JIl
l~\ i:;:" \\t'~: ,~~..i,~'d '.!-"'"
.In ...bu~ ib.~'!"":' n .... ~t pltl
~nal \'u\ir \\-. ~1.1 !',. t r.'
'-<l\li'"hh... l;~tr:hl'~.r:
ra~~r 1~. 1..... ',",'
1""\ . ...,/1
.,q .\;.:1 ~.l:'"" i.""
r~"+,..t : '~'.l" p"",,_,,(, ~'. H" ~
roszl ". roszl
U'....ll '.ld U.. Ira,!tupt'r UUl
that In:U ('uurt.~ ha\'t.> hroatt the (nurth catt'/o!f!r; ~hl}uid
)ow." to .rr.rtuate Ju'tll'e and their Blu. Uook "~lue.
an abuse of clls('retlOn (mh' if
eourt has m"applied the law or
. illUow proper legal proc.dure..
''',,", [~Ol Pa.Super.J at
at 45. The finder of fact"
I weigh the t'\1dence prei'ented
Ita c...dlbilIty. \I',II,am.'">I...
402 Pa.Super. ~76, ~S6. :>86
'8'12 (19911. The fact tinder is
.. . all, part. or none of the
'iz.J the Supenor Court ",U not
tII. credibilIty ~.tennlnallOn' of
below.
'~ViltJ. .U6 Pa.~!;pt'r. ~<). ~.~. tilO
(199~) ,Coun Jdopt' .lIo"ph.,
ItI detennlna~on <if wht>th>r tn:lI
ita di!crt'tl'Jn In pqullar.!t' di5tn-
).
-\ !"
~ ~. .,
,I:.,'
,"
Pa. 6:1';
b. JpprallOl-d ;,t
Hu~hanct l'ontenri:-l. ":tJhe ~la~tt'r'!Ii and
lower C'ourt'8 adoptlon pf the Dlue Book raluI'
for the \'e-hirles in C'atejtory four was ar~lI'
tr3l')', rapncious and un!upported by the t"1.
d.nce:' Appellant'. Un.f, p. 18. Husband
.....rts that h. off.red uncontradicted e\1-
denc. of th. value of the 39 ,'ehieles, and that
the lower court and the ~I..ter, wer., thus.
compelled to employ' husband's appraisal of
these rehieles. -The fact tinder is free to
beli,,'e aU, part, or none of the ..,de nee and
the Superior Court ,,111 not disturb the credi-
bilIty d.temllnation. of the court below:'
.\/0"";1'1. ~lO Pa.Super. at I:;S. ,i99 _\.~d at
';:>3. H..... the ~I..t.r and the lo"'.r coUrt
round that the ,a1u. established in th. Blu.
DO<lK to h~ more \"redible than the \'alue
...rTl"rE'd 1,:.- t-.u~banri. ,\"~ tind no basi:; tu
.tl![Urb !tut tindir.~ a.nd a~corciinj;ly reJt'cl
husband'~ ..rgument that the lower coun
erred in d.temunmg the ,'alue of AF:\ b,
disallo'\1nj: tho :!9'< discount to the Blu~
Book value "f 39 ,'ehicles identified in the
founh t:attgol!' of \'fhicIe~. MOf1'()\'et'. "'en
If "" ",.re to find husband', ,'alue of th.
,"fhlde! to he uncontradictffl. \\.t' not. that
the Master and the lo",.r rourt adequately
t"xr1aint'tt why hu~~and'~ appra.:.sal was rl"
2{l('tffl :\ft. Sfwq,,"k . :'nttft.lCf'4-. ~ffl Pa.
:.:~~. ~~\o,. ;.lr.! .\.~~t 1":'. t!:! 1~."':), ;;uthnuc-h ~l
facUinllt"f r.~t nl:t al'I.'t',tt "H'n trot' unronlfa.-
thcttJd llpmlon 'I! 41. \"a!uOltion t'xp..rt. tna}
{'(Iurt !o'houid nfft'r ~:'I;pi..n~unn n( It$ ;approc.o:aJ.
In the t",'fnt tha.t it'S "rrriu!'a1 \'anp~ frnm
lh. I.nly "a!ue a:1'i'n In t'n1t'r""t'I.
"
}
"
"
t
i
f
!'
.,
.
111 ~..,ond. "!'I'<'Uant argue. that tho
10"-'" rour1 t'1'tt'd in not dt>tiu('Ut\Jr ~m
.U~.\'~ !lnam,'lal ~tatfm"'!l!~ the tran"~t.'hi\nal
t"\l1"t ,t ~17&$t1111J rv...!t'Il ~l !~.t" ...tlC' f
",;ulpml"r.t .-.rHi ~~.' "~'.:r"r:rn"~!al ::dtlll~tY
$."'\lH.i"lIllltl !i" ,~... ~~.~ \.1. f ~'-'rl ~!.,;..~..
