HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-05994
j
.
;;fJ
j
c,::
II
{,
fl
~ Ii \\
J 'I
":(
0--
0-
l.()
of'.' " . J 't
. .
/'J) of Cii i'f1 /I1~Jv ~ a~ ~Jt,~
/. 'J). .0/ 11 "t/i; w.a:J1 Z, aij {?z~'-
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintill'
: IN TIlE COURT OF COMMON Pl.EAS OF
; CUMBERl.AND COUNTY, PENNSYLV ANIA
\',
: NO. 97-5994 CIVIl. TERM
: CIVIl. ACTION - l.A W
; IN DIVORCE
RONAl.D L.. ROBERTS,
Defendant
PRAECIPE TO TRANSMIT RECORD
TO: Prothonotary of Cumberland County:
Plcase transmit the record, together with the following information, to the Court for entry
of a divorce decree:
I. Ground for divorce: irretrievable breakdown under Section 330\(c) of the Divorce
Code.
2. Date and manner of service ofComplainl: by certitied mail. restricted delivery on
Defendant on October 31, 1997 (sce Affidavit of Service tiled herein).
3. Date of execution of the Affidavit of Consent required by Section 330\(c) of the
Divorce Code: by the Plaintiff: December 21,2000: by the Defendant: December 21. 200n,
4. Date of execution of Waiver of Notice in Section 3301(c) Divorce: by the PlaintifT:
December 21, 2000; by the Defendant: December 21. 2000.
5. Related pending claims: None.
Date: Jii,AJ/l1t1f7 /5, .J{)'"
SNEl.BAKER. BRENNEMAN & SPARE. P. c.
1ti1~1"'~
By:
L.AW C",.IC".
!::iNELBAKER.
BRENNEMAN
81 SPARE
Allomeys for PlaintilT
..1''.
t~
"-
VI
C8
/. .. '"
-( ~ ~
..... , ~
""
L f
;,: ;
'.
~ XC
<=0 '>
,
::i " :;:
.
..';
~
-(
Z
-(
: ~
. >-
~- ../)
7-
/.
:( ~
.' "-
- ,
'"
j
:~ ~
~
:2.
:~
'..'
~
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5(1 'i,/ CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN DIVORCE
N 0 TIC E
You have been sued in Court. If you wish to defend against
the claims set forth in the following pages, you must take prompt
action. You are warned that if ycu fail to do so, the case may
proceed without you and a decree of divorce or annulment may be
entered against you by the Court. A judgment may alsc be entered
against you fcr any other claim for relief requested in these
papers by the Plaintiff. You may lose mcney or property or cther
rights important to you, including custody or visitation of your
children.
When the grcund for divorce is indignities or irretrievable
breakdown of the marriage, you may request that the court require
you and your spouse to attend marriage counseling prior to a
divorce decree being handed down by the ccurt. A list of
marriage counselors is available in the Office of the
Prothonotary at the Cumberland County Court House, Carlisle. You
are advised that this list is kept as a convenience to you and
you are not bound to choose a counselor from the list. All
necessary arrangements and the cost of counseling sessions are to
be borne by you and your spouse.
IF YOU DO NOT FILE A CLAIM FOR ALIMONY, DIVISION OF
PROPERTY, LAWYER'S FEES OR EXPENSES BEFORE A DECREE OF DIVORCE OR
ANNULMENT IS GRANTED, YOU MAY LOSE THE RIGHT TO CLAIM ANY OF
THEM.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Court Administratcr
One Courthouse square
Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013-3387
(717) 240-6285
L...-.... O"I'IC['1
SNHDAKER.
BRENNEMAN
8: SPARE
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN &
By: \4~..,,(t.
SPARE, P.C.
Attorneys for Plaintiff
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-,1)'1'1 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAN
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN DIVORCE
COMPLAIN'!'
COUNT I - DIVORCE
1. The Plaintiff in this action is JOANNE E. ROBERTS, an
adult individual residing at 10 Ncrth Road, Mechanicsburg,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
2. The Defendant in this action is RONALD L. ROBERTS, an
adult individual residing at 10 North Road, Mechanicsburg,
Cumberland County, Pennsylvania.
3. Both the Plaintiff and Defendant have been bona fide
residents of the Commonwealth cf Pennsylvania for at least six
(6) months immediately previous to the filing of this Complaint.
4. The Plaintiff and Defendant were lawfully joined in
marriage on June 21, 1969 in Perry Ccunty, Pennsylvania.
5. There have been no prior actions of divorce or
LAW O"FlC[~
SNU.BAKER.
BRENNEM,\N
a SPARE
for annulment between the parties hereto in this or any other
jurisdiction since the date of the marriage averred in Paragraph
4, above.
6. Neither party is a member ot the armed forces of the
United states of America.
7. The Plaintiff avers as the grounds upon which this
action is based:
a. that the marriage betwee~ the parties hereto is
irretrievably broken; and
b. that the Defendant has offered such indignities to the
Plaintiff, the innccent and injured spouse, as to
render her condition intolerable and life burdensome.
B. The Plaintiff has been advised that counseling is
available and that Plaintiff may have the right to request that
the Court require the parties to participate in counseling.
9. The Plaintiff requests this Court to enter a decree of
divorce.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Joanne E. Roberts requests this Court
to enter a Decree of Divorce, divorcing the Plaintiff from the
bonds of matrimony heretofore existing between the Plaintiff and
Defendant.
COUNT II - EOUITABLE DIVISION
10. Paragraphs 1 through 9, inclusive, of this Complaint
are incorporated by reference herein.
LAW OFFICtS
SNELrJAKER.
BRENNEMAN
a SPARE
11. The Plaintiff and Defendant have acquired property both
-2-
real and personal during their marriage from June 21, 1969.
12. The Plaintiff and Defendant have not agreed as to any
equitable distribution of the marital property.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Jcanne E. Roberts requests this Court
to order equitable distribution of marital property.
COUNT III - ALIMONY. ALIMONY PENDENTE LITE
AND COUNSEL FEES
13. The Plaintiff requires reasonable support and alimony
to adequately maintain herself in accordance with the standards
of living established during the parties' marriage.
14. The Plaintiff requests this Court to allow alimony and
alimony pendente lite as it deems reasonable pursuant to sections
3701 and 3702 of the Pennsylvania Divorce Code.
15. The Plaintiff has employed SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN &
SPARE, P.C., as counsel and, because of the anticipated
litigation expenses and costs and her lack of sufficient income,
is unable to pay for the expenses of counsel and litigation in
order to maintain this action.
The Plaintiff requests the Court to allow her
reasonable counsel fees, costs and expenses pursuant to Section
LAw O""ICtll
SNEL9AKER.
BRENNEMAN
Br SPARE
3702 of the Pennsylvania Divorce Code.
-3-
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff Joanne E. Roberts requests this Court
to:
a. order the Defendant to pay alimony and alimony pendente
lite to Plaintiff in such amounts as the Court deems
reasonable;
b. order payment of Plaintiff's counsel fees, costs and
expenses as the Court deems reasonable; and
c. order such other relief as the Court deems just
and reasonable.
Date: October 28, 1997
SNELBAKER, 8RENNEMAN & SPARE, P.C.
.y,Jf~~:' EoQU;ro
44 West Main street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055-0318
Telephone: 717-697-8528
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Joanne E. Roberts
LAW O"ICE:'5
SNELBAICER.
BRENNEMo\N
& SPAR!!
-4-
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing complaint
are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein
are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. S 4904 relating
to unsworn falsification to authorities.
{
Date: uctobe~ 2B, 1997
" ,
Joanne
,\
LAW O"'lCJ:8
SNELDAKER.
BRENNEMAN
a SPARE
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97- CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN DIVORCE
AFFIDAVIT
JOANNE E. ROBERTS, being duly sworn according to law,
deposes and says:
1. I have been advised of the availability of marriage
counseling and understand that I may request that the court
require that my spouse and I participate in counseling.
2. I understand that the court maintains a list of marriage
counselors in the Office of the Prothonotary, which list is
available to me upon request.
3. Being so advised, I do HQI request that the court
require my spouse and I participate in counseling prior to a
divorce decree being handed down by the court.
I understand that false statements herein are made subject
to the penalties of 18 Pa. C.S. S 4904 relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities.
UW OFF1C(!I
SNELOAICER,
BRENNfMAN
Bt SPARE
~...J_ ~
C) A:J 1/ 59--
.. I ,."..' -' /l.J.t-tt..e-l .
Joanne E. Roberts
(Plaintiff)
v
Date:
/tf.,',(y-'l?
12/21/00 10:21
1tTlT 233 Z3U
SOCHA .. lIAFFETI
lilI003/008
JOANNB B. ROBllRTS.
Plaintiff
IN THB COURT OP COMMON PLBAS OP
COMBBRLAND COUNT'{, PllNNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 Civil
CIVIL ACTION-IN DIVORCB
va.
RONALD L. ROBBRTS,
Detendant
1. A Complaint in Divorce under Section 3301(C) of the
Divorce Code was filed on October 29, 1997.
2. The marriage of Plaintiff and Oefandant i.
irretrievably broken and ninety (90) days have elapsed from the
date of the tiling and service cf the Complaint.
3. I consent to the entry Of . Pinal necree in Divorce
after service ot nctice of intention to request entry of the
decree.
I undentand that false statements herein are made
subject to the penalties cf 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904, relating to
unsworn falsification to authorities.
Datal Oetl/loftl<..m. JI, ;)"'0"
f1
j-':),'
~l '" " h ,/' d/} ^', ,,0)
~ canne B. Roberts
SS# No.
r
lZ/21/00 10:21
ttTi T 233 2H2
SOCHA . lIAFFEIT
~ OOZ/OOS
JOANNB B. ROB!RTS,
plaintU~f
IN nIB COURT OF COMMON Pt.BAS or
COMBBRLAND COUNTY, PiNN8nVANIA
NO. 97-5994 Civil
CIVIL ACTION-IN DIVORCB
VI.
RONALD L. JlOBIJlTS,
Darandant
~AVIT 0' CONSENI
1. A Complaint in Divorce under Section 3301(c) of th.
Divorce Code .a. filed on October 29, 1997.
2. The marriage of plaintiff and Defendant is
irretrievably broken and ninety (90) daye have elapsed from the
date of tha filing and service of the Complaint.
3. I consent to the entry of a Final Decree in Divorce
after service cf notice of intention to request entry of the
decree.
I understand that false statements herein are 1IIlIde
subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C,S. Section 4904, relating to
unsworn falsification to authoriti.s.
Date.
(z. . z.(-(!JO
f~~ kU:k-
Ronald L. Roberts
SS. No. Zo~, al.-Z~63
- ..,. C
IJ; :?:'
, 'J --.J ~5
':':J
) ~:~
~... -.,- ~
--1 ;;:1
" ,-
'/1
(\: " ,
~ il(f]
L ole..
... -,
'-0 ::>
C...."J r.,j
11/11/00 10:11
tt71 T Z33 2HZ
12;0041008
SOCHA . ltAFFEIT
JOANNB B. ROBBRTS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OP
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 Civil
CIVIL ACTION-IN DIVORCE
VB.
RONALD 1.. ROBIiRTS,
Defendant
"AIVU or NOTICB OJ' Ift~Aln'ION TO UClUBST
IIJlTJlY 0' A D:tVOJlCII D.CIIJI. URtlllJl S.C!TIOJI
3301 (c) 0' TBB D:tVo.a COD.
1. I consent to entry of a final Decree of Divorce
without notice.
2. I understand that I may 105e rights concerning
alimony, division of property, lawyer's fees or expenses if I do
not claim them before a divorce is granted,
3. I understand that I will not be divorced until a
Decree is entered by the Court and that a copy of the Decree will
be sent to me immediately after it is filed with the Prothonotary.
4. I verify that the statement made in this Waiver are
true and correct. I understand that lalse statements herein are
made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904, relating
to unsworn falsification to authorities.
OATH.
Xt.~tf~8c1:.. 21 2t,,,o
/
1
2 'Co'
t' ({C;-.(./t<-/~ ~5;;j
/ Joanne Ii:. Roberts
~
'>-- ..;:" ;-.
u:
.. , ~
l''': ,-
'.0-
.o~ . " "~j
fr?
(->. .'
, id
,
... ""
--:' ,J
'-~ ~ , )
13/31-00 10:31
0117 333 Z3U
SOCHA , IIAFFEIT
IiII005/005
JOANNB B. ROBlIRTS, IN Tal COURT OF COMMON PLJWI OF
Plaintiff I CUMBRRLAND COUNT'i, PL'IlNSYLVANIA
VI. NO. 97-5994 Civil
CIVIL ACTION-IN DIVORCB
RONALD L. ROBBRTS,
DtItendant
wAIVIa 0' MOTIeB or IWTKRTIOW TO -.QOWST
IIIIDY o' A J:lIVO.CH I).cu. tlNDD SBCTIOIl
3301 Ie) 0' '1'1IlI DIVO.CJ1 COD.
1. I conaent to entry of a tin.l Deera. of Divorca
witb.o\lt notic..
2. I understand that I may lose rights concerning
alimony, divisicn of property, lawyer'a fees cr explnaal if I do
not claim them before a divorc. is granted.
3. I understand that I will not be divorced until a
Decree i8 entered by the CO\lrt and that a copy of the Decree will
be aent to me immediately after it il filed with the Prothonotary.
4. I verify that the statement made in this Waiver are
true and correct. I understand that talse statements herein are
made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904, relating
to \ln8worn f.lsifieation to autho~itiel.
DATB.
rz.'l../..(')o
e..f)) /1Jd
Ronald L. Roberta
IZ'(.(-oo
c,
(
II'
~..:.~
C)
',,)
(:
.:>:
;j;)
,.. ~...
. ~~ ~j
'-,,-
';J')
.; ~::;
-'Iii]
_-:',10-
:3
<..)
..:!'
Lr.
I~'J
.....
,.J..
r".~
.
VB.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND CO~TY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN DIVORCE
AFFIDAVIT OF SERVICE
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA)
SS.
COUNTY
OF
CUMBERLAND)
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire, being duly sworn according to
law depcses and says: that be is a principal in the law firm of
Snelbaker, Brenneman & Spare, P. C., being the attorneys tor
Joanne E. Roberts, the Plaintiff in the above captioned acticn in
divorce; that on October 29, 1997, he did send to Defendant
Ronald L. Roberts by certified mail, return receipt requested,
restricted delivery, a duly certified copy of the Complaint in
Divorce which was filed in the above captioned action as
evidenced by the attached cover letter of the same date and
Receipt for certified Mail No. P 206 994 263; that both the
Complaint and cover letter were duly received by Ronald L.
Roberts, the Defendant herein, as evidenced by the return receipt
card for said certified mail dated October 31, 1997; that a
LAW or'-le..
copy of the aforementioned cover letter dated October 29, 1997
is attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein as
"Exhibit A" and that the original Receipt for certified Mail and
SNnBAKER.
BRlILNNUCAN
&: SPARE
SNELIlAKER. BRENN EM....N , 11 SPARE
" r"O'B~IONAL (o"rl.."lVInON
^,ITORNEY~ ^ r uo>W
""" WUT JotAIN "BUT
MECHANIC5BURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17055
P 0 lOX J..
fACSIMILE t1Il'I eOl.1681
~ICHAAD C. ~N[L'^IC.U"
KEITH 0 IRENNlMAN
PHILIP H ~P^RE.
111 601'''~28
october 29, 1997
Ronald L. Roberts
10 North Rcad
Hechanicsburg, PA 17055
Re: Rcberts v. Roberts
No. 97-5994, Cumberland Ccunty
Dear Hr. Roberts:
Enclosed please find a certified copy of the Divorce
complaint filed this date in the above case.
Please be guided accordingly.
Ycurs truly,
Keith O. Brenneman
KOB/SZ
Enclosure
CC: Joanne E. Roberts (w/enclosure)
Via certified mail, restricted delivery, return
receipt requested, Parcel No. P 206 994 263
EXHIBIT A
P ?Olo ""4 2103
us P__'
Receipt for Certified Man
No 111IUI_' eo...-gl Pr_
Do nol _lor Intoma_ Mall SH,.,..,..
~ona1d L. Roberts
orth Road
PI, 1 g
......
.
, r
, '
." ..!
~F..
IiI>OdoI~F..
1. 35
2.75
1.10
s .;:1
~
--'-'10>_-
,--"........
. ,.. yaw NI'N IN....... on IliI ...."... bin to INII.. CM fIhm iii
I -..-
eAlilllft..1DIm ID '" hnI 0I"~. cw CI'I1lI '** 1I1p1Ce'" naI
=,....",~~ rf ronINlftllllPlclltlIIowl'lill'idlruNlet.
I en. "-'" ...... .. Ihn to wtlom....... dIIIvwM Jnd '" II-.
. -
,
10:
I ..... """ 10 ........ fie
toIowtng _ (lor..
_...):
1.CJAddrI1l1l"~ J
2.lCf~ DIMly
ConIUI poo"-' lor.... I
Ronald L. Roberts
10 North Road
Mechanicsburg, PA
17055
....
P 206 I
41>. ype
o RogialerId XQlI c..1IIIecI
o E>jQu Mall 0 I....... f
o Aobn ' ""__ 0 COO
I
I
I
LAW OI'I'H.:r~
I e,
.. X
PSI'arm 3111, o.c..llllelll114
SNI::U1AKER.
BRENNEMA~l
& SPARE
EXHIBlT B
...
~ .'- i~
.j' ('..'
.,. (..:~ .
UJ'l I.,.
t2;
n~' , ,~: 1
f")r- -,
j'" "I "
(.1'
ll! -
,
it' ~. . i;,;
, ' ,""
, (,., )
t'
..' (jl . )
'~ r:y,
~~
~ I
i~ "" ~di,
~~ ."" .. i
~D . e
~] I
~8 .... ~~
.,. li!~ ~~ .( ~~i I;
8~ .,.
If'l .... i
I . ~I~~ ~
..... fol . . i I
04
;s .,. i f! - ~! !:
. i Cl <~"
i 0 2, !i J
....
.....
JOANNB S. aOBBaTS, I IN THB COURT or COMMON PLBAS
Plaintiff I cmmSJU.ANI) COtJNTY, PBNNSYLVANIA
I
va. I NO. 97-5994
I
aOANLD L. aOBBaTS, I IN DIVORCB
Defendant I
NOTICB TO DEPEND AND CLAIM RIOBTS
YOU HAVE BEEN
the claims set forth
action.
SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against
in the following pages, you must take prompt
You are warned that if you fail to do so, the case may
proceed without you and a decree of divorce or annulment may be
entered against you by the Court. A judgment may also be entered
against you for any other claim or relief requested in these
papers by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other
rights important to you, including custody or visitation of your
children.
When the ground for the divorce is indignities or
irretrievable breakdown of the marriage, you may request marriage
counseling. A list of marriage counselors is available in the
Court Administrator's Office, Cumberland County Courthouse, Carlisle,
PA.
IF YOU DO NOT FILE A CLAIM FOR ALIMONY, DIVISION OF
PROPERTY, LAWYER'S FEES OR EXPENSES BEFORE A DIVORCE OR ANNULMENT IS
GRANTED, YOU MAY LOSE THE RIGHT TO CLAIM ANY OF THEM.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE
OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-3166
JOANNE B. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNA
vs.
NO. 97- 5994
CIVIL ACTION-DIVORCE
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
ANSWER AND COUNTERCLAIM
COUNT I. DIVORCE
1. Admitted.
2. Denied.
Defendant's address is 400 High Street,
Apartment 1, West 1l'airview, Pennsylvania.
3. Admitted.
4. Admitted.
5 _ Admitted.
6. Admitted.
7. a. Admitted.
b. Denied. Strict proof thereof is demanded.
8. No responsive pleading required.
9. No responsive pleading required.
WHBRBPORB, Defendant, Ronald L. Roberts requests this
Court to enter a Decree in Divorce.
COUNT ll- EQUITABLE DISTRIBUfION
10. No responsive pleading required.
11. Admitted.
12. Admitted.
l
r
tfBBRBPORB, Defendant Ronald L. Roberts requests this
Court to order equitable distribution of marital property.
.
COUNT m- ALIMONY, ALIMONY PENDENfE LITE
AND COUNSEL FEES
13,
Denied.
r ...ll:tiff does not require support and
alimony to adequately maintain herself.
14. No responsive pleading required.
15. It is admitted that Plaintiff has employed
SNBLBAKBR, BRENNEMAN & SPARE, P.C., as counsel. It is denied that
she is unable to pay for the expense of counsel.
WHERBFORB, Defendant requests this Court to deny
Plaintiff's requests for alimony, alimony pendente lite, counsel
fees, costs and expenses.
COUNTERCLAIM
16. Plaintiff and Defendant separated in October, 1988
and have lived separate and apart since then.
17. The marriage is irretrievable broken.
WHEREFORE, Defendant requests this Honorable Court to
enter a final divorce decree.
Respectfully submitted:
aith A. Calk n, Esquire
ttorney for Defendant
2201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(717) 238-2312
mmAYII
I verify that the statements made in this Answer and
Counterclaim are true and correct. I understand that false
statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18
Pa.C.S.Section 4904, relating to unsworn
authorities.
falsification to
Date:
(2.. ~&. ~
Robert L. Roberts
Sworn and Subscribed
before me thisK~ay
of tJ · \J. , 1999.
~~
Notary Public
CEBllFICATE OF SEIlYlCE
I, Judith A. Calkin, Esquire do hereby certify that a
true and correct copy of the within Answer and Counterclaim has
been sent by United States Mail, postage pre-paid,
the following person:
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN & SPARE
44 West Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
delivery to
Date:
she is currently back to work full-time and her health
situation has not ~ffected her current ability to pursue her
employment. Upon the entry of a divorce decree wife will have
medical insurance coverage available through her employer but
there will be some cost to her. She also, of course, will
have the opportunity to take COBRA benefits through husband's
employer and if that is an option that she wants to pursue,
husband should provide her with the cost of those benefits.
Husband is 59 years of age and resides at 400
High Street, Apartment 1, West Fairview, Pennsylvania, where
he lives with a female friend. He is a high school graduate
and is employed as a maintenance and repair person with the
Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. His current net monthly income
is $1,965.00. Husband has not raised any health issues.
The parties own real estate at 10 North Road,
Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, where wife is currently residing.
The house was appraised showing a market value of $114,000.00.
However, counsel are going to discuss with their clients the
possibility of listing the house for sale immediately. By
pursuing a sale, the parties will share the costs of sale and
the market will determine the value. There is a home equity
loan currently against the property with a payoff of around
$15,600.00. Wife has been paying $284.51 per month on that
loan.
The parties also own a lot in Fowler's
Hollow, Perry County, Pennsylvania. The lot is approximately
25 acres and was appraised at $37,500.00 Counsel are going
to see if the parties will list the property for sale. The
property was received as a gift from Plaintiff's mother in
1980 but was titled in both names so it has assumed a marital
property characterization.
The only marital vehicle is a 1984 El Camino
which Ms. Calkin indicated she will have appraised.
Counsel have agreed they are not going to
include in the equitable distribution computation the checking
and savings accounts which had a minimal value at the date of
separation.
Wife inherited shares of stock which
ultimately became PNC shares and titled those shares half in
her name and the daughter's name and half in her name and the
son's name. Ms. Calkin has requested information as to when
the actual title transfers were made from the mother to the
children. In any event, we have an issue as to whether or not
the increase in value should include an increase of all of the
. shares from the date of acquisition to the date of separation
or whether we should exclude a portion of the increase because
of the title ownership of half of the shares by the children.
Ms. Calkin has indicated that she would like to do some
research and present a memorandum on that issue.
Wife inherited $24,632.42 which was used to
purchase partially insurance policies and CDs. The pretrial
statements listed values of the insurance policies and CDs and
counsel have agreed that we can simply reduce that total value
by the amount of funds that wife claims were expended from her
inheritance.
The parties also own as marital assets two
Nationwide funds and their values can be updated to the date
of hearing.
Husband has a pension with the Commonwealth
of Pennsylvania which Ms. Calkin had appraised and attac~ed a
valuation to the inventory and appraisement. The valuation of
the marital benefit as of July 31, 1998, was $233,249.00.
That value, which represents the marital portion, should be
updated with an interest factor to the date of hearing.
Wife also had a pension with Compass Group
USA of around $4,497.00. That value should also be updated
with an interest factor.
