HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-00253
\
'r
~
.q;
....
"
~
~
~
'>-....
.....
It
::I
~
"It,
."J,.<",
'''....
\
!
If)
~I
\
t'-
~
~
~~.~~
Paul J. ually, Pla tiff
,
I
I I verify that the statements made in this Complaint are truel
i and correct. I understand that false statements herein are made I
11'1' I
I, subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. ~4904, relating to unsworn]
il
I
II
Ii
I
falsification to authorities.
I
II
II
~ . "
t'/<HIt3lr Il
- ------.---..--J..,.----.-
. It
--.. -..-.--~-.JALm 71I/<;;-Ab~DtENr olf)
__-'PAJ,,)"=- T. Ov.ALLv.~;rPrl;l) L,
>- ~" t
t- 0"1.:
-__ __ ~ g~J - -LQ.___EQtS1YL._A_ f>AR r tV~ S H I P / V rll c.
coo ('J-
...J:;)o'-:~
-- .~~ 5-'~ -; I-f. N.D~ei3AlA.~ I&.LCA5:.LIJl. ~ 1S~.LLil.tE:~s..
(f)~a:u"lG
_ ~~..ir---Lnl!Gk /JtQ.Q,s_L L~ 19?5" SeRIAL
-~t.J~~ I
~l~il--->>vM PvCg 09_~____C:._'L$" ,
oVJ[O~~
Z.ww-~
~....I2:a..
--"-"-~:1tf-------_._----' .--------- ..
. . .._ 5..i~._tA:CH: ~AR.TN~WJ/...L__"'l:$5_v/)1E.___'_sa1o
---- __--E.t_~AA)~_1..6Li=: ( T'f ,co &- 1<.6PAY n1 bVI ()~
. -# ~~TQ.clO 4J)~~ TO ~S_S_VR..t,
- -.. ~- ___Ntr.TIOALIl'=__.C!>.tvu..~_,_&.~J 1-y-s'Bl.!R...~_ ___2_-1-_.__________.,.
'"
::>
!::: ->
'" ",...
..,
/17 /9 I
'- ,
HI L-L/;''tRL:L
WITH
,
.- _.- .---- -----------.-------.--------------.---.-..--.-------------.----.
--_'5liJ'-' ~ ._.()IV[IL- SUc,~MY-J11~__OE L-OAAJ__L>
>. ,~
; ~ Fjj...I6.'=-__r_I?AV-'=-__(-:)YAJ Lr-:2tL~4c--rs E.. Co (::.f VE.___ .
. '-_:"~" t.___2'S 'to__..OE_ ..~~__e,<l{)rt"C TO 71!vC4< _)_____
OM ,_ Z
ii /- ___':JjyW__ HI '=:_~U1fS]::). .sl'flt '-'- ~ E::.J l/e.._~-5~ 7-~ _____
.. - fL_..__12~_ ---.L'Y..€:..r _1.&oPfT.. __________ ____.__. '___'
o
....
.-,$".. --.-----. _______Uh________h.______,.___ ______ ._._____ ...____ _____u___
"0
--~______ El:c._SY..CH___DJ1:1.E. _.AS_~__'=OLjAL_I...:S__mlf:::'__
l-J
lJ
___-3.. Dr1=- --r-6 (EnY.5>.Bi/RG JlJ.4970NAL- I<~
Ul
. --1---- 'PAUL- QUAL-L~ kN:~ ~H7t.)_dL~!_..l;1B-D____W.L'_:4.
___B___ ~ R~~L!/L 5~Il_fa.--oL....I1fE.--tJ/1;.T--e&()f:..!. T
6
'_h_ ~--.-JglJ?Yl THe.... TE.vc..~_fMJJ)-~-0/It...b--tft1:~- --57J;6
.___O_WN~dle___oF TRJ.LGl:<;._ A-;V~ _B,@f__lf)tt~~:;... _ .
.- -- . -.----()AL-_T7TI-E___M~ ~__ -.~,-dr2!~~~__
('-.: : >-
~1 S ~ 0::
~ I-~~ ~
~<( :0
: In ~ z
1~:0
....... . :t
........: : l-
. .0
. .:~
0..
t
,
\
ill
.j
~..
. .
. .
. .
. .
~~~
:~~
>- <'I
~~: ".,'-
t-~.-
UJ~ {'"; , .'-
(.) . '^' .
f- , , .
,.'
,. ' (I...
~~. ,-.
