HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-05673
I".!
"
, ,
I'.
!I
'"
1;\
,;:t~~~
I..',','"
I ! '-}U'j
(' '!\"l
I .': "~'tl:!;i
\1 ""I'J.
. 'i". .~j
, J '_'~~.1'
'tilt
I"'..'.
I \::\:')'!
';I,'
,-i'_l'
P\t-jt-IJ
' .';./'1
')
"
',' 'i
';;\'1
.:I\,'i
II r:i)!i'
'\;;,".i'
l<{.
, (:-:'~l
, "i.
1,1 h!,t;~
II .\.'~'i~::,:r
'. 'I" "'. .~)(,
I 1",.,1"\
;. ,,' .\"
\ :-, ',_i
" ' !, ,-"i~i
"
'"
"
'I
,
i,
"
"
~
U
,
~
"
1
II'
I,'
II'
"
il
.,
II
'.
,','
,
"
,J
\,1
')1:
.
)\1!
I
"
'I'
"
,
01(1'1',1
.
I, "
',' ,
I
",,1
;,'1
"
.,
,I I
"
i,ril
!
I
"
"
~
,
I,
,II
i'
"
,
"
"1,1
"
"
'.,
,
_,I
"
"
1;'1
, ,
"
)
'1
~
~
It
--.....
~
,~
~
"
"
, '
I
1'.1"'1
'i
I i'
"~I;'
I,
,'I
I,
, ,
'i'
'I .
1
,
I
,
,\I
di
,
I'
",
"
1\
.
,.
I'
I"
.,
,
"
l'
'!I
'I
.,Ii':
',:t
oj
.I, 11.1/!4
:1,
'fill
.,;!-: ',:,\;:;.\(~<
It' "" ~ t ,Iii
i' I ' ~';: i'rj
I' . '1',
I, .\1,);'
, , i ;!, \j./,~,
'<;-";i~d!
\ -""\l"~j
II- ~": i '." n
;I..f"'''''''ill",~
,: "',i"l'i,",;~~
,.:'l,', ;Ii~ 1~:I
"":'::"-r{,'
\'\'.'k,l
'-'___",'c""
\,;-:r;~~
j\-:l'{"vt~
'I-:'(Ii'i.l~
'-;":.\~j
'_ .t~. j ! i~': ":l.!~!,
'- ','-,:: }~'-.
"I'I):!,it
'\\."I:I'(';f"S.\"!~
./"""'.1.."
,1,: ',,!'J./ir.
" i' ,t,_ I-.;.;~'l
'-,i,'(.W:
'i";\i'~j
",,:' :/i;'::; ((J!:
".',',ill;;Ui-'-
',,':, I~';\\!il
' -"':f\'~:~i:~1;)~~:
"I 'I.' .J....,::'
'I, "i"'!i,::)a(
, . ,~~ t t,i'J,,'
,01' I:: "I\t'
/1 I '1"'
I Ii '/'
>I 1'1,,1(1
" ',1,,,,
~' "''i,,;'i1l ',~Ii,;'
,/ ,:1." ,:':,~,':J"'\'hh'II,".
','- "r-!"')\'I'-)'t;I';I';l,lt\t!f ,.,
" ,;, '\;,'!i\'.~;Nr'
':"\""'~\'1~i~\}~j,.ti\ ~f I
:;;1;//'\(11;') J
;"1'''. fL r:: ";11
"'\::,:~.'(i~
,11 ~"j!,j\
11,1,;,':;';
I'. .', t:: _ '~'I
., ','-,l"\~-~~rf
III 1)11,'~<t"'}'.It-
,:"j,l!)~
t ~ '\\"
'I,I',IV"
1::;;}f
':,'
,,'
,
, ,
,I
I; ','
'\1'"
,ii'
"
'.
"
;/
,II'
1'1
"
1 II
"
'II
"
1..1. III
,
.1" q
,
)1I
"
"
",
,!I
I,
II, ."'
'I
'I"
"
,,,
"
"
,
"
\,'
,
"
I'
"
t.!
I,
,
',"1:
"1"
'it
"
:'
I",
/'
'. ',' "
,
, ,
;""
:"1,
I'
, " ~
,
,
,
"
,
,
'I..
,-1\
I.
"
,
,"
'"
,
(>II
.,-"
/1))1'
"
"
';,
"
I
01', -' ,I
\'1"":'
"
I,
,
..
,..,
';','1
I'"
'I,'
",.,
"
"
I
,
"
"
,
I
,
"~I'
\11,
!,
,I.,
:'1 \,\
,
'.
"
"
"
'\
.
,\.'
