HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-05288
"
(.':,
'I"',
It' ;,1'1'::1
.' .~.
I;.,,':l:
'i'
,t
If'
/"
'I.
!',
I~t-
{'-.
',-
,;
',;.
.
it
,-.1
,'.':-\~
,,,,,u
Yil
i It~
1;],(
'ily,
~-'\
,
'!,
d,
'1 ,
,.' dl
,
.,
,
"
I
I I
I'
"
,.,
,;1
I,')
..
I
'.
II
~ -f"
I'
"1
'11
"
'I
'1',
"
"
I I
I
,
, I
.1
I'
l,l
"
;1,
"
'I
,',
I
I
I' Ii, I
,;'
.)1 I
it
... I.
.,
"I.!
"
, I
'I
"
'I
.,
,
"
,'"' -<!
111:11 lI'T':, 1.:ETiJl\II
liI::I,IJU,J..
I ^ '.',;F: Il'_': .1'"1';)')', rZt~) .Jj.!.l, I'
'1 1I'i1'11 HH'L:^!'TII, OF I: 1::r'iH:.;YL'IMI [,\ I
, I)'III'I"{ I]F l"I/l'lli[I\I.^IW
11.1 r I . I : 'I. '.' 1':1,,'; !\!:11L,_1, _t;L_.d.b_~.___..:
'V;i:;,
~-:l:~l ) 'I":, L~I~.I!B 2C._t~.",..P"".'-""_.______"~__~'''-~
. J r?f_'(IJJS_.Ji.FJ} I...___.._~_.;__~~~""":_-..--~_.i--_.._J ::; }1I.:n 1 f i u r I).:: p U I~ 'I ' :::i h I,n- J. J. ,1 Ij t
(;Ul'Ir.q-.'];.LAND 1"'~Jlln I: j',
I"}rirl~~i'l LV'-!fll.a,
,
wlit) lJ,:.llII\J du ly :,nlif.Jf n ill..;curtJ,l'flld
'." I.,~. ,; I)':.;. I.hl.' ,,"tlnll Wh.lT UF :.::IJJl11!.lJL-'___'_'~7'
WIJ:tJ u".'r'v..~d
UPI)J'1
HlilTE I..H;\;YE
. .. _ .'___'_""~'__'~_.__._.m____.'.'" __.___j._~.~
-.-------.
t.lll;-;;.'
dl~1 I:"L'II'->.;,f\ t-" a I: --1..~lJ.:lJ.lj)v.' i1UUI;::~, on t hi,' ..~J..tJJ. dd.,/ I.) t c.l.:;1:..~~L~~_
1 '01']] "I,' ._ZU;.ti::;T JU.Q1L~iJ;BJ'a~L~..
I~M3Le?.!~_E;J_ p..Ac.J 71~.LL._._______....._ ~_________,__. .____, UJ1:1lll.::RLAN[1
,
COIJ n:_ y, Pl~'nn ;,.,~ y 1',' ,Hi 1 d,' IJ)' hdnd tlllJ '-, (: kd\HI\' 'I' ..J1..:.._I-'UU n:
" I"", "'1',,( d',':.,:'"t",j ":"'py ,cl II'".. _"I\lT_IJ.E.'::J1ml'lljl'IS~_,___
~~IJ1d () 1. t, he :i;J lIlli' t.L HII} d 1 rl~C t',~,11\J IIJ' ~; d t: 1:,'1:; rJ ,~ 1 i.lj'j r.IJ \:'h~:i' I'; un (c.'n l: t...:; , 1',tit~.I-- '~"J.t,
--'
,
StJf~riff'~:; C~lGI::J:
D n I: 1.; ';.' t:. i IhJ
r;l?iV Lei:;-'
AJel.di.lvit
:::,1,1 ["r.:hal-IJt'-:
:;;(] 1,:.1n;jW'f~1-;J:
r~'''-<'~4!
{nUI('. -SO"', .1.J:.r
HI. ,11,1
j,. L~.1
" I~')
:2. \~,)
rr:--"1"ri 0 III U~;
I~J, La RtCHAHD Wl.::UUl.::R
JtlJ/ 10/ l'':]'J'/,
1)-,/
. .
. .
. {~7ifr:~Sh&;;
---
3'rllj r 11 oJ lId J;;iU b :;:)cr 1 hl';:".J l~ Ij r) I.::.' t 'J r '.-J 1111--':'
th I,'! _...l..q~_ oj,,); <] t' ~_____._
l':J____~'__1. A. D.