~...,
"
c;:!. '-:J
r-: ...1-
-. '.-
,
t:. r- ,
(,) C' .,j
~~~
~
~
"",J
~
~
\
v->
~~
J .. f'--
j rl. ..:::r-
0~~
SHERIFF'S RETURN - NOT FOUND
t
CASE NO: 1997-00253 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
,
\
Ql1M.J.)' .PAI,JL-l
VS.
!UJ.!,.1AijD_ JOI:!ILL____..._
...R.-1l!omas K till'"
_, Sheriff, who being duly sworn according
to law, says, that he made a diligent search and inquiry for the within
named defendant, to wit: IIII.LIARD JOliN l.
but was unab1~ to locate _"i~_ in his bailiwick. lie therefore returns
the [::J;JMPI"AIJiT u____...._._m_______... .
NQUl::E_____ __ ___ ___ _._ _ .
NDL_fQJJ.N.D__J as to the wi thin namerl dl?fendant
IIIJJ,IARD JOHN L
D~YJ.!._ NO LONyEILkL'lf.S_AT__ABO'[F,--A_Dj)J1F:S?,._~U'E ._~P-
YISED liE IS .!"IV !!:!l?_ JiJJ.J' OF IIIS TRUCK.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Service
Affidavit
Surcharge
So answers:
18.00
3.10
.00
2.00
-c
R. Thomae Kline,
~
SherJ.
S~~.10 PAUL QUALLY
01/24/1997
Sworn and subscribed to before me
this J9J!; day of 9~-----
19__.Y7 _ A. D.
'i a .
---. '---~~Pfo{]l[;#tta'r~"
'"
-
~
~
.,;
>
ci
Z
t
~
>.
..
<
'"
-
w
Q.,
-
.,..'
u
w
<
g::
c.
'0
u
ii:
t
q\\~!
.'
\
~
0(
r" . "',"';:" ' '.:
. ., ~ /
r"
'"
-
2:
~
~
r:] ,
. ,
':: ~) ::
t.:i
Q.
-
'~,,'._' ,
1:"-" .,1'".. ,\
~
U
t.:i
<
Cl:
Q.
,;
z
'"
~
u::
APf{ I :'1 IllY!. 1/;
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Paul J, Qually,
Plaintiff
No. 97-.J.S3 ~7e-1/h.....,
vs,
John L, Hilliard,
Defendant
AND NOW,
attached Petit
, 1997, upon consideration of the
accordance with Pa, R,C,P, 430, the
Plaintiff is directed to serve his Complaint on the Defendant by
publication one time in the Cumberland Law Journal and one time in
a newspaper of general circulation within Cumberland county.
BY THE COURT,
Judge
I
t
.
~
,~
l'
~
...
~ (J. ""
,.
, " ~
tIt' ..
( , :',.' /1
f;"
" II..
(. ,
,I ,.
iI, .,
..J
lL r.
, L. " f
,
I'. ....
(; rO,o
L' J
State of Pennsylvania,
County of Cumberland.
Sherry Clifford, Classified Advertising Manager 01 THE SENTINEL.
01 the County Ind Stl1. Ilore..Id, being duly awom, depo... Ind "YI that THE SENTINEL. . new,plpet of
g.lIOrel clrcullllon In tilt Borough of celll.II, County llId Stlltt .,o....Id, WI' .lItabll.hId December 13th,
1881. 'Inct which eIIt. THE SENTINEL hat betn ..,ulltly I.auld In '11d County..nd thllt thl ptlntld notIce
or publication IItlChId h.reto II ,xlclly the ..me II WII pllntld Ind publl.hOd In the reular temlon. .nd
Ilsul. of THE SENTINEL on the following date I, vlz
Copy of Notice of Publication
April 26, 1997
Affiant further deposes that he Is not Interested In
the subJect matter of the aforesaid notice or
advertisement, and that all allellatlons In the
foregolnll statement as to time, place and character
of publication are true.
Sworn to and subscribed before me this 8th
day of May ,19 97
-'~
:L mst4%
. otary Public
My commission expires:
~L~SeB
CateIOBao~1'W:
1.+tQ>.,,~,E>pi-M.An. ~
, '2.11197
t
"
"/
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Paul J, Qually,
Plaintiff
N a7-;) 5'3 Coil/II...
0, L
VB,
John L, Hilliard,
Defendant
NOTICE OF INTENT TO ENTER JUDGMENT BY DEFAUvr
TO: JOHN L, HILLIARD
Date of Notice June 9 , 1997.
