The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About97-01788 \ .... '1 ~ ~ - ':.. .::f ~ ~ ::::: ~ \ '-,,- ""', \ \ J I"J' /" , I I I ..... ::l .... I '-.J , i g) I t'- \,)' ~ " ELMER H. DO~L, JR" P1aJntiff III THE COURT OF CO~lMON PLEAS OF CL1mERL.\1ID COlrnTY, PEllllSYLVANIA 1997 i I , I I I I I i I , r' RULE 1312-1, The Petition for Appointment of Arbitrators shall be substantially 1n the following form: " 110. 1788 CIVIL v. DONALD E. MURLATT, SR" Defendant , PETITION FOR APPOIllTIIEllT OF ARBITRA,ORS TO THE HONORABLE, THE JUDGES OF SAID COURT: Debra K, Wallet, Esquire , counsel for the plaint1fi/~l!~OOdlll(O( in the above accion (or actions), respectfully represents that: 1. The above-captioned action (or actions) is (are) at issue, 2. The claim of the plaintiff in the action is 51.550.00 1:1e counterclaim of the defendant in the action is $3,408.41 The following attorneys are interested in wise disqualified to sit as arbitrators: Mr. Yaffe is Defendant's counsel. the case(s) as counselor are other- TAFF....n:' f\) V"'FfQ Esg. , WHEREFORE, your petitioner prays your Honorable Court to appoint three (3) arbitrators to whom the case shall be submitted, Respectfully submitted, ~ ; I: ~ I I I I I I ! I,Q~-t'. ~ ~ ~!\ OF COURT ~bra K. Wallet AND NOW, ~ I , 19~, in conside~ation of t~e foregOing petition, tZ:'U<l{~ IL, l...wi;;) Esq., XPat'l-d /a~Vj U Esq" and ,Esq" are appointed arbitrators in the above-captioned action (or actions) as prayed for, - . J. COMMOI4WEAL TH OF PENNSYLVANIA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM JUOICIAL OISTRICT DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT COMMON PLEAS No, 1997-lJ8B.Civil Term . NOTICE OF APPEAL NOlice I. given that the appellant has filed In the above Courl of Common Plea. an appeal from Ihe judgmenl rendered by Ihe Dlnrlct Junlce on the date and In the case menlianed below, "AM UP .......L...""" Donald E. Hurlatt, Sr. ..".. all', NO. 0" .."... O~ D.I, "DOlt... 0.. ""..."........" 09-3-04 2 Chestnut Circle Clf" ""T' II" COOl .ATI 0.. 'UD......,. Camp l/i11 P1\ 17011 3/14/97 'N 1'''' CA" 0.. "'-""/ '0._11 Elmer H. Doll eLl"" NO. V., ".N"'TU". 0" ............."',.... 0" "" .TTO""',,, 0" ......T Donald E. Murlatt, Sr. TA 19 Q7 (''IT )1: IT 19 Thi. block will be signed ONLY when this nalalian is R,C,P,J,P, No, 100BB, This Notice of Appeal, when received by the District Justice, will operate as · SUPERSEDEAS to Ihe judgmenl for possession in Ihis case, " appellant was Clalinant (see Pa, R,C,P.J,P, No, /00/(6) in action before District Justice. ho MUST FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days aftor filin9 his NOTICE of A"PEAL, Signature of Prothollotary or D~puty PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE (This secNon of form to bo used ONL Y when appollant was DEFENDANT(see Pa, R,C,P,J,P, No, /00/(7) in action before District Justice, IF NOT USED, detach from copy o~ notic~ of appeal to be served upon ,appellee), ' , .. \' , . , PRAECIPE: To Prothonotary , ,Enter rule upon 'P.lmAr H _ nn 11, .'1,.. Name of app,flao(J} . appellee(sl. to file a complainl in this appeal (Common Pleas No, lQQ7-l7RR Civil Tp-rm wilhin twenty (201 days afrer service of rule or suffer entry of judgment of non pros, /77, ~\: " .J._::: \. ,-Ii .... RULE: To Flg~ H.'ggll ~ ;..,. ,.. )..~ Name'df ~f,PB . II , appellee(sl ,- -.' ~,_.', - ~ . " , 'J~. , - (1) You arc noli fled that a rule is hereby enlered upon you 10 file a camplainl in this appeal wilhin twenty (20) days alrer the dale of service of this rule upon you by personal service or by certified or registered mail. ..... Dale: April 7. (2) If you do natlile a complaint within this time. a JUDGMENT OF NO~ PROS Will BE E,NTERED AGAINST YOU, , ,J"" - , . I . td ,q ,'! ' (3) The dale of service of this rule if service was by mail is the dale of mailing, ',' ., ,- - 'A~/~,,., I-". f 19~ . I .J.jRh ~ Sign.tu'~ f rhonorary or Deputy AOPC 312-84 COURT FILE , ,'I I .. i' " ~ j' , ., j , .. . " '.r! \, t.' PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOtiCE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT -, . , " . '-" . ' , ' (TI,!s )"00; ot s~rvi~o MUST BE FILED WITI/lN FIVE (5) OA YS AFTER liIillY tlw 1I00in' 01 ;11'1'0,1/, CllI.'ck i1pplicdblv/Joxesl, COM~ONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF. """mh~r' ~n" ;u AFFIDAVIT: I herelly swe,r or affirm.h,. 1 surv,,,1 ,,~1. a copy 0\ 't'hic N'olic'c ~f~AI;"lC'~'1. Co'n~~ll'~:~ 'Plllds ~o: 1997-:17,8.