Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-03126 ~ \. ~ ~ ~ ~ 'it ~ ~ '- < o - " \f) ..... .~ ... ~ - I'f') . t"- ~ ~ 1 . ~ t,., , 1 l ., ) j : -~ ., o "~' , '~ . '~ :'l .;1 i / ..., C~: s ~ - .~~ C" \\ C's B s: ~ ~ Q~ co ~~ - u.1 -I if ~ 3 ~ ~ ~ i III t ~ = ~ ~ i g ~ = 10 ... C Z IJ III ~ ~ rd III z . . ii . a: .. = - ... 0 a: .... .. t: ~ II - ~ < . III III ~. ~ ~ ; .. . DONALD SOLONINKA, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA NO. 97-3126 CIVIL ACTION vs. DICK MURRAY Defendant ANSWER 1. The averments contained in paragraph 1 of the Complaint are denied and on the contrary, it is averred that the Plaintiff, on July 12, 1995, entered into a Purchase Agreement for the purchase of seven (7) windows. A copy of that Agreement is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit "A". 2. It is further alleged that on August 24, 1992, a Grace Mickey entered into an Agreement concerning seven (7) windows and a copy of that Agreement is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit "B". 3. It is denied that the windows will not now lock and it is denied that there presently exists bows in the sachs. 4. It is admitted that a window was broken although it is not known when the window was broken. However, the broken window has been replaced by Defendant. 5. It is admitted that the Plaintiff filed suit against the Defendant before District Justice Charles A. Clement, Jr. and it is admitted that a Judgment was entered against the Defendant on May 1S, 1997. I 6. The averments contained in paragraph 4 are denied and specifically the Defendant denies that he called the District Justice in question. On the contrary Defendant alleges that all of the windows in question have been repaired. 7. The averments contained in paragraph S are exclusively within the knowledge of the Plaintiff and hence they are denied and proof is demanded at trial. 8. The averments contained in paragraph 6 are denied as stated although it is admitted that a Judgment was entered against the Defendant and in favor of the Plaintiff in the amount of $3,318.S0. It is admitted that a second Hearing took place and it is admitted that the Defendant did not attend that Hearing. Additionally, the Defendant avers that he did not receive notice of that Hearing. 9. The Defendant is at a loss to understand the averments contained in paragraph 7; the Defendant never heard of Keystone Windows System and does not know whether they are in business or out of business. The Defendant, on both of these situations, sold and caused to be installed Cavco Energy Saver windows and it is further alleged that Defendant repaired or caused to be repaired all windows in question. WHEREFORE, Defendant requests judgment in his favor. " ( -=-- -~ '- --..'';: Harry L. ricker, - Jr.._Esq Attorney for-Defendant--"":> 407 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 (717) 233 - 2555 Attorney I.D. No. 07049 ~ WINDQWS, AND qOORS OUTLET 4300 New Hampshire Drive Harrisburg, P.A 17112 (717) 545-4540 . 