1
'I,
""
, .
"
,
1\
"
I'i'
I
" 'I'
'I'
"
,
,
I,",
"
, ,
,/
""r)
, ,
"
"
,
,
"
,",
"
"
,
"
"
I
, ,
"
,\--.1
,
,
I"
.'.
t ,I ',1'
,
.
"
,
""
,
'"
i,l
'1'-.\
"
, "
,II,
"
"
, ,
i,',
.
,
, .
"
,
~
~
,
,
~
'" '!.
i.r; "~I i" '"R
f l':
II", ..!:J 2 "j- -r
e c. ).. .. - .:J
I"
,. Ii. ~ ~
,',/' " I
, ' 1.O f;)
", 'n -
~-"i ! -:r
",1\ I" ~
ll. I , ,j,,' ~ .~
I <- ',i'I, ~
" ct.
I' r.. .1 o:..J
(,J t'"
, (.J
s~ i !
1 . 0) I>,g II
~~.
UI gl
. I . ~: ~ ~ I
1>0
., ~i s ~~ ~~[
r: ~
, JXl ~o I
~ I ~ l"l o ::>
~ I n ~ ~ ~ ~ I
z ~
... , ~ ~
0'
IZ\
, ,
, ,I
" ,
, j)
I" '
.
Nil 'HIlL\S & I'II1H,.\I",
H, Atlhc tllllc Ill' Ihc 1II11h'r Ichidc IIccidcllllhc I ldelldlllll IIIIS IIcgllgcllt, rcc~lcss uII<1
cllrelcss IIllllcr thc c1rclllllsllIlICCS ill:
II, l'ulllllJ!,llI hlllC his 1I1<1I1Ir Ichklc lllllkr pmpcr 1111<1 rCllsllllllhlc Clllllrul:
h, OpcrllllllJ!, his 11I111111' vchklc ill sllch 1I111111111Cr us III CIlUSC Iltll collldc IlItllund
ngalnstPlnlnlllrs whklc;
c. I'ullillg hI giw prlllllpl, prllpcr IIl1d udc1lunlc \llImillgllfhis upJlronch:
d, Opcl'lltillJ!, his 111<11111' whklc \I ilhlllll duc rcgnnlllllhc prcscllcc IIl1d sulely of
Ihc Plahnlff:
C. I'lIl1illg III brillg his 1II11111r whiclc III II SlOp IlIlilllc IOllvoid tbc collision:
1', I'uillllg Illopcmlc his 1Ih1ll1r whiclc ill II sufe lIlId prllpcr IIIl1l1l1cr:
g. I'uillllglll cOlllpl) \lilh Ihc I<\IIS, ruks IIl1d rcgululilllls lIflhc Pcnllsylvnnla
Mlllllr Vchlclc elldc IIl1d thc lInlillallccs of '-<IIlcr AllclI T<IIllIship pCrlaillillglOlhc opcl'lllllln Ill'
molor whidcs in or IIbllullhc puhlk higllllllYS:
h. Opcmlillg his 1Ih1lor vehiclc alII high alld cxccsslvc rulC of spced undcr lhe
clrcumstnllccs: lIlId,
i. I'lIl1illg III sllIp ala c1eady lIIarkcd slop sigll IIl1d Hlillng III yield the right of
WilY to Plnlnlirfs whicle, SllllS III cllnslilule a ha/ard. in violationofScctilln JJ2J(h) of the
Pennsylvallla Molol' Vchidc ClIdc.
9. As II resultllflhe IIcgllgcllcc, rcc~lcssllcss alld cllrelcssllcss oflhe Dcfendallt.
Plaintiff Susall R, Kirklalld \las villlclllly shakcllalld suffercd scverc alld serious injuries 10 the
bones, cartilages, IIgamcllts, IIII1>c1es, lIrgalls, IIcrvcs alld Ilssues of Ihc body. illcludlllg. but not
limitcd to, illjurics III hcr chcst, shouldcr, kllcck. back, kllcc. hips alld thighs. all of which may be
permanent. PlainlilTSusan R, Kirkland also suffercd a snddcn and violenl shock to the nervous
systcm, as well as achcs, pains. mcntal anguish. shllck and disability. and allergic reaction to
various tre'ltments neccssitated hy and I'll' \lhich the pl'llsimatc causc was Ihe motor vehicle
accident which is the sllbjcct lIflhis Icgal actioll,
10. As al'eslllt lIf Ihcse illjllrks. Plaillliff SlIsall R, Kirklalld has illcurred and expects to
continue to incur illlhc flllllre medkal cxpenscs and IIlhcr cosls related to medical expenses,
II, As II resllltllf Ihese injllries. PllIinliff Susan R, Kirkland has been unable to
underlake her nOl'lllll1 dUlies IInd helieves thai she will cllnlinuc III suffer impairments and
disabilities In the futurc. which hilS IInd will result in II dccrcllse in her ellrnings and earning
capacity.
