HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-02712
~
o
~
.
'"
7
~
IIJ
e
]
]
,,11/
d
c
v
~
~
~
-
J
~
-
r
(l)
,
6-
,
,
,
I
,
I
I
I
\
~
\
I
~.
/
I
I
I
!
I
>- In >-
lr:
." '.~:
I"' " ;
l1J(~ j .<
()- .
p:L' '.....: "
,
~r; ..;.: ,"
f ! ".. ~
Ii'" c:' t,')
,"
L.:'" , 1,.',1
.', ...
,d , ~<~.~
.'
,.. ,- ,
u ..'
u' (.)
J~.)
~~,'
~:~;
.<. i/l
~:2 .'
~~1. j'
:. (
r-'~ ~ K
~~~ .
Sin. ~ .
~~~~
i :
: :
III
Z
o
f-o z 0
!/l 2 S
~ ~ t- t:
dlf:5~~
: 8 ~ ~ :=
:;.. ... III I6J ~
.~ n 8-
_Qz-=
< III II: Cl: :.:
..J III 0 CD =
~ t: .., ~
:J ~ <C :; 8
z ~ )
~ i
!/l
>- .:r f:-;
cr;
r::.: ~
lUr-' .. ?:-;;
<'-I
0" -~~~;
G:'_:' :..:=
-", "
It-r. cc. ..,
)>,- ~ :--i
Cll_ . ....0
UP ('...' ):.;;
lI!' >- ."lid
.J- 010:-:
,. ,- 'Ll.
<'"
t,. r- .~
0 0'\ (.)
\
IUBlllfljO Blnleu6,s
1'h-
l~
.\\
~~
~\h
~
~F(
~ ~
'\
~~
.-. ,
'-61
uo SB/!d1l8 UOISlIWWO:) Arf
,":)1/1010 '1'11
ilfJPUI '''''''-'t''IIP WO~.. 'IOjaq 1."1110 10 .Jrl/pull,S
-61 ' ~O AVO SIHl
31'1 3UOnS 03SIUOSSnS ONV (03I'1UI~~V) NUOMS
'01a,a4 pa4~BIl' Id!a~oJ s,.apuos 'pBW
(pa.olsI601) (pall!lJo~) Aq 0 a~!^,as IBuosJOd Aq 0 -61 ' uo pa"OJppB SBM oloU 04\
W04MOI (./Mlloddea41 uodo IBeddv 10e~!IoN O^oqe04\6wAucdwoOJe IUIBldu,o:) c ap~ OI"IOU Oul pO^Jes IIe41 JOulJnI pue 0
010Ja4 pa4~Blleldla~al S,Japuas 'I,ew (paJOISI6a.) (pal/Ill") Aq 0 a~I^Jas lOuos.ad ,Iq 0--61 .
uo ' (oweu) 'oalladdu 041 uodn PUB '010194 pa40BIle Id!a~a.
S,Japuas 'pew (pa.aIS!6aJ) (pall!lla~) Aq 0 9"^JaS leuOSlad Aq 0 .' '-:--61' , . (9~/M9S 10 91Bp)
uo UlOJa41 paleu6!sap a~lIsor I~I'ISIO a41 uodn ' '~N scald uowwoO 'Ieadd", 10 O~1l0N 04110 Ado~ e 0
.
pO^Jas 11041 wJllle.o .eaMS Aqa.a41. :.1I^VOI:f:Hf
II:
~o HNnO:>
(S9.0q 8/Q.,,/dde P84:) 'Ieoddu 10 O~IIOU Oul (j1l'JII IHilV SA va (011 N3i N/Hl/M aill~ 3fJ iSnn 80IM85 10 loo.d Slul)
YINY^'ASNN3d ~O HJ.1Y3MNOI'lI'l0:l
.1NIV1dWOO 311:f 0.1 31m~ ON" W3ddV :f0 301.l0N :f0 301^~3S :f0 :fOO~d
09-1-01
NOTICE OF JUDGMENTrrRANSCRIPT
CIVIL CASE
PUlINTIFF: "'ME... AOOIlE08
~ABENA'S WARDROBE SERVICE
THEODORE RABENA
418 BRIDGE STREET
~EW CUMBERLAND, PA 17070
DEFENDANT' VS.
r.; . IWoIE'" AOOOEBS
MOSEL, RAYMOND R.
