HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-04774
"
II)
"
,
,I
"I
,
:1
"
/,
./
"
,
I" I
,I
,
,
'1,
t' ,I ,f,
,
'd
.I
, ,
, ,
" I " I
,11 ,
"
"
,
"
,',
,
,
"
II
"
,'1
I
"
,
,
I
,
'"
"I
,
,
1'1 i
"
'"
,
"
, '
f "
,
"
,
"
"
,
,'I
" ,
,
,
,
'i'l' "
,
"
,
"I
"I "
",
I ,
,
I, .i'
" ,
, '"
"
,,'
,I "
, ,
"
..
" , I
:' ,
,.,'\
"
,,'
,
i i I
',,1
,
"
"
",
"
, ,
, ,
"
"
, '
,
"
,
,
I'"
"
"
SI'''iT llY:~Il~o
; I:' .~Il 'nil ; 1:1:~:'I'M
MllW&t).
7',l:\1I I '1 :" III
""^'lI,UN III'Allllll"Il' 1'.1/1 L1AM' N' I'll \l)
,M!2~&O
AII'lIit~I;'r~lftIt:lIUNMII'\lI~^II,^\\'
\/
WI" ,,,,.. p. MMtI ~qN
J""'" 1\, 1'"..".111
U"NIH K.I)f'MHIlII,'1
'11I1\tI.f,l" WlIIIA"h'
'VII V, 01 111111
SIHtI~N L ~ll'IIM
(;IIIIII.to n. FA-IUll}1I .
Mhllfllt J II^MI
TIUII\.fA\(i Culll....'
CA"I C. Ill'll II
UIINIAt..4IN'I'. WAIlNl'Il
~t\JI~ttn l:1 nfltl'I' tlVlt Ttll,.. SI1o..lM ",
nllb\lllll,lI~IIlII'1
1.:"1111'11. I'llm"'\""'H,\ 17Ul.l
TIIIIIIIII-I.OI/lJ",kt.''''
11"1 '1"'111 l/l'J) H.'.IH'U
'N i'lliNII 'frloW",.t1ILIWU,~11II1
~cmber 28. 19911
VIA Jo'Al:SlMILIL 1717176kWIS)
C. Roy Weidner. Jr.. Eti4u1re
JOHNSON. DUFFIE. STEWART & WEIDNER, P.C.
301 MaJ'ket SlIee!
P.O. Box 109
umoyne, Pennsylvania 1704~\-0 IU9
Deur Me, Weidncr:
~ t
\ <-!A A v.:., MJvif'Q \Y" 1'1,\ '1-' ,
116~' cW'. ~~~\\ ~{tI
PurSUWlt to your lelter of Dcc'~mbcr 21, 19913. , have I11l11'ked on the enclosed calcndae~ the
dates on which I will be unl1vlliJuhlt: 10 silaR an arbitrulor In Ihe S1aUI.r:oor v. Mary Jane Olsen
1itisation. ClJ.Illbo:rland County Dockel No. 97-4774. Plell:>e no Ie illY chunge III address to Ten East
High Sll'~el. Carlisle: lhe MechanbbuCJ!! IIddress hllppens 10 be Judge Eukill's chambers. for whom
I clerked the previous two years. Thank you.
Very truly yours.
MARTS ON DEARDORFF WILLiAMS & Q1TO
..- ~
Ben,iumlll T, WlII'nrr
,~:~
I q 0...
<nCl "i -<(
LMI~
J N I' (1 It M ^ I I I) N 0 A I) V , <: ,: 0 A n v <) CAe V '"
nfN r II'/ I.A";N,.I "~ ~~~~,~IUI1 : I?' .'n, f!ll II 'IJ'J~~I III I ~t1 MM . . 71724;\1 ~60 I W:lIf.
""""'1..., '--rru ...--...... --Ir:l1 r.' '~I " or,. -~_. ,",' _..~- 1
,- I "
I I I I, .', ) ~
"""'m~/;;' I i , "I
"I'm;~ t f "
~' I '"
".
,J':lM ~ . ,
I ~":t::x::: "
I 1 I I I' " i i
, ,
...j.....~n~ I~ i~_
.1:'''''~RIQ I
1 I
1 ",
~ "%1111I . tl
,1
lt1.o~~ ~' I I'~l
"~""'.:1~i't i
I J.o::~1': I I
~-,,~x l h
I , \,j "-."'1
~''''''!l1l ,,' ' ..,.,~,"
J..~tl I ,J
I
I ,
'" ,..:tr:;:1lll I !
II
,
1 I
, I
.. ,
'" "
I
~",I --" ..
'1'1 ...
"
":{;:
;
'I
'I!
"f 'i
I 1
. I \'
.I
T
. ,',.:.':Jf"".;r,.
~""I~;,"" oW(..... '.:
i "
I' ,
0\ ,:{ I
"
iI'.... I I,
1 I
" " i i
, .
..... I
i
--;:Ct, ::::1 .---.--....
~ r ' '
"
fa ' , ,
, ,
I r'
, 1 I
" .1 i
,I I
"I I f
, " ,
.I,L, ~ ,I f
,'-.'
--..-... -----.
/.: ~:!,; 101; I'lL
'(W~(I"
"oil;!'; : ,:(: IlG Il<: 01 :
Q,II01'l:AlI OOS,
HL~I UV: ."i<IN,J P^ HIII'~1I1U11i '.',~O fill ":~'M.1i 717 la, O~M
<Il..rthJ\-
I
....~'''r.lf1~
I
T.~~"
~ , . :~'"
.' 'm'~
I
II: ....!'%-:"
I
.., .. ~:~..,
J:;:~l>'
1. ",n:,., ,
. '"~.'l;':
I' ., .l.~ .