I
_.___._~ \~~Q...""h-..ili.~_ lJ.,.".. ..c_
.~/- l'r'Jt.I'IUnl)r.rJ(:/~
'"
'- III .....
b: I.(': (.~~
i~~ ," (
,-)
U l~ ~ , ,
(')" '.'-
F('~
1"'\ L,.. '-;'.
i:if. ""1 "'-'.
G ' Cl ' t)
..)1 N ,
;'J;-, " " ~,
~~: ;j U.I
LJ.. I', ;;:,. :.:,:~ ;1.
,...
1.1 l'r:) :.~)
0 (J' ()
"
"
,
,
I,
"
,
,
, '
,
"
"
,
"
I
,I
,
,
"
,[
,I
"
,
'I
"
t, '
i,i1
""" '
i '
'il
'>-
t,:
,:'~
U.l'~:;1
"i'
I','
"I
t~ J ,-
fIr
,
lj..
,..
u,
C.l
I
I I
I I
"
c,1 ,- I
,.... r-.
, "
~.,,: ~_:"1 '. ., I','
I I i . I
, " I I
('J!
I
;t\.
l.'_1
u;
II'"
d~
L;.
I ~~j;
"
"
,", ),1
,1,1..
I
"
I,
'j
~)
'I 'I
"
,"
I
, I,
") ,,1
,"
.,
,IJ
I
I
,
.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CAROL L. CHILENSK! AND ROGER
E. CHILENSKI, individually and:
as parents and natural
guardians for MICHAEL
CHILENSKI, a minor
Plaintiffs
NO. : 97-5288
v.
LARRY E. FOOTE,
Defendant
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have this day servud a true and
correct copy of Defendant's Request for Production and Copying of
Documents - Set No. 1 Directed to Plaintiffs upon the person Bet
forth below and in the manner indicated:
First class mail, postage pre-paid:
Richard L. Webber, Jr., Esquire
366 Green Spring Road
P.O. Box 40
Newville, PA 17241-0040
LAW FIRM OF GEORGE H. !!lAGER
DATE l JI/Zlll'1Y
BY: ./) I,I~
George H. Ea er, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
I.D. No. 27740
1347 Fruitville pike
Lancaster, PA 17601
(717) 290-7971
, ,
"
,
.... ,~) '..
1 - '.~.
I .. , " .i
.. ...1 ~.,
~J.\ : .l
f.'-' , " "1
i .,
_II, r::l
(.~ . C~ \
I .
, I. ;'" I J
t.: ! , \;1.
.". 'j
I c-'.~
t..:., \.,;, i~)
'..'
':
.'
" ,
,i
,
,
,I
I
,.
II. OUESTION PRESENTED
SHOULD THE COURT DIRECT THAT THE PLAINTIFF FILE ANSWERS TO
DEFENDANT'S INTERROGATORIES AND REQUEST FOR PRODUCTION OF
DOCUMENTS.
Answer: Yes.
III. DISCUSSION
The Interrogatories were mailed to the Plaintiff on November
24, 1998. Answers were due on or about December 24, 1998. The
same is true as to Defendant's Request for Production of
Documents.
In fact, no answers have been filed to the Interrogatories,
no documents have been produced, and no objections to discovery
have been filed.
Pennsylvania Rule 4019(a) (1) (i) provides for an appropriate
Order on Motion if a party fails to serve timely answers to
discovery.
A wide range of sanctions is available to the Court.
Defendant in this matter does not seek sanctions, but simply an
Order compelling the filing of answers in a timely fashion.
There is no doubt that the Court has the power to enter such an
Order, and that such an Order is appropriate.
.
.
4. A copy of the Certificate of Service which Was attached
to Defendant's Request for Production and Copying of Documents is
attached hereto as Exhibit "B".
5. To date, no answers have been filed to Defendant's
Interrogatories. Further, no objections to the Interrogatories
have been filed.
6. To date, no response has been filed to Defendant's
Request for Production of Documents. Further, no objections to
the Request have been filp.d.
7. A copy of a letter dated January 26, 1999 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "Co.
8. A copy of a letter dated May 18, 1999 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "D".
9. A copy of a letter dated October 14, 1999 addressp.d to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "E".
10. A copy of a letter dated January 14, 2000 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "F".
11. A copy of a letter dated February 28, 2000 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "G".
Illhlblt A
Exhibit B
.
