HomeMy WebLinkAbout00-01391
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
.... COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
NOTICE OF APPEAL
FROM
JUDICIAL DISTRICT
DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT
COMMON PLEAS No.~ [tX)
n;;: J
/39/ C-tJ I
NOTICE OF APPEAL
Notice is given that the appellant has filed in the above Court of Common Pleas an appeal from the judgment rendered by the District Justice on the
date and in the case mentioned bel"",
NAME OF APPELlANT
MAG. DIST. NO OR NAME OF D.J.
Chris Jones Construction
ADDlESS OF ~l1ANT
aTY
09"1-01
STATE
ZlPCOOE
c 0 Butler Law Firm P.O. Box 1004
o..TE OF .A.lDGMENT IN THE CASE OF (Plaintiff'
Harrisbur
PA
17108-1004
(Defendanf)
2 10 00
QAIM NO.
Michael M ers M ers Electric
SlGNAT
Construction
CV ~ 0000003-00
LT 19
This block will be signed ONLY when this natation is required under Po. R
10088.
This No~ice of Appeal. when received by the District Justice, will operate as a
SUPERSEDEAS to the judgment for possession in this case.
Signature of Prothonotary or Deputy
/lant was CLAIMANT (see Pa. R.GP.JP. No.
1001 (6) in action before District Justice, he MUST
FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after
filing his NOTICE of APPEAL.
PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE
{This section of form to be used ONLY when appellant was DEFENDANT (see Pa. HC.P.JP. No. 1001 (7) in action before District Justice,
IF NOT USED, detach from copy of notice of appeal to be served upon appellee).
PRAECIPE: ro Prothonotary
Enter rule upon
Michael
Myers/Myers Electric ,appellee(s), ta file a complaint in this appeal
I1JN~Of T:'lee(S), ' '_ :._
\.:-lJi' I ) within twenty (20) days after service of rule or suffer
(Common Pleas ~c)Ztl..... J.3 9/
RULE: To
Michael Mvers/Myers Electric
Name of appef/fre(S)
. appellee(s).
(1) You are natified that a rule is hereby entered upon you to file a complaint in this appeal within twenty (20) days after the date of
service of this rule upon you by personal service or by certified or registered mail. .
(2) If you do nat file a complaint within this time. a JUDGMEI-lT OF NON PROS WILL 8E ENTERED AGAINST YOu.
Date:
1',...... 0<...... 0<............. _ "'...,"...... 0' ~" .. ~
3 -q . .11l#) .' "
~ .' m~ ~
AOPC 312-90
COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY
- , .. --" ,~
, '."."
,'~ .
-..;.,'".,~, - ,,-",
".'
- <-~--F'
. ' ..'~o_ ,.,' ',"-, ,-'",',.... ",,,,,_
.,
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
(This prooi at service MUST,B'J; FILED WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS AFTER filing the notice at appeal, Check applicable boxes)
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY Of ; ..
AFFIDAVIT: I hereby swear or affirm that I served
o a copy of the Nolice of Appeal, Common Pleas No, , upon Ihe District Juslice designated therein on
(date at service) 0 by personal service by (Gertilied) (registered) maii, sender's
receipt altacheO hereto, and upon'the appellee, (name) , on
, 19_ 0 by personal service 0 by (certified) (registered) mail, sender's receipt attached hereto,
o and further that I served the Rule to File a Complaint accompanying the above Notice of Appeal upon the appellee(s) to whom
the Rule was addressed on , 19_~ 0 personal service by (cartltied) (registered)
mail, sender's receipt attached hereio,
SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME
THIS
DAY OF
.19_
Signature of official before whom Mfidavir was made
Tiile of official
My commission Bxpires on
"9~~~
~~'
"'>~ ~ ~
~ ~~
,~ r ~
'{\ ~,,"
~ l.l.J
~
~
~':'\~
~ "'
\
of affiant
()
c:
."s::
~ffi
655;;;
-< :z:
kO
~8
J>c:
'~'
o
q
'3:
:Do
;;0
I
<.0
-0
::II;
~
G3
<.0
~
--j
:.r. ::n
nl,....
'T,1n
:ny
0,:;,
::;:!-r;
(.:5,-n
ZO
On'\
'~
, -<
1
'"
rrr".~ ,_"n~
~~\Oi~~~I'!!"'''F'''''1l~~~
p.~~;'l'J",,,,,"-""'" -,-<~,;"'-w,""e'~"'~"::",!j'''W<',~1RK'!'l(Ijjli~~fl;'i,jI'ti1~-<i-;;1~1":>1!!~I!lIi~F~~!!l
", ",''O"!;....,:'"~-.
. - ,'......, ..-~'--, ~".'
..~, , . '..OMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYLVANIA
""!-\C~UNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
e'-'
;,,, ,.,.;;~~...;.:.
09-1-01
,
NorlCE OF JUDGMENTITRANSCRIPT "
. CIVIL CASE ..
PLAINTIFF: NAME and ADDRESS
'MICHAEL MYERS/MYERS ELECTRI(,;.. .,
67 SHERWOOD CR. .,
ENOLA, PA, 17025
L ~
VS.
DEFENDANT': NAME and ADDRESS
IcHRISJONES CONSTRUCTION,'
424 PLUM STREET '
LEMOYNE, pA 17043
L
/'
.,
Mag. Dist. No.:
OJ Name: Hon.
CHARLES A. CLEMENT, JR.
Add",,, 110,6 CARLISLE ROAD
CAMP HILL, PA
, T'.I'phoo,. (17) 761 "4940
i7011
'""
I ",<,.,;if,
! ~
,
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION
424 PLUM STREET
LEMOYNE, PA17043
~
Docket No.: CV- 0000003 - 00
Date Filed: 1/05/00
THIS IS TO NOilFY YOiJ THAT:
Judgment:
FOR PLAINTIFF
Ii] Judgment was entered for: (Name)
Ii] Judgment was entered against: (Name)
MTt'HJ.F.r. MVF.1HI/MVF.1H'IF.r.F.t''1'RTt'
.
(,HRTll .TONRll ('ONll'1'RU('TTON
in the amount of $
l 11i7 1i1 on:
(Date 01 Judgment)
2/10/00
. .
, C:1Delenda~ts are jointly and,severally liable.
. .":\:f2J'b~~ageS~ill.be~ssesse~o~: .
,c)
(Date & Time)
Ai\:ld6i1totJudgmen(y'..'.....
J\ldgment Costs ."
. Iniereston Judgment
Attamey"Fees .
Total
\$>3t08i ,61 " .
'$.'.".. ." '86.00.
$ ;00'"
$ .00
$3.167.61
<' [] This case dismissed without prejudice.
. y ~ .
;,',1"[' _ !, Ii' I
:.:~ t, -~, ",) ", I If f f
D Amount 01 Judgment Subject to
Attachment! Act 5 01 1996 $
D Levy is stayed lor
days or D generailystayed.
Post Judgment Credits
Post Judgment Costs
$
$
------------
------------
Certified Judgment Total $
" .Dq~jection t? levy hat bee~ Iii)"? ~ndh!;lari~g;Yiil br~.eld:i'" '.': , ..', i'
Dat~r,"~','~"'., -.-.-.,",<> ''';,","-\' '\""'; ~"'" ~--'''' Place:-,"'-' ,'\, ~~,,'i 'j ,I -I -'1") f \ r '.1-
," "
i ~, " ': . I, ;-" " '-,",,' -'-''''.."'"C -,..,~ ,<',I:"",V",~,_, ey,;;",,,
Time:
"
~. ~ 'll '
c:::::: ~:1:E~~;,;;;::,';'~"'':::o~:;~~~~1!~~ '~~:i~;~~~OTIgr.
MUST INCLUDE A COPY OF THINOTICEOFJUDGMENT , . SCRIPTC .,I!H V:<>URNOTIC~~fAPPEAL.
'\" .... '. '."... ".,., .
.2110(290fJ . Pate . . '.DistrictJustic?;'
-" 0'/'__ ~"'-.-'."n;' ,',
""-'
,:';',',,,
Date
''>('\''''-.-'''' "'-"."- ',-
. taininglh~ludgl)lent.
, ,"..",~ ":":~',jC':':';':' ,,-- I
: District Justice
.!,:;,~:'-~{f:,,<;,;:,:~~~-,~-:.,: ,:"-,:': _-',_, ,,~_ :" ,,', :,-' ',' '; , ,'~-'.,'
. L9~qilythatthisisa trlJeandcorrect copy otthe record 01 the proceeding~,
My commission expires lirst Monday 01 January,
AOPC 315-99
2002
SEAL
I
'-.
" ,
,
..,. r "'-- - '"
.-
- "--~".-
'"
P D52 D16 D69
US Postal Service
Receipt for Certified Mail '
No Insurance Coverage Provided.
Do not use for International MaillSee revelSe)
Senti. ~~~~~~
l"'f\ " JU-c
St..et&Nllfr1be~ c",.
