HomeMy WebLinkAbout96-06637
'1
~
"'1
c:'
~
~
"
,
1
:J
"
,
I,
;,1
,',r"
"
'II,)
"
il'll
Itl
\
"
"
I,
"
,
,I
',lI
"
'I
il
, 1
"
" /, I'
'rl
,
,
,
I
"
"
t' ,
,
'ill "
, , I
"
,
, ,
, ,
,
" .,
if
"
,',
"
h \
,"
, "
,
, ,
'},1
"
,
, ,
, , ,
,I
,
\1\1
'I',
, , ,
,
II'
"
,
, 1
I
,
"
, ,
, '
1
" I,
I',
,
, 1 " ,
, ,
, I,' rj;
, " , 1'\
,
"
"
,
"
I,
"
,
,
I
"
'.'.
,
"
I
,
.
,
,
',1\
"
-;/
'I
,
I
"
" ,.j
I' , 'I
, , \' , i !
,
,
"
I' /1;
I
,/1
,:!
'I Ii
I -' I ~! : . ['
j;J.,
,
" ,
"
,
,
j.1
,";
'I
'It,1
1'\
'H'
'd,I!1
I.
I', .J
, , , ,
I' .I
'I , I.
" "
" ,
"I ,.
I, 1i
" II j,
, 1 "
,
,
'O',~
,
, , 1
, I ,
'" I.
,', ,
" I,
,I
,
,
, ,
II
,',
,
"
I
"I
, ! "
j ",.\.'
" '
, ,
Ii)
"
',!
,
"
"
,
I,
"
"
, ,
,
I
I,
,I.:
"I
I"' ~
I:
'"
" ,
, ,
"
I , I,
,'I
,
"
"
III
ill' I~ '
,- '.11"1',
\,.11:1[;,1'1
"
,I
I I I
"
"
"
,
'0"0
, '
'1
"
,
",
I
ilJ"
,~ ,~'
.=.
It
i
,
" ~
" ~
u
:'
"
Ii,
,
"
"
"
"
'I.'
I;
",\'
"1'
I
"
"
Ii,
"
,
"
',fJ
I'
1
"
,
\, "
"
,I
il
,
I
"
'I
"
"
, ,
"
~
, I
,
"
.
"
"
"
"
I
,
, ,
'i
'I
il
"
"
I,
"
\Ii\
, "
'i'
Lit
"
"
':
1 "
,
,
III
,
ill
"
J'
,
,
"
, '
I I'
il;
1,
. ,
I
,
,
'I
i
,
ii'
\"1
,_)1
.I..
I)
j:
"
"
,
,j!
1'10
,; It 1 f,
I,
,
"
"
',',).,
,! II
, "i'
",I,
,,' ,'.,.
" j~
,.f'lI.,
"
jrl
"JI>
,
IN Till COUR'l' rOR COMMON IltlllAS
rOR CUMBlRl/MiO COUN'l'V, PIINNSV~VMiIA
RIClfARD lI. ~MJf, .7R. and I CIVltI ACnON - tiM"
JOllY tI, ~MiN, I
Plainl:Uh I
.
V. . NO. U-eU? CIVIlI TIRN
.
KIHlIMllJN A, HAR'nN, .
OlnNPMiT ,
NOTICI
Vou hllve been Bued in CaUl, t, r f you WiBh to defend againnt
the olaimn lJet forth ill the l!ullQwill'1l ),lllges I YQU must ta)te 8CJtioll
within twenty (;20' dayl'J lItl:n this I!IppfJlIJ:'I1I'1CJI'J personolly or by
attorney IInd fUing ill wl:J.tin\J with the COlII:t YOlIl: defenses 0/:
objections to the c1aJ.ms /;let forth IIgnlllnt you, You ore Wllrnel!
that if YQU tail to do so, the calle mAY proceed wlthout you and II
judglllent mAY be entend ng8inflt you by the COlIl:t withou~, fl,lrther
notice to!: any money clnJ.mad in the lJQllIplflJ.nt: 01.' for any other
monlty or ),In/per.ty or. othel.' dghta iml:lortAlIt to you,
YOU SHOU~D TA~8 TillS ",APRR TO YOUR ~^WYIR AT ONCI. I' YOU DO
NOT /lAV. A lIAW'YIlR OR CANNOT AnORD ONIl/ ao TO OR 'l'BlIIPIIONIl Till
OrrICIl SIT rORTII BII~OK TO rIND OUT WHIllR YOU CMi alllT LlaAlI HILP.
COUl:t I\dmlnistrnl'or
Cumber.18nd County Courthouse, 4th Floor
1 Courthouse Square
Carlinle, PI\ 17013
'l'elephone I (717) 240-6200
J.:l, 1l1111,IIUfC IHlIIIIH,j I" I~UlIll, ,'J/, W(\U l UIIHIPUll.tld IJY 1I111IJullilllle 1.(J
Lhll CnrlhJ1t, )lo/Jlli,l."l lllllllt1dtHl.llly ':lI11f.JWtll~1 tlla HlI.!idalll.,
14, 1\/1 II Il'lOul\: of. till.'! lJnHlII, l'ltltlltlr.f Hlell/lnl I" I<nllll, .11:',
13lI1~r.enlll It IIItd tlloJ.'lIulu /ll. 1'1,,1 II wi.l:lI IIII,Hll:11'1 IlpliH1I1 Slid /I lIeRd
(!olltu/llulI ,
'Il. 1\/1 II J'Il/luJ.t 1I1~ l.1I11! m:lluiI, l'lllJlltll'f. 1~llJiln..d I" I~/Inll, ,II:,
,IICUI:......1l1 t.1I'1u):leIJ thAt CtllHlflll IIJ.III plllll 1111,1 IlUf.f.edll\J, 1II1!llltal
1'I1I>l1I.'lt)', IllHVlJllIiIlI.'lU/:l, IlIllIJII l:I:U/Hlll1l1l1 I. Alld IIUII1J.1.181:J.0II, /Ill to 111./1
.Illl: r 1.III1lllt 1'111,1 1.011/1,
16, r>JHlnl:iff. 11.lcllllJ.'d I" I(!'IIIII, oJI:, lIurrl'lJ:[i,l IInll \-1,1,11 lIolIU,lIue 1:.<)
f.Il1rf.llr 1111 I.nl.l'!lTlIpUrJl1 or IIlIl .I/I.lly hAbllll 1111<1 llUI:fJutta to Ida
UJ'rlllt Allcl /l1.'ll:IIIRnf.lllt .llltJ.'t.llumt AIIl! 1 Of HI , l:tHllll.t I.lIg l'nlll1 1lt1':elldAllt' tI
IIl'1(J Il(JI.'lIIC6 ,
1'/, r>IAlntlrr: HldIAr<\ I,. I<Allll, "'J'. wi 11 ';olll'tnuA to /'lul'tlll:' IIIl'lllt"l
1111>1 tllty, III.'lJ.'VlJlIUllfl/lll, 1I1111HHTtlflflllllJlIl: /lilt' I1I1I11B 1./11:,1.011 /Ill Ii relllll. t. of.
Ulli (Inll:lh,
lU, Tile I'Il11011llt clntmed by PI.III.III't,fl' lachltrd I" I~ltnll, <II:, I'!x<J6l!da
tll'J JUJ:tfJdl.l~U(jIlAl 1I111011ll!: fOJ: llOlllplllfJOI:y IIrbitJ:l'ltJ.QII,
WIlIBRlU'ORIll, P!.llJntlrr I<lchlll:<l I" I<Alln, oJl.. demAlld/.l :jud~Jmel1t
I'Ig!lJ.nllt D6fel1dl'll1t In 811 II 11I0 II II I. in FlX(!eI'HJ or (; ~!),OOO,OO, exclualve
of intel:e/ll" nnd C'ontfl,
COUN'!' II
prJAIN'I'IFV JOIJ'l I" l'tI\NN V. IJIlJFlENDAN'l'
19, P1A1IIUf.f. ,IODY I" 1<1\1'11'1 IlIcoqlOratf!f1 1'111 of the pl:'oceedlllg
Llsl:sgnlpha of. thIn c~lmplalllt 111.1 tf each And everyone ware
indlviduBll.y set forth withln thia COllnt,
20, 1\1'1 a resul.t: 01: the craBh, 1?1aintH f. ,Jody L, I<Al1n haa beell
deprIved of. the flo<Jlo!lty, cOlllpanl.ollallJ.p, contl:lbllUOllB, and
COllBor.Uum of. hEll: husbal1d, PIIIJ.nLJ.f.f IHellard I" 1<111111, Jl.'" to her
greAt detriment Alld loaa,
;ll. 1\1'1 II I:asult ()f the (! l.'fJ all , Plal.ntHf dody I" I<ann haa suff.ered
a dl.aJ:ll(ltion 1.11 lie I: dlll.ly hAbltfl And pUI:suits and a lOBS of.
enjoyment of lIfe,
22, 'l'he amount olAimed by P1Al.lltUf. Jody I", Kanll exceeda the
:juJ:ladlctional amounl: for compulsory BI:bltJ:AUon,
WHBRIlJFORlli, Plaintlf.fs RIchard L, J<ann, Jr, and Jody I", J(ann
demand Judgment agaillflt Defendant in an all10unt In excess of
$ ;la, 000,00, II11CludvI or J.ntlll'lll!lt nnd costJl,
"It:! A 1,J.M--
iUCiiiisl'd L, "WIlIJbll~ oJ/::- .---
Attorney rOl' lllaillt i H.