!,m"'.:- .-n .\r,\ ~,r""r.': ~... \t......r.'r r..'.-,'
l.tt~!l .t'(~ll,,!~;,'n f r '~.I' 'r.lT~",,*.'~~1".,ti,' ,..t
~t7' :t:U;.!t, 'tl ~~t" : ;l.\\",:r.: t..&-..;,.,
4
i
."
Tl'a-rt' :" !'!" tY'! i..r-''', ~~.~"'\*"'r, ~~dt .\r \
"tol:l11" , I ~t'.l '.~~+' f r ','..ry... Thtl...l....t.:!...
\tr \r"j., " , bl.t ..&~;H t-'t'f'~ \,~, l'..t"..~ rd.'
':..i.' '~..t' '!.t""'. ,">1- .t...,1 ....,. 1~.1'1,". -
t '\,"rl-':.... 'r-,~.,i,.-'_' ~~.. '",p. 1.....>
~
t
t
r
638 I'a.
633 .\TLA,"TIC REI'ORTER. 2d SERIES
ft?ct of valuing thoi'e a.!':if~ at lel'l'l than a
fair market ,'alue. [n addition. It would be
.nconoistent "ith the \'aluatlon of .\FA .. a
gOIng concern. Accordingly'. such an .d.
justment is not apprnpnate.
Master's Report, pp, U-IS, Similarly', the
~Iaster disallo\\'ed an adjustment for the esti.
mated cost o( remO\'a1 o( (uel storage tmks:
Fin!. Mr. Wolk testified that he \\'ould
lik.ly trut such e.penditun as an operat.
ing expense. While such an expenditure
\\'ould affect the company'; future operat.
ing IItatfment. it \\'fluId not impact upon it.!
"eptemhor !l, 19~9 ",. Decemhor :ll, 19:;9\
balanrt' ~h~t. :'inre thE" t>'J~Int"5!1 l~ Peinlt
,"a1utd on a rt'Ca.~t t'lflok value' f-'\a.lt1.9. the
pol'!liblt!' in~nre .)f futUff "I'It'f:lUn.r f:I:t.
pen:\(lg I~ not rele\"ant.
~('Ondl~'. no t"1denet> r.d..'" h.tln ;}llE'rt',i
which would indlC"oltf that the- pn>~fn('@ 1'(
the tank. redu.... the ,'alue "f the proper.
I)", Since Ihe parties ha,'e stipulated to
th. fair market ..aloe o( .\FA'. real ..tat..
th. ~Iasttr conclude. that any .mpact upon
illl ..a1ue resulting from th. pre..n"" o( th.
tanks i. a1read)' renected in tl\o!;e apprai..
aI.,
M..ler'. Report. p. 13. The lo\\'.r court
detennlned lhat the Miittr appropnat.ly
precluded an ..tiu>tm.nt for the afo,.,men.
liored ,....1.8. Trial Opin...n ~ I'i!f:l. p. 2.
..u'...t?f eununing the ~ro. .nd tft n~' \.{
the iinal)'!ol' rl'Q\i~ b)' our Cvun in. .\h f'.
/,;, '/. ,up"" w. rlAd that the ,,,,,...r rourt dId
nut J,b~ JU discntlOft In lts dtotet'n'l1-QUOf1.
In <..aluaulIll ,,'bother the ,turd ront.II..'"
!'aloed by hl\5band has .ft)' mtnt. "'.. IMlally
dirt>et QUI' .tt8Uon In the f""...illlllftal}',,,
as (,JuDd by t'ur (";mn in ."t Mft.>/( I" ~.'Mt'"
"t"t.. :131 r~$!,lr;er L 11. I~~ .\~,t lU17. Ifit~
'1~'1; J"T'd f;~ 01#'f''' ':#'fH"t.iot ~MI9 P1.. ~Z.
:.0:: .\~~I hl!l '.1"....
rr,,~,. 1.<1 n-n "!'lm~i.. irm.~.. h :,tud'; ~
b~lt~ manul Jrn,*~Y n.. ~l.t~..t !
.t~ln""tlh\.'n Ii,"'!"!"'" f....m. '.~" LU'\A ,,( th..
