HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06553
,r-
.
...
~ I
,
'" I
,
r I
'..
- I
~
: 0
v
1 'f
I L,
, , 'I.~
'IJ
, iF
; '11'/
',I :i;'li,~
I -H
1;1
d,t
'),
'I
',i
".1
'.'
,j',
,
I
,
i1~
,.
, I.
",
II
',I
,
'I
it
,:,
,
III.
I
1\ J:,
,I
"'i'
" -~
:;/
'I<
l
i
"
.,r
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
.,
.
() IEIIN 1 1,1\ IE CAII'I'I!11 (OIlM>tr, l 'i~,___ "
-.-.--.-.------....-. --
IIIIII~ C'II11'llIf CIIIJIIJIIIIII'IVIIN "'
l'IIIIIIWI'II11I1Il'III1I1I~, I'VIIIII)hllnlll
VI,
/'i",
l'i~~J
_ l'lliI, 1\/ .~~.__ h'_
NAHII WAnE OllllMr.lNO
.._---.~._._.__..._-,--
-- --_.._-~..~-_.. -----.-...........-
--..-lINP.l'If1ltJ lldqmllnt .hl, 9n t'm~d '01: PI.fI1N'l'Iff j OEIlNIL.r:;r:;, CAIi'I'IEIl, (.'J/WIW'/OLiJL____
.~ll'!ul!~l()lJ'lt of nh'519,6'i .i,n~h[/ <Ibovo l1uml:Jerod (lCll1fh JLlllllllllll1t.1ILlll1t!l!.!!U!JI11D!-
"hQfn~~)Wfr,J'!l\IIIII#\PI5uOBlIMr,lN(j.
--~--~. ._._~. ----~--
-.--- -..~.--. ----,.--
._..-.~-_._--_._-_._-
,.----..-..-+-0---.-.-----.---.. .
-., .....-__.,. . ___...._n...____..~_
-...---.---.----- .-" .-----.-.,.
. ...-----.--.-......--.-----.--
-,-1-----------_...- _'._..
.._,_.__," ._.....u~_.____
--..._-----_......_-----~.-,..
To
"tUlIl'/IIUlllty
--_.-._--._--~.
1'1 ,. _~ ._..
!.L,wl", J1~Ji...J)J., ". ~'J)
~IllRIQ~ 1'1111111111'
"
....
.
""
II "I
I ,.j
I' . "
" , I
II
1.',1 ."
I
1.1 I
I, "
, ,
" I '>I
" . 1)_
,
, ,
,
('
~
I
0.
/"I
-:t
~ .~
~ u
q. fJ
., f.n -a. It '2
" ,I - It)
I ,.
III l'j ~ 11 '1t- ~1
' ,
I' , ' , :j cL
".
l.,r: 0
.',
!,," lo-t III IE.
['' / : 1;-'1
.' I'
I , , ,
I' , . I
'. c.' I)
>, '"
i \ '~.
i 1',
I':: " .
1'- , ,
I,
" "11
hi' ,..
n'l i I tl
, , "
I
" I ,
'.,J lJ' " I
..
,
, ,
,
"
I
'(
" ,'1)
I ",
, "
i.'{'; 1,>1
I
II:, I ~
'I)' ,'\ I
[ l' " ,
I' ,
1,1, ,
I I
" .
j
I, \
I..J
....
"
I'
'I
'.. ~\Q ,.;)
'7,: ('l , :""t
,
u\ 1.1' ~
[,I ,I; I, \ ~
\1'''' "1
"IlL
VI I,' I'.!
, I , ,I~) ~
~(, pl
" I ,'f
hi'. t \Ii,~ .....J
(:"; I..,!
I 1...1 ') <l..
\, IJJ 1')
" C'
~
-
-
{2..
1""'\
\>...
~-a
'<M ~
"'lS
~~~
Q'\
2:'
,~
.~ j;
..
