The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About97-00624 \ ) "' ~ J ~ \l ~ ~ - u -..() ~ .''. I~ I~ - , ... .~ .. '-..J ~I ~ <'J- . , <:.' '-. '" ; ("" - ,. >- Cl n: ~ <. .- .. ir: = (:) :r= { "-'= c:. r- a: I ,."I,,. a:> U:.,. W F u.. ~ ~ @) l:: ":io< r_)~ 'J ;,: >. 7~ ;:~'4 ._.....~ :f1r.1 'Ola. ,c'i U "- . ~ Cc) \~ ~ ~ ~ ~ "'"' ~I'() ~~~ - "" ~ ~ '1 :;::" ~~~ 0: l&l Z !!! 8 . ~ a~~8 ~al-c2 5 ~ & i L1, ~ I Icj" 3ffi !. .: I ~ ..J" ~" a z 4: J: ~~ , , ~ , I , I nii! In t"'c.., Dl It , , II-" 1-'.0 '1 , ,< Ullll 1-" , , ,I-" III ::l III , II-' ::l l~ , en '>:l~ , I> , ~ . . t'" ,.... , '0 0 >' Irt zz Q' n if 'I-" ctI ctI ~ ctI 1-" j ~~~~ 0 ~ < < I-' < ::l ctI ctI 1-" !'tI rt. I-' ~ " III S' ::l >-:l t'" P- I S III ( lfl . t:: i - r ~ . c'. 'd '.': , .; ~',' '1--',",.., ...,.::.... .. ,....'.. , ,l,,~- < , .. , , I.... ..." ..",,, '..".. , .. .' :,..".., !: 'I'''.~::''''.'''II;'~ ..... ,: :~, ..'...I..""..IIIIl'~CIll:~1IIIi3_~IIL,,:IIlI.,1II ,,'.', . ,Ill...,..: ....,. ;..,.. I" "', ,:.:~_, .....I..,......._;:.._.,....I...:IIiIII,..:......',IlI'~:~...I!!I........':'_':.'..::!IlI'.' 1'111.....' '.,.......... ..... . ':":':.';:<11II,'..',..,.....11II,..' ..:...1." .11I ' .. .. '. '.. ..., ."..-' " II.' _....11II:.... .; .11Il!1II.....'..,.. "".' .'.......:.r:. ,II..:. ..',:.......:: ..... .' ,.'.' '....' 11III ,ill'. '1IiI-,' .. .' ....'.' " " ".,', ",ii, >IIIIIIIIC"." B"" .... III ' .., ....,..... 11'_"_::_' , 1IIlI,.... III,....... ...'......." ..',iii'.'..' I.,. ',' "..'I!III ~ ',' : Ill. ': , ".'" .. ': "'. ." _" ',<: 1I!Jc :'.' , .' ".,:, iii" 11..'.,11II,;" -.:> ,'" III' , "III,..' " "y. ,.. ... ',' II ,1',11....:.....'...,.:."",',', .... , 11II.11II' ,11II.'., 11I11I: I' ...; , . 11II. .. " " Ill' Jl 11II ,.. .< " III, '1IIIIIIlII' .. "',,, III'" ,III' , :1'.'1111III: . ,11II, '., ",lilli',',' "'IIIIIIII.'-:.".'.',',.',." .....; .' ',...,"..... ."IIiIilll"'":''' ".', ,::,..",: ....,.,-.:.',."1\1:.",,:,.....,:'...,:.11I':.....:,,:.,'11,,1,,..11'...:..11II.'.',......".. __'...'.. . ,III', .....,., ' " ..,III~I..IIII,":,:i' ,',,':.IJIIi<,'.., :..~ .~"" ,....~;,..",:' ,..,'.;''',..:.:;'' :'~'" ".'".' "..::11I,. ~: '.....:', :.':.. .',', ,".", , 1IIIlIII,.,,'..','... "'''II,,,.'' ':',..:..' .., ., ,.,...,'...,::' '.:,,:,..:'., :~" "IIII,..~::,', ,""~,,,:::,",'" ::...., ,. ' ,".':'..:, ',: III'''II!'''II~ 11I'.:'.'11II'" . 11"11'..:..';.... :'.....'.,,11.'. >: ~ I~~",'III. '.,"11II ~ " '::11I,' ,..~,' ~', .~: <1IIl\,IIiI:~.\',,,., 1II::III':.'III;_:i,I!II!I,.i:'; 1.~qlll,:IIIII..,:~:....,IiI""."J.:..::lIltl!lll,.:_'::I.,,<.!I:-'~;~.III,,' :':I',I'...~;,.< ~;., ,,': ,..III,.~ ','.,11I,.,.,; '::::.',:, ........:.::i.., ~,:'.'~,'..,:....' ... ':,' ..'..,'..., :', .,.,.. ,III 'II''''_~''':''.''_''':'' I..II:...._'.,-~~~..,:III'~,~~~:. :',.<,.,_,:,',' "~"''''':'''1Ii III..., _",11 " ", ~. " ,:;1',.' '11I:'''''/., ...:. ":," :11I:.'.'.,11II:',,'.."-"".:.' '.~.'IIl,;~:.'IIIIl,;.,.....'II:.~._':......'.. "...:..'1.......'11'..'11I'.....' , ...... 11III' .11I..... .'11II,11..." 1'!IiI,I!III,... lIII"'..: ..... -."II!I' Ii : .' .'" '-II .:_, ......,1,....: ""'IiIl!":" ':. 'III'~, ."":=11I11I' 11I1.'1 ill". ' .. iIII",... Ill' .' '.. ~'" " ~,', 11II, _' . ." III'IIIIIIIIIII' .' ~ _, : .... 