(",7 e,
PosI OIIice, StateS' ZIP Code
~'l'\1"10'>-S
Postage $ . 3"3>
Certified Fee \ .'-\0
, ~
Special Delivery Fee .'
Restricted Delivery Fee
Retum Receipt Showing to \ I, J-.$""
Whom & Date .Den~red
ReltJm ReceiptShowing to Whom, 7
. Date, & Addressee's Address
TOTAL Postage & Fees $ .2.9 g.
postmal1< or Date
E
0 3;'';00
(,1:L(.
"
'"
0>
0>
~
c.
<(
Q
Q
CD
C')
"-
(IJ
D-
P D52 D16 066
US Postal Service
Receipt for Certified Mail
No Insurance Coverage Provided.
Do not use for International MaillSee revelSel
Sonl!. \c\ ~.~,
(;~. ',.
&rem&~m~r~ ~o-....J
11010
PosInOllice, Stale, & ZIP Code !.'?t
~ II0ll
POSlage ~ $
.3?,
Certified Fee I.~O
"
Special Delivery Fee
Restricted Delivery Fee
Return Receipt Showing to 1\ I . ~.s-
Whom & Date Delivered
Return Recel>l SI10wing 10 wnom, 1/
. Date, & Addressee'sAddress
TOTAL Postage & Fees $ do.9 'b
Postmark or Date
t,1 J.(" 3J.t 00
,
:!l
0>
~
'<:
0.
<(
Q
Q
CD
...
E
o
"-
(IJ
D-
.
" ~
~r,
'C",C ,."" ,,""M,,,"""'''' ''','''' '''', ",,'"
,,"",""'''',",', '''' "'e"" """"'''''''''',''~,'''m''''''NOT1Cil5f'~'~''''''''?~'''-","~
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
FROM
JUDICIAL DISTRICT
C;:_~'~."',;'
>- " ,: - _d_',: :'" ',:",'''_': -:-.:_ ':'.;' ',' _'", d""'- ,_ ", C,_ _ _ : ':' ",- ,'_' ,: ' -
Notie~ isgi;",n ihotth~opPei~"tljos fjledin theab~, Court ,ofCo!rirriOO PI~cis~n~I'lI'Oa' from~~)udgm''"t ri!nde"'~<~t~e,,~istri~ )~stieeqr1 tile
datea~dintheca",me.,tiq;,edbelOw. " .'" "', ", '"'""',,,,,,' ',""'" "".,' ,',"','",' '",' " ," "',',',,,',',,' "'," ',' ,," , '
Chris Jones Construction
ADDRESS Of APPeLLANT
ZIPCOOE
NAME OF APPElLANT
aTY
1 00
1004
r isbu
P
,I;-';i...,.'_(~t)
Construction
17108-1004
c Butler
DATE OF .IlJDGMENT
h e1 M
,..-c,;
. '~o_'_
ClAIM NQ
.', tv llllL0000003-00
"".,,,,,,,,,,,,,,,bwJ, ,"" ," __,' ",'" ."""".,i, ';"'-e',,,;,~,,:
This bioek':"'al b~ signed'ONL'f wh;,n'this nototionisrequirell,dnder,p'<> Ri.
100,88.. , , , , ,,"
This Notice of Appeal, When receiVed by the Distric:t Justice, will operate as a
SUPERSEDEAS to the judgment for possession in this case.
Signature of Prothonotary or Deputy
, '
" ,
PIlAECIPE, TOENlER, R,Ul.ETOFIl,E 'COMPl.A.INTA-f111) RULE JO'FIU
", '_"~'::;'~1;:f,';"",, ,_,"', " ",,';",,__ . ''''-,: ,,:,,':><-.",:--',""'_, :-,:'-":'-':--i-:/:-:>:,
(Thissec;tioilot/onrUo~.'!S.-gd ONWwhenl3pJJeiiant W1!S pEFENDANT (see Pp., R.c.P.J,f., No, ,1001(7) in i1cti(jnA.e,/I!W:]4~'1ct,J~ice.
~~~;~~~:J~~~~~rO(ndtiCeQt~/rObeSeNedUponawel'S)' '.,',' ,,'Hr{f~)(:":~~":~i' '.
Enter~illgupon' . "..."Micheel Mvera/H".:rs Elect.rie '. ", ""appellee(s);~i:illi\Q:Z~~pti!intih.'1"!'(jp~eal
(Comnx>nPle"'N~tXtl- '/39; C!t""';; r;::;~ twenty (;0) days afte;~i"ee' of. rule or s~~:r:~iJy::~f:-t;'m~~zJ~'~~~~
, (z :g/',; ,.' '<i
II RULE: To
Michael Myers/Myers Electric
Name of appeffoers)
. appellee(s).
sture 6f appellant or his attorney or' agent
\
i
I
I
, .;i ",;"(1)YOV;~~il!.~;!WJ:~f'll~;.;,.,!~l~~'VIl"~1;o~"lIli!il"',"'~QJ')I1Jq;l't)n,!his 'i'pj>!~>'(iiliin"~\""'l'tl!~9l?'!J!5;af!<l!;~!t~""tc;~"'i..,,
servie." af. this rute\iP"it:~jil;0'7rsoM'r;~(J'of'IW eertiR .;Oi"rliQisl..rearTldili" 'iT "., '.'..- . ',i.'; .,... .,', ":" , ", ..."'C" .,.,',".
(2) If you do ,nOt lile 0 complaint within this time, a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU.
,/
Date:
3):~ date of se~~::~ rute if service was by mail is the date of "",ili~ ~d ,1 ;MA~~
d{ '0 l!ij.irJfN~
,J.:' ---'j $.,- ~ ~
, AOPC 312-90
-'1".11
C"''''i,..;",_"",,,,,,,4..il.~ .:,,, ;"~ ':,'+~ ~~ ' ~~
~< ,~F~"'~~:'~'.:,.;"~~_-~,~-~~~,~'
.~ . ..C'.L ~~~" ,"';' ';,r,.~"
~ ;~~~-"" "
" , , .
:-,..._"-"",~;..,",,,,,,,,,,,,,,,",,,,,,:,~...::
~,,,::s~ "-c_,," ",,-'.; __ ~\'
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE "0 FILE COMPLAINT
(This proof af service MUST "BE FiLED WITHIN TEN (10) DA YS AFTER fit/ng the notice of appeal. Chsck applicable boxes)
COMMONWEALTH Of PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF
.." DAUPHIN "
; 118
AFFIDAVIT: I hereby swear or affirm that I served
'VJ 'fA C N 2000-1391-Civil h ' , J t' d' d h '
"" a copy of the Notice 0 ppeal, ommon Pleas 0, , apon t e Dlstnct uS Ice eSlgnate t srem on
(date of service) 3/10/20.00 "<,,.,g'f>Y F'0[Scmal serviCe !"iil by (certified)(~~ mail. sender's
receipt attached hereto, and upon Ihe appellee, (name);:'llf,i?l(:~r:'1';.;1I'fypr. /1>\ypr. 'Ill prtri r ,on
J.1arch 10 _, m<: 20000 by personal service'0 by (cert,lied) (registered) mail, sender's receipt attached hereto.
IXJ and furlhe, lhat I served the Rule 10 File a Complaint accompanying the above Notice of Appeal upon Ihe appeliee(s) to whom
the Ruie was addressed on }larch 10 ,"ilL~ctJ by personal service1!J (certified) (!l'JiI~~
mail, sender's receIpt attached hereto,
SWORN (~AND SUBSCRIBED BEfORE ME
THIS I o~ DAY OF 'M~ ,""00'0
~-l
Esq~
~~
:<
)>0
20
)>c:
z
=<
.c-
;tl>o
::l:
:!!1 affiant
r- .
'-om
:u, 9
06
::;:I-;2
o:rl
zO
om
~
-<
~
'a c.
$ignatur~ of o!fic1f!1 ore w},om amd<'i~it was
--c"".JJoT~_D)~(f -
TiiI!1 01: 0fficial -
My commission expires, 0:'1
, 19---,
I\,)
-.J
NOTARIAL SEAL
CHERYL L. FERGUSON, Notary Public
City of Harrisburg, I?auphm. County
My Commission ExpIres April 6, 2000
- '
,"'"
4
'/"-
lu
_ ~ ,,; , ,__0,.> N,~~"'.
1!"!~p:."~!I!W_"~"""'~~''!J~'!f~~Q'B'$:.~i:t~~t\l'~-M!i\''''i'~:--'f':''-f1~'''''~''',Th''''--'''' "-I':c"":,~t'c,,,,,,,,n"'t",I~,,,,,>"\';'-~"'~"",pr~':Il-"""- , ,,:'",'n''=;'''''i''-f'''''''f>.'8'',''j\-''''"'''
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC
Plaintiff,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
v.
No. :
;<000- 13q I
~,~
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
Chris Jones, an individual
Defendant.