,
,
I
Ii
.-. ,
)... l ""'f'
"
1'1
I
3, Compllllllllnl did 1\111 hllVC IIn llUlun\llblle for llppl'1.1Xlmlllely Ihree YCllrs
Illllla Ilmll uf December, 1994,
4, Respolldenl soughl, Ulld IIccepled, cmpluYlIIelll III Cumberlllnd
Mllryh1l1d: elllpluYlllell1 hegun ulIlJecemhcr 2, 1994,
~. I{espolldellt Vlllullltlrlly uffered, 1II1l\ pl'llllllsed, to purchllse II cllr 1'01'
Complulnlllll, Gernllee Curter ulld Ihelr child, lie wus IIcceptlllg employmelll
wllh UII excellellt sulury und he ul\(h:I'SlllOd he WIlS lellvlllg Ihem wllhout
Il'lInSpurtlltloll, lie hud been Ihelr fiuurce uf Irullsp1ll111tlun for Ihe previous
yell 1',
6, At Rl~spolldent's dlrecllon IInd with his guldllnce IInd help II cllr WIIS
purchllsed,
7. Respulldent Ims 110 credil, so the cllr WIIS necessllrlly purchllsed ill
Compllllmllll'S 1I1111)(l,
8. Respondelll promlfied, volullteered, thlll he would be responsible for lhe
eliI' pllymenls,
GERNJI,EE CARTER (GRAM....NG)
CompllllOlUlI
NTIIE COURT Of' COMMON 1'l.IAB
CUMDERl.AND COUNTY,I'"
NO. , 1996
CIVIL ACTION. UW
Y.
MARK W. GRAMLING
Itespllndln'
~E.RTtFICATE. OE.a~
I OcmUcc ClII'tCr (01'11I11111111), w} hereby certify Ihot 011 Noyember 11. 1996, llorvcd I
copy or th.. rO"'8011111 upon Iha RESPONDENT by Ctrtlfled Mall and dopallunl II at the Unl~
SlAtes POIt Ofl'lec, pollAKe praplIW, l\I1dreued IU followsl
Murk W. Gl1IllllIlllI
cIa I A COlllU'\lCllon
P.O. OOK ~O'f
CUmberlond, MllfYllIIld Zl ~01
IInd
Mark W. Oromllllll
30' N Lee SlJ'CCt
cumberlond, MllfYllIIld 11 '01
OBRNlLI!ECARTER (OAAMLOKlI Jt/llJ';J... ~ (lJ,,, '''~ )
III S 14 5T 7
CAMP ::fjPA
DATEt Qt1U1.J.m...9I,li'lt
./ .
v.
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON II\.I~AS
CUMIIICIU,ANn cnUNTY,I'A
NO,'J6.6S!I:ilCIVIL TI~ltM
9~.{P[j!)3
CIVIL AC'1'I0N .I.i\W
OERNIUE CAR't'ER ((lRAMLlNCl)
111,A1N'I'WF
MARK WAPJIC llRAMUl'IG
nll~n~N\)AN'1'
'1'0: MARK GRAMLING
YOU ARE 1IF-lmllY NOTlI'm\)
TO tILEA\) 'TO 'TI\I~ I~NCI.OSm
COMI'I,AINT WITItIN
TWII~N"'Y (211) DA YS 1'lWM
TilE DATI-: Oil SEIlVICE
IIERETO OR A nEllA LJ Ll'
JUDGMENT MAY liE
EN'1'ImW AGAINST yOU,
Oemilec Cuncl (UIIlJiilll1\l)
III SOUlll 24111 STREET
CllmplUIIIP~ 17llll::/v,A ()}n .
)/;AhfL.t,. 1L ~W~)
ProS, ~ I
DATE Mnnf 17. /17?
. I
3. Compllllllltnt did 110t hllve lln llutomoblle ror npproxlllllllely three yellrs
III the time of December, 1994.
4. Respondent bought, lInd accepted, employment In CwnberllUld
MnrylllJ1d; employment begWl on December 2,1994.
5. Respondent volun14rlly offered, lInd promised, to purchase n cnr ror
Complainant, Oemllee Cnrter lIJ1d their child. He wns llcceptlng employment
with lIJ1 excellent salary nlld he understood he WllS leaving them wllhollt
lrlUlBportntlon. He had been their source of trallsportatlon for the previous
year.
6. At Respondent's direction lInd with his guidance nnd help n cnr WIlS
purchn/lCld.
7. Respondent has no credit, so the car was necessarily purchased in
Complnlnant'slllllllC.
8. Respondent promised, volunteered, that he would be responsible for the
car paymenta.
II :J1"t lid L I'i
..... "'/Lll/'l" "ll
4!.. f/",~~!,~.~,~~t M~~','
.I: I'.', I : , I" Ill.' '1~j I, , '1,10 t,
t ~. , " fI" 'II ,. I ~ ..
,II"'.I"fold
""/I,dM,)ll
It W OJ'lIMltINU
r 0 Iklx 50?
