Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06439 .. ~ .... ~ .. ':) .... ~ ;:1 l' 1 .~ ~ ~ "~ \ J , , ,/ , ,.y I / f I.' r y' " I " Ii , ,. , I j'J!!l!!r:ll'l::. t'\.W I,) lIT J 1'/l;~:JlIiE V()!I_~J!!!,~I,.I:I'J' (Mllllt hB tyr_l'<Id ttull llI~t IlUlIllHlI.'l1 III .IIIL1UCIlI.1I1 '1'0 'I'IIE 1'1l0'1'1I0NO'I'I\IlV tlf' CUMLmlll.I\Nll COllN'I'V I l'll!/U1Q Hut thl! within 11111l:tl.lr tor the IlUXC I\rgI.rlllUlC court. ______~___~"______..__~_________"______________.___"_._____._._.__.M_._...______.._____~ CI\L"I'lON Of' CI\Sli: ( ..to t I rrt clJpt.t.on I1IU11 t bo ~ ta tlld in full I r I f. Ii', :n , j ,j r'rl , , .\ " , ,-I to!.' I !,') . ' "\ , . !, \ .', I ',il .. .! ..JI :,'1 .-1 -', ',-' 1.,11 ~ohBmod 1\, Khan, (plaintiff) w. " -. ~ Shlppensburg Universlty/ /\nthony CoddlB and Jamos /\. popu/ ( Oil fendlsn t ) 91." I.IIJ9 ~. 96-.6"-611'_ Civil 19 96 1. Stllte matter to be argued (Lu., p1aintiff'a I1ption for new trial, deftllldAnt'B delW:T1lr to cOllplaint, ete.)l Defendont's Prullmlnury Objuctlolltl to Plulntlff's sl:lcond I\mandod Complolnt. 2. Identify colJllSol who wU1 argull CllIlel (a) for plaintiffr I\ddrees I Kalth E, Kondall, Eaq. 3207 North pront Stroot IInrrlaburg, 1'/\ 17110 (b) for deferdantl Address I prudorlck Cobalt, Jr., Esq. Doputy /\ttornoy Denarol strolib13rry squoru, 15th Ploor IIorrlsburg, 1'/\ 17120 J. 1 wU1 notify Bl1 partil!.S in writing within t1ol:l dayB th.at this case has been l.is ted for IlIlJUfe1l t . 4. I\rgU1lent Court Patel /\ugust 13, 1997 [Hted: (P/().S/17 dt /\ t torn"y for r ~ en f; c.: & t~ . ~~ ) =ll iQ ~ 'J~ 1':/ n;. ~~ \'1:1 ('I , . - 121.i" ~i [. ~ I;; , ' \ ~ Q~ i!; r::: & "3 , I ~ ~ 1_ 1f . . '.;l.,j 'I' r:o ." n \:1, - ,:ll ~I!' ~ II '\ f '~ ~ '0; '1-..' , ~ ",~ l':; c:: (\~ ~ & It lC r.J, ... \,1... I:J;I 'j'~ - ') .~J :t ~re F ~ ~ ........ ~ 1\I0llt\l\WD A. K"AN, 1'I,lInll(! IN Till: ('OUltT 01'( '()I\IMON l'l.I:Mt, ('UMlIHtl,AND ('OUNTY, l'I:NN!iYl.V ANIA VII. !i11ll'1'I~NSIIUIt<l UNIVllJtSI'I'Y, ANTIIONY O:I>I)IA, 1I111! It\I\W!i A. 1'01'1:, Nil, %. M~" I>l'rl'ndtllllll Jury TrllllDl'mlludl'd ~ltmJl~rJJSJf fH'!J.NIDi~I() nfHiNJJ~NJb! J'JSliU~H NM! )'!.)JJ J 'f~JJ!JNb ]l )~~Jli.l"llltJL(( )~U'L~!NI NOW COI\IF.'i till' 1'1.11111111. f\Iuh.lIlll'd A. Kh.lIl, lIy .lIld Ihr<Hll\h hili .llIul'l1l'Y", KIIlld.11I Mlllllr, P.C, hy Kt'llh E. K"lld,IIl, EIilJ" III '\'"pllnd III I ),""nd.IIlI'1I 1'",'UlllllhII'Y ()hllldl'1I111 III I'llIlnUll'1I AllwlILllld CUlllpl'llnl In till' .llxlVl' 1ll.11I..I', .111 fullllWII: 'J~J\[JL9L-'.'i~t~J:,~t~nHUW~J!:iJJK'11~)N I. Ad III I 11.'11. 2. l>..nl.'11. TIll' d.IIIllII M'I IUl'lh In CIlIlI1I11 J .lIld II Ill' 1'1.llnllll'lI l'lHl1plll'nl .11\' nul "d'IIIll[IIW4llrllllnB frOI1ll'lllllr.ldll 1/41'nl"'\'11 Inlu wllh till' CllnllI1Unw"lllIh...." .111 IhUM' !amnII .11 72 I',I.C.S. !H651-4 Ihl\ll! I_'n d,'fllwd hy till' 1"'nn~~'lv.IIlI.1 Supl'l'nw Cllurl. wlll'11 'Ippll..d III lIl!ltllln1l!111 .lgn....II11'IlI1i. s..... K<"'nh...il VL~'UIll'Il!lliW"!!Jlli,_I"'1llJ!i.0v'IIlI'1 s..',:ul'llI.'li Cllmll1f~lIjun. 