NOTICE TO PLEAD
TO THE DEFENDANT NAMED HEREIN:
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against
the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action
within twenty (20) days after this Complaint is served, by
entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and
filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to
the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you
fail to do so, the case may proceed without further notice for
any money claimed in the Complaint, or for any other claim or
relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or
property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT
HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, 00 TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE
SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHEElE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, P A
717-249-3166
800-990-9108
NOTICIA
1e han dernandado a listed en la corte. 3i listed quire defenderse de
8stas dernandas expuetas en las paginas siquientes, listed tiene viente (20)
dias de plaza al partir de la fecha de la excrita 0 en persona 0 par abogado y
archivar en la corte en forma excrita sus defensas 0 sus objectiones alas
demande, la corte tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra listed sin
previa aviso 0 notificacion y par cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido en la
peticion de dernanda. Dsted puede perder dinero 0 sus propiedades 0 otros
derechos importantes para listed.
LLEVE E8TA DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO 1MMED1ATAMENTE. 81 NO T1ENE ABOGADOO 81
NO T1ENE EL D1NERO SUF1C1ENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERV1C10N, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME
POR TELEFONO A LA OF1C1NA CUYA D1RECC10N SE PUEDECONSEGU1R AS1STENC1A LEGAL.
--I
,~
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC
Plaintiff,
v.
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
Chris Jones, an individual
Defendant.
No.: ,;{O()O -/3q I
~~
COMPLAINT
AND NOW COMES, Plaintiff, by and through his counsel, and
files this Complaint against Defendant, and in support thereof,
avers the following:
1. Plaintiff is Michael Myers Electric, 67 Sherwood Circle,
Enola, Pennsylvania.
2. Defendant is Chris Jones Construction, 424 Plum Street,
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania.
3. Defendant is Chris Jones, an individual, 424 Plum Street,
Lemoyne, Pennsylvania.
4. Plaintiff filed an action against defendant with the
Honorable Charles A. Clement, Jr., Camp Hill, Pennsylvania.
5. A hearing was held by District Justice Clement.
6. District Justice Clement heard the testimony of several
witnesses as well as reviewed related documents and ruled in
favor of Plaintiff in the amount of $3,167.61.
7. Defendant filed an appeal to the judgment by District
Justice Clement.
8. Plaintiff is an electrical contractor who worked on several
construction jobs for defendant.
, .
I
-~~
,~
-
9. Defendant is a construction company and served as general
contractor for several construction jobs that hired Myers
Electric to perform electrical work.
10. Defendant individual is Chris Jones, the principal of Chris
Jones Construction and at all times, personally took certain
actions and made certain statements which were tortious in
nature.
COUNT I - BREACH OF CONTRACT
AGAINST DEFENDANT CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION
11. Plaintiff hereby incorporates by reference the foregoing as
if fully set forth herein.
12. Plaintiff entered into several contracts with defendant for
electrical work on certain residential homes.
13. Plaintiff was the electrical contractor for the Manheim Job
and invoiced defendant $1,881.91 for electrical work.
14. Plaintiff was the electrical contractor for the Hummel Job
and invoiced defendant $1,500.00 for electrical work.
15. Plaintiff was the electrical contractor for the Giani Job
and invoiced defendant $8,549.39 for electrical work. (See
Invoice attached as Exhibit A.)
16. The terms of the contract were spelled out in a series of
documents and verbal communications between the parties.
(Exhibit B.)
17. For the Giani Job, Plaintiff provided defendant an estimate
for the work to be performed, provided defendant with
documentation to support the work to be/and performed by
Plaintiff, held discussions with the defendant as well as
other sub-contractors and conducted a walk-through with the
homeowner.
18. Defendant agreed to all the work to be/and performed by
Plaintiff.
19. The homeowner agreed to all the work to be/and performed by
Plaintiff .
20. Defendant paid $5,800.00 as partial payment for the work
performed on the Giani Job.
21. The $5,800.00 was rounded from $5799.79, indicated as
follows:
a) $1,225.00 for a new 400 AMP service and spotlight
wiring detailed in Exhibits A and B.
b) $574.79 for extra work as detailed in Exhibits A and B.
c) $4,000.00 as a down payment for 400 electrical openings
and incidentals as indicated in Exhibits A and B.
Defendant paid $4,500.00 to Brian Porr Plumbing which was
then given to Plaintiff.
22.
23.
24.
",.;o!J
The total amount owed to Plaintiff was $13,631.09, payments
totaled $10,300, leaving a balance due and owing to
Plaintiff of $3,331.09.
Defendant is also liable for costs incurred and awarded in
-
the previous action by the District Justice at $86.00.
(Exhibit C.)
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this
Honorable Court award Plaintiff $3,331.09 as indicated by the
Invoice at Exhibit A and Costs as awarded by the District Justice
of $86.00, for a total of $3.417.09, plus attorneys fees, and any
other relief that this Honorable Court deems just and proper.
COUNT II - MISREPRESENTATION
25. Plaintiff hereby incorporates the foregoing as if fully set
forth herein.
26. Defendant individual, Chris Jones, drafted an agreement
between C. Jones Construction and Porr's Plumbing.
(Attached as Exhibit D.)
27. The "agreement" was signed by C. Jones and Parr's Plumbing.
28. Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that the principal of
Porr's Plumbing signed the agreement under duress.
29. Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that the principal of
Parr's Plumbing was coerced into signing the agreement.
30. In the coerced agreement, Defendant referenced Mike Myers
Electric.
31. Plaintiff had no knowledge of the coerced agreement prior to
Parr's Plumbing signing same.
32. Plaintiff never signed the coerced agreement between Porr's
and C. Jones.
,"_c . ."_~ ~~.
I
~ ,
~< ~
33. Plaintiff never assented to the coerced agreement between
Porr's and C. Jones.
34. Plaintiff never gave Porr's Plumbing authorization to enter
into or modify any agreement on his behalf.
35. In an attempt to remain amicable and in consideration of a
long-standing relationship, Porr's Plumbing gave Plaintiff a
portion of the funds received, the amount of $4,500.00.
36. Porr's Plumbing recognized that Plaintiff was owed money for
performance of electrical work.
37. Defendant fraudulently tried to bind Plaintiff to a third-
party contract without Plaintiff's consent.
38. Defendant made the material misrepresentation that Plaintiff
had somehow released defendant from liability.
39. Defendant intended to defraud Plaintiff of the monies due
and owing to Plaintiff.
40. Plaintiff was harmed in the amount of $3,331.09, plus costs
of the original action of $86.00.
41. Defendant's acts were intentional, deliberate and calculated
so as to defraud Plaintiff of the money due and owing to
Plaintiff.
42. Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that punitive damages
are in order for the defendant's tortious conduct.
43. Plaintiff believes and therefore avers that punitive damages
are in order to prevent defendant from further attempts to
defraud other subcontractors.
, I
~~ "'-
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this
Honorable Court award to Plaintiff actual damages of $3.417.09,
award Dunitive damages in an amount not less than $10,000.00,
plus attorney fees as well as any other relief that this
Honorable Court deems just and proper.
Respectfully submitted,
Dated:
3/24/00
By:
~
Deanna Lynn Smith
Attorney for Plaintiff
ID#77414
76 Greenmont Drive
Enola, Pennsylvania 17025
Telephone 717-732-3750
VERIFICATION
I hereby verify that the statements contained in the foregoing document are true and
correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false statements
herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. ~4904, relating to unsworn falsification to
authorities.
,
Dated: J -.;U -01)
By: ~,/L~
""'".,
"
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC
Plaintiff,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
v.
No. :
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
Chris Jones, an individual
Defendant.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of
the foregoing upon attorney for defendant, via United States
Mail, First Class, postage prepaid, at the following address:
JANA C. BUTLER
BUTLER LAW FIRM
500 North Third Street
12th Floor
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Dated:
3/24/00
tdA-..
By: Deanna Lynn Smith
", ~
I
" ~p
- -,
~
-"
'~''-
MYERS ELECTRIC
67 Sherwood Circle
Enola, P A 17025
(717) 732-6980
MANHEIM JOB
Extra material paid for by Myers Electric
TOTAL MANHEIM JOB
$1560.00
321.91
$1881.91
HUMMEL JOB
New 200AMP Service
Wire New Addition
Repair Old Wiring
Extra Material paid for by Myers Electric
TOTAL HUMMEL JOB
$ 650.00
720.00
100.00
30.00
$1500.00
GIANl JOB
New 400 AMP Service
Spotlight Wiring Extra
Subtotal
$1075.00
150.00
$1225.00 *(1)
Remove old wiring from existing house & roof $ 180.00
Extra material paid for by Myers Electric 269.79
Supply & run 100 AMP wire and breaker for heating 45.00
Supply & run wire and breaker for outside alc 40.00
Supply and run wire for 100AMP sub panel 40.00
Subtotal $ 574.79 *(1)
400 Electrical openings (estimated) based on
square footllge (4700 square ft.) $8000.00 *(1)
Appliance Wiring GFI wiring 300.00
Extras paid for by Myers Electric
Lights, spotlights, bulbs, dimmers 249.39
Subtotal $8549.39
Credit C. Jones for hanging spotlights ($100.00)
1881.91
1500.00
TOTALGIANlJOB 10.249.18
GRAND TOTAL
.,"
$ 13,631.09
D'H,L:> IT A I
GRAND TOTAL DUE Myers Electric
PAYMENTS MADE BY C. JONES
Check # 7204 $5800.00
Check # 7510 $4500.00
(Check # 7510 was in the amount of
$9,035.94 payable to Brian Porr of
which Myers Electric received $4500.00)
TOTAL PAYMENTS
BALANCE DUE
The following paid by check # 7204
* (1) $1225.00
574.79
4000.00 (Y2 paid for rough-in)
$5799.79 TOTAL
$13631.09
- 10.300.00
$ 3,331.09
$5800.00 rounded to total amount of payment
,,~~- "
""T'
EXHI8/T A
fA C-c "),
fA
.- MYERS ELECTRIC
I!i7 Sherwood Circle
. ENOI.A, PA 17025
(71 7) '1'32-81180
t.lcerwed . II1SUI8d
f rJ. '1- if. Pf -' 0;'1
Ctl # 7').0 1-
DATE: 4- - J.. 0 - '! '1
-~
........
