Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout00-02829 ....... .- , ~ .0 ......", " "'1" NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLV ANIA VS. CIVIL ACTION - LAW HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS Defendant : NO. 2000 - 2829 CIVIL TERM NOTICE TO DEFEND You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LA WYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Cumberland County Bar Association 2 Liberty Avenue Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 249-3166 / / ,~ -. -'r;(.- NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYL VANIA vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS Defendant : NO. 2000 - 2829 CIVIL TERM COMPLAINT 1. The plaintiff is Nancy B. Laubach, an adult individual, who at all times relevant to this action, resided at 1465 Hillcrest Court, Apt. 608, Camp Hill, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17011. 2. The defendant is Henry Line, d/b/a! Line and Line Jewelers, an adult individual, who at all times relevant to this action, resided at 21 Dickinson Avenue, Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17013. 3. On or about July 14, 1999, plaintiff and defendant entered into a contract for consignment whereby plaintiff delivered a diamond ring to defendant and defendant agreed to sell the diamond ring. 4. The contract for consignment provided for the ring to be sold at retail by defendant for $3,000.00. Upon a sale being consummated, plaintiff would receive $2,000.00 and defendant would retain $1,000.00, a copy of said agreement is attached hereto as Exhibit "A", made a part hereof and incorporated into this complaint. 5. Said ring was a .50 ctw emerald cut with an appraised value of $2,975.00, said appraisal is attached hereto as Exhibit "B", made a part hereof and incorporated into this complaint. - .~ 1~'Lr.~" _.~ ~ ~~'""'-'-~ 6. Plaintiff contacted defendant numerous times from July 14, 1999 to February 21,2000 inquiring about the status of the consignment. 7. On or about February 21, 2000, plaintiff was advised that the ring was no longer in defendant's possession or control. 8. On or about March 2,2000, defendant advised plaintiff to contact Kathy Trollinger at James Line Jewelers, as defendant believed that she had possession ofthe ring. 9. Defendant owed a contractual duty to plaintiffto safeguard the consigned ring, not to lose or give it to another individual. 10. Defendant has breached his contractual duty to safeguard said consigned property. 11. As a result of defendant's breach of contract, plaintiff has suffered damages in the amount of $2,975.00, the appraised value of the ring. 12. Plaintiff has demanded payment of said damages, but defendant has refused to pay plaintiff said damages. In the alternative, plaintiff seeks the return of the ring. 13. In addition, plaintiff has incurred costs to pursue this matter at the District Justice level in the amount of$83.38. WHEREFORE, plaintiff requests: 1. Judgment against defendant in the amount of$3058.38 with interest on such amount as allowed by law from the date ofjudgrnent until paid; - . ~ '4<': ~~ , , ~.;. 2. In the alternative, plaintiff seeks the return of the ring; 3. Reasonable attorney's fees; 4. Such other and further relief as the court deems just and proper. Respectfully submitted, Date: 5'. 2- 2 - 0 0 !h.t, ac eline M. Verney, Esquire 167 44 S. Hanover Street Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 243-9190 Attorney for Plaintiff - r."l$;'E " - ~' ~ "0" '1101111"" " VERIFICATION I verify that the statements made in the within Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C. S.A. 11 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Dated: S - 2- 2- - D 0 ~"~.~ " .,~:.~'":~~~~- - ~.,-,- ~. -"':--~-- .~"" I " ~ ~.~" nJ ~ 'Jjb, -- ~. 7172457269 p.e5 MRY-15-e0 03:32 PM NRTIONR~.RCCOUNTS. I l _. '- .--.~.......---~ - ~, '~.(.._=,.~.!...)~~. ~~ ""' . .. . K c~ ............ . "I v..~. _ _ ,J ~~ . EXHIBIT A ~ -" ~_ ...."',;,..1. _ :___'~~, ~~MAY';; i :S-00 ~ 0~: a>2 PM _.- .J, HAT 10HAL.. ACCO,UHTS.. 1'11'2451'26~ \ ..-";-,- " , ( (.:~" I" " , , " ,,-.- J , i.... j -)'1 \' . ( "- '-. ~ i I, ,~. ,. \. I(~ I\" " \ ,'i I( / ( -~ ,--, i( ("Cc I>{ ,\ ,~ .., . '/ c ( I',::" \"..) >\ r' "- , 'I , . It '~'~~', .' \( (' 1 I' < \,r'" ~. Ii I .... '~t'l' " ~ ! .' -, L' ,j ," ~: ! \ " ( \... ,_ .i }, l (' " V \. or '\ --'---';~'-'-I'-r'''''\ \ ' ( .' 1 ApPfatJal " '\ /', Musselman's JEWELERS ~58B Capital City Mall, Camp Rill, PA. 17011 tS~tl 'a tp ttrttry that _have Chladay of February 26.1999 CIiif\IUy CWIIlitfd tile follOwiq listed and deIcribcd articlel the property of - M Nancy Laul:);cb ~1465 Hil1erest et.. Camp Hill, PA. 17011 1h-. estimated replacement COlli are bued only on esdma. of the qudty of the stOMll (.... ~ stated URt the ltones weN nmoYeIJ sad paded) DESCRIFl'lON OF .unCLE VALUI One ladies dtamoftd ring. The diamond 1s a ISmerald cut measuring 6x4.5x2.9mm.The total weight of the diamond 18 .50etw. The stone is H in eolor and VVS2 in elarity. The stohe is set in a 14k yellow gold mounting. $2,975.00 One ladies ring. This i8 an Ital10 styled Cameo, Qonsisting of ~ed-Yhite~~lac~ <<tones Qatved into a Trojan's Head. This is set in a 10k yellOW gold mounting. $ 7(0 , " \. 1be fonaoiDs appni8al1l made and .-pled GpOD the expreta 1II'Idetltandln. Chat NO UABILlTY or eeapoaslbiBty is i80une4 by the BPI>>'*<< in rma 1lUIIe. .tgulb ~~ J. ~ AJ:1l1nrhnt' -, ' '- - j_,.~." /~<_/ t "C..>>:~~ "--/ J>,~J ~). (i.'v-(~~~. \..J '-'~.A.~./~'--<' c,:=.Ac-r" ,j,~ ') f, , -\ ,~./ 1.e," . uB" Exhib~t P.04 I ,'I \1 I, ,\ , /, \ " '/\ \! ! ,I ...',./1 , \,:~,:, l- \ -,') , II ':')1 \,"- I ,. \i 'I "' , . )1 , 1 I ",I ) I ,< .' " \1 ! ')I , ','\: .1 ........ , , ~ ) ,) \ ~ \ I~ I. I ""\' , , /' " -' fj! !' " I, c, ) - I , I. , I,',\, , ...II, \;"' "'-. -' ...---'-. ,. i '), l ,~, ., v"~<)' , _ /,.- ":---'" \ ) '.,. i, !, \ - - ~~ . ~~. .' ~ lk~_ CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the foregoing Complaint was served on the following person by placing the same in first class US mail, postage prepaid on the date indicated: Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, P A 17013 Date: 5"- 2. 7--00 ~ .I que e M. Verney, Esquire #231 4 South Hanover Street Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 243-9190 Attorney for plaintiff < " ,... ~." ,'. " - ~, NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. HENRY LINE d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, Defendant CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 00-2829 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this 18th day of Ju~~, 2004, this hearing / Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire For Plaintiff shall be concluded at 9:00 a.m.,1U'esday, ~. the ~ J. \ Joseph B. Sobel, Esquire For Defendant ~ ~ (,.,)J'()</ 9-. Sheriff prs <I [n"<" < , '"., -~" '0" ,~ nLED-O',:F\CE OF 1\1E PHCHHON01N?i"f ~~r: ",,, ",., ~ulJll JUi; t..:; PH 2~ 53 Cu(,.,jr.~<:,:' ,'~'y.,i'~i.~j c:u\J(<~TY \)iE.\\ii:<t2NUJNY:-,\p\ ., --~ ~1.l,-" ~:-"~_.""",,,h ",.,~_ rr._._ , .Illl . . =, ~ -^-~". .~~-"''''. ,,,_'~J~~,., - ,:"!fII!I!IllB.1! - . lOolIiI~"~- -._........."" ,~- JJ.0.- YlMUj tJ r2fw~ ~ k c//)/A- ~L~'~~ In The Court of Co~on Pleas of ) ) 1 ) ) ) ) Cumberland County, Pennsylvania ~o. 2.62,..9 - ~060 Jil!l OATH We do solemnly swear (or affirm) the Constitution of the United States w~alth and that we will discharge the that we will support, obey and defend and the Constitutio~ of this Common- duties ~ our office wit ide~ity. ( ~~~ ~ AWARD We, the undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn (or affirmed), make the following award: (Note: If damages for delay are awarqed, they shall be separately stated.) 1))1 ~AA'J he f~ f I~i{.h ~'am~ t,/::tO_fJilL /~ pffM ~ed J- _~_ 2.,2000, . Arbitrator, dissents. (Insert name if applicable. ) Date of Hearing: /) ~ 2tfo D Date of Award: 11.