HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-02113
'J
J
-;;f)
~
I
I
I
f: i
\,,; i
~ !
J
c-n
---
.--
.
co
,
E;)
(ll
'I
i I
\
NO, II
I:S fill'll IW('lIl1l1d JOliN
KOCII,
I'hdlllilh
IN fllH 'oUIU Of- COMMON I'LEAS OF
l'IIMIIhRI.ANI> ('OlIN IY.I'ENNSYLVANIA
Vs,
1J7-~11) CIVIL
KIIAIIllII ASIIAllIlId
SllMAlllA ZMFAlt.
1>\!f~lIdllnl'
CIVil- ACTION -LAW
1N.1~U: l'lt1.nJ~lAl, l,.'ol'll'l;ltl~N(,'I~
I'rcscnllll II prclrial clInlcrcllclI held April 29, IIJIlfl. wcrll Midulcl J, /')'kllsh. Esquire.
IIl10ftle)' li.r Ihe pllllntln.. IInd I>onllh.llt lIurer, hqulre, IIl1llftle)' Ihr Ihe defendllnls,
Thl.IIIWMUit url811K out III u IClu-cnd lI1utur whidu L'III1I.IIII1 Ihuluccuned UII Nowmner 4.
I t)t)~, Oil Stille Iluute 1 ~ al ur Ileur \lull Strect uutl I rlutlle lIuull III l'Ull1J'! Ifill, ('umnerlnnd
(\'lIuly,I'cnnNylvlIuia, Lillhilily iN lllhnillctllll Ihis CUNe, At the pretrilll L'lllllercnce. Ihl! court
hillnetlll.lipullllctlurtler whleh, iuatllllliuu ,II mhnillinllllllhllily. discllutinued Ihe Ilctilln allRinst
Ihe dclendulll, Khulld Ahhu!'
I he tl iulul this cusc will ill\'lllve oue Ill' mme depllsitionK 01 medleul wilne8ses which ure
ul8(111le 1'lIlllth ('(lunsel 8ullllcsled Ihal the muller mil)' nlll he uhle tutrlcd III leu Ihunlwu Rnd
(lIIC.lllllf dll)K,
April 29, 1')911
_,_:f11~__
Midlllcll'ykllsh, 1~8quire
lur Ihe l'lulllllll.
IlUlIlIltll>lIrcr. JiNllulre
hlr Ihe IllllclllJunlK
',hll
i
t
"HIM
APR 2. 1990tiJ
lAW OYFICIf..Il OJ! KUBINATK, JACUllH " SABA
114 Senal. Menu., 8ull. 503
Camp 11I11, I'A 17011
'rel.phon. Number! (717) 7JI.09811
Attorn.,. for Uef.nd.nlt
ESTIlKR M. KOCIl ANI) JOliN KOUl,
IlJ,A1NllFFS
IN 1'111 COllllT 0' COMMON P1.a.u
CVMJItIlLAND COUNTY, PaNNIiVLVANlA
No. 97-1113
Vii,
CIVil. AenON - I,AW
JUIIV TIIIAI. UI!.MANIlIill
KUALIl) II, MIlAI AND S1JMA1KA
ZAFJI'AR,l>KntNDANTH
PRE-TRlAL MEMOUANI>UM Oil' I>Eil"ENDAN'I'S,
KUALID II. ABIIAI ANI> SUM AlitA ZAFJl'AIt
I. BABlCJl'Al.'TRllIWARDING_LlABlLlnl
1111. Iaw.ult arlac. oul of I rear end molor vehicle collision ocrurrinll on November
4, 1995 on Sllle RouIC 15 al or near 32nd Slroc:t and Trlndle Road, Camp lilli, Cumberland
COIInly, Penn.ylvanla. On lhal occallon, the Defendanl, Sumalra Zaffar It ruck Ihe
Plalnllffl' vehicle In the rear, 11le llefendanl, Sumllra Zaffar lllpulale. as 10 her nellllllence
for lhe occurrence or Ihl. molor vehicle accldenl. Counacl for the pll1le. herelo have allreed
10 Ihe volunlary dllC(mllnuance or Ihe Defendant, Khalld II. Alha!.
II, IWilC.lAC'ULREGAlWlliG..DAMAGES:
l'leasc refer 10 Ihe Independent modlcal examlllallon relxII10f Dr. Alan VanSanl dalod
April 6, 1998 pertalnlnlllo hi. examlnallon of Ihe Plaintiff, Illllher Koch, allllchcd herelo a.
Ilxhlbll "A", and lhe Independenl medlcsl examlnallon relx1rt of April 6, 1998 by (Jr. Alan
VlnSanl pertalnlnlllo hi. eXlmlnallon of l'lalnllff, John Koch, attached herelo a. Ihhlbh
"0".
1lle Defendant II nol pI'Cscnlly 111I Jlolke as 10 any recovel1ble medical bill. or walle
h,SSC. II time of Irlal.
III. I!IUNUfLElSSllESI
PlealO see Section I I and II hereinabove.
l\Jlhlblt A
(';:\
i 'I
i
i
I
I
I
I
I :i
I I
I
i
,
i ,I
i
U,III'J 1'....11 111','IIl/1 'k'rll '''1/ : ,Ill II 1./11111 i' :,/U I 1"',1l
I
I
'Ii '! I, " 1111 1111 ", III
"'
I
,I
;1
I
I
AI AN L. VANSANT, M.p.
IiflfNI/(/TA.lIOf'/ ^,II~( jI\,{ ANIlIIlc/f(()(JI'\fi(VO'il\
!
i
I
I
I
I
~ '
" 'JNllltll' II'~
'A~': 11111'" 141 i
"~ i I
I I:
I !
,
I
t' M11N(,PAlI MID '.AI UNIlA
R/llltJOO ROAI
IJtlk 'A t,-IO'
I ~prll:l 1(1\18
llnlllllct I, 001'11 .
kublllo'll , ,1Auul I
214 lion to )Welll
Cli~\P IIi 1. I'll,
ll~lJU i 1"1'
" allba
, suite
'/011
!l03
I
i
i
'!
I
"
,
I
I /
nY-I KOCH, UTHlql VII. Khlll lei II. ^Jl~a I
and sumalt'f Zilffnr '
aSN. In-l -1l2l" ,
~::::I.'l ::01 t:::l,.' 1;11 rot. wu neeI' fIB' Ind.p.ndln~1 HlcHoll 'lIll~ln.t J (;In
today, 'l'h8 IlCIO pllllying lnedtclll r.conb of ~I" Cho, Dr, Tnrc~h
"lid h,.Ul oillt.flU, J l't1JlthSOIl'l'1I Hahab Ilnupit/ll, lIe'ly 6pltit IOI(l1t41,
'l'rllvclfll lllalll" lOW co., anti tluponillon (If Ms.1 Koch wnollvlew1.:l,
FillllinrJfl In th III etlnll roll ow, '"
! I,
Sh.. Willi ccompu 1 ntl by II lonq lima tdrilHl IIIHIIIII,;lutllllt.. IlIBldry
ill II 1.'01\\ )111l:llln. f thl.! IlfJol!l'lllnt.'!i Ilnll MI. Kll~:h'll rec,,1 Ibatlon 11In
14,,11 iltl rli. I<D", 1111(1 I'oviow or th... pledlc/ll I:oconl". lI.n memcln'
141\$ fll'ol y III C I t.tdn IIreafJ, (HI till /llj dill 011 ~"'I ot.heL' dpl.l\l III ,I
, I
I ,l'
Mnl. I "LvIIII In /l ml)lOl vuhlclu 1I(:ld(I8nl. NOVllmh8r 14,
1!l9!\. B 141 wall llUal-l.ulted l'"IUIllII\Jf'l' lit II c",' '"'hl...h WIllt Iitop,l.,,1
IInd was hll, filii thn 1'('111', mH> (Atllt.oW thht '111" WIlO hnJltlliHI
tollow,!" I t h", Iii 'I: 'tlel11 froln tilt' IInilUHilt.. Hhn ',lid Iwcr, 1'11;111, 1'llili
1I,,1n hll" I:on1'.11I18 t 1\11I.1 l'IHIi"t'ld IlIto I.hu 111ft IJppll1' .ld nl~'ltr dqwn
t.u tho h nd <lTld t. dll if; lIolH.'rHlml I", lH.'lnq ""ln~II1\lLlU", f>JH'1 R linl
lIWOl'1I ot /IllY orq ",vlltlIH) tc1r:lon' iiI rnOVrMlIiJnt.,.., or I'O\lIt. ClI\1I U\"l
lII...ke 1'.11., pllln 1C rill!, SII(' t10111l t:akl.l Elet.la btn'II'Jth '1' 11lI1"l lal
bflrltiml'l 01 the f lek 1'.1111, !;l'
BhQ 11 lid hill' /HI! i!ltolll trillfld fit atll \.hat !~h. had rll tticIIly
nmb\lliltl,q IIftr.' lh... accld"lIt, Bhe .litl r".,l Il,-uhl"III"IlII I~d
dJflC1omto'l. M, I dfl1imft nhe Wlllks wllh nfjllil~t/l'l"e with lIllunlon
,it.l'lllrjIIHj bllhlllll 11 t. hl.lldlll<,l IH.I: Will..\.. Sho n'quire9 IlllulllfllllCIl rtlt
lJllt.ldn'., nd dlf'i$lillll' mil' IIn.tlllll\t..1l II,' thu bllrtroOITi. '
SIlt! hod /1 CV^ 1'\1')\1:1, $llli '1"" 1II1IIp It II 1 1,\II'd Itno! h,d ; Phl'lJl Cl!I I
t.hnL'lIf'Y 'J''',loid' tl9 CIHI} nt.. p/,. eh'). t:lte WilLI hnt\pltlll iHHI oil f'uld:l.
~h)IlII.lLlI\I 1I0f"dt 11 ill tile, arlilll) 01 )'JfJ4, (;II"lhllll !ilnv"r~ "aln till
th'~ 1 nw IIIC1k un ,101ft. lug. I
I, I
; f,;!IEi did '1IIVl' ilIl : ~o niljht. fill I F.l Ilttut the 199~i lJtl'l.lKo. Uhf! hid! tI
'rli~cllll".l 01 the IT1VI1l lhllt /'urjllll'",d hl'd rout,j I
I I !
lH \:-1'J I ~J'~JU I U ~;,,'j III j kUl1
;/1 ',ftln \.1111<<" ....\J I 1<'''1
III
'Jl'j'l'l'lJllYJtfl f',~2
'I'
, '
"
I
I Apr~l 6, lt9H
REI l(OCH1' ,ltSlrHER M. ~II. 10111l1d
1\. AIII.1l1ud SUllIlIJra ZIItlH
SSNI12-14-023~
11..1 trll> HI 1111& n tell lncr"lI.ed dependflllcy in ,I,Plh\llatl()1I /till! ..11 f-
v~r_ nVu' th~ l~ t ~ov.rftl yeArs, r
;
I
AprlJ 1997. 11111' tr!tIld dsarJdl1.oB har lali
hh.. .tal... till. omlm IItlon was I tho o,me
: I
! I
i
lih.. Ill... of hl<Jh hlood IJ(,ulllln.. f.lh 1m on II vI\rlety lof
roli,lIc<ltlil"'. I uludlll<J fllnllrlllMI, '1'r!llIot:.~loIJrllll, CllrIHz~,",
Ol<V,hlltvn n, I'll. c, I'ftlllllll'ln, 'f!cllr1, nill'vOl::"~, llynthrnHI. 1I1tlo-
f'lll{ pate I, F.''''''H t, l'rllorH"-' and ona ..upllln It day, I
I
I 1
I i
IInl Inf.ll'ltBI. C/ltnl' 1111]. 1'11.. flf.l1'il'\.lIIent. ot rtlldlol~CJY
IllH1 Illa'J ,filii ic "i,lIJlllrJ,J(.l/~1. C1' or t.h... bra II, llllPl'l'llBlon. ~IO
eV\d.,.nc.. tOr hi. ,j ll{ mllfill Ilnrl no (Ira,... ()f IAt 101'11I..1 at.t, nUIII:lo.l1.
niHIl/H. ...rivan licoltH (\jmlnlllhu,J at.\:enuat.lol Iii ~'omplllt,blll WI/th
dlttllfJ" ilia., In Il.bl dllillllli. III'obablv hattem! in origin! I
, I
11"')""111' 1",'1111') ('''lit.." MUGhtlll,j':,Bbllrg .'A MIlV ]~, l~lJ., M)U
ul t 11.. liI,.lll, JIi'l'lwullIII: 'l'hB Int,,:ct III the ri\lht
I '"' 1/'1/'1 , I
"..IV lildl!\ o"plt,'}, n"l'lIrtmallt of HlIdt01(1(JY, Camp I,ill, I'''''
11/11/'JLj Jm!.>! ..,tOil, 1lll!lttHII1IJulJlc rrllf'tU(OEl'
I ,I~y (ho. Ml'l" H!'lllt'll) MH,l1dllH Asr;onlllt.flll:,' Offlr;l'I I'/oteo IJt
"jll/tJJ. "'/'rll j lady WhO IlAB loft hfJml duCl \(., CVA ~i1th,1ow ba::1<
,"/tIn Ill'" IhjJ'tor "l'elvll' tr""'"re luturll", lJII(t')'t,\Hllltl'lIV. thlis
[Iilllbnl ,\ III ".. l 'lt'I\' 1I1l1it(l1'l.ly 911it ~'''I I win,! I..dillll,::. wll:h
IIH'I"ulfc.r11 hi:t lff '''Hi 111"11.1 tfli.'rt'Jt1IHht (,nin III tilt,' 1t)l\ ili.ml t'J1IJ l()"J
ldpt' 'lIit'.. ,;<"" HJ:td tn. hill LllHfl 1 a., yot t Ilq W(>t I\P and )Htl (fl.l j t.: i fl. (J(ll))..
