HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06422
In
]~
~~
t:)
~
.
"
, ,
I
)
(t
"': 11'1\
, 1,',' '.1
'I't""'I'!;'
\;'1,1'0-\
,(-t< .)
,',1 .
'f' ,! .'"
'I'
p'll.
),.
,'I
'I
.1
"
\i'
,
'J,)l"'.i~!,I,,,,,
':"~~
;' "*
'I~
~i,""-
~'
,i
"
"
, I.
".,
1,1
~
~
~
"
'0
\"....
.~
'V7>
.':B
'I'
....
......
" ~.
.) , "
,
I " .,
"
'.f . ..
'11'\'
Il.)
, ,
'I
I
1,;")
,
I,'
,.
"
I"
I
,I ,
,
I
,
I
,
',!-.'
"
,
Ii,
I
, '
'1
"
,-i1
"
, .
"
\'
'.',1
I'
Ii'!,
"
,
'I
':,i
";1
I
"
.
"~,I'
,
I
['
.,
) -"-'!'
,
('/]
1,1
,:'1
,-','
.'
.,!,
"
Ii,
,
rio, I.
','-'
KASSAJI AltCllJIOW & O'JlRIEN, 1.,1..1',
IIYI JOSJo:I'III'A'I'IUCK O'IIIUEN, ESQUIlU~
Altonll'Y I.D. No, OHMH
214 North JllckNUII Stl'cct
Mcdill, "ClllIsylvlIlIllI /1}C)tiJ
(till)) /lI\/I.JHOO
AlIIll'IlCY fili' l'ctlthmH
IN Till! CUllltT Ill'" CUMMUN I'l.li^/i Ol' CUMlllilll,ANll CUUNT\', l'I!NNIl\'t.v ^NI^
CIVll, Al'l'lON . "MV
Iml AI'I'I':AI. 1ll;/PIIUI'.mn' OF Vlnllll ANll MAIIIN^
Il, WIIITM^N Frolllthc Dcdshm 01' the Ihmrd or
AsseSSlllellt Allllcllls or Cllmhcrlllnd COllllt)' III
Ccmllcctloll Wilh l'rclllls!!s Sltllllh!.11I1 171 Vlnc
Slreel, ShlrclllllllslrlWII 1I111'''lIl1h, l'clIlISyl\'lllllll,
ItcllIlllllllo 11}1J7 It I'll I EsIIII!! Asscsslllclltlllld All
SlIht;C111I!!nt AsS!!SSmCllls 1l1I1'1I111 till' Pelldellcy or th!!
Allll!!1I1
NO, '7'. I. '1.1 .:I..Jd.v11 r;........
T,M.I'. No. J7.2J.OS57.lti7
PETITION I:OIl AI'I'MI. FltOM Tim ASIiI':SIiMEN'I'
OF TilE CUMlIElll.^Nll COUNT\' lIo^,1J) 0.' ASIiI'AIiMEN'I' MI'E^I..')
TO TIlE JUDGES OF THE SAID COURT:
Th', Petition of Victor and Marina D. Whitman respectfully rep I'CSC 11I5:
1, ThaI Appellom Is Ihe legal and equllable owner of the premises sllualed III 171 Vine Street,
ShlrelllallSlown Borough Cumberland Coullly, Pennsylvanill,
2, That the Appellalll's address Is 3200 SW 60 COUl'l, Suite 104, Miumi, FL, 33155,
3, Wllhlnthe time allowed hy law, specifically on August 30, 1996, Ihe Appellant filed an Appeal frolll
the 1997 assessmenl of Ihe real eslllte before the Cumberland County !Jollrd of Assessment Appellls,
4, 'nlat subsequemly following a hearing before the Board, the Board caused to be issued a notice which
Granted Reduction the requefil of Ihe Appellant and I1xlng Ihe assessment for lhe subject premises lit
$56,000.00 utilizing II 7.0% 1'1I110 bused upon an Implied value of $800,000 (see lI11ached Exhibit
"AU).