&u '2-ooct NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD Now, the I ~y ofb~~ , -JOCO, at rZJ;2., E..a., the above award was entered upon the docket and notice thereof given by mail to the parties or their attorneys. . ~ Arbitrators' compensation to b~ ~ paid upon appeal: $ ::J:/I), "0 --,--',--,,'"__""___-"'_,,'~MiilirIlM,I"...""-,.., !~~~m'~;<i';j~~,'H'"",~I"''''''~.iii:!!I;m..iii;jl;:tufullii~~."''';li~~_~~t.".OiJ"~~lI~ fl""~~~~~1llll Cc'r ~ - C {J , ~ILL rtl2 ;LLcC ~c~Glel'l'\e M, V><-r'i'Qy 18.- (\-00 - ?~~lly c;;::,o~ 0o~;j Qli 0 ~ ~ -J:'::xL ' fYl~L Wd~ - ~cL rLB~ [:vn ~'-I - ~s-I~~c~VL- ~ f+;;scX-(d'C~ ~ (k, A ~ //31/0f - -, ioi!il~iIiii1II '-"~"'- . (') c:;:. 0 ~ 0 "'f:'~ D "'00;; 1'1 mm c-) ~ Z::n ZS; , U> . ~~:2;.:Q -<Z ~2:~ kC) .." ;p ~C-T. ZD :4:: ():D 0 "':.a-(j ~c: r;::> On"l ~ --I ,-:." $5 (.:J --< . .. ~ . "~',-,,-,'~'~~- h -"-~"~_ =>~,~~-'>,_ -"~_ ~, _<."__~_~ , .~ 0'" . - Taryn N. Dixon Court Administrator OFFICE OF THE COURT ADMINISTRATOR CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS 1 Courthouse Square' Carlisle, PA 17013 Phone Melissa H. Calvanelli (717) 240-6200 Assistant Court Administrator (717) 697-0371 (717) 532-7286 (717) 240-6460 FAX MEMORANDUM TO: 6J The Honorable J< :"j I, A T1: is E%..< P::" &yl~ 'f FROM: Melissa H. Calvanelli, Assistant Court Administrator I ~ ~ i% . ;t -\' DATE: May 28, 2004 INRE: 00-2829 Civil Action - Law ~ ~- :;, {, Nancy B. Laubach v. ! ! t i i I I ! . , [ I i i Henry Line, d/b/a Line & Line Jewelers The above case is assigned to you for a non-jury trial. Please provide me with copies of your scheduling orders and final disposition date so that I can monitor the case for statistical purposes. Attachment 4. \-\es<;, ~s C- (0",.1;1'<<0.( ~.. - - -.. ~" L -- ~ . "'......'h f __ \p PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL MAY 2 4 ZO04,t (Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate) TO THE PROTHONJTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY ...... = = J:" r(; --1 :J: -rl rt'I- r -om ~6 ~-ri o:D ZC") OITI """I J> :~ o c <' ~nw ~ [fir'" :>:>- ~5= ~ for JURY trial at the next term of civil ~t. c- >~_\ -0 ;2'\..'- :::z: """:{c':.J ~ f',..) -::;:;-- -------------------------------------~-~ CAPTION OF CASE N (entire caption must be stated in full) (check one) Please list the following case: (Check one) x for trial without a jury. (X) Civil Action - Law Appeal from Arbitration NANCY B. LAUBACH, (other) (Plaintiff) I , vs. HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, The trial list will be called on 6/15/04 and Trials comnence on 7/12/04 (Defendant) Pretrials will be held on 6/23/04 (Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials. ) vs. (The party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.) No. 2829 Civil 2000 Xi9- Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire, 44 S. Hanover St., Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-9190 Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: Joseph B. Sobel. Esquire 212 N. Third St., Suite 202 Cranberry Ct. Harrisburg, PA 17101-1505 (717) 234-2200 This case is ready for trial. Signed: }<-J ~.~ 4" t1~ Print Name: JacquelineM. Verney, Esquire Date: May 24, 2004 Attorney for: Plaintiff - ~ ~ - 1i1. .l::,!(:~ ! "'" ColIl'MONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM JUDICIAL DISTRICT DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT COMMON PLEAS No. CO -,;; '6'.;) '1 ~ NOTICE OF APPEAL Notice is given that the appellant has filed in the above Caurt af Camman Pleas an appeal fram the judgment rendered by the District Justice an the dale and in the case mentianed belaw. NAME Of APf'ElLANT MAG. OISt NQ OR NAME OF OJ. LINE AND LINE JEWKLjml)/HENRY LINE ADDRESSOFAPl'ElLANT 'C/O IRWIN McKNIGHT & HUGHES 60 WEST POMFRET STREET DA.TE OF.R.I>GMENT IN THE CASE OF (Plaintiff) OTY x)(xix)x 09-2-01 STA" ZlPCODE CARLISLE PA 17013 (Defendant) APRIL 7, 2000 QAJM NO. NANCY B. LAUBACH AND LINE JEWEJ.ERS/IlENR.Y LINE ATTORNEY OR AGENT CV ~ 0000089-00 LT 19 This black will be signed ONLY when this natatian is required under Pc. R.cP J,P. No. 10088. This Nati~ af. Appeal, when received by the District Justice, will aperale as a SUPERSEDEAS to the judgment far passessian in this case. Signature of Prothonotary or Deputy ~MARK D. SCHWARTZ, ESQ. If appellant was CLAIMANT (see Pa. R.C.P.J.P. No. 1001(6) in action before District Justice, he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after filing his NOTICE of APPEAL. PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE (This section of foon to be used ONLY when appelfant was DEFENDANT (see Pa, R.C.P.J.P, No. 1001 (7) in action before District Justice, IF NOT USED, detach from copy of notice of appeal to be served upon appelfee), PRAECIPE: To Prathanatary Enter rule upan NANCY B. LAUBACH (Cammon Pleas No. [)() - .;1.&;).9 6:J , appellee(s), to file 0 camplaint in,tills appeal Name of appeJJee(s) RULE: To NANCY R. T.AlTRArn Name of appelloe(s) . appellee(s). (1) You (Ire natified that a rule is hereby entered upan you to file a complaint in this appeal within twenty (20) clays after the dale of service of this rule upan you by persanal service ar by certified ar registered ,maiL (2) If you do nat file a complaint within this time, a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. (3) The date of service of this rule if service was by mail is the dale of mailing. Date: ~ 5. ,r.~. < ,-"./ Q,~ ~/4"tA K ~ ~~y",DepuIy POPe 312-84 COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY "'imi_.~""",i{';'i:;,<<f-~'J:l'-'''1fHi~~WIl!i~~~ill~,*M~",j,,"I'oiP.I~;t;jj~~~t:1llIl.'li'1.1iiiilill1\iJ~~~~!g.;j;il.tU!I(~~!!W.N....~_~~;-fMlI "'.". .~~ "' ~"' "1 ...- , ..." PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FilE COMPLAINT (This proof of service MUST BE FILED WITHIN TEN (10) DA YS AFTER filing the notice 01 appeal, Check applicable boxes) COMMONWEALTH OF PENIIlSYLVAIIlIA COUNTY Of ;" AFfiDAVIT: I hereby swear or affirm that I served o a copy of the Notice 01 A~peal, Common Pleas 1>10, , upon the District Justice designated therein on (date of service) 0 by personal service 0 by (certified) (registered) mail, sender's receipt attached nereto, and upon the appellee, (name) , on _.__ , 19_~ 0 by personal service 0 by (certified) (registered) mail, sender's receipt attached hereto, o and further that I served the Rule to File a Complaint accompanying the above Notice of Appeal upon the appellee(s) to whom the Rule was addressed on , 19_ 0 by personal service 0 by (certified) (registered) mail, sHnder's receipt attached hereto, SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS DAY Of' ,19~_ Signature 01 alliant Signature of official before whom affidavit was mads Tit/a of official My commission expires on , 19--.. (') 0 :'0 c: 0 ." l s:: :x .-l ~ "Urn J:>> :J:;n mf'rt 2::0 -< mFn z~ I -0 t. ~- U1 ~~ ~ ~CJ -0 -'-:l:I ~O :x 9-~ -0 :;! )>c: - ~ .. ~ Ul 55 ) 0'\ .-< !III, -" ~ ~ ~i~~niil'l;i -, r "':tJJ~JJILb...lirl!fel~~""""'~." ul 1'1' .-';- - ~-""''I'''~'~ -11 ~fl'il:cl!llitl!!!l@IiI!lM.~~illi!:I'~',_ "". ~ '-li'l \ ~ --.?!'~.. MMONWEAL.TH OF PENNSYLVANIA . \ \$;OUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND '"S: ~. Mag. Dist.,No.: -" .' , i! .. NOTICE OF JUDGMENTITRANSC.RtPT .' . CIVIL CASE '.'..~ ' PLAINTIFF: NAME and ADDRESS ~. IJ..AUBACH, NANCY B I 1465 HILLCREST CT APT.