HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-00887
7. At the aforesaid time and location, the Defendant Smith was following the
Plaintiff's vehicle when he lost control of his vehicle and slid into the rear of the Plaintiff's
vehicle.
8. The aforesaid collision was caused solely by the carelessness, recklessness, and
negligence of the Defendant Smith in that he:
(A) failed to keep a look out to see the Plaintiff's vehicle;
(6) failed to keep an assured clear distance between his vehicle and the
Plaintiff's vehicle;
(c) was following the Plaintiff's vehicle too closely;
(d) failed to avoid striking the Plaintiff's vehicle;
(e) struck the Plaintiff's vehicle;
(0 was operating his said vehicle at a speed in excess of the speed he should
have been operating his vehicle for the conditions of the road at that time
and under the said weather conditions; and
(g) was otherwise negligent.
Count I
SYlVANA D. LATORRE V. GREG A. SMITH
9. The Plaintiff incorporates by reference thereto Paragraphs 1-8 inclusive of the
within Complaint.
10, Solely as a result of the Defendant Smith's carelessness, recklessness, and
negligence, the Plaintiff Silvana Pate-Latorre suffered severe and sundry injuries to her
-4-
.>0
- ""
r-- I"
- \lo
~ .... it ~
~ ~
~
~ :-.. . ~ ~~
(r \.
.;.: -" '-;..'(
1- <"u
U.1~: .
0" 0.'- e ~ e,
Cl:~ ',-:j
t, .' ';;)
(3) O~ ' ..) . I' ~
\I) f~~~~ Cl "1
(-.I ~ ~
-o::!l" , ( , :,J
l., L- ' u.. ~ ~
f:, l~
I', r- ,.J
0 (f\ (.J
,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
SILVANA PATE-LATORRE and
GREG LATORRE, her husband
Plaintiffs
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v.
No. q7-887 tv.:.L l.unv
GREG A. SMITH
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PLAINTIFF'S REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION
OF DOCUMENTS UNDER PA. R.C.P. NO. 4009
TO: Greg A. Smith
46 Kensington Drive
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Pursuant to Pa, R.C.P, 4009, you are hereby requested to produce the below-listed
documents and/or items for purposes of discovery. This material will be examined and/or
photocopied, photograph negatives will be processed and photographs reproduced, Said
documents or tangible things are to be produced at the offices of David W. Knauer,
Esquire, 411-A East Main Street, Mechanicsburg, PA 17055, within forty-five (45) days of
the date of service hereof and supplemented thereafter in accordance with Pa, R.C.P.
4007.4:
1, The entire contents of any investigation file(s) and any other documentary
material in your possession which relate in any manner (excluding references to mental
impressions, conclusions or opinions regarding the value or merit of the claim or defense
>. U') ;..
IT; .:J
;::- <.;; -t~
f':
~- /,
.~ ( .~
t,. . -..:
.Il_r "~Ie:!
<\:.: i,;
2:,( "
U.J4_ N ':-;;
-"1 r.;;,.- .~
G..:! . ~lU
W .}u.
~: ..... -<.:
IJ. f' ::J
Q ()"l U
.
.
>- ...:,. ,-
c:; c': I
i -' ~
\t\( ,.:
C):
\1_ ~ L...
"
U'
rl" ~ ',:OJ
0: I
~-1. c:: " 1
\.,
I \..!.
.-
\!. r- :5
u I:" 0
6,-13, The avennents containcd in Paragraphs 6-13 of Plain tilTs' Complaint are
conclusions of law or fact to which no response is ncccssary; to the extent that a response is
deemed necessary, the avennents are denied pursuant to Rule I029(c) ofthc Pcnnsylvania Rulcs
of Civil Procedure, By way of furthcr answer, Smith hereby incorporales by rcference as though
fully sct forth hercin Paragraphs 14-21 of New Mattcr hereinafter,
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Greg A. Smith, demands judgment in his favor and against
PlaintilTs and that Plaintiffs' Complaint bc dismissed with prejudice and costs of this action,
NEW MATTER
14, The avenncnts sct forth in Plaintiffs' Complaint fail to state of claim or causc of
action against Smith upon which relief may be granted,
15. IfPlaintilTs sustained injury and damagc as a result of the actions or inactions of
individuals or entitics, as allegcd in Plaintiffs' Complaint, such actions or inactions werc ot
individuals or entities other than Smith, his agcnts, servants, or employees and over whom Smith
neithcr exercised nor had thc right or duty to excrcise control and for whose actions or inactions
Smith is not responsiblc or otherwise legally Iiablc,
16, Any claim or cause ofaclion set forth in PlaintilTs' Complaint is barred by
operation of the contributory/comparative negligence of Plain tilTs as may be developed during
discovery,
17. Any claim or cause of action as sel forth in Plaintiffs' Complaint is barred by
operation oflhe PlaintilTs' assumption ofa known risk as may be developed during discovcry.
