Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06332 :~ ,,~ /~ :i.f . I ~ I I H I . .... I . \. " -4l '" lIS 4 ~ I "'I'l 'd , .'i I II ~ j ji I( !.'ll , '", , ,: i.~ , J i '. I' ~ \. " -- >... " I l ~ ~ r I I' - . .. .0 - CJ r.J. C'l1 f(1 .J , , 1,1 [Ipllllllllllllllllllllll IlIId hl'lid, dIM'IIlCI) I C'IIIC~I~ IlIId IChllllllhCh IiIlIC hCCII C~dlllIlI1Cll 1IIIlic "Ill ~ \"111111) 11"111111 I~, llplllllll/illl1l1lll1ll1ll/lIl hcliei', dl'llll~llIlIlIh Iillw hcclI ~IIll1hl,'lcd IIl1d l'IIllIplclcd lillllll lil~llI'llIlc~~c~ IIllhc VlliI, \ '1111/11)' 1)(111111 Ill, [lp'llI 1I11il/lIl1ll11111 111111 Iidlcf, Iillhillly IIl1d "IIIIIIIIlC~ ':~pCII '~lllll'l~ IHll'c hcclI cxdlllllllcd hclllCCII Plllllllllrlllld Ikl'clldllllll{clIll/lllhllllllllic VOl'k ("1111")' 1I~1I11/1 17, I\IOhShcl'H II liS 1I11ll1ol1l1~d of, 11111' dl" Illlil/llclplllc III, IIIlY III' Ihc pklllIJII1!6 IIl1d/ol' IlJmlVcl'Y 11~1I1'lIlch set lilllh III Plll'lllllllplih dCICl1 (II) IllIIIlIllh hlXlcCII (I (II. I H, llpllll Illlil/'II1I1I1'l/lllI1d hdicf, Ihc "ol'k \ 'IIll11ly' IIC II 111I Is I'clldy lil/' 11'1:11. 1'1, Shollld Ihc ('lIl1lhcl'llIlld COli III)' IIClIoll hc II'IIllsli:n'Cll III "'Irk COllllly' IIl1d CIllIslllidulc" willi thlllllct,oll, Ikli:lldllllll\tohshcl'll Ilill hc IIl1lilil'l)' pl'cjlldiccd, ::l~\: l1WiIlrilil.li..M1I1 !.wi, Cu, Y..MJJJJ:J:, Slllll'll, (holdillg 1111I1 il is II lIlullcl' III' Ihc COllrl's disCI'CliulI Whclhcl' UI' lIul hi cXcrci~c cOll6uli""lioll IIl1dcl' RI/k 21 ](11), 1111" Ihlll Ihc Rllk IlllIsI 1101 hc cxcl'ciscd ill lill'ol' <If Clll1~IlIl"UllolI WhClllhcl'c is II plJlclllill1 of pl'cjlldicc 10 IIIIY pllI'ly), fJ'11 ccd III'1IWb1llJ:.\:..ulJJ1.\:-.t' UJIIJH:rJUJlJLf':!l.lIJ!Jy-Al:JJJlll 20, 011 01' UhUlI1 NovcllJhcr 19, I 9'1Ci, I'llIilllilfil1Slillllcd Ihi~ IIclillll hy Writ OfSlIllJlIlUIlS IIgllill~1 Mosshcl'g, 21, 011 or IIhOll1 )111111111')' 2, I'N7, Ihc Wril'lr SlIllllllOIlS II'IIS scrwd 1111 Mosshcrg, 22. 1'IIIIlllllfls I'CpI'CSClllc" ill ClIllIhcdlllld \'lIl1l1ly hy A\lIlIllC)'S l'iscllhcl'g 1111" ZIIJIIC, Ihc SIIIIIC COlIlIScl 1111I1 I'CprCSClIls hilll illlhc "ork CUllllly IIClIOI1. 