HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-01010
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
THOMAS M. ESTILL,
...-
v.
NO. 97- 1010 CIVIL
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION,
Defendant
OATH
We do solemnly swear (or affirml that we will support. obey and defend the Constitution of the United
States and the Constitution of this Commonwealth and that we will' arge the uties of our office with fidelity,
:0- r-) . ..
u~ "- (
" ,.,
... ..
u'~- , .. .,
(,.
r,~: ' "
l.;;-
r_>. 1.,,:'
1.;.-' C,; , I
G ,. I
"
I. r- ... AWARD
( -'
v' .J
Choirmon
We, the undersigned arbitrators. having been duly appointed and sworn (or affirmedl. make the following
award:
(Note: I( damages (or delay are awarded, tl1ey sl1al/
be separately state.lr-J. _
fi"1' ~'''ht6 M ~ t-T 137. 7~.
Date of Hearing:
~/Z(,/11
, ,
fij2u/tf7
Choirmon
Date of Award:
] 1
/ J. nh P. Ruano. EsqUlrll
~'. 1/'
.'~ J....0'L...., .', " .1'1> ).-y,,--,..., -
Bnrhllfll A. Zil11l11cr/l1l1n. Esquire
NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD
Now, the c.7(/-'1 day of ,'{;tf(..J t . 19 J!L. at /(.)] o'clock. ~.M.. the above
award was entered upon the docket and notice thereof given by mail to the parties or their attorneys.
Id
~ I.A ~ /. ,_
/</ t~'--- u~ '"'U' I-IC.J! (..: Lo-'" ~
Prothonotary
Arbitrators' compensation to be
paid upon apreal:
$ "'?!/!;>. Ci>
By: orjl/"'-: ,r y;./r... ;:jPj
.
Deputy
v.
: COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY
:
:
: NO. 97-1010 CIVIL TERM
THOMAS M. ESTILL,
plaintiff
.
.
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION,: CIVIL ACTION - LAW
:
Defendant : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against
the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action
within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served,
by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and
filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the
claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to
do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be
entered against you by the Court without further notice for any
money claimed jn the Complaint or for any other claim or relief
requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or
other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
DAUPHIN COUNTY LAWYER REFERRAL SERVICE
213 N. Front Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
(717) 232-7536
NOTICIA
Le han demandado a usted en 1a corte. si usted quiere
defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en 1as paginas siguientes,
usted tiene viente (20) dias de p1azo a1 partir de 1a fecha de 1a
demanda y 1a notificacion. Usted debe presentar una apariencia
escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en 1a corte en forma
escrita sus defensas 0 sus objectiones alas demandas en contra de
su persona. Sea avisado que si usted no se defiende, 1a corte
tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo
aviso 0 notificacion y por cua1quier queja 0 a1ivio que es pedido
en 1a peticion de demanda. Usted puede perder dinero 0 sus
propiedades 0 ostros derechos importantes para usted.
THOMAS K. BSTILL,
Plaintiff
v.
: COURT OF COKKON PLEAS
: COMBERLAND COUNTY
I
:
: NO. 97-1010 CIVIL TERM
I
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION, I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
Defendant I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
COMPLAINT
AND NOW, comes Plaintiff Thomas Estill by his undersigned
counsel and respectfully brings this Complaint at law setting forth
in support thereof as follows:
1. Plaintiff herein is Thomas M. Estill, an adult individual
residing at 1101 Linham Court, Apartment 708, Mechanicsburg, 17055,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
2. Defendant Penn Warranty corporation is a corporate entity
with a principal place of business at 360 South Keyser Avenue,
Taylor, Pennsylvania 18517.
3. Defendant is in the business of, among other things,
issuing policies of warranty coverage for used automobiles.
4. On or about May 6, 1996, Plaintiff purchased a used 1990
Nissan automobile from Groff's Auto Sales. As part of the sale,
Plaintiff purchased a warranty contract on his automobile.
5. The warranty contract was purchased from Groff I s Auto
Sales, which is an authorized issuing agent of Defendant. A copy
of that contract is attached hereto as Exhibit A and incorporated
by reference herein.
6. The agreement was accepted by Defendant on or about May
10, 1996.
