HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06511
~
.....
.
.
:)
"..
-
-
~
,
I
i
)
,"
,'"
/'
"
I
I'
I
, ,
"
I
~
"
'\.
~,
II,'
'1
ii,
:,~
'J
,~
'-'Jf~
"
il;
\H
'r
I CO
'I'
d
,~
ll~
if;
,
"
":(
,\'4
I)
"
'ill
'/
j
:'1
"
,i
'.
I,
.1
),'
"
,1,1
\~
, '~
.-Ii
:t
,I
;')
j~
'::1
'I
,.
.I~~
1',',1
,J~
. \;it
,i'\U
(,I
,- 'I, ~~
.1 '_IUL,
I i~iJ
, - "..~!
, ,~~
,I"l~
11 !~, ~t,t
) .,/,':il
'.:'illi'
I': '.:;!'~~'~I
, /;',lf~>_
~ I .', -',,)
" 1';j,,:J
I ~ ,l j f
"
.
:,1 JUN 1 0 199/
MSLISSA A, BAR'rH/
1?1aintH f
IN 'l'HIE COUR'I' ol~ COMMoN PLJ;:T\S
CUMJ3JERLANP COUN'I"f / I?IENNS'iINANIA
9G-G611 CIVIL TIERM
CHIf"P cus'roPY
vs,
PTWIP R. IWt'I'H,
Per.endant
OllPaR 0' COURT
, /If I ;1 I, - ,--,
ANP NOW, this ~ dl1Y' of ~' ,- / 1997/ upon
conl!lideration of the attached Motion for a cont,inuance/ it is
hereby ordered and directed as followsl
1, 'rile hearing previously scheduled for 9100 a,l1\, on
July 23/ 1997 is continued generally, to be rescheduled upon
request of either party,
2, The father, David R, l3arth, is entitled to partial
custody and visitation, including overnight visitation at a
mutually agreeable time during the summer and upon exercise of
such visitation shall complete his por-tion of the custody
evaluation by Dr. Stanley IE, Schneider, IEd,P,
3. In all other respects the Orders of November 27, 1996
and March 13, 1997 shall remain in full force and effect.
illc:;'( AI,
Harold lE.vSheely, P,J,
cel
Dale F. Shughart, Jr./ ESquire_ e,..J~ (}..."J,.l'/lt/t1'7,
Hubert )t, Gilroy, IEsquire --v ... ,kif'-
M~LIaBA 1\, RARTH,
l'laint if f
va,
IN 'l'Hr:! COUR'r O~ COMMON Pr.,SAS
CUMBIi:RLAND COUN'ry, P/ENNS'ilN/\NIA
96-6511 CIVIL T/ERM
CHILD cUB'rODY
DAVID I~, 13AR'I'H,
OefencJant
MOTION VOR A CONTINUANCI
ANO NOW, comea the Plaintiff, Melissa A, 13l1rth, by hllr
attorney, Dale ~, Shughart / Jr, and makes the following Mot ion
for a Continuance,
1. Plaintiff ia Melissa 1\ 1~aJ:th,
2, Defendant i9 David R, Barth,
3, The issue in thi9 Ca9l!1 involve9 the e9tablishment of
appropriate custody/partial custody/visitation arrangements for
the parties minor child, Ravyn M, Barth, born October 16, 1994,
4, On March 13, 1997, Honorable Harold S, Sheely entered an
Order pursuant to the Conciliator's Report which provided, inter
alia, as follows I
a, ^ hearing waD scheduled for July 23, 1997 at
9100a,m"
b, The father was to exercise partial custody and
visitation with the child prior to the hearing,
c, The parties were to engage the services of
Stanley IE, Schneider, Ed,O" to try to work out a long term
custodial arrangement for the child when the father, who lives in
the State of Wisconsin, was in the area visiting the child, and
d, Either party could arr.ange to have Stanley E.
Schneider (or another agreed upon professional) complete a
custody evaluation,
J, Shortly after. the custody conference, the Father
rescheduled his visit with the child from April G to the week of
May 18,
Ii, Immediately therl!ll(ter Mother scheduled appointments for
the parties with PI.', Schneider for purposes of trying to agree
\Ipon long term custodial arranqomentll pursuant to the Court
Order,
7, On or about Thursday, May 15 Father telephoned Plaintiff
to advise her he was cancelling the May 10 visit with the child,
The Father haa not visited with the child since January, 1997,
0, Following the cancellation of the scheduled visit,
Mother decided to make arrangements with PI.', Schneider's office
for a custody evalufltion to be completed prior to the Court
hearing and the undersigned advised Attorney Gilroy,
9. In order for PI.', Schneider to complete n custody
evaluation, the Father, must coopernte and meet with
Pl.'. Schneider,
10, PI.', Schneider'S office has advised the undersigned that
Pl.'. Schneider will be unable to complete a custody evaluation
prior to the hearing date scheduled on July 23, 1997, a copy of
which confirmation is attached hereto, made a part hereof, and
marked Exhibit "A".
11, Plaintiff has scheduled her appointments to complete
her portion of the custody evaluation,
12, The Father has agreed to continue the hearing and
complete the evaluation, as confirmed by letter from his
attorney, a copy of which is attached hereto and marked
Exhibit "B".
13, In order to allow Pefendant an opportunity to visit
with the child prior to a hearing, to allow the parties an
opportunity to try to reach an agreement, and to complete the
custody evaluation, both parties agree that the hearing date
should be continued generally to be rescheduled upon the request
of either party,
-2-
B, Pending Held heerlng, Fathet Intends to Ilxdrclsa at 0
minimum a period of portlal ouetody and visitation whloh
tentetlvely Is to ooour Irol11 April 6, 1997, through April 13.
, 997, The Fathor Is ontlllod to ovornlght vlsltotlon during thllS
tll11e frel11e, In the evont that this 111110 Irome Ie not oonduolve
to hilS sohedulo. upon i5grllel110nt, Ihe partlos IllOY sohodulo
another period 01111110 which Is available to the Fathor, In
eddltlon. If Fothor Ie ablo to cOl11e Into tho orne at othor IImoe
pending Iho hoorlng, tho porllos sholl work Ollt on appropriate
visitation schodule lor thoee tlmo periods,
C, The parllos agroo that they sholl ongoge the servlooe
of Ston'ey E, Schneider. Ed,O.. lor purposes 01 trying to work
out on appropriate long-term custodial arrangamant for the
child. It Ie ontlclpatlld that the partlas will meet with
Dr, Sohnelder when Father Is In tho ora a for his extonded
parlod of vleltatlon with the child,
0, In the avant that elthor party wlshos to have a
custody evaluation complllted lor use at the scheduled hearing.
the parties shall engage the eervlces of Stanley E, Sohnelder.
Ed,D,. or anothor profeeslonalthat the parties may agree upon,
Tho parties eholl sharo tha roepectlva costs of tho evallJatlon
6. Tht! Pllllnllll'lI poslllon on oUlltody III 011 folloWlI1 Plolnlllllloporotod fro 111
tho Dofol1dont In Novol11bor, 1886. Sho l11ado 1101110 olll1gollol1l1 at tho oOl1clllollol1
that thoro woro soma COI1Cllrns ovor Fothor'lI bohavlor towordf hor and tho child.
Hor primary CO"COrll, howovor, at tho conciliation wall thot tho propollol by tho
Falhor to hovo tho child 00 out and bo with him for oxtondod porlods 16 too much of
o disruption ot this tlmo ond sho wontod to do 0 transltlonol phoso.ln of this
arrongol11ont. Sho would not commit at tho conciliation to 0 spoclflc schadula for
tho phl.lso In but wontod to dotormlno tho opproprlato phoso In porlod by revlowll1g
how the child I'oacts and In conjunction with 0 profosslonol.
