The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About97-00197 ~ I j ). I IU - i , , , ! j : , i , I i , ~ I i I \. " - 0--. ~ It <:l... V) , ~ , .':l ~ ~I it'- ,'I:l- ; , UONNA A. SI'ANGLEI{, Plaintiff v. : IN TilE COllRT OF COM~ION PLI:t\S : CUMBERLAND COI JNTY. PFNNSYI. VANIA : NO: 97-197 EIUC ,I. W. SI'ANGLEI{, : Civil Action - Law Defcndant : Divorcc I'I{AECII'F. TO TRANSMIT RECOIU> TO TilE PROTHONBOTARY: Transmit the record. togcthcr with thc lilllowing inlimnation. to the Court filr entry of a divorce dccrcc: 1. Ground fordivorcc: irrctrievahle breakdown under *3301(c) of the Divorce Code. 2. Date and manner of service of the complaint: Service hy certified mail. restricted delivery on January 24. 1997; Certificate of Mailing filed Fehruary 10. 1999. 3. (a) Date of execution of the aflidavit of consent required hy *130 I (c) of the Divorce Code: by the Plaintiffon March 28. 2000; by the Defendant on April 4. 2000. 4. Related claims pending: No claims pending - Agreement and Stipulation dated March 24. 2000 resolved all claims. 5. (b) Date Plaintiffs Waiver of Notice in *3301(c) Divorce was liled with the Prothonotary: March 31. 2000. Date Defendant's Waiver of Notice in *3301(c) Divorce was tiled with the Prothonotary: April 4. 2000. ,~ h\.~Ht..J- Kathy M. Sh Ighart. ES~I~=:?~ Attorney for Plaintiff P.O. Box 6315 lIarrisburg, I' A 17112-0315 (717) 540-8511 Supreme Court 1139779 Date: '? -1(reX) . r DONNA A, SPANGLER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA VB. NO. 97 - 197 CIVIL ERIC J.W. SPANGLER, Defendant IN DIVORCE THE MASTER: Today is Friday, March 24, 2000. This is the date set for a pre-hearing conference in the This action was commenced by the filing of a above captioned divorce proceedings. Present in the conference room are the Plaintiff, Donna A. Spangler, and her counsel Kathy M. Shughart, and the Defendant, Eric J.W. Spangler, and his counsel Michael S. Travis. divorce complaint on January 13, 1997, raising grounds for divorce of irretrievable breakdown 0f the marriage and indignities. Counsel indicated that the parties will sign and file affidavits of consent and waivers of notice of intention to request entry of divorce decree so that the divorce can be concluded under Section 3301(c) of the Domestic Relations Code. Those affidavits and waivers should be filed within seven days of today's date with the Prothonotary. With respect to the indignities claim, that action was non-prossed because of failure to file a Bill of Particulars. The Defendant filed a counterclaim on June 2, 1999, raising the economic issue of equitable distribution; the Plaintiff filed an amended complaint on September 2, 1999, raising the economic claims of alimony, alimony pendente lite, and Counsel fees and costs. The parties were married on November 16, 1991, and separated January 19, 1997. The parties are the natural parents of three children, Shannon Ashley, born February 11, 1988; Ryan Joseph, born February 20, 1990; and Kevin Michael, born June 28, 1992. The parties, by agreement on June 30, 1998, stipulated that the children would be in the primary custody of wife. After negotiations this morning, counsel have indicated that the parties have reached an agreement with respect to the outstanding economic issues. An agreement is going to be placed on the record in the presence of the parties. No changes can be made to the substantive agreement as placed on the record; however, the parties and counsel can review the draft of the agreement for typographical errors and can make any correction of typographical errors as required. Once the agreement has been transcribed and any corrections of typographical errors have been made, the parties will be requested to affix their signatures affirming the terms of settlement as placed on the record. However, after the agreement has been placed on the record, no substantive changes can be made to the agreement even though the agreement is not signed; the I r parties will be bound by the terms of the settlement whell they leave this hearing room. When the Master receives a signed copy of the agreement affirming the terms of settlement, or if the parties or one of the parties refuses to sign, the Master will proceed to prepare an order vacating his appointment so that counsel can prepare a praecipe transmitting the record to the Court requesting a final decree in divorce. The agreement is going to be sent to counsel after it has been transcribed for review of typographical f t , I "f errors rather than having the parties and counsel return later today to do the review. Mr. Travis. MR. TRAVIS: l. With respect to division of personal property, the parties have agreed to divide between them and have already divided between them, to their mutual satisfaction, joint bank accounts, stock portfolios, personal effects, household furniture and furnishing and all other articles of personal property used in common. Husband specifically retains ownership of his Merck stock options; his investment savings account, No. l75092; his ESPP with his employer; certificate of deposit, No. 135439-40; checking account, No. 135439-11; savings account, No. 135439-01; and securities account, No. 1075-48459. Wife specifically retains ownership of her checking account, No. 159393-11; savings account, No. 159393-01. Husband will retain control of the certificates of deposit investments for the children which are deemed property for the children. 2. In exchange for the above mutual agreements contained through this agreement, husband shall pay to wife the sum of $100,000.00 cash. The payment of the $100,000.00 will be made within thirty (30) days to wife. 3. The voluntary payments for wife and children in the amount of $450.00 per week shall continue until April 1, 2000. At that time the child support will be $1,375.00 per month and wife will receive alimony in the amount of $575.00 per month. The alimony paid to wife will be non-modifiable and shall be paid for a period of sixty (60) months beginning in the month in which the divorce decree is entered. The payment of alimony shall terminate in the event that either party dies or wife cohabits with a person of the opposite sex or remarries. The alimony shall automatically terminate upon the receipt by wife of the 60th payment. 4. With respect to life insurance, husband will maintain a life insurance policy naming the children as the beneficiaries of his policy in an amount not less than $l50,OOO.00 until the youngest child reaches the age of 18. 5. With respect to automobiles, the parties are owners of two automobiles, a 1999 Isuzu Trooper and a 1993 Chevrolet Lumina driven by wife. Neither car is encumbered by a loan. Wife shall have sole and exclusive possession of the Chevrolet Lumina and husband shall have sole and exclusive possession of the Isuzu Trooper. Husband shall also have title to a 1994 motorcycle and the parties will take whatever action is required to transfer documents of ownership as soon as possible following entry of the divorce decree. Both parcies agree to assume all responsibility and hold each other harmless for any and all liability, costs and expenses associated with the ownership of the above vehicles. Cost for any transfer or fees shall be borne equally by the parties. 6. With respect to distribution of the real property, husband and wife hold title as tenants by the entireties to the premises identified as 418 Linden Street, Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania. The parties agree that wife shall have sole and exclusive possession of the property. Husband shall transfer to wife his right, title, and interest in said real estate within thirty (30) days of today's date. Husband's counsel shall hold the deed to the property until it is refinanced. There is also a mortgage encumbering the property with GMAC Bank in the approximate amount of $79,000.00. Wife shall obtain a refinance or have the mortgage assigned to her name within a period of three (3) years. If she fails to have the property either assigned or refinanced in her llame, at that point, the property will be listed for sale with all agent acceptable to both parties and any equity on the sale of the property would be the property of wife. Any costs incurred in a refinance will be borne equally between the parties. Upon wife's refinancing the property, husband's counsel shall deliver the deed to wife. 7. With respect to pension and retirement accounts, husband and wife shall maintain separate pensions, IRAs and/or retirement accounts. Wife relinquishes any and all right, title, and interest she may have in existing or future retirement assets or benefits of husband's pension, retirement, cash balance retirement plan, 401 (k), investment savings, ESPP or other accounts. Husband also relinquishes any right, title, and interest he may have in all existing or future retirement assets or benefits of wife's pension, retirement, 401(k), or similar accounts. B. With respect to medical insurance, husband and wife shall be responsible for providing their own medical insurance. The parties agree to hold each other harmless for the costs of obtaining any insurance and for medical expenses not covered by insurance after the divorce. Also, with respect to medical insurance, husband shall continue to provide medical insurance for the children. 9. With respect to marital debts, there are no marital debts of the marriage other than individual student loans. The parties agree to be responsible for their own student loans. The parties agree that neither has contracted for any debts or other obligations since separation. 10. With respect to filing of taxes, husband nnd wife agree to file separate tax returns for the tax year in which the divorce decree is entered. Wife will take the deduction for the mortgage and related expenses and an exemption for the minor child, Ryan. Husband will have the exemption for Shannon and Kevin. This is to continue until the children are no longer dependents. 1l. With respect to counsel fees, each party shall be responsible for paying his or her own legal fees and expenses. However, husband has advanced $2,000.00 for payment of wife's counsel fees which shall be deducted from the cash lump sum payment of $100,000.00. l2. Except as herein otherwise provided, each party may dispose of his or her property in any way and each party hereby waives and relinquishe& any and all rights he or she may now have or hereafter acquire under the present or future laws of any jurisdiction to share in the property or the estate of the other as a result of the marital relationship including without limitation, statutory allowance, widow's allowance, right of intestacy, right to take against the will of the other, and right to act as administrator or executor in the other's estate. Each will at the request of the other execute, acknowledge, and deliver any and all instruments which may be necessary or advisable to carry into effect this mutual waiver and relinquishment of all such interest, rights, and claims, THE MASTER: Mrs. Spangler, have you been present during the statement of the agreement on the record? MRS. SPANGLER: Yes, I have. THE MASTER: Do you have any questions about the agreement? MRS. SPANGLER: No, I don't. THE MASTER: Is it your intention to accept this agreement as a final settlement of all the economic claims that have been raised in this action? MRS. SPANGLER: Yes. THE MASTER: And you understand that when you leave this room today, you are bound by this agreement even though you haven't signed any documents affirming these terms of settlement? MRS. SPANGLER: Yes. THE MASTER: Mr. Spangler, have you been present during the statement of the agreement? MR. SPANGLER: Yes, sir. DONNA A, SI'ANGLER. Plaintiff IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COlJNTY, PENNSYL VANIA v. NO. ). .-- 91- / q 7 C.wJ U- ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, Defcndant Civil Action - Law Divorcc/Custody NOTICE TO DEFEND AND CLAIM RIGHTS YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT, If you wish to defcnd against the claims sct forth in thc following pagcs, you must takc prompt action. You are warncd that if you fail to do so, the casc may procccd without you and a decrec of divorcc or annulment may be cntcred against you by the Court. A judgmcnt may also bc cntercd against you for any other claim or rclicf or property or other rights important to you, including custody or visitation or your childrcn. Whcn the ground for divorce is indignitics or irretricvablc brcakdown of thc marriage, you may rcquestmarriagc counscling. A list of marriagc counselors is availablc in the Office ofthc I'rothonotary, Dauphin County Courthousc, Harrisburg, Pcnnsy1vania. IF YOU DO NOT FILE A CLAIM FOR ALIMONY, DIVISION OF PROPERTY, LAWYER'S FEES OR EXPENSES BEFORE A DIVORCE OR ANNULMENT IS GRANTED, YOU MAY LOSE THE RIGHT TO CLAIM ANY OF THEM. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS P AI'ER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELl'. COURT ADMINISTRATOR CUMBERLAND COUNTY COlJRTIIOUSE 4TH FLOOR ONE COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PENNSYLVANIA 17013 717-240-6200 7. PlaintifT has heen advised of the availability of counseling and that PlaintitT may havc the right to request that the court require the parties to participate in counseling. 