11I-'" , "', 1IlII" _.... ; --,:: __. .:,'1. ..I!II: lIIII..l 1IIlI'''' .' '~ ' .", ".'.' ~ ,".'. II, ".... r ...,., .....' .'...' '- 11II,11.. .,'... ,'." IlIII ... '11' "II, ........_..III~, II ...... ...'..,..,..~-.:.,.,-'I'.I,-:... :' .'11I.",.. .,IIiIiii::..'IIIIII~.IIII,.....'_',,:...I'... .'.'.' ._....ii.III_~".,I.I,.'.-".III'.......I, ' , 11II:.'... ....' ... III ,II, .. ..... . ,II, ..' ,...... ,.:-...., .' '. .. ....... ......"...'..._..":. '11II,.' __ _II, .... .. ....... ... ....'.....',. I '.1' II,. _' '" 11:11'11' '...,..'. III .1II1IIIa:,: I,. 1,.' .... _ ' -.'.-"'-.'11III ".-11-=-,,11'11."'.'" '.'1' ..... --, ='... . .. .'.... -..IIIIIIIIIIiIIII_ ......11I 'Ii".,' '.. _ _II · III ......._., ... II'.... . _,'-_B _~.: .'..IIII~II'..'....I '.' "._' .1...., III, ,..11II , .' ....... ...., ' .. .-., .'. -II..' III. - III,. . II .. ..- II" '-... II... - IIII/Iil!l: -': . ,_.', ,1IiIII 11I'.'.'.".'1 1lIIiI1III,. .111111 ...'. .... III . -- 1111/II .." , ........:''. '11I11I11 .' _, _'_ --..-. . -"." III 11IIIII:11II ,'. 11II." III .,.,.'_, "IIlIIIIl,".."."I_"" III ..., ......-... .-11.... . ._.. "...'.....,....., ._. " : ' 11I.11I.' ..'., .11I: 11III 11I...._,., 11IIIII __ ': 1IIIIl. ..., ,:'... _'.. _'.. ... ..'IIIIIIIIi'1 11,..11 III '11II 1M.' ' ." ", 11II.1., I ., '.,'11I, .....'. III'.'.. _. .' , ." .11I: ."11I III' :.. .:, '1lIIiI"1I~ '.,.' '11I:' ' '.' -: " ",:' , ,.. ," ':: '..' _~ III'.' p. ' _: 1lIIIIIII' . ~~I__ "'.. ,I " ... ..., " ".", II , . 'III' 11III. ....." .. _'.' '.. ., B.... iIIiI'. .. '.. .., 11IIIII11III ,'II III! 111II' ,II~ 11II'."'1' '. .IlIl,., III" .' '..'.... . .......-.. ..I.... .11II'.. ..1\1.... "M1'., 'IIJIII. 11II,'" '__ ,.11I'11", ,II,' "I.. .'. ...'...... .. III, I ..11II11I11, IillllllllIIIil .11 .'.,. 1l!I,.., , '11II 1IlII. .. I... . III ..... . .... ", ..'. 11III 1111I, '_', .',IIIiI, .'." ' _.. .. III. --11III' .- w.,. .11III.. ," '..' ..' . .-" :' _' . n.III' ~ " ~ :II!II, ' . III _11II -.11I11"'" .. .... III -, '..., .,11II,,,". .. . 'c ' \ "11II"" --.."', ',.'. 11II.. ,lIB, 11II' .11....' '...'."." ,., ,-, !IIII.-~ ,II!. III .' 11IIII" III .... 11II' 11IIIII, ...L ,.I!I'IiI,'III"IIII!I!I!!I;IIlI,"", ~'IIIIII: ":":', " . III. .- . .,'1 .;.':11I:..'11III:. .II"IIIl'III!l'I~'..:, ,lII!!I':III!'." 11IIII,_,,,, . .'.... .'. 'I' .'<, I:. ,iIIiIl"I"III,..., 1I!lI,.~', 'I'~=,III,.~_.I 11_, "IIi'''IIII': II ii, .' ...., '., '.. '. .'" :'11 ".' ...,,: .,: .11I_1. I' _.' ' ., .11I' ,'IIli', .',11III , ' .. Ill: . '." .,' ..II... 11I._.11I " II'..""'" I' ' . .' " III" 'ill . III.. _..' 1111III, ...11.'11." ."." "11".11I..", ~ .....: -: ._,,~ . ",' , ... 11II'_.'11I" -- III."..,'" ...' .., ..'. .11I, _...' ...... ' .. " -,' .. ' "-III .......- --.. . . .. I . III" 11III ..11I, III ...~ _ ...., ... ....... ".. _'__. _............ ' .. --,' '___III _ ."_,_ _,. I!IIII' _..... I!I.. ._,I!II . iii.=-, --:,...11":,';;..':'_:,.'11: '-'-.11I'.,.:-'..', .....,... .I":',::l:"i:'.'-""-"="I!lllII,..I,.~.. '.IiIiIIIIiI....,...III,,, ...... · ilIIII' .-.. · .', ...... 11II_.11II11III 11I11III 11II11II11I1.,., Il,. . \'- '. ",' '''.: -.-, " .. ''''.'J ... .'"' '.' 1iI.- E. - 11II.11III' .'