"
, ,
"
" ,
, '
, ,
"
,
,
,
, ,
, ,
,.
"
,
"
,"
,'I
,
,
,.
"
, '
, ,
,
"
I,
! "
'I
" , I
"
"
Exhibit C
)'
"
.
I.
, ,
,'.
'"
.'
..
, L
, ,
'. '
I,.
,
"
,
,
"
"
.,'
, ,
,.,
i
"
, ,
(r~
"
"
Exhibit 0
,I
"
, ,
",
,
"
"
"\
'I
, ,
I
,1
,.
,
,
I,',
""r"
, 1
"
, ,
, ,
"
,
'"
"
,
,
".,
, ,
"
,
I', I,
"
;',
,"
"
"
"
"
"
,
,
"
',1'
I"
"
:'
EXhIlllt I
Ioi &'.11.0"'110 hl.l. .".
,
'iiI'
*
"1'.";1'
'1"
, ,
"
..
,"
"
"
I'
"
"
"
"
,
"
"
"
"
"
,,'
:
".,
,
,
"
I,'
<I,
"
".
"
i'
"
,"
,
,
II
.... ,
ExhIblt G
"
, '-,
, ,
, ,
"
'I
, ,
"
"
",;
"
,
,
,
,
,
"
,'1,
','
'I
"
, ',1 ,
, ,
,\ ':
,
I, , "
"
, , "
,
" ,
"
,I:
"
,
Exhibit H
^., "'1"1.;1,."",.
(j)
In" '''''''1
"
"
II
, '
"
,
I
",
"
"
',"
"
I,
"
"
" I
"
"
,Ii
Exhibit I
I
<,)
"
,
, ,
",
,
,
, ,
"
, ,
,
,
"
Exhibit A
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CAROL L. CHILENSKI AND ROGER ~
E. CHILENSKI, individually and:
as parents and natural ~
,guardlans for MICHAEL ~
CHILENSKI, a minor I
Plaintiffs ~
:
v. :
NO. ~ 97-5288
n '=7't n
~.: , , ' "
"IJt! 7'~ .. I
'.I."
1."1. ,/ , '}
,"
4", ,j ....1
...., . 1
(' " 'l~ ,0'., ,
~ ~ i. I '1 r. ~)
. :'f
" ,
I' , " 0: ;
), " ;.~) ,11'1
, ",
" ',' <;i
.. I ,~I
",
LARRY E, FOOTE,
Defendant
MOTION OF DEFENDANT TO COMPEL PLAINTIFFS TO ANSWER
INTERROGATORIES AND PRODUCE DOCUMENTS
AND NOW, COMES DEFENDANT, AND REQUEST OF THIS COURT THAT IT
COMPEL THE FILING BY PLAINTIFFS OF CERTAIN DISCOVERY RESPONSES,
AS FOLLOWS:
1. The above captioned action was commenced by
Plaintiff in the Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania.
2~ On November 24, 1998, counsel for Defendant, s~rved an
original of Defendant's Interrogatories directed to Plaintiffs on
Plaintiffs' counsel, Richard L. Webber, Jr. On that same date,
Defendant's Request for production and Copying of Documents, was
also properly filed and served.
3. A copy of the Certificate of Service which was attached
to Defendant's said Interrogatories is attached hereto as Exhibit
!fAil .
4. A copy of the Certificate,of Service which was attached
to Defendant's Request for production and Copying of DocumentB is
attached hersto as Exhibit "B",
5. To date, no answero have been filed to Defendant's
Interrogatories. Further, no objections to the Interrogatories
have been filed.
6. To date, no response has been filed to Defendant' s
Request. for production of Documents. Further, no objections to
the Req~est have been filed.
7. A copy of a letter dated ,January 26, 1999 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibi t "e".
8. A copy of a letter dated May 18, 1999 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "D".
9. A copy of a letter dated October 14, 1999 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "E".
10. A copy of a letter dated January 14, 2000 addressed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached heret,J
as Exhibit "F".
11. A copy of a letter dated February 28, 2000 addr~8Bed to
attorney Webber requesting the above discovery is attached hereto
as Exhibit "G".
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF' cUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNS~VANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAij
CAROL L. CHILENSKI AND ROGER
E. CHILENSKI, individually and:
a~ parents and natural
guardians for MICfIAEL
CHILENSKI, a minor
Plaintiffs
NO. : 97-5288
~,~ \ ~.. t71
,<
~/'" ~~ '."