JIl15 lJl."lIllll spring /load
P,O, Box 40
Newvillll, /.'1/\ 1'/:.141-0040
(717) 7'/IH55l51S
..i
~ J -
, IV) ,~
r'''llt -.",.J -
.\ q... ~
, -... "'"
'~"
'~ 'It ~
\~ ~ ~
~
t-,
I, ""
' , "-
0) ('I
I ,..j \.;)
'~!)' , 'n ~
' }
'- . : ~ :::)-
liti ~
"~'po, III
1m .11,,,,.., "nl~""JlJJI I '.",
,I" ,,",' '.j',
'-j;r...' tf III.,' I III "j.", 1"/' WI' i'
011"/1'11" ""111'111:11:
'"
"II,Y>I
114j
Ilf 111111 HI II 1I11H l'tlII,', .II'IJII) I\'jlll j Ivl ,.~tl'
"llllllj I -II, Hill. j,llll I" i "jlll_'jl 1'1 'II
""'''1 Ii. II "j'I,,1 J'lll' I <I, ,"It', .1 "1 I
I, ;. 'iI 111,1111,,).1+111 01,1 -II lip tI"ld,' .. p'dill"II' " 'II' ..Ill' ''I. ,.1 ("I'
, I H'.', ,q ii' I " 'il II
"
"'I-LI! 'j'
".
'Jll.
ill' li"ill"" jt
"II ',III' j,l,
;-'1,1,,, II'/' I ',,11"1 t I 'I ""I ,.
",
"~I j
,';" ,pJ I I I
"
''IL/I I, 'dl/iid'l" '-ill 'I' ,HI I'll . .,...., 1,lill 1I11;! ,dl" .lli
'I
Ii, I I 'I ,,; II II~IHI I)dlll'l"i 1i I-j I I
"III 'II' " "I. '! dl',j'l ~ .11I';!'j '1lnl" <Ii
I'" "J ,I'I,!
, ,
"I "Ii I' ,"/
"I,'I'IIj,j .'ql'
,,'oI'!1
'l'Ij HI'
Ihl hit) I II'ljl1I1l1IIII '" II,,," "I'It"'1 I
:ll^Vdld,JV
..
III AJIH1J}
wIH~!\ I'-!;Im ", .fllltll'l 'MHI}YlIh' J
'I'
..
/,'.tl ""', I "",'I!'i'
""'"
I II /1 II
'\
I, " I,' I" "'"
I Iii I I'j'.," ,I d' 1 "
"
INIV"tWO:) J 1111) I ,"ifill <If'lV IV IrldV .II) I:JIIIH'I ,,) l;')'^,1 J'j lOll )Olld
.
-, ,
COM_WIAWI 01 'IHHIYIVAHIA
COliIl QI cOMMoN mAl
':lIl11htlrl'"i11 1'lJllllty
IUlllelAL PIII.ICI
'It,Io
l.h,J. /J,G-'/~
HOYlel 0' A"IAL~
tliOM
DIIYlUCY JUITICI JUDOMIHY
COMJlIQHmAIH. IHI " (, 0 J I (, (', f! 7"~""1
NOYlCI O. A"IAL
Noll.. I. yI"", tl104 Ill. ,~~..lI."" I." "lid IlIlh. .~~.v. ("..I 01 (",,,,,.., '~.lJl ,'" ,~~,,"1 h.." Ih. 11/,11/",,,,,,.,.10,.,' l>y Ih. 01'1,101 1IJ111t. ,., Ih.
..... ",,.j I" Ih. un. "...~Io'''.d btll>W
'WII1'JI ~I~ ,.. I il.).fj 1lI111lll'ljltllW IlInl
'~~II~":JrJi' I~~,",/ ,'r~, 111111 ,In,1Y I" 1(111111 till . ~1~liJ.-9,2 .,.
1 Hlo1lil1t1d 1111"" Iluwvlllu I'^
l\L"IlIIJ)lll.llf"". l.tllll7lll01 il\i"'" ,IltJt>>...,
l,l-11Il-'jl) Il1ell'H'o1 I.. 111l1I1I/ .J..., F. ""'J/ In HiH't.l'~ 1111111JiJr1y
nlWl~ "~n:~~~~~~.l:~ll~~ti~... ,wmj':rl:'~;It::':~d~'l/' ... ...,...
-ij~i i~,.~ wlllh. Wll';'" aillY v.l.."II."",I"(j",, " ,..".,.d I/,.J., "'1 RCJ',)J>. No 1/ Iq~HlIIIVII WlI~ cl-A1MANT r~rJ<l Pu, /lep,)p Nil,
loon
n.. 1'1,,11.. III "H.."I, wh." ,...Ived by tl.. 1);",101 )",11.., will "1'."". "' II 100 Uli I 1/1 IIcllm 1m/om rJl~Irlcl ,)wl/lClJ, IN MUST
61J1'fMIII!OI!A1Io Ih.l,oloon..'1 I", ,,""."'1111 I" ,hll''''. I'll,/; A COMI'/,AlNT WIIIIIII tWlJllly r20} dlIyI; ultlJr
fllllIU IlIb NOTICE 0/ A/~'t:A1..
,~ ~l"i>t
17241
S;()iIllIIlIllOl l~lJ,ht)lIr)IIIIY III n.'f~j/v
PUIC"I YO INTlR RULI TO fill COMPLI'INT AHp RULI TO fiLl
m,'s boclhJl' 01/,)/11I 10 IJlIII.,M ONl,Y ",',m ill~"'111/1I1 W,J,\ IJIIINIJANI r'Uf) 1'" /lCI',II' Nu WOlrl) IIll/ellIJlI Iwlll'" /JIM"';I JIIbI/CIl
IF NOT IISI/), "./"ell II'JlII CtflY olllu//CIl or '~~JI!I/I IoJ IllI bI'IV"'"10JlI 'V~JlII1"f)1
'lAIC".1 T" '>,,,'I,,,,..lo'y
rJ~" ,IJI, III"'"
~,~;,;, ,., '1j,k'II'>,'UJ
, oppell..('I, 10 III. 0 <on~>Iolnlln Ihll "''P.a1
(C.,,,....., 1'Ie", No. __...
,I wllhh, IWI"'Y (201 day. all., I..vl.. 01 ,01. Of II/II.. .Illry 0' II/<loon...1 0' non 1"'"
&1)''''1_., 1)l_.)tfMW"~)t 111$ .,,.;j~-;.~ii
RULli To ,~,,,_"nn'
Nir,., ."1 ,n)dHlMf.,
... , oppell..(.),
(II y"" nre,,,,lIfled Ihol 0 'ot.I,'....l>y enl...d I/potl y"" 10 fiI. 0 .""~~olntlll Ihl. 0"",a1 wllhlnlWlllly (20) doy. ollllt 'h. dol. of
....1<. 0' 1I>.,ole """" you l>y """"",I...,Ic. or by ...tlll,d Of '.Ol.'...d "",II,
(21 If yuu .to 1"" file 0 ,,,,nplolll' wllhllllhl,lImo, 0 JUD<lMI!NT Of NON PMOS Will BE fNTERED AGAINST YOU,
(3) The dolw 0/ ...Yk. of ,1,1, ,IJI. II .1It'1c. \WI by molll.lh. dot. 0' l1lll1l1ng.
00Iw:___, 19_,
IiI\I>IlInd--.,."'1>ttluIY
'.
lOPe 311f.a.