~,on the biS't~i(;I:J'~~'ticl~;d~Si9Ilat('d therein on (claw o( sorvice)...Ap.;d.l 10 ,19-9~, 0 hy IImun,l scrvic', 51'! lly (emtificd' hOl!listuroul'mail, sender's rf!ceipt attached herelo, and upun thl! iJppcltec, (n.lmcJ_ ~ll!l.e~_~I. 0011; Jr. ___ . on --Apri' 1 n ,19--9..1-.IJ hy personal st!rvicl' ~J hy (cl~rtifil!lll (lt~lJl~ll!rl!d) mail,stmrle,'s'feceipt lIttnchedhercib',: (!CJ and further that I servl!(1 the Rule to -FIle a Complaint whom the Aule WilS iHldressed on--Ap...ril--'lO . moil;'sender's 'receipt ...ttached hereto, \>. '. ' < .', ",' - SWORN (AFFIRMEDIJANOSUBSCRIBED REFOREME' THIS , nth DAY' OF..A ,19--97 , 'l. accomprtl1yinU the ahove Notice of ~Appeal "lion Ih~ 8ppellep.(s) to . 19 __9...7, [J . hy person,a1 .!.ervicl~, [?9"h,Y ICt!rtificdl (rc!!isti!fl!(1I -~~y~-' cti/j ~~ S'9".'U'. uf.t,I",!t, ~:- "i, Tir/a 01 01 leiiJl " My comml.~sion l.')(pircs on , 19 ~,lr"NOTAAJALSEAL , ", JEI'I:REY N, YOFFE, Notary PubIIo :;\ CampttinBoro, Cumberland County ,M Comml..lon Ex Ill" Oct 2000 " l '(0 " , (") ')' , " ' , ; ~ ' ' !; .... "n ,- "" -j ."t)l:J ..,., , -.::n Qlll. :;0 ';\- Z-,. -' Zl J;" i~ '!A' ' ~( ~!.~ ::"> .., ;L;c :z 2 Zc- \9 I';' ~~" =< .', :::> ?Q :~ (X> ~ COMMONWEAL TIl OF PENNSYLVANIA COURT OF COMMON PLEAS NOTICE OF APPEAL FROM JUOICIAL DISTRICT DISTRICT JUSTICE JUDGMENT COMMON PLEAS No. 1997-1788 Civil Term NOTICE OF APPEAL Notice is given that the appellant has filed in the above Coun of Common PIcas an appeal from the judgment rendered by the DiSlricI Justice on the date and in the case mentioned below. N..... 0,. ...".L.....H' Donald E. Murlatt, Sr. .....0.1I1U. JIll. 0" ........ 0'0.'. 09-3-04 "'00.'" 0.. ..'''.LL......' elf' "A'I II' COOl 2 Chestnut Circle Camp Hill PA 17011 OA" 0," JUDO"'NT I" 'HI C""I 0" ''''_'-''1 rO'...,.j..." 3/14/97 Elmer H. Doll n. Donald E. Murlatt, Sr. I.GNAT"". 0.. ""'11,1,11I"' 011 "It AnO""I' 0" Aa.", CLA'1I4 "D. TA 19 Q7 /"'1I_l/; LT 19 This block will be signed ONLY when this notation is rcqulr R.C.P.J.P. No. 10088. This Notice of Appeal, when received bV the District Justice, will operate as a SUPERSEDEAS to the judgment for p05\e5\ion in this case. t!/J , If appel/am was Claimant (see Pa. R.C.P.J.P. No. /001(61 in action belore District Justice, he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT within twenty (20) days after tiling his NOTICE of APPEAL. Signature of Prothonotary or DepufY PRAECIPE TO ENTER RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT AND RULE TO FILE IThis section of form to be I/sed DNL Y when appel/ant was DEFENDANT(see Pa. R.C.P.J.P. No. /001(11 in action before District JI/stice. IF NOT USED, eletacll from copy of "otice of appeal to beserveell/pan appel/eel. PRAECIPE: To Prothonotary Enter rule upon Elmer H. Doll. .Tr. NJmc of appelfee{s} . appelleclsl. to file a complaint in this appeal (Common Pleas No. 1997-] 788 Civil Term within twenty (20) days \liter service of rule or suffer entry of judgment of non pros. ~ RULE: To RlmPT H nnl'/ .Tr NiJme of appcflee(s) , appelleelsl (1) You arc notified that a rule is hereby entered upon you to file a complaint in this appeal within twenty (201 days after the date of service of this rule upon you by personal service or by certified or registered mail. (21 If you do not file a complaint within this time, a JUDGMENT OF NON PROS WI LL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. (3) The date of service of this rule if service was by mail is the date of mailing. Date:-.April 7. ,19....27. k'. Aore 312.84 COURT FILE TO BE FILED WITH PROTHONOTARY >- a) ~ ~ ..:t i... ,.- ~D -:'<f'" .-i\ _ J "~;: /1:2 .- '~i: '0:.: ~ .~ ~(' ,1;.:1 c--,' r- . - \~ ~ 'I) L!. ,'i. "(" -. I ':2: 11! [(:111 1 .,. t:\: \iaJ ~ f.: 1:1. ~~ .... .~~! a... h. I'- ::J ~ U 01 U ~ \r) lUl'/Ill' Jfl "mJI':j~__~~_._ tpaldlStli,lJ) I I'aljll1,1:Jj ^q L"! ,1:l1^lilS 11!1I0~1;ld All lJ '---'G1 ,----+-.. 01 (!.)Jall,Hltle ,llll utldn ll?iHldV 10 a:'HloN Jwqe iHjl Ih.uAuedwo:lJI: lUlcul.uuJ -""'GI' IlO Silllllll:;) U()I,)'iHlIUlO:1 ^~"J /PUIIIO/Ili/JIIl ",W,ll SI'.\1 "~I'/}'JI" Wflf/'" ".0I"l(II"/,"I/fJ Jll ..J"lf'ldj,s ---Gl'---.._._.-~o^va SIHl 3~~ 3UonU 0381U:JSUns ONV..I03\^JH,"~VI NUOMS , 'U1;1I,HI jJJlpene HJ!./:!,IJ S,JiJpUilS '1!t'ul .----.-Wl II.l':i'id'PP" W,'.\ :JI"U .UIl UIOqJ\\ e ap:J 01 .JIIIH illll P"^J,I'i I H!ql Jilljlllll put' l] 'OJ.Hall pJtjJl?lll! Id!,IJ,lI S,Japua.. '111~UI tPill;tl"diill) IPilql\ I;):>) All [--1 ,1'lIfI"I\ WIHI'ihHI ^q ['-; -- -- GI ,----- ---.