. lII'llI!I' -III II' , .. 1IIil., _'., _~.'.:.IIIIIIII.III, .,.;.., -, ., '_.""=,."..,-....,~ , .,..' . "'IIII11111111.. 11II': Ill:, ..'.., 11II:.11I,: III., _ ' '_~ 11I'11II 11IIII'1" ..... ',"'- r CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I hereby certify that a eopy of the foregoing Praecipe was served this date by depositing same in the Post Office at Carlisle, P A, first class mail, postage prepaid, addressed as follows: Matthew S, Crosby, Esquire HANDLER AND WIENER 319 Market Street P.O. Box 1177 Harrisburg, PAl 7 I 08 By George B. lIer, Jr., Esquire Ten East High Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-3341 Attomeys for Defendants Dated: February 26, 1997 i 4 ~ " , " :>>- 0) n- \- ;::-~ - .. Lll!:l <S " . 0.' - ;.~ f'" "- " . J.: .~ 'j :l~ ~[; 01:,,- ~.;~ . ~. ~,. - " a:l ~ ~-I L.~ ~. .~ - i!.Q li:~ I n.: ~.--:JS; ,1; ~,. '1-] :t: '/J'j ".. ~;", u... Q ,... ::5 0'1 <.J II: bI Z bI ~ e Q E z o c( ! II: bI ..J Q Z c( 1: 8 ~ H"~ & i : a J . i;; 01- ! .: . ~ .. ~ ." 6. On or about February 18, 1995, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, was traveling northbound on Sporting Hill Road, in Hampden Township, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, and had stopped his vehicle behind traffic, 7. On or about February 18, 1995, Defendant, Lisa Neve, was traveling behind Plaintiff, when she suddenly, and without warning, failed to stop, striking the rear of Plaintiff's vehicle. 8. Prior to the date of the above-mentioned collision, USF&G Insurance, issued a policy of motor vehicle insurance to Plaintiff's father, Robert Lobel, on which plaintiff was a named insured and said policy was in effect on February 18, 1995. 9. Plaintiff's father, with whom Plaintiff resides, elected the limited tort option enumerated in the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, 75 Pa, C,S,A, !l1705 (a) (1), et ~, as amended, However, pursuant to Act 6 of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, 75 Pa, C,S,A, !l1701, et ~, as amended, plaintiff is entitled to seek damages as though his father had elected the full tort alternative due to the fact that no "Notice to Named Insured" was provided to Plaintiff's father prior to his election of the tort option, as required by 75 Pa.C,S,A, !l1705, 10. Furthermore, Plaintiff is entitled to seek damages as though his father had elected the full tort alternative due to the fact the Plaintiff suffered serious personal injuries as a result of the collision, These serious bodily injuries include, but are not limited to, a herniated disc of his cervical spine, 11. The occurrence of the aforesaid events and the injury resulting therefrom to Plaintiff, Brian R. Lobel, was caused directly and proximately by the negligence of Defendant, Lisa F, Neve, solely and/or in conjunction with the other named Defendant, Joan W. Neve, generally and more specifically as set forth below: (a) In failing to keep a reasonable lookout for vehicles lawfully travelling on Sporting Hill Road; (b) In failing to be reasonably vigJ.lant to observe Plaintiff's vehicle; (c) In failing to operate her vehicle under proper and adequate control so that he could avoid striking Plaintiff's vehicle; (d) In