11(800) 479-0509 " I PURCHASE AGREEMENT I ,PHONE . 7.J V f ")).f'.LJ ,:BUSINESS PHONE '1/ "L,' -., . c c:... DATE h A 7, /":J , ~\.... ....... oa'LOCA!~i~. 1:""""'';' "0:',' .. '........ .' l - "."'i . . .. I i . t,', ":,,'r:~::., "",.,.~ I. . GRIDS 't' r-., ,. ~,,(/~..c .... lOW E FROSTED FUll CAPPING BLIND STOP CAPPING .l/-P ,'. I, , , " , ; ;'! .' " '" .. .4 I; \. I, /. " .. <. . I ,.....L . -. I ~I .!.,. ..~ ',.. f - . J dr./ .6.--, , , .' .' ,J WE PROPOSE hereby 10 furnish material and labor. campllteln accordance wilh above specifications, lor IhI lum of: , - /.',,~) /.,. ~. .~. I! ,/..; , ;(j.' ..... if''':'-' vL...' . -t' .;'~~~/i!/~~- . ~1"", / r......... . ':i ..' ~',j,/ //..itJ':!. r--. ,.".:....,........~ .- Paymentlo~,mad~, 1011<,,/0: / :11/ _' ", I ' .; \.~?...~.. L-- 0/. ((."fJt) 0 0 " . .-) I . ~ ''-2 ' " I ./'.-; tJ /L. / ../ I,:\-.I) ,~ ~ ~(;"",)..::>. (70 r-v ,'(.J~,r-. ~/ .,,:~<S7lY//f'J7U/' AIIMI.rW and WOl'krnanahlp gu anlMd 10 tM.. ed. \.,;" d";lal';;;;' ~ ~1C~lbn' ~YCW~ ..". emll wII '- COfTl'I.'ed ontr upon wnn.n or.. and wll bIcome an .'lr. dtarge 0'1" .nd IlboYe 1"- eO'.mlnt. s..., lhaIl not ~ IabIe lor an, dele" caUMd by wat, tIoC. IlrlkeI,.ct1 01 Gcd, 01 oth.r ceUIIlI beyond III con1tOl I77Y7 ~;/158..t-f -'" . !,l,{, You mar canc.lthileorM""rt 01 purch". br 1NI11ng. wrItIen nolle. to the ..1.' poIllNarked not Ie'.' 1,,-" ttidnlghl on It.lhlrd tulln... der aII.r th. d.l. of Ihlt .grMmlnl. You INY UI.lhll peg. ..It\:!.ll1O(lce by wrillng"1 hllwre.ne.r atth.bonom.nd.ddlogyour n.mI.ncfedcfr.... ThilnatlOlmuAbemaledbWlNOOWS AND ooons OUnET, UOONewHJlIt1:lIh".Or~.. Halrltburv. PA 17112. :~~:' _!1d~~ A'li#:17 Nola: Thill proponI"'Y be 7 wfthd,awnbyut" not acc:eplldwthln ......,.,. "" ACCEPTANCE OF AGREEMENT Th. abcMI prato ,,*'lcallont and cond.lont .r. Ulillaclary ard at. ..,ebt lIClC:epted. You at. aU'ltooflZed 10 do Ih.Mrir. at apec'led. Payment wf1 be mad... ovtlned abov.., . .?/:~ ,f; ,,; O,'\l.olnl"O'lPlllnoe.:~ _.~._~_ _ _ ___.._____4 ' ._' . .u.__~ .J..__._ '-.y, I () ,/'j .)' . flr;; 6~..M' \ ,(7)'1 c.t--"cIJ. _' i (.Ir,4)\)-'l ", . DIY A '..'-:-> so..'"" --EXHlon- . --- ~ 0 ;-. ri In " ,.-. .. )...1; r() P - .~ ~i) - J% .Jl Ef.~ -:r:. )~ ~ .... ..;: 'l>: ~ '" ~ ~f: N ;~~ tlI c_ .e Vi ~ t{! Z tl ~ ~ r.: => ~ ..., ~~ 1I. 'b,.. 'V " r- Q 0\ U ..; -:-, '-6t UO S9J!dvs UOIISIWWO' An I.!