-- till ____. ------.--------- - (aWf.'II) ';;dlFlddl' dljl uol!IlIHJI' 'IlHlaq paq:Jl'lIl' lIll":}.11 \, JiJpUil\ '\!(!lll (paWISll;,)l) IP;llllll;':>) Aq ! 1 ,1:)11\J,I'i tpllll\l;ltl Aq tJ '---61' ----~---- -----(.1J.1,';aS}0 ,1lf'1') un UltlliJtll piJlp.ufilS:ql iJ3l1Snr pln\IU ;nll HO('" ,------ 'oN SP;)IJ 1I0tlllllOJ 'IP;I{ldV 10 ,,:lItON ;lIil JO AdOJ r \" I P;lfll:l<; 111'Ip willIe j() 11';1,'.".. "'l;1Fllll :ll^'tfal:J:JV 1\: ~O^lNn03 VINVA'ASNN3d :to Hl'\f3MNm~~~03 '<;iJ\'oq .1/rW::J.'llfdt.' .pill';) "";1110/' JO il)'lOIl illlI 6/1.11-'1 U]l J\l S), va fCJJ 3,'LI Noun: OJ7/J J.f] _lS,IIV ,l"I/,U'-Il,}O I(J(IJ/I mu) ~-------~-_._---_.- -..---- 1NI'lf1dWO::l 311:1 01 31m! GN'If l'\f3dd'lf :10 3::l110N :10 3::lIAl:J3S :10 :lOOl:Jd COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA COUNTY OF: CUMBERLJ\ND 09-3-04 NOTICE OF JUDGMENT/TRANSCRIPT CIVIL CASE PLAINIIFF: N^ME '''''AllQflEOS r; DOLL, JR., ELMER H . 270 REESER RD. CAMP HILL, PA 17011 L ~ . '. ~.\_ , I { "I~ . V" ..' ..' ,.. ", . ,"j ~'" L, . . i, , . " .',' OEFE;NDANT:,.,...." "'~'..,. ,I "":" .1 .~. ....., '\~ r; . , " NA....;.n<tAOl)f)f.99: '.' "". t, " . r "MURLATT;'"'SR., ,'DONALD IE? ',. '. . ".'~ '2 CHESTNIJT CIRCLE'~' ',,,,,1,::. ,. /.. . ".CAMP HILL,'PA 17011". " ,",," : . '. L . DDckel No.: CV-00000J6-97 Date Flied: 1/23/97 MI.., (}Ill No.' OJ Namll: lion. GLENN R. FARNER Add,.... 5002 LENKER STREET " :~{,:, .., :.::.'. .,MEC,HANICSBURG,PA' ""<;.-:.1, :i:',:;! <,!-\"q;, ;f'j~~~ 1:;:I'i!.)f76 1': 0 230"";: . ~{", 17055":0000 ' .."... .I'1.{,I. . I' ',.' .'. ....; . . . ',":",(/~'~tC..\'r\'''':,.'';''I-' ~...' '" 1.:"'; .... \ ,~:, I""'" "/t'l' 'l~i/;'''''t.('.t.~~..~.jrt-f'~~.la:.'',:: ,."1'1'....1..'1;:.~.. .' ..~I ~k..;' d,' ..;.~ ",.\' "\':, t~" f;r'\- "', 'f:; . \ ri~NALD'F:. MURLATT, SR. 2 CHESTNUT CIRCLE CAMP HILL, PA 17011 THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THAT: .. " Judgment:.. , ..' ". . ", FOR: PLAINTIFF ,. " - .... .\ - --..-,.... ~ ~ , , Judgment was enterod lor: (Name) DOLL. JR.. ELMER H MURLATT. SR.. DONALD E Judgment was enlered against: (Name) In the amount of $ , ,,;,, 'iO on: (Date of Judgment) :1/14/q7 ". . ~'i':,.. ':, ~.:':# e. ;.; '__ . .,.': ",.._...\}J.~ ,r h'..,;,.'S.l~ t. '.I:.t. .'1.' .i<l ,.~:--.(..~ .~ . ":';:/:,,: .;,/', "'i;-'~ ,;,;:. ,. "',., " , ., .'" 0 This case dismissed wllhout preJudice, . . I.... '," , o Damages will be assessod on: (Date & Time) .. .... '1' . " ,.. .' TOTAL 1".550;'00 71.50 .00 : .00 1,621.50 . r.~ '. Amount 01 Judgment' $ Judgment Costs .$ . Interest on Judgment $ Attorney Fees $ $ o Levy Is'stayed lor _ days or 0 generally stayed, o Objecllon to levy has been filed and hearing will be h.eld: ... 'j ....... Date: Place: ~ '. Time: ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JYBgMENJ.BY FILING A NOTICE OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARYICLERK OF COURTS OF THE COURT Of~spMMau P~!:A~. CIVIL DIVISION. ; . .' ;.\ : YOU M~ST INCL~DE A COPY OF ~HI If>pCE.oF.~U.~~~ENY.n:R~SCR1PTl:iI;lM. ~?H,Y~~R N~~!.c,E OF APPEAL. ,i:., ......::;..~\ \-q'!:(Dale. ,'.' .. (1 ~'L-'~'\. if", FTJf}(U1~ .:..<..bi.st~ict:~~lIce. ':'. '. ",:" ",\..' ,.1 ce{111Y:th'althl~ is 'a true and,correcl{~~p(Ol t~e record of th~ pro~e3~lri~;b.~~llainl~tl1e 16d~rr;i;' ~-\L\-ql Date ,.' \\(()ltV\,\ 1-', ~{1jt;Jt(j.>........ ,.DISlrIO(J~Sllce" ..... ' -"'.' ..... '", ".:-:-:-Se'AL My commission expires first Monday of January, 1999. AOPC 315.96 \- >- 0' f;; U; ~" 1-- c:: ,')...r- (") ~.k 1--' ) .c~ ~. ~7 fE!' :L: :~~~ ~( /" ':'" / . C> U) l,- Co"; I ;~--::: Ii! t~: (.~ ,~-? If,) r~= IL ,']u.. ~ .:-.: It. r- .~J 0 0' U ~ . Z > . 0 P:: ~ lI-I [J) +J lI-I t:: ... 0 . 'rl . 11l liil = CJ co P:: oIJ E-t 'tl ...... ~ ti ~ co .., t:: E-t t:: r<. ,... 'rl oe( QJ j ~~~~~ 0 .-i . III ~ lI-I E-t I ..:I .-i QJ Z E-t III ,... ..:I n. iJ Q H ~ 1Il...r t!. P:: oe( '" 8 oe( (Sl!li......I o;::! 0 lal '" ..:I ..... == 0 ..:I .-i p" & <::1:=1105' CJ p" . lal :c ~ llil:i ll.o t:. . :%: 0 lal 0 Q CJ gj~~ :%: Z P:: =i! E-t !il Q U Z Z ..:I 8 H lal . .. ". ~ . 12. To the date of the filing of this Complaint, Murlatt has made no payments on 8. Doll gave Murlatt a personal check in the amount of $500 on October 21. 1995. 9. Murlatt cashed this check and received the benefit of the $500. 