failing to operate her vehicle in such a manner so that she could apply his brakes to avoid striking Plaintiff's vehicle; (e) In failing to operate her vehicle at a speed, and under such control, as to be able to stop within the assured clear distance, in violation of 75 Pa.C.S, !i3361; (f) In failing to operate her vehicle at a speed which was safe for existing conditions, in violation of 75 Pa.C,S,A, !i3361; and, (g) In failing to maintain proper and observation of the traffic conditions there existing, (h) In operating her vehicle in careless disregard for adequate then and the safety of persons or property, in violation of Pa.C,S,A, !i3714. 12. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of the Defendant, Lisa Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, sustained serious bodily injuries including, but not limited to, herniated disc in his cervical spine, 13. As a result of the negligence of Defendant, Lisa Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has been, and will in the future, be hindered from performing the duties required by her usual occupation and from attending to his daily duties, to his great detriment, loss, humiliation, and embarrassment, 14. As a result of the negligence of the Defendant, Lisa Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has undergone great physical pain, discomfort, and mental anguish, and he will continue to endure the same for an indefinite period of time in the future, to his great physical, emotional, and financial detriment and loss. 15. As a result of the negligence of the Defendant, Lisa Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has been compelled, in order to effect a cure for aforesaid injuries, to expend large sums of money for medicine and medical attention, Plaintiff continues to receive treatment and incur expenses for said injuries, and will continue to do so in the future, to his great detriment and loss, 16. As a result of the negligence of Defendant, Lisa Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R. Lobel, has suffered a loss of life's pleasures and he will continue to suffer the same in the future, to his great detriment and loss, 17, As a result of the negligence of Defendant, Lisa Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has incurred lost wages and may incur future lost wages, to his great detriment and loss, 18. Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, believes and therefore avers that his injuries are permanent in nature, WHEREFORE, plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, seeks damages from the Defendant, Lisa Neve, in an amount in excess of Twenty-Five Thousand Dollars ($25,000.00). COUNT IJ: BRIAN R. LOBEL v. JOAN W. NEVE 19. Plaintiff, Brian R. Lobel, incorporates by reference as part of this Count paragraphs 1 through 18 of this Complaint as if fully set forth. 