Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06319 \ ~ , l~ i~, ; i~ ~ ~I U ~ , , ,~ Ii' J " ,~ " ,1 ," 'II , I, ." [ , ~ : .' , I' . I Ii . I I, " , I I I 'I i , , '\';' 'l~l I . \,' I, I" , DREW A. KIRBY, I PlaintiU I I V. I I TROY A. BEAM, I Detondant I I V. I I SHIPPBNSBURG TOWNSHIP, I Complainant I I V. I I TROY A. BEAM, I Defendant I IN THE COUR'r OF COHHON PLEAS or CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA NO. 96-6319 CIVIL TERM CIVIL ACTION - LAW onDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 27th day of NOVEMBER, 1996, the following ollses are transfer~ed to the offioe of Distriot Justioe Helen B. Shulenberger for disposition and sha oan set up new hearing dates. 1. Shippensburg Township v. Beam, No. CV-OOOO 216-96. 2. Shippeneburg Borough Water Authority v. Beam. I have no other caption for this case. The cases are presently in the offioe of Distriot Justioe Donald W. Daihl, and I 1irect that he forward the papers to the offioe of Mr.. Shulenberger. By the Court, COI Distriot Justioe Donald W. Daihl Distriot Justioe Helen B. Shulenberger Troy A. Beam V-1~.u.4I (l'u.'J.c.L.L ,.,../ J./ ~t \ I I~' " '':) 1-.' tJ: ~, " r, , " 1J1," ., , rJ. II~' : '-j f.ji ". . , 'l {'I' ,. I I.j.-! r <. r, :(/; <: " fl" '" , \ll ," t.. I~ ) I,' r I: ,'t I,ll'" )', ,,' 'I j I, , 1 Iii i : I j' I . /1 ,'. . i I .~ . : . lilt} I'ld'~t.t... '''''''., '~Nt~q.jt)q 'i~, '.. .1,", " ( '. ,'. .' ;'. I ~, <, (, ( i I I ,,) . I , j, f I. " till'! 1J;:IH,"""liI,l.Il"" Mhlll."'''1 ' ,1, 'l'h<'1 /;I:IF/J"'iIiIHI/,,1 t,:.., I. ',',l, JII /!d..'ill1<1,1 h,J lHl i1",.ltd 'II DllCUlI\iJ,~)'. 1 ~j:;r, , 'l:hlLl'.:J.lIJJn..l\\JltWII; tl;" J/~,/ir..l..:.,;l: J4lln l~,lj" " .'. On lh' t l) h U I' J 1\ . ~';'\"" "'r'JI !" i'ellll, tU",d (i COlllp~IU/lt with thl! <:ulllbl'll'l<Jrl':l cIJlInt:'t ::~"'I.I'~"1: .V.I,C):ll',IYO' QtI!i.CCi l'lhl.lr'li.n : t i$ !IlleS/Old tll.1l IJl.IH,I'i.r:l ;rllsl:~<"(' DCIl<<.!d ;c;,\ihl, witll oLI';Ul' individll",tll !llld FJIll:iti.,JU, lic.;.,d 1;0 '/j')lllt,. 'l'r,"}' A, fJl!I1IIr,'1'1 COIl13t:ltuti0I111] I'j~rhtrJ 1I11d ti~l'.'~ ,~~ C(''';',tpI\I\tr,; ~'f tho J,1l"OFurty in Shipp@naburg Townnhip, It WdB np~~1fi.cfi:ly nV~rr~d thaL The ditltl'iCI: -:1I.9t!CiJ Ilct..,.1 Idt:h l'<:}.I)'('1'iGr,l.:ilt i\'~ll ,~f th., 'rowl~ahip ~.