2
18, Any claim or cause of action as set forth in Plaintiffs' Complaint is barred by the
applicable statule of limitations, including specifically, but not limited to, any claim or cause of
action which, by reason of lack of spcci ficily of pleading. particularly in Paragraphs 8(g) and 10
thereof, is not directly and specifically set forth in the language of Plaintiffs' Complaint. but
which Plaintiff seeks to raise at a later time by further amendment, claim to have preserved such
claim or cause ofaetion within Plaintiffs' Amended Complaint.
19. At all material times, it is believed, and therefore averred that Plaintiffs were
named insureds under an automobile insurance policy with Nationwide Insurance Company
under which Plaintiffs elected a limited tort option,
20, The aforesaid election of the limited tort option by Plaintiffs is in complete
confonnance with the Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility Act, as codified at 75 Pa,C.S,A. ~
1701 el self. specifically the notice provisions as set forth at 75 Pa,C.S,A, ~ 1791.1(b),
21. The injuries alleged to have been sustained by Plaintiffs do not meet the definition
of "serious injury" as set forth at 75 Pa,C.S.A. ~ 1702, and Plaintiffs' elaim or cause of action is
therefore barred by Plaintiffs' election of the limited tort option and the Motor Vehicle Financial
Responsibility Act, specifically 75 Pa.C,S,A, ~ 1705(d),
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Greg A, Smith, demands judgment in his favor and against
Plaintiffs and that Plaintiffs' Complaint be dismissed with prejudice and costs of this action.
3
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Jack M. Hartman. Esquire, hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the
foregoing document upon the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service
satisfies the requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure, by depositing a copy of
same in the United States mail, first-class postage prepaid, as follows:
David W, Knauer, Esquire
David W, Knauer, P,C,
411-A East Main Street
Mechanicsburg, P A 17055
(Counsel to Plaintiffs)
HARTMAN & MILLER, P.C.
By:
a M, Hm1m n, Esquire
upreme Ct. I.D, #21902
One Keystone Plaza. Suite 107
Front and Market Streets
Harrisburg, PA 17101
(7] 7) 232-3046
Dated: '-II y/ 91
6
[J' en .....
..
...~. u-,
~'i' i?: ,;.~
. ' :'!L: '. :,~~
C u_ .-
".r"1
~!L . -.
en ()
I .'
.
it' .-..-:. ' :.: ~1
t:.. .'t!.l..
~. -=. -.
u, r- :s
y l:f'o V
,,- C') '-
c:; ..
'C 3 .~
..' i:-:
r ,'.'.
IU-' , .
c.. ).- .- ; ';
u:\ c..
~~- i".J
0,
- . en
LL.... ~ :,:;
rr:~ c,: ;~u
C... ;u..
,.. .:..
It. r- )
0 '" u
Mellon Bank -- Assistant Operation Supervisor
Poplar Church Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Desiree Blackwell -- immediate supervisor
37,5 hours/week
$20,000 per year
Union/Somerset Federal Credit Union -- Teller
16 East Lincoln Avenue
Roselle Park, NJ 07204
Sarah Zennario -- immediate supervisor
37.5 hours/week
$18,000 per year
5, As of the date of this answer, the Plaintiffs have not yet determined the experts
they intend to call at time of trial, The Plaintiffs reserve the right to supplement the answer
to this Interrogatory if and when necessary,
6, The Plaintiff Silvana Pate-Latorre will testify with respect to liability and
damages, As to liability, the Plaintiff incorporates herein by reference thereto her
Complaint. On damages, the Plaintiff will testify to the impact the injuries she sustained in
the accident that gave rise to this case has had on her life and person, The Plaintiff
reserves the right to supplement the answer to this interrogatory.
7. As of the date of this answer, the Plaintiffs have not yet determined the exhibits
they intend to use at time of trial. The Plaintiffs reserve the right to supplement the answer
to this Interrogatory if and when necessary,
8(a), The Plaintiff Silvana Pate-Latorre and the Defendant.