803 ROSEMONT AVENUE
NEW CUMBERLAND, PA 17070
L
Docket No,: CV-0000123-97
Date Filed: 3/19/97
'COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF: CUMBERLAND
.... 0l0I."'.:
OJ NIIN; Horl
CHARLES A. CLEMENT, JR.
Add_: 1106 CARLISLE ROAD
CAMP HILL, PA
T~:nI71761-4940 17011
RAYMOND R. MOSEL
803 ROSEMONT AVENUE
NEW CUMBERLAND, PA 17070
THIS IS TO NOTiFY YOU THAT:
Judgm(lnt:
[!] Judgment was entered lor: (Name)
[!] Judgment was entered against: (Name)
FOR PLAINTIFF'
RABENA'S WARDROBE SERVICE
MOSEL. RAYMOND R.
In the amount 01 $
7 ,471 ~c; on:
(Date of Judgment)
(Date & Time)
4177'Q7
o Damages will be assessed on:
o This case dismissed without prejudice.
Amount 01 Judgment $
Judgment Costs $
Interest on Judgment $
Attorney Fees $
7 .311.65
110.00
.00
.00
TOTAL
$
7 .421.65
o Levy III stayed lor_days or 0 generally stayed.
o Objection to levy has been flied and hearing will be held:
Date:
Place:
Time:
ANY PARTY HAS THE RIGHT TO APPEAL WITHIN 30 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BY FlUNG A NonCE
OF APPEAL WITH THE PROTHONOTARY/CLERK OF COURTS OF THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION.
YOU MUST INCLUDE A C Y F THIS NonCE JU jMENTfTRAN R. ~...FORM W~:~UfI NonCE OF APPEAL.
/._'I')_Q7 Date ~QJV ? '7 '..' ,.DistrictJustlce
,.
My commission expires first Monday of January, 2002 .
AOPC315-96
PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT
(This pro\")( of surv/cu MUS T 8E Fll.[D \\0'/ THIN TEN" '0; DA YS AFTER fllmg tfltJ T}(Jt,co 01 appoal ChoCA ap1Jficdblu bOAO$)
COMMONWEAL TH OF PENNSYLVANIA A
COUNTY OF -C-l.l-""l_b_~~Lt:i_~U;l_____ : II
AFFI DA VIT: I hefeby swear or alflrm that I sor~cd
[J a copy of ttw NOllce of APPPill. Common Pleas No 9_7~~_7..C~~_. . upon lt~ Di~lrjct Justice designated therein on
(data 01 sOrIlICO) -11JE..~_3._a_, 19:1_1_. 0 by pl'r~;ofl.lr ')PfvtCn ~bY (cerllfled) (reglsIOred) m:lll, sender's
receipt attached hereto, nfHi upon thp (Ippelll:"f', rn,rmp} ______._~_.__ _..___ ,on
___,19_---0 by pcr..,{in~l! 5;_'r.'ice C bl' tC.....,:tll~.'{fi (rpglsh'rCd) mad, sonder'& receipt attached hereto
o .1nd further Ihiltl ser\rro tile Ruh' to F .1(. a Ct.rllpj'!'~ll dce' Ifrlp;ln,'lng !t~.: <tb("~'t~ Noti(,(> 01 APP('J,1 upon HWIlPpellcch) IO'Nhom
thco Rule \.vas addrt:'<"Sl'rl on __.___.________~_ __ ~..___._ 1~L._.,. ,[] 11,' rerson;ll SN'wlr.e 0 h}' (certified) (H~9Istcrr.d)
milrl. sender's rrcclpl atfilcl1ed h!}qHO
SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME
THIS _3(j~DAV OF_(!7~y____ . 19_9_1
-~ ~-~._-
S'f#n"lLj'e t.l' (J'I.~',Jll_flfO'f1 ...~o'" "~r',J.h,t \tli) /';,h1l<
''''.0101/",., Mo f-a.. ~
'/.Li._, 19~.'