(, o!lutho)'i7.1j li n'...!jl:.I\~J/l, I', tnl', .'Iii',) cqr,,(.t copy of tl1... C<lll1plaillt ill attll.ch(,;d li~):",r.:,') bf, F.;r.liibi.L "A," 6, tJi.IJO'ict ,r\tf/t.io::... P,dill 1:"" h(!~r, infol.'ln..d ,;.t t:~ti CQIlIP 111 i. nt /,1":,11 ibi I, "l\") wh i r:!; n,ploe (. h 1,'1', ~ :ld i v j,d~la lly , '7, 011 Nov'~IIII,~'r 11. 199(" 'r1:OY 1" ;;';;1111\ fi lod " ~~C!',lti,'Jt 1'li':1-o Adll'oil1itltl'l1tOl Ronald Jolinson ~€q'oI':Util:g that the Kil:"by r'lntt.H' 1IIiO thfJ Shipp~nfjbul'g ~l;;tt"'l' be t'(,llI'~"'"d f.rc.lr, r,:.:.tl'ict Court (9,:; _ 0, and thllt: V 0;> 11\1 (, b.. ':!lJ.1'lged tl' 1i11,.,t:h'il Pir,t,':.:t COUrt, B. Upon illf.rJ1,II1IiL.l.oll, ill n~:!'p\l"l"'''' I:,'.~ UHl 1:'''q\l'~fJt tc ('h~,n~1" '/ell\lllJ, Plf"rict :fllnt,i\:Oj (J,'d,ld :JL"l', oitd 1 I'm going tu rronBc~t0 hi~ [T~QY A, Buam) in 11;)' COUl't, ,N" 1II,ltU!I' 'di':iU, UiHl'i<:t COll}:t. :'.t 9':lE'U i.l1. it wiJ,l bo:' ,kin" u!"d",I' Ii',y t<.ll'I1\(;, . I'm 1~"'Jt_ ':-i\.'~tjtJ L....l di:;n~'(.:rr thf:O ~~[i,tl:.~::.t1 "-,u ttlllPLL"I'.'tlll-I'1 1"'1""1,'1111 H"tlu' 111I\'",,'!1', 111l"I:I"II\y Itll',11 V~,,~t:WI" ,~,ff ,<I.. 1-, !:)I,II'dJl:,.1t1 I '~"_ll'l III ,t: VHd'!I'1 l';I,I,t" lil'I'1 111"";1 .:,. ~ j",j. 11;ll1(t/I':IC. "" V\"\lil'"q', .:.(' 1.111-.'11 ..l'/I', \'/il(I'/. I(t::-I"Yl[f} ,'1,,11.1;": fIne l'nIJH},'I,\:\('nlft l'tllfl;'t.'-'I'. 1'-;,,'1(,~.tt,ll,'11f1111 h:" ,,,,','ell W,\U II. VI':' I , '/1\"."1 rhlD~ t' I 'h',.1 I;, ,;-,,', ~lii\l'l Ct-lllt: ,,\ IH"l!lb'lil,II"I';' lUHt htul r"-:I~ bn~,II', [J':!J'IIH I:'t'l tljl\ I',IIJW ill'tlll 1'11,'1.:. "/i"tltl' lUI'.t Wi.H'.I'I't t"\'lfh, rn." )1'" p',Jbll'~' Itlrt.tl', thli\t r....lltllf',1 r,'I:'111 ,I tl"I,",'\tllllfl'd: 'j\l~\llty, f~jH;t'l'::".IUly tl"Yll"b1 t'(, Ihuctll1y Wh...'lt'lJYI!I" tl'lf f,I)'.'dIJr.-II' Itli\l,~ J 1;"r'ltl:\ctlJd vll',\tul' '1\I.ltIH:'l'll::. fl::I)'I:lfl1L\I'lt (-h't bl,l1th_ 1111 hCold It'd/y tlll-I,I,',lly cld'l I It: I ~.\ tl'tlat 11'1 (-t,(-" "~191l1 iH'If) ~t 1:111: c:ltl';I)")I'llt IIJYl,l ill 1l1!;1) 1~",.:oIqJI., I'p' 1'i,"\l~~tli'I'lj,\ ~':\ll. hltt" \',~. hi-: "':'I'll{', 1'1"I"d. 1'1 H-t'I' IJ':~' n,:. It>l. t",ld 11\1'1 J V/"ll,t\tj Ul.j\(1))-' PAY 1f,:W \t. "'11:11,1)0 L'lYI,'i!', I>t"lt.U L'I:\UI', )1' 1"'iH:IlUI,"""j.'. I-H+ vjo',\.E lYllutt'I,lctl1c1 t)y h(II'~.,'I'Uh I~H,llc'\t'''II' f:';I\'OfJt. IllYhl'H r.:-, hhllt tIll" vltlltn" I~,ff ~'I\y.