~, '11U1llhe rllllll Ill' II~M:~~llIeIIlU~ed IiII' IlIxlllH ~lIhJe~1 pl'upel'lY vllllule~ SllIle IIl1d Fedeml CUII~IIIUlhllllll
IteLjulre/llelllN Ill' due pl'll~e~~, c11ulllprllleclhlll 1Il1llulllfllnnllY,
6, The Appelllllll ~llnlelldN Ihlll Ihe u~~e~Mnelllu~ ~el fUl'lh herellluhllVU I~ ullluwfulln Ihul:
A, The IlIl1l'kel vullle Ill' Ihe pl'llperly u~ fuulld hy Ihe II11Ul'd IN 1I111 the II~IIIIII 1IU1l'kel vlllue uf Ihe
pf'lJperly 1I~ hu~ed Upllll Ihe ~llhl~, III~ullle IIl1d ~lllllplll'uhle ~lIlc~ IIPIH'Ullch III Ihe IIcluul /llul'kel
vlllue ClllI~ldcred III ~uIIJulI~llulI wllh II lie IIl1lilhel' IIl1d IIHlIldlllCd hy ~IlIlUle,
11, The UppllCIIll1llluf Ihe h"lll'f'e~1 IlIl1rkel vlllue ~l'eUle~ u re~lIl1ll1l! me~~/llef1llhul I~ hlHhel' IhulI
Ihe 7,0% CUllIherllllld Cllunly ClllIHlIlllll..:vclltullulill' Ihe 11)97 IIlX yellr,
WIIElmFOIU!, 1>ellllllller reLjuehl~ Ihe Clllll'l IU:
I, Fix Ihe currellllllllrkel vulue Ill' Ihe plllpcl'ly II~ re1lulred ulld Illulldllled hy the JlI'llVIHIIIIIH lit' Ihe ACIH III'
AH~elllhly HuVernlnl! Ihe HlIllle ulld ~el lill'lh III 72 1>,1), 5348:
2, Apply Ihe COIll/ll1l1I J..:velltullll U~ delel'llIll1ed hy Ihe SHlle TIIX l!ljUll1l1Jlllllll Illlllrd of 7,0% fill' ull 1997
UHHeH~meIllH III Ihe Illlll'kel vulue IIH delenllllled hy Ihe Coun III reuchllll! Ihe IIJlproprlille U~HeH~lllelll
hnpUClllI!! Ihe premlHeH;
3, Order the upprllprlllle IIlXhl!! uUlhlll'lIleH III refulld III 11Ixpuycr III1Y HIXCH herelofllre or hCl'cllner
Improperly puld: Ilnd
Exhibit A
I",,' I' f.J,'
, :.t '
, -,
,
, ~r.:
~ (~
: en'
;" ~.I
Ut, ' ~1!
11. ~~
~. ,r;;
,~
'C
:l~$
,..'
r'O
,,;~
: :7j
[lilli'
,:::1
, '
:1
I'
,I
"
, I,
i !
"
,
I '
- -- --....-....---...---
-'-' +--""'-" -......-...
~ lll1 "
~I~
U I. iilb I ~'I~t
~ ~ 'is 2ci~~8 ~ .. It~
I i I ~ ~~! ~ i ~Il
~
s I ~
*1 ~ A
~~ i~ ~~~
15 0
, ----
, ,
,
"
"
, ,
I 1'1,
Ii
, I Ii
, " I, ,
I,
l'
I I ,
" ,
, , I , ,
I, ,
I
, I
,
;',
I I I,
,
i ,
, , ,
. , I
,
"
, ,
I
.'
.
IN It 10: I
AI'I'Io:AI. 01' l'IUlI'lmn' ()Ii
VICTOIt ANIl MAltlNA I),
WIIITMAN I'IUlM Tm: Illo:1'ISION
()Jo' TilE 1I0AIUl OF ASSESSMENT
A1'I'Io:AI.S OF ('III\IIIEUI.ANI)
COlINn' IN ('ONNH'T10N \VITII
1'ltEI\IISES SITI'ATI-:Jl AT 171
VINE STltEET, SlIlltEI\IANSTO\VN
1\01Wl!ti II, I'ENNS\' I, VANIA.
IU:I,ATlN(j TO 1')')7 ItEAI. ESTATE
ASSESSMENT ANIl ALL
SlJIISEtJLJIo:NT ASSESSMENTS
UlJlUN(; '1'1"': I'ENIlENC\' 01' TilE
AI'I'1o:AI.