Mothor oleo cloll11s thot slnco tho portles soporotod, Fothor hos only ollllod
the child six limos desplto Mothor's roqullsts to him thot he havo contact with tho
child. Sho did ocknowlodgo thot tho Fother hod C0l110 In ono tlmo ovor January for
a three day period.
a. Tho Dolendont's position on custody Is os lollows: Father maintains thet
he Is oblo to tako core 01 tho child and has provon that In tho post whon tho parties
woro living togothor. BOCllUSO 01 tho dlstonco Involvod In this coso (approximately
1 B hour driving tlmol Fathor wontod oxtendod blocks 01 limo to occur and his
propoBal was to hovo tho child lor Intorvals of three wooks ot a tlmo. Ho was
ogroeable to 0 transitional typo of arrangomont but wantod a daflnltlve schodule set
up as to whon ho would havo tho child alono for an oxtondod period. Slnco Mother
would not agree to that, Father wanted to push the Olllle forward to alther gilt II
long-term 1I0hlldula or havo tho oourt 1110ko suoh 0 datarl11lnollon.
7. Need for lIoparalo counsol to roprosont chlld(ronl: Nolther party
requestad,
S. Nood for Indepondont pllychologlcol ovoluallon or oounsallng: Nono
requollted and tho Conciliator does not bollllvo ony Is noclllIsary.
9. A hearing In thllll11atter will taka one-half dey,
10, Other l11ottors or commonts: This Is 0 difficult cOile In that wo ore
dealing with 0 two yeor ohlld and paronts who IIvo 1 B hours apart. Mothor Is
roportlng thot tho child Is oxporlonclng dllllcultlos with this chango ond that Ilho
feels uncomfortoblo hovlng tho child simply go out to be with the Father IIlnoe tho
child has 0 hord tlmo separating from her. Father, on the other hand, believes that
ho III copable and able to take cere of the child now and IIhould havo extend lid
perlodll of time,
Tho Conciliator Indlcatod to the portloll that tho Father ultlmatoly would havo
extonded periods of tlmo with tho child elone out In Wlllconllln. The problom arose
all to when that IIhould occur'. Tho Ordor all statad Is an ottempt to get the partlell
to work tho problem out with en appropriate profellslonel end It III hoped that onoe
the pertles go over this mottoI' with e profaslllonal, thot 0 IIchedule IIhould be
worked out on the long-tarm.
Viii,
IN 'I'HIiJ COUWI' 01" COMMON PLMS
CUMI3IiJHLANO COUN'I"f, Pl~NNaYLVI\NIA
9iS- Viii CIVIl.. '1'1iJ1~M
CIlIt.P CUSTODY
Mk~LISBA A. I3AI~'l'lI,
p~aintJ.ff
PAVIP R. l3A1ml,
Oafendnnt
OJ(PItH OF CQUH'I'
ANP NOW, thia L(~h day of t]k-,tml,O" , 1996,
upon conliliderntion 'Of t11e lJttlJclltldComp~llfi1t'-;-TtTiI hereby
directed that the partiea and their reapectivG counael appaar
before -1!'llLbe.t.:Ll.J~_"~Ll),~~____ the conc.:i liator, at
~ . "_~.i-t.ldL,M~t.l'lLltJ.1J.__._n..._.____ on ,jhe .!!.t'L- day of
r!MJ~,----=- ,197' at ~ r.. .m" for II l're-
llearing CUliltody Conference, At IltieF.-- cOIlf:erellce, Iln effort will be
mada to relilo~ve the issues in disputer or if this cannot ba
accomplished, to define LInd Ih'ln:ow the i~lSUea to be heard by the
Court, and to enter into a tempoull:-y order. Failure to appear at
the conference may provide gl:ounds for entJ:y of a tempol:ary or
permanent order,
YOU SHOULD TAl<E THIS pI\pEH '1'0 YOUH LAWYBI<. AT ONCI?:. IF YOU PO NO'r
I.IAVE A LAWYIiJH OR CANNOT I\n~OHD ONI?:, 00 '1'0 OJ( TELEl'HONl~ 'i'HE OFF!CL~
SlET FORTH 13Ef,OW TO FIND OUT WHEHE YOU CI\N 01::'1' I.EOI\L HELP,
Court Administrator
Fourth Floor
Cumbel:~and County courthouse
Carliflle, 1'1\ 17013
Te~cphone (717) 240-6200
AMERICANS WI'l'H PISI\D!LITIES I\CT OF 1990
The Court of Common P~cas of CU\\1berJ.and county is required
by law to comply with the I\mericanlil with Disabilities Act of
1990. Por information about acceasible facilities and realilonab~e
accommodationlil availab~e to disab~ed individua~13 having bUliliness
before the court, p~ealile contact our office. All arrangements
mUlilt ba made at ~ealilt 72 hours prior to any hearing or buainelils
before the court. You mUlilt attend the scheduled conference or
hearing.
FOR THE COURT,
Patal
~~--v ..e, (,
13YI_~ 4" g~t~,'1.
Custody onc i tor ~)'.d
.. "....
MIiJLtSSA "', I3M'l'H,
tl~aintiff
IN 'rHE COUR'I' OF COMMON Pl.JIlJAS
CUMBJilRLANP COUN'I'Y, PENNSYLVANIA
96- r.,fll CIVIL 'rBI~M
CIIIl.JP CU/l'I'OPY
Viii,
PAVIP R. I3I\R'I'H,
pefendant
~QJJX COM~
ANP NOW, comefil the p~aintiff, Melilillila 1\, I3nrth, by her
atl;orney, Pa~l! l', Shughart, Jr" Blilquire and relilpectfullY
reprelilentlil 66 fO~~OWIiII
1, 'rhe l'~ aint if f ifil Me lifilfila "', a,uth, age 26, reliliding at
144 cherry Grove Road, Shippensburg (Southampton Township) ,
Pennfily~vania 17257, cumberland county,
2. 'I'he pafendant is Pavid R. aarth, age 25, rvaiding at
40B clay Stroet, Nel~~sville, Wl~conain 54456,
3. PlaintHf liIeeklil cUliltody of the following childl
Name
Present Relilidence
pate of Birth
Ravyn M, Barth
144 Cherry Grove Road
Shippenaburg, PA 17257
Agel 2
POBI 10/17/~4
'rhe child W61i1 not borl1 out of wedlock.
Tha chi~d ilil presently in the custody of Meli$1iI6 A. Barth
who relilides at 144 cherry Gr.ove Road, Shippenlilburg, PA 1.7257,
Puring the past five yearfil, the chi~d haa resided with the
fol~owing personfil and at the fol~owing addreslilesl
a, From November 19, 1996 to the prelilent at 144 Cherry
Grove Road, Shippenfilburg, PA 17257 with her mother, Melilillila A.
aarth, hllr matllrna~ grllndpl\rantJ.l, Jimmil!l W, Watt and Mape~ p,
Watt,
p, l~rom Septemper 15, lrJ9G until Novomber lO, l!l9G, at
408 c~ay street, Nl'lil~avil~e, Wia<lonuin 5H'ir, with her mother,
Me~ililaa A. aarth and her rather, David M, Darth,
Q, I\'rom Augllllt 10, l!l96 until on OJ: about flaptemper l5,
1996 at N3587 Fairground Avunue, Noil~avl~~e, Wisconain, with her
mother, Malilillila A. Ilarth, hel: father, David 11.. Ilarth, and her
pat.ernal grandpanll1ta, Hobel:t Darth flnd l<ath~eon Barth,
d, From shortly aCter her birth in october 1994 unti~
Augulilt 9, l!l9G with her mothor, Melilillila A, Barth and her fathrtr,
Pavid H. Barth, at lJOGl Welty Hoad, No, lB, Wayneaboro, Frank~in
county, Pennay~v~nia,
'rhe motheI' of tho child ilil Melissa A, Barth, cunently
relil~ding at l44 Cherry Grove Hoad, Shippensbury, PA l7257.