20. The occurrence of the aforesaid events and the injury resulting therefrom to Plaintiff, Brian R. Lobel, was caused directly and proximately by the negligence of Defendant, Joan W. Neve, solely and/or in conjunction with the other named Defendant, Lisa F. Neve, generally and more specifically as set forth below: (a) In allowing Plaintiff, Lisa F, Neve, to operate her vehicle without keeping a reasonable lookout for vehicles lawfully travelling on stopped on Sporting Hill Road; (b) In allowing Plaintiff, Lisa F, Neve, to operate her vehicle without being reasonably vigilant to observe Plaintiff's vehicle; (c) In allowing Plaintiff, Lisa F, Neve, to operate her vehicle without maintaining proper and adequate control so that she could avoid striking Plaintiff's vehicle; (e) In allowing Plaintiff, Lisa F, Neve, to operate her vehicle at a speed, and under a lack of control, as to be unable to stop within the assured clear distance, in violation of 75 Pa.C,S, ~3361; (f) In allowing Plaintiff, Lisa F, Neve, to operate her vehicle at a speed which was not safe for existing conditions, in violation of 75 Pa,C,S,A, ~3361; (g) In allowing Plaintiff, Lisa F, Neve, to operate her vehicle without maintaining proper and adequate observation of the traffic conditions then and there existing; and (h) In allowing Plaintiff, Lisa F, Neve, to operate her vehicle in careless disregard for the safety of persons or property, in violation f Pa,C,S,A, ~3714, 21. As a direct and proximate result of the negligence of the Defendant, Joan Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, sustained serious bodily injuries including, but not limited to, a herniated disc in his cervical spine, 22. As a result of the negligence of Defendant, Joan Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has been, and will in the future, be hindered from performing the duties required by her usual occupation and from attending to his daily duties, to his great detriment, loss, humiliation, and embarrassment, 23. As a result of the negligence of the Defendant, Joan Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has undergone great physical pain, discomfort, and mental anguish, and he will continue to endure the same for an indefinite period of time in the future, to his great physical, emotional, and financial detriment and loss, 24, As a result of the negligence of the Defendant, Joan Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has been compelled, in order to effect a cure for aforesaid injuries, to expend large sums of money for medicine and medical attention. Plaintiff continues to receive treatment and incur expenses for said injuries, and will continue to do so in the future, to his great detriment and loss, 25, As a result of the negligence of Defendant, Joan Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has suffered a loss of life's pleasures and he will continue to suffer the same in the future, to his great detriment and loss, 26, As a result of the negligence of Defendant, Joan Neve, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, has incurred lost wages and may incur future lost wages, to his great detriment and loss, 27, Plaintiff, Brian R, Lobel, believes and therefore avers that his injuries are permanent in nature, ~-_._- -.. ' . t ~ ~J ~ ~I ,{i ..1 ~t~ II l&l Z ~ 8 ~ h~8 I ~ i - ~ I: ~' 0( )'11';. ',': II 'ft, ~, IIJ !,~ ~ . .~;-~..~ oJ "'-'" ,; Q' '~', ~, L''''<: .~l,j~l~11 ",. ~ .....- m.......u 1'IW .'IaWVW tta'1O:)lI'tlA'IG ~ a\ ~ Cl II .. ~ ..:t g~ ::c a.. "I .::r 2 I ") W n:: ~ a.. c 15 ,.. a O't 0: III Z III ~ 8 ~ "";: ~ - ~ ,. - ~ 0 01 - C S ~ lii~ ~ 0: acq!:: III ! 