21 Thcrc II liS 110 dllCkclllClilil)' Illlhc ('lIllJhcdlllld \ '011111)' IIclillll hclllcclllhc )lIl1l1l1ry 2, 1')1)7, AllhlllVlIlIr SCl'vj~c 1111.1 Ihc Octohcl' ,\ 1,2000, RChpollsc or I'llIillliffil1 OppoSlliolllO 1~lIlc .4.. \II Show CIIIISC Why CIISC Shllllld 11111 hc 1lIsI1l1~~cd lill'IIIII~lil'lIy, A II'1Ic IIlld 1'lllrccl copy uflhc t.'lIl1lhcl'lIIlld CIIlIllly' dllckl:ll~ IllllldlCd hCI'Chl II~ I':,xhlhll "c." 24, lIy Ol'dcl' of Jlldgc Okl' dlll,:<I N,)wllIhcr H, 2000, Ihi~ IIClioll WIIS tclllllVC<llhJllllhc purllc list. 25, 011 or IU'llll1lllllcl'clllher 21,21)1)0, 1'IIIIIIIIll'pclill')lIcd Ihi~ ('<lIu1Io 11'1I1l~1i!1' Ihi~ IIclioll Iu Yorl, ('<llllllY 1'01' po~~lhlc cOllsoli,luli'lll 1\ Ilh 1'llIlIllill'~ cOlllllllllioll ~u~c illlhu! I'CIlUC, 2C1, lIy I1lillg lhis AI1~wcl', Ncw MlIlIcl' ull<ll'c1ilioll, lklim<llllll <llIcsllol wuiYc Ihc rillht 10 lIhjccllo sCl'l'kc orpl'occs~ illlhc ('Ulllhcrlulld (\IUl1ly IIl'.lillll, lli:I~IlllJUl.lb-ElIJilJw.Jlul JllllWII~II1Jlf..N!lJlJ.'.J:JJJdlL(:lImbmu II d C ou III)' 27. Ul1dcr I'clll1~yl\'UllilllulI', IlI1ul1dllC dclllY hy II plllil1lill'ullcl' II Millis ClllJ1lJ1cl1cc<lls groul1<1s 1i.11' Ihe CllUl'llo dCIlY rccovcry hy 'Ir<lcl'll11! 1111011 pros of the lIeliol1, SJ:J: rJlIJJJIllhcl' 1'..IJm:JJ;h llilJi\lilll1 ^s~UciUlhJJLl.liEhjJJI~lJ:JllbjJI, .125 I'u 112, 22M A,2d 732 (I %7), 2M. OVCI' ri.1Ur (4) ycurs 11I1I'C elllpscd ~illcc Ihc Wril uf SUIIl1J10l1S wu~ Issued III CUllIbcrlllll<l ('OUllly, 29, To dllIC, 110 plcu<lil1l!s huvc hcclI I1k<l. 110 dlscovcl'Y hilS bccl1 cxchullgcd Ul1<1l1o dcposiliol1s hllvc hccl1 cOlldUclcd il1lhc CUlllbcl'lun<l COllllly IICliol1, .10, I'llIinlifl'slililurc 10 prllscclIlC Ihis uclion <lelllollslruIC~ II hh;k or<luc diligcllcc, ::iJ:J: Slf.1ililll,..i:.IlllJ1llUni1~B:.tJlLllillillilJlJ, 529 I'll. ]60, 36], f103 A. 2<1 1011, 1012 (1992), .11, I'lullllirfhus dClllonsll'lllcd 11" cOlJ1pclling I'clIsonlilr Ihc <lclIIY, ::iJ:J: W. U. I'llIilllitrs deluy hus cuuscd prcju<llcc III Ilcli:ndunl Mossh':l'g, ::iJ:J: w.. ]3. Irlhcrc IIrc c0lJ1plllJill11 CIISCS arising Ihlllllhc ~IIIllC sClorlilCIS, Ilcrcll<lulll i~ cnlilk<l lUll JUdgll1C1l1 oi'Non Pros whcll "lInc orlhc IIcliolls \VIIS III1Clldc<llll Wilh diligclll pr'lscclIllull, while .5. I'V:i',11I ('1111I1111' 1 II lid t'lIllllly l"lIlllllllllldlY'1l Of' 1"11 1'1 V II ,'dill' 11"1"11 Y 1'1'/1, II" II.' 1'11111.:11 1~^11I< I VIII MIII,I,III.:III; 1 N" Pdqll 