HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-00220
\~\
\1 i
\J
\.
~
~
.,
~
t
o
i
i
l?
'>
v
u
...
~
tl
L1
~
, !
- \I.
~ q
()
- .
l.1 ~
"1 ~
~~
~d
"~
'.
\
I
!
-
.
,
.:)
~
~I
~I
!
Leisawitz Heller Abramowitch Phillips, p,e.
Attorneys at [aw
IIlan 9, I]askln 1951,1990
IIlan (j, Ceisawitz
MervTn II, Heller. "Jr,
<Jalj IIbramowitch
t:harles <], Phillips
William R, I]lumer'
IIl1en R, Shollenberger
Robert <], Kirwan. II
KevIn II. Moore
Kathleen I/. 1], Kovach
Douglas paul Rauch
Kenneth Millman
<]onathan R, Wachs"
October 19, 1999
. c.l.M 'Taxation
.. Admittrd to practice "" Mary/arid.
Conntrticut""" D.C. on/I}
Wayne F. Shade, Esquire
53 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013-3217
VIA FACSIMILE 717-249-0017
&
REGULAR MAIL
Re: Professional Resource Group, Inc. v, CompSource, Inc.
Cumberland County CCP, Civil Action No. 97-220 Civil Tenn
Dear Attorney Shade:
This letter will confirm our telephone conversation of Monday, October 18, 1999 with reference
to the above-captioned action. Please accept this letter as the explanation of the events resulting in the
Praecipe to Settle, Discontinue and End this case not being filed. While this case was pending
Arbitration, the parties reached a settlement which was executed in March 1998. The Settlement
Agreement provided for three payments made over time. Once the payments were completed, the
Agreement provided that Plaintiff would file a Praecipe to Settle, Discontinue and End. By letter dated
May 11. 1998 this office forwarded the final payment to Plaintiff and requested a copy of the Praecipe
to Settle, Discontinue and End. However. the Praecipe to Settle, Discontinue and End was never filed,
rather, Defendant, without the benefit of counsel. filed a District Justice action before OJ Placey to CV-
376-98 alleging that the final payment was one day late. I later confirmed that Attorney Craig Diehl, who
represented Plaintiff in the above-captioned action refused to represent his client in this matter. After I
informed DJ Placey that I would not be appearing for the OJ Hearing, Criminal Contempt Proceedings
were initiated against me, I later clarified these issues with OJ Placey in a letter dated October 20, 1998.
which is attached. We took a de novo appeal from the District Justice action in October of 1998, and
before any Complaint was filed in the Court of Common Pleas, the matter was resolved by and through
the execution of a Settlement Agreement and General Release which was tied to the 1998 docket number
98-6039. That Settlement Agreement and Release did not include language providing for the settlement,
discontinuance and end of the 1997 action.
!Je,ksll/,e Commons Suite 400 2201 nldgewood noad Wyomlss/ng. P"'- 19610-1193
fJ~'m1(' (Glr)) 37) 35{){j t0x (fJlO) "~1) 8fj71 r:. mill! kHUXJ'CGlJUfl1jJhlWlOH1
lIH N()fUI'rhl,(I~rll d l/am/JWlf. INI 1')';/1) (',10) 'JI) Ij/lj') 138 N 'Jlh 0..;,,, d r'lwlim/ 1711 ")fj01 ((JI()) ~/} ~')n(J
I :~~, 1
To: Wayne Shade, Esquire
Re: Professional Resource Group, Inc, v, CompSource, IIlC,
Date: October 14, 1999
Page: 2
By copy of this letter, 1 am asking Attorney Craig Diehl, lhe attorney of record in the 1997 action,
to liIe the appropriate Praecipe to Settle, Discontinue and End, as 1 arn unable to do so representing the
Defendant in that action. 1 trust this letter clarities the situation for you. 1 regret any inconvenience the
delay has caused you. If you have any questions regarding the content of this letter, please do not hesitate
to contact me.
Very truly yours,
LEISAWITZ HEUER AORAMOW/TCII PIIILLlPS, P.c.
/ /' /.-,-~
~-/~ .'
KEVIN A. MOORE
KAM:bel
32465.010
Enclosure
cc: Craig Diehl, Esquire
11\1'1
W A \'NE F. SIIADE
^ Ill)R,~I,\' ^" ^,v
~JI\'IS11~J\IIRI,I\nll:ll
CARlISI 1'.1'1 ~"\\'1 V^~I^ IlUIl
171712H.()220
1&001 24J.o220
f^XI7l7ll~9.{l()ll
September IS, 1999
Craig A. Diehl. Esquire
Attorney-at-Law
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, Pennsylvania 170 II
Ke\'in A. Moore. Esquire
Baskin Leisawitz Heller & Abramowitch, P.C.
220 I Ridgewood Road
Wyomissing, Pennsylvania 19610-1193
Re: Professional Resource Group, Inc. v.
CompSource, Inc.
No. 97-220 Civil Tcnn
Gentlemen:
You may recall our letter of July 20. 1999, with respect to the above. In response,
we received a letter from Mr. Moore covering a Praecipe to Discontinue. However, the
caption of that case indicated that it was docketed to No. 98-6039 Civil Tenn rather than
the No. 97-220 Civil Tenn to which this office was appointed as Chainnan of the Board
of Arbitrators.
Before we alert the Court to the fact that the case at No. 97-220 Civil Tenn
remains an open case, we wanted to give you an opportunity to educate us on the
relationship, if any, between the two cases.
Very truly yours,
Wayne F. Shade
WFS/cjt
JIL-27 1 'J'J'J 1G: 10
DASKIN LEISAWITZ HELLeR
Gl0 372 OG71 r.02/04
uw 0IIIm
Alan o. LcIuWIt1
M....InA.H,U...lr.
J.y N. AbrllllOWtldl
CIwIM I. PblWpt
WIWa.III R. Blumor t
AlIto R. SIlolllaboq.r
Robcn I. Kirw&ll. D
JCn In ". t.loott
lCIllllMo A.B. Komb
DauaIu P. .....h
K.....lbMIIIIIlIl\
Baski
Leisawitz 'JI},
HeUer61
Abramowitch, P. C.
171 Ncnlt Thlrd 5_1
Hamburl. PA 19'26
(610) '62--414'
'.
III N. '11I5",..
RIIdioa, PA 1ge01
(610) 372.3'00
IIorklbln Coounons
"'I"~
2201 Rid&1To'Olld Rood
W)'CClIiIIicc, PA 1~1()'1l03
(610) m.]jOO
PAX (610)372..671
e-Mail kmoorcOt..l....