She ilil married,
The father of the child is Pavid R. aarth, currently
reliliding at 408 c~ay Streat, Neillaville, Wililconlilin 54456,
He ilil married,
4, The re~ationlilhip of the plaintiff to the chi~d ilil that
of mother, The p~aintiff current~y ralilidelil with the fo~~owing
pel':IiIOnal
Ravyn M, Barth
Jimmie W, Watt
Mabltl D. Watt
Relationlilhip
Daughter
Father
Mothar
Name
5, 'I'he re~lIt ionahip of the defendant to tho chilli il3 that
of father, The defendant cUrrent~y rellidelil with the fo~lowing
peJ:lilOnlil1
None,
is, 'l'he p~aintiff haa not plll:tidpllted al3 a P/'lI:ty or
witneua, or in any other capacity, in other ~itigation concerning
the cUliltody of the child in thilil or another court,
V~aintHf halil no information of a custody proceeding
concerning the child pending in a court of thilil Comlllonwealth,
P~aintiff does not know of a person not a party to tha
procaedinglil who haa physical cuatody of the child or claiml3 to
have cUliltody or vililitation right iii with respect to the child,
7. The belilt intarest and permanent welfare of. the child
will be l3erved by granting the relief requl!IliIted becaul3el
a. 'rhe p~aintiff, mother, haa remained at home alii a
care provider for the chi~d since the chi~d's birth and is
therefore the proper person to provide primary care for tha
chi~d. In the paat the father has been a subordinate caretaker
for the child who alillilisted the mother in liIuch capacity, At
current, the behavior of the f.ather, evidenced by violent rages,
ia creating a danger to the child, It ilil be~ieved and therefore
averred that at the prelilent vililitation between the father and the
chi~d IiIhou~d be liIupervililed,
8. Each parent whose parental rightlil to the child have not
been terminated and the person who has physical cUliltody of the
child have been named as parties to this action.
M'~LI SS/\ A, I3I\R'l'II,
P~aint if f
va.
IN '1'HIiJ COUR'l' Ol~ COMMON PLIilAS
CUM13IilRLI\NP couN'ry, PliJtmSYTNI\NIA
9iS-iS511 CIVIL TIilJ(M
CIHl.D CUSTODY
DAVID R, I3M'l'H,
Defendant
AlllDAVIT or saRVIC.
COMMONWli:AL'l'll Ol~ PENNSYLV/\NIA
COUN'l'Y OF CUMl3lmr..l\Np
SS
OU~e 1", Shughart, Jr., being du~y sworn according to ~aw,
depolilaa and fJays that he i'3 tha attorney for Plaintiff in the
above captioned custody action, that on November 27. 199iS, he
mailf'd a tl:ue and con'ect copy of the CUliltody Comp~aint, Petition
for Speci,~l Relief IInd Temporary Ordel: for r.ustody, to tha
Defendant, by certified mai.l with restricted delivery, pOliltage
prepaid, return receipt requested and eVidenced by raturn receipt
card No, P 269 313 2713 to Defendant' s ~alilt known address I that on
Dec<!mber 9, 19%, Defendant did persona~~y l:<!ceive samel that
attached hereto, made a part hereof. and marked Exhibit "/\" is
return receipt card No, P 269 343 2713, with Defendant's signature
affixed thereon, and that on December 12, 199&, he mailad a trUa
and correct copy of the Order of Court schedU~ing a cUliltody
conference, to the Defendant, by certified mai~ with restricted
delivery, postage prepaid, return receipt requasted and evidenced
by return receipt card No, P 269 343 275 to Defendant's last
known address I that on December 10, 1996, Defendant did
perlilonl111y raceive samel that attached hereto, made a part hereof
and marked Exhibit "B" is return receipt card No. P 269 343 275,
with Defendant's signature affixed thereon, and that the facts
liIet forth in the within Affidavit are true and correct to tha
belilt of hie information and be~ief. 1
~~~-Q~h(5~~LI
. a e f', S ug ~rt, Jr, , Elilq,
/\ttorney for Pia inti
35 East High Street, Suite 203
Car~ilil~e, 1'/\ 17013
(717) 241-4311
Sworn to and
th iii 6th day
" .
liIubscribed bafore me
of Januar , 1997,
'CAe
..'-'- .
llOlMl'Al51'Al
IltlNNIF.l WI/C, ';,II,1f,y r~Jfl.Ir.
l)t)1ir)OF '.'1 IIlilll' (-,'I'H:';'\, r;1/V11".t'.ttn(('!
MYt:lI',I~I':'l,f:,.j I \t"'ift; 'k'l':"" 11. IW:,1'
'-""'..~.."......... .....-.............,.........,...,
! ..
".. -.
I' ..:J
I .. 1.1'
It" p.J (' I
,
, ) .
I':' " :i
t'; : , I
I, It.,1
Ii .,'
, r,j
." " ,,-
U, .
. ,
I ,.., ,',
<., I)'
[jll/ : 'I
Viii,
IN 'rHJE COUH'l' 01" COMMON Pl.lilM
CUM13JERlMP COUN'I'Y I IlIl:NN13Yl.VANIA
fiG- {SII CJVIJ~ '1"EI~M
CIH LP cUSTODY
MELISSA A, 13M'l'II,
PlaintiU
PAVro R. I3AI~'l'J1,
Del!endant
ANP NOW, thi/,!
OHIJIER OI~Q!JJrr
l2f~ay of _lx\tJi~,
199G, upon
Petition for Sp&!cia~ I~eli.ef filed by tho PlaintJ.r.c, MeUrHla A.
Barth, pending further Ordel." of COUl."t, it i/,l hereby ol."dered and
directed alii follow61
1. The mothel.", Melilil6a A, 13arth, shall have tomporary
phYlilica~ cUliltody of the minor child, I~avyn M. Barth, born
October 17, 1991,
2. The father, Pavid R. l3arth, shall be entitled to
ft'equent and extensive vJaitation with the minor child, Ravyn M.
Barth at l;he residence of the Plaintiff, 114 Cherry Grove Road,
shippenlilburg. Southampton Townlllhip, cumberland County,
Pennsylvania,
3. Neither the mother, Melissa A, Barth, nor the fether,
David R. Barth, shal~ remove the child, Rnvyn M. Barth, from the
juriadiction of the Court of Common Plealil of Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania.
By the Court,
~I;: . 't-
fJ.
VB.