# 608 CAMP HILL, PA 17011 L ~ . '<<- 09-2-01 DJ Name: ,Hon. PAUI,A, P. CORREAL Addm", BAS'!' WING - COURTHOUSE" 1 COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE,.PA T"'ph,""(717) 240,6564 17013-0000 VS. ATTORNEY D~F PRIVATE : MARK SCHWARTZ 60 W.POMFRET ST CARLISLE, PA 17013 DEFENDANT: NAME and ADDRESS 'LINE AND LINE JEWELERS HEl</RY LINE 21'DICKINSON AVE ~LISLE, PA 17013 Docket No,: CV- 0000089 - 00 Date Filed: 3/02/00 I -.J ",.. F;tt THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT: Judgment: [iJ Judgment was entered for: FOR.. . PLAINTIFF (Name) T.lITn:lllr.", lITlIlITr.V R [iJ Judgment was entered against: (Name) T.TlITF. urn T.TlITF. ,TRWRT,R1HI in the amount of $ ? OA~ ~A on: (Date of Judgment) 4/07/00 o Defendants are jointly and severally liable, o Damages will be assessed on: (Date & Time) O Amount of Judgment Subject to Attachment/Act 5 of 1996 $ $ 2.00Q~:OO $ 83.38 $ .00 $ .00 $ ~~ 083 .3,8 , ." ;'."')" ,,' \ lliU;""-j$,;%,1.Ail,41i'ii,(;..1./:;,\:..il i /;j!. ,; :. ,i":t'~'~l'_U:4~lf1IJFI~I&~~~}" H~_ i j lJ'V~-\_:_ Post JYdg~ent Costs".! '$' ',:' r" Amount of Judgment Judgment Costs Interest on Judgment Attorney Fees Total o This case dismissed without prejudice, o o Levy IS stayed for days or 0 generally stayed. ------------ ------------ , Certified Judgment Total $ Objection to levy has been filed and hearing wili be held: Dafe: ---- .~-.'~ "...- . - "'- , .. ~_... ,..~. Place: -,. ._H " -~-- - ~'-:'.- ~' -~ ...- .. .~ ,- Time: . \ , ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY Of JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE OF APPEAL WITH THE P'0THONOT RYI~cL~.... F T~g~SclURT OF lfMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION, YOU. MUS. T.IN...CLUOE A. CO~/ OF. THIS. OTICt. :O.\J.UG~~'AN.SCRI ;lORM WITH YOUR NOTICE OF APPE.AL. , . .... 4'7.::o0~: Da:'~,';' 7.\< :',' .' ~L "'~ '. , District Justice ~~- - ,">,",,,,,~,; , Iqertify thAtthil;is<y1we ,AI) 4.,..7-00 Dat i~rreqttpYqft6~Jd~the pr.;;dings containing the jU,dgment. , ) L ..J2. (_~~~-':v.'v" , District Justice '''''''~~,,~,- My commission expires first Monday of January, ',,;.>,,2006 AOPC 315-99 SEAL .'~ . ''-'.;''\" '"-~: " ,;. >,.' ~ '.-". ~. $<_ " -'-'-_ci';_' -' '~C+,,;, "'" --''c.-',,'.,'->, --,.'-j,c_'_ >OyO -""~:,-,,,...' 0"" '___,',",,;._ ._t_ 0'-,-".__;'" ,__,__ ",'';::'';''~_'-;'!T,>~~___: ;.... ,',_0,,"' _G'_''',,~;'; fj " ~ fl 1'-_1 ,,' " r< l, 1; " v. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW '~ NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, Defendant : NO. 2000-2829 CIVIL TERM i~ Ii L. 1\ '11 ] "1 NOTICE TO PLEAD !] I: I' :i ~ ~~ i~ ij 1\ r i I; I' I; Ii TO: NANCY B, LAUBACH YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED that you must responsively plead to the within Answer with New Matter to Plaintiff's Complaint, pursuant to Pa. R.C,P. 2252 (d) within twenty (20) days after service, or a default judgment may be entered against you, ~ 'II p ti ~ ., ~ " If :,l Attorney for Defendant, Henry Line ~l i i Ii , ! ~ f; ! ~ , ~ ~ . By: Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 717-249-2353 Supreme Court I.D. No. 70216 Dated: July 27, 2000 ",)-, <'"'~ ~,_~ ,',' . - -; , ~c-"_" 1_'''''_ --', - '.-'",'y'~ - _ .,"- '"" --"_~'''''__ 1M '-,-,j ,-;.. < ",,,"_':.;';",--J" ,-.'- "".;,.~_ .-'.",,,, ;",",,,',,,8,,- u,~___ -.-~,.~- ,,____-_""''''',__~>' ,,;-:-,. .'"~'~-.,,,,- -~J., v. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW "'il'.. ., Ii, ~~'I I, I\i II' U ii.l. ii .~ I, r~ Ii."..', ~ ri I: .~ i:l m 11 ~ ~~ iii' r, :~' i!~ ~ I 'I [Ii. il II I i NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, Defendant : NO. 2000-2829 CIVIL TERM ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER 1, Admitted. 2. Admitted. 3. Denied as stated, By way of further answer, Defendant Henry Line is aware of certain documentation which indicates a "consignment agreement". Defendant Line has no personal knowledge of the agreement nor did he ever see the ring in question, 4. Denied as stated. By way of further answer, Exhibit "A" speaks for itself. Defendant Line did not authorize or participate in the formation of the "consignment agreement". 5. Denied as stated. By way of further answer, the actual value of the diamond at issue is well below the attached "appraised value". 6. Defendant is without sufficient knowledge to form a belief about the truth or falsity of this allegation and strict proof is therefor demanded. 7, Denied as stated. By way of further answer, Defendant informed Plaintiff that they could not locate the ring in question on that date. 8. Admitted. ';"-"" ,,,-. ,,- ^' ". . -'" " ~-~ ""1""'--'" -"'----""'~<"';- "--"".~ '" -- ,,-. -.' _ . , - _ -.""~ ~" '-0 ;,.1,', M .",<:-.0'--"__ '" ; <__-w.~_"-_ ""-"'''''"''''",'~U~'r'-'-'''C-''';---- 9. This allegation is a conclusion of law to which no response is required. To the extent that an answer is deemed necessary this allegation is specifically denied. 10. This allegation is a conclusion of law to which no response is required, To the extent that an answer is deemed necessary this allegation is specifically denied, 11. Denied. 12. Denied, Defendant has offered to replace the diamond with a replacement of equal or greater value. Plaintiff has refused this offeL 13, Denied, WHEREFORE, the Defendant, Henry Line, d/b/a Line and Line Jewelers, respectfully request this Honorable Court to enter judgment in its favor and against the Plaintiffs and dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint. NEW MATTER 14. All of the Defendant's responses in paragraphs one (1) through thirteen (13) hereinabove are incorporated herein by reference thereto, 15, Defendant Henry Line did not participate in nor authorize the formation of any contractual agreement with Defendant. 16. Under the "consignment agreement" alleged by Plaintiff, the amount Plaintiff was to receive upon a sale of$3,000.00 a payment of $2,000.00. 17. The "consignment agreement", does not provide for Plaintiff to receive any monies unless the diamond was sold. 18. Defendant Line has no personal knowledge of the existence of the diamond or the "consignment agreement". >10,,' , I.,....'... rr Ji It.'.. ~~ ~ it; I' ~,i ~J ~,i ~ I. i... ti: !1 ~ r;; ~ Ii Ii Wi ~, ~ ~i l;! Ii ~! ,~ f1 tl F.l ~ ~ " i - -,-" ~,~ - ,,~ ~"~...., _W'" u., -,,~ r." .,. '~"'~',.'<_~ ~ "_" _~ ,v' ~.~._~_.._ ~ _ ~~ ,_ 19, Plaintiff's intent was to sell the diamond ring through Defendant's business" 20, The diamond ring was not sold to the best of Defendant's knowledge and Defendant has reason to believe that said ring may have been stolen, 21, On account of being unable to locate the ring, Defendant will replace the ring and diamond with one of equal or greater, size, quality, color and value, WHEREFORE, the Defendant, Henry Line, d/b/a Line and Line Jewelers, respectfully request this Honorable Court to enter judgment in its favor and against the Plaintiffs and dismiss Plaintiff's Complaint. Respectfully submitted, By: Date: I /27 ~o~e Mar D. Schwartz, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 717-249-2353 Supreme Court lD. No: 70216 Attorney for the Defendant ''',-' " 'J}; ~ I~' I" !~ ~~ t ! !: N /, ~ ~ I:, f,; I' I ! !: Q ~""""" f Ii I i,!.,.,," " : \ Ii ! IT ~ , " , ~ I: ~ I' _c, ., ''> ,,~,,~-_. ~~,- :_,,,"''''~' . -' '_"io.'~~'.,,; '. ,_ - "' u,~ ~"" " . ,," ,o~_ "--..=_~"~_,_ o_-o.-,,_~"~, --,,,~--,,- . '-'-"'~V~_A~.<--~' ,,;-~~,~_-,*,_""_+ '-~-:-->"', ,>'-, ..~ 'j-,: Ii I' fu;: ;;i: b, I' I" I, Ii' II 1"..1 11 :11 '''' II ,! )i ," ,: , ) ii 1; 1..I,i ~i 1 NANCY B, LAUBACH, Plaintiff v. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, Defendant : NO. 2000-2829 CIVIL TERM VERIFICATION I, HENRY LINE, do hereby verify that the facts setforth in the foregoing pleadings are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C, S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. ~A Date: July 2. 7 , 2000 -.'""- ,'_ ~ .,',',- ',~'''",.."n,",-'c.'-'~''- .' "o,,-,_'~_"',_,_:.;;__.'" .'O_"",_",__~",",<"-.___,,,_ - ~_,_,,,,,,,",,v,,,,",e--<"'-'_""',~ h',E'-'~,.~ ,,-', ~",'-'" .- , NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff v. HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, Defendant Ii no P:: r? ~; 11.' ~i Ii ~] Jij f" Ii. ~: ';' ~1 ~] ~ Ii t! ~ M !i ii ~ II M ~ '~:I " , ~ ., I ! fj Ii !! ! Ii IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW : NO, 2000-2829 CIVIL TERM CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Mark D, Schwartz, do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the foregoing document upon the person, and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing the same with the United States Post Office in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, postage prepaid, certified, restricted delivery, and addressed as follows: Date: July 27,2000 Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 By: Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, PA 17013 717-249-2353 Supreme Court J.D. # 70216 Attorney for the Defendant, Henry Line - .';"'''''''- >, ',--,'~- ..