8. Plaintiff avcrs that thc marriage is irrctrievably broken. 9. Thc parties havc becn living scparate and apart. At a subscquent timc, Plaintiff may submit an Affidavit that the partics have lived scparatc and apart for at least two (2) ycars. 10. Plaintiff avers that Defcndant has offcrcd such indignitics to the pcrson of thc Plaintiff so as to render I'laintiffs condition intolcrablc and Plaintiffs life burdcnsomc. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffrcqucsts your Honorablc Court to cntcr a Dccrcc of Divorcc from thc bonds of matrimony. COUNT 2 - CUSTODY II. Paragraphs 1 through 10 arc incorporatcd by rcfcrcnce hcrcin. 12. Plaintiffsccks to confirm primary custody ofthc parties' minor childrcn: Shannon Ashlcy Spanglcr, born Fcbruary 11, 1988, Ryan Joscph Spanglcr. born Fcbruary 20, 1990, and Kcvin Michacl Spanglcr, born Junc 28, 1992. Plaintiff is thc natural mothcr ofthc childrcn and Dcfcndant is thc natural fathcr of the childrcn. Thc children wcrc not born out of wcdlock. 13. During the past fivc ycars, thc childrcn havc rcsidcd with thc following pcrsons and at thc following addrcsscs: Plaintiff and Dcfcndant Pillsburg Plaintiff and Defcndant Camp Hill/ Mcchanicsburg, P A 418 Lindcn St. Mcchanicsburg, P A 14. Plaintiff has not participatcd as a party or a witncss, or in anothcr capacity. in othcr litigation conccrning the custody of the childrcn in this or anothcr court. birth-1991 1991 - 1992 Plaintiff and Dcfendant 6/92 - present Plaintiff has no information of a custody procceding conccrning the childrcn pcnding in a court of this Commonwcalth. Plaintiff docs not know of a pcrson not party to the procccdings who has physical custody of thc childrcn or claims to havc custody or visitation rights with rcspcct to thc childrcn. 15. Each parcnt whose parcntal rights to the childrcn have not been tcrminated and thc pcrson who has physical custody of the childrcn has bcen named as partics to this action. 16. Thc bcst intcrcst and pcrmancnt welfarc of thc childrcn will bc scrvcd by granting thc rclicf rcqucstcd for thc following rcasons: a. Plaintiff. thc natural mother has bccn thc primary carctaker and nurturing parent of thc childrcn. b. Plaintiff, the mother, providcs a safc homc and a stable and loving cnvironmcnt for thc children. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffrcqucsts Your honorable Court to confirm hcr custody ofthc minor childrcn. Rcspcct~ Ily submittcd, .. h~'~~/' Kathy M. Shughart - U Attorncy for Plaintiff P.O. Box 6315 5440 Joncstown Road Harrisburg, P A 17112-0315 (717) 540-8511 Suprcmc Court 1139779 I ~ DONNA A. SPANGLER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA (I v. NO. Defendant Civil Action. Law Divorce/Custody ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, VERIFICATION I verify that the statements made in this Complaint are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. f)[~J\-i?{ (\, S~~t.{L\~ Donna A. Spangler, lainti, t ~ UONNA A. SI'ANGLEI{, Plaintiff v. : IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO: 97-197 ERIC ,I. W. SI'ANGLEI{, Defendant : Civil Action - Law : Di vorce AFFIDA VIT OF CONSENT 2. The marriagc of I'laintiff and Defendant is irretrievably broken and ninety days havc clapsed from the date of filing and service of the Complaint. I I , 'I I I 1. A Complaint in Divorcc under Section 3301(c) of the Divorcc Codc was filcd on January 13, 1997. 3. I consent to thc entry of a final dccrce of divorce aftcr service of notice of intcntion to request entry of the decree. I verify thc statements made in this aflidavit are truc and correct. I undcrstand that falsc statements hcrein are madc subject to the pcnalties of 18 Pa.c.S. Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Date: .3/ :Jy } ~ , I} Donna A. Spanglcr, Plai - -- If) ;- 1I-: ,.; . : , .. . ') , , ;\11 ...~ .lll.. .-:' :} , , '..1 ,)(I/,fI~ :, , I '- .:r .. .. lj" ~:;: , --) - , , J , , , : ;-j ; ! . .. :~,j I ~_. , u.. ...... I , '.J , , L:> (J (Hl/rlFi U I .., .,,-....,.,( ?. . r , v. : IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PI.E^S : CUMBERl.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO: 97-197 nONNA A. SI'AN<a.EI{, Plaintiff ERIC J. W. SI'ANGLER, Dcfendant : Civil Action - l.aw : Divorce W AlVEI{ OF NOTICE OF INTENTION TO REQUEST ENTRY OF A IlIVORCE nECI{EE UNnER SECTION 33()J(c) OF TilE IlIVORCE COnE 1. I consent to the entry of a linal decree of divorce without notice. 2. I undcrstand that I may lose rights concerning alimony, division of property, lawycr's fees or cxpenscs if I do not claim them before a divorce is granted. 3. I undcrstand that I will not be divorced until a divorce decree is entered by the Court and that a copy ofthc decrec will he sent to me immediately alier it is tiled with the Prothonotary. Date: 3/ d. '2 ),6)) I . u~ It ~ Donna A. Spanglcr, Plain If I verify the statements madc in this aflidavit are true and correct. I understand that false statcmcnts herein are made subjcct to the penalties of 18 Pa.c.S. section 4904 relating to unsworn falsilication to authorities. f'"' -,- ,= . - c.~~ ~ , , . , l l. : , :..... , r.j .. .-- ..... ::5 1:-1 . I.:::t U tt~ OFFICE OF DIVORCE MASTER CUMBERLANO COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS 9 North Hanover Street Carlislo, PA 17013 (717) 240.6535 E. Robert Elicker, II Divorce Master Wea' Shore 697-0371 Ex!. 6535 Tracl .10 Colyer Office Manager/Reporter March 27, 2000 Kathy M. Shughart Attorney at Law 27 South Arlene Street P.O. Box 6315 Harrisburg, PA 17112-0315 Michael S. Travis, Esquire 4076 Market Street Suite 209 Camp Hill, PA l70ll RE: Donna A. Spangler vs, Eric J.W. Spangler No. 97 - 197 Civil In Divorce Dear Ms. Shughart and Mr. Travis: Enclosed is a draft of the agreement which you put on the record on March 24, 2000. Please review the draft for any corrections with the understanding that no substantive changes can be made. When you have reviewed the draft give us a call and let us know if you want us to send the original to the Plaintiff's attorney for signature who then can transmit the original to the Defendant's attorney for signature, When I receive a signed copy of the document, I will then obtain a Court order vacating my appointment. Thank you for your continuing cooperation in bringing this matter to settlement. Very truly yours, E. Robert Elicker, II Divorce Master 9iJN}j A A 1;\1'Iv\0 !;'~,{~ PI^\\~ r\ If Ldl'\C (6 ~B.'ltfffV\UI(!tj,.~ Ojf4{\QkfY\ A f [ IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PI.EAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA CIVIl. ACTION LAW NO. Q1.1L11 CIVIL 19 IN DIVOllCE , e STATUS SHEET DATE: . I r , I "'I ! , I t , ? ( 7-'iIHrUt) a .vt1. ,'j .;:"'.1 t'i 11",. ,.tf'lt ..It"':'!t.t/- ~ (11"1 '",:.{I"-'!<_"t"t: iV/l, ,'/'/"./,.., ..J:l!ib"I^,I"'1iil'W,.~..rlftlr/.I! . II, .J1.~t.I,,~j ~tIJ' "'''';'' 0"/ (." ,.,.,/,.1 "'. ,,"/" "/ '" ".,' '.'----t- .r'tjr~lI '\-('fl'!'l/:'.'~("" t .....1(".. (I. '. ;'1,,\ d\' tt . '. 6(1,.//. 't/.., ." (It' ",..' ,'//1'1 ,f, f''''7Z.. -/~ {,rJ.t! / t I:, .....Fl"d/l!.. '; ~'u> 6//' ,:./,-,'1';/' ~ . OFFICE OF DIVORCE MASTER CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS 9 North Hanover Slreel Carlisle. PA 17013 (717) 240.6535 E. Robert Elicker, II Oivorce Master West Shore 697-0371 Ex\. 6535 Tr.cl Jo Colyer Office Manager/RepMer June 11, 1999 Kathy M. Shugart Attorney at Law 27 South Arlene Street P.O. Box 6315 Harrisburg, PA 17112-0315 RE: Donna A. Spangler vs. Eric J.W. Spangler No. 97 - 197 civil In Divorce Michael S. Travis, Esquire 4076 Market Street suite 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dear Ms. Shugart and Mr. Travis: By order of Court of President Judge George E. Hoffer dated June 9, 1999, the full-time Master has been appointed in the above referenced divorce proceedings. A divorce complaint was filed on January 13, 1997, raising grounds for divorce of irretrievable breakdown of the marriage and indignities. No economic claims were raised in the complaint. On June 2, 1999, the Defendant filed an answer to the complaint and a counter.claim. The counterclaim raised the economic claim of equitable distribution. I am going to proceed on the assumption that grounds for divorce are not an issue and that the parties will either sign affidavits of consent or have been separated for a period in excess of two years. Based on that assumption, I am directing each counsel to file a pretrial statement in accordance with P.R.C.P. 1920.33(b) on or before, Friday, July 9, 1999. Upon receipt of the pre-trial statements, I will immediately schedule a prehearing conference with counsel to discuss the issues and, OFFIC! OF DIVORCE MASTER CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT OF COMMON PLEAS 9 North Hanover Slreet Carlisle. PA 17013 (717) 240-6535 I. Robert IlIeker, II Dlvorc. Muter Treel 010 COlyer Offic. Manager/R.porter Welt Shore 697-0371 Exl. 6535 July 13, 1999 Kathy M. Shugart Attorney at Law 27 South Arlene Street P.O. Box 6315 Harrisburg, PA 17112-0315 RE: Donna A. Spangler vs. Eric J.W. Spangler No. 97 - 197 Civil In Divorce Michael S. Travis, EBquire 4076 Market Street Suite 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dear Ms. Shugart and Mr. Travis: In reference to Ms. Shugart's letter of July 6, 1999, I am Withdrawing the directive to file pretrial statements on or before July 9, 1999. I will not is~'. a new directive to file pretrial statements unless counsel advise that they are not going to be able to settle the case as Ms. Shugart has indicated. Counsel can advise me if no settlement is reached and I will issue a new directive. Otherwise, if the parties enter into an agreement, please provide my office with two signed copies of the agreement so I can prepare an order vacating my appointment. Very truly yours, . nobert Elicker, II :dvorce Master ~ ~ , Ms. Shughart and Mr. TraviB, Attorneys at Law 26 August 1999 paae 2 * FAILURE TO FILE PRETRIAL STATEMENTS AS DIRECTED BY THE MASTER MAY RESULT IN THE MASTER'S APPOINTMENT BEING VACATED. i "i DONNA A. SPANGLER, Plaintiff VS. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 97 - 197 CIVIL ERIC J.W. SPANGLER, Defendant IN DIVORCE NOTICE CF PRE-HEARING CONFERENCE TO: Kathy M. Shughart Counsel for Plaintiff Michael S. Travis Counsel for Defendant A pre-hearing conference has been scheduled at the Office of the Oivorce Master, 9 North Hanover Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, on the 24th day of March, 2000, at 9:30 a.m., at which time we will review the pre-trial statements previously filed by counsel, define issues, identify witnesses, explore the possibility of settlemert and, if necessary, schedule a hearing. Very truly yours, Date of Notice: 9/29/99 E. Robert Elicker, II Divorce Master See item (I) above. copy of Defendant's last employer provided statements which are attached hcreto as Exhibits C and D. (ii) Non-marital portion See itcm (I )(ii) above. (8) Counsel fces arc not at issuc. (9) There does not appear to bc dispute as to thc value ofmarilal tangible property. Defendant does reservc thc right to obtain an appraisal of the marital rcsidencc. (10) Marital Debts. With thc cxccption ofthc marital home, therc appear to bc no significant marital debts. The following student loans are owcd by the parties: (i) As of Separation Studcnt Loans owed to SLSC $3,500.00 (H) Student Loans owcd by Wife UNKNOWN (ii) Payments sincc separation $106/mo since 8/25/98, totaling $1,060.00 (H) (11) Proposed resolution. Dcfendant attachcs his offcr of scttlemcnt made on Fcbruary 23, 1999, as Exhibit E. Plaintiff has neither accepted nor rcjectcd this offer. By communication bctween thc parties, Plaintiff apparcntly believcs Dcfcndant is "worth morc." On infonnation and belicf, Plaintiff may be rcfcrring to Defcndant's Stock Options with Mcrck Mcdco, which the Defcndant was grantcd on March 4,1997. Bccausc the third stock option was grantcd to Defcndant aftcr scparation, it is not marital property subjcct to equitable distribution. 5 ~ r , Defendant proposes the offer of settlement with adjustments made for the increase in the '. , I , , i I i marital assets since February, 1999. DA TED: '7/i./9') B~' y: "'-""~ /' lae! S. Travis Attorney for Defendant 4076 Market Street, Suite 209 Camp HiII,PA 17011 (717) 731-9502 6 0978527 Srarement or Earnings and DeductIons Soc..! StCJ,;rIIy ~1J,.,tler $' 'St. W(,,_ Merck & Co.. Inc. and Subsidiaries ERIC J SPANGLER 3250 W SIDDONSBURG RD DIlLSBURG PI, 17019 OTHER COMP IHPUTED INCOHE ESPP IMPUTED I TOT OTHR COMP EARNINGS BASE PAY TOT EARNINGS PRE-TAX OED ~on MATCHED ~OlK UNHATCHED TOT PRETX OED ADJ GROSS TAXES FICA-MHI FEDERAL TAX STATE TAX PI, OTHER COMP IMPUTED INCOME ESPP I MPUTED I TOT OTHR COMP EARNINGS BASE PAY OVERTIME SICK PAY STOCK OPTIONS VACATION HOLI 01, Y PER~ONAl TIHE TOT f~RNINGS PRE-TAX OED ~OU: MATCHED ~OIK UNMATCHED TOT PRETX OED T...........,.')' 1216.~0 1216.~0 72.98 ~8.66 121 . 6~ 109~.76 17.72 128.6~ 3~. 