HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-03871
>--
d
l..
o
C
-t1
o
./
./
,
5
~
J
-
~
r-L
0-,
,I
. .
i.f
I
j
!
:1
,
12. Plaintiff accepted the offer of Defendant for the lump sum payment as itemized in Exhibit
A except that Plaintiff indicated to Defendant that he failed to reflect a credit due him in the
amount of $.333.00 for Ihe paint job to the Probe: an incorrect deduclion of $100 for the
reconditioning of the Faust vehide and a failure to credit a $200.00 payment on the 1989
Toyola.
13. Despite this agreement and acknowledgement and repcat~'ti demands by Plaintiff.
Defendant has failed to make any payments 10 Plaintiff.
14. Defendant has funher proc~'ti~'ti to sell the \'ehides to third pank'S and. upon sale of the
vehicles. has neither lransmill~'ti to the Plaintiff the monies 0\V~'ti for the initial cash outlay of
the 1iehicles. the costs of repairs or his one-half share of thc profits.
15. As a resuh of Defcndant's breach of the panics' agn'Cment. Plaintiff has suffered loss
in the amount of SEVENTEEN TI10USAND ONE HUNDRED TIlIRTY -THREE DOLLARS
AND SIXTY -SEVEN CENTS ISl i .13.l.6il ....-!lith Plaintiff belieH>S is the com'\.1 amount due
as a resuh of the direct buy-out agr~nl bet....ccn he and lhe Dek'!1dant a.~ agreed 10 in
February _ 199i.
16. Additionally. Plaintiff is due a ~un\ to be d..1~'t1lli~'" ....\lith ~'S('I\\S one-half of the
total profit realih'ti b~ the ll\.i..'l1Itanl IIpon tl1l.- sale of lhe H-hides (lUtchalit.'ti jointly ....ith
Plaintiff .
I)';; ...:
I"':"'::
x 7'17":....h';'.)3
'jP: ~.: ',; ';';!) T')
.)1
j}6~ ~
_K.&?.E!-====--...
'} q T (?,.., ,., tP
,,;(0/3. ';;3
-----.-------...-..--....... .',
'..........- .-'"
I
I
-,'-- .. . ..-- . --
.n_3..~~ r 2.-L._.,
. -.. --- .'
._-
e6",-~d~' ~Y c.~', ~
i __ ----.- ---.---....-..-......
9-/1' /J/f,(I-'- (U'~:_.___._..j2oo'-~--. - - .... ,,'-"-
. .. ___. . ...._.. ._.5. ;-~'~,-:!-=-_ 7101, .f7.... /)1fA!..~~~'._qfs ~
.__ ___J~~KAM"; (~!,{o~::.. . __...- . ....
I
: ..f.::../t/ - '7..::'. pO
, .__ .___~ "__'~_ _._._..___~....~._~ . ___ ___ ._.. ,.__u_._
.515/. ,~
_ . :rV"/T./1I"/'ifr.7.r1' ~I~ ;~... 7t"';-'-'
_ ~AW~'-E' . e."'" _' ._.!~q:>:,e707, ~,-u.._i:?!:~ ~..fil,<~JaY --
._._ . ..' ____ ___._ _1~r'~~/--....._-.3.E' z::;o - --fJq;-ill- ~::t'b--t;..
....&(:,:,,!F..~ ~'d..e., .._-1.1-.9$7 .,.~.___~4-.~::>!~ J"'f:.==-..__
\'_ . .._ __ ._ .' _.S'~/l.fJ- (1A/"""'''''' .t;Mf~.. --...---
~t.it"~!.'~.PA"~~ .!fJ11t(____. ...-...- -'" ----.' .-' . -. ., -- --.- --
I, /~~S 1;1; ,.r1' e ., ~"o - /t, 0, 3Y
. -- -----.--- ---- -.- ---.-.-' - _.~- -- . . ", -_......- -.-
\ ~?;',",;;~ .. -' . ~UI's;.'J- ..~~:~---
/./I.:l! '". #A.(..:.~J!~' -- .{
r~..~T~b~~(;~'~, ..._' L
~AJ,;o/AL :;.7 I
_ fL' 41.- tI_~I';-. ..,JS,
\ fv..~'.~":. ,.,b..A. J..'?,
_....__~_.._.___w_
---'
------...
--.-
-..-... .---
..-.- ...-....
(Nl' :r~t.""'u
~-
-..,-.----" -.