~~ ~" , ~ (") r.':''i- \..i C ':'::-1 I ~: -0 , '",- - rn 2: "/" r ,~) ~) " - ~: -- ~ ,- - , '-- ....." c: ,- '-7 =< . -' "" JI " ~.I -- ~ .'_<lJl! '. < NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff VS. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLV ANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS Defendant : NO. 2000 - 2829 CIVIL TERM ANSWER TO NEW MATTER 14. Paragraph 14 requires no response. 15. Denied. By way of further answer, an agent with apparent authority to bind the defendant entered into a contractual relationship with plaintiff. 16. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that the consignment agreement provided that plaintiff was to receive $2,000.00 ifthe ring was sold. However, when plaintiff inquired about the status of the consignment, defendant advised that the ring was no longer in his possession. Plaintiff requested the return of the ring or the appraised value. 17. Denied. Defendant admits that the ring is no longer in his possession to sell. Plaintiff has demanded that the actual ring be returned or full value be provided. 18. Denied. An agent with apparent authority for defendant entered into the consignment agreement. 19. Admitted in part, denied in part. It is admitted that plaintiff s intention was to sell the ring on consignment with defendant's business. Defendant however, has not sold the ring, nor has he returned the ring to plaintiff. ,_....>n,. "M ~ . M "':"- 20. Denied. After reasonable investigation, plaintiff is without sufficient knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averment. 21. Denied. Paragraph 21 is in the nature of a settlement offer and no response is required. WHEREFORE, the Plaintiff respectfully requests that this Honorable Court enter judgment in favor of Plaintiff. Respectfully submitted, Date: 9 / 1110 CJ ~k.L. cqu ine M. Verney, Esquire 6 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 717243-9190 Supreme Ct.1D. 23167 Attorney for Plaintiff '"-",..~""'"-~'~ -.- ~-.'" Illl!:!'-C VERIFICATION I verify that the statements made in the within Answer are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C. S.A. S 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities, Dated: "$/'U/oo A~~ (;3, ~ado~ Nanq B. Laubach ....' ---" ~~" ~ .",", - ' l'~' '1fr.,. NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,PENNSYLV ANIA VS. CIVIL ACTION - LAW HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS Defendant : NO. 2000 - 2829 CIVIL TERM CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire, do hereby certify that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the foregoing document upon the person, and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing the same with the United States Post Office in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, postage prepaid, and addressed as follows: Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, P A 17013 Respectfully submitted, Date: 1'(11(6-0 ~~,tI~ cqu 'ne M. Verney, Esquire #231676 44 S. Hanover Street Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 243-9190 Attorney for Plaintiff ,J ",' "" l:r, NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. 2000-2829 CNIL 19 HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, Defendant RULE 1312-1. PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire, counsel for the plaintiff/defendant in the above action (or actions), respectfully represents that: 1. The above-captioned action (or actions) is (are) at issue. 2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is $ 3.058.38 The counterclaim of the defendant in the action is 0 ,,/--'-.... Th~91toWi;;gattomeys are inlerest~rHI1 the case(S)' as cou;;;e~r are otherwise disqualified to sit as arbitrators: Jacqueline M. Verney, ES\;(Mark D. Schwartz, Esq.; Irwih,l1cKnight & Hughes "':::"-------..... _m _ / \, / ~ WHEREFORE;y;;ur petitiotier prays yourHOnQfll1:l~,eourt" to appoint three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted. Respectfully submitted, tl_ a AA, r;' Jacqueline M. ver~t167 ~ 44 S. Hanover St Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-9190 11-;;1. -00 ORDER OF COURT Esq., and actions) as p , }f;~, in consideration of the Esq., /Jztf:d'c & ~_ sq., are appointed arbitrators in the above capti ned action (or By the Court, , PJ. ill >- cc ~ '"'" t.uO &~~ ;.t:"r:' ~f G:-!-,~.' '~-, ",.co_'" ' r;':: " o o <:;:, C> <":> i=: ,5 0$ 0< Cl~ .::;:>OS=! :5~ 0:'-,. tLfJ'C;.. C1Jt:e ~ Q ESt -,.. O~ C") I "'"' a ~ J'- ~ f~ F1\_Et}-O\':F\CE C)'r,- ,~, '''T['R''{ ',' '-"'..' 1 J-li f:\';) ,\, " '" ,. /. 00 NOV -9 AH II: SO CUMBErV\ND COUNW PENNSYLVilNIA d IX) ,~ ~ '2 ~ = ~ a.. {) o k-) - I!!IlI'T~ _ _ ,_ T_~~_ ~ !1:g.lIlk~ ~"""'I"""'" ~ _ . , -- .~ _..0 '. ~ 0--- rr:J S2 ~~ \() c(} .2. "~ ~"-~~m~_""''''''''1'~_>;f'1i' _~,JI!f!1WF --"-, P.o''''- NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. 2000-2829 CIVIL TERM HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, : Defendant : NOTICE OF ARBITRATION HEARING The Board of Arbitrators appointed in the above captioned case, have fixed Monday, December 11,2000, at I :00 o'clock, P. M., in the Second Floor Hearing Room of the Old Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, as the time and place for the hearing. Anyone finding this time unsuitable will please make appropriate arrangements with all counsel involved for another time, including the scheduling of the Hearing Room. November 16,2000 cc: Mark E. Emery, Esquire 5115 Trindle Road Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 Arbitrator Julie A. McConahy, Esquire 2320 North Second Street Harrisburg, P A 17110 Arbitrator Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PAl 70 13 Attorney for Plaintiff Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, P A 17013 Attorney for Defendant Office of Court Administrator 1 Court House Square Carlisle, PA 17013 Bulletin Board .,-1 - '_"'o:,~__'_, v- ___ -', . ".' ~ , , Ii I' I' I!' i' " I:' NANCY B. LAUBACH Plaintiff/Appellee IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs. No. 2000-2829 " HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE & LINE JEWELERS, Defendant/Appellant ~CIPE TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Please enter my appearance as counsel for Appellant in the above-captioned matter. J~~, c!W JosepH B. Sobel Attorney for Appellant LD. No. 17715 P.O. Box 828 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0828 (717) 234-2200 ^I,- . ,,-,'- ~,,'-, --" --,- "," <: '",' -~ ' _"~ ,C < ';'~ "j 1 . " CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that on the 9th day of January, 2001, a true and correct copy of the foregoing Praecipe for Entry of Appearance was served upon Plaintiff by mailing same by United States mail, first class, postage pre-paid, to her attorney of record, and to counsel for Defendant, at the following addresses: JACQUELINE M VERNEY ESQUIRE 44 SOUTH HANOVER STREET CARLISLE PA 17013 MARK D SCHWARTZ ESQUIRE IRWIN MCKNIGHT & HUGHES WEST POMFRET PROFESSIONAL BUILDING 60 WEST POMFRET STREET CARLISLE PA 17013-3222 ~@()~, 8. Jv Josef]' B. Sobel Attorney for Defendant 1.D. No. 17715 P.O. Box 828 Harrisburg, PA 17108 (717) 234-2200 ".;:. " I~~_ . ,",,' '.r." ;,-,,,.-'-; ~ ,,"," ~ ,-' _,.' ", "'," -J ,"" ,,-, .. , !> !:-. I" I, 1,:- I' I' , NANCY B. LAUBACH Plaintiff/Appellee Ii': !\: ;., ~, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA , ;(, i" vs. No. 2000-2829 11, HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE & LINE JEWELERS, Defendant/Appellant J~a 8_ Joseph . obel Attorney for Appellant 1.0. No. 17715 ~ :1 'I ~~ ~:~ [1 L ~J I~ ",1 !j I I I " j 'I II ~~ ')1 '1 I II Iii ~ II Il ti , i1 !