Cl/mge~ 11llld Ill}
~I~O~
$ ,S"~
/./6
11 ",
-....
'"
, .',
~ I,' .
, "
I,
"
:{'
'f. ~I.I"m" I """" I I., 'ddlll""~ "'>I,..
, · CIHnf>>I'I'I,.m. 3. .nd ... . b.
, Pftn, VOII' name .nd add",. Oil Iht "~tI.. or .hl. hm" '(I 11111 ~. till
liNt" llll. a.twf IIJ VIN,
. ""'th "" '"m I. 110. ".n' 0' ".. mOl"'''', ., ",".. both II ',,,,, I, I A~~"...... A~~"..
do.. 1\01 '*",11
I . Will. """"""""pl A......."." 00 'h. m."..", 1tM... "" """''''''nbo, 2, Cl AU"/I."~ Ooll..,V I
· . TllI "ltU," ~.ulpt v..ItI Ihow IQ .,.,hOllllh'"I1c1. WI' d.H~".d IIliJ Ih. ","
B !!!!!Jt~_ C.II!J!!ljlO"ll1'"'' ,~, ,~
, 3, AiiJel. Ad."...d I.' ~., 'II.li1lumb.. I"
ATIN M GRAMLING r 344 7G3 137 J
r A CON5'l'RUCTION ~II, SiiWclTVIII :--____ _',
n A'UI"."" u III'''''~ .
P 0 IlOlC 507 IX. C."",.,. 11 coo ,r
aJMBl':ALAND tolD 21502 h h,,,... M.II [J 11.'""1 A'."III ,.,
--.:---~--~.J~IIJJdit'--__ It
7. 1J"..r O.II..,v 6 ..
-.--- --,DBL..:~ 19!_.___l
e, SlgII.IU" IAd~I"".' 8, Add......'. Ad,',... 10ll'V II "q"""dl
~~ .n~ ,.~ I. p.I,"
i e, ~""l :'"1 -- -___
: ! .'m 91 .".',11I'OI I............
I ".0 WI.h '0 IIc.'v. 1/11
/.I/owlng ..'.1... lint III "'"
'"/1
I
DOMESTIC RllTURN RICIIPT
" oo-'J'
I'
1.1/ " ~ ..
/.
t.'j "
Ii-: ' It: , [',Ii
,
I
"', ,
'. '..J
.
\
\
d~:l..cw" ",~II (I,,,,,. d'
'''''''-
CHl'1"',.k' ,(.." "",-
Il" L II/" /...l'f' ,. ,'-
"
.J. ",II', p"'1 /,(. I'I
'J, II)' ~ l\"".",""j", .. I' IL
f(, ~ C,.,,,I'.
IlJ' I;~.~.
........ (a..t, H '-ll ~~Vl.1. ,
..I "'I
11.
It),d, I '6
II.J .,1I-
(' '
..1.. '0 ,,,,,{,
)
~ ,\." I.. ,( L.. ~,.._.~
() ",t..." II' ,.J~' -rOI" y.' L. ;j)'1'" AlII ,.J..\
~v-..4..L~.i.~ (~..... f'"' Ll.."..... l" t./.,.,t /".,1
.Ii \\ 'j~.~"'lr-I I
.-'--'"
",-.._~.....-
<::_,.
,I
-,
"
I.MI'II';/'H:I-; I';. WIl',IOW, i'11l1'l'1I1I/'Il)"'^,lY
CIIMII";III,/I/'III CI)U/'ITY 1 'l III 11'1'111)11111';
I ('1)1)11'1'111)1)11I'; IllJU/lIII';
C/lllloIIII,"; 1'/1 ''II) 111111/
('/1.'/1 J~I)-hl''''
/)/1""';1
(..I~""" 'I.., ...,._.._' I ",.'1J
"'I) WIII!M I'" MM CI)/'ICIWN I
Wo ilrU 1'lIll1rnln'J 1:lIll llnl1lllllOlI Inlllll/Illlllln( III IIII' 11111 ('clI.lllwln'l
I'll ,Ill< 1II ( III .
/'10, I
/III IrlltlllllUtirlllll 1I1.routllll I,u
~Illl !lli Illj 1~!)liJ'!.Y.'!o I ,0 I!~
~'U~:.J!