IN TUIiJ COIJWI' ~ll~ COMMON PLIiJAS
CUMIJIERt.I\NIJ COUN'I'Y, PIENNIlYtNAN IA
91i" I. ~'II CIVI L 'l'IiJJ(M
CII Wi CUSTODY
MIELIIlSA 1\, JJARTH,
Plaintiff
DAVID R. BARTH,
Defendant
Pf::TI't'ION l~OI{ BPECI.lll.Wl).';1illJU!Jllil.\JAl'lI
TO PA, R.C.P. 191~1
ANP NOW, Clomelil the l'~lIintitf/PetitionaJ:, Melilillila A. BaJ:th,
by her attorney, Pa~e p, ShughaJ:t, JJ:" ElilquiJ:G, and relilpectfu~~y
represenCIiI alii fo~lowsl
1. That your Patitioner ilil Melissa A, lJaJ:th, who J:elilidelil at
144 Cherry Grove Road, ShippensbuJ:g, CUl11ber~and County,
Pannlilylv~nia 17055,
2. That the Defendant/Respondent is David R. lJarth, who
relilidelil at 40B Clay Street, Nei~~liIvi~le, Wililconlilin 54456,
3. That the Petitioner and Respondent are the pl'.\rentlil of
one child, 1'.\ daughter, Ravyn M. Barth. aga 2, bOJ:n October 17,
1994,
4. That the Petitioner halil fi~ed II Custody Complaint in the
Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland county, Pel1l11i1yl vania, liIeeldng
phYlilical cUliltody of the chi~d, a true and cOJ:rect copy of which
ilil attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit "1\".
5. That the Petitione~ believelil and therefore averlil that it
ilil in the best interest of the minor chi~d that a statuliI quo
Order be entered providing the mother with temporary phYlilical
cUliltody of the child and i1110wing the father frttqllflnt ISl1d
extensive vi/Jitation with the child in tho hom8 of the mother,
ponding II conoilintion conference,
IS. 'I'he pllrtieu werll llIarL'ied 011 /lpril la, 199~ in
Chambllrl3burg, Pennuylvanill, /It the tilllll Petitioner WOfl a IiItudel1t
6t Internotionl11 lla6uty fkhoo~, gr6dlloting in M6Y 199~. 'l'he
J(elilpondant W6fl an enliated man, ru-6, in thfl United Statelil Navy,
working aa II carpenter at Camp David, Thurmont, Maryland,
'7. After the marriagll of the partiea unt.i1 Allglllilt 9, 1996,
6 period of one (1) year. tEin (10) monthlJ following the birth of
their chi~d, the partiea relilided in W6yneaboro, Pranklin County,
Pennlily~vllnia,
B, 'fha L~etitiol1er' a parentlil reaide in Southampton 'fownlilh.lp,
Cumberland county. 'fhe Rllapondttnt'liI pl1renta relilide in
Nei~~liIvil~e. Wililconlilin,
9, Since the birth of the child, the Petitioner'liI parent a
have had frequent contact with the child. The Petitioner'liI
mothec provided occalilional babYlilitting. PollowIng tho birth of
the child, Petitional." went to her parents' home for a week. At
one time Petitioner injured har back and spent liIevera~ daYIiI
recuperating at her parenta' home. One wea)tend per month, the
Roapondent worked at Camp David from Priday until Monday evening.
On auch waekandlil the Patitioner and the child IiItayed at her
parentlil' home in Cumberland County.
-2-
10. During thl!) firat ono (I) yellJ: ten (10) montha following
the birth of the uhi~d the Reopondent'liI parentlil vililited them on
three ouc8li1iona. On thJ:ee occaaionlil the paJ:tiea visited the
I~elilpondent'a parents in Wiuc()nsin,
U. On Auguat 9, 1996, the Respondent walil diuchaJ:ged fJ:om
the United Statea Navy, 'rhe partiea moved to hia paJ:lmtlil' home
for approximat.e~y aix (G) weeltlil. nUl:ing that liIix (Ii) weeka the
partielil l'Jlll:chaaed a home in NoillaviJ,~e, Wisconain, and readied
it for occupancy, mOVing to their home appl:oximate~y
September 16, 1996,
12, Shortly bafore the birth of the partiaa' daughter,
Ravyn, Ralilpondent'a younger brother died in an automobi~e
accident. Since that time, the Reapondent halil racurring and
increaliling out of contro~ intervallil of rage and tantrum. On one
occaaion he thre'lI a rocking chair and on another occaaion threw a
plate of food at tha Petitioner, while they relilided in
Waynelilboro, Pennsylvania.
13. After moving to their home in Neil~svil~e, Wililconein,
the Reepondent'a behavior deteriorated, He becl,I.me more and more
verbally and mentally abulilive and demeaning to the Petitioner or
ignored her,
14. Whi~e the partielil reaided in Waynesboro, Pennlily~vania,
the Petitioner provided primary care for the child and did not
work, A~though working ful~-time alii a member of the Armed
-3-
l~orca/l, the I~ellpondent did PI:OV ide cOlHlidol:abla II/milltance and
appropriatlilly cared for hi~ child,
15, Aftel: the partiell moved to WillcolHJin, tho Hl\lllpol1dent
IiIpent. ~elill3 and ~e"lIl time with the child 1111<1 increlHling periodJ:l or.
time away fl:om the home. The Petitionel: l:equolilted tho
Oppol:tunity to obtain omployment jn ol:del: to l:alieVll tho
financial prelillilura, The I~(tlilpondent inrJl:t'ucted hIll' thaI: hel: job
Wall to l:al11ain at home to talte cal:e of him IInd tho child,
16, Alii the l:e~ationship between Petitional: nnd the
Helilpondent detedol:ated, the Hespondent committed two nctlil which
endangared theil: child I
a. On or about Thul:lilday, Novembel: l~, 1996, the
Helilpondent was ~aying on t.he sofa with the child, Havyn. Ravyn,
age 2, decided to get up and wa~k ovel: to her mother, The
Relilpondent l:oliltl:dined his daughtel:, In the process he cauliled a
bl:uise on her cheek,
b, On Saturday, Novembel: 16, thfl Helilpondent was
wOl:king at the pal:tios' home on a ~addel:. He fe~~ off the ~addel:
and bacame angry, He threw 11 too~ and the ladder in II fit of
l:age. The ~addel: ~andad ~esa than two (2) feet from hel: daughtel:
and cou~d have caused hel: gl:eat harm, 'rhe petitionel: became vel:Y
upset and yelled at the J(aspondant. The HeBpondant stated, "I
don't cal:e, Gat hel: out of hel:e,"
17. Fol~owing this last incident the Petitional: decided
that fOl: hel: we~l being and that of the child, sha ahou~d l:emove
- 4.
llel'/:lelf trom the homQ, On Novombet' 111. 1991\ IiIhfl len and
returned to the home ot her parontll,
10, l'ennllylv6nin ilil thl! home IItat;e of the child, Ravyn wall
born in the COlllmonwealth or. Pelllltly~vl1nit\ IInd rellided hare fol."
appl."oxilllately one (1) YO/II." ten (10) IIIllnthll following hl'll." bil."th,
The chi~d I."elilidcd in the St6tu of Wiaconaill fol." IIlight~y 1II0l."e
than threo (3) monthll,
19, Althou(jh the child spent moat of. her ~He in Fl:anldin
County, Pennlily~vania. tho lIIothel."'a cUl."nmt I."eaidence and the home
of hel." parenta, who havo had frequent contact with tho child ovel."
the period of her life, ill in CUlllberland County,
20, Pot it lonl/ll." ilil t:oncertled that the l~eapondent might file
a cUliltody action in the Stato of Wiaconsin, which doe iii not
qua~ify alii the hOIllE! state of the child, and I."oturn to
Pennlily~vanill in an attempt to un force auch Order.
21, 'l'he Petitioner ia concerned that the father might come
to Pennay~vania to try to take the child back to Wisconlilin
without an Order of Court.
22. Petitioner be~ievElIiI that the sl.lfety and well being of
their chi~d reasonably I."equirea that the Court enter an Order of
Court granting her temporary phYSical custody of the chi~d,
subject to frequent and extenlilive viaitation for the father in
the home of the mother, pending the conducting of a conciliation
conferenco and until further Order of Court.