The parties own considerable items of
tangible personal property. Many of the items have been
identified as antiques and collectibles, and the parties are
going to talk to their clients about having a public sale to
dispose of all the items. The sale presumably would occur at
the marital residence and counsel have suggested that perhaps
Chuck Bricker could conduct the sale, The matter of
scheduling of the sale should be done quickly so that it can
be accomplished in the next couple of months while the weather
is still conducive to an outdoor auction. With respect to
items not identified as antiques and collectibles, Mr.
Brenneman is going to have his client identify items she wants
to remove when she takes up a new residence and have those
items appraised. Otherwise the balance of the other household
items can be included with the items to be sold at the
auction.
Attached to Mr. Brenneman's pretrial
statement is an exhibit identified as nonmarital property.
Husband agrees that all items listed on the exhibi: in the
living room and kitchen are nonmarital; in the family room, he
only agrees that the snowmen and the salt and pepper set are
. nonmarital, the rest being marital.
Ms. Calkin has requested a copy of the
probate documents from wife's mother's death and the
documentation of when the now PNC stocks were titled in wife's
and the children's name.
A hearing is scheduled for Thursday, December
21, 2000 at 9:00 a.m. Notices will be sent to counsel and
the parties.
E. Robert Elicker, II
Divorce Master
cc: Keith O. Brenneman
Attorney for Plaintiff
Judith A. Calkin
Attorney for Defendant
Recapitulation of Assets:
House (net ofmorlgage):
Perry County properly:
PNC Stock-:
New York Life Ins. Policies:
Nationwide Tax Free Income Fund:
Nationwide Non-Qualified Annuity:
CD - Bank of Landisburg
CD - Bank of Landisburg
Compass Group Savings Retirement Plan:
PSER Retirement benefit
Cash from sale of personal properly:
El Cwnino
Separately appraised personal properly:
Total:
less Wife's non-marital inheritance:
Total Marital assets:
$ 98,500
37,000
135,600
81,752
15,770
10.622
3.000
4.000
4,497
233.249
24,229
3,500
3.165
$654,884
-24.630
$630,254
-This figure takes into account the $6,960 value of
stock inherited by Wife from her mother.
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
10/11./oDt
v.
NO. 97-5994
CIVIL TERM
ACTION IN DIVORCE
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
DEFENDANT'S MEMORANDUM OF LAW
1. FACTUAL BACKGROUND.
During the marriage Wife received Inheritance from her mother of stock whose value at
the time was approximately $7000. Sometime afterwards, Wife Included the names of the
parties' children on the stock along with her own, By the time of separation the value had
increased to $105,000, Husband claims that the appreciation in the value of the stock Is marital
property and therefore subject to equitable distribution, Wife agrees that one-half of the Increase
is marital property, but she argues that fifty percent of the Increase Is the children's and not
subject to distribution. Children are now emancipated. They have never liquidated their portion
of the stock, nor have they paid any of the taxes on Ihe eamlngs from the stock. The taxes have
been paid jointly by Husband and Wife.
2. ISSUES
A. WHETHER AN INCREASE IN VALUE OF INHERITANCE OF STOCK GIVEN TO A
SPOUSE BY A THIRD PARTY IS A MARITAL ASSET?
Answer: Yes,
B, WHETHER MARITAL PROPERTY WHICH HAS BEEN CONVEYED TO CHILDREN
FOR NO VALUE IS STILL CONSIDERED MARITAL PROPERTY?
Answer: Yes
3, ARGUMENTS
A. AN INCREASE IN VALUE OF INHERITANCE OF STOCK GIVEN TO A SPOUSE BY
A THIRD PARTY IS A MARITAL ASSET.
The Increased value of the stock at the time of separation Is a marital asset and subject
to distribution. Wife can only claim the value of the original amount Inherited as a nonmarital
asset. The relevant statute is Section 3501 of the Divorce Code which defines marital property
as "all property acquired by either party during the marriage, including the increase in value, prior
to the date of final separation, of any nonmarital property acquired pursuant to paragraphs (1)
and (3).' 23 Pa,C,S,A, !i3501(a). Subsection 3501(a)(3) describes "nonmarital property".1
"[p]roperty acquired by gift, except between spouses, bequest, devise or descent.' Accordingly,
while the giflto Wife is not to be considered marital property, "the Increase in value prior to the
date of final separation' of the bequest is to be treated as a marital asset.
Beginning with Anthonv v, Anthonv. 355 Pa, Super. 589, 514 A,2d 91 (1986), it hIS been
well sellled In case law that the appreciation in value of a spouse's property during the marriage
Is considered a marital asset. In Anthonv, the Court addressed the issue of "whether under the
Divorce Code an Increase, during the parties' marriage, in the value of premarital assets
constitutes marital property.' Id. 514 A,2d at 92, The Court concluded that the increase In value
of a home during the marriage, although purchased prior to the marriage, was marital property.
The Anthonv Court rejected the appellants' argument that only the "appreciation in value'
attributable "to the joint efforts and/or financial contributions of both spouses' should be
considered marital property, Id, The appellants contended that, "to the extent an increase II due
to economic factors such as inflation, It should be excluded.' Id. The Court disagreed,
The Court began its analysis of the Issue with the .threshold' question of "what comprises
marital property.' Id, The Court looked to Section 401 of the DivorcQ Code' which defined
'Act of April 2, 1980, P.L, 63, 23 P,S, !i 401. The language In this Act, where relevant
here, is essentially the same as that which is found in the current Divorce Code,
2
'marital property as 'all property acquired by either party dUling the marriage, ",2 The Court then
observed that the Divorce Code "excepts from the definition of marital property certain
enumerated assets with a proviso that as to those assets the increase In value during the
marriage is marital property:3 Upon finding that the Divorce Code "includes all property, real or
personal, acquired during the parties' marriage by either spouse, whether titled individually or
jointly," the Court held that "the time, rather than the method, of property acquisition determines
if an item of property constitutes marital property under the Code." !.Il, 514 A.2d at 92-3.
The Court reasoned:
Even the limited marital property exceptions enumerated in subsections
401(e)(1)-(7) of the Code reflect the significance of the time property Is
acquired in differentiating marital property from nonmarital property. For
example, subsections 401(e)(1) and 401 (e)(3) exclude from marital property
any real or personal property received during the parties' marriage either in
exchange for premarital property or by gift, bequest, devise or descent.
Nevertheless, these subsections specifically classify as marital property any
increase in the value of such exchange or given property durillg the parties'
marriage. In other words, if accrued during the period of the parties' marriage,
an appreciation in the value of property belonging to either spouse represents,
in and of itself, property acquired during the parties' marriage, I.e" marital
property, ~
!.Il, 514 A.2d at 93. The Court's conclusion that "time, rather than the manner, of acquisition. . .
detennines whether property constitutes marital property under Pennsylvania's Divorce Code"
and that "the spouses' efforts and/or financial contributions are not germane to definition of
223 P,S. @ 401(e).
323 P.S, @ 401(e)(1) & (e)(3),
'23 P,S, S 401 (e)-(I).
S:Z3 P.S. S 401(e)(1) and (3).
3
marital property under the Codeoe Is the applicable principle here. !!I.
In the present case the property at Issue is the increase in value of the stock bequested
to wife during the marriage, As found In Anthonv, the appreciation in value constitutes 'property
acqulrad during the parties' marriage, i,e" marital property.' Thus, the amount of appreciation in
the value of the stock prior to sepliration must be considered a marital asset.
B, MARITAL PROPERTY WHICH HAS BEEN CONVEYED TO CHILDREN FOR NO
VALUE IS STILL CONSIDERED MARITAL PROPERTY,
In \he Instant case Wife cannot exclude the increased value In the stock from the marital
assets by claiming only her and her children's names are on it. As shown above, the
appreciation In value is marital property, Section 3501 (a)(5) only excludes from the marital
assets "[p]roperty which a party has sold, granted, conveyed or otherwise disposed of in good
faith and for value prior to the date of final separation." 23 Pa,C.SA !j3501(a)(5); emphasis
added. Here, Wife's merely pulling the children's names on the stock constitutes a conveyanca
without receiving any "value" or consideration In return and therefore does not remove the
Increased value from the pool of marital assets.
In DeMasi v, DeMasi, 366 Pa. Super, 19,530 A2d 871 (1987), the Court applied the
equivalent of Section 3501 (a)(5) to find thai the trust accounts established by Husband for the
parties' child was a marital asset because Husband had not received any value In exchange for
the marital funds used to purchase the trust accounts, Husband had bought the certificates of
deposit with Insurance proceeds arising from the parties' double coverage nn their son. The son
"The Court's holding that '[t]lme of acquisition Is the factor that the legislature mandates
the courts use in determining whether property is a marital asset' was recantly reaffirmed In
Smith v, Smith, _ Pa. Super. _' _,749 A2d 921, 926 (2000), when the Court held that
"[u]nder the statute the court first determines what Is marital property based upon the time of
acquisition.'
4
had sustained serious Injuries In an accidenl. According to the Court's findings, the son'.
"medical and hospital expenses were covered by separate health and automobile Insurance
policies,' so "husband and wile received $19,800,00 from one policy which was the amount paid
to providers of medical treatment under the other policy.' 1!L, 530 A.2d at 884.
Husband received the proceeds alter the parties were separated, He opened the trust
accounts for the son without Wile's knowledge, Wife argued that the money/proceeds was a
marital assel. She claimed the money had been intended "for travel or to redecorate the house,
and that husband unilalerally changed those plans by placing the funds In trust for the children."
She argued that Husband "did so to place these funds beyond her control and outside the realm
of marital property.' !II,
The Court agreed with Wife's argument that the funds were marital property. Its analysis
began with determining that the time when the property or title to the proceeds arose was during
the marriage, Specifically, the Court found that, although the payment from the insurance policy
was made alter separation, the amount of the payment received "was guaranteed" to the parties
prior to separation. 1!L, 530 A2d at 885, The payment was "guaranteed" because of the
"identical coverage provided by the parties' automobile and medical insurance carriers': "One
carrier paid the provider of the medical services; the other paid the parties for those same
services." Id, Furthermore, the Court pointed out, "the amounl of the claim was ascertainable as
the $19,800,00 represented medical services rendered belore separation, Therefore, there was
nothing conjectural, speculalive or nebulous about the validity and amount of Vincent's claim."
The Court thus concluded that "(t]ille to the insurance proceeds was acquired prior to
separation." !II.
The Court having resolved the issue of when the proceeds were obtained then addressed
Ihe questions of 'whether the insurance proceeds were pro pert)' acquired by the parties; and. . .
5
If so, whether they were 'disposed of In good faith and for value prior to the time' divorce
proceedings were commenced, " Jg, On the first Issue the Court found that the Injured son "was
merely a subject of coverage.' On the other hand, the Court observed, "[h]usband and wife were
the owners of the Insurance policies and were obligated to pay the premiums,' The Court
therefore determined that "the insurance proceeds are marital property b.scause they were
acquired during the marriage.' Jg,
On the second Issue, Husband had argued that pursuant to Section 401 (e)(5), he had
disposed of the marital property, I.e" Insurance proceeds in "good fallh.' The Court disagreed:
'Husband may have disposed of the insurance proceedS in good faith by establishing trusts for
his sons; however, the trusts were not established In exchange for value, Section 401 (e)(5)
requires a disposition that brings some value, yet husband disposed of the proceeds as gifts.'
Similarly, in the instant case, in pulling the children's name on the stock, Wife gifted them
a portion of the marital property, As demonstrated above, the appreciation In the value of the
stock during the marriage Is a marital asset. The increase occurred prior to separation, and the
value Is not spaculative but, instead, easily determined, In addition, while Wife, like the husband
in DeMasi, may have made a "good faith" disposition of the stock by alloceting it to the children,
the transfer was gratuitous, The children gave no value In retum for being named as owners of
the stock, Therefore, in spite of Wife's having named the children as co-owners of the stock, the
appreciation In value remains a marital asset and subject to distribulion,
'See 23 P.S. @ 401(e)(5).
8
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Judith A. Calkin, Esquire, do hereby certify that a true and correct copy of the attached
Defendant's Memorandum of Law was sent by U,S, mail I!) the following persons:
Keith 0, Brenneman, Esquire
44 West Main Street
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
E, Robert Elicker, II, Esquire
Offico of the Divorce Master
11 N. Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Date'
/~J~/ttV
~
dith A. Calkin, E:squire
201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(717) 238-2956
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
P103in tiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY. PENNSYLVANIA
,
,
I NO, 97 - 5994
vs.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
: IN DIVORCE
ORDER AND NOTICE SETTING HEARING
TO: Joanne E. Roberts Plaintiff
,
Keith 0, Brenneman Counsel for Plaintiff
,
Ronald L. Roberts Defendant
,
Judith A. Calkin Counsel fcr Defendant
,
You are directed to appear for a hearing to take
testimony on the outstanding issues in the above captioned
divorce proceedings at the Office of the Divorce Master, 9 North
Hanover Street, Carlisle, Pennsylvania on the 21st day
of December ,2000 at 9: 00 a.m., at which
place and time you will be given the opportunity to present
witnesses and exhibits in support of your case.
President Judge
Date of Order and
Notice: 8/23/00
By:
Divorce Master
IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN
GET LEGAL HELP.
CUMBERLAND COUNTY BAR ASSOCIATION
2 LIBERTY AVENUE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
TELEPHONE (717) 249-3166
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
IN TilE COURT Of COMMON PLEAS Of
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO. 97 - 5994 CIVIL
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN DIVORCE
NOTICE Of PRE-HEARING CONfERENCE
TO: Keith O. Brenneman
, Attorney for Plaintiff
Judith A. Calkin
, Attorney for Defendant
A pre-hearing conference has been scheduled at the
Office of the Divorce Master, 9 North Hanover Street,
Carlisle, Pennsylvania, on the 16th day of October 2000, at
9:30 a.m., at which time we will review the pre-trial
statements previously filed by counsel, define issues,
identify witnesses, explore the possibility of settlement
and, if necessary, schedule a hearing.
Very truly yours,
Date of Notice: 7/17/00
E. Robert Elicker, II
Divorce Master
~~
OFFICI! OF DIVORCE MASTER
CUMBEnLAND COUN T Y
COURT OF COMMON PI EAS
9 North Hanover Slrcet
Carlisle. PA 17013
(717) 2406535
E. Robert Elicker, II
Divorce Master
Tracl .10 Colver
Offiee Manager/Reporter
We.' Shore
697.0371 Exl6535
June 6, 2000
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire
SNEL.BAKER, BRENNEMAN & SPARE
44 West Main Street
P.O, Box 318
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
Judith A, Calkin
Attorney at L.aw
2201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
RE: Joanne E, Roberts vs, Ronald L. Roberts
No. 97 - 5994 Civil
In Divorce
Dear Mr. Brenneman and Ms. Calkin:
Ms. Calkin has advised by letter of June 2, 2000, that discovery is
complete. I hove not heord from Mr. Brenneman nor has he filed his
certification document; therefore, I assume that there will be no
outstanding issues with regard to discovery matters. Based on that
assumption, I am going to direct that counsel file pretrial statements.
A divorce complaint was filed on October 29, 1997, raising grounds
for divorce of irretrievable breakdown of the marriage and indignities. The
complaint also raised economic claims of equitable distribution, alimony,
alimony pendente lite, and counsel fees and costs,
MR. BRENNEMAN AND MS. CALKIN, ATTORNEYS AT LAW
6 JUNE 2000
PAGE 2
I assume also that there is no issue with regard to grounds for
divorce and that the parties will either sign affidavits of consent or have
been separated for a period in excess of two years.
I am directing each counsel to file a pretrial statement in accordance
with P.R.C.P. 1920.33(b) on or before Friday, July 7, 2000. Upon receipt of
the pretrial statements, I will immediately schedule 0 pre-hearing
conference with counsel to discuss the issues and, if necessary, schedule a
hearing.
Very truly yours,
E. Robert Elicker, n
Divorce Master
NOTE:
Sanctions for failure to file pretrial statements are set
forth in subdivision (c) and (d) of Rule 1920.33.
THE ORIGINAL PRETRIAL STATEMENT SHOULD BE
fILED IN THE MASTER'S OFfICE AND A COPY SENT
DIRECTLY TO OPPOSING COUNSEL.
FAILURE TO FILE PRETRIAL STATEMENTS AS DIRECTED
BY THE MASTER MAY RESULT IN THE MASTER'S
APPOINTMENT BEING VACATED.
J U D I T II A. C A L KIN
ATTORNEY-AT.LAW
220 I NORTH SECOND STREET
HARRISBURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17110
(717) 238-2312
FAX (717) 233-2342
June 30, 2000
Robert Elicker, Esquire
Divorce Master
9 North Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
RBI Roberts v. Roberts
Dear Mr. Elicker:
Enclosed please find the following:
1. Pre-trial Statement.
.,
, .
Inventory and Appraisement.
'\
I
3. Income and Expense Statement.
If you have any questions, please give me a call.
V]:;YO~
Judith A. Calkin
JAC/er
cc: Ron Roberts
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire
-
...
*
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
ICUMBERLANO COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
I
VI.
RONALD L. ROBERTS.. d
Dehn ant
NO.
97-5994
CIVIL ACTION-LAW
IN DIVORCE
INVENTORY AND APPRAISEMENT
OF
RONALD L. ROBERTS
Plaintiff
( x) Defendant files the following
inventory and appraisement of all property owned or possessed by
either party at the time this action was commenced and all property
transferred within the preceding three years.
) Plaintiff (~Defendant verifies that the statements
made in this inventory and appraisement are true and correct.
plaintiff (X) Defendant understands that false statements
'herein are made subject to the penalties cf 18 Pa,C.S. 4904
relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
l2~ ~~
( ) Plaintiff (x) Defendant
RONALD L. ROBERTS
-
-.
AssrTS OF PARTIES
) plaintiff
those items applicable to
on the following pages.
( X) 1. Real Property
(x ) Defendant marks on the list below
the case at bar and itemizes the asseta
( X) 2. Motor Vehicles
( X) 3. Stocks, bonds, securities and options
( Xl 4. Certificates of deposit
( X) 5. Checking accounts, cash
( X) 6. Savings accounts, money market savings certificates
) 7. Contents of safe deposit boxes
) 8. Trusts
(X) 9. Life Insurance policies (indicate face value, cash
surrender value and current beneficiaries)
( X) 10. Annuities
) 11. Gifts
( ) 12. Inheritances
( ) 13. Patents, copyrights, inventions, royalties
( x) 14. Personal property outside the home
( ) 15. Businesses (list all owners, including percentage of
ownership, and officer/director positions held by a
party with company)
) 16. Employment termination benefits--severance pay,
workman's compensaticn claim/award
17. 401 K Plan
(X) 18. Pension plan (indicate employee contribution and
date plan vests)
19. Retirement plans
) 20. Disability payments
.
21. Litigation claims (matured and unmatured)
) 22. Military/V.A. benefits
) 23. Education benefits
( ~ 24. Debts due, including lcans, mortgages held
( ~ 25. Household furnishings and personalty (include as a
total category and attach itemized list if
distribution of such assets is in dispute)
( xl 26. Other
MARITAL PROPERTY: () plaintiff (xl Defendant lists all marital
property in which either or both spouses have a legal or equitAble
interest individually or with Any other perscn as cf the dAte this
action was ccmmenced.
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION I
M:lIrf~n1 hnmA
VALUE: 114,000,00
DATE or VALUATION:
1?/ln/Q1
NON-MARTIAL PORTION I None
AMOUNT/NATURE or ANY LIEN:
Mortggae Sl;_~&R nn nG nF linn
ITEM NO. 1
VALUE I 31,500.00
DESCRIPTION:
Undevelooed land
DATE or VALUATION: 1998
NON-MARTIAL PORTION: None
AMOUNT/NATURE or ANY LIEN: None
ITEM NO. 2
VALUE:
DESCRIPTION:
1984 El Cameo -Used by Husbsnd
DATE or VALUATION:
NON-MARTIAL PORTION: None
AMOUNT/NATURE or ANY LIEN: None
ITEM NO.
VALUE:
2
DESCRIPTION: -190/, Saturn-Wife
"lrecked,Wife received $5000.00-$6.000.00 from InsuranlJ!
DATE or VALUATION: Company
NON-MARTIAL PORTION:
AMOUNT/NATURE or ANY LIEN:
ITEM NO. 3
DESCRIPTION: PNC Hank N .A. Rlll11"fut
VALUE I $89,223.14 DATE or VALUATIONI 3/11/00
~III,l)I.~4 8S of 12/31/97
NON-MARTIAL PORTION' None
Haif of the shares 990 In name of wife and daughter
~'nlUXmxUIXJ.XDmII
Half of the shares 990 In name of wife and son.
ITEM NO. 4
VALUEI~OO.OO
DESCRIPTION: cn Rnnk of , nnrllQhllrR A~~t! OflO'1Q171
DATE OF VALUATION I Prp~~n'
NON-MARTIAL PORTION I None
AMOUNT/NATURE or ANY LIENI N/A
I'l'EM NO . 4
VALUE I 4000.00
DESCRIPTION I CD Bank of , nnrH qhllrg A"...t-. n~l Ql/.An?
DATE or VALUATION: Present
NON-MARTIAL PORTION I N/A
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIENI
ITEM NO.
4
DESCRIPTION I CD Corestates Acctl 3108115857
VALUE z Unknown
DATE OF VALUATIOIh
NON-MARTIAL PORTION: N/A
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIENI
ITEM NO.
4
DESCRIPTION: r.1l rnY"oct-~t-n"" ^ggt I 11 n_'lE\7'l"~'1
VALUE: Unknown
DATE OF VALUATION:
NON-MARTIAL PORTION: N/A
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
ITEM NO. 18
VALUE I 4,497.07
DESCRIPTION: ComnS98 Crauo. U.S.A. Tn,.
Employees SavinRs Retirement Plan-Wife
DATE OF VALUATION._ 1?/11/07
NON-MARTIAL PORTION: N/A
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN: N/A
ITEM NO. 18
DESCRIPTION I r.ommnntJPSlIll"h P!l:Ina.-f nn_Jtltcha...,,-I
VALUE: 233,249.00DATE OF VALUATION:
All IQA
NON-MARTIAL PORTION: Non marital Etnnroy c; Y,.Q nr hAnaF-f ~a a.,.A p,..a_'n<I'.-f ~a'
or post separation.
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN: N/A
ITEM NO.
25
DESCRIPTION:
Collectibles & antinllPR
The parties acquired hundreds of items of collectabl~s and antiques during the
marriage. Husband has a few of these items and has provided wife with pictures
of what he hss. Attached are those pictures and some pictures of the items
remaining in the marital home. Husband has proposed that these items he put
up for auction, ,and the parties could bid on what they want and divide the
proceeds. The other alternative is to have the items appraised and then
divide them between the parties. Wife took a video tape of these items, but
has refused to give it to counsel for husband.
ITEM NO. 26
DESCRIPTION: Safe-Located In 2ara2e
This safe contains valuable coins, etc.
DATE OF VALUATION:
VALUE:
NON-MARTIAL PORTION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION:
DATE OF VALUATION I
VALUE:
NON-MARTIAL PORTION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION:
VALUE.
DATE OF VALUATION:
NON-MARTIAL PORTION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION:
VALUE:
DATE OF VALUATION.
NON-MARTIAL PORTION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION I
DATE OF VALUATION:
VALUE:
NON-MARTIAL PORTION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
NON-MARITAL PROPERTY: ) Plaintiff ( xl Defendant lisu all
property in which a Ipoule has a legal or equitable interest which
is claimed to be excluded form marital property.
ITEM NO. 2
DESCRIPTIONI
1984 Monte Carlo
VALUE: I ?nn nn
DATE OF VALUATION:
1998
REASON FOR EXCLUSION:
Acquired after the Reparation
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIENI N/A
ITEM NO.
VALUE:
DESCRIPTION:
DATE OF VALUATION:
REASON FOR EXCLUSION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION:
VALUE:
DATE OF VALUATION:
REASON FOR EXCLUSION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIENI
ITEM NO.
VALUE:
DESCRIPTION:_
DATE OF VALUATION:
REASON FOR EXCLUSION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIENI
ITEM NO,
VALUE:
DESCRIPTION:
DATE OF VALUATION:
REASON FOR EXCLUSION:
AMOUNT/NATURE OF ANY LIEN:
PROPERTY TRANSFERRED: () Plaintiff ( ) Defendant lists all
property in which either or bcth spcuses had a legal or equitable
interest individually or with any other person and which has been
transferred within the preceding three years,
NONE
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION:
NAME OF OWNER
DATE OF TRANSFER:
PERSON TO WHOM TRANSFERRED:
CONSIDERATION:
ITEM NO.