10. A true and correct copy of the front and back of check number 2403 on Plaintiff's account at PNC Bank is attached hereto as Exhibit "B" and made a part of this Complaint. II. Doll agreed to loan Murlatt this money at no interest, but they agreed that it was to be repaid as soon as Murlatt was financially able to do so. either loan. 13. Murlatt has refused to repay any of the money loaned to him by Doll. 14. The amount in dispute requires compulsory arbitration under the local rules of court. WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests this Honorable Court to enter judgment in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant in the amount of $1,550.00, plus post-judgment interest at the statutory rate from March 14, 1997, the date on which the District Justice entered judgment in favor of Doll and against Murlatt, together with all costs of suit. Respectfully submitted, Dale: April , 1997 \.OiMA.. "( . WMW- Debra K. Wallet, Esq. 24 North 32nd Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 737-1300 1.0. /123989 Attorney for Plaintiff ELMER H. DOLL, JR. 270 REESER RD CAMP HILL. PA 17011 2403 (Je.L.c:ilJ 19'J!:.- 10.12731313 101 P^YTOT~" ^ .. <:;' ORDER~ ~. ~~ PNClBANK' PNC BanIr. N..I. 'Priority Soulhcnttal P.' ~o Plus ~ /\ \ I Ii \.\ _ ~tr'a.w... t; J7' '1-' .. ~---4Q{!c-U 1. 6'-'": ' .. I:OHH2B81: 21,03 II'S~1,0~bHI,211' wJ4a ~~ CO L\R5 m ;:::::~:.::~.. $ ~~ct'O. C'll ,"0000050000," )""""'-"""," ;0: ..' ,- o. . -. :: ::: : "'. \.""', ;~~:::~"\ "."-' .~ '. - S ~~ :;. ... . ~ ,-' .. .... ~~~. ~ . t>>14miiRi;:" tl ~ 'JlIlU~~"".'!~ \' '" \ tt.l'1::ll";;l ~ '::"j ::i ~"'-<:6 l.al..' i '.,'1 ~~"'-' ~. .. ~ .~ . . ..' ~ " . ~ ..~C: ..' . ~ ~..~ . ~:.~..--:,:i ~ i7. f' '.1 ~ '-.., CJ 1..::= ~. J A .:: A -.:., ,i . ,. ..-:' ,..., , .... a... EXHIBIT "B" IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ELMER H. DOLL, JR. Plaintiff No. 1997-1788 v. CIVIL DONALD E. MURLATI, SR. Defendant VERIFICATION I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Complaint are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, infonnation, and belief. I understand that false statements made herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. ~ ;.1. dJo-ti\~, ELMER H. DOLL, JR. Date: 'II :n1'i'1 I I ! IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ELMER H. DOLL. JR., Plaintiff v. NO. 1997-1788 DONALD E. MURLATI, SR. Defendant CIVIL PROOF OF SERVICE I, Debra K. Wallet, Esquire, hereby certify that on April 28. 1997, I mailed by regular first class mail, postage prepaid, a true and correct copy of the attached COMPLAINT addressed as follows: Law Offices YOFFE & YOFFE Jeffrey M. Yoffe Esq. 214 Senate Avenue, Suite 203 Camp Hill, PA 17011 \.0 U\t;, o\!. W.......... Debra K. Wallet, Esq. 24 N. 32nd Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 737-1300 I.D. #23989 ELMER H. DOLL, JR., Plaintiff vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA No. 1997.1788 DONALD E. MURLATT, SR., Defendant CIVIL TO: Elmer H. Doll, Jr.: NOTICE YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Complaint and Notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing in writing with the Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you. YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. COURT ADMINISTRATOR 4TH FLOOR, CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 240.6200 NOT I C I A Le han demandado a usted en la corte. Si usted guiere defenderse de estas demandas expuestas en las paginas siguientes, usted tieno viente (20) dias de plazo al partir de la fecha de la demanda y la notificacion. Usted debe presenter una apariencia escrita 0 en persona 0 por abogado y archivar en la corte en forma escrita sus defenses 0 sus objecioneB a las demandas en contra de su persona. Sea avisado gue si ustod no so defiende, la corte tomara medidas y puede entrar una orden contra usted sin previo aviso 0 notificacion y por cualquier quoja 0 alivio que os pedido en la peticion de demanda. Usted puede pordor dinero 0 sus propiedades 0 otros derechos importantes para usted. LLEVE ESTA DEMANDA A UN ABODAGO INMED1ATAMENTE. S1 NO T1ENE ABOGADO 0 S1 NO T1ENE EL D1NERO SUFICIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERV1CIO, VAYA EN PERSONA 0 LLAME FOR TELEFONO A LA OFIC1NA CUYA D1RECC10N SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA AVERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. COURT ADMINISTRATOR 4TH FLOOR, CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE CARLISLE, PA 17013 (717) 240.6200 COUNTERCLIUM 15. Paragraphs 1-14 are incorporated herein by reference. 