COURT FILE
~,
II, ....
(', ~I I,
.'
rl!( ~'.', , \'"
, "
:': : I ~1
0' ,.,
I'
hr- . ' ' :111}
tIll
II " ; \,I\\!
I ,
.
" , .
, , 'J
,.", ~ " 0
~ >,1 I
~ 'I ~
~~. jai l~
~ If ~
denlod thllt 1'IIrllqrllph 4 dO/lodbell tho IIlIhiolo thllt QlIhndllnt Willi
drivinq. The remlllndllr of the pllrnQrllph 111 ,,1110 dllnied,
7, IJonied. !t 111 IIpoOitiOllllY dlllllad thllt the IIlIhiole
biting drillen by DUfondnnt 1I0rllllhedll into Pllllntitf'lI lIehlolll,
O. Pen hid ,
9. (II) Penled.
(1.1) pon1od.
(0) Pllnled.
(d) Pen led .
(e) penilld.
(t) Penied.
(9) 'l'h il lIubpllrll9rllph hall b.en ....moll.d by
atipullltion of ooun/lel.
(h) Ponied,
(I) Ponied,
(j) Peniad.
(k) Denied.
10. Danied,
11. PeniQd,
COUNT I
PLAINTI" RICKARD L, ~I JR, V. D.'."D~T
12. 'rho answers to Paragraphs 1 through 11 are hereby
inoorporated by referenoe herein ftII though set forth in their
entirety,
13, PenJ.Eld,
2
14. Penied.
1~. Denied.
lIS. Denied.
17. Penled,
10, Oenied,
WHI!:IUWOHI!:, JJ8tel1dllnt:, IUmb....ly A. "'uHn den"sndlll judlj/menl:
againsl: Plaintltts IInd 111 her rovor,
COUHT II
PLAINTI" JOOY L. KAHN V. OI'IHOAH'
19, The onswers 1:0 PBrllgrnphs 1 through 10 are hereby
incorporated by rehronce heroin liS though set: torth in I:heir
entirel:y,
20, Denied,
21, Thie poragrllph hos been removed trom the complaint
by stipullltion 01' counsel,
22, Denied,
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Kimbel:'ly A, Martin demands judgmenl:
IIgainet Plainl:itts IInd in her tllvor.
lfD....JiM.'UB
23. The answers oontained in paragraphs 1-22 inclusive
hereot are incorporotod by reterenoe as it sel: torth in I:heir
entirel:y.
24, Plaintifts' olalms, if any, are barred by the
applicllble stlltute of limil:al:ions,
- 3 -
~. n/
1I, I"
I l.~ .
t'"
, ' I '
[1 '.
I
t, "I
\: I' l. I.
", ~:
~J ~ 'J
IN 'l'lIR COUIl'I' f'O/{ COMMOI'I PI.I!lMI
rl011 CUMUJERlJl\NU COUN'I'Y, PIilI'lNI3Y/.NAI'IIA
RrellAnO lJ. KAliI'l, JIl. and I CIVI~ ACTION . lJAW
JOOY I., KAliI'l, I
Phl.nl:Uh I
I
V. I NO. 9CS.6U'1 CXVXlJ TlRM
I
KIMBIIlRJ,Y A, JoIAR'l'II'I, I
O.FlI'IOAli'l' I
s'n PUlJl\'l'IOI'I
~Il/lilltl.r.f/J, IHc!hnrd J.., K"nn, .II:, olld >lady 1., 1<1\1111, 811d
Lll'!r.l'llld"nt 1\,l.l1IbeJ:ly A, MIIl'tlll, by "lid Llll'Ollyll their ulldL!rllilllll'!c1
O::OlllIlH,l, do hereby rj\',ipulntl1 811 f.ollC)\l1n1
J., LJlIl'ogropll 91'J) Qf tlJlJ COl1lplllilll: r.iled by PlalllUUa
is hereby df! ),!'!tnd,
2. lJnl'Agrnpll;l1 of th" CeJl1Iplnlnt HIed by lJlnilltiCt/l
ill hereby dclctod,
3, In all other rcapocLlI, the COl1lplAillt fUed IJY
~18inUff' II IIbl'll1 remnlll the 118111e,
I 1..'
U(\I:",I, ___.,._:......._,.. ,_..'
,/, .I
,) , ", I ~ I (
--- - .~"'-,--_.~ _.-..-'~-.:.._"-_.-----.-
Ri~h8rd lJ, Webber, dr,
Attorney for Plaintiffll
366 Greell Spdllg IlOl!Id
I?O, Box 40
Newville, PA 117.41-0040
(717) '77G-G'jr;(j
Oated I..J.P./......
By I, ...,
Michel ,T,' horp
Attorney fo!: IJc~f'~1l
10 I Pille St'n~(!t
p ,0, Box 917.
IInLTlnbur'f, l'A l'ILOn'O~'ll:1
('117) :1Jr;.:17.00
-" fl
t:
\,r "
,/,
, ,
" ,I.
I~' I J
II ' ,')' , I
IiI' " I , ,
l.,' t~ \ :'1
i' j
y'l ,..
,,) I'j~
I,
I~ ~ f-1 j
.. ':~eG
;, -
.~: ~: '~
:I~ II
~ r'" (' ~l
I . ,I.,
.t.I , "'~ 'irE f
p ~~ ')
,
~J ~ "
{
I;,
I ,
"
I
"
I
"
I' i!
I' I, "
"
/,
"
'I',
:1;'
"
il :,
('
1'/
I~~
p~ .
, . I
1",i"li'
I.!-
1
,I
i'l
" ,i..I'_'
~?::
t)"
~i!;';-" I
~.',"", :.',
',', 1,1 \
~.,:_II d' 'I': ',I I I
II .,'Ii
1,'.1 ')\':" II
f ~, I ',I ,i "I
~~!~:,\ ' ,I
, 1')1,1..(:1,' ,',
~~lrl':I'I.' ,
','11
,lJ~ ~J:'
W:I,
,
~ J ' II . I
I
'I.
'.'
"
'I
/ "
, , ), " I,
I, 1 .
, "~I
, , , ,I,
, !<
, \11
;1 "
" ','
" 'I!
, ,
,
"
"
. I
'I'
.'
, ,
,
,
I
'r"
'.,1
.1. . .
~
'I,
.
IN Tltl COURT rOil Cl)MHON PI:.II\IJ
roll. CUMDIRI:.l\NO COUNTY, PJNNQY~Vl\NII\
RICIII\RIJ 1:., If.l\NN, JR, Ind
JODY 1:.. Itl\Jffl ,
1'1aintUh
V,
I(IHnIR~Y 1\, Hl\RTIN,
DBrlNOl\NT
CIVlu ACTION . ~^W
NO. 96~U37
CIVIl:. TIM
JURY TRII\~ DBHANOID
P~I\IHTI"IJ' RIBPONIJB TO HIW HATTIR
l\HP NOW CGl11eD Lilt) IJerl1ndlllll:u, IHC'MJIrJ I., ~J\NN, .Ilt. IInd ,lODY L.,
I<I\NN, by And through tholr nttor.n6Y, I1i,!lwrc1 IJ, II/"bbl'll:, ,'11.'" /lnd
'1,la thlu Illl/lponlle to New Matter, IIvJn:ln'<l tho Col.lowln\jl
;n, No re13pOnllQ i13 I:equl.rod,
2,', Dented, P11Il.nt1ffll inltlRteJ lhta action wit:hin the
appliCAble ntnlute of lil11itnl:ionD,
2"', 'I.wied, I\t all relevant timeR hereto, Pl.aintiffo acted free
f. rom any (",mtributory negl igence,
26, P'1IIied, for l'enllOlHl st.uted in PBrRgl:llphll 7 thru 9 of
Plnlntiff'u Complaint,
27, Denied, Plalntiffo' carried "full tort option" automobile
lnaurance covernge aB of tlm time of the accident,
WHBRI!:FORIll, Plaintiffs ranpel;tfully reql\eat judgment in their
l:f IAN ~ ~ 1"'1/'
~,JAM" ~.VN'"JII, JIl,
JUliN II.VAJ
1Il1I'''.'',~UAlIlIIlIIlI .
II 'J1"Jj I, ~Ajjllll, J~,.
~IIII J. W~l/I~,
~.~~V I\. W~IINllW,
.11111.1'" IU.II~
11'''' .UllllI~~
IU;VNOI.I)Il II IIA V All
A."'II"......~I..I.,.....I"..