18 28.29 130.77 159.06 31932.9~ 337.20 598.8~ 1l6936.~~ 3036.32 720. ~8 77~ . 28 15~336.50 2223. 7~ 1200.15 3~23_89 YTO TI...~. w..... ...." s.u,.. FEDERAL FICA HEDICARE PA LOCAL 151071.67 H 68~00.00 15~413.68 153569_2~ H 308770.78 I'IJlS,WOlh(([l /"Jls, ~A10 /,,10 VA' Hks. I"V P",oe EI'IOI'" .93 ~.29 5.22 MECHANICSBURG TOT TAXES OTHER OED UNION DUES OPTI DNAL L TO DPTI ONAl L I FE OPTIONAL 'AD&D DEPENDENT lIFE CESPP TOT OTHER OED NET PAY /'0""01 hlJmbtr 98216000QB6 I, 12.21 192.75 30.69 I. 50 3.2~ 2.22 ,~ 0 2~.33 62.38 839.63 150912.61 ! I I I ! I I I I ., I I ADJ GROSS VE':'~.TO.O":'iE I"'FC~'.';..rl:J"" TAXES FICA-MHI FICA-OASDI FEDERAL TAX STATE TAX PI, CAMP HILL SO 0 MECHANICSBURG TOT TAXES OTHER OED UNION DUES OPTIONAL LTD OPTIONAL LIFE OPTIONAL AD&D DEPENDENT LIFE CESPP HISC STOCK '--"''''D'' ....'I A"'1I;l..'" ""''''''~.II 3 DESC RATE HOURS 3 o /,,0 VA,... AVA" 1"'0 'c.... E>:hibi t A TOT OTHER OED 75318.73 2239.00 <2<0.80 36777.8~ ~299.96 10.00 15<3.91 <9111.51 I J. "I 238.11 ~5.15 99.<5 68.82 12.40 7~ I. 28 7~113.52 BASE/ST 30.~10 ~O.OO ! I I OIT DBL TIME OTHER VIO ,'c. ... ..." /,,0 "., .., /,,0 .,., .., AVA" G . ., 104Q ubel :!u ,~ I ~'Ij C 11I1 rll ="uQ,'ZI Un tll.IR!:. \.Ib.l ",,,,,,,,,, pl"UP'"'' 0' I~P' PruldentJal Election Campaign ~ ISlIu;'12.1 , FIling Status !SUP,,"2.) Clllt_ ",lfy COli eo.. Exemptions IS",.;,'::) I' "'ell !~ '" .', Il'C'''C'~1S u.el;'''' Income ArtlC/'! Cop.,. e 01 your F'1l""'W-2. W-2G.&IIll 10n-R hl'fe. il ~Oll e,e I'Icl '"IW.2. '''U;'1!. [n":",t"I:O "CUIlIe".'''''' :ll",""'"!""",lllj/ 'tllj'''. /ustments to Income c..llhon; St. ''''If..CI.e'', Adiusted Jl Gross Income l A " , l H , . , 17 18 19 20. 21 22 Zla b 24 25 ~ 26 27 28 29 JO D~.nl 0' Ill. "....U.., - InUln\a' Riven... S'fVlr... U.S. Individual Income Tax Return 1994 rT ~O' ,,,_ .'1' .',,, '. ....It ~', 'hi III 01111' U. .....r Ct;...",,,,; 'VIoI.no,., IJl~..... 0"'\'. OonOl ..."" Dllllet. ,,,,,,'. Itlt' 'Yo,,' aoaaJ ,1Cl.lnfy "1II1'1b" Olnl return. does vour spouse went SJ 10 00 to ttus fund? . . . . . . . . SIngle X MameO filing jOint return (even 11 only one had Income) Mameo fdlng separate return, Enler spouse's soc. sec. no. above &. full name here .. Hue c.l household (wllh qualifying person). (S~ page '3.) lithe Qualifying person IS . ChIld but not your ee;;cnoenl. enlet (hiS chlld's name hefe .. I OLia~ltvlnc wldo.....fefl wllh oe:Jendent ChIle (vear soous€: dleo .. 19 ).ISee Dace 1::1.) IE Vourself. II your p~renl (or some:Jne e!se) can clalrT'. you as a aepenoent on hiS or hef ta.. felufn. do not c~ec~ be. 6a 2ut be sure 10 che:r. the ball on line :J3t on ;:age = "O,,""'ln,""'l'Itll'lll'" ..al,n,,,,. ERIC J S?ldJGLER I" ... ..~.~ ~.~ ~~'. "n. ~.-. ..... .....'.. '.11"""'. CAR-RT-SORTaaR019 186-66-519J S28 10 A SPANGLER .~..*:e: AI 178-60-7080 ERIC J g DONNA 418 LINDEN ST MECHANICSBURG PA ACI.tIC 005 17055 ...--..--.------.- , Co you want SJ to go to thiS lund7 . . . . III , 2 J 4 5 6. b ~ Spouse c Dependents: 1') """" l""I~-"" .~t lU' n,,,,,, ~JCPl'" Pl 11.;.1 t. CIC". II ..~Cl.f I Cl'C''IC'rI\''IItC.,1 '.11 UCvflhnvme.' 1204-68-5610IDAUGHTER 1165-72-6078IS0lJ 1165-74-';058Is0N 1 I I I I I 1.1 C'C.~.lI."rt rtl&11:",Pl1tICyCIoI SHJ.JJlJON J.. S?ld,GLER RYJ..N J S?J.JJGLER KEVI!J !1 S?J.JJGLER CI II your CMC Olon'l live wllh you tUtlS CI21mec as youl oe; unoer p,e-1S8S ag~eemenl. cn~c~. e 'iotal numcer ::1 e,e-nollons clalmf'C 7 Wages, saJeTles. I:~S. e:c. Anac~ Form(~1 \,\'-2, . 8a Taxilble triterest Jncome (see page 15) ..:..r;3:l'l S:necule = II ovef S';OO b Tax-uempllnlerest (see page 16), :::~;'" ,"ClI/ll. 0" 10'" II. I 8b I 9 Oivldenc Income. Anach Schecule 8 II over S40:) . , . . . . . . . . . . . . . 10 Taxaele retunc~. creaj~s. or ot1se:s of st31e and lo::al Jncomc laxes (see page '6). . . , '1 ":'Iimony receive: 12 lJ 14 IS. 16. 8usJness Income or (los:;). Anach SCflec.:Jle C or C-E,2. , . . . . . . . . . . . . , ' . . . . Capital gain Of (loss). II reculred. anacn Schecule 0 . . . . . . , . . , .. ,..".... Other ;ams or (losses), Anach Form 4797 , . . . . . . . . TOla! I~":" clsmcullons. . . . . '1 ,Sa I Total penSIons and annUities. . . ., '68 I Men:a! real estale. rovallles. pannerSI"IIPs. S corporations. Farm InC:lme or (lOSS I At:acn Scnecule F . . Unemployment comoensatlon (see page '8). SOCial SE-Cunt~' benrfn!: ~I Other 1Mcome. Add the a.mounlS 1M me lar nanl column lor lIne~ 7 lhrouch 2'. ThiS IS your total Income , . . . . . .. Your IFJ.. deCluctlon (see p21ge 19). . . . . . . . . . . . . . . .. . . . . . . . .. 23a Spouse's IRA C!eduCtlon (see page 19). . . . . . . . , . . 23b I MOVing e)"j::enses ;"nach Form ::IS03 Of :J903-F 24 One-nail 01 se1t-em;::loymentlA.ll. . 25 Sell..emotovec health Insurance deduction (see page 2') 26 t<eoS" re-llrcmenl plan ana sell-em;:>loyed SE? deouCtJon 27 PenalfY en earl~' wllhera.....al 01 savIngs .. 28 ;"llmonv pale: Recl:l,enI'S SS'~ .. 29 AdCl lines :::Ja lhrouan ~S Thc!.e are YOUI toUI adlustments ~ I 30 SubH3clllne 3C Irom tine 22, TM; I~ you' ildJus1ed gross Income, II less Ihsn S2~,29Ei am: II Child I hveO wll", vou fle5~ th2n $9.0::10 II cn,~o Olon'll!vf: Wllh 'Iou). see ~Earnec Income Credrt" or: oc 27" 3t ..,# b Taxacle amount (p~. b Taxable amounl (pg. trusts, elC. Aliach Schedule E. . b Ta>:~ble a"T1ount (;:g. 16) ." C",'!i"'o . ~'!. r: 14 178-60-7080 SPD~II" ,IlDolJ ..am" "lI,"bll 186-66-5190 For Privacy Act and Paperwo~ Reducllon Act HoUce, lie page 4, Yu No holl: ch'~~I"II""'" X wIUrlOIUII"'II''''O''' \&.O'"OIiC'ylllll X IIluMI } "0 t'lt... c~'o,~ :. 6l,.e(t 151 f.C. 01 Nc_ t' r:~' ....1l1,.'~'C ," C~,IC"" e" "1l",.H\U !t...,.c 12 12 12 . I<"'I\~ ... ~. O'C ~ . e,c", O. ,",''1 r t.l C II I ~: :,... t . : . c' I':"'::~ 'III ~'.' ", ~.::."t'.~1 c.,t:rn '''"'' t . t:~. "0 "ee~","'a'l ,,,,,'.et. h~,U'C:''' ~ ~i 59,5061 1801 10 II 12 lJ i I I 1 I I I I I 59,6861 17) 17) . 14 I 1Sb I 16b 171 IS 19 20b 21 22 o 59,6861 r~,... 1040 I'H. )(- ~ r I r I ~ I I 1 I I 1 I f '0'''',''<'''''' ERIC J .LJiD DONlJA A SPhlJGLER 178-60-7080 Tux Compu- tation !SttPIg. al II ~c.. ....1\1 'P'I,.';'!tc !'....r"e..' I,. ..'c.;. ,. Credits :~" eli' ,., 01her Taxes [~tt 'J.' : ~ I Paymenls :OIlier 'c''''.W-2 w-zC.,t'1C 'on.=.,,, III,trOIl:. Refund or Amount You Owe Sign Here ..,,:.ttt., t I ~ '1'1 ., I.'~ It' ~t..' PH:r:1 Paid Preparer's Use Only In 34: Arn:lunl "om Ilrl[, 31 flC)U:illlO grO&5Incomt.'1 JJ a Clwel>. II [J You were E5 or oleer, 0 811ne; 0 Spouu was E~ or olcer. AOe:! the numtf' 0' bOlle!; checllec lDO\lt .na enter tho lalal helB b II your pa,ent 101 someone 'I!.e) can ClaJm you as I depenaen1. ChOCk here. DEline. .. 33. ~ 33b o c II you jJle m&!,ncd filing seplIIIH, aM your ,pouall IIcmllu CCCUCllons 01 you lie , cual.SlaluS Iloen, Set: pa;e :3 ,no chCtCI( here .. JJc 0 J Itemlud deductlonllram Scheculo A. line :!9, OR SundJ,d deductIon Sho....n belOW lor your filing Slllus Built you checked 34 Enler Iny bOI on line 3Ja Dr b, go 10 page 23 10 llnd your standald deduCliOn Ine "you checked bOI 33c. ~our sllnoaro deouctlon IS zero. larger 01 l. 5In~IEl" $:J.BOO · HalO 01 housenold . t5,600 your: . Mzrneo riling JOlnUy or OU611t~'ln~ wloow(er) . 56,350 . Mamed filing 'sparllely" SJ,1n 34 I 3S Subrr.ct lme 3.. fram hne 32 ' . . 35 36 II line 32 IS SSJ_~D ar less, murlJply $~,450 by the tolal number a1 elCempnons ClAImed on line 6e. II tIMe 32 IS Dover SE3,B5;O, see the wO'I'.sneel on pagl: 24 lor lhe amounl 10 enler . . , . 37 Taxlble Income. Subtract linE- 36 trom line 3~ II I,", 3i11 "'C', '".~ I,". 3~. '''1'' -0- 38 ToU. Check II trorr. I ~ Ta..: Table, b 0 Tax Rale SChedules, or dO Form E5'~ (see page :!4). Amoun: from Form:s) ee,4. 39 AC~llronalla.e! Check If from iI 0 Farm .:970 b 0 FOlm ..Si2 36 37 cO Capnll G&ln Tv: WorKSheet ~. I 36 :!9 40 Ace tines :!S ilMC ~E 41 CreOlllor et':ilc r,c Cf~er,:!:.,t cz.,e eJ;En~(:! Ar" Form ,~",. 42 CreMlor mE e:,,'lov or lt1E' c,~i!.t;lec :"r:~c~, ~cnE'CulE: F; 43 Foreign tZJ: cr(>e,~ Anaeh Form ,"E 44 Other creOII!; (SH r;:2.;Ie 2~) ChE:Ck Illrc~ a C Form ~E'JO b C Fcrm e:!~e cO Form eea, de Felr:1 45 ,1..00 hnes';' ~t"c.:;t1 '-4 ~ 40 41 42 43 44 4! ! ~ '5 4, 45 '9 SO 5\ 5. ~I 53 46 Sutmeetllne':!; :':-m line.:O If I,ne .:t IS f"!"::rf mi!.n line .::' E:nle~ <i~ 47 Sell-emOloymer,: IV,. An Sen. SE 48 Allern2.II...'e f""l:n,;:-,'::":'ltaJl;. Anaeh Form €2~1 49 Mecaplure tales, :~eek Illrof!'l iI 0 Form .::~5 b 0 Fo~m Ben cO Form ee2E SO SOCIal seeunl'',' Z",: MeClcare lax en 11; Inco~e not rCDonec to em:loover Anact': ~or:'1"': "':;7 51 52 53 54 55 56 Tall' on cuali!le: rENemenl :::1ans. InClUCln; 1;::';"5 II rec.WEe AOvance ea~nec i:'1come creCll p.!:ovme~ts Irc:r, Form VJ-~ Aoe lines 46 Ir,t~u:h 52 ThiS is va""r toUI UI a~aeh Form t3::9 Feceral Income :Z.l wllt'lhelc Jl any IS trorr. F:rm(s) ':OSS. .:hec~" 0 '95' eSllmateC tax oayme",s ano z.mOlJnl a:plleolrom ,e51~ relurn Earned Income credlt II reCUlreC:, ar:a:n Scncoule Ele (see page 27) Nonlaxaole earne::: .n:cme. amourol .. I L! NO 54 55 S,0961 56 S7 S8 59 and type .. 57 Amounf palo Wllh Form "BSB (eX1enslon re~uesll. ,. . . .,. .. .. . 58 EJtcess SOCial se:ur.ry anC RRi,l. lax wl:MelO (see page :i,) ., ., . . 59 Olher payments. Check II tram a 0 Form 4:'39 b 0 Form "136 60 Ac:~ lines ~, Tnrouch 59_ These arE' vour 10lal payments 61 Uline 60 IS more 1t'.an line ~::. Su~:maclllne~:: 110m line 60 ThiS IS the amount you OVERPAID 62 Amount 01 line 61 you wan: REFUNDED TO YOU . . , . , . , . . 63 Amount oll,no 6\ you want APPLIED TO 1995 ESTIMATED TAX. ~ 63 I ~ I 60 . . II- 61 ~ 62 64 II line ~:: IS more trian line EO, suClractllne 60 horn line 5::. ThIS IS the AMOUNT YOU OWE. For del aIlS on hOv- 10 pay, Incluamg what to wrIle on your payment. see page:12 , . , . 65 E~Tlmalec tax t'e~i!.rtv (see pace 331, Also !Melucle on line 64 . , . , , ,. I 65 I 64 =::( :;S', Le( 11,015 48,671 12,2501 36,4211 5,4641 5,464 5,464 5,~6'; 8,096 2,6 J 2 I 2,632~ 'J"O., 1l,",'Io.I lOt C"I"'~'. I:lel&" lnat I ~,'''' ''''''I'''C I,,",a ,"",FI'l'''C ,e:c"':l'"'''''' len.OIlIIl .no IUI.""nu. '"0 Ie '1'1. b'1l0l "'~ l"owl.OIl' '''0 tl....I, lll.,..rr """, cc"'c~. ,IIC c:...::,.lt. :.Cll't!,cn Cl "rC''''laH'.' Ho.n lUIl')"')" tl.uc on aUI"IO''''II.on er -".(1'1 clle.'" "'II '"y tl'lowl.all'. ~ YOII'III."a,..,. ~ I Call l"'c;~;;~CIST 15e~"'~~~;;:~~R SeD"" '1'11"&1.." 11')D'<"i""..'". EC.~'" III..SIS'II"1. $1"10"'" l --r.. .u, ~:;.......:.I- f.~~!(~-'" ~ '- ..,,,,",, ,. Tn-my J WILLI;,J'lS H & R BLOCK ,.,,11I', "...., Ie_ ~e,,'; ~ .IIf"-,-e'e"'CI.~e , iO W. 11J..IU ST. &CD'"' NECHJd~ICSBURG. PP. tn.Ctll PI"a,."IIDtl.IUC./FIty<"!t. I [ ND. I Z:PUlC. 070-50-8901 23-2314357 I.'.-....IlIO..'C 0 li055 SCHEDULES A&B (Form 10401 Schedule A-Itemized Deductions =.t.t"...~, {' 'r" 1f",.",~ '~Ir"_I' A,~,"~, ~I'.'el IT) t,...., "1"0_' tn .0.... H..(' ... Atueh 10 form 1040 /Schedule B Is on b~ckl ... See InswctJons for Schldulas A Ind B (Form 10401. ERIC J AND DONNA A SPANGLER Medical and DenUlI Expenus Tues You Paid 15.. 'jjO'''.1.} Inlerest You Paid l!u Ur' ".n NOlt. "t'IC"" ,,, 11 ' .1 ~ ,I ^" e,e"c:, ~II Gifts 10 Charity Ilyo..II'IC" GllA"C;:l' C,'t'illo'll. '''c';'Jo-] ~SUilITy and Then Losses Job Expenses and Most Ol~er Mlsc.ellaneous Deductions ToUI itemized Deductions 2 3 . 5 6 7 . Caution: 00 no: Incluce ellpenses reimbursed or PIJC b~' OlMer~ MedIcal Ind cental expenses (11I0 p19" /Jr.. 1). . Enler amounl trom Form 1040, hne::l2 2 MultlplV line 2 IbOlJe bV 7 .~':-. (.075) SublrlClllne:3 from line' 111mB J IS more lhan line " enla' ...{).. SUlle and IOCZlllncome lbe~. , . ' Real eslale laxes (see page 10,,,2), Personal propeny laxes, Other la.xes .. USl type and amount .pyJ__________________________~~ PA SUI 91 =~E~~QI~~=====================~!~ 9 10 11 Add Imes 5 mrouch 8, ' Home mongage Inleresl and pOints reponec on Form '056, Home mon;age Inlerest nol repone: on Form '09B.11 Pl,e: I: 1~' p"lon "lIm .. "t'"' )Ill... CCIol;nlln. ~,1I,",'. "' c.;. ,1,. J l 1"0... 1"'1 C,'lIIn'. "'....., I': nil. ,.adll" . -----------------------.------- ------------------------------- ------------------------------- ------------------------------- 12 FOlf'lb net repone: on Form ,OSE See page A-3, 13 Inveslmenlmleresl II required. an;;cr-, Fcrm ..952. (See page ';-3). 14 Add lines 10 H'ltOuoh 13 . . 1S Girts by cash or Crleck II any girt o! S:~O or more. s~e page A..,j . 16 Other than bV C~Sh or check II anv ;::' 01 $250 or more, see page 1.-3. II over $500, you MUST anaeh Fcrm S,e3 17 Carryover Irom pflor year. 18 AcC lines 15 tnroucn 17 19 Casualty or men 10SS(eS). Anach Fcrm ..684 ISee caoe 10,-4 ) 20 Unrelmtlutsed employee ellpenses - lOti travel. union dues. JeD eoucallon elc. 11 reQulfea. you MUST ana::n Form 2106 or 210S-EZ, (Ste page 10,-5_) . LICENSE FEE 120 =tfi'lQIl )J,p=E~O}'j:~~~Ol'N.=~t[E~= = = = = ~~:[ ------------------------------- ------------------------------- Tax preparation lees. . . . , , . . .. ..........,..."......,..... Other ellpenses .. investment, sale ceposlt ball. elc. USl Type and amounl ------------------------------- ------------------------------- ------------------------------- ------------------------------- ------------------------------- 3 5 6 7 2 JJ5 1 194 . 