'. ~".Q,o;Ili'
; ~'''''l'lr~tt.
I :
".Uq,~,;
. t~ "!fl'l'l: ,'.
.,.....i
"t. .
,~."W.}
'~:"~;:r:
\,.;,"r
':r";~
~,~{
',';'"
'k~',
,.:';
;E,
.... 'rl".
'~h':'\"
.'. '. ,," '.~
.\, ",'.,
',' ,do':
., ,~ . '
J .',' ~:;.
,.. ,.i
... ..::;.,. ,:
...--.'---
I,: .,S\IIGI'lL
~.
~"
"
.'
,',
,\
. r+
"
, "
,
..,',
""I'
I"~
'"
,',';,
(j
il
"
"
,~i
\ .~
, J
cl
,',
;r,
_______, ..".. ~"J
7,j
',1
F\
I
"
,;.t
'",
~~
,',
""--. ,q
,. 'j'Jr,'--'" I - __~-m_ -___----- "',
,9 ;", if:/ I
it: r'.1 ~ i~" I
". j J.J I
['~ ["I: ., '~I\l
, I' .'
I!, ': : ,;~ :
:') , ~,
, . . i ,:
t' _..L... · '; .~
.~..
I
I:
I'
.
"
',;
;:j
'/j
',~
1/
J
~1
---.11,
,
.'
----.--.--
----~._---- .
"O~'~()I\
'f,'
'.
, .
717~~'llR"l)i ~./fi
v
~
j:;
:i
I,',
I 'I
',I ,
. , ~I ,
I I' '!
"
.-11
ot<
, ,
.
"
:.
"
'"
",
~
;r.
"
~'.;.'
~~
i"
l~.::l)' .-....
lJ .c
I,': ""..
tj
LI
~:
I"'.'
~~:
~'.1
',;'1
t,\.':
'Ii.
1,.1
~i
't,1
~1
'..1
1;;.;
:v
~l
",C;,
.1:
(',
I\d~:S:,;I' IJG-ij,;,,;\:
i
i
~
HI-Nt flY' LAJ<lN,.J PI< ~IJt'f'nl,mi 1~.'f1.~1I II :~.^"'i /II l<11 o.na
''',-
-I.
'-rg---~;;;'-' ----~~ _..._-~
"'....lQUI'll
J "~R"
J "ClII"
I J ""II"
f ,) . ~.,q
I
Ii "'l!~i"~
q ''''l''~l~.
I
II
~I
I :
,
ri-
f
",'''ut:.t;
+" .1~'"
..j.,..~~~, -
'f ~ ~~~~' ./
,: ~:'H~. .,1
J .,:;~".;
] _t'o .: I
"C1Uq . ,
;;,': ,.J
. ':L ,', , .
, '~/~( ,
'/;~ 'I
\ t, .' _,~
, ,~! :::.' ..
. .,"
" '
...'
,
,. .---"
, I
I
"rf;..
~.~ " '.:'
"
"
'j: . . ~' i ~
,;,::,j:,
, '
'""
i
,
'I
;'<v i1
,';". II
i:~~ f-
,:-\~ '~:l\
~C-,:';,:,l
, '" ~ r! I'
:...... . "i.'~
. V1 . )Jo/:
"-. . .,',,,,
'WI: ':"'['
::~ .'~;ij
t .. ~.t;':'~
:,;~::I,i '
:'.~tIJJJiII . ";'~: r
,~ ','.:r:
i
'I
!
I
I
I
,
, I
VI,
,
I
I
Ii'
.,--L "___"..
. O~~(I!,;
~
~._.._.
1'"'1
I"
1.:,1
1.,1
I.:::i
",1
....
I, I
1,,1
't:1
, I
i ,',
i'"
Iii
, ,
-,
11i24al 8~1l1 .~/~
Ii';
,
,
- 'rr
1
,
i
I
I
, .
I:..
;'i
.,-'-- t
II ~
I,
I
l
r
"
,I,
, j
1"
Cl
~.i .
":N
I
.1
I
I
I
r~ .. ,.,
I:
I
,
I
,
,
:' ,I
--- 'JIll
, I
Ii
:,/
,
--- J
, I
"
/ .
,
i
I',
I
..
:'1
t!l
._~--,
Ij
Ii
__fl
I'
I I
'n
I
f
I
: !';dHi:,;I: ijG-IJ(;-(;(:
--., H ~ III
1'/ l"i ~,
II! '"
H
~o.Qt:JFl~ '{ '-..
:' , H
" "i
, . "'lI'la~)lI ~. ,~
,
">1 "\
" ~ ......::e>> ~,
, ,^
B !I"'SC;~t;l
i
~ t"N"'~I=l~
~ a:-lII~mllJ
Ill' Cl :!I.
VI "';!;F11f
';\ ,
/
'~' / ,
I f
_J Vl'4~Fl~
',\ I I
j) ~~~e:1lI A
~ ......::~IQ '\"~I (11
f .~:lt::~
t-J Jf'lI1':!l~ 'It' '!!II '\
'" ~",II)~j:l \
, I
'1 VI ,..:!,Q~
" I
,~ I
''j-
, I/~
j
'.
