HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06384
'i
~
.
J
j
,
I
I
"
,
.
ct.
I, ~
~
~
~~
. I
I
I ,
I
, I
"
~
J
.1
-:t I,
~ I I , I
..9 II
"
1;,'1
I,
.
,i
i')
'I
,
I'
,
;1
I
I""
II'
'II
..
,','(',1
"
"
":~"
1"'1 ,,~,
\
~
q
'::f-
~
"
't' "
. ....
1,;<..'
It'~
~~
I,.
.
..
I.
,
.,
.,
il
I,
'iI'I,"
, I
I.
I,
,
q ,
"
ql
,
I
)
I,
'J'-;
ij
"
,'.
,
If'.,
, ,
"
"
:, " , "i
'.,
" ,
,tl
, "
',i i
"
,
"
"
NOV '25 'i896
V
i'
,
:",
1,111
'I
"
"
."
"
Ii
,
'. ,
'I,'
."
~. '11luLlhe nlllo of UN5CSSmel11 llsud IiII' lllxlllll iuhJuct propurlY vlolules Stule Ul1d Fedeml COl1stltullol1ul
Reljulremellls of due proceNs, uljllul protectlol1ul1d ullllilf'flllty.
6, The Appellulll cOlllel1di l.huLthe uNNeNifllel11 IIi Nel rorth herell1l1hove IN llnluwl'llllnlhuL:
A, The fllurkel vulue of Ihe 11I'ollurly us rOlll1d hy the nourd Is 11Ill the UClllill fllurket vullIe of lhe
properlY UN hUNud uponlhe COiIN, Il1cofllu und cOfllpuruhlu sllles upproilch to Ihe uClUullIlurkuL
vulue comldered 111 conjunction with une unolhur und fllundulcd hy SlIlIUle.
Jj, The UppllCUllol1of Ihc Incorrccl fllllrkut vulue crClIleN u rCNuhlnll UiSUSNfllUIll IhuL Is hll!her lhun
Ihu 7,0% CUfllherlund CoulllY COfllfllon Levcll{ullo 1'01' lhu 1997 IIlX yuur.
WHEREFORE, [>ulhlonur rUljlluNlS lhu Court 10:
I. Fix the currelll nmrkul vuluu of Ihu properly us I'uqlllrud und fllllndlllud hy lhu provlNlol1s of thu ACli of
Aisemhly I!ovurnllf!! Ihu sUfllU und SUI forlh In 72 I'.S. 5341:l;
2. Apply lhe COfllmoll Level RUllo us l!ulurl11lnud hy Lhu SWlU Tux [~UUlllJlllon Dourd of 7.0% for ull 1997
USiUNNfllel1lN to Lhu fllurkuL vuluu us determlnud hy lhu COUrl In ruuchlnll lhu IIpproprllllu UNNUSNfllCIll
hllPUCl1111! Ihu pruflllNuN;
3, Order lhe upproprlule luxll1l! uUlhorltleN 10 refund 10 luxpuyur uny tuxes herutofore or hereufter
Improperly puld; und '~
4. Such olher relief us the CourL l11uy delerlJllne 10 he u proprluLe.
KASSAB ~1{CIIDOLn ,\'lUUEN. l"L.I>,
By: .\
JOSEI'fll'ATIUCK o'iiRmN, ESQUIRE
Altorncy IiII' Appellllnt/Petltloner
NUll, \ 1\396
.
(
DATED:
Exhibit A
SANNOREL OF PA, INC. /
IUMCO DEVEl,OPMEN'I' COltl'.
Appe llant
IN 'l'/lE COUIt'I' OF COMMON PLEAS 01'
CUMBERLAND COUN'I'Y, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 96-6384 CIVIL TERM
vs.
Appeal From Assessment.
Paroel No. 10 22 0531 020
CUMBERLAND COUN'l'Y BOARD Ot'
ASSESSMENT AND REVISION OF
TAXES,
Appellee
pRAECIPE TO EN'l'ER API'EARA~CJlj
TOt Prothonotary of cumberland county
Please enter and note the appearance ot the undersigned as
attorneys for cumberland Valley School Oi$triot and Township of
Hampden in the above captioned matter.
,Ii SPARE, [J,C.