10 6,817 519 C'-' 1;0"'1 1~. ~ - 0 ~ 1& 1994 AN~"""'" 07 !l'Cl...n~. ""11 'falll_g,a.l~y"",.._ 178-60-7080 . o 9 4,048 11 12 13 I l' I 6 8,~1 , -, ,5 , 16 150 I 17 I 16 lS0i ......... 19 01 I . ~ 20 4d:a . 21 85 22 23 ACId lines 20 Ihrough 22 .,.."....,...."...,.,.............,. Enter amount tram Form 1040. line 32. ., , 24 59 , 686 MultlplV hne 24 above bV 2~. (.02).. . . .. . . .,.....,.... ,... 2S Subtraclllne 25 hom line 23. Jlline 25 IS more lhan line 23. enler -0- MOVing expenses Incurrea belore 199'. Anach Form 3S03 or 3903-F. (See page A-51. . . . , . . , . . . Other - from 1151 on pace A-5. ust type and amount ... - I ------------------ 1,194 ----------------------------------------- , } ",,'" 21 22 . 15.. p.gl ",. ~ I:;' ..11......111 1I'lIwt1r-"'1 23 2. 25 26 Other 27 Miscellaneous 21 Deductions 29 IS Ferm 1040. line 32, over S1'~,800 (over SS!..900 ,"mamec II1Ing separalely)? NO. Your aeauc:lon IS nol hmned, ':'Cd the amounts In lhe la7 nghl column for Iines.4 throug" 28. AlsO enlel on Form 1040.JIOC 34. the larger ollhls amount or your SUlncara aecue:lon YES. YOU! CcduCl1Ol'1 mav be hmllC::: See pacE: 1...5 lor Ihe amounllO e"'er For Paperwork Reducllon Act t~otlce, see Form 1040 InstructIons. 488 26 27 o o 21 o 29 lJ., 015 Schedule A (Form 1040) 1994 RlCt-18-199:: 1(,:34 ~'O1 782 (,4(,1 : ~ II' II " II .1,. SUte your ~mpl~ edur'ltion and cmplo)1oeDt bistOfY aDd &IlY i; spe.::Lallzzd Ulli.o.ing YOIl have ~ved, .1 '! , "'~::rc...-r.l~dco f'n~j Co.r(' :! I I !! !. f'.04 '05 o' j ; , I I: , . . ,i ,. i i . ; I, ' 0, I ! . i. i !I I; II I' I <:IJ:? S. SWewbelbayonareCl1titledtoorpanl"'p"I"iDII1Y,''d'I>'~nt,~oo., ',: ! ~~"..m,Ll or l.Oy oth=' dcfcrTcd Q~.. fur BlI)' cmTtOt act :t~ I:li.fi I i ~ ; " I provide the following infomuIion: ,,~~c:! . :?.YI; I I!' . (a) The nature oftht plan; ~ ~ . r _.; I : ~....J Cl (b) The name and address .ofW enti~ or perso~ providiml the plan; ~frejCO 1~r;jT Jl (c) \\'hether your IIltereSt III me plm 11 vested, U1 p3y 5U\1U.S 01 o~ise; .(,01. ~ tf;r>;- (d) Unot vetted, SUlt the d= and conditiom underwlt'icli!he plm ~ vest; 1ttn..n 11f4' (e) Whether the plllIl is contribOlOry or ll0n-c0mribUtOI)~ ~ . (f) If contributOlY, the amount you contribuzed p:ior 10:!,our ~ar&ti:l? from your spouse, clelin...-atiI!g those contribtrtions occurring prior to md ~ your fin41 . ! sep3Iltlo:t: loll" .! i . (S)' If contributory. the amount your emp\oya con:Iib~ during th~: rna.'1illie, dclinez.ting thoSt COllditions made pnor 2nd subsequent;o your filUl.! o! I . separation; /J l~ . ; ! ,! (b) 1foOD-contributory, the IUtlOI1Ol y01.ll' employer cotitribuIed d~ the I! ' m=icgc. dclineatin~ thoU' conditions Inlldc prior and subse:qllali Ie 'your ~ ;: I:: ~tion: 5i~.(i~ \$ C\O(I~~ W+ury. 4h: et.n1"C WI!<<<- hl16 ~ conHb.{W (i) 1rtfbe~~'=cd in the plan during the mania.g~ ,! :. (j) lfyou bsve w ri~t 10 withdraw all)' monie:! from ,the plan, bO~I'lDuch :; i mone)' :nay )'ou withdraw IlDd II what interva1s; ~e. bc-bu:>) I :, . (k) If you have withdrawn and/or borrowed 1lIl)' moni~$ from any ~f:,h p~, ; i . indicate when and how much \\'t.S borrowed and ....nether the tIlC1i'e>~ must be ~d or i repaid; tJIA :, 0) The cla1e on which you aze eotitled 10 rec:eive retiretrient or ~lon ;; i : benefilS;~~) .. . :1: i' . . (m) !he preseot balance or your interest in the fund; Q:b. ~ : 1. :::,'. .J. (n) Amount ofbenctits receivable per month upon ~t; ~~Il" ~~r. (0) Ift~ are any survivor beneUt.s, give a de"..criptl~ithereof; ~e 'be.1O><?) I. (p) AtlLCh lCornplett: eop)'Of any such plan. ;' , Ii ~ ltJDn ~1~1'1l, fl~~+ \6 ~ll~~e -b ~ ~ ind(~~~Url- b.ttb ~ on ue~ ~ M-~t\lIle,p Wtr-l~"'~, j: :::.:' (y NOHTIFr\ ~1MI~~~tA) i~ ~\I~r ~ llSilrbO, .e!i~;b/t; -to eltcl- It tek~Ml- ~ ~ ~ti ~ ~ 56" W"% m-; ~~+ '1'~ oP cre.di.Jcd gen leE, . .J.I . ;,., . ~ &~ ~ beoeO;+ A"f> ~ l{I~11S~3,4ln,14~ (js ~ ~.m~n~.'r~ . ~ N~r.t ~ oP ~ G,.-lMM"ed ~clf.flIl\5 i 5 t\ ~\iCW :5l)~ 'JDi~ ~ ~itt>r A-nflv-ittb~~g,~ &f!~ A,r vJ'ItT'I~1 'led~~ l1.f 66~t>lW.l OJ. Jlrq~~ ~~1lIJ.> . : i , .: LDll:l U:Il:2:G:a QGbl-Cl-93 6t .... Exhibit C MEDeo ~1I1l1';) SA\'INGS I'LAN MG 3SR90 - ERIC J SPANGLER 325B W SIDDONS BURG RD DILLSBURG. PA 17019- ~. /. ! ;; L\.. _ , - i t , SUL:ial St:curi1)' ~umbcr: 17~.tJO. 70~O nl> Slllomonll'criud: "pr DI. 199R lu Jun 3D. 1~9R "c.. Stllcmcnt Dllc: Scptcmhcr 3D. 19~8 Clic:nl SrnicC' "'umber Plan SI.1IU' Region Active 47 I ':~~:"~:~.~~'':. ~"'''l;-~~~~i: . .~. ~.ri;.i~':' MARKET VALUE '.. ....... .'.\..' Fund!lo 1 Ko~c Illuc Chip \'angu<ird L .5. Gr()"tJi - \1c:rd.. Com Slod. Fund Share) D3/31/19~R O~/30/19~R 21b ~~r ns 2Ui J I,C . ,; I 1:!9':, fl;~ Int., t,o~,': Price U3/3I/1~~R Of./3U/lQ~R 521.55 S2S j., Sj3 15 D5 ~r S:l y~ 522. n T oUlI -'"cunt Value: '.. ",.';,. .... '...;....,'';jd~.~' ',,,'.. , Yl'T" . U' . . ,'. ;'-:,....=....:~,,'..,., .';.;::'.t":.,f~'~)'~t: ,,;'CONTRIBu .101\ S M.y1AR\ -. '~';. ,.- Salary Deferral Account Co M.uchin[: ConlJib AcCl Additional Com pan)' ,\latch T etal ConlJibutiom This Period S I !'l. os Yea, To Da1e S:. 195.:3 S I, r~l Si SlOO.OO S:, 360, 80 !-C,i .:..:. SO, 00 S~,~'9."Q . ';-1",:-";' ;/g,~ESTMEJ'I,'T ELECTIONS..AS OF 07f16/1998:h:. -: ~ ~.' ;. Funds A\"Milable T,Rowe Blue Chip \'an~uard L'.s. Growth \lerck Com Stock fund TOTAL VRS ~ umLer ll86 33~S i&t'l8 You I CUllenl lm-nlmen1 Choic~ 10. OO~'. 10.00',. SO 00'.. 100.00.... Exhibi t D I-KD~33-2bJ.l .. \1aIl..Cl \'"Juc 1I3/3I/1~~R (1(./311 1.0' ~~."~~ IJ Sr,:<' .j SiC~ 75 Ct. Sn,H.': j'1 S31.~< .. S3':,.:r"'; ~~ sn. .:;~ :) . .};.-.- ~ '. .. <".~,. :. :1::., ; . . ~:T,~':~.i!.(': ,"" or Ob/JO/I ~~R 'our Inl'cs1mcnl Allocalion 16.0)'/. 0.92"" 81.015','. 100 00.... ~~ r-. .:1 ACTIVITY THIS PERIOD ~- T.H.(I"~ Uluc \'ancuard 'ltrd. Com Cblp U~. (;,oMlh Slod. fund "TOUL f Opminc (Jallnct 03/3111 WK 11.977 I' 1101 71 S2h.38': 19 l3'.4C7 OJ Contributions Ill7. B. 12lb 01 II. B21. II $2. 279. ~1j DIVidend SO 00 10 ou S9..01 196,01 c UNuh.zcd Galn:Lou SI88.61 111.9. 1I,381.1B SI,19~.~7 ClopnC B.llnct 06/30/1998 lb. 393. b3 135,438, S~ 13~2, 79 131.692. 13 .. "'Cl~~'~"..:.v.,,'" '''Ii'''' ""'.".r__~. . ' ~;:'''C'f;~~',;,7~~~~.d;"...;:~~~\~I~ORMA nON r 'i I ABOUT- YOUR" ACCOUNT'$;,.' -".,l.,- _ ..J ::",:" ~ . Salary Deferral Account S26.547..+4: Compan)' \1aI'hing Conuibution ,""count SIO.fi9.t.20; Additional Company \1al.::h 5996.91; Rollover 50.00; If your account had been diSltinuled on 6.30'98. you would have receIved the equivalent or 236.9505 shar~ of \lerd. Common Stock at a price ofSJ3J.75 per share. I(you have any quesLJom plC35C conLacl Fidelity Customer Sen'icC$. If you are hearing impaired call Fidelity, TOO numb" all.MOO.blO.~OIS. ; . Page 2 ".,..".IOolO "'J) i t Ms. Shugart February 23, 1999 Page 2 , I " , c.' Pro\losal/Offer Wife will receive the house, Chevy Lumina, and $75,000.00 cash. Wife agrees to obtain home mortgage in her name. Husband will pay for the motorcycle debt, and both parties will be responsible for any individual credit card debts. Husband will pay $ I ,21 1.00 in child support, which includes the amount o( unreimbursed daycare. Additionally, husband will pay the amount ofS377.00/montl1 for two years in alimon)'. In return, Wife waives here right to receive any additional spousal support, alimony, alimony pendent elite. and any interest in Husband's Pension, 401(k), ESPP or other retirement or benefit account. She will maintain her own health insurance, and Husband will manage the children's savings. formerly in certificates of deposit. The parties will file ajoint tax return for the year 1998 and separate income tax ren.:ms for the year 1999. They will jointly divide any income tax return or liability. If! have failed to include any material ternlS. they are not waived by subject to discussion until a manial senlement agreement is signed The offer is contingent on a divorce being entered within thirty (30) days of signing. I I ..r I Because of the amount of cash which Mr. Spangler is currently holding, we propose that the parties senle the maner as soon as possible to take advantage existing interest rates and opportunities for investments for both parties. I believe you will find this offer generous and equitable; please contact me should you have any questions; this offer will expire on March] 0, J 999. This offer may be accepted in \\TIting only. Very truly yours, ~~ ~~ ~chael S. Travis MST/aw pc: Eric J.W. Spangler/ CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Michael S. Travis, certify that I have this day served true and correct copy of the Dated: 7/f/9'f ~. B . :.c-........- ael S. Travis ID No. 77399 4076 Market Street, Suite 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717)731-9502 Fax 731-9511 foregoing document by first class mail, postage prepaid, on the following person, addressed as follows: Kathy M. Shugart, Esquire 27 S. Arlene Street P.O. Box 6315 Harrisburg, PA 17112-0315 (Attorney for Plaintill) E. Robert Elicker, II, Esquire Divorce Master 9 North Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Attorney for Defendant >;:: 1.0 r- r., C\,! ? '1 I.. ~ ::j~ Ul~.'? 0..,. ~\'-_\ . - U~ u. ~. n" '-, ~'f;i ('r);-; r- C. S -, I .. '- .. - :~~ " , U:" :::'J " " ~-; I -, r:_ en ::'3 () 0'\ U " ", " - - - - . - --- ..: ~:~~/: ..,'.,~,..'....~,..."'C> ... _ ":',. :. ',' ,', """',:" : ,', .',., ",," ',',; ;>_ / ",' '.' ,".., "',, '_' ,,' '" "> _-Cc.' u .,"'_'_ '>< -',. "', ":.~~-'-d,'.<:q, <""-':':",," ,...',',>./~{{ .' ',.' ., '; .,.\'! ".", ,', .' "".', . " "", - " ,,', '".,", <:';<~'" ' :,;;!../- ",' "',' , ,. '/'" .. '.,..,'...:,.,,' ~\~,: c. ,"', . '>:' c ..,)'..:-. . ,'"'.,, . ....: " " "," . '"'.:-' . ,-., -' , ':, . ' '.'.,\:":' "" . ',' '.; " ,'C,.; (<::/y , - .' , . - , ,',. " <<.:. " '''",.;,,: '. ;., '", - . "':;" :~-~'-' ,. . ,;';. .; ~'-:,!~f. '^;>:t--'-ih~, :.;,:;'" .,' " - "'.:,-:/:.'/( ::.~; ''';-~'/ ' ,.(',. . ,"'. <;2~.\':; '.', - ,'7,"-'" ;'C ;':'" ,',: _" " ',", ;'.;:> "- ,. "', :,:!'.c- c:.,...:,'-',.:::.-....:..'.,....,..,"", ,'C" , ',,' ",. /' :.,': "''';" ij ~"'_ ;.!:,~ ,"/' , " ~~'." , ;,<}.', '" ':C'." ,.C.C,::;;,~;" ._~, ,. . ,..'. " ;' ',; .', :> ::'';,.',:;',' '",', .~ :::,: <',', ','; .',,' . .' , ,',t ..'...,.. ' ',... :'C" ,.f ''>'' ,,:. :. 'o. ,",' , ; ,"'>:,.:,t:'; ,', ::. ,,;:, ",'0'_:; :. '-' ,<:,',A",::."" "i" ',",.' ;', '._.);"C: ,.,'. _ ~'.: .'." ":"';':,;, ..:,. ", , ';, . >:''--'"".;---; ,.;: ': '. ":;' ":' , !..'<- ',' :',' ".;i" '.'< ...., .; , .:' :"., ;..;';:__"'. '.', ",. " ,,:, ; 'C': ' , " ',' ,-.,": 'j,,' ,'" :''':. ;::' ,,< ; ':" ,';> ':"';,' ,:r:,.:;'~)"; ':> '", >.,,:.:, ";,( '. "r;i~( ',,i .,'.' '::'.' ".', ..,:~~'(..'.?~~. ~j~" ',: ,"',',', ',{~: "'.. >,:,)\.,: >',.' J~;;>, ?"{,:"/..:; ",:,~::~.'. '::'~~:\'~~rL" .:' , '., . .. ., ",::r~ (', " ,," , ,,',' ,;:"'.~ :',:\'. :~:::, ..'.'; ; :.', ~: :eL; :,;.. ;;4.;',:C... "'.' ,'. " ' ",' . ",,;', ",";'.".' ,';.';.~,.i.".:,;:.." ., ': '.' .... :::., 'fJ,,, ",{C '.': ,,' ", ',,"':':",:; .:': ",' "',,:\" '.. . o. ' ,;., , ":".. ,"".. ,:- - _', ~. v' > _ _ '. :;'::'",,':;.: ...:" .::",': ,';','; ., . , " , ".' . ',:: ,: ~~;.,: :', .,:~:~;;::/,..~~,_<~.t:___ __ __ . .,... "/~:::>(;~/~':",~/ C':, 'j. ",;",,',,:, ' , .: ',' ".,' " ',..,', : ,,'.:' ", ,>'::T'" ::-',", '; " .'"., . ,:.,: ,,:, ~~~rt~~...,,; .> ;':~:';','. "," ., , ..'.::..."',:" '!~!' f,."," ,..j,:.::',:~";"" " '~t'-~",-,i.'\o "C'':" . ., ," o. ".., " .,. ",.' ,t;.C,,": . .' - '."/" ", .' ':}'),', ':':.<:: _',t ' i5-. ~ .,. " '-.-~J 0-- -37~7-t~,,:..::~~~;:~~~~;~ikftlii f~~;~'~6':7:: - ?~'~n~~~~~Sr~~~~r,:1f~hf:~5!~~~ .- fC".,,,,El;..l:I.,,, "IS ""'_'" ".._,'~__...t__#,',,", '-",' , ~':'g:t~~r~: '" : i . ':~?