111'11'1"1111' Nil,. t , "'d' 'I'y\,,"" , ,I WIII'I' 'II' 1,1I1.1M'INI. ,/1/11"11I1111 II"',: ,lIil Illdl'" ^IHi 1IIIIIId t III ~q IIlti I'd I h Iii I' 1 {'''liU {'III11I1lPIlI /0 1'11'I.t....'" .1 'I' flllt, , .,. I., I I':~I" 'III 1'111 "'" I., ,'III Y 'I', I,ll , , , , /11'11"11"'" Ilol'", '1111' l',1 I, I , II'I l'l I ~,I 1I1I 'J 11'/'1" '11'1'1 11/110/11111111 11/1111/11111111 l ~ I .. I .. I ,. ,. .. .. I .. .. ,. .. , , .. '" .. . . .. .. . .. . . . , .. " . " .. .. .. .. .. .. .. , .. .. .. . " .. .. , .. .. .. . .. .. .. .. .. .. II .. , , . . . '" II . , .. .. .. . '" .j " '" ';"11"1011 111""" ^""lflllY 111111 I'IIIW" r~^III< 11',1, I':I'I'I.I-:Y III J^" I.I!,'II^N I' 'lillIlIllI I'^ I'I,^I N'I'I 1'1,' "^'llllll.l, ,I^fIlI':li II I , II', '. "lll~i:i"I':IHi I Nt' "/" 'i1';<lIl';I-:^ N ICII<lI.M, I 'ill^lilitl ^VI:NIII': 1/1111','11 II^VI':N '''I' 11(,0 I III': I"':NI IM"'I' I l , , . .. .. '" . .. , , .. .. '" .. .. . . . . .. . .. . . .. .. . . , . . .. . . .. . . . . .. .. . . . .. ~I . , . .. . .. .. . . . .. . .. . . . .. . .. "" .. .. . .. . .. .. .. . '" .. .. I)d I I' ":111.1' I Itli .. l , , , , , . .. " .. '" '" . " '" . . . . , . . . .. . " . . . '" .. . '" .. .. .. , . .. . . .. .. . . II .. . .. . '" . , . .. , , . '" . . . .. , .. .. . .. . . . " . . , .. . I: " , 1'11111'1' i':""'I'IIY 1/1'1/ 1'1"" I'IIM;CII"': I,'<lll WIII'I' <ll' l,lIMMo""l; ,,.., CIVIl. ^"'I'ION WIlI'I' Ill' I'"MMCINH 11,IBIi':1l 1/0.'/1'1'1'1 MTIIJ^VI'I' 'IV lit.:IlVln: 10 I III ),11011 I '/11'1/" 111111 '.'OlnOIlO I.!!:, I nooo I,'o"nooo I'I.^ I ""'1' 11'1" Ii 1li';:iI'ONlil'; 1 N OI'I"lIi 1 'I' I ON '1'0 IHII,I'; 'I'<l 1,II0W CMllii': WilY CMiI'; lillolJl,II NO'I' III,; III liH' 1'lit,;I) I'<lll I ""M:'I' I V I'I'Y IIY I';IIIC li Z^,I^,: ^'I"I'Y 1'011 1'1.1'1' 011111';11 01' COIIII'I' IWI'I-:tl I I II 00 1 N III'; )000 1'1I111ii': 1lI':,i^,IIlJ ""'i III-;cl.;N'I' ^,"I'IV"I'Y ON '1'111': "^I"'; '/'111'; CM'i': IIIM'I' m: IlEM<lVi':III,'IlJM '1'111,; OC'I'ollEll \I WOO I'lIllCiI'; 1,1/"1' ,I W'::II.EY 01,1'; I ,II ,I NC)"'ICI';li M^",Im \lIIM:C1l"'; FOil 1,II''I'I'''''i CMiI'; FOil ^'.Il;IIMEN'I' PIo^IN'I'IFF'H I'E'I'I'I'ION '1'0 'l'Il^N:W';II VENII ,; IIY EIU C Ci Z^,/^C 1';:;rJ ^'I"I'Y FOil I'IoFF 1'1o^'N'I'IFF'li I'I-:'I'I'I'ION '1'0 'l'II^""IWI';1l VI,:NIW