5231'11.223,565 A2d 1147 (I Ill')). II. IH.AI,INSUHICIJ:NCY (JWI\IUltltt~j{) 3, Adl1llllL'1l. 4, AdllllllL...llh.11 ~llwl'l!lgn Illllllunlly ,11I.1,'hllll Iu till' .11I"1\.llIlll111 ,lgllllll1l ShlplJl!n5hurg Unlwn;lIy Iil'I forlh In COllntll III .Jnd IV llf 1'1.llnllfl'~ l'ompl'llnl, .Ind I'I.llnllff Ihllltlll'n.rlll'l' nI....t .111 Alllllml",1 Compl.llnl.,11 or .'llU"!i.i, PU''liU,1Il110 I{ul.' I02ll<tJ(I) llr IIIl' I',l. J{ul.'li llr Clvlll'rlll'....tun'. ,'olllJ!mpomlwoullly wllh till! nUIIlI Ill'/'l'or, whkh l'un'li till' llbj....'lIollolbl.. .llIlIg.llIoIIII. Ollll'rwlp;,.. dL'I1I",llllolIIIOWI'l'lgII hl1lllulllly olll,I,'h,'li 10 till' .ldl'lIlII Ill' jndlvldu,lllI IIlll oIdlllll wllhlntlw ".:llll<' " \II ~-' , ,.. - I. .. U 0 f"' U '.," .. ..' I ~ II ", , . , . I tJ tl ' ' Li ''J ".J , . ~ ..., ,. '(;1 1 I" ." "!. I I' r" :. '.J - ~j .,. I,) ~ Kenda~LMHler,~. c. Ill'7 Nunh Frlllll SIr.'ct II.Hn.hllr~, 1"''''''111.11\1;1 171111 ..,. ". I .. lj~ ',}; , 1'- /' f r- , .j , ILl ' , ' 1,.lr " , , , l'l, " I , \, , , " I II'" I, " \,1. I to', , " '" iJ , j ..~. , <J.J~ p.; .. tj I sJ ~~ j ~f ,---.- Kend~!!_M i!!~!,p.c. '1\"\7 Nllrt h Frlll\l ~I n:l'I I Llnl-~hlll!, It'IlIl,~'I\',IIlI;1 I i Ill' ,'" {I' I.- .. " r; A'/' '. 1\/ \ ,,' ,'r. /.1 '" ~ . , ).1( '.. 1., .... tit.. ',-1 frl., -~ " ''I I} 1:.:.1/' /'.1 .I, f> "..; I 'J " ~.. I, L., .~ CJ ,.., t' 1)1 .j '. r-' I t:: o S , .. .1: ~( "'. , ~ JE ... ' . (I " t \;. I ~. I ~ i ~1~ ,on ,Ill =J ,-,,: ',., '1\1 ~ l f [" .. it:.. I , 1,1, 1'- \ 1...1 '~J .. '.l ~ ~, Kendall Miller, p.e. \2('7 NO'lh Frolll Str\'l!l IllIrrlshuru, l'ollllsVlvllI\111 1711 (1 '- . . MOJ/^MI!I> A. Kl/^N, 1'1.11111(( IN 'mil COURT OF COMMON 1'l.I!Ni, CllMIII!RLANI) COUNTY l'I!NNSYl.VAN'A YI. Clyll AClllIn - Law SIIII'I'l!NSltUR(lllNIVI!RSI"'Y Ind JAMI!S A. l'OI'Il, I>c(cndlllll No. 96-6431) Clyll Afl!JJlAVJ.'LOl!Ji1!RYJ.c1! I. Kellh [:, Kcndnll. EKII.. nllorney for Ihe PlnllllltT Inlhe nhove clvllncllon, MllllBlIlcd A. Khnn. hereby cenlfy Ihlll I hnvc Ihis dUle scrvcd II Irue nnd correCI copy of thc <'Oll1p/allll Inlhe IIboye IIIllller. upon Rubcrt A. Mulle. Esq.. !he Allurney fur !he f)efcndllllt5lnlhi5 IIcllon. who Ilccepled scrvlce uf Ihc clIlllplnllll on behulf of !he l)efelldUIl!K. A Iruc cop)' III' Ihe Accelllllllce of Service Is ullnched hereto. Pille: Jalluar)' 27. 1997 ZJldI ,~ Kehh E. Kendall. Esq. Altorne)' (or IIlaltHlf( Sworn 10 alld Subscribed before Ille. a NOlar)'JPubllc, Ihl5 ~ 7ft1 Da)' of "'~... '7 ,199.2. _~ c1J'~ NUlar)' Public liT!! NOTARIAL SEAL ell\' ~ ~i.':,~H.',?;ADS. NolIIy Public I ~'''' IU InCoun ,g~PP'",nl'tIcJ1J'f!I",J:R.1J1, ,~ I" l' II, i' " ..' , I I. '" , , , , I , , I " I", :,') "" ( ~ l;" I tJ s ~ J~ ~il )af Kendall Miller, P.C. ,.