16. A third person who lived with Doll had a videotape collection consisting of 586 videotapes. 17. Said third person had a detailed inventory of the aforonaid 586 item videotape collection. 18. Said third person gave his videotape collection to Mr. f !' Murlatt. 19. Prior to said third person giving hiB videotape collection to Mr. Murlatt the third person removed approximately 50 videotapeD from hiB collection. 20. The entire videotape collection conBiBted in part of movieD which were purchased from video Btores (Btore bouqht videotape") or movies that were taped off of the televiBion. 21. Of the approximately 50 tapeB that were removed from the collection by the third person, Murlatt iB unBure how many of thoBe videos were atore bought and how many of thoBe 50 were moviell recorded off of the television. 22. The total number of tapeB that were given to Murlatt by the third person was approximately 536 (586 . 50). 23. Doll gave away the videotape collection consiBtinq of the 536 videotapes (approximately) to other individualll bOBidos the aforeBaid third person. 24. Of the approximately 536 aforosaid videotapeB, Murlatt was able to recover posseBBion of 232 videotapeB leaving approximately 304 videotapes which are missing. 25. At the time the third person gave the videotape collection to Murlatt he also gave Murlatt the detailed inventory of the tapes in the collection. 26. In considering that Murlatt has 232 video tapes in his possession, using the detailed inventory provided by the third person, Murlatt is able to ascertain that out of the initial inventory of approximately 586 videotapes, missing are 197 store bought videotapes and 157 videotapes of movies recorded from television. 27. Murlatt does not know how many of the approximately 50 tapes that the third person removed from the collection were store bought tapes and how many were videotapes of movies taken off television. 28. Murlatt can ascertain that the smallest number of store bought videotapes that are missing are at least 147 (197-50) and at most 197. 29. Likewise, Murlatt is able to ascertain that the highest number of videotapes missing which are movies recorded off the television is 157 and the least number of videotapes which are missing is 107 (157- 50) 30. Murlatt has valued the 197 store bought videotapes at $4,083.69 for an average price of $20.73 per video tape ($4,083.69 divided by 197) 31. Accordingly, Murlatt estimates that the value of the missing store bought videotapes not returned to him by Doll is $3,047.31 (147 x $20.73). VERIFICATION I hereby state that I am an adult individual who is authorized to make this verification and that the facts set forth in the foregoing Answer and Counterclaim are true to the best of my knowledge. information. and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. 54904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. Dated: ~~U~ _---eonald E. Murlatt. Sr. :-- CI ~- O' c; I..., " f-. UJC' ~,2 ; 'c. 0, . 0 C)'. - . , '- C' t...,' " ..1, c..' ., , -'. , .i LL l"- e} t';''' u >. >.. f:-; u; "'........ j::: It 1~:1 (.\ - ~~ .r. <"-~( ., If.;>, .. ~ :.-~ ~c ?;~~ (-:) 'rf) 'J>'; ..J ' ,~;,;..' r-I' , ,'qtJ .1~, I - I". 0-. :.:!U- J.. t- :5 0 O' L) ~ ~ ~ ~ c:: ..:! .,i . III 11< ~ ll::'tl 0 :E c:: rn c:: E-t H Z . ..,i Gl < tl = 0>- ll::1ll .~ ll:: ..:! ~~< ,..,.-i E-tGl ~ U ..... ~ti ~ Cl) 11< E-tO ll:: Ot:lH Cl) . < rn til ] ~~~UJ~ u8~ ,... ..:! . ~ Z E-t .-i ..:! > < z r.. > I ..:! 0 ~ t:l So. :fZt!. OO..:! ,... H 0 rn 0 g'~~-g~ E-t~~ en > - U en H . r.. ~ ~..,:c~!: ll::~Z .-i U :I: til r.. rn '11< t:. t:l Z H - f5Z:g Ofiltil . ll:: 0 E-t E-t l:l~6 ~~11< 0 ~ ~ Z ~ Z H ..:! < 0 :I:U til 0 ..:! Z E-t 0 11< til r.. Z til H 0 .. .' ~... . . . ~ IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA ELMER H. DOLL, JR. Plaintiff No. 1997-1788 v. CIVIL DONALD E. MURLA'IT, SR. Defendant NOTICE TO PLEAD TO: DONALD E. MURLA'IT, SR. You are hereby notified to plead to the enclosed New Maller in response to the Counterclaim within twenty (20) days from service hereof or a default judgment may be entered against you. \..P.lMI.. ~. W........- Debra K. Wallet, Esq. 24 N. 32nd Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 (71 7) 737- 1300 J.D. #23989 21. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to how many tapes were removed by Mr. Corriveau or how many of those removed videotapes represented movies recorded from the television versus videos bought in a store. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. 22. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to the total number of tapes given to Murial! by Richard Corriveau. 23. It is ADMITIED that Plaintiff Doll allowed other individuals to take tapes from the collection after Mr. Murlatt had failed to remove them from Plaintiffs home between January, 1995 and July, 1995. Plaintiff is without knowledge as to the total number of tapes given to other individuals. 24. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to whether or not MurIal! was able to "recover" 232 videotapes and whether or not he failed to "recover" 304 videotapes. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. 25. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to whether or not Mr. Corriveau had a detailed inventory of the tapes, whether or not he gave such an inventory to Murlatt or when he may have done so. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. . 26. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to how many videotapes are in Defendant's possession, how many of these were store bought, and how many of them were recorded from television. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. 27. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to how many of the videotapes kept by Richard Corriveau were store bought and how many were recorded from television. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. 28. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to how many of the "missing" videotapes were store bought. Therefore. the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. 29. After reasonable investigation, Plaintiff is without knowledge or infonnation sufficient to fonn a belief as to how many of the "missing" videotapes were recorded from television. Therefore. the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. 30. It is DENIED that the entire collection owned by Corriveau exceeded $500 in value. The tape collection was appraised by Auctioneer Chuck E. Bricker on January 6, 1995 at $500. 31. It is DENIED that the entire collection owned by Corriveau exceeded $500 in value. The tape collection was appraised by Auctioneer Chuck E. Bricker on January 6, 1995 at $500. It is specifically DENIED that any tapes were "not returned" to Murial! by Doll. To the contrary, Murial! never took possession of the tapes by removing them, as requested, from Doll's home. New Matter 32. Plaintiff DENIES that a blank videotape costs $2.30. To the contrary. tapes can be purchased at far less cost. In any event, the cost of a blank videotape is irrelevant. The value of the entire collection in January, 1995 is known to be $500.00, based upon the appraisal. 33. Plaintiff is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to the number of "missing" tapes recorded off the television. Therefore, the allegations of this paragraph are DENIED and strict proof is required. 34. It is DENIED that the value of 157 blank, previously-used video tapes is $361. To the contrary, the value of the entire collection was no more than $500 in January. 1995. 35. Plaintiff and Richard Corriveau shared a home at 270 Reeser Road, Camp Hill, Pennsylvania for 40 years. 36. Upon separation, an appraisal of their jointly-acquired assets was conducted by Auctioneer Chuck E. Bricker on January 6, 1995, including a "large tape collection." A true and correct copy of the appraisal is attached hereto as Exhibit "C" and incorporated herein. 37. The value of the tapes given to Murial! by Corriveau was less than $500. because Corriveau took a number of the tapes with him. 38. After repeated requests from Doll, Murial! failed to remove from Doll's home at 270 Reeser Road the videotapes which had been given to Murial! by Corriveau. 39. After more than six months of storing the tapes at his home, Plaintiff Doll assumed that Murial! no longer wanted the tapes. 40. Rather than throw out the tapes, Plaintiff Doll allowed other mutual friends of Richard Corriveau and himself to take whatever tapes they wished. 41. Murial! abandoned the videotapes when he failed to remove them from Doll's house for more than six months. ,. Approls .J:".#'.",.', . Y Chuck E. BrIcker .".:', ITEM ~ " . .. . ~ I ~::".~~. ~.. .:. . ~':"''',. 'I : .'..,.: ~ ',; r.~.. '\ ../~. .._, ,!.: .~:.. .: -:' .' . . '\.'" .'j.;., . '.\' ,', .:..:.t." ";..~'i'~\;~... i cLd' 3tJ.~b SlJdO .20;4b CD . /J.bu la ',00 :.: j:~.