~
C: snelbaker
44 West Main street
Meohanicsburg, PA 17055-0318
(717) 697-8528
Datel
Deoember 10
, 19915
-,. I~'
I c:
I .. .'
II'
( L "
II;, ~-.. I
~'( . ,;l "1
[,\ .-. , J
'. iI..)
l. I 1-
,.
" I,JI
I. ,.'
" ,
/;,;:
"
II.'
I'"
'.
Li, "
, ,
I"i ,
I ;L,
I ..
,
..
.\'1'i.'
, ';'1
'''. .,
H _:"~'-'
;~'! -- "
.1
I.
.
"
i'
',11
1'\
.,
.',
,
"
"
"
..
II:
'I'
.,
,I
U',
Ii'
,
,
'.
I
II
"
,
"
L jd
,
,
I
,
, 'I'
,
,
..'
"
I ,
"
'I, i
,.)
.'
.I,
"
.
"
, '
".1
i,111
,I
"
,
.'
1. J,
J ". \'.'!;'. [-
'1' '_' ,1..\<0
/" ,'\"l~':c
" i : I, ,1'1'/ , :'!}J~X~l~,
.rl'.I',It,{'-i
tt,;'\.I)
, 'l'"
i.i,!_r.!
,I; II._-,n;-.r-:
i;:_'I,.!,',i, :!-/:~'
'I' '1,;;",I1"J
'I ',': I.! :'<:',-'1,\"1,:,
I, . .') ...t:.I..-. ,rq,L
, 'i I , Jii'~!'.';'\
_/'1' tJ.i1_\t.-:\!
,l,},.,t'
, ,.'.!{~r{~\1'llJ'
1 "H,;[h'i '
, , "I..J
'''':i::(;{>\2~fl
;"'(~')\'W,ib!J..,.
[ ',;v"':;'j-jl'/'
',"';'-.1."';\\'1 "t,it!!
,\','I~'i i~i-': ())Ii~{
t__. ,1'-',1'.1..,,';
~''';' I, !J I' ,,\-, t-1 ,
-:I,.,;,'-.')J:'idl~'~
I' : ,. i'I. ~ '. F-(\t(' .1
,'I'_i'._:;;i,}/J.'-'J-:
. , I., ,.1.1'\h)~"j
,I i ,jl;,''-~~Ifj''
IJ"",I_'-Hlj"L
,',. '''' :,'!Iji. '.
'. I". '1 /, fr\"III
:"!'{-'Itl"~';jl;~l-
t .i' ~(\I'rtJij
';,1 ,"; ; LijJ;jl\t
j' I, "[;\i"i'l.
. J; '!;'-~;''.l'U
'I jlP",:,',)J\/-ift
'J . ijl '.; ',"ir~"I;~
I' "u,',':i,,'WI!
..'I.....!..,' ,/
. ,,:", .!dj)':Pti
I ,. __'I t!;'i;J!I!~;l'-lV~
I I ,'_.n:.'i "'It "-\";Ji'J~
'. ' " "'11'1"\
I ',,0 d'-}'h..,
~ : I..' '.' 1, ,?,/\I-r:!/l'l':
I, I, ",'
I' ~I ',,"",:' ~'{
, I I' I' ",;.~ jl
, 1,';1,,,,,"'.1,. .1 ~t
J. , ,,':::"'.'i::;,:~l;rli
',II"\""'jr,,/.f11
, t I i>~'1 'Ji
, \; 'lll~ll,.
, ! . 1"fJ."(!,
,1:): )~:',':~
I " ""'il:t:i~{'i~:~:
--~l"i:;r!-fF '.
, I /, ,'I l' ill f '." _ f ~,
: \; /11(1 {i~,i . "~'
. ,.:,1; "i!'i:i'
,;1 ,1,"'kl(I$~I'
"VI !l)-'';n.',,';Vd
.'/ .1'~)FfL'-
!1'rk~:"J,lt-r~
'd.l/l$~bj" 1
"'..1.