1'..1.,,,/,1 r,,,"'1>, "";"1'1,,'1,1 ';ll,.,)'''' .Ill II,:\I,\I\"t<1; \iilh:1i ,lid" i,l'ltljrlt;J1Iltl'd
I, '"'' Ipy "',,,I(J'~1 un, '11,,'1 I'elt 10lll II: l'ompl,d,nly r,lJii<)')lnq tho left
) {~q , Ii i
I
1101\11111
, nOl'. , lequ t..8
~i-
",'11" hllll ~'rwt."hlot trolla III
I:>e j I"" II" rti, I>ell i G,'.nt,
Ilflc>r th IOtnl~ ,
till LMJtIi
4'Y
MtW!!.!lll ' tlJ!':QtQ ,
" 111"1 "" ',,," 1,1111111'''' '11111"'11
(1,1 (},) 1"'JlI Ill:,' ,ill ' "
1'1
'I I ,'il\!!li j< llj
;,
i
I
I
,
I ^prU II, Hili
RII KOCH,! Ii:/iTtIlIll H, J.. 1<11.1 III
II, "1I1~.t AntI MunlAlra htfll'
tJ~1f1 In-11-ua,
IID1! Bpl1'1 tUlip I tal, O.llartm.lIl of l4i1d I Cl~ fj(JY. ('.mp If 111, "A,
12/13/19 3. (~r lnlll I'il'ln.,lmpl' Gluilonl I,lIW'MYI Oii I II, IInnompAllhA
d1l1l1 lipa ,ll narr) Inq III c4-!J Ilnd ('!l-6. M ,ltt: fOllUilIr Jllv.1 thatll
lu bUill rill II~' I nforllmlllill EllIl.'ro/wllmllllt, I
1I01~ Spll'i' 1(lllpltlll, P'r'oH l "'lilt ut f,",Holn'Jr, C.If'P IIi 11, fA,
l;.!/22/l./Jk lion nl\lI, 11101'1'13111110111 Th..rll wa~ ulllllLJll1 'Nulton
rnl$ed 0' II pORI bIll lillur"l trnctur.. uaclu1 t. normal.
HIU of \.h t\lmbur I'pln., April :lb, lli~41. bUn ..un"l ~Ild
ucintto t'Il" ul l(;, 11\11 on 11/\lL 1 IlIl't'.'lllpn 1 I 'l'IlI,,, h; IIIvldlt1lJ'
of mild to ",,,llIlIte "pinal IItilnoall' III lit.. \.1-4 IHld 1,(-6
lntBt'vll' :UVI:Il I 11 lie I ",vel,., 1
POM I d
I
I
" Oar", ".qulre
.J..
II
:1
I
I
II
!,
'I
" Hit Y J Il , I '" ~ 4. ""'"l I '" III I" ab I fJ I () a IhtJllllIl II
( I thn lL'ft lc'l U"IIl'J h l'iln.. IIUI 1"(1 Illm Ih non'
! 0 Intl",.:t"ldc ,,/1111 the, I'I.tle~1I1 had IHiT kCftn of
Itjeh uhow,," m(jiliHllt<l Ilplnhl 1,.lllll"..t" 1,)-4, 1.4-5
velll, 1',1l1Ilnl hUlli 11l<11(,QljPHhY 1.4-~ ',n the
,
,
JIIY Cho,
wi thoul P hrdC'll
f.lIllct I QUill. llll I
the IlImbill' up,III'
Intnrvel'1c"bl'it I I
.tort. "
il
!I
I
:1
,1ny Cho, ~, " ll..hllh Hedll'lllll ^!iljur'il1t..~, ottl.:.;, noltt. \pt
9/2\1/94, "Th t lJ I (Iy \Iho hll!1 IlPVI"r. I'd In III t 11'1 low ,,,"~, 1 11111111 "I'J
1,0 tho 1 tt I'''J \1 I h hnnwlI 1.4.. !I, f."; Ii I I,t 1I11".I'\ .."d ,.,11 ,.u h'I'~t ItV,
lun hum, h"III1'" 11I1IIdltlO ",",l tu" IIIIIi 1)/11'\ 1"!.llln~, Pllth./lt
ututou t~llt lilt. \.I 'fll Iii ,Inlllll' 1101'1 ill~, ali,l ',Iilll '.' WiI' ."\J11, lllltIJ"",Y
UIl Ihu 1 w b"...k \J tl rc"""I1'IWIi,Il>(l. 1l'.!('K ""Ill Ill, nut 1",<1, Thllll11tt
,nrm 11Iw lqlll1J illl IIII f lilt..", i:lml tIIJht""'Ui 1111 wrll..L ilnd I/ohnuldel
nll'\ ,,!g,dticnnl pdli IoIh\,11 1,,,t1l'IlIl,,, " htlilltldl'\/h~"d ..y"'lJo~III,"
I I
I
I
: 1101-1 (il'lrl lor.pl!ul, Ilt'pilltlli'1nl (j( ''l1011ullJ\JY, 'lIJn!, IHl1, I'~,
,11/~'/!I~,1 C-flpllt'J, Il\Il'tf:IHdfllll 'Ill"", ill 11-1 1'{'('1oIIII>'J (,f doj.c; 411.1
C~l-C,j dillk "I"1f.' L 110 ..nil.. "bl""III'tJtty lh Ill'. I, TII'"'!' I. rw.ort
'timlll. ,hnOII\l"~, 'rllo.'" iB 11<> f5UtliIIXllti,., .dU, t1.a,don /lr
: &)(1'."11111011, I,' "111,", 1 IiiI' I *'H,j UI,; 'lltell" IIJ <111 tll~" '''I'elipol'O..IIi,
In\",'rvnI11,,1>1'I1I ,ql~, lifol'Jht Ifl li(" '''''' '
Ifilll;nry (11). I'hyulutl H""ltll~i()l1'fti I' II IIlAb I I llnlnun ut
HC'chillll"tlb\lI"J, ,It ntHl K'JIH Ill' Y I 11, II" 41 II/'J/, I "Th... pill \fll1t h"ll
wOl'f>fJnnd '\()VOt l n lllflt J W13lJy'fj lwell \liat lih_ ~.. 1I1111bl. t,. III Ilnl1 ,
belH wul9 It nr 'i fl irlde.pund,mt Iy. OVUI tit.. 1",.\ "Olv..rl1l .1IlVl6 t.hlil
I:
,I
I,
1"1 11"1~1 '1111 ~,!~n VIIIIllk (,lflll'llllJ
11,1 U'.1 I 'J'lIl Ill',' I"
'"
'.11 ','j , II '.jlrjjj',' ".(M
I
"
I
I
I
1
-4- j' "pdt 6, lUll
"~t J<OCIl, Ell'flffH H. ~,III. Kh.i t<l
II. ",hal and aum41r~ Zntt.r
I $liNI 1'1<1 14-9238 :
, 'I
PAt.ient.,1 fAlni r I'll"" nDted tih, hlU bl!lmlm.1 l:o"flHHH1, : llom.w~lat
IUliortUllr.d .111\1 the pholt and tl111e and 1611n she lI.velo lid
dlfflo\llky UWIS llwing rt\od. She 1. admltte~ wlt.h IlUW onllet ,of
IU1\bUlato~'y ~'Yllf Ilotlllll /lIHI fiOlnlt r;o<:jn!liv0 l$bll1t11lalltlelil, Ii
lIol\{ tlpll'j, IInfll'1tltl. Uepllllment, uf r,tJdJ41[)(JY 11,,,1 lJIllqnolltiv
tlllAljJIllCj.1 c"mp 1111. Ph. C1' brnlll 1":1111, t1nprf!,wlonl Modenlte
lUlllt/lt!bn ot /" vl'.llllric:luu 1\1111 l;llll.fH'1111 ~)1th lIlll']Y dlftllsfl
"adventr leullll l1rnlnil.h.HI attellu~t.l<'1I und tho IHlriV~'l\tl'lull]llll
wtdt.J lnll~llll' I" tlllllv whull C:OIllpi.U;ul II,' 1992.1 'I'hel'o hila be." nn
IIl'ua of ~nt.l'vi.I nfaretlull l'l1l\.endllllJ upWind fr'om the 1'flgiun of tJhe
InterlHlll CII)"".l. un the 1'lylll, 1I1dl> 111\.11 thul ,-'.ntrum aflml(Jvlt~..
'l'ho1'1l IUll10 hili ( or mllllll, I
Clin1!Jall ElL"m!n Ui,1J1 !
8tHl 1'1"tlfH)lItec1 <'l' II ",pol''''l illl vu '}\J~ye'H'...lll Illdy In II Ylht'udl.lhnir'.
i Ther... 101('11 1\ lat 1&\1(.1 tlfdll lu,.", fill" hnd (,...jmplutff fliH'l1lYllil Ihl
tlHl hIt\. lup"", I X ..",mil,' ~/ilh cnntn\C\.llrll" al !jjhll ahnuldfll'i tllhuW,
wl'lli\. an't hand. 'l\fI.lv~<ly Bill;! wO\lld allow the IIhollldlll' to come \Jp
to IIhlJ\1t nhlJIlIIll t!nlyht. "lid with pidn. IIIJoJ.l!l \l0 df!l.lreflB. lJ~tJ
allowed 4bollt. ~ , of lnt(lllllll ilnd fj><ll,lrnlll rot.I"IJoll and there W fJ
II mllt'kollllcont nl 'tHee In lit. WI'I"'t /ll\rl hdfllj, T/1er.. 140" nOl0l100 r
I ucnllfll.1ull un th I uft "Id" ill bCJtll U"1ll al\tl )"~II. ,
j f>h... llift I+~V" vol i 1(.1\111 ""nl rot ot t.he 160\ t hiP; ;,nee IInd Illlkll!l IIhd
'(,)0\1, p]III1~llr dor i 11;)( \'.Ill' too\. flaClt'll((H, IHl'l" ]I\l]/t lIIlJrt'llwtlvo
'011 tho l",'t. III<'h/, TlllHIJ It> 110 llnkle 1';)OIHIa> 0" '\"ftn1111111'1. 1'1'1t,eul..
,sh. ,,100r1 with 10 It,t~l. I fJ lnlll<imnl Itl!Hlt!llunCJf3' BIl.... 1\1<1 IImhulate
with U f1llow q;dt IlI1 IIqain lIIOclel'lll" Ilflfdst:11110~. f;t/llltUnq blllllnf.
,W'1!j P()fjl'.1 I I
1 ,
<In oXltlmlljlll.lOIl lit t.Ilo ct'lIvic/l1 r>rdnfl "11" cll'lv(l~oped ~o r!Q'll'fHtll ~,t
l'lelllL fIlIII ]el\ lllLQrnl H,t ,'llc'n. ;!~, d"fjIUt'll, of >H.lht li1tl!lt'~l
/o1"",III)(J. 1)0 dN)r'lftll 0', h,tt l(\j(H'.11IHudJn9, 4(1 rll<lJnlO" ,,ftlfll(!OIl,'
~o 1lf)IJ1'C!(H~ of .. t;l ftfJ1tJll, 1
,
!lonol'" It, Dunl. I!;tqult.
I
I,
{H-U9-P.J'JH Ill:~!.lllll fl.1MI '1"11 ','1111Iil"lil,' '.1*11"1111
ILl
" 1 ,1" , ~ I U'jlj
.' ll"
I
I
I
Uonbl~ J. norot, i.qulre
.,.
""rO " lUll
I
I\I:'I<OCII. U1'tla;IIH, VI. 1<1111111
II. Alhd IInLl Illlmll!r/l Z.tt~I'
,8NI 17' 14~'21U I
It WII16 ~H f ieu t to Gv.1Ullte th. lumbln ,pI II, flit. .tllod w~t.1l
1U1IJht/ln lO ancl Ii ) hdt lIunbar ."in. motion, ut it 101411 ItUtifJ it
t.u .valll t. wile h r t.hh WIIIl trllll l1mlt,lIt lon, trllilJht lwJ ral. ng
waf IIAQII lvo, I
I, ..I.. I!
u.wnm/l.t.i'-!"Il",~ .1l.llUo>'n(j , '
Mu. I<OClIlwall In 0 VlHI In /l lfIotlll vehicle IIcClld!nt t/Qvemh.r 4, )~9!1
ft. /I ueft1helted 1I00lln90r. I
sh. had h hiuto uf 1\ CVA In ,Junfl lGll~ with tift h*lId,,'r...l..