1;11111 onluo /'lIHI'I"t:I%IIIlM ~ alJ,!!!,~
!' () 11'1' /I..1i I';, 1I /I l'otllrtl
in lI'llIlnlll. 1'lIVll1l1nl of filillg
Ill' '111'1l1 In Ol/IH'V 111111;/11100,
rlll1olJll;, '1llrl;l.tl.llIIl;ll 01' UUIIY
hill wIll hu ('011111. nlll III; t:l 100
/'Ill, J IIlCIlITOI1I. 1'110 r.oool.1/1lI1 G,__.,__....
I 1111011111. liB G_____
/'Ill. ') /'10011 ,,1~JlIlll.llro ___"'_'_'__'__~____n_'__"___"'_"__'n
/'Ill. 4 /'10011 I'<lWOI' 0" /l1;1.1lr.nov ,_._,___.......
No, 'i (~,J<:_,!A~.. \I''..!1.1..:.) i:.,nltu:.,.,.' I LL_:l/!!1J t.J.._.......I~.J~~/..." ..J ~ L~
.__J~Jt..u'- _~I.l-.......!.~..LJ..t!:;""-.!.!...I~_ 11...1') .",,~!~,____
)~~~--.f'p~'WJu.i....:--';~.J,:"'--')Ij.L111f-~J:. A" H. ..:..t... -Jj.
"'0 (!.!n~!..!~~t.1_._.._.__..___,____..___... ...__........._....... ,
L_~_ 1.(i,1...."4J....:u..~/1LI.u..,_Il..tl.J.L..._...~I~._ (1,,'--~.!1:~0_~-1u~a"'_
.n ) .,)
_,J::h.t,.bo~..J~.J4~Y- fl" ...L_L~!'.!.!.tI.....Ul.L.c.__._._.._..
'L_Ch.tu..- . .i'~'Jl.I...dU.lI..~ I l..1i......:- )"''';1''--...J1.> /iJ.L9''':'''- d,,,, d...a...,..._
II AA . . · ~ ' /) " C f\'l ,.. U J'- ,., .. I) I
.~ J"""-_......."'"""""--. . !.__u.v.:c..~,_~J!l.l._.LJ..!,-... .r ~I,Uh..l4J.. ...~'A.,_IflJ.LL..~~J1'.....!.1.,
._c.:&,j4......._vf-.ltu.-!l.d.tu....._k_..A,J.....d...J.r... ~.J. c.......~.(J,. 1/ , ... .t!.Ilt....~
...\~"'~.._..W.L,._ AA..L4.t....,....JJll"1J..A. (L...wLu....../../ /1.It.ll... ..;rJ.t4..~.L h....
"~u.."'...l1.,JJ.._,..~ll'.Jd..,lu......t c... ..,. .......
"i ~. ~,~tl ~{J..(... /"'~"/4",y., )1J."1",...J ...,...
{i.11d..4,.ld' >>all..l.,~ C~'I,.~'a_ (JIl,..".",
III ", (I' ,I.J.., .;J 'I" .j I
. 1/ ( J) 11"1'
( J 1"" I ' ,
r "/
1,^WIlI-:Nl:I': 1-:, WI-:I.I< 1':1" 1'/l1l'1'1l0NO'I'MIY
'-')~"L'" C. )h, ('(,..... IVl'i.~'
III PII'1 \' Pllll hllllrll d"'-Y'
j~~ '-II ".
I"
.11 ,
r, L'~I , ')"1-
III' , ,I
. ) ,
1(: ' ii, ,)
.,' ,~
I" , I"
" , ~ 'L~,
I'"
(;)" " l\~
t.l. 1'1
I I'll I.'
., f" d
I:; ,./1
r?::;;r?':,
L\ '.
II
..
m:ltNIU:I': C,\lt'l'Im 11lltAMI.INU)
I'L,\INTWIo'
IN 'I'll\!: couln 010' COMMON 1'I.1':Mi
ClJMlllmLANU ClHJN'I'Y, 1''\
NO,lJtI.tl8tll CIVil, 'n:I(M
~
CIVil, '\C'1'I0N .I.A W
~,
M,\IIK WAUI~ llIUMl,lNll
U1W.:NIMN'1'
TO: MAI~K CJI~AMLlNG
troJ~~
YOU ,\IU.: IIImEU Y NOTWn:U
TO 1'1.10:,\1) TO Tm: 1':NCI,mmU
COMPLAINT WITIIIN
'I'W I': N'I'Y (211) I)A YS FIHlM
'J'Im UA'n, OF SE/(VIO:
IIImETO O/( A 11Io: FA 111 ,'I'
,/L1I)(iMENT MA Y liE
1':NTEIUm t\(iAINST VOL1,
Gemllec CIII1.C!r (Cirulll II Illl)
J I J SOUTH 24111 STlmET
Cllmp 1I11~:'t: :~)~~('_L .. (~r!:z .