NAME OF OWNER
DATE OF TRANSFER:
DESCRIPTION:
CONSIDERATION:
PFRSON TO WHOM TRANSFERRED:
ITEM NO,
NAME OF OWNER
DESCRIPTION:
DATE OF TRANSFER:
PERSON TO WHOM TRANSFERRED:
CONSIDERATION:
ITEM NO.
NAME OF OWNER
DESCRIPTION:
DATE OF TRANSFER:
PERSON TO WHOM TRANSFERRED:
CONSIDERATION:
LIABILITIES: () Plaintiff (~ Defendant lists all liabilities of
either or both spouses alone or with any person as of the date of
separation,
ITEM NO.____ DESCRIPTION:
VISA
AMOUNT OF DEBT PRESENTLY: Approx. $6400.00
AMOUNT OF DEBT AT SEPARATION:
DATE DEBT INCURRED, INITIAL AMOUNT OF INDEBTEDNESS AND PURPOSES OF
$3814. J2
DEBT. Credit care used for miscellaneous marital purcha&es.
Husband will be solely responsible for this debt if he iR 21ven credit
on the final distribution. He has made all payments since the separation.
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION:
HortgaRe
AMOUNT OF DEBT PRESENTLY:
$15,648.00
AMOUNT OF DEBT AT SEPARATION:
Unknown
DATE DEBT INCURRED, INITIAL AMOUNT OF INDEBTEDNESS AND PURPOSES OF
DEBT: 1990 Used fnr rf::lllih~",,.1 Q ...n 11.08'<:> ......1 hr.m,:) -f mp'l"'n..n............t'J
AMOUNT PAID BY DEBTOR SINCE DATE OF SEPARATION: Wife has paid the
mortgage as she resides in the home.
ITEM NO.
DESCRIPTION:
AMOUNT OF DEBT PRESENTLY:
AMOUNT OF DEBT AT SEPARATION:
DATE DEBT INCURRED, INITIAL AMOUNT OF INDEBTEDNESS AND PURPOSES OF
DEBT:
AMOUNT PAID BY DEBTOR SINCE DATE OF SEPARATION:
OUA NOAMAlIUSINISS NUMIERS ME 114 ,1414 OR lOa ,llI,llll. 1 AM . i PM MONOAY TO fRIDAY ANa II AM . 5 PM SA TURDAY
TO REPORT A lOST 011 STOlEN CAJlO CAll THE A!I1'IE NUMIERS OU~ING IUSINlSS HOU~S, OTHERWISE CAllI00.ne.5111
-ri
on ACH HERE t
, ';
MalUIIT ~
0206322353
10/31/97
31
H,814.32
to.OO
f77.00
11/25/97
USE THE SST TO MAKE YOUR
VISA PAV"ENTS 24 HOURS/DAY.
IUWNCl NUMIU
,.. ,'.'
.< ~T
-104.~
414. (
t"
"''''j. jl-.l{
.~,Of
1018
AV"ENT
T PRODUCTIONS INC
XL
2415S019802NP9A285969
ITASCA
"-"'aIllI
PIIMlU1
IlIIIMCI
3,475.46
0.00
.. .CIBlIT
.. lMT
. ..IWMMY
TOTAL
'J: -,/llW ~
29.13 3,814.32
0.00 0.00
PUIlCHASB DfIIT
+ IMNNtCU. +, ADJUITMEffTI
414.00 0.00
0.00 0.00
I'A'IMBlTl
rAalI11
-
TOTAL
6,000.0
.....-
_'Al
09.900
12.900
ANNUAl.
09.898
00,000
-3,814.3
0.0
2.185.6
01."3
PERIODIC
TRANSACTION .
TOTAL
0.8250
1.0750
3,531.51
0.00
29.13
0.00
29.13
0.00
0.00
0.00
29.13
0.00
29.13
VISA IlAlAHCE
PSL WANeE
AVAILABLE
--
lOTAL '
Pa.lrl bj
hcLShand. SlflC e.
.s e t tL 'rd.. fi ~ YL
PENSION
RESOURCES inc.
!"j'!!"IICI'1/J M'IUl'lIlf'/ltllf./I' /1.,\\'" ,'1 '\liihf',.II;!;,'n
July 31.1998
PENSION EVALUATION
l'tIAXDIUM OPTION - LUMP SUM WITHDRAWAL
PARTICIPANT AND SPOUSAL DATA
Name:
Retirement Date:
Data of Plan Participation:
Date of Marriage:
Ronald Roberts
6/5/99
6/5/64
6/21/69
Sex:
Date of Birth:
Date of Hlra end Service Credit:
Date of Separation:
Mala
12/19/40
615/64
11127/97
BENEFIT DATA AND EVALUATION
Plan:
Commencement Age:
Monthly Benefit:
Payment Form:
Benefit Accrued through:
SERS
58
$1,811.00
Ufa Annuity
11/27/97
Presant Valua of Banafit:
PBGC Annuity Value:
$274,572
Valuation Oate:
Valuation Age:
Employee Account Value:
In addition to Monthly Beneflt1
8/1198
58
$ 26,895,00
Ves
COVERTURE FRACTION:
Vears of accrual during marriage:
Total years of benefit accrual:
84.95%
28.44
33,48
PRESENT VALUE 011' BENEFIT EARNED DURING MARRIAGE:
$233,249
The above valuation is based on annuity rates effective for Aug-98
and published by the Pension Benefit Guaranty Corporation. Thesa rates are
Intended to reflect current annuity contract rates offered by private Insurance carriers.
Tha current immediate interest rates, as of the above date. are
Interest rate for first 25 years: 5.40% Second Interest Rate:
5.25%
Tha monthly benefit shown was obtained from the attached statement prepared by the
Retirement System shown above.
2040 Linglestown ROJd .lfarrisburg, PA 17110, (717) 541-8510. (717) 541,8093 fAX
January
29, 1998
RONALD L ROBERTS
400 HIGH ST., APT 1
WEST FAIRVIEW PA 17025
SSNII 206-n-2353
Oear Mr. ROBERTS,
The following information was used to calculate your retirement benefit
estimate:
Proposed Oate of R.tirement: 04/17/1998
Total State Service
Total School Service
JJ.9674
0.0000
Final Average Salary: $35,583.63
SSI Credited Service: 33.9674
Frozen Present Value, $0.00
Frz Present Value Oebt, $0.00
Frozen Service Credits, 0.0000
Your Birth Oate
Your Sex
12/19/1940
M
Survivor's Birth Date
Survivor's Sex
Pre-Taxed Contributions
Total Contr & Interest
$5,101.H
$27,961.95
Total Service Credits. 33.9674
(Breakdown listed Below)
(Total excludes SSI service - class Sl
Service:
Class
A
Credits
33.9674
Special Comments,
ESTIMATE CALCULATED UNDER PROVISION OF "EARLY RETIREMENT". IT IS BASEO ON
YOUR CURRENT BI-WEEKLY SALARY OF $1095.00 (, ASSUMES FULL TIME EMPLOY OF 75
HRS/PAY PERIOD THRU 04-17-98.
The following pages will provide you with various estimate amounts and a
brief description of each option. For a more detailed explanation of your
retirement benefits and options, you should refer to your State Employes'
Retirement System Member Handbook or talk with your retirement counselor.
Please remember that many factors affect the computation of a retirement
benefit. Changes to your years of service, Final Average Salary, retirement
date, and debts applied to your account can change your benefit amounts.
This estimate is based on the information as it appears above. The actual
computation of your retirement benefit will use the final information
available after your employment with the Commonwealth has been terminated.
*** ESTIMATE INCLUDES YOUR CO~SroN FROH JOINT COVERAGE TO FULL COVERAGE
ON YOUR DATE OF REI:IIIDIENT.
PENSION
RESOURCES inc,
l\j,'i~h" rll Mldl'll. 1,1 fYIII 1.1.-'\\'11 ,", \tU/iI/llltrJlil!1l
INVOICE NIS09
July 31, 1998
Judith A Calkin, Esquire
2201 N. Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
RE: Pension Evaluation Ronal Roberts
Servicos rendered for the captioned individual:
. Pension Evaluation for the captioned individual
. Prepaid amount
$
$
250,00
250,00
BALANCE
s
0.00
PLEASE MAKE ALL CHECKS PAYABLE TO:
PENSION RESOURCES, INC.
2040 LINGLESTOWN ROAD, SUITE 103
HARRISBURG, PA 17110
NET TERMS DUE AND PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT. FINANCE CHARGES WILL BE APPLIED AT 18% PER
ANNUM AFTER 30 DAYS.
2040 Linglcstown ROJd .J1,)ffishurg, PA 17110. (717) 541,8510' (717) 541,8093 rAX
HUSBA~IJ HAS [~l illS I'OSSESSION
0\
!
./
o J
\
IIUSBAND liAS [N \I (S POSSESS WN
!
,
IIUSBANIl liAS [:-< lIlS POSSESSION
HUSBAND HAS IN HIS POSSESSION
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, Judith A. Calkin, Esquire, do hereby certify that I
served a copy of the foregoing upon the Defendant by U. S. Mail,
regular delivery, postage prepaid to the following person:
KeIth Brennerman, Esquire
44 West Haln Street
Hechanlcsburg, PA 17055 .
Date: 6/30/00
Judith A. Calkin, Esquire
Attorney for plaintiff
2201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
rnn.rlv n'.cr'nUon UNIFORM RESIDENTIAL APPRAISAL REPORT FU, NO 10NORTHR
lrop,r1Y Add'... lQ.J!Q1!.1'JLROA!L-. ____._______~IIy.w;Qt,4.IUc;.~I,lR<:;___Slal!flL_...1lp~55.___
ill!l.Qm!tRli2!ll1~!LllooK..nH. PAGE 185______________ __~~.c;.!l~;RbA!iIL________
!o.!.!!!!o,.. P.!t!LNo SEE2!I\J' REFERENCE JlJ,lMIlER__ _____.!!~.wLt29L1LUm.!.!.._ ~9.c'!I_A!....'!'!nl!_t_.Q- _n____
~, NA r"rr.nLOWn!LROBE1!.T~.RONl\LD L/JOA!!tiE Oc'~R!n!JiL~!'!L.TI~n!nL._D_Ymn!
~ rinh', .nn,'I..d [X I F.. Slm"l. r I. ....hnld I ---- P!~j;,JTYP._DfI,Io n Condo~!!n!'!.m jHU!1LY~JlI)l1L__._HQ.AL_____-:~!lo~
N.lahbo,hood or Proltel Nlm. SIL VER SPR~N<:;_TQWJl~IHJ'_ _._._.__II!p!!!!!!!n~l!:-~~::.Q.1l!.'! -008_C-'nmIr!c1 0 H~_____
'al. PriCt iliA. 011. 01 ~~~A__~~CJ.lll~Q..n_~I1Jtl!IJlQY'J!.Qt~n c~ri!!/~ill~Jgn. ~~2!!Lby_!!!!!:~A__,____
l.ndl//CII.nIRQll~~=!OB;~ __ _ M4'm~g._~9RI!LR.QAQl...w;CIlP.1'!LCSBURG.J'P._=J~B~i;~"'-_ on
1/ MAR N Add".. '-'OQ NI'IoI' nNn 'A "U IU
locallon ~ Uftlln Suburban ~ Rut.1 Predominant Slngl. family houllng Pnsentlandut. '4 land u.. change
Buill up ~ Ov,,75~ 25-75~ >- Und,,25~ occupancy rr":;;f 1~.~ r: Onol.mlly _I9. ONolllk.ly Ollk.1y
Orowlh /II. l- Rapid Slabl. >- Slow ~own" 1--:92 low _"- 2-41.mlly __ (i) In p,oc...
Prop.rtyy.lu.. ~ In<rt..lni Sllbl. >- Otellnlni T.nlnl 1 qO Hloh ~O UulU-lamIIy --,_ 10' FAMilY
Otmand/.upply l- Shon'i' klbtLva >- OItfilWY VICII1I(<r51) ~~m!n!n.L...,.,,- Commmlll 10
IU....,lnnllm. IX lI1dtrlmo' 11-~ "".'lJMl _. j<..."t(,!t!j'LJ.QQ::JZ91__1~ yp,c[IIfl' I 20 _
Not.: Rac. and th. racial compO.IUOA of the n.lghborhood are not .ppral.aI factor..
Nalihborhoad boundtrl.. .nd eh""II/lllIel Sub lect Rr9perty~located _l!lAU.,.er Sl1.LinllJQwnsh l1'-L--
: Factoft Ihl' all,cI Ih. m.rk.tablllty of th. propertltlln lhl n'lghborhood (proximlly 10 ,mploym.nt and amlnlUtI, Imploymlnl liability, ,ppIIllo market. .Ic);
~ITh1s suburban ne1&hborhoo_cLh.as most_publlQ._utilllies avaJ1!!QJ.~l rel!!tivelL!!.asY~Qges_~.J9___
.. employment and servicel!L-1'n<! is competitive with 0~her-,!e1.11hb9rhood.'-1rI the general area. Host
have similar amenities. Market activ1tY..lnd1c!lte.~veragfLQr.. better_-",cce&anca in the IIIlIrket
place. No unfavorable factors~~_~_Q~served wh!gh_wo~ld a<!~ssely effect marketabil1ty~
Uarkal conditions In the aubllCl Mlghborhood (including tuPP0r110f the .boVI conclusionl ,.Ialld 10 Ihl trlnd 01 proplrly valulI. dlm.nd/lupply, and mllklllntllm.
..... .ueh II dall on compallllvl proplftitl for ullln Ihl nalghborhood, ducripUon of thl prlvll.ncl olul" and financing concl..ionl. .Ic.):
ITHIS IS A "COMPLETE: APPRAISA[ - SUMMARY REPORT" There are no foreseeable economic trends which
miRht slanificantlv Influence market conditions in this area. The current mort RaRe market
Inrrers a wide varietv of convenUonsl 'oans With' competitive interest rates. As a result......!M_
terms of financ1na have little If anv 1mRact on sale prices. If interest rates remain
Ireasonable oronertv values and mArketabllltv ShOUld be Rood
_ ProJ.ct information for PUO, (lI.ppllc.bl.).... Is Ih. dtV.IOplf/build'f in conlrol ollh. Home ON",,,. Associallon (HOA)? U YES UNO
Approlllmal.lol.1 numb" 01 unlllln lht lubj.cl proj.ct Approxtmal. lolal numb" at unlll 10f ullln IhI .ubJlc' proj.cl
ul I _0' 'I'll''''
OIman,lon. 80 X 150 Tapog/lphy LEVEL
511. ".. . 28 AC _ Comtr lol U V.. IiJN; Silt TYPICAL FOR AREA
Sp.ellle lonlni el"ltne.llon .n..dJ2 dm:',IPllon R6 RESIDENTIAL Sh.pe RECTANGULAR
loolnieomplllne. 00 l'ill t.gaI""""'*'I1rini(_Iwroduot) OIll.g.1 0 NOIonlni O/lln.g, APPEARS ADEQUATE
I Hloh . P'.'.n' u.. n Olhtr u.. Will.lnl VI.w AVERAGE
UIIAU.. Public Olher OIl-llIt,lmproy""",Io Typ. Public P,ly.l. Ltnd.<apln<J AVERAGE:
EI.<Ir1elly ; 200 AMPS Slrltt ASPHALT 00 0 Orty.w.y Sun'" ASPHAL T
all NONE Curti/gull.. NONE 8 00 Apptr.nt ....manll NONE OBSERVED
WII.. Sidewalk NONE FElAA 5p.el.1 Flood HIII/d A,.. r I V.. 00 No
S.nllary Itw.. SI,..llIghll NONE R R: FElAAZon. ZONE C ....p o.;;5l2l!!l__
Al!!Y.- NONE _ _ HM.\Mll~ID/0020B__
Commtnla CapPI,.nlldverll 'l5.m,nls. .ncroachm.nll. Ip.cl.1 assessmenls. slid. Ifill. lII.gal or Ilgal nonconlormlng zoning, UII. Ilc): SEE ATTACHED _
ADDENDUM
GENERAL DESCRIPTION
No. 01 Unll. 1
No. 01 Slort.. 1
Typ. (OIl/Ail) DETACHED
OtllinjSIyI.) lST.ll~
ExllllnyPropo..d EXISTING
Ai' (V/I.) 14
~ 20
~ Fo.tr lIYl!!L "'nln'
gOtl!!!!m!nl
'...11
. llvI12
F.l ___
1;1 Flnl'h,d
IN7ERIOR
Floo"
. Will.
Trlm/Fmish
Bath Floor
8.llhW.inscol
Ooors
EXTERIOR OESCRIPlION FOUNOA liON
Found.llon CO BLOCK SI.b NONE
Exltrlor W.II, BRICK/ ALUH CrwolSpaco 33~
RooISu,'ac. SHINGLE BII.monl ~"---__
Oullm I [mn,pl. I\LUMHi\LM___ Sump Pump fjOtiE
Window Typ. DOUB HUNG D.mpn... NONE NOTED
SlonnlSc,..nl YES/YES S.III.manl NONE NOTED
""",. NO I NON~ NOTFD
KiI\h!!L. J='L.._ F-,!!J!!Y.Bnl . Roc. ~~ "drool1)1.. _U!!bl
BA5ElAEN7
Atll Sq Ft.
~ Flnl,h,d 0
C.lllni UF'
W.II. CO BLOCK
Floor CONCRETE:
~.Idt Entry NONE
1212
INSULA liON
RooI
C.lilni GOOD
Will, GOOD
F"'o, AVE
Noot
-
...
...MEA
"undN
HKUPS
J___ __.L__
OIher
'~,'n"
1.212
1-77"
1 __ 1
--- --.--...-- .. ------~
. "r'd' 'on"'n' -'7- ';;nm. - -i "ri;'-~;;; --'--I BalM. .
Mal.rllll/Condilion HEATING KITCHEN EQUIP ATTIC AMENITIES
HW/VINYL/CPTI A Typ. BB Relrlg".lor 0 Non. ~ Flllpl.e.(.)' 1-- ~
PNL/DRYWALL/A Fu.1 ~LE~_ Rang./Ov.n (XJ 51.1" Plllo i--
WOOD/ AVERAGE _ .!;ondtb~nlWERAG~ Oi.poul ~ O,op SI.lr Otek I-
VINYL/AVERAGL COOLING Oi.h....h" Seulll. Po,eh __ ,..
CERN!lC/AVL_ C.nlr.1 !iQ!!~_ Fln/Hood ] Floo, RU F.n" _
!iQ!,LOUQ!.l.~l1L Olh" NOfj; __.. lAlc,owlVe Q 1l"I.d Pool _
COlldtbonNA WI.h.,ION" r I Flnl''''" ,
Ad\Jilion.llulur" (sp.eill .n"QY .llicitnl iI,m,. .Ic) H-oof~!'r.~-9-1~_LJ!j:~J.n4!~L~.99~_QrkJ~Q.rJ8.!111~J~_hous. has brt ck
'!.Iter .Lq~~H;L.'!I_h.11!'..1hI!J!,m.! ly_roqm a<!<!JJJ.9!l..J!a~_lli\!!l!.!l!.!l!m ex.ter lor walls.
ConCillon ollhl impro'l.mtnlt. d.preci.tion (phl~lcal, tunchonal. and ...I'UlII). I'Plill nl.o.d. quality 01 conslrucllon. t.mod.llng/lddllions. lie' S[[
~TI~gt;JU..Dr:>E!iQ\II'lL_________ _ _.__________ _______ ___ _________ _____ ______ ______
OF'nc
1. 776'm ,~F..lnl
CAlI STOAADE,
None 0
GlII19'
Attaehed
Ot..'hed
Buill, In
C.rpon
-..
Adv"" .n\lironmtnlll condillonl (Iuch II. but nollimil.d 10. hlllrdoul wulfl. tOlflC tubllanc... elc ) pl...nlln tht Implovlm.nlt, on IhI III.. or In lh.
Imm.dill. YI,:n'ly ollho ""'itClo~"P"IIY llq _.!ldver~e_ef)vJ_r9~l11ental_ c:'<1Odlt19!l"..~"re_ql;>"ery"d_ !!L!;h,,__ll!1provuellll.a
on the sIte or in tne mmediate vlc1nitv or the subject orooertv
'rlddw~'...70 .11
rA.l,~ 1 Uf 2
....,............... ,.....--......,...........,-....,........
V.lu.tlon S.."nA , UNIFORM RESIDENTIA APPRAI .u. u.
E5TIMATEDSITE VALUE . I Comment. on Coil ApPfoach (Iuch II, laure. of COlt ..lIm.t..
ESTlMATEO REPROOUCTlON COST-NEW Of IMPROVEMENTS: ,II. Yllu.. squI" 101)1 CllcullUon Ind lor HUD. VA and FmHA. thl
Dwtlllng 1 .716 Sq FI . I . I "limited rlmllnlnglConomlc Ill. 01 the properly):
JtBSMr: 123~ Sq Fl. ,__ . <:;LQ~s L1YlnB-Area "___lm-
. [lrst 28.00 X qq,9JLL.-l_~___...1~3L
Qallll'/c.I]lOrt _ Sq. FI . I . . 1 h!l9...!-...3hQQ X 1 ~____5i'L
lalal E.llmat.d COil N.w .. S .L- ___T9.t~UgJ.-nJ_"--_-_ll1L
L... PhyIICl~rFuncllon'l~ --- - ------
. Otplld.Uon --31'1. . I
-_._._,-~--------_.._-_._--
Otprtclll.d Vllut ollmpro....menll . I
-AI-I,- Value 01 SIl.lmprov.mlnll . I
,.... "... COST IDDanIC" . .-
ITFU [ SUBJECT COMPARABLENO , COMPARABLE NO. 2 I COUPARABLE NO.'
10 NORTH ROAD 16 NORTH ROAD 32 STATE ROAD I~~IFE DRIVE
I.'"" ICSBURG M:-CIIANIC<:RURf: MECHANICSBURG C ~BURG
.hixlmllv I~ '"h,.-t . L'lAME BLOCK 1 MTLr wrST 2-BLOCKS rAST
S.ltt POCl I N . - I 110 000 . I "q,e;oO '. :. II' 0001
:'"tlCl/GronUY. Arll II III . QO 02P! . 68.681ll__ , 71_"211I .
0111 Indlor JNSPECTION ASSESSMENT RECORDS ASSESSMENT RECORDS ASSESSMENT RECORDS
VtflflCIUOn Sourc.. ~ .LMLS __ ________ ~S ___
.'LAlI.l:ADJJSMN1S OESCRlPTION DESCRIPTION I .1.IlAdJAJ~1 DESCRIPTION [.1-11...",,,,,", DE5CRIPTI!lIL-L!1'lIM~-_
5.111 or Fln.nelng ONVENTIONAL . CONVENTIONAL : CONVENTIONAL :
.
ONE . NONE : NONE ,
Conell.lon. , ,
In.l.oISI,;-m... I NA u /Q/q6 , +q.OOO 1/7/q7 , +1000 6/27/.'JL .
, , .
loc.tlon AVERAGE VERAGE . AVERAGE . AVERAGE ,
I[;;_,uo..- Frr FEE InE FEE [
, , .
SII. ~ _'lQ AC : -1.000 _77 AC , -1.000 28 AC ,
, ,
I VI.w rnJij IAVrRAGE . I AVERAGE . AVERAGE .
r;;;,on .nd An'n' /AVE Ci RANCH/AVERAGE' IRANCH/AVERAGE: IRANCUIdV~F!
ClaIIlvofQJrotructon BRICK/AVERAGI BRICK/AVERAGE: BRICK/AVERAGE: BRrCK/ AVERAGE:
Ao. 'lq/,O qO/20 , 32/20 , 110/20 ;
Condlllon AVERAGE AVERAGE , AVERAGE , BETTER TN AVE' -2.000
, . . , . .
Abov. Grid. folal 'IIdlM.' 811111' fola"lklrlll" 8111111 , Tolal'Ikl'IIl" 811111~ hlal' Idflll!.. "Ill' ,
B ;oom Count 7: 1: 1 6, '1: 1: 6: 1: -1,000 7 ,--:t : I'
Gron lIvlnll AIU 1 - 776 5n. Fl. 222 Sn. H : +"_1;00 1. ~ 1,e;665.FI , +2.100
1 1_7QOSn.Fl. , ,
a ~..mtnll F1nIthtd PART BASEMEN' FULL BASEMENT: FULL BASEMENT: FULL BASEMENT:
. Rooms Below Grid. UNFINISHED i ,
UNFINISHED UNFINISHED , UNFINISHED ,
. Funcllon.1 Utili'" I AVERAGE .