,
, I
VEIUFICMION
I, Itlll1l1lL1lt, Klrklllml. wrlfy Ihllllh~ sllll~IIl~I1IS Illl\ll~ Il1lhll lilr~l/,lllug CllJllplnllllnl'V '
Irll\lnull IIUrrlllll, I uu<lllrslllmllhnl l'nlslI slnllllll~l1ls hllrllll1l1r~ lIlil,11I Sl1hjllllllll 11I1)n, C. S,
SIlIlIlIlI1 4l)()4, r~lnllulllll UIIS\I<1I'11 flllsll1l1nlllll1 hI lIulhllrlll~s,
Dnlll<l: Id/r IP 7
~~~J
IWN^I.D It. KlltKI.^NL>
.,
, ,
',i
"
",
.
,
,.
','
,
,
, '
, I
r.- -. ~
.? In I,;
~.
I.. 0, 110,
r") ~ ;~ ) ;':';.
Iii"
fl l- j :l: \~) :..
IJ:;1 I., " ~j
~)" f,l?,
en '11)
~::. ' '1:.:; , ,
.." ::-.' ~ 11f;)
. , f.~ :t I";
,;.;. - ;f~
~) ,... t' "
en
. ,
N
0J I
~ ~ "~
~qHj Ii
I- ~
t
It ~
0(
,
"
, ,
".'
, '
"
."
,"
, ,
,.'
,
,
" ,
"
'"
'I
';'
"
\'
, ,
"
4
.
'.
Count I
5, The answers oontained in paragraphs 1 through 4
hereof are inoorporated herein by reference as if set forth in
their entirety,
6. Denied. The allegations oontained in this paragraph
state a legal conolusion to which no response is neoessary.
7, Denied, The allegations contained in this paragraph
state a legal oonolusion to whioh no response is neoessary, By way
of further answer, with respect to any allegation that Plaintiff-
Wife sustained injury as a result of a motor vehiole aocident whioh
ocourred at the time and plaoe stated in Plaintiffs I Complaint,
after reasonable investigation Defendant is without knowledge or
information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of said
averments and, therefore, they are denied,
8(a) - (i), Denied. The allegations oontained in this
paragraph state a legal oonolusion to which no response is
neoessary,
9, Denied, The answer oontained in paragraph 7 hereof
is inoorporated herein by reference as if set forth in its
entirety,
10, Denied, After reasonable investigation Defendant i.
without knowledge or information sufficient to form a belief as to
the truth of the averments contained in this paragraph ancl,
therefore, they are denied,
- 2 -
11. Denied. The answer contained in paragraph 10 hereof
i. incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in it.
entirety.
12, Denied. The answer contained in paragraph 10 hereof
is incorporated herein by reference as if set forth in its
entirety.
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Jonathan T, Ehret, demands judgment
in his favor and against Plaintiffs,
Count II
13, The answers contained in paragraphs 1 through 12
hereof are incorporated hereof are incorporated herein by reference
as if set forth in their entirety,
14, Denied, The allegations contained in this paragraph
state a legal conclusion to which no response is necessary, By way
of further answer, with respect to any allegation that Plaintiff-
Husband sustained injury as a result of the motor vehicle accident
described in Plaintiffs' Complaint, after reasonable investigation
Defendant is without knowledge or information sufficient to form a
belief as to the truth of said averments and, therefore, they are
denied,
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Jonathan T, Ehret, demands judqaent
in his favor and against Plaintiffs.
- 3 -
.
,-
.
.
~ .
. .
...
" '...
, i
, 1,1,
I"
, .
'14\" "
, ,
,
,
,..~..."....
,'"
\
't
r
I
\
1\
"
(
\'
i'
, f"::
'\'r-:!'
" 'f<-
- I~,
f
;
;
"
,I"
,
I'
6: ,... ,"
t._
". I'
/, .. " ,
Ijt' r"
( ) ~ "n
r--' , ~~:
'.
II,'
;j:: ' , "
to , /.1
JI' /
..I r:.: ~I 0,:..
o.:~} .. >...
L\." 11.',1
(" , q.:..
. ...... ~;,t
/,1. S; ::.)
0 (J , "
,\
.11
l;;
I.,
].,
,
"
,
",
;!
"
"
,
,
"
d'
".,
,
.'