I '
Pdor tOflhe rno 0 vahlcle IlLJCldent, aha hud " hlllt.llrv of numerJu.
t'dlf1 ftn I\onr d /lllng hack /lnd nick pllln. )(- uV. IIlId JIl!.9~ng
1It.\IIU" .howeel Il,qlnorlltJva .rthrlll., Bhe 1l41ilUI"ed " 11.1"110
frl,ctUl'u,in ,199 11\ one of the flllh. I '
i ,I
Rha hud L IJ8con ,I CVh in hili 11 IIf 11191 with 1l,l'tf Iralltv 4",11111111,109
/Ifill CO(lnlitlvo b onn;\l1tltll,j, C'.' .e/lll fthow~' Inraretloll 1/1 ttl.
, I '
1 nl:','I"I1/1 I ;t;UPfHll "I th. ,'I\lht. .
Ii., I
011 ulCumllllllloll, II Ie hRII II 1..tt; vllI"lIl f'll:lld 1f) I. 1'lIltllYflll fit l/ll
I lort IIPlJtr: nllt.r Ity wlt.h mllrknd (';(JIllrllcturllil Impulllnlmt ur t~"
! leet IEl'1i Il1ftJ '\I tv wlt.h baltJIH:t, I
! 'l'hern WII~ lllnltl t nil of thu nHvlcal /:IlId I "",hili , 01'1119, I
: It I!J my I Op111101 thll' lhfl 11I/)1;01 vuhlcllo' I~Cr:ltl1'lIt ili 1'1'J':l did n~t
,/lIJ(Jl"nVlIll] nl' W r WII thll Ifill h"," 1 1'11I 1'1161. lj , 'I'll.. 1I'"lf'l v,hltllu
!t,;t;ldollt III lll1l nllllfll. lo \ h... ''')1''"111 t:VA th..tl (j(:('iln",\ In April
199'1. r~ do 1111: ,It.hlnk flhn hi'" any 16fi11t111.11 illlll'tltI Ili..nt IIll1t I..
l'lllated 1.0 tho OIlCll v.h1ole lH:ddfHII, t,lltt hall rilthll' 11111I ..iii'" Pl'\f'
lll<lntll1q id,qflllll '"f'IVU IIrthrlttu 11'1 thf~ conl1'11 ....Id IU/IlblU 'Plflll
pIlot' t.o Itho Ino 0' vllhlr:lt' Iludd.nl, I tin not I,h 111~ ,
. i :,
1 I'
. I I
I
I
, ,
i
~,.~ l'Et l(j':/';1 IUi;?4ltll f "'l.lll
'111 iA1Hl l.Altlill! 1:)11 I Illlllj
Iii
',-11',' I I/ ~I ~J_:Jtj'1
.~ ~.lf~
i
!
i
AVlJlflillll I
I
i It I 4/(0/911
I " 4/9/114
I
I
, ,
'I
.Il~ "prU ., lU8 I I
Inr !<OCI"IJI;fl1'IIU4 M. VI. KIlllUd
H. ".hIJ land "urn.lr. ~artlr
..n, 111.t4-'23.
I
"h.. hi\d .IIlY "9 r, VU'l,ln of tho .nhrH.lI tror th. motor vehhlllil
lien ldelll
W"P~gt'"lly &~Jmltt.d.
/J~ a(Jf~/
A~t. VlIllllln;'1 M,P.. .'AAtlll',CXHIl
I
1J9l1t1111d
I
J .". , """j"
; I
,
I
,
II
I
,
I
I
, I
I:
! '
I
,I
; I
, I
/
I
I
I
j I
I'
I
/
Ellhlblt 0
!I
Ii
:1
I ;1
:i
il
d
II
,I
,:
, 'I
I "
.. d
I I;
I
'I
,I
!I
'!
I:
ll4 -l)'J "".Ill Oll: ,1)1 i I I hH 1
II j SIIII! I,ll t'll h' '.111 I Ill/Ill
IIJ
'JlIlIiljUMi 1',01
ALAN E. VANSANT, M.
RfiWJIWMION MmCN AND UCCIR\.1(l!-\
.
i
,
JRINGDNI MUlr UNI\l1
9 \RAIIIlON ROAIl
Y~k, rA 1740'
I ,
, ,
, 1
i April 6,llllllU
I I
I Donnl d nj DorAf'1 .'lllu t re
,nllhin/ltfl .1 II cmhu liar.
! 214 f1enn ,II AVllnuo, Bu1U 1503
, Camp 1111,' I'.. llOl1 j'
I Ril:l I<OCIlI JOliN VI. I<hllHd
I I II. ",n 1 and &lumatiu unl...
I /HINI 112~OI"Il\(j!l. !
I "
! Mr. Kocl W~II ',en for All WUl IIfUHl tor :~n".p.nd.nt: HUlcsill.
; :::::::: ::':.:.:~v 'ho ,ooo.p,",l.. ,,",,' "~.,," or "" ,*,;,.
; IInd hiB e(ll1!1illo \ were rllvhwllcl. flndlngll 111 thiu Cllell toll 01..1,
: Mr. Koc.:hlWlllhll t lit he wall lnvolvo"l III /I IlIOIOrj,Vf.lhlc'JII twoldent K1II
Novllmhorl~' 1995, Ifu WIlIl lhe driver ut II IltoPlll'" Vultio:la with ht.
oOlltll,,11;1 ftllllullt'll, lInd wall hit tl'om th.. ralIT',1 II" HI.,,(,,11> that t.n..
belt dU'J Into hl 111ft 1010101' I':h.." \ , Ill) f.lt nkk lIill kno"" nil ""l<
dIlShbo/lt'1 Ilnd hll '/ld dlfC1ctllly witll hit; tmdc.!
),"~
tlll'U 171 PI ... "11
fA,)( (1111,.16141
....
!;
I;
;'
I:
:,
"
Ills w1.f Wil" <l!1' n III I ho I:m",r"l.-IK'y 1<""". hilt hl' dl<1 !lOt. ..i/..k
,medlGnl tt.~ntllln..t thi\t time. II... ,lill 11IHl ilL', !'l"J/'('IlIIl, Ill/I f'lIm*y
I phYllioiill, after the IlGotdflllt. II., had till x-'rIlY fit lI,oI1,.tt 1'110
i calJe wh I :h Wall 1I0llJllll, lie WU <J IVA" Ilol'l:jm, ill Iwhll.'h 1I1I t.clok (J1l !iIllI
! every ot Ifll' ,IllY, 1/H1l.. tor n'ildl pliln, filII Illwk I,alll hn.. Impl\l\ll""J
I and no\.l 'I.' laku!i j')f<JliIl'Ilc CIliA Ill' t_WII t Iml!!i 1:1 \}I@Ukwhld'C)lVUlllm
I good n)) Inl III III JU( 'JU niln\ltflll. ,
Ills 1'1lill~jll 1'111113 Jly dfJllt-,ddl"t In lhl; 1''''VII+ill 11\.1'<1. i\10/1f) \oIlth
L'lght"rdtICH! 11",..1 polJn, It 1" hll'"'Jllt Un 1,1' 1'" hi",! rilovemlllltlll 01
tho hllll'\. lie hIll nr, Til,tlatl'm llItr, tI", "1!1''''I' .", ''''I' It I.... or
fnul1/iCl I'f numbn 'lfi "I W/Ja~,!II!(j~ III th.. IllJ!i'j III lI!tnf:il), ilL! lIell no
hJnt'HY ~,t prlilvilllll lIlml1ul' 11f'c1~ 1'f'''ldllm'',
,
'I
I
"" hu!f. 1"1,\111
L)nt;tll1'J into
nnlet,
1" 'I'" Inet !0WIIl /HI! 1111<.. db f,'!HJll. I" llitH Jly will'"
I. el\,ll, '1'1\1" I,'"" t'ft ,,,)1.,11,,,1 by'.!t!:,!,,) I;J lItAndln']
lie hon
n\ltnl<lo
, I
l'lcJhL kn~M
LII'I' hO\ltlf',
\tI/llm
,
ilmblllllt1n'J. 114. U~~1;l ;1 (:lW.
1/1'".,,1 iiI.< 1l\J1I111'Hj of \ ht; knflfl.
pit In W"~'JI
" Iw tf,' IlIl f\
1',111'.1
ItjlJ[i \'Ii: (l.blll
I
I
I
I
I
'11111 ~.llfll \.>lllll..Io' I..t~ t I'll)lj
III
'J) ',' I 'l'lllll'Jlf,'
1',111
f '" ~ ,
,I
II
II
, I
I
I
I
I
: I
'I
I
!
I
I
I
, '
(10M 1 d nl'
I
I
I
..]..
I '
Aprl1 6, lll\lU
,
I
I
:1
II
I,
I
I
DOrin':, Ellqllin
I
MI 1<f,'CII' ,IOItN VII, Khalic.l ::
It, A..h 1 eml!lumairaZllCCal "
SSWI 7a-Ol-160lJ ,I
I
1 ,I
, I
on llllCIlJn nation f the lumbar apine hl;l c.IlJVO:t1l'Ud 30 dOljreOB lilt ! I
tlOXIOn" 5 dUYIr Oil at exten.ion, 25 dt'yrf!9iJ, nf riyht IInll 1.ft. 'I
llltorllll banding. fltrlllght 1119 1'illll1119 and Ulollu,,'" luot. woro I
n.CJllt tv. Pool' tontlon Ie Ol'l>l.. Wl'lre d.pre led In both lOWel",'
mdTtlml\;I.I. II. Willi ablfJ to walll UII tlw heult!. /lIHI loes, st/lndln9!' i
lI11ulnlll.l\ly on 'ClI II foot. Great toe ItrenCJth wali equal. 1l1a !;Jllit I !
wlla eve,) 111 !lIJ! 10, lUfl<Jlh /II III rhythm, Hn dill brlng /I straight' '
011 no to lthe exum 1I11llj room, but did not UIIII Il durlnCJ the exam. '
I
f1llnlmA1::t-11l11';! <;Q~\; u11Q[1I I
Mr. 1<0CI~ wa.. IIIVe Iv..!) in ft mlltor vehicle IlGcid.\nl. November 4, 111115. i I
II. h",. h Id non1'~c;l atineJ cf.l1'vical lumbar fil'inu Ij",ll1, dhcomfort over III
the let i lOWCl" 11- h "SIJO, lIoc;l r ilJIIt. lIoee PIS In. ~ ' , '
011 (llC-<'Imllnnl1llr; If tho eOL'V!t't\l lumlHIl" spih, he had moderat.o i I
limltution ot ~o ion consistent with hln IIgo. NDUl'lllugic exam wal '
lIonnnl. ' Un w"" tnl1r1nr' OV01- l,hA cOHl.odllltHlr',ll tlunction 1'11'''11 ln the' ,
io{\', lOWu{' rib il' I)Ll, ' ,I
i lh111111111'. KUc llulJla1nutl 1\ myotafidl.11 Iitruln of tho oervlclll 'i
lumbar ~plne u.d contu.lona of tho left lnwo~ rib cage IInd rl~ht II
kn(lB. t dl) "rit thlllk hI! hall \!IllY residual lrjlpall"tn(jnt !',nilltnd to ,I
tlulI'e l1Jurh",i I ! i
Il.,pecttully Illl!,rnHtad, II
I (f:i/ / / /1 , I ,
pitt. c.-{J.. ,;.,',~/'
II an I:. VanPllll1t, tl, 11., I"AAllEl', CIHE
!
I
I
:1
:1
:1
I
I
~ I
II
I'
!
II
.1
"
:1
L
II
:1
I
il
I
, I
"
I'
,
"
AV/j/b... i
(II 4j1/qfl
tl 1/0/QU
I,
I'""". I
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURl OF COMMON
PLEAS, CUMUERLAND CD,
PENNSYlVANIA
NO, 97-2113
CIVIL ACTlUN - LAW
.JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
ESTHER M, KOCH and .JOHN
KOCH,
Y.
KHALlD H. ASHAI and
SUMAIRA lAFFAR,
Defondants
fill-TRIAl.. MEMORANDUM OF r.LAUU1E.E
1. Stlltement of bllslc fllcts liS to llllblllty
A Sltpullltlon liS to negltgence to be filed
2, Stlltement of bllslc fllcts liS to damages
Mr, and Mrs Koch suffered physIcal damllge liS II result of
IIn lIutomoblle IIccldent of November 4, 1995 1I10ng with
1066 of consortium
Mr, Koch - InjUrieS to hIs neck, bliCk, sIde IInd knOB,
Mre Koch - Injuries to her neck, back, laft shoulder, rIght
thIgh, left wrIst tlnd elbow tlnd regressIon In recovery
from a prIor stroke
3, Stlltement tlS to prIncIple Issues of ltllblllty IInd dtlmllges
There 16 to be tl sllpultllton of negligence filed In this
mllller, The trltll would be one concernIng damllges,
4. Summllry of legal Issues regtlrdlng IIdmlsslblllty of te8tlmony,
exhIbits or tlny other mtlller
None lit thIs lime
(. , 011 NO\llifr.tllH .., I \lY", PI alnll! t J;j IlIlt her M, I<o<:h amI <John
~'" h \of"'I. UPIIUt III{J II motor vshida whell IJMollllilntl1 vehicle IIlruck
I'lalnllffll Autoll\pl,llu frolll the rear whllli! Plaintiff 104M O~'tlral,II1Q
hili! vehicle 011 fltlHe !loute 15 at or Ileal' J;ilnd !llreet and Trlndlll
\lOil'!. ('Am~' 11111, I'A, l>Jalntittlf believe tllD (lot'OJulalltll may have
dlll'l\Jetl llell,D tollnwlnH Ihe a(,dl1l1nt,
" 1~. vuhicle opllratJ;jd by (lefendalltll WiI. operated
lIli\J II \jent 1 y by l
(0) fAiling to exercise adequ411l cOlllrol .aid vehicltl.