IIY EIlIC Ci Z^./^C NI"I'Y Hili I'I.I'F 111/101'; '1'0 lillOW eMlliE "^'I'EII 1212~/OO IN IlE \lI.FFIi I'I-:'I'/'I'ION 'I'll '1'll^NIiFI';II VENIII'; ^ 1IIIIoE Iii J IiHIIEI) III'ON IIEF'I' '1'0 IiIlOW CMIIiI': "";F'I' lillM,1. FlI,l': ^NIl ^NI;WI':Il '1'0 '1'111': \l1-:'1'J'I'ION WI'I'III"" ),1 ll^Yli OF 'l'IIE tINI'I'; OF '1'III:i OIlIlI':1l MO'I' I ON IiIlM,1o III,; IlI':C IIlEII IINIIEIl I'^ II C I' 20(,1,/ . 11I-:1'0:;1'1'IONli 'iIlM,1. COMI'I.I-:'I'EII WI'I'IIIN 1') "^YIi OF 'I'IIE 'INJ'E OF "'III:i OllllEIl ^'HiIlMI';""'I' 1;1I^1.1. liE 111':1.11 ON III '110 I ^'I' '~IO \1M 'N CIl I OF 'I'lli': ClIMIIEIO ,^NII COlJN'I'Y O)lIlI'I'lIolllit'; C^1l1.1 :iJ,I': I'^ /1111 EFIi IiIIM'I' m; liIJIlMI'I"I'EII ^,I' U:MI'I' 'i "^Yli 1'1l101l '1'0 '1'111'; ^'HiIlMI';N'I' IIY 'I'IE COl/ll'I' ,I WI'::iIoEY OIoEII ,III .1 COp II';:; M^ I 101m 1/210' Ior,H'I' I':~''I'IIY .. ,...,,, ... ..." ,. '" "'.. '" '..", I.". '" ...",,,. I.,...."......,..."...,....".,.,...., .,., . 1':IlCrllW Jntonlllll.llln . . """'" ""1'111111 11,',/11;11 I'VIIILIl/^d} End 11,11 . ",... ......,. ,..""..,"'''' ",..,. ".."""~..""" I.,..,."................"'.... vllll'I' 'iI" la/MMoNI' .I'i,OO .l~,OO ,00 'I'^X ON WIII'I' ,~O ,!iO .00 :il':'I"I'I.I':MI';N'I' r"oo ~j , 00 ,00 ,If 'I' 1-'1':1': r" no r. , 00 ,00 ,,'-. . ~)() 4 ~,'iO ,00 ,,&...... ..."',., .,....,. ,.". .,..,,, .......,......"..........;...................." & 1':lId III CdHrl Inforlllrlllnfl . ~ ~'" "'.,. ....... "'.", I......" ,..,."......................,..........................,. IN '1''''': ('Olllt'!' ()Ii COMMON IIU:Mi ('Ul\lIl1ml.ANU COUN'I'Y,I'I':NNSYI.V ANIA MAlIK \'OIlHI~. NO, 'Ih.h.B2 Plulllllrr v, O,F, MOsSIllHW & SONS, INC, Dcrellllul\I CIVIL ACTION. LAW UIUHI~ AND NOW, lhls .!uyof .2001. IIpOll cOl1slllcrullollllflhc PclitlOIl or Plllillllll' Murk Yollcl' 10 Trul1sfcr VCIIIIC of lhls UCIIOll rrom Cumbcrlul1d Coullly, PCl1l1sylvlIl1lul<1 Y<lrk Clllll1ly, PCl1l1sylvul1lll, ul1l1 UpOIl cOl1slllcrullolI orul1Y J~CSpOllsC III Opposllllll1, III~ OlmERED UII.! DECREED liS rollo\Vs: I, Plull1llf1's MOIIllll III Tnll1slcl' VCIIUC llrlhl~ uclilll1 is GRANTED; :>.. DcrcllllullI's Pclllioll 10 DI~lIliss lhis Ilclloll 1'01' Il1uclivity is dlslllisscll ulld Is rcJeclcd by virtue llf thc 1I0clrlllcs of "lu\V or Ihc cuse" ullll/or /'I!S jflt/iccll(/; 3, Thc Prolhol1olury is illsllllclClI 10 Irul1sfcr lhis liIc 10 York COUl1ly, PCI111sylvU1111l ul lhe cosl orl'llllnlilT, BY THE COURT: ~Md> ~ cd'tLdv/ 07 dM.4 , V\~ ~ ~~ J~ ~tl.. V, J, 1,1. It IS ihlllllllcd ollly thai MIIIIC dISI'OICI)' rC'illcsl, alld ~I,III1C 1'I'Sp0I1S1'S hlll'c hccl1 c.