~-, '2\17 t\llrth Fr\11H SUl'l'! Il.lrrt...1111Il!, Pl'IlIl,~'Iv;l1l1.1 17t 1(' . 4, Plolllllfl' Wll6 employed by Defendlllll Unlvmlly 116 IIllrormor or morkellng, In Defendolllllnlverslly' 6 Collcl!e oflluslnc66, frum Scplcmhcr, 19K9, Ulull hl6 re611!Ilullonon MIIY 24, 1996, 5. PllIlllllrr gulllcd lcnurc U6 II fullprofcssur Inlhc lollcgc or IhulncS60r Dcrendulll LJnlverslly In Scptcmber, 1"1'14, followllll! II 5 YCllr prohullunllry CVlllullllon pcrllKt. 6, Following Ihc grnlll of ICllurc 10 PIIIIIIIII'I', U dlspulc llrorsc hClwccn Dcfcndunl Unlverslly und PlullIIlI'I', which Ihrclllcncll Plulnll""'s cuntlnulllg elllllloymelll wllh Dcrendulll LJnlvcrslly. 7. Pllllllllffllcrccivcd Ihc fOl'cgolng dlspulc 10 hc IIIlI'CICXI for rnclulllnd/or nllllonul origin dlrscrlmlnllllon, IlIld WU6 prepllred 10 nle u dlliCrlmlnullonllcllull DefcndulllLJnlvcrsllY III defend III!UilUllhc lhreUllO hl6 cmllloYlllclII. 8. Thc dlsputc wus ulllnllllcly rcsulvcd by Plulllllrr's IIgreclllclll 10 resll!n his emllloymclll wllh Defcndlllll LJnlverslly, In exchllngc for lhe consldcrullonrscl rorlh Illu ccrtllln conOdellllnl AG/ll:'EMf.'Nl'AND GENERAl. Rl:'l.EASf.' ("AgrecmeI1lU), The Al!ree llIe 111 15 nOl auachcd herelo, as requlrcd hy Pa.ltC,P" Rulc 10(9(h), becuursc lhe lerms lhereof are conlldellllal. Ifowever, III order Illllllel!e his claim, Plallnlrf muS! herelllafler rererencc and parnphmrsc III Icasl pontolls of lhc Agreelllenl. 9. The Agreellll:1ll required, among olher lhlnl!s, lhal the Presldclll or Derendant UnlvcrsllY, and thc Dean of Ihc Derendlll1l Unlverslly's College or Business would provide letters of reconllllcndalloll \0 prospecllvc cmployers. UpOIl Plalllllff's requesl. 2 10. Oil JUlie 2H. 191j(1, PlullIlIff IlIlervlewed wilh Prufes5ur hHIJ1 Muher, the ChulfllCrliOlI uf Ihe DepUrlll1ell1 uf BU6111ess Ulld Fcollum!cs fur WI16UII ('ulle~e, fur U lell1pomry leuchlllg poslllolllhul hud heell utTered hy WIlIilIIl College, Ihul WU610 he cUllduc(ed ullhe Spl11ll 'I'rl1ll1ll1g Celuel' III Curll61e, II. Plulllllff WU6 IU leuch 2 six-week courliCs III Murkellll!! MUllu~,emelll, Ihe nrM cuur/Sl~ lelllllllvcly 5Chedllled IU helllll OClllher I, \9'16: Ihe 5Cculld IU hc~11I N'lvemher 26, 1996, 12, PlullIllff'6CUll1pClllilllloll fur Icuchllllllhc cuurliC5 WII6 IU he $1 ,(~X)'()() per cuurtil:, for 101111 Cllll1pClllillllulI IlIlhe Ull10Ullt uf $3,2IXl,IXJ, 13. Durllllllhc IlIIervlcw, PIlIIIIllff ulld Prufcs5ur MlIher dlscus5l1d Ihe PUICIIIIIII for further lellchlllll cmploymellt uf Plull1Ilff UI WllsolI Culle!!e, III Ihe Murkellllll currlcululI1. 