~"O 10 'ml 'PPW tit'" 1'~'PI/I' WO~"" "JO,'Q I'/:;JIIIO 10 ,,,,,rue,s lUfllJlB 10 oJnuw6!S -61' - ;01.....0 SIHl. 3~ 3tlOj38 03SItlOSSnS ON.... (03~tll;;"") NtlOMS 019'B4 P94JUllB Idl909J S,JapU9S 'I!BW (p9'9IS169') (pall'IJBJ) Aq 0 BO'''BS leUOsJad ~q 0 -6 t ' uo paSSaJppB seM alntl B41 , W04MO\ (.)aQlladde 941 uodn lnadd.... 10 9~IION "^oqu941 6U1~ucdwoJJelulUldwoO e 01,; OIOlntl 9~1 PO^JOS IIe4i JB4lJOI pue 0 '019'04 pa40eneldlaJaJ S,JOPUO" 'I!ew (PO'BISI6B') (pOIJlilBO) ~q 0 B~'^,OS leuos,ad Aq o-'--6t ' uo' (aweu) 'BBllodde B41 uodn pUB '010'94 pB40enB IdlBOBJ S,'BPUBS 'I'ew (pBJ9ISI6B') (pB!l!lJBJ) Aq 0 BJI^'BS leuOSIBd Aq 0 '-61 . . (OO!MOS 10 B/ep) uo U,aJ041 pOleu6,SBp BOllSnr IJ!JIS!O B41 uodn ' 'ON seBld uowwoO 'IDBdd.... 10 DOIlON B4110 Adoo e 0 P9^'BS IIBY\ WI'IIB 10 JDaMS Aqala!l I :~I^,fal:l:lV II : ~o UNnO:l YINY^'ASNN3d ~o Hl'Y3MNOIII'lO:l (SBroo a/OeOlldde PB40 'Ieeddelo BOI/OU B41 BUlI'1 U3Lfv SA Ita (01 I N31 NIH1IM 0311:1 38 lsm~ BOIMBS 10 100Jd s'lur ~NIV1dWOO 311:1 O~ 31ml ONV 1V3ddV :10 30110N :10 30lMf3S :10 :lOOHd .. PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT (ThiS plOOI 01 SOfVICO MUST OE FILED WIT/fiN TEN (10) DA YS AFTEFllilmg tho nOlicu 01 appoal, Chock appli~ablo bOKOS) COMMONWEALTH O(!!J-NSYLVI\NIA~ COUNTY OF -~.L1. ;u AFFIDAVIT: I hereby swear or afllrm that I served 97~ 2j~L o a copy of tho Nollce 01 ~J1').-Eommon Ple~5 No ji;;I; ? ~_, upon the DlSlrlct Juslice designated therein on (dalo 01 SOfV;CO) -~-'=7-, 19-'7~"" By po's~ serv}~~ D..hY(C9'lified~\listorod) mail, sonder's fOCOiPIjIl~~ hereto, a!l,d-y~~ Iho appellee. IndIQO} _--C9p&l~___~a''''.A1L~ ,on -{;;1-//t: . 192LJr:.bY porsonal servlc, ~y (certifIed) (registered) mall. sender's receipt attached hereto. o and further that I servl~d thu RUll~ 10 File d ~~pli1lnl ;:lccOrTIpanyi~? the above Notice of APpe.eon thcoppellcc{s) lo~hom the Rule was addressed on ---6~~~ , 19~ 0 by ptH!tonal SCfVIC~ by (certified) (registered) mall. sender's receipt nttactled hereto SWORN !AF6iMED) AND SU CRIBED BEFORE ME ~~ '"''L :;"0 -. ,/'rz -~~=- S~OI v"" "b.ro," ""0", Tm"o'off'cl", , 192:1., NllTARlAl SEAL 1e""',1 II CTTO, NOTARY PUBUC ! U' d. reno CIlMBERlNIO CO.. P,I ) '.' """ ,',,"-:Ji, EXPIRES OH:EMBBI22. .997 I...".."'.... _..... , L _...._~ ^~ .~ ~~ 1<;\ ~ ~to 'm i> lY'j ~ ~ ::E "" ~. ~' IT1 <n ... ~.:: , ..... ~u <;i I ~ <Il-.., I. .- ~- '\ s'l::. '" ~a:~ " Q) ~g v:; '", "- U ~ ~ ~~'4 ~ - <:1...>'& ~ _ otI .. r- ~ 0 0 E "-~.~ i::....t.J .... '~ "\:. .D ~ ~ 0 l/)'" u- " '" . ITl --0-~5: ~~......~ .' ~ ~'Q;5:J ~~"g) . ~ a- n U III U 2 K ,~ tf u. c: c _ .r'! - . ~ CU- ~I- ~ <r>_ '.' .' (j) a: 0 0' <~ ~,....- .. L> ::'J 20 \ \ ;J "- '- t ~ " ~ " " .~ . jt t ~ " ~ . u " ~ .. ::, ~ .. --- "... ~ i'f ~ 1"-. c; ". r,.... 