July 27, 1999
.4"'" I. ..,kIII mZ.JgPO
'LLM II TWlloI
Wayne F. Shade, Esquire
53 West Pomfret Street
Carlisle, PA 17013-3217
VIA FACSIMILE
R,: Pro/'SJiorud Rtsourct Group, Inc. 1'. CIlmpSourt:t. Inc.
Dear Wayne:
,
,
!
I
I
'1
Enclosed please fmd a time-stamped copy of the Praecipe to Discontinue with respect to
the above-caption case. Should you have any questions, please do not hesitate to contact me.
Very truly yours,
BA3KlN LEISA. WlTZ H1IUER & ABRAMOWlTCll, P. C.
/1V/I1.A ~U
KEvIN A. MOORE
KAM:bel
32465.010
Enclosure
JUL-27-1999 16:10
DASI< I N LE I SAW IlZ HELLER
610 372 0671 P.03/04
'-
0,
Plaintiff
IN THE COUll.T OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUN'l'Y, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 98-6039 CIVIL TE
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP. INC.,
v.
CIVIL ACTION - UAW
COMPSOURCE, INC.,
Defendant
PRAECIPE TO DISCONTINUE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
please mark the above-captioned matter "Plaintiff
full and case discontinued with prejudice."
LAW OFFICES OF CRAIG A. DIEHL
Oar-ed: . DUltftlY H IH~
By: ~.lr~
Craig A. Diehl, Esquire
Attorney ID No. 52801
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
(717) 763-7613
Attorney for Plaintiff
T '..0 n
c.... "11
-,
"T, " ,
r", . , .,'J
;"::., ... c.
:~'. I I , '0
l:-.:. (..': :7
'.. .. ..... irJ
~.. :".'..)
..
('1 . ~CI
:~', . ":? '.'l-fit
,
~ ~., ~~
IX) :1)
....
Law Offices of
Craig A. Diehl
~4M Trimlle Road
Camp Hill.l'el1n~ylvania 17011
~@[JJW
Telephone (717) 763-76D
TeleCllpier (717) 76~-R2l)J
Craig A, Diehl. Esquire. C.P.A,
Linda A. Cllllfeller, Esquire
In Spring Grove. Pennsylvania
119 Wesl Hanover Street
Spring Grove. PA 17362
Telephone: (717) 22~-1929
July 26, 1999
Office of the Court Administrator
Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas
One Courthouse Square
Carlisle.PA 17013
RE: Professional Resource Group v.
Compsource. Inc.
Dear Court Administrator:
Please be advised that the above-referenced proceeding was sellled prior to the arbitration
hearing. Kindly make note of this and vacate the appointment of the Board of Arbitrators.
Sincerely,
~~a. !J:d
Craig A. Diehl, Esquire
CAD:her
cc: L wn)'ne F. Shade, Esquire
Robert p. Nelson
I
~
,
WAYNE F. SHADE
AlTOllNEY AT LAW
II WEST I'OMFIlET STREET
CARLISLE, PENNSYLVAN1^ 1701l
:'
t717l20-4220
(800) 14l-4UO
FAX(717)249.{J()17
July 20, 1999
Craig A. Diehl, Esquire
Attorney-at-Law
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, Pennsylvania 17011
Kevin A. Moore, Esquire
Baskin Leisawitz Heller & Abramowitch, P.C.
220 I Ridgewood Road
Wyomissing, Pennsylvania 19610-1193
Re: Professional Resource Group, Inc. v.
Compsource, Inc.
t
I
'-
Gentlemen:
,
,
I
I
.
Enclosed is a copy of a letter from the Office of the Court Administrator.
.
Please contact that office and advise of your intentions with a copy to this office.
Very truly yours,
Wayne F. Shade
WFS/cjt
Enclosure
~~~.
fJ)I
::;~ ;~'r7'Q1
t'
Richerd J. Plorce
Cou~ Admmlslralor
OFFICE OF THE COURT ADMINISTRATOR
CUMBERLAND COUNTY
COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
1 Cou~house Square' Carlisle. PA 17013
Phono Teryn N. Dixon
(717) 240.6200 Assislant Court Administralor
(717) 69700371
(717) 53207286
(717) 24006462 FAX
~
July 16, 1999
Wayne F. Shade, Esq.
53 W. Pomfret St.
Carlisle, PA 17013.3217
Dear Mr. Shade:
I am writing to you in regards to Professional Resource v. Compsource. On June 16,1997, you
were assigned as chairperson in the above mentioned case. Currently the Prothonotary's docket
indicates no settlement or disposition. On behalf of the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland
County, we arc asking you to contact the litigants and notify the court by August I, 1999, of your
findings.
We realize that many of the delays involved in this case may be of no fault of your own.
However, should the court not receive adequate information regarding the status of this case, the
court will vacate the appointment of this Board of Arbitrators.
Sincerely,
CJv~rUJ-. O~~
-
Christine Anthony
Office Intern
l..."OfTktl
Alan G. lelsawlll
Mcr"lOA. Hellcr.1r.
Jay N. ,\hramllwlldt
TIUlOlU W, Deaver
Randy A. Rahcnuld.t
Charles J. Plullips
Wilham R. U1umer t
Allen R. Shnllenbtrger
Roben J. Kirwan. 11
Kevln'\. Moore
Douglas P. Raul:h
Baskin
Leisawitz&
Heller
Abramowitch, P. C.
13M N. ~Ih Succi
Rudll1g, PA IlJhOI
17H Nonh TIurd SUCCI
lIamhurK. PA 1I)~2h
lfllOl ~h2--'14S
ISI We\IIIlKhSueel
WnmelsdtJrt'. I'A 11)~h7
u'>101 ~HI).2().l3
Derk\tllre Cllmmnm
SUlle 4()()
22tH RldRewlXllI Ruad
WynmlSslnlf. PA \IJhIO.l (in
(hill) J72.K427
FAX Ihlllll7lHhll
Kathleen A.D. Kuvach.
Cuun5el
Alan I, 8aj~ln 19n199t)
.-'1..., Mrmlltr l)llUII:IIlI ("ul\lmllllllal
tLLMm rU111I1II
October IS, 1997
Craig A. Diehl, Esquire
Law Offices of Craig A. Diehl
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Re: Professional Resource Group, Inc. v. CompSource, Inc.