(b), See answer to Interrogatory No, 8(a).
(c), See answer to Interrogatory No. 8(a),
Dr, Robert J, Beaudry, Jr.
3600 Old Gettysburg Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
- 2-
13. Beaudry Oral Surgery
3600 Old Gettysburg Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Orthopedic Institute of PA
875 Poplar Church Road
Camp Hill, PA 17011
Mechanicsburg Family Practice Center
122 South Filbert Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
Miller Oral Surgery
400 Nationwide Drive
Harrisburg,PA 17110
The Plaintiff will provide copies of her medical and bills records upon receipt.
14, The Plaintiff will provide copies of her medical and bills records upon receipt.
15, The Plaintiff is currently receiving treatment from Dr, Robert J, Beaudry, Jr, See
answer to I nterrogatory No. 13,
16, The Plaintiff was last examined by Dr, Beaudry in January 1997,
17, The Plaintiff was unable to perform her normal work duties without having great
difficulty due to the pain in her neck and back, Her injuries put a tremendous strain on her
marriage because she was unable to care for her child, her husband and her home which
ultimately resulted in a six month separation.
18. As of the date of this answer, the Plaintiff is still receiving medical care for the
injuries she suffered in the collision that gave rise to this case, The Plaintiffs will provide
copies of their expert reports upon receipt. The Plaintiffs reserve the right to supplement
the answer to this Interrogatory if and when necessary,
19, No,
20. Not applicable,
-4-
~... \.;')
.,'
1
I' ,
, .
1
,
(
1
L., ,
L
r
<.. \ (:. I, ,
COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYL VANIA
POLICE ACCIDENT REPORT
r::oED~Rr:..B:.E =- '.;:', =E=:=~':'5.E Z
.
'pt;
~(~/;
...~.......
(" '
. :;
C'':
~ -
_ ~ / A
._.....r~ .~
~
,XX =EI=ER TO O\'E~~..Y SHEE"S
POLICE INFORMATION
1 INCIDENT I J . ..-. AI
NUMBEI:I -, (.... .... -, Y'r
2 AGENCV , ~ .-.-- r __
N'ME L",-~t.. l L. ~ f<\..,.,.. ,-~ .
'3 STATIONI - I _ I" PATROl." r:
P"ECINCT J.J /,.,..', ~CNE ,']9 '/
5 INVESTIGATO",. BADGE /'" ,,,
/r.r:'.t!- NUMBER , .~"'-
6 APPAOVE~~ /lkl" _ ~~~~~A I ""
T INVESTIGATION ,. "/" Ii:;'" 16 AAAIVAL O'j:;~
DATE r /'1I/'f;J I TIME . -
ACCIDENT INFORMATION
D ~~~~ENT 1/11 ft.t 1'0 CAV OF ~E~."~ P,y
, ,. TIME OF .. ' 12. NUMBER "7
CAY 0'''(,; I OF UNITS :J'
'3 . KIUEC ^ I'" INJUAEC A 1'5 PAIV PAOP 0 1?1
(j {: ACCICENT V N ~
16 010 veHICl.E MAVE TO BE REMOVEO ~7 VEHICLE DAMAGE
;:;:;OU THE SCENE' I O. NONE UNIT 1
UNIT 1 UNIT 2' , . LIGHT
2, MOCEAATE
v 0 N I2l V 0 N 1iI I 3. SEVEAE
18 Ii.;zAROOUS 0 r:1"9 PENNDDT
MATERIALS Y N ~ I PROPE:;n
UNIT' 1
"1AE. $51'!
'"f;r'{",~;' ;1c:C i
c'; (.t'~"
UNIT 2
ITJ
OJ
vO
NI2l
i3e~w
36 LEGAL!. Y Y N 137 i=\EG
:l.a.~I(EO" 0 ~ PLATE
1,9 PA TITLE OR
~,,- ""'C' to........ .Ifl
0:0 OWNE~
"<.', ,.Jb"';f>,. "";l~-:;.
41 OWNE~ .., <:
'OCAESS J--:''; I , I/'~t'''... <,..