SALESMAN
F.O.i11
.~
. 13 ~;{;~.
~~"'1f~'"
. ~ "~""~--1"'"
~.~~-
-Ja,-.~ 1ir'
~. .".,......,.,.."..
~ -:-~~4. ..'
~ - /~iiju-+
.-/'-../ - .
~ . ,
-
~.~/~
~. --
r;::. ~ -.
~-~~
I
I
!
I
INVOC.7S0-2
PFflWlEO IN U.s.A.
it
,-/
\
i
'-...,/
........
INVOICE
- -,
I
Ot.!l;: CraOER NO.
AMQUNT
I
I
I
,
!
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
:1> 't! 000: DD.
. I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
j
,
I
I
i
I
i
,
J
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
1
,
,
I
I
I
. " j
_ :...':L.Q & (): () 0
~ ql&l!
~~A'
EXH181i f3
~
- 1-'
-
g
~ ~-~
--
f IJ, Lf- ~ d- O! --1:[0,
cN. #- 7J.bt
..
MYERS ELECTRIC
e'1 Sherwood elide
ENOlA, PA r1025
(717) 132-81lllll
~d -Insured
"e.~~
-~,~-~.,
'fOO/fMfl ~ 1.
TE_
:~,,~~-;.f:' . ., .
",' -:::":'~" :.)h
~ 'f-O~D '~' "~ ' ,
~ ~,~''J:,f!O M'(l,
't6 ~" ~r~
~.,"~~,~"'"
~4~.
'JrYj1i ~'
"CC-,....
\11NTED IN U,S.A.
"
""""'-
-'.----'
l j
-..../
- < ,~
-iCJ
~
f.O.8.
PIlw:E
'::,,'.
,
I
,
\
"
I
,
I
I
I
\
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
;
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
.
INVOICE
OUROOCERNO
-
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
,
I
I
I
,
I
$~075iOD
I
I
I
I
I 5' 0 : 00
I
\
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
,
I
I
,
I
I
I
j
,
I
,
I
,
I
I
I
I
I :;':l'f : DO
91wJ ~~&ll
~~.-
6XH }fJJT Jl '1
-r
.. " MYERS ELECTRIC
aT Sherwood Circle
. ENClLA. PA 17025
. (717) ~
LIcet II8d . lneured
po: '
If--~''' -OJ"1
cfl H 7J.04
e.~~.
DATEstllPPED SHIPPEOVIA
""""
(JIt Ie: .
3-JI) .,,, . ~. ..".t,( ~.~. .
~~~"'~~.
~ /lU<I\- ,+71- JUtS i NilS
r . r.." ....,'...' '
~ - cI'-....-M -~
~~~,~
4 + ~.l./.)INVOI<(5
~ /00 IJ/tl~ ~ ~
~~~~
~ ~")(J 19""1' IJ,;'
J;r4~~~~
/N.W' ~ /fc. ~
~~
~ jDO/l-""fJ ~ ..L..- ~
~~~~..,.
INVCC-,.....
PRINTED IN u.s.A.
st.
, I
'--"
!
........-/
INVOICE
OUR ORDER NO.
AMOUNT
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
J/'io:OO
,
,
,
I
I
,
I
$ J,. ~ G) i7'!
I
I
,
I
,
,
:1'1-5:00
I
"
,
I
,
I
I
I
.$ '7-0: 00
I
I
I
I
I
'}, io1 001
,
I
I
I
:; S 7 4-: 7?
ffia,J ,cy&11
7~ Jiq~
5X)-}J/?JJi ~ q
,~ .,."
-
~,.." ~
~
COMMm>JWEAlTH 0;:: PENNSYLVANiA
GOUNT,' OF: CUMBERLAND
1 Mag Cis! ~0
I :J.; NarT'.e Hol'1
I "'d',,,
I
I Te"""" (71"') 761-4940
CHARLES A. CLEMENT,
1106 CARLISLE ROAD
CAMP HILL, PA
JR.
NOTICE OF JUOGMENrrrRANSCRIPT
CIVIL CASE
PLAlNTIFF: N~MEandADDAESS -,
~ICHAEL MYERS/MYERS ELECTRIC
67 SHERWOOD CR.
ENOLA, PA 17025
09-1-01
L
,
-'
VS.
17011
DEFENDANT: NAME andADCRESS
!CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION
4U, P'LUM STREET
~EHOYNE, PA 17043
I ~
iDocketNo.: CV-OOOOC03-0Cfl., '.
II Dale Fiied: l/I)!;/(~,Q . "".
, . .
I ,
, ,
I
MICHAEL MYERS/MYERS ELECTRIC
67 SHERWOOD CR.
mlC<LA, &>A 17Q25
Tl:lISIS TO NOTIFY YOUT.HAL..
Judgi'lent: FOR PLAINTIFF
'---,
~ Judg""ent was entered :or: (Nama) MT('iI'J!,F.r. MYF.flA!MVRfll'IF.r.F....'I'RT('
liJ JiJdgrr,en: was entered against: (Name) ('H1HS .Toms COlliRTRUC'1"TON
in the amount of $
3 , 1 67 61 on:
(Date of Judgment)
2/1 nlllO
.
o Defenda-cto are jOintly and severally liab!e,
n Damages wil! be assessed on:
L-J
(Da's & T:me)
$ 3. 081.f511
$ 86.00
$ .00
$--~
$ 3,167.61
r-I A~;CUiY 01 JU-Jgrr:en! SUbje'cl to
LJ Attaohmel1t'Act 5 Of 1 E-9€ $
I' Levy IS s\aYild tOl __. days 01' 0 genmally stayed.
L_J
IAmount of Judgment
!Judgment Costs
: interest on Judgment
i Attorney ;c aas
!Total
I '
i
I Post ,Iudgn~ent Credits
I Post Judgment Costs
I
i Certified ~lJdgmenl Total $
$
$
o This case d',~'ni5sed without prejudice,
------------
------------
== Objection to If NY 11as been filed and hearing will be held:
It Da~.~~-----.;:::--~-.--Tp\ace:
I, I'
Ii j
Ir--:-------- -----1'
I',' TH'-,O: II
1 II
~ __ '.'_. II
l
,j
ANY PARTY HAsrHE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHiN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF ,JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE
OF APPEAL WITH T;.,E PROT~iONOT ARY/CLERK OF THE COLlRT OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION. YOU
MlIST INCLUDe A cop, OF TH N TICE Of UDGMEN'~. SCHIP ITH YOUR NOTICE OF APPEAL
2/"0/2000 D t ~II
., a W ' District Justice
I cartily that this is a true and correct copy cf the record of the proceedings
Date
, District Just!ce
i'Jy ~olTlrnissicn expi;"es first Monday 01 Janua'y,
2002
SEAL Exf/ltJ IT ~
AOPC 315.9'3
;-"'1f-, ]
.'.
",~~p
~ _~_I,,""=, ~,....,..~<w___
C. JOI1es eon_ion is paying the balance of the jobs done by Parr's Plumbing &. Mike Myers Electric
In full. Because oflhe money tllat was owed on jobs was never satisfied, C. Jones Construction is not liable
for any otbermOlley,owed. ~p
c_(~ ~ ~ - ,,",',- ':P ~-
~~...- . .-.-...-.... _.
r:u"~r~
~,
-.N~ "\ ~ ~
~~ ~ ~~\\N
~~ ~ '~"
~~
1
(\\-"
~
EXHIBIT .Q
5
I"
,
~ ~,~
~fm"W
,-,~
'H. HH ,
. J.II!IIm'r=
""'"
llill1!lll;!J]Il'!flR.
.. ,~.
(")
C
':9
(J')
o
"""",,,,~,~--~ "
,~~
<':J
C)
~ll:
~
::v
<"";
.r.-
~
-,,,.