'i'. ;,1).'\""\1-,
j;,,;;.,~!"n'rl
, IH;-'. \.:,:,l~ ~,'\'hi~;
\Ij, ' .'i :,.,.,iJl;~
Iii ,i!,. .;,i:;.i.1!Hi{
'II - ,th.;l'IH'.t'i
"'Ie'l'!'_
'i.,"li\(.~ ,lIJ
""Iu.r,'n/,ti,
l' f' ~; i" :':: I j :-1' ~',~~
;:11 .j:, ,lY''''itj}\~~:~,
,~_\. .:: ;r,.,./tl/~~~~:
1,' ,_,.\:::\/.:!!.' - j._,'.Ji{1 ,)
"I,h! ""11'iJ. !AJ!t'
I'.; ,.,.....:....'.i---L-_,l,_"..
,'l'".-!: ,i-I].:'j\ lc,;;"~.~ll)\
/; , :'//;!'_)'(j li,f~'\;\t'i!:'(I,;'1j
, ",'.' . ""1" ',t
,.." ,;', ..-' '"..,,'.l, '-_', '!"Iih~
' ., II !e' -', ..,'- ,.\.'- c. '.' .-~"L.4'
d, l,.~I,' _I:,', I ,I /""{~:\'dl~
' \iJ',""."- 1..J:-,"l'
'III'" I' ';", .,::.I"I\)~(lh
I' .,.. "",-,1 '1 (i'Jf,
" ,,'\',-"i~\',~
l'l-,:._,..,.l.'l
. ,. 'fl~: /f'I(','
. " '~l
',.'_(,1/",':
,I, '~-:/l
. 'J
11 ~ ,,"t:l
;',:;d:~,.
"
I"
.I,
Ii'
".J
I'!'l!
I'
,I
I
I
,.
I'
, ,
,
,
"
Ii
,
1'-,
.,
I
,
;1
,,'
"
>I
I I
1'11,11',,>1 t\~:II'ni,J','1.\~,.1f\\\V,~~lj\\i/:f~$"j
}, ~: 1"1
,.....
.r', ~ 'j'.,..
'~ ,
.. ,(..
'-'1 'oti
'II ~r ,t.; "'."
ipJ ' I ~ I~
ii r:... ;'1:;:1
(,,~k r:1 - ,.... .
tlol, 1, I ~1 ('I
, ,Irt;~: . I ~',
, rr 1'.j
.'1, '/('~
'~i
16 ~ ~j "
I.) ,
, I
'/1' ,
."
'1,
"", i' -'
.. ~!
e
'. Ii i*~ ~
I' ~ ~~~
I ~
88 III ~~~i~~
~ ! ~ :! ~!8~$8 f:!
I I ~ t!11
~ ~O;~ ~
" ! ~, ~=~~ .~
el < ~ ~~I~ I !f
~~ 0 ~ ~
:II".
,,'
.
, ,
"
I )1.
.,
, ,
','
,,".
'. ,
i',
,
!'I.,
.
'.
~
.
'I.",
,
, !
,
,..
IN Iml I IN 'I'IIE CUlm'l' OF COMMON I'I.EAS
I OJ>' CUI\IIlEIU.ANJ) COUNTY,
AI'I'I':AI, Olo'/l'IUlI'EIlTY ()to' I I'ENNS\'I.VANIA
SANNIHml. 010' I'A, INC.lKII\JCO I
J)J':VJo:UlI'MEN'I' cOIm J>'IWI\J'I'IIE I
m:CISION ()Ii 'I'IIE 1I0AIW 010' I
ASSESSMEN'I' AI'I'I':AI.S OF I
CUMIlEIU,ANIl COllNTY IN I
CONNECTION WITII l'ltEl\lJSES I
SITlJA'I'lm A'I' SIMI'SON FEIUt\' I NO, %.(,3114 CIVil. 'I'EltM
ItoAIl, IIAMI'IlEN TOWNSJIII~ I
IIENNSYI.VANIA, IU:LATIN(j TO I
1997 ImAL ESTA'I'E ASSESSI\JEN'I' I
ANIl ALL SlJIISEl.)lIENT I
ASSESSMENTS IlLJIUN(j TilE I
l'ENIlENt:\' 010' TilE AI'I'EAI. I
I
J>'01.l0 NO.1 III 22 115.'1 11211 I CIVIl. ACTION. I.AW
REEJ.Y.JO_EEIIIJ9H.EOAn AEEEAL_fAOM_TlIJLAS.6fS-SMENL
OL~C!lMBERLAND__.cO.uNTLB_OARD~LA.5.6E.6.sMENI__AfP-EAL.S
AND NOW, comos Stephen D. Tiley, Assistant Cumberland County Solicitor,
and Illes this lieply to tha Petition 101' Appeal From the Assessment of the Cumberland
COUl1ty Boord of Assessment ApperJls of which the following Is a statemant:
1, Admitted In part, denied In part, It 15 admitted thot Sanndrel of PA Is the
