The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About97-04364 ~ ,0 ~ , \, o ~ U \. ~ " >-- III -C cJ \J b '" > It. ~ ~ If, ...... ~ -.) ") ~ , {" a- , ~' % .. SAMUEL B. FINEMAN, Esquire Identification No. 75717 CAPOZZI AND ASSOCIATES, P. C. 1711 North Front Street Harrisburg, PA 17102 (717) 901-5795 Attorney for Plaintiff SCOTT and STEPHANIE STUMP, h/... 475 Nt. Rock Road Newville, PA 17241 COURT OF CCM<<>N PLEAS COUNTY OF CUM8E1U.AND PENNSYLVANIA v. THE CBJ\YSLER CORPORATION c/o CT Corporation 1635 Market Street Philadelphia, PA 19103 CIVIL CQG>LAINT LAW DIVISION NO.7 7- /Jj~4- GA~Le., NOTICE TO DEFEND You b€en s~ed in court. If you wiSh to Oetenct agalnst the claims set forth in the following paqes, )'ou must tak.e actlcn within twenti' (20) days after this complaint and nctice dre served, cy entering a ....ritten dFpearan.:e ,personally or by attorney and fIling 1n Wrl tlOg witr. the court you \j~fenses or obJectlons to the claims set [erth d,Jdlnst yc:u. You are warned that if I'D:;' fail to de so the case rnay proceed wi trj':'U! '{:~u and a 1udqment rnay be entered agalnst. you by the court without further n0tlce fer .:1:0,/ rrv:.r.ey claHned in U"je .::omflaint or for any other claim or relief req'J.€ste,i by Hoe pl2iUitltf. You mdY .ose money or prcperty or other rights Hnp::rtant t,,) y;",u. TOO 5110UUl TAla: THIS PAPER TO FOUR LAWYER AT CH:E, IF TOO DO NOT HAVE A LAIfYER OR CANNOT AITOfU) CtlI:, ClO TO OR TELEPIIOtlE TIlE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND ClOT 1IIIE1lI: TOO CAN GET LEGAL HELP. COURT AIlMDlISTRATOR FOURTH n.oOR C1JHBERLAND COIlNTY COURTIIOOSE CARI.ISLE, PI. 17013 TELEPHONE: 717-240-6200 AVISO Le han delTldndado a usted en 101 c'':-rte. Sl usted q:'llere defenderse de esta.s de estas ;jemandas eXpiJ€sta.:oI tin ias pdqlr.dS slqn..ent€'s, i.ts':ed tiene veinte (201 dias de plazo 3.1 p,lrtlf ,11;" 1.a fechia de la ,jett,dnJa y ia n::tlficdcicn. Hace falta. asentar una c;JlTtpdrerl.::ia escrit.::. C En pers.;:;n.?s c ccn un .lhlF.Jdd(! y entregar a la corte en forma ese-eHa s<.JsieftmSd;5 0 S\JS ct;)t,'Ch'nes d LiS Jt'!'!\df1,1as ~n ~~Gntra de su persona. Sea dVlsad.::; -:r~e si uste,j n,:. se ;jl:>llt~r;j~. it? ,~'o::.'rte t-:mldra medidas y puede continual la deIT"~-indd en .:.;:,ntra. S\J}'d sir. prIl'Vl(; dVlSC <..' n,-.tlfl,:::",:icn. Ademas, 1a corte ~uede de>':lda a Liver d\?l demardante y requH?t€ '~Uf> u.s! e.j ...~u."!'.pla .:cn todas las provislones de est a demand,). Ustej f''..lE'';1.:' p"r'lt>r ,jtn'''l': $il,~ pre-ple-dades u cstros derechcs 1!nJ:c,:~rtantt-~5 paLl usted. LLEVJ: ISTA IlDWlIlA A UN AIIOGNlO IMCDIATAMDITE, 51 NO TIDlE AIIOGNlO 0 51 NO TIINl II. DINDO StTFICII!lTI: DC NGM TAL SUVICIO, VATA EN PlRSaIA 0 LINlE POR 'l'lLEFCIlO A IA OFICIIlo\ CUTA DIUcctON It ENCIlEN'I'IIA ISCRIrA AM.JO PARA AVERIGOAIt DONDI: It P\lEIlI CCMltCUIR ASIS'l'lNCIA LlGAL. COURT AIlKINI5TRATOR FOURTH FLOOR CIHlIRLAIlD COUNTY COURTIIOUIt CARI.ISLE, PI. 17013 'l'lLlPHONl: 717-240-6200 correct copy of the repair invoice is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit "C." 20. The third warranty repair attempt is believed to have occurred on or before April 25, 1997, when the vehicle's odometer showed 12,442. On that date, repair attempts were made to the defective brakes, including drum and cylinder concerns. In addition, repair attempts were made to the steering gears. A true and correct copy of the repair invoice is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit "D." 21. The fourth warranty repair attempt is believed to have occurred on or before June 6, 1997, when the vehicle' s odometer showed 14,360. On that date, repair attempts were made to alleviate a ticking noise emanating from the engine. A true and correct copy of the repair invoice is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit "E." 22. The fifth warranty repair attempt is believed to have occurred on or before June 18, 1997, when the vehicle's odometer showed 15,522. On that date, repair attempts were made to remedy a rough ride condition, knocking noise in the engine; and a brake pull. A true and correct copy of the repair invoice is attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked Exhibit "r." 23. The sixth warranty repair attempt is believed to have occurred on or before July 2, 1997, when the vehicle's odometer showed 16,569. On that date, repair attempts were made to remedy a noise emanating from the back of the vehicle. A true and correct copy of the repair invoice is attached hereto, made a part hereof c. Implied Warranty Of Fitness For A Particular Purpose. 39. The purposes for which Plaintiffs purchased this vehicle include but are not limited to their personal, family and household use. 40. At the time of this purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Plaintiffs have justifiably relied upon Defendant's express warranties and implied warranties of fitness for a particular purpose and implied warranties of merchantability. 41. At the time of the purchase and at all times subsequent thereto, Defendant was aware Plaintiffs were relying upon Defendant's express and implied warranties, obligations, and representations with regard to the subject vehicle. 42. Plaintiffs have incurred damages as a direct and proximate result of the breach and failure of Defendant to honor its express and implied warranties. 43. Such damages include, but are not limited to, the purchase price of the vehicle plus all collateral charges, including attorney fees and costs, as well as other expenses, the full extent of which are not yet known. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs respectfully demand judgment in their favor and against Defendant, in an amount equal to the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral PENNSYlVANIA MOTOR V[lUClC INSTAllMENT SALE CONTRACT, H AUG _ _ . ,19 96 Accounlll Oalt'd ANNUAL PERCENTAGE RATE The cost 01 YOUI Cledll is ayeallytale FINANCE CHARGE ThedoIlJI.lmounllhf" credll Win [o~l you Amounl financed The l1mQunt 01 credit provided 10 you 01 on yow twhdtt T olal of Payments The illllounl yuu will t1i1ve ~Id afler you IldVI~ IIIJtlcall \cllcdulcd payments 7,75 6799,05 0' 26808.39 33607, 44 % $ , I Your Payment Schfdult will bf' N~12~!!.~~t\ - A~ounl D!l~\r~1f,- !,hfon P~Y~~h All Du! $ _M~n,'hlr.:.~,,~n,,"r 2 r-st'P $ T alai Sale Price The lolil cost of your pUlCh.Sf on [ll'dl!, meludln! yOUf downp.ymt'nl oil 4770.29 , .38377.73 1996 Security: You Ife livinr' stCunty intrlesl 1ft tht motor Yttucle btlnr purchued. "'PI,In,"1: II YO" Pi' olf tarly. you .,n nol "'we to PlY' pen.n, Fllinl""; S . lit, Cb",,: If I pl'fmtnt iil.1e, you .,n be cf"'Ctd "of 1P\e porhon of lhe Plymtnt .h,ch" lile 101 each monlh, Of Pirt of I monlh ITI.I!!'f than 10 d,yt,lhat it frmaim ImPlId See btIow 1M any olhtr Confrlct documtntJ lOt' anr ,dd1hoNI mtormatlOJ1 ,bout nonpaymrnt, default. any requlfed ffPJrmrnl in tun before lite scheduled dati .nd prrplyment ,elundllnd pel1Jltle~ . Wins f~hmJle II YOU DO NOI M[(I YOUH CONIHACI In Ihn Conlu,!. , OBlIGAIIONS, YDU MAY 10Sl IHI MOIOH ..." CUHBI!:RLAHD VALLEY IIOT 6714/20 CARLISLE PIK IlECHANICSBURG. PA 17055YlHICIEANOPllQl'[RIY1HAIYOUBOUGIH ".. S[ll[t, '---- ----___ ' WITH IHIS CD1ilRACI AND/OH MONI Y ON ....O,.T. ST Add"" ltp Cod. OEPOSIl WITH IHI ASS1GHI[ ,~ n. UKP 475 Hr. ROCK RD P,O. HARRISBURG PA 17108 '0"," STI!:PHANIP: L.STUIlP 475 Hr. ROCK RD, P,O IWlRISBURG PA 17108 ~~"'~~~:~:."'Stl1~: Ih. eUYIRIS), Namthl Addrfnln} -"---~ Codf(\J mtendl to mien thts Contract to IfIt Assl'fIH. Itemintion 01 Amount Financed _.._--~ --,. en" Pnce lllh~f rs more lh..n ont Ru~. nch promiW1.1tt>>f'ltf, 'nd fottlht'f. to par." lums dlH! uS .nd to J)ffform ,ft alfHments In th~ ConllJd "----'-m--l~ ,----- ----,-----.-- TRAD[,IN 1991 DODGI!: OAICOTA 8573.00 3802,71 Yuuh.lvetradrdm lhe htlluwml vrh'l.le 4770, 29 Yt'oIl ..nd MoI~f $ CfO\sAllo.'lItt' -I Shn O.1fl1 ~$ r-M hade,ln s,.,,,, II ~ b~f.l/\U 110 sM OWIng on the ~hlCle you h.lye bidPd tn. I1lt Stft~ .m P"~ off n\lS amount on your bt>h~tt You .""Jnt ,nel ff'pU!'wnt to u, 1tI.1llny f~ oI~~~t~~_!f.~_tn ht"n~ 1!""n:..t'rn:uRl~.I.~':.~.~~uflty~!~~~t'.'~~pl_'\ \~~_~~~~_~~f!!"-1!lIo~~I..'.:.~h" .ll.!n~ :" PlOPUlY tNSURANCE: You m.l, (Mo5.e ttlt PfflGn ltlfouCh whom lfl\UJitn(f IS oblilltt'd 'r"lll'.it loss Of d.limiet 1II the Vt'"tlll:tt! Ind ,g..'nsf ltibthfy J_~lllII!.~~!. o!...u~_.l!'...!I_..I'\tI~lllP u',I"e._V!htt:,!_I"]~~oll'!~I.Jou_.'_e.JH~~!\l~~!!.\~r_e_~'~_ Vt'fll~Ie_~!W _"tl"p__~IfI.~u,~ Ct(DIl INSURANCE IS NOT R(QU111ED (Il'd.t l.lt Inwrlnte and e'M!' Dtubtllly tn'>Ur~n(f Iff not ftQUlfed 1" obl.,n [ffrhl. 'nd wIn nof bf "fO~I(led unltoss ,OU slrn ttt40w "lid "Cfee tu poly ttlt i(hlfllGllJI tll\II\J J'lto,,>t rl!id ttlt NOllet Of PHoPOstD tRIOlt INWI-fANC[ on lhe! rtvfl'\t ~"lt' YI.lIil' Ifl\UlilJ(e tl."ll!!lc..lr 01 pokty w,1I h:!1I 'IOU 1he MAXIMUM ..mount elm\ufinrt ilIU11Jbte AIf mw'..lfCe Ptll(\'I.\l"I1Wllf be tar tht! In", at It'l."tletlll ti, i1rnmf. you stlttl Slnflt C'("hll,fe InsuJlncr WhJt I'> yOUf .'Ilch cosh S _~(_A_ . 1ft' _. 'fin 1 Slrn.llu1e ol8u,'llo' bf rn\u,td tot Stn~Cfedlt I Iff In,wlner --- fly l'l"lfle. you wlfet SIf'l(1f C,t'd1t AWdtnl & Htlntlln\Uflnct, .t\lttl to\h S __N/A___ Whit 11 YOUf Iff' _ Yflll I So(NIuo. 01 flu,.. to be......, lot Soncte Oed. ""_ & 11oo111I_. Br slfnml. t'Ou both Stlttl Jom' N/A Clfdlll!te hf\lHIIlt r. ,,'ll(h Utits S ". _... buill_I .... Clod<u 'A Ai:C*flt &HtJlth 1tl\UfM\:l!. "htttl(l..lf'-_.__~ WhltlFe y&u11tn' WhIt Iff Petctnlllf JGUlI('le'S' tobe """led --' 1 Sl(tl~hlft\of both Bu~s to bt'tn\Uffd Iuf Joefli Cttdtlllff Ift1Uf,nc-r-- ~ltul"ofboltl~ftu'fl\tobtlflwrt'd-;;-~i-^'- ----, Clrdli Atuk'"'' .. Ut....,,, 'nWf....'. In,\,,_~ v[H'CU: YOlt luvt' 'f'et'd to plHCMV. tiftdft' tht 1ft",,, cd "", CIftIIICt, tfW tuIIowtnr IJIOIOf ",uell.M Its fatl" I'qUlPfJWflt .hl:h is tlMfd thl hVrhl(lt"lftU",CIlfll!JC:1 _N::]_ YUf ,,~ M.h Senft 1996 'ooixoi;- 2500 PU RoofS11"'_ No_C~_ TIC VIO _'I~.