~.o:'~ .~"~J.Jl.t. '-i .r.s.. ~..:~~~,~ " f~;:f~.?Jr. '''':~..1.;~.: ~~ ~" .~ ~~. . '.": "J.::I..... .j;;.~t.....~ .~.. .~~"I'" \'.':':i~', .. -.. ,. ," , . . '" t..\~,~.~.1-:-.:: .. '.,.e'\, -',.J, " . . ....0',........ .. . . ~"(:";". :i~'~'!r': .; .. ,"'\0, .",u. .~ ...,: ~... '-:t.;~...N.M ~. :":..;.,. -'{ " ,. ." ~., ,. ..' ,..~~.; '; ..ri'lJi' .!I.'::i)~"':. Ml..~"'"...' Ali .':':~~~I":'t.r ~';'~I~ . . -\.,....i\.~..-~ . ......411l~1.. v 10..1_ .......... ."~,,,.:.:;:...'-'w,. . . - . . . ~'.l.-",: .:. ...1\':' ...... .." . ". .'}~...: "r . 11..... ..,' " .' :1"'.';"1':,' ......,'...~~ ';-"":!1"O:. ~.t.\u..".. 'il...".,,~.. '~;.~-r'i.4:. ':4'.~" . . ~ "':~'i'~:~ Exhi.bit "C" ~~.,; ~Si.;-~., , ... ... . . "''1'' ,...... . '.~ :4t;I't I ':'j'Q r '.1.0 Date .;; - '" -:.'. ~/fo.j .:~-"';; ~~" ":;; '!:o"'f~~~II'(ITEM )'~)I\i' VALUE ;~ ":'::'IlmHi4;WJ,\~+~"'f.iC'''I. . ".' .""..'1.......,..... '. .,. :. \!, ".."'~,:...,.:';l't<;:;:z~... '. : .... ./....,,".(:~~::..... ".~l .; .:J~~)~!tJ;t:!;~JW{~,.~..... .~ .~.;.u:.~<J.;;:~~tI..~~~~., - :.. \'__'j !",,:.~_.. :..;........r.,... ~ . :," :-: .....:~.;p.!\":'., J~f'{~'.........-. .';"i"w'r..t':'j', .t~~~~"t*"'l/.~'.'~""'" ......~, . ,: {., ...~?,.:- ';""'~"',.- ,'. .-'. .. . ". """\".:.-.~Ii~'~r~t'_...\ .~~'_.." '~~'. :J+4r.:;:. ~~-,,,,-=~,~,.I~ :il.~Wj.~...!t./h' ... ~. ...." ...,';;.~', ....".'fdr"'...,. __. ~,:-';\O~'~~r~~~~_r~:;~rs~~~ . .#.~f\:h_'r;~":~~".;,,:,:. . ..; .!' .. .. .ati!;r,~~1 ... '.... ... t.'~;~.~... '.. .'f.ri,";""-~""~.: . ..~.. .'. A......' . ',L,'. ~~.'LM..lI.>' ."" .. l."",:'l-.iI;;~~~~,~....,.i"'" ...... "~"'''''''~''~~i.-.!t;;~',.: .....~.....~I..'li~..tJIIF,.;..'-..f. .' .- . .'. ,~:""""'''''_~V~f'.'::. ;'. ';:U.'tS~!;~~:~~:,.. y.\toy,-... . ,- . "~' ~: :-. , 7.S" l~.{.:t:.:. ...:; ,:.... rf l4: ..~~~.,. . ;~..' I I." J;r . ~/~~" .,;; _ ... . . .~ Vj -I~~J':;.iv-t.-,....:J .1.....":... ;~'~"l:'.li~~.tr.;.:.~; i: ", l'.f.Y';4J~.~'lJllfr...~, . . ,';'t~......''''~~r":',,, ""l!_'\:~~?J;~/.f.~t:'4;_,.., . 'i<fw.i1t'ml...l"!11\\t:t~.: .: .. ; '. .f.... .' ..' .:,.. .. .t.... "', , .:i1'tt~. 11';: ,': . ~. ~~~( ~-'.>' " . ~.~~,;,-' ..:.,;i ,,~,'.i..t-.. .... .... .:OJ,., ...: '.'.,'. .. . " ,,','., ".. .. . ".~.. " , " ~').." ,. :.... "o! I~"'.' '. i!i~....!; :.,,.. ",~'~i'"L r ~~. ,.... ..........t.~.~.: :....;J;.J..;. 'r..7.~!J.'~1 . ~.. " ...~~"i".r""-',, ,I ~~11';:Jl':-... ...~" '.. -\f:(:;.'i~'~~~~.,,,;,..t.y'" .;"....I.W'...iJ~~~f~.~tl.;.(( ..' .4:.r~..... ;';1' .~. . I;. J .,'.' -. ";"" :\:~','r-'..' t. . .~... r.!~'''' ", ~ :.t~~ .' IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA ELMER H. DOLL, JR. Plaintiff No. 1997-1788 v. CIVIL DONALD E. MURLATI, SR. Defendant PROOF OF SERVICE , , I, Debra K. Wallet, Esquire. hereby certify that on June 6. 1997, I mailed by regular first class mail, postage prepaid, a true and correct copy of the attached Plaintiff's Answer . 1\ To Defendant's Counterclaim addressed as follows: ~ " Jeffrey M. Yoffee, Esquire YOFFEE & YOFFEE 214 Senate Avenue, Suite 203 Camp Hill, PA 17011 \J!w......1(. WMMY Debra K. Wallet, Esq. 24 N. 32nd Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 (717) 737-1300 I. D. 1/23989 ELMER H. DOLL, JR., Plaintiff vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA No. 1997-1788 DONALD E. MURLATT, SR., Defendant CIVIL ACTION LAW RESPONSE TO NEW MATTER FILED BY ELMER H. DOLL. JR. 35. Admitted. 36. Admitted in part and denied in part. It is admitted that the auctioneer appraised what he called a "large tape collection". It is denied that the "large tape collection" was anything other than a small part of the total collection which is the subject matter of the Counterclaim filed by Donald E. Murlatt, Sr. 37. Denied. The value of the tapes given by Corriveau to Murlatt is the amount set forth in the Counterclaim filed by Murlatt, plus the value of the videotapes returned by Randy Dohl to Murlatt as set forth in paragraph 40 herein. 38. Denied. Doll never requested that Murlatt remove the video tapes. 39. After reasonable investigation, Murlatt is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to what Doll assumed. The same is therefore denied. By way of further response, the videotapes were stored at Doll's residence from January 17, 1997 until July 5, 1995. 