0: i !: ..I l'l ~ o :t Z <( J: '- . 1" "~'";';~ '.>"'11_"'" , -'..,.",,,,,,,, , ~,_.,," . .., "'"c. ",.", '-"11I,,11II: ,", ' . ," , "11II"""'.. ' , ',," ." _ "...IIi". '".,:, , .:". '."._".,:', , . ,"" ' '"" '. .,=,~:II~._'.,. "'...I:."IIII..."'IIII.,_".'}::_._',~(IIII_.'.'..IIIIl.'.."IIlI.1IIIII.~_'..,'__'.......'.'.III'.II...-.:,,'.'_~.':.., II ""':-, 1ilII'':::-il!I'IIIlII/, '; , " '. ".'. " '~IIIII"",P 11IIII, ... '..11:.' iii' ':. III.".,' :._" ;.', ' "'_,'.: '!IlI'_'~ .' ,,11II. ," '11III' , '. III .11II ", -, , ..' II' , '. _,. III.. III 'III ': _'.' -.' '. -:., "'I':'" "1111II" 'lI'IIIiiIIi":",: .'11II, '-III'''~III11.''I, '.'11III" 1IiI,,1II':'_~III. -,.-_'iilllIIlIII.'.. . :-~I!I' ':--;.".'."':..0" _'II " _: I .- - III' .'.11II . 11II11' _. III -, - '. __, _. ...,,11II,11II.. .' '.11II'." '" '_1 .. 11IIII - .. '.. - - -"., ....', _.. ,.' _ IlIIlIIIII 11tI1II1I"'II. .'.' .'...,11I; .; ,." '.' .'11'''' '.'.-. 'Ill" 11I:-', ""-IiIIIIIllII' .'" ,II'!!I,_": :".".':..,.'..,11II11I" 11I111_ II _ '. III -'.' ''""11I'-'-'''' ""'. 11'11:'" ". I!I_ , _II . ' '- - '""-'" 1-, .. '. _ "11II _'_'_' 'III '... 'I'., 1I--,..IIII'BII"I!lI,'., ,II', I ",.., III, ":"'''1"'.,, ,'", ._.'<-"'."" '~" :".', 1II.'1I1,.:IJII.IiIII',,: ""--.': III> -;, ..':'.,. ." ',-' , II' .'., ; III. ", ..-, ".._' "'.'_ 1!I"'-.:"_,,:-'~'_:IIIII11'_ III.,. " ;..,'. -' ,." ,11III :'_" '11IIII.11IIII 11'II.- _. 11II11I __. .,'II"'.IllIIII_'. ".-." ..,. , .:' II:. -1ilIl!l!!':.,.:,.'...'_ ' '. , III '. ... . ',.- '.' III 11III ',., 'II .'_ II · '1III111i1,_, 11I11II-' ; .., ,.' II .' lilli, ".' " -- '. .,11,11III '." .'..:., ."..'-"., , ill , " B..' "-' III"',. - .' -"--:' .'.' " . 'lIIII "II '_. .. .,'11I_:.,,:, III '-:":' 11I'11.. '1I',IIIII'~."'..,IIIl,:II'III" ,'IllIG" "'.. ',: III.,', .', '11III,.", . " II _ _. 11II11:, ",....',__ '..._ lIP'" .. ,11II11II' II' . '.," III ..." -, 11IIII,11III..... ..,11I,......'_. .......1".." "..'_'.'. 1,._. ,11IIII,11II'."11III-' Ill. , . "11IIII,'.'''.,., " ":"-."IiI"'II1I, .'.:.11II', .: ',,,_~." _, ,'-'.IlII...'..".:,: (. _. .,..:.. ,III ~,._, II. .11I''- 1Ii""'.:_"".' -....' -. I.. '.'''.e,.,III..,IlII'II, _",," ""....' '11II-- --.... ' .II.. '...,' ", -.., , '.. ...... -.....r.-. 7. "11II':.11I III..". ','III" "....... .,"IiI'I"_::III:iIlII'_'_~"IIIII' ,.:II!IIIIi',.. ,III: ., _ _. ...11I:" III." rJI,...' 'II' ", " ,,,: , 11II ',," ".'11' iii , ,_ iii., " , , ", " "~ _, _ . .-., -' -'III '", ..11_, '.11I ill" .. '.'. ' ..._.'" .,.. --.'11I ' 1-..,.-8_, ,.IIIIlIIIIIIII, .1.".",." ....,,_11 _11II., ',."..~ .~.-.._' .".' Y'':'IlI.' ._.111II...'._....... ...., .'..' , '." . .. ill .'. '. __III. II ...- ,. .'....'.. -" , '- 'III _'_,,1IlIII ,Ill .._ ., ' 11_". ..." 11II .' III .' lilli, II,' -, 11I11I ' _ _ In, _ III" _ -" .'.. '...' ...--.. '.'" , '." . '..',_: . .-'...-..- I .'.,....." ..-11III'-' ~'IIII111'II:' 11"_,,.,..11,,_..._,... ,"'-II: .'-, ,II _.' 11''',__,' _..IIIII'...-II!II.III1" . . 'I .,11.. .'.' 11II . 11III III . . _ . 11III 11I...- ._..... '.'."'11IIII ._" _.'. ", ..__ ',11II. ..',._ . 1lII!, '_.. .' _.11I., _.",...,_-,,,11I...,.,.,.,. .:.11....11.., "....'