1- 6; lUr? fit .....1. I!. c~i" .:::> c L:..... ~.,~ ",,-' if:: 1-.. t.: ~.: c:: I !_ I- e 01 G; ~'~"-:. I ~ : ;"'i "., :':"-- U J'U {. - ,;'>..1' ....:..... "hI , ( I IIAnny L. unlCltEln, In. ATTORNCY AT LAW 407 HOR'H rRON' STAtU 1lA1I1l1"DUHO, PHNNHVLVANlA. 17101-12&0 . "'RU. COOl: 717 1321 .1585 FA'" In" 85115 July 25, 1997 Mr. Richard Murray 4300 New Hampshire Drive Harrisburg, P A 17112 Re: Solonlnka v. Murray No. 97.3126 fll f COP j' Dear Dick: Enclosed is a copy of my Certificate of Service concerning the above-captioned matter. The next step in the proceeding is for Mr. Soloninka to follow the rules of court in Cumberland County and eventually list the case for trial before a board of arbitrators. I am not certain that he knows how to do this and I do not think there is any point in either you or me telling him. If he contacts you it very well may be that perhaps you and he can settle the matter. This is really a small matter to litigate although, of course, if that is what he wants to do, that of course is what we will do. In the interim, I am sending my statement for services to-date. It is very difficult to estimate where this case may go from here; certainly if the case is eventually tried before a board of arbitratqrs we will need' additional fees. probably in the vicinity of $750.00. I give this information to you now so that you know that while the matter is not all that excessive, the professional time involved to represent you properly can easily be considerable. Hopefully, this matter will go away one way or the other. With best wishes. Very truly yours, HLB,Jr.fjcl Enclosure Harry L. Bricker, Jr. r:"l.'j"IT A V~l ~ I"i _--Ct- C", ...... ..~. ~ '...1 DAnny L. nnlCKEln, In. ATTORNEY AT LAW 407 HORTH 'RaNT IUtU, FfL E' "'[l'j~~r~E" Dr ,I, , I' i/~"U ,.... I ...... 1 AX J...II DARRI.DURo., "BNNHTLVA.NIA 17I01'12S16 January 30, 1998 Mr. Richard Murray 4300 New Hampshire Drive Harrisburg, PA 17112 Re: Solonlnka v. Murray No. 97.3126 Dear Dick: Enclosed is a copy of a Notice which I recently received. You will note Mr. Soloninka has listed the mailer for a hearing before a Board of Arbitrators and that the hearing is scheduled for March 9, 1998. If you want me to represent you in this mailer I will appreciate It if you will telephone my office for an appointment in order that we'may discuss it. It appears as if Mr. Soloninka is proceeding without counsel although that may change some time in the future and you will note the Arbitrators are all attorneys; Roger M. Morgenthal is Chairman and the other two members of the Panel are Messrs, Perkins and Orr. We will take no further action on this until wo hear from you. Very truly yours, Harry L. Bricker, Jr. HLB, Jr.fJcl Enclosure EXHI81T.:D . i i I i~ >- c. j::: ~ ..:J I~ ,.. _. llIr? N :i",,*" ( "'I.... to:) .