~ "(, ,'.';'",-,', , ", ASSETS OF PARTIES Defendant marks on the list below those items applicable to the case at bar and itemizes the assets on the following pages. (X) I. Real Property (X) 2. Motor Vehicles (X) 3. Stocks, bonds, securities and options () 4. Certificates of deposit (X) 5. Checking accounts, cash (X) 6. Savings accounts, money market and savings certificates () 7. Contents of safe deposit boxes () 8. Trusts () 9. Life insurance policies(indicate face value, cash surrender value and current beneficiaries) () 10. Annuities () II. Gifts () 12. Inheritances () 13. Patents, copyrig.'1ts, inventions, royalties () 14. Personal property outside the home () 15. Business (list of all owners, including percentage of ownership, and officer/director positions held by a party with company) () 16. Employment termination benefits-severance pay, worker's compensation claim/award () 17. Profit sharing plans () 18. Pension plans (indicate employee contribution and date plan vests) (X) 19. Retirement plans, Individual Retirement Accounts () 20. Disability payments () 21. Litigation claims (matured and unmatured) () 22. MilitaryN.A. benefits () 23. Education benefits (X)24. Debts due, including loans, mortgages held (X)25. Household furnishings and personalty (include as a total category and attach itemized list if distribution of such assets is in dispute) (X)26. Other. . Names of all owners: Eric Spangler and Donna Spangler MARITAL PROPERTY -ITEM NO. J Eric l.W. Spangler lists all marital property in which either or both spouses have a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person as of the date this action was commenced: Description of Property: Real property, 418 Linden Street, Mechanicsburg, PA MARITAL PROPERTY-ITEM2b Eric J.W. Spangler lists all r.tarital property in which either or both spouses have a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person as of the date this action was commenced: Description of Property: 1994 Chevrolet Lumina Van Names of all owners: Eric and Donna Spangler MARITAL PROPERTY-ITEM3a Eric J.W. Spangler lists all marital property in which cither or both spouses have alcgal or cquitable interest individually or with any other person as of the dalc this action was commenced: Description of property: Securities - E Tradc 50 Shares WCOM/60 Sharcs Intel Cash Addrcss: Account Numbcr: 1075-8459 Name of Owner: Eric Spangler . l , NON-MARITAL PROPERTY-ITEM3c Eric Spangler lists all property in which a spouse has a legal or equitable interest which is claimed to be excluded from marital property: Description of property: Employee Stock Option Address: Merck Medco Name of Owner: Eric Spangler i ! Note: Option was granted on March 4, 1997. after separation and is, therefore, non-marital. I I MARITAL PROPERTY-ITEM 3d Eric J.W, Spangler lists all marital property in which either or both spouses have a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person as of the date this action was commenced: Description of property: Savings Bond Certificates Address: In possession of Donna Spangler Account Number: Name of Owner: For Shannon, Kevin and Ryan Spangler t r " MARITAL PROPERTY-ITEM Sb Eric J.W. Spangler lists all marital property in which either or both spouses have a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person as of the date this action was commenced: Description of property: Checking Account Address: Account Number: 159393-11 Name of Owner: Donna Spangler MARITAL PROPERTV- ITEM6b Eric J.W. Spangler lists all marital property in which either or both spouses have a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person as of the date this action was commenced: Description of property: Savings Account Address: Account Number: 159393-01 Name of Owner: Donna Spangler ~ MARITAL PROPERTY-ITEM6c Eric J.W. Spangler lists all marital property in which either or both spouses have a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person as of the date this action was commenced: Description of property: Investment Savings Account Address: Account Number: 175092 Name of Owner: Eric Spangler Note: Formerly Merck Stock Options sold in February, 1997 and 1998 and $15,000.00 used by Defendant to buy the Toyota Pickup truck listed under Item 2. 'j I. . , . l F r ! , " ( 4. s= your CQmplcl;C cu......v........ -".-,-- -T" --. spa;Wi.z%d ~ you hn~ r=ved. I' .! !: I j .. Ii i I' I. ' 'Il I; I ~ _....... .d..... _..l' . . . . II. I S. St1.te w",,",,:a)'Ou ~ ~ 1;...10 or t""~cip;l1c m :m,.l~ ,n n::~nt, p::IISloc, " ! ~,.,.;"g or any oth::r ~faTcd 2bll fur my =t~~ Jl~ a:# ,:: ; . provide the foUowiDi: infomulion: ~~ ~~ . ; ; I ~!. , (a) The naturOofthaplao; ~,~~,'(.!: I> 'fI\M, ~: I : ~.J~ (b) The Il3II1C and address of the enti\)' or persoo providi,ng the p1m;~Il'fDCO I. I r (c) Whether your interest in the plan is vested, in pay S1ll1\I.S Of otherv; se; .(;IJ1.IJ~ IP~ (d) Tfool vested. stm the d=:md eondirioo.s underwh'icli IDe plm' vest; 'ran..(1I1f41' (c) Whether the plm is cootribmory or non-conttibUlOIYi ;J~' ' (t) (( contributory, tb :wlount you eOlltribt:ted prior to: ~Jur s..-par:llitp from " : ' your spouse, d:lin...-nting those colllribations occ~ prior to :md after your firUl . I separation; foil" . 11' (g)' If contributory, the amount your ~p\o)'cr con:zib~-d during thd: , . m3I1iazc, dclin:ating !host conditions ~ prior and subsequent io your fitcl : i I : scpanUion; .v ~~ ' ; ! i,! ' . (b) . lfnoo-wntributo:?': the amotl11t .}'OUI' ~ployer coiir~uIed duri~ the : i : =e.,,<>e, clclin<=B those conOJtlClns ~ pnor and ~uwt.loyour fiIJ.:l1 " ,:. separation: ~i'\t;e .l:l"ql~ \$ l\0II-='*" 'Murf' ~ enHr-e bAl~ hl\o$ ~ co~b.j.kd (i) ~~~'=ed in the pbll d'Jring the lIUlri:1g~ .! :, (j) If you b.3.ve the rigilt to ....ithdnwan)' monies from:thl: p[1lI, bow;much ii' money:nay you withdraw and :!.t wlut intcrr.llS; (:see. o.J.,u:>) ,I' ; . (k) If you have y,i\hdrawll and/or borrowed any moni~s fromllI1Y r' I P,Ian.:l. , ' iodic:ne when md how =b \\'a.5 botrowed :md wh~r ~ m.o6'ey, m'tlSt be: d or i rep;tid; !JIll ; : ::: .' (I) The dale on which you are entitled to =ei'le ~ent or ~kin ;!! . benefits; C: e.... ~-..A) 'I ; i' . , '(m) 1M present Wancc or your int:r'of! in the fund; ~ ~ :1. : :: " .1 (n) Aniount ofbencfits receivable ~ month upon reti.~t; ~~!lf) fe:fi~T' (0) IftbQ'C lIl:C IlDY survivor benefits. give a descripti~riithereof; ~~ 'bid,,?) i, (p) Atw:h a complete copy of lllIY such plan. ;' ': ' Ii ~ it> On ~'I~I'Il, ~~f":'I'+ '6 ~ll~1Je.\!) ~~ ~ in(!<~'(;iccqWrl- ~ ~ Ot'l ue~ ~~t\lT\e'# -Wwi~"~, ., ':! '" (YN~f'l1 ~Ul'Iorrt- tA)i~ ~11~r ~,It1'lS!~'eh~;ble: 10 eltd- II- e.ek~o.tt- A-fl\c.r AAA1M ~ ~ SQ' w"% A'l-; ~~+ 7''fitC '"l 't:;:.fd .=1'~t /I<> '" ,1,~1. t~~I~ ft. ~ ~~,!li:7~'~~. . D5 N~At Qor1'"\ oP ~ (k. rMrT'eJ ~clpfllt\s i~ It ~\i~ Pl>;? 'JDI~ im) ~i~ AnOl.4ttl-~~(.1.,r1Jl ~~ Por \olfIm~1 '~~.1.DMk ~j 66S29l.trtW.t OJ. Jlrq<.<;:.-~ ~ Hf't/lU.l . :. rT . = ~d ~:~ =l-~t-E13 !' I ! ! f i ~ , , II i I , I' \ I i' 6t'd t-.i' ~ --;,"\" ~, ,~. '-.'~.'" ~ .'.-........~ . '"" .... -.-... ..--., .- ~~. -"!""~..~~. .', .-.-... --- Chip L .. l;"I'"'' "I"llo. t''''i UP"'Il/1l: lI.d.'Il.-. u\/lI/IN" \5. ,," " S,.: ., \:".,q ., Canltl~Ullanl So:'27. '0 S:H .;~ SI.lI:J Sl DlvI<1end 10 00 10 ')/) Se,., ')1 Unre.altlcd Oian:Lou 118',6) II', ,!J 51, Hit H III :,,~ , f , I , : :..:.. .<: '-~ ,. .. ~~. :...~. ~ j S';.,.Ol 51. :i.'iS 91 ClolOinz: Ualance I)b/JU/19"1~ 10.393.6) Illl.79 Sll,692. Il SJ8, '38. SS ::.. _-'.f::-~'. ,-.:.r~;:;: JNfORI\IATION ABOUT YOUR ACCOUNT"; SJI:u)' DefeIT.J1 Accounl S~6.S";:...w: Comp.Jny .\1.:lI.:hin~ Cmtribution .-\.:counl SIO.!:N.$.10; ..\Jdltional Compan;.' \IJt.:h S94fl.QI: Rollov.r so.oo: Ir your .Jc':tJunt hJd been Jistrihuled oJn 6. JOQ8. y\)U v.oulJ ha....e rCl,;:in:d the equi...alt;nl of 136.9505 shares of .\t~rck Common SloJ..:k at J price 0(SI33.75 per share. I(you hJ\e .Jny questions please canuel Fideiity Customer Services. If you are hCJ.ring impaired call Fidelity s TOO numb.:r at I'SOO.610..UJl5. .I . Page ,2 11I1t.O./0000 ~4n ~ 401(1\) ~Avin()~ Plnn: A. CWTent participant in the 401 (k) Savings Plan B. Defined Contribution Plan C. Employee is cum:nlly 100% vcst...-d in all contributions and earnings based on salary deferrals, as well as contributions and earnings provided by Merck-Medco MlIIIlIged ClII'll, L.L.C. D. N/A E. Contributory F. That lU110unt is unavailable G. That amount is UlI.1vaiJable H. That lU110unt is unavailable l. The current balance is $38,820.48, as of 8/17/98. 1. Participants are eligible to requcst full distributions. Lo:l1lS from the 401(k) Plan are available on a shon-term basis, or for the purchase of a primary residence. Participants are also eligible to request a H:ll'dship distribl!tion to satisfy a h~a\")' :41d imm~dUlu financial need. Hardship dinributions llre only available from the participant's own contributions, salary defemls and rollover contributions. K. Participants ",bo hal'e 5 years, or more, of credited servicc arc 100% vested in the 401(1.:) Savings Plan. L. A :-;onnal Retirement distribution from the 40 I (k) Plan is available for participants at age 65, and on an Early R~rement basis for participants who re.lch agc 55 v.ith at least 3 years of credi~ senice. M. S~e ilem r above. N. Distributions are paid in full from the 401(k) Savings P!.ln. O. A Death Benefit will be paid to a p:uticipant's designated beneficiary if the participant dies prior to receiving 100% of the vested account balance in the 40 I (1.:) savings Plan. Death B::nefits are paid as lump sum distributions. . i t. r I ! "I I 1 TOTFl. P. OS ~ -":..' ~ .r ,~ ~. ,~ , " ,. ,. " ,". ~ ..~ .~ . NON-MARITAL PROPERTY-ITEM24b Eric Spangler lists all marital debts in which a spouse has a legal or equitable interest which is claimed to be excluded from marital property: Description of Debt: Student Loans owed to SLSC Name of Owner: Eric Spangler l l NON-MARITAL PROPERTY- ITEM 25 Eric Spangler lists all property in which a spouse has a legal or equitable interest which is claimed to be excluded from marital property: Description of property: Gun cabinet, queen size bed, footboard, headboard, frame, maple dresser and nightstand and 19" television. Name of Owner: Eric Spangler t , , f I I i r '1 PROPERTY TRANSFERED- ITEM 26b Eric Spangler lists all property in which either or both spouses had a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person and which has been transferred within the preceding three years: Description of property: Certificates of Deposit, Rolled into Investment Savings Account Address: Members First FCU Account Number: 135439-40 Name of Owner: Eric Spangler .;: :J ':i - '-. i~I" '" co ;'; 1;:1 M <: 5= '''1 J. ~ " -, I" - a.> ~ I~ ,.,. - > _ ~ _I -, - 5 ~~ B ~ Gj ,;;~.(~ ~ I.... ': ~ i'l -3 II; ~ I~ ~ ~.~ :t:J - :.. ~..!.t:ii~~;~ = 1.;:' = '3 ':l ~ ""'" Y.rTl--12~~11 ; ~ ~ II /lr-~.... - -_~_' l :5 ~ j :;' ~ :- : ., J--'O~.<-- .:..-.::: . .... - ~ " "' H ~_.;] -~ Q ~ ~ j , ., 5 u './j~ ':; ~ g ;....: ~:;; ... V; B:;' .., ~J~ ij p;;, ~ .....- ~ ~ \_ 0 IJJ< ." ~.~ - ~ . . .: :: :'.('00 ~ ~ ~ ~ () ~ tz~ '!"'. '-A' a.> u - o Z >- - ..... .- ...- .... <l.i U J~. d ~ ~w ~ "'J< t1 :; ~~ ~ :J :::J", ( j ~e "' I ~ I ~ ~ ~ !:J S! 'l ~.- ,~ 0"""" /gl' 1;5 I i I , I I I : I i I ,do,o!./ ~ < j ~ ~E:! ....,.-:' - . ..., -- .. , -'-' < ~.; ~g ~- .- .. :it~ "!'i~ c': "0 .:." ~.~ ~~ ~'" ~!! ~= ~o ~- :'::J ~~ ~~ u~ ~~ ~~ g] ~ .u ~; '3 u u = u5 -~ I ::::a = -!l.!! u<~ I ;~ -;; ,::.'"2 ~ __::J cJ .5-5 ~ - 5 :-:::1 ~5~ ~.; ; H ~ '.' ,1 ;; ~ ~ ~ ~ / .eN! ~VJU=~~ ~). C ~ C 0 U '~--- ; ;; ;; : : I ~~ ~ ~ VJ ~ ~ ~ ~~~~~ ""5.. ..., ~ ~ ...., ..,.c .~ 00 ~~ =~ ~ . ~,g ~~ g;; ~" ~.~ ~,. ~~ ~~ cjj ~~ Ou 7l" u"" 51! ]!.'i -." ~~ -~ u- u~ ,g; J:25 ~." :a ::e -~ '. - I .;:.= = rl ' ", Cr-J - - ~ .; ;;::. . H~ ji}~l~' }~ii~;H z... _... _ 7-_ "'-:J -" :,,_..:J ..,- < ;: z. .......:3'.~, f. oJ C ,~ --! ~ ; . :: i.... : Q _ _..5 c:.:: . ~~....... . "ii - .. ':: . .. ~..J:i;.;.; ......"1.-=~': t. :-.;;,..: ~e:l S!::U~ ~.~~...,-,::.~~'::I1~.:-t )0 <~:=..;-'1::""" ......__.~-:..i(.. _ ~ _ ~.~.... 'q ~ ;>0' 3. '"..:. 5. .~ j ..a.' ;;; =:..i--"~;:r.-:..':~.' ., z'.:)~ _\.s.(./~: ,,'2-,. z;,~ '!~ ;:!;~ 2:: :: ?-' i':~ ~:'~ i'-_~ j': :: 1 ~ ; ~ ; ~ ~ ..; :> z'" ~ =.5- '''.. ,;/!_ _.. .. :.. ~ i :-; ~ ;~~iSlH1tHti!t1H c:: t:~ '.:-' -.-.. <...{]'"\.' .' " "('" (J).'j" .-A' ': .:; :. -.= .2'. ~.'._' :~~; ..- ~ l,~ ~ 3 ~ -= ~ ; '": =: ; r~yj' " , \J 4 ,', _'S ~ ~_- ,?, . ":';' . . - ,~,':~:,Hi:1 ;f.f . I _~., . -"-~";', ' _~ ~. :,; i :,,; . .'j-,- 'J ...:j - -= . ~:-:-: ::: 3 :; ~" :!"' \\ ~ ~ i :.' _f r:/t ~1:~~' ..'~'- C> ~~ _ ..0 ; ~'.:j: u' .:i ~.~ .~/..L .~~< ! ." ll. .: ',,;,;f;' ':':.0 ;.i~~m'.~i---:~&'~ .~ '. --IJJ' ..'. .-1 to ; ~~.\'.':'-'!g':- ., '"~-'-o .a..OD _~ . .'1' :.1 .~~~:'-Oo,.;,. \~...... a:: ""!,~:.:... " _ ;'. ',' . ~::Ji . _l--~' . ~.ltI ~,/~~~~ .~~".:..~~_. q ~::r"~ . "'It ' . - ~ ... 1lI'..J ":';'~{l.j:...;:', ~'7'f ...:....:<. ,~'.! -. .-.-....;::.:.: ~. . ..~ ~. '. " " . i ~ Z Q .. . ,jj a: :> ... <: z Cl in en a: w III :ii w :ii t t " Lii ... <: c - 3- ~ .. i!lJUl ......J....;;; " ;7 ~ ~ ~ ?- I < ~ ':::)t ..l' I~" d";' - uJ ~ ..... :-, <: ~:-.I U ~ ~I~ ~ g S! "1 '" ~ H C/)z ";: a:: , : ~ 5 U.I ...., ~ u ~ Q,): 0;:;; :.! ,D.- i' W lj : 0 ~ - ..J ~ R; ~ 1 ~U \j .- - o Z >- - 'C ::l - - .... :2: C) - ('J u .- - .- - C) u C) u . . ""! . ':: -.... "! ~ ~ i ..; ~==3~.i.;~~-:. ~11' ~<-r i =3-0I.i~"-\,o~C"J:. i.~~~~:1~ ... z ~ "'. ~"':. ~ ". ~ . ~' z>-< ..l",,--~ ~~l'L~: <<u"':".;-;...:;;~~. ~"';"'!'':'~::::4s ==="-'::.o_~ ',1';"2.,_,." ~.:j...,... ~ ~>-!::z:-';..!:,~S"'":: -'~.n ;;j=-l n . ~ - IlJ ~ ;:":.,; ~ C ~ ~'. < - _ II _ ~ .. "7 _ ri ~~~rJt.:i~h gH i1HH \1 ='-__~""='_~" ~ _""'" I z" >- ..:oJ ~.:: ' L." ~'1; , , ,~~ .-; ':i <"" z,~.:: _ ;:', _~ >:! '" : ~ ~ , ! H ~ U.ij.J} H!.~H i H l Ii 1--<-..- ..', 'I ~:. ~,'r.'.:' .~:~'. '? 2 ~ f. ~ (i?;.:( '.' 3T~ ~ : ~ ~j I : 11.'.,jH!Hi I'~ ';~ . ': ' ;:F ..<.~ ! 1.. ~ :_.;. ~__:: i_~, ~:'-~t"c _ ~' _ . ' _ ," ,~:r ,--.. ~"~ .n~ ] r}J.~ 1 -',' . '-. :- \.XX.:. ':.0 :':Q'f\':" :N - ..' - .: ... co ~C2:<:!"':'" :>! . 1t '" -.' '\}<" III ':~:i~;?:~-'~~:'l,..: u ~~."~ "':~'-:J.a.;..(I).a= ~=:'.m -<' ':~~_ ~'~-z.'~ -. ::J "'. .. " <CUI <0 ?~!;(':~~:i'..z ~ ~ .\. ..Z,~ ~...O..... Z -~::~ <: ~-f~ .~,~ .., a: " '-..::I: '~ "::~"l:l[:.,-:":..:".", ... "-:~'-' .:' . '-..:E ..... .:... ;.-..., . ,. u :; Cl W ~ ,- ~ ~! "'.~ :j~ ::J~ Jw " " ~ . < .. W .,.~ 'l~ 6J:17'1~ -~ '-6 11 0' ~ '13 ~ :; I'~ :::1 1-' I~' I:i i~! i I :.2! " co .,. I: C) "" 'l' III n !~i :::: i<: .:: ':2' '.1 ~ '~I ::1"'1' ~i ~I Ii . '" '" -::.- \k ~ ~ ~ - :; c u u .. ~ = g - - - \OJ _ :J =- - :5 ~ < ~OUVJ - U U I- ~UC(:::: =~g:g ~~~:;;.: - u ..... u 0:;: ""'" =- '::::_ :~~=u ~o2~< CD.... _..... -==v;:: Vi V1 ~ 0 ...J ~~~~3 ~ ~ Q C ..c 0'; ;:~ ~~ -~ 'u 3!! c= ;;'3 ~a ~'g aI.: ~o. .u ~= ~o ~- c" -u u., ~~ -=-~ -::., " - ~ ::; "" .