14. AI Ihe cUllcluslulI of Ihe IIIICl'vlcw, Profcssor Muher offered the pU611lo11 10 Plulllllff, ClllIIllI!!CIIl UpOIl her pnllnpl rccelpl of Plulllllff's Ph.D, I/'Unscrlplulld two leHer5 uf reconlll1endUllolI frum DefcndulIl l/lIlvl:rslly, 15. Profcssor Muhcr ordered (hc CUUr5l1ICXlhlJl.lk, ulld dlreclcd Ihc Ilullllsher 10 selld a copy of Ihc ICXI IU Plulllliff, which hc received III July, 1996, 16. Plulllllff wus llSSurcd, UpOIl his requc51 10 Ihe Office of Ihe Presldelll of ShlllllCnsllurll UnlversllY, AlIlhuny Ceddlu, Ihul leHers of recoll1l11cndnlloll from Defendalll Ceddln nnd lJefcndulIl Pope, Denll of Dcfendlllll Ulllvcrslty's Collellc of BuslIlC6S, would be selll dlreclly 10 Professllr Muher al WllsolI Collelle. 3 24. The provlblulIIII Ihe ^greulllelll re1lulrlllg IMelllfllllllllllvcrblly IU IlrllvhJe lellerb ur ~cullllllelllllllloll UII PlullIlIll'b hehulf, IIpOIl hlb re1luebl, Ib uf Ihe eblil!lICe uf thc COlli rIIC I hetweenl'llIlmllT und DerendulIl lInlvcrbllY, 2~, Derelldlllll lInlvcrhllY'b fullllre IU provldc II lellcr ur reCOlI\ll1elldllllulI rrom Ihe DCIIII III' lu College or lluhllll:Sh, IU Wllhllll Cullege, Ub re1luCbled hy Plulmlll, Ib II mlllerlul hrench or Ihc CUIIIl'llct hetwcell Plllhulll ulld I>efclldlllll 1I11lvcrblly, 211. Plllhulrr Imh flllly cUlllplled whh, IIl1d dlliChurl!ed hlb uhllgllllunb ulld dUlleb ullder Ihe buhject COlltrucl. 27, 1'111111I"'" hll5 buffered dllnllll!Cb lib II rebllll of the Dcfendllm'b hreuch ur the Clll1lrncl bctwccn Ihc 11lIrllcb Including. bllt 1101 Ilmlled 10 dlllllUl!eb 10 hlb replllllllun: Ihc IU55 or IIn clllploYlllelll opportunllY wllh WlllilJn College wOrlh III leUhl $3,2IKI.OO, ror ICllchlllg lhe IWO courscs ~rc~nccd III Pnmllrllphb 10 IInd II hcrelnbefore: Imd Ihe IJOlcl1llll1 for pcrmoncl1l empluymcllt wllh Wllbun ('ulll:lle UI' clsewhere Ihcrcllfler, InllnllllluulIlllI eXCCS5Ur $ I o ,()()(). 00 , WIIEREFOlm. 1'10111111'1' dCl1lllllds judllcmelll olllllnsll1efelldunl Ulllverslty III nil omuul1I In CXCCssor SIO,()()(}.I)(), cxcluslve uf Il1Icrchlllnd com, olld onllWIII'd Oflhc lelllll rces nnd costs or this oCllulI. s 38, ASlIl'Csll1I or Ddendul1ll'l~lC'H lllullclllllS, unllrlvllcllcd IInd unjusllllcd fnllllrc or I'C I'll 11111 to Ilmcly Ilrllvll'e Dr. Muhcr wllh Ihc Icncr Ill' rccllllllllcndulllln rCljulrcd by lhc subjccl Aurecmclll helwccn 1'llIlntlf'f IInd Dcfcndlllll LJnlvcrHlty, lind/ill' UH II rCHll1I of Dcfcndnl1ll)oflc'S dl6llvllwIII of Pllllnll""'~ prior cxpcrlcncc ICllchlnlllhc Iillmc or IllIubMllnllully Hlmllllr cour6C III I>cfendlllll LJnlvcrslly, 1'IIIInllfl"II clllllloymclIl by Wlllil.lII Collcgc Willi ncvcr CllIlllllnll11llled, 39. AI Ihc IIIllC of thc uctll lind/or Ilmllllllonll dClICrlbcd In I'lIl'l1grBph 29 herelnbcfol'C, Dcfcndllllll'olJC WUII nOlucllng wllhlnlhc IICOpC of hili dUllclI und/or employmcnl with DefendulIl LJnlvmlly. 