~ I i " " j I II I I I I I I I I I NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM AWARD OF BOAElD OF ARBITRATORS TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Notice is given that Defendant appeals from the award of the board of arbitrators entered in this case on December 11, 2000. A jury trial is demanded. I hereby certify that the compensation of the arbitrators has been paid. P.O. Box 828 Harrisburg, PA 17108-0828 (71 7) 234-2200 - ,. .....~,e:: PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate) TO THE POOTHONJTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY Please list the following case: (Check one) x for JURY trial at the next tenn of civil court. for trial without a jury. ----------------------------------------- CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) (check one) } Civil Action - Law x} Appeal from Arbitration ,,/1 ( (other) NANCY B. LAUBACH, (Plaintiff) vs. The trial list will be called on l'eb JZ, 20 2 and HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE & LINE JEWELERS, (Defendant) Trials commence on 11arch 11. 2002 . vs. Pretrials will be held on Feb 20, 2002 (Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials. ) (The party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.) No. 2000 Civil 2829 'i~ Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: Joseoh B. Sobel. Esauire This case is ready for trial. Signed: ~J;L< (/~ Print Name: Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire Date: ,- n -0 ^ Attorney for: Nancy B. Laubach, Plaintiff ~.~ ""_~ c , _.,,"""" .__ _ '.'~'. ..,,_ "'__,~" ",.. ., h_._ "' .,,,---_~;"'I-."' _,' ..,' ,.""_ ",.'"_ _~ _, '''~'_"' ,'~-C ,n"',,,",,,,,_, ' . l-llIii~~; " I' I, NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 1 , ! v. CIVIL ACTION - LAW HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, Defendant " : NO. 2000-2829 CIVIL TERM " ; f, I' i\: Respectfully Submitted, !j , II I' I i !1 1:1 )'j , [1 I), " l 1'1 F i' I [, H I rJ PRAECIPE TO WITHDRAW APPEARANCE To Curtis R. Long, Prothonotary: Please withdraw my appearance on behalf of the Defendant, Henry Line, d/b/a Line & Line Jewelers, in the above captioned case. Joseph Sobel, Esquire remains counsel of record for Defendant Henry Line, d/b/a Line and Line Jewelers. o.re. 'L (r1 ( b7- Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire Supreme Court J.D. No. 70216 West Pomfret Professional Building 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013-3222 (717) 249-2353 F" ,_c _"P~_' '" _C' . '-<,~"-... ____;"-.~"-<_ ,_,,'.' .,_", -,' _~~."~._-~C___",' ,- , N:_,_~.~, ,_ O^",,, ""'.' ;>( ....'-, '\,,' " M ! CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE f I, I,; Ii " I, Mark D. Schwartz, do hereby certii)' that I am this day serving a true and correct copy of the foregoing document upon the person, and in the manner indicated below, which service r ~'j ~, ,,; satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rilles of Civil Procedure, by depositing the same with the United States Post Office in Carlisle, Pennsylvania, postage prepaid, certified, restricted delivery, and addressed as follows: t': i". t " ( ~ Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, P A 17013 1'. ;;; ~, ~ I Joseph Sobel, Esquire 212 North Third Street Suite 202 - Cranberry Court Harrisburg, PA 17101-1505 " r: f;- T & HUGHES E ~ i r , f:. I I ~i I' I ;: I !, i I ~! By: Mark D. Schwartz, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, PA 17013 717-249-2353 Supreme Court J.D. # 70216 n.re.. z.-l n I D '-- -~..... 1I ,~;6-o 14. Nancy B. Laubach : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA V Henry Line d/b/a Line & Line Jewelers : NO. 00-2829 CNIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, February 12, 2002, counsel having failed to call the above case for trial, the case is stricken from the March 11, 2002 trial term. Counsel is directed to relist the case when ready. By the Court, /-4line M. Verney, Esquire For the Plaintiff ~ B. Sobel, Esquire ') For the Defendant Lr OJl.-N-OJ. Court Administrator ld ~"l~iIi!E!", PRAECIPE FOR LISTING CASE FOR TRIAL (Must be typewritten and submitted in duplicate) (Check one) for JURY trial at the next term of ~ < -rJi-1; m?7; Z-:'L' mS,~ -<" - ~C,I ";;;C~! 7' _~ civil ~t. z ~ ....., 0 = = ." .J:'" ::it :2 ;J:>. m~ -= N :86 .s:- ~-i. -v 0-'-' ~... 2'0 r:--? (3m -..; -"" u'! :u N -< TO THE POOTHONJTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY Please list the following case: x for trial without a jury. CAPTION OF CASE (entire caption must be stated in full) (check one) (X) Civil Action - Law Appeal from Arbitration NANCY B. LAUBACH, (other) (Plaintiff) vs. HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE AND LINE JEWELERS, The trial list will be called on 6/15/04 and Trials comrence on 7/ 12/04 ( Defendant) Pretrials will be held on 6/23/04 (Briefs are due 5 days before pretrials.) vs. (The party listing this case for trial shall provide forthwith a copy of the praecipe to all counsel, pursuant to local Rule 214.1.) No. 2829 Civil 2000 Xj& Indicate the attorney who will try case for the party who files this praecipe: Jacqueline M. Verney, Esquire, 44 S. Hanover St., Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-9190 Indicate trial counsel for other parties if known: Joseph B. Sobel. Esquire 212N. Third St., Suite 202 Cranberry Ct. Harrisburg, PA 17101-1505 (717) 234-2200 This case is ready for trial. Signed: ~ j ~.<-~ ft.t. t!~ Print Name: JacquelineM. Verney, Esquire Date: May 24, 2004 Attorney for: Plaintiff . L -'-~, , , '.',< ",_ . """,'P., -,,,-. <,-. _\C:{ 1 , NANCY B. LAUBACH, PLAINTIFF : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. HENRY LINE, d/b/a LINE & LINE JEWELERS, DEFENDANT : 00-2829 CIVIL TERM ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, this , ~rd-- day of June, 2004, IT IS ORDERED that a non-jury trial will be conducted in Courtroom Number 2, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle, Pennsylvania at 9:30 a.m., Friday, June 18,2004. BY~:IQ~~ Edgar B. Bayley, J. ~ueline M. Verney, Esquire For Plaintiff ~eph B. Sobel, Esquire For Defendant "7 01-,-03-0,) Court Administrator :sal I FILED-OfFiCE O~r 1'1-1:-" o;_~O"'UI~'lt \(jThq\f d:: III 1\ ,\'",'1,.- H ;" I zoot J' '" ~ J! u;c~-j PH 3: \ 2 CU(v\~;i'::-:...; "iL ;'.jJUr{f't 1""'I'dj\")"YI \Iii,;',' . l~_" l' ..."h j ,<if"''\. I I j ,I I Ii f-:e " " ~- U,," ~~"r<" ~~,fII5ff.~_ .~.' '" - IIIIi 'IJ:'_~"'l ." ,,",",~ u, .TIl/HMl!'l!ll'1"l1!l!lll!l!l!l ---,:y--'+~ j~,iU~LLb"__.c,,,,_jlii!llfliM<t j J1"~..ll '"--'"--~~'iI__~_~~"U~_, Appraisal Musselman's JEWELERS 3588 Capital City Mall, Camp Hill, PA. 17011 mIJis is tn tfrtify that we have this day of February 26,1999 carefully examined the following listed and described articles the property of - M Nancy Laubach , , Address 1465 Hillcrest Ct, Camp Hill, FA. 17011 These estimated replacement costs are based only on estimates of the quality of the stones (unless specifically stated that the stones were removed and graded) DESCRIPTION OF ARTICLE VALUE One ladies diamond ring. The diamond is a Emerald cut measuring 6x4.5x2.9mm. The total weight of the diamond is .50ctw. The stone is H in color and VVS2 in clarity. The stone is set in a 14k yellow gold mounting. $2,975.00 One ladies ring. This is an Italio styled Cameo, consisting of red-white-black stones carved into a Trojan's Head. This is set in a 10k yellow gold mounting. $ 275.00 PLAINTIFPS EXHIBIT The foregoing appraisal is made and accepted upon the express understanding that NO LIABILITY or responsibility is incurred by the appraiser in giving same. &igntll ~ ~ ~ Appraisal ;_v , ~l)'"'''-",!_"~~~:~~~.-:.-~,,,~, :ZJ8.'~ '''Jl,,;'rl;.,'~?IJ-i/' ,WI:~~l'\TW: ',,~iri;'-;m~~~" 1\p~ruisul ; " " . ,,~\~~,Ui.~'1~i.~_,;~,)lp;.,.:F.i_;j\:;'\,~S'.' ..,,_:'~J(..