7. In approximately mid-September, 1996, Plaintiff
experienced a low brake pedal condition. On or about September 20,
1996, Plaintiff took his vehicle to Meineke Mufflers and had brake
work done on it.
8. The condition of Plaintiff's car was subsequently
diagnosed as being a failing brake master cylinder. The brake
cylinder was subsequently ordered by Meineke Muffler on or about
October 7, 1996, and was installed on or about November 6, 1996.
9. At the time Plaintiff applied for the warranty on May 6,
1996, Plaintiff's vehicle had an odometer reading of 84,740 miles.
On September 20, 1996, the odometer was recorded by Meineke as
91,707 miles. The average daily mileage during this period was
65.73 miles.
10. On or about May 10, 1996, assuming an average mileage of
65.73 miles, the odometer reading is extrapolated to be 85,003
miles.
11. On November 6, 1996, Meineke Muffler recorded the
odometer reading as 93,518 miles. The average daily mileage
between that and the last two recorded dates, to wit, September 20,
1996, is 38.53 miles per day. The odometer reading on October 7,
1996, based on the average daily mileage calculations, is
extrapolated to be 92,362 miles.
12. The mileage between the time of acceptance of the
contract by Penn Warranty and the date the brake master cylinder
was ordered is 7,359 miles.
13. The failure of the master cylinder occurred well within
the time limit and within the mileage covered by the warranty.
14. Despite the fact that the Plaintiff made a valid claim
under the warranty, Defendant has denied payment.
COUNT 1
15. Paragraphs 1-14 above are incorporated by reference
herein.
16. The failure of Defendant to honor the contract
constitutes a breach of the warranty agreement.
17. Defendant's breach of the warranty agreement is willful
and deliberate.
18. The cost (parts and labor) of replacing the master
cylinder and correcting the low brake pedal problem is $137.75.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests judgement in his
favor in the amount of $137.75.
COUNT II
Paragraphs 1-18 are incorporated by reference herein.
19. Defendant I s actions as set forth above constitute an
unfair deceptive trade practice or act within the meaninq of the
Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Act.
20. Said Consumer Protection Act authorizes a penalty of
three times actual damages, together with other appropriate relief.
21. Plaintiff to date has incurred $500.00 in attorney's fees
to prosecute this action and will continue to incur reasonable
attorney's fees and expenses on this appeal, which was made by
Defendant to a judgement entered against it. Further fees and
expenses are estimated to cost (through arbitration) between
$750.00 - $1,000.00.
i
t
r
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests judgement in his
favor in an amount three times actual damages or $413.25, together
with reasonable attorney's fees of at least $1500.00, together with
interest and cost of suit.
COONT III
22. Paragraphs 1-21 above are incorporated by reference
herein.
23. This warranty agreement is covered by the Magnus and Moss
Warranty Act.
24. For the reasons set forth above, Defendant's violations
as set forth above constitute violations of the Magnuson Moss
Warranty Act.
25. Under the Magnuson Moss Warranty Act, multiple damages,
together with attorney's fees, are authorized.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff respectfully requests judgement in his
favor in the amount of actual damages plus multiple damages as
provided by the Magnuson Moss Warranty Act, together with
reasonable attorney's fees, interest, and cost of suit.
Respectfully submitted,
//
f
Date:
.') /;r J
L/
I
tl /
I
, ,
"
KENNETH A. WISE, ESQUIRE
10 NO. 16142
126 LOCUST STREET
P. O. BOX 11489
HARRISBURG, PA 17108-1489
(717) 238-3838
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
,.
THOMAS H. ESTILL,
IN THE COURT OF CO~~ION PLEAS OF
CL~BERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
NO. 97-1010
CIVIL
v.
THE PENN I~ARRANTY CORPORATION,
Defendant
RULE 1312-1. The Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be substantially
in the following form:
PETITION FOR APPOnITlIE~T OF ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Kenneth A. Wise
. counsel for the plaintifr/A" Jane in
the above
1.
2.
action (or actions), respectfully represents that:
The above-captioned action (or actions) is (are) at i~sue.
The claim of the plaintiff in the action is S 2.000.00
The counterclail:! of the defendant in the action is SO. 00
The follolling attorneys are interested in
wise disqualified to sit as arbitrators:
the case(s)
No on",
as counselor are other-
WHEREFORE. your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3)
arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted.