'2. CtiV. STATE
& :IPCOOE 1J,e.HA';'~i!- ~
~3 vE.A 8'1 I" MAKE b.e:;r..hET
~5 MOCEL, INOT -;>'." _ L' 1'6, INS..",
BOCv TYPE):) (...i'..;...:.('1...- V I<ll NO UNK lJ
~;50CV S;,: 1('6'ISP:CIAL r", ~VEHICLE I
'iYPE -- 1'-" USAGE V' OWNERSHIP
e,INITJAL IMPACT IA I~VEHIC:'E .....-:. j\52.)TRAVEL ~L'1
POINT (~ STATUS <.-J r- SPEED 77
~..I'EHleLE "1 rCiCRII':R r-;--"l, K55,1CRIVER I
G"AOIENT ~ I' C~ESE'lCE I I I I......... CONDITION
~6 ~~~~~~R J'-t tf 51 0:> <) 15T S~i,/\
58 ORIVER L" I
NAME .:->, '-1/ ~ t.l ^ ,,"t ..://(4 'PP,j.! - Jj, TC.t:.r...!.
59 O!:lIVER . ..
ACC"ESS 17,~ I s 1~"r.,i..L~ S.
50 i'i7p~~~~E (v~"'J ;.I~ 11<';"..1.0 . V.' ,1(.',],)
61 SEX_ 162, CATE OF . ;, '163!,~QNE, (,1'
.- BIATH /I "",,,11:41 - <;"'irf.
64 COMM V~'165 QFlIVEM ,66 DRIVER ,
v:j N:xl CLASS I S 5 .
67 CARRIER
i . .,.:,He
.-
l'7c'i?
'68 CI.RR1ER
AOORESS
E9 CiiY. STATE
& ,IPeOCE
70 USDeT,
lice'
K73:,CARGO
l"-BoOY TYeE
.'76IHAZAACOOS
''-.J MATERIALS
IPUC,
74 GvWR
~I'EH
CQNF1G.
'5 NO OF
AXLES
M....S11fQ21
1-' -
~.~-
" . :... ."1
(".. .....'
~E~~t~~C'- ..;~E ':'~.\
ACCIDENT LOCATION
2C CO,;~".r ..,.'l....2l
c.....- L.\ ."'j~/'" ....
2' MUI~ICIPALrry /I -J
1" .,of' -'~4~ :';'_":l'~"'"
;:C:E
z'
eO:E
Ie;;'
PRINCIPAL ROADWA Y INFORMA TION
22 .0urE NO 0" <'" ,." ' l.., ' -,
STREET NAME ..)J.... 7UU;:J r~~""SJ"'.l.rll~ 17. 0\,)./') ,
23 SPEEC , ..- '~TVPE .... li2! ,ACCESS "
LIMIT ~, I' HIGHWAV .t:.. 1'-' CONTAOL ~
INTERSECTING ROAD:
Z5 .OUTE NO OA /. 'Y ,
ST"EET NAME <,'Z, ~ I <;'" ~ti!: 1'::'- N. / I
,7 SPEEO -~ ~TVPE J. K~ACCESS.2-
LIMIT .::; ) I HIGHWAY I" CONTROL !
IF NOT A T INTERSECTION: ,
30 CACSS ST"EET CR
SEGMENT MARKE:t
31 OIRECilON
F"OM SITE N S
33 01$1 ANCE WAS
34ICONSiRUC";'ICN
......... :ONE
: 32 01$T ANCE
E W i F"OM SITE
MEASUAEC 0
j~JS ,iRAFFIC
6: i- CONTROl..
--' I O:VICE
o
INrE=lSEC":':~G
7F
FT 1.11
ESTIMATED
PRINCli'AL
[1J
UNIT' 2
r. ,a ''''' "J
JS Si,c.,',:,=
I ?/f
36 I.EGALi. Y Y N ,3~ ~EG
PARKED? -:z g:,.A iE
:!9 PA ;IT:..E~ 1 ~
e. .. _ -: " " /'. -./;t;:;!(:;1
_0 OWNER,.. _' -__
,~" " A ;'1"1,7,../
., OWNER " 1/.' """'
AOO;:;'ESS -6 L..:..\.J ~iNe".-:-..'''''' ...!....A':l.
'2 CITY STAT: / I i ~I '. 1701/
& ZI~COOE L~""'? r /,,'- -
"3 yEAR ~~ MAKE . I
9':/ fle....:>;1"
45 MO:.1EL. lNOT A ' 46. INS
BOCYiYPE, C(G~ f) I vg) NO UNKC'
~7IBOCV ~ '" ~SPECIAL /", I~VEHICCE /'
- ",:"yPE r J ../ USAGE '-' OWNEQS..uP
e;INITIAL IMP:'CT I :~IVEH1C:'E 0 1'C;7='':'VEL U f
oOINT SiATUS SPEED 7
e;VEHICLE '" ;:5.;OAIV:A r----11 IC'O"IVER I
GI1.l.,DIENT ~ . '- pr::;ESE~CE I I I I CONDITION
56 ~~~~:~A /-1 c.:J~~' '54/ 157 ~/\
58 ORlvE=1
N'ME 0.:: c,. .A Sf. 1"1'10{
59 C"'VE" , , I' ,/, ""i"--
AOORESS J'1 ~ r~J\.J'f:Jj.\j1 :-rO'\,J -J......l(..