(hi failing to IUIHCilil1l due and IIdeljUllle DiUII unlier the
nlrcufIllllanc811,
lc) Iltrlkln!l PlalntHf'. vehle11! from the rearl and
(dl VaHlng to Iltop lJrlllf to Itlrlklng the vehi,!!. Vldntitf'll
wore In.
WWfI'~
Wil1WlIU,IClLv. IUW.lUll~_AllUAl
II, Pllugnphll I,., ot lIdlCl ('oll1ldlilnl are Inoof(loutlld hiH'llin
by ntfenll1ce all \:hl)\lljll fully IIllt forth,
!I. All II rellult frl)fIl t II", nll.j\ lUtlllct:l ot IJllhndalll lIll oet tor'tll
above, t'1111ntlff, ItlllIIIH M, 1<0011, lluttel'll(1 llIHI(J\11l injul'tllll 11I0111
lll'fldtlcally \:0 IIllJlwle I:ltHlllllll IIIJUIY tu 11101 IIl!ck, '~P1J.r /lml
mlddllil back, lower back, ll.lfl flhoul(\!H, dgh\: IhiUh /:IllI! left wdlll
'U1I' elbow,
10, The l'llllnt Iff. lt13tlllll' 1<0011, allw lilKl'erllillce l'llin and
llutfedllg, and incufTllIl medical bUill III a direct and llliproxlmately
rellult of tho llforeml!l1tloned nelJll(Jllnce of [)ehmlant,
11, Vlalnt i ff hellev!'lll and tlUHufore aven that thll rl11fll/l\Jllli
descriuell in par'agraph nino (9) a 11I1 tell (10) are ongoing, thUD,
makes II claim for future pain and sufferlllll ami payment or future
medical bills,
WlIHHHFOHH, PlaintiU, Blither M, Koch. demand. judgment IIgllinlt
Defendant in the amount in exe... of TwentY-five Thouund
($25,000,00) Dollars together with COllt of thie IIction and reque'Le
a trial by jury.
COUNT I J
B8'l1lBR KOCH v. ZAPPAM .Il\lllAIItA
12. Paragraphs 1-11 of this Complaint are incorporated herein
by reference as though fully set forth,
13, 1\s a result from the nog1 igence of Defendant all set forth
above, Plaintiff, Bsther M, Koch, Bufferell 1I11I:iouo Injuries more
upecifically to include uerioue injury to hllr neck, upper and
middle back, lower back, left Ilhoulder, riUht thigh and lert Wrillt
and elbow,
14, The l'laintif f, Bether Koch, ,,100 exper1ellce pal nand
Buffering, and incur-rell medical blllB at a dll'ect and 1l11proxlmately
reeult of the afOl'omelltioned negligence of Defendant,
15, Plaintiff believes IInd therefore averll that the damages
described in para~lrllph thirteen (11) and fourteell (14) are ongoing,
thUB, makeD a claim for future pain and Ilufferlng and payment or
future medical billa,
WIIIlKKl'OKK, l'lllllltltf, !tilt her M. Koch, demand" judumellt IIIJalllol
lJofolHlallt In the amoullt III 811cellll of Twellty' t1ve '1'houBlInd
($;.1'>,000.00) lJollan I,oll.ther with COllt of tilt. action and reQueBtl
II trial by jury,
cowrLIU
.;IQflH IQCn-y ..',. KJIAL 11L11~_ ABIlAI
16, paragnphll 1"1!> of this Complaint are IncorpOl'lted heretn
by rererence aa though fully oet forth,
17, AI a UIUlt of neg II gOIlCD of the Defendant al aet rorth
above, Platnt 1ff, .10hll Koch, lIuttered perlous Injuries to hts neck
and back hernia,
18, l'lalntlff ~lpo experienced palll and suffering, and
Incurred medical billa,
19, 1'Ialntlft beltuvell and thereforll aVllrD thllt the damagell
depcr1bed In paragraphu Sllventeen (17) IInd elghtoen (10) ant
ongoin9, thUll, he makell II claim for future I'lIln and suffering IIml
paymBII! of medlclll b1111l,
WIIKIlHl'ORH, l'latll! ICf, John Kuch, demandll jUllYlllen! agalnll!
IJflfllmlanL In all amoullt In ellcellll of 'l'wllllty-flve Thousand
($~'>,OOO,OO) \Jollarll !o\Jltther with the cost or thiN actton and
requests a trilll by jury,
COUN'l' IV
JOJllUWClLy. 1W'l'AH aUHAlHA
:l0. Paragraphs 1-19 of thla Complaint are Incorporated herein
by reference aB though full y llel fort h,
n. As a rellult of nS!Jllgence of the Defendant aB Bet forth
above, Plaintiff, John Koch, puffered serious 11Ijurles tu his neck
and back hernia.
22. Plaintiff aleo experienced pain and Buftering, anel
incurred medical bills,
2), l'laintHf believes and therefore avers that the damagell
described in paragraphs twenty-one (2ll and twenty-two (22) are
ongoing, thus, he makes a claim for future pain and sutferlng alld
payment of medical bille,
WIIBRHlIORH, Plaintiff, John Koch, demandB jndgment in 1m amount
in excess of '1'wenty,five Thouaand ($25,000,00) Dollan together
with the cost of this action and requeBts a trial by jury,
COUN'l.".V
<TOlIN K.OClLy.. lUlAlJ.U_ll..AallA1
LOlI1l01'C:OlillOR'l'lUM
24. Paragraphs 1- 2 3 of thi Il Complaint are incorporated herein
by reference as though fully set tonh,
25. At all material timoll, Plaintiff, John Koch, waB and
continues to be huaband of Plaintiff Rsther M. Koch.
26, All II reBul t of negligence of Defendant, the Plaint if f
John Koch Buftered l.oSll of Consortium for which a claim Is made.
~1 061
I
I.AW OFFICIi.H OF KVlUNA'l'R, JACOUS 8c SAUA
114 Senate Avenu., Suite 503
Camp 1111/, I'A 17011
'I'elephone Numher! (717) 731-0988
^Ullrne)'1 ror Uerendllnt8
ESTllIlR M. KOCII ANU JOliN K(K~II.
P1.AINl'ln'S
u
IN 1'111\ CU\JMl' ()t' CUMMON .".ItU
CIlMUF.MI.ANIl CtJllN1'V, I>aNNIlVLV ANIA
"
Nu. 97-11 13
VS.
KIIAUU II. ASIIAI ANU ZA"''''AM
SllMAIRA. DnRNUAN'l'S
CIVil, Ael1UN - I.AW
JIIM\' 'I'MIAI. UIiIltAN\llm
VERII>'ICA'l'ION
I, Zaffalll Sumairu _____,~, verify thai Ihe slalcments made In Ihc
fllregolng ^Qswcr wl1ll~~U~L.LlLJ.h:fcmlllllll. Khlllid lLAahlll ami Zaffam Sumaira.
to Plaintiffs' COll1plaint ________, which are wllhln Ihe persllnal knowledge of
the undersigned, are true and correct, and as Illlhe facls hased IIn Ihe Infonnallon of olhers,
the underslgnoo, aftcr diligent Inllull)', helleve them to he Ime, And 1\lrther, Ihb
Verlllcation Is slgncd on Ihe recoll1lll"lIdatlon or my attomeys, who advise Ille Ihat the
allegations and language In Ihls documenl are re{julred legally III rllbe IUlles fur reSl1ll1ll11n HI
trial, hy the COllrt, IIr hy conllnulng Invesllgatlon und prepurutloll fill trial. I IIndenlood Ihal
511111e IIf these allegallons Illay plllve Inapplllprlale after Investlllatllln Hnll trial preparalll1n are
Clllllplele and I leave the delennlnallon IIf Ihese matters III my allllmeys on Ihelr advice,
I IInderstllnd that all slatelllents heroin ure Illade 8l1hjC(1 10 the penallles of 18
I'H,C,S,A, 04904, relatlnlllo unswonl fulslf1cullllns III aUlhorhles,
Daled: I> 6, 01, (n
~'~
<Wf4 ~
"am Sumalra
CRRTIrlCATB or BBRVICR
AND NOW, this 24th day ot June, 19Y7, I he~eby e.~tify that a
true and eo~~.ct copy of the foregoing document has been served
upon the following by depositing the Ilame in the United State.
Mail. tirst clan. poetage prepaid at Harrisburg, Dauphin County,
"enneyl vania add~ened as tollowlIl
Donald R. Dorer
RUlJ tNATB , JACOBS " SAIlA
214 Senate Avenue
Suite SOl
Caql lUll, VA 17011
BY;
,/)'1
M eh..l J, Pyko~, B, q" ~; (
Atto~n.y ID# 58851
Wagner Building - SU e 205
355 North 21st Street
Camp lUll, VA 17011
(711) 975.9446
Datel
June 24, 1997
l(l J 113
, I'll III' Ii AI'
1'111',11"'111111111',10 ;,I'IlVIi., HI' A :,IlIlI'IIHIA
1'lIl1hllAHl III Ill"., "III'~ n
AI . l'I~"'lllh\l1l III ""Ivl," "' . IIlI"III~II' '"' lllll '111I"111 "",llhlll"l I'Ull1l41l1
'" 1111111 4ullv,U
I1C ~ "II h~h.'l "I ~lJMPJ", !J1J~l", U'.I!I Il~
"..rolld.", ,,,"111'" Ih4'
III A 111I11'0 '" 1"'0"1 'iI "'VII ,h.. '''''1'''"11' wllh . "'1'1 "' tI!!, .ul'I"I"1I1 r
.11.. hOlt 11'"'""1 .... ,".110,1 "I ,jollv",".ll" ..0\, IiI"'.' I".., ,
1,,",,1 Y ,l.y. I" 1"1 Iii Ih~ "Ii" "" wit I'" II," Illhl""'''' '" ""111"1 III 1'0
fltii'VPlL
(lJ ^ I fillY II' !lIp 11111 tni! of 11",,"1, IHi II~diIlM Ill, IJjUl'"UHt 'HiIJjttlil'H4. t\li
.11., ho" III Iho 10,111 I, "'0,
(II U" "1'1~"I",, III Ih. lul,I'''o'", hu """II II" ..In'l. .,,,1
(/" Iho lul,I'''''"' whllh 11111 I.. '''IV.,J I" Ilt""I\,.1 I" Ih. ."1.1....'.. IIh'''1
I. """ h.,t III Ih. IIUI IIIl III 1'111111 Iii UIVI Ih. 1,,101"'''''1,
l'AlIt, jUU4/Y!,
V!!!tA\'UA, JM"M U'IUIU
Atllllli.y till lJ.t.'lil',,1
l1t,ll"lil!h~ll It.' IfJ~,j {'le. I
....,
l<"
c :1'1 lilt "1\"1';/\1,'1'11 III" l'l':r'IIJ:.YI,V^lll ^
C ;III1l"I'Y III" I :11l'1I11';IU.^I.JI'
III 1111' I,^ I H~ II Ii ,
t:llll~l Ill' 1;lllUIIII/ I'I.I<^S
"'>llthH II. ~1lt:1I ^'W Willi ~IIelt
Tt:Hlt, 11111111
.VR,
c^st. 1m, H,IIIl
ylt^I,1II It, ^~It^1 MW hlltl^"I^ 7.MII'^R
N()'I' I CK 01' I N'I'I(N'I' '1'0 1lf.IIVI! II !ilJlIl~QRN^ 'I'V J'IIQU\JCR 1J00:Vf4I1N'I'1j
M./lM/lMVHf.Rh trlSIIIW/l:I': .1111 II/Sl/HM1CF.
IlIlm',H, Hlelt, YF.^RIIEV ~ IIE11IC^"
Ill. IIt.ItAF.L liYKO~KI, f.SljIlIRf.
111:5 "" h..h.ll "t /JllllALIJ /l, IHIRF.R. "SljUI/l~ .. __ 11I1~1I".'" ""IV" . Iuhl'"lll.