'M' '$Ii I~
::J , ~
,
...
I
'"', I II
'1
-J
'V-
I'< ~
-.,./ .. . .-._--~._-.--"---_.
.,.J
c::-
-0: en f
en
en I~. .
...
H 01)' l\!l I {
~ I I j::j' .....--.-
I
I
fa
::I f
.. r
oJ:>> " I
Iff
:. ,,' \ . i,'~ i
( JA"'-/) \ "I
.;.Ii , , . j. ~; I f
\ V if
;"J
i,.,:tt:;;Fi
,
~''I~~~1ii1
I
........~~rq
~ I
i i ~:;FlIII
1 ~~I'l'"
~ VI~t:1'I
vi "::~IQ
'1'4~~~
,
u.,\I\~e:~
i
~ 'r=fll'l
i r~t>;o;i'1
~NlfI,;!!J:J~
~"'.~~FJ
1
lit "~F:in
G\
G\
G\
...
.c
~
'"
Z
""'
:~
:Ii'
1
,
If
IF!
IF:l
Ill,
,.,
~
~-
..0
! j
1 !
11
r,l
,;.
,.
f1
:1
I.,
:;,\
~,l
l.~
, I
1,1
~! 1
~I 1
t ,j
1'1
vt
I
. I
,
I
, '
I I
1.(.,
1;1
d:~
1'''1
',:,::1
, I
,J
,
'I'
I'
!I~
11(',
I' ,
\~
'\
! j
~'! / -
f~; ,/ rt
liil ~~~
[I: I i~
i. f' ,,\
, ' . " I",~
~ j \ ~I
r,j "~:J.J
:N:
,
'I
I
"
I;,);
,";
\,;~
~~'J
KI;
'!'
fil
f!
j
~:
......
~
x', //11,:,,1
'"j
I:;
i~
,,~ ;Al'
I iii,
/ f;J1
,e!
I ~:,,"
,'J
I,.
'It:tl
:,','l
rt
',"Ij
~\,q
gi,"lj
"I) 1
, ,
;/
",I,
I :
I ·
,
: ';
I' ,~
~
;,...,~-,:,
:""
j ~i'J
";"11
\1,'1
';\11
i.:l~ I'
y~
~,')~
i --
Ii '.
, \'-'\
'(
'II,
"
I'"
;It
II;)
,"j
r;'~
!',~",:;,f'l,,)<
"1
"/', "-',
,I
;!~
,\;i
f~H
iN
i;l
I.: /
,,' ,"'vii
, )CJ\']
" .~
\.
f
, .
. ,I [Ii
:u' t; ~
"
C' ~
f" "
"
IoIl'lO~llJ i
~ I "":;:eiIQ \,
i il"'SC:~M ..
+~~I'lf'l I'
""~~~I'I
~ ~~I'll'l \1\ tj
1~~1Iill'l
r:l~1'l
~ r=~1Q
f ~]c:::
)..Ula~~
~ ~~Ill'l
""
,.,"
M
i
,i
,"1
t;r
I "
"
i~
, j f,'.,
~i;~
M1
,
~ 'i);
~ k
!..\.
:';,'
,j,
,
I
I
I
L
,J Jll--~'-----
"
_>______ i. _
--M
('
:1
en
:en
~"
,
,~.
',Li.' - ,
· fa 'I
:.... ,'i":'
-'''''''''1.,:<\,
'I.i '.
;:;,a;'" "
, 'CU
I,', ",'
ILl.
:'
OJ
.1
'\i
','
i
5
f
"
,'~,
,...
,
"
l',flt)1j
It "j"'~11M
, ....~m~
~ I~ ~.t1M
~ t lII~'lNf) , ~
~
"'CH'11l!
,I . ":1~1
lJ "'t'I"Il~
It u't'tt'llq I
f ' .~1l1'1
" '''Ut:;~'-l
i I ''lIto'tlI:1Ji(
~""I<lfl~
,,/ ,..~~'"
en
en"",
,..., ,"
w. "
.,. "
-,'qrJ,: "',"
~~i;"
ill; "
,C "',l.'
,,'j\,
t'" , ",i"',I.
, : ~1 .,
1',1"',
. I,"""
,IY,,. .,
" ~ I! '''' I
. ;'1
. .~,__.......__--l._
.~ jFl ." ~ III
1'1:
\ ~ ~i .
'I, "
tl:1 if "
,
, i 'I ~
, 'J
.
\
,'t, , 'I,
V ,
, .t I: ,.
, ". ,j'
,
. r,
..
..'f
Ii,'
I! ',I
,
Ii ,
I
I
><
,
"'I
~
"
')
...
I
l
~
%
~
i
i
~
:2!
rr- .' ~
." ...
T~l'l~1'J ~
~
II '"'~.~~ ii
m ~rllil'"
1IlC1e2lQ I
,.
"-:::!".!~1
"'fH'::lt:M
N '~i ~- -""" ~ ,-''''-~
l..t1I~j::'J'" I ...
~ I
Jat:;I; I
i
r-;o1'I\Dr-:J~ I
" .
,.
m ":r:~~ I
i L__,___
<ocmJ:1 ';:4 j
1I1Cj!nlQ ~ I
"-::~liJ
~
,
...
..
i
,
)'
f,t,
~Ji
1.\1
't.,:
,.
~.:
,'/
,!
"
J'.
I
,
",
;"
,
"
"
,'.
1.";1
'Ch
>en.
ien.