60 CITY, SiATE / H 'D II
& ,IPCOCE ,-","'7 M_ r A {70
6' sEX/"" i 52 ~~rTEH OF ':: I;; /" Pi 163 ';ZNl_ 3~ c. '1
64 COMM v~ ,ES :l~lVER i 66 ORIVEr:;
vO N71 I CLASS I 55'
67 CARRIER
68. CARRIER
ACCAESS
69 CITY. 511..1E
& !IPCOOE
70 USDOT If
I
I
r72,~VEH
"-' CONFIG
n REl~SE Q!.HA.Z MAT 75 NO OF
VU NU UNKO AXLES
f' .., .- ... .-.. ~ ..,
.: i._' :.~: t...i ~ ..~ I
i'CC' IPUC'
~73 }CARGO 17.. GVWR
I-aODY TYPE
I~Ho\ZAACOUS 177 AEI.t.ASE \lE HA;: MAT I
MATERIALS Y U N U UNI( 0
PAGE -'- ~'Idl PeR H1G1lWAY ~
...IllG EMS AGENCY L /:J.Jrr. .At. ~...j "-"', INCIDENT It: (,I w' -C,J ",/0 ,
- ACCIDENT DATE: 1/1' /"6
.. MEDICAL FACILITY ui.
~:?EOPLE INFORMATION NAME AOORESS K L M
BCD E F G H I J
I I~~ ~ 1 I f V 1 ~"It.c..::"j'~- I ",( I kf 11 13 :-; !e e ,
, I t=' < <oJ~ :~c., ~. .., I;~I ~ r~.. ... .,.'1.1': ':'", I
:-1 I ,.. )7 '1 f 11 It'y1'...4 's',"<oI i../1. if-:... "..u \). j, ~. ;1. ' ?~ I?,,,' Iv I~ Ie II..: Ie iC I
,u
I I I I I I I I I
I I I I I 1 I I I
I
I I I I I T I
!!)tL.LUMINATlON []J @WEATHER [Q] 88 DIAGRAM
0
0ROAO SURFACE CD :
:
:
&0, PENNSYLVANIA SCHOOL DISTRICT
(IF APPLICABLE) .... ..............................................................,....,.... ,~.. .. . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . '.'
: :
:
as, DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGED PROPERTY
:
:
... . .... ..................... . ..."". ...... ..... . .. .... ..~.. . .. . ..... ...
OWNER :
ADDRESS
...... . ...... ..... ..' ... . ...... ....... .... .. I
PHONE
: I
87 NARRATIVE .10ENTlFY PRECIPITATING EVENTS, CAUSATION FACTORS, SEOUENCES OF EVENTS, WITNESS STATEMENTS, ANO PROVIOE ACDITIONAL i
DEiAILS, L.IKE INSURANCE INFORMATION AND L.OCATION OF TOWED VEHICL.ES IF KNOWN
ru / ' ^' ~,.,. or' '.J.~'- -,c......."'" 7,.,c .cA'VI.':) .....,.1)0...., ,.,1'-'(- ~- ,., i
.... ..;..
Cu .J I
'v,,~'r;.) , , uCt:.rc ,.J ..,..., . ,SIt' " , n -- '.., .....z / ......,.. !
....~- . i
,l.;.5~ 'r.s:- IN-II .t. 46l? /',,(. :J H.- /,,. / '" - ,,,," ~..?, I
. I
-"";j." "Ill, -r'" "'" ;..".. 0"10. -:;.t6 ~G""~.4" I
- v i
'#k 121/Jr1... 01: .....? / r"""A;cA/A.:~ /Jt:' tJ5i't Ie -;:::-4/Al ..I.F~L
l'2:=.Fuc,; ,J,';. /.......~c 4': ~=-'-r:...."..,..:.T -r A--:O""'.':5,...... J.X"/' -" I
-Y-1V ",.f;ell.>, t:~,.s~.;..,,<..- Lr-. ~ ~/,;o.^"". ."..... A:: ~.........J ...s ?........ n .=-,
I
I
I
I
INSUr:\I\NCE CO),lPANY J'v{ J.'.J::'. ,....-;.. , INSURANCE COMP6',cI& CC I
INFORMATION ,'A"i'J^'J..:,',""(; v.I....., INFO~MA TION /.'VS.