)
~'?" '.'-'
'.-
_.---.. -
oc;tI,.{) ;,.;..; I)
~ _. - > .' .-- "I.;.:-
~ "'-. ~ c:. J:::i.,:,,-: .. ~
------- --
.... ......-...-........-
,S..:>-
.
"J...~1.
~A~,.,',.~ tJ!!/L. ....
.--....-..-
'.1 ~ .:' 1.:' I":",~
z ;-1,~:'Hl0;-I)S
;j~~'.' s: AUTO
01
,';/ -.3
I;;' b ~
V;(II ,,', e.
fOJI
~,4K;5
77J;A '-
if {'/I,:J~O( "',
(j3 I;H~"'.q /1S'
1:(1 -; ~,., /JQ /07S"
>-9 TtW'(.;J T ;:z.. 0
9:? SCoM'dto "
97 I' 8/;('<) 0
:Jr..?r'../~T
.7() ,1rs..-
/c7..~
,.,fdO ~cp<ZJ 90D
-,0- ..., -
..24/. .J? 7of..i?
<:;)
,P
f. //to"'!
-
/A~ ,,~
7' If/ S /}I c; of'
.~,
/;4 ~~ ~
~{;..;- ~
-----.-
~-!"..... ~S# ~ 3~~~.:l..
...~.~~
02Tfi '- /.()~~'-~ -_
/'?ft:"1.
. '
6"4~ ..,!;A'C- /~I:"g_l..j
, -- - ---4--,
- -
.
--- -- .
. .
- '
.
-
- - ~- -.----. ... ,".- _e.
'--. - -.
_. '. "-'-''''
.' -."",,"" - .--
C00dG0
R!.[D-OFFICE
C~ T' .,. '-"',-; ,,,,,..-.,,....
,4 ,-- . .:; J; '" '~",,:'''''':H
(17 'u' 17 ",111: OC;
~.. "" w
1';,....., '. (-'''4I'mr
V"..,J,\'JU{,J', ~ , )"",,;;,".
[-9'1:,::1.\', .t.,!,\
.$ 45. 5upd ~
Qu.'" 1~'1'l
~ 'jj 5-4"11 a
.
UW OFPtca
8AR8ARASUMPL~SULUVAN
.... __ .TM:n
Nf,WCUMtlGlLANO,l'E.HHsYLVAHlA tJ070.1I
DARWIN GIRTON, I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
plaintif f, . CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
.
.
.
VB. CIVIL ACTION . LAW
.
.
STEVEN GRAY, I NO. 97-3871 CIVIL TERM
Defendant. .
.
NOTICE
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against
the claims set forth in the following pages. you must take action
within twenty (20) days after this counterclaim and notice are
served. by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney
and filing in writing with the court your defenses or Objections to
the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail
to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be
entered against you by the court without further notice for any
money claimed in the counterclaim or for any other claim or relief
requested by the Defendant. You may lose money or property or
other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO
NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE. GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
COurt Administrator
Cumberland COunty COurthouse. 4th Floor
1 COurthouse Square
Carlisle. PA 17013
(717) 240-6200
8. Admitted.
9. Admitted.
10. Admitted.
11. Admitted and Denied. Defendant does not agree that he
owes Plaintiff the sum of One Thousand Seventy-Five and 00/100
Dollars ($1,075.00). plaintiff took this automobile for his own
use from the automobiles purchased within the parties agreement.
Therefore Defendant states the amount of monies owed to the
Plaintiff are Fifteen Thousand Eight Hundred Sixty-Six and 83/100
Dollars ($15,866.83).
12. Denied. The Three Hundred Thirty-Three and 00/100
Dollars ($333.00) which Plaintiff alleges as a credit due to him
for a paint jOb on the Probe, was actually paid to the client when
Defendant paid the Plaintiff Five Thousand Four Hundred Twenty-
Eight and 69/100 Dollars ($5.428.69) at the time the vehicle was
sold and the profits were divided between the parties. Defendant
has no knowledge of nor has he ever seen or been provided with any
receipts or invoices for the One Hundred and 00/100 Dollars
('100.00) charge for reconditioning the Faust vehicle. Defendant
haa no knowledge of nor has he ever seen or been given an invoice
and/or receipt for the TWo Hundred and 00/100 Dollars 1'200.00)
payment on the 1989 Toyota. On page J of Plaintiff's Exhibit -A-
there is a Twenty and 00/100 Dollars ('20.00) towing charge, which
Defendant believes Plaintiff may be referring to and haa made an
error in the placement of the decimal point.