~~~~
S'(}fliJtulU 01 aft/am
My (.ommlSSlon CJlpUes on
Notarial SIal
Laurle L. Tennant. Notary Public
Hampden Twp.. Cumbectand County
MV Commission Expires March 13 ?f'~~J
ember Pennsylvanla AssocIalton 01 NOlafles
P 42', 184 'I 4 8
c . .n : )
_., . ,
-
'.. -q
L' ; ',..
:,..) ,:"
~., 'C)
,(I)
.-, '",
1:1)
-.e)
::'~" _.)'-'1
1
.....:-- .,
.. "
us rL'~t.11 S~h-Ile
Receipt for Certified Mail
r~o In~UrJnr:(l Ccver.lge ProvIded
Oll nol U~\.l 'm t/lll'm.llton.ll Mail /Sj'~ feVt'fSjl)
s.'flll.) I
_Rd&:NA" l\"A'{Og,
Sl't"~,\ r";lT100f
O(l~1Jk S,
Ff)~1 Cillr" 51,11t< 'liP COljft
N,d.'.>"A"i!lt'r.; Po
ro~td~ S
C~ttlt.~Fe'"
1'0
~a31Cel'I'l'f,;fee
R(!~'nclM(h<h"ryFI'"
on
~ n....lurr.V.f'tl i.d;c1rJ
_ \"";;t'f~ V.r>>ClO:'~~i....lt:[
~ A~~'/~~rsn...t'i;"t..:.."
ot. ::," 'Af.t...... "-J.."'tf.. "
g 'OfAn\"r~l'Il i ~I"-,
IX)
M P,,"T"l..l1..flo"'l..I.'''. "
f
o
"
if;
"I
_J..!-L [\
I
J.-(\
pay for the dry cleaning, less a 35% discount, and, finally, Defendant
would deliver the cleaned items back to his customers on Route #2.
5. On or about January I, 1996, Plaintiff began to perform the
services as described in paragraph 4 above, and continued to perform
them in a workmanlike manner through and until the end of March, 1996,
until it became apparent that Defendant was not only not paying for
services rendered, but switched to a different wholesaler, without
notifying the Plaintiff.
6. Plaintiff's records presently show no monies were received
from January I, 1996, through March, 1996. A copy of the Plaintiff's
records are attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit
tlAft.
7. On May 28, 1996, Defendant submitted a check for $2,000.00 to
Plaintiff; this check was returned for insufficient funds on July 5,
1996. A copy of the returned check and notice is attached hereto,
made a part hereof and marked Exhibit"B".
8. The amount owed for January, 1996, is $3,391.04, less a 35%,
the amount owed for February, 1996, is $3,660.48, less a 35% discount,
and the amount owed for March, 1996, is $3,705.82, less a 35% dis-
count. The total owed from January through March, 1996, giving the
35% discount is $6,992.27. Plaintiff has added 1.5% interest to each
month's past due bill, making the current total amount owed $7,311.65.
9. Plaintiff filed a complaint on March 19, 1997, before Dis-
trict Justice Charles A. Clement, Jr., demanding judgment in the
-2-
NAM;--;? Itt; /11().j't t.
ADDRESS xr-I,'1 l1/)t$ fY7tlll/ 1It1~
/l/tlwi 111~/tfl./l!l17 f;? I~()~~T
FI" TING
CITY
DATE
REFERENCE
CHARon
r
CREDITS
BALANCE 'ORWARD
.. I
14'-0'
Acel I
~.i !
;
NO
CREDIT
LIMIT I,
r BALANCE (.
<t-?
I
..
/,
,
.:
t
.
,
L
,
\,
...""Dl"'''. ..
. .OLLOWU,.
OLoa.T ITa..
..
"'~.
"
NAME
ACCT.
f.~n ~
NO,
'. ADDRESS
: CITY
CRlDIT
RATING
CREDIT
I.IMIT
-
DATE fU'EftIENCI CHARGE' r CRIDIT. r BALANCE
BALANCE 'DftWAftD
/. ~. 91 -
~~N'I:'._. ~Af-_._, .- ~ . .. ..... -
... ~ 1t~'1IIVt1) ,
._~~IIL [11#41 -
. . ~ 1!ff-r..! (I.