Ido"III.1 I" Iho """ Ih.1 I. .11.01,1" I" Ihl. 1I11111e, YIIIl h.yl' IW,,"ly UII)
d.y. 11"11I Ih.. d.l.. Iill..d h..l"w III willi 1,111 Ill.. III ,,,,",,1"111 "'IVI' "1"'" tllP f
IIlHlff. ,. J KIlt',1 RII oli) PI t 11111 I \I I lip !iUlJl'tlPIlA. It 1\11 Ilh let t illll IIlI l1Iall.. t h.. lIuh(ltltH'"
lII'y h. ...Iv..d 1"""'"111 I" Ih. ftl'l'l\lohlp "PIIII.Y)VOIIII Rulu III (;lvll r",,,',hll.'
IdHJ1Lllt, CIHIlI'I..IH llll'jPII IIf IllY 'f'l'lllllul fHI '91'lIldll IIl.Y h~ lItLlpl'tHI ,,' YOUI' ;
""I'''''.'' hy """1'1.1 IIII! Ih. .11101,,,11 ,"uIIMPI 11.<1 ftl\il lelUtllll'1! 1811I" III lies '"
hy '''"l.' I IIlI! "'" t,,,. I IICS III f II",
/JAU, Ill/OJ/VI
Hcn 1111 h"ltlll HI
..QIJllAl.U I\. ,UU((Il.~L r.~111I1 RK
^IIHIII"Y 1111 UEI'F.IIUMll'
U;I 110111\1,11 R, UURlR, ESQUIRE
INURtIJ "A HOB
V 1. UO,
6011 I'51119Y I J ,,v
^"Y '111_.' I "'IN '"11"'"1\11 thh In.,'"'' '''''' II"
TIIF. IlG~ UIWUP, Ill(;,
10111 HARKEr STREn
leoo
I'll 1I.^IlF.LI'1It ^ I'A I Y 1111
(lI5) l40.0VUO
ltF.lIJ,iI'l1l1~1 1111 In l,j ':11:.>
I':~I'I "'NATION <<)Ii HEC)llllU:U ItH 'OIWS
TO: 1'1 IS I Olll/\N 01' Itle 'OllllS I Oil
AI'I Nt\IIIt/WH I'IIS INS' I It,\Nl'I, ('()I\t
I' 0 1\11)\ I qK~
Ilh\lJINlI, I'A l'lhl!
leI>:: 4111f1'1
IOIIN I\IHII
1'II1'Y I'NIIIII; I'IIlSII'^llTY 1:111; I'OW 'Y #llISYIHII4IHIIIHl4I'( 'S
IJlJA I H"I~
,'/IV allll all 11.1111I, Ilk,
Illlh'~ ICI'tllll'~tt'll: "1'111 111111 IlIdllllhlll IIII' 1II"'~"III,
SlIhJnl : ,'OliN IW( 'II
".I" "'I>:SS"'II \"I.L\tiI,;, MI\CIIANI('SlIlJIUl, I'A 17U!I!I
Slid". SI'I'III'Il~ II: I 72.11 I. ifIll!!
1I"lr "' IIhth: 111.1.\.1..
IIl1h' ..I' LII~~: 11.1I4.",!!
,U III I 111111 J I I fIt It' I t l I
1
(l""'It~!'N:111 (Jr' "t'~IiVt.V'illl^
( U !\(!'Y Ill' < '.""~1(INi I
.
tSllffH M. Koell ANll ,JOliN KOCH
"iI. No,
WI-Jill
-VB-
~-~-
KIIA\.IIJ II, ASIIAI ANII 5UHA1U unu
'll~.IQJ'IllD.~ ~,.1lJltQI
fQL.Q! lMYfl!t .l.\IItI.Wit~tQ JU.l_jQl1Ut
TO,
I'USl!!!.'.!ltL!J,t!\E..l!!\!'! tOIi'. [J)N~t"":!IULKl!A.Hl:!:JVWIIA AnQ.kl~l"
(H.I. ot PlW'ton or Entity)
Ud, 'l.ClJlOtN, YOU Ir' c:rdrld bv Uit (II:.1U"t W
-.. . ~"-'--'~'-"--'--'~+""'~.
Within tWlW'lty (rO) dlly. aH." 'ilt'" I". of
IJn)CiJc. the fo II ow lllil ")(A.-I.lt. 01' th Intn I
__!~!..~! l~l:tfIV
-", "" _'"...v.,~.___..._.~>..,_,.,_.. "-"'~'~'"'-_~'~'~"N.. ,_ '~'.,~~_.._.
-'"-'~~-'_._.""...<-" ~""-'" >.,,~
"., "-_...._-,.=,=.._.=.~==~~=:~=~..=r:.._... .,..
mm I ~~lU !1!!h..11!ll!l!1L.tlt1!ll'A..1UJ.!.Lf n,_..
(Ad<..... )
.t -.l!!!.t!pu!.!lli!!r~ !N,l 11 ' !~(! I M!\JJi!
Yoo qy dallv. or 1Il,,11 1~1l>la cnlll... of the I1lUmeonh or pr'(4IC, thlnga r~l..tlll\i hI
thl. .\.tlJlQiltll, toe4Jthlf' wIth tha c.t If IC4lt. of cw,lI illnCl. (0 V" perty IIlIk IIlI thlt
r~st .t th, alU'... lIst... ab(l'ill, Yl~' I\lVII the r It;;lt t~ sMII In advanc. the r.....llblt
co.t of preoer log th. twl.1 or 'J( odJC lrlll the Ih IrlQI lOUijlll.
If yoo f.n to l>ltlI."". th. dt>Qfllllflll (.lI' Ulin"l r.'Jjked by thh ,,~ wIthIn tWlrlty
(20) dayS .ft.,. lh .ilt'vlu, U.. ,larty 'ilt"viog thh '~may allk . IlOIrt ardlW'
CICIlPI" iog YOU to tuft) I y wIth It,
lUll ~NA WAS Ilq,O AT lit "eut.II
1Wt!.,.....__...,l!.!!1i!l:!J,~, II!lRtk\t~(llJIKt
AOOI'IUS, p?14 !j.!!!~g hVt.~lJtl ~YUk '01
CAMP Ill!.!.! I'A IIUII
ll!LEPlOlf I U ~ (41) o~oo
fU'Rt1'1! O:UH III II
A TTOONfY raIl __ _, l'Ut~\jc'~~'!
C.f fit; "~l(Mll<<'l PIRIa"
. - '.~. .,.-<_.".<-..~
c.-'.
DATE' >-t.*uhJ}J.~{fI-7
~f, , it.., (;
. .' ..,J '.,,- ,,2 LL._
o', It,
/
(ttf 1/,1)
";XI'L\N,\TION Cw ItU)"IIU;U IW('OltUS
TU: ("~IOIJl,\N III 1111 \lIlIIS Hill
I ONNI'II, lilt II. 1\1 ,\IINI'\ .\
I lIllIllI,\ ,\SSIII'
.'11/1I0l'SI'I\VI'NIII'
1M.1I'111I1,1't\ 111I11
111':: ,Illlhtl
IOIlN IW('II
I\IIV alld allll'l'Il"IN, I 1111 I'Sp"'IIil'II.... , li"'" illltlltl"lIIl1ll1lllhllllll, IUllldwlflll'lI
1I1lIt'S, hllllll)l i111l111.l)'IIIl'IIIIt'lllltls, Idillilll! hi ;III)' P~Ullllllillillll.
I III1SI1 Itil 111111 , ..illl' III tll'i111111'1I1
I)nh'N Ih'lllIuh'lll "I' hi 1IIIIIIIIdllllhlll till' III'I'NI'IIl.
SlIhlnl : "UIIN 'Wl'/I
H.'" I\IESSIAII VII.I,I\m:, I\IE('II^NI('SIIlJIW.I'^ 17n~~
Sudnl SrL'llllh II: 172.1I1-1(,l1~
l)'lh' ul IIhlh:' IIZ-H-I"
"it 'I II I I" It I I I t ~ , (I I J If' L~
f
,
,
ql ..tIU
U,IlIII'I' An
l'II~,Il~'llIllllni. tll 1l~IlVlq, II Ii ^ i,III1I'IIH'A
l'lIMnU^H'" 'lU MUI,l( ~HH~, II
^" 1 11I.IPllllhll~ III Ulvlll 1111 "lhl"'""1 1111 ,11I'UIlII"I" 11111 thlll"" 1"11'111"1
I II Rul. 41)(/'1.0
flea 1111 1,~h.1I '" \JIlU^~li Ii. IJ!J~'., UW'II.
01.1.11111"1 ,plllll.. lila,
III
^ 111111,0 "' 1,,1,'''1 I" "'Y. Ih. ",,1'1"'.'" ...lth 1 "'I'Y ill III. "11'1""'''" r
.1 III h..1 Iholo," Wit mall." "I Iltdjv.,..l," ..,h I'lIq II 1.1-' ,
I Willi I Y tt_Y'_ 1'11111 III Iii.. Illllt lIn whldi Ill. luhllll.ll. 'I tilHtMhl 'H II"
'UH YfHL
(I) A llll'Y ul III" 11111 !tit III 1111"'111, t,,~ IU1ttnti Ih. Ilfl"HI't,tJ 'UI'I'I1f1114. I-
,"",h.oIllllh.I.IIIII,al.,
(I) UII "hl"i1I"" I" Ih. IlIhl"'""" h.. h.." ..,.Iv.... 1",1
(4) 1'h. ollhl'''"''. whl,h wl'II.. "lv..1 I, t"o"lhlllll ,h. .,,1.1''''''. \llIllh
10 I".,h.,llll IIIP 111,11'0 il' 1"'.11' III '.'VI Ih. "..1'1'''"''4,
I'^IF.I JO!l4/UIH
l/I!fl^~U!L.WU~. n'jlllU
All ""11' 'Ill ,t.r'""'1l1
/l111.''''6VOI I,IJ /nn HI:,I I
""I
..
~
." " "'"'ILJI':AI ,'I'll ""
I . .. , , " i , " I ' \I 1\ I , I i\
0:" , " I "",' ,,', C; , II II \ ", If I .1\ "' I
III 1111' "^ II t It lit I
, lilli' I Ill- . fltllll!1I "II'AI)
I", /lItH II. Mill II ~ '''"1l tilt II
I IdU' , 0111111
vn.
!:MiE IltJI ~I, Jill
~1I"'!.1l1 II. A""AI . "llllAl"^ l^ffA"
"Vl'lt:~ 01' 'NTI~"'I' "'0 II t:IIV'l ^ IH1/It'Ql!fff\ "'(}I'HQI)vC:ll !JII(:!IKJC"T"
I "AVU.IEH' & IIlhll"^,H,t U'llIi^'l't'
'li'W',H, "'1.11, H^fIfHiV .
IAV 11111, 11.1>,
II"LV ""I HI I lliiblill^',
"'^l.lIf~iJllIl 1t',II^h iJl' IItlll^'4I<:
f ll~lJH""ll'V.
IIWI!:A!.
IIWI!:A!.
IlIi,III!:AI,
1I1'.IJII.AI
I'j, IIf111An l'friJ"", 1',i"lllll!t,
flU, ,," 1,.llall "t IliJll/\L1! 1(, lit!HI',II, "hljlllHle , IIl'NIIlIl III ""VB A Olllol'''HIi" r
IdHlIl11.1 III llt~ 1II1~ tll..l I. a11"duIIJ III ddll 1t"I'I.. YOIt h..VM t"'"tlly (/O~ t
dl10 """1'10. d.l. 1I01.d 1,.11IW '" wh'lh '" It!. III 1811l'I' .,,'. "M1U "1'''11 Ih. ,
11lId~llllKl1pd all Hhl.", t 1011 10 Ih,.. llIul'lltl"Il.. It nil llhlll t tllll I. lfll~l~ till. lflllhl'lIH1I4
IIIMY 11M ....vltd l,ut.uI.iI III thft ."plh.llt.. P"IItIl,lVIIlI. IfIlIHI lit Civil IJllltl'dlllP
tdJlJY.J" LlIllll'lt+ltt Illld"lt "' .ny ,1l'lqlHJUi 10111 IPlllflh "'.y I1f' 11111",..11 4' YOlll
"'_I'Pltf'P I.y IOflll111f1 ifl", tll.. 1I1'.I'U~iJ IlItHlI.1 'I.d 'lHJ '.'Ufllthti '"11I" tll tleU II'
I,v l(lnIA,'III" IiU, 111111 tiCn "flft..,
II^ I ~ I I II I II II ~,
HCU ilU I,HhA II III
~Im^'-l) H, lJl)H~H,_';;~ljlll\(1t
All ii' u~ y I" I IIKVf.NIMIIT
II,I 1"'I4AI./) R, Iii/au, IUI/UIU
IfIllNII! I.AHuI
u ',lift'
ull~H'4uull',U
^IIY 1,1l."I"u. INIl."lI". 'hit IIIII1NI, '"ul.,1
lllV. itCh IiHlJllr, Itll:,
10111 "^"Mr.!' hHII,f.T
,"1111
~IIII.AlIt,('I'111 A I'A I ~ I Ii I
("'1 Hr'.Il~1)1I
IJY.Ul.jj', 111',/ '. el'"'' ':'I~'
11M.tHoll'1IJll1! OP'I'!:JlN:IYl.vAN t^
lU 1tI1'Y OI'Q,t1I_~!t1.1INI1
-~, ,- ----'-_..
.:S'IIIRIl H. KUell ANIl .JOliN KOCII
.