(j 1'1'~lt dr:. t."d'I)d.:hll'lfJ f.:w III:. J ,1\il'pd L.I)'~ilJl tllH ',)j"l\!HIJ..Il"L' tl:p.l, 1-111 lH'lCf thl~Y ut!l,wl)'1 llL.t thl: fJI'1J f.'('hIIH"'YI)' (" cf,;, " lH'fH..',UIIt'U trrEt tht"';:-d,ll]h l:ht!i '1)1"1:1 hyd'"iHlt. 1 ,""",t..,.C'lIHl l,.h~L\' Fl"" F1I"':! C,,:,.. ViOllfll'lt Ik'Hl.;- (\I'ld C\J Iklt-Hi> (:""1:' C'~"tlpt"'jlllit:. illl tht'I.'Hi IH\tlf till':)' thCll,I'III-1~ tIH"fY C,,;'d,dd ,,,-", it, bl,d, l,htty h~.ljd 1,:,::. lIut 11'. ("."'lt~I~.t \tnth i. flt"8tlh~d" l,~', 1'111'1 thtT tl'I,ICII. ('lft_l'l' I'P,:rt /)1',,_1,' ~(IU i:,I',yt'hll"l] 1',:1\' AI)';",I\' 1:'1'1 h'~ol,II' J c,.~11f'1d CV I lu t.! 1.1' 1'1':\1:14, r:it'Fvr: fP 1)':-:"'11"1[;,11 1:!'~lt' I:IH'ty ''lit 1'1-, lr,t!,tl'lJct(.,>ti by thp t':"vll'ILhlP tl':lt t,', dc, ill pr'Hld',I,II"'" (Il'Ft ft.l/~ Itlt!-. ;1... '5.ti\ic, 'II \t'(:",l~rt 1';1_\ Itl\;.-..,,j t:(1 (I,::. il tJI,tt d.~)y,lI~ Wl'l'lt t,:, uw.: lV,t,':. tl,l; liD rJo 1 V (,f 1 t ", 1 {t'ld" l 110 "'! dell n ''',11' I'Jhu t ", HE. [',1\ 1 d ",. (I' I',,:,t al.It~Il-. b',lt ] \.'iijdi 1-t'-,Hl."I,lctrJtI l'I(,t (:(1 d(. thl:f tlH\t. Ho' tIH'tVI told 'M':' t';:J cl\ll l'iIRfJU CI~'Y F')",:"", 'oj, Ul11'\I'11 tl(I'::I:'~ cor,; 1 (.,(i r~I"(f-ll C(,y i\1'll' 1.'.::1<.:.:,: hiM C-_b'~1I.1t d':'li'II' thn pn:Hl:!-~t,tl"2 tt:dll~. I'h. '~;:-'l(! hr;. ""Hi ~)ot U,-,,\t''I; t" 01:' .\1:. l'lhlfl'l l .-..'dll'(l 1'11,,1 l'lh,_~, t"',,,1 /1111\ I+,::.t 1.-,', tk. lt hu nil.H,j t..:. \.'I F.',U,YI, t 1~':'1-Yq; t.;. 1:"ji'''Y. 1. t"t\SI'I';.d hlllJ why'1 ,..(..:- lu,jd 11I1 dld~,t t \.'iGrl\: i",., rJat lYIY(,lvlJd. t';'lld hllt' hl" v""",lld IHlVC, t:,:, 1 f tll"7- H,:,t l.il.tbp'~'l':'rll.\h'n 1YIt.~1 rQ1.Jl-"t, HH H,!\it.l 1'1f~ could \'i'Y 'in'lythiYq]ilh c'l=lI.n~t) i;lrld th(~)' VIC'.llrJl'ltt ~{YI'~'Vj ~\j'IY d\ffLJI"(;;\'IC'.'H. (H,:<ld, "l !;;IJUIit-l if >;.~'I.l e:.::lldo llVl: with Y('I,U" c.:.t"It'1c-ilifl'lce ~hF.\l: j 1:2 Whfd; Y':I'.l W':II,llo hi;\VO t,::-. dO::I"~ DI,.\t"'irlg All thmtH~ tll.,ppel'lilrlr]F'1 r C(l)'.I,:i"rtt!d ~IBtE!I-" l\l,lthcl\-~i t:y chc\il'/lli'\l", GatRY P,;'Vi~i. HI.} 1~">>jP("':.lfH5t~'d Ill" jq',PVJ i\ ilttll-? (Ij't whHt \..jLH~ LJ'::>ll'll1 ':'1'1 bl,lt (1il'.lYl1t I{h':~'\tl tlll;ll: 'Mlch. I 1".lpli"'ll'Il'1l thf~ vlh(,llJ nitUl\t:l('I', t;.:, hitl'. 11L~ f1.:dd WE' ,,,.,'''.dtl 11".\VI~ to::. !Jpl i\ l'll,lf'."t' hfEt 1..'1'ltl h-l (H'fH:;'l;'It.tn:, tal:tt cj('l"l-:. 