IAVERAGE ' AVERAGE . AVERAGE '
~ HuUna/Coollnll EBB/NO CT All ~FAlNO CT AIR: OHW/CENT AIR , -2-"00 QiM/CENT AtR: -2.500
,
Entr"" Enld.nlll.,", TVP FOR AGE IAPPLIANCES , -1 000 APPLIANCES , -1 000 TYP FOR AGE ~
Oll."/C.mort 1 CAR GAR/AT' 2 CARPORT/AT!': 2 CAR GAR/DET: -1.000 NONE :_.!3&0J1_
Porch. P.llo. Dock. NONE LARGE DECK , -1,500 PORCH & SHED , -1,000 NEW DECK : -1,500
. ,
Flrtnlmll' .Ic. ,
1 FIREPLACE 1 FIREPLACE , NONE , +1 000 1 FI REPLACE ,
NONE EW BATH -1 000 NONE , NONE 1-----
F.ncl Pool .tc. , , .
OTHER HW FLOORS W FLOORS : HW FLOORS , IlW FLOORS ,
, ,
N.IAd'. '10111' xl. I 1- :, ~ 000 I I. -TiI- i, 5.5.QQ. . I 1+ Ixl- '. QOO
Adju,led 51ltt Prico . e~~~lII1~:~ I GroslI:l1.3 GrossI 9,9 11\ \00
01 Comftlflbl. .' . lIe; 000 IN"t. -4,6. 11 Q 000 IN"~, -0:1, I
Commenl, on SIIII Comp.nlon (Including the lubj.cl prop.rty., comp.Ublllly 10 the n.lghborhood. .Ie. ): SEE AT!'ACHED ADDENDUM.
-
ITEM SUBJECT COMPARAllIE NO 1 COMPARABLE NO. 2 COMPARABLE NO. ·
Dal.. Pric. .nd o.t. NONE ~O PRIOR SALE OTHER NO PRIOR SALE OTHER NO PRIOR SALE OTHER
Sourct for prior IIln ~HAN THAT LISTED THAN THAT LISTED THAN THAT LISTED
..tin-II of .nn/llsal IABOVE ABOVE ABOVE
Analysis of.ny cumnl.greement of Sill. opUon. or listing of the subject property Ind anatysls ollny prior 11111 of subll!cl.nd cOfTl9lrabln within one )'Ilr ollhe dale ol.ppfllul:
Accord1na to Information provided bv the multi-list services In this rea10n the sublect
propertv has not been listed for sale within the p~ear.
INOICATED VALUE BY SALES COMPARISON APPROACH S 11 q 000
NlICATED VAL~BVtlCOIolE APPROACH III Aoollc.bl.) E,lImll.d M"k.1 Ront I N / A /lAo. x Oro" Rent WtiDlI" N/A . I N/A
Thll .pprllsalls mid. ~ "..Is" --U subjecllo the rep.lrs, Illlrallons.lnspecUons or conditions listed below TI .OO[1t11> comp1ollon pt' pi.... oncllptdlcolono.
Ccn~tionsoIApPIII'" ~EE AT!'ACHED ADDENDUM.
.----
Finll Reconclll.lIonSEE AT!'ACHED ADDEND.\!M'-___.____
--.-.---.
. -
Th. purpoat ollhi. appraisal is 10 ulim.l. th. mlrket v.lu. ollh. rill proplfty lh.llslh. sub!.c1 ollhl. report. bls,d on h IboYt conditions.nd.. ttrti'calon. conlngtnl
and limiting conditions. and rNrhl....ILIt definition thai I" llaled In lhe .11Iched Freddie Mac Fonn 4J9IF.m1e Ma. Form 10048 (revlsed 6/93 ). IQQ7
. I (WE I ESTIMATE THE MARKET VALUE, AS DEFINED. OF TIE REAL PROPERTY THAT IS TIE SUlJECT OF TIIS REPOftT, AS OF DECEMBER 10
. (WHICH IS THE DAT.E OF INSPEZ AND TH!,.EFFECTlVE DATE OF THIS REPOftT) TO BE . 11 Q .000 .
. A.PPRAISER: 'I J iL~ . . '~ SUPERVISORV APPRAISER (OIlL V IF REQUIIIED): o Did o Did Not
Slgnalur. . U . - SlgnalulI
Nlm. Hi\lUt \I. HECKMAN -- NII1\' Inlptct PlOptr1y
Oil, Repor1 Slgntd DECEHBE!L19....192L --- 0.1. Repo,t Slgnld
Sl,le ClltJlicllion' CA-000666-L.. . Sllle PA-- Sl,l. Certiliellion' Sial.
OrSiIIIlI"n"'-REBROKER- LiCIiHiJ:Oqllq60:LS'"I~--PA -- O,SI.I.lI,,"" --_._~ -
Sial.
L SAL REPORT
rlt44,.Uatrm..l0 '~1
I'Atl[ 201 2
....,.....".......,......-.<.-.,-.........-..../...'....
rllM..YH,_11llW1II3
~brk lIeckman Real E3tete Appraisers
MARK HECKMAN REAL ESTATE APPRAISERS
I';t. N". 1 ONORTHR
. -.- - - .. - . -.'
SITE COMMENTS:
Site has average site improvemen1s, average landscaping, and typical maintenance. The site
improvements and services to the site are adequate and acceptable in this market area. There
are no apparent adverse easements, encroachments, or other adverse conditions on this site.
CONDITION OF TilE IMPROVEMENTS:
These improvements are of average quality frame design and reflect average maintenance.
Property reflects normal physical depreciation and no deficiencies are noted. No unusual
functional obsolescence or external inadequacies were observed. The bathrooms, kitchen,
mechanical equipment, and other features meet current standards for houses of this age in this
market.
SALES COMPARISON COMMENTS:
Days on market: Compo No. I: 39 days; Compo No.2: 6 days; Compo No.3: 29 days. After a
thorough search of all available market data, the three sales used are considered to be the best
indicators of value. In order to find comparable sales it was necessary to use less recent sales.
Time adjustments are based on appropriate research of the market data in the market area.
Appropnate adjustments have been made for all differences. Comparable sales used are all
closed sales. Comparable Sale No. I is considered the best indicator of value and is wei.8hted
more heavily than Comparable No.2 or No.3. All three comparable sates are located III the
same market area as the subject and would be considered by the same prospective purchaser if
all were on the market at the same time as the subjecl.
CONDITIONS OF APPRAISAL:
This appraisal report has been prepared with the property in "liS is. condition. No personal
property has been included in this valuation. According to records provided by the county
ass~ssment office, the subject property has not transferred in the past year.
FINAL RECONCILIATION:
This appraisal assumes a reasonable marketing period for the subject property of four months.
The Sales Comparison Analysis reflects recent activity in the market place and is given the
most weight. The Income Approach is inappropriate because few single family houses are
rented in this market. In the view of the age of these improvements, the Cost Approach cannot
be considered an accurate indicator of value.
11I19IlRIIXlI!STRI'ET. NI'W CUMIII'RLANIl. PA 17070 (117) 774.7201
l'ill Nn. 10NORTHR
DEFINITION OF MARKET VALUE: The most probable price which a plOperty should bung in a competitive and open mllkot
under all conditions requislle to a fair sale, Ihs buyer and seller, each acllng prudently. knowledgeably and assuming the price is nol
affecled by undue stimulus. ImpliclI in this definition is the consummation of a sale as of a specified date and Ihe passing of title from
seller to buyer under conditions whereby: (1) buyer and seller are typically motivaled; (2) both parties are well Informed or well advised,
and Bach acting in what he considers his own best interesl; (3) a reasonabls time Is allowed for exposure In the open market; (4) paymenl
Is made in lerms of cash in U.S. dollars or in terms of financial arrangements comparable thereto; and (5) the price represents the normal
consideration for the property sold unaffected by special or creative financing or sales concessions' granled by anyone associated witillhe
sale.
'Adjustments to the comparables must be made for special or creative financing or sales concessions. No adjustments are necessary for
lhose cosls which are normally paid by sellers as I result of tradition or law in I marke1 area; these costs are readily identifiabte since the
aeller pays these costs in virtually all sales transaclions. Special or creative financing adjustments can be made 10 the comparable property
by comparisons to financing terms offered by a Ihird party Inslilutionallender Ihat is not already Involved in tha property or lransaction. Any
adjustment should nol be calculated on a mechanical dollar for dollar cost of Ihe financing or concession but the dollar Iffiount of any
adjustmenl should approxlmale the markel's reaction to the financing or concessions based on Ihe appraiser'a Judgment
STATEMENT OF LIMITING CONDITIONS AND APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION
CONTINGENT AND LIMITING CONDITIONS: The appraiser's certification Ihal appears In the appraisal report is subJect 10 the
following conditions:
1. The appraiser will not be responsible for malters of a legal nature thaI affect either the property being appraised or the Illte 10 It. The
appraiser assumes Ihat Ihe title is good and markelable and, Iherefore, will not render any opinions aboullhe litis. The property Is appraised
on the basis of II being under responsible ownersh,ip.
2. The appraiser has provided a skelch In Ihe appraisal repoltto show approximate dimensions of the ImplOvemenls and lhe sketch Is
included only 10 assist the reader of the report in visualizing Ihe property and underslanding Ihe appraiser's determination of its size.
3. The appraiser has examined lhe available flood maps thaI are provided by lhe Federal Emergency Managemenl Agency (or olher dala
sources) and has noted In lhe appraisal roport whelher the subject site is localed in an Identified Special Flood Hazard Area, Because the
appraiser is nol a surveyor, he or she makes no guarantees, express or Implied, regarding Ihis determination.
4. The appraiser will not givs teslimony or appear in court because he or she made an appraisal of the property in question, unless specific
arrangements to do so have been made beforehand.
5. The appraiser has estimaled the value of lhe land in the cosl applOach at Its highest and best use and lhe Improvements al their
conlributolY value. These separate valuations of the tand and improvements musl not be used in conjuncllon wllh any olher appraisal and
are invalid if they are so usod.
6. The appraiser has noted in lhe appraisat report any adverse conditions (such as, needed repairs, depreciation, the pressnce of hazardous
wastes, toxic substances, elc.) observed during the inspeclion of the subject property or Ihat he or she became aware of during Ihe normal
research involved in performing the appraisal. Unless otherwise staled in the appraisal report, Ihe appraiser has no knowledge of any hidden
or unapparent conditions of Ihe property or adverse environmenlal conditions (including the presence of hazardous wastes, toxic
substances, elc.) lhat would make the property more or less valuable, and has assumed Ihat there are no such condillons and makes no
guaranlees or warranties, express or implied, regarding the condition of the property. The appraiser will nol be responsible for any such
conditions that do exist or for any engineering or testing that might be required to discover whether such conditions exist. Because Ihe
appraiser is nol an expert in the field of environmental hazards, the appraisal report must not be considered as an environmenlal assessment
of lhe property.
7. The appraiser obtained lhe information, estimales, and opinions thaI wsre expressed in the appraisal report from sources thaI he or she
considers to be reliable and bell aves them 10 be true and correct. The appraiser does not assume responsibility for the accuracy of such
items lhat were fumished by olher parties.
6. The appraiser will not disclose the contenls of ths appraisal report except as provided for In the Uniform Standards of Professional
Appraisal Practice.
9, The appraiser has based his or her appraisal report and valualion conclusion for an appraisal lhatls subjeclto satisfactory complelion,
repairs, or alleralions on the assumption that completion of lhe improvements will be performed in a workmanlike manner.
10. The appraiser must provide his or her prior wrillen consent beforelhe lender/client specified in Ihe appraisal report can distribule the
appraisal report (including conclusions about the properly value, lhe appraiser's identily and professional deslgnallons, and references to
any professional appraisal organizations or the firm wilh which lho appraiser is associated ) to anyone other Ihan the borrower; the
mortgagee or its successors and assigns; Ihe mortgage insurer; consullants; professional appraisal organlzalionsl any slate or fedarally
approved financial instilulron; or any department, agency, or instrumentality of the United Stales or any slals or the District of Columbia;
exceptlhat 11'.9 lander/client may distribute the property description saction of Ihe report only to data collection or rsporting service(s)
Without having to obtain Ihe appraiser's prior wrllten consanl. The appraiser's wrillen consenl and approval musl also be obtained before
the appraisal can be conveyed by anyone to lhs public through advertising, public relalions, news, sales, or other media,
Freddie Mac Form 439 6-93
Page 1 of 2
Fannie Mae Form 1004B 6-93
APPRAISERS CERTIFICATION: The Appraiser csrtllles and agrees that:
(,It N" 1 ONORTHR
1. I have researched the subject market area and havs selected a mlmmum of three recent sales 01 properties most Similar and proximate
to the subject propsrty for consideration in the sales companson analysis and have made a dollar adjustment when IllprOprilte 10 rellect the
market reacllon 10 those items of signilicant variation. If a slgmticantllem In a comparable property is superior 10, or more lavorable thtn,
the subject property, I have made a negative adjustment 10 reduce Ihe adjusted sales price 01 Ihe comparable and, il a slgnificantllem in a
comparabte property Is inlerior to, or less lavorable than the subJect property, I have made a positive adjustmenllo increase the adJusled
sales price 01 the comparable.
2. I have taken into consideration Ihe factors thai have an impact on value in my development 01 the estimale 01 market value in the
eppralsal report. I have not knowingly withheld any Slgnificanl information Irom the appraisal report and I believe, 10 the basi 01 my
knowledge, thai all slatements and informalion in the appraisal report are true and cOllect.
3. I slated in the appraisal report only my own personal, unbiased, and professional analysis, opinions, and conclusions, which are subject
only to the contingent and limiting conditions specified in this lorm.
4. I have no present or prospeclive interest in the property Ihat is the subject to this report, and I have no present or prospective personal
Intereslor bias wilh respect 10 Ihe participanls In Ihe transaclion. I did not base, eilher partially or completely, my analysis and/or the
estimate 01 market value In the appraisal report on Ihe race, color, religion, sex, handicap, lamilial status, or nalional origin 01 either the
prospeclive owners or occupants of Ihe subject property or 01 the present owners or occupants 01 Ihe properties in the vicinity 01 the
subject property.
5. I have no present or conlemplated future interest in the subject property, and neither my current or 'uture emptoyment nor my
compensation lor performln~ Ihis appraisal is contingenl on Ihe appraised value of Ihe property.
6. I was not required 10 report a predelermlned value or direction in value Ihal favors Ihe cause 01 the client or any retaled party, the
amounl 01 Ihe value estimate, the allainment of a specilic result. or Ihe occurrence 01 a subsequen1 event In order to receive my
compensation and/or employmenl for performing Ihe appraisal. I did not base the appraisal report on e requested minirrnm vatuatlon, e
specillc valuation, or Ihe need 10 approve a specilic mortgage loan.
7. I performed this appraisal In conlormity with the Unilorm StandardS 0' Prolesslonal Appraisal Practice Ihat were adopted and
promulgated by the Appraisal Slandards Board 01 The Appraisal Foundation and that were in ptacs as 01 the etfective date 01 this Ilppralsal,
with the exception 0' the departure provision 0' those Standards, which does not apply. I acknowledge thai an estimate 01 I reasonabll
time lor exposure In the open markel is a condition in the delinilion of market value and Ihe estimale I developed Is consisten1 with the
marketing time noted in the neighborhood section 01 this report, unless I have otherwise stated in Ihe reconciliation section.
8. I have personally inspected the inlerior and exterior areas 01 the subject property and Ihe exterior 01 all properties listed IS comparables
in Ihe appraisal report. I lurther certi'y that I have noled any apparenl or known adverse conditions in Ihe subject improvements, on the
SUbject sile, or on any sile vlilhin the immsdiate vicinity 01 the subject property 01 which I am aware and have made adjustmenls for these
adverse conditions in my analysis 01 the propsrty value 10 lhe extenl thai I had market evidence to support Ihem. I hive also convnenled
about the eflect 01 the adverse conditions on Ihe markelability of the subject property.
9. I personally prepared all conclusions and opinions aboul the real estate that were sel forth in the appraisal rsport. II I relied on
signilicant prolessionat asslslance Irom any individual or individuals in the performance 01 Ihe appraisal or the preparation 01 the appraisal
report, I have named such Individual( s) and disclosed the specifiC tasks performed by Ihem In Ihs reconciliation seclion of Ihis appraisal
report. I certify that any individual so named is qualified to perform the lasks. I have nol authorized anyone 10 make a change to any item in
ths report; Ihsrelors, it an unauthorized change is made 10 the appraisal report. I Will lake no responsibility lor it.
SUPERVISORY APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION: II a supervisOlY appraiser signed the appraisal report, he or she certi'ies
and agrees that: I directly supervise Ihe appraiser who prepared the appraisal report, have reviewed the appraisal report, agree with the
statements and conclusions 01 Ihe appraiser, agree 10 bs bound by the appraiser's certilicalions numbered 4 through 7 above, and am laking
full responsibilily lor ths appraisal and the appraisal report.
ADDRESS OF PROPERTY APPRAISED:
10 NQRTH ROA~. MECHAN~S~RG. PA
17055
APPRAISER:. ~ ~J .
,,~, /,; l " . a.. t --
Signalure: / ,I frt J t{. -
-
Name: HARK W. HECKMAN
Date Signed: DECEMBER 10. 1 991
Stale Certificalion I: GA-000666-L
or Slale License I: RE BROKER LIC. 'RB-044460-L
Slals: P A
Expiration Date of Certification or License: 6/30/99
SUPERVISORY APPRAISER (only If required)
Signalure:
Name:
Dale Signed:
State Certification I:
or State License I:
Slate:
Expiration Date 01 Certification or license:
[J Old 0 Did Nall.specl Prop.rty
Freddie Mac Form 439 6-93
Page 2 of 2
Fannie Mae Form 1004B 6-93
MARK HECKMAN REAL ESTATE AI)PRAISERS
/'iIo N... 10NORTHR
APPRAISER CERTIFICATION
APPRAISER STANDARDS
I acknowledge and certify that: (i) my appraisal of the above referenced property me)' be used
in a federally related financial transaction subject to the requiremenu of Title XI of the
Financiallnslltutions Reform, Recovery and Enforcement Act of 1989 ('F1RREAO); (Ii) the
appraisal must comply with FIRREA and the al'plicable regulations implemen11ng Title IX of
ARREA; and (iii) the appraisal Wll5 completed In accordance with USPAP,
APPRAISER COMPETENCY
I certify that I am fully qualified and competen1 by training, knowledge, and experience to
perform this appraisal.
APPRAISER INDEPENDENCE
I represent and certify that (i) the appraisal assignment was not bosed on a requested minimum
valuation, a specific valuation, or the approval of a loon; (ii) m)' employment was not
conditioned upon the appraisal producing a specific value or a value within a given mnge; (iii)
my future employment is not dependent upon an appraisal producing a specific value; (iv) my
employment, compensation, and future employment are not based upon whether e loan
application is approved; (v) neither me nor any person with on ownership interest in the
company employing me, is related to or has any ownership or other financial interest in, either
the builder/developer, seller, buyer, mortga~e broker, or real estate broker/salesperson (or any
person related to any of them) involved In the transaction for which this appraisal was
requested, or with the most recent sale or refinancing of any property used 1I5 a comparable
property in this appraisal, and (vi) I am not aware of any facls which would disqualify me
from being considered an independent appraiser.
SIGNED:
DATE:
0~{. - t/J.#i~'/}--
/
J(}. -10.'17
1309 DRlllOn STRI!I!T. NEW CUMunRLANll, PA 17070 (717) 774.7202
COMPARABLE SALES PIIOTO ADDENDUM
MARK HI!CKMAN RP.AL F_nATI! APPRAISP.R!l
llOQ DRIUGI! STRIH!T
NEW CIJMIIERLANn, PA 11010
(111) 1H 1201
I'll. Nu. 10NORTHR
COM.AIlABLH SAUl "
6 NORTH ROAn
MP.CHANIC50URO
s.Io.-: "'1196
s.IoPrioo: '110,000
COMPAIIABUI SAUl n
11STATR ROAD
MP.CHANICSOURO
s.Io'--: I nJ91
s.Io Prioo: '119,~
COMPARABLII SAI.II n
) RIPI' ORIVP.
MECHANIC'IIURO
Sa" 1_: 611.11'11
s.Io Prioo: '111,000
.,
J
II
o E.hmAilp8F G
"'OJ'U' 1.IIfO,ono " U'IWIO'
~ I
~
~
r
;
B C
"'00''''
"'IU'OO'
n.. 5,..., 11
,....., i'J
~"I" s" .
1I11t1""hll .
rlKt
. ,-,
11 "141
K
..
~\
3
81 VER
.;j
fil .b\\~
4
~
i 5
::0
It
I. ' --.--
16
I ,"'"
I .'
1 ~
j h
,
:
8
.
~
,
iI-
9.
'i
~
~
~
~
..,a ,.~ ~
....r;:. " \II
.- ~
\ ~
t ..
:s
..
\ 3
Ii
\
~
"'00''''
II J
~q,
~
"
..
'l.
'1-"
" "'0
-7090(} "Fe)
L'A'l:M"~ Au.AND........ be.
}
i
10
.
.
"
~
rA MID UOll,OOO "
""01''''
o E.hm AiIp 28 F
71'01'10'
Jr'OJ'OI)'
G
c
\
IP 12 \ I~ ~
m \\ .r\ ~ ~
~, ,Iii ~
\ .
\ Cl ';)
:) llo I ."
\)I~' ~Ir
~ ~I
~,
fi ~
II: ~
IE
~
l:l
~ ~ j ~ ~ j ~ ~! ~ ~ l~ ~ j ~ ~ j ~ ~ ~ ~
,..."" Q8 II II f\J'./J' (\0.." 0-...11
I. ~
)I! t;
I
~
-1. a
IV
Ii ~
"I-
-Jl9 I
-.
~ii~I!~
II II
II
~~
.c <:) ""
-.;,_~ .. OJ .~.:
,'.1 '" h " \.., t,., \.
. 1--,,"':'''' .." C\l
... -" "''<J\ ~ ., ..
Z '.J 'J ' -:i' U
C H -"....... j \.:
:r-~ ;. + \
:.." -:,.., .~,' '.,s \, \f\
..~< 1\1 ~. ,
," '1\"''' "- \.
w _" I.., "r M ''I
,-' ,.... . ',", ~
.-"1""\..",
,:Q'I,)~:~'~~:
.....N\\j\::"~N
I
I I
I i
..
;I
u
K
I
\N~
~S
I
..
.
I\~ l~ ~ I
I~ ~..
I,.... II.
I ·
OSjL\ ~-
~;t1 ~ ~ i
I": J:I .
,~':.:::'" I
-..! ~ " f- -+-
-. ---.
.
I;) ~ ;;
\t-' ~
~I :
,
,
I~ Ig
.~ 10
I
~.e..I~ _
-~?~....
I.... l1.
,.
,i
~Ia
!I
i
!I
=
!r
:z:
, Xl
~I:i I
I ~
..
.
8
...
.
~
z
c(
>
..J
)-
III
Z
Z
W
lL
)-.
I-
Z
j
o
u
)-
a:
a:
w
lL
..
. . ,
c~.;:1. IA'....
. ..._-~
~ .' ~ I,)....
I;~~ ~;'"...~
z
C I I :
tit ! I i
E: j I
O!l !
:; = I I
.. I
"
...
. ~
o .
u .
!l
=
1-
~I ~
~ l
o
o
o
.
.,
'"
o
~ I
i I
, '
, I
I
W
i
III '0
Nt !I\j
! 1~1 !~
I
-: I
. Ii
9
:: il~
~ -.9
~ ~!~
w''SI!l
Q;~I~~
I~ ; I; Ii
':l l!W
\,) .~,
I\l
! t~
" FlIIl '\j,
t'-/I
I
I '
~ ~ .~
i ~ N "
<:>, ,
Il I
~,
"':
ti
N
~
I
o
o
.
'"
In
...
I .
, I
-
~.....~ .
..... "'
~ .....
- ~ ~
~ ~ 'l...
\ _ -'.{'J
.lJ
~ .
~ '.:!
i "',
lil -
"' -.
o ....
o '"...
;'--7
~
J 1
I
II , ..