40. Denied. Doll was angry with Murlatt because Murlatt and his family would not have a special picnic for Doll on July 4, 1995 at Murlatt's residence. Because of his anger, Doll then gave the entire video collection to an individual named Randy Dohl (no relation to Elmer H. Doll, Jr.) and told Randy Dohl that the tapes belonged to Elmer H. Doll, Jr. Because of these misrepresentations Randy Dohl believed that Elmer H. Doll, Jr. had the authority to give to Randy Dohl the videotape collection. Randy Dohl then gave to his nephew (Brian) a portion of the videotapes. 41. Denied. The videotape collection was in Doll's residence with Doll's consent. Doll never asked Murlatt to remove the collection. By way of fur.ther response, Murlatt saw Doll on several occasions between January 17, 1995 and July 5, 1995 and he never asked Murlatt to remove the videotapes. Often during that time period, Murlatt would even take certain tapes from the collection, remove them, watch them, and return them to the shelves where they were being stored in Doll's residence. 42. Denied. On July 5, 1995 and numerous times thereafter, Murlatt made demands upon Doll and others to return to Mur1att the relevant videotapes. 43. Denied. Doll did have a legal duty to store the videotape collection. Furthermore, Murlatt gave Doll consideration for this duty in that Murlatt was constantly doing hDusehold chores and outdoor work for Doll at Doll's residence. 44. Denied. Murlatt's response to Paragraphs 38, 42 and 43 are incorporated herein by reference. WHEREFORE, Murlatt requests that Doll's Complaint be dismissed. YOFFE & YOFFE, P.C. 203 res .mur vs. IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA No. 1997-1788 CIVIL ELMER H. DOLL. JR.. Plaintiff DONALD E. MURLATT. SR.. Defendant CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE The undersigned certifies that on the date indicated below he served a true and correct copy of the foregoing Response to New Matter on Elmer H. Doll. Jr. Service was accomplished by mailing the same to his Attorney at the address indicated below by depositing the same in the United States Mail. first class. postage prepaid and addressed as follows: Debra K. Wallet. Esquire 24 N. 32nd Street Camp Hill. PA 17011 DATED: 6/2,6/17 YOFFE. P.C. ,/ I /,1. .~ By' ,'\,P ~FFREY . YOFFE. ESQUIRE Attorney for Donald E. Murlatt. Sr. 214 Senate Avenue. Suite 203 Camp Hill. PA 17011 (717) 975-1838 Attorney ID No. 52933 ro, .mur VERIFICATION I hereby state that I am an adult individual who is authorized to make this verification and that the facts set forth in the foregoing Response to New Matter are true to the best of my knowledge, information, and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. ~4904 relating to unsworn falsification to authorities. I I I I Dated: .Jo"-t.. /9, Iff? '7J,(.-</~/J//! {" lYC --Donald E, Muulatt, Sr. '- ,- 0" "0 I .' j.. lll~. : ( )-: ro, / l. ( \.') U' (0,: U;L. - " 'J l-- I : .J-:1 :.j ,,' I- I!. r- '.) U U' U _f /WlPV ~-2-lJo 1/) ~ , In The Court of CDcmon Pleas of ) ) ) ) ) /)0 1I100h{ ~~. WJuv-/qH: [", ~ Cumberland CDunty, ?enns~lvania u ~o. 1919.. rfB B 19 OATH We do solemnly swear (or affirm) that we will support, obey and derend the Constitution of the United States and the Constitution or this Common- wealth and that we will discharge the duties of 0 ice with fidelity. AWARD We, the undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn (or affirmed), make the following award: (NDte: If damages for delay are awarqed, they shall be separately stated.) fI~,.",iL.1fI<,. ('bt;Yv'\ \,..or ~1'v.J 1~ .r;,vcIv cd- dl.-( P("f(l-t)q.J!.CJ'1 n!J U "f"k", (' leu'vV\ l/-I ~ h':,J I ~ r:N '" (1...., 6f ~ 0,,- J';p.tt1-14Clv.7 '( -f r", PIA tiff(. , applicable. ) Date of Hearing: q /~ /r% I J Date of Award: -4;/6 !rf( . Arbitrator, dissents. (Insert name i= NOTICE OF ENTRY OF AWARD ~ -, liow, the I. day or Lt./<cf &ward was entered upon the docket partie~ or their attDrneys. . 19 iff, ac 3:.),- , fJ. .:1.. the above and nocice thereof gIVen bY-mail co che Arbitral~rs' cDmpensacion CD be paid upon appeal: $ .J'J",.-v ---. I! IC,,~ h-' J ?tochonocary r; 11(.(1',. Deputy (~. 11 i , By: , \....__ll.,t. ~ , \ /d., b1"f"'Q{dv S rd'7e"J""r{(o,- .......... . I' f (4,;"1"(,, r. {c}."J:k~ - ror rJ.r- .....( ,r,~"",~~ ' Gp6+-P(~ S' :;^~# - fC^i -{D i I 5~ r d r )) S 4ft r tjIIv. 5 ~I D14v,~ LM~ r~"t fa Jol.,V\S"", ov{f't, ~t-""""'/ ..... v/ o!!.\J,,~ U{~ fl d.2,3,QI Q ,,: ~ L.t>'.... " ~ ..------- , ------ , ~l') , CoJ " i. " .... .! " " J "n " .--- , 1;2' I I (;1 I..J : ,.~) ...., '-11 '-'J ., ) I :,J , irtJ ,'.) :, -~ .... c :u .... , , ~ , ~, ..,