~
o
11 F'~
;~;~,
-"im
"]l;]l
:):'"'-
"-ft.;:)
:~:c~_:g.r .
~;:--<5
(3m
g
::e;<
-
=~~ ,r
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL V ANlA
v.
NO. 2000-1391
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
CHRIS JONES, an individual,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NOTICE TO PLEAD
TO: Michael Myers Electric
c/o Deanna Smith, Esquire
76 Greenmont Drive
Enola, Pennsylvania 17025
YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED to file a written response to the enclosed New
Matter yfi'thin twenty (20) days from service hereof or a judgment may be entered against you.
BUTLER LAW FIRM
B~~~
Attorney for Defendants
J.D. #80574
500 North Third Street
P.O. Box 1004
Harrisburg, P A 17108
(717) 236-1485
f~o, ,,- "-" ~ "-' _':'f7"_\"'~}I,~'Fi,,_". ~
-,',^""
-',""f''-''_''''!,o ,,~~ _"_ '("co'_"_,_,', -.' "
~', ,.',.. ",,,.. co
"'-
.
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL V ANlA
v.
NO. 2000-1391
CHRlS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
CHRIS JONES, an individual,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DEFENDANTS' ANSWER AND NEW MATTER
AND NOW, come the Defendants, C. Jones Construction and Chris Jones, by and
through their attorneys, Butler Law Firm, and file this Answer and New Matter averring as
follows:
ANSWER
I. Admitted upon information and belief.
2. Denied. Defendant's proper name is C. Jones Construction and has an address
of P.O. Box 266, Lewisberry, Pennsylvania 17339.
3. Admitted in part and Denied in part. Defendant's address is P.O. Box 266,
Lewisberry, Pennsylvania 17339.
4. Admitted.
5. Admitted.
6. Admitted.
~'::",-, .?' - , .-~ -,,*_, -'JI':-""~,_""""_~';:;'*->-" -"," ~. ""J' ", "''',~ of>" _~_ _
",' n
_eo, -"""'_~,yr',__,_
". ---,-' ~"='- - -.,
,0 .
,
7. Admitted.
8. Admitted.
9. Admitted,
10, Denied. Chris Jones is the owner ofC. Jones Construction. The remaining
allegations contained in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw to which no response is
required.
COUNT I-BREACH OF CONTRACT
II. Plaintiff merely incorporates by reference the allegations made in paragraph
1-10.
12. Admitted in part and Denied in part. It is admitted that Defendant hired
Plaintiff to perform certain electrical work for several construction jobs. It is specifically denied
that there were any written contracts.
13. Admitted.
14. Admitted.
15. Admitted in part and Denied in part. Defendant admits only that Plaintiff was
the electrical contractor for the Ginanni job (spelling in Complaint is incorrect). It is specifically
denied that Exhibit "A" is an invoice. It is also specifically denied that Exhibit "A" shows a total
amount billed for the Ginannijob of$8,549.39.
fL,
c>''>' <~"f-~I~'~:"-'" '''-.'--' "" "~ "~_"',,,",'-~. ~-"",,- ~F"'"'::'5
-- :' "j ':,"'_ _~'"^_;;' !N~, _ 0 ' ~-
, '-1-
,. '-'-~" ,
16. Denied. It is specifically denied that there were any written contracts. In
addition, the allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw to which no
response is required.
17, Admitted in part and Denied in part. Plaintiff did not provide Defendant with
an estimate for the Ginanni prior to starting work. Defendant admits only to having received the
Invoices dated April 20, 1999, which are attached to Plaintiffs Complaint as Exhibit "B" and
which speak for itself. Defendant is without sufficient information and knowledge to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations that Plaintiff held discussions with other sub-contractors
or conducted a walk-through with the homeowner. As such, said allegations are specifically
denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at triaL However, Defendant specifically denies that
Plaintiff conducted a final walk-through with the homeowner.
IS. Admitted, Defendant admits only to having agreed to the work as described
in the Invoices dated April 20, 1999, attached to Plaintiffs Complaint as Exhibit "B".
19. Denied. Defendant is without sufficient information and knowledge to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations made in paragraph 19 of Plaintiff s Complaint. As such,
said allegations are specifically denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at triaL
20. Admitted.
21. a) - c). Admitted in part and Denied in part. Defendant admits only that he
made a first payment to Plaintiff for the Ginanni job in the amount of $5,800.00 (rounded from
$5,799.79) in reliance on Plaintiffs Invoices dated April 20, 1999, attached to Plaintiffs
~., -'-.
"_O'~'_'~_"";I_'''','~___~~'_''' ',,-,7_ _ .', ,- "'-_." ~-':'~__~ __~',s'_.'-,-
- -, ,~ .<" - .', ---" ~".-
Complaint as Exhibit "B". All other allegations made in this paragraph or subparagraphs are
specifically denied.
22. Admitted in part and Denied in part. Defendant gave Brian Porr Plumbing a
check dated October 21, 1999, in the amount of $9,035.94 with the understanding that a portion
of that check would go to Plaintiff. Defendant acknowledges that Plaintiff admits to receiving
$4,500.00 form Brian Porr Plumbing. However, Defendant is without sufficient information and
knowledge to form a belief as to the truth of the allegation that the total amount Brian Porr
Plumbing gave Plaintiff was $4,500.00. As such, said allegation is specifically denied and strict
proo f thereo f is demanded at trial.
23, Admitted in part and Denied in part. Defendant admits only that he made
payments to Plaintiff totaling at least $10,300,00 for the Ginanni, Hummel and Manheim jobs.
Defendant specifically denies that he owes Plaintiff additional money for these or any other jobs.
24. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required.
WHEREFORE, Defendants respectfully request this Honorable Court to dismiss
Count I of Plaintiffs Complaint with prejudice and grant all such other relief as is reasonable
and just.
COUNT II - MISREPRESENTATION
25, Plaintiff merely incorporates by reference the allegations made in paragraphs
1-24.
~, >.
'._,- '''');,~1i:',_~<I'''',,'''~''''" - -."',' --~',. _C,_""''''_''~'',1;.____~__ '<,<, - ..
'.-","""".
. --~-"
-I' -
. __B, "'_'."'~_<", .
26. Admitted.
27. Admitted.
28. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required.
29. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required,
30. Admitted in part and Denied in part. Defendant admits only that Mike Myers
Electric is referenced. The allegation that the agreement is "coerced" is a conclusion of law to
which no response is required.
31. Denied. Defendant is without sufficient information and knowledge to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations made in paragraph 31 of Plaintiffs Complaint. As such,
said allegations are specifically denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. The
allegation that the agreement is "coerced" is a conclusion oflaw to which no response is
required.
32. Admitted in part and Denied in part. Defendant admits only that Plaintiff
never signed the agreement. The allegation that the agreement is "coerced" is a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required.
33, Denied. Defendant is without sufficient information and knowledge to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegation that Plaintiff never "assented" to the agreement. As such,
,:7 _""'1":"_':"'.;'-'0;-"
'-,"-'
~ - "'!;-~---'. -~'-<,-:-'" ;. -,-
"',c,'''~'' ,.,,~,
.,ro'_'-
.
said allegation is denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at trial. The allegation that the
agreement is "coerced" is a conclusion oflaw to which no response is required.
34. Denied. Defendant is without sufficient information and knowledge to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations made in paragraph 34 of Plaintiffs Complaint. As such,
said allegations are specifically denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at triaL
35. Denied. Defendant is without sufficient information and knowledge to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations made in paragraph 35 of Plaintiffs Complaint. As such,
said allegations are specifically denied and strict proofthereof is demanded at triaL
36. Denied. Defendant is without sufficient information and knowledge to form a
belief as to the truth of the allegations made in paragraph 36 of Plaintiff s Complaint. As such,
said allegations are specifically denied and strict proof thereof is demanded at triaL
37. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required,
38. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required.
39. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required.
40. Denied. Defendant specifically denies that Plaintiff has been harmed in any
manner whatsoever.
- ":i"';'I~'_ '''''',,''1' ~'~._"~":-'-~-~~ "C';
- ",,- "'""'. -~, 'C'=-""'~'-,j:
- -r,__,~ _._ -C,- .'- "",,.. .,d,., r"
41. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion of law
to which no response is required.
42. Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required.
43, Denied. The allegations made in this paragraph constitute a conclusion oflaw
to which no response is required.
WHEREFORE, Defendants respectfully request this Honorable Court to
dismiss Count II of Plaintiffs Complaint with prejudice and grant all such other relief as is
reasonable and just.
NEW MATTER
44. Defendants' answers to paragraphs I through 43 of Plaintiffs Complaint are
incorporated herein by reference as though fully set forth.
45. Plaintiff began work on the Ginanni job in or about March, 1999, and
completed the work on or before May 13, 1999. Plaintiffs work on the Hummel and Manheim
jobs was completed by or before June 10, 1999,
46. Prior to Plaintiff commencing work on the Ginanni job, Defendant explained
to Plaintiff the work that needed to be done as well as the fact that Defendant had allocated only
$5,500.00 from his contract with the homeowner for said electrical work. Plaintiff did not refuse
the job and began work on the Ginanni job.