Cumberland County CCP Docket No. 97-220
Dear Mr. Diehl:
A review of this file indicates that you were served with discovery on or about July 23,
1997, which you have not yet responded to. In addition. I further requested that you provide
me with available dates for which to depose Mr. Seo, and have not yet received any possible
dates from you. In order to move this case forward. I am requesting that you respond to
discovery on or before October 31, 1997, and that you provide me with possible dates in
November for Mr. Seo's Deposition. As you may recall during a previous telephone
conversation. I agreed that Mr. Seo's Deposition will take place in your offices.
This will further cClnfinn our agreement that the Arbitration in this matter shall take
place as soon as practical followi,"~ Mr. Seo's Deposition. and once we confinn the date of
Mr. Seo's Deposition. we will imonn the Panel of our availability for the Arbitration
thereafter.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
Very truly yours,
BASKIN LEISAWITZ HELLER & ABRAMOWITCH, P.C.
/{/ ,?pz~
KEVIN A. MOORE
KAM:smm/32465.01O
cc: Russell A. Hinnershilz
Charles J. Phillips. Esquire
Wayne F. Shade, Esquire - Arbitrator Chainnan
~
r
!'
'-"~"'"
.,~~ . utl~.
,-qt, ._,.- .
Lo. otlka
Alan O. U:WWlll
Mc~in A. Heller. Jr.
/ly N. AbrunowllJ:b
TIwmu W. Beaver
Randy A, Rabeoold'f
Charles I. Phillip.
William R. Blumer f
AUcn R. Shollcnbcr&cr
Roben I. Klrwln. II
Kevin A. Moore
Doualu P. Rauch
Baskin
Leisawitz&
Heller
Abramowitch, P. C.
Il8 N,'tb Su<er
R.ldllll. PA 19601
178 Nonlt Third s.....
IIlmbuq, PA 19'26
(610) 562--4145
.^IIO Mcmbet DIIU'K1 ofCoIymbll BaI
tlLM In TU&1I011
DcrluiUre Cnmmoru
Suite 400
220 I Rida'wood Rold
WyomlS.lIll. PA 1%lo-lI9l
(610) l72-8427
FAX 1610) In.867\
I' I W.stlllah S"'OI
Womclsdorl, PA 19'67
(610) '89-200
K.ttbl..n A,S. KoYlcb 0
CllWlICl
Alan I. &utln JgJ2ol990
July 17, 1997
Craig A. Diehl, Esquire
Law Offices of Craig A. Diehl
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Re: Professional Resource Group, Inc. v. CompSource, Inc.
Cumberland County CCP Docket No. 97-220
Dear Mr. Diehl:
This letter confinns the substance of our recent telephone conversation wherein we
agreed that the Deposition of your client. Mr. Seo, will take place in your offices as soon as
we confmn dates. In addition, I will send you a Request for Production of Documents which I
would ask be responded to within three (3) days prior to the Deposition of Mr. Seo.
Very truly yours,
This will further confinn our agreement that the Arbitration in this matter shall take
place as soon as practical following Mr. Seo's Deposition, and once we confmn the date of
Mr. Seo's Deposition, we will infonn the Panel of our availability for the Arbitration
thereafter.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
BASKIN LEISA WITZ HELLER & ABRAMOWITCH, P.C.
j:'/ ~
KEVIN A. MOORE
KAM:smm/32465.01O
cc: Russell A. HinnershilZ
Charles J. Phillips, Esquire
Way~ F. Shade, Esquire - Arbitrator Chairman
Law Offices of
Craig A. Diehl
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, Penmylvania 17011
~(IDlPW
i
r
"
Telephone (717) 763-7613
Teleeopier (717) 763-8293
Craig A. Dichl, Esquirc, C.P.A.
Thomas J. Rozman, Esquirc
Jeffrcy C. G055, Esquirc
In Spring Grove, PennsylvAnia
402 NOrlh Main Slreet
Spring Grove, PA 17362
Telephone: (717) 225-1929
July 1, 1997
Kevin A. Moore, Esquire
BASKIN, LEISAWITZ, HELLER & ABRAMOWITCH, P.C.
Berkshire Commons
Suite 400
2201 Ridgewood Road
Wyomissing, PA 19610-1193
RE: Professional Resource Group, Inc.
v. CompSource, Inc.
.f
!
i
Dear Mr. Moore:
I attempted to contact you regarding your correspondence dated
June 27, 1997. Unfortunately, it is my position that the contents
of said correspondence are unfounded.
Initially, I believe the pleadings are closed. On what basis
you may believe the pleadings are still open has me somewhat
disturbed. Defendant's Answer with New Matter was filed in
February, 1997 with no notice to defend nor endorsed with a notice
to plead. Accordingly, pursuant to Pa. Rule of Civil Procedure
1026, no response is required.
Secondly, you suggest that a violation of the Cumberland
County local rules occurred because you did not receive a copy of
the Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators. Notwithstanding the
fact that I do not believe such a rule exists, as a professional
courtesy, I apologize if a secretary from this firm did not send
you a courtesy copy.
Finally, your statement on discovery is more troublesome.
Four months have elapsed since the final pleading occurred. I
believe if it was your true intent to conduct discovery, more than
sufficient time has elapsed. It is my client's position that your
comments are only serving as a dilatory tactic.
~
r
:;.
Kevin A. Moore, Esquire
July 1, 1997
Page Two
If it is your desire to spend money on a Motion for
Reconsideration and travel to Carlisle to present it, that is
obviously your choice, If your Motion has merit other than what I
have seen so far, we will not object, However, if the same
meritless considerations are raised, we will vigorously object.
Sincerely,
Sr~ l[:;,
I
,
1.
Esquire
cc:
~ne Shade, Esquire
Mr. Robert Nelson
,I
,
~
i
i
I
CAD: her
.. ....
..~.**..**..**************..***.***.~.*..***..*...*..**....***.*.*
\ -
,~ P. 01 'I
· TRfltlSACT I 011 REPORT .
* JUN-24-97 TUE 15:47 .
. .
* DATE START RECEIVER TX TIME PAGES NOTE *
* --- -- ,I
* JUN-24 15:45 16103728E71 1'14" 2 OK .
* *
***************.*.**..*.*.***********..**.***..*********...*......
~
~ ~
l' ~
~ ~
,l)..\:.
~J.
d
.
~
~
';;)
.
'-"
-
.lib
0'
-'
....
C l,~
i:~
\1)(-!
U.
11::
,'-
Lr"\:,
C. ,
-'
L" I.
~: '1\ .
'I_
I
I'
U
\-
,"
.." 0.'
_\ . ~'.
".j
. "
,0!
.co
. ~~, '-
r-
O'
"'
o
!i! Iii ~
!!! ~ if ~
~ z ~ ~
" ~~~
~;~1;~
~ l:5 ~
o ~
en 1;
~ ~;: ~
u:~~~u.
l!i ~ ~ ~
~ J!';;: ~
.J ~~1;
'"
J
,.