= ::; -"5 _ u ;j= 52 :g~ u _ u~ -;::;~ :::", 11'=i -.; ;:5 1J'\:;:! !; ~ ~., ~-g .,~ -., ;:;~ -=;. 5 u o~ u~ iS~ ~;:; ~ - "N;'\~i i ;) _ ";= . = u . > 00 u,:J -c UJ !!.~ ,,~ e~ o~ ~., U"" ~.- '0>- E~ ~- c c !:~ Ou D"- ~- u~ Sa ~~ ='0 ~c ~.. -::U ~~ g~ ~" -., '~'S: ;::ii Iii .... < ~ I 3 - < ^ ~ ~ V". ~~ 2 .; :: r t~ :: <:;: <l: a.. ~ s Iii c: :J .... < z o Iii III c: W '" :: w ::< ...... t I t "I PROPERTY TRANSFERED- ITEM 26d Eric Spangler lists all property in which either or both spouses had a legal or equitable interest individually or with any other person and which has been transferred within the preceding three years: Description of property: Certificates of Deposit, Rolled into Investment Savings Account Address: Members First FeU Account Number: 135447-40 Name of Owner: Eric Spangler (for Ryan Spangler) @! "', SQ' .~ 1- '<, t~! ell -' :iii u u .- ....1 .... 0 <, ",. Z >- ! .... I .;:: I ::l 01 .... =1 (tl ~ L:.Ji 2: <I -, ~I ell .- <=, - - w (tl .... u U .... .- .., - , .- J .... .... ell ? U ; .:; '" ~ ~ i8 Cfj~ ~ ~ ~: ~ ffi ~ \~ ;; u ""4./- .:::! ~ . (",: '?! w .. ~ g: t""'"...J .... ~.=:; ~.6 ~a ~_.... ~. -- J. J~ ~ := .....w~ thI ~~ ,:( .J ,- ~'J 1 rr/>- 5U;: 0; ......:,:: '-l5 ~ffi ~< n.U \ -"= ....,j... - - # 0: '" u w .... " o w U ;: g ""' ~ " ,.., ':1:1 '" "'~ ~ '" .,.. " to- .,.. .,.. ~) n . ~ 5 ~ ~.. ~ ,- "'""i "" !; ~ ~ f :~~Vi ~=~~2 - -' -..., - " :t - ~ IS." % E !- '.... - '. '-' 1_..; -;:.... J==":"=-:" ..., <l l.lI .... l1J S ~ I1l ::J: I '" lU \ '< II I ' I I I I. , i .: i ' I .1 ' ; O'OQ II ~ J , , < , -== ~ . 3 ~ < V1 ~ -~ ~ v, ::: '-' ~ E .2 .... , ~ , ~j - , , ~ S .:? ~ ~ g k~ ~~:....g :h'~n.. ~:~iHnL z: ... "'.. .. .' So - '!! . -=" ~ ,.. < -:-~ .,. ="~ ~ . ~ ": - -= - . " ..- <<u.... ...=.;:- ;:.. -l!"'~=501ol~ 0- ""::l .., 2 < ",., -!l". _., z-~;:'1Il = ~ :l,O. ..:'~ "I"!:;";...J 'i <...;: z. 'J ~._ _ ,.~' .__ . ~ ~ _ , _ ':: ~ ,.:1 = ;; =.; '?:= ~_": ~'l := -: 1:! '# ~ ~ =~:-:~"..j~.':-:''''r. <:-:::: ;J=""'! s ::.....;.. .... c.,o :: ~ ;;.' .~.~ = : .; '"!. ~ i '7 ~;~~i,i3:HF:'~H i1 ~~2~ ~ < ... ~ .II - . c -'. . ~ ...... '.;; 1.1 :II: ':::_:l.-~~~.=... '::.' z ~.:. ,. =.3.=. i"':= Szl"'";~:...~.:.!:..:! ~ .~ !?~-=;': "li 3 ::;..:>:-:':::.-1jc....}.:..;._:.O...:i::; ~:: ~',o .... ';! =' z ~..; =" -<!..:.,? t~ -' ~ 0. ~ .. : :" ... - - :.;J ~ - ::j ~ " - it .....tf -= :. . : :I ~ :a ~;: ~ <=.~~:i:l.-~'~ ~'~:. .~:::~ ,= , - . .- '(r--;... , ~ ~ .. ~ 2 -.-:---. I .. . _ . 5 0-1 {~ :3 ~ : : ~"I"" '.': , g '3 - '" ? ..: l'0,-,.;. .: ::>"--1 .: - .'C 1-' 'C.J". f- - <:,;..:,; -.0-. "-- 1" ..: " ._ .'2:~ .,.! ~.}~ ~rn ~ -. .;-.. Cfi.~.~T~'~: ;.: -. '. ,.-~ .... ..... <Xl ...~t -~; -..N .,. .' :-".. ':" :.th ~ -,- 1II <.:1.. ~ :,.. . <: . ll.. . . ......'- .. " j" :.~: ". h' . '- c: w ~ =< :; U CO U U < ~ '" U ~ 0 ;; .... W '" U '" '" CO m - ~ ~ ;;; in 0 CO .. .. ~ w C CO ~ :; CO U U '" '" - ~ 5 ;; 0'" u '" u _ '" g s ~ VI ... W ~ ~- u '" CO ~ - ~ !:: '" '" o CO .. .. w w o CO ..... ~_'_'__u---....__..~ !!.; .:~ ~.:; - u ~u ~~ ii~ -g;::; E ,9- UU ~ .S ~- UQ, -u U _ -"= ~o ~- =~ - " o~ 'B~ ~:.:! ~= "" ~ -~ :::.:; -.;; 2~ ~~ ~ ~ :3;; ';::j~ !:i '-.I ~~ ~- -~ ., = - " ~.1 ~~ '" ;: :::.., -~ 1"lI~ ~:~ ~~ '" ,,~ u .;:; 5. .~~ or( . ~ t.J _ . ..~ ou ~-" ;;~ i~ ~o ~~ =~ ~~ ~.:: ~~ e~ o~ ~." ~:!! .,,> uu ~~ ~~ ~~ Ou Do.. :~ =~ "ii,:l =." ~~ .-=.. '='U ~~ 0'; i5 .~~ ;::'" W to- <t o W a: ::> to- <t Z (:J in '" a: UJ Cl ;l; UJ ;l; Michael S. Travis ID No 77399 4076 Markel Slreel, Suite 209 ClUl1p lIill,I'^ 17011 (717) 731-9502 i 1" , < DONNA A. SPANGLER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff v. NO. 97 - 197 ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, CIVIL ACTION - LAW DIVORCE/CUSTODY Defendant PRAECIPE FOR RULE TO FILE BILL OF PARTICULARS IN DIVORCE To the Prothonotary: Pursuant to Rule 1920.21(a). please enter a rule as of course on Plaintiff, Donna Spangler, to file a bill of particulars under Section 3301(a) of the divorce code. ~~6'- 1 a . ravis Attorney for Defendant RULE A rule is issued on Plaintiff, Donna Spangler, to file a bill of particulars within twenty (20) days of service or suffer a judgement of non-pros against the cause of action under 3301 (a) of the divorce code. hi (l,~~;,~ ~ ~.9 'Pr thonotary C7-" Date: 11'1 .1. /99( MICHAEL S. TRAVIS ATTORNCY AT LAW .076 MARKeT STRE:[l, SUITt Z09 CAMP HILL, P/. '7011 TeLtPHoNE 17171 731-P!>OZ 'AX 17171 731.0511 August 2, 1999 C1II1is R. Long Prothonotary One Counhouse Square Carlisle. pA 17013 RE: Donna A. Spangler \'. Eric J.\\'. Spllngler, No. 97-197, /1/ Dil'orC(' Deal' Mr. Long: Enclosed 1")1' filing. pkasc !ind a Praecipe for Rule as of course. for a Bill of Paniculars in this divorce. Plcase contact mc should ~ ou havc any qucstions 01' concern" Very truly yours. ..,;:';::':': />' ~li~II.:X~.~;a~';s-- !\ttOrllL'Y for DefL'lldalll MST/dt Encl. pc: Dcfcndant Kathy M. Shugart, Esquire E. Robel1 Elicker, II, Esquirc ~lichacl S, Tra"is II) No 77399 4076 Markel Slrcel. Suilc ~Ol) Camp lIill.I'A 17011 (71 7)731-950~ DONNA A. SPANGLER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff \'. NO. 97 - 197 ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, CIVIL ACTION - LA W DIVORCE/CUSTODY Defendant PRAECIPE FOR RULE TO FILE BILL OF PARTlCl'LARS IN DIVORCe To the Prothonotary: Pursuant to Rule 19~O.~ I (a). please enter a rule as of course on Plaintiff: Donna Spangler. to file a bill ofpal1iculars under Scction 3301(01) of the di,'ol"CC code. B)::--::::,::.0S-. ~' . .--Alicha'crS. Tra\'is . Attomey for Dcfcndanl RULE A rule is issued on Plaintiff. Donna Spanglcr. to file a bill of pal1iculars within twenty (20) days ofser\'icc or suffer ajudgelllenl of non-pros against the cause of action under 3301(a) of the divorce code. Prothonotar)' Date: DONNA A. SPANGLER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA t r PllIintiff v. NO. 97 - 197 ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, CIVIL ACTION - LA W DIVORCE/CUSTODY Ill'fcndllnl CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I. Michael S. Tra\'is. CCJ1ify that 1 ha\'c this day scr\'cd truc nnd correct copy of the forcgoing documcnt by first class mnil. postnge prepnid. on thc following pcrsoll. nddrcsscd ns follows: Knthy M. Shugnn. Esquirc 2i S. Arlcne Strcet P.O. Box 6315 Hnrrisburg. PAl i 112-0315 Dntcd: s/~) 1'/ v/.~.:; / E. RobCJ1 Elickcr. II. Esquirc C) Nonh Hanovcr Strcct Cnrlisle. PA 17013 ~-/ ~" yy~/,: -LC>-- . ..-/i iclfncl S. Travis ill No. 77399 4076 Markct Street, Suitc 209 Cnmp Hill. PA 17011 (717)731-9502 Fnx731-9511 Attomcy for Dcfcndnnt Michael S. Travis ID No 77399 4076 Markel Street. Suite 209 CWl1p lIi11,l'A 17011 (717)731-9502 ~ '. DONNA A. SPANGLER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff v. NO. 97 - 197 ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, CIVIL ACTION - LAW DlVORCE/ClJSTODY Defendant PRAECIPE FOR JUDGMENT NON PROS FOR FAILURE TO FILE BILL OF PARTICULARS IN DIVORCE To the Prothonotary: Pursuant to Rule 1920.21(b). plaintitThaving not filed a bill of particulars within twenty days of service, please enter judgment of non pros against the plaintitTwith respect to the cause of action for divorce under Section 3301(a) of the divorce code. B~~ -*trcha S. Travis Attorney for Defendant JUDGMENT OF NON PROS A Judgment of Non Pros is entered against PlaintitT, Donna Spangler, with respect to the cause of action for divorce under Section 3301(a) of the divorce code. ~' I . , LI../L.LuJ P thonotary D", ~.L1Jl I /) /I l H'JJI^ /!J. '771 MICHAEL S. TRAVIS ATTORNEY AT LAW ~ l , <4076 MARKeT STRrn. SUITE: Z09 CAMP HILL, PA 17011 t. TCL.CPHONE '7171 '3HH~OZ FA,>. 1?l71 731.&511 (~ (Q) [P))f September 20, 1999 CURTIS R. LONG PROTHONOTARY ONE COURTHOUSE SQUARE CARLISLE, PA 17013 , l i i I RE: Donna Spangler \', Eric Spangler, No, 97-197,/11 Di\'O/'ce Dear M... Long: Enclosed for filing please find the inventory of Eric Spangler, Defendant, hetein. contact me should you hal'e any questions or eoneellls. Please Very truly yours, llliehael S. Tral'is Attorney for Defendant MSTil111l Ene!. pe: Defendant E, Robert Elicker, IT, Esquire, wlEnc!. Kathy M. Shllgm1, Esquire 1(at/i!} %. S/iug/iart ; (. 27 South Arlene Street P.O. Box 6315 Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17112-0315 Phone: (717) 540-8511 Fax: (717) 671-9601 ~ . Atlorney at Law E. Robert Elickcr, II, Divorcc Mastcr Cumbcrland COllnty 9 North Hanovcr Strcet Carlislc, P A 17013 Septcmber 23, 1999 I~e: Spangler \', Spllnl\ler 1 look forward to a pre-trial eonfercncc on this rnattcr. Thank YOll. Dear Attorney Ellicker: Enclosed pleasc find the original Plaintifrs Prc-Trial Statement for filing in the abovc-referenced case. I will be tiling an Inventory tomorrow llml an Incomc and Expense shortly thereafter, if not tomorrow. cor7diallY, , ---:K fH C-- -~//"I, \' UV\. ._~~ Kathy M. Shughart, Esq. ~ I ., I ec: Michael S. Travis, Esquirc Donna Spangler DONNA A. SPANGLER, Plaintiff : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO. 97 - 197 vs. CIVIL ACTION - LAW ERIC J.W. SPANGLER, Defendant IN DIVORCE ORDER AND NOTICE SETTING HEARING TO: Donna A. Spangler , Plaintiff Kathy M. , Counsel for Plaintiff Eric J .W. Spangler Defendant , Michael S. Travis , Counsel for Defendant You are directed to appear for a hearing to take testimony on the outstanding issues in the above captioned divorce proeeedings at the Office of the Divorce Master, 9 Hanover Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania on the of North day which at a.m., at place and time you will be given the opportunity to present witnesses and exhibits in sllpport of your case. '1r ,g,,',: 'tJ" ,>,," id,,' ',dge Date of Order and Notice: By: Divorce Master IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. CUMBEHLAND COUNTY BAH ASSOC I AT I ON 2 LlBEHTY AVENUE CAIlLISLI.:, PA 170]) TELEPHONE ('11'1) 24'J-3Ih() DONNA A. SPANGLER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA vs, NO, 97 - 197 CIVIL !, ERIC J.W, SPANGLER, Defendant IN DIVORCE ORDER OF COURT AND NOW, thi, ~ d., OJt~ 2000, the parties and counsel having entered into an agreement and stipulation resolving the economic issues on March 24, 2000, the date set for a Master's hearing, the agreement and stipulation having been transcribed, the appointment of the Master is vacated, and counsel can conclude the proceedings by the filing of a praecipe to transmit the record with the affidavits of consent of the parties so that a final decree in divorce can be entered. BY THE COURT, cc: Kathy M. Shughart Attorney for Plaintiff Michael S. Travis Attorney for Defendant i ~ , .. ,"/'n'", //". '/",j ,/. E. ROBERT ELICKER. II j, /-#{fu- I ~~~ ~ 4(~ (-",-,-<--....l'. ~J, ~~~. M ~ cJu..,. ~ LL.. ~ -re..J'" ~ a..tlNl ~ ().ruJ:> ~ .Lv<- ~ ;.x (JJO..P,..v.At ~ ~ -t,....... .4 ~ . )... ~~crv-~~~ ~ Lt..L ...DU""~ c:u ~ ctt lIJ.I~' /' _n. .....J.P... 9. J ~ ~ . I (VA- u..J:" '7"'- ~ --"'1~..p'fl ~ G.- 6--.L. ~ ~ ~ ~- ~ <.0 /6/Lo. u 1999, raising the economic claims of alimony, al imony pendente lite, and counsel fees and costs, The parties were married on November 16, 1991, and separated January 19, 1997, The parties are the natural parents of three children, Shannon Ashley, born February 11, 1988; Ryan Joseph, born February 20, 1990; and Kevin Michael, born June 28, 1992, The parties, by agreement on June 30, 1998, stipulated that the children would be in the primary custody of wife, After negotiations this morning, counsel have indicated that the parties have reached an agreement with respect to the outstanding economic issues, An agreement is going to be placed on the record in the presence of the parties, No changes can be made to the substantive agreement as placed on the record; however, the parties and counsel can review the draft of the agreement for typographical errors and can make any correction of typographical errors as required. Once the agreement has been transcribed and any corrections of typographical errors have been made, the parties will be requested to affix their signatures affirming the terms of settlement as placed on the record, However, after the agreement has been placed on the record, no substantive changes can be made to the agreement even though the agreement is not signed; the parties will be bound by the terms of the settlement when they leave this hearing room, When the Master receives a signed copy of the agreement affirming the terms of settlement, or if the parties or one of the parties refuses to sign, the Master will proceed to prepare an order vacating his appointment so that counsel can prepare a praecipe transmitting the record to the Court requesting a final decree in divorce, The agreement is going to be sent to counsel , ~ after it has been transcribed for review of typographical errors rather than having the parties and counsel return later today to do the review. Mr, Travis. MR, TRAVIS: 1. With respect to division of personal property, the parties have agreed to divide between them and have already divided between them, to their mutual satisfaction, joint bank accounts, stock portfolios, personal effects, household furniture and furnishing and all other articles of personal property used in common, Husband specifically retains ownership of his Merck stock options; his investment savings account, No. 175092; his ESPP with his employer; certificate of deposit, No, 135439-40; checking account, No, 135439-11; savings account, No. 135439-01; and securities account, No, 1075-48459, Wife specifically retains ownership of her checking account, No, 159393-11; savings account, No, 159393-01, Husband will retain control of the certificates of deposit investments for the children which are deemed property for the children. 