1,,'h\~,tU41 c;t.--" n.. .."'t ,f f.\\",,,,,,, (
r;~-~'~.l\ I "'.'".... .i.' ~ .....,i-n""!;n~ t, ''''r'':'I'\
"rati~~n. .:tl.tb.u.:h 'h~ :,..t :," !':"itt'wr v'\.t'ia.u...
!,'" '1'''' ..'>t'fi::;' I'" " .....t. 't..:..~," ....
"""""~ 'ht' \ ...t"l"\~' . J,,"! T' . !:'.i-' "., " ",j!'""
,"' .\.,,! ~~,!\
f !'.' ~ r "i . l
assume!! ftJtlponsihility '" rf>r.rtennc :.... (t~.
ci!ions.
Set Sirgl I'. Sirg. :lS1 ra,~ul..r. :,,.,., :,:'~_
600,506 A.2d 928, 934 09&6, 'while "Mth.r
court ma)' ~hoose to give rlifterent WPIi!ht tu
the farton of [t 3502(all, il i, .pparenllhal
the trial court considered the,. i.",o.. In It'
determill3tionl,
(8J HlIllband contends lh.t the ~I"ler
and I",,'er court erred in a\\'ardmg the ",fe
50'< of the marital propert)., Husband .ug.
go'llI that the Muter and the coun below
pre.upposed that a 5n;o .pht w... nece..an.
Iy the m~t equitable and th~ ('Qmmlttt>d an
error o( la\\'. .\ppeil.nt"s Br:.i. l'p. ::2-:,1.
St" l'mn'li t. POh'f'IL 395 Pa.:'::.l~r, ;it.\ --I:;"
.\.2<1 S76 .1990lUrial court mu,: n,j( """U,,,.
:>O,j() di\iFion and must ril'St .a!'.al!'%t !'t"tiJ.~u'
!!" li..il.t o( factor'!' to be {'!.In!'::!t:.red :n l':J.Se
r'P(luirin~ equitable mstnbuc'..In,. (untrary
to hu.band's ....mon. ..... find :hat the ~I...
ler did not presume a SIl:,o .plit In his
tquiuble distribution analy"', [n hi. R..
pol"t. tIw }'Iaster hocan his ...Illuauon of "'I'
uitabl. distribution by recognIZIng the ("".
ton presmbed in , 3:iO'.! ,,( ,h. Di,'n"",
Code. The M..ler th.n pMl-..,ed ,,, '''"'tl.
I1IU tIw facts o( the taSf In relatwn.hlP to
tho,e factors and nnly th~n t'('tnC'!l1dtc>,1 t~at ,}
:.n;o dins.on \\'a.' the moot "'1:.uuhl.. \!J;.
lfis R@fMlrt. fP. "2~ti. \\'f' 1'P.:..rt ha:"-f1..r,j';
~'Ont.ftti.on that I p",~umptlim ..nt)UiJ. ~ t." U~.
piled from th. Master'. \'tlOe,,,"""n
Huslwld ....n. that the M."..r ""d I~"
ll)'a-.r rourt. nnod in ..~nt' ~ 1;t" f.u.1l~r!' ~t
(onh in t :!:ill:.! vf the On",""< \.. ,!to Th.
m&ll of hlllllland', aJ'1l\Im.nl .' lhat h. "
'I\tiUed t. . gre.ler """'" ,,( the mantal
HUt. ~..... o( his .m"'.,."..nl .IT"n,
Th. ,.,,,.., roun \\'I~ t'\irtu:l1tlt ,'f ih.. f.k.1.
!ftal hu.",band \\,,'rkfoli l'tl1'!P.JuU.,";\' ~_l 1t"'''1''v.
th~ ~~ll ..f .\F.\.. Hm.\t"\'t't. .t"." ,-'ur!
tlf'h.... al~ N't"I;lIrftl.Zrct th~ "wt'''~.l:-,H.i.~ "~~r:
hUtll\n . If \\11'" 4L" hHm.-.rr,""'l'r TIw I ..I~" ,..,.
hiM' f"Ur duM""n. "!'W ,i \\~.!"". L;~...i ~ ".t
...t 11\ Tht! 1,1 \.... .'l\.ift f .l.nvl '~:...:, ~ht' . ',! .ft"
t<ur-h<~ ,.f d',lhi"";lr'H~~ ~\i\~ ;1:.'.'.1 ": Y~'f
tn ....U~!:,',n" !tw ('1'uN h.j..\\, ~._tq~;,~,',1 .;.....t
.,-,.f.. ,<O\fltn!'U!,..l ,'qn';l.it-nL' '. h1~t "'......1 ~
rr:'~f''':oO~\'!::d ..r-., ~".