~ 'I"
- ..1- I
~ Ii -
: 11 I
.
f
!
I I
I I
I i II
I
In
-#
o
O'
o I I
...., ..
00 ..
"
-"'
.~a
" L
7.....:!i
. ~
"'
"
o
~ ~
.
..
III
Z5
~
~
..
III
. -
o
..
u
c i
... I
~ I :
... i
... r::
o u
.
L
I~
B '- ~ I~
:IJ \
.....-< I-
s ~ ~ I':::~
~ n-
! ! ~ il! !
; IJ~i
1--
'11
t;
I.
.
.,
i I
a i
~ I _! I
..." ~~ I
..",. \_" . I
, '-
~ 'I .
"to: ~
I- ~ N
~.,
~_; !i ~
C)......:: .. ~
-..... '
.
: a
(J1
'I--
I
-
:I
:l
~
~
l!
i
IlJ
~
-:1C\
,
~
;1
. '
E I ,. ~
....
u .,
...
CO 0
II>
....
0
z
...
....
....
:r
rr.
. ,;
" ~
~ - "
~ , -
.oln M"
'0 ii ~ ii
. v ~
. ~ 4 C'
a. OS!
&I - '0 0
... 0 .. l:
11 al 0 ""
~" 0
~ . u-=
Q 0 '.Ii
III ~ >. to.
... 4.1 J: 4.1
ClI... a c:
.e.: ~ 0 tJ
~ ~ Of U II
Q.c ~ c: c:
0'" 0 0 2
J: - .&: .;; ::
... 0 Q. _ ..
..... > 0
o c: ii u Q.
... &I : tJ '"
. 5 : c: ii
.... ;,... ! :;
g iJ..... " E
E &: (J'l C -
a-III""
.. ... e
'^ In ~ .. Q
::) ~ ~ i
"
.
/
'--.....t,~~ /
',,-
/
I
I
~"~r
II)
....
c:
4)
E
....
o
.-
-
Q,
E
o
()
I
I
I
I
,N,..'j~, l
I' ........',.:.. ~
'11-'
I tIs
..~
;" ~i ~
, Px
~~
~~
...
l~
~:"~"'~1r4
.,
"
..
o
~
...
c
=
o
(,J
~
..
~
D.
I60t
o
C.
lU
:E
Gl
f
't
o =
;;,
~
~
:>
III
\
\
';! I
'"
fJ
.
~
.. 0 \
o \
"- \
~ \
. ~ ---\
\--. ------ \ ~
. '- OO(i}A. \ ~
\ ~"fVl/l:J!) \ r
tr,.~ \
. (f\~<J... \
<-f7~
\
\
\ ~c
, !
\1
\/
\
\
\
"~ .'
:-'it
\.
~q,
~
,
\
.~>
RESUME
Laurence W, Brodisch
L. W. Brodlsch Reel Estate
10 Church Road
Newport, Pa 17074
717 . 567-6905
717 - 567.6906. Fax
LICENSURE
Real Estate Broker, Comm. of PA, RB-029335-A since January 1977
General Appraiser, Comm. of PA, GA-000869-L since January 1993
EDUCATION
Westminster College, New Wilmington, PA BA In Economics 1968
PROFESSIONAL EDUCATION
Appraisal Institute - Reel Estate Appraisal Principles ( Exam 8-1 )
Residential Valuation ( Exam 8-2 )
Standards of Professional Practice ( Exam SPP )
parts A & B
Narralive Appraisal Report Writing ( Exem )
Income Capitalization
Numerous Courses for the BrClker's License
Continuing Education Courses for both Broker and Appraiser licenses
Highest and Best Use
PROFESSIONAL EXPERIENCE
Licensed General Appraiser, 1993
Licensed Residential Appraiser, 1991
Licensed Real Estate Broker, 1977
Licensed Real Estate Salesman, 1973
MEMBERSHIPS
Greater Harrisburg Association of Realtors, since 1973
Central Penn Multi-List, since 1977
National Association of Realtors
PA Association of Realtors
MAJOR CLIENTS
First National Bank of Liverpool First National Bank of Marysvllle
First National Bank of Mlffllntown First National Bank of Newport
The Bank Of Landlsburg Juniata Valley Bank
Farmers Trust Company Mellon Bank
PNC Omega Bank
County of Perry PP&L
Numerous Altorneys in Perry, Cumberland, and Dauphin Counties
I have appeared as an expert witness In both State and Federal Court since 1977
Tax 10 1# 23-2227557
FAX # 567.6906
.1
LAND APPRAISAL REPORT
Jt No
C"""lIeI306.02 M.pRtI."nc. 090-156-024
80ffower .N::ne
P,Gpetl"tAdd"ss R.D.II 1 FcJ,.;lers ~bllCIW Road
C,tt Blain Countt Perry
I <9.lIlesCllo"'o Peny ('cunty [Eed &:ok Vb1ll1E 292 ~Je 144/115
s.1t P,~. I V... 01 s.1t Lo.n ""0 ,ra PIOp.,tt Atqhll APPlIllOd I X! rtt I i L....ho~ I , Uo M,nulII' PU
.1<1\1.1 RuIE.llto T.... I 194..86 IYrJ Lain eh.,v..1D bo p.id bl"wer I 0111., UIlICOnc..."'OI N::t1e
Lend",clenl V~rgil (l.Jtshall Add,,,. R.O.II 1 B;:>>c 144 Blain, PA 17006
OceuplnT Vacant larrl App..i." I".W. Braiisch InlUuebonllDApPII"M Lard is ~ l:rt
Joanne E. arrl Ra1ald L. R!:h!rts h w
Lo"Don I I U'b.n I I SubUlb.n
Bu," Up I 10... 7S\ I] 2S\ ID IS\
Growll1 A.1e I I fully 0.. I I R.pid I I Sto.d,
Prop"tt V.lues [ X 11rn:'''''IlQ I I SlIbll
Uormndr.iuppl"t I I Shor1ovo [XI In B.~nct
M.1'k,U"9lime I I Und" J Mo. I XI H Mol
Pr...nIL.oo UIo __lQIIIf.m'l"t . ?l2.4 hmil"t ;LUpll
l.li Ioousllll 81\ Vlc.nl \
Ch'I19oln Pr....II..ndU.. I. J NOlllko.., I XIUkel"t I') [ I hklno Ptact I"
I') flom'laqmt;: To Restclential
IX] (}wner L I T.nlnl .1 U"lnl
ISO,QQO IDI16?,OOQ PredommlnIV.Iu., 76,000
1. '" ID. 170 III Predomln.ntAv,. 4S III
Stale PA
/Ip Cod. 17006
!XIAulll
iX1Under25\
iX]Sklw
I IOeehnll19
I 'lli'''UPPl"t
I I lliM 6 Mo.
0\ Conda . 5\ CommMell1
Ernplo,m.nISllb,.~
Convemencelo fmpklymenl
Convemenc. b ShoppinQ
Comenienc. kJ Schools
AdeqUiCY 01 Publtc IrallsportJbOn
Reclubon,lI f iClktles
AdeqUOCI 0' UbkUes
Proporly Camp.bbl.'"
Protection horn OelJimentll Condltlons
Police Ind rifll Protection
General Appearance or Propllr1let
App..11D M..k.t
PredominJnt OCcupancy
Sil1911 F.mily Pr~. RlI19'
SII1910 F.mil"t Aoo
Good AWQ f.u POOl
I XII , !
I [ IIX]!
II ! IXII
I IXII I!
II IIXII
IIXII.! I
IIXII I!
IIXII 'I I
flXI! Ii J
IIXII II I
II X] L I I_I
Ilxl [-J I]
Commenll lrn:llldll19lho.ol.clDrs, I"o"bll or vn'.....bll. Iff.<:II19 m".,"blily 100 pubhc p..k.. SChoolo, ,Iew, nol.o) Jackscn 1bM1Bhip is located _
arr.urrl tre l:ora.gh of Bla.iD.LI~j13 <::nl of.tre prirre farminJ areas of Peny O;unty. 1re soils
.inrar;t,9.Qe~t;:CJ<.I.18hi.p~. iQe<1l tor agriculture. ElBTE!lltary sd-ool in Blain, tre others are
miles awa . 1here is a lot of State ~ wxdlard in \ooestem Pe CbJnt. Gxx:I hunti area.
Oun.nsion. O::py 9t ~ attached. = 25.16 Sq It 0' ACles CornM 101
Zanino etassill"Don JJ::J zcni.n3 in. th! ta..nshiP p"...t1mp,,,,m.nll I 'do I I dQ not conlorm 10 lonino 'eou~Don.
HiVllos'lOO b..t u.. 1-'(1 Pr..lnr "0 .JOIhtr l'peelly)Q?l4qJ:~. ~ for a hurltirn. canp site. .. .
Pubic 01I1ef iOes'"bo, OFF SitE IMPROVEMENTS Topo ~tle 131cpe- hilly:i,rl the rear
[XI SleetA'cllSI I X/ Pubic II PINIIe SI/' Ab:Jve average
1.1 Surl"ef1;l~_.._ ShlPo!<eCtargular .
Wiler [ ".I N:re M.lnlen.nct [XJ Publ<: [ I P'o.1e View Ave~ ....
S.n Sew.. [ ] N:;re I ] SIO,m Sew., II CU'bIGUIte' Oll!n.v.overall- average
L I Underground fleet & leI I I Sidewalk 1_ 1 StteelllQhl\ " Ul. ,'.plny lo..,.d In. HUG Id,ntlll.d IplIl,l ".... ttaJl,4 A'.., I X 1 No [. I'"
Commfflts (Ia.orablf or unlnorabl.lnclu41rQ any a~r!li! .Iduri. fuement;. tncrOachm.nij, Of othff advtfSl condlliOf1'1 A{::proxirrately 11 acres
U!l~lE!-,lr~LJ;h!_ k:l3.laOOL'@:t;~:I,.tlJ_ yalll<>l:Jletint:er c The subjE!ct. pm;erty ill ~~ly @Wo'I..
for.i!;.fllel]3t!kSRUJl'l.J.TRI?Uy caJYiD/~~L tl.1e _ r:trl ~e twe.. .1DeJ~ \JSe fYilMthe subjE!ct..
is eitrer farmlarrl or w:xxIlarrl. tioo rext d:or arrl arother ale re' brilt.
The und"'toned h.. ree'lod butt ,ee.n\ules of prop,r1Ies mo.\.lm,~, .nd pro~m'le ID IUbleel.nd hu can.~"ed 111..0 In 1110 milk.l.n.l"t.!. Tho descrlpUon Irn:lud.. . doll.1r
Idiu5lment fellectlncJ market IClacDon 10 those Items at siQntflcan1 vIllanon between the subject and comp.mble properties III SllJnlllunl item In the complllble property Is superior
1D 01 more flvorablB Olin Ole subteCl property, a minus t.) adlustment is made thus leducinqlt1l1 indica led value 01 subject ill slonillcoInlllllm In ltIe comparib1e is lnfe,io, 10 or less
tl'i'Ollble lhJn f\o subject propertt," plus 1+)lidjullment is mAde thus inerenlno the mdicale{t 'ulueollt1e sublett
ITEM SUBJECT PROPERTY
-R::O.# T Slain---
Jack.9::n. Th.$?" Peny_C:
Pro"m,.., 10 SubJecl
~~Ies p~~~
P!ice
0." SoU/co
0.1e 01 S.Ie.nd
Tune Adlu.bnont
___ u <;'OMJ'A!'ABL~ NQ!
R.O.U 1 Elliotts-
b.Jrg, Saville Thp.
12 miles t-brthea.9t
-~__:_.:__ _ j L 4i; ~~~
Visual, F\Jb. Reeds.
O[SC~IPIION I +(-jIAdJusl
9-26-n.
Simil<U"
_S~m.LSim. .
.,,0 ac..:~. ~7,!;QO
F\Jblic-Sim.
N::t1e- Sim.
. . C.QM~A!'A~L.E. N02 _ _ COMPARABLE NO. J
R.O.U 1 lDysville U R.o.ii isiain----
Saville Thp., Peny Jack.9:n Thp., Perry .
9 .miles t-b);theast 2 mi les t-brth
........_ .. J:~4U~~____ .'__J: 7g:g~g~
Visual, F\Jb. Rf:rrJs. ._Vi8).lal" P\!!J'I~"-u
OESCRIPIIQNu l+1~1$A<!lu'l_u JlESGRIPJloIL..!~JB~I~!!
8-20-97_12~11l-516_ u.;u+~,.!1QO.
Similar Similar '
sj.rnJS.im.___~~_~._ __~__ ~SW J~irri. _ :;i1: 509.
34i!C:.-Sup. ~:l;!,~Q() __ 35ac:,:~SIJp.>:?Q,()QQ.
private +2,500 Public-Sim.,
N:;re- Sim. ~~Sim.
Net Adj JTJl~L_
Indl"lod V.luo
or Sublee' I 37 500 I 38 685
Comm.nlsonM"keIO.ta ~ 1I_1.l-.ClS n::;stly. w:a:led 2ro lc-..ate:l alC!B 1\ to,''f_''hj.P..rQaq,_Q;;ml_Jl_ Lwas
~ai-rlary l~t;ed__oo ~ private ngl}t-of-way. ChxI huntirg lard. Q:m>_~ .3_was ~_~---
. .__._ ___Q;;atoo near aJa.iD, l,Dts of mad frrntag'!. Older sale.
Comm.nls .nd COOOIDonsol App"iul 1heSa1es O::npariscn An>roach is the cnly_ retEY<iD~: ~~ch_fg~..t:fu-", :tyPe
ofprc:perty. M:>st lam sales are of emIleI' lots. 1l'ere is arotheLl;;:rge.h::~L<:perat;iq1. .
scheduled to. re bJilt just \ooest of this prc:perty 00 the Fisher farm. .1t iSca1,l8irg. a 16i;.Of----
a:ntroversylll the. local papers. Actually, this is a g:xxl valley for.such an ~tioo. --..
r~="'on~ subj~i p~y isextrarely narro.-.< am rot typicaUor tl1ls~ai!n~y....~'-::'=~'
. . __ope __ ___ fPt;. CIW a narro,.J lot to re sub:liviOO:l_9ffa larger tract. Jack8::n
'!bwnship has yeW few real estate transfers d.1e to its rarot~ss.}\g_a!1:U9~tii:iiiJ._~==---
If~T1MA 1~I"AAMf'TVAlUf.A'OE."H'O.O"U'JECTPROP'RTY"O' M'ud1 4 19 98 IDbol 37 500
. ' . (e6~ ) I. . ..... _..J_______
cr;...., '- c( .{f.-....._ ,
laurence W. Braiisch G\-869-L
!
___ Sg!L acre
l~iq\
_ _ _ QE~GBlI'.tIOl4. ____.
_3~4-98 . .
'leryrural
.1',,'19, !l\yg. _ ___
..:?!1.,<I(;a~s
RtPlic
N:;re
~oCillon ._
SLI!{o!I",__..... .
~--_.
Pccess _
1rrprovrmts
N:::re
N:;re- Sim.
~-Sim.
~- Sim.
Tl..:JXL:" 7,509 ._LL!ixl::":"':" 10:1,00
r-I+
.I Old
[] O~ NoI Phyl~'" ""poet Pro"q
Ae'I'lN ApPl.alsef III .pplicable)
l W Brodl!'.ch Aflaf Estale
fO,"lLPm ". "'OTAl 2000' ,aPPlllts.1 software br 1 ~ mode. inc .. '.Boo.MAMOOE
I
, ~
I
j tr\
I ~
~
0..
i\J
Cf'
01
~
ca
g]
c:lI
,
/I't"-
In 1M ,tlf ninrltfn hu".IIIJ .nd Elqhty
B[rW[EN GLADi'S 1<. GUTSIIAl.l..
.J.nua"v
oU,oI
119801
w11Jo\ol, of 81dLn. Vurry County.
penn.y 1 V.llll.'. GIl~'rHOH,
MlU
Ju,i:IlIE E. POUErtTS and iWflALO L.. lmUER1S. hor husband, of
Hechanlcaburq, Cumberland County, Pennlylvenla, .1 tenant. by the
entit.ti,., GRANTECS,
WI rNESSE"fIf, Thll In (onUdt,ation 01
Love and Affection
llC~~IfJC~x.l~llMlt.UjlClllI..~ilfoll)jXItJ<.lUUllJllX'h. ..id I',n".
and conn', 10 1M ...iJ lunh..... their heirl and ...ignl,
do..
lloIIuuc
_"b,I'''''.
ALL
TI~T CEPTAIN PIECE, parcel or tract of land ILtU6tl 1n
Jacklon Townehip, Perry County, Penneylvenia, boullded and d..crlbld
II followsl
BEGINNING at a point In the cantorlln. of L. R. IS0007,
thence from .aid point or place of beginning 1n the clnterline of'
laid road, along land. now or formerly of Jamel ~ol.r, South 32
degreel 51 minutel 19 seconds East, a distance of 2,189.14 feet to
an iron pin, thence continuin9 alon9 other lands of the Grantor
heroin, South 6S degrees 19 minutes 13 second. Welt, a distance of
413.80 feet to an iron pin, thence continuing 810n9 other land. of
the Grantor herein, North 32 de9r... 16 minute. 19 .econd. Welt, ·
diet.nee of 1,545.59 feet to an iron pin' thence continuing along
other land. of the Grantor herein, North 2 degre.. 40 minute. Welt,
I
. diltance of 294.81 feet to an iron i,in, thence continuin9 along other
lands of the Grantor herein, North 32 degree. 21 minute. Welt, a
di8tance of 965.18 feet to a point in the conterlino of L. R. IS0001'
thence along the centerline of said road, North 65 degree. 39 ",inut..
10 .econdl Ealt, a di.tanco of 299.90 feet to a point in the center~
I1ne of L. R. 150001, .aid point being the point or place of
BEGINNING and CONTAINING 25.46 acr.', more or 1..., accordinq to a
lurvey of Earl D. palm' 60n., R. S. dated November 2], 1919, . copy
of which il attached hereto.
BEING part ot that piece, parcel or tract of land
."1')
-
~.,'/
!'II"I" "11'11 .I'III'''''I~.I
.1I',"~"".,
Vir.!il ';IIt',h.,11
U,D..I Fowll'r~; Hollow Ih11r1
1'. 'II r
,l.jl'k'\OI1 Twp.
P^ ill'rlldl' 1/!1I1f1
I". ,,II'
II \.Ii 11
, .f., N,\
,,~~
,'\1 II 'Ill! ," "I I I I,', f' .1' "'11" , 111111 \ I nc;r;: SIDE
, , I.;.
FRONT OF
SUBJECT PROPERTY
REAR OF
SUBJECT PROPERTY
STREET SCENE
.. ,
.
MULTI-PURPOSE SUPPLEMENTAL ADDENDUM
FOR FEOERA(LY RELATED TRANSACTIONS
Bonower,tlenl. Virgil Ultshal ..'
~:~.;~tili"---- g.,[)c~_L-~J~~MOooI _Road
_ . ...__._m .m _.. n:y
l.nder
SI1Ie PA'
Z,p Cod. 17 006
'hll Multl,Pulpose Supplemenu.1 Addendum for fedflollltt He~led ".nucllo"! was desioned 10 provide dll! 'PIHIlsef With I conventenl WilY 10 comptt With the CUllenl
IPPIIllIlll1ndlld. Ind rOQul"m.nls ollho red",1 O,pOIIIIII""11" Co,po"bon (rOlCI, Iho Oll~, 01111. Compoollel 01 Cun.ncy (OCCI. Ih. om" 01 Ihllll
S'pt"lllon (0151. Iho Re.o~lIon Trull Co'po"lIon (RIC). .nd 111. red.,,1 Roso".
Thl. MulU.Purpolt Ouppl.menlal Addendum I. lor u.e with eny epprel.el. Only tho.e
.lalemonl. whloh h..o beon ohookod by Ihe epprol.er epply 10 Iho proporly being epprelltd.
[X] PURPOSE 4 FUNCnON OF APP/WSAL
The purpo.. 011110 'PPIIIIIII. " esUmlle Iho mllkel..Iu. 01111. lubleel pfOp.r1y II d.lined h."ln Ih.luncUon 01 \he .ppIIIIIIII " mill \he .!lov..n.med
Linder In "1~'Uno \he IUbjecl prop.r1y lorlendlno purpo.es. Thl. I. I r.d"'lIt ,,1J1ed blnmUon
[Xl EXTENT OF APPRAISAL PROCESS
[&1 Th. .ppIIIIIII. Oiled on 1I1.lnlo,m.Uon g.lI1ered by 111. Ipp"I." lrom pubHc reeOld., oll1er idenolled lOu"es.ln.p"aon 01111. .ubjecl properly Ind
neighborhood. Ind solccaon 01 complllble llle. wlll1ln 111. lubleel mllk.I.... Ih. o,lgln.IIO'''' 01111. complllblello Ihown in 111. 0.11 SOU". ."aon
01111. mllk.1 g,id .klOg will1 111. .ou". 01 conll,m.aon.llmll1ble. Th. OIlgln.llOu".I. p"senled fllIl Th. 10."es.nd d.11 I" con.ldered ,oI.ble
Wh,n conl1lcang Inlorm.aon WII provided. 111. '0'''' deemed mO'1 reH.ble hll boon u.ed 0.11 b'hoved " b. .nreNlble WII nOllncluded In Iho report nor
used IS 01 basis IOi Ile YJlue condJslon,
In] Th. R,produeUon CO.II. blled on _m'_"_' .___________ _ .._...._nnw -- -
.upplem.nled by \he .pp"l.er'l knowledg. 01111.10011 m..k.l
_I Phylk.1 d,preeilllon II blled on 111. ..am'led ,lIeellv' .g. 01111. .ubjeel properly r.ncaon.l.nd/or 'lIelll.1 d,precl.aon. i1 prmnll. IpeelliClIIt
.ddrelled In 111. .pp,,11I1 report or oll1er Idd,nd. In ..Um.ang 111. IIIe ..IV., 111' 'pplllser hll reHed on per.on'l knowledg. 01111.10011 mllk'l Thil
knowledg' II blled on prior .nd/or currenlln.Iy.I. 01 III. Illes .ndior .b.OlOlIon ol.II...lVeslrom Illes ollmpro.ed prop,rtles
LXl Th' sobjecl prop'r1y 1.Io"led In.n "" 01 p,lm..11y owner.occupled .ingle I.mlly re.ld,n", .nd 1I1,lncom. App,olCh I. nol con.ldered "b. m..ni"'llul
fOI this reuon, !he Income Approlch wn nol used.
[J lh. EIUIT..1ed M..k.1 R,nl.nd Gro55 R.nl M.mpHer .ailed in 1I10lncom. ApprolCh... bmd on 111. ,ppIII..,.. knowledg. 01111. .ubjeet mllk.l.re.
Th. renl>l lmowledg.l. blled on prlor.ndior cun.nl "nI>l "1Il'u"", 01 resld",a.1 properties. Th. G,o.. R.nl Mumplle. I. blled on p,ior .nd/or curr.nl
"'1y.1. 01 p,lces .nd mllk.t /lies lor resid.nU.1 prop.rtles.
I] ror Incom. producing prop.rtles. 1C1Il11 renls, ....ocles Ind exp.n.es h... been reported .nd .n'lyled Thay hlie been u.ed 10 proleellulVre renls,
vacancies and upense5.
IX] SUBJECT PROPERTY OFFERING INFORMATION
AccOldl"'llo _~!;Q.:r:______.__ ~~_________._________._____ .______~____ ____ ____ . .._ 1I1'lUbjeel plOperly
IZJ hll nol been ollered lor..1e In 111. pilI 30 d'YI.
[J I. currently ollered lor llle lor S ________
l --J WII ollOled lor IIIe wlll1in 111. pili 30 dlYI'or S .
CI OIIerl"'llnlOlmlUon WII con.ldered In 1I1.lIn.lreeoncl",a';;;;;;;;I;;;--- -----~--
I . J OII01lng Inlorm.aon WII nol con.ldered In 1I1.lIn.l reeonctH.aon 01..1V.
rJ OIIerl"'llnlormallon WII nolmi~ble The rOlson.'or unmlilblily .nd 111. .lep.l>k.n by \he ,pp/llsor.re ..plllned IIIIlr In 1111. .dd.ndum.
LXI SALES HISTORY OF SUBJECT PROPERTY
According" Public Records . _ 1I1esubjecl proptr1y'
LZJ hll nol b.n.I.~;;; j;; 111. p;5it".~. ,;.u;;-- - ---- -- -
[J hll o.n.lerred In 111. Pllt IW.~. monll1..