.'.'__ - III. ..._'. .. '" __II ...., __.._ · ..'..' ......, " ' , lIIIi'.' .,'.. .'.'1/1I"_"11III .....,11I:-_- 11III,' . _.. .._ ' 11I'...,-:...' .-., , -....11IIII1-, .,'...'11II_" ....'.11 _'.' ............:..., 'III,.. .'....___~ . 11I'11I II' - , -. ___ _.IIlIIiIlII_.., '..' '-- '.-"'IIIII~" ---, ":.""" '.,IIIII!II", '.1111I, ,.-..' ._..... 1IlIl!!II,'.;......:IIlI.. '_,_ _- . ."' ...' .' II,.' ,11II, _.'. _..'..". _ _ '. -'III .. -'. ';'f'\L'.'-="I'-"IIIll1IIiIII" ,11III:11'_-'-". :,,~.,.,III.."iIl!I'III".' ""11III"', '..'.' ,,,.. ,i,'.. ___ '........'.', _'11' -- '._--. ..-.. ."-11I"'.' ." -' - -- ,,' "_-!lIP..,',....: .,11I .IIII'.'..."IlL"._' _'.__.' '."L '." _...,. ' .-. '.'- -- II III III, '_-.11III,' .',' -: ':'.,'_-.'''''IIIIIIIIlIIB.... -, '.11II111II._'_11' :...11II' ,IIIIIIIIP...... .1_ ' ,II!l,'III, .... '11II 11II ".' -.'..:"-"". ,," ' " '''. '.. ,: .-11I., :..' '_"'_, .. n~.. 11II11'.. '_, ',C n IIIIIIII'IIIII'.' ",' . '.. ,__, _ _II_ _.... '.. .... ,', II nil. - II!I .. :", '- " , .....' '. ........ __ ., _ ,., 11II _, III "'.' '.'''II!!I'IIII!i'.'' II.II~-'III " .,.'.' ;>11II11III,. 11II'11I' . ' . , _-,,'lilli' '11II...., .''',,11..' ,.".11II .',11'. .~II_"""" III '.:..... ..'., -- _III '_, '._., _...' , .... . '-,.,11' "', 'II, II!!I; -, --..' ... , ... '11I _ 11III'....".. III .11-"-' ,II...., '.'.' .'.." ,.""1,,.., .. ,,_, ",,, 11III'11II; ....:,~;..."..';....III"""."'..,_, ,'.,"',11,...", _"':_',:.- _,' ",', , " "',",,", '..'",..,,' ,II" .'- ",' .', , ..".' , ,':.., '.' .,.,.,. ,., III :',..,:,:: ",n;'.. ',,'.',,' _, '",11,_11',:",11, ,,11II..11II::11II,11II"., "'.';' " .'.:.>. ",: " '. 1'-.11II,11II, -'.''''', .' , _'11II'":,,....,_11I'......', '" .',. :" -"'.',,, '. .,.'11,..,., ,:11II._'..-'..".,.,.; ':":1' III,,'" _ '_":, , III ' '." '1-." " ... ,', ....-IlIIIIIII' 11I_11IIII'." ,.' '.." ", '..' ".-,......-.., ..', "II 11II1 '!II .. '- " .', ."', "'.....,' ", ""', n, ...... " ~'":-:""IlII",.."',,-"'II.II,,.:..'.-.IIII'.::I:;.,..>,.;_iII,,....,',1111II"11II...,:'..,...,1,.11IIII:",,,.,,',....' ...,:,"":. ' '" ,'., '", ':." ',' , -'-..",,',' .,' -,~ -'. ,- .11I''':', ,.. ':;:"" .' ',.., . n -', -. :5::"-~< 11IIII.._. I tlll.SllATAIIU IMA\'nU,"';1.',/rI ASS I "IJ... l'ItalN Ol"";bV7 lu \1111 AM IttUIN (J~:lbo,J' II ~~ B AM J(M)~,"" t BRIAN LOBEL, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA . i . ~ v, CIVIL ACTION - LA W NO, 1997-00624 JOAN W, NEVE and LISA F, NEVE, Defendants JURY TRIAL OF TWELVE DEMANDED DEFENDANTS' ANSWER WITH NEW MATTER TO PLAINTIFF'S COMPLAINT TO: BRIAN LOBEL, Plaintiff, and his attomey, MATTHEW S, CROSBY, ESQUIRE YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIED TO FILE A WRITTEN RESPONSE TO THE ENCLOSED NEW MATTER WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM SERVICE HEREOF OR A JUDGMENT MAYBE ENTERED AGAINST YOU, AND NOW, comes the Defendants, Joan W, Ncve and Lisa F. Neve, by and through their attorneys, MARTSON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & OTTO, and hereby responds to Plaintiffs Complaint as follows: 1-6. Admitted, 7, It is admitted that on or about February 18, 1995, Defendant, Lisa Neve was traveling behind Plaintiff, The remaining