:;,'f1._", Tr:"l' 'J-lf'll.--n ..: it;
"""~,-r~.!',;!'..' "."
'l. ~ \\,. :-).. t
....,.'1..;:- . ~ .t,....r.-.:-,~..
.r'''
,.
\..",
UI~U'.u \lJ 634 IP.!tl,llWr IU)1
; ...essment ;.j facto~ In thi~ l"a....e. ~ff. [Jill' :,ultkwot to redui.'f' r.::, tlut!'tandm~ t'al;ln~t.
.: WlDnd r. Dill '/lfJlld. :ViO Pa.:;uper. 101. II:!. to 51.\}I~J.t.JOO. The $1.000.000 ~halllht>n bt'
&19 A.:!d F)l~. 101~ \ 19~jl. (IJ1Jlnll ,IOllfrL paid I:': t',~ual in~tallmt'nt.to. at 3 rate I,i Ii'";
&16 Pa. 633. .}33 A.~d 92 (:98';) 1m a~("ertatn. .m tr.t' ,,:..It...:tanumg balance ~he \\111
IDi eqult.ble distnbution ~l..ter mu't b. be rece,,;ng pnnclpai p'~1llen15 o( 5100..
permitted r..:ubHit)" in order to do economic 000 p.r year plus ..terest in Ihe oUl.<t.nd.
. .
justleeJ. in.r balance
(91 Husband also malntain. that he
" Ihould recell" . gn.ter share o( the marital
.tate on the gTOund that "if. is noW d..
,_ed. The lower court (ull)" con.'ldered
INsband's argument in ita detununat10n \Of
equiuble distnbution. The coun b.low
found th.t ",fe was entitl.d to her "IUltabi.
!hare dunn2 h" lif.time. .nd. und" the
1,~' tirtum!unco, o( the c.s.. IS .ntltl..j p "...,
fl' her share to her E>5tate. Tnai I }pInil,:n
';''' f/16J1J3. pp. ~-:). Here. the di\"(\~ -1t'("rt't"
,,~ was enttred "0 July ~". 19&7. From' )I,.'tol!t'r
J.
29. 1990. tr.rou~h J.nlUl)' Ill. 19~11. tr.. ~l"".
a, &If conducted :-lX da~., of heiilnnlZ'~ tv ill!tt'r-
mine claims of eqwtabl4!' distnbuuon. ...hml,my
IIld <oun...1 f.... On De<ember Ii. 1!'\\1. the
Waster ,ubmlltod hiS R.port. On Jun. ~':l.
1992. ..,fe dlod un..poOl.dly. l'p'," ...',.w
. 01 th. rocord. .... conclud. that the lower
'_ eowt did not abuse Its disCf"ftlon In r"Jf'(un~
.. husband"s contrnuon that he 1S l"nhtll?'d hl "'
'W" ,"Iter 'h.... of th. manta! ..tat. bec..... 01
;-.,: wife's tlnth, Sf" /liJstU:Io:fk I ru.\h~:Ik.
t Sl6 Pil.~u.rt'r Uti. ~~19 A.::d l("~. t H.~:);. ,'p"
.# pro1 d(l1:tli 19....;.. 'o)no!' .l dl\'or{'p ,l"t'rt't'
has bHn i-ntdf'fi. the nil!ht t~f !h~ ~rdl[lt" ~ ,
"': the dlstr.b<;uun l( manUl J'J"(1pt"rty .tntl \~tht'r
tcoftomu:. cla.ml~ "he", thll!O-tl mat~rr... h..n'
bttn propt'"r;\' rut ;.n I~SUf' ht>fdl"t" tht> ,h...th
01 thf ~pnu~t' I' \htt'di Ha"n~ "'.,nc\..hk-'(
i thalth. ,,"u.. nl...<t .. hu.h.n,l', third .or.
I\Ift'W-nt d" r.ot ~ arrant. n\"l'!'al. 'A to .i\1..t",'!01l
. 'lo 'huband'~ final ("9:'ln\"nUon
FOSZI '. roszl
;~
,-
...
,
.!
'.&1
.,
~
1101 H.,I'.n,j, (.!I1fth ...."I.....".t dt>!
Itftl"li tr,t' ","'''f i..",..Iar1'1I rW,,'rmm.lu. n "t ~h.'
... tal ~d .r.tt'M'!i.t ;,"'~,n!lfl'4ut'n('1'''''' AnHr.~ :~'m
th. "i..r: : t.....~n'r-'.iH\,rl lrutu.,: 'H f-'!l
that th" ~l.t..tt-f p'Pt..........t.l .!,~.r1hl',.I.