-vs-
fll. No. 97-2113
KllAl.lll II. ASHAI , SUMAlRA ZAn'AR
IUPOI!NA TO PAm! n: UOC1.tENTl. a.:oo~ ~ ~
FOR DI~RY fUlSUAHT TO ~E 2
TOa CUSTODIAN UF \([r~_!!!~ AE1N~ I 1IlAVEU:RS INSURANCE CUHP~Y
(Ntme of Peraon or Entity)
Within twenty (20) day a after aervlce of O1la al.lbpoena, you ar. ordered by the ClOI.rt to
prodJC4I tha following docunanta or thing., ____
UK Al1AI~J;L._.__._.__. "___.______....___
I
I
r-----
at _l.lULl1!;.s...!llill~_lIiE....-liOl HAIlKF.l SlIlEE1._~tlLROO, PIIIJ.AOItI.PHIA, I'A 19103
(Adere.. )
You may deliver or mall legible copies of the docunenta or prodlce things raque.tlKi hI
this a~a, together with the certificate of c:arpliance. to the party making thls
requeat at the adere.a llated above. You have the right to .eek In advance the reaaonahle
cost 0' preoarlng tha cople, or prodlclnll the things sought,
If you fai I to produce the docunent, or things required by tnla aLlbpoena within twanty
(20) dayS att.,. Ita aervlce. the party ..rvlng thl, a~ may ..ek a court order
~Illng YOU to CXJl1l1y with It.
TItlS liUII'OENA WAS ISSUED AT TIE RE~5T a: TH! FOlLCW1NG PERSONa
IWE'____, I!UNALV Il. I!ORERLli!!llUJ!!..~..__
AWlESS I ___? l~~!!!~!~ AV~N.!!~L~..!'J~.~~.u.}.
, . c-'!t1" .!!J1h,I'A 171LI..
TtLEPlmE I ,.lJJ_: HHi9.QO._......._____
Iil..REtt: QUIT 10 "___..___..____n__ _,
AlTOONEY FOOl I!EFltNDANl
(,..~--...
DATE I .,.' ~~--~-l----
5.' of the OoiJrt
l
.. HI civil Division
~-_,,~--
(Ef(, 1/97)
(U11ltMW1I11 IIr 1....HIYt.vl\Nl^
(Un/l'Y 01' Ilf111UtlllNIl
t-~llttK M. well ANIl .JOItN klll'lt
,
, V~'.
FII. No. 91.JII)
kltAl.l11 II, ASIIAI , SUHAlMA lAHAR
'''~~Io.J'AmInr nrn-NTLmJllig
t'llJUIQ1Jlftt-l'UIl(,MtfLIo....m.u..JQQl.11
TOI,J:1!lli!!HA!t,Q! !!!t.:l!!!!J~, Jl!!t,! ,[l!~~~~-kJ~:I!::Kf.AJ:t~~'!.~!OKL'1I1A ASS!!fIAa~
(N..,. 0' P...1OrI or Ent I tv)
" . c ,,_.._.~..__....... _~~___'___---.
--_.__.-.._~- .
Yw IfllIV dell....' tit" nllltl legtbl. <:4l1.... 0' the docunents or prOl1Jc. thing. requntltli hI
lhl. .~, togeth... with the l:llrtjfl~t. 0' lXl'f1)lIanc:., to the party IfllIklng thh
r~..t .t the adlt-... I t.ted ebov., You ',.v. the r1l11t to aMII In ad...anc. the r...oow..
wet 0' j)f'tKlar tr.g th. t;()fllu Of' 'If'odlC tnil th. thtr'VI ,ought.
It VillA tall to IlrodAc;. th. d.XUllll1t' or thlnvl r.qulrlkl by this a\Jbpoena within twenty
(:0) !Mve a'ta" Its ....vlc.. th. party .......Ifl\/ thll altJpoeoa nlllY ..ell . court ordllr
(Q1f)elllfl\/ vou W tnfl'lv with It,
lltll ~NA WA' llGUm Ar lie RfcU:sr of' ltl! fQ..LQIIIti3 pr;nSONI
IWt: I l'\}!'},lV ~. !,~Ik~~t f.~111I1 Rf.
ALUU'1$1 114 lit,NAlt. AnNUl, IWllE 'JOI
L.\i11' ItUL, I'A t/(lll
Ttlkl'lU4t I ~ D' {lth 119011
we-I'm f~UII III II
AI'(l'tNt:v fUll 1.t.HNlJAN'1
- .~ "---"---'---..~..-.
UAlr, '?lit &ti.~jjI7---
(Eff, 7/91)
(U'tHMt1\11l11 O!, !.tlltfjYINNU~
n 1It11'i' Ot' {'"!!~ll~NIJ
t,lllllU H, ~(J( It ANUllIltN ~(Jl II
.
-Vll,
1'1 I. H\). ~!..:.ll1L..._~
...-"""'....,.~.._.,-~~--~
~ItAt.lU II. UItA! " IUl'IA!1IA UUU
TOIDlU~Q!A!Ll!.t. nrllM,!!! rUM!
, LA.v J, i,!llJJ ~,lJ, ..,_'.
(N",", of I'''tllfl or Entity)
thll .\.<K*>I, VOU Ir. ClI'"drM by thtt QQl,rt to
- ,.._, "',,-..., '.--------
Within t._.tv nO) d'VI .fh,' ..nl,. f>t
~ ~ ,,,,I lowll'ljj \L(;uIW,tl t.' thln""
..JU -"l1A(It~fj
"'-"""~"~~"'''~-~-'--''"--~-'~'~-~''''---'--
.t -1111 t1Ui lilI!ur. I~L" l~!!! !iAI!~I[L
You /I.y dill I.... or 11II11 1*Vlpl. (ollIN elf tot.. Ib:UIl~flll or .-'QQJc:. thine' F'qu..t.~ \),
lhl, ,~. ~thll' wllh tt,. c;lI'tHlc:ah 0' CXlITJllanc., 1.0 the PlI"tv making thll
r*",.... .t tt.. ......... II.tlKl IbaVI, y~, h.vI the rllt1t to ..... In .aVlU'lCI the r,,,onablt
ooa" ", rw~artng I,he OOIlt.. 0,. pn:,,1Iclnll thl thlrlll' 'DUlt,t,
I' YOLI fall W Pf(xLc;. lh. U.,lCl.nlltlt, '" U,hl\ll ,.~\t'.a by "hit .,"....-.. wlt.hln tw.nty
nO) cUYI 1ftII' Ih '''vk., lh, Harty lIlI'vlng thla ~ IfIlV ..ek . oourt !)I'd..
~'lIng '1'(><1 IQ mrt'lv with It, '
tHlI filAlIU~ WAll Il~ 41 Ilt RIiGU:fil U' Ht! I'CU(NII;n I"AIOOI
1Wt;, [1\lMt~ ~: !1l'~tM, fll1liJIU
NnlIHlII ll4 tiM4Alf AVklWf. blllH 'JOj
C^lif llEt, YA lllJll
Tl!lJf'lnn:' u.~ {.~ 1J~1Jl/
IU'ftttt ClUB 10.
Aflt"Nfy Foo I lJ.~~~l/UAtfl
O.4ltl
[
",LOt! l , ~'<1 ~f;"J
ha V of the &~Ir( l
~~%~.Ton
.J~""'i'
(tff, 11ull
I'::\I'L\N,\ liON ()Ii UU)IIIIU,U IU:( 'OIWS
10; Il'S I 0111 Mol III IIIIIIIW," I Oil
I,,, 1110, ~I (J
111,11,\11 ~II'IIIIINI,\SSO('
~ I !,II, I IlINIJlI' IIIl
~IH'II,\NIISIlIIIlIi, I'^ 17m~
111':; 11l11.H
IS 111111 M 1\1/1'11
'\IIV ,11111 "II II" III",~, . 1111 1"1'"111 kill... , II"'~ ,111111111'111111 IlIlIhllll~, IlIlIllhvlllh'1I
IIIIh'~, 1011111111 illI" 1'.IYIII,'1I1 Il'IIII"~, ,\'1,1111111'" "llY nlllll 111..1 11111 ,
'"11'111l"tl"ll, 'illl' III 11,'..11111'111
r
I
1I111r, 1I1'11'1I'~1I'11: "1'1111111.11"1'111I111'11 IIII' 1'1'I'~1'1I1,
SlIhlrl'l : I'Xl'llIm 1\1, Im( 'II
".1" I\IESSI!\II \'ILL\m:, I\IIWII,\NIl'SIIlJIHl, I'^ 1711~~
Sul'llll Snllllh 1/; 112.14.\12,1"
IIlllr IIf 1111111;' lIZ.II.I" '
" 'Ill I III 11 III! I.. It. H I It \
EXPI.ANATION (W IW()l'IIU:I) ItH 'OIWS
TlI: IllS 11I1l1i\N III 1111 'OllllS Hill
11111 \ Sl'lllIl lIoSI'II,\1
\111 N .'ISI SlIll'll
(,\1\11'1111' ,1',\ 111111
Ill':: ~lIlhK
I SIIIl II 1\1 I\llI'lI
'\IIY illlll allll'lllllls, !'1I111'S/'lllld"IIL"', Ilks illld 1II1'1IIU1i1I1<1uIIIH, hllllllwlllll'lI
lIi1h's, ,1'1;1111111 hi ,III)' 1'\;111111;1111111, l'IIlINllltilllll1l !'illl' IIr IIl'illllll'lIl.
UlIln 1C~1111I'~h'lI: 1I1111111llllllldllllhtlC 1111' 111'1'81'111.
SlIh,ll'I'l : I~STlllm 1\1. 1(0( 'II
H.'" I\U:SSI,\II \'11.1.,\(11':, 1\I1':('I/t\NIl'SIIUlUi. I'^ 17U~~
SlIdlll S~nlllh II: 171.14.1)2.1"
Illllt, "" IIhlhi 112-11-11)
I
l
""III 1 1 111111 Ii ''''f,'. ...,
I';XI'L\NATION Oli HE()IIIlWU IU.;('OIWS
III: (1ISIIIIJI,\N OJ. 1ll101lIJS 11111
Ilh\I.IIISIIIIIIIIlHI/\1l Ill' MI'('II,\NIl'
11~ I i\N(',\SII'1l1l1 \Ill
I'll 1l11\llllfl
"III 'II^NIlSlll1Iltl. 1'1\ 1711'~
IW: ,107/oH
ISIIII'Il M 1\0(11
I\IIY alld 1111 ll'l'lIllls, l'''lIl'NI'"lUh'III'l', IIk~ 1I11111111'IIIIlIllIllIIlIllS, hllllllwlilll'lI
11"1",, 1111111111 ami paYIIIClIllL'l'lIIlIN, ,L'lalltl\l h. allY l'~al1lll1l1t1l1l1,
,"lslllall,,", \'all' "I IIl'IIIIIII'111.
Ul1trs Ilr'IIII'Nh'll: 111'111111111 IlIdllllllllllhr l'I'l'NVIlI,
SlIh,lrll : I(STIII\!( 1\1, I(()( 'II
H,IH I\mSSI!\1I VILlACif':, 1\If<:('II^NI('SlIlIIW. I'A I?ll!!!!
S"l'Inl SI"'lIllh H: 171.14.1)2.IH
Uall' III IIhlh: lI2-11-11)
"1llllllllllll 1111..,. '11'\
~
r
I
,
I' RAEetr,!L_!11!t!.J 81 I Nll_,SABK_ t,(IR_TJ(] AI.
(Must "0 typewrittell 11I111 Hullllllted ill duplicate)
TO '111f; !'llYlU <<11'NIY OF ctfllUEIIlJ\N) mul'll'Y
Pleaso llut tho fnllowlllY Cll&O,
((1lOck 01101
(XX) (01' ,JURY trial at the next tann of oivil court.
for trial wltl~ut a jury.
---.----------------------------------------
CA/'l'lON OF CAllE
(ollth'll r:>apllm Ilust 00 stated In full)
V:Bthor K,x~h aud
,John Koch
(check one)
( XX) CivU Action - Law
( Appeal fran l\rbit rlS tion
ft>.
Civil
2111
19'J7
(other)
(Plaintiff)
vs,
(Defendant)
The trial list will be called all
MId iU 11 Jjr
TrlalB cxxlTllllnco on -J..J I\<> , q,~
Pretrials will be held on d J::,.c;. I qfj"
(Briefs IUD duo 5 dayu be(~
Khalld II. Mihal Ilnd
BlI1Mira ZaHar
vs.
('I11ll party lis tiny thiB caae (or trial shall
pruvido (orthwlth a copy of the praec1l111 to
all cowlsol, I>>.ITSUll/lt to local Rule 214.1.)
Indicate the Ilttom!!Y wl~ will try caso (or tho party wllCl (iles this prll&:lpol
Darrell C. !lothlo(e
Indicate trial counsel (or other parties If knowrll llulll1ld Il. !lorer I r~Fl(l\l1 re
214 fl<mato Avrmue, Buite 503 CanqJ lilli, I'll 17011
1111s caao la ready for trial.