13. Denied. Defendant hu made several offen of . payment
2
schedule to repay the Plaintiff the monies owed to him in the sum
of Fifteen Thousand Eight Hundred Sixty-Six and 83/100 Dollars
($15.866.83) .
14. Admitted.
15. Denied. Defendant believes the correct amount remaining
to be paid to the Plaintiff per the attached agreement in Exhibit
"A" is Fifteen Thousand Eight Hundred Sixty-Six and 83/100 Dollars
($15.866.83) .
16. Admitted and Denied. It is admitted that Defendant at
this time does not have statements of the profits. losses and costs
from each individual vehicle sold. Defendant is therefore unable
to calculate the final profit. if any. Wllich the parties realized
from the sale of the remaining vehicles. Defendant is compiling
this information and will provide Plaintiff with the itemized
statements and the amount of the total profit. if any. as soon as
they are completed.
COUNTERCLAIM
17. Paragraphs 1 through 16 are incorporated as if fully set
forth herein.
18. Plaintiff stored a Bucket truck on the Defendant's
business property from May 1994 until ~arch 1997. The fee for
storage of this vehicle was Ten Thousand Bight Hundred and 00/100
Dollars ('10,800.00). Plaintiff stored a Chevrolet Street aod on
Defendant's business property for ten (10) months and a boat
trailer on Defendant's business property for one (1) year and four
(4) months. The fees for the storaqe of this vehicle and trailer
J
are Seven Thousand Three Hundred and 00/100 Dollars ($7,300.00).
Plaintiff has never paid Defendant any fees for storage of these
three (3) items. The fees for storage total. with tax. Nineteen
Thousand One Hundred Eighty-Six and 00/100 Dollars ($19,186.00).
(Please see Exhibit "B".)
19. Plaintif f requested Defendant repair a Bucket truck
belonging to him. The cost to do the repairs to the Bucket truck.
including tax. are Two Hundred Thirty-Two and 14/100 Dollars
($232.14). Plaintiff has never paid Defendant any fees for these
repairs. (Please see Exhibit "C".)
20. Plaintiff borrowed an auto buffer from Defendant's auto
shop. Plaintiff returned the auto buffer broken and without the
wheel cleaner. The cost Defendant incurred to repair the auto
buffer and replace the wheel cleaner. including tax, is Fifty.One
and 94/100 Dollars ($51.94). Plaintiff has never paid Defendant
any fees for the use and/or the damage to the auto buffer. (Please
see Exhibit "D".)
21. Plaintiff took two (2) vehicles, for his own private use.
from the vehicles purchased to be sold for profit by the parties.
Plaintiff did not share any profit which should have been realized
from the sale of these two (2) vehicles. Therefore. Defendant
believes he should be reimbursed for one-half (1/2) of the profit
which the parties should have realized had the automobiles been
sold at their book value.
WHlllroal. Defendant requests a judgement be entered in his
favor in the amount of Nineteen Thousand Four Hundred Seventy and
..
fin }.. 'I, I' I ~A
X ;I~"]..lnn;-nn
O'OOy .SHOP'~EPA"H.OnD~
TO ilEOROl!1l1HESE rOAMS
. l;AlLli"i1l m~E 1(800) ~J3:'~"J
~ .... ..... "
-
_ V 1-.,1
""",t,'vIIVf: ~ '~I~t,4'" ~J;';OCIATI!tt
...' '.~~.H'I,ffIr"N"'.1 r"".,,,u
'11'1""W41"'AIlI\t.'.",llCll
A-PDR
"'i'."',-"I
: GRat's'AUTO SAlESl& S~RVICE
825 NEWVILLE RD.
CARLISLE. PA 17013
1717) 240.0708
...."Ml -...-- --
,G::J-i'~~ ,.)
Ar-ot'tC'!:
. L.fZ....2~.!S!! ~ ...
~:;'701:)
d?R.
~.'A'I
~:V,l I;
P'A' ,___ /?~,. _.
H[ '^ILS (IF ~FI'AIH
." j,.' n. ,II'" .
'J '
"
,(/~r ,_.&.(?,<,.-S
t.iL-.-L'iLu.~ /
..-rd~E 4,(,~,1 ~{:(/.Jc-:.{/.