legal owner of tile premises Imown as 3431 Simpson Ferry Road, Hampden
Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, Respondent Is without sufficient
Information to form an opinion as to the truth of tho remaining averments of this
paragraph regarding Klmco Devalopment Corp. and the equitable owner of the
property,
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted,
4, Admitted. By way of further Reply, the Cumberland County Board of
Assessment Appeals denied the Petition,
REPLY TO PETITION
Pogo I 01 2
INlml
AIII'Jo:AI. (W/IIIUWEltTY 01'
SANNUlU:1. (W I'A, INC./KIMCO
ImVEI.OIIMENT COIU'. I'ltoM TilE
U1~CISION 01' TilE 1I0AIUl 01'
ASSI':SSMENT AI'I'EAI.S 01'
CUMIIE1U,ANU COUNTY IN
CONNECTION WITII I'ItEI\IISES
SITUATEU AT SIMI'SON I'Eltn\'
IWAI>, IIAl\ll'UEN TOWNSIIII',
I'ENNSYI.VANIA, ImI.ATlN(j TO
1997 IlEAl. ESTATE ASSESSMENT
ANI> ALL SlJIISEQUENT
ASSESSMENTS IllJIUN(; TilE
I'ENI>ENL\' 01' TilE AI'I'EAI.
1'01.10 NO.1 III 22 115.H 11211
t IN TIm CUlmT (W COMI\lON I'....:AS
I 01' ClJl\lIIEltl.ANU CUlJNT\',
I I'ENNS\'I.VANIA
I
I
I
I
I
I
I NO, 96.(,,"14 CIVIL TEltM
t
I
I
I
I
t
t
I CIVil. ACTION. LAW
k.E.B.IlEJ.c.~YlC.E
The undersigned hereby certified that a true anti correct copy 01 the within
Reply to Petition lor Appeal From the Assessment of the Cumberland County Board 01
Assessment Appeals hae been sorved by regular, United States mall, deposited on
the date shown below, postage prepaid, to the dale shown below, postage prepaid, to:
Joseph Patrick O'Brien, Esquire
Kassab, Archbold & O'Brien, L.L.P,
214 North Jeckson Street
Media, Pennsylvania 19063
Dated: rlMtr ..loP; 1'117
Richard C. Snelbaker, Esquire
Snelbaker, Brenneman & Spare
44 West Main Street
p, 0, Box 318
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
_ ~4. ~~~_____
St~rtru~~Esqulre
Assistant Cumberland County Solicitor
5 South Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243.5838
Attorney 1.0. No,; 32318
"
I.
1,I'i
.,
"
I'
,
,
,
I,;
"I'
;.',
,'j
'"I'
I,
,
I
I
Ii ,
,I ., ,
I I I
,
I'J)
t'i ' , .1
,. J I
~ . "
), ' il 1 "
,
ill" J ~! I f I -= If Ii ,
II
l:t
''lIlli'' . ' m
,II 'I .1 lIll 'I l ; i.
i i~'
I r. ' I Ii
.' .', i {.
! "E . r .'
,
.
..
i
'I
\, "I,
.t""'.,l'll~'I:_.,....
\",,.,,..,, ,-
.,
--
'i
'\'
,\;'
'I
.,
dl
"
i, I
'I: It
,
,
,
,
,
,
,
"
'\
, ,
"
.'.
"
.'
:,
.,
'1-', '1I' l I
1'\ _III'
"j ';t,
'I",
'.j
i,;
,
"
'.
Ii,l
,
,
I.",'
I ',I
~..
,.
,
. .
:' ..~~:"
''''~l~''"i\
I " 'I i'\;;~JH H
,
Ii
,