Respe.ctf~l}y ~~t:ed,
't//ltt1J. /; It tn
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, JUA1 L I~ . 19 I( 7. in consideration of the
foregoing petition, CfOtlkJJ.... L,'IIUI~Esq.,bii.s~ ~WAItJL/
Esq., and ~~~"I?1I11~.ESq., are appointed arbitrators in the
above-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for.
By J;-y;r ( ~
P. J.
fo- Lv-f7 ~
6-to-17
9. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted at the time
Plaintiff applied for the warranty, Plaintiff's vehicle had an odometer
reading of 84.740 miles. As to the remaining allegations of paragraph (9),
after reasonable investigation, Defendant is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments of
this paragraph, the same would be denied.
10. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without
information eufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
this paragraph, the same would be denied.
knowledge or
averments of
knowledge or
averments of
knowledge or
averments of
11. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
this paragraph, the same would be denied.
12. After reasonable investigation, Defendant is without
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the
this paragraph, the same would be denied.
13. Denied. It is specifically denied the failure of the master
cylinder occurred well within the time limit and within the mileage covered
by the warranty. On the contrary. the Defendant, The Penn Warranty
Corporation wae contacted on October 30, 1996, pertaining to the master
cylinder at which time it was discovered that 8,770 miles were placed on
the vehicle which is over and above the contract terms between the parties
and therefore, Defendant, The Penn Warranty Corporation is under no
obligation for reimbursement on this repair.
14. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that
Defendant was denied payment. It is specifically denied that the Plaintiff
made a valid claim under the warranty. On the contrary, said warranty had
expired when the claim was called in for a master cylinder therefore, the
Defendant is under no obligation for repairs.
COUNT I
15. No answer necessary.
16. Denied. It is specifically denied the failure of Defendant to
honor the contract constitutes a breach of the warranty agreement. On the
contrary, the agreement between the parties had expired based on the
mileage of the vehicle and therefore, the Defendant is under no obligation
for the repairs.
17. Denied.
warranty agreement
agreement between
under no obligation
It is specifically denied Defendant's breach of the
is willful and deliberate. On the contrary, the
the parties had expired and therefore, the Defendant is
to make said repairs to the Plaintiff's vehicle.
-2-
':ti:~~.:,'!' .~~ "!, .~'..... ", ..~:~., 'I. .:. -'. ,'" :-~-....t' -:=--.,'.......;,:;-'...J'--=---." -', ",
I ..~Ifii.;-~ .!/t..'A..~:;. -':t"';":l', ",:,.""'1':" .. :.\..\ ~ _;tU,':~) ~!l: ..'~~':-: ~l,'.''''~\' ,.};; . It$, ~l\."
"1~ '/'JI\" \,;:'w;h.(:,~1i"::;1 ";:a:':':'~":tl.:,t.!', ~j~'''~' " ''"''1'''' "j ~'''f''~'''.'''/jf'\'f;' . Ji~",{!:i;.
~~ ':,~:!"q \h': >!:Iq\\~; ,. ~(i~\\~:' .i!!II\\\'.' i;Lf/1I'\~i~ ~r'Al ~\i;: !"~fI1!'\\I,; "~tf1 ~"\I;:l~A1I.\\!\:I~' II
>Ai,~ '~--, "':.r:..,_ ,,~I!:_';:'~'C,'--,-~~,L:_:~_'~'~ .
I \!%': The I'enn Wllrrnnly CorpllrnUlln
\ fI d Jr..) ~ulllh K(')"rf ^\'t'IUU' . TI)lnr. r^ IR~11 HAY' 1 0 19l1C
IRlMll.\ll,.Y441 . 1111Il('2,ll~XI ilU
STANUAJU) CONTRACT HOV (Jg ..
S/~)r16 ....___.__'/___'_ VIN. __:TA1L~_MIWm'~,
OWNI'II'S NMtI,. . TlY'!Wf. ~L F.$tr/ ________ VI:II1CLr: YI:AR ____10. _ ___ ___________.