--, .1I,lB.,:. ,'\,,' '" _ '. "",,-: - , , .' _ ", ',_"" ',." ,,'~. "J;' ,_ >,'.,'.,_ -, '.':.-1,' "'.,', 'C'" "', "_' 1 -,''' ~, __ i., <>.'-. ",_,,,,, - - "" ,_' " , -.', '" '-,' - ',:_'":/.',:,<",:_>.,:'i;:::'.~:,,, -,:::" ">.' , ;.~:':' ,',_,~__,~'." -'. -', ',..'-, .i.' - , J:EWELE!R8 3588 Capital City Mall, Camp Hill, PA. 17011 '~~,itlt1ltJJ;!'n~rtif!l.that we bavethis j}ayo( " February, 26,1999 carefully e~ed the fon~wing~t~~ and describejl:iIrticies ihe property of - , . '~r .N~ ta:~bac.li';, \',; , .,' .~' tib.;,,;, " ' ,,'.. '. ,. ,; ..:"<i"'~~~~'l~'~~l~~;~t~f~tf~ll~llti'I,;".,',t~'^;~j~~;:';;';'~;T"" , . These esfimatedrepl3cerile~tc()stsllreb3se.~,9nlYOl).estimates of the quality of the stones ;(i1~~S'.~l'ecific,~statelJthai\the stones were~in~ved ~nd graded) t_ '_:t' , DI;;SClUf,l'ION OF ARTICLE VALUE y.. , " 017-e\laqle~ di!illlohd.tin~.. Thedi~mqhdi S,",'1i '". j;:llIera:l.'~ciutmea.l;tllcrH~g, 6,,4.5:it2.9mm..The.total . we:\:~litofth~;,<Ha:mQna' is ".50ct:w..The stonels H""" ili'cOl,',o,ra,"n,'dVVS2 in,'clar. it,Y', '"The ,$'*:'one fs' set, ina",14kyellOw, golqmounti'ng. $2,975.00 One, ladies ring. This is an Italio styled Cameo, consisting of red-white~black stones carved into a Trojan's Head. This is set in a 10k yellow gold mounting. $ 275.00 ^"i' '"':';,"'"',- '~,,,.,, , ' , '- ' '1;befjil1ig~jIlg 'aIlPI'~~~m~!ie;U#~c<:~pt~~p()tl;~~e~lIresSund~t:Standing ,that NO 'tIABILl'tYor ,resll~~sil'~iiS, 'illC,qtre.a:bythe JiPVl:l\iSIll"ili.'glying, ~<upe..,.,. ", .' <,' ',..., "~t!lrttb(~~~' .i\,PJttnisal - /~. ~J,~\7i:-,>)'~::,~;{;",,',i-~4o'>~1t,!H;,: /',;':21:f!,~~:~~\~I,ii;'.'; '\<" ,:':-:: ,.' "'i';'A1tV,;" .,' ..;,;';i,~ ,~':~,:K~~- c." ~-"4,,~-"'r...J:; ,..l f:'i,';,:~!.i\;{,,:,;,i"ilii~.#,j-b.l:>~""'''U1o.V:'';''-''"";'';''' ,. ^'i'i'. '-' ^,"~" ,.,~'w ~I I I I ''f I J , .~ "!j ~! ',:~ C,.' " ;;i "",' '''~'~'\~'''';'~'I'''''\''=';'1j:~'''11?{\!!I~''''''''_''O''''~''~'>~''''';;{''''"~$i!Ji~"~;rl!:',.,l'">il",~.,,"'''l't'!~tl:~,,~,,,:'!'\'h,)''~\'''''~'''':,~)"'W'~"'~~'-'--"-~~': , I i Appruisuli " ' . Mu sse I. lB,au' s JEWELERS 3588 Capital City Mall, Camp Hip.,--PA. 17011 , I , ,; ! OJ~t.shnlllittrtify that we have this cIa! of February 26,1999 carefully e~e4 the fOllowing listed and described articles the property Qf - M "'Na_c', Lau"bach, -,'" ;" ",~ \"'",, " ",,"',,, ' :, ~,"',,J';_':;,i~,,',!.dt'__,"." '~,',', ",' ,", ',' '''','':''''_,''''''',ii<i'~"',,W'M,'' ':,"~~',4 !'-',",~,,'~i!'~"'--', ; ,,'!,',<,",';""""', ~"",I!!;'''''''''' "~'.-, "_:'W~:3r4'l)'5'"'H'I\:!'l-c-r_~1:i-,'~~J.~'",''<K''''','>''''''}''''!''' ,,,-",,,..,,,,,,,,,:-,,,-, '"-,, - "J' ""'"'':''~';''' ", :", " ":',,---: -:' ,- " i _ _' , , " .c. , These ,espmated replacemell:t costs are based'Q!Ily 011 estimates of the quality Qf the stQnes , ,t -l,} - '~ ''', I J~~~~',!eci(i~'statell that\the stones were,remQved and graded) , , :J~ _ , I i I I 'I I , ,:'J j. ,.<; '"" ~" ,,~~ 'DESC8'IgTION OF ARTICLE VALUE .' r' One ladfElli! !5i!!imondring, The dhlllond is, a . ~llIeJ;'a~d6t/J: llIElllst/rlng6x4. 5x2.9mill. .The total weignJ:6fthedfamondts .SOotw.The stone is '. H incCllClr' artdVVS,2 in clarity. The stone is set in, i!l 14kyellow gold lIIountin~. $2,975.00 "1 q !:l ,1 I J I i ; )i ~r- J;; One ladies ring. This is an I,talio styled Cameo, consisting of red-white-blaek stones carved into a Trojan's Head. This is set in a 1 yellow gold mounting: $. 27-5.00 - ".,;,,-, ~- ,"'- l ''', ~-- 'i'-....;, I J , i ! I ~ , I ( TM fQregoing appraiSal is made ap(l' accepted uPQnthll expreso;understanding that NO LIABILITY Qr resPQnsibility, isiilcutred by the appraiSer in giving same. ~- "._'~''-..<" -,~'-, \ /1- ,I ,,', /\ / .1--"'<_}A,'~ ~~- "'~---' I 1 j I i ;1 :1 &igUtll Appruisul " . ' , ',,_'I; "J '__ . , , f i... " - ~-~._a"". '~' '! I i Ii I I , I "~'" ' : _~ ,,~ ". _"" -'0 '"----";',',-,:,,,, -.:" , :1lI;<::"<:::S:~," ,A","""",_ ,_' ,',,',,',",', he' '," ,,' ',:,r\1','.','""".,,' ~S __, "'" ,~~,~:;c, ,:.,.~ ~;.~~ik--' ~~,t~&"'('~ " "';)"/ ' ,,',"'/'7:" Phonel~~>'i~'~, W~~~i.l,ti5 DateBeR'." ""ft'IJ:I"'.',',' '. .~ ,I : - __'. ,- '; ~:, ~. - :"':_'- ,'_, __ -:' _: ' :' '_ 0_: _":'~,,,--'- --.-- ':c ':;_--- , : ~'" ,. 5"'C1V V 5 -C). -,"'~,',' .wlprR : j I ~ I () \'0 ~C'b '0 xv 1'<\ 'eiv ~ , , i i 0< ,Cioc,6c +-0 m~'9<t.,M~1 I, 400 ;00 +0,' '~"'t, PLAINTIFPS EXHIBIT i i.Rh ~ , ~ I,. ,'_~'__<.""_"''''l'="~''~''''''''H''''_'''''_~>''"~'''''-'''=''=~'"""-""",__,,, ,.. ._ ~, ~ ro S ~ Q) rJ) r./) ;j ~ ~"' ~, ~,' , ". ':C (ft\' ::E :i_ ("). CL _ 0)/ -::J 00....... cO '0'/11,''\1''\\ 1.....1. ~ ~ - <=> <<I" ::"l~ ,S-oS u . <<I~ -~ '5. c. '" S u '" u '". o ".,c. ,~~-. ~ ~ '0 ..,,, u~ .., . ..c:Wo<t; UQJ~ fll .. ,Q U . ~.-I.-I fll.-l.-l H..r-i ~r-1 ::r:::r: >, U m 0. ~ \D e fll'<;j< fll Z,.,U ~- --'~~~"'.~-'" - - -:: -:: - , - - - - - - - == ::: . . - - "': :::: -: - vl (II ~ '" .. .. o I" .. "L"'; .,..;i"'""-"'''--iM M ie "5'C\t0vilc~i~ ~~/t~" __,fJ/~7z./ -;:::. I f j If I /&/1 . oj 0 i-merc.{!C/i (C/'II tillS-v-- rt eCtO/? '0..,6 '/L( .J-Y;; 9mm 1'-/ Lf G-o/cll \J \ \, 0 IU C. 0 ~ ~ " J l\) \^('. -e 10 +- , J, 0 00,,0 C ,J c " A ,y'~~{ Ie Nf't-rucy .LCtLthC<.;Gh Jeb ~)\J\Je\cpl:: '0 ::t 1'0 ~\G-c..J<( +:-\' l ~ - ;;YS-71'75 I, ' "," . _~__c, o~~-'_ _'e.-__ " -" ,L;:,i" _ _ .' ~~, . , :i: I ~ I H I i I I i ""/ ' YJ3 I /CJco ,0 c I - , , PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT G e" ,f'l,' Arno, +'n~{~s,-+ Hx \ 0 W,y'n' \ ~ - ~~+ OCU'''Y10()~.s , 1 Ii I: I d;Ooc,OO ii - 3-5"10 i i ~ j I ~ I I i /) 000,00 I I #~]J-j-- l^jec1d~~ ~v.."-lJs ON C:OI\)S"~I\.l rn-eA.,-\ 0~e~, 100.00 +0 do+OJ<:'~f\J. i"'1cMe\.hOI0 li 1J~\){t c J'e 6 S )\J \J ~\c jO e '1: l'0 \0 l <\. c.\( +' \ \ .'(, Oy.l0 '1\X\ \ J~ I-Jd J ~ ?\ q -\- \ '6 Ky G- \0 ~(j (J #j;)(P ita, .JiC .t~. ./1\\' 1I-;'d'l -/j j,{) g . d. 6 Co Tw V S - \ F O.CcMon6S ~S006fOO ' '{Y\ou('),\-.o'6 (/; Q)0.06 C - I f+' O:G.mO()js OFfer ro r [j [16--00,00 ' ) '105100 -#1;;)9 ~ \P\ C,,'kIlU(Y\ \--\€ G~~ ,\ ~ k~\ B'tJo.<\\< two 3xs G:CA-~e A C\u~ ~ sCcfr,h~{~ i \ cJ- c.-e(ll,€,\ p-ec~\ 1~,oo \(0\.,\0.\ C~CAXl rZJ' S.. K 0.X)~a ;;)!i.' \J ~., ((OD{)~ wh-<?6,:\ I.Ll jV1yV\ -#l00 . 11/0\ q, )LfS. S6 I R 00 ~ \ CVJ(A';() ~~. Cl (( l,'00'60 \ 0 \1 ~a0\.f\6 w\'\\;"o,A ),4 \""lM $~7J"aBl ! 7 . .~ - , LAW OFfICE OF JACQUELINE M. VERNEY 44 SOUTH HANOVER STREET Carlisle, PA 17013 Invoice submitted to: Ms. Nancy Laubach Camp Hill PA 17011 June 18, 2004 In reference to: diamond ring Invoice #13892 05/19/00 Draft Complaint OS/22/00 Meet with client 07/03/00 Draft letter to Schwartz 07/06/00 Call from client 07/17/00 Draft 10 day Notice; draft letter to schwartz, Esq 09/11/00 Draft Answer; draft letter to Schwartz, Esq. 10/02/00 Draft letter to Schwartz, Esq. 11/02/00 Prepare and file Petition for appt of Arbitrators 11/16/00 Call to Eakin's Esq office Li >.-- ...r;'-',,fo Hrs/Rate Amount 1 .00 150.00/hr 150.00 0.30 150.00/hr 45.00 0.20 150.00/hr 30.00 0.20 150.00/hr 30.00 0.70 150.00/hr 105.00 0.70 150.00/hr 105.00 0.30 150.00/hr 45.00 0.50 150.00/hr 75.00 0.10 150.00/hr 15.00 PLAINTIFF'S EXHIBIT ~, , , Ms. Nancy Laubach 12/11/00 Arbitration 01/11/01 review corres; send to client 01/17/01 call from client 01/17/02 Prepare & file Praecipe to List case for Trial 02/07/02 Review corres from Sobel, esq; draft letter to Sobel, esq 02/12/02 Draft letter to Sobel, Esq; call to Trollier; meet w/ Trollier; meet w/ Det. Egolf 04/08/02 Answer Interrogatories and Production of Documents 04/23/02 Draft Production of Documents 06/27/02 Draft letter to Sobel, Esq; call to/from client 07/01/02 Draft letter to Sobel, Esq 08/05/02 Client conference 08/06/02 Prepare for and attend Plaintiff's Deposition in Harrisburg 05/07/03 Prepare for Deposition-1 .0; Deposition-1.0 Review file; prepare for and attend Deposition Hrs/Rate 1.70 150.00/hr 0.10 150.00/hr 0.10 150.00/hr 0.50 150.00/hr 0.70 150.00/hr 1.80 150.00/hr 2.00 150.00/hr 1.00 150.00/hr 0.50 150.00/hr 0.20 150.00/hr 0.50 150.00/hr 3.00 150.00/hr 2.00 150.00/hr 2.50 150.00/hr ,~ 1Il"'-J,l" Page 2 Amount 255.00 15.00 1 5.00 75.00 105.00 270.00 300.00 150.00 75.00 30.00 75.00 450.00 300.00 375.00 .