UNIT jPOLICY ~ff'" ,'(7 '>,-1../ (c;Jj6 UNIT /POLlCY &6/ - ie - C-:g,7'f<:;'-j
, NO C. ~ NO ,
~~~ I SL~A '" t'U"..o tl,? S. 161~ ADDRESS !"A~I' ,.,:k ~ /7()11 I.,HONE . ' I
88 0;;;. :6;l. 7 .,-.>~o(
WITNESSES NAME AOORESS PHONE
851 VIOLATIONS INDICATED 190 SECTION NUMBERS tONL Y IF CHARGEDI Te N1C I
UNIT 1 I 00
UNIT 2 I 00
1j1 )PROBASLE ':e;iYPE ~"ESUL 1S ~ NO TEST ~PRO&AB'E ~jT'YPE ~RESUL 1S iZ 0 TEST I
\... USE TEST o % C REFUSE USE TEST N 94 INVESTIGI.. TlO,,",
UNIT , () 0 UNIT 2 CJ 0 o ,~D REFUSE I COMPLE'TE'
'-- 0 UNK '--' 0 UNK YES g) NO 0
2 0 0 0 2 31 PAGE ..z-
C:!HT!ll F~il HiC/f,yAY :J:J';;'Y
'" .. "''''''-':'''':,,;.'~:,.,.u:. ':'"., ,',C,.,' '~",',-,'" ",',.. .,',,',.';..',',.:; ,",-'1.,' "',' .."..,.., _ ~,:,','
::,I, .;i'''. ",,".., ,.,:".';.,' ',.'.,;, "'-;',',~" '?", .",":,~:';..~...,;.,~. >',.,'~" :;. ';.", ,.
.' ',.'.;: ~ " ..,'.', '" .' " '.,.' ,:t.... .' .. .'~~ .. / "j' "~", ~';t~~~..:;j:';'''''', ..
..:...,"'.'" , .. ...,::,:, ,,~':'.2:'" :E:', '.',. :'. ,',:: ';;:~ >',' ,";, " ", :' :7
.,..... ..'
,,':'c' ,: ,..,: ':",..,:: ," :'.. ..
~L'" ':' ' " ' ':' ' : ..>:':':':"';"::~'<~~';,;"'/.},;r'::', ,.'.;:-' ,::X<
:';, ..' . "., ':.. :\'-:': " : '. ,:",:.. '.,',,,, ',' "
.. ,:.', '<>;:'. :;:; .': ',n;':; <,: ;',;:";.. ;,:;:: ,.,;~'
:i:~::', ':" ':''':''';::;'''''' ",' ,';,j-'.~ .:;t;, ,:,',;..:i:::";",~:, ",';',.."'t'."..,,
ff{~t:f~::~:~!~" ,: :;, "'?f;0~-;'~~'}~:~;;',,,~~~~~:t~~~(~
"'::,,'.,:,) -',:,,, .',:::,C','..',>."..",.." ..,',L"'".,..',, ,:. ".",..,"...',
0:: ~~. ;'>":\>-,1 ,"~ ,,~,?~:f/;-, " 'i~'<>, l:} :>}':~'(<:' \ ~ (: \/'..> J~':,:::,- !!,";.,{-:}:.,~ ''t'~'~:';', :.}:,:;i;, <-;: .. _ _ . _
" ..' "<",<,',,:,,, ,,~," "'".. p.......,... ......... .. ,..~,.." '. ........ ..
,',' ,cl:::'.,''';'" ;'''/:1:;,:'', ';"'+:~~', ~ ',:;/ ',,: ',v; ~,::'. ~;~;';i,~\'< ',', ;, "..'"
".,:rCt~"T'::~}: .' c.:' "::c' ;,;,,~r;~:~;
" ;'..' ,""...', :"; ",' ;'~i"'"'' "",,'
, "i:,..':,,:-" ','" ...", :,.',,' ".", .."