1 t,:.ltl hllll \.'II~ Irl t"V" r.' I , rl)d it bef':"l'i.l t"'ll'l tl1i't: thn \.I/iltl'1l" l\I,d;h(')"lty ldwf.tyr, did )t f(ll" I,\r~, 1 t,~,ld h~M th.:ot tlt"t SI11ith \:';".)11 thfl)' hi"lyn ~l', I:hf? p.\'~t (lId ,1 ch\':_IJ'J,t'''~ l"l-!Ht i;,I',r3 1f t:i)t'.\ chl';'.'j'i,'I(' lliv81 w,:n; ~l~nh 1~-i'I'~-"lIlli, tlll.:oy dldl'I' t h.:,\'l! tr,:, d,.." .H.y (:ltIH!iR {:<?Ift. ,*f\,1.d I'Cr'WI't Y':.'.,I hnvl' hl,I,' ckl ltH, I-I", (,t\lu"lt lit y,:.II,Ij" 1'"(~f'.p";'I'lnLIJlit'/ L\y,d Y':"" wi 11 holV" to:, [Jet nVl?t'ytllll"tJ cI,:,y,e t",f"..... the WAt'rl' wlll be- ta.I)")'I(-;.d bl\C'1lt ('i',ll, J HHlrl IICl.\F'- t \.IILI bl-I 1'L:~f\E::(_'nt.ltllc,.:- f\h(>I,lt th)\i'ill 1 V;:,$id ""IHH~el E i_, 11)~';d,lp (:,f tK-IYU IlVit"!J )r, the!'!'} '-'Yld tlHlfy ctw,' t r;'~' wlth.')I_lt \.I1i.,tOI' I.d 1 vll:'el,q;'I..tlll. Hp 1:,i\HI "V.,"I,I v111) hClYCf t'~1 f\y.d thetc, ':-lthIH" tKII,t'::-:lrIO"' l'k,thll'-Iq I:'VI:'I" O.;:,t 1"1.:~:,:,lY(ni \,,:th l1i,." 1~1~f.JI.lrjtJ :3Jf.~I'1 11'1 tilE i,ft<,,'\"t("::Il'. (r:\"Jdi"y CJct,',:.(iPt' In, l'i}'-](,) fiYtr,lly tJl'::d: LI','.l.:il,lch vl\th tl'l(.., \f'i,tr;'," '~II,tltl("'lty j'll'IOlr,"-I;'I", W, l)'}vlr;Y~Ii! Dn1tll"i:;I'.du. 1 O):pli"iiI'IL'd t(1 111M l>/h._,t tl.-.rj h{\PPI~l'i1:~d, Hp c,t,id HY~~,I.I wlll l\l-'VO t.:. rJut the' PI"I?Ff".I,U'CJ tOt!,t d.~tYIL> ,1r-,tl t, bf.'ctel'il;' tl:ll="tH. t.,~,ld hll., Ill>' p)(pr~I")I:'''ICC' Y~llh Lhu "11'''' ,-.:.r'lp"(llfll,i. Ill': vliq~ l;l,wpr'i'--,t:Jd. 1 l.,t;Il(~d I'llrl' If the> I'H'L'(','~'IUI~r.~ ic ll(.l:;> tln'I';.'(ttUYI1,...U. Hn d)dYltt nive' ;'j 1I1ttH'IIlI' 1'.,11 t,il\1/ II VII/lil'l lilt I' tri,(tl,'III,1 tL'lll, 11,:dl,d) td.-:'IiJI I,.'!' ':II,."dll)lqj 1.,I/f"11 1111/ l'ill\I:I' lllf,'111 11.1.1'11:,.: 11IHI, 1,11'1. lill HI_lId 11" ~:}lJl'll t' \'1'1,""1 Il'lh J I "ult! 11'1,1, II 10", 'I I l.j, ('I:iet ct,,'I'I." ,;'yL', l'l"Il/ ~jlll,I'I!I'jtl, LIIll.;1.j I "III",'I.::L '1111111;)'( " "I j.I-"j L")lplll\I"~i";' thl.~ 'JfI,II'1I 1Jl:/l'lr l' hI ttlii,ll':Il'.. TIII'o")' \'IlHlJ \.'/11 J llll! t,:, ntl\)I (.Yll!" t 11.llf 1'(1\ 1111 \,;. !Jut: 1'11,. VlI,ttUI' tlJl,t l)'ji;(, tlll_itl" "1'01:' E:I'''].I'Il,~'h'I' VlOI'.~ ,:,,"1.';, ('!-ILl ''',' \'Ilth "'If l,..' tnl'l, 1\ \'1.\tlll' H 1,\I,qll It f";tj I' l\fH.tlf't'll\ t'Obt ':vI1I\rl', l'll/,'I' I'lf,r;I' 1'>1_\(,tl.d'l,.