40. All II rCllullof thc IlIlcntlonlll, IlnjulIlll1cd Imd unprlvllcgcd uclS lind/or omissions IlIld/or IlIlerferencc by I>cfcnduntl'opc wllh I'lulIlI I 1'1" II Ilrollpccllvc contl'llclual rchlllonllhlp wllh Wilson Collellc, deliCrlbed hcrclnbcforc, 1'111111I11'1' hUll lIuffercd cmOllollal dlMreslI; dllmagc to his rcpulllllon: lOllS of emplllymclll with Incomc Inthc amoulllof III leu III $3,200.IJO; and the loss of prospecllve fllturc cmploymcnt Wllh Wllllon Collegc or cl6Cwherc, Inllnlndelcrllllnllle amounl In exccss of $lO,()(JO.OO. WIIEREFOlm. 1'IIIIntlff demllnds judgemcnl agalnsl Dcfendants I)ope In IInllmounl In excclIs of $ 10 ,()()().OO , cxcluslvc or COSlS and Interesl; and IInllwllrd of lhe legal fees IInd COlliS of lhls nellon, 8 '. lI~lIlit " 1""'\ {'. . " , . , , ... '. Elhlblt I . ....."'...-. ", '.... .""'\ , , . , , , ..........k. ' .r'- ""'''-'' \~\ ~~, :\ \-~' \\ '~, ~ "-.) 1.......,. r ,.:j' "~ ~ i/: .. \\, ,...., a;;.: , . . !~ t..1':' " ~ q;( , I :t; J ~ f ~... t:!, \\ ' \:-1 ~~ ~, ,. fdl - i,) fl!' ,I-J ~.. - '}'):J ~~ I ,., ", 'II.~ b I r... oJ In ~ . ., , . ... . .. . Ktin@l19w KEITH f. KENDAU 1101 NDrth fruM 5rnilt' Il,,"jdxlfl. PrMI~tII" '" It} ~ III .,jlf h ~ E 't ' . , , . 01. I'lulIlIlff gulncd ICllurc 1111 u rlllll'wfclIl\llr IlIlhc ('Illlcgc Ill' 1I1111111CIIII Ill' IJcf'cl1lhulI LJnlvmll~ III SClllcmbcr, 19901, IilllllwllIll II ~ YClIr I'rllbuthlllury CVUlllllllon pcrlod. ~, Followlllll thc l\ I'll lit of tenurc hI 1'lulnlIlT, u dlspUIC ururic betwcell Dcfendlllll LJnlvcrlllly IInd 1'llIlntlff, which lhrclItcncd I'lulllll""'6 cOllllnulng cmplllymcnt wllh l)cfelldllnl LJlllvmlly. (I. I'lulntlff III II I1IlllJrull/.cd LJlIllcd SIlIlC6 CIII/CII, uf ElIbI IlIdlulI ruce IIl1d 11111luIIIII orlglll, 7, 1'111111111'1' pcrcclvcd the furellUIIll\ dlllllllle to hc II prctcxl fill' rllchlllllld/or 111111011111 orllllll dlliCrlmll1l1tloll, IIlld Wll6 prcpllrcd lu Illc II dlllCrlmlllllllulIlICllOII Dcfclldlllll lJlllvcrlllly 10 defclld 1I1l1l11l1l1 thc thrclltlo his cmlJloymclIl. II. Thc dlspUIC Willi Ulllllllllely 1'CIIlllvcd hy 1'IIIIIItllT's ugrecmelll 10 rcslllll hili emllloyment with lJefclldlll1l LJI1IVcr6Ity, In cllchllllgc for Ihc cUl1l1ldcrulloll 6Ct forth 11111 ccrtaln cOlllldclIlllI1 A GRf:'f:'M/:'NT AN/) G/:'Nf:'RAI. Ilf:'/./:'ASf:' (Ihc "AllrCCI1lCIII"). The Al\rec l1le 111 IS lIot 1I\lllChcd hereto, 1111 required hy 1'1I.ltC.P., I{ulc 1<119(h), heCIIU6C lhc terms Ihcreof IIrc cOlllldentlll1. Ilowcver, 111 urdcr IU IIl1cgc his c1l1lm, 1'111111111'1' mlllll herelllllfler refcI'Cllce IIl1d pllrnphrn6C porI 10115 of thc AIlI'CCmcl1l. I}, The Agrcemel1l I'Cqulrcd, IImollg olher lhllllls. thlll lhe Presldcnt or Defclldlll1l lJlllvcr6lty, IIl1d the Deullof the Dcfelldlll1llJlllverslly's College of llullllle611 would provide lellers of recommelldlltloll for prollpecllve employcrll, upon 1>111111111'1"11 reqlJe61. 