, I AI p,lor Illes which h.1.. occurred In 111. pili tw.~. mon1l1. "' Noted b.low '00 ,eeonclled 10 111. ,pp/ll..d nlu.. .1111" In \he body 01111. report 01
In Iho .dd.",,1
Date
S.I.. Prlcl
Document /I
SeU..
Bu .r
r.xl FEMA FLOOD HAZARD DATA
I XI S.bleel prop.r1y II nOIIo"led In . rEMA Sp"I.1 Flood H.llld A".
L] S.bjecl prop.r1y 1.IoClIed In . rEMA Speel.1 rlood Hlllrd Are.
Zono
FEMA M. Penolll
Ma Oa'l
Nam. 0' Communi
Zcre C 421952 0015 B 10-15-85
1..1 The comm,nlly does nOl p.rtlclp.lIlln 111. N.aon.1 rlood In.u"nc. P'og/lm
I XI Th. communily does p.rtlclp.lIlln 111. N.aon.1 rlood Inso/ln" P'llQ"m
[XJ III. coy.rod by ~ proa/lm
[ ] Ills co,eled by an emefaency program
Jacka:n 'It1.o.nshi
P'a,'oI2
rOlm MPA .. "IOlAl2000" ,pp/lI5.I.ol1w.re by. II mod..lnc .. I.BOO.ALAMOOE
'.
.
,
L&J CUFlRfNT SALES CONTRACT
.
,'~R_'_'_______"'__'_'_"'_'_'''''''___'_'''''
I XI Ihuubjecl P'OP'r1I ~ curren'" nolunder conbocl
I I The conll.ct and/Or acrow lnstutllonl were not l'lillibla lor review The un.....ilibl.ty 01 the contracl ts upLilned 'alef In IhI &6dendi section
TfVlconlllcllnd/Clr escrow InslJuctkml wefa le"IleWed The lollowing 5ummiflzes the ccntrlet
Contract oe.e Amendment Oat.
Contr.c. Price Sell"
/__1 file ,0nblCllnd~11Ild Ih.1I p.rson.1 plOperly .,.. 1101 Included to !he...
L ~J lhe conb.cllnd~.1Ild 111.1 perlonll properly .,..lncluded n conllSlIld or
[.bmtllld conb.bulllry ..Iu. ~ S
r _J Pmon.' plOperly .,.. nollncluded In !he n..1 nlu' ..bml.
I - I P".onll p,op,,1y .,..Included In !he nn.I"Iu. "bm...
I_J Ih. conblCllnd~,1Ild no nn.nclnG conc...ionl or oll1er Inc.nllv..
fJ The con"cllnd~11Ild Ihe lomlna conc...ion. or Incenltl..
Ll
--------- ---..--,
ii~~~;;lonl or Incenllves exllllhe compa,ables Will checked for similar concns..,nl.nd approprlitl.djultmenll Wlft eNd', II appkable, 10
Ih.1IIhe n..I"Iu' conclu.ion ~ In comphnc. .,ill1 !he M..k., V.Iu. d.nned "".In
[&J MARKET OVERVIEW
Inc:kll" Jl1 uplwllon 01 CUlllI1Il11IIbl condl,," ,nd hndl.
;l :~_____ monll1. I. con.~ered . ,...onlb. m..k.bOlJ period lor !he .ubjecl prop'r1I bued on
l,~ _l!!!tt;i,::UlIt , ________
l.8J ADDlnONAL CERnFICATION
_ _~tGlt13Jrgn tre
lhe AppfJl.., certllles.oo '0,...111.[
1'1 IIle .n'~.... opinion. .nd conclu.ion. .,er. dev.loped. '00 lI1i. report.,.. prep..ed, In conlo,m,1y .,1111 Ihe Untlo,m Silnd..d. 01 P,ol...IO..1
ApPlllul Pile 11<. rUSPAP"). ",.pl 111"!he 0.p..1II" P,..i.lon 01111. USPAP do.. nol.pp~
(2) their compenution ts nol conlnoenl upon It1CI reportlnQ of predetermined Villue or direction In value Ihal 'avolS Ihe cause 01 ltle tlenllhe amounl
ollhe value esUmatB. O1IItt1lnment 01 II stipulilted raurt, or the occurrence of I subsequent event
(3) IhI. Ipp,,~,'u'lQnment.,.. nol b..ed on . requ..1Ild minimum "lulUon. . .pecific ..Iu.bon, or 111. ,ppr..,1 ol.lo.n
lKJ ADOlnONAL (ENVIRONMENTAL) UMmNG CONDlnONS
lite ..Iu. ..b,..1Ild Is bued on Ihe mumption 11111 Ihe proper1ll. nol n~.IIv.~ .Necltd by 111. 'li,lence 01 hm,dou. .ub.ilnc.. or d.bimenill
envilanmenttJ COnditions unle$s olherwlse stated In this report The appraiser is not an elpert In the idenbllcaUon of hllirdaus lubslilnce5 or detrimental
emlronmentll condlltons. The appraiser'. routine inspection of Ind Inquiries Iboullhll subject property did nol de'lekJp any Information Ihal indicated
any <1pparenl slgnlflcanl huudaus substances or detrimental Ilnylronmenlill condItions which woukf atfecllhll property n~atrvll~ unless olherwislIstated
In ltIis report Ills possiblll thai tests and Inspections made by a QuaMlied hazardous substance Ind environmental expert wou" ..Nul the ellstence 01
hllilldoU5 subsl.1nces or delrlmenlal environmental conditions on or around the property that would neg.uvely af1ecllts u.lue
o ADOlnONAL COMMENTS
Q{J APPRAISE?",GNATtJRE & L1CENSE/CERTIFlCAnON
APP..i.....SiQ..hJ,~-i.L("1L...I(,I!J;.czf2.~[Necliv.O... 3-4-98 O.IIIPrep..ed 3-6-98
App..I..,.. N.mejprln" _uI4~_W~_].gcdi.s(::ILu_______ ____ Phone' __i7.J..l.__S~l.::fi~Q2..______ _____
SIJ..~A _ LZ]llc.n.. fZ]C.rtlflClllon, __CA-OOQ869-L ___ rulO, 23-2227557
o CO-SIGNING APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION
!.-~, The co. signing appraiser hIS Dersonati Inspected the subject property, both inSide and oul and has made an uterior Inspecton 01 a. comparable SlIes
bled In !he report The report WIS prepared by Itle apprliser under direct supef'flsion of lt1e co.signlng appraiser The co-siQnino Ipprliser Iccepts
res~nsjbilly 'or Ole contenlS 0' the report Including me value conclusions Ind the Nmiting condItions. and confirms "lithe certifications apDIy
lu" m 1M cO-QlQnlfllJ appraiser
I The co.s!Qnlng appraiser hu not oersonaltt Inspecled the Interior of Itle subjecl plOperty and
I I has nollnsD<<~ the ellerlor or the sublecl plOpSlly and aI comp,mble sales hied in the report
L.J hIS Inspecled !he eItellOr or Ihe sublecl property and alt comparable sales Rsled In ~1l' leport
[J The report WIS preplred by the appl.a!ser under direct superviSIon 0' the co.siQning ~ppr~isef The CO-S1Q11inO Ippr~isef ~ccepl! responslbilty to, hl
conlonls ollhe reportlncludlno 111. "Iu' conclu.lon. .nd 1I1.lmibno ,und,bon.. .nd conft,m. 111.,111. certlllc.boll! .pp~ luty Illlhe co..lQnlng
.apprllser with ttle lllcepban 011\8 certlllcdan regilding physiC.a1 inspections The above desCribes tie eve! a' Inspection perfOlmed by "-
ca,siQnino Ipp,alser
- I The CO-Signill9 appraiser's level of Inspecbon.lrwoNemenlln the apprlisal plOCesS Ind certllicibon Ire COVlled elsewhere in !he Iddend.a section
olthls .appraisal
o CQ.SIGNING APPRAISER'S SIGNATURE' UCENSE/CERTIFICATlON
Co.SiQniOlJ
ApPllile(s Signltu1e
CO-SllJnlfllJ Applliser's Name (prinl)
SIJIe ! 1 lie''''
[necliv. DIIII
0.. p,....ed
Phone' l _ 1_
lulO'
L I C'r1Il~'bOn ,
P'Q' loll
l W Brodl~ch Af!al Eslalf!
Form MPA .. .TOTAl2000.apprlt~11 SOINt,r! by I LI mode. lIlC .. '.800.ALAMOUE
,
.
DEFINITION OF MARKET VALUE: Tho moollUoblblt pllC' whICh I plOpotlY lhauld b'ln9 In I comp.llIv. Ind Open mI,kel under II COndl1lont
'oqulSllI II I ". I.lt, "" bll\''' .neI ....., IIch KIno p,udtntr, knowltdQllblY Ind lIIumlno lie prlC. IS nol ,"..1Id by undu. IIlm'~1 !mplellln 1111
d.'1nI1lon " ... con,ummlllon 01 I 5110 IS 01 . 'plCllIed dill Ind "" pn'ln9 01 lilt '10m stilt, II bUY" under cunel,lIon. whollby II) buy" lneI Itlltr III
fyplCdy lnollnted, (2) both Plttlet .It wd lnfOlfned Of 'lWei IdvlSed. 100 Uth Ictlfl9 In whit hi cootld", hit own besllnllrnt m Ii 'e.nonlblll time II ,ilk>wed
lor uposullln flf open mllkat (4) p.ymen11t mId. In IDIml 01 (Uh In US dollill 01 In lerms olllnlnc:all"lnoemenl5 compallble 1heulkJ, Ind 151lhe pllce
Icprnentllle norm.' conlk1er.Uon lOf Iht P'OPerf1 loid unitfKIed by specl.1 Of clubve Imlnclt19 Of ules concessions- glanted by anyone USOClited Wllh
t\eule
. Adjustments kJ tie compatIbles musl be "lide 10f special or crelhe 'mInCing or ules concenlons No Jdjuslrnenls ,af' ntcesul)'
for 11011 cosll whICh 118 oonnJly pild by seier, is Ii resull 01 tradlllon or YW In . markel IIU, lhasa costs III 'e.dl~ ldenllfllble
sine. III lelaf PlY' these costs In vlltUipt d ules 'Inueaons Speclll or creluu 'Inlncing Jdlustments Cln be m.lde ~ the
complflble propertt by comparisons ~ financing 18lml ollered by I turd PU1y institubonill Iend.r thilt is not ak'ildy Invo~ed In lhe
p,opef1y or trtnSlclton Artt .dlusrment shoukt not be cak:u!,lled on I mechilniul do~' 101 doll.Jr cosl of the lin.aru::inlJ 01 concesston
bul '" dollr lmount 01 any adjustment should apPfOlimlle fle milferS reaction tl l1e linanclnO or concessIOns blsed on !he
.pprall,,'.j.dQ.ment
STATEMENT OF LIMITING CONDITIONS AND APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION
CONTINGENT AND LIMITING CONDITIONS: lh. 'PO/lISer', certllicahon It.., 'POII" In 1110 lPO/I,..1 report ;, ,ubi'" II Iho lo"w;no
coRdllonl
I The .appraiser wII not be responsible lor mltters ola IelJII nltufl ltllllNect either the proper1y being IPPr;uS~ Of Ile blJe to Il The Ipprli5er illUmes ttlat
ttle aile Is lJood and m.allle~ble Ind, therefore, wll not render .Jny opiniOns .about ttle nile The property is .Jpprllsed on ttle buis 01 II being under responsible
ownmhip
2 The IPprliser has provided a sketch In the appralul repor1 ~ show Ipproxlmale dimensions 01 the ImprO'lements and !he sketch is Included ontt ~ assist
Iho ,..d" or lie r'9ort In .I,u.lllno Iho property '00 .nd."IoOOlno Iho 'POII~O'" delll,m,n.lton ollis SIll
3 The IPOIII." hi' e..mined Iho mlloblt 11>0<1 mlp' III., Ire provided by lI1e fed",' Em"Q'ncy M.nIQom.nl AQency (or olhor dllo '0'''''' 100 hIS noltd
In the appraisal repor1 whethel the sublect sihl is louted In an identilied Speciil flood Halird Area Becluse the appfliser is nola su~eyor. h. or she mlkn
no QUltlnas, express or Impled, reolldlfIQ !his dete,mln,aUon
4 The apprillsef wll nol o~. testimony 01 ilPpell in caur1 because he 01 she mlde In .Jpprll5l1 of the propelti In quesbon, unless specl'ic aflallV.ments b do
50 hay. tleen mld. beforehand
5 Th. Ipplaiser has esbmlled the valu. 01 the !,lnd In the cost appralch It its hlghest.Jnd best us. lnd ltle improvements Illt1eir contributory VINe lhese
seplIale nlJatWns or fl. land and Improvements musl nol be used in conjunction WIth any other .Jpprlisal ind ire inukd il they are so used
6 The Ipprltser hIS no~ In the IPP'llsal report any Idverse condiUons (such IS, needed replirs, deprecl.ation, the presence 01 hUlfdous WliSleS. tlric
substilnces, e~,) observed dur1no lt1e InspecUon of the subject property 0' Ihil he or she beclma IWlf, 01 during the nOlmal reselrch Inyoh'ed In perfarmino
the apprllSlf UnleSS oltlerwlse slalrd In the .ppralul report lhe ippriiser has no knowledge 01 lny hidden or unlpplrent conditions 01 !he proper1y Of
.dyelSlJ environmental conditions (Inelud1no th. presence 01 hlurdous wastes, tllic substances, elc ) th.1 would make the properly mOle 01 less nluabc, lnd
hIS ISSUmed lhlt there are no such condl1Jons and mlkes no guarlntees 0' wlulnbes. express or Impled, .eqardlno the condlbon 01 the properly ,he
Ippraiur wi. not be responsible 'or Iny such conditions lhl' do elist Of far loy engineering or mUng thlt might be required ~ discoyer whlrtle' such
cONSilons exist Recluse the Ipprllser Is nol In expert in the lield of envi,onmental hUllds. the apprlisal fepor1 must nol be considered IS ln
I!!nvlronmentillusessmenlof the propertt
7 The appuisl!!f obtained the informlUon, esUmlm, Ind op!nlons thil we;e elprlSsed in lhe iPprliSlI repor1 110m sources Ih,al he or she considers ~ be
reliiblll Ind beleYes !hem tl be true and coned The apprll,.r does not lSSUlOe rlSponslbi~ty lor eM! accuracy of such illlms Ihat were lurRlshed by olher
PI""
8 The Ippralser wil not disclose the contents or !he lpprli5l1 report ucepl 15 provided lor In lie Uniform Stand,ards of PfOlesslOnll Apprllul PrlCbee
9 The apPlalse, hIS biSed his or her apprllul report Ind uluaoon concklSlon lor ln .Ipprllul lilt is subject ID SlbsllclOry completion, "pillS. or
IltellltOns an !he JSsumplon It1lt completon or Ihe Improvements WI' b. pet10llned in I worllmanike minnef
10 The ippriiser must provide his 01 her plior written consenl belare lt1e Ier.Jer/c~I" specified In the apPfllul tepOr1 can distribute lt1e IPP'ilsal repor1
t1nc~djno conclusions .boUI lilt plOper1y ullJe. the lpPIi1iser's klentil'f Ind p;o:esslonll desiqnlbons, lnd relefences b loy prolesslOnll .JppralSiI
o:.QlnilllJons or !he fi,m wilh whK:h th. lpprllser Is lssocl.1led) 10 Inyone olin ~.n Itle banow.,; !he mortolgee or ils successors .Ind Ission5. the martjJQe
InSUler. consulbnts; professionll IPP'llul orl;llnlllUons; lny sf.1te or farlen', lpproved Ilnlnelll lnSbl1Jbon; or Iny depar1menl loency, 0' inslrum.ntJkl'f
01 the United Sl.Jtes or iny stile 01 110 DistriCt 01 Columbli; except lh..llh. il!!nder/Cbent may diSlrlbute lt1e p,operty descflptlon secDon of lhe report on~ to dlQ
colection or repor1:lng slJ~lCe(s) witr'lout hlYino " obf.1in l1e lpplliSer', priOr wrilten consent The Ipprliser" wflttl!n consent and IpproViI must .150
be obtained belo'e !he apptJlul Cln be conveyed by Inyone b the pubic lhrouQh .Jdvertlsing. public: re!,lbons, news, ules, 01 ohl medlt
Ifeddre MiC 10fm 439 6.93
P'Q' I 0'2
fanm. Mie FOlm 100486-93
fOfm ACR -. -TOfAl2000- .Ppr011511 soflwife b, il.l mod.. Ine
1.800.AlAMom
\ . ' ..
,
.
.
"
.
APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION: IhI AppII~OI cor1llies Ind Igr...ttut
I 1 hlVI r"",chld I1IlUbjec:1 ml/kel 1/" Ind hlVI ..1oc:1ed I minimum alth'.. ,occnl llleI 01 propor1l.. mo.t Ilml~r Ind p'o~moll tlth. IUbjec:t p,op.rly
10' can.IdOlollon In 111 llleI compl/I.on Ino~ll. Ind hlVI mid. 0 dolllr IdlUlbn.nl wh.n Ipprap'lolII tl ,,1Ioc111l ml/k.t ,...lIon tl tho.. IlIIm. 01 lignll~lnt
,"lll1on II I 'i!lnllltlnlllllm In I compl/lbll p,op.rly I. IUp"Io' tl. a' mo" 1IY0llblo thin, th. lubleel p,op.rly. 1 h... mod. I naglbv. Idlu.tment tl reduc.
I1IldlUlIIId ..lei P'~' all1lcomplllbllllnd. II 0 .lgnll~lnlllllm In I camplI.blll p,operly ~ Inl"Io, tl. a,leIl IlYoroblllthon the .ubjec:1 plOperly. I h... mid.
I po.lbv.,dlullmtnl tl l..."...th. Id/ullIId ..lei prlt. oll1lcompl/lbll
2 I hlVI liken Into con.IdOllbon the IlCtl" thll h... In ImplCl on YI~' In my d"'lopm.nl 01 "" ..bmllll 01 mllk.1 YI~' In th. IppII"ol "port I h... not
knowllllJ~ withhold Ooy .ignllltlnllnlormlllon I,om th. IppIII.., "port Ind I b.M"e. 10 th. b.., 01 my knowlodg.. thll 01 'lIlem.nts ond InlOlmlllon In ""
Jpprllsll report aft trUIlnd correel
J I .1I1ed In I1IlppIIIIII "po"an~ my own p."ono\ unblued. Ind p,ol...lonlllnoly.I.. opinion.. Ind conclu.lon.. which "' .ublecl on~ tll1l cOnlllllJ.nl
,nd 1mI1ll1J cOndlllont Ipeclfled In thlllolm
4 1 h", no p,...nt a, prolpeebv. Inlllr..t In th. propOlIy thll II th. IUblecl m thl. ,.port Ind I hm no p,...nl ar p,o'pecbv. p.rsonlllnle,..1 ar bill with
r..pecl tl "" Plr1lclp.nls In 111 b.nmllon I did nol b.... .lthOl P'rDllty ar complllllly. my In.~sl. Ind/or the ..bm.Ie 01 mllk.1 VlIu. In th. ,ppIIIIII "pOll
on "" IICI. calli'. ".glon. ,,~ h.ndle.p. I.mllll llIbil. 01 n.lon,'a,igln 01 .Ith" the prospecbv. ow",,, or oceup.nls alth. Iublect prop.rly or olth. pr...nl
awn... 0' ..cup.nts all1l p,op.rD..ln th. 'ltlnlly al "" lublect p,op.rty
5 III.VI no pr...nt a, conlllmp~1ed IUbi" Inle,..t In th. lublecl p,op.rty. .nd n.lth.r my cun.nt or lubi" .mploym.nt nor my comp.n..bon lor p'lIormln<j thl.
Ipprallll ~ conblllJ.nt an I1IlppIII.ed ..~. olth. p,ap"ly.
II 1 WII nol requl'ed tl "porI. p'ed.III,mlned ..Iu. 01 dlrecbon In ..Iu. th.t 11Y0" the C1U" alth. cN.nl or ony "~Ied Plrty. th. .mounl olth. ..Iu. ..bmolo.
Ile Ittillnmenl 01 01 Ipeclllc ,"un. or !tit occurrence of 01 subsequent e'lent In order 10 recetve my compenuUon andlor employmenllor per1ormino the IPP111511
did not b... "" IppIIIIII "pOll on l,eqU..1ed minimum "~llon. . .peelllt ..Iu.bon. or the n.ed m .ppro.. I .pecllle mOr1Q.g. lII.n
7 I p,,'ormed thll ,ppIII..lln conlormlly with 111 Unllo'm SlIndlld. 01 P,of...lonol AppIIIIII PrICbCl th.t w". .dopled ond p,omui!l.1ed by th. AppIII..1
SlIndlld. BOl/d 01 Ih. AppIIIIII found. Ion ond thll w". In p~CI II olth. .II..bv. do" olthl, ,pp"IIII, with th. ",epbon olth. d.p.rtu" pra,l.lon 01 tho..
SlIndlld.. whleh do.. not .pp~ IlCknowlodge th.t on ..Imole 01 0 "...n.bll bm. lor expo,"" In th. op.n ml/kell, 0 condlbon In the dellnlbon 01 ml/k.t VI~e
.nd "" ..11",,11 I d".IIIPed I. con,I,lIInl with "" ml/k.llng 11m. noled In th. neighborhood s..bon al this "port unlesl I hIV. oth.rwll. llIled In ""
reconclhllon secUOn.
B 1 hm p".on.1y In'peeled th. Inlll,lo' ond el1e,lOI I/U' olth. sub/eel p'operty .nd th. .mllor 01 .1 p,op"lIes N'1ed u compl/oblos In Ih. Ipprallll "port
Ilullh" celllly th.11 h'" noled 'OY .ppo"nl ar known od,,,.. condllon. In Ih. lubjocllmp,ovemenls. an Ih. sub/eel ,lie. ur on .ny silll wilhin "" Immedillll
'lelnl~ al "" lubleel p,op"ly 01 which 11m oWl/e .nd h.VI m.d. od/usbn.nls lor Ihe.. od,"" condilons In my .nl~sls ollh. p'operly ..Iu. tlth. eIlenl Ihol
I hid ml/k.1 "idence tl ,uPpolllhem. 1 h... olio camm.nled .boul th. elleel ollh. Id..rse candilons on th. ml/k.llbiily ollh. subjecl property
9 I personally preplIed II conclusions and opinions about the real cstata tint were set forth In the appraiul report If I relied on slonlllcant professional
1551'".... lrom 'OY IndlYldUlI ar IndlYldu.~ In Ihe P'lIormonce ollh. Ipplll5l1 or Ih. prepmUon 01 the .pp"llIl "port I ho.. n.med such IndlYldu.lls) ond
dllclll.ed "" Ipeclf", IIsks performed by Ih.m In Ih. reeonclM.llon ...Uon allhls .ppralsl' report I c"lIly 1h.1 'OY IndIYldUlI sa nomed I' qUlklled tl perform
I1Il1sks I h... nollulha,lIed loyon. tl mok. 0 ch.ng. m 'OY IlIIm In Ih. ,eport Ih"eto". II .n un..thorlled ch.ng. Is m.d. III Ih. opp,,15I1 "port I wil Ilk.
no lesponslblily la, II
SUPERVISORY APPRAISER'S CERTIFICATION: "0 sup.rvlsory applllser signed the opp,,11I1 "port he or Ih. ",Ulies .nd .g'''' Ih.t
I dlrectt supe~lse the appraiser who prepared the appraisal report have reviewed the appralul report agree with the statements and conclusIons of the appraiser,
Ig'" tl b. bound by I1Ilpplllse", cellllle.llons numb".d 4th,ough 7 .bove. .nd .m liking luB ,..ponslblhly lor 1h"pPllI5l1 ond Ih. oppll15l1 "port
ADDRESS OF PROPERTY APPRAISED: __R..ll-,U._fa.oIl~_H?ll,~J~()a(;UI]'<liQt.1'i'U79IJP__~ _ _ .~
SUPERVISORY APPRAISER (only If required):
APPRA~ '
Slgn.bi" tMJ,J"L,=--f{/ P1.eU--~- ______ ___.___
Nlme L3uren:-e W. Brcx:lisch
O.IeSig;;"':--------Mill:h 6:1998-m_-
SIIIIICor1Illt.tIon#: c:;p.-000869-L
or S~tIl Uc:ense,: _.~_____
SIIIe _______~1\___ --------:~=-.:-_==
EJjl~'lIOn 0111I 01 Cor1Ille.lIon a' Llcen..:
Slgn.bire _~ ______.m _.____m ____ _n _ .__.n_.__.