A""RI:SS, 101' AI, t14~/_o;l::__..._.__.__ VI'.1I1CWMAKH__:l.'I" s)(._ .___.._____
('II Y . _. f1t:'~1'1~~1n .... .n.... VI',lIIrl.l! MOIl!'!. ., ..PIn'''' nn.__ __.... .....'_" _
SlAlI, r/l. .. _______._. ';.' ZI.I'. ,._L7/J..~'~__ MII.I!A(]r:__'?~J..:..~'tQ _. '_n___..__._n._. _____
OWNI'R'S 1'1I0N!:. L:J17). h 7.. ">110 __ ....n l'IIRCIIASIlI'RICIl_, ~'. ')'It.'r:J .____ ...._. n___.__
I Ulltll',\'alltl ;1/111 "~II'(' 111:&1111(' lilllil('11 "':lIlilllly 111/11 rlllft'IIiI,llI~ j, :l1l1lf!1(,(,1l1t'1l1 htlwtrn lIIy,,'lf nlUl'llll~ I'I:NN W ARRAN I Y C'()RI'()RA"II()N
I hlllh('r 1I1111('I\I.IIUI n1ltlllJ:lrr Ih..lll1(' C'IU drllk, hUlI1l4hkh II'l11l:h:l\rtllhl' ('unlrnd h:., nlllil1hilil. y 111111(' ;lJ!fr('ltlrnl,lIlhr, limn 'Ull111illin, Ihe
r")"lIIC'nl :nul n('l'(,\\;II)' Ilaprrwlllk 1t,'IIn:A'I:~'lN W~nJt^N Y l'OIU'()RATION hlr Jllucr"illJ!
11I'AIHl'S N^~II' ___C-n/fJ IMtJ ~~f____ l'lm"t rtad tills rOlltrart ill filII b,filft ,';/llIill/l.
SAI.!:SMAN'S NMI!' ..__Il~A.. ~/f._. ______ OWNI'R'S ^CCIW,^NI'I' 10 o 11m
!J!'AII'R'S I'JIIIN!' ,_.. c....,.L?Ll?'j::jQ~:3 _ X Z~.T- A.,_e:..<:.:e'~
.p{r, M"l1.l'" Mi .~JRIlIKI 012 M"m,IKK' Mi . tllKIlKI 024 Mo.lJIl,lJ(J(] Mi., ~oIRIlI" OJr, M,,/H,IKXI ML, ~14IIlKI
!JAI!:
\l'IIU IS ('on:nf:ll?
ENClINL:. c) lillck, hlu. k.qliIMk.'f h(':..I". 1',"1 1111 illlrrnalll..1th ()linlklll(";I.IJ:;"Lrl"lnbke 1Il:\nifClMFI1\Lcl~,'Uld "l:IlliflIJ.l~ Vnh\"Ir:lilllUl.ll'mm. 11)'\\hn..'I.
(':umhall ;u)lllil1liu~llli\ l'I'CIlIlIll""llh f )ilIIUlUII:Ul.lllilll:UI St":II';IlI.I':I1\Lrl.. ""ilhllk"ru"t"JII""11l1 l')'IIIMkt IM':"lra,Lrhlul(l illlal.rIlL'Ulill11tlf::l\Lrl".Nrctl\1"lTtl
unly ill ('11I,jlllk1illll "".11i 11 lll\'rlt'l.lIrr-1ir. C)lillck', h(';)I1 mI.l iniaL\" IILlllifllM f:,,\Lcl.lU'tcU\'ttl"t1 lurcnnlalll k'ah nlll)'.
'1 U^N."i~'I~."iI()N {'11'>C' :Ull! 1111 inlnu:lIIL111" TI"IIUC l'I"l\nlrr lUlll\'IIlI\'rllrr IMlUd..,. St.;II. nntl t:;I\Lrl" all" lll\ ('rnl tmly In mnjlllld"'" \\ ilh 11 nnrtnln'I",i,.
1 JltIVI: ^XI 1:.1 "111,11" II':U Illi\l"lI,k 1.IlI\illl!m.1 :llIlnlrn);lll'",h l>tht'\hallllllllllllhr"-11;'liuh.l:flIC1l a\lt. j.illl\:ul'lll\etnll'III)'11l1 fl"" \\ IK1"llhhr \'thil.:k'".