~- - . Ms. Nancy Laubach 06/19/03 Review corres from Sobel, esq 12/04/03 Draft letter to Sobel, Esq 12/10/03 Review corres from Sobel, Esq 03/30/04 Draft letter to Sobel, Esq OS/24/04 Draft Praecipe to list for trial Draft Praecipe for listing case for trial 06/17/04 Review file; prepare for trial; meet w/ client For professional services rendered Additional charges: 11/03/00 Filing Fee 06/23/03 Transcript Total costs Total amount of this bill 08/09/00 Payment - thank you 10/05/00 Payment - thank you 12/06/00 Payment - thank you 01/10/01 Payment - thank you Total payments Balance due . ~,j Page 3 Hrs/Rate Amount -------- ------ 0.20 30.00 150.00/hr 0.20 30.00 150.00/hr 0.10 15.00 150.00/hr 0.10 15.00 150.00/hr 0.30 45.00 150.00/hr 0.20 30.00 150.00/hr 2.00 300.00 150.00/hr ------ ---------- 23.70 $3,555.00 15.00 96.60 $111.60 $3,666.60 ($135.00) ($35.00) ($60.00) ($85.00) ($315.00) $3,351.60 -------------- -------------- r:cJ-c: I I I ~LlyYl'vd ic* 6.4o"..,e:;' _II u/d'lfoL/_lpcZ,S D;u."",.J 1J...le.:j\-t Icolo e C \4 S\-';paS '/'('le\,,\O S3l.<(ct .:l1- vs: /- vs- I;;: s..).." G- S.r ? 6- SJ;? 6'S~ -;:::- Yd VS-:~ V~ , -I .r-;;2 S..L ~ ~Q... L 5::1/ ;;1 VS-\ \jS- I - '-------r-<--- - .Ir-__ -_"_. . - ~- .~ ." r~.~' . - -~ ~ ~. .~ - :--~.. """"-~".,,,~,,--,_.,- ,-- ~ . It . G'\C-lcle _-<IJ cc~-\- ?~{ C Cdct. \- . J- 4 . . .. ,. ..' .. ) 3,600 .3,300 /9SQ ,,,,-,! I ~'~"_': ex OLd LOs\-- C It-'b-kOler 'Sulci ,0 , vo S + -{.C- lcol:: Re~lk~.s C LCJ-kfller (01::>+ 7)(", t5 ;? 700, 33~~ --r .;:;lS-O 0 /0(/.0 5'0 L 0 j5Lj93.bO Jg. ;)74 33(00 ';),jyS.UJ (go LJOdO. :) 9-0 G," . . t.. 7/<<} . 4 . ~ i ! \&L/ 0 i I . :l ! gD,O '\ C(( Of,(L =# \7.u. 0\0 (\} ((eO€\Jec\ h-o(Y\ Oo.t-e. 'f'^ e "'0 So\.."<:e. \\J",-,,\\;:,e( O,0-()\C~", \J. H' 0.( L_ '^-'~\3111 color S-\oneS Sn:,'-Z~ 3~ ~ "" ~\o.rJ(); 1. .jL/ G I .;]3 I ,.7? C- ,70 /--1 -1.- !30f.l;f/tJ! ,:Yo if 5T~? rec~(' ,LIS- G SJ.-\ (\~ .d3 ~ VS -;) ell ,.'.I<:oLcC'\d .l G V~-J . ~~'r\6 ,20 G _ V $-;) . .S-;;.-F& 'Ii;:" J ~ f 1::;- ~/F19 ' Ii I /1Cuu/ IS' // S~-,;l . (1-1/--91 ~33 / /,oC J S7-:- / 0 S ~ /6 -9? rbo9'L/ i uN- /:Ot:. if 115-1 0; fj-/o-f'1 s-tL/9 I IfOkl //6- G 3I-/ . o ~/o.f1'1 .57,J 1j I /?cud ,S-3, G- 5.Z . '5'0 . kr f,?-?-9/ co-il.~j ''5Cf 'Jif;,; fei/)) ('::''':''''2rtf,J5cfXY . /"tA-e I '. .'.. / I '-~-."'--' .---------- -G=O<1+2--\ ; ,.---.---, ._------, ----.---/ . " ~- ~--'" ---'-'-f;"" - ....."~" . ~~ - ". . .,f , , , . . ~. GrecO e I ~ Or, \ -= i C'u s-6<Y\E' I CaS-\- ,-,},! '- Cu.S1oroC( Dee OLLI Oo.:,j. or Sold c.os-J. ((eCl1Cl(kS 20.(0.+ c..os+ ;e-tvfr'l'€d \0 goaa ", ~o;-- ffdfl/ :;:l-~ ------ --"---' ---...--71-::;-7<;-....-...-----....-..'-- ..-,-.....-....-. ""-.-....,..-...-- --_.______~.'iQ<:L__ _Ll::LJ'... .8cf" f /Jc-';'t 7 , . - -.---7,iO&P -.,.----.. -- ' I 3_._~._ ~JCK.L_.. J-~S2. _!L-ct~!IJ./(fo... ".7!..~(=-J:-._~.==~- '--'T ._-f--~ _ _.L~O~___..._.._~€.c...__ '7__ 11 " /.05~ '. '__~ 3_____ I So so/, dlo;i(j"---..-.--.---.....---.'--.-'e.-- ",. I 7 -' ---- .----.-- .. . ,c-'ifj3r ----.-..- r'---'--C:,~- ..--" lie? 0 ," . ;_',""_'h _ .";',0-"-'" ''/to-IJi/(J.'-'''1V '" -r~:s:oa ----.---.---. , 3", 3;Go..c ,00 "..', 5p,o.C? .,..~'2.QLcl.__.,.~~~~~~~p\L/~~IO? 3-~_ ::'f:';$t(jr),<r)()! 3'C~3'<6., '5o\d ."" U J"=~"",'" teJC6. O() fLl'Cf ,50 - Safe.) .." .-. . ~,~-~__.. ::3+$Q~' ':"dY ~.'~.5q;:':jl~~t~~-~~ ,~~-4GI9-' ----- ~I \ '~~~,. " ..-~~l[il.u:o' ""acg9QO~~'Jctili:;~~~:;;~[-~' .'7/ ';-">""",.e. ~~. \ 3 .3, iPa;;.ao ~D 7?<<.t/~-I,u 'l'te";';; - 7d~ I :#'~";o-~;F'S~hq(/D~" r ___ _____ ._____~.__ _______zc:tJ ~Cl.__ ~I<.!:.(' ..:..__ _ _.._ _~,l~I__6:"...u___e"",i::. ....", ' _.~=''''' ~;f!yg;-$'Fsy~7!/fJfffJ5'~~'~~-:~.~drt/~Je/ " " ' 3.._' ~.3t_9:~</o '5 ~~'t'Q_ _d ~H:rf::!t1.'l lk( -- -~_:"}~': .-'--.... .-. '~,"",'",,"" ,', ...4'.,',' ,..,...,..,.,~..,..,2.':i.a,',(,.7. .. , ,'.:.<1,',.,,',",,;,~,,7, ,~" . f,e ic-9'~7? ..~~.~;2',::L!.~_ -;,',,:'-:~.~~?'cJ!:~-~-~'~t;\': >~;~[i{:J~/'-dr- ; .-J GteJ - , - .... __ 3' ".3, 306;~"'3 7'!{5- 5'~id" -;0 LlftCf 'slt/;--e J ~ j) -'1..11 el .-.:......_<:.:..:.::. ~;" '.. '., . . ' 3'+..At'!9~(J(j(j;oo' Joe-a ',,' ~~I~~f~tJ~~(l'~tii5 --VlS__~___ '6 '/1 9ocJoo 9/d-''''' ., J. g~lkl'f' ;f(Y'if .-..------_... ..~----.-. 1J..ry!. ~. ~", ,5:500,00 5!5'OO C/o! , ....,}, m','_' .. ,.,.._ ___...,.__...._.____.___., "~ ,......~..iiiliJ-,...,.,."" ,.'M.'.,>1f.'i:i'ifii'.... ,"" "'-r'''''''(;;'1' . !b'''!~J'c;'' ,,}4r:"~'()~'"tr~ ;-""7'71';[ L", . ." _m..:? (){.~_.._.____...._ "rL:'?:'7tflb(j~;'Cl0""9j."j(.", Gdba"l'so t d' ..-.--.----. ,;L Lf,/Oc:,CC;2.;Z('f.CCQ__~()I~ .", ....>.. 1- ~r'" j;QfO.G6 3&7,00 5c\~___ .!l__._i-/', bGCO(J. lL 73G~__. 1+0 e.C' Zd :3 '6SG,OO I) 600,00 ScAd .. -.-. ,...-.... -,....-----.---.'-'-.. -----..-.\.--.-.- --.._....~..-- ~~" ~ -"--;-~--"'--:-*"'~ ' , r- -- i l)\CtVY10 i-.d ,'Re.c; {lid lP.\e. "J illltl:t ( , I ;:j:f- +-,0 vv\ l'v\-C\,'io 5:).,#.CI: 0\= DCt~tI{J ~~e.~nt' Color l)~31D Ist-_~-:- - .7-,= ?'~;:~ Z ,;:;:':;~ G- =" ;l~.Q_;i JU.~jF,i(),"'o#"99 {J-iJ 581) . rfci; 1;~~:Gt---~ k.;z ..~ 7J./f1 "i -ru f k~ I 10 -tl[;-9r t ~ 7 t, I ffoL.. ,S-"t/ G- 'd-JtjJ '! ;cd Ke1 /0 -;1f-9't.~:1.{, 7 >-c-/ " Act.: ' '.' .,,,,,.~ ~.2f '" tI.5~1 .. . J ;lq3_i E (/( el 10 -;' ( -'19.f.lz.~ c..J,:-.. lie! - .'?'}:~ ~.~ v.s:.~--?~ d~_l.\ Lt ij \ ' \. 3- '1, ()Y..L_~_Kst.__ .taL._ ,,6__._. SF . 2-Q..y c; liTU.L~?\...JCLd~.:T .C€:i.'iO _.1.__. J?:.~",._..L '3.~_ I SJ) 'dG_:-t ~.. Tu(\~e \. \O'd)-9~(o~ i9_~_J__,.KA..___' ---,-35'< 0 S;<-f: , ~~AL%~~:Eit"t~c/50'- .~~;.,- '''"''1'''';:; J:.go.l, ;!o. C-' .'S;P;Z .. , 'j,,{jLfl 'i < ".,\t:'",">""GCl ',' - ",,"'~ 'I' 2: .' 1,0 :::"'U:5- ~ ~2_~li-~jT~~\~, Il)~.::ft "~9-iL:'-'~~~J:!L'i.; ~~\:I~e1'" ' ~'ta-:. "(7:..,:. u5~~d ,.J~d-l\ S Prj 51-" e-e-r.. I[ ~f5 ''19.o!3?<iIJ'" ../ ..J7-cI!!.!!! _~ !)-.;3 V5 -/ ' ~i1qCO ~I,~~r'}T)J'7fj -:.:' _L:_~~~~~.,' ,::< I .. .'~(;; .. st~-~: _~2Lf Cf__ nLk.~.L ld:'L:.'t'l_~~t:_~_.J_ f5.QI1.al;, 73> .. (Vi . VV,s;L.~ J J gO' Tut f( (' L_, 12) ~<;9 5"0 ~? I Rou;:;d ~ T/5"IC'-c : [;...' -r - I ,d. ;l.:Y'T' . _ft;ffi:7'i;1~l-11" Cffr/(f"'",;:L' '5~Hcwc)" ,;rz;57"'" ",~J':l;'~i3, ,,~I~., ~~~<I ~(~k~~.,I;;~_-;;~':-f1:~~ I ~:~ --;~5t--)~ ~~J- _~~;;;~"I':~~;--- :J)~/~7 -~'-1'I9 }_ ~4A.C1 I,//__r~~=-'_~ -;). '!J . ;;;r~S'S 7] (k I 1?:+'1'1.,~q9.5'" J 'ifCtU;cl (J' '.7'" s::r;I.;J d-d.5C, i Iclfk~1 ' 1;1,/-9'7 S-3 '8/ ) __lYzu.d /jl' 6-' -:r~/c. od J:J,5'7 J ..TJ.UJs-e/ 7.-/-'l1 ,~lS- J ,))011"#, /,15 G-- SJ.:~ J~_~~_7j1J:kel_ll__J-f7 .__.?~/O /,. P:,~J /1/9 ,i., Sr:;Z .~ ;)J.S5 . '/i;r/1'<"1 IJ"hr.~?1..$9/~ ..J._____ fP,i~_c:y5 /r;;t6 "G->\" :L:"~ oj J,d. C:zC !I-rutl\'~ ~!;t~/--99 ~a..~d:: 1'.1. Jl1Gi ;) c / ! If 1=-1 ,j J1 ___ .>> <0 .J) tlc~~ \Ct: S) c~ ,v.e{' C~m=:( ..... C05-t- Ou( 1f\C\~P.( k:s -t G-\cJe oK. ~\d yer Cao-\- R-e.~\ ,vJ Cc;s1- h CCdCc \- \0 LjO()O rOO 7/q'oo,oo '3 '3 1'100 .~ ","-"19'00 I ;2'800 I t.(Ov 0 L(~ ;;"800' ;;2300 :175'0 ;2.S"00 3 ,. i LlS-ao JloG 3". .,,__~:J - -'f"'-~ 3 3--:; .5 '5 4---. . .3 .. -:> . "' .5;~p,oo . ,;-;-'~~ ,;(100'-' I/l-O 0 ~3M 21b7' 1:18~;? '. '8- 0/~o dv7 dO' 3;;l. 'is J,73 .) 3 eFiS ~?7g I I I \ S04fC_ ~Umbt1' Diu.l1blVd~Oh\- colae l'rI-e.\,^C : .Jt: o~ Sh{pe "'j)\,-\~ ,:Jd:trJnt ':er /CJ.-j~'9 r 1,i:~'_I____ ikJ{~ ':{f5 (' ,_ :r:~~_ , ~Q?c..q7J, uIKe /J. -/ ~99 5""tJt;, I, uJ I 3, ~ 1 '"':J__,"-. ,].a(p~ !~LJd.'n-9'JI. ~,' ,c2.! 12 ~(cdd 'I I~J" _(}:,.SJ:~)'. j '")h',.t'"' 'c ~,':y"""C'c<"'<"("'V~P#~~':';'~<J'~':'..::> ":;~l '~'''r~, ",' ',; '~m:",'~~ '" " .~_iO~'-:"l'" ' ,: :1' ,;:' . '''; ,", ,v' v:;:o,,: .' '" ""'7"': < ..' -", t... d-JIos"l'IT t'e.' ,Ck?'1 i ~307 I IF,S /,/5 0 \ -_I .. . , , .-..., , '.,,-' . --_.... - I n(p~-",hTl.il\<tI 11,;l''i-'i1;4~, 1"" .;c:"'I.o7 +' l5T-1 JJ,fi7 !NL;~'VG'~i?..~10 "'rr-l 51iu~c ~-L,_L~ if-; / ,s t ({III sf-7'" ~ , ,*I\~r'Tl<de_' _ ~dol.Co 1 is ~ 1;)-1(, -9 9 CAN . 7s I 5;I> / Jd.Cod '~!