\chllllgcd Illlhc YOI ~ I "llIlIly 11,'111111. IliscllI cry IlIlhc Yor~ ('llllllly IICIIIIII, h011 C\ cr, Ih 1101 dllSl'd IIl1d IS ul1g'lllIl! I~. Ilcl1kd. Ilcklldllllllllllkch III1Cl'lIl1l1y illl'OIl~ISICIII alkgllllllllS. Spccilklllly, ill I'lIl'11grllph 110. ~ I lcl'clld II 11 I sllIlc~ Ihal II "Is II illi'llll ~II'lI\kdllC Ill' illliml101llol1 ~lInklellllO Iiml1 II IIchcr liS 10 Ihc lrulh or Ihc 1I1'C1'IIIClIls rcgllrdlllgllic disclll 1'1)' IIcliI il)' Ihlll hilS Irlll1sl'lrcd illlhc Ylllk ('Ollllly CIISC 10 Ilhkh Ileli:lld,1I11 is 1101 a pall)'." Olllhc IIlhcr hlllld, 1IIIIIIkcs hCIWlI1 rcprc~clllllllol1s, hC1!11I1l1I11! hcrc, as III IIIc SllIIlIS orllic d"clllcry IlIlhc York ('OlllllY IIcliol1, II is spcdlklllly dCllied thlll all racl II III1CSSCS Iialc hl'l'll dCllllscd illlhc York ('Ollllly aClillll, No ClII'llOI'llIC dc~ll!l1cc dcpositiolls hlll'c hCClllllkcl1. Thc dCpllsltllll1 or 1'IIIIIlli 1'1'. Wi l'c hilS 1101 hcclI lilkcll, IlIdccd, illlppcllrs as Ihllllgh Ihc IIllly ,kpllSillolls Ihal hal'c hcclllakclI IIrc Ihlllor I'lailllilf I\Il1rk Yoder IIl1d his hl'<lllicr. I (I. DCllied, II is spcci Ikally dCl1icd Ihal allliahlllly IIl1d dlllllllgcs cxpcrl reporlS hlll'e hccll cxdHlIlgcd il1llic York COllllly IICIIIIII, Olllhc cOlllrury, 110 lillhilily CXpc1'1 rcpol'llllls hcelI prodllced hy Ikl'clldllllll{ClIlillgloll dcspllc ils rcprcsclllaliollllwl II cl'Clllllally will d<l so, 1;lIrlhcl'Il1orc, 11<1 "illdcpcl1dcllt" Il1cdklll CXIIllIilllllioll hilS yct hCCIl pcrlill'll1cd 1I1'01llhc I'llIil1lirrill llic York Cllllllly acllon. 1\11'. Ylldcr is slillllllder IrcIIllllcllllill' Ihc injllrlcs hc SIISllIllICd illlhis IlIddcnllllld 11<1 Ii 11111 dial!lI11sis <II' pr<lgllllsis hilS hCCII llIadc. 