-s-
l3arl;h, her l1Ial;ernlll grandparuntlJ, .:J inunia W. Watt ",nd Mabd /).
W",tt.
b, 1"1.'0111 septenl!Jcr 11\, 1:J9IS until l'Iovomber 1.0, 1.99G, I1t
400 C~8Y fltreot, NciUtJvil.la, Witleontlin IIHliG with her 11I0thl!r,
Mclililu8 fl., I?arth and hor I~nthor, IJllvld N, I.lllrth,
c, l"/:om Auguut 10, l:J:JG IlnUl \')n ur 1I1.>0ul: Septol1lber lIJ,
1'1% at N31i07 Fai/:ground Avonue, l'Iul11uvillQ, Wiuoonlilin, with her
mother, Meliusa A. )3arth, he): fathel:, 1J1IVid IL Barth, and he):
paterna~ grandparentlJ, I~obert 13urtll lIJ1d I<nthleun Barth,
d, l"rol1l IJhort~y atter her bil'th in October 1994 until
Augulilt 9, 19% with her mother, Me~lfllHl A. Barth and her father,
David R, Barth, at 130Gl We~ty Noad, 1'10, 10, Woyneaboro, l"ranltlin
county, Pennay~vania,
'rho mother ot the child ia MeliBua A. Barth, cUrt'ontly
reaiding at 144 Cherry Grove J(oad, Dhlppenuburg, PA 17257.
She ilil married.
The father of the child ilil David N, Barth, currently
reliliding at 4013 Clay Street, Noil~avi~le, Wiaconlilin 5445r,.
Ila ia married.
4. The relationship of the p~6inti(f to the child ilil that
of mother, The plaint iff current 1 y residea with the following
persons I
Ravyn M. Barth
Jimmie W. Watt
Mabel P. Watt
Relationlilhip
Dau\Jhter
Father
Mother
Namo
IIA-211
I), 'l'he l."e~al:ionlilhip of the dofendant to I:ho child i8 thaI:
or. focher, 'l'he de fondant curl:ont~y 1:13/Jideo with the following
p13I'OOnlill
Nono,
1\. 'rho p~nintH r. hlHl not plil:tic.i.patl1d au 13 Pl31:ty 01:
lI'itncfJa, or in any othol: copocity, in othol: litigation conce):ning
tho cuatody of tho child in thiu or onol:hol: COlll:t,
P~l.\intHf hall no inforllllltion of a cuotody pI:oc<leding
cono<ll:ning tho child pending jn II COlll:t of thio Conullonwea~th,
P~aintiff doe a not know of n peraon not a party to tho
pl."oceedinglil who haa phyoicn~ cuotody of tho child or claimll to
have cUliltody 01: viaitation I:ighta with respeot to the child,
? 'I'he bOllt interest and pernlllnent welfare of the child
wil~ be served by granting the relief roqueetod bocaueel
11. 1'ho p~aintiff, mother, hao remained at home alii a
care provider for the child oince the child' 0 birth and ill
therefore the proper perllon to pl:ovide primary cal."O for tho
child, In the paat the father haa been a aubordinate cal."etaker
for the child who aosiuted the mothel: in uuch capacity, At
current, tho behavior of the father, evidenced by violent ragelil,
ilil creating a danger to the child, It is believed and therefore
averred that at the present visitation between the father and the
child should be Ilupervised.
B. Bach parent whoae parental rightlil to the chi~d have not
been terminated and the person who halil phyaical cUliltody of the
child have been named as parties to this action.
II A... 3 II
WHlJ:Rl1Jll'ORIi1, the lJlaint if f ):lJqueQt Q the c:ou):t to gl.'snt hel.'
lJdmBl.'Y oUliltody of the ohild QubjfJct to fl.'oquent IInd Q)ttenlilivlJ
viiiJ.I.tation with the DeflJndnnt at tho homo of the r~aintitt,
I~OWLIEH, ADDAMS, SIIUGI1AH'l' & HU m,~
." ~~!h~~-"I
Attorney I,P, No, 19373
26 south Pitt Stroot
I'. 0, l30x 206
carlilille, pA 17013
(717) 249-6300
Attorney fo): p~Bintiff
Mo~iQlila A, IJal.'th
I vel.'ifY that tho atatementa l11ad~ in thilil complaint al.'e true
and COl.'l.'ect. I undorliltand that false statements herein are made
liIubject to the penalties of 16, pa, C.S. 94904 re~ating to
unlilworn falnification to authoritielil,
,
)
,/
lIA_411
. .p
I I',
I " "
II( I) ~
'.fl :' ~ "
I',' 1/;,
'-,', /--,
(;" ""'j
. .1
L' [ '..
I ~ ' , )
.. Ll1
, '.' , J
,
,
.
lit I
,~ I '1'1 ~/7
MELISSA A. BARTH,
Plaintiff
I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
I CUMEBRLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
I NO. 96-6511
v
DA VID R. BARTH,
Defendant
: IN CUSTODY
9RPt:Jt9f_c;9.1.! RI
AND NOW, this ~~ ~ day of October, 1999, upon comlderatlon of the attached
stipulation slllned by coumel for the partlelln the above me, It Is ordered and directed al
followl:
When the Father, David R. Banh, Is In Pennlylvanla the week of October 25'h, he shall
enloy custody with the minor child, Ravyn M, Banh, born October 17, 1994, as follows:
A, When the Father arrlvelln Pennsylvanl,l on Tuesday, October 26'h, he may
contact the Mother by telephone at the Mother's home no sooner than
3:00 p,m, and he may go to the Mother's home and spend time at the
Mother's home with the minor child and the Mother. Subject to agreement
by the Mother, Father may take Ravyn from the Mother's home on Tuesday
from 5:00 p.m. until 7:00 p.m. It Is the Intent that Tuesday shall be for
Father gelling reacquainted with Ravyn before he starts more extended
visitation on Wednesday. Father shall not have overnight with Ravyn on
Tuesday night.
B. Father lhall have custody of Ravyn from Wednelday, October 27, 1999 at
7:30 a,m. until he shall return Ravyn to the Mother'l custody on or before
Friday, October 29, 1999 at 7:30 a.l11, or 5:00 p,m, prior to Father
leaving to go home to Wlseomln.
C. Should Ravyn not adlust to the overnight vlllts with the Father, he shall
telephone the Mother, and the Mother shall speak with Ravyn In an effort to
reassure the child. If the Father bellevelthat completing the overnight visit
may adversely affect hll reacqualntance with Ravyn, he may then return the
child to the Mothel"l home and pick her up at 7:30 a.m. the next morning,
\ It' \. (, '. t , ; ~
viI \ 1.1 fJ,lICf,
OF ",' , "" 11''''Jl~F/
990C1 76 M~ \01 \i \
CUM\~U\,I. ,U ic\AM1'f
P\:.Nt6'1'\.W'l'IV\
,
{\
\
I
,
"
\
i
\
\
\
\
\
I
I
\
\
\
\
I'
I
\
,
~~
4
'I)
" ~'l
"
. .!
11,1
,
,
\ ;,
Jpl ,
'I. J. , ,
I, " ,
It. . , .
l) t" ..,
'I
'.