__,e{(!t!~~I'(". Np
, .Arf{IiJM,
, . Nt. t.-'AJ 6"iNi J."t;1(t
(c~!J1i Alii,)) I' f
A ,rrJfi..l!Pt.JJfJ-'''(fJA~ __.
JUrJlt ~ 19~t. .
/ tr' :tl fJ 'f ~r ,
k-& I _ f"/$N
t.N lOti-I( ~G-~ <J,r' -,
.-
a.N . In. ';J ::t t, lif <l/7
wHIt. CAlM 1ft'
1'1J ~ iJ~b ~~ ~RrM
~/~ trJr, 7N~
1 i:.1I~~ 4J M AI1
~O()P, ()~ . -~.~--_...
.. .
. .------..----.---.-..,.. , " . , -
".'"'1101''''' ..
i
I
\
}
,
:::,~7:GC:lY
D ~'.'Cd:AN
:'.ri~~U :lY
7A::..JRIN
:7::1:1C:::
~~::=/M
TCTriL~
~:'~.~..,. ~..~l:
'.
,
"
"
... . .~ ' ..,
..... ;',
,'., I 'f,'
:A:"':S ';Ct.HlNAL
.:::,';c~:r:':= ::~~ ~:.'C:/,)~ 07: 13 PM
~::1 7:1r: ~:::\:::: ::'':,':1/')6 TO 0~/2C)/f)6
:7~~7 r:MC c~ C END TIM~ 24; 0
:::.~r:';;~r/: CTCRC 2
...'......'\1
1......1'1....
:11':'.~:~ GUMMArlY
..........,---
1 .""t,.... , ....
.,..,..,-~. ~,.- -......
IWln... rll,'. 1(1" ..
TAX 2 PIl::CES
UPC
CISC:~NT~
"'''''lr-r''lotr''''
W04II.I,.....,.'1....
.,
~.r,(jc:= 45
. . ,- . ..-- ----_.~.~---_... --- ~.. - - ..~-_._.. .-- ... - -- -. ...
.~ . ~')C~. :)- .... 0" .00 484 '3&. 05 .00 .C~
.. ",., oJ .........-
....,...a ',' ...,.... .~ ~ ."","!\I .00 un .00 .00 .CIJ
..:;.~'"\ ..... ",,\jw . io'~'
"., ",.,. C'" .00 0 .00 . ~0 M'
. ........ . ... . "",.
,.,. .~'Z ,...... .00 0 .\':I~ 0" ........
.. . v,,", . '" ."'..
,.,. .CC . ~0 .00. 0 .00 .00 . ~0
'V
. ..
'.-.--_. . -,..-... --- ------ ------------.----..-...... .--- ...... . - . , -
4n~ :C,C,C.4J .... ~- .00 1&5& '3&.05 .00 .eo
~. ......
CAT::cOny T::JT:~:": :t:C:"'~D:: :iAL:::S TAX
:;:;T=G{Jn'/
DRYCLl::m~
LAurmnv
TA:LO~IN
STOI1AC~:
~!~C/~
\
...'1....",..,........
n~_I\I'I.I~ \
.,
,
,
I
)
r:c.;=:~'-': ~71-;TIG7[C: - T;;;~ NOT INCLUDED
"'-'1 ......,..,.._
Ih...". ". .L..'-a....
r'l"'" ,_",....,__
1\_". , . .\OOlu....1
PI l::Cl::/TICI{CT
U~.S;:
,_._.... _.. . - _n_.. _...~__ ._.... .... _ ___ ~_._________________.~___________
4.~C
1~. 1') 2.4<:1 4.0
~.37 4.0') .0
,.,.... .00 .0
...."'.
.....,. .00 .0
. .~
~,~ .00 ,.,.
.......... .'V
1.43
n.~
...."
.ce:
.~"
...."'.
... -,,~
............'
.., .a"
,.10.'....