2. In exchange for the above mutual agreements contained through this agreement, husband shall pay to wife the sum of $100,000,00 cash, The payment of the $100,000.00 will be 3, The voluntary payments for wife and children in the amount of $450,00 per week shall continue until April 1, 2000, At that time the child support will be $1,375.00 per month and wife will receive alimony in the amount of $575,00 per month, The alimony paid to wife will be non-modifiable and shall be paid for a period of sixty (60) months beginning in the month in which the divorce decree is entered, The payment of alimony shall terminate in the event that either party dies or wife cohabits with a person of the opposite sex or remarries, The alimony shall automatically terminate upon the receipt by wife of the 60th payment. ~. f ( I made within thirty (30) days to wife, " 4, With respect to life insurance, husband will maintain a life insurance policy naming the children as the beneficiaries of his policy in an amount not less than $150,000.00 until the youngest child reaches the age of 18. 5. With respect to automobiles, the parties are owners of two automobiles, a 1999 Isuzu Trooper and a 1993 Chevrolet Lumina driven by wife, Neither car is encumbered by a loan, Wife shall have sole and exclusive possession of the Chevrolet Lumina and husband shall have sole and exclusive possession of the Isuzu Trooper, Husband shall also have title to a 1994 motorcycle and the parties will take whatever action is required to transfer documents of ownership as soon as possible following entry of the divorce decree, Both parties agree to assume all responsibility and hold each other harmless for any and all liability, costs and expenses associated with the ownership of the above vehicles, Cost for any transfer or fees shall be borne equally by the parties, 6. With respect to distribution of the real property, ::'lsband and wife hold title as tenants by the entireties to the premises identified as 418 Linden Street, Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, The parties agree that wife shall have sole and exclusive possession of the property, Husband shall transfer to wife his right, title, and interest in said real estate within thirty (30) days of today's date, Husband's counsel shall hold the deed to the property until it is refinanced, There is also a mortgage encumbering the property with GMAC Bank in the approximate amount of $79,000.00, Wife shall obtain a refinance or have the mortgage assigned to her name within a period of three (3) years. If she fails to have the property either assigned or refinanced in her name, at that point, the property will be listed for sale with an agent acceptable to both parties and any equity on the sale of the property would be the property of wife, Any costs incurred in a refinance will be borne equally between the parties. Upon wife's refinancing the property, husband's counsel shall deliver the deed to wife. 7, With respect to pension and retirement accounts, husband and wife shall maintain separate pensions, lRAs and/or retirement accounts, Wife relinquishes any and all right, title, and interest she may have in existing or future retirement assets or benefits of husband's pension, retirement, cash balance retirement plan, 40l(k), investment savings, ESPP or other accounts, Husband also relinquishes any right, title, and interest he may have in all existing or future retirement assets or benefits of wife's pension, retirement, 40l(k), or similar accounts. 8, With respect to medical insurance, husband and wife shall be responsible for providing their own medical insurance. The parties agree to hold each other harmless for the costs of obtaining any insurance and for medical expenses not covered by insurance after the divorce, Also, with respect to medical insurance, husband shall continue to provide medical insurance for the children, 9, With respect to marital debts, there are no marital debts of the marriage other than individual student loans. The parties agree to be responsible for their own student loans, The parties agree that neither has contracted for any debts or other obligations since separation, 10, With respect to filing of taxes, husband and wife agree to file separate tax returns for the tax year in which the divorce decree is entered. Wife will take the deduction for the mortgage and related expenses and an exemption for the minor child, Ryan. Husband will have the exemption for Shannon and Kevin. This is to continue until the children are no longer dependents, 11, With respect to counsel fees, each party shall be responsible for paying his or her own legal fees and expenses. However, husband has advanced $2,000.00 for payment of wife's counsel fees which shall be deducted from the cash lump sum payment of $100,000,00. 12. Except as herein otherwise provided, each party may THE MASTER: Do YOl! ulld(!rstalld the agreement'? MR. SPANGLER: Yes, si r. THE MASTER: Do you have any questions about it? MR, SPANGLER: No, THE MASTER: And you understand that when you leave the conference room today that you are bound by this agreement even though no documents have been signed affirming the terms of the settlement? MR, SPANGLER: Yes, I acknowledge that I have read the above stipulation and agreement, that I understand the terms of settlement as set forth herein, and that by signing below I ratify and affirm the agreement previously made and intend to bind myself to the settlement as a contract obligating myself to the terms of settlement and subjecting myself to the methods and procedures of enforcement which may be imposed by law and in particular Section 3105 of the Domestic Relations Code. WITNESS: DATE: Kathy M, Shughart Attorney for Plaintiff Donna A, Spangler Michael S, Travis Attorney for Defendant Eric J,W, Spangler MICHAEL S. TRAVIS ATTORNEY ..T LAW 4076 MA~K~T STRtET. SUIT[ ZOIiJ CAMP HILL, PA 17011 TELEPHONt t'l?l 7.11.>>e02 'AX 17171 7.11.81511 ~(Q)~W June 6, 2000 Kathy M. Shugart, Esqllire 27 S. Arlene Street P.O, Box 6315 Harrisburg,PA 17112-0315 Re: Donna Spangler \', Eric Spangler, No, 97-19'1, /11 Dil'orce Dear Kathy: It has been more than a month since 1 sent YOll the signed marital settlement agreement in this case. Usually Mr. Elicker will send notice vacating his appointment when the agreement has been entered of record. I have received no word from either you or Mr. Elicker. If your client has not signed the marital settlement agreement, kindly have her do so and send confirmation that you have filed the praecipe to transmit record. Please contact me should you have any questions or concerns. Very truly YOllrs, MSTlhrn pc: Eric Spangler Divorce Master ~ r WHEREFORE, Plaintiff rcqucsts thc Court to cntcr an alimony award in favor of Plaintiff. COUNT 4 - ALIMONY I'ENI)ENTE LITE. COUNSEL FEES, COSTS ANI) EXPENSES 9. Paragraphs I throllgh 8 arc incorporatcd by refercncc hcrein. 10. By reason of this action, Plaintiff will bc put to eonsidcrablc expense in the prcparation of her casc, in the employment of counscl and thc paymcnt of costs. 11. The Plaintiff is withollt sufficient funds to support hcrself and to meet thc costs and expenses of this litigation, and is llnablc to appropriatcly maintain hersclf during thc pendency of this action. 12. Defcndant has adcquate earnings to providc for Plaintiffs SllppOrt and to pay her eounscl fecs, costs and cxpcnscs. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffrequcsts thc eourt to award counscl fees, costs and expcnses and to compel Defendant to pay alimony pendcntc lite to Plaintiff. ANSWER TO COUNTERCLAIM COUNT 1 - EOUITABLE DlSTRIHUTION 17. Admitted. 18. Admitted. 19. Admitted. ubmitted, .... \"\ ~S~ Kathy . Shughart Attorney for Plaintiff P.O. Box6315 27 So 11th Arlene Strcet Harrisbllrg, PA 17112-0315 (717) 540-8511 Sllprcmc Court #39779 DONNA A, SI)ANGLEIt, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO,97-197 Civil Term ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, Dcfcndant Civil Aetion - Law Divorcc/Custody CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hcrcby eertify that I have on this day served a truc and correct copy ofthc Amended Complaint and Answcr to Countcrclaim on thc persons and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requiremcnts ofPa.R.Civ.P. 440. Service by first class mail addrcssed as follows: Michael S. Travis, Esquirc 4076 Market Strcet Suite 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: 9/2/99 Respectflllly submitted, - D ~~ . ~ athy M. Shllghart, Esq. Attorney for Plaintiff 27 South Arlcnc Strect P.O. Box6315 Harrisburg, P A 17112-0315 (717) 540-8511 Suprcme COllrt #39779 "'- ~ t-. ~ J >- 0 ~ "- ~ It: >-' N B~ w9 ~ Or, :t: 0;1: p: ~! a.. :..:)~ Jjl _ .",~ (V' f.rC N :~~ (Jo,. I ..'- Ull . ,l-"? G"Jlll 2: :iljjJ :1 ~ lUll.. ~ I ., ~- ~ en :; en U ~ COUNTERCLAIM COUNT I Request for Equitable Distribution of Murilall'roperty Under 311I4, 3501,3502 and 3503 of the Divorce Codc 17. The prior paragraphs of this answcr lire incorporated hcrein by rcfercncc. 18. Plaintiff and Defcndant havc acquircd propcrty, both rcal and personal, during their rnarriage from the datc of said marriage until the datc of their separation. 19. Plaintiffand Defendant have bcen unablc to agrcc as to cquitablc distribution of said property. WHEREFORE, Defendant respectflllly requests the cOllrt to eqllitably distributc thc marital property of the parties, pursuant to 3104 and 3502(a) of the Divorce Codc. Respectflllly sllbmittcd, . _C~ lchael S. Travis ID NO 77399 Attorney for Dclcndlllll 4076 Market Street, Sllitc 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 731-9502 Fax (717) 731-9511 '.- '11 - - h: ('. il. , "' " t_:. U () . -" ...( 1I_ 0- j .'-: (( ;/J L' , L , '" - 1 u.. U.. h : I I .. U C' U Q. DONNA A. SPANGLER, IN TIlE COVlU OF COMMON I'LEAS OF CUMDERLANI> COUNTY,I'ENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff v. NO, 97 - 197 ERIC J, W, SPANGLER, CIVIL ACTION - LAW DIVORCE/CUSTODY Defendant ORDER APPOINTING MASTER AND NOW, master with respect to the BY THE COURT r , t DONNA A. SPANGLER, IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY,I'ENNSYLV ANIA Plaintiff v, NO. 97 - 197 ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, CIVIL ACTION - LAW DIVORCE/CUSTODY Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I, Michael S. Travis, certify that I have this day served truc and corrcct copy of the foregoing document by first class mail, postage prcpaid, on thc following pcrson, addresscd as follows: Kathy M. Shugart, Esquirc 27 S. Arlcnc Strcct P.O. Box 6315 Harrisburg, P A 17112-0315 Dated: ~('l/97 . By':'-~ _C.c....__ dlae! S. Travis ID No. 77399 4076 Markct Strcet, Sllitc 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717)73] -9502 Fax 731-9511 Attorney for Dclcndant J ~- (Y) ~ 0; tr. ;~ II ' (- ~ ~ ;3;~ (,)...: ~l: ~I ' 'I:: .') :~. ,,;;,. ''- .):"~ , C' -.. "0- Cl:. ,... . (1) ~jl;~ - I .)/~ ~- 'z .,- :.-:j i"'i) i .-J .,0<1. IL m :'3 c ", (.> DONNA A, SPANGLER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA va, NO, 97-197 CIVIL TERM ERIC J, W, SPANGLER, Defendant : CIVIL ACTION - DIVORCE/CUSTODY STIPULATION FOR CUSTODY ORDER ~IS STIPULATION is made this 3o-h... day of J~ , 1991i.. ' by and between, DONNA A, SPANGLER, hereinafter referred to as "Mother," ERIC J, W. SPANGLER, hereinafter referred to as "Father," WHEREAS, Mother and Father are the natural parents of three minor children, Shannon Ashley Spangler, born February 11, 1988; Ryan Joseph Spangler, born February 20. 