11:111\fl"' r;1..... I'll fl"lf \\1.'''' Ilch-r \chil k" m.llllIllIlI:III:11 11Iuh Sral" 11I1.1 t:11\LI'" Nt' enven.UlIClly ill \l.njUlkliClll \\ilh a l"llvt"n-d Irl1;li.,
('f)(JI.lN(iS,",SIrM. fan:mllflll1dllllh Ehll....,.llliah.. 1:llInllllllr, Willet 1"1Il11'
S 1J=.I]tIN(j . SII"("lillJ! f.!(';U. mc.~ nll.l i~II.1I11 :1~o;clllhly" nlkl all illle'III:IIII;UI', I'uwcr ~llXlingokllcf ftlkllinr".
SlJ~I'I:N~1f IN. Sl'lilll!...llllll"11 IUIll". mI.! h..1I ;Hl1l"
11Jt^1<I:." . ^II hfillt''''I"l1p1l1k'nl''. ilkhllltllJ: :dl ('IIlIlI.IlK'llh Ilrllk" nllli II,L l"aLr 'y..tclII. ela:rl"lillill):'" p:..I\.IIIlI....lIlklllnnn.".
H.rrIHWAI.. AIIl'IIMIt... \ull:lfl' n'):ul:lIl1f. willtl.JlirM wil....' mill" PI'III ~1;u1rr miliCII'.
ItI:NI AI.{"An . "''-'l'Ill)'li\t' 1"llIal'l;I"" I"i,:.hlll.."" llf n..1 ",Ie lilllt' hlu'I1;lit c..ttldill.-c act1vrml n"IlI"III1K'111 \\itll:lI11:1\innll1111rl\\tlllllll.bnlllllll rill~'I~I":tn
'1 ()WIN{;. II) 1"11 (:u 1Il11\11~ Ill\\rllh,'(;)il\(, n\'II\'rmlllJ1l1flllll("lIll1:1\ fnikll.lIl"intt i"cuvrmllothr nr;Ifr\111'1:11ifinln11O,il'lynlt1 upluOIlltL\ilUtllllnr rin)' dullan
I.AIUJIl.11k' 1:11.111 h.llrl'" 1l:1'<11 1111 hllhl\lf)' tkT\1"1'1.IO;l1 mlnh1lt"Il:lil.llf 1t.III:k"CrlmvrmloMllp.....1l1
now WN(: IS 'I 11I-: \\'^RR^NT\'?
'111('1II.Olt ;tllilllill~1 ";IIr:ml)' II.'J!ill' 1"111"lb)' \\ Ik'"llli. ;11:1\'1.'1)1('111 i.lk Irlllnlll)' '11 IE PI~N W ARltAN'rY ('( lit I" )ltA TU)N nlklla\l" II" tll('I"lillll \l'1 rllllh
alm't', SI. 111M )'''111114 1l'l..,.i\'I" II. IIUit.:lIinl1l1l1l11 II~ ""ilhin \t.\t'll l1)tll)'" III III..' \Iall" ur )'ll..lr L'l.IIIIIlI..:llI..."'IIl:lIkL'.lIl1til)' ""1111'11\11"11.'1 ~'f\'in'lIlll(llll.1~h II.MI
WIIA liS NlIITOn:IlF.Jl?
'1111~ I'I:NN WAltlt^Nf Y ('OItI,mAlll)N \\i1Illlll 111vt"t nil)' n.ftlit t"Mrr "itlllll,lll"linr DlIlhldn"""I. 011I11""11,'111 f:lillln:.IIL111....CIlII.K..lil 11ll" Ik:t't"l"OllU'
III Ilk' L'IIIIr.k 1:1It" 11114 tll\c:n'll hy 4hi"",:.lt"Cllk'nl Ollle'r he'll'" nll4 L'lIVC1\,1 illdlkk di:lgllKlic ch:ugrs.lI11kJ knL... ml.l tLUII.11-'t 1II<It ~Illl" rMllll My pre\"II....I..
illll..l'.....rIt"I1.1i,,,
'll,ilO \\ilrr:llll) IIt~\ ,,,I4\'ll\rr tilt' '1;\11\ nlkll;dl.lt 11"'1 rut' Ik."lrll hltnailllain ),ltlft.:u (nil". fillrr.ctc.),lhc 1\11'"nl )'(lUI t':1I111:t1 arc "uhjre! III unml.,1 wem mkllrw
1,:,"11('11\. r,,,liall" IIlN.... rlr ,J.lblltll!C lu )" "'r rat Illallt'liollll" IIlMIlIitt',lkl.'ilk'IlI.lhrn.lItOnJiltum fll Ihe (,1l\'il1llllll("nl.ll;1I11:l~ 111.11 l\.""ull" rnMl1 \("''''''1.:' IIllrtil1~
Ilrr L':l'. lIlim\ll1p. lilt' (':U.I:tlllf1C'rinf: wilh II.. (";If.ITI:l1in~ jlltflfllf"t I1Ilju\lmrnl", hnrrnp~t fuel\' Irnpn~,ly mlilll:lillillf: IIlt'cnr.l.. rAilil1t: III ntlinl:ain IhC' l'N.