IN 'I'l1l': COllIn (iii COI\lI\lON I'I.I':AS
OF ('LJI\IIIEIU.ANIl C()lIN'!'\',
I'l':NNS\'I.VANI,\
NO. 'U,-Ml1 CIVIL 'I'I':IU\I
CIVil. Al."I'ION . l.AW
BE.fLY.,..TO . PETITJQtLf.oBAPPEALJ.BOM~tHE_Afu)UeMEtiI_
OFJ.HE~,U MBJ;A I.AND.CJ)UNtY_eOAAO__QfAS.5E.5SMENt._A~ALS
AND NOW, 0011106 Slaphen 0, Tiley, Asslslanl Cumberland Counly Solicitor,
and fllas this Reply It) Iho Petition for Appoal From the Assossment of the Cumberland
County Board of Assessment Appeals af whloh lha following 15 a statement:
1, Admitted,
2, Admitted,
3. Admitted,
4. Admllted, By way of further Reply, tha Cumbarland Caunty Bl'Jard of
Assessmant Appeal<l found the fall' marl<ot valuo of the subjaot praperty, as of the date
the appaal was 1II0d, to be $800.000,
5, Danled, The averments of Ihls paragraph contain conoluslons af law to
whloh no responsive pleading If; required,
6. Denied, The avermants of this paragraph, and Its sublettared paragraphs,
oantaln oonoluslans of law to which no respanslve pleading Is required,
REPL V TO PETITION
Pouo I 01 2
IN IU':, I IN TilE l'OLJltT OJI COMMON I'I.I':AS
I 011 CLJl\lIllml.ANII COlINTY,
AI'I'EAI. OJI l'IUlI'lm'!'\' OF I I'ENNSYI.VANIA
VKTOll ANI) 1\I,\Il1NA I). 1
WIJITMAN FllOM TilE I)ECJSION I
OJI TilE 1I0AIW OF ASSESSMENT I
AI'I'EAI.S OF Cl'J\IIIEIlI.ANIl 1
COlIN'I'\' IN l'ONNJo:t'T10N WITII I
l'IlEJ\IISI':S SI'I'l'ATEII AT 171 I
VINE S'I'IlEET. SIIIItEMANSTOWN 1 NO, IU..M22 CIVIl. 'J'Jml\l
1I0IWlJl;II, I'ENNS\'I.VANIA. I
ItEI.ATlN(; TO 1""7 ilEAl. ESTATE I
ASSESSMENT ANII ALL 1
SlJIISI':IJLJENT ,\SSESSJ\tENTS I
UlJlUN(, TilE I'ENIIENn' OF TilE I
AI'I'EAI. 1 CIVIL ACTION. I.AW
C-EBIJ.El.c.AIE...oFJEBY.l.C.E
The undorslgned hereby oartlllad that a true and oorrect oopy 01 the within
Reply to Petition tor Appeal From tho ASlloslll1lent of the Cumbarland COUl1ty Board of
Assesflment Appeals has been served by rO[Julor, United States moll, deposltad on
the dote shown bolow, postaga prepaid, to Joseph Patrick O'Brien, Esquire, oltha law
lirm of Kassab, Archbold & O'Brien, L,L,P" 214 North Jackson Streot, Media,
Pennsylvania 11l063,
Dated: ~>>-. /1'11 PrJ?
- ~=:~2 -~-_._---
S~~lIey, Esquire
Assistant Cumberland County Solloltor
5 South Hanover Straat
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 243-5836
Attorney 1.0, No,: 32318
.
.
.
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON I'LEAS
Olr CUMDEltl.ANl> COUNTY, I~ENNsn VANIA
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO. 96.6412 Civil
REI AI'I'EAL 01' VICTOlt "nd MAIlINA I),
WlU'I'MAN Ir,'om the I>l'CINlon of thc nonrd of
Assessmcnt AIIIIC"IN of ClIllIbcrlnnd County III
Conllccllon With 1'l'clllIses lit 171 Vlnc Street,
Sblremonstclwn noroullh, l'ellnNylvonhl, Ilehlllnll
to 1997 ncol ENf.nte A/i.~e8SllIcnt lllld All
Subsequent Asscsslllcnts Unrhlll lhe I'cndcncy of
tbe Allpelll
l'OLlO NO. 37.13.0557.167
~'J'n"JLATI.QN 01' COUNSEL
WE HEREBY Nupulllte Bnd ogree 1I1l111llC Order 1.0 whlcb 1I11s SlIpulolion is ottacbed shall
be entered by the Court of Common Plells of Cumberlond Coullty, Pennsylvonill,
'H ~ l;;L'1
ST I TILEY, ESQUtRE Y
Attorney for Cumbcrlond Coullty
.R /.7lJ/P1
I" A ~ "
" -J "
, -
~. '" '~ "'1
,-t , "
-, .'-1
, :J
.., ~
~.I . - , ~
, :-d
: .'. to)
" r.> I,','
. , .. ,:.!
I. ',~ ..I
,,;\ .,