..- ..,
::;lj .'"
" ~
~.. . , , ~'n
~~' I :.,,) . '"
\.".,' ~ ".
.. :!l'!"
," --, . ~iI
" - , "j~J
'I!)
.....' I'll
L .. :'~J
"
-, ~:.:r
-.
v.
LARRY E. FOOTE,
Defendant
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have this day served an original of
Interrogatories of Defendant Addressed tq Plaintiffs upon the
, -
person set forth below and in the manner indicated:
Fir~t class mail, postage pre-paid:
Richard L. 'Webber, Jr., Esquire
36Q Green Spring Road
P.O. Box 40
Newville, PA 17241-0040
LAW FIRM OF GEORGE g. EAGER
CATS: J/~t.)J9r
BY:
George H. Eager
Attorney for
!.D.No.27740
1347 Fruitville pike
[,ancaster, PA 17601
(7l7) 290-797l
exmBrr ~
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF, CUMBERLAND ~OONTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CAROL L. CHILENSKI AND ROGER :
E. CHILENSKI, individually and:
as parents and natural
guardians for MICHAEL
CHILBNSKI, a minor
Plaintiffs
'NO. : 97-5288
r.-:: I.,-~ ,~
r.::. <:.;J
~~ ". -r!
-'.r
, 1 oj
:;;;, ;;11
;,,';1 :...) I, "'1
..' I'::';;;, ...:'i'
..
, - ", '::,~
. :;., -. ";:;p
oJ' ,/ "I I
, ~< .. '.;JIJ.':,
,<. .-.,.,
;:;; :!..;
-:;
v.
LARRY E:. FOOTE,
Defendant
CERTIFICATE OF SERVI~
I HEREBY CERTIFY that r have this day served a true and
correct copy of Defendant's Request for Production and Copying of
Documents - Set No. 1 Directed, to Plaintiffs upon the person set
forth below and in the manner indicated:
First class mail, postage pre-paid:
Richa~d L. Webber, Jr., Esquire
366 Green Spring Road
P.O. Box 40
Newville, PA 17241-0040
LAW il'IRM OF GEORGE H. BAGJm
D)l.TE: ItlzL/lftf '
BY: ../) /,,~ '
George~. Ea er, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
I.D. No. 27740
1347 Fruitville Pike
Lancaster, PA 17601
(717) 290-7971
'(' ,
~U3H B
"
"
~ 11:1 I"",
:,' ('J I" ,
,.
I , ,. ",I ,
,-. I.J.
I,. I ('
l,,," '!I.
:l'~ . ""j
I' 'I'
I."
I
..."":.
I , ,
. :') , :'
r.; \" , ,
i
~'i ,I" -
, ,'0'" '''1
< , ,.1 6,
,"
"
"
'1"
.' t'
, ,
, ,
"
"
./,1
"
'II'
.'
"
"
,
"
I'
"
I)
.J,]
.
.'
.
.
,. .:I' b
~ I' ,,-, "
" .. '')
,.- I"~') :.5
" ._~') :"'1'
"l:
" . )::~,
, .', >-;,
~J II
." l.~
~' ! ,-,'i?:5
,,) ~l-
"'i d
,;'CJ
CJ
"
:! ~
~
~
~, j
t c~
Z $.~
< 0( < 0(
:r::'- ..
. < : I
- ,-
, - -
uj ~ ;i ..
0( ':'J ~
"!"" - ::
S Z; I..
.;:: f"""
..t: ;It - ;t
l.o.lJ ~;
G,~" ;:;
w '" ~ ~
U ~ /1-
::;: Z ; ~
Ol.l..~; -
'" X"",
- Jt. 1'-
:> ,.. , ~
>. < .. 'r,
0( .,
..J ,...
,"
"
=s::
~h
~-
--
~-
"
1\'
...-.....-.
L.----...--..
.,' ---
IN TIlE COllin OF COMMON "LEAS OF Cl1MBElU.AND COUNTY . PENNSYLVANIA
(,(VII. ACTION. LA W
"
CAltoL I.. t'lIII,ENSKI AND ROGER
I~, CIIIl,ENSKI. Imlivldllully IInd
ilK pllr~'nIK und nlllll1ll1llUllrdlunK "Ir
MIl'IIAH. ('J III.1\NSKI. II minor
1'llIlnlifI~
, '
i
NO: 97-5288
!',
"~I
v,
LAI{RY Ii, FOOTE.