Slgnedl 7 t ~. :.I~c~IIJ~
Print Nanru ~hJ!Jl!.LJ~ll."'>~
Attomoy fon ]~;~Ln.t..!lt:..
Dill (!I.I/_~h lliB-----
..1, Nlo 91065,
COMI\IONWE^LTII OJ! PENNS\'LV ANIA
COlJNT\' (w CllJ\UnmL^NU
Hslher M, Koch and Juhn )\\.dl,
I'lalnllff
Pile No,-li:llll CIVIL
VI,
Khallll Ji, Adlai and Sumalra
Zaffar, Defendanll
SUBPOENA
I('!;_Johns 1IlW.klli11l1lJ1lilll.J1OO tlW1b..wulfG.Sltwl,palllmore. Mil 21287
I, You ale ordered by Ihe court 10 wille 10 _the Law Office. of Rubln.le. Jacob. &. Sabs. 214
fi~o...sll11QjUJ",_ aLCIliuJlllllL. _C~llAlI.IL County, I'cn/llylvallla, on ____,___ al
2.:.UlL o'clock, _A. M" 10 lelllfy on behalf 01 JheDdCJulw11LK1lAlidll...Alhal and S\llllllraZaUAL_
III Ihe above case, and lu remain IInlU excused
2, And brinK wllh yuu lhe following: _.Y.lluL'l!IIl1lh:lc.lIIC~~ll file. ImJulllni bul JluLlimilWJL!.
1II1Y and all r~ClI.Lur'.I1\llll A1u1bllll1~ut~ill\Iinl~J.\itheLM~Kw;UJltMmiAIl,\'llIull. Mmniubur~.
l'fllillI)'lvanla 1705S; Sodal Sroull)CNum~r; 1 ni4:22JH; lW.lUlfllinh;H;hIlllO'-11._1212~___" ,,-
II )IOU r.lI 10 attend UI tp fwdu". tb. dUCUUlfDl, u, thin,. .aqullt>d hy Ihill .ullvoenll, yuu tnl)' b. .ubjerl to Ih. ,IOl:IHlD. IUlbodnd
by Kull 214.~ or lb. 'f'IlD,yh'lnil Itutu of ("hil JJwc.duft, lodudlRI bUI nnlllmll.d lu ttJll', Ilium.)' r... and hnpruamaDL
ISSUfiD BY A l'ARTY/('(JIlNSHI. IN ('UMI'UANCll wrm l'a,R.C,P, No, 234,2(a)
NAMll:..DllnBld R.,lliutl._llmUlJL.. ,_
AIJDRBSS:.2H.,li.ruillc AYCllU~. ~ul1eJ,lU
J:AJiULllll1.l'ClUll)'lvAJllll _HUll
TllLlll'IIONll:_il11L1Jl:ll!lUL___
SIli'H1lMll COURT llJ#.,.J!I12L__
BY nUl COURT:
I1ATE: 3:cJ'l:_c;L,____,_
Seill ofthe Court
MAR 27 1998
;f " 1- ,__I! dol44.. lh.IL
~. Clvlll11vll11n
~4f;,~/. '~9Lj~:~/
Of IIi'IA" NOTC: 'llil. 'u"" of 'Uh,K".1 """U b. u..d wb.n.." a lul."",,," '" IlIuaLI., ,"dudlll' h..'i",.11I "llInkUun willi
d'I'u"UlH'U and ".(ort l.lli111Ioll, mut'u, UJll1h1J..Juo"., .,(; in i:olDplilm. wilh I'.R ('.P, Nu 2\4 I. It I .ub,)()aol 'hi
J"o\lu~ tioll of ducument., ,enHd. (lJ Ihin,. II dul,.d, ,uwplel' )1.lIln,,1I 2
I~'" 11~lti
I
LkM11I'II:^H
~UUIIU I h IlK 111 h~MV II H III' A !iU"I'II~""
,'UM tlU"H'I'W MUl.... ~ 1111'1, ~ ~
iiI III~ "^ I 'I r,H Ill'; i"UMl Of COMHllN H~,"'"
t'>III~," II. ".1'1 It " hiHN t'~oLlt lUll, H!iUU
Vb" I"U UIJ, 9/, till
YIIAI.IIJ It, MItA I ~ !oIII1AI"" 'AHA"
t"i ot IquP"'jlllodl" III hUllJiq! HI ;~ ltUhpUI!Il. to' IIWWflHlI'i ~"d tldhg.. l'IUiliUl\.tt
II' ttlilw '.HU'l.I'}
fjCll "II I>.II~ II "I !!1)lj"L,1J M, !JlJ~~H I lb'llJ! ".~
.t~f,,"d"Ht I HI t 'II.... ,,,..I
(1) A Hilt tltl p' In'Hllt tu '1fifl/tt Ilw ~qhlllH'"ll' with M lliV~ Iii tl1. 'UhplluHa
411 oj. h"l~ t tU".11I wJt~ iutjal",J III dt, l \Y~I I'll t II l'~' h li..l Y II:t t...liil
IWtHlIV th,_ l',liJI III Iht! thtu lif1 ~hh" Ih., 1~llhplltfll. JII "IHJMhl tll hw
tJHI \.ItI\1,
~t) ^ 1111')1 of II..:! 111I1 tl. lot 1'1 lll''''lIl1 lltlIWlillt". I Ill" 1'11I1'1I-".,tl l'UlJPlllofllit, JIo
;i11;.illih,J 'II t li~ 11:11 t J f i i d' ,t.
t l} Uti 1I1l1"! t IIlII lit Ilu# !tUhI'IJHfHII hiU 1,,16111 If'! .ti\l': I, 4fIlJ
11>1 '11w ,,,1'1"'0'" ...hld. ..III Iw '"IVOII I. 1"lonll, _, III \I.. '''''I'''''U ...lill II
l.. -il11.duHI "U ltlll Hulllt" lit I"'''I!'- III lHi"Y~ Ihw liulllllllHl4,
f;AI~. ~U(I/Y'
/11.1
r~',.".."-..f./A Jr, hi I
PIJH,\~(J H IU'"lll, '~\IIJIM'
1\11 "11101 'ill .j,!.",h,,1
"~II ", <. 'J I. I, II I n << t. II I
(:IIHM.,NWII;A','I'11 1'1" 1"':NNI.YI,VAN I A
t: ( 11 J N 'I' Y l) l" t: II 1"1 U I.: It .. 1\ N \.I
(II lilt, liMn" Of'
"'1IJ"1' Ill' C'JHHIlIl 1'l.KAti
t,lil Ur.K H, KOIU ~ Intltl KI"U
n';KH, IIl1l)U
..
'V~.
CAb~ UU, ~1.ZIII
WALII. U, M.lIAI I, 1;III1AIRA l^H^"
~
~O'I'II:~ Ill" !N'J'!(tf'I' 'I'U tlr,IW!tA.l!!!It1'-OJt~,~.'!IQ 1'!illl!.!l~~l)Q~!tMI"U
UI"~1 \4fJ~ l"'nrlll'lt"d ll~t lit 111181 I 011 Ii I
1Il1 HICUAH liyn'SKI. t;&I/lJlltt,
111;5 "" 1,,'''.11 ,01 LJIIIIALIJ.Il' IJIIKI'It,_~S'JI~IK~, ,__ 1111"1101. III "",v.. Iluhpllenl
lu,'nll,.1 '" 'I... 1111" Ihal I, alt.,holl '" Ihl. 111111,,,, YIIU hava Iwenly (lO)
day. fliun Ih" da'p 11.,",1 (,..tll., III whl"l 'II Ill" III li'IlIlIlln" ,pIV. up"n Ih..
\Illdwt~jMIl~d ,HI tlhllfllllll\ III till' '1I1hl'llI'"Il. It IlIlllh)tftlipl1 lA mad... Ih.. lIuhtJIHH1.
lIIay Ii... I:lPIVtllllllll<;IIiUlI III lh.' ,1111'1It'8hlH 1'''''''I1A)'IVR"lft RlIllI.. ot Clvll t'rlH'tldul""
l.OUIJ"U., COlllpll't fI IlIp!tn-l lit ,lilY IUplUtJUl ed lttt:lJHh may lip lIrdU"'ll It y"ur
"lIIP'."'"" by I PIIIl'll't IIlK tllii ftt 1St IHfd 1'1lIltPul) I'.ad !Iud I''lundalll ':flllll'" tu HCS Ol
IIy I tlOI dl t tfq~ "lit I lie 41 HC~: 011 il H,
"^TE, 'dlll/VH
flCS "" "~h.ll III
.\JON/I(.1I !!., _t).Q~lli_!sqU!!,~ ,
Allllrn.y rill' tJl!F!N1IIINT
u;, IltJNIIW R, DORKR, UqUIll1t
WOR fD LAI'TOS
U I-OO~
601lPH14V91149
^"Y Illulltl",," 1'1'1111'111"11 thiN 1Il.'I~r, lillllll"
TilE HCR OROUP, INC,
1601 H/lRKItT STREET
1800
PIlILADELPHIA PII tVIOl
(ll~l l46-0900
1JII:1I;' 1l1l)'.'J' "I) I'hft. (~(}:I.
>>) Ll)l:^tll)~ I. I 5J., <<<
PAGE,
HECl)Hllli H~~qUF.~:rJW
_..l,tle^" I Uti l!(\~W,
I WillH^NCE
HEli I l:^L
HWIl'AI.
IIlWIC^1.
HEt! I CAI.
tiEl> t CAI.
llTllf;H
UTIlEH
{HIIEH
'tIIAVF.I,I.f.R'li I NIiUHANo;r. ,;otWANY
CIINlIEH. RIcH, KEARNEY'
JAY CHO, H,IJ,
HOLY IH'lftl1' HUSPITAL
HEAL1'IlS0UTlI HEHAB, OF m:C1IAN I C
.lDIlN5 HOI'K I N5 ~IElJI eAI. GIWUR
tlAGIlHIC IHAlllNG CENTER
A,Z, R1TZI1AN A5SUC, INC,
IIOI.Y sPIRIT HOSPITAl.
llWl.U6l453 'lo70B-nn...
~t 01' l'lNeYLVMJA
Q;!!!!'Y (W <lI4IImILN<<>
,
ESTHER M. KOCH AND JOHN KOCIt
Fil. No.
91-2113
-VS-
KIIALJD II. ASIIAI AND SlJHAI RA ZAFFAR
1II11Ul1'W..~ TO PIKY1.... ntn~ ~_!!.ll~
"Of! Oll:trMrllY PUlSUAHT TO l\loLg ~!1'QI, n
TO. CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS WRI
MAGNI!TlC IMAGING CENTER
(NIITMt of PIt'lM){l or Ent 1ty)
Within t~ty (20) day. aft.r ...vlc. of this eubr>oena, YOU .... order-lid by the lXlU"t to
Pf'OC1Ice the following doc:unenta or thlll9ll __
SEE ATTACltED
at Tltl! MCS GROllP, INC., 1601 MARKET STREET, SUITE 800, l'ltI LAIJELPIIIA, PA 19103
(Ader...)
You nwy deliver or mati legible oopl.. of the doc:unent. 01" Pf'OIilce thlnga r~..ted hI
thia a~, togeth.. with the e..t iftcatl of oarpl lance, to the party IIlIk ing thh
r~st at the adlto..a Ilatad abov., You hay. the right to aeek In advl/'lCe the r.asonable
ClOst of preparlll9 the oopi.. ur prod.Jcill9 the thinga .ought,
I' you fall to Pf"O<Lce the docunants or thlnga requlrlld by this a~ within twenty
(20) days .ft.. Ita arvle., the party .rvlng this a~ may auk a lXlU"t order
CCI111IlIlng you to carp 1 y with it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT 1'IE REQU!ST a: TIe FOLLQVINQ PERSOHI
tWEl DONALD R. !lORER. ESrlUIRE
AOORESSI---114 SENATE DRIVE, SUll'!! 503
CAMP ItILL, I'A 17011 _'__
TELEPHONE l----ll 5-246-0900 ____________
61FR&I; CXllNtT 10 II
A TTllflNEy FOR I DE FENDANT
BY
,
d~ty
OATE1lf..V\ ( '7 (qq l.