~'O~ flp""'t ~l'" Ntmlbff Hl7H 2 3110T"191956 IQ""""," AI PS AMIMS..... H/ld Wt", __-=- A.~_..:>::;;:UI,_p, W __AM fM_'...._ __~Vlflyl lop AUICIIU We mol., h\ltflltU\ Co<<IIltt and ~:.ltt, l;t(lt' l:ulltlKt tl1. \ublfillWllt J\....nn. ttlf 1rt'''' .tw tt'1\'I\ "" WI. " fonll....' ltl\lltllhl' ""u',l~ rlt't~nt ,h..lIlwlont hi Jrnt t~ n\'fftfflt"lll 01.... _,*...m _'__......._.., --------- '.... '''wt"'"'. fl tt... A'I'IlCflt'tl\\ttll\ Utt nt .. Itt:!jh. JIlLt bffltotlh 01 ftwo s"tIrt lit ttu\ W.fll".l<lt ~.141 .1!1'11 4:lld I' s.4Irt m...." In nlf. VORl! tl.'Nll AI:D PLAINTIFF'S I EXHIBIT _.,_~u ." r(l ':'fT!jO'h1llhl Ru~t"hl, tu II.. all \Ulft\ ~O"t9 CO tiC"" Ail, f1f'wn \,'I\mf ''''' Cll ,\,tftt"l', ltfttmt'1l1 t..1u Cu, ,M It) l'flluUl' .It .t't't'lllt'llh IfI ''''', luHtl.i\ 1 C8 S,<<M' ~ CO 0."1ll AfI' pt"lwn \.pmflf lhl- rlf O*l1{'l'\ SriU"" rlJ!jrt""W{I 1I* t'lrt'\ 'Ii~ ~ lMUt<, "'.!"'t' If' Jl'l- \'r\'1 '" .',,! 't'tt\ \('"11.'"."" fI'\d t..".lht-t .,,1"1 ,It t.o 11.tJtli,1 ,rllt !it.l,~q\l lu tlt'ffl.lllill!lI 'i't'"nwt'" ," r>. \1'10"" A~I..t''''rlll ."Ll.." 11"""11),11'\ 11'1',,\ 1 <.\,,"..,.1 1''' ~I'! 1"'1' '-"llJrtll~ III t'.,'. ,,,,lllHl $ 30_201-=-<19 C.sh Oownp.trmenl $ I'll'" NttI "adrIft $ 4770, 19 lotil OownPlymenl $ 4770. ~9 Unpald Clsh PfI(f lUJ,nct $ 25.]0,71 Yo C,td4Im"oct Compjny , NO; te Pubhc Olhc~l, hw' lKfn\f. TIC' and ReoClstllhOA I litnrft 5,00 ~_RLM!LV~r.l.tL 30,00 ,_SJ....X 1297,68 I, $ Iii). TIU 'I'Alf $ _f.... $ r_, Cbrat _$ 67U..OL Illel,l P_.II....IloIen'" $ 5 26808. 39 J ~?rl-+ ..,...t $c,.4.1. . hi 'I'" t. Pi, ""'...A_r_....._I.. 72 --......_hIt ........,~e1$ ii6,77 'Uft. .,,_ I 11"11 ,.,.~"t It I 466.77 I....~ .........1 ." be dot.. S tp " 96 ,'nd"'" ~,....nl1 " $ 466,77 ...,.....t ..I be dut" S r:p 19 96 . and Ihtn pJ,menh .. be due Oft ttw yme dlY of fKIt mont! Wow.... SE(Ulln aCln.(I': 1. weure 1M pa,ment of I. sum! due and tht ptttorm.nct 01 . ff'QUlftd ubllc.tlOft\ Wldef ttu, ContrKt JClU Ifwt I Stcatflt, tnlPfnt In 1he VehICle. 1Il!1l pj.l le;dled RKtft\lOfl\'"l ."_htd te the YthlC" .1 &II, "1ft 1u:.o!, .nd If' 1ft, p,ocud' 01 It, Y"\Id~, MKlud1ftt tD\IU""t pl'OtHdt 1t1e ASS!I"" Ny Sort Qft In, .moun's dut Ind .,np..' undft I,", C8fl1'"d 'lilR\I jft,of youf mont, on depo)tl..lh A)\llntf lhl\ tnelud" In, mOllr ekb f\ ""' 01 _., 1ft Itw fulu.. be depusdrd wl'h A\~,tnH by YO-' ASSf(ntt m.r do III ~_~-,!!,_pt'~ ,!!,!.!..Io~ AODmOlll 111.5 AND COIOIlI015: IHIS CONIRACI COIlIINlJ{S ON IHI RIVIRSI SIDI ,ou ARI otll1GAIID '0 All WI HRMSOIIHI WIlkie! WHICH AmAR ON tHI lHOll.., RIVItr.il SIOlS NOTICE TO BUYER-DO NOT SIGN THIS CONTRACT IN BLANK, YOU ARE ENTITlED TO AN EXACT COPY Of THE CONTRACT YOU SIGN, KEEP IT 10 PROTECT YOUR LEGAL RIGHTS, ~.A-Wj/ 8UYIR~d~-:~r .'''\.11 I......~, _.______..~___._ oIr.C'__ 11.11" ..........."....."....,..'''.."........____''...1_. ~.. - ,.-. , $ti-nJlulf 01 Ruyer 10 tit ,"suled 101 Single Cledrlt~i;~e- I ,____---- S.grulute of Rurtl10 ~ In\urt'tl lor S'"P' Dedll Aculrol & Uti"h IMulance H, Stinml. 'OU bolh srleel JOlnl MIA C'l'lJillllt In\ulinn. ""hleh co\1s S ____._ H'Sllnml. roo both \llftl Jom' ut'tltlu JA ~"e Accident & Htihh In\urancl'. fllulh u"J( I.~__ your ,len' Pl'fctnfilt 10 be Insuled WhitJrt ~our .ge\' I, ,---,--,---- 7 Sllnllu,n 01 boIh OUyffS to be InSUffd fDf hMnl Cttdlltlle InSUI,nee 7 Slln,lum 01 both BUYIn 10 be IOsurtd lur bot C,edll Accident & He.hh InWllIICI Insulff" YIHICU: You hlV' 11,m 10 pu,chne. unde, Ihe lefms ollhil ConIlKI. lhe f..in. molOt ,ehKIt lod lis Ialfl equlpmffll. .tuch is ulltd fht "V~hKIe".., Ihli ConhKt N/U Yt'" ,nd Ma" 5111., NEW -1996 -OODGr:-- 2500 PU Dod,S'I.'!. TK ~ V10 huc..'onC4rPKft. Se,'" Numbd 3B7KF23WOTH191956 Olliff (quiPJl'd AI PS, ~MrMSI.... SSpd w,l~ Ae PW _AMrMlape '/on~-,-Ofl ASSUiNU: We m,l, IUlen IhlS Cooll<<1 and SKUIII, Al'frlnfnl to I urn Itfllnn tamPlin, .hlCh It 1he '"ASSllnHM If Iht Assilflft nsaps Iht CO"IIKllo. WbW\lutnIISSIIflft. ttlt lerm .M ,elen 10 W(h ",1htqWf1II\sr.~ Anti ttlt "'''rnmfflt..1 "CMs Ind benefits of lhe Sef\ef IAlhis CenUlt1 ,1M In the Seeu"" Alftement sh._ btIonl lo.nd be tnlufte.~ by tht AiStlnte, lhe A~ .1' noll" .ou .hrn .nd If StfItI fill'" 1ft nSllnlMnt nlE YORI! OAf'll( AND TRUST COMPAlIY, Ycr~ Pa, 17405,0969 eO,5ICIU: Any pmon SIInm, tilt (o,Sipor'. A".._I below fI""'''' .......lfty.nil 1DIt"'" wdh.1 (0 $lpe/N.nil Bv",I>I, to....,.N IV"" due Ind 10 ptftOfm 1IIIIfftmfflls In Ihit tonUKI Co.$ll"e, WIO lot "'II Ow..., 01 t", '''iell, CO,QWNU: An, po"OO.....I'". (0'0...... s.cU!~, .........._ ..... us A S<<U!~, mI."", mlhe V,,,,,,,.nil '..'" ..p...le1y '"" 1DIt"'" .1Ih aft ClI OwMtM Ind 8uytl~l. to petlofm 1I'l'ffmenlt m thl Seeufll, Arrrtmfftt.nd lfIottltf parts 0I1hts Ct.Wrld elCfpt IfIt""PrOlftfW 10 "," ~tlOft. TUIIS: The Iffrm sho." m Ihe bolfS Ibcm are PIn of If'llS CanUm PlOMtS( TO 'AY: You '1'" 10 Pi. us the Totll SlIe f'tIU for '''' Vrhc:It by fftI~1I'l11he 'aI" eownp,I,lMnllnd P'ylfll us Itte Amount f ""nud plus ",ltlnt You IJfQltlI\t 10 fill." PI,fNflIS In ilccOId.nce WIth th. '.yment Sdltdule. You pt'oml\f' to m"e 1U,lftt'flfs on Of be'or."" wmt d,l, ot lIeh monUt IS Ihf hlSl p.ymtnf due d.fr You .er" 10 pal' .In DI~ ,mounts WNth IN, bKome due undrr Ihf knit' of fhtl ContrlCt You IpH 10 pa, thf Selif'f Of AUIIItft tom gf SUit You.1sO IEJtf 10 SW, ,el\CWbIt ,nOfnty1,' trn II Se,," Of A\\lInt'f "fin 1ft ."",ne, to toltKl .mounts due unde, th" ConltlCl 0110 pl'otrd Of let po\V\~ ut ttIt VefKlr_ You JCfH 10 mi" par_nit .llhe pQcf Of to "nd PlYIfttI'lIt 10 lhe Iddtt'\\ .Iu"'~ ttIf A'\oIlnH ....\1 rKtn"y sptCIl1IP\ 1ft 1M "'II1t'ft ftOhCt'" you 8, \rpInl below,.! IrrH to stfI the YetlKle 10 you undtt lht ttfm\" l1Ms Comfltl CUHBERLAND VALLEY MOTORS SIIlIR 8Y: 0... ,. lle!n\f.I,,\.nd Rtll\tr.lton I llfnfH I 5,00 I.CUHBERLA~D_VA~L~ I 30,00 !o,.J~r.,EU-"X I 1297.68 ,. 10 $ !~j. TIAr. TAX $ AMOI..t fiDlftCtd l n..." CIIAr,' I totllot ",".11 (Time 8.I.nce) $ ",.'" Schadul. . You '1;"10 P" 10 IR 1t1t Amoun1 finlnced ptus mltresl 1ft unmterrupfed month! 72 ...,.....,.01$ IIcll. lid. 466.77 liu' p.,mUlt 01 . Ththf\1 ISflt)8/24(.?''- (SflQ8I..H/.96. Dlte CO-SICNER, YOU SIIOt'lll Run TilE NOTICE TO ('O-MCNrR, WIIIClIIIAS IUN ClnN TO YOl' ON A SEPAUTE OIK'llMENT. IrrORE SICNtNI, TIlE ('Q.SICNrROS ACREUlrNT, ro-SICNER'S ACRl:lMtNT: YOU.lhe pendll (Of pc1Wftl) tilniaa hdow ,,-COoSi......." promi.. ht,.,.e .l.n MImi due N Ihit COftlfKt .nd 10 pefform all..rctmcfl.. II fhi, (.'onlr.... YOII ..Iud 10 be tt..II, bullnd tty .11 1M Iff"" at Ihn l'GAlfll1. .,.,..irly an4 'optMf. ","k lhit BUyt:f. Vo..... """"'1 this prom.. to induce UI 10 m.kir lhl l'onlrKl "'Ith IhI- Huret."" 1,"",'" wt ",.0 \1M ttw P'~ onl, lor ,he All,,"" ".nac. Y.... '1'C"f t. pa, tw..ho.,h WI tN,'" hawe me.k '11I, ptHH .kmafMI rur p'JnM'1I1 on the fhl,.e, 0' Ul'fctWd _ ~Jfll: ~nlcrnt, ~~. .hu,kltttnr,.kdP rruwi"l.comptC'tN ......., ~ 1M' ('Uft"" \: (. _t!!:::b..MY}::-::' l~F.^']5 !"f~_ .OCl(_.D-,-,-..O..BOlL1l5U_BA1-0812t/g~ Cu-Silntf\ SilftlllUf't f/ / . ,,' / Addm" l).I~ \~ '''ll/~ "_)~~':!____l~~"IJ l'U-SiIMI" Si,ft.ture I E / ~_.~ . n..c u)..QWNl.a'!i ~1t:ll.IT'W ACRt:lMI:NT: YOII,'M ~ "'In.n, klo... '"('0.0....... I"I'Itw-1 ....h thl' all)ft Of ........... ht"'a.n oflhe o.wn-. of lhe Vchidc. It" la, St(lIrtty ''''1'11''' In 1M Vchn "mifW\l .how Ym. "ftl' lu N bt>tt1\\1 It, the Irum. ..llhe \"..tt, AI'"'.......... IM...twt,.... pi lhit ('onlf8(1 c_"'pt ,... Ml'nunlM To r., W\:hoa 'Vuu ..-e 1,.NtlaIM Ift..il, tlllc'ut 10........ Vi hi fila" lh." ('uftUiICt ."h,hI BllliC'I..ttd hI Wt.1l1t'IN pol,..........,.he 811"""" uf aM ,.""ttut "n'~I' ('unU.I, You 'It, nllJl bt ~rClft!olhll It.. .... .r~;WMlI .tUth IRllhI k daw .h., "I"mnUl",.nd WI" uf ,hi \'rh.dl' ._,___"___.l~""1J A:ij;~~ _.--._------ (.........._1.' 'it'hllffC l\alt' IPnh~stblNs\~~~'lCO-OWNER. AS APPLICABLE. ACKNOWlEDGE RECEIPT OF A COMPLETED COPY OF THIS CONTRAC RUI'IR Iiiilf.--- ,.------ (0 llG",i NOlin ,It IIn'II" 'IOE IlIR '''P''.UNlINIlIII''UltlN, 1A~1_.If..'..,.,I....( m"'''1 nORROWERlCO-SIGNER COpy co SIGHlR OR CO OWIIU .1")~'UIWl'" MV 'O/J;:;7.:)Oq" 119-92' ", 0.,' , VlttI(IIIlJt""tl(:'-'IIl')Nt~ut,.ltliHIVlt(I" !HIII Ifl\. I'"'''' "~I' 1~,1It111\ I'MtJlJlll(Nt 'If WlllIl) tAf't !,f (Utlll'f' HIHl"1 IISl UI" Till') COpy . Ill!..> IIC t JB7Kr2JfWiOjTM191956' 'l'K ^~ OIN/lA!~t ""41)'1'''' AUlttciiiiION()l"'llYrvollconcrmlft:n""J'[C'lONMf'CttmC:IA.'~ ....::...J., '. 'J22C ~.. If'JltlTNAMII' ..',.~ . I,... .". n ~. ~.'" ,,,f\; "'\"','" -"I ,"'1" 'No .,-." I '.u,~.\.. ,1'.~~I'", I I,' :h..... .W"~Jt~~..,~.fl I.. ..... . l..., .,..'.........,. t. " .. Icer1ItythallNi"".....IlIdIhaf.IIrgtbIe~~..::~NH[H( '," ," : ~ .' IrK*'qWlRJlblt~&rdrtIlIChl .'. ," ", , . ..... OOlESEl OflECTRlC ~vw!-~.~~JIt'~I't\ini,"""', .1,'t~ll"jjl....~I.I. ~AkYffll,'....!,) t''l'-r:f~~.ht.~,_;,r,~~.~ l},ST~ lOR tUtl HlJSM<<:~SNAMll tfj~1 NAA4I; MlUUlI: 'PllllAl UfAl(H IIJNV"'Ul.H STUMP, SCOTT A. " AI"lCNllll MMI:' Of- 'It I tiC! t DODGE ""It GnOSSVltllut WI f ~ HAIIt4G . -~ ,. ~ FUEL B co.PUOCHASER L,STUHP,STEPHANIE :i 6 ~;"'~r li . 475 MT. \ ~ ' ' 1 NOTE F A CO.PURCUASER. OltER JItAN YOl/R SPOUSf. IS lISTW "uovt. TItlE Will Hf lS5Ut:O AS "lNANI:> fl I..:()WAfIW JUlNT TU"'NTSWlTURlGtlT Of SUfMVORSlF . . A. r-K ,ONUUntOfONEOWNlf\TlflEOOl:ilO 1~ In. . U' ~OWNEHJ NOTE:1 F OtE vtttlClEtSBElNGlEASEo,CtIECk UIIS8L.COI; 0 nTY ~IAlI. ("IAIF ACQlJJifOI punCUASEO n8J.lli96- II' ROCK RD P,O,BOX 11523 HARRISBURG PA 117108 nit (.K ON[ Of HIES{ 1110CKS II' .~lJ fk(l(;f( IS CU[(~K[O. TENANTS" COMMON B 0 IlJf~Ot:AHlor Ot*- OWN[R. NTEREST OfDfCUSED VNNtR GOU IU t~ uH lilH HEIRS OR ESTATE I F ll.OCK ISU1f.Cf<EO.COIrMU.TE #Hi)ATIACufQUMMV.L . OlJ(M:.lf.HflEAONJ c 0 ACTlW.MlIFAGfDlfTERSFnoUClOOMETfRREAONlFOR "ll~ H{.Aso"~onll,H TtWf(.;AllPRAllUNtfifk.lfINON.;TUAl.. ~ J MlFA(it- 'S\INK~ . j ~ MRNN:i AN INACCURATE ()()()METrA STATEMENT MAY MAKE YOU lIARtE FOR 0AMN"A:9 TO YOUR 1 ~~~~~~~:::~' TLll4WloOf "*,WOlOUVEltlU.E...ORMAIUNANOcusr 1I 1ST llE.N0A1[ VOl ~"ll ~o + F NOtI(N,Cltfn<D 1N01IlNOAIE ~ 'STL~M""Of..rUKKtlJ\NK i TRUST CO, 2NOL~MlOIlJl" ~ I, STllflT 11 r.rrr.