"
'I.',
,
,
.
,
'.
:>- '-II
1,'- ,.
il.: (" I.. , ,
It,~ ~ (~. 'J (.~
, ) I'll'
il': ; j, "
1.1.~ ).
"
l " 'I'-.J "
[', ~ ") ;ll)
'I' 'I
1..
Ei:' f' ,...j.
"i,! ,1,;(,)
...t. 1)11.
I' 1'1 ..',.
U .,/
(I'" ':.J
! R
~ I. ~
!!llai
rJljl i >
~ io~j
~-r I
"
"
.. .
8
H
..
t:
, ,
STEPHEN I, BANKO, JR.. ESOUIRE
PA Ano,ney I,D, No, 41n7
REYNOlDS rr HAVAS
A Prol.lllon.f (;QrporoUon
101 'In. Sit...
POll omc. Bo~ 832
Horn.burg, P.nnoylvanlo 1 71CJ8.OU32
(717) 231.3200
Attorn.y far Dol""d.nl
JOHNATHAN T. EHRET
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
SUSAN R. KIRJ<LAND and
RONALD R, KIRKLANDl
Pla ntiffs
No. 97-5673 Civil Term
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOHNATHAN T, EHRET,
Defendant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
NOTICE 01' INTENT TO BHE~~ A,BUBPOENA
TO PRODUCE ~INI!NTB ANn T_HIDB .EQ~...!!!.~!:;OVERY
PURSUANT TO RULE 400g.21
Defendant Johnathan T, Ehret, intends to serve a subpoena
identical to the one that is attached to this notice, You have
twenty (20) days from the date listed below in which to file of
record and serve upon the undersigned an Objection to the
subpoel\a, If no objection is made the subpoena may be served,
Date:
STEPHEN L, BANKO, JR,
PA Attorney I,D, No, 41727
REYNOLDS & HAVAS
A PrOfessional Corporation
101 Pine Street
Post Office Box 932
Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17108-0932
(717) 236-3200
Attorney for Defendant
Johnathan T, Ehret
,
,
{
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY
SUSAN R, KIRKLAND and
RONALD R, KIRKLAND,
Plaintiffs
No, 97-5673 Civil Term
v,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOHNATHAN T, EHRET,
Def.endant
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
TO: RECORDS CUSTODIAN
Jay J. Cho, M,O.
5124 E. Trindle Road
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
Within twenty (20) days after service of this SUbpoena, you
are ordered by the court to produce the fOllowing docllments or
things at the offices of Badowski, Banko, Kroll, Kronthal,and
Baker, A Professional Corporation, 101 Pine Street, Harrisburg,
Pennsylvania 17101:
You may del iver or mi'lil legible copies of the documents or
produce things requested by this subpoena, together witn the
certificate of compliance, to the party making this request at
the address listed above, You have the right to seek in advance
the reasonable cost of preparing the copies or producing the
things sought.
If you fail to produce the documents or things required by
this subpoena within twenty (20) days after its service, the
party serving this subpoena may seek a court order compelling you
to comply with it.
I,
, '
"
!
i\
~. \.l) '..
c.;:. I:
~~ '.. ;
ti L~~ i ,
~),. ! "
f' u..,.
.c r"
~)t,lt 0' '/;
C' I ,
.1/1- I ,
[j,; e'l ;:i'j
l!\\_1.
F: ~'i '>
~. ,'. r~j
(1-. (.i)
I,
I,
"
.
"
, "
:
,
,
,
.
,
,
,
"
, ,
.
CE~TIFICATE OF S~RVICE
I hereby certify that I have served a true and correct copy
of the foregoing document on all counsel of record by placing the
same in the United States Mail at Camp Hill, Pennsylvania, first-
class postage prepaid, on the 3(J day of 11 ~ ' 2000,
addressed as follows~
Jeff Foreman, Esquire
Nicholas & Foreman
4409 North Front StrQet
'Harrisburg, Pennsylvania 17110
(Counsel for Plaintiffs)
"
.t6 A ~. /. ~ ':I L.~L
8arbara,J. Smith, Secretary'
"
, I
,
"
I. , "
" 1<
,"
, ,
~ In ~
..;;j ~.
It'{{? ~ +>r.
<;.. "iJ
r, ')', :Jt: <"Ji!/:
ft.; ~{~ i-l.. "l-J
{'it. . ';. rf. "
g;" - ~OJ; i'l ,
..Jr' (>l
..'l;: :>-. 1~?E
tl,.., , ~': I..!'
[,' :r:: i3.
". I;')'
0 (;;)
':
"
'j
."
",
. ,