17, Ikllie,llIs slalcd, 1\1 SIIlI1C p<lillt, l\I<1ssllcrg II liS illl'olvcd IIllhc York ('<llIlIly aclIIIIl hy virlllC <II' illwl'lllg hccll 1I1111lclldcd hy I lel'cndlllll RClllillglllll, III IIIlY CI'CIII, wlicther III' Ihl[ ~IIIsshcl'l! WIIS Iloli lied III', ,)r pllrllclplllcd ill, allY Ill' IIIc pklldillgs IIl1d/lll' discol'ery aclll'ilics is IlTdC1'1I111 10 IiiI' issuc <lrlhc 1\/lllllllllll lrullsli:1' VCIIIIC alld III llic isslIc orwhclhcr Ihis IIclillll ,II,lIlld hc dislllisscd lill' IlIck <II' IIdil il)'. Sw I'llIillli Irs' IIncr. allllchcd, I H. Ilclllcd. ()lIlhc l'lIl1l1o1ry, Ihc YlliI, (""lllly 1I~II'"1 '" 11111 rClld) "11'111,,1 1\ II 1IlIIII IIlhcl' Ihll1l!~, Ihl' dcf'cllsc Illlh,' \'Ilrk ('IlUl1ly i1(11I1111",s 11111 p1lldIlC~d 0111)' IllIhlllly rCllllllh Nil "llIdcpClldel1l" IlICdlClI1 CXill1UllIllllllI"rlhc 1'1,l1l1l1lfhll~ h~~l1llcrillmll'd, IIlth'IUl!h II~ sdlcduhllll I",s heclI di~l'lIs~c" hCIII'cclI (llllll~d IIllh.1I111'1I1111 N'll'llIlhlnllc dCSIIlI1Cl' dl'P"'"IIII1~ hlllC hcel1 IlIkcl1 il1lhlll CilSC. IlIdccd, Ihc dlSl'lllcry rChlhlllS~S fly Ikl~lIdlllll RCIIII1I1Jlllllllllhllll'lI~c IlId,(lIlc Ihlllll hils yCI hI supply IIddlll'lIl1t1llllill'lllllll'lIl i1l1d IIII1ICIIIIIs hI Ih~ 1'IIIIIIIIIfllllhc Y'II~ ('IlUllly IICllol1, il1dudil1ll, hUllIllllll1l1lcd hI, IIISIII'IlI1(C IIlr,)rI111l1l111111ll'l)"n C\PCIIIClhlrlh 1I~1'1) 1/ II I IIl1d CUllIplllilllS 'II' III1t1filll(1I11l1S I'Cllllrdlllg Ihc pl,"hll'l tl{1'1l1/21 I IIChl"IlISC hlllllllll "l/cf'clldluIIIS il1lhe pro~ess orculkclillg Ihc 1I11<II'lIl1l1iol1 r~'llIcslcd III IhlS IIIIClTlIglIlllI}."I. Acwrdil1l!ly, lhc Yllrk (\IIlIIly ,lcliolllS dCllrly IIlII "I'elllly filr lrilll," I ,/, I kill cd liS il rclc I'll II I. Thc issllc 111'11 hl'lhcr III' 1\llllhlS IICII'III hhllllhl he cumolidlllcd Wllh Ihc OIlC ill YlIrk COUllly 11111 hll 'II II hi 1{lIle 21,1(11) 1\111 hc 1I11111l1cr IiiI' Ihe Ylllk Cl.llll1ly COllrl UI1CC Ihis IIcliulI Is Il'IIl1sfi:nd, i I' Ihlh 111I1111l'i1hk ('IIl1rllll'llllls Ihe rclicr (1Il'rclllly rC4l1c~lcd by Plllil1li 1'1' MlIrk Yudcr, IlIolhcr wurd~, lhc IS~lIc i~ l1ul rillc IIl1d Ihh Ilul1umhlc ('lIun (UIII1,,1 preelllplivcly I1li1kc 01 mlilll! 'lI1lhi~ issue IIl1lillhe 1I(lillll i~ Inll1sli:rrcd, 20, ^dllllllcd, 21, DCl1ied liS ~llIlcd, The IIffhllllll III' scrl'ke II'IIS fllcd OI1UI' IIhlllll JllllllilI'Y 2, 1'1'17, hUllhc dllle uf sCl'vicc II'lIS lllll.lr IIhuUI lkcclllhcr 10, I')l}{j, 22, ^dlllillcd, 2J. I kl1icd liS Slillcd, This I hlll'lnlfllc ('III1r1, .