-"Cl:'mrerST, SfI'" r ~ CITY IUNK STATE PA lP J 7. 4fy StATE ''"!':"IoW\ElIfv(I~H IVIN J87GG23X511S3S1380 hlllOUtl'1lAH ~:~ BOO'thPEIS{)N nus lli. ltCI TK n ':---l~Ot'''ll'fflot "'-t.;;t"[.Jf'..tXlO [.lf~ IJ~.JH h\~',fM.itll "'''''-SfNGiR U ''''lJ' llMOU~LJ ~.1""'1I U l,4A',~ I J Olt.IlUII:.lAIIUGCAf'AUTY IAlIl.Au:,; .1 .;). Roll::; lioA~~S" _ flU'" II: -~._-- -TYlhniRf.AMf7'[J' YfS O'N() ffll.-~Kr... r.,JI'~.-oq-'-O' .1~TI) O(Wf'.!lI.' MOTOROClf "':.olJ\~i.:;.~IH~J~?___.-___::::!.::.:'-lIUt~'(.~R_~:-, ll~~___~__, _____ 1'.~)~g;I'Hl"t'~ l-f~L~~~ll L]Yf~_O~~~':I.~t.~~~IOD..':~-=_Cl~~) .' I~MOI'rD ~~!~~~~r~~'llON ['1'1fS [J"'}__~:~~~~A::'l~l"I'(J r::'1"'5 [1N{) "MUTUfll~AA "~(.ItA'>~I~i;"';';; ._.._-- ._- --. -.-- - R(i.I~-.M~i'---------- -. t~~~~~ '. .-NUMf\ER Of AXlES RiO"!GC.~~Rr'Or.ROSSWTtKtlK.<<HOAO' IMHlJW 5lJUOff'oIIWRS uP-a40n~V'fT(rMPrY) lL~ TRACTOR ~~:.~~,;nHlO 6tlO:iS ~~_~[,,~I(_~~_~~!?_~.9-1'Gff(l:~~_("~~U.I~~,~,_~~_p ~ ~.1C.; ~<r... ~PSll"J'flOf>ftlfU IK'M'ANllWlt'Il(I')lIfllMtl u~u~ rJ~~( , Or:1+I'tn~~Jf>lllfD O MlfAGt:oVtR W,II'J8. , TOnus J 63181 , ~ .'. 1 " " I. lAX AND fEES PURCHASE t:'.'~-" -- - , f'fOCl - ~; .'. " ..... l~mh~~~~I-=..:~ __:.102ot1oo II:,', l""llf .1'" . .. IAlCAntF AMUiIUf _AS7LOO X 6\ 1061 SAUS tAX l(l'\!01)f1tl.ARt~ -IS-raMon,.,...,..) IF !is tAlC Cl<f0fT 2J.UYQ --11n--6.a. . SAlESTAJ: '7 11I::. DuE ,..ll27......... ""_~_""", :, =-:"~'.r~li) ~'~j I.~;..t::-:,~ ,....,....,'. . '.' \B:i.~~/'j I,,), ,;,,:'; : <M".r.iIll;h','-"". I, c' ",Il'J 2 TITlE f" LEN fl:E l~, 00 s, QQ.. ~ If NO lIr.N.CHH;";O. · AEGfSrRAmNOR f1o.J:~~~f(t . '" ql ,..(w,:W~'... ~1Ir..~>.. , ... ~ '--If" ILAn fWG ,n NO '"' CAAllS . . tRANSfER fl' __kQQ_ .ICJl[ AS{ III 2J.00 . f<<PlACfI.lENT ". . . lOTAl. ..., l/UA)t lfH.is, s.na 0.. (,,.,.... ... fI_ An1l.Uf . 1342,68 . CIRlGlNAl f'lAlf J/ f'he<" One l~~WtSllRO' P!l(1A1I.1Sl'f lS'MJtfll'lAll O~:::.A~~:;~l~O~~._ ,.~. DtRAHsrER' fllPl"C(WENt Of PUT( "'t)~Itit:AI''''''--''llll fIl.Al'E~_;', .. ..' o "CU'HGf f'1'" TO _ 4700&~3iUJ.; 1~ltlJal U\lflt.AU EIU'lHtS 11 96 OIOSf "~O~(N DnrncfD DNr\4:ARf:cOltOS,...........1 ,D'~'~L:.',':~.c", T1..ffi~WM8'~' ,:-; - - NOTF_"_~EVfR[~"'ElVfO~:: :-:::~:::: "'c!"1 ~eForm_MV:44_ I Sl(lNAt\JUf {Jf J'lA'il."'l IHil:-'- W..1M.... .-.1l-ij'IIfRf -----.--.----- rtnAll(lt&..'U....,,'t..~ANI 111~:...r~..':;:~;llltA..:"lttlQIII. 1'111'1<., ' " ./ SPOUSE: ! rWNJftA~~~;~;;:~NS ~ --~ "-------.-.-----I-:.iE;,;':;.'.~~:,-~.--,L._j._~~8;6;Oo~1~~y;~';~/Trv;6 --It.~,.;l~;;w.i~;;;---' I I-~- AVe 24 ..-- -, 96 0'>'...,,,"", ."..r.....,-'~' ",-", -.. AlifNI",,-lOlO2l96 '''51.... '<l"Tn"..".,..."."" ""___ ,_"AI'_..__ CUKBERLAND VALLEY KOTORS !'8S.-ll2.rlJ I 1",11'-01 IIIA.1 ll.I~11l hll""^Hfo.~. THAI hM: \111..11 I') t!\i'.tll,tp At4l -. ... --l'J," -- - !\~\ - --- I :"l+dt.....UON [''''''''ofll lI....".,Ail1' """',It,AII(IU TO lilt ...."'VI ",~,.. .\Ill" t','.lIlNl,AlJ.;l "..".MllHl II II 1'l1l.1INI '"f I i"iMllW\Ht.1 Willi 41\ At"'11l AIUf f'fh~lIn tll It II VI t"'lI ~,1('t 17-<"7-""..8 I """!Ol~""ll"""'lllll.tJI."I"IN'" ,,7 .,." , . 1/\iIrt A(flNOWUuut WAf 11M MAY \O~ M...,mm lWtMAllfilltA t'it1\ltUlotl':>l OM ""HtLll t1U.ISf...."tlfili!i1 tOft IAIUHlt III 11.\4'-1"'''' .....trIt,;lAl "l~S1tltIlt.. ON IHI. I nJHMt,.,u tlHi'~II..to \lt1ttt;lI tOM Utl ....1"Un Ot tlttit1iUtAI~ 11m IIIM"..-" A\....Mrttl~ tHAt 11M....... m ~JlU 1101 A ,..... lIlI\if ...t.u...... I"'ouu AIIIU ! .......'..............1 ,.. "'-II MUMt. lHA"lWOtll1'tAftS'll1il .flY 'AIM ""AU-'-N' 'nAIl/Wi MAkt UfW 'UI'lotOHM. Afiltl IIWl U",.... t...., flwt.ttAvt ta..MW\U ANU s.u*,tU .~. tHtS 'Oft... ",nflI15 CUI.4ptl ftoM..lt.1tIU IHAl.1I- AN t. 'HoM ...",...*,1 Of- S."'ltS ,..... IS n AIM1:0 I AM/WI. AMI AU1HOMtl\b fU Cl..... 1t..'It l/l.tMt'ltuN I./Wi I:. ,''1l ~ I'!flt t. A'otl ~... "'" l'lI+IHttMC.~'M'IU 1I1A1"'U "IAUMt,IilIISHt.lUINAMt "tutl Ar.oCOM"', (;I .NO.......' ........ILA11U'II . f"IIf""'l~ _.n."ilJ,__..,,_.llJl',______.,'t"-'li -' 'UM(lHlltk:lt.llOl11U"Utt'utVttOCltO'"cMltlfU""'IlK'''.A_._'-___a__.__ -. - 1....'j,ol,l\,HI ,~ fI'.Ol"""l('*4 1__ """""blll'j.ll.,tlt I. "","'''''1''. tlf f'tR......AlIUlNI'ioIlJlNl.llA.U ~. ~ - .-- ..-.---- '....."'''fl.t~~-.0;.,.M;.lIillll~;~-.;~'k-;.-rn::-.-;;H~.-'--.----~..,,-.. -.-- .. - , S \ " i E ;' SIGN IN PRESENCE OF NOTARY ,,~:-;;-,;;.-,;,---;- t7flT6'T1;571f---------------"-- ~-il t".. " ,"iIIl h..l'~h,I!"1Il '\;"'IHII'lIh "Hl l__lI I'MrSSfNGlRNUM8ER .q' It "I .'1\1\"'" ......illllll 111.1 d.l..... !"'-'.hlt ~ullt.k:t 1\"iIU!l..f [J lRAHSllR' AtM......... Of PlAlE O'AAHSHAQr "\All 'N:J'lAC(MfHt lY :,1e.:.(M RlASUH' OR R(t'UUto4lNJ 3, APptlCANT'S COPy,TtMPORARY i ...fINtlnA.,. I -.........:. -~. i l/H 1<+ {"Ovt,,,,,{,r Ulltt<;1lJf'4 , --t UJM1'lllltf N~\/'E , , , ,,',lllfVlltlU( r HI",t'.' ';-.; n I \/hflllt ~fl'~HArUArs wlJ ._'~- -- ........L.-. -' ~ t ....,.. ,',,", H~II' ../_ ' ,,','/1 '1(//' C <- -'. ~ ,../.r7" . ~J,.I I I , ,-' ..1,'i I/J;'''~~ ',~, '" (.~ ',{"" (.! IT (~'r 'l' '''''''11'1I1I'jl i 14'.;. ~ W _~,/ ./,1/i~' " J' ,\ I',"'" ,1 l ~../ 1111'>' I"" "jl J,,,, " '-"/ ~. -, 'I ' tk,l".lIl,J,l,',I'l"I< ""1 t",'IlllllW"jt, ,t..1 PH iN I "',II' 1 \lill,"f I) .1I.t (11111". >',..) 11.l"'" ~'I~'1. C' (.. ~ . lIIlAt~'. ',. 'I i, I _..' ,I. ~.." ..."l ""'1'A1'1" J 1.;'.;';//f;.-.::7J.JOr'//y.I'IIO ,I, If ~. .. I"'""." (,,,,,,, 11'11 ,.IIl'!' . ! iii) I 'I. I"" 'Ill ,,) ,"".Ii, j Y..".'. 1"'''1'_ J;';, J:If; 1/1<..'. L( 7." '1\..., nlll~ PAIr- II' ..4"It!,'I', ;";,1 lA, "lllT . ,1,IAllll! J'"ltNAWIAt41, ,''''' :It, ''''1.;,/ ," "'uIAI,1 1""'\"1 ! . I" l).) ;'.1 I ' -', 'j ,,"t'It IIl'V , '~""".'~ .1",~_ ','J ./.- '.. _',Ii ..W....~..l ,,," ',II ,,,, I.,. .....~.;W",.W "..1 II"" .,.... II "..-.", <0' "",'.1' "111.., 1 '''' .........'."1'..... It" W'"I.''' ""W,..II"",~., ...., .ot.lHA.", ,'11...,',..<1-",,,,1.., '.\....11'....1\-" .....1 "All _ '/' -. T- .-~---.- r:_~_~_.:.~.,. , i"'>;W '..... i .' , {, .~ .. 1 - I""'"'''' ~l :J! /, I, .,' t,,\fl _________._, ___.__n...n I",I(~I ',-/ ,;"-,..t,. .. ,...., !; (~, lit' 1'_ -~ri"A~~ , ) '''illY f," ,/ '.. ]..J '.",I'",j .,'f1'A,..." ....'.. ~\ " ~',)' 1'\-' il'oj" (~,' f IIIAN', 'A-. .", , " - ~ ~,. ..' - (. !"r., 'j",,! [II\l!' Pillet ,',,'ll"","'t H' ""'11" 'I<tl'.-..,I\'","\ I'M."I' > ! .\,: II lH'f 'i'lll:,tj", -- ..-t ,f AI f H IN~1All t (J il'llil-NS . , '"'o'-i-AU S fA."- -=-=-!-~- -'.-'----- n._.____ ..,.. _. ."','.'''_ _____.. st"";;;"! ,- I I '''lAm f: AMOUNT l' t --'-- j i':- + .l_ " .. ,_: I~'SS TRADf tNAllOWANCf \ ,LltlO I UH 10 !lAY') I ~ '0 .- '''-. " " ,.,. :l.' "', '---'j'- "j' !; l L, "'If ~lf1fP_f~"TtnN J':: ..._--,_...I~. AND PU fAl( Ilf II f ll~ Tf \tl> 11lA.P-4'i-l lH It''~,H''{''; . , PA.O" AUl.)IIf\iT1Ilvf , Ut\f1HAI)l-\: , , i j lIU"1 IllII~' , I j qRVI{~f" "~.lli I "UNT lll'illliH~, '~~I'" I"'. I'AH!!AI ht''''ft.jl !ill ,oI-'''AlllI oil I ".I~.... ," 1.1 ~Il", r i I t, 'A',I.I-~iltllvllh' 4",\l~! 11~..l\Nl It 1 IIIIn.""ft. ",...'.'1' " r('CVM CUMBERLAND VALLEY MOTORS l"14~'U CAHIISI.L PIKl . MfCltANlC5UURG, PA PHONE. (117) 6'Jl.Y44tJ '70SS BMW SUBAflU DODGE .'_V,' -'I.I'"I'" j,,'tjf r'II""1 . - A(llll'I',', .,'. . fiop I ,0: J I J NO j Y", . ,-' '1--' " I ~"T \ ~ I, , . .;< . , it"."",1 ! " M'!""',,'lI ^'.j"ll "_-'1 F.l".'~ fIll', 1 (,A 1{ \ If H'''!'~ ' , 1 "'''''(,fI1;I1" I . ' " ,'! u., I ~i< I ,~' _, )'1..7 ,/~ ,.r ..../ . , '~'I" , 'A'l,> F"fClIVf Y I ;-__J f _PI'lt :-J~'T~r'.- .. - "'-,--:.::.'~,: , . j-' -I~"C-'-- tlAtf I ',~ --.'--' . ""1 '.r " Q(<Ht " ,Of {ltJtCTI&f, .rut,Il' . "!l,lt' . ,(otrnlC.1IHlI. 1."'I.U.i)f PlfA"'IH{ fl aOTH f_1 'rj-p.SS~f 1i1-!i-'-H.AINT'i-'-~ 0'--- ClIItHT.Al.AUM LJ '. [1 AW-, I".J AJItBAfi " It 1 I OA ACV ---; .' ) The front and back of this Order comprise the enlire agreement aUecling this purchase dnd no OUldf agrV~111t.>1I1 ~ undef~I.lOdlf'9 01 <.Iny I1ftlu'e coflCtffnlflQ 5afll~ has beett"~ Of fmlefl>(J tll10 ~ will be fecogftlll.'d I have lead the mOlttL\f punted Of! the b~lCk hereof and agree to.t dS a part of !tIlS mOt!' tfM! ~Imft as .I.t Wtlltl PHIl'ud ",huve my !tlQn.11uHI I cer1lty Ih<ll I ,Int ol k'1J.tl otl)U, dud hCf~h'f dt.klluwh~1ge ft'l:~1 01 ':1 LOP, 01 Ih,~ l)t(ltll 1 HIS OmJI" SIfAll NOT BI.COMI BINDING UN III ACCfPHD BY DEAlEll OlllflSAlJTltORllro Ill.PllfSINTATIVE AN01N Tiff EVENT or A liME SAI r, OIAllIl SIfAll NOT !II OIlUGAlID 10 SUl UNfll APPIIOVAl Of 'IfL .IIlMSHlIUOf ISGMN By A IlAN~ 011 IINANn COMPANY WilLING 1OI'URCHASI AllUM INSTAllMlNI CONTRACT BETWELN "'1 PAil III sin RllO BASlD ON SUCIf lLIIMS f w1llefmOle. l.lgttte thoU the ahove dt~Y'nbftd vphtC~ betng traded ~ subject 10 UM(lJll'.1ISal at 1t~ lime of OO!;very and.1 II It,15 aC[fved e"Cl"-S~lve m.ltM9~ sutltitHtf med'-<lllfCdl OtoI~uOlallOfl, Of ., p.lrtS.iotn:;PSSOItttS havtt been rt'plau.od IIlll.Judl/tg !ll('sl IhlS t.Mf)$.W.lIS.ll m,ty df1ef !hl' tf..Kko m .lltowduCt! d'i "ho....." h....w I .tfJ'.w to hta held IMhle ff tn.! ''''0 p;tyolt .-"noun' ~hown "thovp '"i n(ll (Ofil,r1ll1'l.lhy lfH:!>ll,;utlr'iMtll'9h.tll1l 'n thlt ~enl 01 cann~ll.lttOll OJ tH~ach ollhls agu....nent t'ly tt1e boyet'("1 ft1tf dt',t~ 'l'oh.;tlfbtt P.I'111~ 10 It-I"ln J.~ 1ItlttlddhKtdiinl,tCw'S_ fhtt sum of S_~ HUyt" h.ls '"Okl ;tfll1 ,u:lInoVltIt....tqe" dll ul Ultt .tt)Uyto ')fOVI'S*OnS ""H. P"'..1'~ I ./ <::./..r: ~ " - . , / " f~'f,' ,1._/ t_..- ;. l' {tAli L 1 (1"11 I I " "';'1. ",\..tll ,,_ l/I! ':''''.-..J..... -", iPIII,lh '''fIlII -II 4, .