\1'/10\ l TIIf.I'F.NN WAltRANTl' ('ORI'JRAlIIlN W1/.1.IK'
IJlllk"lhi" 11!\1:1)( 'AR 1.I~tl J lil)W ^f{R^N '" ,1111:I'IWN W AnnAN'I1' (.C ml,)RA nON ""III n:inlhUl'l')IIII fl" III(' n"p.,irt.,q.I:1l."("u..nlul IUl}'rolllrll'k'UI
t:cl\r't"t1 hr Ihi\ ;1J:IlTllk'1l1lhalI" 111111111 In I.... 11cr1..:liV(' I" WClllll11')'l"1l1 V'f\'kC' Ihulh, ^ner 11lYr'li~lllilll! t'''''I''''''I''"1'1I1 railutt'. III lilt' rat".(" III ntli.....n.I1:UII."). in
lil,,'ill~'" III: 11:NN W^,UtAN'I'Y fl)IU'fIf{AItIJN m:IY dul".(' III h.1\1: lIlt' 11'1'C11r'l...."lt' nl n oJll,lllilku'nIUI<III11Il'I"... )'IlII);1\'r 'IoI:hl01 11m I1:NN
w AIUtAN I Y ('t Uti, IIlAI U IN \\ i11lrillllllll'l" )1"11111111.:' t'1l1irc nll.Il.111I111 f1".tI\'("n-d I'l.JlIII"1f1C'1l1 Inillll\". k',,, n'!;llnl dtll~t"" Illll L'lI\l'Il'l.1 11)' Ihi"llf:I\'f'lIl('lll.l~"
l\lornl) Ihrlltlll:1n'....'IHlll1\.lk'C.
\l'IIAI'\'lIlJMIISrIlO
,",11111 \dlh:k.' nlll\ll..:II a n'l'"ill."rnlrl illl"ll-r rill Rt'l.1irn 1111....1'11("11.'1.1. C )11.'(' IIw: \dliclr i. nlllc 1t"11.1i, n'lllr. )1'" tin' n'\l..""ihlr 11111.,,\(" Ihe It"I"lir tTlllrf ('a11
t1~ 1I1IRllll.1.IIri(,".U 1 \\ ilh lilt' C'\lilllale clI n'1':ail"ldlllt" ,'Uly Wl"k t"'J!im .11.... WiVlllllly Illlldcr 11O IC'iflllCI'ihlr rllr :t111'h;Uft"" It"Ialin(!.ln Ihe' le;u llt'\\'1l nJkllli;lrnttlii,
uf lilt' \1:lIi, II.", I( il i\ Ilt:lwuinN thai :I01\('ft"lJ\1"1~lllllC"nllL'\~ r"ilnl 31111 lIlt' r"lilll.,lc It It Ihe n-pain jo; :lgrrnl 11111111 11)'(11.11 :Mljmltt.nl'Plllllllfl1.:tlnlll IIlImh:r will
11:' i(\II('t! 11)' u.. re" Ihr 1t"l1.,1it 11k' pUllui1;llilll1 nlllnl......lIIll\1 "I.,..nr Ilf' all m:cil"~ ..uhOlillaJ relf PJyul("ul Rrll;lit ("~lilll:ll~l'n.11 hc.....JlIC :II any clllalirK'\1 n'pait
lOll." )'1111 rlllllt\('. When IlI:,Lill~ R:IJai,o; the It"(\,it ~11l",hallllli(' n""llllt..nl"nfllw: !'o1nletyp: nntl1fUo,lily 3" 11.1\(' f1:1I111\nl. \\1lt'11 11.,1\ illg llL,inlrn:UkT tllllC 111
)1'11I \fhidr )'1"'lIlIl\II\'latn:1l1l11ptc'tll ,-""L 1....lrIJlllk'l.l. \\t" n;lioClYt Ilk'li~hlltlf\"ql~ NI)' and all U\aittlCIl.:llkt" 1t'l1"11, 1....ll..inillJ: 111)111." \dIM.'le. A nnctJrtailnl