,;~
1'\;;....,
,-
"~I:
'.'~.
I...
:'Cc
','
i.i;
t
j':
r,\
i
i
f
"
,
.Jl,tl~1Nr:;" ~'
"'Utt)q
~
t? ,"lUtl~M
, t 1""'~II1'" \.!,
,1 J ','1
'~ ".~'ml'lll
, y I~'
q,
""1.r.j~ ~'I\
,'."'1\
" "i,
"
I U: ~ 7 '0'11 7"'1 Il~I"1 MShl1 I' , il/]lIl/:!
r -- ,... -0- - 'r---T;)'--- ~r- ~
J"" , , ."
4, I. '. r<
d
~:,.. ,,)
~;; ~I:
' , '"j
"
~I 11 I"
"
" ,,'
" ,'r',.
.!~ --
~
i
f
JnN.-ll:1-'tJ9 "lOt-' llJl~6 UnV11J ~, 1..thtlJJ,EI-J PC
00""
p~ral
Daviel W. Knauer, P.C.
411.A Eut Main Sheet
~il!chan\clburg, P A 17055
(717) 795.7790
Da,.id W. Knauer
Narllt D. Schwartz
PLEASE DELIVER THE FOLLO\\'1I~G PAGE(S) TOI
Oat. !I!UL
To (1,~ W..LA.~ ' p.
r
))all1d aJ. h /lUi.bL.--
From
- () /5e.rJ
In R. ;-,:)t>r V
Fax No. '71.11 - 301-K
MUllge
TOTAL NID1BER OF PAGES, INCLUDI~G THIS PAGE ~
If ,'ou do not receh'e all the pa.'u, please call (111) 795-7190 as soon as pouihle.
Thanlt You.
.'
Th. attach.d m."as. i. for the "du.l". u.. of the Idd....... Illd contains cOllfid.ntial,
privil.,.d, and non-di.do,.bl. informallon. If the re'lpient of thi. facsimile transmluion is not
the addre"e. or a l'"r!on re,poll!lbl. for deli\'erill~ the m...a,e to the addr.".., fUel, recipient II
prohibited from readin. or u,ini this me,,".e in Iny ..'.Y'. If )'ou hl\-e recei".d thi. m.III'. 111
error, pIeS!. call u. imnadiltely slth. .bo\'. llumber a:~d d.'lro)' tIll fac,lmUe trlmmlulon
documenh,
J IH~-. 11],. -;i'., "Hill
11..) t "Ii .'IlV 1 U 1.1 1,11111 Il ,.' I.'j
n_____.
] I"
: ,~ I ';1:,;' , / "
, . .' .~
"16~~ 1',,11: ' ,
i I ~ ',\
, i1::
""':1t':.14 " /
I,
, '-U~IQ ,
~ " ,
<
i "'~~~~H ~'
,", l'
N~~Fik; .:1
" ' I; "
" . "
..~~~~~,. \
"l .. ,'!"
, ~.}~:
. .~~ . I,
,l~/:}
1
T~~~'
, r~~~\;L
. "" "
lHhl
'r-f
!i "
, ')
"
I ,
b' ): ' ,
J I~
,'~ ,,' i
\~ :i
'.I :,j
.1
~
j
:t X
.
'I
\
I
I'
l.lI.'
x
~ 1
x
"
x
ill
;~
d
,
~
~
3~
t'{)~
~<:
~~
f~
j:':
~ J
,
.~ :
~\:
~~
,~
~.:
j
i
~
I'
,
\
I
\
I
I
,
I
I
,
"
I
,
I'
"
"
, ,
,
"
I"
"
I
,
DAVID W.I<NAUER, P.C.
I\fTOANEyllAr LAW
., ,1\ EMr ~lN 8TAfer
MECIlAHIcSllUllo. PElMYLVAHfA 110M
(717) _7710
'nft,~.J!~RnrlEDrolll! 1\
6Aia'~~.COPYOF lHl
,1"t'.I,.jl
..,
I
,I" ""; 'I
.
~
,
I
\
~'
"
,
-
...l;.O ~.~ - >;._. .... t-""- .~.''''.::,~.
',I
7. The oarelessness. recklessness, and negligence of the Defendant Olsen was
the sole oause of the aforesaid collision In that she:
s) failed to keep a vigilant lookout for east-bound traffic on Market Street;
b) failed to see the Plaintiff Foor's vehicle approaching;
c) failed to yield the right of way to east-bound traffic on Market Street;
d) pulled directly Into the east-bound lane of travel on Market Street;
e) failed to avoid striking the Plaintiff Foor's vehicle;
f) struck the Plaintiff Foor's vehicle: and
g) violated the rules of the road,
8. As a result of the carelessness, recklessness, and negligence of the Defendant
Olsen, the Plaintiff Foor has suffered severe and sundry Injuries to his person.
9. As a result of the careless. recklessness, and negligence of the Defendant
Olsen, the Plaintiff Foor has suffered the following elements of damage:
a) past and future medical expenses:
b) past and future pain and suffering;
0) past and future emotional distress;
d) past and future loss of enjoyment of life.
.2.
"
,'I
.... -, ,~
f,". - C.;
r" r:-I
.. >"l..,f',
,,- , N " ~ 'OJ' I
" ,
, . :;'1 ( "
" ,f.
, ,""";j
I: . , eL. , t, ;.~
~', I" ""\1)
L\: . ~. I"
t,(.
[, ~! ' 1,,\,.'1
, ' " ".1..