-,,~ Itit;' I' J., ,1,..1 .... f ,h'lntun 5121 7.. B 2 1 SCO'M' A. STUMP STEPHANIE L. STUMP 475 MT. ROCK RD P.O.BOX 11523 HARRISBURG PA 17108 HOME: 717-697-5734 BUS: *INVOICE* AK 0 L PAGE 1 SERVICE ADVISOR: VIN r{-C\iM CUYBERUND VAllEY 1I0TORS TAG MOSS GRE DEL DATE 3B7KF23WOTM191956 YV47008 7818 7818 PROMISED PC1 NO, RATE PAYMENT INV, DATE 24AOO96 R,O, OPENED READY 17:00 073AN97 48.00 CASH OPTION6: STK: 18024 OLR: CVM 1) RON 3ACKMAN 173 15:1 073 7 73AN97 LINE OPCOOE TECH TYPE HOURS A CUST STATES THAT THERES SPOTS IN PAINT. CAUSE: ATMOSPHERIC FALLOUT 23700101 BASIC PAINT PREPARATION 276 O.K. LIC/: 8557 WD93 0.00 Fe: PAKr/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 8557 23701604 PANEL, PICK-UP BOX SIDE, OUTSIDE-Refinish (A) 276 O.K. LIC/: 8557 WD93 0.00 FC: P7 PAKr/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AlJTH CODE: 8557 23701605 PANEL, PICK-UP BOX SIDE, OUTSIDE-Refinish (A) 276 O.K. LIC/: 8557 WD93 0.00 ' . Fe: PAKr/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AlJTH CODE: 8557 23702101 HOOD PANEL-Refinish (A) 276 O.K. LICI: 8557 WD93 0.00 FC: PART/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTtI CODE: 8557 23704102 ROOF PANEL/SPORT CAP-Refinish (A) 16 C . 8551 PLAltmFF'S I EXHIBIT ~ Il",nMlt\lT Of Ot$UAIMt'R 'M '.'.' ....... ltuMot...... .. ...... ...'....... """' ........ w .... ..... .. "'- .............. tt. '-'* ...... .~-, ~-. .,. ....w..... ...... ....... .. .......... ........ .... ......... ..HIt"" .. "'...~,,~. ... toto... ... . ............ ....... ~.....,... - ,- ........1iI.. "'t ~... ...._ 1. -..... ... .. .... ......., .... o;_hOn .".. tt.. .... 'If I"" ......~'. ell \Wt" ~lO,.A'\*1 CUSTOMER COpy LIST NET TOTAL (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) Dl~ .ABOR AMOUNt "ARts AMOUNT HAS, OIl. lUIIJE SUIII [f ..MOUNf MtSC OtaftQfs fOTAl CHAftQlS 'I S5 ~SUftANa ~n t.x PlEASE "AT f HIS AMOUNT TOTAlI 5121 74821 r{"CVM SCOTT A. STUMP * ItNOICE* CUIIBEJllAHl) VALLEY MOTORS STEPHANIE L. STUMP 6714/20 Carlisle Pike 475 MT. ROCK RD P.O.BOX 11523 Mechanicsburg. PA 17055 HARRISBURG PA 17108 PAGE 3 BMW/Subaru {7171 697-9452 HOME: 717-697-5734 BUS: Dodge/Shelby (7171 697-9460 SERVICE ADVISOR: 380 DAVID B LOWY LO A K OOEL \!IN LICENSE MILEAGE INI OUT TAG MOSS GRE 96 DOOG 2500 PU DEL DATE PlIOD, DATE WARR, EXP, 3B7KF23WOTM191956 YV47008 7818 7818 PROMISED PO NO, RATE PAYMENT IN\!, DATE 24AUG96 R,O, OPENED READY 17:00 07J 97 48.00 CASH OPTIONS: STK:18024 DLR:CVM l)RON JACKMAN 17JAN97 15:11 07J 97 10: 3 17JAN97 LINE OPCODE TECH TYPE HOURS 8557 23010515 STRIPES, BODY SIDE PANEL-Replace (B) 276 O.K. LIC/: 8557 WD93 0.00 Fe: PA'KrI: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 8557 85333333 SUBLET PROCESSNG ALLOWANCE 276 O.K. LIC/: 8557 WD93 0.30 Fe: PA'KrI: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 8557 LIST NET TOTAL (N/C) (N/e) , , SUBL SUBWAY AlJI'O BODY WD93 PA'KrS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: (HIe) 0.00 .*******.****************************************... (US t)t;tf Sti...Ahiftt IJ€""""""'" tAaoA AMOUNt I"AR1S AUOUNT GAS. Oil. lUBE SUfttEl """""T N1St: ct1ARclfS rOUI CHAftUfS H!ioS INSUAAtIK,.'f ~Alt'5 'A. PlEASE PAY T HIS AMOUNT TOTALS ".n"N1Of DtS4..'lAM" ,.. t.... ...... c.......... .. ..... ...........""""........... .. .... .. ..... .............. '- s.-~........................ ......... .... ...... . ......... ~....... .., ......... ...... ... ~ct.1I..... .. ....... _. . ""OlIW. ,.....- s.. 1W!I'1If -....n 1_ ......... ... ..... ....... ,. --.......,,~...... ~.._"""I .om II.. ..... .. ..... ~~-. o o 00 o o 0 o 0 1'7;,.. C II m ]VV"' t:. - DAMAGE REPORT 02/06/97 at 16:39 FED 10 23-2234441 STUMP D.R. 18235-0004793 Est: J. NAILOR SUBWAY AUTO BODY FAX I 717-243-7370 1231 RITNER HIGIlWAY CARLISLE, PA 17013-9381 (717) 243-9978 OWner: SCOTT STUMP Address: Day Phone: ( Other Ph: ( Deductible: $ ) ) 0.00 Insurance Co.: Claim No.: Phone: Adj. : 96 DODG BR2500 4X4 LARAMIE SLT CLUBCAB 20 LONG MOSS GREEN 10-S.0L-PI Vin: 3B7KF23WOTH191956 License: Prod Date: 0/ 0 Odometer: o Power steering Power locks Air conditioning Cloth seats Clear coat paint Power brakes Body side moldings Anti-lock brakes (2) Split bench seats Rear step bumper Power windows Dual mirrors Driver airbag Alloy wheels -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- NO. OP. DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGE QTY PART COST LABOR PAINT MISC -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 HOOD & CRILLE \ 2* Refin Hood 1 3 Add for Clear Coat 1 4* ADD FOR TWO TONE 1 5* Repr R&I GRILLE 1 0.5 6 STRIPE TAPE 7* Repl RT Strp tp cmplt sd, 1 0.8 8* Repl LT strp tp cmplt sd, 1 O.S 9 CAB 10* Refin Roof/XTENDED CAB 1 4.5 11 Add for Clear Coat 1 0.9 12* Repr R&I LEFT DOOR STRIPE 1 13* WRINKLED FROM FACTORY 1 1.0 14 PICK UP BOX 15* Refin RT BED SIDE TOP RAIL 1 3.0 16 Overlap Major Non-Adj. Panel 1 -0.2 17* Add for Clear Coat 1 0.6 18* Refin LT BED SrDE TOP RAIL 1 3.0 19 Overlap Major Non-Adj. Panel 1 -0.2 20* Ref!n TINT/BLEND TO MATCH 1 1.5 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Subtotals __a> 0.00 3.1 19.4 0.00 Page: 1 /)/h&tt cvm'S I~/'" DAMAGE REPORT 02/13/97 at 10:58 FED ID 23-2234441 STUMP D.R. 18235-0004793 Est: J. NAILOR SUBWAY AUTO BODY FAX' 717-243-7370 1231 RITNER HIGHWAY CARLISLE, PI. 17013-9381 (717) 243-9978 OWner: SCO'M' STUMP Address: Day Phone: ( Other Ph: ( Deductible: $ ) ) 0.00 Insurance Co.: Claim No.: Phone: Adj. : 96 DaDG BR2500 4X4 LARAMIE SLT CLUBCAB 20 LONG MOSS GREEN 10-8.0L-FI Vin: 3B7KF23WOTH191956 License: Prod Date: 0/ 0 Odometer: o Power steering Power locks Air conditioning Cloth seats Clear coat paint Power brakes Body side moldings Anti-lock brakes (2) Split bench seats Rear step bumper Power windows Dual mirrors Driver airbag Alloy wheels -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- NO. OP. DESCRIPTION OF DAMAGE QTY PART COST LABOR PAINT MISC -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- 1 HOOD & GRILLE 2* Ref!n Hood 1 3.2 3 Add for Clear Coat 1 1.3 4* ADD FOR TWO TONE 1 1.8 5* Repr RU GRILLE 1 0.5 6 STRIPE TAPE 7* Repl RT Strp tp cmplt sd, 1 0.8 8* Repl LT Strp tp cmplt sd. 1 0.8 9 CAB 10* Ref!n Roof/XTENDED CAB 1 4.5 11 Add for Clear Coat 1 0.9 12* Repr RU LEFT DOOR STRIPE 1 13* WRINKLED FROM FACTORY 1 1.0 14 PICK UP BOX 15* Ref!n RT BED SIDE TOP RAIL 1 3.0 16 Overlap Major Non-Adj. Panel 1 -0.2 17* Add for Clear Coat 1 0.6 18* Ref!n LT BED SIDE TOP RAIL 1 3.0 19 OVerlap Major Non-Adj. Panel 1 -0.2 20* Ref!n TINT/BLEND TO MATCH 1 1.. 5 -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- Subtotals .._~ 0.00 3.1 19.4 0.00 Page: 1 DAMAGE REPORT 02/13/97 at 10:58 FED 10 23-2234441 STUMP D.R. 18235-0004793 Est: J. NAILOR SUBWAY AUTO BODY FAX I 717-243-7370 1231 RITNER HIGHWAY CARLISLE, PA 17013-9381 (717) 243-9978 Parts Body Labor Paint Labor Paint/Materials 3.1 units @ $30.00 19.4 units @ $30.00 19.4 units' $15.00 -------------------------------------------- SUBTOTAL Tax on $ 966.00 at 0.0000\ $ -------------------------------------------- GRAND TOTAL $ -------------------------------------------- PARTS SIlBJIX'T TO IIVOICl FAI , 717/24)/7)70 EsHute based Oft 101'OI CI1SlI ES1'llIATlIIC CUll)[. IIon-asterisk(') itelS are derived frol the euide IlIlT194. Ditabase Dite 8/% Double astetistfU) itus indlClltt part supplied by a supplier otller tbaII tile oriqiul equlpltllt UIIuficturer. em itus biVe betII certified for fit and fiAisb by tile certified Auto Parts AssoclaUoa. ElEst - A product of Ctt InforutlOft Services IIIC. paqe: 2 0.00 93.00 582.00 291. 00 966.00 0.00 966.00 r€:-OIM CUllBEJILAND VALLEY MOTORS 137 I 4/20 Carlisle Pike Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 BMW/Subaru (717) 697-9452 Dodge/Shelbv (7171 697-9460 90 C W CHI E LICENSE MilEAGE IN/OUT 5121 80746 SCOTT A. S'nlMP STEPHANIE L. STUMP P.O. BOX 11523 HARRISBURG PA 17108 HOME: 776-9637 BUS: *INVOICF.* 776-3100 PAGE 1 SERVICE ADVISOR: VIN l A MOSS GRE 96 DODGE 2500 PU DEL DATe PROD, DATe WARR, UP, TAG 3B7KF23WOTM191956 YV47008 12282 12304 PROMISED PO NO, RATE PAYMENT INV. DATE 24AOO96 R,O, OPfNED READY 17:00 2APR97 50 S OPTIONS: STK: 18024 DI..R:CVH 1) RON JACIQoIAN 17:15 lAPR 7 5.00 23APR97 LINE OPCODE TECH TYPE HOURS LIST NET A CUST STATES THE ENGINE SEafS TO HAVE LIFI'ER NOISE WHEN FIRST STARTED COID. trI'D UNABLE TO DUPLICATE AT THIS TIME 407 J.G.M. LIC/: 8071 CD 0.00 0.00 PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: 0.00 TOTAL LINE A: .*****..**.*********.*************........**...***** B CUST STATES THERE IS A SHIMMY FROM THE FRONT AND REAR BRAKES. CAUSE: BRAKE VIBRATION 05905092 REAR WHEEL CYLINDERS-Replace (TSB '05-002-96) 407 J.G.M. LIC,: 8071 WD93 1.10 2 4761603 WHEEL CYL 1 4318080 BRK/FLUID-MOPAR-12 OZ PC: PO PART': 4761603 COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 8071 05202604 DRUM, REAR BRAKE-Reface W/60-70-80 axle (8) 407 J.G.M. LIC,: 8071 WD9J 1. 50 PC: 2X PART#: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 8071 23APR97 TOTAL 0.00 0.00 (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER : 0.00 TOTAL LINE B: 0.00 SfAllWttH Of (HSClAlMrn onClWTlON totAL. h. '.t.., .........'c~.. ''-''_t ..... ......__.....~..........I. --....~....~... '" P.....'s AMOtJNf "....two"...5""".'''''....._... ........... ..1l_ .-- . UAS, Oil. lOB( ........ W>e:tu..'f .. ..- SU8ltfAMOuNT ....-. ~ .....,..........., . PlAINTIFF'S ...._I......I~.....~ MtSC OtAAQEI ..... -- -. .~ EXHIBIT ............. .... .- ....... 10 JOT Al DtAftO(S I - .. . .. -. . ,................... !h.. _ of th.- '155 INSURANQ (. ._~ !.AllS TAX CV'!i'uMI/4 'at.., I'" ....EAII! PA'- tHIS AMOUIllT CUSTOMER COpy 5121 80146 SCO'IT A. STUMP STEPHANIE L. STUMP P.O. BOX 11523 HARRISBURG PI'. 11108 HOME: 716-9631 BUS: *INVOJCF.* 716-JIOO PAGE 2 SERVICE J\DYISOR: VIN C L A Y AK 1M L 6 PlIOO. DATE U [{"C\4M CUYBERlAHD VAllEY MOTORS 6714/20 Carlisle Pike Mechanicsburg, PA 17055 BMW/Sube,u (7171 fi97.9452 Dodge/Shelby (7171 li97.9460 390 ERIC W IAREI.LI LICENSE MILEAGI ;'1/ OUT TAG 3 PROMISED 3WOTM191956 YV47008 PO NO. AA Tf 24AUG96 A.O. OPENED AEADY 17:00 22AP 97 50.00 CASH OPTIONS, STK:IB024 OLR:CVM I)RON JACKMAN 23APR97 17:15 21APR97 5:00 23APR97 LINE OPCODE TECH TYPE HOURS LIST C CUST STATES THE VEHICLE PULLS TO THE RIGHT UNDER BRAKING. CAUSE: SERVICE ADJUSTMENTS 05010190 BRAKE SYSTEM EVALUATION 407 J.G.M. LIC': 8071 WD93 3.60 FC: XX PART': COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 8071 *....