, , '''''','' H,' ;, ',;~;
" '::;...':' ;;"1~:;'i~ ;,e; .<: ,.: ,e..,
:.' ":,/:",:.,, t~j;\:::!~i!:~;~ ':>;";(~::
;';"'~, i;;,:,:,"n"'::.."';";:::';~I~~l';' ;,', ,.""..',!'Y",;, .':-;:-,
,...., ''-';'.':'.:>,',:;:'';< ",;':,'" '". ;..c"""::
," ",i;',:.. .>;,:,':\<:'~":.. ',,''';;' ,:':'" ':, (,'".:. ]':' "..i":~;?:,:,~1 ,::;:
.';., "/' :,J "..,',', ,',:,', ',:,' "';:.", c, ,,' ': ,:.; t> " :,.,:" :f:
>"':.;;~; , , ."c.',<.:,:' ' C,>. " , ;:;.:;/'::2: ,,:
:', :<::;\';.:{":;; 'i,~,;<"'i':~;: '/:;~:'lLL1;)/' ":~:,",
::~..:'~;~!"":' i:!'f ..f}:;'::';,..' ,.. ,", .:,.;:":::;,
''',1,<,,' ,..,';' ',,.,' 'i;'i' "\ ~1~~~~:
'."'...';. !i...' '.'",'" ", ,', "
',' ','.' , ;'.,.', "..,',]1, ; ,,,,;{"''';f,;' "r,~'~",'; oct'..,
;, r:,:'; ;",">, o:,'-"':;"::} '" ::""1,;,' ':';:: ".
,~,,: f(";,:; .. :":,,:'>:d~~,,,(,:,;,,:;c> ,." ;';<,:...,.;" ,: ",
;< ,;, ,,;: ...,', ".:i,".;';>',.,.. ',\/ :;":: .', :.. " '.',~, "',':\...
;:,::;',..., '.;,:. ,',: >~:; <~,/.( ~'t;~~:~;'
':; ':C ..,'; .; ':;;/;: ;',:, ;~ei,~';\5t~;t ;J;i~g:
.. ,~;>" ; ',"> ' ,~"':'~\".,,~ ';:~~~:;;~~~..,...~.:1!':':;?;;:,:,;';'::, ",
,:, ...','., , t .' "', ;,;:',' :',:K!1"]"': .,,:.. ;,.: " :/~, :'j';.;iii;i~;';;,,";' !.;; "
,,' ".. ::;'-..:';",;.';',: ,..~n':N,
',,"';;': , .;,;, ":., ".;~,'f }'-:,
.' "",.;,qr ,'i.:,;:,..'" ,
',0;:"" :;7i?: l~;' ~,/;~; ;:;!,~;~~~~~~ ,,;,~;~
..~,~..~" /~!t: 'J~'rZ '0i~J;~~~:~~~;t ,,'
~; ',~::::>r~:~;~ ,:,"\" " J:
.. ;~,;,!.',:>,:;;;~,,;:. ,~, ;:;~;};:~~;,::;,':j;/
.' .< ",':f:,..':.';f;;~::;~ ," y, :~;j::: ~(::.:;:<,~
",.,,: " ,.'.. .'. ,,.:.' " " , ;',;, " ,~::: c~:':: ; 0;', ,,:.,;;:~~~{~ ::~},
,,::.; " ",;;;\:: '..,f;';>;';'::,'::)<:~~f
'~"', '", ,', :,;::.,::/ ; ':;. i'.."c,\";:' ";: "Y" ~',:":i"",:
::",', ',.", ," ' , "': '; :,"/ " ", ':' 'C.,' ." ..",; .".... ;,,\,';:
",:;,,';,':0 , ,," "" " ' ",' " "">:,,,,, ' ,.,.."".. ':' :":
;~~~';".;'.<.'~ . , , . " . ,-. '. ..,~ "7'Y7>:;~-'
'.'::', :" ',',.n_'..,.n'n':::,~_n~ ,- U,__ ... ,:'f -:,'-' ," __,,__nO
, ..." I~:'" ~', "
';::;,
~;"{",,;""
:";
" "
, '..~
~',~~;:,'"
;~
;,:
\'i
,
.' ;;
,",
;"
;'::'~ ';.~'~ ;t:~
" ,,':
:" ;::;: '.
, ", ,,;' "
.. - -~
" ., .C':.' ,t'j.