^nll~~'V.ANlIl.IIl'NIIUI~IAI '.A1l
IUII'IN'~lllm
""11 Umn '~I~ YJJ
1I.1l~llII"~Il, 1"NNIIIVAI'III' IIJlI.qjJJ
'I".....'"
,II IIIUIII
,..
IIllllllI'U
,....,
..,....,..,.. ""
JanulI~y ~O, 1990
nlahard J, Pieroe, Cou~t Admini"trator
cumberland County courthou.e
one Courthouse Squllre
carli.le, renn.Ylvania 17013
t 'j~d'
( .)
1\;}1\1~ f,11 ')
Re. IaAA..h.JlU.tJ.n
Dooket Ho. ,. - ..J7 oivil
Our rile Ho. JIOg-l
Dea~ M~, Pieroe,
~nolosed plellse tind Brief ot Detendllnt, Kimberly A,
Ma~tin, In support ot her Motion to compel Disoovery, whioh
Motion ia being tiled with the prothonotary, BY oopy ot this
lette~ IInd in aooordance with the oertitlollte ot servioe, e oopy
ot the oriet is beinq $erved on oounsel tor Plaintitts, Should
you have any questions plellse teel tree to contaot me,
Very truly yo~rs/
. / I
! I" / 'I
I /' /' II , .
Mi~hJl. J, 'i'horp'
J. . I
. ',/ 'I
,I I
MJT IIdg
Enolo.ure
001 curtis R, Lonq, Prothonotary
00 w/enol Riohard L. Webbe~, Jr., Esquire
.(.,.11".... II . ('I.tI Ttil' Ad'''II, b, I'" Ntl""" IkIIN "nbl Ad.......,
A f'rnn.)h,."I. AUI)f'fmf ('lMolt1 AlTtNll'" ,q"nr,
~AN 2 2 1008
lnterro'illltor1.., II.. VII,R,O.l>, Ho, 4001$, It th. IInflWldn\l pllrty
duma IInv intar.roqlltol.'V oPj8otionllb18/ then the r81180nl tor the
objeotlon must bo stlltsd In liou ot nn nnswor /lnd Borvsd within
thirty (30) daV/l. lJ~g Pn,R,C,p, No, 4001$,
Furthermore, tho Ponnllvlvnnln Rulo/l ot Civil Prooedu....
thBt Bnv pBl'tV IIInV lIel~VO on IIny othor.' pnl,'LV n 1.".lClllIlst tOI.'
produotlon at doouments, tJllll Pa,R,C,l', Ho, 400\1, ^ written
responlle in tho to"'1II ot un /lnllwo", 0... an objootlon must bB s....ved
upon tho ...equestlnq pnrtv Within thirty (30) dnYlI, tJlla P/I,R,C,P,
Hl). 4009.
When no rOllponllo to n request tor lnto......oqatories 0'" II
request for produotlon at dooulllonts 111 reoelved within the allotted
time period the remedy for tho aqqriovod pnrtv III to tllo a 1II0tion
to compel tho Appropriato dlllcovory. Upon roo.lpt of suoh n 1II0tlon
the oourt io Blllpowerod to lSlIue nn ardor oompolllng tho porty to
respond to the outstundlng disoovery requests, tJ~a Pn,R,C.P, No,
4019.
In the Instant oase, Plaintltts have ohollun to ignore the
mandatory time restrictions impo/3ed by Pa,lt,C,P, Nos, 4006 and
4009. The initiai requests for dilloovorv wore /3orved upon
Plaintiffs on or obout Maroh 6, 1997, Qesplto the ensulnl'j time
lopse and reminders to counsel for plointlffs, no answers to the
discovery requestr. have boen forthcoming. No objections hove been
made to thlJ disoovery roquests, nor hove anv protective orders peen
filed with regard to the outstanding disoovery, Therefore, Bny
~ 3 -
-,
II/IN y;. 1'1'1/,
(.~y
~,IA/II~~n""W.,11L
1'"IIlIA~AI
hllI.'IIA'I, JII, ..u~IW.~',
"""Jljl, .AJj~",I~,.
~llIl" W."IJ.
~A..V'" W."""IAI,
I..II~AI"''' uw"
hllc'IIJi"I, 111"~'
IU:\'NOl,U!j" IIAVA"
It .....".,... . 'I".~I'"
Al1l1."'VUNlIl"III"UI"~. A' ,..II'
IQII'IH~ Ii,"."
~'"' Qm... 1101. ~Jl
IIA11.II.I'~II, 1"N~IVI,VANIA 11llJlloll'l)J
I"~"."I
,'1""" ..
,..
cI",,,.,,,,
......
,,,..............
JlIJlullry ~O, 19911
curti. R, Lung, Prothonotllry
cumberland cuunty courthou.e
Olle Courthouu Square
CarliMle, Penn.yivanift 17013-33117
R., ,ann v. Martin
Docket No. 86 - 6637 olvil
Our rile Ho. 3508-1
De8r Mr. I,ongl
Enoloeed tor filing plellB4 find ori9inlll and one copy
of the Motion of Dofendant, Kimberly A. Martin, to Compel
D1Boovery, with proposed Order, along with 8 oopy ot the Order
8nd a stBmp.d envelope addressed to ooun.el tor PlllintittB, By
oopy or this lotter and In accQrdanoe with the certiriolltu or
Bervioe, 8 oopy of the Motion is being Berved 011 oounsal tel.'
l'lllint j,trs.
Additionally, by oopy at this letter I om providing to
the Court Administrator the origln81 of DetendantlB Urief in
Support or Motion to Compel Oisoovery, as woll liS 8 copy of the
Motion, In acoordance with the certiricate of servioe attaohed
to the Urief, a copy or that document is being uerved on counsel
for Plaintiffs,
Please clock in the oopy or
sheet or the Brief and return them to
8ddreS8ed onclosed for that purpose.
assistanoe in this matter and, Bhould
plellBe feel freo to oontaot me,
Very ;t~uly yours,
I ' I
, I
I I, , I
/ ( , '(
Mioha' e J,' Thorp
the Motion and the f8ce
mo in the Btllmped, solr
Thllnk you tor your
you have any questiollS
"
(
MJTIsd9
Enclosures
cc w/enol Rlohar.d J, pieroe, Court AdmlniBtrator
Richard L. Webber, Jr" EBqulre
.("MI,,"... ('hlll,..1 Alh...l. ht Iht N.I..,..III.,...., I' TIt.t AI.h....'1
A t'nuu)'t"'''.. ~,,",," l'MU1 Al"n...Ul.... AI'M'
,-
attaohed hereto, incorporated herein by reterenoe and marked
~~hibite ~^~ and ~ij~, raspaotively.
I), lJy way ot letter.e datad May l:l, Illll? I ./una :l l, IfJ9'/ I
and peoember I~, 1991, Dotendnnt requastod rasponseR to her
disQovury requests. CopieR of thuRe lutter. are Bttached hereto,
incorporated herein by reference and mnrked as R~hLbit8 'c', 'po and
'R', raRpectively.
6. To data, Dotendants has not ronoived any raeponaes
to the outRtnnlHI1'1 Tntarroqntot'1eQ Ilnd llequOllt for Pr.oduotion or
Dooumunts.
,/, JlIl,H.C./l. Hl', 4001\(n) p) raquirall answors to writtolln
interrogatories to be served within thirty (lO) d~YB atter a.rvio.
tharaor.
o. Pn.R.C.P. Ho. 4009(b)(~) requires n responsa to a
request tor production 01.' documents be served within thirty (lO)
days attar BarvLco tharGor.
9. Pa.H.C.P. Ho. 4009(b) (~) nuthorl:eGB the pnrty
RUbmitting the requeRt tor produotion of documantR to move for an
ordor under Pll.fl.c.P. Ho. 4019(6) if the party upon whom the
requeRt wns served rnils to respond within thirty (lO) days.
WJlEflEf'ORE, Pefondnnts, Kimberly II. Martin, rllspeottully
requests thllt thia Ilonorabla Court enter IIn Order compelling
Plllintlffs to provido full Ilnd complete answers to Defendant's
lnterrogatories and respond to Defendant's Request for Produotion
- 2 -
exhibit A
."