~r;""~:I~''"dl,..cr,' 65"/7.. ! /1ot<~':?,q,,::'. G- 'S;t'57 UU&'lfJlL{-{1;w.qq I ..,' ,.."'.' I " ,.,..;". '.~3 ~., t1'-2-__ c~ ~.9..,(p~ ~1~~~~(::'!~:3,~O"H:~ \ r ,~___\M ~,.--'- .,.~~t.-- ~ 1,:7-9 "..' " ~lL,,;LJ~r1-~.- , 2l6-_.. LffiL~ r-\-~:-'" ,~{~'I~\ J~~~f~~ :Xlt~~_~T:It-A~~" ') f'13!1 {~fk~(ll:::~ ~Qg"'I,,p,~tR;}._ ".~ ,\ f~g~ ,~~_ ,.l{~~ ;:r:Lff / -'0 .' . J:r14111~(~'I-Y-oo,j &aCJI 'd::.J&..;:r . .3.~hw. #-i=t V;S-~ , , J?15JnV\d~.Q~~ 1~4:~~___-t-~'i2. .:f JBL ~. .CjpT f'..f:"\..~ 7-i. " _ d-d-1lP~II'fLLlIuL\T~cf=~~,LGQ,Lf_?__':t:J12L_s~..H<6-r:~,I+ J Y$;I ~2 ._' t ",. ;if' I '1:_D,..~I_~ t.( . ,I J." .1:-<)"c __l;"! 'J Sz:: ' , , -:tl:1S '12~ " ",.. , " ".,," .,."",. ',.' . .,~., "S;:"_.' I:< II. ,"n><~I_~,,"~~.ttr.) ..... .~.'4 "..." "-,~.~__,,' ~._'- ". "\ fI>,.',:,..,, -' :,' ,.. ,. l:... ";>' "'tilfi/I:"~ t...r ..'. , ", ,," ,... .' ',: "L~- \ ". - 1J:J:LjllWV~_! l.<Z~t.lt..~,,~ J _,' . I .7D,,-< ( I~~l oJ /'l~O \'-mUtJuL I t1 ,0\ IteM 5 I ~,. k' .>;,~.._-~ ,,' ." ,......L""r,__'P,,- !if tfl_V )" / ,uu -- .- - '. ~-,,,.Y,' '- ,- ...~~~-_. ,-,."" . ...-. __.. -'- '..., .. .., " , ' . " ,..' , . . '. ".' _..~.;:'.d:JLJ:~ .L:~ 222LL::~tJtf11u~ \1 -'1/ DO I Pf11~JL_~'2.._[~t. /Jo, I:S' ;~t~,~~etJ- I :l-L/~ ~.. '-~iU;;>~~. ,~~. '-~.. _.,.\:&b._. . tf imSr2:~3m_- " "m~ !:;t~:J~q:~rn:;/fJ&;_~rr~~fp-- i.L9~ '~~~;? , .. ~.,,- ",.d 11\x;,,) Ill'> TT I ~ ! -\={crv! , i I 7 , . p . . " '. ~ . . G,qJ e Cc e,i- ~'c\ ~\ct.\- Glt.? Ccb-\- .q \J l., C \.l0 \-crre r c..1O-b.-e~ . -, SC\.cJ CcS-t KE)/k,j,t To No IT/}-; , . - I 3 c~~.l. ~ - :3 ;~. i 3_____. . . 'l/ -;- ~~""""""~,Jllli>>U...oI...~~' I _I' I "......".W~ ,;",.,--; '.w.' ~,,'''' -'~I~i.",,JJ...I~i~~ij,,jlil~"":~flil.1Ji,,.:'I;- .' '~IhiI~':~ - ~-- -,,:.,j....I...~---, --"~-~'","""-'_ii<i!iIkJ''-' , . __R9~(e~ .~ ~-!~~399~-?:r;:L ~.. .~~-~ -, ~,."-2----Tce~~--,-""",-,-,,J_--,J2--_-_---,--~-Q..---,~~--'t'-""--.-,=,-- ---.-",-- .2J:2i) ~, J - '_1-__.__ "ffi!\"~'19,(05 J>0,'vS '?,3S ' ' \wc"(I~~~Cb ~ . I ~, ' "!.. ' ..J_~ SL~t \ __ ____L.,' ,~L.l1.! '3 _ " ' I L-aO~ ~__.. I~H~~E -J~,:,Q~ &1.:C5::--J-.-..-6L------- _e~~~J._:=...~ Q_ G- V01-;1' :..aJ:>t>8'lt IY,S~\"!L\.ta:Q~CO_'______11 _.E?___ ,-rl'ine-e<;:,c;;. _,.50 '6--1/'1 VVS, ( '<"""/' '57 ?; 3\-rt L - q . __ '- ,~~. 7 T(:j ~ '~ ~~ 3 Q~~~ \) - 15-0.1 ___ , L_ , ~o\J.()cl ' 53 :~ ,,;~.l-~~?~~'l3 LL_- ~, l.oa f,..dZ3j .~. _.a~-Q_lti--._.__- '__,L,._j_.fIIO __ di () (p Ib f J1- J ~ , ,~. _ ',_ .. ,_ __~______,_ '_'~_'_"_X~~ ir~~~'lc_ ~~r I-ILQJ ~______, __.J, j__~ d.ak G v'4 ir' 93:-3 <=:t P ~-l- i1:93-Qf ______. --1----1 CNCA \ 7-:S $X-I' , &II ' L.a3~1..S: \) '.. ~~L~. ---__ ,J..__J_\kv. ' .0"0 G- ~ 'cill1' , -:2. '2. C r:: s.\recl I \ I r? ~ ..!\ z:- ...." SiP 1.-7'" "'1 vvl r C\..c,' A't'~ I ! ~~.L1UJ_U-. ,V V fJlf-L-I: :i ---- -f:'I'1'J'" :To ' ----1'''---- -----.. --,- - I :" t'\ t2. '2, Q f 1(' l'\' LU l' .' 2...L..... I~ 2 ~ ,1:',..1lI_<.l~.!.~__ rtb2.Qg,,_ .Q\.::2a.~C_..__,....._....___,_=T_-,--,-, -~.~ --.---- i.1__~39f11f- H;ll~c,,!:1_.:'J:.QJ _ .JJ:.(P~<6..._ __ 1..__._____1. 8.D.L1M: .._LL~.... p.__~ ~::__d_S35~, 1:LJteL:!~~:_O:L??~_.:_JJQQ.. ___. 1.._...__..Le~~c___L.Lq__.__ E._,S~.9~ l!__.2lA:J$l:[,..H; \,l~_c_-,ij':'~'3L..~LJ=-~~-- ______' L.....__.._":,~'\~_LC2Q.,_..T~ 'V~"I" . ~ ; " \'" ~'-~--~ - -.-.;.: ~-~-.~- ~= ...,.------~- -" - --- ~ . ",,"-- --- -- - : 9 \ I , OCv\~~ Q~ ('rl~'Y)O -It- VI 1;-0<'0. (Ate I ~I #1 , I I -II of O-a~ 0, "ffl:.J\ ~f'? lue'6 ht' -"'_Q2;~~_ ~i~~Q;Q;~- _2iL~.".~=T=~=~~:.2~:Q;3:-~_~_~i;- . .. ..~YL I~L~I J~j~_~,CoB-.~L_. _..J_...;..,"__;{Zo~...., J:..(P.i1::.",' .~_ ~ i .-G'2:QS.._- Th!.b_~\LJ~j~~S9 28..'::lQ.L_.-' ,..~iL.__\~~Q___ J..!,5'L,...' E_ ::I.,__ . .~~:p Q.~_ ,T0:(h~IIJ;2~L?:Q:?5<6.'-:/O "'.,._9.___, ..~"~_._ ~6.]... /;> .,__ ---~ .d. -. ..~ ~~~ .........~ ~- ~ ~ '~II"rlO!I/,~_ uur CO&r Pee Cevq+ O\.t( CD'&1- Doie ~ekr(\~ or~ -Po:, 0 IO~ C uEb( CO'br 30\.9 w/o TD TC\ P'\ ~I ! I , ii ,~ , ~[ -'-'\,.) . \..l <;\-0"""", . /t-o G€ -t- $/ 7cX),a:} I~ ,I , I I I 3 3 ~ I v60,oO '44- , 2>30o.ool..:./ 0 'd.CzYO,coi A49'X',oo/ J.8~O..odlj ~o. 00 i S \el V\ R.€~'f'<'-e),. 1n-'5"-O) ::r:3; ::o\\) 1 0 'S '<'LO{ W? '-"'~"",,=~',c,~_I~~~r." _. ~_...__ -! = ,~ ~ II .... ~ ~iI'Il;", ,_ ';,'"' OWloM N,^l"~'" Q,€O;>~ G-c<.., \V\eM() S:fL>KE' OClk: #- kf or \); C{Y1c<)~ \) C<<LJ\d3 . ehtf-€' l0e~\'1t cob- clc.r'}-' '-"'<~'--~ ,._~-~.._~<,~-_.~. -~~'_"'__'^~___',".,_.", ...._~o ___-.,~,,__.,'_""'.~_. ___ ~'."__'e~~." _. ,~".___ _.", <" _,~~,_" ,_,_.____~_~_ .~.~____~,_'_._..._._ _."..,..,_. ____~~_....,...,.,.",..~__ lci3ljQ_~_f:L tLJJer_ .JLh.Q,I,.. 5:~,.:1:L~,. ~_L.__..,__. _thnce,g;_ ..~LQ1_._ _.(2... .~fL ' .~ . ,;JQiLl}QEJ:L ..H;\1~{...U=@..'1~L~JL::(Q!Q'1._..L~...,__ .~rl:....L,JLL. .k,_... S..;t:,J.._. ".,' 3.':illIi. J::LJJaL Li:Q>.:L-Qlr3-<rt~.. .._L___,..,{<CIlc0..ct ..J:g~L.. J~..,... \&- \ '~Y.f>J:L ' Jtil\.:e..c"... .,\JkI:L::Cl \" .J.~,:.J.L~. n_":..J__._~. .iliI e"L,.., _.L~.lt_ ",",!:::_ ;J> :"d3..~.Q.I:tL _J:L:n.~..C.. :a1l=2J~..q;.:J!5Q~....J..___.___,.~~._,..._.LQ.(:,L _~.... ,!-\ ' , .,.d3~.Q3:f{ .1-.k.\~.~.._l2::l~::~J -tG2:::Y.B..Q..... L..,.".., .J!.J2..,__.. .J,QQ..._ ,..~.. .::>.~ ,1 "~..d3...l\OhlL.J:J~\l€,L_ J2~Jlt:Q'\ J')'1i&", .__....L_..,._..__~.._.. I,QL__ ~.. : ~Lit __. I~~:t.' 1~,,,,:JI:01 _(g?~_?__...._,_L.____~.~___.~.~~___ G_, ws-~ .. ,~"a'bl::UJ\-~i~. I~.::fl ~t Jl~ L~,~......~~___.. .R \:Lw._~iL._.. ~~.. ysp ". H, " ~o 1 ta3/j,.LBliHllleC_ !l-:-I~-'L. _.~k...__.. _...:....J.___~,,9_S2._...__ ......:i~.__ h " ~~~ ~ ,~L~H _I::LJ.l~c..l~:\91::Ql ...~a~'L,___.,._I.____..... R)~L__,. < ~"l:L__ .__...... ._" '%~.@_~~j! ~;1":_ I.::J6.:-~_ ._~_.____..__J_._~<L.. I . :. I -- J ws- ~, . il""Q3.Y.l ~H..H~ltS?L,.. !Qd:.{P~ _.1:If:~2.... ___L,__ JdY~._...1J_Q..... r 8I ~JX.3~tL J\~\1eLa.,1:fl~3,-~10__,_._,L___E_j)__.___J~'OQ~ ~ S-7 fll-~J0_':Ll~J=L_Hj\~L'. 1::0.-0;2 6~qQQ ___.L_ .Q\1.0.L_ LQ..Q......, r:- VS-J ~__~_3~ ~._. Tl,}.!,(.'.s:.\2.L . \-:lJ ~2:,~,. (Q'iD,8-_.., ...----1--.... 12~.u \~_,~5_'~:L.__. ....._, ~~ ',,_ct.'Sq<iJ1,,~~~rl, >Q~_ __._." .._..~.~-_:::.. __.~ 1..55" G-I{ V5"J., ., -.d.3y:-a&(&h~: _\-:fl.~~~..?~~':!g.lfI0L .~. .eCY0ces.$ ,JliL__).L .~.\l)- iL2'2:H.ac.~~. d;-:~ .. ilL~ ~..9._T.. 6LL~~_.gQllQd:.__ Jc.9JL___ 6:. S! , "d3.~~!2H.HJl€.{...._ ' .' ,..1i~Js;2..__L.._.._,.._ .~._ L.~L._._ t=L_.s~..:L' ,,-~~5.~2(:;,.. _~ _~.:.~~~~_______..__ __J_____ _~,_. _1:-16> _', tj-.=- ::I.~l . :~_.J3~lLJ--lj\~(-. ~-,,~..~g,e.. t__",_.___._~___~ ~~ ,8' G i :d:2:>.1'd,~ti.._~4:~..1:&J:._f.______._.J__..._ __ R-CMd ..._._J..t. . f' " :!'i.! ...~~ LU, H_.Q~~t_._ .6::s..::9.fi __.......1_...:...__...1 e 0.C_,... r,i"LJ (en) ,. G.__ v ~':.1 Q3 '). \'fkL\- ~~% QfJ [V\e''f\O '~<6 I?o 6- J) foe; · ____,;.:Jcx1, ...J2tfll~ _________'___... I o:i~___.. __,_____.... ,_..._~(L..., \,07____ ____ __...__. ~ I , -j ".oI)ilj~i",li1jj1lililiiililljllkIUIJII"",U1~~!lIIIiIi" J - , - .= .. ~,-'~~ ~""'-=' ~ I ., ~ IOu-I (1J-e Q ...Q O~cr<'\c""~ I coSt 01..'-(' (2~ Cu.'&~e\ Co 8:l- ~ , Co8t 01 Qold W"~+ Rcme.-~ G,Wde I fe, Coro--t Posd ~ I~)< (0 // ,r // //: / : / . 4J ~ ~ I 00,00 3 5,00 " ~ b2 6GL G..GL GG l1 \ I I 62)0,00 ~GIL l-Q. / y/'~ /' /' ,,~ C; <\$\; s; ),i""""'"'- -~ NANCY B. LAUBACH, Plaintiff VS. "-,,- -:" "-~ , --~7_; : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : CIVIL ACTION - LAW HENRY LINE, d/b/a : NO. 2000 - 2829 CIVIL TERM LINE AND LINE JEWELERS Defendant PRAECIPE TO SATISFY JUDGMENT TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please mark the judgment in the above captioned matter satisfied. Date: 7 -d- 7 -0 r Respectfully submitted, ""ll 'ooM. V~Y'E~~ 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, P A 17013 717243-9190 Supreme Ct. ID. 23167 Attorney for Plaintiff iliiI'~" '"' 'llI~~~!illl~~lISl~~~"'~ .l!iLLJilli1Ii,~__ - A^ <._ "., ~~'- 0.,,L .". " -....Wli 1 I.i ij ,,1 l'i ,1 i'l :,1 Ii ,I ri :1 II , I ,I II II I 0 '"-' 0 = ~ -'11 ~;::: -I <- :;r--n (= ,l'P i"'~ -urn t'-J ;139 -.; ~~Q -'.- -; " .'0 Q5 (:' (~~rn c::- --~\ ~ ~~ N :j~ -" Ul .~, ~~