I ;.1.. "
i,l,.,
L\ I'. i.),
CJ 0'
,I I'
,
u
, ,
'!
"
,
"F I
"
,
, ,
:1
, ,
,I
I,l,
,
.
,
, ,
", r.'
(- ~...
i ..
ILl' ..J , , .
,
" :I , ,
H.
<...1
, - r"
l ~ : """ ,
"!l , : r<l
L,_ , to! . i',l..
1
" ,4. )
... , ....'1 t..J
. .
-,
, -
-,
"
..
-\ ,
"
-,
I
,
,
','
...... '" '/"
c" .', I':
~
lll~b) ('; rl'),
0 ....-. .1,
~; ~., . ~
,
I, ("J .
61' <'J
ei ,
L.', , I
r 1'.1. .'
tl f" .'
.:." ',.J
, I
,
I
,
,
I'
"
,
,
,
",
, ,
,
,
I!
~)- r"' '"
fr-; (.
n <' .
I".'
III
('," .,-, , . .
I ;! ~ I 1....
~ I) I',' ..".. , ,
l,. t ....J ,"\'0
(,1: C".l , "
"1 '..,'
.' I CO ~ I :1 ('f)
L:
r~ . I., . Hl.
<.;; . I ~
t.'. ,-- ,;.\)
(" C". (.)
, '
"
"
.,
,
"
.,
i I I
,\,
I
I
I,
',. ~.. t ~'. ,
1'- L,;
, ~.
I t:.j . .
I,
Ii " I:' ~ .
"
('1 , I; ,
I' " ,
. , ,
(,: ~.":.I.
, t -, ..:1
L lit '1"_'
I' I,t>i
.' , \:,H,h
L.!': ." "
I [\ i~\..
r.. .' - i ; i ~~ '
I.' r-. U
<..) cJl
.
,
II!
,
,
'I'
"
"j
,
.
"
"
".'.
.')
assumption of risk.
13. Ms. Olsen was confronted with a sudden emergency
not of hi. own creaticn to whioh he rosponded reasonably under
the oiroumstances.
14. Plaintiff's claims are barred by the applicable
statute of limitations.
15. The named insured of the automobile insurance
policy oovering Plaintiffs electijd coverage under the limited
tort option offered under that policy in accordance with the
terms of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle Financial Responsibility
Law.
16. Plaintiff's claims are barred in whole or in part
by the terms and conditions of the Pennsylvania Motor Vehicle
Financial Responsibility Law, Act of February 12, 1984, 75 Pa.
Cons. stat., S 1701 ~ a~, as amended. specifically,
Plaintiff's claims for medical expenses and/or wage loss may be
barred in whole or in part by 75 Pa. Cons. stat" S 1722.
Moreover, Plaintiff's claim for non-economic damages may be
barred by virtue of an election of the limited tort option of
Plaintiff's motor vehicle insurance policy.
'.. .,., '..
j..1
.'. Lf. ..'
..
, , "..; 1'1
.,-,
,
, I "
" ('q
I I ,
, : II
, ,
~; " IU"
I a;...;
1 ,.,.. .)
( fI' I') ,
,
"
,.
"
"
I
"
"
,_., '.
i ,,, C~,~ ' 'I
I /:j r. i
" . ],' ,
J :
no.
,
, 1 -, '," ,
( , II,
L. " ,,.
I I . I.'d ''',II
1 j :.~,.
I 1"'- ::J
, lj' I,.)
. ,
\,
J)Jl1Wt1lfili...,."".,..,,,.,....~""T"'il~.\f'''~r'l..~'I. ." H' -., 1 '1 "/'''''"r:'!1\i '
~,iyi ' t\~~~\lt;;t!MtJ;!'li"i'f~~-:I ~'1i~lft'" fJ, 'I" I~ " '1 ~. 1 j ~
',(,Ill.. ,n,.~hi"'T'l,nl;"~ Ufhr' . ~1{Iit;ldd.' t,ld: lj'~r.'! " '/!ft! ft
~ \ ';', 1'\ ,;,t,,",,,,, ,,"lIj') I ."~.,l) ',"\" !t /l,4'.jf" oj' f '" I t 1 1 , I I' ! ,II ' "
"'VI III . ~j" 'if..'l I ,,' , t. I ,j,i I, . I -", . I I,. , ' ! I' I Ipl , ' I ~
~\ ~ ','I ", . \1 \ I', l'~' I! " I . It 1 , )" I I" ,'I I
! y./fl,l !1\'"~;l\~'!.""eJ :~~f>l1",l; If', l,f,j\'I~ \'~ ql, ' \ ..,~ ,,' II Ijl,\,:
1 l') , ~ I"" '0'< J' 'In Ill)!' I j' W" ..,....-' I,
.",,(,'," I '~ 'i'" , '
I,'\'.-"'i'jll' ,', ,\ ,
._-_t",;, " ,t
.'_i{i>'i. id"- 'l '. I' ,t I ,
lli,'h'!',l:':-, _I: '
./t"
.\"\',1
-,. .,:r, t
rl~ I~ '+- (?E ~
~."": I;':
G"" ~/1 c:: ~
, ),
c.., 11.; 0.': ~ 8 C;
~~: .:~j
I
w'" ['-' ti.-. ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
- r' 1.1 "l J
C;j " ...
LJ. ,.;. '&; ~
Q r~ .:\ ~
a- u c:/..
'I
"
.
.
"
,.
I!