\ (11'''1[1) II',', \.'II} 1:"d.1111 I}( tl". h'.te-tUI' Ili.C.'14 ('1'1, l,nlctl, \,1 \'H-illf ';'1" t.I1L [',1 tit IlL" jIHIJI"C'Olol:d 'Il Wi"! VIt,')' 1,IPlt'ihl' vii t,. 1"I:q"Ii'Ht /,1)'1 I i'",q Hii'lll ttllH V.ho:.'I,I)I! I"..'V....,~ Ill,VI. l),',ll:lri" th,u Fi,.1' ,\t'ld 11':~ppl:'jlflz.J t:!, ~';f'V, 'Iho ~'Il\tlll'V VitI!; I:,(ff t,:,,' t'/II'LH {!"~)'t:. (Thl~ tl!l\rlt\rtt,., hr\l,1 l:1l.1l'"1'1 !1V\I"1l \:hld~Ii' f,_:q. 1;"VI:'1' i.1 VIE'I'I, bL(';;'1"U j-.11 th~1t '\.:,;'1(.1.. pll!\l::"", FI')dilYI Ol"t('dHJI" In,l'a'.:)('.., 1\)'-'1:".11'.(' It':I'1 PI}I, 1 VH\.U rll~.t)tlrfd by j,\ HI,d)"{~'('I'ltl"f.\t't.~I)' t1l6t: fjl1iPPIl:lI'lnLHII'li t'::l~'II"'Jh)p l"UPI-Ul$l.:I'llLlt IVlH: VH'-'I'U " L:'f'j bt,II',t'JfHH,1 C'~IIII"t, Lih' pPl'Ir.I; ht,IJ"~11 nfl, I,II'ItJ vllHl CI~q>ltIt9'11I'1l.1'ln t hrr PI"~IPf?I'ty~ nt/IUIl'I,i' LUI'llJ (C';'IOI..I l:nf...q"cu,.u'.'l'lt (,f fiCI:'>}-"), J(,!1I'. rli;'I~lj It'''~Il'.uh,p t~UI:ult'yj!!,cl)"), i\j'lll e,lel" nCI'.II,i'1' (l';-'VI\,.Gh1!-,,) HtltP)'~IYPC?) t.' )l\-i: \'~, UHt t:hn tr.d',nl,.tc- t(', uiUr-t ,:) 1I1'~,:,t:)r.'.,. .;.( [.~I)'ldl.~'ill'I~t:tl:II'.II. ThE tl~j'-II.\I'lt\.~ l'uf',\€>I'HI t,;-, r \Olt. E':' H':'fl'l-:-u.::,tly "l'~pl'[':'E:el,.tJ\-'IU thE' t('I'/ltFII:II, -.t"tRd,lt'J!.I)c:.'l"lt!y L~ fjt'.l-?-d 1-'0 r,i;;",l(!' i.'/'l,Fi. L,,,II't: hn IMti-i."\(j I',d.: thlf l;;,pt\l'I~- ~,,:c-f}iYtHJ 11yt....~"'t.".", .),:,,'11'1 l':iil'd ~.jlt""IHhUU[j thj',- t:,il~ilj\t.1.111 TtlFY Old lhJ.h', 11'j fl"("','~ (If 0::,(/"\(:,,;,," L1YEiYI dt-i-t'lIc:tl.\l.'.~ H,llirll1l~-I'1 tf1F.- tE1YltW,tu lHld ~~ HI,lb" C,~I)'ltl'i,c't':".. "It-lE-I'. tt1L-ic'Y pl.lll-:aej H">-<\:~t' "Hd (;-'~Ii'r"f'hlr,6ti.'::'I'1 ulurll', 01'1 !~I.:Vf'i'I'1 r;'':''''f'F 1-1'ld b~,ld the tlll'IE\\-'.tl:: thr-iy ',lH' b~:. ';.l,lt It'l j.t:'l l'lI:llll"'b I~q" tIll:')' C"';'oIl\(l hI" i"d")"C'I~tl?d find PI,lt il" .JilJ I, (.t'.ii.J;III,-:'U ~L 1:IIC' 1'..~,t:I'I; (,r 1",,'lll!l.r';I.:.~t j,~,j', tl',i'.~ ll--,c tl:IWlil.:'\\P/ j':t'.Lit,:1 l.':.lrlr; ti\p12d t..:' (:h", ('l-('Ylt (kH:oI '~If thE'- ~,pi',-trtlli\'lrlt lHli ldl"".n, It "'.1" ~dnl"E'I!gud t,::, lilt: ,,'I',d lilY I"'l fl.:- ':Hlt: r'..~.t tht!: ',~'vlt'H?I'.!!t 1:lf which rtO\ tlil pe\l't y vllH~ [-i'Vfn" l1io?i-"ved, T11h' t 1'~I',{,yd; r.: f';Il-'VIH,'ch:"1d i t~ 1:"';'1 t (I hll~. j,:lhYI E;t;yC'1, (.1nu~lc, L':'1't9, Gll"!l'. nlE:~E-I~t 1:lff~CI:H"B Fr"(inc:h 8'''ld Hl.