.'
. .
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND
COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP, INC.,
Plaintiff
No. 97-220 Civil Term
va.
COMPSOURCE, INC.,
Defendant
PETITION FOR APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Craig A. Diehl, counsel for Plaintiff in the above action,
respectfully represents that:
1. The above captioned action is at issue.
2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is
$ 13,303.80 plus interest from June 30, 1995
at the legal rate of 6% per annum and
costs of suit, $113.50 (Arbitration, $15.00,
Complaint, $45.00, and Sheriff, $53.00).
The following attorneys are interested in the case as counsel:
Craig A. Diehl, Esquire
LAW OFFICES OF CRAIG A. DIEHL
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
(717) 763-7613
Kevin A. Moore
BASKIN LEISAWITZ HELLER
& ABRAMOWITCH, P.C.
Berkshire Commons, Suite 400
2201 Ridgewood Road
WY8misq;n~, p~ 19610-1393
(610) 372-8671
WHEREFORE, Petitioner prays for this Honorable Court to appoint
three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted.
By:
c~~ tc(~t
Crai A. Diehl, Esquire
Attorney for the Plaintiff
SHERIFF'S RETURN - OUT OF COUNTY
CASE NO: 1997-00220 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
P_RIW~::?SION~I~ Rl':SOURCE GROUP
VS.
CllMPSllURCE. IN.G
_H. _ Tht;lJ1!;;IJL_It\.t!1lL ' Sheriff. who being duly sworn according
to law, says, that he made a diligent search and inquiry for the within
named defendant, to wit: COMPSOURCE INe
~. ------ --- ---------- ---.-
but was unablp. to locate
Them
tn his bai liwick. He therefore
County, Pennsylvania.
deputized the sheriff of BERKS
to serve the within COMPLAINT
On January
27th.
1997
. this office was in receipt of
BERKS County, Pennsylvania.
the attached return from
Shp.riff's Costs: So answers:
Docketing 18.00 -
Out of County 9,00 -.. . "''''~ --
Surcharge 2.00 H. Ihomas 1\11.ne, ::;her111
Berks County 24.00
$53.00 CRAIG A, DIEHL
01 /27/1997
Sworn and"" sUbscrtbetJ~Lo before
this .) C, - . day of ~
19 '11_ A.D.
me
Ci C- ~ 'J
-r~ ProthOriot.ar1~ I
SHERIFF OF BERKS COUNTY
633 Court Street
Reading, Pennsylvania 19601
BARRY J, JOZWIAK
SHERIFF
PHONE (810) 478-8240 FAX (810) 478.8222
ANDREW G. HUGHES
CHIEF DEPUTY
SHERIFF'S RETURN
DOCKET NO.97-220
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF BERKS :55:
Personally appeared before me, CINDY TOOLE, Deputy for Barry J,
Jozwiak, Sheriff of Berks County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn
according to law, deposes and says that on JANUARY 21, 1997 at 2.52
P.M., she served the annexed COMPLAINT & NOTICE upon COMPSOURCE,
INC, within named defendant, by handing to BEVERLY HINNERSHITZ,
ADMINISTRATOR, and person in chargeCOPIES THEREOF,at 546 PENN AVE.,
WEST READING BOROUGH, BERKS COUNTY, PA and made . known to defendant
the contents thereof.
PA
subscribed before me
day of J UARY, 1997
CO., PA
Service made as set forth above,
NOTARIAL SEAL
.nmt M GAqOECKl, Nou'y Pu~"
BERN",,' PA
Readtng. Ber1csCounty,. M
MyCOfOOlI,SionElo"'" t.-."
So Answers,
o
F BERKS
Sheriff's Costs in Above Proceedings
$ 75.00
$ 24.00
$ 51. 00
DEPOS IT
ACTUAL COST OF CASE
REFUND ATTACHED
Refund check II:
All Sheriff's Costs shall be due and payable when services are
performed, and it shall be lawful for him to demand and receive from
the party instituting the proceedings, or any part liable for the
costs thereof, all unpaid sheriff's fees on the Same before he shall
be obligated by law to make return thereof.
_Sec. 2, Act of June 20, 1911, P.L. 1072
h. luser.lou.anlkev;n. mlpleadinglcmp.rcan.12/27107Irjw
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP, INC.,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
No. 97-220 CIVIL TERM
COMPSOURCE, INC.,
Defendant
DEFENDANT'S ANSWER WITH NEW MA TIER
TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT
AND NOW, Defendant, Camp Source, Inc. Va Microage Computer Centers by
and through its counsel, Charles J. Phillips, Esquire, Kevin A. Moore, Esquire, and
Baskin Leisawitz Heller & Abramowitch, files the within Answer to Plaintiff, Professional
Resource Group, Inc.'s ("Plaintiff') Complaint and in support thereof avers as follows:
1. Admitted.
2. Admitted.
3. Admitted.
4. Admitted.
5. Admitted in part and Denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff and
Plaintiffs employee kept some itemized time records of hours incurred on behalf of the
Defendant. It is denied that Plaintiff and Plaintiffs employee kept itemized time records
of all hours incurred on behalf of Defendant, and it is further denied that Plaintiffs
employee performed any services on behalf of Defendant during all the hours averred
by Plaintiff. To the contrary, Plaintiffs employee who initially submitted itemized time
records to Defendant gradually ignored these requirements and would load up his time
1
l
t
,
I
,.
h :Iu serslsusanlllevIn. mlpleadinglcmpsrc ansl2/27/97Irjw
sheets and invoices at the end of the parties' relationship, seeking payment for
unapproved and unreviewed work.
6. Denied. It is specifically denied that invoices were timely and continually
mailed to Defendant itemizing said individuals time incurred for professional services
rendered without dispute by Defendant. To the contrary, invoices were neither timely
nor continually mailed to Defendant, nor did said Plaintiffs employee perform
professional services during the total amount of time set forth in the Plaintiffs invoices.
It is further denied that Defendant did not dispute said hours, to the contrary Defendant
repeatedly questioned and challenged the invoices and time sheets submitted by
Plaintiff for various reasons, including but not limited to, non-performance of work for
the hours listed, non-attendance at the client's facilities during the hours listed, and
failure to accurately report hours.