C 'Ihe Jlilllll'l' willlhlvr, hy villue of Ihis olllll'ellll'lIt, ,\ pellod of vi,It.lllol1 with IIIl'
~hlld, 1IIIIWlI\I,lIll'e with the folllJwiul\ telll)S 0111.1 cOlldlthlllbl
I, MOIIIl'1' ,h,IIIIIOU"fel' cu,lody lJf the child 10 I Ill' P,lIel1hlll\l\IlIdp,u\!llIs, Itllhell
~lId K,lIhleelllllllth (hm.lthlflrr "( 1,.,1I1dp,II\"IIS") Oil Jllly ,'a, 100~, ill I ~)lldllY Uly, ()hlo,
l, Mollwl' ,1",lIl1wet (;l\IlIdp,lI\olll' 1111 the 111111llilll\ of July .10, 1005, whl'l\! Ihe
p.utle, ,hllll 'pelld ,lJllulthlle 10l\elhel' h) ell,lhll' ,he I'hild tolhlve ..mil' II~UlbllilJlI while 1111
p~llle, Ill\! '111I pll',elll, If IIIl' child exhihits iIIlXk'I.Y'll'l'xpll:,.e, 1\,IUCIIUll'e tOl\lJ thl\llIllh
whh Ih~ vUiIt, Mothel' .h,III nll,lilllllblody of the child ,111.1 l\!tUllllo Pellllsylv,lIllll.
,I. I'ollowilll\ d1l' illitl,IIIl',ulslthJll, if the child exhihhb 1)1' I'XPI\!S\\!S ,lilY illlxielY 01'
5IKlIlfblllll~lIlifest.lli()II' of hlJllIr.idlllm dutillK the l'llUIW of IIw visil while lI',\Velllll\ III or
while III WiwJI1,ln, (;l'.IlId)lill\'I1IS ,h,111 il1l1lwdillldy l'llIlI,ICt MOlher ,ullt .1I1'.lI1ge for the
Immediate 11'111I'11 of Ihe child \() Ihe cuslody of MOlhrl',
~, IlIlhe evelllth'"lllJ .uch dlffkuhirs ,lb comrm)llnted iUI1.1I\II\I\I)lhs IWOOl'Illll'e
hell'of occur, Gmlldpill\!IIIS .h.III'1'IUI1I ph}'SkillcuMOlly of Ihe ~hlld to Motlwl'OIl AUKubl
5,2005 nllhe 'llIlIe 10~,llilll1 ill J lolld'lY City, Ohio,
5, Dutillg the time while Ihe ~hild Is In Ihe physbl ~uSlody of Gl\llIdpllrl'lIUi, F~lher
5h~1I1111Ve ,upelvlsed vishilllol1 wilh Ihe dllld '"1d .hilll not be pelmlned III exeldse
Un5upclvl,ed custody of Ihe ~hild.
6, MOI1'ovel', GI\1I1dp,II'Cllt~ sh.ll1l1ot relinquish physic'll ~uSllldy of Ihc ~hilr.lLO illlY
other Pill!y wilhoullhe ptiOl' ~ollsel1lof MOlhel'.
7. Bnsed upollthe 'pecific l1Iedk,11 needs of thc child Ihe following plUvisions ilI'C
~150 h~ll'by ilKI1':cd 10 illld ,lcllIlowlcdgcdr
II. Dulil1g thc vishation pl,tiod, should the ~hild be~ol11e ill 01' l11edicill
lI'CnllllCl1lls dccml:d l1e~c",")', GI\1I1d)lill'CIlIS ,1K''Ce 10 imnwdiill.cly t'llll! the chlW to
thc IICill'CSI medic,11 f,lcilllY for Il1'illnWI1l. Gmndpilll'l1lS shilll ~'III Mother ~llhe
cillilm pmsiblc Oppoltullily 10 Infol111 hcr of thc silu,ltiOIl. Should Ihc child require
mcdkitlll'CiIlI11CI1l, Gl\lndpilll:IlIS ,lgl\!C 1<) P,IY illlY l\!,\ulred oUI.of.poclwl ~OSlS 10
tlw IlWdk,II plllvlo.ll'l~ ,llllI 0111,1111 ,I r\',"~ipllol' 1 "')'IlIl' 11 I 1111111 s,Iid pIIlVidl'''' MOlhl'l'
sh,llllll' glwll Ilw 1\'l'l'lpl ,lIld bh,11I bllhlllil tlw bol/I\l' III Iwl' lI\l'dIL',Illllbl"',IIl,~
pl\lvidl'l', lIpllll Mlltlll'I"'I 1\'l'dpl'llldllllllll~l'llIl'lllllllln hl'l' 11lb\1I',IIIL'~ '1II1i~l',
MUlIWl'llglWb \II IOnl',11\1 b,lld IdmhulWlllL'IIl\l1 til'ollldp,II\'lIlb, Nlllhlllg ,0/l',llIwd
h~I~11l sh,lll hl' L'lIlIblllll'd \II 'OIlW)' till' '"llhlllil>' hI L'llllsl'lllll) Illl'dk,IIII\'llIllIl'lll,
ulhl'l'lhm IIw gl1l1lllllg 01 '1Il1holilY \I) till! t;l'ollldp,II~lIlb 10 ,lIl1holi~~ IlIllilll
elllelll"IICY ll\l.'dk,IIII\'oIlllIl'lIllul' Ihl' dllld, Nllotll('1' IlIcdkJl,h'lslllllb shllll be
Illlllll' hy(il'ollldp,II\'IIIS III' F,lllwl' witlMII Ihe l'xpn'ss CIIIlS~IIl'll MOIIlL'1' whkh sllllll
be Obl.lllll'd l'ilhl'l'lll wlilillg III' hy dilWI Il'l<'phollL' ClI1l1l1111llk,llioll hl'lwl'l'lllhl'
Illedlclll pl\)vldl'l' IIlId Mlllllt'l'.
b, I )ul' 10 till' I,I,llh,1I till' ,hild h,IS ,111 ,'xislillg IWJlt cOlldillllll, .l,Opy 01 her
Ilwdlc,,1 ,11m ",11\1 will hl' Pllwldl'd 10 t il',llldp,u\'lllb Illlhl' l'WlIllhl'Y shollld 1~'luh~
II (ol'llll'dk,IIII~,Ullll'l1l dulillg Ihl' l'isil,ldlllllwliod, If ,lilY ~llll'll\l'lICY dl'l1l.lllll'eds
,uise, Gl'ollldplu~llI.s ,Idlllowll'dgl' Ih,lIlhl' ,hild C.lIl1l1)1 h,Il'l' 1I\'o1lllll'lll willlOUI
IlIlllblolks bdllg ,ldlllillisl~ll:d Oll~ hl,)ul' (I) prill I' 1.0 s,Iid 1I~,llIlWIll dul' III h~I'IlL'llIt
cOl1dilloll, Mollwl' shl1l1 pl\ll'id~ s,Iid ,lIuihilllks 10 (j1;lIIdp,u~lIlb 111 ohill, which
sh,,\I bl' l'elul11l'd 10 Ml)lh~1' with Ih~ chil,loll AUgllsl 5, l005.
8. Gl'.Illdp,II'elllS 'lIld F,ulwl' hrn~by ,IcllIlowblg~ Ih,u b,Iid villI is I,Illillg pl,ICe durillg
Lhe period o( Lillle which MOlhel' h,Id sel ,IS ide 10 Obl,lill Ilew s,hool cllllhes ,lIId supplies (01'
the cblld, 'lIld Ih,ulhe COSIS Olll'oll'dillg 10 ,llld IIlIm Ohiu 10 ,"',Ollllllod,IIe Ihis visil will PUI
1111 ,Idditloll,11 fill'lllcl'It Sll'olillOIl Mlllhcl', 'I1lel~f<ll~, (jI'.IIldp,lI\'IlIS ,Illd F,uher ,Igl~l' Ih,ll
during Lhe petiod of s,lid visil, Ih~y sh'll1 I,lhe Ihe .'hild Sh'lppillg for Ilew s,hool clolhes 'lIld
supplies.