\t,lff,.l._,I" end 6e~U8ant RabR~t N. Van Bcyoc Illegally trespassed onto thu pt"l;Jpli'I..ty iYI vi,;:tli:\ti.':'rl I'::'f thu r~OCA Nn.ti.':,r-I",l Pl,~,:tpet..ty tll;ait'ltc,:.Yti:W,CE- C(-,ciU'/ l''::;''~:t.. "k', YI':tt i CI~r. \"'I~l>n n 1 y,-"y, '~'l. (""'('1'1 .;:,t tEHtlpt ed t (_, bu fJ 1 YUl't t th(: ':'Wf/G," I",y,(j/,_:"" l~eEpO:tl'/oitJl(} P(E-'-EO::'I'lt vl,:,lr:.=<ti.l'll1 sect:l(It'1 PI~I'" ll:I~~..:'. 1('5..1, !<It::,,'a, 1':17,1_ 1')7.;;.:, l(I.',:~,. ,':17./1, iW'lrJ 11:18..3 I:lf till: t'lOCrl COlj(?~t,tt[,chp.(1). 'tho pl::I'~f!Ot'1 (.'I~ pE'I~r.:,;,wlff i"ffHctc!(l by th1.p- ,--"-r:t h':';H tWG'rlty (12';1) dl\Y15 tl'::. l.\ppeE\l fl-'(.ttt\ the;: d.:.tt-., L,F-:t"ynd. ,:\cc(".IMdiYlfl t.:, 'Et~C't).I:'t" PI'I....1.11,1 ':If tilt:: f;:'l()cn C'~":~F- (,~.tt..'1ched), TIHOlVfJ Vli;~r, I't<' (1'111,-, t:j1.vel'. t.;, ("1ppocd, ll:!t 1:.1':01'10 iQ'I)' t',.::d:iel" '~Jri'l'v('uj. 6l\tl,H~dBY, Oct,:dJIi?I" 1'3, 1';)96, ,.:Jft Jc(H~ 1'{al"lfftltiHr. p'.llled 11"1 rRt 11:':tt=j~~ PItt', I t.'PP1-"OE\C!ic,rj hittl fll"Hl i"d,,,lu:_lt; 11. I r:O:II.lld hfllp 1'11111, He Gf\1d he l'WS t/''li?t~E by ver,ll,un:t ,:11: the t'~'I.>IYILlhlp. I i\a~((?rJ hi.., if ho hr.H; ,,;\ C('I,It"t .:'t~Uel~ t.':-l which he' l"I":'p1.1(0( ""k,". 1 t(lld hin, thflt hn V/t-,\: tl>ep.:ptH!-sll'ltJ l:wrd thi..t hr::> cl,:1I.11d IrJt,YIJ, H<l? Ii:i.'l.d tl1ol\t hl~ didl~,lt he..,,(; ta;:, lr:f\vf1 l\\".rJ {'Iti-,yr:d. flfflcr>l~ F,'c.'r',<:tl fHlllcd 11', J\t It('.!; p,'tl, J.::,hl'l r'j,'I"lJ "H.d Glr~lrl ('h:ipf~l~ p',llll.'rJ 1-... j,t; l~l',1/1 p,r,l. itt i.\ pi(:,14,-",IP tl'uc:ll v/lth plYVI(,,:,d litld a:' (-h':iiv'f~.~\I'" 11'1 t.hl" lii\cll, t "Ppl""('t.-\Chf~cJ .le'/HI ric,l~fl ,0;.1'10 t.;.,ltl I'll'" tlli',t h,-, "II'!':' tl~c'~"(lf;.~"~',iyqJ ";.Ytd lYlf("o\"flll?d Ill/I' tl'li.t ho h.,(' rIHVI1I" HI?I~Vecl lWIYOy.l'2'. HI? f-ii\\d, III th.:..,If]ht Arloelt1 to,:oI<. Ct\lM(? (,f tl1.::.t", I tii\irl,I11),::., yell,l hilVE' Iw~:,,:,f .:.f \-l.,E-I'V;CfJ"',l I).;\l-d !!..,iri, III dt;,j-'t't I{\-'t(_'~l l. t Clhf.l ((.)Yt[lf.'l tt LOYln) d,-:,r.~',;:. I ck,,"- t ~u'-'('If' vlh,.,t I-_~h(l hIH~II. 1J!'rlCI!, "ILIIl'I \.'\'111 ~"dijJlI ,",,,hI. ""'111, l' 'I) ,.\ '1 tIll' t I ~ vii'." I ','IAI) I"F 111.'1 I" t.;. I I.I'!-I'U J'JI'UI./ ,..,'r "11:1 1',,!ollff'IllIlI'1 hh..'\l tIll ') ti::/q(l, I.,'"'' ,"II tllb (I"!';!',", l'lhl!HI thtr)-' vll"I"!., IJ':'11',U t(. PI'<"'(H/r! l,:, h'."j1t'O t'/l' pr':'phl't)'1 l'1I1t,} ,:.fflCI!I' ':"1;11'1':.11, "Y''''',l rh.:,w .." 