C:OMMOHWJ1:IIL'l'11 01" PIt:NNIIYLVIINIA
IN TIIJ: COURT o/" COMHOH PLI!:AB 01" r,:UHBERLANP COUH'l'Y
IHellARD L. I<AkiN, JI~. I Ho. 91$ - 1\6J'1 civil
and JODY I.. I<ANH, I
lllaintifl.'s I
I
V. I CIVIL IIc'I'IOH - LAW
I
I<IMLH::HLY II, MAH'l'lH, I
O.hnd~nt I JURY TRIll/.. DEMIINDED
IN'I'J;I~ROOA'l'ORI Ell 01' OEf'EHIJIIH'I',
\<IMIlERLY II. MIIIl'l'IH,
IiUDBElW~IJ '1'0 l'1Alli'llrDL:.::J:JJ!.e1:..J2&I
'1'01 RichlU:d L. I<ann, J.... and JQdy L. I<ann, Plaintiffs
0/0 Richard L. W.bber, Jr., Esquire, counsel for Plaintiffs
366 are.n Ilpring !load
Po.t Offioe Ilo~ 40
Newvillo, Ponnsylvllnia 1'/241-0040
PLEIISE TIIKE NOTICE that you ~ro ha...oby roquirod purSUant
to Pennsylvania I~ulos of Civll I'rocedll"'o tlos. .\005 and 01006 to
serve upon thlll ul1dersiqned within thirty (lO) daye from llervico
herlllof your answers ill Writing Ilnd lindeI:' onth to the followinq
Interrogatories.
Theso Intarrogatoriell shall be deemod to be continuing
Interrogatories.
If, between the time ot your ,1nSWers to 9/\ id
Interrogatories and the time of the trial of this case, you or
anyone Ilcting on your behalf loa...ns the identity and whoroabouts of
any other witnesses not identified in your 9aid answers, or if you
obtain or become ;lware of 'ldditional requested information not
.,
,'-',
DlllNlllQll.a
AI UQod in thelle ~>>terrogatorioB, the wordu Ilnd termQ a~
set torth below shall be defined au tollowsl
(a) "You~, "your~ or "yourseLf" shall mean nnd inolude
the anllwering party, eaoh of uaid party's representatives, nqents,
BervalltlS, workmen, relative., omployeel!l, /lttornay, /lnd /Ill other
PQrBOnU aoting ror or on bllhalf ot the answering party.
(b) "tr.llilntlfj'" or II idelltity~ whan "eterrinq to an
individUal meanu to statu his/herl
(l) n/lmef
(2) present address, If known, or last known
addrees (lJusinesll /lnd residence) I
(3) job title, busineu affiliation or job
olaeeifioatlon at tho timo ot the .VQnts reterrod to in the
interrogatory ansWerl
(.\) .;:urront omployer, L f known, or 1,1l1t known
emp loyon and,
(5) telephone number (business <lnd rl!lllidence).
(c) "td.ntlfy~ or II identify" 'lIhon referring to documents
means to I
(1) state the type of document (!L.!L., record,
report, 1l\lttQr, memoranda, telegram. charge, photo, ute.), its
date, its title (if any), its identifying number, a
generalized summary ot the Bubje~t mattor ot the contents ot'
the documents, and its present location I and
1
-',
,-,
(~) ,.tatll "aoh person who prepllred Lt, uIlch person
tor whom Lt Willi prllpared, the Ild~resa of each person Co whom
It wu nnt, the "ddrllll8 or QIIoh parsoll who pl~esllllltly hns
uUatody of th. oriqLnlll or caple" Chernof.
(,;1) "IdencifY~ or ~ iduntlty~ when r:otel~rj,llq to II ~~l.aim~
or "aotlon~, rnel\ns 1:0 tJet forth the 11111110 of tho coUrC where the
caso, LIlli im or not ion WIIR t llud, the dool(t1t Ilumbor, the j'l.Iar IInd
datil when thlt IIction Willi commellaed, Chili 11nmell 'Jf 1111 l!1alllllHlCII
(inoluding YOU), thl!! nllmOIl or .1Ll pllrtiell againat '.;hom II dl\Lm wlla
IIssertQd, the dnto or dlltOIl ot tho trllnllactLoll or O~CUrroncon which
'/l\ve dllo to tho clai/ll, ,\ doacnption or il1'Jurioa "11<1 dllmllqea
claimed to have I\ccruod, the LdontLty of inaurl\nco carrLer tar tho
person or oncitieo against whom 1111 clllimll or lIuitll wore IIl1l1orted,
the outcome of the clllim or lIuit, tho nmount rocovered, trom whom,
And if no recovory WIIU roalizod, why Ilot.
(e) "Documonta" tllcludo AllY '.;ritton, recol-ded or qrAphic
mattar however producod or reproducod including but not lLmited to
corrolJpondenoe, telegrllMs, other wrLtton cammuniclltLono, contrllctlS,
Agreemonts, notes, roporta. records, ~-raylS, memorandl\,
photogJ:"opha, tape reooJ:"dingn or nny other '.;ritingll, including
copios of any of the foregoing now or nt any prior. timlil in your (as
dofLned herein) posselSaion, custody or control.
(f) "statomenl" includes II written statement signed or
otherwise adopted or approvod by the person making it. It includQs
the stenographic, mochan Leal, electl' ica 1, or other method of
recording or ,1 tranacr ipt ion thereof which Ls .1 cJubatant io1 11 Y
ii
-....
t~-.
verbat1m reoltal of Iln oral statement by the perlon making Lt ~n
~ontemporGneously reoorded.
(II) ~'l'relltment~ meanl ~ny lIUrq8ry, e>lamlnation,
dleqnol1s, th.repy o~ other medio~l oare or ntt,ntlon rendered.
(h) "Med tOlJ L l'erlSonne 1" loeenll phys id~n, dent lilt,
chlroprGlltor, LJodlatrillt, ..:hiropodillt, therllpLsl"" Lnter", rellident,
nurse (LPN or I~N), or Ilny "ho/Ilth ll~ra provLder~ o,~ l1thLn" person
who rond.red Rervllle to, nttended to or otherwllSe ~lSsistod In the
,:lIre of the I'Lalntltt,
(i) "MedLclIl l'ilcllLty" mellns hospitlJl, dootor'lI Mfice,
dLnie, rehabilitlltion cant,,,,., nurlllng home or Ilny s1mLtll'" fllllLl.l.ty
in which or through Which mediclI!, therapeutio, rehabilitative or
other servloes Were rendered.
(j) "Person" h,lR Itll (:ustomary brond moan ing ~nd lIhall
1I1so Lnclude Ilny human boLn,!, corporlltLrm, pat Irsl",ip, solo
proprIetorship, unincorporated AlSsalllatlon, Joint Yenture, or ~ny
other arganL:eation or entIty.
(k) "Delicribe~, "specity", .1nd/or "lltnte~ shall mean to
lIet forth fully and unambiguouBly, us1ng professional worda ot Ilrt
If necessary, oach lInd every fact ralevant to tho ~nswer <l1\llod for
Ln the Interrogatory of which the answering party or his agents,
employees or representativelS hllve knowledge.
(1) "lIcoident~ means, unless otherwise indicatl1d, the
acoident thllt allegedly occurred on May 15, 1995, out Of whillh this
action arose.
i11
--.,
r-
~O, PllllS" ldentlry Any Iwd (\11 tlSct wltn....s 'I/ho hftve any
knowledqe whatlSoever portulnlnq to tho IllSuell LnvoLved In the
lnltlSn~ oosu, ~s well n. Any und ull potential wLtne"selS or
indlvlduol. whom you MY call I\t tdal and who have not
heretotore bun identif iltd, Lno ludlnq the Mml!, 1.0),1108 and
mlSnner of contllct between the potential wltnesl and the
pa".ti.., tho l:Iubstanca ot l:'llotlt to whioh the witne.. could
C..tity if aalled by uny pArty, And method of dllSoovery of the
potentiol witnel:l"uQ, tho purpcftO ar tho wLtne..' testimony (if
a~plioftblel I\l1d whethor Rny stlltoment or lIummory or writtan
memoranda ha. been tnkan with re.psot to the potentlnl wltne..
and It so, who haR posseRBion at that atatement or documont at
the present time. (pleuse Attach A copy of the Bame without
the neoe.Bity ot n 1111q n forma 1 l'lIquost for product 1'111 ot
doouments. I
- 20 -
-.,
J8.
Plea~1I ItaU wh.th..... 'Iou hilI/II ,P1DlltIlU the llmltlld Q... tull to...t
option and ptau Wlth splllltialty thl nallll of. '/Qu", p...lvatfl
p4...n9.... i\utomopll,.. Inlurllnoa oomp"ny and Ita Bdd.......