************....*******..****.......*.*.**.**** D CUST STATES THE AIR PUMP IS NOISY. SOP SPECIAL ORDER PARTS 407 J.G.M. LIC': 8071 CO 0.00 PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 OTHER: PARTS: 0.00 LABOR: 0.00 CYI'1lER: 0.00 0.00 NET TOTAL (N/C) TOTAL LINE C: 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 TOTAL LINE D: .***.****.*******...**.......**........***.......... E CUST STATES THERE IS A NOISE UNDER TIlE TRUCK WIlEN FIRST DRIVEN COID (SEE DON) . CAUSE: SERVICE ADJUSTMENT 21030891 TSB 121-13-96 407 J.G.M. LIC/: 8071 WD93 0.60 FC: XX PART/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 8071 PARTS: 0.00 LABOF: 0.99_ ~: 9.00 SIAlIUlN' o. t1~":tA""'-R ,.. '--1... .......... ............... .. ... ..... ........_ ..._ .__. t. "'-....................~'... ~...._,....."................ ........_ "1_. ......._ . ...... .."'....... ... ......... ..1"'" _ t......."hao........ . ",,_ hM . ...Iou.... flU"'" ~~... -_...... .......".. ...., "'1,.. __ I. __ 100.. ..., ,,-...... '" ......""_. ....t'" 10......... "- ..--.., l\t., t'IMf" ""''''Atl,"t (N/C) E: Of5Cllll''''1OI lAftOIt AMnUNI PARtS AMOUNt 61\5. OK. lUN: SUftU r AMauNt MtSC GiAAG( S lotAl ai.Me,,$. t(55 WSlmA,..q SAlfs fA. o 0 tOtAlS 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 0.00 o 00 PlEASE I'A Y THIS AMOIMT ./ .' 5121 8 1 D 9 1 SCOTT A. STUMP STEPHANIE L. STUMP P.O. BOX 11523 I~SDURG PA 1710B HOME: 776-9637 DUS: 776-3100 INVOICE I'AG~; 1 COLOR YEAR MAKE/MOOn SERVICE ADVISOR: VIU [{"C\4M'" CUUBERLAHD VAI1EY 1I0TORS 6714/20 Carlisle Pike MechanicsburD. PA 17055 DMW/SubaruNW (717) 697.9452 Dodge 17171 697-9460 390 ERIC W CHIARELLI LICENSE MlLfAGE IN' OUT TAu MOSS GRE 96 oqOGE 2500 PU DEL DATE moo. OAf[ WARR. EXP. 3n7KF23WOTM191956 YV4700n 12442 12442 PROMISED "0 NO. RATE PAYMENT INV. DAlE 24AUG96 R.O. OPENED READY 17:00 05MAY97 50.00 CASH OPTIONS, STK:1802'1 DLH:CVM I)RON JACKMAN 13MAY97 16:17 25APR97 14:30 12MAY97 LINE OI'CODE TECH TYPE HOURS A-CUST STATES 'l1IE VElIICLE HAS A DAD UIW<J:: I'UL::A'I'ION. CAUSE: DRAKE PULSATION 05202604 DRUM, REAR DRAKE-ReCace w/60-70-BO axle (D) 449 R.J.S. LIC/: 0759 W093 1. 50 2 52007905 DRUM 4 J4200303 WASHER-DRAKE HOSE 1 4761600 SHOE KIT 1 4761556 SPRING-BRAKE SHOE RF.'TURN 2 52007905 DRUM 1 999 OG rn.EIGtIT NIT 2 52007905 DRUM 2 3496557 SEAL-WHEEL DEARING 2 52007905 DRUM FC: 3X PART': COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 0759 05202604 DRUM, REAR BRAKE-Ref ace w/60-70-no axle (D) 449 R.J.S. LIC': 0759 WD93 1.50 FC: PART/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AlITH CODE: 0759 05202604 DRUM, REAR DRAKE-Hoface w/60-70-nO axle (B) 449 R.J.S. LIC': 0759 W093 1. 50 FC: PART': COUN'l': CLAIM TYPE: All111 com:: I PLAlNnFPS EXHIBtT D suttMlfllt 0' t"~I.AM" ""....." ...i_" t............ .. .. .... .......... ."" .._~. "' _......~.....~,.. ---....... ._"... ~.. ....-. ~ ......... .. ---. ---.. .... ..-.. ....... .. _.~...., .. __t... .............._ ,.,.... - "_If_ ....._. ... _. ..._ tot -.-. .. of .... ......... ... .__c_ ..... 1_ ._ .' ..... --. t\.;:t.;"j';-:::;:';;;'j7:';~----' I..IS1" NF:T TOTAL (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) bf flCRIPTtON ...8OM AUOUIiIIT P-ARt!l A,Ull\.JtltT GA!l Olt lut\t ~"f\U t ....nu..t MtM: OtAMC.t,. hHAl CHIt.f\("'~ liS", IlNSUMANrt ~.A'I!'l ,.. fOtALS n, ,. ~ r-~ .., 0_ 5121 81091 SCOT!' A. STUMP STEPHANIE L. STUMP P.O. !lOX 11523 I~SBURG PA 17108 HOME: 776-9637 BUS: 776-JI00 INVOICE PAGE 2 COLOR SERVICF. ADVISOR: VIN VEAR MAKEIMOOEL MOSS GRE 96 OODGE 2500 PU OEL OAT[ PROD. OAT[ WARR. EXP. .- n-CVM CUIlBERUHD VAlLEY MOTORS 6714/20 Carlisle Pike MechanicsburO. PA 17055 OMWlSubaruNW (71 71 697.9452 Dodge /7171 697.9460 J90 ERIC W CHIAREU.I LICENSE MIUAC[ IN! OUT TAG 307KF2JWOTH19195~ VV4700B 1241lJ12442 PROMlsto ')0 NO. RA n PAYMENT INV. OA T( 24AUG96 R.O. OPENED READV 17:00 05MAY97 50.00 CASH OPIIONS STK:18024 DLR:CVM l)RON JAClQoIAN lJMAY97 16:17 25APR97 14:30 12MAY97 LINE OPCODE TECH TYPE HOURS 0759 05202004 DRUM, REAR BRAKE-Heplacc (Il) 449 R.J.S. LIC/: 0759 WD93 O.JO FC: PART/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AU'l11 CODE: 0759 05202005 DRUM, REAR BRAKE-Repl~ce (D) 449 R.J.5. LIC/: 0759 won 0.30 rc: PART/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 0759 05700650 Brake shoe and lining-Replace-One wheel 449 R.J.S. LIC/: 0759 W09J 0.20 f'C: PART': COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: lIUTH CODE: 0759 05700650 Brake shoe and lininq-Replace-One whet~l 449 R.J.S. LIC/: 0759 WD9J 0.20 rc: PART/: COUNT: CLAIM TYPE: AUTH CODE: 0759 85410000 DIAGNOSTICS 449 R.J.S. LIC/: 0759 WD9) .2. ~)O FC: PART/: COUNT: - -.. .hh _ ClAIM TXrl';.:___ ___h' _ _. .__ SfAU..un Of O&ClAIM(A ,... '..... ...._. t-....... .. .. - -...-. ..... ._~ ,. -.-..---. '''' ...... -.. ....".~ .....-. ... ...~ ....... ......n . ......- -~ __oJ ...-. .. -.-...... .. --.. t.. .. _........ ..._ ....... -...-- -....,....__....t. .....- ... .. .... ......, ... ,....._ ...'" ... 1- .. _ -......., I.. v\ It-;;t;";,;"flIo al Ufit l.IST NET TOTAL (N/C) (~l/C) (N/C) (N/C) (N/C) lit !.tftlPlR)lrf ~Alln" AMO\Jf\lT ....U!o .....OUN' t....... Olt.lVtsf. ~.U"lt' .....tJltf\ll ......,_ nIAnt.(!i rOIAl Ot4nt".(, lI~!l.IN"'tln"Nn ~. AU.. r" II. totAl' rlfAr;r r^" and marked Exhibit "G." defects and non- use, value and/or 24. The vehicle continues to exhibit conformities which substantially impair its safety as provided in 73 Pa. C.S.A Sl951 et seq. 25. In addition, Plaintiffs aver their vehicle has been subject to additional repair attempts for defects and/or non- conformities and/or conditions for which the dealer did not maintain records. Furthermore, Plaintiffs 26. Plaintiffs have been and will continue to be financially damaged due to Defendant's intentional, reckless, wanton and negligent failure to comply with the provisions of 73 Pa. C.S.A. Sl951 et seq. 27. Plaintiffs further aver they have resorted to Chrysler's Arbitration process (Customer Arbitration Board) prior to filing the within Complaint as required by 73 Pa. C.S.A. S1959. 28. Pursuant to 73 Pa. C.S.A. S1958, Plaintiffs seek relief for losses due to the non-conformities and defects in the above- mentioned vehicle in addition to reasonable attorney fees and all court costs. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs respectfully demand judgment in their favor and against Defendant in an amount equal to the purchase price of the subject vehicle, plus all available collateral charges and attorney fees. . SCOTT and STEPHANIE STUMP, plaintiffs 1J IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA V. THE CHRYSLER CORPORATION, CIVIL ACTION - LAW Defendant NO. 97-4364 CIVIL TERM IN RE: PRETRIAL CONFERENCE At a pretrial conference held Wednesday, February 25, 1998, before the Honorable Edward E. Guido, Judge, present for Plaintiffs was Samuel B. Fineman, Esquire, and present for Defendant was James W. Stevens, Esquire. The Defendant has related that this case was only filed in August of 1997, and there has been a recent development where the vehicle was involved in an accident. The Defendant has only recently received the police report for that accident and additional discovery needs to be completed as follows: 1. Deposition of Plaintiffs. 2. Depositions of various witnesses listed in the police report. 3. A reinspection of the vehicle. All of the additional discovery shall be completed May 20, 1998. Upon completion of discovery, Plaintiffs may relist the case for trial. The Court has indicated to Defendant that it will not entertain any further requests for continuance from the Defendant. By the court, ./~ ~ Edward E. Guido, J. . J) '^:';i "1 " --''.1 .-' :j. ;~. ~,,; -' r'~ ~:-' I .f: I , ~, ~, ) I"",' B. DAMAGES - PllRCIIASE AND COI.LA TERAI. CIIAR(;ES: I. Purchase Price: The purchase price of the vehicle totaled 538,377.73. not including all collateral charges. Under the appropriate lemon law refund calculation. the statutory deduction for mileage. detennined by the odometer rending at Ihe firsl repair (7.818 miles) multiplied by S.IO. totals 5781.80. See: 73 Pa.C.S. *1955. Plaintiffs. if successful. ",ill opt for a refund of their purchase price in exchange for lender of the subjt.'Cl vehicle. The undersignt.-d believ'es counsel can agree as 10 the amount. should the jury find a violation undt.'I' the Lemon Law. 2. Collateral Charges: L Interest: Plaintiffs claim incum.-d finance charges and other documcoled collaleral charges as ",ill be established at trial. In addition. Plaintiffs claim incidental damages via loss of wages - due to time spent effecting repairs on the subject vehicle. C. NEW VEHICLE LIMITED WARRANTIES: .3 YEAR/36.000 MILES Defendant issued several wrinen warranties for the vehicle at the time of sale. which it refers to as a "Limited New Vehicle Warranty". providing "bumper to bumper" coverage for defects andlor non-confonnities during the first 3 years and/or 36.000 mile period after actual retail delivery. Only nonnal wear and tear. nhu.'iC. negkct and modification were excluded from coverage. It is undisputed Ihat warranty work was never declined by a Chrysler dealer based upon a warranly exclusion. It is also undispult.-d that Rmtine maintenance was perlonned in accordalK:e \V ith the manufacturer's guidelines. It is also awm.-d thaI J}el~'lldant is in possession of a copy of said warranty and is requesled to pnld\K.'C same IiII' trial. .1 recovered. 