I'm Se (.J!~o.- .__j)
OA'I'll ~""Wrl! 17, LN 2
( , , , , ,/
'I,
II'I '1'lIli COll/l'I' Olt COMMON L'LIEI\f:I
ClIMIlIUtl,flNO COllN'I'Y, l'liNNfI ,
I NO, 'JI\ '1\1\1).\
(,IV 1" 1\("I'10N .. I,flW
CIliRNU,lilt CM'L'liR (()JlI\MLINQ)
l'ltI int i r. r./Illtrfpondellt
MflRK W, C1llI\MLINCI
DlIr.endRnt/l'/ilt it lelllltl'
l'Jfl'I'I'ION '1'0 Ol'IIN mll/Am,'J' JUpcJMIIN'J'
(l'Ul'IJURnl: to l1fi,ll,C,I', n'l,)(I1) (h)
'1'0 'rHli 1I0NOJlfl13LI!, 'I'IIL~ <JllLXIIW (w tJflJI) ('Ol)WI'\
1. Plail1tlfr/lla/lpol1dal1t (hl'll'1911lIlftal' "I'll1il1tHr.") Hied
tha complaint in thilJ /)(:1:1011 on ,JAI1\Hll'Y 1'/, 1997, Pro Be, And IIBid
Complaint WIUI aan"lc1 UpOI1 Plltlll1dant/l111titionel' (hereinafter
"Defendllnt") by certifillc1 mall 1,1: Defendllnt'a buaineBlllocation, in
Cumbol'lanc1, Maryllll1c1, 1\ copy of th,~ Complaint ill attl1chec1 hOI:oto
and made part harllof AB Exhibit "1\",
~, On 01.' About flpdl 30, 199'1, Def<ll1dant received a CArd
haued by the Prothol1otary' a OffiCI/! regarding judment entered
againat Defel1dAnt in thia Ilctiol1 Oil I\prH 20, 1997, 1\ true And
correct copy of aaid judgmel1t card ia attached hereto and made part
hereof aD Exhibit "0",
3, Plaintiff And Defendant were formerly lIuaband and
Wi,fe, with minor chlldJ:l!ll frol11 the marriage, and were involved in
a very bitter divorce which ia finall and continue to be involved
in a difficult domestic action aB to iaauea relating to cuatody,
aupport, atc,
.., Pefrmdant did not receivll the ten !l0) day Noticl! or.
Dllfault Judgl1\ent purllullnt to l>a,I~,C,I', 236, /Ill required prior to
the entry of jlldgl1\ent by der.alllt, which may huvu 01110 been lJent to
hill bUllineIJ6 address only,
Ii. Defendant, puruuallt to 1>a,H,C,l>, ;!]'1,:Hb), hBlI
lIpecitic, meritorioull dofrlllllea to the Complaint, which include but
are not limited tOI
A, thore wna nOVtH' nny wdt tell agroemllnt betwellll
Defendant and l>lnint iff, that IJefondllnt would purchaae a clIr fOI:
l>laintiff or mnltll paymentll on anid carl
13, PlaJ.nt if f' a Gauae of act J.on J.n aped ficnlly baaed
upon an nllllged oral/verbnl ngniement for the purc:hlule of perllonal
property, the automobile, by Dl"ftlndant for 1>laint if f, which IInid
automobile ia J.n oxcess of el,OOO,OO J.n value, and therofore even
J.r. there was a vel:bnl agreement (which Defendant daniell), said
agreement ia not enforceable an it is in Jirect violation of the
Statute of Frauds,
6, 1\1 though not IIpacif ied in the Complaint, Defendant
believell lInd therefore averll that the relief requellted by Plaintiff
is in excess of $15,000,00, and a judgment by default, without
addreslIing tile merJ.ts of the case, part icularly in view of the
aforementioned meritorious defenBos to the Complaint, is extremely
prej udicial to Defendant, and clearly outweighs any potentl.al
"
prejudice to Plaintiff if the default judment is opened,
3, Cornplalnllnt did not hllve an autumoblle ror approlll/llll\l:ly Ihree yelll'fl
lltlhe time of December, 1994.