- HI -
Exhlblt B
~ " '" , " " (1) ,...,
COMMOHW~IIL'rll 01" PH:NNIJYLVIIHI1\
IN 'rilE COIJR'r 0,," COHMOH PLli:l\fl or CUMIJEIlLIINO COUH'I'Y
IUeIlAI~1J L. KANl'/, JR. I Ho. ?/S - '\1\17 Civil
4nd JODY L. KANl'/ i I
P 4intiHII I
I
v. I CIVIL IIc'l'IOH .. l.AW
I
I<IMBF.RLY 1\. MAR'l'IN , I
O.tendallt I ;IURY 'l'IHIIJ. OI':MAl'/IJIi:O
I'IRST HEQUEBT Of' DEFEHDIINT,
KIMI.IEIlLY II. Mlllt'l'IH,
t::glLfl3~n.Qn-ill:...~M,Elms.
'1'01 IHllhard I.. I(ann, ,1.... ~nd Judy L.. I<alln, Plailltltts
a{o Richard L. Webber, Jr., Esquire, ~ouns.l for Plaintiffs
1/S6 Grssn Spring Roqd
POat Office Box 40
NewvLlle, Ponnsylv4nia 17241-0040
Purauant to RUle ~OO? of the Pennsylvania RUles ot civil
Proc"dure, Defendqnt, Kimbor.ly II. Mqrtin, requ~sts that Plnintiffa
produce the documents hereinafter. described and permit Defendant,
through her attorneya to inspect them and copy ~uch of them as they
may desire.
De fondant r.equesta that the documontB be made
available for this inspection at the officea ar Dofendant'a
attorneys loclltod ,lt 101 Pine lltreet, Ifarrial:Jllr.g, Pennsylvnnin,
within thirty (JO) days at the date of Dorvice hereof. Detendant'u
attorneya will be reaponsible for these documents as long as thoy
are in their. poasession.
Copying will be done Ilt Defendant'a
o~pen4e and the documonta will be properly returned atter copying
has been comp loted.
Th is rl1qlloB~ l,.. intond13d to '~ovor .\ 11 documonts : 11 thl)
pOSBOsf310n, custody ,Ind control fJt Plnll1tlrfa, the1r '''l'J11 ta,
omploYDlul, ~n.uranlle Llarriol:lS IIlld nttorneYIt /lnd ls Llonllldaruoj to IJIS
Llontlnulnq. Plaintirfs' r.IlPonse to the Huqu..t ~hould ba modirieoj
or lIupplumentllld liS Plaintir.rs, lind/or thulr IlttorMYR llbta In
further Ildditio/1l11 dooumullts up to the tine of trial. 1~.'lUutl!llt
dooumunts lire moro partiQulariy ltemi~ed /lnd dusorlbud /I~ follLlwRI
1. llroduoo II tl'Ue Illld correot copy or 'IllY ,Il1d 1111
lnvllllt lqllt lve reports, tost rOllu 1 tll, lIumrnllJ: iell, rU<lOrclll, llr<\W In'llS,
IIket.ches 0': photographll or the lnoldunt 1I1Volved In tllla ilbovo-
retorenced ":,ll1e, '4 1.11 ,lilY 'NIIY portllllllllq to tho OVUlltB tlll/."rOllll,l1n<!
It., or ill Ilny 'NIlY pertlllnll,., to tho tll..:tll whleh will lit! oILhllloed Ily
/lnd 011 behalr or Plnintlffs ~t thu trllll or thill C/lBO.
~. Produce true Ilnd ..:orro..:t coplon ot /Ill l.ittltomenta,
Qr memoranda or fJtatemonts, of Ilny IIlld 1111 pononJ:l who wlll bIJ
called all witnollselS at the trilll or this ollse.
). Produce true /lnd cor.reot copies or III 1 lItlltelnellta or
momoranda of atatomentfJ, or 1l11Y p"rty, IIla/hor 'Igant, .Jr r.llnploYfloa,
concerning the lIub1o..:t matter ar thill casu ~nd the oventa
aut-rounding it.
". Produce true IInd correr.t copies or tho report or. any
o~port rotllined by tho Plaintl.ffs .Ind/or tholr ,Ittornoy In
connection with this CQl.iO.
5. produco thfl curriculum vltllfl or your o~pert
witnesses IInd 0 list or all or thoir publicationn.
Ii. Produce .1ny and i\ 11 other documents prepnred by each
expert Idllntit ied together with II tl correspondencQ bctWt.!en sa id
- ;! -
~
Exhlblt 0
1"'.
,', l
fII!
, ; t""I
Exhibit 0
~
r
, ,J
EIlhlbll E
~
---
COMHONWJl:A1.TIl or PJl:liliIJY1.VlltfIA
Iii THill COURT or COMNON PLIEAII or CUMIJIIU,^ND COUNTY
RICHARD 1.. KAHN, JR. I lio. 91$ - 6637 oivil
and JODY L. I<^Hlit I
P aintirr. I
I
v. I CIVIL ACTT.OIi - LAW
I
I<IMBERLY ^. /4AR'rIH I I
Detendant I JURY '1'I\1A1. OEMANDIO
PRDJ!:R
AND NOW / thi. day' of , 1998, upon
oonsideration of th. Motion ot Pefendant, Kimb.rly ^. Hartin, it 1.
herp.by ORIJERI!:P and PI!:CRI!:I!:D that Plailltirts, Riohard L. Kann, Jr.
and Jody L. Kann, shall provide tull and oomplete an.wen to
Pefendant's Intorroglltories and respond to Oetendant's Requost tor
produotion of Ooouments within thirty (10) days, or upon further
motion I sutter suoh other .anotlon. 48 the Court deems to be
appropriate at that tim..
BY THE COURT I
I J.
"..,
attaohad hareto, inaorporat.d har.in by r.taranol and markad
E~hibita ~~~ and ~Q~, r.apeotively.
e. By way or l.tte~a datad Hay 1:1, 1997, June :11, 199'/,
and peoemb.r Ie, 199'/, Defendant rllqueated roupon.ea to her
disoovery requeetN. copiea of these letters are attaoh.d hereto,
inoorporated heroin by referenoe and marked au ~:uhibil:e 'c', 'D" fInd
'E', respeotively.
O. '1'0 date, Oefendanta has not reoei ved any reapCll1Sell
to the outstanding Intorroyatoriee and Requeet tor Pr~duotion of
Doouments.
7. Va.H.C.P. No. 400~(a) (2) roquireB answers to written
interrogatories to be served within thirty (30) days after aervioe
thereof.
B. Va.H.C.P. Ho. 4Q09(b) (2) requires a r..ponee to ft
requellt for produotion of documents be served within thirty (10)
days after servioe thoreot'.
9. Pa.R.C.P. Ho. 4009(b)(2) authori:ees the party
submitting the request for produotion of documents to move for an
order under Pa.R.C.P. tlo. 4019(a) it' the plll:'ty upon whom the
request was sarved fails to respond within thirty (JO) days.
WHEREFORE, Defendants, Kimberly A. Martin, respeotfully
requosts that thin Honorable Court enter an Order compelling
Plaintiffs to provide full and oomplete anSWer. to Defendant '.
Interrogatories and respond to Defendant'. Request for Produotion
- 2 -
Ellhlblt It.
..
f"
eOMMONWEIIL'1'1I o/" PENNIIYLVIIHIII
IH 'rilE COURT 01" COMMON PLEAB 01" CUHBERriAHO eClUNTY
IUOIIAllO L. KAHtf, JI~.
Gnd JODY L. KAHtfi
l' aintLftl
v,
I Ho. 9~ - 6637 Civil
I
t,
I
I CIVIL IICTIOtf - LIIW
I
I
I .JURY 'l'IHIIL D~~MAtfIJI!:O
I<LMUEllLY A. MAI\TIN,
OerltndGnt
Itf'l'EHROGA'l'OIU v:a Of' DEFEHlJlltf'l',
KIMBERLY II. MARTIN,
^DDRE,Oll.D....l.O PLliltl.'.l'.llf1L=..::J:mf,l'1' 6E1:
TOr Riohard L. Kann, Jr. and Jody L. Kann, Plaintiffs
0/0 Riohard L. Webber, Jr., F.squirEl, Gounsel for Phintirts
J66 Green spring Road
Post Orfioe Box 40
Newville, Pennsylvania 17241-0040
PLEIISE TIIKE HOT ICE that you are hereby required pursuant
to Pennsylvania HUles of civil Procedure Hos. 4005 lint! 4001\ to
serve upon the undersigned within thirty (lO) days from servic~
hereof your answers in writing Bnd under onth to the rollowinq
Interrogatories.