; "
"
. >
"
ii'
, I
""Ill
, ' , M~~
~~ .S ~
J w I
~ - !I~
8 i~~
d ~ ~ '~ '~J~~
~'
~~K ~
~' I'
. .... ....Q
'0 .... .....
..,. ....H
"
,,'
01:
I'Jn JIIIl ~u
nlr;/) (,'fIe': ,
'It"" 'liI'HJTI-.!'iY
PH :11 ~5
, .., 'I)'
eLl'}"I';I' \;, ',,'.,1,\\
I." " . " \' I' \
1'~Ni',(i'(L..,
l'),;
~.
1;101
~
.'
,I
~
,
"
'.
'I
,
"
"
,I
i Ii
.
,
, - ,.:1,/'1 '_1 ""-:",/','_\')',/)1:'"
'" ,d. ,(," '1),,1,
":F,-II:111 ~1~1t.''.th},\j I' ~
'-,Ip~ :~l:'-jfll{;Jf.\-r~:,!'.,,'
-;'f'l!(1 1'1""'1', ,,;
1,.\J[(1-;J '~I, \~ -~lj,JY-1 .1: ,~,lli"
I .,'0'," ":;')" ~r'/;~_':,"
i' ','I' /',,'<,,,,
- ,'I -: "'J ,,'
i I J:j'l~ ", '
,,'
" ,
,
\
"
II ./
"
"
" ,
"
.'
'I'
-" 1-"_ "'...
, IJ~
"
~t,tl
'. .1 ,'.
. 'I
. ,
',},-, , ~ "
I I. ,
If' ~, I " I,
." , I)
OJ ," 1 I,
:,,) " :.1
;,jl
R
! 8
~ f !( ~
~iJi~!
a8 ~ en n
II: ~
>(
8
! ~
~ ~
~~
c
, ,
,
,'Ii,
"1'
I'
,
"
"
"
"
"
"
,
,if
'j.,
;1 I
"
"
','I
'I ,_I:h\,',
r'~ :'"
r I -lt~!I\1 .Ii
"'11 ",
II ~V\;,:' I
't~ Y '}~,~~:l
','g-!'J:'::'1'/_~~I~ ;
"
'I;,
"
,
,
, ,
, ,
, ,
,
,
'I,
.-1"
\
-
'.
'Ii
,
"
1',i I
,
.
.
,
,
.
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
SCOTT FOOR, I No. 97-4774 civil
plaintiff I
I
v. I CIVIL ACTION - LAW
I
MARY JANE OLSEN, I
Defendant I JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
MOTION OF DEFENDANT,
MARY JANE OLSEN,
TO COMPEL DISCOVERY
1. Plaintiff, Scott D, ~'oor ("Plaintiff"), oommenoed
this aotion by way of Praecipe for Writ of Summons filed on or
about September 4, 1997, at Cumberland County docket number
97-4774.
2. On or about November 17, 1997, a complaint was
filed.
3. On or about December a, 1997, Defendant, Mary Jane
Olsen ("Defendant"), filed an Answer and New Matter in response to
Plaintiff's Complaint.
4. On or about December 9, 1997, Defendant served upon
Plaintiff a set of Interrogatories together with a companion
"I
I ','I,
Request tor Production ot Documents. copies ot suoh documents are
attached hereto, inoQrporated herein by reterence and marked
EXhibits "A" and "B" respeotively.
5. By way of letter dated April 22/ 1998/ Defendant
reminded Plaintiff ot his obligation to respond to discovery. A
oopy of said letter is attaohed hereto, inoorporated herein by
reference and marked as Exhibit "C".
6, To date, Defendant has not received any responses to
the outstanding Interrogatories and Request for Production of
Documents.
7. Pa.R.C.P. No, 4006(a) (2) requires answers to written
interrogatories to be served within thirty (30) days after service
thereof.
8. Pa.R.C.P. No. 4009(b) (2) requires a response to a
request for production of documents be served within thirty (30)
days after service thereof.
9. Pa.R.C.P. No. 4009(b) (2) authorizes the party
sUbmitting the request for production of documents to move for an
order under Pa.R,C.P. No. 4019(a) if the party upon whom the
request was served fails to respond with~n thirty (30) days.
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Mary Jane Olsen, respectfully
requests that this Honorable Court enter an Order compelling
Plaintiffs to provide full and complete answers to Defendant I s
Interrogatories and respond to Defendant's Request for Production
- 2 -
Exhibit A
DI!PIHITIOHB
As used in these Interrogatories, the words and terms set
- forth below shall be defined as followSI
(a) "Person" has its customary broad meaning and shall also
include any human being, corporation, partnership, sole
proprietorship, unincorporated association, joint venture, or any
other organi~ation or entity.
(b) "Identify" or "identity" when referring to an
individual means to state his/herl
( 1) full name;
(2) socia 1 secur i ty number;
(3 ) present addresl!.;
(4) present home telephone number;
(5) present business address; and,
(6) present business telephone number.
(c) "Identify" or "identity" when referring to a document
means tOI
(1) state the type of document (~ record, report,
letter, memoranda, telegram, chart, photograph), its date, its
title (if any), its identifying number, a generalized summary of
the subject matter of the contents of t.he document, and its
present location; and,
,
"
,
,
(2) identity each person who prepared it, each person tor
whom it was pr.pared, each person to whom it was sent, and each
person who presently has custody ot the original or copies
thereot.
ed) "Identity" or "identity" when referring to a claim,
action or other legal proceeding, means to set forth the name of
the court or other tribunal involved with the legal proceeding,
the date on which the legal proceeding was commenced and the
docket number or other index number assigned by the tribunal to
identify the legal proceeding.