IMPORTANT WOTICE
YOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAUSE YOU HAVE FAILED TO ENTER A
WRITTEN APPEARANCE PERSONALLY OR BY ATTORNEY AND FILE IN WRITING
WITH THE COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET
FORTH AGAINST YOU. UNLESS YOU ACT WITHIN TEN (lO) DAYS FROM THE
DATE OF THIS NOTICE, A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU
WITHOUT A HEARING AND YOU MAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR OTHER
IMPORTANT RIGHTS, YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS NOTICE TO A LAWYER AT
ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE FOLLOWING OFFICE TO FIND ,OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET
LEGAL HELP:
LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE
CARLISLE, PA l7103
TELEPHONE WOo (717) 240-6200
~~~~
Paul J, ually
,
../
.
,
Of. ,
, ,.".\
I
I
.
"
'I'
I
,
"
i
:;~,(
PROOF OF PUBLlCA'tION OF NOTICt
IN cUMDkRLANU LA W JOURNAL
(Under Act No. ~87, approved May Hi, 1929), p, L.l784
,~
\"',
;)i
',' 'I
',j
, I
,',
"
STATE OF PENNSYLVANiA I
"
','
.~t' '-\
- :..
&s.
. '....
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND !
Roaer M. Morllenthal, EIIqulre. Editor of the Cumberland Law Journal, of the County
and State aforesaid, being dilly swont. according to law. deposes and says that the Cumberland
Law Journal, a legal periodical publUhed In the borough of Carlisle In the County and State
aforesaid, was established January 2, 19~2, and designated by the local courts as the official ,'"
legal periodical for the publlcl1tion of all legal hetlces, and has, since January 2, 19~2, been
regularly Issued weekly In the said County, and that the printed notice or publication attached
hereto Is exactly the same as was ptltltM In th~,tegular editions and issues of the said
Cumberland Law Journal on the following dates,
vlz:..t
MAY 2,1997
.-
~
< r .' ~ , . H.
, \, ~
. ',. hI
,
'."
'.A,
Affiant further deposes thlit he Is authotlted to verify this statement by the Cumberland
Law Journal, a legal periodical of geMral t!lltblallon, and that he Is not interested In the subject
matter of the aforesaid notice or advertlsemertt. Md that all allegations In the foregoing
statements as to time, place and character of publication are troe,
, ,y~
R::JM.e~
SWORN TO AND SUBSCRmED before me this
......i.day of -MAY....122L
nL:.) {~~.0A /
" '.,....
,,'
.""
;;;'~'1
~j,::"'.;
.
~'\
'hI;
"'...i-:~
,:..~...
" - ,\~ ,I
. '
~I'", '
"i ;"
IfOTA~ leAl '
lOtS f, INYtin, NDldIy'flubk:C.....,
Carlhl. ...., cumbtdond dIdIoly; 'A '
11., c-m1Ol1... bpi'" Marth S, 2001
,
!
I
I
" ..
"
; I
,', ,J'
'.
i."
,~
NonCE
Court of Common Pie... of
cumberland County
" i";\.l
"'.
;'.,
,
!.
~;:.:.:,...".
No. 97-253 Clvtl Term
PAUL J. gUALLY, P.O. Box 3,
Orttanna, PA 17353 ''''''
n.
JOliN L. mILlARD
"
I' "1
, '
NonCE TO JOHN L. HILUARD
If you wish 10 delend. you mUll!
enter a written appearance pe""'"-.,..
ally or by attorney and rue your de-
lenaea or obJecUona In wrlllng with
the court. You are warned lhatlf yoll
. , !aU 10 do "" the eaae may proeeed J
without you and a Jud~ettl may ~
entered agnlna! you wlthoul further
noU.. lor the rellel reqursled by ~ .-
ptalnUrr. You may toae money or
property or other righta lmportantlo
YOU~OU SHOULD TAKE tHIS No! f.,
nCE TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONC!:l1l1i
IF YOU DO NOTHAVI!: AL.AWYEROR
CANNOT AFFORD ONE, 00 TO olt
TELEPHONE Tllft OFFICI!: SET'-
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT
WIlER!!: YOU CAN OI!:T LEGAL HELP.
Court Admlnlalralot
4th Floor
Cumberland County CourthOUIle
1 Courthouoe Square
CarlIale, PA 17013
717-240-6200
"~I'
n f''' .!
i
.li
.1
, '''''
12' :':"
~~;>1
,
. ~ 'q'
"'" ....
..... .
"f"..",
,trar'"
:. ~i'. .. t'; ,
"
Ma1'~~111;"':' ("
"
,j',
'.
.~
,
{'.' ,'r
"('11<1 . ,~
..11';<'
."......
, ,'\'"
. 1.
o
Lli ,', ,.".