N.Jrne
Dole Signed
SIIIe CellllltoUan" ._ .__._________m_____m___~______
or SIIIII Ucen.. '" _n _______.
SIIIe ___________ __._.... _.__
flpl"ban 0'1e 01 C.llllle.ban or Ucen..
G-30_.9lL..._____
DOrd
[j O,~ Nolln'pecl Praperly
LW, Brodloch Real Eolol.
fredd~ M.. fOlm 439 8-93
Plge 2 al2
fOMII MI. fann ll104B 8-93
fo,mACR .. 'fOlAL 2OO0'lpp"llIl ,a""." by oil mode loe .. I.BOO.ALAMOOE
,
"
,,1
:)
,
~
s~ i ~~~:
p..~
i~ ~ '"
... .. '" /:l ..> ~
... ~ U~i2;! ;
..... lol g
U~ "'.. ..., '" <I~~I-
S~ '" Cl &'i
~fS I-< III
el~ alj..i i: ~~ !:
~8 Ill.... zg !:
"" lil""' "'l'l
'" lil i _ 0040
8~ '" ~ ~~ilj
'" .
I ... .
... ~
'" I ~
;~ . ~
III U
~ .> Z
., 0 H
i
,
i
I
I
,::..1
. .
. . . ..
.
/l...u... \ ..f ?( ~/"7- ~0
('U~
JOANNE E, ROBERTS.
PlaIntiff
v.
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN TilE COURT O~' COHHON PJ.EAS
DAUPIIIN COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994
IN DIVORCE
INCOME AND EXPENSE STATEMENT OF
RONALD L. ROBERTS
INCOME
Commonwealth of PA
Harrisburll. PA
Employer I
Address I RiversIde Office Comnlex
Type of Work I Haintenance Renal r
Payroll Number:
Pay periodl Rf-'tAw.ly
Gross Pay per Pay penod 1777 ~o
ITEMIZED PAYROLL DEDUCTIONS:
Federal Withholding
Social Security
Local Wage Tax
State Income Tax
Retirement
Medicare portion/fICA
Credit Union
Life Insurance
Health Insurance
Other (specify) spousal
support
Net pay per pay periodl
Other Income I
Interest
Dividends
Pension
Annuity
Social Security
Rents
Royalties
Expense Accounts
Gifts
Unemployment Compo
Workmen's Compo
70fl.C)} + lj.OO
82.31
13.28
37.17
36.64
19.25
10.00
118.17
77 8.86
Week
Month
Year
Insurance
Company
Policy No.
H W J
Hospi ~al
Blue Cross ~tone Health Plan lIMO HC140650
Other
x x x
Medical
Blue Shield
Other
Health/Accident
Disability Income
Keystone Health Plan
IDl0 HC 140650
x x x
---
---
---
Dental
---
I verify that the Statements made in this Income and Expense
Statement are
true and correct,
I understand that false
statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 18 Pa,C.S,
section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities,
Date: ~I JAleo
Q..
ClA~
Ronald L. KODerts
, (I l- ~t I~ I. ' '~.' . .
\, .
\
Po', "..7
II.... n.. if'"
.
I(-
,. II \..'. 'r.1 ,"..l I . .- 10. ........:... 4 ./ n. ~
CQ""QNWEALT~ Of PA - E"PLOYE STATE"ENT
"" '111" rlDI.':
v" I 'tttOlQtOdOO
,w,; &tU.. 'HI:
IfU: AI 'n lue"
1IUWI"'CMlhllltM
O' 11 00 .U GUlf ".u..oo
01111: OCUI ax: 01*
10??oo ioU. 106 >> un
0' UEPt 10 uwn I 00
na/'t'W'l "oat... "'W'
". "" .... ... n. .... YO ....
GltHI CA...IK" ',.2".10 ....... M
MI.u, OloutIIO.' .
flO II" 11 , .. lfa." a,nO.Of
Igc ue u . . ~ 0000'I .,.11 9Ol.n
lor: 1t""1eI U I . tfOOO'\ ".J. 2M'" I>~
IfU, ...." n " , .1_ 11.1' " .n v
\1( .. '1-1" .. .. tot 1.- 11.11 I"',"
liT 'IU CUI lUll I'" i.OO*", :M." "01." .
"'" OIlOEA-PA CUOIIRlllO CO - DOO RIL UI.1l 1."','1
UIIwtl ,tltIlt .. 11 ItU 14." ,.I.U
n, Iftlf ?I-ADD f.OO 11.00
'1IIDI' U. .. " 111I' CU 10.00 110.00
RUN.ll.D l. IO.IITS
'00 WICH 'T,. APT 1
w'~1 'aIIVr,W PA 1102&
._~-'.~'l_',~l!.!!~'!!!~__..._._."" ____ ~"'4_'
~'ITM "1"'" .,"IaM' ~1'ltH .. Clll.~
..M Mia 1IlK' ." ,.. III I. "OG IRI'"
u" III...lI<<'
,__UI CGKr
Helll. UWIIII'
Muua.,
anlllAn' nUl 1"""O'l'U Itl no"
._-;....__.....
_11 I&.MII"I
"'U1 IlIMlUlllMEMn
n....
1".00
100,0.
'.11
..."
1'.11
1',"
II."
.v'"' "... r..u ........
'110 "IVI .un....'
't.~ICI '.IDI1; J& V.
""LiAYiUiiili"ii,oeiJiii
.
.''I'..lif
l",lL !H'" ..IIIT .
"....
,..
.. I"
o..JI"CIIJ
''''-''-1--'
--;: ". ,.. . ",~!,,!~~~!"'~"""I
un
.uu.u
11.DO Of~ll~ 1(0 II~
".00
n.l0
-~~
1.UJ.,a
,,''''1 .crt_1ft
.-
'IICII' .
':'~"" .~,
,. :, ....AL IW'.,,'. Wluci- ''<<1 ,.Y
. ~_" Il.J.~~. ~.ft_"I~,_.._
,
_.~
1,J21.10
aa&MCI un ITAU"11fT JII." l,Otl.n 11.00 GI.I....L .000,~y 11.11. CIIDU Q,AU
.r:r.tIUI nfls " 1.to J.U ,00
LV .fltOlIlU Ihll P' \I.GO ,00 .ClO I", _ILllA.,. 0.... 0 nUll DA"
~f1I(.n .00.00.00 CUDlT DAti 0'5' 12 0(1
...*1 'HIS 11trt JJ'.OO J.OM." 11.00
,.oct,lllll'Un, ........ lid ll'iluC::]'.1l ji-.'""",;,.:
- -.-. ,...- ~. --
",'SAGI c,.,t't LOCjL MAle T" CaulTY~IC1'ALlfYl cu.er.,'.D COU~lY ,,'1 p,..,.o.o 1Mf.
COInlS 01 'If LUIILI": 1I3.ft 'NT TU, 010'" 1.1t0.,.
.: '
PtNNSYLV ANIA ST.\ Tt POLlCt APPLlCA lIONS
Th. Pennsylvania s..t. Police Is ""Ptllli IPJIli<..iolll for S~t. Pollee CadotulrOUih lun. 1~.1.000. Visit
)~ 10<&1 PCMSylvu". Sw. Police iIulaIl.t1o~ 10 obt.in 11\ .pplicllrion or canllel oW" loll. free .prlle....t
hothne number II 1-I77.PACADET. To Iwn mora: .boutlhis ..elrins oppol1\llllty to join a lead., in I...
enforcement and tu obtlU1llistlna or Slale Polic. f"I1:Nh:en. vii it our wcbsitc &c www 011I0, UIIue I.,. UI
Info"" you, frlen4, III1d relllJive, .boIlI oW' C\\ITenl appliellion pellod to become I PoMSylvlni. Sm.
Troope,. Women and Ininorltlu an: 'lr""i1y .ncOU1l&cd 10 apply. Th. Pennsylvania Sta.. Police is
1<<,.4il.4 by the ~nmmiSlion on ".-a-ediration for Law Enfort,mcn, AitTIciu, Inc.
;
i
I/lM
! ~,e~ ee~ L ~L
<. eILI;OU~L
!L;:S o. Le-;
!100NN3d :A8 lN39
. .
'-
ORDERlNOTlCE TO WITHHOLD INCOME FOI\.SUPPORT
Vlcr ')7.nJ';C,V
Slate Commonwealth of Penn..lvan;a . (;) '11 Ji ,I,) "I 0
Co.lCity/Disl. of CUMBERLAND 1.10
Dale of Order/Notice 08/01/00 .:)f_l. 7 ZhJ
Court/Case Number (See Add..ndum lor Cdse SUmmdry)
Ot1m11ll.ilC1rli,'r/N"IIlI'
@ ..../Il'.ndl'll t Irdl'r:Noht l'
o Tl'fnunollt. (Ird",/Nullll'
Em"lo~','r^Vllhhuld"f'" h.d",..1 fIN Numl.'f
COMMONWEALTH OF PA
Eml,lclyt.,I\Vllhh.JI.h','" NJnll'
C/O PAYROLL OPERATIONS
Emp1tl't'I'rl\Vilhhclllll"" Alliin.....
PO BOX 8006
HARRISBURG PA 11105-8006
iRfROBERTS, RONALD L.
Emplll'tI'I.}(Hilijotlu'.. N..If1W 't....t, fj""l, Mi,
206-32-2353
E Jj\I~Il't'I"./(lhIiJotur'.. 'Ult r..1 ~I.t unl't' Numb"
&623100024
Emph''t'I'''/( lhllWI'" ('.I'" hl4'nlllh"
(SH Addfndum (0/ pI..;nliff n4m,s tluori.."d wUh r41PS on .".chm.nl)
{u..lodi..1 PJn'nl'" N.Jnlt' ,lol..t, Flr..t, .\.111
Se.. Addendum lor d..p..nd..nt ndm..s dnd birfh ddt..S dssocidt..d with CdS"S on dttdchm..nt.
ORDER INFORMA TlON: This is an Order/Notice to Withhold Income for Support based upon an order for support
from CUMBERLAND Counly, Commonwealth ot Pennsylvania. By law. you are required to deduct these
amounts (rom the above-named employee's!obligor's income until further notice ..ven if the Order/Notice is not
issued by your State.
S 256.80 per month," current support
S 0.00 per month in past-due support Arrears 12 weeks or greater/ Oyes @ no
S 0.00 per month in medical support
S 0 00 per month for g..netic test costs
S per monlh in other (specify)
for a total of $ 256.80 per monlh to be forwarded to payee below.
You do not have to vary your pay cycle to be in compliance wilh the support order. If your pay cycle does not match
the ordered support payment cycle. use the following to delermine how much to withhold:
S 59.26 per weekly pay period.
S 118.52 per biweekly pay period (every two weeks!.
S 128 40 per semimonthly pay period Itwice a month).
S 256.80 per monthly pay period.
REMIHANCE INFORMA TlON:
You must begin withholding no laler than the first pay period occurring ten (10) working days after the date of this
Order/Notice. Send payment within seven (7) working days of the paydate/date of withholding. You are entitled to
dedud a fee to defray the cost of withholding. Reier to the laws governing the work state of your employee for the
the allowable amounl. The tolal withheld amount, and your iee, cannot exceed 55% of th.. employee's! obligor's
aggregate disposable weekly earnings. For the purpose of the limitation on withholding, the following information is
needed ISee #9 on pg. 2!.
If remining by EFT/EDI. please call Pennsylvania State Colleoions and Disbursement Unit (SCOU) Employer
Customer Service at 1.677-676-9560 for instructions.
Make Remittance Payable to: PA SCDU
Send check to: Pennsylvania SCDU, P.O. 80x 69112, Harrisburg, Pa 17106-9112
IN ADDITION, PA YMENTS MUST INCLUDE THE DEfENDANT'S NAME AND THE PACSES MEMBER /D (shown
above as th.. Employ..../Obligor's CdS.. Id..n/;Ii..r) OR SOCIAL SECURITY NUMBER IN ORDER TO BE PROCESSED.
DO NOT SEND CASH BY MML.
BY THE COURT:
Date oi Order;
A1@Ist 6, 2000
000: Roo!. Sha.i:I.ly
xc: Def en:Iant
Service Type M
"\tfl'..,
I ,~
Ju:Ige
Forrn EN-02B
Worker 10 $IATT
i 'j'''~P'' " i '.,j,', I':' ',' '. '
~
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO EMPLOYERS AND OTHER WITHHOLDERS
o If, tH'( kt'd YIIlI .In- ft'qulIl-'d Ii I pn I'o'ld.. .1 I fillY Ilf llll~ 1111111 III YIIlU "llIplr ''1'''1'
Pflonly: \VilhholdlllH Ulld,', Ihl' Ofllt'r/Noli,,' 11.1\ fHlflflly 0\'1" ,lilY fJlh,., 11,~.11 prill I'"'' IIl1d,-, SI,llt.I.lw .IH.lill'l' lilt, \Jflll' in( 11111....
fl-'d..rJI tJll, 1I-'vit"'l ill ..fft'c t Ilt'forl-' 'PI ,.ipt ()f rhi... IHllt-, IhIVI< prlllrity If 111...,... .HI' rlollt-,.II l.ll!; It'vi,', III pUt', t pi.....",. (OIl1.JI t 11u' It'qlJlH,liIlH
J).;l-'1l1 Y li.."..d l-wIIIW
2 (lllllhlllill).\ PJynl....lIh: Villi t.m I fllllhilH' wilhlwld JllIllulI1.. frfllll IlHHt' Ih.iIIllllt' ,.l1lplllyt.t'/fJbliJ.;or.... illt Olll" ill J liinMI.. pJynlt'1l1
10"'.11 h .JMt'IH Y '..qlll-....tll1K wilhhflldill}.t YIlU 111m!. hrlwl'w'" WpJf.lh.ly idt'nllfy Illt-. portion flf lilt' ...iIlMI.> p.lynwllIlhJI i.. dflrihut..hl.. to
t'.H h t'mploYt'I'hlhli,.;ur.
J.. R"portinR tnt'" P.tyd.m-JO.Jh* of WithholdinN: You mu,t ""Plrt Ih", pdydJt..JdJtt" nf withhold inN wh..n ,,.ndinM th", J'dym..nt. Th..
payddh'"Jdah* of wirhhnfdinM j, Ihf'O dJtt" nn whit-h Jmount W.1' wirhh",ld from Ih", ",mploy",,",', W.:I';"'. You 11111\1 ( rllllply wilh Ih~ l.1w of Ilu>
\t..lt~ o( lhl'" t'mplllYt"e'vohli,.;or'\ prine ip.ll pl.H" o( t>ll1ploynwnt wirh U'\p..t 110 Ihl'" limt> pt>rill(h wilhin whi( h you mu\I hnpl..nuol1l Ih..
wlrhholdil1K ordt'r .md forw..ud fhl'" \upport p.1Ynlt'III\.
4.. Employt't'JOhIiKor with Multiplt' Support Hllldil1Kli: If (Ilt'rt~ i\ mort> Ih.m ont' Ordt'r/Nrllitt> h. \Vilhhord hUOIn.. (or SUPflIlrt
JKJinolil thioli ~mpIIJYI-'t'JGhlj,.;or Jlld you Jrt> UIlJhlt' 10 honor .111 "iUpport Ordt'r/Noli( t'''i dut' 10 F.-dpr.11 or StJtp wilhhuldinR lindh, yuu IllU\.
follow rht' IdW of lh~ 'it.1rtl of Pl11ploYt't'\/uhliKfJr'oli prindpJI pl.1I ~ of "l1lploynwlIl. YOllI11U\1 honor .Ill Ord..rvNoli(..\ 10 Ih.. W"JIt''i1
t'xtt'IH pcl\\ihl... (51"'1-' #9 htolowl
i. rt>rmil1Jli(JI1 Nlllific .ltiClll: YCIU I1lU\t pflJll1prly I1cllity Ih.. R"qu..\lin~ AR..n( y wh..nlll.. ..mplrly....JcJhliWJr i\ IH' IClllKPr .......(ukinK (rlr
you. PIt'Jst> providt' Ihe inforlllJtion rt'qut>\lt'd Jl\d rt"lurn J (Opy uf Ihi.. Ord~r/Nlllil t" 10 rht' ^Ht'm)' id,mfifi..d 1lt'luw.
WITHHOLDER'S 10: 232172H'O
EMPLOYEE'S/OBLlGOR'S NAME: ROBERTS, RONALD L.
EMPLOYEE'S CASE IDENTIFIER: 6623100024 DATE OF SEPARATION:
LAST KNOWN HOME ADDRESS:
NEW EMPLOYER'S NAME/ADDRESS:
6. lump Sum P.lym~l1ts: You O101Y ~ rl-!quirt'd to rt"porl Jnd withhold froll1lump 'iUI11 pJymenl'i surh J'i hcmu"i""i, c-ollln1i\'iioll'i, or
~t'\'t>r.llll t" poly. If you hJvt' .IllY qUt'\liol1\ dhout lump \UI1I pJYI11t"I1I\, (Onl.11 t lh.. PfOf\OI1 or Julhority 1lt"lmv.
7. liJhility: If you f.lil to withhold inc lllllt" .1\ Iht' Ordt>r/Notic t" dir..,"', you Jrt' liJhlt" (or hulh lilt' .It (Ullluldlt'd oIl11f1unt you should
hdve wilhht>ld frum the employ....JobliWn's inromt' dnd olllt'r pHI1Jltit'\ \1"1 hy Pt>l\mylvJniJ Stdle l.1w. Pt'I1I\\ylvolniJ StJlt' IJW govt'fln
unl..olis Iht'! uhliJ{ur is employed in .lnolht!r SI.1le, in whic h CJ\t' the IJW of Iht' SIJlt' in which hI" rJr \he i\ t'mproYt'd wwerm.
8. Anli-dis( rimin.1tion: You .Ire SUhjt'lllll .1 (jilt' dt'!tt'rmint"d undt"r St.llt' IJW for disc h.Jrging .111 t'l11proyt't'JuhligOf (rom
t>mploymt'I1I, refusing to employ, or tJkil1K di\ciplil1JrY Jrlion .lH.1inst Jny t'!l1lpllly..../ohIiKor ht'c-.lll\t' of .I supporl withholding.
PellluylvJnid Stolte IdW governs unlt~soli Ihe ohligor is ..mployed in Jnotht>r StJlt', in whil h f.l\t' the IJW of lhe Stolle in which he or she is
emploYt'd WWP.rIls.
9.. Withholdillg limits: You m.lY nol wilhhold mOff' IhJIl I"" I..\\..r 0(: lllh.. JIlUlunlo; ..lIowt>d hy Ihe Ft"dt'rdl Consumt>r C(f'!dit
Prolenion Art (15 U.S.c. ~ 167 J (h)l; or 21 lht' .Jn1Ollllls .llIowt'd hy lilt" SIJtt' of tht' t'n1ploYt't"'i/ohliKOf''i prinripdl pldfe of employment.
Th.. Fedt'rdllilllil Jpplit'\ 1(1 th.. .1AArt"Kdl.. di\fXI\.1hlt> wt"..kly t"JrninR\ (AOWE). AOWE i\ Iht' nt'1 ill((IIllt" l..fl.Jftt>r lll.lkinH IUJndJt()ry
dt>durtiora \Ul h .1\; Stoltt-!, Ft->d..r.1l, I~Jrdll.lxt"\; SlIriJI Sf>l wily 'dXf<o;; Jnd M..dirJrt' IJxt>s.
10
.NOTE: If you or your agent are served wilh a copy of this order in the state Ihat issued Ihe order, you arc 10 follow Ihe
law of Ihe slale thai issued this order with respect 10 these Ilems.
Requesting Agency:
DOMESTIC RElATIONS SECTION
P 0 BOX 320
CARLISLE PA 17013
If you or your employee/obligor have any questions,
contact WAGE ATTACHMENT UNIT
by telephone at (717) 240-6225 or
by FAX at (717) 240-6248 or
by lnternel @
Page 2 of 2
Form EN-028
Worker ID $IATT
Service Type M
('\H'''.. "","U_1I1H
1'1';"1;.,,,1:..1<-1:'\1';'<1
.... r=
fc.
;:~: :~
-.,
" , oJ r-J~
(1: - -"
y-,
~. : ' ,,- :.:f.;
/;. "-")-::~
......
., ., (/1
)z
L"; l:Z
" LlIU
~ i~f]U..
.<
IL a :J
L' CJ <.J
/
.
SNELlIAKER. BRENNEMAN 8 SPARE
.... '....UI."IUN^l r ORrdll^ll_ l~j
ATTORNEYS Ar LAW
401 \1Vf-ST MAIN ~rkEEr
MECHANICSBURG. PENNSYLVANIA 17055
Itll IlAlIl1 I "'NIl.AMP.
JIHIl II IUHNHU"MN
NIII'" II \liAR'
1I7.60/.852t1
POBOX .JIM
fAC)IMlLf (.1m 69.1./681
July 7, 2000
l!. Robert Elicker, II, Esquire
Office of the Divorce Master
9 North Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Re: Roberts v. Roberts
No. 97-5994
Dear Mr. Elicker:
Enclosed please find Plaintiff's Pretrial Statement Pursuant to Pa.R.C.P. 1920.33(b)
rellardinllthe above mailer.
YOU~IY,
l(f011He-t----
Keith O. Brenneman
KOB/sz
Enclosure
:J
"
SNELBAKER. BRENNEMAN 8 SPARE
^ rIlOfl-'~ION^l COllrOllAtloN
ATTORNEYS AT LAW
44 Wf.3,T M^IN ~TREET
MECHANICS8URC. PENNSYLVANIA 17055
RKtMRD C ~NEl~KER
KflTH 0 ftRENNEMAN
PHILIP H !IPAAE
lV-607.852t1
p, O. BOX JUt
fACSIMILE Clln 601.1681
July 18, 2000
E. Robert Elicker, 11
Divorce Master
9 North Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA \7013
Re: Roberts v. Roberts
No. 97-5994
Dear Mr. Elicker:
I just received this date the Notice of Pre-Hearing Conference with respect to the above
case scheduling a conference for October 16,2000 at 9:30 a.m. at your office.
Unfortunately, I have a conflict in that I am scheduled to select a jury for a trial in Perry
County beginning at 8:30 a.m. on that same date. Accordingly, I would kindly request that the
Pre-Hearing Conference be rescheduled.
Keith O. Brenneman
KOB/sz
CC: Judith Calkin. Esquire
J U D I T II A. C A L KIN
ATTORNEY-AT-LAW
2201 NORTII SECOND STREET
HARRISBURG, PENNSYLVANIA 17110
(717) 238-2312
FAX (717) 233-2342
July 24, 2000
E, Robert Elicker, II
Divorce Master
9 North Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Re: Roberts v. Roberts
97-5994
Dear Mr. Elicker:
This letter is in response to Attorney Brenneman's letter
requesting that the pre-trial in this matter be rescheduled. I do
not object if the rescheduling is before October 16, 2000 or very
shortly thereafter. These parties have been separated for well
over two years. I was held up in filing our Inventory and
Appraisal because Mr. Brennerman's client did not file her answer
to interrogatories for over a year and then not until a contempt
petition was filed.
Thank you for your kind consideration.
Very truly ~
cc: Keith Brenneman, Esquire
Ron Roberts
DR 27.2JO
Pacses# 418100010
JOANNE E ROBERTS
PLAINTIFF/PETITIONER
IN HIE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
DEFENDANT/RESPONDENT:
NO. 97- 5994 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COllRT
AND NOW. this Jl!h. day of Februarv. 1997. based upon the Court's determination that
Petitioner's monthly net incomr. is $ 1112.00 per month and Respondent's monthly net income is
$ 1754.00 per month. it is hereby Ordered that the Respondent pay to the: Domestic Relations
Section, Court of Common Pleas, $ 278.5J ($25680 support and $21.7J on arrearsl a month payable
$ 118. 18 bi-weekly as alimony pendente lite, elfective 12/08/97. Defendant is \liven credit in the
amount of$144.89 lor direct payment Arrears set at $ 625 51 as of 2/11/98, shall be payable at
$ 21.73 per month First payment due on or belore N/A, and each month thereafter.