1990; and Kevin Michael Spangler, born June 28, 1992; and WHEREAS. Mother and Father were married on November 16, 1991; and WHEREAS. Mother and Father have since separated; and WHEREAS, Mother filed a divorce action on January 15, 1997; and WHEREAS, the parties desire to act in the best interest of the minor children; and WHEREAS, the parties desire to settle and resolve the questions of custody of the minor children; NOW THEREFORE, it is agreed and stipulated by the pa..ties as follows: 1, LEGAL CUSTODY Mother and Father share joint legal custody of the minor children, 2, PHYSICAL CUSTODY A, Mother shall have prirnary physical custody of the minor children, Shannon Ashley Spangler, Ryan Joseph Spangler, and Kevin Michael Spangler. B, Father shall enjoy liberal partial physical custody rights with a rninimum of alternating weekends from Friday at 5:00 p.rn. until Sunday at 5:00 p,m" and such other mutually agreeable tirnes as determined by the parties, 3, HOLIDAYS A, The parties shall alternate the holidays of Memorial Day, Fourth of July, Labor Day and Thanksgiving. In odd numbered years, Father shall have Memorial Day and Labor Day and Mother shall have Fourth of July and Thanksgiving, In even nurnbered years Mother shall have Memoriel Day and Labor Day and Father shall have Fourth of July and Thanksgiving, Holiday visits shall be from 9:00 a.m. until 6:00 p,m, B. The day of the children's birthday's and Easter shall be split between Father and Mother as mutually agreed. C, The Christmas holiday shall be split into segments as follows: Segment A shall consist of 12:00 noon on Christmas Eve until 12:00 noon on Christmas Day and 12:00 noon on December 29th to 5:00 p,m. on January 1 st. Segment B shall consist of 12:00 noon on Christrnas Day until 12:00 noon on Decernber 29th. In odd numbered years, Mother shall have Segment A and Father shall have Segment B. Conversely, in even nurnbered years, Mother shall have Segment B and Father shall have Segment A, D, Father shall enjoy custody from 9:00 a.m, until 6:00 p,m. on Father's Day and on his birthday, E. Mother shall enjoy custody from 9:00 a.m. until 6:00 p.rn, on Mother's Day and on her birthday. F. The holiday schedule shall supersede the regular alternating weekend schedule. 4, SUMMER VACATION Each party shall be entitled to two (2) uninterrupted weeks of vacation in the summer. The first to notify in writing shall prevail in the event of a conflict, Father shall provide thirty (30) days notice of his two (2) t , DONNA A. SPANGLER, PLAINTIFF IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY , PENNSYLVANIA " v. NO, 97-197 CIVIL TERM ERIC J.W. SPANGLER, DEFENDANT CIVIL ACTION - LAW DIVORCE/CUSTODY NOTICE OF SERVICE OF INTERROGATORIES DIRECTED TO PLAINTIFF TO THE PROTHONOTARY: Please take notice that Defendant, Eric l.W. Spangler, has served the first set of interrogatories to Plaintiff, Donna A. Spangler, llpon Kathy M. Shllgart, Esquire, 27 S. Arlene Street, P.O. Box 6315, Harrisbllrg, PA 17112-0315, By: ~~------------ Michael S. Travis Attorney for Defendant 4076 Market Strcet, Sllite 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 731-9502 Fax 731-9511 Date: mil w I q,y MICHAEL S. TRAVIS ATTORNey AT LAW 011076 MARK[l STRceT. SUITE 209 CAMP HILL, PA '?Oll TEl.ePHONe 17171 731.9!oOZ "AX 17171 731.9511 Allgust 25, 1999 Curtis R. Long Pr0lhonotary One COIu1hollse Square Carlisle. PA 17013 RE: DOllna A. Sp:lnl!lcr \" Erie ,/,\\" S(l:lllgler, No, 97-197, //1 Dim,.c!' D,'ar 1'\1... Long: Encloscll for filing. plcasc find :lPraceil'e felr clllry of Judgmclll \'on Pros in this dh'orce, Please contact mc ~hould you havc :lny questions or ellnCCJ'llS, Very truly yours. ~~' ~..:;~-- ... . ....,~,-;,. ~. .'- ~. "/,..,: " .- .' Michael S. TlaI'is At10llley for Defcndant MST/dt Enc!. pc: Defendant Kathy M. Shugm1. Esqllirc E. Robcl1 Elicker, II, Esquire Michael S, Tl'al'is ID No 77399 4076 Markel Street, Suite 20l) Cmllpllill,PA 17011 (717) 731-9502 DONNA A, SPANGLER, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plaintiff \" NO, 97 - 197 ERIC J, W, SPANGLER, CIVIL ACTION - LAW DIVORCE/Cl1STODY DefeJl(/:l/Jt PRAECIPE FOR .lliDGI\1EI\'T 1\'0:\ PIWS FOR FAILl'RE TO FILE BILL OF PAHTICULAHS II\' DI\'(}J{CE To the Prothonotary: Pursllant to Rule 1920,~I(b)'l'billliffha\'ing not filed a bill OfJ':1I1iclllars within t\\\"nty days of serl'icl', please l'nter jlldgmelll of lion pros against the plaintiff with respect to the calise ofaclion for di\'OIec lindeI' Section 3~OI(a) of the divorce code. . ----;- B~~<'-;:--___.. ,-~jich;lel S. Trmis Attorney for Defendant JUDGMENT OF NON PROS A Jlldgrnent of Non Pros is entered against Plaintiff. Donna Spangler, with respect to the eallse of action for di\'oree under Section 330 I (a) of the di\orce code. Prothonotary Date: IJONNA A. SPANGLER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLV ANIA v. NO.97-197 Civil Term ERIC J. W. SI)ANGLER, Dcfcndant Civil Action - Law Divorcc/Cllstody ORDER APPOINTING MASTER AND NOW, this " ",/ day of ~W}r\ 1::J,.1,\ ,1999, E. Robcrt , Elicker, II, Esquire, is appointed Master with respcct to the following claims: Alimony, and Counsel Fees, Costs and Expenses. BY THE COURT: t r j , J, DONNA A. SPANGLEI~, Plaintifl' IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA v. N0.97-I97 Civil Term EIUC J, W. SI)ANGLER, Dcfendant Civil Action - Law Divorcc/Custody MOTION FOR AI)I'OINTMENT OF MASTElt Plaintiff, Donna A. Spangler, by hcr attorncy, Kathy M. Shllghart, Esquirc, rnoves this Honorable COllrt to appoint E. Robcrt Elickcr, II. Esquirc, as Master with respect to thc following claims: (X) ALIMONY (X) COUNSEL FEES, COSTS AND EXPENSES and in support of thc motion statcs: (1) Discovery is complete as to the claims for whieh the appointment of a Master is rcqllested. (2) Plaintiff has appearcd in the action by virtlle of her Complaint and by her atlomey, Kathy M. Shughart, Esqllire. (3) The statutory grounds for divorec arc !l3301(c) and !l330I(d). (4) E. Robert Elicker, II, Esquirc, has prcviollsly becn appointcd Master in this action on the claims of Divoree and Eqllitable Distriblltion by Order datcd Jllnc 9, 1999, and thus Plaintiffrequcsts that hc also be appointcd with rcgard to thc aforcmentioned claims. (5) The action is contested with rcspeet to the following claims: Divorce, Equitable Distribution, Alimony, and Counscl Fccs, Costs and Expenscs. DONNA A. SPANGLER, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO.97-197 Civil Term ERIC J. W. SPANGLER, Defendant Civil Action - Law Divorce/Custody CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that I have on this day served a true and correct copy of the Motion For Appointment of Master on the pcrsons and in the manner indicatcd below, which service satisfies the requircments of Pa.R.Civ.P. 440. Service by first class mail addressed as follows: Michael S. Travis, Esqllire 4076 Market Strcet Suite 209 Camp Hill, PA 17011 Dated: 9/2/99 ..-~- 'ilin::~r Attorncy for Plaintiff 27 South Arlcne Strcct P,O. Box 6315 Harrisburg, P A 17112-0315 (717) 540-8511 Sllprcmc COllrt #39779 -..---.-----'- ---- l , MARITAL I'IHlI'ERTY Plaintiff lists all marital propcrty in which cithcr or both spouses have a legal or equitable intcrest individually or with any othcr pcrson as of the datc this action was commcnced: Item Descriotion of I'roocrtv Names of Value Number All Owners 1. 418 Linden Strcct Husband & Wifc $12,000 (equity) 2. '93 Chevy Lumina van Husband $4,500 (in posscssion of Wife) 3. '94 Kawasaki motorcyclc Husband unknown 4. 401(k) plan Husband unknown 5. ESSP Husband unknown 6. Cash balance rctircmcnt Husband unknown 7. Certificatc of Deposit Husband $2,285 8. Merck Medco Stock options Husband stock option (I) rcportcdly sold $92,515 stock option (2) reportcdly sold $72,000 purchascd '94 Toyota truck with $15,000 from stock option 9. Invcstment savings account Husband unknown rcportedly combil1cd Mcrck stock options and CD's 10. Securities E- Tradc Husband unknown reportcdly purchascd from Invcstmcnt Savings Account II. Chccking account Husband unknown 12. Savings Account Husband unknown NON- MARITAl. PROPERTY [ , I , Plaintiff lists all propcrty in which a spousc has a Icgal or cquitable intcrcst which is claimcd to cxcludcd from marilal propcrty: Item Dcscrintion of Proncrtv Rcason for Party with Number Exclusion Possession 1. CD hcld for Shannon propcrty of parties' child Husband 2. CD hcld for Ryan propcrty of parties' child Husband 3. Savings bonds held for property of parties' children Wife Shannon, Ryan & Kevin ~ r , PROPERTY TRANSFERRED " Item Number Description of Pronertv Date or Trnnsfcr C'onsidcrntion Person to whom Transferred I. Merck Medco stock options unknown unknown Husband . l. , ! I , I "1 I v. : IN TilE COlJRT OF COMMON PLEAS : ClJf\1I1ERI.ANI> COlJNTY, PENNSYLVANIA : NO: 97-1'17 t r I IJONNA A, SI'ANGLEH, Plaintiff ERIC ,/, W. Sl'ANGLIm, [)cfendant : Civil Action - Law : Divorcc PLAINTIFF'S PRE-TRIAL STATEMENT ANIJ NOW, eomcs thc Plaintiff, Donna A. Spanglcr, by and throllgh her attorney, Kathy M. Shughart, Esquirc, and filcs hcr Prc-Trial Statcmcnt pursllantto Rlllc 1920,33(b) as follows: Plaintiff tiled a Complaint for Divorcc on January 13, 1997. Defendant filed an Answcr and Countcrclaim rcqucsting cquitablc distribution on Junc 2, 1999. Thc issuc of divorcc is not contestcd and thc claim ICJr divorcc undcr 93301(a) ofthc Divorce Code has becn strickcn by virtllc of a jlldgmcnt of non-pros. On Scptcmbcr 2, 1999, Plaintiff filcd an Amcndcd Complaint including thc counts of Alimony and Alimony Pcndcntc Lite, Counsel Fces and Costs. I. Plaintiff is filing an Inventory and Appraisemcnt. However, thc marital asscts of conscqucncc arc as follows: Marital rcsidcncc 418 Lindcn Strcct lIusband's 401(k) plan (3/31/99) Ilusband's cash balancc rctircmcnt plan (12/98) lI11sband's Invcstmcnt S.lVings Account (6/23/99) lIusband's ESSP (6/23/99) Toyota 4x4 pick-up Buick Skylark Wile's Chcvy Lumina Ilusband's 94 Kawasaki motorcyclc Ccrtificatcs of Dcpllsit 135439-40 cquity of $12.000 $53,759 $6,610 $141.653 $4,878 unknown llnknown $4,500 llnknown unknown 135448-40 (f(lr Shannon) 135447-40 (for RYlIn) Ilusband's chccking account Wifc's chccking account Husband's saving account Ilusband's sccuritics unknown unknown unknown $300 unknown unknown 2. Plaintiff docs not anticipatc calling any cxpcrt witncsscs at this timc, but rcscrvcs thc right to do so und will notitY Dclendunl of such witncsscs prior to trial. 3. PllIintilTwill tcstify on hcr bclt.tlfus to thc valuations and circumstances surrounding thc ucquisition of thc marital usscts. and Illarital debts and liabilitics of thc parties. Shc will also tcstify with rcspcct to thc issuc of alimony and cOllnscl fecs. Shc rcscrvcs the right to ea\l any additional witncsscs und will notify Dcfcndant of sllch witncsscs prior to trial. 4. Plaintiff docs not anticiputc submitting documents as exhibits at this time, but rcscrvcs thc right to do so and willnotilY Dcfendant of such documcnts prior to trial. 5. Plaintiff currcntly carns $8.66 pcr hOllr and works a forty-hour work wcck in a medical officc Thc Family Mcdical Ccntcr of Camp Hill. Hcr gross weekly pay is $346.40 and hcr nct pay avcragcs $260.00, 6. Plaintiffwilllilc an Incomc and Expcnse form. Currcntly, Plaintiff is llnable to mcct hcr monthly expcnscs without thc assistance of support from Defendant. 7, Plaintiff docs not havc a pcnsion of any sort. Defcndant has a cash valuc plan, a 401(k) plan, an invcstmcnt savings plan and an ESSP, which arc belicvcd to bc marital asscts. Plaintiff only has thc information rcgarding thc value of these accollnts as, providcd by Dcfendant in rcsponsc to Intcrrogulurics in October 1998 and in his Prc- Trial Statcmcnt. It appcars that Ilusband has madc somc transfcrs and roll overs and liquidatcd ~ t ,~ somc accounts in cxistcncc ut thc timc ofscparalion, during Ihc coursc ofthc partics' sep:lration and Plaintiff dcsircs to vcrify thc slrcam of thcsc monics. 8, Plaintiff rcqucsts counsclli:cs in :111 amount yet to bc dctcrmincd lilr thc proccss of Ihc mastcr's hcarings. Plainliff has incurrcd Icgal fecs to dutc in cxccss of $2,000.00 and thc liquid asscts mc in thc posscssion of Dcfcndant. 9. Thcrc is no disputc with rcspcclto tangiblc pcrsonal propcrty. 10. Thc marital dcbts consist of studcntloans for both Plaintiff and Dcfcndant, as wcll as thc mortgagc on thc marital homc of approximately $79,800.00. II. Plaintiffsuggcsts Ihc lilllowing distribution of marital asscts: (1) Each party to rctain thc pcrsonul posscssions currcntly in his or hcr posscssion. (2) Plaintiff to rctain thc murital homc and thc Chcvrolct Lllmina. (3) Plainliffto rcccivc scvcnty (70%) of the marital asscts, which arc conscrvativcly valucd at $257,000. Thc marital homc cquity is $12,000 and thc Lumina vallie is approximately $4,500, which Icavcs a payoff to Plaintiffof$163.400. (4) Plaintiff to rcccivc alimony of$500 per month. (5) Dcfcndant to rctain his accounts, subjcct to thc payoff to Plaintiff. Rcspcctr 'fy submitted, ~\,~~~ Kathy . Shu art -------- ~ Attorncy for Plaintiff P.O,Box6315 27 South Arlcne Strcct lIarrisburg, P A 17112-0315 (717) 540-8511 Suprcmc COllrt #39779 / / ! l Plaintiff : IN Till, COURT OF COMMON PLEAS : ClJMIIERLAND COUNTY. I'ENNSYL VANIA : NO: 97-197 ~ DONNA A. SI'ANGLEn, v. EnlC ,/, W, SI'ANGLEI~, : Civil Action - Law Defendant : Divorcc CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hercby certify thai on this 23rd day of S~rtcl11bcr, 1999. the original PlaintilT's Pre-Trial Statemcnt was scrvcd on thc flJllo\\'ing pcrsons by Unitcd Statcs Mail, first class, addressed as follows: E. Robcrt Elick~r, II, Divorcc Mastcr Clll11bcrlund County 9 North Ilunllvcr Strcct Carli sic. P A 17013 I fllrther hereby certify that on this 23rd day ofSeptcmber. 1999, a true and correct copy of Plain tilT's Prc-Trial Statcmcnt wus scrl'cd on thc following persons by United States Mail, first class, addrcsscd as follows: Michael ~. Travis. Esquire 407b Markcl Strcet Suitc 209 Camp Hill, P"\ 17011 ~/ -~ ---, / lv{--- L.~ Kuth~Ughart ~ Attorncy lor Pluintiff 1'.0. Box 6315 27 South Arlcne Street Hurrisburg, P A 17112-0315 (717) 540-8511 Suprcmc COllrt 1139779