Delimdunt
CERTifiCATE OF SERVICE
,'I,
IIIEREBY CERTIFY thUl1 huve this day served un original of Answers to Interrogatories
\1
of Defendant. directed to Defendant's Counsel as set forth below and in the manner indicated:
'.
. ".
First Clnss U.S. Mail. postnge pre-paid:
f)
George U. Eager. Esquire
1347 Fruitvillc Pike
Lancaster. PA 17601
LAW FIRM OF MICHAEL J, HANFT
Date: ,f,);\ oU
BY: ?\:./ "t.. ...-./ ~
Richard L. Webber, Jr.. Esquire
Allorney for Plaintiff
J.D. No. 49634
19 Brookwood Avenue. Suite 106
Carlisle. PA 17013-9142
(717) 249-5373
'\1''''ofM\.'IrM~~I'''.~.1Itt~2''
)1;"':;-:
:'
,'1 d,
~ -.:I' rs
[',',.
,.. ~. ,',
.. I'!.:_
'" or- ?:~~
"
" tJ ..:.,.
I,..' ',. !,)?-i
'I ,- ,
'I:i~ , "
I '1.... "..;"
~) , IILl
-, 1,1)11.
I:
, ..,I l;') a
t.~')
~
OJ
.. ,
~~
"
~ :t
1;:, r;: ~
z ~- ;
<..J~ ~
If- ,!:
-.<:; ~
..d= ::
~ ~ ~ ~
$ ~u ~
Q~~~
~d~ ~ 6
"" -C'
O~,;j~
..../, :=.- ,...
UI-zt::
~ z:;: ~
"" ~< .
o ~. '"
';)..-"'''''
~.\:~::i
...J ~r:-
~~
~ I":
t;;':
, ,
,,'
"
.... -
n_
:OJ
"
. () l::)
".
,'.. 'I;
"',
~-,
.-...-..-...
~
~
H\j TIlE COURT OF COMMON Pl.EAS OF CUMBERl.AND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIl. ACTION. LAW
CAROL L. CHlLENSKI AND ROUER
E. CHILENSKI. individually and
as parents and natural guardians l{)r
MICHAEL CHlLENSKI. a minor
Plaintill's
NO: 97.5288
;
,
i'l
v,
LARR Y E. FOOTE,
Delendanl
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
"
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have this day served Plaintiffs' response to Defendant's Request
for Production ofDocurnents. directed to Delendant's Counsel as set forth below and in the manner
,'I!
indicated:
First Class V,S, Mail, postage pre-paid:
George H, Eager. Esquire
1347 Fruitville Pike
Lancaster, PA 17601
LAW FIRM OF MICHAEL J. HANFT
Date:--1.! /1.1......
BY: "'^-.:/,'t ,_~
Richard L. Webber. Jr.. Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
1.0, No. 49634
19 Brookwood Avenue. Suite 106
Carlisle. PA ]7013-9142
(717) 249-5373
I
, I
I
!
'\U_'IlIWrIInnDoc~ln1.2c"'oI'MniCf'.
i;
, 'I.
"'''',- "".1'
"*,1,,,,,,
,.::: .,-
" '; I
.. ~..) ,
. .."}
..'~ I)'
,r,: ~.:,) ~'r:
... , ,..- ~J
. '1'~1
''-L) ,,')
'-, ~
I If....
()' ~\(I"
" \ ll.
;." '.
,-,I ".i
f:,J u
~~ !H!~i
"'~ ~ ~
...
~~ ... .. I
... ~
.. ~ o-l f
z~ 'tl ~ '" ~
'tl C ... c:
~~ c: 111 ~ V H
111 H ... U
~!il . '" V l" ~c!~El:l
8 . H H . '" '"
~~ I~ ~iJ!iH H 00 ii li~ I
'" I>ol U 00 J
ffiffi'" . l" N
~8 o-lo-lffi ~ <2 '"
1
ZA HHo-l 8 '" ..... ~5!~~~ f
~~ 0 ~5H . '"
~:;j U ~ > ~
U .
u..... . . . 0 . - Sl I
<~ ~e~ l" z I ~
i::'" o-l >-
z~ ~~ ~
60.....
HU u..., "':0:
"
'" --
--