2 Ill. Oil JUIIC 2K, 1'I'If!, 1'1111/11111' IIl1cr...lcwccI wllh I'rllk!llllr JUIIII Muhcr, lhc CllIllrJlCl'l\ulluI' thc I>cflurllllcllluI'IlUl\llIc~~ /11111 I'.cUlluIIIICI\ "01' WIII\III1 ('ullcILC, 1'01' utcllIlJlIl'llry lCIIChlllg Illll\ltlllnlhal hlld hccllulTcfCd hy WIIIIIIII ('lIl1cg~, thul WUI\ tll he COlldUClcd ulthc Sprllll Trlllnlllg ('clltcr III Curlllllc, II. I'luhlllrf Willi llllCllch 2 Hlx.wec CIIU r6C II 111 MllrkclllIlL MUIIIIL(cmcnt, Ihc nrM ClIlJrlie lI:nllltl...ely IIChcduled lU he:!!11I OClllhcr I, 1'I'IlI: Ihc 6CCUllcllII hCL.\11I Nu...cmhcr 2rl, Iljl/f!, 12, 1'11I1/IIlff'lI cumpelllilltlulI 1'111' ICllchlllK .hc courl\C~ WIU III hc $1 ,(j()(),OO IJcr cour6C, for IOlal cUlllflellslIllolI IlIlhc 11111011111 uI' $3,2()(),()(J. 13, During thc l/IIcrvlcw, 1'111111111'1' IIl1d I'ruleHlil.lr Mllhcr dlllCul\liCd Ihc IIIllCIIIIIII for furlher tcachlllg c/IIlJloYlllc/llur 1'IIIII1tlff III WIIIil.JI1 Cllllcgc, IlIlhc Mllrkcllllg currlculullI. 14, At lhc cUI1c1u~lol1 "" Ihe 1111crvlcw. I'rulellMJr Mllhcr uffl!rcd lhc IJuHltlon to 1'llIll1tlrf, comll1gcl11 UPUI1 hcr IlI'llllll" rccclflt uf 1'111111111'1"11 I'h,lJ. lriulliCrlplUl1d IWU Icltcrs uf recol1l1l1clldllllul1 from I'lall1llfr'lI prlur clIIllluycr, Shlppcl1l1hurg LJI1I...mlty. 15, I'rufellllor Mllhcr ordcrcd lhc cour6C IClltbouk, IIl1d dlrcclcd thc l)ubll~hcr 10 6Cnd II CUllY of Ihc leXIlo 1'111111111''', which hc rccclvcd 111 July. 1'l1/6. 16. PllIll1llff WII5 1I11~lIrcd, UpOI1 hili rcqucllt to lhc orncc III' thc I'resldcl1l uf Shlppcl1sburg Ul1lverslty, Al1lhul1Y Ccddlu, thlll Icltcrll III' rccommcl1datloll 1'1'011I I'resldel1l Ccddlll IIl1d JIIIl1C5 A. llope, Dell 11 or lJcfcl1dlll1tLJl1lvcrllltY'1I ColICIlC of IlUSIIlC55, would be 6Cnt dll'eclly to Proressor Mllher III WIlIIOII Collclle. 3 38, A~ II rc~lIllllf DcfcndUlII POpC'1\ 1111111c1ollll, lInprlvllcgcd und lInjlllllllled fllllllrc or re"ulillllO Ill11cly llruvldc 1>1'. Muhcr with thc Icllcr 0" rccllllllllclldlltllln rCllulrcd h)' Ihc MJhjcct ASI'CCIllCIll br,twccn PllIlntlffund Dcfclldlllll 1I11Iwr~lly, lind/III' liS II rCllllllof Dclelldllnt Popc'~ dl6llvowlllllf pllIllIllfrll IJrlllr eXl'erlcllcc ICIIChlll~ lhc 1il1l1lC ur IIUllllllllllllllly 11111111111' CUIII6C III ShllllJeluhuIIl University, plullllllrl\ Cl11pluYl11cl1l hy WlIlIllI1 Collcge WIII\ Icrllllnlllcd, 39, Al thc 1,lInc III' lhc IICtH IIl1dhll' OI11I~lIlunH dClICrlhcd In 1)lImgmph 29 herclnbeforc, Dcfcndllnl I'llllc WII~ IIcllllg Wllh thc IIdvlcc IIl1d CII1l6C1l1, IIlld/llr UH IIIlCllt of lkfelldlll1l Ulllverlllly, 40. Dcfclldlllll UnlvcrHlty III jull1Ily IIl1hlc 10 PhlltllllT ulldcr lhc IcgallJrlllclflle 0" rcTlfJOlldellt ~uperlllr IIl1blllty for lhc IICIII IIlld/1l1' olllllllllollll of Itll IIgCI1l, Dclelldlllll Pope, 41. As II rc IIU II of thc Intcllllonlll, lJlljUIlIIf1cd IIlld ullllrlvlleged IICIII IIlld/llr oml55lon5 IIl1d/or Il1IerferCllcc hy DclelldlllllLJlllvcrlllty Wllh Pllllllllff'~ flrolllJCcllvc