~\'rolllt' In h,ll"w \\111.'11 11..,kin~ n rqul, I"If rrplnctlllclll "'Iller dlilO wnrrnnly will he!\Cn( 10)'tlU wilh )lJtIf ['u..luUIl" ilklllirlL.lIlitM'cnnl,
U IllER WARR^NrI'lERMS ANII SrAU: RIGIIIS
'111(' (11(111'111\('111 l<tillllt' 1Illl\llICXur UIllk"'llll'T1l:llu\(' ol Ilk'l'i.., dUlill1! Ihe ":IIf:lnl)' nn"Clitgt p:riud lhi~ ll'lC\ILallilllil\'l.1 \\;ur.mly jlO 1J:u,~rrrJhlc II. "utN:ttl1rlll
""'lk'r-;llrr ('IWJ:l' rllf Imll~rrf i. CllIr hllTkln.,II.,lIar;. 1 he' 1r:IIKknro w:ur.llIly will trm:!in in dJccl ftll" IlK" rrmailkl'f IlrlhellligilL11 cmcrn(!1: pcriOll WillklUl
311:\ll\k. hI lIlt' 1k'"'II\\IW',lhi"l'"IImc.1 i"ICl1l1ill:111"11 nl Ih(' lillK" nl ~11r 111 lilt' whidc cm-rml In Ihi" ""11111( I
1111,1'1 NN W ^1t1t^N I Y (1ml, )J{A'llf IN tl.w;'lj, f1cll ulItl..ile:lIIY 11..'~"1 1I1\1\':\le rill" IlaIlYI~~ig:1IH"IIJI h.lhlll'/ iUlllllllnlil'l1 ""ilh ilt t\;ur:lIll) 1111~ I,:NN
W Af{ltANI Y ( (1Il1,)ltA IU)N "i11lxlf ~ 1t"~I'lIlt,~ihJr fur:Ul) li,I'lC'lh.,1 )'111111';(". rill" My IOOIC1\"tniclk't" )Iltllllit: II h,"\:llIo;nJ,11t 11"'''t,1 )'Illt hnn~I""I:llic"'.111C'
lrl.llll) 1,1 a 11"1"1111') lhr rt"l1;Iilll'lllrr. tlf "" :111)' 1>lI'lC'r itk "!,rlllal,,, llln\("I'M'nli.lllLlIll:l~~ )1'1(1 m:r)' IIo1\r Nlllllhc:' t 11I1111I1lK'nl".IIIIIrIIIL111111.1\C' h\lrJ. o'lft ol\rml
ll) lit" \\,III.lIlI) NULI",III '-' ill h.' i~"IIC.'l.ll'Il1r:uI)'lrnllillalitll'" y,,,,, 1l\('dl,lllimik'tJ w:unully (:iV('~)I'l(I(I'("t. ifM; lit!hh YIIIIIlL'yh:l\ellllw:rlif:h'~U);11 \;uy '"1111
~I:llrhl..lalr OIW\ l...J'mn\\'lIml'I'("'T......
.. .,
'." "':~~":~"'~~~.~";!J':,,'(;::~.:r:~/l'-t:JI";4>
. ..~"...-.., -."~ 'u" ':10:' \.I ",.~,F" '~l" ,":.,t.
"-"~:;I::--:=-.':-'~_~ ,~.: ':':,. -":r.!:""~~';~~U..._.,
;",.". ,",'-
. ~... .', "'! .t.,'~ '_..... ',\: .'. .,...~~;..:
. .
-......0;.",..'.......___..
" '
._~~..';;~
'~.~ - .,t...~~
- "'''''1~''''. ~j/)'.I
"~' ';H' '
".i,. "frY''"!'
-,. ,I..,.
..I.",.\...
..........
.. .
.. --..- -.....--. ..
THOMAS M. ESTILL,
IN THE COURT OF CO~~ION PLEAS OF
CUHBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiff
NO. 97-1010
CIVIL
v.