3.45
2.!J
.3 '~()t if
/~J](, 17
\3'79. ;5 k
),"J.o't, I
.../3 fJ1
~~. o~
{L.()I//)'
." c. ~ J{I
J..~ll
f1.1& 'f f,
tA /{I ",/J6 ~N
'7
J /J'~ ~L.-::1
W {. r~ {-IJ
~ a/tfJ1r1t.. FA
(,J i ~ rt1 A J.., p.. T
. ra'(
((IJ-'~ I~,
gt.
P fl r(
Run D~tu: 04/0t/,)6
Time: 00:00.:\
Salus JI)l.,t'I1,i11
Fer the Period: 03/01/9& to 03/31/9&
Str: 2 RABENA'S WARDROBE SERVICE-RORY
Tot.:\l Sales Summary
Paye: 4',
St ,we Sales S...'mmat..v
Discs/ Cash,'
Catuyo;", UT ii, $ Total Aii1t Tc.\x t /2 IlPcs Upc:lwgs Til, Chg Coupcns AIR Cllg
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------
DR'!C:.J:::AN 1')5 l')f)~. 32 . [.2 1.<)3 111.85 .00 .00 47.')5
.00 .00 19'1'1.37
LAUNDR',' :l ;2GE. 171.3.50 .00 1103 .00 .00 .00 61.15
.00 .00 1&52.35
TAILOr1It~ 0 .00 .00 0 .00 .00 .00 .00
.00 .00 .00
STORAGE 0 .00 .00 0 .130 .00 .130 .00
.00 .00 .00
MISC/M 0 .00 .00 0 .130 .00 .00 .00
.00 .00 .00
---- ._--- ...--------- - -------------- ---- --- ---------------------------------------
Totals
4(,1
3705.82
.42 1&7&
.00
111 . 85
,00
.00 109.10
.00 351)6.72.
Categol', Totals Incl'Jde Salas Tax
Revenue Statistics - Tax Not Included
Cat e 9 OI'Y
Rev./Piece
Rev. /Ticl,et
Pieces/Ticl,et
Upsl'-
---------------------------------------------------------------------
DRVCLEAN 4.0'1 10.21 2.52 5.6
LAUNDRYiI 1. '14 6.4'1 4.44 .0
TIHLOR!N .130 .00 .00 .0
STORAGE .00 .013 .00 .0
MISC/:--~ .00 .00 .00 .0
---------------------------------------------------------------------
A 'Jill'., !; e
.=- .~,
..........""
8.0.3
3. (,3
1118.5
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Theodorc Rubena, et.al.
Plaintiff
v.
No. 1997.2712
Civil Term
Raymond R. Mosel
Defendant
ANSWER AND NEW MAnER
Comes the Defendant, Raymond R. Mosel, individually and as Ray's Cleaning
and Maintenance Service and sets forth following Answer and New Matter to Plaintiffs
Complaint:
1-3. Admitted.
4-5. Admitted and denied as follows:
Admitted Defendant entered into an oral agreement with Plaintiff. Denied that
said agreement was as set forth in the Complaint. To the contrary, the original
agrecment was that Rubena told Mosel that he could go for several months
without paying the dry cleaning bill in order to build up cash for Mosel's business,
Rabena subsequently sold his establishment to a Mr. Balaban who reneged onlhe
delayed payment agreement. Mosel then took his business else\\'her~.
Subsequently. Rabena took his business back from Balaban. At that point Rabena
stated he would forgive all past debts owed by Mosel if he would bring his ury
cleaning business back to Rabena. Mosel did return his dry cleaning business 10
Rabena and the debts owed by Mosel were thercfore forgivcn.
6. Admitted that no money was receivcd, although denied that any monc) I\;IS
due. As stated above, the debt was forgiven.
... o.Ll ~
Cr; \I".
.....
,- ~ -><<.
. (~, 13~
"-"'..
, " .- \ .,.-t
,,;.r ,'-
\.' u.. {~?j
'.~:' t .4"_
.~, t". ,n .,;.fn
," :?
~:-\I , \ ..1'
n:::Z
t,.} HHU
.. uJ (iH)..
c: ~
p. 0 ?
c:- o u
.'