.,
'{
"t
,
'1
Cumberltad Notl...
.::. 'h,;,/l
.....!1 "
s
~~. .
l
J
. - t.ll
r' .,
I
" " ,"
(
L. ,
,
L ,
L (:,
I' I
I.
I' r-
'- C, ,,)
PAUL J. QUALLY,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBEIH.ANI> COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. ')7-253 CIVIL TERM
JOHN L. HILLlAlm,
Dcfcndants
ANSWER WITJI NEW MATTER
COMES NOW. Dcfcndant John L. Hilliard, hy allll through his anomcy, Jumes J, Kuycr, Esquirc
who does hcrchy uvcrs us follows:
I. Admittcd.
2. Dcnicd. Dcfcndam John L. Hilliurd's officiul mailing addrcss is PO Box 946, Curlisle,
Pcnnsylvania, 17013.
3. Admincd.
4. Admincd.
5. Admincd in Pan. Dcnicd in Pun. It is admittcd that the panics executed an agreemcnt dated
January 7, 1991 which ohligatcd euch pany 10 repuy onc-half of Ihe $32,000.00 loun to Gcnysburg
National Bunk us a condition of the pannership. II is dcnied thut the proceeds of this $32,000.00 was
spenl entirely on the purchuse of the vehicle. Defendunt is aware that Plaintiff utilized u ponion of lhis
lIIoncy to finance a vacation to Florida. By way of funher answer, Ihe Plaimiff tenninated the
pannership agreement when he unilalemlly seized the 1985 Mack Truck in June of 1991und would not
allow any funher use of Ihe truck hy either pany.
6. Admincd.
7. Denicd. II is denied that the pannership busincss was tenninated in 1992. By way of funher
answcr, Dcfendant avers that the pannership wus tenninated unilatcrally hy thc Plaintiff in Junc, 1991
when he seized the punncrship's tnlck and would not allow it to hc uscd hy either the Pluimiff or lhe
l"'fl'ndant for thr pnrposr of prodncing furthrr rrvrnnr. This unilatl'fal a,tion of thl' part of the
Defendant rcsultrd in a dissolnlion of thr partnl'fship in that thr rxprrss purposr of thr partnl'rship, till'
olll'ration of a tnl,king hnsinrss, was no longl'f possihlr. Wilh rrganllo Ihl' amonlll of mOl\l'y that till'
Maek Trador was sold "Jr, Ddcndant is wilhont knowlrdgr or information snflicirnt to form a hl'lil'f
as to thr truth or falsity of till' aWfIIll'nt wntainrd in this paragraph. Thr aWflnrnt is tlwrrforr d"med
(k'nirdand proof is drnl<lndrd.
8. Drnied. Aftrr rrasonahlr investigation, Defendant is without kuowledgr or information
sufticirnt to fOfln a hdirf as 10 thr truth or falsity of the avrrment that Gettyshurg National B.mk was
paid in fnll for the loan rxtemblto the partnrrship. It is further denied that Defendant re,eivedany
demand for reimbursement from the Plaillliff at any time.
9. Denied. It is specilkally denied that Defendalll is Iiahle for one-half of $19,000.00 dne to
the PlaintilTs unilateral actions to tenninate the partnership arrangement, as well as his unilateral
drcision to sell the partnership's truck at a price of $13,000.00, therehy causing the parties to suffer a
deficiency in the loan with Gettyshurg National Bank in the amount of $19,000.00.
NEW MATTER
By way of further answer, and as aflirmative defenses, Delcndants states:
10. Plaintiff's complaint fails to state a claim against Dcfcndant npon which rclief may he
granted.
Ii. Plaillliffs claim against Delcndant is harrcd by waiver and estoppel.
12. Plaintiffs claim against Defendant is barred by the applicablc statute of limitations.
13. Plaintiffs claim against Defendant is barred by lack of jurisdiction as no proper service has
heen made on Defendanl.
WHEREFORE, the Defendant resprctful1y requests thallhis Honorable Court cnter judgement
VERWICATION OF PLEADINGS
TIle foregoing document is based upon infonnation which has been gathered by my
counsel and myself in the preparation of this action. TIle language of the document may, in part,
be the language of my counsel and not my own. I have read the statements made in this
document and to the extent that it is based upon infonnation which I have given to my counsel.
it is true and correct to the best of my kllowledge, infonnation and belief. To the extent that the
contents of the statements are that of counsel, I have relied upon counsel in making this
Verification. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.
C.S. Section 4904. relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Date: ~L "... I 1
, 1997
({t.oI Wl6;.1