7. Admitted.
8. Admitted in part and Denied in part. It is admitted that Plaintiff has made
payments to Defendant. It is further admitted that an outstanding balance on
Defendant's account exists, It is specifically denied that said payments were made
sporadically and it is further denied that the outstanding balance owed to Plaintiff in the
amount of Thirteen Thousand Three Hundred Three Dollars and Eighty Cents
($13,303.80). To the contrary, Defendant properly asserted charge backs to Plaintiff on
account of improper, inadequate, and fraudulent billing statements submitted by
Plaintiffs employee. By way of further answer, Defendant speCifically denies that the
information set forth in Exhibit "B" accurately reflects the outstanding balance on its
account as set forth more fully above andlor Plaintiff has failed to properly credit
Defendant's account.
2
h :Iuserslsu.anlkevin. mlpleodlnglcmpsrc onsl'2/27/97Irjw
VERIFICATION
,.
I, RUSSELL HINNERSHITZ, President of COMP SOURCE, INC. verify that the
attached Answer with New Matter is based upon information which I have furnished to
my counsel and information which has been gathered by counsel in the preparation of
the prosecution of the within lawsuit. The language of the Answer with New Matter is
that of counsel. I have read the attached Answer with New Matter and to the extent
that it is based upon information which I have given to my counsel, it is true and correct
to the best of my knowledge, information and belief. To the extent that the content of
the attached Answer with New Matter is that of counsel, I have relied upon counsel in
making this verification. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to
the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S, Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
(c~m)ourCe,\I,n~. : '.
j'Y,~Li.I!lcLt /
Russell Hinnershitz
President
qtY"7
5
h :\userslsusanlkevin. mlpleadinglcmpsrC.cerl2/27/g7lrjw
~
r
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP, INC.,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
No. 97-220 CIVIL TERM
COMPSOURCE, INC.,
Defendant
BY:
,///'."...- //-,'
/_'n . n, ./ //---:__
~.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the "Defendant's Answer with New
Matter to Plaintiffs Complaint" was this day served via Facsimile upon the following:
Craig A. Diehl, Esquire
Law Offices of Craig A. Diehl
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
I understand that statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.
C.S. 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Respectfully Submitted:
BASKIN LEISAWITZ HELLER & ABRAMOWITCH, P.C.
CHARLES J. PHILLIPS, ESQUIRE
Attorney 1.0. No. 39260
KEVIN A. MOORE, ESQUIRE
Attorney 1.0. No, 75068
Attorneys for Defendant
2201 Ridgewood Road, Suite 400
Wyomissing, P A 19610-1193
610-372-8427
Dated: February 27, 1997
1
..... In --
t"
" c-;
'. ..
lJ)c Ul ~
(:1-
LJ. . C
l!.
C " :i
I ' "n -,
r ,
" (',,:
"- r , ~ r J
I.
I '. '0
I. r-
C 'J' l)
-
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP, INC.,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff I
NO. 97-220 CIVIL TERM
i.
"
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
COMPSOURCE, INC.,
Defendant
TO: CompSource, Inc.
c/o Kevin A. Moore, Esquire
BASKIN LEISAWITZ HELLER & ABRAMOWITCH, P.C.
Berkshire Commons, Suite 400
2201 Ridgewood Road
Wyomissing, PA 19610-1193
DATE OF NOTICE: February 17, 1997
IMPORTANT NOTICE
YOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAUSE YOU HAVE FAILED TO TAKE ACTION
REQUIRED OF YOU IN THIS CASE. UNLESS YOU ACT WITHIN TEN DAYS FROM
i
.\
I
,
I
THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE, A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU
WITHOUT A HEARING AND YOU MAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR OTHER IMPORTANT
RIGHTS. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS NOTICE TO A LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
FOLLOWING OFFICE TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP:
Cumberland County Lawyer Referral Service
Cumberland County Courthouse
Third Floor
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-1133 or (717) 697-0371
LAW OFFICES OF CRAIG A. DIEHL
~
By:
Craig 'A. Diehl, Esquire
Attorney ID No. 52801
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
(717) 763-7613
Attorneys for Plaintiff
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP, INC.,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO, !I;G - Q~. .nn CIVIL TERM
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
COMPSOURCE, INC.,
Defendant
NOTICIA
Le han demandado a usted en la corte. si usted quiere
defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las paginas siquinetes,
usted tiene viente (2) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la
demanda y la notificacion. Usted debe presentar una apariencia
escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma
escrita sus defenses 0 sus objectiones alas demandas en contra de
su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, la corte
tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin privio
aviso 0 notificacion y por cualquier queja 0 alivio que es pedido
en la peticion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero a sus
propiedades 0 otros derechos importantes para usted.
LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO INMEDIATAMENTE. SI NO TIENE
ABOGADO 0 SI TO TIENE EL DINERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICIO,
VAiA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUYA DIRECCION SE
ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONeE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR
ASISTENCIA LEGAL.
CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT ADMINISTRATOR
Cumberland County Courthouse
Third Floor
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-1133 or (717) 697-0371
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP, INC.,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. ~-97.;l:lCI CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
COMPSOURCE, INC"
Defendant
COMPLAINT
AND NOW, this ~ day of January, 1997, comes Professional
Resource Group, Inc. ("Plaintiff"), by and through its counsel, Law
Offices of Craig A. Diehl, and files this Complaint against
CompSource, Inc. ("Defendant") of which the following is a
statement:
1. The Plaintiff is Professional Resource Group, Inc., a
Pennsylvania corporation, whose principal address is Southpoint
Offices, Suite E, 1001 South Market Street, Mechanicsburg,
Pennsylvania 17055.
2. The Defendant is CompSource, Inc., a Pennsylvania
corporation, whose principal address is 546 Penn Avenue, West
Reading, Pennsylvania 19611.
3. Beginning on or about March, 1995 through August, 1996,
the Defendant contracted with Plaintiff to utilize Plaintiff's
employee, Anthony Seo, to perform programming and other like
services for Plaintiff.
(See Exhibit
IlAII
for copy of
Subcontractors Agreement) .
4. The Defendant contracted Mr. Seo to work on specific
projects for its own clients including, but not limited to, Penn
Treaty Life Insurance Company.
5. The Plaintiff and Plaintiff's employee kept itemized time
records of hours incurred on behalf of Defendant.
6. Invoices were timely and continually mailed to Defendant
itemizing said individual's time incurred for professional services
rendered without dispute by Defendant.
7. Defendant formally notified Plaintiff of a dispute over
the billing subsequent to Plaintiff's counsel writing Defendant on
September 17, 1996 demanding payment of any outstanding balance.
8. Although some payments have been made sporadically by
Defendant, there still is a delinquent outstanding balance owed to
Plaintiff in the amount of $13,303.80 as shown by the statement of
account, a copy of which is attached hereto, marked Exhibit "B" and
incorporated herein by reference.