;>s",~'~_~ ,r_'-n_O_,' "",_,_~,;',,~_;,,"I__'_;'_ ,-_~~"'( :" --c""_"-' -.--,'" ,-__~. ice" '0'
. 0_', "'""~> ,',~, "Y. ,__' . _' _' ,. - - -- ,-C)' -~. -,,,,,~
,~ --
47. Approximately two (2) weeks after beginning the Ginanni job, Plaintiff told
Defendant that he would need more money to complete the work. Defendant responded that he
could offer him a couple thousand dollars more, bringing the maximum amount allotted for the
electrical work to $7,500.00. Plaintiff did not reject this amount and proceeded to finish the job.
48. On or about April 20, 1999, Plaintiff presented to Defendant the invoices
attached to Plaintiffs Complaint as Exhibit "B", Said invoices total $5,799.79.
49, In reliance on said invoices, Defendant gave Plaintiff check #7204 dated April
21, 1999, in the amount of$5,800.00 (rounded up from $5,799.79). A true and correct copy of
the back and front of said check is attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit "1".
50. By check #7510 dated October 21, 1999, Defendant paid Brian Porr
$9,035.94 with the understanding that a portion of this money was to be given to Plaintiff.
Plaintiff admits to receiving at least $4,500.00 of this check from Brian Porr, A true and correct
copy of the back and front of said check is attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit "2".
51. Said $4,500.00 was allocated as follows: $1,500.00 as final payment for the
Hummel job; $1,881.91 as final payment for the Manheim job and the balance of$1,118.09 as
final payment for the Ginanni job. Thus, the total amount paid to Plaintiff for the Ginanni job
was $6,918.09 ($5,800 + $1,118.09).
52. In November, 1999, Plaintiff presented Defendant with additional invoices.
True and correct copies of said invoices are attached hereto and made a part hereof as Exhibit
"3". Said invoices indicate that Plaintiff is due an additional $3,331.00 for the Ginannijob.
1:~7-~ ,~,"~ . "," , , ~--,-'-"---~'''K-~r-~-" . , ?",~"....~" ',' .,- ---"'?'-"~'--- ",' .~ ~~ ,,' ," , " >~ ~, ,,,.
However, this amount would result in payment to Plaintiff for the Ginanni job well in excess of
the $7,500.00 estimate.
53. As such, Defendants admit only to owing Plaintiff the difference between the
estimate of$7,500.00 and the amount paid of$6,918.09Ieaving a balance due of$581.91.
54. In addition, Plaintiff, according to its own terms as stated in the invoices
dated April 20, 1999 (Exhibit "B" to Plaintiffs Complaint) and November, 1999 (Defendants'
Exhibit "3"), overcharged Defendant for the electrical work, Specifically, Plaintiff charged
Defendant for 400 opening at a price of $20.00 each. However, Plaintiff did not install 400
openings. Rather, Plaintiff installed only 308 openings, which means that it overcharged
Defendant by $1,840.00 (92 openings x $20).
WHEREFORE, Defendants respectfully requests this Honorable Court to dismiss
Plaintiff s Complaint with prejudice and grant all such other relief as is proper and just.
Respectfully submitted,
BUTLER LAW FIRM
Attorneys for Defendants
500 North Third Street
P.O. Box 1004
Harrisburg, P A 17108
(717) 236-1485
Ir'c~--'-- '-, '"' -C'_"_,__,__3i'!'>!"!I_:_~;~__,-'}<","1" c" , ~M" ...",' '" ",~ ~. " ,--' . "-,~~ ~", ,. O'_~; ", ",- .e., .. ," "to-
";
HARRIS@
SAVINGS BANK
Mon Jan 24, 2000
ACCOUNT NO: 1600014551
RESEARCH IMAGE REQUEST
KENDA N JONES OR
CHRISTOPHER L JONES
DBA C JONES CONSTRUCTION
PO BOX 266
LEWl SBERRY PA
The lmage(s) shown below
represenl off Iclal copies of
original docurrants processed
by our Institution.
C. JONES CONSTRUCTION
CHillS oIONES
P.O. BOlt 266 PH. 717-737_
LEWI5DEIlRY. PI. 113311
~-7a1 7204
2313
~':WA~~~/..d)IJ
=.;"~'\(~ ("\'ft.Qs ~'ukiC.
..:FiVe:. -\-N:lll~OI..si C~h"" \ndr.\~<".t
IDHARRIS
W SAWlGS BANK
-.oCr~._..~ ~'" ~":..~~ ..
.:.i!:I ~:I ? i! 318 7': ~ SOOO ~.. 5 5 ~.. 7 m.. ...oooosaooo,Q,t
,
I $ 5f1ltO.OO
~.
- ~O OOLLARS l!Il!ii'=
4590830
4/30/99
5800.00
.. i'J (,~~~
~ l: ~ ~~
~'ol~~wt.
~ WI i!. r=
/!~ it f a i~!
il:' g" ~~ t~;
= !5 r ~.~ 'I
:::D. "Ji;>1
< . I'! ~ I
"'.. ._* I .::v 1("
~ il:~~:tt:r.]. ~!.
s; !!fi!:;~: H~ f
o ~ ,:":i~o It.
0- t:"lIl:C$- ~!~
"ft ;i2..i:,.s?: :i 'P~:
8 -.." '.'~ ',I
< ~~!.i.i~~1 It'
~"':::-..-~ =
I S.&SS=~E. iJ
z ,- ._-" I
iJ;' i:i~~ II
",~i: ~~!! ·
g., ~~ h~ I
n'll .. .. I
0_ J ~
"
~. 'CI.. I
'I: . ~~i
.,,~... '..... <Cj~~
o.,.~ 30C>>~~
tt.lSi~~-~ ';;...
- """ -:)- cS.
c..l>~.r.':'l':l.Jol :r!!l
_,":,~'l.~_ . ~~.
t.:J"l"":i;''C'94.["4 -........'V
....,:r..,,1t.~ I!o
t"..,,,,, '~~>I-~"" . ~ $..lII
~Y'\ c).. ~..
A ... A'" ...g...~3
- fool -.. s.'Z
:; ........02=..
- . - 'TI
:=.~~~
~..~ ~:e. ..
J:;! 1
"in . I I
t, _. ... ._ -.: .-1 . .1 .' I
- --.. y ~';:a ~'!Ir ;.:..: '4. obi ~ I
m. I
. I ...
~n;
~ ~
"
C'\ ...
~~1."'
: .....
, "1
, I
~.. _"t ""''''t:
..
, ;
~
~
00
~..
..
I
Back side
E XHI13rr #/
-, ~
-
-~~
.
HARRIS@
SAVINGS BANK
Mon Jan 24, 2000
ACCOUNT NO: 1600014551
RESEARCH IMAGE REQUEST
KENDA N JONES OR
CHRISTOPHER L JONES
DBA C JONES CONSTRUCTION
PO BOX 266
LEWI SBERRY PA
The lmage(s) shown below
represent official caples of
original documants processed
by our Institution.
-;'':'1'' '.' . .1510'
_ifl'\~ t), ,QCl ......
""11l~
$ q 035.'9l(
CD 1 : .': - /.
J DOLLAJisI!l=.-::.
MEMO
9740190
10/22199
9035.94
.-:--:;.~--;........~;.~. -~
;II. C'!I ! ,: '1
w' ~., .
~, .c.'';
"" i.;i j, c~ i' l- I
,... ... i ;;;:! ;:~ ~
j5.-:~~~:",.
~, r ~~-
~~ '" li:"'C
III, .. . ". T ~:
~ g~:;~::.lI:7;: ; l
t'11i~~=-:a. f,.'
g ,! ; ~ '""1 > ~:'
!i: i:.. 'l'..... ~ - - '!
Cl ~:~\'~i~~ <..
e "",.,.q f~
;:i ~ij~ii;:~
i =~K"~':';':- ;.
~ :~} ~!.t~ :
~ '~ ~ ~:; ~ :
. r,,;.::..& f .
R? -
""
"Jllll\jlroHun HSlf.l 00
"M! l6'6tE'6 JJl\I\>6'!;tO'6
69t0 SOtOtOO T~g.T00091 8S6O 666T-22-o1
"
o
~z
..0
v....
"'=:
'11"
""l
Om
."
11!j
,...
i~
~o
-'"
c..
~,;;
-z
=1D
=f!!
io
c=:
J!!;!
-w
c
z
.m
~
Back side
I"
EXIIIBIT #2.
.,"- -I
.~
..
'-- . . ~
&ul"0l0'....
(Y)' I m
;j( ~
.....:p J
00 I
-I I
~;
::::.- ,ltl
~,8 ,g !\J
() :..0 ,~\
K.D .
'0 U.,
. ,.. I
'h' ..... .