\111/ .I'f"J//Il', IShllCd II Rule III Shllll' ('IIU~C why Ihe Mlilll1 sh'IItld 11111 hc "i~flIisscd lill'lilck III' IIclil'lly. Aflcr I'lltillll,r Mllrk Ylldcr rcspul1dcd ill OIlP'lsiliul1, Ihis Ilullunlhlc ('111111 r~l1lllwd Ih~ IICli1l11 f""lIl1lhl' pllrl!c II~\. 1)c1'clldulll hud UIl 'IPlllli\lmlly III I'llkc a pllSllIllll us Illlhc Hille III ShOll ('UllhC why Ihc cu~c ~holll,11I1I1 hc disllllShCd IiII' illill'lil'lIy, Scc 1'III1I1111fh IIncfullul'hcd, 24, A<lmillcd, Jlldecd, Ihc Oldcl' c~luhlishcs lhullhl! 1I1'Iillll shllllld U!l! hc dismisscd lill'illUClil'ilY, l>eli:lldlllll'S Ullcl1lpl III 11111", 11m t"IIIIIICI'islllhc ISSlIC lilllulcs Ihc ducll'llIe~ ur "rille urlhc ~USl!" 1I11d /"'.1/11"""'"'' Scc 1'11I1111i1fs IIl'icr, allllchd. 25, Adllllllcd. lIy wuy IIrllJl'lhcl' ICSp"l1hC, Ihc i~sllc orpus~ihly Imlls/'clrlllg Ihis lIcliOlll1l Ylllk C'III111Y lill' pussihlc l'ol1,'ulldalllll1wllh I'lullllilfs CO/1lpUl1iOIl CUSII illlhllt I'CIIIIC WIIslIl'llllllly miscd IlhclIl'llIillllrrpl'lIpOscd Ihc 1{1I1e III Shllw t'lIl1sC why Ihc ',lIse should 11111 hc di~l1Iisscd IiII' ilHll'lil'ilY, 2(1 I kllic,1. Thc I'cculd I'CnCCIS Ihullhc 1)c1i:lldI1l11 II'US scrved wllh U Wrilllf SU/l11110IlSUII 01' lIhUlIllkccl11hcl' 10, 1'1%. Ill' lI'uy orllJl'lhel' I'C~pOI1Se, whelhcr lhe Wrilor SII/l11110IlS II'US served 011 Del'el1lhcl' 10, 19<)(,01' JUIIIIUI'Y 2,19<)7, sCl'vkc II'US clTeclcd \Vllhlll lIillely (<JO) duys ulluwcd p"rslulIIIO Rllk .to.t, 27, DCllicd us slUlcd, Prclil1lllllll'i1y, Ddi:lldulIl is hurrcd rro/l1ruisillg this issue pllrsuulIllo Ihc dOCIl'll1csor"hlW orlhc cusc" 1I11d /',.'.1' /11""'1/111, Scc Pluil1lin's Brid: ulluchcd, Whelllhis Illlllomhlc COlIl'lrcl1lovcd Ihis actiol1 fro/l1lhc pllrgc Ilsl hy Ordcr or NUl'c/l1hcr H, 2000, it dclcl'/1Iillcd Ihallhis ClISC shollld 1101 hc dislllisscd lill' illaClil'ily, Ikl'cI1<1al11 hud ulull, fuil' Ulld COl1lplelc OppOl'llll1ily 10 hc hcard IlIlhallil1l11, hili chllsc 1I0110lakc allY positioll olllhc iSSIlC, It Ihcrcllll'c Call11111 nllsc Ihc issllc 11"\\'. Scc I'Iuil111lrs Brlci'. ulluched, 28.2<), Dellkd us irrdcl'tl1ll. Sce rcspol1sc 101111, 27 ahow, al1d I'Iail11i n's UricI', ulluched, 30, DCllied, Sce rcspollsc III 1111,27, IIbol'C, 3\. DCllicd, Scc rcspollse III 1111, 27, uhovc, -'2. DClllcd. Thcrl' hils hCClIlIO prl'IIIlIICC 1111 kl'clldilllll\hl~~lwl'll, Thc IICIIIIIIIII York ('oullly i~ 1101 II CII I' Ihc Clld or dlhCllI cry IIl1d I~ 1I111111il1 rClld) (1111) III II dcpo~ill'llIh hllle hcclI IlIkclI illlhc Yod, ('OUIII) 1I~lIl1l1 N'llllll c.