13 Pa. c.s. ~:!714(c). Section 2715 of The Unifonn Commereial Code allow~ n.'Covery for: "any commercially reasonable charges, expenses or commissions in connL'Ction with eITecting cover"; (2715(a)-(2)) and "...any other reasonable expense incident to delay or other bn.'aCh." (2715(a)(3)). If any clements of damage are found not to be applicable under the lemon law. plaintilT asserts recovery under the Unifonn Commercial Code. VI. UNfAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND ~ONSVMER PROTECTION ~L..MMi PlaintilT advances two separate but related theories of recovery in accordance with lh: Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law. Section 1961 of the Lemon Law specifically mandates. in no WlCenain terms. that a violation of the Lemon Law shaD also be a ,iolation oflh: Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Prolection l..aw. *:!01-9.2(a). It is clear from the wording of * 1961 that the Legislature sought to rctnOve the issue of wbetber the manufacturer's conduct was "outrageous" (as required by the UTPCPL). b)' limiting the Court's discretion to the mlpltade of that conduct. The Court is compelled to award some amount of treble "actual" damages under the Lemon Law. 73 P.S. ~201-9.2; McClelland v. H\lllldai Motor Americ!!. 93-CV.3399 (E.D. Pa. April n. 1994. per Katz. 1.). for example. in lIassinlZer v. Genera1 Motors Comoration. (U.S.D.C.E.D. Pa No. 87-56n, March 2.1988). the Court awarded plaintilTan additional 55,000 under the Unfair Trade Acl for a violation of The Lemon Law. Section 201-2(4)(xiv) defines unfair or deceptive acts to include failing to comply Vlith the terms of any writtm guaranlee or Vl1IITanl)'. Section 201-:!(4)(x\'i) pnwilk.'5 for a violation if the manufactllm': "makes rcpain. impnl\\.'fllC1lts or rerlacements on tangibk. real or personal property, of a nature or quality infcr10r to or below the 14 standard of thaI agreed to in writing." IQ. Thus. if the jUI)' finds a violation of thc Lcmon Law. the Unfair Trade Practices Act has been violated as well. To wit: (I) thc warrant)' was breached; and (2) the repairs made to the vchiclc \\'ere below the standard agn.'\.'d to in writing (i.c. the New Vehicle Limited Warranty promise to repair dcfects in materials and workmanship). Lending additional suppon 10 UTp<"PL damages. it must be remembered that the Lemon Law requires Chrysler to compl)' without need for litigation. By refusing its obligation at law. the LegislalUrc sought to sanclion such conduct by awarding treble damages to the customer. If UTPCPL damages an: not awarded. the manufacturer is merely faced with the prospect paying a judgment equal to a refund. precisely the same amount to be paid prior to litigation. Such an outcome SCl'\'es no deterrent effect and ignores the mandates of ~1961 of the Lemon Law. The facts surrounding this case establish a clear \;013tion of the ternon Law and as such. plaintilh.ill seek an additionaJ award of up to Three (3) times the actual damages incum:d upon successful result in this case. VII. (>OSSIBLE DEFENSES tiNDER THE I.,EMON LAW: I. Business use: Plaintiffs' vehicle was purchased primarily for personal. family and'or household use. 2. Abuse: Plaintiffs' \-ehicJe was not subject to aOOse. 3. NC2lect: PlaintitTs' whicle was not sUl:li\'Ct to negl\.'Cl. 4. Modijication: Plaintiffs' \'Chicle was not subject to modilication. 5. Non~R'IIllih' not substantial impairment: It is clear that the detects complained IS of constitute a "defect or condition" which substantially impair the use. value and/or safety of a motor vehicle. Simply put. defendant's anticipated defenses are neither credible. nor grounded in fact. VIII. WITNESS LIST: I. Plaintiffs, Scott and Stephanie Stump. 2. Bany Yeager, expert. 3. Ives BeU. NCDS agent who inspected the subject vehicle on July 19. 1997. 4. Any and all \\itnesses identified or called by Defendant including its expertS, Corporate Representatives and/or Dealer Personnel. IX. SPECIAL COMMENTS: 1. Should plaintiffs prevail. they \\iU seek a mandatory award of attorney fees and court costs pursuant to the Pennsylvania Automobile Lemon Law and/or discretionary award of fees under The MlIlIIIuson.Moss Warranty Act. and \\iU petition the Court. 2. Should plaintiffs prevail on the underI)ing claims. the undersigned \\iU seek a discretionary award of up to three times the damages recovered, pursuant to Pennsylvania's Unfair Trade Practices Act and Consumer Protection Law. 73 Pa. C.S. *1961. upon Petition to the Court. X. mJMA.TED TlYAL TIME: I. Plaintiffs' case: one day. 2. Defendant's case: one-haIf day. 16 XI, F.XIUBIT LIST: P I. Manufacturer's cxpress \\Tillen warrant). (10 be supplied by Defendant) P2. Retail Installment Sales Conlract P3. Purehase Contract P4. Repair Order dated January 7. 1997 from Cumberland Valley Motors PS. Repair Order daled February 6. 1997 from Subway Auto Body (subcontracted authorized warranty repair). P6. Repair Order daled February 13. 1997 from Subway Auto Body (see alXl\'C:). P7. Repair Order dated April 21. 1997 from Cumberland Valley Motors P8. Repair Order dated April 2S. 1997 from Cumberland Valley Motors P9. Repair Order dated July 6. 1997 from Cumberland Valley Motors PIO. Repair Order dated June 18. I 997from Cumberland Valley Motors P II. Repair Order dated July 2. 1997 from Cumberland Valley MoIors P 12. Repair Order dated August 27. 1997 from Cumhl.'t'Iand Valley Motors PI3. Repair Order dated November 7.1997 from Cumberland Valley Motors. PI4. Expert Report of Mr. Bany Yeager dated No\'ember 29.1997 PIS. Curriculum Vitae of Mr. Ban)' Yeager PI6. Independent Vehicle Insp'-'Clion Report of Mr. h'es Bell dated July 19, 1997 P17. Technical Smice Bulletins isslA-d by' Chrysler that relate to the subject ,'dUde's concerns PlaintilTs cxp'-'Ct Defendant Chrysk'l' 10 stipulate to the admissibility of all exhibits. supra, save Exhibits "Plb" and *PI7." PlaintilTs submit .Plfl" is admissible because IS USCA , 1'1 23103(C)(i) of the Magnuson-Moss Acl states that "any d~'Cision in such procedure [NCDS) shall be admissible in evid~'Ilce" Mr. Bell's repon assist~-d the NCDS in reaching its decision and is thereby made a pan by incorporation. Plaintiffs' Exhibit "PI7" is admissible because Technical S~'l'Vice Bulletins are tantamount to pany admissions of defect by the manufacturer, As a result. uthey should be admissible. presuming authenticity. 18 \~ FEB 23 1995tJ; J'lltLA21/SYS; \LJA9\JWS\I.U"1\12',.,.! 03043-413 MARSHALL, DENNEHEY, WARNER, COLEMAN & GOGGIN BY: James W. Stevens, Esquire Attorney I.D. #40534 1845 Walnut St, Philadelphia, PA 19103-4797 Tel. #(215) 575-2684 SCOTT and STEPHANIE STUMP, h/w Attorney for Defendant, Chrysler Corporation COURT OF COMMON PLEAS CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PA vs. THE CHRYSLER CORPORATION NO. 97-4364 CIVIL PRBTRIAL MEMORANDUM Defendant, Chrysler Corporation, by and through its attorneys, Marshall, Dennehey, Warner, Coleman & Goggin, hereby submit its Pretrial Memorandum in accordance with CUmberland County Rule of Court 212-4. I. STATI5lUlfT OF FACTS AS TO LIABILITY I This case involves the purchase of a 1996 Dodge Ram 2500 Series truck. Plaintiffs' counsel has brought this lawsuit under several theories of liability including the Pennsylvania Lemon Law, 73 P.S., et seq" the Magnuson-Moss Act, 15 U.S. 52301, et seq., the Pennsylvania Uniform Commercial Code and the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, P.S. 5201-1 et seq. Plaintiffs' claim under the Unfair Trade Practice Act is predicated upon his claim under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law. The Pennsylvania Lemon Law provides at 7) P.S, 51961 that a violation of the Lemon Law is also a violation of the Unfair Trade Practices. However, as will be established at trial, the defendant has not violated the Pennsylvania Lemon Law. In addition, plaintiffs' claim under the federal Magnuson- Moss Warranty Act is predicated upon his claim under the Pennsylvania Uniform Commercial Code for breach of warranty. Plaintiffs have only attempted to plead the Magnuson-Moss Act because it provides for attorney fees should the plaintiffs finally prevail and if fees are awarded in the discretion of the court. Plaintiffs' claim in reality is no more than a claim under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law and one for breach of warranty, The plaintiffs have identified only two allegedly unresolved complaints with their automobile. One deals with the paint on their automobile. The plaintiffs reported very minor spots in the paint of their Dodge truck to the Chrysler dealership five months after purchase. However, the dealership determined that the paint spots were caused as a result of atmospheric fallout or acid rain. The cause of the spots was substantiated by plaintiff-husband's own repair shop who submitted an invoice stating that the paint blemishes were caused by acid rain. Acid rain damage is not a condition covered under Chrysler's warranty. In fact, acid rain/atmospheric fallout cosmetic concerns are specifically excluded from Chrysler's warranty, Nevertheless, in the interest of the customers' satisfaction and to settle the claim, Chrysler agreed to re-paint the vehicle. The plaintiffs refused and insisted that all repairs be done to his vehicle by his chosen repair facility. In settlement, Chrysler agreed to pay for paint repairs at the facility chosen by the plaintiffs and the repairs were performed, Payment for the repairs was made in settlement of the claim and an accord and satisfaction was worked. Plaintiff-husband now complains that his own chosen repair facility did not do a good job; however, his claim has been settled by operation of law. As can be established by the plaintiffs' own complaint at Paragraph 19, the first report of a complaint with regard to brakes occurred on April 21, 1997, when the vehicle had 12,281 miles on it. Chrysler's warranty only covers brakes for the first 12 months or 12,000 miles of use whichever comes first, The Pennsylvania Lemon Law applies only to conditions reported with the first 12,000 miles. In the interest of customer satisfaction repairs were made after the expiration of the warranty. The plaintiff-husband remains dissatisfied with regard