.~<""LA"".c_. /../~t:.d.,-~. .~(C.t'"/ d../It
~~/"'d
./J./~
JI'LI"':-:".. . c441'l'"rt.~~;~
;; 62.. /~~ ;4~~~.
A.-:i:r .../"'''''''''''''L'dt'.I:L . ._~"..)
. _.L'~ #'.u:s.._______
.../ co vo"
"hefPbv truthOnr'" 'h...~ WOIII.-wJ ~Iti"'~~~ Attt'tpf ~tf I:..'Y
I (lIAI '.
fl~
~~~,~
-l'IIIOR DAMAOE ..
.~~""Itf~ ,
..........,- ..."'...
"N".f'll"~c1\tdt-]
.............
- CUMtNT "TlMATI -
:.~."'c'
14 .
\,<..,
OPIl',' ~ nllTn n,
IIHWHIIVIllf U'MI. ~. . .'00" '
n.ttl'
--' J.J g,
TO flER,R~Jil' T ese I"OI'IMI
l'IW"II~Jflalf'I"I""'." r.AlL \. f.E tOlY3)tj'l'?9",O
Ii'"
'I un
e
7
I
9
10
11
12
"
-
14
IS
"
If
"
II
2t
21
22
2S
24
1-
l'^"I~
,
2
3
4
-
,
.-
r".,
,.
114"
L-.
U AIM NO
,- -
,
I'
,
.--.....1-
,
J
,
t..
,
,.
,.
I.
, ..
I
,
IWNT
l "llQI-l
"AllYS
10WII..\.~t~At;'
(,N -'-N1At
11..
....-..
IItt.tNt
oCOUcTllk!
WRtnc;.i'f'.
I ^lIflll
P^'N
suel ET'MISe
,.
3.'::"
,
..~:"-1
,
- 1__...
""';e:>
.. ~.
''" -
I
r
~_.i-.J
, I
,'--' -
_.1-.,
,
1.-.
,.
I
,
,
I
I
,
,
I
.---
,
I..-~
I
,.
...- ..
,
,
"r-
.:i:.s-
""~ ..
....$...
"~CI' .. j
, l
,
<~f ~:. \
/"D ; ...-"1
_. --- --+_.--~
,.
-,
"?Lf~,,~
i
1 if ~
.1.../'/ . /, ,
,
.'JA~~y
"-
.
101M
>J
lI: 717248879"
BlODtlY~5A;;OP"REPAlltoRD;R
'-" ...... """" IV ! '_
."11 ""oll\1t ~.Y':'.lty~..t; "Il.t"'!;!;
."_.,,,ll"l'fl~'IllAI r.lln.~A~
,,"......;1 A,U,A'tIo\O./'lI
II-
~'"
~ ~'_1l1 I I I I i lLtJ, :
",TC I "noJ'O!:C11 lIfl
IN l / qlll I /
Li !Nn NO j' oll\tMt-HA ",,'r
. no
If"'~
H .'-fiii: NO .
oe"'27/97 13129
TO A~OAOER THESE FORMS
CAT (rolr~(F. t (flOO) r..1l1\1!.tl
~
....
..
'-
~
....
A-PDR
^_IIU., (.'1
GRAY'S '41110 SAlES:& S~RVICE
825 NEWVILLE RD.
CARLISLE, PA 17013
(717) 240.0708
f.II'
c:JA'~~.J
~.#
:"'-'l
,;??4.~~ . ~
____ nu . 4 fJrl!,U r: (Jr.~r"'^II~
-11\"" I,',!I) " ,Il""" .'1\ '1'1.
f' ( "", III '$4
~--_... I
_. /U,.f'W/-'V
.ll\lt4t~
'_ ..d... . ~ ~~d~P...
~WI'
"
...-U.-..
r~ 'tnJ<<:
..__. l ~)!Z:L, '/
l.r
,/ /"~-J.-
I ~l. ,H~.
, A!I' ..... AI~I .
~
.. ",..'?,..,.
""'~ .. ~_f':"':.~<
~.!!:.!...":'<"...,.,.. ~,
4~.7. .........>(
,
~~~~5!
-. ~"l-~r.1:.L__~""'" I -.-
__::-&&:"".....co: ~,<',... ~ ..._--r:~~-IJ;"'..
/I.-,rv.--< 4 ,,,,,,(' '~'.~ ~m__._ _
i....j
! I
t 1
I -..". _.__ _...... ,.__ ~_.._
II he.ebr II\llhclI1A "'" - __ atl1I octonowIedge...,...,..~ "ot"
;
M~:tl(~!