1'/111)1'1. llli ':<,ll':'~IIJIj P"':'III'.'I' I" "j:I~I:I.11 I;' "'YI(l a~,.\'t,>lj IUlJn' 1,..:,llCUIJ,I'. I l\lti." t:",:" ,',f' t 11':111' "1'0"111, tlli,t II 1'1" hlli '"nen('l'iljllJ~ 11ty l.. "".,l'l' \:1,11'" t'll,lt. t'll'''}! 'l:':'vlllf."llfJ) J,IIVl: 11:li" 1'1 ~;ht t:.;. lH:.t '~"'I thn PI'(lfJbl't )1, 110 III" 111, 'N,'.. J' hi hlrl.d l.;, liL.H,' th..,{ t'l':,t h 1.1"1; Ill}'.:t: Vl('11ul'.t ", I t.:.lI: thO/.1 thnt- thl-:'Y ~'Ili:'l'l~ 11'1 vI",Int 1,;,,'1.:.1' 'I' \1 1111).1.,:,( thn U.~;. C>:I(f(i-(drolp.'lViltl(II'1 '~If t"lUht:u), t1':dlrtl"t Ill, V,'-l'l Gt')1C'C tlh....'vHHt I,I(J iil l' (I'~i fl. ,.1, Offl.C6t' f;'"t'It-t'u:I'1 IHdd tli~t Ilu Vh;EI',' t U(,~r"J iHlywl'IIU'l"'I' -,Itlt 11 tIn: i;':I\.'/l'H!hlj:1 c'-:'I.lfJll..ttHI tllt1ll' J'~,"l~ HE' t'\lr~"~' {1,t1\tl, lilt: tklr:lHY,' t hl.\Vl'~ t,r,y~hlr,o toe, I',', WIth f:/", I'JIl:i <:'vl1 11~IJ)llty ,""', ,'," cIvIl "IUIlI r:I:.th.'f. N.~,th)I~19 V~hl'tt::C.ItVHI,II. 1 hl!;.ld thB-\: thE' C'(Il.ll't C Ii' y, dl'H:idn tllt,t. OfficG'" Vi,~I'1 F~cy(..c tHI),U,IITh.:.\t't: '"),uht, tht.;. C'.:du't cor,.... dl~c1dr.. It, We.'~e (,,:,t IF.'l(IO t.~. dlfC'ldl? II IUi-n;> tl:'C~>,Il. r~lC:-)1 l"~: 11 )1',1;) ntr.-LJ thHY WU.I~l~ lVdl'lt} t,;. /1,".,,,'1'-'.1 1 \;:i\lC, l'I"il"O. bl.lt fll'l,t uh':'~'1 1'0'1:'1'1:. thF pI' ':. (..1 PI (1.:.11 ':'ViE:,(j It. l'=lftf~t' c Jrdi"utll'.l dpOF.\tr.' .1(dl~1 J:i'U'(J {~1''j(1 (~1f..:1" (f';p",' tHft \1'1 p:..c:I'.....I.lC,. 1'hul'l VL\I'. [Jcy.;:.c' I.H~I~lid 1M':, "WhEt cd.l.... tllL'r}' lio.Ylt'1I1 Y';:H.lt VI!: Oo::,r,ff Vi>:', lI'H.'~Il'ln hlH'U',lll I t:....lcJ... I d'"II'.' t Iq'I'.'~'I." Thl-'t'. ll:l-'\O. "LlIJn 1 licd.d. 1 (klt'I't ',II'IOOI"I;t':\I',O," ill'l. Y' "I ';"".I'HJ \.. Ij"""; '. I F't 'I, jjl..f ,t {t. 'I"l" ,I, ./" ~ "":"1 II' II", () I' l' 1.'11.' I' II,,,... f 1/, 11 t 41 ,"j ~~: t '-. I! I : t I f I,' , rlaB'-'1 ltlrl'tl'r,';I"i: thl-i PI"':'lwn'ty, pi-.':C_'l.fll.l,"r:l.:. I'I{' I.j. <;1'1,' th,,'( hr: Or. T'.{UUCJ/.y ()ct,~,,)[;'l' f"~~'t l'('I'tJ(1 tlui' t"'~'lIn'IH"',lp nt,tp("I"Vlfl':ol''f. .J.;.ht'l I.'[\)"u i:\rl{! GE-1Erl (h!ppt' i\l'.d (lI'IUe1i.\ 1..(>1'111 lo.!":''''I!J wl~h ,.\tt.~.t~t'H7Y F.:.t'Ht:t /l:YI,;:I" ch-?tutcti.Yl,! 1<), lllYIfJcH", rClH'I"'Y PI?I",.y ( t~t1PI'Ci't,H"lt 11"fJ (-he tHi.