'tJ ~ I
jl) I I
! I
---- ilL!'t N } ~ 0 ~ 6TT---'--~-------'-' ..----f--. -.---.-----~--,
._" ____._..____':tQQ___r2f.f!1!.I/IIJri__.X'i.2:.0..______ _'.'., _:d $_~Jo-9QtQQ
. "
/ !II c E W-Lg I !!lr...::._W./JJ..JIe/1S-_.. ---..-..-..L---- -------L.-. _
d. ,fJ{2)' E ;2:S Gt.-J Vvli!~ !t.D~ .kIL1---.___.___.l__. _______ ,_L_.,
, ,
G PI' 1Aj( (2/ nJ Cr _.__________ .-..-----J----3Q-tL-:..Q.Q
(J:. T R,1t '~_Ett1f2---f~ fl. -il'1---- ,'U_ -.-."- - i--- ----.------ f .,,--,
_______ ___ ___________.,_J"J_t.fiJ2...5.__Ek<:I&LC[)(!'IlJ.figf, ,.,."".",u.:., '.., :
'd. '3
_________________EidILJlt; S' ' Se.IL4um.1-____. ___.{.... JL_J/f__c;,_:...'J
________ ____________..___.Su 811l!,T , J2Q Eofl:::,~bl L!r;.t::l ._L_.:J.,:L 0 Q, Loo
: 11 tt'f : 3
~T ",., , ~O: 00
.I.~i_,_.__ftt.._.. ,__..
, ::::;.. ,
'~~ $ 7~O:0
: .$1.00_:00
: 0:00
~ ~ s-oDloo
~j/t~Di 00
1_5'0 Joo
,
-$ 5'"0: 00
.' ,
3?-J:'11
...--- .,..,^"'-._+,- ...+- ---.
1~"lJ :'1/
-CJ1wJ cy01l
C ON Tift i/ EO c,
MYERS ELECTRIC
fIT Sherwood Circle
ENOlA, PA 17025
(717) 732-6980
Ucensed -Insured
CUST. ORDER NO. DATE SHIPPED SHIPPED VIA
TERMS
INVOICE
- o;i
OUR ORDER NO.
.. m_..,,""._ ...,.' ,,~_....
___,_.__iil!..l'1JJJi.L5j_IL-:JY...!w..__[JgjJj~t. .. '..
-.., , , 'f-OQf(I!I/lJ/JrX $ / 'D
__ _5}hy.I5S_._$~f'A,gII'.lCr.e~OVJLo.,e.k
"_d'_ TE 111- - N-L1'OCl.f-TWi)(l/<
.~_._,______m_m+___._____,~__+._._.+__._++__._,..,._ '''_. __.~ ,_.._
INVcc..750.2
PRINTED IN U.S.A.
*
1ffiMR'"
,," " f'1IJ/lIJ1!1/Yl73_0f?11lIlifrS/'$-a.O
.. Jl~OIf::-1.I ~/L,,_C.Q.JI11lI!.TEA,.._...F:,tJ,~<l..JT ,.
,
faD /0-3 WIgf,~fL fpTQ/1!i GIl/MJrE.
{~I ?I!_rl/f..!f?ft: 1111.:bJ:'Q.t3z '..
(VIv € 5 Ii C.rll(~, cHJl11J
t.JG-/1r;l1J& - FlfN,f.,'lJ-/tr
lJL,t.dS - d"'okE DI1Tf.cr~fS
EXHIBIT #..3
',"
-I
I~ 0
4/ ,
,
.. "
kt
,
,
I
,
-.,....,,1
,
I
o=lO , _ _ ~,~q"""'_
, .~
1,1" i, '~,,' ;~ ',I
]!::Ifl,,,
b\" ~~('''~~I
~ '-':'f'1c1
/,' '.'
MYERS ELECTRIC
fr7 Sherwood Circle
ENOlA, PA 17025
(717) 732-810
Ucensed -Insured
INVOICE
E,~ -
---~-rtlJ'i------JaLiJJL/'(-
OUR ORDER NO.
CUST.OROERND. DATE SHIPPED SHIPPED VIA
TERMS
SALESMAN
F.O.B.
-----. illLJ2fi ({) f1 'j e.r -,-------..----~-.-- -------
______. __ _________ kLIH'Ll___;IQB-_____________________,_._:,_. ____..___
I
_._____ __,________________. ,_Nz_w___':1:_~9.P,., 1.__.I~_/2.1!I_~,g__.,"'_.!-- _.'.'."__._.___,_
s PoT L lJd{L..JlJLE:.l (II_y- _____.__,_._______1.... :$ /)..J ~J..QQ
I ' I ~
C Q /I ~ 0 L [) INJAlI1l [r _ ____... ______.___~..- -1__ ) '7l f2..~Q.~
.....___ ___ _____ ll~_~_:.ffr~ .H~lfrGIJ__{Jfl.f_.TwM'r(.._______L-- .__, -1..--
I , ~
._ ____ _.__ _______ ._ s !dJ.P-~.lL.Jl't-.f'4~f.-...&.. L~I&.!_",,_ ',~_.k2L~
I
.._.____,__ ,----._____ jf)DIlI!1L..Jdt/J ls__:~.L/"If.B.i:&1..~~..._+..t.-, "'-1::1.0....0
I I
Svf! {)LWl~f.Mt2 I3~M fft;.fe. : 1
. I I
.___,____ ___" __.____._t.rd~:..A_'_~~_.lfjVLL____._____.. I . ,.;i..,--'f....D.i,e..~
----...- .,SfLIP_~'j.jlJ1Lf)...w_L@'f,.IbJ)/'9_/VIe. -. " i
I
_._,..._ _'_H' ",.,~(}(!i::~__.b&,S.v..6~I'l}LV.~L,. 0 I
_fItLQ9ILtt7lf2t+, ,TbTA-Li ..~
! $17'1>J:,71
I
.1>. 't;.9-QQ :.?~ .
I
I
,
,
I
I
I
I
I
n_..__..'_'______ .. _ I ~^
I
I
-....-- - ...,
~7 ~'t :79
mnJ cy01t
INVCG-750-2
PRINTED IN U.S.A.
. ~~
,."..._...J;,f}.}_~tLJ1!,L.1.3LlLf'O'lI.. fJ d,II/L .
BL~L ,PILLa lJ)"t:-/kc-K
., ,$:2~-Q'i----$SIJQDl.:::
I
I
. ----I'
I
I
- '--'1
I
I
.1
I
I
I
IR:ed'~;;r;.;J
,
..,- I.
I
,
--- 1800, oc;~w;s~e.*u...wO;::Cas.r ""
,.. .... '$ . {1J:"::Wo.su-Rsr f1ilJ..(lr~v..Jf.:-ih
*
llE{lNER'.
-,' ,
MYERS ELECTRIC
67 Sherwood Circle
ENOlA, PA 17025
(717) 732-e980
Ucensed - Insured
INVOICE
DATE:
_._____>._.__________..u__.~_______~.__.._._._._.______ . .__..._...~._.__________._____.__.,__________.______
CUST.OROERNO. DATESHIPPEO SHIPPED VIA
TERMS
SAlESMAN
F.O.B.
OUR ORDER NO.
fttc. E J------- ---------L :3 Q.
I I
I I
".___._________ ___ _____._______.... __..._._....___...___.___.______+__________,_._____.....,._"..._____.._...,. _._,. __ ...._.... _..1___- _._ _".___~_._"."____.'".._"__I __..
I I
-----.-- J1uJ~.l___J}.IJ:JjL-Ll't--.-.-,-- -...--~..---.----.---L-
eA:'" I I
, JON e S I I
_ ___..__, __... , __ #' ___. ._._L _,_ ________,..J_
_______. ______.._'_ .1.fHv l /2OY...uL.Lio!....IJ.!..t.~~~. ]_~.Qtf.__~_. .::-('t~QQ..i 0.0
.____.__ _____ .__.______ EJUfi1. j?.Il'l.fVJ~l1Lr--f.fft€"'K -#- 7~ J D L ___ ~t'fi?Oq lO1J
I I
I I
,
, .-----.---'.--T--.-
W-JJ-:.J.O
.. -C.____ I9 Ttt L
BI/-LI1NCe
__..__ _BI:tL_~L.L1 u e
I
I
.'".., -----'",_.
I
I
--------------.---1---.."
To
is
,
I
I
,
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
___UI'"
I
I
I...
I
I
$.133/
mnJ. cyme
I
I
I
I
I
I
, ,
I
I
.~
:00
INVCC.7SQ-2
PRINTED IN U.S.A.
*
REC(NER'~
-"'
.,"".,.
-
VERIFICATION
I, the undersigned, Chris Jones, Defendant and principal ofC. Jones Construction,
Defendant herein, hereby affirm that the facts contained in the foregoing Answer and New
Matter are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. This statement
is made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to
authorities.