9. Demand for payment on this account has been made on
September 17, 1996. In spite of this demand, Defendant has refused
to pay said balance of $13,303.80 plus interest at the legal rate.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendant in the
sum of $13,303.80 plus interest from June 30, 1995 at the legal
rate of 6\ per annum and costs of suit.
Pursuant to Cumberland
County Local Rules,
the amount claimed falls within the
jurisdictional amount requiring arbitration.
LAW OFFICES OF CRAIG A. DIEHL
By: C~ l;:A.f
Craig A. D1ehl, Esqu1re
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
(717) 763-7613
Attorney ID No. 52801
Attorneys for Plaintiff
1
~
PROFESSIONAL RESOURCE
GROUP, INC.,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERUAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
o
No. 96-
CIVIL TERM
v.
COMPSOURCE, INC.,
Defendant I
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
VERIFICATION
I, THE UNDERSIGNED, VERIFY that the statements set forth in
the foregoing COMPLAINT are true and correct to the best of my
knowledge, information and belief.
I understand that false
.
I
..
Dated: 1:<'/,;2..::1/9l.
.
_ ~..;f?/~
Robert P. Nelson, President
Professional Resource Group, Inc.
I
I
I
-\
r
,
!
statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.
Section 4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Exhibit A
SUBCONTRACTORS AGREEMENT
In consideration of remuneration provided by
ComllSource Inc.. 546 Penn Avenue. West ReadlnQ, PA 19611
(hereinafter called the COMPANY),
for services provided by ProfessloMI Resource Groull. Inc.. Southllnlnt Offices Suite e,
1001 S. Market Street, MechanlcsburQ, PA 17055
[hereinafter called the SUBCONTRACTOR)
at the facility of Penn Treatv Life Insurance Comllanv
CUSTOMER),
[hereinafter called the
located at 3440 LehlQh Street. Allentown, PA 18103
the SUBCONTRACTOR agrees, warrants and covenants the following:
1. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees to be responsible' for the Worker's Compensation
Insurance on Its employees. If any direct claim for Worker's Compensation benefits or awards Is
asserted against the COMPANY by any of said employees or, In the event of death, by their
personal representallve(s), then SUBCONTRACTOR shall Indemnify and hold the COMPANY
harmless from and against any such clalm[s)to the extent of all benefits and awards, cost of
litigation, disbursements and reasonable allorney fees the COMPANY may Incur In connection
therewith. Upon written notice, SUBCONTRACTOR may defend the COMPANY, with
COMPANY's approval, against such clalrn(s).
2. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees to Indemnify and hold the COMPANY harmless from any
and all liability or expense Ihe COMPANY may Incur by reason of bodily Injury [Including death]
to any person, or property damage, or both, solely and proximately caused by the act(s] of
SUBCONTRACTOR and or SUBCONTRACTOR's employee(s] while performing work or
services for you.
3. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees to provide, at Its own expense, an Indemnity Bond or
I.,......"......... ...hl...... .""..... ..... rc'''':rod ~" tho "U"TC".u:t':' ~.' ~\' -.."" ~u.'nil thel '..O'ft' "'f 'h'.
".........11...__ f. "...., I.....'...... "'..... ~J ..... ~ I .."Co." 1.11 I.Il .,. ',J 10 I ''''tlll "" .. I.,) . I
agreement. .r'N./</"'''NUO t1nvnv TNII'" w..I(~..S' c.-,. -/~t i',,~o'I.? NO" A~..n> 7i v""~U
J"P~UPIt:A/'" y #4'Gon,.nn> 'i'R'DR To .f.,.1I "T ",,; Go<Im..cr; 1ZPJ1, c."i_.
4. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees to pay any and all Federal, State and miscellaneous
taxes which are required to be paid by law, pursuanlto the employment of SUBCONTRACTOR
by the COMPANY, and the SUBCONTRACTOR further agrees to Indemnify and hold the
COMPANY harmless from any and all liability litigation or claims made by any Federal or Slate
Revl!nue agency or any other entity for the payment of said taxes. S</{JJor~r r. A GR.al>fIf>oJ'r t,,;
FFF4"crBi!7Wa7IJ "1<4- __4 SUBt:~""m"CTl/X) /IVDIIIIDlhf'. 1?l/lt, ~'~'J-
5. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees not 10 disclose, divulge, copy or reproduce any
confidential malerlals or Information enlrusted to him, It or lis employees during the term of this
agreement.
6. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees that any Invention, Improvement, or discovery, Including
but not IImlled to all software, all documentation and all programs conceived or first actually
reduced to practice by SUBCONTRACTOR or SUBCONTRACTOR's employees during the term
of this agreement and In performance and provision of SUBCONTRACTOR's services
thereunder, shall be assigned and shall become and remain the property of the CUSTOMER.
546 PENN AVENUE' WEST READING, PENNSYLVANIA 19611 . (610) 375-4231 . FAX (610) 375-6213
301 PENN AVENUE' SUITE 100 . WEST READING, PENNSYLVANIA 19611 . (610) 208-0510' FAX (610) 208-0516
dba MlcroAge Computer Centers
I
f
.'
\
SUBCONTRACTOR Agrotmonl
Peg. 2.
7, SUBCONTRACTOR further agrees, covenants, and warrants Ihat all malerials,
Including but wllhoul IImllatlon, all reports, programs malerials, tapes, card decks, listing, and
any olher documentation prepared, crealed, wrilten or reduced to human readable fonn by the
SUBCONTRACTOR during the term of this agreement and In perfonnance of sold services
provided thereunder, shall remain the property of and belong exclusively to the CUSTOMER.
8. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees, covenants, and warrants that the SUBCONTRACTOR,
lis employees, servants, or agents will not accepl employment dlroctly or Indirectly 01 the
CUSTOMER, which would circumvent or olhelWlse destroy the contractual arrangement between
the COMPANY and SUBCONTRACTOR, nor will the SUBCONTRACTOR, nor will the
SUBCONTRACTOR st'!I~lIthe CUS;OM!:!R 0: place other ~mploye~e at tl10 CUSTOMER, lis
subdivisions or subsidiaries during the term of employment pursuant to the tenns of this
agreement and will continue to refrain from performing these prohlblled acts for a period of six ~ 3
[5] months fOllowing tennlnatlon of services provided purnuantlo this agreement. JJO": J'.rtr"".Ttr1 ... ;
~",vl
9. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees to bill the COMPANY bl.weekly by Invoice for services
rendered during the past week. In addition, SUBCONTRACTOR agrees that it Is required to
supply a verined statement, executed by and authorized signatory 0' the CUSTOMER or
Company evidencing and veri'ylng lhe actual hours provided by the SUBCONTRACTOR In
accordance wllh lis bl-weekly Involceo SUBCONTRACTOR agrees that COMPANY Is not
required to pay any Invoice which Is not supported and accompanied by the a'orementloned
verlned slalement supplied by the CUSTOMER. ~: J'L'Z"NoM:'".2. .,... 'P:J 3:.!!!!f, ~'6111
10. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees to adhere to CompSource, Inc.'s quality standards and
reporting requlremenls Including, bul nol IImlled to, Weekly Time and Expense Report, and
Project Workorder Document. I acknowledge that I have received copies of these documents
and I understand how they are to be applied. Other projecl and time reporting fonns are 1?P1f
acceptable I' approved 'or use by both the Com~any and the Subconlractor. P",,"U",,!7vrr- llJ,tr"R.r>:~vcrJ, ~
p'OJ".srmA~<~prrovod'" n) ~~."'..u. -1lI.rAGIZ.f!?"n To. ~/,J"
11. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees that II will be paid only 'or actual serviceS provided to
the CUSTOMER, and that the SUBCONTRACTOR Is NOT enlltled to compensallon for over.
time, sick days, holidays and CUSTOMER's closing 0' Its business 'or any reason.
12. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees that the provision 0' services pursuant to this agreement
Is subject to tlnal approval by the CUSTOMER, and the SUBCONTRACTOR agrees to hold the
COMPANY ha,.mless 0' all liability " tne CUSTOMER rejecls SUBCONTRACTOR for any
reason.
13. The term SUBCONTRACTOR, 'or the purpose 0' Ihls agreement, shall mean the
SUBCONTRACTOR, the SUBCONTRACTOR's company and the SUBCONTRACTOR's
employees, servants, agents and any other pernon or enllty that the SUBCONTRACTOR uses or
employs In any manner or 'orm In connecllon wllh the services provided pursuant to the tenns of
this agreement.
14. SUBCONTRACTOR agrees and acknowledges that this agreement shall remain In
full force and errect during lhe durallon 0' lis contraclual arrangement with the COMPANY and
that II shall terminate al lhe complellon 0' lis performance 0' services 'or the CUSTOMER or
upon term/nallon by ten [10J days written nollce.
15. SUBCONTRACTOR acknowledges that the CUSTOMER has estimated said
assignment, work or project purnuant 10 this agreement, will require aporoxlmatetv 12
~ to complete and the SUBCONTRACTOR agrees, covenants and warrants to provide
exhibit B
t
'"
CompSource Inc, "
Outstanding Invoices
December 17, 1996
Inl'Oice Finance Total
Invoice note Invoice No. Amotlnt Cltarl!e Amotlnt nile
05/31/95 1537 2,115.00 0,00 2,115.00
06/28/95 1556 1,207.50 0.00 1,207.50
08/23/95 1586 1,650.00 0,00 1,650.00
11/15/95 1633 720.00 0.00 720.00
12/01/95 1638 562.50 0.00 562.50
01/25/96 1665 1,800.00 222.01 2,022.01 ,
02/08/96 1675 1,770.00 202,95 1,972.95 l.
02/21/96 1682 900.00 95.40 995.40 i
04/03/96 1701 420.00 32,76 452,76 I
06/26/96 1737 480.00 10.88 490.88 I
07/10/96 1743 180.00 2.40 182.40
07/25/96 1752 720.00 2,40 722.40
08/07/96 1755 210.00 0.00 210.00
TOTAL
12,735.00
568.80
13,303.80
,
e
l
"
arranged between counsel. Further, to the extent any additional response beyond the
,.
production of documents is made or required. the Requests are to be responded to in
writing and served upon the undersigned within thirty (30) days of service on you.
Objections must be made in writing, signed by the person making them and served upon
the undersigned within thirty (30) days of service of these Requests on you. You must
furnish such documents as are available to you. your employees, representatives, agents
and attorneys, These Requests are deemed to be continuing in nature. in accordance
with the provisions of the Rules of Civil Procedure, as amended. If between the time you
originally furnish documents and/or respond to these Requests, and the time of trial of
this matter, you or anyone acting on your behalf learn of additional discoverable
documents, then vou shall oromotlv furnish those documents to the undersianed and
suoolement vour oriainal resoonses.
2. If any document(s) is/are no longer in your possession or subject to your
control, then identify the document(s), state what disposition was made of it, the reason
for such disposition, the date thereof, and the identity of its current or last known location
or custodian.
3. If any document has already been supplied to date, then identify the
document, the date supplied, and the circumstances surrounding the surrender of the
document including to whom it was supplied to.
4. Where exact information cannot be furnished, estimated information is to
be supplied. Where an estimate is used, it should be identified as such and an
explanation should be given as to the basis on which the estimate is made, and the
reason the exact information cannot be furnished.
5. Where knowledge, information, or documents in the possession of a party
")
are requested, such requests includes knowledge, information or documents in
possession of the parties agents, representatives, employees and attorneys.
CLAIM OF PRIVILEGE
With respect to any claim of privilege or immunity from discovery, you must first
identify the privilege or immunity asserted and provide sufficient information to
substantiate the claim. If you claim that the subject matter of the documents or oral
communication is privileged, you need not produce a document. You shall, however,
"identify" such document or oral communication and shall state each ground in which you
claim such document or oral communication is privileged.
DEFINITIONS
1. "Plaintiff' - as used herein, refers to Professional Resource Group, Inc.
2. "Defendant" - as used herein, refers to CompSource, Inc.
3. "Person" or "Persons" - as used herein, means a natural person,
partnership, association, corporation or government agency.
4. "Concern", "Concerned" or "Concerning" - as used herein, means referring
to or relating to, or pertaining to, commenting on, or connected with in any manner
whatsoever.
5. "You", "Your" and "Yours" - as used herein, means Professional Resource
Group, Inc., their officers, employees, representatives, affiliates, agents, and attorneys,
or any person working for such persons.
6. "Identify" or "Identity" - as used herein, means when used in reference to:
(1) a natural person, his or her:
a. full name; and
b. present or last known address and employment address
3
(including street number, name, city or town, and state or country);
(2) a document;
a. its description (e.g., letter, memorandum, report, etc.), title
and date;
b. its subject matter;
c. its author's identity;
d. its addressee's identity;
e. its present location; and
f. its custodian's identity.