(e) "Describe", "specify", and/or "state" shall mean to set
forth fully and unambiguously, using professional words of art if
necessary, each and every fact relevant to the matter requested
by the Interrogatory.
ef) "Document" includes any written, recorded or graphic
matter however produced or reproduced including but not limited
to correspondence, telegrams, other written communications,
contracts, agreements, notes, reports, records, x-rays,
memoranda, photographs, tape recordings or any other writing,
including copies of any of the foregoing presently or previously
in your possession, custody or control.
(g) "Statement" includes any written statement signed or
otherwise adopted or approved by the person making it. It
includes the stenographic, mechanical, electrical, or other
20. Identity any and all fact witnesses who have any knowledqe
whatsoever pertaining to the issues involved in the instant
case, as well as any and all potential witnesses or
individuals whom you may call at trial and who have not
hereto tore been identified, including the name, place and
manner ot oontact between the potential witness and the
parties, the substance of facts to which the witness could
testify if called by any party, and method of discovery ot
the potential witnesses, the purpose of the witness'
testimony (if applicable) and whether any statement or
summary or written memoranda has been taken with respect to
the potential witness and if so, who has possession ot that
statement or document at the present time. (Please attach a
copy of the same without the necessity of filing a formal
request for production of documents) .
.! .I, .1,
.J J
31. It your claim in this action i. based in whole or in part
upon expert opinion, please identifY each and every expert
you expect to call at trial, his profes~iQn or occupation,
the subject matter upon which the expert will testifY, the
substance of the facts and opinions to which the expert will
testifY, a summary of the grounds fQr each opinion of the
expert, the date upon which you first contacted the expert,
the author, title, date and publisher of any article, text,
part of a text, treatise, paper, speech, or any other source
of medical information upon which the expert will rely in
expressing his opinion and identify all claims or actions in
which such person has served as an expert witness.
, '
"
"
"
, ,
!
,
,
"
f.xhlbll 8
I,
'I
"
1,li
"
l'li
Ii
','
"
I
"
, I
I;)
. ,
"
"
I
,
,
;1
"
Tni. r.que.t i. int.nded to oover all dooum.nt. in tn.
po.....ion, oustody and control of Plaintiff, ner agents,
employees, insurance carriers and attorneys, and is considered to
be continuing. Plaintiff's response to the Request should be
modified or supplemented as Plaintiff, and/or her attorneys
obtain further additional documents up to the time of trial.
Requested documents are more particularly itemized and described
as follows:
1. Produce a true and correct copy of any and all
investigative reports, test results, summaries, records,
drawings, sketches or photographs of the incident involved in the
above-referenced case, or in any way pertaining to the events
surrounding it, or in any way pertaining to the facts which will
be adduced by and on behalf of Plaintiff at the trial of this
case.
2, Produce true and correct copies of all statements, or
memoranda of statements, of any and all persons who will be
called as a witness at the trial of this case.
3. Produce true and correct copies of all statements or
memoranda of statements, of any party, her agent, or
employees, concerning the subject matter of this case and the
events surrounding it.
4, Produce true and correct copies of the report of
any expert retained by the Plaintiff and their attorney in
connection with this cas..
5. Produc. the curriculum vita. of your eKpert witn.....
and a li.t of all of th.ir publications.
6. Produce any and all other documents prepared by each
eKp.rt id.ntified together with all correspondence between said
eKpert and Plaintiff and her agent, attorney or anyone acting on
Plaintiff's behalf.
7. Produce any and all documents or papers of any kind
which would have any probative value on Plaintiff's behalf in
connection with this case, or which will be introduc.d at the
trial of this case.
8. Produce any and all medical bills, reports, hospital
reports, hospital charts, physician's reports, c'r scans, MRI's,
K-rays, and their companion reports, and all medical bills
concerning the injuries and damages allegedly sustained by the
Plaintiff which per~ain to the claims made in this case.
9. To the extent any document requested has been withheld,
identify each document by date, author, SUbject matter and a
brief description of the document's comments, and state the
grounds upon which document has been withheld. /
Date:
ROLF E. KROLL
PA Attorney 1.0. No. 47243
Attornoy for Defendant
3782-1
.
,
,
I I I Ii
It I
"
"
exhibit C
I.j
.
.
(v)
.
.
, i
,
"
'I
,
"
t,
" ,
"
il
,.."
,
,
"
,
"
;'1
.'"
~
.
.
.
., 'j
" , . \
, !l
, , t "
\
.' \
., I
" ,
.,
.
'il
~
,;....-;r.'Ti~
';'''''''':-r: /':"1,<_,..;...;::;.;." +~ .,..--
"
I,
"
'>. C'I -,.
I,' I,
~:,: ~I
I' I-
'" ..iL
".1; -
(J.
_1_'j I
~;; .
I' ,:. i
(;1'
i/,"' I,'
r.:.1.' . , ,;0
r. 10::
, !],t
II. m ...'
U u\ <II
\
"
'"
",
"
"
"
"
.1
,I
... orl ..,..
II':;
.. .,.; I.
,,' ~~ t'J',
Plq '0-"
f" il
I' .., "
Jll- ..1.. , /;';
(1' r- ",t'
ld; - . '1
,.~
(l--'i ( F_; " .