Date: 4-1' ~ rJ (/
r~ -t~~
Chri ones, Defendant
~ ?_~. ''''',. -', - I,:?S" ,~;':--;: ~ .-
,< -"~-;"'--~~,"-'" ",'
~--" -
- ~---".,.-
..,
.",
1"'-" . -...;,,<-.--
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO, 2000-1391
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
CHRIS JONES, an individual,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Jana C. Butler, Esquire, hereby certifY that on the 13 Uv day of April, 2000, I
served a true and correct copy of the foregoing Answer and New Matter by depositing same in
the United States Mail, postage prepaid in Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed as follows:
Deanna Smith, Esquire
76 Greenmont Drive
Enola, P A 17025
500 North Third Street
P.O. Box 1004
Harrisburg, P A 17108
(717) 236-1485
. , ". --- _~: _":_c'.I_" ,-
'...",'.."
,"-
~_~~"_' .~__'C__~ _ ___'_, ,.'"- - _""_.'-
1.
-""
, -=- -
^ ~ ~-~
~,
~~
p r:-:-, {~)
c=) - "
,~
C ,'"7'> --,-,
, "
, I
,
"V
" I
, ,';) ,\,
-- ^, :.r.7
-;: (,0 .......;::
,
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC
Plaintiff,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
v.
No.: 2000-1391
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
Chris Jones, an individual
Defendant.
PLAINTIFF'S ANSWER TO DEFENDANT'S NEW MATTER
AND NOW COMES, Plaintiff, by and through his counsel, and
files this Answer to Defendant's New Matter, and in support
thereof, avers the following:
44. This is a conclusion of law to which no response is
required. To the extent a response is required, it is here
by Denied and strict proof of same is required at time of
trial.
45. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that the
jobs ended in the Spring of 1999, it is denied that the
exact dates cannot be ascertained by the defendant.
46. Denied. In the presence of two witnesses, Plaintiff told
defendant that he charged by the opening. At no time did
Plaintiff agree to do the job for $5,500.00.
47. Denied. Said conversation never took place.
48. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that
Plaintiff sent an invoice to the defendant, it is denied
that said invoice was labeled as final or in any way
represented a final billing.
I ~,
"~=
"<_Fl!
.
49. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that
Plaintiff presented defendant with an invoice, it is denied
that defendant Rrelied" upon any such invoice. At no time
did Plaintiff lead defendant to believe that said invoice
was a final billing.
50. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that
Plaintiff received $4,500.00, it is denied that Plaintiff
had knowledge of the transaction prior to defendant issuing
the check to Porro
51. Denied. The breakdown by defendant does not relate to the
invoices and payments.
52. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted only that
an invoice was submitted. It is denied the amount was in
excess of the estimate. By way of further response, the
estimate was based on the number of openings.
53. Denied. The numbers provided by defendant do not relate to
the invoices and payments.
54. Denied. By way of further response, defendant incorrectly
counted the openings, for example, three switches equaled
three openings, a fan and light combination equaled two
openings; there were light openings, appliance openings,
attic openings, basement openings, cable openings, phone
openings, as such, defendant incorrectly counted openings.
"""'ll'_""",_
I ~
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests that this
Honorable Court award to Plaintiff actual damages of $3.417.09,
award punitive damaaes in an amount not less than $10,000.00,
plus attorney fees as well as any other relief that this
Honorable Court deems just and proper.
Dated:
5/3/00
Respectfully submitted,
ey !1PJl
Deanna Ly';nSmith'
Attorney for Plaintiff
ID#77414
76 Greenmont Drive
Enola, Pennsylvania 17025
Telephone 717-732-3750
IY'-
-
"~~
VERIFICATION
I hereby verifY that the statements contained in the foregoing document are true and
correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false statements
herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. ~4904, relating to unsworn falsification to
authorities.
Dated: tj-'J.-OO
By: -m.u~ a. ~~
-",~""'.,",~
~,'
.
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC
Plaintiff,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
v.
No.:2000-1391
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
Chris Jones, an individual
Defendant.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I served a true and correct copy of
the foregoing upon attorney for defendant, via United States
Mail, First Class, postage prepaid, at the following address:
JANA C. BUTLER
BUTLER LAW FIRM
500 North Third Street
12th Floor
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Dated:
5/3/00
By: Deanna Lynn Smith
0"_
~
,<,.
~,~ _IT
-
"W"~,",,.I'ffiIllI,.., -1~JIIJ,~._
o
r-
"'D::''2
fil~:
If,~~
~l5
€(c;
~(::
:>-
~
'7' __""'~ ., ,<, RTT, MM'l;~;1'f~;llj;J~~,*,~ ij;m ~~'f
.
<:::>
c..,
:::I!:
"""
'-<:
I
c.v
p
,}
:::0
,.,
-1-
;"'/'7:JJ
...,-,.J;;
i,g(? ,
~~
:;:'-:n
~!! C)
c'5rtJ
$
-<;
~.t.
~
-
.r;-.
"' ,~_~fiIJ:,fifJl!'lfflillilffl~N_"
~_~.I!IlD!
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC,
Plaintiff
v.
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
CHRIS JONES, an individual,
Defendants
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL V ANlA
NO. 2000-1391
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRAECIPE
Please enter my appearance as co-counsel for Chris Jones Construction and Chris Jones,
an individual, in the above captioned matter.
'?CO,""'"''
- ,-_.-~, "-~:;':'_~'_I~,':_~'_< :-~ --, ._:'.'--c-." , , , .',- ~'-"-'
;,,_,0,
~t.
Robert B. Lieberman, Esquire
Co-Counsel for Defendants
1.0.#07089
500 North Third Street, lib Floor
P.O. Box 1004
Harrisburg, P A 17108
(717) 236-1485
,
;,---,"--_ .,- _~- 0';;'/' _,__, _~,
~- ." - -~ - . " ~- ,
(") co ()
. c: CJ -n
-..;{
g ~ "
-UO) -,'1
rnfT; ~~\) .~
Z::c -~, 1 ,
;l: --~ \.:J
(./) ~cc C'.D -}~?
-<L_
~c; ~ ;--,-
).>.,--, ..,J..',. , (')
2:<
p.L' 0.) -'--", I' 1 .~
C ::~
:z L,,) 55
-.-!
-< (,.:t -<
<,-'",-~.~, -
--",
,-~
'",
"
11'11
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC,
Plaintiff
v.
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
CHRIS JONES, an individual,
Defendants
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO, 2000-1391
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PRAECIPE
Please withdraw my appearance as attorney for Chris Jones Construction and Chris
Jones, an individual.
!~,':9"""-'- , "-
"",,,"_,7_',,1_'-'-_< ~.~----- ~-:-," .,--.. -<--~-~"
~~
,/fana C. But! ,Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
1.D. #80574
500 North Third Street
P.O. Box 1004
Harrisburg,PA 17108
(717) 236-1485
, -~
" --' -,., ,-' ~, "
~" - .
0 C)
C c:;
~~~: -
-eJeL "3.
tTif::,
Z:-:c-'
Z,.
S?,~L en
r:;:.c.-; .'tJ
"-
~C) _.'J:.. '.~
=:: f'-j r..:? C'i
>c --.!
~ '"""
:::> ~,;
-l =<:
,
"
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
: NO. 2000-1391
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
CHRIS JONES,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
DISMISSAL WITH PREJUDICE
TO: THE PROTHONOTARY OF SAID COURT:
AND NOW, comes Defendant, by and through its counsel, and files this Dismissal with
Prejudice as the parties have amicably settled this dispute. Please mark the record in the above-
captioned matter closed.
Respectfully submitted,
Dated:
December 14. 2000
~6.~
Robert B. Lieberman, Esquire
.500 N. Third Street, 12th Floor
P.O. Box 1004
Harrisburg, PA 17108-1004
(717) 236-1485
Attorney for Defendants
?p<!J'- -
'''-'''_:'~-,__I - _o_~;_"_"____, ,',-,"<Y. -^-. .: ,,,-=,,,1,',,::, ,'-_~__:'~ _,_,'''___ '",
"<"'-,..-
,
.
\
, .
MICHAEL MYERS ELECTRIC,
Plaintiff
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
v.
: NO. 2000-1391
CHRIS JONES CONSTRUCTION and
CHRIS JONES,
Defendants
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing was sent, via first class mail,
to plaintiffs attorney at the following address:
Deanna Lynn Smith
76 Greenmont Drive
Enola, P A 17025
Dated:
December 15. 2000
~.B,~
Robert B. Lieberman, Esquire
500 N. Third Street, 12th Floor
P.O. Box 1004
Harrisburg, P A 171 08-1 004
(717) 236-1485
Attorney for Defendants
',<w..,
., ~~'5.I'?"""'_ :'_ ~ .0,_ ~" .
, -, --,_., ' .-,- -.. , ,~ - .'~rc
'--'-,'
.
d
o
c:
<'
-uf."~;
Qli+1
Z::r,
Z[H
~i;~:.
...-'-j
p,-..
?;>-)
Pc
Z
:3
,
- -.-~ -
I
.
C)
c:>
U
,"'I
~:-")
co
L
',.J
:'?
:_~ ~ ~~~
..-.,'"
~,
~~
.J:!
~~
w
'"
t'''"'
-