~IIIF.:'t~ c\l.lt~l,:'t.~ty) .\I'ICJ (h't S'.I1th ()'P,P"Hl.2t;l'lti)-',{] thl;' WL,tl?t' c.t,tth(t,'ity) sh(,.,ad ','p <It the fwope,'ty vlith l\ l;e'I>t'ch V'M"'l>y,t f"or" l1l<;trlc:t J~II,tiee n'~r'<lld 0<11111. The stllweh wl>t'nmt W"'l! fN' 25 'H,d 85 Sur/beaM CCIl.lI..t. Thl9 P.:tun"ch lI"ii\I'I~f\l'lt (BUlf ttt t ached) at lilt ~H t h 1.\ t t h [' pt";:lplH'ty Cillll'lL-t' ."nfl.It~IH~ t(:-. pClj''''it I?Ylt.'y t.:, pt"l:tllliElrEJ, t.:, 11~II:!PL?Ct thl' pt'\":.per-ty pi":I'til'lny,t t(. thl'? ,".q"dll'H'l'.C8G (IF thl,;> t(-:'vlt"lship (,f ~ihlPP(:I'.E:b',wn.,.. Thf-.~t'l.~ W..15 \',flVI:t' ~r,y "'I':lt il:'f::' r;:r?)"vnd .:.t' <:Ol'.tt.H;t\~ t.ll\de t.:.. 1I'II~pl?ct thl:: tll.tlll1i I"U. ThHt"uf(lt-(t.', n.;.body WtH:. f'vt:n" l'r..fl.lf:c.r t.:J lrwpect tho ~'Jt~'~lpet'~ty. Thpy rt'('CfJQCt~rf 'Vito th8' buil(1)"'.Jt tl\lor-Ql P\ctl.\l"lEC (,f thn l\pnl'tIIH/l'ltF: \.dth I!\ viclf--"-:,, T,::wJI',r:hlP t:.I,lprH"v~n~:,t.. ,JOh.'1 f-lt".d Iw.d .'ltl(oJ'I'.I.~Y F':II'I:~'l Myt.-"t~H t ,"iF.'d t..;. t.....ln: ',:d.:, d.::..:-.t"l~ .:.(( .:.( ttll~ hll'l{JV"'''' t.:-. rJl?t \"ltC' ,:,1"1 {;pc,,'tr.1U'I',t thc-l' \oJ.'-t-; }':I(,:l/f!l: Or-I WOdYIl:-:'Gdf1Y nC'to:,bet~ i~'~, l':Y;J(, nlnlt"ict ,h\fi>t iCI:- JJ.:.rleld 1J"",,ihl i561"ed ~rl':.lhfH" 5(111)"r.h Wl\t""ElI'lt, (1r'f}ell\ l..;-,y.U. .1fte:,"" 5Ql\Se(t~hlr"lpLJt"II.:bl.lt'l] L(,,:"'('I.lf1tJ [':II,II'IC11 PI"(t~~ldl':>t.,t)1 JJeYly,t~_ McNl\Ete)- (Chip" (If P'~ll1Cl:>), (,ll':i't f-h:.pe.t- ,/IYld l\ I,I''''lY(H''Glty fK'.l ic:r-.lf,l(.t', YII~I',t t,'---"'.:dlllh thn !J1.llld1rq) "'O..\il" ti...ki(tL ytdf?I~' ptct',lt'P.'i (.f thC-C'I" pt~lVt-.tl~ .1pr.l"tt,H_'ntl'"t nlt~lt'lct ,fuLt1CC Ik'YlillcJ Di'lhl tllL'{Ji\lly 1r,~.il.lr?d the hE.,-.~'ch Y'f.\t't~8Yltf'i. Thpl~r) w.:tn ~'jI) pl~,:,bi\blfi' Ci.\'.I!:il.i' to 16!5Ur~ tIH?f.!.-C? Wl.H~I~i\l'lt!r. ht:Cltl,1 !-:.r.; h,:dJ('ldy \'HI\; (~V(~l- ) ,...f',t'/,(.'rJ t (. i r.'~ P(~C.' t t he pl'~('r.Hn~t i (:.>!.~ fll'ld thr.'t~l:!' \",i'.l I...... ["':'Ci,\ 1:".:.dI:J vll:,l.Jt 1('l'l!~ ':-'Yt ttll:" fJr.'1I"t (If tllo t..'-Yld OWYIC"t~, . l'i' f' ..,. , .:.. f:'1'. t; I I " lJ): [', '" U'; :-' ( t I,' .1' (.J \/1 l..JI ' ) .,r# "I . i I , , . . (J! . . '" ~ \{1 ~ ~ ~. ,... .... ,.- ''''J ,1 r .. i.f. .. IIj" .',j 'r" ~.~ I ~'f. r -' ,,:.. ~ i1 -\1 ~Jl .;:, . ;'IJ l' <'I 1;', I' ;.. 1m iJ.t ~ ., 11.1. I ... .J I.', ,,] \, I '" U "