0-....
/~
~?F~'.. .
- ~ DAMAGI.
...."" ........ ftJ. W\ .
-"'............
~.......W~
-' "tlt .....
.. C\MMNT UnMAn.
,.1{ )l\'
4.:~~'
",'''
".t fit)
f-"I'''''j''''I&II'" mI,,,,,,
l CO
",~.;::i; ~_.
"/II II Il
I
2
J
4
5
6
7
.
h_~
_'H
9
10
11
12
1:1
14
IS
"
17
.-
"
II
~
-
21
n
2:1
.
I
I
,
I
I.
""INT
- lo\UOfI
, "ARTS
F'o\lNTISVf'~' ,tS
GRAY'S RUTO
ItUll'NlS"'llU :~l:ff
.,
-' '.,.1
T ?^~TE1~r-R~~/
N~
"Attr'
""Jlltl
111\....,.
DCDUe'lttIf
I ^1\(l1I
PAIN
I
I
I
-'-'-
I
.
.
I
I.--
I
I
_ .1
.
.
.
.. ,
,...-
I
'-"''''T'"
.
!'--..
'-
._.L..
I
I
I
I.
I
. h
I
.
.1
I'
I
I
.
,..,. . $
,.~ .$
""
SU8l Et
T~lOnA(,.e
~E~Nl~
r """""'--;---
!,n
.
81
"..."."
Q.
I!SI! rOAMS
Uftil'l "''''-:'\1<.(1
o 4109
[:it - --1'-;;-
l'ATi ~
.1 Jjj~:
_ ':~ct
...L,l._--
t..lAfMI'lfU
0.- WPtTTi';'gy
~ltJ8lE I 'MIS';
l.
'1
I
r
_._.~..
L'l:~.
~ ;....-:r...
./~ \ DO
I
,
------
,
I,
I
-, -
.--.--
,
I
<.-
. ,
'1--;' .
.-----
'-'---..
,
--..---
-.-
._----;---
.
.~J'!3
,.I' ""
-. ,::]
s/, 't.
". _~_ ..___i..-
.~
IN TIlE COURT OF COM!-DN PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW NO. 97-3871
CIVIL TEmI
r-~ r:""nr,:"r,."'\c
C ':':;;y
r' ,,,....... i
',; I!
,
'I
DARWIN GIRTON,
Plaintiff,
VS.
STEVEN GRAY,
Defendant.
ANSWER AND COUNTERCLAIM
l"W OHlen OF
GATES - a - ASSOC"Affs~p:c~
____~__._._.~___'~~.,,~_.<_,.,.._~w..~~. w'_,___._'_'___
~---~.-_-,--_..-,._,~._._-"._."..__._...-..._"." '~---'---'-.
___Slll'It1Cll~",,_,'_I'O&l
.
Z
~
o
c m
3: )-
m :II
III m
;u ,.
>..:11
Z.)-
o ..
. l/I"
" . ..
Ill! C ~
Z !l 3: 0
Z I't -0 ...
Ut en . 1t
0( ;: fit ~
~~cn.
)O~C
~ r
)0 r
- <
~ )-
9 2
-
..
Cot
-
"-,.--
. .
2 :i ..,
.n
-~y~ t/'l ~t
,"
rt" "'0 q,;J
.,
~.~ .;~ .- 'I~
i2~ ": "..... -j
I'it; -0 ' .~
'.":. .....,. ,:i('>
-
~ ;)f\'\
. :Fl
'...-l '0,) .e
... U' ~
z
~
o m
c: )>
~ ::u
111 m
;u )>
~..::u
z . )>
0" 'A
. . v.
'1IlIe
111 - l:
zll"
Z",.
(11"11I
0( it .
!:'"\j\
~!;~
)0 ,.
:4 ~
!3 z
9
~
.
w
~
. .,
. .
(' ..l:l 0
,"'. -I Of'l
~ j
~ ,,-( ,- ,.]')
{:' 3
E ,~ \~
0 0
.. ~.~~
.. t
ii :-: . "1'
" "
..
,,- "in
C)
.. ...
:;> r.l ::\}
"'I'
'i.....'{
i
I
c~) ,~'~ -
,lei v
, "
1.! I
io It.
,
,
!
loA_ _
8AR8ARA SUMPUlt-8ULLIVAN
... __n
NllW CU".I'llNtO. .....WLVANIA l'1O'JO.l...