. S I of tha Court
(Eff. 7/91)
10: X I...ANATION 01' IUo:()IIIlUo:U IUWOIWS
III: n'~IOIII,\N OIIlH(lltIl~ Hill
~1,\(iNI'11l' I~L\(iINIi IIN 1111
11111' 1I11 N III I IIC L\I'
~III 1I,\NIlSIII'IIC i, 1'/\ um,
111':: ,1II711H
ISIIII'11 ~I "II( II
11//11111\11 ~IIlII'1I ~114"I"I"II, 1I11,\lN Mill I'II~IS tll.'."1. l.~,"!. 11.'1""1
Suh.)..... : ESTlllm 1\1. I\lIC'1I
",IH I\ln;sli\l1 \'II.L\CiE. I\lIi( 'IIi\NIl'SIIIJIUl, 1',\ 1711!1l1
SUl'hll Sl'l'Ul'lh II: 171-14-lJZ,IH
IInh' It I' 1111'1 h: 111-11-1'1
:11111,111',/11 I,ll Ihn..l.f1 "
CKN'I'lt'It:^n
I'NKNt:'IIlIRI'I'I~ Tll i1KNYICI( III' ^ 111l81'llt;NA
l'IINIIIIAN1' TII HIII,t; 4 1111 ij ,17
IIIIIIE tlAlHN liI'l
l.UllNI' III' l:1I.IHolI ~I,"^"
1"I'III\N II. ,"I II I, 11)1111 KilCII
I'KUI, lIlItHI
,Y!I,
l.AIlE 11"1 '1/, Jill
W^1.I11 II, M,IIA I ~ SUIt^ I N^ Z^,,'t'^N
^a a Illltt'Hlut'ilf~ In "lJlvlt~ III it Nul'I"lfJlll till tllHlIIluflltlf anu IhlllMII I'tHljUli&..t
,,, N"l. 41l1l~,41
lieu "" h.hall III "pU.N.~L!!. ~:!~li~~Nl,L F,S'iIIINlL '...'
oI,o(","t.,,1 IMIIII .." 1111"
(l) ^ !tIlt il'" tlt IHt~1I1 III 41l1V" llit' qutll'lIPlI1l with II ropy III th., Buhpotfna
d"~IIH~d tlWH'Ill \0/8'1 IlI.1tl~lIl1t d,~llYl'lt'd III ,.[tlll 1IIIty,,' lpI'"
tWt'lIty d"y~ plltll tu Ih.. Ilat.. 1111 ~hilh 111t~ 'HIIIl'lIfll\., III ,wuaht tu lut
'WI Vf'd,
(2) ^ I lip'" of I lip nllt Ie It 111 Inllllll I IIHllldJI\M '1111 ptOIHJNltd '~Uhpll"I\.1 l~
AlIiSdH'llln IIu- 11l1,tllllll".
(11 II" "",..,Itll" III th.. Hul'IIiIM"A h.. h."" 'H."lv,,,1, .,,11
141 HIM """1"'."1 whllh wtll he '''lv"ll 10 1110"11'11 III the R"lll""UI whllh
II all.chell tll th" ,,"111'. lit 1,,10'11 tll OWIV" IlIe HUlll'''O''I,
lJA1'EI_ ~H'HgL
~().!JAblJ~~, JJOI\~"I,.lllq\illl,
AII"rnoy 'nr " "nl I"!.
liP. II lJl' 5 8 () 'Ill' fi n .. I . II n
GOMMONWt1;Al.'I'11 0.... PIl:NNHYI.VAN 1 A
COUNTY ul'" OIJMUltltl.ANO
III IIIK HATHk 0',
COURf 0' cU!1HUH PLIAB
f.STItU H, KULII & JoltN KOCIt
l'gkM, '1000
-Vi.
(;AU NO, V/.llll
KlfAI.fIJ It, ANItAI ~ 5U'1AIRA lAHAR
ttlll'l(;g 01' J"'rIHi'r ,1'9 tH~!t'lIULl!YI!fQlf1.a.'1'\LI'f\.QQYS;I_,~!mIm
I Nul. I UH '''1 I",o~ 1111 III 1"'"11\1'" I
TO, MICItAEL PYK05Kt, ESQUIRE
Mea IIn hoholl ,,' !~)I'l~LU.!i., lJ'2~~K, !~IIYIKl,.. 1"'01\01. I" ..'vo . IU"I'''.''"
l~ontl,,"1 III 'h. IIn. ,hit I. .1'., hOll '\I ,htl nlll Jr., VIIU h... 'wooty IlO)
~IYI Irllm Iho d~t. 11&'.11 "olow I" w"Io" 'il 111. \II ,o"'rd Ind "LVO UI'"n 'ho
illldHlII~1l811." i'''lollll1n 1\1 ,tw '\I'Ul'il8111, II "\I \lhlo,lllln II mid. Ih. IUUI'\I.UI
""Y h. ..,v.,1 1"110111111 '" ,h. ""pllrahle P.llUBylvl,,11 Rul.t III ctvll I'rm:ollll'.
4IJ09,l4, ellml'l.'. 1111'1.. \II OilY Ilfl'rudulod 'Olu,dl mlY IJ. u'dll'~ .t YI'ur
.'I'onu "Y "''"I''olIUII'''. o"o'hod 1'11'1\180111111 Ind ,o,u,ulnl '"011 III He' \I,
"Y ",urlnlllK \1'11 111,"1 Mca ,,1111.,
llAU, 4/l0/U8
Hel 011 h.h.1f of
_pg"b~P ~,~_ltq~1I1,
Attorn.y f'lnUINlllllf
ee, DONALD a, DORia, .IQUlal
'NGRlD LAnai
9/-0U
061I~H1UVIlU
Any '1uUllonl nlUIlI"1 thh m" '0', '''''IICI
THI Hel GROU', INe,
'la' HAR_IT ITRIIT
1100
'H1LADIL'H'A 'A ,'IOl
'2iS) HI.O'OO
IIJII/ ,Ofil4H ,.01" 8,- () O;.!,
~I Of' PJHm1,VAN~
axJNIY or <UlBI'JU.Nt)
ESTIIER H. KOCH AND JOliN KOCII
I
I
I
,
I
I
I
97~2m
.
File No,
~VS-
KIlAL1D II. ASllAl AND SUMAtllA ZAFFER
J:lIIllINONA TO pAmI nil DOC1.H!NTlI ~ 1lf I NI1\!I
FOR DlSOO\/ERY P\JISUANT TO fU-! 4001.22
TOI CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FORI A,Z. RITZMAN
(HIme of P"'aon or Entity)
Within tW*lty (20) days aft.,. ..,.vice of thi. .Ibpoena, you ar. ordered by the OOU"t to
PI"O<1Ice the following cIocutwlts or thing.. _
SEE ATTACHED _
at TilE HC~ GROUP, tNC" 1601 MARKET STREET, SUITE 800, PHILA!lELI'HIA, PA 19103
CAdera..)
You ~y deliver or IIlIII I legible copl.. of the docunenta or PI"OdJce things requllte<t h)
thl. .li:lpoena, togeth.,. with the certificate of CXIllIllance, to the party making thh
request at the ader... II.ted above. You have the ri9ht to .eek In advance the r.aaonabl.
cost of preparing the ClOPles or proc1jclng the things .ought.
If you fall to PI"O<1Ic:e the docunents or things required by this .~.. within twenty
(20) daya aft.,. Ita ...v Ice , t.ha party .erv Ing this .lbpoena ~y .eek . OOU"t ordr
CQTpe II Ing you to CXJ11l1 V with It.
nilS SUlPOENA WU ISSUED AT llE RE<U:ST OF lle FQ.LQl/11<<1 PERSONI
lWEI !lONALD R. !lORER, ESQUIRE
AOORESSI--t14 SENATE DRIVE, SUITE 50)
CAMP HILL. PA 17011
TELEPIOlE I 215-246-0900
6l"Ra1! cnJlT 10 II
ATTORNEY FOOl DEFIlNDANT
CATEI A. ,~I ..,. (f1!
~ Court
(Ef(. 1/97)
l: 1\ liT I I' I l:^n:
l'III1I1.:llllIHI't'l'. Tn HliltVll:1I III' ^ 1I11IlI'm:Hh
1'1l1l1l1lhH'r 'I'll ItIIl,lI ',11119, n
IN I'll.: H^THR il" I
':1111111' 01' ':I)HHON I'LI\AS
EHII.:II .1. KIl<:1I ~ JIHIU Kllell
'\'KilN. UIlIIII
. V~i-
I:^~f, Uu, ql-n 1\
KII^L III II, ^:.tIA 1 ~ BUllA I RA I.AI'I'^H
A!i il pltJIPflUl'II11' 10 IU.1lvil'f! III .. HuhpOllltR 11Il dllrtllllf'lIt~ 111\1t thil1MI IIUI'YUlIllt
Iu lIul" 4011q,U
IIe5 UII II"hllll ilII!UUt'!!,!J, H',J)(III~R"EII'I~IR~,
01,,1 "Iillolll 'If II It I,," Ihal
(1) ^ 11111 inl tll Ill' *"1l1 III '11'1 VP lllll '11I"I'IIlIIlM \<11 t h i1 11lllY tll t hI' ",,11(10"111'
:'\I'adlllll t1uHH11I WHlI UI;lll...d III dl'llvt'lttd III p.lth p""y l\t It'dltt
l\lIpnl y dAY~ I'rllll" t II I lit' tilt' (I II" ,,,h II h I ht. '4llhI'OPIUI i.. !llIUt\hl 10 h..
..PIVl'dl
(2) ^ ['III'Y lit tl... 11111"" III Inl"III, 111I 11101 111M Ihl! 1'1111'"."01 'I""I'U"II., I.
IHlll.lwd 10 Illl. nlltlf Illlt...,
(J) No uhtfnttlltl tll tlw '1\1hpl'~IHI Itftli IJP.PII l"IIfI~I'dl lIllll
(',) 'fIll' '1""I'""n. whirh wi II "" "IllV,,<1 1. I<llfnl I. lit I II Ih. ',"hl'""n. wh I..h
i'l "ttALhll,1 t,u thp Ulllltl' lit lntt1t\l tll HttlVt-t lllU ulIlil'"l!lI..
D^Tf.'_~I.2lU ')S_
!!l)Il~~P'. R, 1)l)~~I~", ~LIW! Rlt,
^lIl1lnHY Ill' d.tHnJ.IlI
IiFII,III"'lHI I'll'" 6 n.. 1.11'.1
CQ.HureMll'll or m-mvlNANL\
...--
CXl.IHl'V UP <1.t4IImUANl
I r
ESTIIER M. KOCII AND JOliN KOCII I
I
-VS- I File No. 91-2113
I
I
KIIAt.1lJ Il. AStlAl AND Sl1HAIRA ZAHER I
liUIlI"OfHA TO PIIml nr DOCJ tfHrl at lliJlQI
Fat DI__DV PLRIllIANT 'filM-I "OO..~a
101 CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FORI
ItOt.y SI'IRl1' ItOSI'ITAI,
(Nne 0' P.,.son or Entity)
Within tWVIty (:to) dlYS eft... '..vlc::e 0' this 'LAlpoena, you are ordered by tht OOLrt to
Pf'OC1Ic. the 'ollowlng dooun.nt, or thing" ____
SEE ATTACIIED
at iltE MCS GROUP, INe.,1 bOI MARKET STREET, SUITE 800, PIIILADLEPIHA, PI. 19101
(Adlt'e..)
You may dallv.,. or mall Iltlllbl. copl.. 0' the doc:uTtInts or ~ thing, rt/J.I..te<l hI
this ,~, toQeth.,. with th. c..tl'IClte 0' OO1pllanca, to the party ",.Idng thlt
request It the ader... listed above. 'You hive the rillht to ,Nk In advanc. the r'..onabl,
c:ost 0' preparing the copl.. or Pf"O<1Jc1nv the thlnga 'ought.
It you fill to Pl"o<Lce the docun.lnte or things rltqUl,.ed by this ,~ within tWlllty
(20) diy, 1ft.. it, '..vice, the party ,..vlng this alJlpoena may aMII . QDu-t Of'der
tlCITPIlIl ng yOU to oarp I y wi th j t .
THIS liUSPOENA WAS ISSU!D AT llll RE<:U:ST OF llt! I'OllCMINCl P!RIOOI
NN'IlI DONAl.l) R. DORER, Y.SllUIRP;
- --.------
AOOftES$1 214 SENATE DRIVE, SUITE SOl
-- .. -~-.~_.'c".~_"_..
...J:AMI' .!!!!:t., _1'1. 1 !~ ~l",_ '" ,_ __
TELEPIUlI!, 21S-246-0900
~-.....""' -~-~"""'''~'..--.._-~
6ll'Rf.I1! nun 10 II
--~--""~'-----" -
ATTOflNt!y FOR, IJU'ENDANT
----
DATE I AlIJt 1_3..:.... ((jet
P"N1of th, ~~
Ivl,"lon--
Oeput y
(I!ff, 7/91)
~ /{16~
E.nIlR M. KoclI ANn JUlIN KOCII,
Pl.AIN1'lvt'ft
IN '0.. COlIMT Ur COM~N .....41
(:lIMuaUNU COllN1'V, I'ItNNIVLVAN'"
Nil. '7-1113
VII.
HUl\tAlllA ZAVI'AIl, J)Ht'KNIIAN'"
('1\'11, AnlllN - LAW
JIIMV 'I'MI"" UMtANUl!1I
,
..RAJ((:II'I( l'U HE11....(, H.liCUNTlNlIK ANI> ENI>
TO niB I'ROnIONOTARY:
l'leaao mark 1M ahove-captloned caao ""1\141, dilwnllllued and ended,
BY:') /fY~(ILt(" ___
Mlchsel J, 1')'~llW, I!ftlU
(Jaw Oflke. or darrell" lJelhlef.
3BO' Ma.bl SIn.~1
Camp lUll, 1''\ 11011
Alloroe)' I.IU ~1I8' I
AIIOI1lIl)' fur 1'llIllIlIIh
Oal.: :5/~JqK
",\
......