(3) an oral communication;
a. its date;
b. the place where it occurred;
c. its substance;
d. the identity of the person who made the communication;
e. the identity of each to whom such communication was made;
and
f. the identity of each person who was present when such
communication was made.
(4) a corporate entity;
a. its full corporate name;
b. its date and place of incorporation; and
c. its present address and telephone number.
(5) any other context; a description with sufficient particularity that the
thing may thereafter be specified and recognized including relevant dates and places,
.j
REQUESTS
1. All statements, including but not restricted to those defined by
Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure 4003.1-5, signed statements, transcripts or
recorded statements or interviews, or any memoranda or summary of transcripts of
statements or interviews of any party, person or witness, or their agent or employees,
who have any knowledge or information of the facts concerning or pertaining to the
subject matter, the claims, the damages, or any other matter involved in or concerning
this case.
2. All documents or exhibits which you intend to offer or identify as exhibits
and/or evidence at any deposition in this case, or in the Pre-Trial Memorandum of the
Defendant, or at the trial of this matter.
3. Any and all copies of the invoices referred to in Plaintiffs Complaint.
4. Any and all copies of timesheets or any document describing the time and
services Plaintiffs employee, Mr. Seo provided to Defendant's client.
5. Any and all copies of any written reports made pursuant to any
investigation conducted concerning the allegations set forth in Plaintiffs Complaint.
6. Any and all documents or things concerning the cause of action alleged in
Plaintiffs Complaint which either proves or disproves any claims in Plaintiffs Complaint
or proves or disproves any of the defenses alleged by the Defendant.
7. Any and all documents relating to this civil action containing the names and
(,
'.
home and/or business addresses of all individuals known, identified or contacted by or
on behalf of the answering Plaintiff. as potential fact witnesses whether or not they will be
used as witnesses at trial and all copies of all written correspondence with any and all
such persons,
8. Product all documents which support Defendant's contention that the
prices charged were not fair, reasonable and market prices.
I J
Dated: July~, 1997
BY:
_~O./ ~,--
CHARLES J. PHilLIPS, ESQUIRE
KEVIN A. MOORE, ESQUIRE
Attorneys for Defendant
2201 Ridgewood Road, Suite 400
Wyomissing, PA 19610-1193
610-372-8427
9, Product all documents which reflect Plaintiffs understanding of its
agreement with Defendant.
11. If any document or statement (oral or written) is withheld on any claim of
privilege, or otherwise, set forth the following:
A. The basis of the privilege claimed;
B. The author of the document or parties to the statement;
C. The date of the document or statement;
D. The recipient or intended recipient of the document or statement;
E. A brief description of the substance of the document or statement;
F. All persons who received copies of the document or who were
shown copies of the document, or was a witness to the communication or statement
along with the identification of each such person.
BASKIN LEISAWlTZHELLER & ABRAMOWlTCH. P.C.
7
>- --'" ,
f1~ LJ: ~'.;
t~. ,,':-'
lLI(.'
l.)'
, ,
IL I..
1
<..::
('-." :..,
Lc C'.
, : I
Ci".- - , ".
i '" ,
lL r- "
v U' U
>- O.
no ,
~l' '''' l -
'-~":' .
L": . ,...
( I.
r - :'-:
( ,
eLJ ,~: J
,
, .. .
l I
C'
'. c' ;
... __J
,.,
(,I).II" ',) 1''')'~~1
'Z',
...
W A \lNE F. SUA!)E
^r111KNI\'MI^W
l.1 WI SII~IMIKII SIKIII
('AKLlSI 1', i'I'NNS\'I.V^NI^ 1701.1
(7171 nW120
(MUU) 2".\.U220
I^X 171712l~~N)17
October 26, 1999
HAND DELIVERED
Ilonorable George E. I loiTer. P.J.
Cumberland County Courthouse
Carlisle. Pennsylvania 17013
Re: Professional Resource Group. Inc. v.
CompSource. Inc.
No. 97-220 Civil Tenn
Dear Judge Hofler:
On June 16. 1997. I was appointed Chainnan of the Board of Arbitrators in the
above matter.
When I attempted to schedule a hearing. I received copies of correspondence
between counsel in the case which reflected procedural disputes and the ultimate
agreement for further discovery. Copies of those lellers arc included in the liIe.
We heard nothing further Irom the parties until we n:eeivcd a leller IrOJn the
Office of the Court Administrator on July 16 of this year.
Upon receipt of that letter. we inquired of the parties as to the status of the case.
Lellers in response to that inquiry indicated selllement of a case with the same
parties. However. the docket number on the Praecipe to Discontinue was 98-6039 Civil
Tenn rather than the 97-220 Civil Tenn of this case.
Enclosed in the liIe is a kller Irom Kevin A. Moore. Esquire. which endeavors to
explain the situation. The rclereneed leller to Tom Placey was not allaehed to the original
of the lellcr that was sent to this office.
It would scem that the appointment of arbitrators should be vacated.
i':~
".'
-:J'
t.-;
,
I'":
.'
I'
11'( I
t,
" '
( ./
(~ ~;
;
~ .;~
\ ~..
t',
_',.J
';1
! I ~
.-,
'"
- ,
i,
, '
--
I,
L'
( ,
l','
f.
r--,
(..-\
.-t!...'
:::j
u
... Ifj ~
i5 ~~~
is ffiul~
cC~~~
~~~&I
(J ~ g:
Ii. - II)
o f':'
1II ~
W ~ _ t:.
" ~ ~
Ii: ~::! u.;
~ ~ ~ Ie
3: z ::f ~
:5ii&
.
,
I'ROFESS10NAL RESOURCE
(,ROl))', INC.,
IN TilE COURT OF COMMON !'LEAS OF
CUMDERLANU COUNTY, I'ENNSYLVANIA
l'llllntlff
v.
NO, 97-220 CIVIL TERM
COMI'SOURCE, INC.,
Ucfcnllllnt
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CEIHIFICATE OF SERVICE
The undersigned hereby eertilies thaI on the date hereof, a eopy of the foregoing
t
I
,.
I
,
I'RAECIPE TO SETTLE AND SATISFY CASE was served to all parties of interest by way of
United States first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows:
..
LA W OFFICES OF CRAIG A. DIEHL
Kevin A. Moore, Esquire
BASKIN LEISA WITZ HELLER & ABRAMOWITCH, P.C.
Suite 400
220 I Ridgewood Road
Wyomissing,l'A 19610-1193
Dated: December ~, 1999
By: jilt{ ;;
Helen E. Rasmussen, Legal Assistant
3464 Trindle Road
Camp Hill. PA 17011
(717) 763-7613