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION,
Defendant
RULE 1312-1, The Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be substantially
in the following form;
PETI!!ON FOR APPOINTItENT OF ARBITRATORS
TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT:
Kenneth A. Wise . counsel for the p1aintift/" . jaR~ in
the above
1.
2.
action (or actions), respectfully represents that:
The above-captioned action (or actions) is (are) at issue.
The claim of the plaintiff in the action is S 2.000.00
The counterclaim of the defendant in the action is$O.OO
The following attorneys are interested in the case(s) as counselor are other-
wise disqualified to sit as arbitrators: No onp
WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3)
arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted.
RespectfUjY
" ,-/.
till!l! .',
sllbl:1it :ed,
! / .
I t v;.t.
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, WUI\J L I tt, , 19 97, in consideration of the
foregoing petition, C;eVkJ"- /" '~IL'.1d y- Esq., ~.s~ i' UAN.i..,,1
Esq., and &Il.IJALIi z.,'YnlYlrLJnAItJ, Esq., :re appointed arbitrators in the
above-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for.
By ~h/court, ..:
t: ( '-< I ( -
J/~
P. J.
(,. L..;- 17 11.1-~
~ ,'( /1
>- C'J --
n~ u: (-:
i.... .
, "
lU(- , ,
c'.
P:' . :
..
Cd"
~ "
2~' .:')
I:' I ,
E~~t ( " I
'. !:.:..
1
II r- ~;:;
U 0- U
T.,._ (717) 766-4575
17055-0000
NOTICE OF JUDGMENT/TRANSCRIPT
CIVIL CASE
PLAINTIFF: N'M' ....~,"..--.... ~
r.: ., )r,-- ''''Lf
ESTILL, THOMAS M. __~ ,: i~ '\.'
700 N.MARKET STREET -j.~."
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
L ~
VS.
DEFENDANT:
NAME aM AOOf\ESS
~HE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION I
360 S.KEYSER AVENUE
TAYLOR, PA 18517
L ~
Docket No,: CV-0000010-97
Date Flied: 1/15/97
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
Mag. [)I,t No.
09-3-05
OJ Name: HOt'
RONALD E. KLAIR
""..... 507 N. YORK ST.
MECHANICSBURG, PA
THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
360 S.KEYSER AVENUE
TAYLOR, PA 18517
THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT:
Judgment: DEFAULT ,TUDGMENT PLTF
00 Judgment was entered for: (Name) ESTILL, THOMAS M.
00 Judgment was entered against: (Name) THE PENN WARRANTY CORPORATION
in the amount of $
o Damages wl11 be assessed on:
<14' '7<; on:
(Date of Judgment)
'/14/<1'7
(Date & Time)
o This case dismissed without preJudice,
Amount of Judgment $
Judgment Costs $
Interest on Judgment $
Attorney Fees $
913.25
29.50
.00
.00
TOTAL
$
942.75
o Levy Is stayed lor _ days or 0 generally stayed,
o Objection to levy has been filed and hearing will be held:
Date:
Place:
Time:
ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGH~ !9.APPE;AL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE
OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARY/CLERK OF COURTS OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION.
~O.UrUST I~CLUD~,A{~~~ .~F~~I NOTIC~ O~ J DOMENT~RANSCRIPT FORM WITH YOUR NOTICE OF APPEAL
) 1. I ~( ( ,I }~te . ~. .., . District Justice
I certify that this is a true and correct copy of the record 01 the proceedings containing the judgment.
2 / 'I(r~' . /C~" -~
// (11/ (ate.<. G(- 'j
My commission expires first Monday 01 January, 2002 ,
, District Justice
-
SEAL
AOPC 315-96
:0- '- >-..... ,-..)
a; "" t. \oJ
., -,<. .~.J
t-: .. ..
IJlr~ - ;, ~ f\~ "---.J
t).: ) :',
r:(." '.
, , .-.'... - nJ
,j~ . ::j ~ .J "-
- ....
0: t_:,) ;;;- -
L..:.Jr ': ~." p:.
_J .... ~
L:;! c....:; ,....... ,j
t. : 'cJ
, '-' .'.'U... J ~ u
" (:~ :3 ~
c; ~ () 0 ~ .....,1
:>..1 "'tI
""" ~ ~
b...