. , i,'I(
I "'" ',.!\ ,
II. I
('l t'l
u oi I: .
... .
it i,
"
'II
,I
"
"
,
,
,
"
"I'
I!I
" '
, .'
"
~ f;1
~ t ~ I
!J !ai
~(r~l t
~
, '
",It
,-I
,f)
,
, i
"
"~I
"
"
:111"
,I
,Ii
!
~ I !
1,/ 'I'
,
, ,
_i,I'
..
,
8
N
l~
,;,
l'l
',i,
,
,
I,.'"
,'I ,,\
Exhibit A
, .
CERTIPICATE OP BERVI.CE
I hereby certity that I have served a true and correct
oopy ot the toregoing document on all counsel ot reoord by plaoing
the same in the United states Mail at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania,
tirBt~olass postage prepaid, on the It-7/. day ot June, 1998,
addressed as tollowSI
David w. Knauer, Esquire
411-A East Main street
Meohaniosburg, Pennsylvania 17055
(Counsel tor Plaintitt)
REYNOLDS & HAVAS
A Protessional corporation
BYI
tJI/~j Mc/~
aron Dell~Gal ag e
seoretary
1
,
"
",
"I! )1
" , I.
, I, : ,
"
, ,
" '
20. Identity any and all taot witnesses who have any knowledge
whatsoever pertaining to the issues involved in the instant
oaso, as well as any and 1111 potential witnesses or
individuals whom you may call at trial and who have not
heretotore been identified, inoluding the name, place and
manner of contact between the potential witness and the
parties, the substance of facts to which the witness oould
testity if called by any party, and method ot discovery of
the potential witnesses, the purpose of the witness'
testimony (if applicable) and whether any statement or
summary or written memoranda has been taken with respeot to
the potential witness and if so, who has possession of that
statement or document at the present time, (Please attach a
copy of the same without the necessity of filing a formal
request for production of documents).
The Defendant. See answer to Interrogatory No. 19 above and the police accld'ent report,
31. It your claim in this aotion is based in whole or in part
upon Dxpert opinion, please identity eaoh and every e~pert
you expeot to call at trial, his protession or oooupation,
the subjeot matter upon which the expert will testity, the
substance ot the facts and opinions to which the expert will
testity, a summary ot the grounds for each opinion ot the
expert, the date upon which you first contacted the expert,
the author, title, date and publisher ot any article, text,
part ot a text, treatise, paper, speech, or any other source
ot medical information upon which the expert will rely in
expressing his opinion and identify all claims or actions in
whioh such person has served as an expert witness.
At this time, the Plaintiff has not determined whom he will call at time of trial, and
reserves the right to supplement his answer to this Interrogatory if and when necessary.
"
"
I I
, ~;
',',';
.',
I , /'
, ;.,
37. xt you were in a motor vehicle at the time ot the locldent,
was it equipped with seat belts? xt so, were you wearing a
..at belt at the time ot the aocident?
The vehlole had seat bells. The Plaintiff was wearing the shoulder belt but not lip belt,
'"
',I
,
I,:., hi",
,'",,(:\,.,/,.
I:':L ,'~.
:i'Vf>ii
, '! I :, ,~{
'\;':l'.lm
, ; "';,;:k\~
, ,~: ,Ij !
I I ,I ,,', ~"'~'i
",;ir;tf
:.,::./11\
Hi,;'ki
, i.T
'1,'(
" .1
""_'1
'!'I'
,
, ,
, "
-Ii
38. Plea.. state whether you have eleoted the limited or full
tort option and state with .peoitioity the name ot your
private pa.senger automobil~ insuranoe oompany and its
addres. .
Respeotfully submitted,
DATEI/2(l(f1-
BYI
No, 47243
Attorneys for Defendant
101 Pine street
P.O. Box 932
Harrisburq, PA 17108-0932
(717) 236-3200
3782-1
"
, I
I
"
, 'I;,
,.,. <'I ',.
f. ~', I,
, .. t',.
l" , u;
C':
I: ,
l. ,I
,..
,
I.
'" t' ,}
i 1"_,
II. , "
'-J V' '.~
"
I,'
,I
"
I
'"
"
I'
. I
I'
"
"
I,
"
I
'I,
"
'I
SCOTT FOOR
v.
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-4774 CIVIL TERM , /
MARY JANE OLSEN
J.ttB.E;.--ABfillB.AII.Q
QB.D.EB..QE..OO
AND NOW, March 29, 1999, the Court having been Informed that the above
case was settled without hearing, the Order of Court appointing the Board of
Arbitrators Is hereby vacated, and the Chairman, C, Roy Weidner, Jr., Esquire,
shall be paid the sum of $50.00.
By the Court,
C. Roy Weidner, Jr., Esquire - c"tfj ".,;........(,cL 3/ 3V/"". )
~ ~~,..., ,
P.J.
, I OJ:) I q
",
, ..;: "I
:It . 'h~
! I ~ :'J
<., ]l
f:;)' "
I'
~.: ,j1~
I : co i
.>-'1 ..
.j
',:\ .'->
-, C~
Court Administrator
:ssg
\
, ,
", cr) ?"
., .:-' .~...
.. .,
.., < .
" .. ..)t~
, I'. (.It,.
'II ) ~!~
dO' ',') ~;),
',.
'n :CfJ
- )~
';' , ,n,~
"
;.;.: 'a
':",')
,I I;:)
,
'J 'J
I
,il
,