4, Rcsptmdent 5uught. Ilnd llccepted. employment in Cumberlllnd
MBl')'lnnd: empluyment begwl on December 2, 1994,
~, Rcspundcnt vulunlarlly uffered, llnd promiscd, 10 purchase II Cllr for
Complab\Jlnt, Gemllec Cllfter llnd Ihelr child, He WllS llccepting employn~1\l
with an excellent slIlnry lInd he ulldel'fltood he wns lellvlng Ihem WltJlOUt
trnnsportlltlon. He had been tJlelr source of tflll1SpOrtllllon for tJle previous
year,
6, At Respondent's direction and with his guidnnce wld help B car WlIS
purchased.
7, Respondent has no credit, 50 the cnr WBS nemsnrily purchased in
Complainant's name.
8. Respondent promised, volunteered, that he would be responsible for the
cnr payments.
v,
IN 'I'HIS COUll'!' Olr COMMON IlLIE/l1l
CIJMIlIIIU,/lNO (70UN'I'Y, VIENN/I.
1 NO, !.III-lilliI'!
CIVn. /lC'I'ION .. 1.,1\1'1
OlEllN 1 LIlIE Cl\ll'I'llll (CIIl/\/llL!NO)
lllllint it r
M/lllK 1'1, GrU\MI"INQ
Oatl/ndBl1t
1>1I1111NlJM'I' I S MfIlWlIlt 1'11'1'11 NlIW MJ\'I"I'Ult
MO NOW, COI1lIlI1 IJetl/ndBnt, M,'I'I~ 1'1, Gramling, by and
throUgh hili at tol.'l1oy , Jllmfm 1'1, /lbr/lhal1l, I~aq., /lbl:"llham LIIW ot Hoes,
Hllr.rj,aburg, Pflnnllylvllnia /lnd tHea the r.allowingl
I. Admitttld,
~, /ldmlttl/d and Dellied, It ill denied that Detendant
rellidl!1J at 3011 North r.l!elJ streot, CUl1Iberland, Maryland, all thiB ill
the street odd nHl fI tor Ilefendont' B current employer, 11\
Conatruotion, 'I'hll 1:lll11aining OVllrmllntll /)rll admtttad, howllver, by
way of flJrthllr IIIHIWllr, Defendont uubmitll that Plaintiff:" II incluBion
of Pefendant'lI domllstic IItatUIJ in thill paragraph, typtfies
Plaintir.f'u personfll, vengeful attitude and/or agenda toward
Defendant, which Pefllndant Ilubmitll, ill an underlying reallon for the
alleged caulle of /lction,
3. Denl ed, The avorments contained in this paragraph
are denied in that lIaid avermentll are vague and non-Ilpeclfic, and
therefore Defendant further denies r:;nid averments in that lJefendant
lacl~s lIuffidont knowledge and infor11latJ.on ao to the truth thereof,
Strict proof thereof io demfll1ded at time of trial,
4, Admitted,
EXHIBIT
Ie..
li, penied, ll: iu upecir.tlllllly denlllld thllt LJetendllnt
eve,: IIgreed, verblllly 01: tn wdt In!l, to purllhlllltl II Cl/lr tor
L').aintUr lind/or the plll.'tl.~u' llhl.J.d, and tt I.u turthor derll.etl I;h/lt
IJl'ftendllnt "lInderllto0<1 he Willi lOllvln(1 thalli withqllt tronupol:tllttoll"
or thnt IJetl1ndllnt Willi L'J oint j,tt' u /Hlun:n ot tl'lIlHlpl1l:tal:ioll, Uy Imy
oC tUl'thuJ:" III1I'1WUr, PllltntH'~ Willi tully nlllponuil:ll.e, ou hal: own, tor
any Ilnd all. tl:anllpOl'tllti.on tor h'H'UllH olld the pnl'ti'H!' chUd,
whila Plllintitt hud cuutody ot the child,
(j, Dented, Thu IIVOrl11Llntu containod in thill pllJ:"a~lal:ph 111:0
denied in that they Ol:e VflHLJO BI1<' n<lIl"lIpe,:ir.ic, Iln,1 thel:af:orrJ
Detendant fUJ:"th"r del1icHl /wid IIVlll:11l0ntrJ IIIl Def.ondal1t lllclUJ
l3uttident ItJlowledge Ilnd infol.'1I\nt.l.on IIrJ to the tnlth thereof,
Strlct proof il3 demandod at ti.llle of. tdal,
7, Admitted IInd denied, It 1.1l deniod thllt IJefendnnt han
no credit aa Pefendflnt doao hava cJ:"lldit wJ,th fJ,nllncilll
inlltitutionl3, It io admitted that I'laintJ.tf purchaaed aaid
autOlllobile in heJ:" name,
0, Denied, It iu opecitlcally denied that Dafendant
ever agJ:"eed, pl:omiaed 01: vol.ullteered to be J:"eaponaible for the car
paY11lenta for.' Plalntitfa vehicle, eitheJ:" verbally or 1n wrJ.ting, ay
way of further unf.lwer, Pla lnt If.f, at all relevant t imea hl!lJ:"eto, waf.l
rel30pnsible for any alld all payments on purchallef.l, 1ncluding said
car payment, mode by L'laintJ.f.f In heJ:" name,
9, Denied, It is del1ied that Defendant eveJ:" l1lade any
aSl3unnces to Plaintiff, veJ:"bally or in wril;ing, that Defendant
would make l3aid car paY11\enta, The remain1ng uverments contained 1n
this paragraph are denied in that Plaintiff. lacl(f.I l3uff.icJ.ent
Itnowledge IUlll inr.Ol-mlltioll rfl91i1:ding tllfl truth or. IIl1id IIV1/1:1llentll,
atriGt pl"oor. I;hal:llof io demlllJded ill; t il1le of. tdal., By wny of.