averments of this paragraph are denied pursuant to Pa, RC,P, 1029(e), 8-10, The avemlents of these paragraphs are conclusions of law to which no response is required, To the extent a response may be deemed required, these averments are denied and proof is demanded, 11-18, Denied pursuant to Pa, R,C,P, 1029(e), WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and dismissal of Plaintiffs Complaint with prejudice, COUNT II BRIAN R. 1.0BEI. v, .lOAN W. NEVE 19, The averments ofparagraphs 1 through 18 are hereby incorporated by reference, 20-27, Denied pursuant to Pa, R,C,P, 1029 (e), WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and dismissal of Plaintiffs Complaint with prejudice, NEW MATTER 28, Plaintiffs claims are barred or reduced by the tcnns of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law, 29. Plaintiffs claims are barred or reduced pursuant to the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Law to the extent Plaintiff has chosen the limited tort option, 29, Plaintiffs claims are barred by the applicable statute oflimitations, WHEREFORE, Defendants demand judgment in their favor and dismissal of Plaintiffs Complaint with prejudice, MARTS ON, DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & OTTO By Geo e B. Faller, Jr., Es e Ten East High Street Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 243-3341 Auomeys for Defendants Dated: May 16, 1997 , , .' ' , - ~~_._.- . ~x ~!. ,'.' '. J. ,-,:,'- f,Y;' j~;j' ~{,' ft',,",,: ~t:.;: t~-[., ,'J L;~.~ .' '~, ~,; }-, " . ~ d:S ~);'i: qi (") 3 ~ ~ a Q N :c u. r- O'i . u ~ & ! a: III Z III ~ o z <( a: III ...I o Z <( J: t i ~ " ~ i i : a II li I i' II &: ;:: i'i - 8 ';',\,' ','':,,'': ',';, . .",' ,.... ~---' e'" ',' ";? ',.: :'~~!~;T~r~;: ',";,,,. . . . ;\ .~ . ~ ';;':, .j"':- :1;;' ;,y;. tdnanswf'r\lohl"l.l\t!w BRIAN R. LOBEL, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA v. NO. 1997 - 00624 JOAN W. NEVE, and LISA F. NEVE, Defendants CIVIL ACTION - LAW PLAINTIFF'S REPLY TO DEFENDANTS' NEW MATTER 28, Denied, The averment contained in Paragraph 28 of Defendant's New Matter represents a conclusion of law to which a response is not required, However, if it were judicially determined that a response is required, the averment is specifically denied, with strict proof thereof demanded at the time of trial, if deemed materiaL, 29, Denied, The averment contained in Paragraph 29 of Defendant's New Matter represents a conclusion of law to which a response is not required, However, if it were judicially determined that a response is required, the averment is specifically denied, with strict proof thereof demanded at the time of trial, if deemed material, 29. Denied, The averment contained in Paragraph 29 of Defendant's New Matter represents a conclusion of law to which a response is not required. However, if it were judicially determined that a response is required, the averment is specifically denied, with strict proof thereof demanded at the time of trial, if deemed material, Respectf~}7Y submitted, HANDLE ~ WIJ::NER Date: ( - {')-7"7 By: I S,' Crosby, #69367 319 Market Street P , 0 , Box 11 77 Harrisburg, PA 17108-1177 (717) 238-2000 Attorney for Plaintiff 2 j . [ I