, '. ct.', ,..,,;,"
"
,.,>'i:.:H;:,.>,,: .,.,.,'.,., <,; ',:",'.,~.',',.,., '>;, ';:',~",',: ,"" ,
'_;H' .'0 -. "~tf ~,?~: :,' ,.' . ", '~,;:.' ."',::n .. ",". '
. ',..''./
. , "." ';',',
'oS
. ,.c'.':,' '" "', ,," ',:' "
,,;n . ' ",',',',"','-':.;u~U
~,.>':,',' ..",','.,' ::" < .:> :,:<,r, <<),,%;}~
"::: . \, '.'" .,..':'. ;";':f '; ,
;,":>,. f,"" "',,.':,.::r ',;:;, ',",- ',' ..'"
,;" :;..';, "" ,~',',',', ~:..,.:':i' X;;:".,~,;:, {i.;,)?;~.,~.,".:,;:;;<, ,:
,,', ",,' ,,~'..;l;;,:, .'/:',:'~~;.'>'r;,'"
:.',,' ' ," "", ". ',";.",'. ":," ':::', "", "" '~: ';:' ,
.' '." ,,' ..'...." :'" ',:;.- t'..:.:,
c; :,')"/'1. ',;, '.', "::..;", ',;, ':.'.- ,',',
';2", /.. ,~;:;.; ,,::' ,"'n', ',; '.
';; ,"\"', ' '.: <;'C""'::,:,::" ,>\
:~,:.":' ;:};~;:!<.'.:~,:.,:.\; ::L
-:.: :>. ' ,"', Si,)?:~,,;
.~, ::'.'\;:: ",: ".';.',
,y ":::.;",~ ':",'
"'.""" ;,~ :.".: ,,".'..',, '",
, ":, ',:, '~;.'..,
.':" "" :,.;; '",.'" [:-,
:',' ..' .,. '
,'.\-:' ~;:;'.~:::'L;.~: ;,";':
" ,,;,,:,:, ,,:,; :';!'.,",
, ;:...',
'.,.' ,...,','",.".':..;,: "
\,' ',.)\'F':.'.:'~." ,>; ,'"
:f(",." ,'f<':,: ">' '/'I~ :',f :~~::'.,.:.;:' ;/~ ::ic~H
. '; '.,. ":, .' y,~?
..~ '::' ,.,...', ' ',',',i:r.~,,'..' ':, ,c;: .'"
.".' ,', :., ;;', ".';':.'.;.. c';'
; ,i', ..,:: : ~".,'~:, ,:,~ ";,;:,'~, ":,
'j:: ".'; ~:.',....;, '.., "':'.""";::,},: :,,\' ::.' f"'',(':''"''
c: ,,;.t:' ;,~': > .. .' ,', ,\'.. ".,i;;:
"''''i'-,: ',,:;.,;:.,:-,:.:, :i:'~!'
.~:'.'..: '.':' ~.:;,.,,:'., 'J,
;..,':;; "':.;)::' , "., P,
;': ;'~~r:' i:
:'
3': '"c.
i,
:.;,::oi~
,';' ~':'," ";,"','; ,,';,:,
":," :,::;:l\;'
, )'.':.
;i, ',"0..;
.'~
.0",
",
i~ ,.. :
~j~:
~..
;'..
i.'
C". f~::g;;,:" "','
:'.-',.'.', \7,~,...;~:>;i ;;'-:;t
;, .~;; ;J} "":,:.,,:u;;...,,.';,:' :,";
'>'''"., ,,..;'.' ':: ."::.' ,"';'~:';,. ,',
"",0.:;,'" '\' ;',:' ::\::: '
. ,.,,:.A~~;:!'~?"d .'.i:~:~~,1' '.',:: ~',' :"
" ' .:.... ", "': ' ,', '.',; ',: ,,::,.''' :',': '.. ,,', ".. ."
,,' '::.:";,;,;",;. ;:.";;." ," ,', : .',' : .''',' ';,,' , ,'\' "C'.'
,';.' " ''::-,' ',:'>..\ ' , '"
,"
~
;
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
:1
SILVANA PATE-LATORRE and
GREG LATORRE, her husband
Plaintiffs
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
v,
No. 97.887
GREG A. SMITH
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, David W, Knauer, hereby certify that I did this 12th day of August, 1999, serve a
true and correct copy of the within document on all counsel of record by United States
mail, first class, prepaid addressed as follows:
Robert A. Lerman, Esquire
Law Offices of Griffith, Lerman, Solymos & Calkins
110 S, Northern Way
York, PA 17402-3737
~ - ~ /
I/1JfJQ ) ~
""~ w. "",ee, L
Attorney for Plaintiff
Attorney I,D, No. 21582
411-A East Main Street
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
(717) 795.7790