~I .,(. :r.: ( ~7 ~t~ lL -'~ . )..;. Co ~...~ if r- :~.&~ , . EE~; u:l!.J a~ i!: w tz.JllJ -- u. f~~:l. u.. ' co :5 a", a> u . . ~~ -..~ I1l ..::!. ci '1 ~ s:: ... i": 01 j:: .' ~ ..... ;:"". C~ .~~- f' ,- >-!7::: .- 'a'~J.,~ i..~;, .... i~-'~ '- ~- C") .--:!t;! " , .- -~,: t.g .... i:..' 0.: f'- :;.; ;]-- ., "" ih~ " :ll: - OJ d en i r- ~ M CiJ ,o!. ~9 a~ l:E~ :t: (J":;~ ...: ~. ~E r"\~ '.~ u. <::> .~~j ~"- N ~...- 'c - ~ te"'; 0:: f!JeQ F .n; t@Cl- ~ ~ a:: .<. 0" a . UAI~Y L. DmC~II. JR. ATTORNEY AT LAW THe CAMlRON NAHalON 40J NORTH '''ONT "'''ECT JIAlllllHnuno, PUNNf:I,oJ.'"A.NIA IT101-1ROO 1117. 23'.IIU'D DONALD SOLONINKA, Plaintiff IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA No. 97 - 3126 CIVIL TERM CIVIL ACTION LAW v. DICK MURRAY, Defendant PRAECIPE AND NOW this 10th day of April, 1998, by reason of the Order of Court as handed down by the Honorable Edward E. Giudo on the 7th day of April 1998, I hereby withdraw as counsel for the Defendant in this proceeding and ask that the Prothonotary note my withdrawal in the official records of this proceeding. Date: Lt-- ~ , D' 9...."( ~. .- ~~=- _._~ ~ ... ) Harr~ncker,Jr COPIES TO: Brian K. Zellner, Esquire 355 North 21st Street Camp Hill, PA 17011 Roger M. Morgenthal, Esquire FLOWER, MORGENTHAL, FLOWER & LINDSAY. P.C. 11 East High Street Carlisle. PA 17013 Mr. Dick Murray 4300 New Hampshire Drive Harrisburg, PA 17112 .. _. ~ " f >- Cc: j'5, lUI:; [Ef~ C)i,~ . , P' ~~) t ...J 1..';, I' " G \,,() C-,' r.: :::{. ;:;:.;.,:"," --::;.:.' (~: c: ,. ~< ;~.~~ ~:'''/';: - ., - .-- .:diJi ~:; ,.... \.,.) r" f'" ;:.: ~ 0' ~~ ..... "i__ ~--_....... -- -- .-.-- ...... . -. ~ - . . DONAld 5olo/v,',vJ~ PI Mv T rr-f. c,q~c. ~o .97-~!~_~~_~~~:::~=.:=~~~= _u._ __ v. ,____" _ __ DJ'GI~yY)/)f..f-.'fIJY(V/fo/J()v.JHD()oF-S) ______________h_._ __ , D12 re.JJdA/V1S Corn. PIA '"}oJ1 u_._ .__. <D A roTA I 01 I ~ WI M:lcHJS I.U~,.'-_PL.~~_~~~~____ u_ b,-Twee.N 1'1'\3 ~ \'1~ FI<"~ \;);c IS r1\1~~~_h ____ Ail w;j./cl.o(,\)S 1.0'\11 ,vO\ J...o<..1c; Out:. To__________ _. bow l't-J T-+\c. SAC.~S . , _ ~. Also ,1'\ WI ",clo (,; wAS b Rd ~e.v 0 /J______ MAY .Pil /99C ANd 'if sT,'ll ,',S N 0; &:.PA~g.e.sl____ - ..~ ~).r lOoK b}cF: m.ufl..f..A~ To CouA,..__._______ ..OJ.;) rY'\A~~H ).S'/''t'll A,p.,;d. WDIJ' f. ~vJjc:._u------ "u At wik ~ Tl ~c:. IN) Ml 0 ws weRe. To h~ Ft ~~ b(' A P~l' I 4. ~ (@CJ fJ AP~I \ 9 DI<:"- rv1lJiLftAY G~ It _ _ D,~TR;Lf ~ ~S1i't. A,.J &~/d W}lvdO_~~ lI-JtR e. Pi xed PA,~ e 2.. '-'-_."-_.~-------"- -. .._._....__...___... ...-__,.. _'__"'__.__"__'___d___._._ ."u:.(~i"i~A;;ie~'U'~~ Tr )~'-Af'~l'l .1 ~....~/"J...__n. _..