f.lIl.'thel" IInIlWOl', Plaintir.f. io tile only P/H'ty J:tHlponllible fOI: oBid
ClIl" pllYlIIl!lntll 1111 evidllnca by the /191."301ll0IJt wIth Chl"Yflllll: Cl"edit.
10, IJlllJiod. lJer.lllJdlllJt 111clefl flllr.r.Jdont ImoWllldgo LInd
ilJfo/:1l1l1tioll n!9unlJ.nn the tl:lll:II of tho aVO'.ll1ento Iltatad in thio
plnngl:llplt, Stl."ict p,:oof thoreof ill d[ill1/1l1dod lit till16 of tdlll,
IJ., Denied, It ill 'Ipedf ie/Illy dOllied thllt lJer.lill1dllnt
11 V Ell: Ilgl"oed, VGl"bllll.y or ill wl.'iting, to II1l'Jlell Ill'Jid ellr pl'JYll1entll IInd
thel"or.Ol"l1 lJaClllllll'Jnt 11IHI nevor. bae!ll I:OlJponnible fo,: /laid paY11\ontll,
'1'he r611111inin9 IIVG,:m611tu contuined l.n thil'l [JlII:lIgll':ph, 1"0gBrdin9
Der.endllrlt'lI domalltia IItl'ltllS, 81:0 dOIlJ,ed ill that the dOll1ellt.ic
sitlltl1ion of lJefondant has nothin9 to do with the 1l11ged cllr
PBYlllllnmts, which 1J0r.ulJd/lllt WUIl nOV01' rQapOlHlible f.or Ilt uny till1e,
By wuy of furtller 1I1l11Wer, Per.elldlllJt l1ubmita that Pl.llintiff.'1l
inclul1ion of Defendant'lI domeetJ.c atatUIl in thill paragraph,
typifiea llJ.aintJ.r.f'l!I porlJonal, veng<llful attitude and/ol: agenda
twoal:d Defendant, which Defendant lIubmitl1, ill 8n underlying l"oaaon
for the alleged cause of action,
12, Adll1itted and Denied, It is admitted that Defendant
is employed by IA Conutruction, It is denied that Defendant ia
under any Obligation whatsoevel: to purchase said car or to be
responsible for aaid car payments,
COMPLAINANT, Although not numbered, Defendant' u I:eaponse
to this paragraph is a denial that Defendant ever promised to make
the cal: paymenta, and therefore then~ was nevel: any contl:act,
verbal 01: Wl:itten, Obligating Defendant to do SOl and the
IItlltlllllllntll hlll:eto in the Complllint Ill:e r.ul:thlll: denied ill that they
conlltitute II legal concluaicm to which no nllfJOllall il.1 requind, 'ro
the extant 11 I:lll1pl1lllle ia I:lIquil:m1, Per.lInc\lInt incol:ll0l:atl!Hl by
l:eforQnC!fI itll IlnllWOl:1l 1 thl:()lJ!11l t~ hal:oto, and the Naw Matter
IItated balow,
WIIIIIUHr()llU, Peflllldllnt I:allpllctr.ully I:equolltll YOUI: 1I0norablo
Court, to diamiull 1'111 int it f' U Complaint and award Par.endant court
cOllta, attorney fOllu und any ()thel: I:elillf tha COUl:t lIIay deem
pl:oper,
NI.lW MA'j"j'l.ll{
13, Defendant inc()l:poratell by raferencll it anBwerll 1
through 12 (plUB anflWel: to COMPL,AINAN1') to the Complaint,
14, Defendant nevel: agl:eod, verbally or in writing, to
pUrcl1o!HIIl a vehiclll r.OI: L)lnintitf and/or. the pal:tiea chnd,
15, Plaintiff wall fully {!ware that at 011 relevant times