II. lleC,llIse Ihis l'isil,uilllll1':pl1':SeI1lS Ihe fil)L tillle Ih,Ulhl' ,hild is beillg I~le.lsed 10
the cusLody 01 GI;lIldP,II1':Ill.\ (01' ,I peliod 01 dllw ill Wif;,OIlSill, (iJ;\lldp'II1':I1lS ,lglW 10
pltlvlcJe Mother wilh ,I wl1l,uive sclwdllle of ,,,,tlvilies pllllllted for Ihe l'isiL. SIIld schedule
sh,11I be sUbjecllO cll'lIlge bill slgllific'llll. ,'h'lI111es sh,III be nlllfil1llCd wllh MOtllCl', 'Illis
schedule sh.11I 'I\low MOlhel'lolll' Infol1llCd ,IS 10 Ihe chlld's well,hclng .11I.1 whel~,lhoul.\ ,11\.1
to ,IVoid disl\lpLing spl'd'll '''Iivides wilh <,ollllllullk,llions belweenlhe child ,11\.1 MULhel'.
10, '1111' (jmlldp,lIt'fllb, whilc Ill1l p,\Ilil'b hl'II'IO, h,IVC cxel'llll,d thc illl,ldll'd
ildulllWledKIlll'1lI ,11I.1 il,lIl'/lIelll sublel'lillg 1I11'lllbdws hlllll' ,Hllh'lIiIY llf Ihib ,lglt'ellll'1l1 ,11I.1
\lllhc lllliidklioll 'If i1w ( <HIli for ellfol\'CI11"1ll of IIw fOIt'fIOIIlIl ,IKII'l'Il11'1I1. (A 1/1IC ,111.1
Oll1l'l'll'OPY of s,lld ,11l1t'CIlll'11I1i ,1I1,ll'hed 1ll'II'I'1 ,11I.1 lilL'oIJlo""l'd hell'lll ilb Fxhlbll A.)
D, MOlhcl' sh,11I h,IVC It'ilbllll,lhlt, Il'leph'lIlc OIlIl.ll'l wilh Ihc .hild whilc the ,'hlld Ii '"
lhc .llbLOdyof (imlldpiut'fll~, III ,ll'COIlI.IlIl'C wilh this pl'IVibllll1, MOlhel' sllilll plllvide lhc .hild wilh
il ccllllL... telephollc 10 he ubed I"lI' the sole plllpose 'If C01l1111ulIl.-,1I1011 hel\\','ell Mlllhcl' 1111.1 t1w
child. Moilll'I' hilb Plllvided Gmlldp,lIt'fll~ with her hO/lle illld cdllll,\1' Id':phollC lIulIlbel~ 1111.1
Mllthcl' hilb (jmndpilll'lll'S hOl11e 1111.1 cdlulill' Idephlll1e IlUI1111l'1~,
1'., 111 ,lddiliol1lolhe bperii\1 plllVbiollb Plllvided IWIl'ill cOl1cel11lllg Ihe child'b hCI\hh,
thc (jmndpillt'fllb illld F.llhenhillll\l!ep l'oKh MlIlhel' ,Idvised II11/111:dl'Hdy Iclalive tll allY
clllelllellrics clll1cel1lll1g lhc child illld Sh,lll fUllhel' 1.111f ill1Y rll'l'CSbiUY btepb lll111SU11' Ih,\tlhe hCilhh,
wdfllll' 11Ild wclI hrll1g Ill' Ihe child is prlllecled ,II illl times,
F. '111e p;1Jlleb ilgl'CC t11.1llhey bhilll dlll1ot,hlilg thilt n1.\Y Cbl/.lIl"C the child fmlllthc
other plllllcs or hil1dcl.thc IliItllml devclllpl11elll of the child'b love or ilffectlOIl fill' the othcr pillllcb,
G, lnthe cvelll of Ihe bn:iKh of the ,lgl'eCl11em of Ihe pmb by 'lilY !l'lIly.the
1I0llbl'ellChll111 pmy shill! h'lVe Ihe lighllo file ,I pelitiol1 for COfllel11pt of COUll 'lIld to seck sperific
pClfol11l1lllCC of Ihe lCI11\S of the Ilgll'CI11CIll of the pmies. All costs, expenses '1I1d re,lbOIli\ble
iIllol11ey fees Il1cul1'Cd by the buccesbful pmy ill '\I1Y lilil\'lliol1tll Obl'lill ,111 Oilier of cOlllCmpt 01'
bpeclfk pe,.{OI1I1I1I1Ce of this ilgll'emelll slli\1I be l'Ccovemble ,L5 plllt of the ludgl1lel1l elllcl'Cd by the
COUlt.
H. While the p,lItleb LII'C frec to modify the provisiol1s of Ihb blipuliltlol1 by Ihelr Il1Ullh11
'lIld complcte IIgl'Cel11el1l, 11IlY subst'\I1lhll modiflc.lllol1 01' w,Iivel' of LillY of the PI'Ovlslollb of the
Ilgl-eemem of the Plllties shllll be effective ollly if l11ilde ill writing IInd ollly if executed with the slime
f0l111l1lity of this IIgll'emCl1t elltered into by the Pillties,
~""'6
Sf
,. ,n
" III
(0)
"
I
".
,.,.
, I
'III ,..
'''' I . .
,~,
I" I"
,', t...
NATHAN C. WOLF, ESQillRE
AlTORNEY ID NO. 87380
37 SOUTH HANOVER STREET
CARLISLE PA 17013
(717) 241-4436
AlTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
MELISSA A. BARTH,
Plaintiff
v.
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DAVID R. BARTH,
Defendant
: NO. 1996 - 6511 CIVIL TERM
: IN CUSTODY
STIPULATION AND AGREEMENT
THIS STIPULATION AND AGREEMENT entered into this ~ day of
:fc:t..-~1 ,2005, by and between David R. Barth (hereinafter referred to as "Father") and
I
Melissa A. Barth Ballew (hereinafter referred to as "Mother").
NOW THIS AGREEMENT WITNESSETH THAT:
WHEREAS, the Father and Mother are the parents of one minor child, namely, Rayvn
Marie Barth (age 10 years, born October 17, 1994) (hereinafter referred to as "child"); and,
WHEREAS, Mother initiated the instant action in custody by complaint filed on or about
November 27, 1996 at the above term and number, and,
WHEREAS, the parties wish to enter into a custody agreement relative to Father's
ternporaryvisitation and physical custody of the child in WISCOnsin; and,
NOW, THEREFORE, in consideration of the mutual covenants, promises and
agreements as hereinafter set forth and intending to be legally bOWld, the parties hereto agree as
follows:
A The Mother shall continue to have legal custody of the minor child.
B. The Mother shall have primary physical custody of the child.
C. The Father will have, by virtue of this agreernent, a period of visitation with the
child, in accordance with the following terms and conditions:
1. Mother shall transfer custody of the child to the paternal grandparents, Robert
and Kathleen Barth (hereinafter" Grandparents") on July 30, 2005, in Holiday Gty, Ohio.
2. Mother shall meet Grandparents on the morning of July 30, 2005, where the
parties shall spend some time together to enable the child to have some transition while all
parties are still present. If the child exhibits anxiety or expresses reluctance to go through
with the visit, Mother shall retain custody of the child and return to Pennsylvania.