COl1ll'llclualrellltlonllhlfl with WIlIilJl1 Collegc, deliCrlbed hcrelllbefore, 1'11111111,.,. hllll IIlJflered Cl110tl01l1l1 dlllrcllS: dlllllllge to hili rellUllIllolI; 10ls of ClIIlJloYIIICI1l wllh IlIcome III Ihc 1I1ll0UI1I of allclIsl $3,200.00; illld lhe lOllS of Ilr05IJecllvc "ullm~ Cl11plOYI11CIll with Wllsoll Collcgc or elllCwhcrc, 111 1I1111ldelerrnlnllle II1110unllll CXCCll5 0" $IO,()(JO.OO, WIIEREFOIU:, 1'111111111'1' de 11111 lid II judgclllclllllgnlnstDefelldllllls University alld Pope In 1111 IIIII0UJ1\ 111 CXCCIIS of $10,000,00, excluslvc of costll alld Interesl; IIlld IInllward of the legal fees IIlld costs of lhls IICllolI, 8 '" .' , CO.uN'I' IV. NliOLWliNT.INTlHU'lillliNCILWl'fJl.CONTJlACTUALJUJLA'l'IUNIi IWAN_Y...liJJU!I)J.lNIlIIUUf,j U NIVUKIlITYANU.JAMlill. A..I'JJI!1l 42, IIlImgl'llllh~ I thrlllljl,h 41 IIrc IIICUI11Ul'lllCtI hcn:11l11Y rcfcrcllcc Ihcrchl, 1111 IhulIgh 6Cl fUI1h III filiI. 43. 'Illc AllrCCI11Cl1I hCIWCCII I'luIIIIIIT IIlld IlcfclltlulIl IJlllvcrlllly, dClICrlhed hercluhcfurc, crclllctlu tlIIIY IIl1d uhll[.l,lIllulI'1I11hc 11"1'1 uf IJdclltlul1l l/lIlvcr~lly 1I11t111efelldlllll Pl~lC III III1Slsl PlllllllltT III IIrl)(;lIrc ulicrnllllvc CIIIIII'JYlllcnl fulluwllIll his I\eIlUrnllll1l frul11 cl11ploymcnt wllh l>cfclltllllll l/lIlvmlty, 44. llcfcndunl~ Ulllvcr~lty ulld POllc hrclldlcd Ihclr tlUly uf tlllc cllre III lI~slsllllg 11111111111'1' 10 ublJlllI ullcrnllllvc Cl11l1luYI11CIII, hy ncgllJ!,cnlly pcrmllllng Ihc IIIMlllncc uf Ihc derogalOry IIlId InjllrllllJII ICllcr uf IIIHl-rcculIllllClldllllllll 6C1 furlh UI Exhlhll II hcrclo, fmm Defendlllll I'I~JC III WIIIIUII CoIICIlC, 45. llcfendul1l PUlle hrclIchcd hili tllIly uf duc curc III 1'11I;nlll'l' hy ncgllllcl1lly Imllng II dcrogllllJry IInd InjurloulI ICller uf I1lllHeC1Jl11mCndllllon, .....hkh hc kncw or IIhould hllve known would jcopllrdll'c I'lull1lll'l"lI IlPIJorlunlty 10 ohlJlln or 1\1I51l1ln his employmelll with Wilson Collegc, 46, As II rC~lJII of Ihc hreuch hy l>efcndllllll1 uf Ihelr dUly of tluc cllrc In IIl1slMlng 1'111111111'1' 10 oblllln lllicrnnllvl~ cmplllymcllI followlllll his 1ICIlIIl'l1l11ln from cmploymcnt. with DcfendlulllJnlvcrsllY, Pllllnllffhllll sufICrcd CXlrCI11C CUllll1oU1I1 distress; dllll1l1gC 10 his reputlltllln: lhe 1055 of prosllccllvc cmpluymcul wllh WlIlIllI1 Collcgc with Income Inlhc umoul1l of IIllclIst $3,200,00; lIud IJnll\IlCClivc flllllrc cmpluymcl1l Wilh Wilson Collcgc ur cI6Cwhere, with IIn IlIdelCrll1lnBte nl110llntuf Incumc In CXCCSII Ill' $ 10,000. 9 " bhlblt A ~ '" ., " , , " . (.hlblt B ~ t""'\ I . I , .' -'~ -~mw /WI,. .. /IIH/WJ. I/QI II..., IlWIel.... II......... ,.....,....,. 111/ Q - -.