to his brake repairs; however, his dissatisfaction does not equate to a breach of Chrysler's express limited warranty and the Pennsylvania Lemon Law is inapplicable. II . STATBMBNT OF FACTS AS TO DAMAGBS I The plaintiffs have not been damaged as a result of any action or inaction on the part of Chrysler Corporation. As stated above, Chrysler's warranty does not cover acid rain damage which is a condition outside of its control. Further, to the extent a claim existed, Chrysler extinguished the claim when it paid for re-painting done at the facility of the plaintiffs' choice, Plaintiffs' complaint with regard to brakes occurred out of warranty and there have been no damages as a result of the Chrysler Corporation paid for a re-paint job at the facility of the plaintiffs' choice. Plaintiffs' complaints with regard to the brakes of the vehicle and in fact all other complaints occurred after the vehicle was driven for 12,000 miles and none of these conditions are relevant to a violation of the Pennsylvania Lemon Law. See plaintiffs' Complaint, paragraphs 19 through 23. Indeed, Chrysler's express written warranty only covers brake wear for the first 12 months or 12,000 miles whichever occurs first. There are no damages under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law. Because the Pennsylvania Lemon Law has not been violated the plaintiffs cannot rely on 73 P.S. ~1961 which provides that a violation of the Lemon Law is also a violation of the Unfair Trade Practices Act. Further, plaintiffs have neither pled nor can they prove any unfair trade practice which involves the unfair/fraudulent culpable conduct required under the Act. The only remaining avenue the plaintiffs may attempt to recover under is for breach of warranty under the Uniform Commercial Code. However, as stated, there can be no breach of warranty for the paint condition which was excluded under the warranty and which was settled. Nor can there be a claim for breach of warranty for the brakes when the alleged condition occurred outside the period of warranty coverage. Even if the plaintiffs were able to suport an allegation of breach of any warra~ty, the measure of damage for breach of warranty is only a sum equal to the difference at the time and place of acceptance between the value of the goods accepted and f I , the value they would have had if they had been as warranted, 13 P.S. ~2714(b) AM/PM Franchise Ass' and the Atlantic Richfield ~, 584 A.2d 915, 920 (Pa, 1990), Cober v. Corle, 610 A.2d 1036, 1040-41 (Pa. Super. Ct. 1992). The difference between the value lias is" and "as warranted" can be measured by the cost of repair. See, Pomoa v, Hart, 15 Pa. D.&C, 4th 119, 124 (1992). The plaintiffs must prove by expert testimony the difference between the two values or provide evidence of the cost of repair. Plaintiffs have provided no expert report which provides the value of the difference in the product as received and as warranted. The failure to prove these elements is fatal to plaintiffs' claim. Even assuming arguendo the plaintiffs could prove a breach of warranty and damages, their claim would be limited to either the cost of the vehicle with and without the minor acid rain spotting or the cost of its repair (which has already been provided to the plaintiffs) and the cost of a brake repair. at most the cost a completely new set of brakes. Under the worst case scenario the value of this case is well under $2,000.00. IV. SUMMARY OF LEGAL ISSUES: Defendant incorporates by reference the issues and authorities discussed above. In addition, defendant contends the testimony with regard to repairs and complaints outside Chrysler's applicable warranty provisions must be excluded as irrelevant and prejudicial. V. WITNBSS LIST I 1. Mr. Matthew Zielke, Chrysler Zone Office, Malvern. PAl .Hltl..I'I"S RETURN - .UMMONS/COMPL.AINT ,j~'1? cL-1):'W' ((]V r' cjo (. 1- ~v(? SERVED AND MADE KNOWN TO _ .Qr/l-L- [~~/7~j COMMON P~EAS NO. COUNTY COURT NOF'Irc, )-f 17- IJl-t/ TERM, 11 o Defendant JZU>efendant Company by handin"a lrIIe and allested copy of the within SuIDDlDns/Comploint, issued in the above captioned maUer on ! h~ <.oJ 2.., ,19 ~'J .al /0 'Y>-o'c!ack, /1 .... E.S.T.lD,S,T. at llo ~ ) ltl-B k ( , in the County of Philadelphia, Slale of Pennsylvania. to . ~,~ . Jl ( c; /' / o (11 the aforesaid defendant. personally; o (21 an adult member of the family Df said delendanl, with whom said defendant resides, wha stated that hislher relationship lo said delendant is that 01 o (31 an adult person in charge of defendant's residence; the said adult person having refused, upon re- quest, to give his/her nome and relationship to soid defendanl; o (41 the manaqer/clerk of the place ollodqing in which said delendanlresides; t'l((51 aqent or person for the time being in charge of delendant's office or usual place of business. o (6) the and Dfficer of said defendant Company; So Answers, ,.-ORIt 10 Alfl) ~ S(P 1 , -- .tn., ... 1M IIf ~ 19P)~ "....,. ,...... I. " / I , Not.l"dI S.dl ....,.... 81.... Jo No'~'Y ~blOC Pht~!pt'1.1, Phtl.,<<'tt9J!".. \,:;JJn\) . My CO"'''',''''~$('I'' E '''<IP' Ju......1 ,~'JU Mtlll"t.- I"'.rt,r<..-.J~QI""'" lI.l1 'h,. U '" JOHN O. PEEN. Slterill /; :It 'Ii <- II , IHERII'I"S RETURN - SUMMONS/COMPLAINT UWl-t ,.sho d-nfiM",Cavt' cjo (-r~V~ COMMON PL EAS NO. COUNTy COURT tj 7- (J& '/ TI[RM. " NOF!j-1 '-f SERVED AND MADE KNOWN TO ~ o Defendant ilZ1Pefendant Company by handi'1lina true and altes~ copy of the within Summons/Complain~, i~ued in the above captioned molter on , ,.:) ,19 f 7 ' at .lJLji o'clock, /l II., E.S. T./D.S. T. at - ~ k I , in the County of Philadelphia, State of PeansylVllllia, to '~ I ~ ,j jJ (t:; /' I o (I) the aforesaid defendant, pelsonally; o (2) an adult member of the family of said defendant, with whom said defendant resides, who stated that hislher relationship to said defendont is that of o (3) an adult person in charge of defendant's residence; the said adult person hoving relused, upon reo quest, tD give his/her name and relationship to said defendant; o (4) the manager/clerk of the place Df lodging in which said defendant resides; ~(S) agent Dr persan for the time being in charge of defendant's office or usual place of business. o (6) the ond officer of said defendant Com pony; ..,. 10 AltO ~ SEP 1 , tIP- ./of. lilt IIlIt .IIP So Answers, JOHN o. GIUt.N, SIl.rill < ,it.M..If'::c~"f,t: 1f'li<- n'''.'j Ibf fI l1-J. I..... 13"1 52. Denied. To the contrary. the Plaintiffs have sought help from numerous other dealerships as well as from the National Cenler for Dispute Selllement, Chrysler's "non-partisan" arbitr,lIion unit to no avail. In fact, none of the self-help measures employed by Plaintiffs have had an effect on reconciling Ihis mailer. Further. in response to Defendant's Answer, Paragraph 27, Plaintiffs aver that they in fact resorted to said Chrysler's Arbitration process and their claim was denied. Chrysler's Answer in said Paragraph 27 is patently inaccurate. 53. Specifically denied. 54. Denied. As stated in the Complaint and as shown in attached Exhibits "B," "C," "D." "E:' "F:' and "G." the vehicle was serviced in order 10 attempt to repair the defective engine, brake drums. and rear wheel cylinders, at least three times. \\oith no effective repair. As such, a reasonable number of repairs were attempted. Finally. the non-confonnities of a defective engine and brakes, most certainly, impair the use, value and safety of the vehicle. 55. Denied, Rather, it is averred that Plaintiffs' claims are not time-barred because they fall well within the applicable statutes oflimitation. Actions under the Lemon Law and Magnuson- MDSS Act may be brought within four years of the discovery of a defect. Actions arising under the Unfair Trade Law may be brought within six years of when the cause of actiDn accrues. Gabriel v. o '/lara. 534 A.2d at 493. As for breach of express warranty, the applicable statute of limitations. 13 Pa.C.S.A. sec. 2725. provides that a breach of warranty action must be commenced within four years from the date it accrues. A claim for breach of an implied warranty accrues on the date the seller delivers the vehicle. Nationwide Ins. CO. I'. Gf.'tIcral MOlars Corp.. 533 Pa. 423, 625 A.2d 1172,1178 (Pa. 1993). addition, it can be served at the CT Corporation Systems, 1635 Market Street, Philadelphia, PA 19103, BACKGROUND 3, Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that plaintiffs obtained a 1996 Dodge Ram 2500 Series truck that was manufactured and warranted by defendant bearing vehicle identification number 3B7KF23WOTM191956. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a beli.ef as to the truth of the remaining averments of paragraph 3 of plaintiffs' Complaint and the same are therefore denied. 4. Denied. It is denied that the price of the vehicle including the charges and fees enumerated in plaintiffs' Complaint total more than $38,377,73. On the contrary, the price and the alleged charges and fees do not total more than the sum alleged. 5. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle cannot be utilized for the purposes intended by the plaintiffs. It is further denied that defendant or its dealership performed ineffective repairs on the vehicle. It is denied that the vehicle is worthless. On the contrary, all repairs on the vehicle have been effective and the vehicle performs as intended. 6. Because plaintiffs have failed to define the specifics of the alleged "several written warranties", after reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge with regard to the averments contained in paragraph 6 of plaintiffs' Complaint and the same are therefore denied. COUNT I LEMON LAW 7. Defendant, Chrysler Corporation, hereby incorporates its answers to paragraphs 1 through 6 of plaintiffs' Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 8. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the averments contained in paragraph 8 of plaintiffs' Complaint and the same are therefore denied. 9. Admitted. 10. Admitted. 11. Denied. It is denied that the plaintiffs experienced nonconformities as defined by 73 Pa. C.S.A. section 1951, ~ ~ On the contrary, no such conditions or nonconformities existed that substantially impaired the use, value, and/or safety of the vehicle in question. 12. Denied. It is denied that any nonconformities in the vehicle violated any express warranties issued to plaintiff by the defendant. On the contrary, no written warranties in effect were violated by the defendant. 13. Admitted. 14. Admitted. 15. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle experienced non- conformities or conditions that were not corrected within the terms of the express written warranty issued by Chrysler. 16. Denied. It is denied that the plaintiffs' vehicle has or will be out of service by reason of a statutorily defined non- conformity for a total of thirty or more cumulative days. I ! i I 17. Denied. It is denied that the vehicle experienced non- conformities. It is further denied that any condition covered under the terms of Chrysler's express written warranty was not corrected within the terms of the warranty. 18. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that Exhibit "B" is attached to plaintiffs' Complaint and that such exhibit appears to be a repair order from January 7, 1997. Defendant denies the characterization of the service and the remaining averments of paragraph 18. The document speaks for itself. 19. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that Exhibit "C' is attached to plaintiffs' Complaint and that such I II " I! II Ii 'I I I I I , I ! I , I i i Ii " II . I I! Ii I! ., ii " :1 exhibit appears to be a repair order from April 21, 1997. Defendant denies the characterization of the service and the remaining averments of paragraph 19. The document speaks for itself. 20. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that Exhibit "0" is attached to plaintiffs' Complaint and that such exhibit appears to be a repair order from April 25, 1997. Defendant denies the characterization of the service on that date and the remaining averments of paragraph 20. The document speaks for itself. 21. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that Exhibit "E" is attached to plaintiffs' Complaint and that such exhibit appears to be a repair order from June 6, 1997. Defendant denies the characterization of the service and the 27. Denied. It is denied that the plaintiffs have resorted to Chrysler's Arbitration process. On the contrary, they have not attempted to arbitrate this matter. 28. Admitted in part; denied in part. It is admitted that the plaintiffs seek relief for alleged losses. It is denied that the plaintiffs are entitled to such relief pursuant to any statute, doctrine, law, or regulation. WHEREFORE, defendant, Chrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiffs together with costs. COUNT II MAGNUSON-MOSS FEDBRAL TRADE COMMISSION IMPROVEMBNT ACT I I I I , iJ I: 29. Defendant, Chrysler Corporation, hereby incorporates its answers to paragraphs 1 through 28 of plaintiffs' Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 30. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the averments contained in paragraph 30 of plaintiffs' I I I II 11 Ii ;I 'I Ii Complaint and the same are therefore denied. 31. Admitted. 32. Denied as stated. It is denied that the express written warranty states in total as alleged by the plaintiffs in paragraph 32 of the Complaint. Defendant's express written warranty speaks for itself. 33. Denied. It is denied that defendant's authorized service facility has performed ineffective repairs. It is further denied that defendant has breached any warranty or is [, ;i , ;! !, II otherwise liable to the plaintiffs as a result of any action or inaction on the part of answering defendant. 34. Denied. The averments contained in paragraph 34 of plaintiffs' Complaint constitute conclusions of law to which no response is required pursuant to the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. It is denied that answering defendant breached any warranty. It is further denied that any action or inaction on II I' I' Ii II I I I, II .1 'I Ii I. 'I , i .1 I, II Ii II ,I il II jI I' II !i ,. il 11 ;i " i: the part of answering defendant caused plaintiffs any damages. 35. Admitted. 36. Denied. It is denied that plaintiffs are entitled to attorney fees. It is further denied that upon prevailing in this action that reasonable attorney fees are recoverable. On the contrary, any attorney fees awarded is within the discretion of the Court. WHEREFORE, defendant, Chrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiffs together with costs. COtlNT III UNIFORM COIOCBllCIAL CODE 37. Defendant, Chrysler Corporation, hereby incorporates its answers to paragraphs 1 through 36 of plaintiffs' Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 38, Denied. It is denied that plaintiffs' vehicle experienced any defects or nonconformities which constituted a breach of contractual and/or statutory obligations of the defendant. It is further denied that defendant breached any warranties either express or implied in law. On the contrary, ,. ., I; ;, ;; ;; defendant violated no such warranties or contractual and/or statutory obligations, 39. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained in paragraph 39 of plaintiffs' Complaint and the same is therefore denied. 40. After reasonable investigation, answering defendant is without information or knowledge sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments contained in paragraph 40 of plaintiffs' Complaint and the same is therefore denied. 41, Denied. It is denied that defendant was aware that plaintiffs were relying upon defendant's alleged warranties, obligations, and/or representations with regard to the vehicle. On the contrary, defendant was not aware of any such alleged reliance. 42. Denied. It is denied that plaintiffs have suffered any damages as a result of any action or inaction on the part of answering defendant. On the contrary, no such damages were incurred as a result of defendant's conduct. 43. Defendant hereby incorporates its answer to paragraph 42 of plaintiffs' Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. il II I I I i i !I ,. i' I I WHEREFORE, defendant, Chrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiffs together with costs. COUNT IV tlNPAIR TRADE PRACTICES AND COKStIMBR PROTECTION LAN 44. Defendant, Chrysler Corporation, hereby incorporates its answers to paragraphs 1 through 43 of plaintiffs' Complaint as though the same were set forth herein at length. 45. Admitted. 46. Admitted. 47. Denied. It is denied that defendant has failed to comply with the terms of any written warranty issued by it, It is further denied that defendant has engaged in unfair methods of the competition or that any action or inaction on the part of the defendant caused or contributed to any allege damages of the plaintiffs. 48. It is admitted the Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law authorizes the court, in its discretion, to award up to three times the actual damages for violation of the Act. It is denied any violation thereof occurred. WHEREFORE, defendant, Chrysler Corporation, respectfully demands judgment in its favor and against the plaintiffs together with costs. NJnf MATTJJ:R 49. Plaintiffs' Complaint fails to state a claim for which relief may be granted against Chrysler. 50. Plaintiffs' claims are barred and/or limited by the applicable disclaimers of warranty and limitations of damages provisions. 51. Plaintiffs' claims are barred and/or limited by their neglect, misuse, abuse, modification, and/or alteration of the vehicle, which is the subject of this litigation. ;, 52. Plaintiffs claims are barred and/or limited by their failure to mitigate damages. 53. If the plaintiffs sustained any alleged injuries, damages, or losses, those injuries, damages, or losses were caused by persons and/or entities over whom answering defendant had no control and for whom answering defendant is not responsible. 54. Plaintiffs' alleged claims of nonconformity do not substantially impair the use, value, or safety of the vehicle. 55. Plaintiffs' claims are or may be barred by the applicable doctrine of laches, estoppel, or waiver. 56. Plaintiffs' Complaint fails to state a claim for which any attorneys fees may be awarded, 57. Plaintiffs are not entitled to recover treble damages. 58. Plaintiffs' claims may be barred and/or limited by the Pennsylvania Lemon Law, Unfair Trade Practices and Consumer Protection Law, Uniform Commercial Code, and the Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act. 59. It is denied that plaintiffs obtained the vehicle primarily or normally for personal, family, or household purposes and plaintiff is not entitled to recovery under the Pennsylvania Lemon Law, Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act, or the Pennsylvania Unfair Trade Practices Act. 60. Plaintiffs' Complaint may be barred by the applicable statute of limitations. 61. Choice of Law rules may dictate the application of another jurisdiction's laws. VERIFICATION James W. Stevens, Esquire, hereby states that he is attorney for Chrysler Corporation, defendant herein, and verifies that the statements made in the foregoing Answer with New Matter of Defendant, Chrysler Corporation, to Plaintiffs' Complaint are true and correct to the best of his knowledge, information, and belief. The undersigned understands that the statements therein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. Section 4904 . relating to unsworn falsification to auth~rities. I 'j .. I \ JAMES W. STEVENS, ESQUIRE Dated: ", I / -, I , C' . ! . ) l_ I I "ILAJ1/CYI.\L1A8\~\LLPQ\21'." II , : , i I I i ! i , , i i i I