~,..... ',\ r.<lT /'l.,....:-.-'i " 1.1\. tt\..~. . ':" !9' ~ -.~
b.andt....\-:h. tn....~j._J\ld _\Ir-r,':~r'.'tt:
IIlOrtth l"!"- -- \ ;i ~..,t -.l!i:' ,",;.>,1 ,t.'~ " , . I .. .', .
th. ~a,....t. j 4>: !.\.'!F;L.I, ~ d.'tl~: 1
~!lt""h' i ,i..' \,<~~ ~ ~'t'"';' ',,' , .t., .....
H;J~l~' l ;~..,.' ,.t ,. .", .'-
'\1'"
", I .;
'\ "
,,' ,'.
.
I'a 6:l9
.\pp.Uan(, Exceptio", to ~1"1.r"' R.port. p.
Iti. The lower l'OUn. ~ustained husband':!,
..ceptlon and pro"d.d the follo"1n~ di.tn.
hUUlJn ~"ht?me which a 5im1lar to husband'!
rPilUtl:o:tfld ill.n:
h1 "rdt'f to re-du('1! the t>ronomlC hardshill:'
"n H'J!l<Oand and ensul'f' an et\uttable: distn-
hU~}L)n .If the mantai l"~tate. the payment
..('ht'r!:tl' ~hall be l,....med out o\"er 3. pl"nod
Hf,.n 10\ )'us. Husband.ha11 make a
lump _...urn d.lstnblluon 1n th. amount of
g;r;:';..)~I.\MI !.l \\\ft' '.nttun ~l.'uy ,t:.t)\ d.y~
,,1 "!",:.:o Dt-t"n>t' ThlS \\lIt rPftun" Hu~-
han,i".: ',uL..;t.1ndm.: balance to $1.000.-
,~l(] ...) Th. "u!funding balance shall
then ~ ~ 1''''<\ in ten .qual annual install.
mfr.t:;, \\lth an lnterest rate of primf plus
t')M pt'rt'l'nt i 1 tt} .In any ouuunding bal.
one<
~l.m.'r.nd.m of Final Decree' :::l9"!. PI'. ~-
:1 Hu,hand h...... ","Ion"" that the hill'"
~'purt f.l:.~~ll t,) \"'.,n!'id..r the- ta.\ and mtfrP!'t
r:l!n~tli.'J,tl;:n<\ In It." ,it,tt'rr!lmOAUpn <If t'o_tultahlt"
,h,:tr:~':lt:c-'n HU:-D;,Wlt l'1lmp!t>ti'l~' lllnnrt>'"
~h.. I~.."t ~hat th.. t'1'~ ~t'i.)'ol' adupud J, J~:,tn-
t'utl,;n ..,.nt.rr,t' !'It'lrl'; ~dt'!\U(,;ll t..> thfl Fl.,an
r...t'.Jl...~t'rt h hu!"i101.r.ii ".to ~in\l that Ih...
"\\ ,.r ,.~::4t ~hof'l'U4r.~.;Y ""'''''f;'!il'-Pfi tht!' t"\'"Dni\m
,( ," ,r;..t'"'il1"H~ .( .r:~ \U:itrl'lutkm !"('h"mt'<
J.ft<.t \Ul .'"nt.'llJO,it' ~r....t the rf't"t!rd (.lll!' 1.1
rft1m .n .tJu~ ~)( diK'"rt>UOft Oft th. piArt tI(
.h1:> ~r.al. \""<'\Un
~.,. .:!",.\. i....:f'rl ! 'l'rtrmt-.., ~. l:.~l:': ,~
\~!:r!"',~'1
~ p. :J
~ - ~
-
~~ -
-"
:c
Q. 0
~~.
te' 0 z
i.: N i
aX -
r. f..)
c:
u. (1\ a
<;) U\
.
~ \f
.",
~ -1
.:::;
,j
J ~
"
...
~ ..... ~<
lr-
Q e is.....
~~ - '-)~~'
u - --
~I' ...: ~.1~
('". - :)~
t (-.I
~". Q.. 'ri~
r ~ :'l
~ C"\ a
t1'
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 96-5705 CIVIL
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ROBERT A. NEILL, JR.,
Plaintiff
JENNIFER PHELABAUM,
Defendant
J?2AECIPI4
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Please mark the above-captioned docket settled and
discontinued.
.
CLECKNER AND P'KARiN
~~~
PA Attorney ID #25675
111 Locust Street
P. O. Box 11847
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1847
(717) 238-1731
Attorneys for Plaintiff,
Robert A. Neill, Jr.
Date: ~_I, 2.400