hereto, Plaintiff Willi fully financially J:esponaible for payment of
any and all purchases and/or car payments,
16, Plaintiff receive/l /lupport from Defendant for the
child (whiJh includes continuing support the ex-spouse under
Maryland law) fa!: child's needs, which include transportation
needa; and aince the panies divorce ill 1989, Plaintiff haB been
fully reaponsible for allY and all financial matters of Plaintiff
and/or the child, except for the court ordered BUpport,
1'/, l111fendllnt lJUblllitll t.hllt thll VII 1 II III lIf t.lll! vuhicle ia
over U,OOO,OO IInd thnt. tllu verhlll Il\p:elllllllllt. nllogl/ll by I'lalntiff
(which IJefendallt <1enl<lIll I,n J.n violatioll of t.ha Pannaylvllnill
StatutI! of L'ralldll, Iltl thl!! Illlfl!led VII J:bll 1 IIgrllllll1ent, Wllfl nlilver
J:llducl'/l1 to writillU, IInd/<ll: tlllH'1l WIW nevil" Ii Wl:it tllll II!] l:allll111nt.
batwelll1 tho pl.\rtiflu tOJ: t.he pUl:challe of t.he vahl,cle, IInd/ol;'
l:'ellponfJJ.bl,l ity fOI: pI'lYIlI13I1t.a thor[Jon,
111, Plaintiff'u purchalle of the Vllhicll! in her nllllle
alone, conrl.J:Il11l tho): thr~J:'ll wlln no ngl:l1elllont by Defendant. to
pUl'clllllle tho vehl.cle tor l11ailltHf, II lid allid llClt conlll".ituteu
Plaintiff'a tQJ:llIin/ltioll of any IIlJ.Q'1od a(jl:ellllllllllt hlll:eto betw(Jl!ln the
partielll and PlaJ.ntitf'n loall with Chrysler Credit ill alllo uolely
in Plaintiff' Il nalll(J, wh~ch c<mfJ.J:1111J that th(Jl:e wan no 1l'11:llelllflnt by
Def(Jndant to be r(Jnponllible tor 116id pnYllIllnta, and Ilaid IICt alllo
terminatell Imy alll!t!]ed Ilgreel11ent betwuen the pllrtietl all to cllr
paYl\\llntll,
19, Defendant IlUblllitll that L'lllintitt'll COlllplaint ill 13
frivolouB action and an unreaBonabllll bUI:den upon Defendant and 'l'hh
HonoJ:llble Court, in view of the dafenllell stated hereto, Bnd
particularly in view at tho statements made in the COl11plaint
regarding Defendant'B current domeBtic statuB, and Baid personal,
vengeful BtBtel11entB by Plaintiff clearly constitute the prl.mary
underlying reason for the filing of the COlllplaint,
VMlll,lC^,,'lOH
t I V~,,/vt ~_.I~L._..S.d~ ~~\_~.::U~" thn unrlOr.1i ignod I hlll\:,QPV
IIItIr.ity 1I11t! llonf irlll thll\: I 11111I0 rUlliUWOlI \:ho fOI~llIlninlJ doOu.mont
nnd the t:ll:nl:olnonttJ tl1ol:el.n 111."0 1:1."1l1! IIlld (lClrrltQt \:0 t,he ):JOB\: of >>IY
knowlodljO, intormll\:!.on nlld bolLae, [furtho~ undar~l:lIlld I:hlll: oilY
fllleo t:I\:IlI:O>>lelll:a >>Indo horo!.n nro "ubilla\: to 1:110 ponnltiot:l of lU
plI. c.S,A, Seotion ~90~, rolnl:inlJ to un~worn flllt:liflontlona to
nutl'loritLQs.
o~'rB I) - 7. ??
I (',
(, . i-I.
_I ',,/tA't_,.1
.r:\//
~\..