These Interrogatories shall be deemed to be continuing
Interrogatories.
It', between the time of your answers to fJaid
Interrogatories and the time of the trial of this CBse, you or
Ilnyone Bcting on your behalf learns the identity dnd whereabout~ of
any other witnesses not identified in your said answers, or if you
obtain or beoome aware of additional requosted information not
-
DJ::flHI'llllHl
II. uled In these Interroq~tQrlaR, the word. nnd torms all
set forth below shall be defined "s ralloWHI
(II) ~Youll, ~your~ Ol~ "yourllQlt~ uhllll melSn /ll1d inollld"
the answ~ring party, ol\uh or uaid pnrtY/lI representntives, ~~antll,
sarvants, worlunl!ln, rolntlVlls, omp!oyooQ, IIttorl1l11Y, Ilnd /Ill utili".'
p6rllonR aoting for or on bllhalt or tho nnswerinq party,
(b) "tdel1t1fy~ In" "ldel1tlty~ wllell l~eferl'll1'1 tlJ 1111
individual means to utnto hlll/horl
(1) 11/111101
(~) prosent nddross, if known, or last known
addra.Q (bu.inulls and residenoo)/
(J) job title, business IlfHllnt:ion or 'job
olassification at thq time or the event. referred to In the
interrogatory ansWer 1
(,\) current omployer, I f known, or laRt known
employer/ and,
(~) telephone number (business and residence).
(c) ~ Ident i fy" or ~ ident i fy" whon rererr ing to document.
means tOI
(1) state tho type of Jocument (!LIs..., rocord,
roport, lottor, memoranda, to leqram, churqo, photo, ute.), i tB
date, Its title (If ilny), its identiCyl.nq number, ,1
generalized Bummary oC the subject matter or the contonts or
the doouments, and its present location, and
I
.-..
(:I) IJtBte 'I/wh porBon who pr"llarod It, eaoh j1lJrlll1n
tor whom It W~s prepBred, the nddreaN ot eRoh pqrson to whom
j,t Wl11 aent, the IIddl'Ol'lR at elloh perIJon who In,.,sqntly IIIIU
uUlStody of thG original Qr copieR thereot.
(d) ~Id"ntity" or ~Iduntity~ when ".oton~lnq to II ">J1Blm~
or ~IIlJt ion", mennf:l to llet forth the nllme or. tho I:OUI~t whore thO!
>Jase, olaim or rtotlon Wlll'l rllod, tho dockot numbor, tho yoar Ilnd
dnte when the notion Wllf:l commencoll, the Ilnmel'l nr. 1111 I:llllmllntu
(Inoluding YOU), tho nllmOIl or. IILl pllrtiel'l IJ<Jlllnst whom II cluil11 WlltJ
usuerted, the <Into or dntos at tho tronlJoction or occurrenceR which
'J')Ve 1~I.IJO to tho ,;ll1im, ,\ description 11': \njul~il?tJ 'Ind tllllna<Joll
cllllmod to hllvo Accrued, tho idontity ot insurnnce oArrillr for tho
person or ontltiell against whom nil claims or suits were nSl'Iorted,
thIS outcome of the claim or tluit, the "mount recoverod, from whom,
IInd if no reoovery wae roali:eed, why not.
(a) "Documonts" include ony writton, l'ecorded or graphic
mattor however produced or reproducod inclUding but not llmitod to
correspondonce, teleqrllms, othor wr i tten commun icat ionfl, contr"ctB,
11greements, nCltos, reports, rocordB, ~-rays, memoranda,
photographs, tape record.lnge or any othor writings, Including
copios of any of the foregoing now or at any prior tima in your (as
det'lnod haroin) pOBsel'lslon, custody or control.
(f) ~stutement" includes a written statament signad or
otherwisa adoptod or approvad by tho poraon making it. It includos
thll stonographic, mechanical, electrical. or other method of
raoording or II transcription theroot' which iu a uubstantiaUy
ii
,-.
verbatim reoltal of un orAl lItatement by the per.on muklng it un
oontompornnuouply reoorded.
(g) ~Trentmont~ meuna uny .ur~ery, e~nmlnution,
dlnqno~iu, therapy or other medloul aure or attention rQnd'~ed.
(h) ~Medioal Pllrllonnel" moanR phYlllainn, ,llIntillt,
ohiroprlllltor, podiatriut, ohil'opodillt, thero'lpiet, lntel:n, l'Ollidllnt,
l1urulI (LPH or IlN), 01: nny ~hOlllth <litre IH'OV Ido,:" or othor; 11lU'son
who l'lillldored uervloo to, IIttl!lndl!d to fir othorwillo IHlslatod 111 tho
.:nro ot th", Jllnlntlr.f.
(i) "Modiclll Fllcility~ moanl! hoopital, doctO';'ll otriGll,
clinic, l'ehllbllitntioll cOl1tl!I', nursll1g home or nny lIimllilr faoility
ill Which or through which medical, therapeutic, rehabilitative or
other IiIllrvlcoo woro rnndarod.
(j) "PerAon" has its cllstoll\nry brond meaning Ill1d shall
'Ilso include nny humon boil1q, corporation, part;norship, solo
propl'iotorohip, lInincorporotad allsocintlon, joint vel1tura, or any
othor organlzotiol1 or ontity.
(k) ~Ool\lcribll", "apeciry~, "nd/or "atllto" llhall rnolSn to
Ret forth fully and unllrnbiquollaly, llsing profossional words or art
ir neceuunry, each and overy f,1ct rolevnnt to t.ho IInBwer c,111od (or
in the intorrogatory ot which tho answering party or hie agents,
employeea or ropreaontativus hovo knowledge.
(1) "lIccident~ means, unless otherwiae indicated, the
accident that allogl9dly occurred on May 15, 1995, out of which this
(lot ion nrolle.
Lii
~
,I, It you have IllV'H alSlllertao:t n IJlntl1l or tlllto:t n IS\lH: for nny
purpolll InClludinq, without llmltatian, a olaim ~or Injury,
o:tnmalJ8/ property dnmllqo, Ll1snl:llllty, workmlln'lII IJOmpenlllllUon (it"
oco"pationlll dllSease to ol:ltllln bene~ltlS, plltae. identity the
olaim or QUit, the nature ot the Injurl~1II all.q.d In enuh suoh
suit, the period durinq whioh you were diSAbled, "nd, It "Rid
lIIuit hAil been terminated, stAte the rse"lte at the triAl or
IIIl1tt~'ment, Inoludinq the nmount" ot IIDoh reoovery or
IIl1ttlement, if nny,
"" .\ -
EIlhlblt B
"..,' ,.jI,II'.',j ......-,.. t, ,.j."" (1)""'"
,""'
".....
COMMONWIl:M.Jl'll 01" l'l!NNII'iLVAtl1A
ItI 'l'lllt COUIt'l' 01' COMMotl r~.IW3 01' CIIMnl!:llJ..Atlll COUN'I'V
11ICIlAJlll
and JOOV
1.. I<AtlN / .m.
L. I<AtlN
l'll\1nt1tfll
tlo. ~~ - ~~37 civil
v.
CIVIl. I\C'I'10tl - LAW
I<IMIl/i:IlLV A. MAW1'IN /
Dltflllndnnt
JIJJl'i '1'1ll/11. IlI':MAtlI)I!O
FIIlIIT IlEQUEIIT OF DEPENDANT,
KIMIlEIlL'i A, "'AIlTItI,
l~lLI'll!JD.JJ~.'lliJL9.r..JJ~MJ.mx.a
'1'01 Jlic:hal:d t.. I<ann, .,.... Ilnd ,lady L. I</lnn, 1'1aintLftll
ofo Jliohnrd L. Wqbber, Jr., EBquiro/ counael tor Plaintiffs
3~~ Orlllllln Ilpr ill(J HO/ld
Poet Offioo nox 4Q
Newville, ponnaylvnnin 11~41-0040
Pursuant to kule 4009 at the Penneylvnnin HUloe of Civil
Procedure, Defendnnt, Kimbe...ly A. Ma...tin, ~equoata that l'lnintiffll
produce the documenta he...einnfter described nnd permit Detondant,
through her I\ttorneye to inepect them nnd copy auch of them na they
may derslre.