3. Following the initial transition, if the child exhibits or expresses any anxiety or
significant manifestations of homesickness during the course of the visit while traveling to or
while in WISconsin, Grandparents shall immediately contact Mother and arrange for the
immediate return of the child to the custody of Mother.
4. In the event that no such difficulties as contemplated in paragraphs two or three
hereof occur, Grandparents shall return physical custody of the child to Mother on August
5,2005 at the same location in HolidayGty, Ohio.
5. During the time while the child is in the physical custody of Grandparents, Father
shall have supervised visitation with the child and shall not be pennitted to exercise
unsupervised custody of the child.
6. Moreover, Grandparents shall not relinquish physical custody of the child to any
other party without the prior consent of Mother.
7. Based upon the specific medical needs of the child the following provisions are
also hereby agreed to and acknowledged:
a. During the visitation period, should the child become ill or medical
treatment is deemed necessary, Grandparents agree to immediately take the child to
the nearest medical facility for treatment. Grandparents shall call Mother at the
earliest possible opportunity to inform her of the situation. Should the child require
medical treatment, Grandparents agree to pay any required out-of-pocket costs to
the medical providers and obtain a receipt for payment from said providers. Mother
shall be given the receipt and shall submit the same to her medical insurance
provider. Upon Mother's receipt of reimbursement from her insurance carrier,
Mother agrees to forward said reimbursement to Grandparents. Nothing contained
herein shall be construed to convey the authority to consent to medical treatment,
other than the granting of authority to the Grandparents to authorize initial
emergency medical treatment for the child. No other medical decisions shall be
made by Grandparents or Father without the express consent of Mother wlllch shall
be obtained either in writing or by direct telephone communication between the
medical provider and Mother.
b. Due to the fact that the child has an existing heart condition, a copy of her
medical alert card will be provided to Grandparents in the event they should require
it for medical treatment during the visitation period. If any emergency dental needs
arise, Grandparents acknowledge that the child cannot have treatment without
anubiotics being administered one hour (1) prior to said treatment due to her heart
condition. Mother shall provide said antibiotics to Grandparents in Ohio, which
shall be returned to Mother with the child on August 5,2005.
8. Grandparents and Father hereby acknowledge that said visit is taking place during
the period of time which Mother had set aside to obtain new school clothes and supplies for
the child, and that the costs of traveling to and from Ohio to accommodate this visit will put
an additional financial strain on Mother. Therefore, Grandparents and Father agree that
during the period of said visit, they shall take the child shopping for new school clothes and
supplies.
9. Because this visitation represents the first time that the child is being released to
the custody of Grandparents for a period of time in WISconsin, Grandparents agree to
provide Mother with a tentative schedule of activities planned for the visit. Said schedule
shall be subject to change but significant changes shall be confirmed with Mother. This
schedule shall allow Mother to be informed as to the child's well-being and whereabouts and
to avoid disrupting special activities with communications between the child and Mother.
10. The Grandparents, while not parties hereto, have executed the attached
acknowledgment and statement subjecting themselves to the authority of this agreement and
to the jurisdiction of the Court for enforcement of the foregoing agreement. (A true and
correct copy of said agreement is attached hereto and incorporated herein as Exhibit A.)
D. Mother shall have reasonable telephone contact with the child while the child is in
the custody of Grandparents. In accordance with this provision, Mother shall provide the child with
a cellular telephone to be used for the sole purpose of communication between Mother and the
child. Mother has provided Grandparents with her home and cellular telephone numbers and
Mother has Grandparent's home and cellular telephone numbers.
E. In addition to the special provisions provided herein concerning the child's health,
the Grandparents and Father shall keep each Mother advised immediately relative to any
emergencies concerning the child and shall further take any necessary steps to insure that the health,
welfare and well being of the child is protected at all times.
F. The parties agree that they shall do nothing that may estrange the child from the
other parties or hinder the natural development of the child's love or affection for the other parties.
G. In the event of the breach of the agreement of the parties by any party, the
nonbreaching party shall have the right to file a petition for contempt of court and to seek specific
performance of the terms of the agreement of the parties. All costs, expenses and reasonable
attorney fees incurred by the successful party in any litigation to obtain an order of conternpt or
specific performance of this agreement shall be recoverable as part of the judgment entered by the
court.
H While the parties are free to modify the provisions of this stipulation by their mutual
and complete agreement, any substantial modification or waiver of any of the provisions of the
agreement of the parties shall be effective only if made in writing and only if executed with the same
fonnalityof this agreement entered into by the parties.
1. The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County has jurisdiction over these
issues and shall retain such jurisdiction should circumstances change and any party desire further or
require further modification of said Order.
VERIFICATION AND
CONEIRMATION OF AGREEMENT
We do hereby verify that the acts set forth in this stipulation are true and correct. We
understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. ~ 4904,
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Furthermore, by the execution of this Confirmation,
we do each unequivocally express our mutual and voluntary agreement to the amicable custody
arrangement provided above and request that the terms thereof be entered as an Order of Court
without the necessity of a custody conciliation, hearing or other proceeding.
'3 0 -::rJ-i;
,2005
Oo.fi~c-QAL)
DAVID R. BARTH
~(7(j
go fc1if=-, 2005
,2005
/
--~~
. <? 0 TIA/ ,2005
- /
~y)ql/c&~~
ltness
MELISSA A. BARTH,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DAVID R. BARTH,
Defendant
: NO. 1996 - 6511 CIVIL TERM
: IN CUSTODY
ACKNOWLEDGMENT AND
CONFIRMATION OF AGREEMENT
We, the undersigned, do hereby verify that we are Robert and Kathleen Barth, of Neillsville,
WISconsin, identified as the Grandparents in the custody agreement executed in the instant action,
and that we hereby voluntarily agree to accept the responsibilities and obligations conferred on us by
the parents' custody agreement. In so doing, we acknowledge that we shall be subject to the same
penalties for contempt of said order and shall be subject to the jurisdiction of the Court having
authority to enforce said order. We furthermore verify that the facts set forth in this stipulation are
true and correct. We understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18
Pa.C.S. ~ 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Furthermore, by the execution of this
Confirmation, we do each unequivocally express our mutual and voluntary agreement to the
amicable custody arrangement provided above.
~t"'::> . "f../U.J
""'--1. L ,2005
.
~~ ~:8 ~ (SEAL)
ROBERT AATH
D~~~
'-30 ...:JiJ-----}' , 2005
Witness
30,fJ7!
,2005
~til-&J~ f~~AL)
THLEEN BAR H
'S? --:JiL J
J
,2005
~___ O~
Witness
EXHIBIT A
v.
RE<E1VE~411l>
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
MELISSA A. BARTH,
Plaintiff
DAVID R. BARTH,
Defendant
: NO. 1996 - 6511 CIVIL TERM
: IN CUSTODY
ORDER OF COURT
NOW, this tl..lh day of i~'1'-- t ,2005, upon presentation and consideration of the
,
attached Stipulation and Agreement and upon agreement of the parties, it is hereby ordered and
decreed that the attached agreement is made an Order of Court.
BY
J.
Distribution:
Nathan C. Wolf, Esquire - ~ -fl """, ~d e,.,,.L <//- / /OJ-
Fotthe Plaintiff f. (J -/1 0 J '"F/'
David R. Barth <;f / ~
Pro Se Defendant _~..-t O;,y! QJ tl. ,
:',)
-<. co
'"
C':;:)
C"~
c,n
~J
'n
;T;"
,ilj=.__
-,....,-fT1
';....-,
; i '.~"
i .,,_,
I ~ I
'. ;~r'i