---- MOIIAMED A, KIIAN, 1)1,lnllrr IN TIm COURT OJI COMMON l'UlAS, ClJMlUlRLAND COUNTY IlllNNSYl.V ANIA VI. Civil Action" L.aw SIJIPPIiNSIIURO UNIVERSITY and JAMRS A. I)OPE, l>ercndanll No. 96-6439 Civil I)RAECIPIl JlOjlRElSSuANc,n 011 WRIT 01' SUMMONS. TO TIIH I)ROTlIONOTARY: Kindly relnue Wl'lu or SlJlllmOll5 In Ihe IIbove,cllptlollW 1\1:11011, originally Issued November 22, 1996, IIl1d fOI'Wllrd lhe reluued writs to Kclth E. Kendall, Esq., c/o Kendall Miller, I),C" 3207 North Frolll Slreet, Harrisburg, PA 17110. Respectfully 5ubmllled, Date: December 19, 1996 - ellh E. Kendal, Esq, KENDALL MILLER, P.C. 3207 NOrlh Front Slreet Hllrrisburg, PA 17110 RnlSSUBD WRIT OF SUMMONS TO THE ABOVE NAMED DEFENDANTS: YOU ARE NOTIFIED THAT THE AOOVE-NAMED PLAINTIFF HAS COMMENCED AN ACTION AGAINST YOU. Date: /2 IN )U, , ' ~('I.U'~ E. W~ PrOlhonolAry or Cumberland County OY:&1y.~ (), lYtl&&,_ Deputy '1$ ~f .J ' ~..... -:t ~ ' " ..~ .... ~ ",. ..1' ';)-1 I" ,..J I' r' . i,', , j,.. r~(' , , ~ , " ." " \." ,.- 1. j t Jl\._. <'>1 " 1 ('oJ "-.'1' :=t.. \I') ..' '-:1 I :oJ; ..l.. " .'1 ;j U (n -~ ~ k Co "Cl'J ~ ~ ~ -n ...... "n ....... .......... ~ ~ ';:j :e. ~ ~ ~ "'" ~'- ~ J -:;.\cv 0'" f.l - '':: III Iollf i~ -- ..- IN TIm CUUllT UF CUMMON I'....:i\~ CIJMUJ':IU,ANIJ CUUNTY l'I':NN!iYI.V i\NIA MOJlAMt:J) A, l(lIAN, 1'llIlullfT Nil. l/a.Cl439 civil v, SJlJI'I'I~N!iIlUIU; UNlvt:llSITY IIl1d Ji\M.:~ A, I'l))ll~, ,Iury Tl'hlll>~III,,"d~d I)~f~udlllllll ))I~FI':NIJANTS' 1'lmJ.lMINAltY 01lJECIIDNti_:nHllj:;.A~ruNDliDJ:.o.M1'1tillIT Dclimuunl~, Shlppen~hul'~ Unlvel'slly und JUll1C6 A, Popc, hcreby prelll1llnary objecllo the Al1Iende,1 COlllpluill1 u~ ri.)lll)w~: LACK.Ol':.J1J lUJSDH.::I10N.!lYlilUllLJillJIJECU\\A'I"rlm I, The All1el1ded Cllnlplull1l C,)n6isl~ Ill' roUl' c,llInl~ scltln~ liwlh plulnlll1'lI clIlll1IlI: I) Bl'cueh or COl1ll'Ucl 1l~U11j',JilJjllll.c;JJ~l1ur~JJnl.l'J:rJiil:t) (Count I): 2) Urcuch of DUly of (JoOlI Fallh und Full' Dellllnl\ (!~)lIILY..JiJJ.lIlIlJ:JlJib.urll.!JnlYsJ]jm~) (Collnl11); 3) InlenlllJllul Inlerferel1cc wllh Pr06pccllvc Contl'Bcllllll Rcluuonll (KlWLY..J.J1Imi.AJ!9jl1:) (Counl11I): unt! 4) Nc~lI~cnllnterfcl'cnce wllh Conlrucluul Relullons O<'hul1 v, Anlhony F, Ccddliul.llilJJnnell A. I \ ~jlI:)(CounlIV), 2, Counll ul\<l11 of lhc Amcnded COl1lplulntllrc conl\'llClUal c1all1ls a~ulnslll stille entity In cxccs~ of $300,00 un" us ~uch clln only he brought In Ihc Bour" of CI III 111 II which has "exclusive jllrlsulcllonlo hClu' und uetcnnlnc ull ClIlll1Is uglllnlllthe commonwealth 111'lsln~ from conlrncts", entercd Inlo wllh Ihc ClIInl1lonwculth", ," ActofMllY 20,1937, P,L. 728, No. 1')3, ~4, IlA IlllWwIDl (72 P,S, ~4C151.4,) ~ ';:1 '>. c'; I.. t . ~ "~I , ,i .~!i ~: , J ~~ ~' 01.. I i~ ~'!f N j.;,,'} , !Jill n~ F-, ~~ I', ~ ~ r,~ ~.. '-', I' , I.' ./ I'll . " , , I' , '. .. , (' 1-, ,/ . , I, , , , , I,. , .', l! ". I', ." - . '.' , ) ,- Kendall Miller, P.C. o ___. \2l17 NIltlh Frllnt Slh'l'l I !;mhh"r~, 1"'I1I1.vl"ill1l;' 171111 <J. s~ ~ Jl'"' ~ !f ~~l ~ ~J ---,_.._.~