\pclI rcplll'l~ hilI C hcclI CldlllllllCd illlhc York ('Ollllly IIClioll, No "illdcpClldclIl" 1II"lltclIl C.\1I111111111111l1 hll~ hcclI pcrl'ln11cd 111 Ihc "ull, (""l1lly IIclIllll Thcre IHlS hCClIlIO dCUlh III' IIllirn11ly or IIIIY 1IIIIICllill II IllICSh IIllhc "ork ('IIUllly' ill: II 1111 ACCOl'dilll!ly, I )OIi:lldulIl 's IIlkllllliolllhlllllllY ,kill) hilS Clluscd prcjudkc 10Ilcl'clldllllll\los~hcl H ih WilhoullIIcl'll. .1,1, DCllied as 1111 illClllTCCI hllllCIIlCIll or 11111. IlIlhc CIISC dlcd hy lkklllllllll, LIJIIIL \ LnRUJili!J, .Ill IJ, & (', ,1.12 1l\I01I1l!olllery ('OUllly I'/'/Xl, Ihc "COlllpllllioll CII~C" Ilclulllly 1\'lIh OIlC raiscd by II iJilJwSJlI PlllilJlJlfwhcrc Ihc 1IIIIurc ol'lhc rclid'was IWY dlll'crellI. Spcdlklllly, lillI' plllilllirrclllilllcd physkal illJllrics whilc Ihe olbcl' dllllllcd ollly propcrly dllIlIIlI!C. Ilcrc, thc "lilli' pllllllllrrll'ould bc c1l1illlilll! Ihc SIIIIlC IlIjul'ies ulldcr joillllllld scvcml Itllhlliiy'. FUrlhcIIIIIIIC,lhl'IC lI'as Ihe dClllh Orlll11alcrialll'illlCSS III L!lJJ!l, whkh prlllllplcd lhc court III cOllcludc IhllllhclC I\'ll~ prejudice 10 Ihc dcli:ndlllll. I fcrc, Ihcrc is Illl such IIlkl!alioll. Third, therc \\'lIh 110 illdkllllolllll L.wJ!llhllllhc court had prcl'illllsly miscd Ihc IsslIc .\'/il/ sf'(J///,> Ollly 10 COlldlldc lhllllhl' 111111111 should 1l!ll hc dislIlissed IiiI' lack IIrllClil'ily, Mcordilll!ly, I.hc L.wJ1;: CII~C did Illllllllplll'illc lite iSSIlCS 01'''11111' oflhe CIISC" alld "".1' IlId,('(//a whkh IIrc il11plklllcd hcrc, SCC I'lillllllrrh lit lei, allilchcd, 34, DCllicd. Ikl'clldillll spcdlklllly is 11111 Clllllkd hili dclcnlllllllllllllllrllh I'elll \I II 1 I," NOll Pros hCCllusc Ihc issuc is balTcd by Ihc d'IClriucs orlbc "liI\l 'Irlbe I'IIS~" lIlld ItY'/"1 /11.1""",/. Filially, sillcc lkl'clldalll alrcady Itlld a I'ullllud Clllllpkl., OPlhllllllllly III hc hl'III,1 IIl1lhl' ISMIC whcll il \\'IIS mi~cd s/la .ll)(J///" hy Ihis I hlll'll'lIhk ('IlUII, Ihc I~MIC hhllllld h., d""1l11'd 1I'II11'cd S.'C Plailllil'i's Briei' aunchcd.