__ ...~JIe.J '" '(S",~ C/elf1e~1! ,lutl1Ji/A)!..tll}'(J._-;-y_ un.,.'>>.) I\d. ows fA)~!.e sTj\II.~..s t1~c,L ~~Tfi'x~c(..J.__ .. ... . .... ....a;.:> v.211e "'_ TO . s e COI"~ tlc M.il.>~' ".. mAtH:_- . d '_H ~"r'i).. ~ T ..lA>ij\cj~ .Tlm c. ::[ w~~Sf\_lJ.l ~~ ...?4.. ..n.n_ .,.. ....My.ToTh\~\}dSt-~~/J( .o-f..s3J~.!oo_. .~~,c,~(J~~_ .' .._DJ<;'1s r1tJR{Z.~lf~'lJt:d , TOfl PeA~(. A t~~...____..._ ._._.. ...._ _r!1Y WI~ot0"ffl~"T V_iAa bl2o~c.~n~JSu _____'.u ..-,yol bc:e~ Rl;.TvR.lved~ u AN d iT J"L.qs.b~c::.y.._u. uu_ U. 'u' '__un 0, \.U~R u.3 l' ('t'\op (Hs , m __uu . - --_.-.-- .-. ..u'" .,.,. \Z) 8IcSClr-Fte.co~pfl}J1. ,/<.cy~Th",~..I1J).~J~.IJ>~, u, _'_u" s)"sJe 'fI'.'I v->~e0' 0 U,' 0 -t~\)s S:l J/PSS ...'u__' ' , ,___...oveR. n37~A p...s,. . 8Cja. ;I-k R~ fo((~ . rn7 1).Jf1 (C~'fT,,,_ ,uu ..n __,;Su. NO ~OOd. ,_ . 'CjJ(7Y}~J~ D6/./1/ lei S'./OiJ/,vkiJ --- .. -. .. " --.. . --.--. --- _.~~'3.0-97 . , , - - ~~ASe.~--_______un_ Jl~gi ftc,ql\o'lJ "~-'-'---'-"~-._._---.-_.._._--._- -.-.---..--..-. -. .-..--.. -. , , . _u -..-----.:r:--- DOl/Aiel " SO/OAJi,4l/yl, ,J4ege./;)Y-__II..~ti..ff';__h____ .-.------------__.__'rll~T rHe ,STATYIlG....7S ('ltld.e. ,_JIJ.'J'f/e,___~~/filiv':t- __.____u______fIRe TR-vef\#vJ cot?l!.ecT To .rfk_.bes-r_o1..~1__h --. -- ____n__ ..----J:;J.J5?-'!!Jyc/~e..F-~JJ-~~~ "'Tr'p~"...cl _ ~~ fie:+,_~__JJP:.~e~.::-__ -----.... _...__.n__~Th_J#__~~T_" F~ Isc.. ,_~;71rrcf1'lc:.)'!5" , Ht;~l::-i~__8 Re _rn~dg______._ -- -- --- -- -~.5lJ.ks~?'C _ ,~_ rHe.. (t!.J 1/ /7Tcs_ nC?l-t _ JS_ _~~'_ ~.sL__ ___ _h.._ ______________s..'t'7:0.'t. \ .f{~/A.O_i-$, To _,VAJ_~.wO~~_ rA_(~J.fl~l4:n_'lJ.~ __~_____.__ h_' ----.. _'_"_ht9l.imcJ.~r7]~.____.., _ ,',_,_ _ ------____u__u._____uu__ ---' ---..~-:--~~--:.==~:~_.__~-,_~_:_--.,__,:':_',-',___'- ,-_-_ _~~-~ i]~,_~=-:_-.-~- __________________________ un _ _.. _ ,bO-''!AJ::I So/pIVIP59______.._._ ____ .,.q"T2t 1;-30-97 .. _._.__.....,__..uL~____......_..___ __._. _ ...._______.._~ .__.___ ._ ._ _~ "_ _ ____ _U'_ _,___..__._______._~_. _..__.... . _ _._.__.___ _..____.. _ ._.__._.__.___..._.. _ ._.._._._...'___.__.___.____._..__........_________.____________._. _. _'__-._', __._,..______.._.....__._.__~_._.. __L____ _'___"_",'__'_'___~'_~'_______,_,___ .._...... "' .,.. .~.._____._."_..___.._.___,"',_.._.__.______________..~_.___.,,_.._____ ---.+----.---".--..-..________ .._._.,.__.__".________._.. ._."_..'.._.._._ ....... _ ~...__,.._ ... .._._......._.".._.__"n.___.__~__.___,_.__.._.._~..___.....,__. ._ _.... __ .,., _...._.._. ~.. _.. _.__.......____._...... '_"_.__ ..,,_.'._,_.__. '0' ____ .., ,._. ...__.. ____._. ,.. __." _" _ ,,_.. .___,,_...,..., ,__ .... ...._.~ ___. _._________.. ._"._.___ .___.._