Defendant requeete thot the documenta be m/ldu
nvailable for this inapoction nt the officee af Defendant's
attorneys located Ilt 101 rine stroet, IInrril3hurg, i'ennaylvanin,
within thirty (30) dnya of tho dato of Dervic~ hereof. Dofendant'u
attorneya will bo rOllponllible for thoBe documentlll na long I\a they
are in their poasoaa ion.
copying will be done at llefendant'a
expenae I\nd the documontl3 will be properly roturned ntter copyinq
hila boon comploted.
Thia roquerst ia intended to covor nil dOGumento in the
pOBBoasion, custody .Ind controL ot l'lllintitfa, their .Iqenta,
.......
employ..e, ineuranoe oarriers and nttorneYB /lnd ill oonsidered to be
continuinq. PIAintiffs' response to the Ilequest should be modif1ed
or supplemented as 1'1Aintiffs, and/or their nttorneyu obtain
further odditionol doouments up to tho time of trial. Hequeut~d
documontq I\re more porticUll\rly itemi~od nnd deucribed as tollowol
1. Produce tI trlJQ nnd correct 'JOPY of IlIlY I\nd /I \ I.
lnvDlltiq/ltivo reportrs, test rusults, summnries, reoorda, drawings.
sketohes or photoql:aphs of the l.no1dent involved in tho 'lbovo-
reterenced caoe, or in tiny wny pertllining to the avonto surrounding
1t, or in /lny WilY pertnining to the fl\cts which will be tldduoed by
and nn behalf of l'laintitfs at the trial of this cnse.
~. l'roduce truq and correct Gopies ot all statements,
Qr momorl\llda or atatoments, of any I\nd all persOll11 who will be
called as witnoBseu at the trial of this cl\se.
3. Produce true Bnd corroct copies at all atntements or
memoranda of stl1tements. of I\ny party, his/her agent, or amployeeB,
concerning the SUbject matter of this case and the oventa
surrounding it.
4. Produce true find corroct copies of the report of any
expert retained by the Plllintiffs and/or their attorney in
connection with this cllse.
5. Produce the curriculum vitae of your Qxport
witnesses I\nd a list of 1111 of their publications.
G. Produce any and 1111 other documents prepared by ellch
expert identified together with all correspondence between Baid
- 2 -
~'
Exhibit C
(,) ~
~'
Exhlbll 0
"....
~.
It) ",..
exhibit E
, ,,4:>C
I) ./I'-'J,;)I
'tl\,l':V', '
,
,
:;
~ j I
lil\
j,:
;,
"
"
',;
'L'i
'l'
':'
"
"
"
,
"
'"
!
,
I,
,
,
,I
"
"
,I
"
"
,
,
"
I'd
"
"
"
"
"
"
II
1,1
, '
I.'
I,
"
,
I', ';
, '/;,"\1
" '
,"
.'/ i
, , \ "
" , ,
I, 11 j! I
, , Ii ,
I "
','
I'
"
\1
,
!
"
,1'1'
,
'iI
'll'
I
'Ii'i
"
"
II
,
I, :1 ,
I
, ,
': ,
"
[,
")fl
"
'I
,
"
"
,
,
,
,
"
)1
\;1
"
0'0
"
i'-
,
'I,
,
,\
Ii
,
!!),'
";I
"
'Jt',,1
"
"
"
,
, , ,
"
" ,\ i-I
,
" ,
,II
"
':/
t'
,
"
Ilj
'i"}'
, ,
,"
,,;
,
;i\L
"
, ,
"
"
, " '"
,
" "
;Ii
"
t;,
,j\'li- .,J
. . Iii j' I iI,,~
I I " }{\J~./. dY::j!~"
, ' j I, I, '1 ~' '\ ;' ;1ijl,,' II I t
,,~ ,}i,tt,,! ""II \'~ 'J';, III.
.' ,i\" ,t tt ,
, 1, ,; 1~;J ~ \.: j \J II ;,I'{.1,I, ~ I !
I 'I,I I" d '.'#r~" j' t "'11, 'JI"lt 'J'
I II I I l ; 'I . .~~jf!lj /,; . 'i/. I~ l ,I t
J " ""I "1ft I I' t' If ,,'
, II',', ' I'" I '";!Jfl', I'ill J,
, I ' I' 'I, ," '1)\ I Iii l
'I ",, I/~, L. ~I' ,ft. ' j llt!r', "IT'''"'l'
, ' " \ iii'" '( " if"' 1
"I ".,n .. liil "'II' "/'1 l'
I II 11"I~"\"I"lfll!'lIr~'}I"lt",~, II
" "" ,'II, ,,,It)" "
, ',: '," "~':V,II."::,:~';~,:i ~"Ji'll~i..ll
I, j'" I" .; t: ",I, i,ild,)" r ~
I .-' r ,I,i. r I~' '.J ,'~ll"-I"
r,,';'!! ('.' 1_,:;jL:}_-~';:';!i,,/J","~'ij,
i ' I",~ t' I '1'\' J"~l)'I'dtl';~'hl il i-
, ',I 'i,~'',I!~' "':i~:m:!i:, ,;;,'a,;; ;:
""'_Y'i;,.;I~)I"i.J;il' I
. ~ "f.{':~ II) (t,l:,"nii~',';~lt~~." ,-
,. ',':,',,/, _ J/,t~1)~I'\tl'.';f/.';
\I j "I i' ,', '/ _ \ ,.Ir, l1i
!.',)~! ~-~lj;\;l/;>il'~I'i\:!'~;V::~);'"j_
,,1.1 I' -',
!I ,in,',!, ,,' t" I',tl'h f' t',
, Ii',' -'_ .- ',-,1':'1',' ,j,'/
'i' :Ii,' '/1';(: '/lin "
!h'~'--j!, -",f1[,~!Hff',I_ !,',:,'i'.'
-, "~I '1,1 "I ,;';J "
,I {~, ~i; ~,;H:,'~" 1'!.;:.AiH",~
, -1"\-1' ij'j'-'/:"Ij_j!~_' 1<11_'_1
""j"', ,'"i.lII'I,'q.','" ,~
" "i,t",:,( ~i\ 't'." : .\');\1 -i~; 1,
..t' 1,"'1;. :-, ~ "I'.~'JI.I.
'I, I', ,"l:,'-hf)', 11''1/.-'i~4
",_,;_1;-,', ,q,'-:~I\i'li~~i
.1,1], _Jtfj'j''-I''',
, ,1_' ;',I,"''-'-,,:JA.''',
,_"ifl{ {I",-;.fjl",;,
';<ill' j -lb, _',;,~
:-I~\-,._\_:!!'; 1;"jjl{;r'\::-.J1-'~
.- ! _ '. ~ _ ,I if' I J ,:1 'f ,; ,: ,
1;-f~~I,'!", ' '( 1,' -J::'"
.rl_., \I\'~"I ld,II-'IP/
"1,.,1 , ,'(,I l'("~?
'I)', I. 'f '. '1.. ',,' ';1'1,.,
'j I:f)/d://!I;'l;{~\-~;hl;'
" '1". ,- ':'~~'I; f}'"
, """,i,'()~<,I~,,:rt'l
",')','- J.";-,P~ ,1~
~;,:I/ ;';';;":{'\I;I-~,*ffi:1
"I'".:"" !.~h'
"J I" 'Ot!,-,'tlWl'/b-"
,') i \i'I'h.J.i-I::i-H~;I~(
11'1.1" <i" r'\<':::~I."1
I' II;', Iii)'
i ',)' l,~ ",; "', ,rJ'f~I';f
Yi, ',r'li,I':h';+:'/}i!
,1- I 'j'; ..~Lh h
, \ 11',' :L "I~L-'-;',,I<",
I "I''''''
" ,1:'1,1. '<'i)'.r~"-.'l_~.-/~'L'
I ';,''''-,/ ':'..'\'II!';'::';I"~}~i,
,,1 > ,I H,'_':,- ~ I" II!
',I ''';; "2~)Ut+
"
\ 'I
,
!:
,
,ll'(I
i\1 1
"
,
ili
Ii
n
111'1
"
,',
j i I i ~'
1,1'1
il",l,
, "
,
"-I' f
I'
" '
\
lot,
,<,1
illii,'
'1'\;,
"
'1,1
I:'
,
'.
j ~'
"
"
,
,
'I
,
"
,;
',I, 'I
" \'
, ,
,tC) 0
,"