0-
f "
...
,-
I
',' , ;
. , "
, "
( ~ ~-)
f~':t IJ
'0 '0
CfiI C
"U .. iii
;:S ....
-> - <Il
"'~ >000: >0 I-
....fi1 .... ell
i;l> ....'" .... .... 0
.-l >l .. .. lo: z ..
:lfil :l 0 0
"'''' 'OlQ '0'" ~ ell ~ n !::
sa ....0 .... .... - .
- . <
Z >00:..... >'-' C fiI tIl ~ ..
0 fiI ....~..... 'OZ .. !-< . .. ~ .
S! '" '0 .... C.... -'0 ell 0 < ~
C .... ....~Wc: ,., u
0 . ....~C U Q) .... ~ := ~ OIl .. 3
U ~ .... ... H.... > ..: . ~ 8 '"
ell z
- '" .. >,.,,., > Q) .... ,., ;. 0 Z ir w
'" Z ..:: .... WtJ~Q U ~ ~ m =
0 ::> z":,,, CIl fiI I < ~
0 filZ OCllCll N ~ w l:" >:
. - "
l;; U lQfiI ;.:- - Z < 0 < .. "
~~ :><fiI "- 0 ....l .
. ~
~! ,,;~~ N .... . "
I !-< l.i
~ .. "- U ~,
""..z '" ..: :t.
0..... Z.....fiI '" 0
i5fi1 "".0 o.ot;: - ,., I-
0..... .... tIl
z~ "''0 ~:a.... . >
i5::; ~::;~ 0 ....
....u Z U
,.
, .
correctly and statutorily within the time period of four years after
the Complaint was properly reinstated by the Prothonotary of the Court
of Common Pleas in Cumberland County on November 7, 2000. Service of
Process was effectuated by the Sheriff's Department of cumberland
County on the Defendant on November 14, 2000.
By way of further answer, District Justice Clement entered
judgment in the amount of $7,421.65, which included court costs,
against the Defendant on April 22, 1997. Defendant filed his Notice of
Appeal from the District Justice Judgment on May 21, 1997. Plaintiff
filed his Complaint in the Cumberland County Court of Common Pleas on
June 1B, 1997, and served the Defendant via First Class u.S. mail on
that same day. The Complaint was properly reinstated by the
Prothonotary of the Court of Common Pleas in Cumberland County on
November 7, 2000. Service of Process was by the Cumberland County
Sheriff's department as evidenced by the attached Sheriff's return was
made on November 14, 2000. 42 Pa.C.S.A. ~5525(5) in pertinent part
provides that [a]n action upon a judgment or decree of any court of the
United States . . .must be commenced within four years. Therefore, the
Complaint was filed within the statutory time period prior to the
Statute of Limitations tolling since judgment was entered on May 21,
1997. (See Sheriff's Return marked as exhibit "A", attached hereto and
made a part hereof).
-2-
15. Denied. Averment presents a conclusion of law to which no
responsive pleading is required. If an answer is required, it is
specifically denied that the Defendant has met his burden of Accord and
Satisfaction. Plaintiff at no time ever forgave the debt that is owed
to him by the Defendant and strict proof is demanded at time of trial.
16. Denied. It is specifically denied that the Plaintiff failed
to properly revive the complaint and that service was improperly made.
The Complaint was properly reinstated by the Prothonotary of the Court
of Common Pleas in Cumberland County on November 7, 2000. Service of
Process was effectuated upon the Defendant by Richard Smith of the
Sheriff's Department of Cumberland County on November 14, 2000. Both
service of process and the reinstated Complaint were within the Statute
of Limitations time period of four years since entry of judgment.
17. Denied. It is specifically denied that the Plaintiff failed
to timely file his complaint and it is specifically denied that
Plaintiff is time-barred from this proceeding. 42 Pa.C.S.A ~ss2s
et.seq. specifically states that the Statute of Limitations is four
years for a action and/or claim of this nature. By way of further
answer, see Plaintiff's answers to Paragraph U14-16 above in their
entirety.
-3-