Failure to make each payment on time and in full will cause all arrears to become subject to
immediate collection by all of the means as provided by 2J Pa.C.S.~ J70J. Further, if the Court finds,
after hearing, that the Respondent has willlully failed to comply with this Order, it may declare the
Respondent in civil contempt of Court and its discretion make an appropriate Order, including. but not
limited to. commitment of the Respondent to prison for a period not to exceed six months.
Payments must be made by cash, check or money order. Cash payments must be made in
person. All checks and money orders must be made payable to Domestic Relations Section and
delivered or mailed to Domestic Relations Section. I J North Hanover Street. P.O Box J20, Carlisle.
Pennsylvania, 17013. Each payment must bel\r your Domestic Relations number (Pasces#
4 I 81000 10) in order to be processed.
Respondent is responsible for service fees of 26.00 to be paid within N/A as determined by
the Domestic Relations Section.
~.- r", r.:
. ,~ '":
"
f".: .r:
l.1.:: C;) , '.
f ) , .
'L '-
'.
(?: .' 0
r:, C:, : ',,:,
Ill' -~
" r' "Jt'Lj
i....: ~
i L~ !~~
u... ::5
II. <r:
u Uf U
\
In the Court of Common Pleas of CUMBERUND County, Pennsylvania
DOMESTIC RELATIONS SECTION
Defendant Name: RONALD L. ROBERTS
Member ID Number: 6623100024 b~:J. 7.130
Plt&Jl' nolr: .\U corrnpoodL'IIcr mUllllnclude &he ~ll1llbfr ID Swnber.
COMMONWEALTH or PA
C/O PAYROLL OPBRATIONS
ATTACHMBNT AND RBSBARCH
PO BOX 8006
HARRISBURG PA 17105-8006-06
ORDER OF ATTACHMENT OF INCOME
F1nandal Break Down or Mulllo1e Cases on AUachment
P1.intifTName
JOANNa I. ROBBRTS
PACSES
Cue Numher
418100010
AUlthmenl ArnnunllFreauencv
S 128.17 /BI-WBBK
S /
S /
S /
S /
Doc:tct
l!!!!!!!!!!
91.5994
TOTAL ATfACHMEi\T AMOL'i\T, S
128.11
To: COMMONWEALTH or PA
Pursuant to the laws of the Commonweal1h of Pennsylvania the income of
RONALD L. ROBERTS , defendant obligor, SSN 20~-32-2353
of:
APT 1, 400 HIGH ST, ENOLA, PA. 17025-3125
is hereby allached to the following e~tent.
You are directed to pay to the Office of the Domestic Relations Sec1ion of the Court of
Common Pleas of
County the sum of $ 128.17
per
CUMBERLAND
BI-WIlEK
from the income due the defendan1 obligor. The allachment payment
must be sent to the Domestic Relations Section within ten days of the date the defendant
obligor is paid.
S.rvi". Type M
Form EN-028
Worker 10 $IATT
RONALD L. ROBERTS
PACSES MOlllho:r NUlllho:r: 6623100024
CHECKS SHOULD BE MADE PAYABLE TO: DOMESTIC RELATIONS SBCTION
AND SENT TO THE DOMESTIC RELATIONS SECTION AT:
P.O. BOX 320, CARLISLE. PA. 17013
This order of allachment for support is binding upon you until further notice and shall have
priori1y over any attachment, execution, garnishment or wage allachment under state or local
law except one relating to a prior support order. You must commence the attachment of the
defendant obligor's income as soon as possible but no later than fourteen days from the date
of the issuance of this Order of Allachmenl.
YOil are n01ified further that pursuant to law:
I. The def~ndant obligor has been notified that an order of attachment for support would
be issued.
2. Willful failure to comply with this order may result in (i) your being adjudged in contempt
of court and committed to jailor fined by the court; (ii) your bebg held liable for any
amount not withheld or withheld but no1 forwarded to the Domestic Relations Section; and
(iii) allachment of your funds or property.
3. The allachment of income or the possibility thereof as a basis, in whole or in pan. for the
discharge of an employee or any disciplinary action against or demotion of an employee Is
prohibited. Violation may result in (i) your being adjudged in contempt and committed to
jailor fined by the court and (ii) an action against you by the employee for damages.
Paso 2 or 4
Form EN-028
Worker 10 $IAn
S<rvic. Typo M
RONALD L. ROBBRTS
PACSES M.mber Number: 6623100024
GENERAL INSTRUCTIONS
1. b.;p!Cy;;is may elect to deduct up to 2% of 1he attachment amount for their costs, This
amount must not be deducted from 1he attachment. It must be paid from the employee's
net earnings after 1he income attachment deduction has been made.
2. Dates monies were withheld from 1he employees' pay must be provided on 1he payment
transmittal fonn to the Domestic Relations Office.
3. If you choose to make payments via an elec1ronic funds transfer, instructions may be
reques1ed from 1he Domes1ic Relations Office,
BY THE COURT:
Date of Order: Februarv 13. 1998
.~
DR()' R.J. Shadday
CCI defendant
Sorvic. Typo M
Pag. 4 of 4
Fonn EN-028
Work.r ID $IATT
~; -!J j d!
Clt >- j L-S
. ~ l - c!i.
III ~... .. j 1
( ,. en .'
f~: ,~, :~ (l ]
t;,. ....;;.: z .J
" -.1
p.o', ,.,., ~ ~
1.-
... .! --'~ J
(L\ (.:~~ .'
; 4, :-."j c:
q. ..... ~ ~ ..- 0
co - . E. <:i.
u "
CJ' 0
"
.'
.
, .
,
In the Court or Common Pleas or CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania
DOMESTIC RELATIONS St:CTION
Defendant Name: RONALD L. ROBERTS
Member ID Number: 6623100024
Pkaae Doltl AU torrapoadml't mWi' kldude the Mnabtr III Numbtr.
COMMONWBALTH or PA
ATTACHMINT AND RESBARCH
PO BOX 8006
HARRISBURG PA 17105-8006-06
A'lENDED
ORDER OF AITACHMENT OF INCOME
Financial Break Down or MulllDJe Cases on Allachment
Pl.inlitrNamc
JOANNB I. ROBIRTS
P^CSES
ClleN'l!!!!!!t
618100010
I>o<k.,
~
91.5994
AlIachmenl AmountlFreouencY
S 118.17 /BI-NBBK
$ /
$ /
$ /
$ /
\)~ a'n3D
TOTAL ATrACIt'IEl\T AMOVNT, $
118.11
To: COHHOllWBALTH 01" PA
Pursuant to the laws of the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania the income of
RONALD L. ROBERTS . defendant obligor, SSN 206-32-2353
of:
APT 1, 400 HIGH ST, ENOLA, PA, 17025-3125
is hereby allached to the following extent.
You are directed to pay to the Office of the Domes1ic Rela1ions Sec1ion of the Court of
Common Pleas of
County the sum of $ 118. 17
per
CUMBERLAND
BI-WEEK
from the income due the defendan1 obligor. The allachment payment
"
must be sent to the Domestic Relations Section within ten days of the date the defendant
obligor is paid.
S.rvico Typo M
Fonn EN-028
Worker 10 $IATT
. ,
RONALD L. ROBERTS
PACSES Member Number: 6623100024
CHECKS SHOULD BE MADE PAYABLE TO: DOMI!STIC RBLATIONS SECTION
AND SENT TO THE DOMESTIC RELATIONS SECTION AT:
P.O. BOX 320, CARLISLE, PA. 17013
This order of allachment for support is binding upon you until further notice and shall have
priority over any allachment, execution, garnishment or wage attachment under state or local
law except one rela1ing to a prior support order. You must commence the allachment of the
defendant obligor's income as soon as possible but no later than fourteen days from the date
of the issuance of this Order of Attachment.
You are notified further that pursuant to law:
I. The defendant obligor has been notified that an order of attachment for support would
be issued.
2. Willful failure to comply with this order may result in (i) your being adjudged in contempt
of court and committed to jailor (med by the court; (ii) your being held liable for any
amount not withheld or withheld but not forwarded to the Domestic Relations Section; and
(iii) attachment of your funds or property.
3. The attachment of income or the possibility thereof as a basis, in whole or in part, for the
discharge of an employee or any disciplinary action against or demotion of an employee Is
prohibited. Violation may result in (i) your being adjudged in contempt and committed to
jailor (med by the court and (ii) an action against you by the employee for damages.
Page 2 of 4
Fonn EN.028
Worker ID $LUT
Service Type M
I-
I
I
,
RONALD L. ROBBRTS
PACSES Mom""r Numboor: 661J1000H
4, If there are in your employment one or more additional employees whose incomes are
subject to the Order of the Coun of Common Pleas of
County
CUMBBRLAND
for attachment of suppon, you may combine the allachment payments into a single
payment to the Domestic Relations Sec1ion and separately identify the ponion a1tribu1able
10 each obligor.
5. You must notify the Domestic Relations SeC1ion when the defendant obligor terminates
employment and provide the Section with the employee's last known address and the name
and address of the new employer, if known.
6. The maximum amount of the allachment shall no1 exceed 50 % of the employee's
net income which is within the limits set in the Consumer Credit Protection Act, IS
V.S.C. U673.
7. The term 'income. a\ defined by law includes compensation for services, including. but
notlimi1ed to, wages, salaries, fees, compensation in kind, commissions and similar
items; income derived from business; gains derived from dealings in property; interest;
rents; royalties, dividends, annuities; income from life insurance and endowment
contracts; all forms of retirement; pensions; income from discharge of indebtedness;
distributive share of partnership gross income; income in respect of a decedent; income
from an interest in an estate or trust; military retirement bene filS; railroad employment
re1irement benefits, social security benefits; temporary and permanent disability benefiU;
worker's compensation and unemployment compensation.
Plao 3 of 4
Form EN~8
Worur 10 $IATT
S.rvice Type M
.... ". (;;
f- Ln
~~
~- ~ '-i .'
Uj~~ ~_. J :-~
~n'. :-r: ,:>:"
Il.o .~' ..~ .-,:1
(5~~-
8\ -"T ;,'f.."'t
~; .%
;1.. '-' .~l5
f.:.:\: l~ : :_; rl..
~ ~
"
I.. (<l -)
L.' <J' U
'.
.JOANNE E. ROBt:RTS
Plailllilf/Pelilillller
IN Tilt: (,OIIRT OF COMMON PLEAS (H'
nlMBERI.ANIl COlINTV, PENNSVLVANIA
VS,
(,[VII. A('TION . DIVORCE
RONALD L. ROBERTS
DeCelldJIIII/Respolldelll
NO. IJ7. ~'J'J~ CIVIL n:RM
IN DIVORCE
DRI/ 27,2JII
PlIue,1/ ~IHIUIlIlIU
ORUF.R 011 COllRT
AND NOW. Ihis l:!!!!. day oC Jamlao:.. !'J'J7. "1'0" cOIISlderalion oClhe allllclied Petitioll for
AlimollY Pelldellte Lile andlor cOIIIISel fees. it is hereby direcled thatlhe parties alld thcir respccti\'c
cOllllselllppcar before RJ. Shadd;!1 011 Febma" II. I'J'JH at 10: .111 a m. for a cOllference. at D N.
Hallo\'er SI.. Carlisle. PA 1711D. aOer which the wllrerellee omeer may' recommelld Ihal an Order for
AlimollY Pelldellle Lile be elllered.
YOU arc rllrther ordered 10 brillg 10 Ihe cOllferellee:
(I) II tOle copy ofyollr mosl recelll Federallllcome Tax Retllrn. inclndillg W-2's as med
(2) yonr pay slnbs Cor Ihe precedmg six II,) months
(.1) Ihc Income alld E.'I'Cnse Statemellt allached to Ihis order. cOlllpleled as reqnired by Rille
!'JIll.1 Jo'
(4) \'erifie,lIioll oC child clIre e.'I'Cnses
(~I proof of medical co\'erage which yon may ha\'e. or may hale a\'ailable 10 you
IF YOII fllillo appcur ror Ihe conference or brillg Ihe reqnired docnlllenls. Ihe Court lIIay issuc II
warmtH for )ollr arrest
BV HIE COURT.
:&t. r E. Shcely. Presi 2:"1 ndge
~. '.I
- ..
. . SI", ay. C ICe ellce Olflcer
YOU IIAVE TIlE RIG liT TO A LAWYER, WIIOE MAY ATTEND TilE (,ON FERENCE AND I'
REPRESENT YOII. IF YOU DO NOT IIAVE A LAWVER OR CANNOT At'FORD ONE, GO T
OR TELEPIIONE TIlE ot'F1CE SET FORTII BELOW TO FIND OIIT WIIERE YOU MA V GET
LEGAL IIELP.
. . d . .~
cc; petitioner UII rcspolldcll!i
cc: Kci~h Brclll,lcman. E.sq. , I'f\C:..~ ~\ N~\\.~
cc: Jlldllh Calk III. Esq. ...-/ I-I \-'l!
Dale oCOrder: lanall" I~. I'J'J"
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
FOURTH FLOOll
CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURT HOUSE
CARLISLE. PENNSYLVANIA I7I1D
(717) HII.(,21111
/
,pO ,-
.-,
"II
(,-
C" I'."' It
.'-.l.! .. t
r .." \'~
."
,\i
cu~,
\~
, :.,
. .
, . ~ >
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN DIVORCE
PETITION FOR ALIMONY PENDENTE LITE
Plaintiff Joanne E. Roberts, by her attorneys, Snelbaker,
Brenneman & Spare, P. C., files this Petition for Alimony
Pendente Lite and in support thereof states the following:
1. On October 29, 1997 Plaintiff initiated this action by
filing a Complaint in Divorce, which Complaint was subsequently
served upon Defendant.
2. In Count III of Plaintiff Divorce Complaint, Plaintiff
requested, inter~, alimony pendente lite.
3. Plaintiff is without sufficient income at that present
time to properly support and maintain herself without
contribution from the Defendant during the pendency of this
action.
4. Defendant has failed to support Plaintiff adequately
since the parties' separation.
LAW O..,.,CEII
SNELBAKER.
BRENNEMAN
a. SPARE
5. Defendant earns, or has an earning capacity which would
generate sufficient income to pay alimony pendente lite to
Plaintiff in this matter.
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff requests this Court to schedule a
conference through the Domestic Relations Office to establish and
require the payment of alimony pendente lite by Defendant to
Plaintiff.
Respectfully SUbmitted,
Date: "~AriErr 8. '''7
SNELBAKER, ~NNEMAN & SPARE, P. C.
By: H~1;t~~~UH- .
Keith o. Brenneman, Esquire
44 W. Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA
(717) 697-8528
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Joanne E. Roberts
17055
LAW O""'CI::I
SNELBAKER.
BRENNEMAN
it SPARE
-2-
VERIFICATION
I verify that the statements made in the foregoing Petition
are true and correct. I understand that false statements herein
are made sUbject to the penalties of 18 Fa. C.S. S 4904 relating
to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Date: /kUJIttftdl ~ I'"
(l".-a-H_L<-€-- ~ K~~
~Joanne E. Roberts
LAW O""IC~.
$NEL.BA.KEA.
BRENNEMAN
6: SPARE
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, KEITH O. BRENNEMAN, ESQUIRE, hereby certify that I have,
on the below date, caused a true and corract copy of the
foregoing Petition to be served upon the person and in the manner
indicated below:
FIRST CLASS MAIL. POSTAGE PREPAID. ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS:
Judith A. Calkin, Esquire
2201 N. Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
/(J
J-k;tWN~~~( ....... ..-.
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN & SPARE, P. C.
44 West Main Street
P. O. Box 318
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
(717) 697-8528
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Date: Qa...OCfC.. lfer..,
LAW O"'ICE&
SNELBAKER.
BRENNEMAN
81: SPARE
/
J U D IT H A. C A L KIN
ATTORNEY-AT-LAW
2201 NORm SU:ONIl SrR[f.f
HARJU.~UIIRlI, P[NNSYLVANIA 17110
(717) 238-2312
FAX (717) 233-2342
June 2, 2000
Robert Slicker, Esquire
Divorce Master
9 North Hanover Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
RE: Roberts v. Roberts
No. 97-5994
Dear Mr. Elicker:
I just wanted to inform you that Discovery has been completed in
the above captioned case.
My Income and Bxpense Statement and Inventory and Appraisement will
be filed next week.
Thank you for your cooperation in this matter.
~e truly yours,
~
udith A. Calkin
JAC/er
cc: Keith Brenneman, Esquire
Ronald Roberts
NOW THEREFORE, the parties, through their attorneys, hereby
stipulate and agree as follows:
1. The preamble of this stipulation above is incorporated
by reference herein.
2. Defendant shall continue to provide medical insurance
coverage for Plaintiff through his employer, the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania. Such coverage shall be provided until anyone of
the following shall first occur: (1) Defendant's termination of
employment with the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania; (2) the
parties' divorce; or (3) written agreement of the parties.
3. All other terms, conditions and requirements of the
Order of February 11, 1998 (erroneously dated February 11, 1997)
shall remain in full force and effect.
4. This stipulation shall be subject to approval by the
Court.
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN &
SPARE, P. C.:
~~
A.~
y:
Keith o. Brenneman, Esquire
44 W. Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
(717) 697-8528
Attorney for Plaintiff
Joanne E. Roberts
th A. Calk re
01 N. Second
arrisburg, PA
(717) 238-2312
Attorney for Defendant
Ronald L. Roberts
ATE: 1t4.~~, ~9'
DATE: ~~ If. I~f'
LAW O"..ICIE:S
SNELDAKEFf.
8RfNNEM.\N
8: SPARE
/
-2-
"
>- ...0 :>-- \l
rr:
~ -
~:. ,~ ,
," ,
~"H :.J
l'.~ : t.:'...
L'r ,
~"I "
\':) ..,
...-" ('-I ! - ,
t..-l,' , .
c j{lj
- ~~ .~Ju.
,-
- .:i
,. (1"!
0 O' U
~
I
.
~.
't.
.
-
.
...
., I
. .
,
~
t' ...
.
, \
.
\
,
.
,
.'-:;-:"~~~
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
Defendant
DR 127,230
PACSESI: 41Bl000l0
IN DIVORCE
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
ORDER
AND NOW, this
llj-H.
day of
(MI> '-~
, 1998,
pon consideration of Plaintiff's Motion For Order Approving
stipulation concerning Medical Insurance Coverage, and the
Defendant's concurrence therein, it is hereby ORDERED that the
arties' Stipulation attached to the foregoing Motion as Exhibit
is hereby APPROVED.
J.
LAW OF,.ICII
SNI!LBAKER.
BRE:NNEMAN
8: SPARE
li"I'-'
1\....1,
, ' _",.,!,r" :':~.I
. .~'"
. .' ioJ
..,. ,. ., I _ H .,- I' f\(
lj:":';" :.-t tl\"l U'.n "J
F"L ._: I i ~l ;jJ
::8;~:~'~ -Q];J
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
DR #27,230
PACSES#: 418100010
IN DIVORCE
MOTION FOR ORDER APPROVING STIPULATION
CONCERNING MEDICAL INSURANCE COVERAGE
Plaintiff Joanne E. Roberts, by her attorneys, Snelbaker,
Brenneman & Spare, P. C., hereby submits this Motion for Order
pproving stipulation and in support thereof states the
following I
1. On February 11, 1998 this Court issued an Order
respecting, inter AliA, Defendant's obligation to pay alimony
endente lite to the Domestic Relations section for the benefit
L.A,W Ol'iIIlCES
SNF.:LBAKER.
8RE~.~EMAN
8: SPARE
f Plaintiff.
2. During the conference in front of the Domestic Relations
fficer, the matter of the parties' health insurance coverage was
iscussed; namely, that Defendant provides medical insurance
overage for Plaintiff, his wife, through his employment with the
ommonwealth of Pennsylvania.
3. The above-referenced Order of February 11, 1998 does not
the matter of continuing medical insurance coverage tor
laintiff by Defendant.
4. The parties have reached an agreement concerning
efendant continuing to provide Plaintiff with medical insurance
NOW THEREFORE, the parties, through their attorneys, hereby
stipulate and agree as follows:
1. The preamble of this Stipulation above is incorporated
by reference herein.
2. Defendant shall continue to provide medical insurance
coverage for Plaintiff through his employer, the Commonwealth of
Pennsylvania. Such coverage shall be provided until anyone of
the following shall first occur: (1) Defendant's termination of
employment wi.th the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania; (2) the
parties' divorce; or (3) written agreement of the parties.
3. All other terms, conditions and requirements of the
Order of February 11, 1998 (erroneously dated February 11, 1997)
shall remain in full force and effect.
4. This Stipulation shall be subject to approval by the
Court.
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN &
SPARE, P. C.:
y' ,..eft......- --
Keith o. Brenneman, Esquire
44 W. Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
(717) 697-8528
Attorney for Plaintiff
Joanne E. Roberts
A.~
th A. Calk n, Esqu re
01 N. Second Street
arrisburg, PA 17110
(717) 238-2312
Attorney for Defendant
Ronald L. Roberts
,.
ATE: 114."-,1. ~, /99.
DATE: ~~ I~ Iff'
t...loll O"ICL'J
S"~LD.\KER.
8RF~lNF.:"U.'1
bl Si>AA(
-2-
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, KEITH O. BRENNEMAN, ESQUIRE, hereby certify that I have,
on the below date, caused a true and correct copy of the
foregoing Motion to be served upon the person and in the manner
indicated below:
FIRST CLASS MAIL. POSTAGE PREPAID, ADDRESSED AS FOLLOWS:
Judith A. Calkin, Esquire
2201 N. Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
ri17~~~
Keith o. Brenneman, Esquire
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN & SPARE, P. C.
44 West Main Street
P. O. BoX 318
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
(717) 697-8528
Attorneys for Plaintiff
ate: March 23, 1998
I
~~
","9
~
If)
"
f1)
'!
4
r
,..
'>-
I,c
>-
r,:
~::
II:~:
( 'I'" ~
t~-~ ':
~:~-
C
N
..
.
. ~ ,_.
~.
-n
c. .
L-~
I
l>.
G
.-
r
"
tJ'
,
(..)
JOANNE B. ROBBRTS,
Plaint if f
IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS
CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PA.
NO. 97-5994
vs.
RONALD L. ROBBRTS,
Defendant
Civil Action-In Divorce
MOTION POR APPOINTMBNT or MASTSR
Ronald L. Roberts, Defendant, moves the court to appoint
a master with respect to the following claims:
(X) Divorce
() Annulment
(X) Alimony
() Alimony Pendente Lite
(X) Distribution of property
( ) Support
(X) Counsel ~ees
(X) Costs and Bxpenses
and in support of the motion states:
(1) Discovery is complete as to the claims for which the
appointment of a master is requested with the exception of the
exchange of certain documents which Attorney Brennerman has
promised to promptly send.
(2) The defendant has appeared in the action by her attorney,
Keith Brennerman, Bsquire.
(3) The statutory ground for divorce is a 2 year separation.
(4) The action is contested with respect to the following
claims: Alimony, p.quitable distribution and attorney's fees.
(5) The action does not involve complex issues of law or fact.
(6) The hearing is expected to t<lkj one (1) day. ..,
(/q)!'zz:L A iJd.L..:
.dudith A. caiktn, Bsquire .
Attorney for Defendant
Date'
;j/7!6't/
Bsquire
ORe.. APPOINTING MAST.R
AND NOW ,~ Iv<< IV') o'?, 2000, ['.e'.. t.-.c...1 U~<ICcL/ ,
is appointed master with respect to the following claims:
l~le
~
. PI
J.
I
'jD ,1'\' ? ,j
t;: flj
C:.;:'.i' . .,';,:~ r'
;1~~~~ !J.J
R~
C- r-.. ~
.~ CO"
I.;
~. '.J ~-. "
~ '1. - ~:5
, .~~-= p;;
f.:" u.. ,--l;~
, . :::'I--::j
, O"l }~
-
tl; :r j~
...,
--; Ct:J ltJ
. -11.:
':...' g d
F1L:;o- O::ACE
r,' -.,~ '-II ,. "",.r""(
v'. \...; r 1 .~. .',L /",,,,,\
~1 tlOV -5 p~ It: n I
CUI.J,lJ:;'-;U';':U VJU:-.j{'{
n.:;."..~v,.,..,,^
n_I"\" Il.yrJ""
I.'
6. On or about October 29, 1997, prior to 12:00 o'clock
P.M., Respondent, while Petitioner was absent from the marital
residence, began removing and did remove various valuable
antiques and collectibles from the marital residence without
Petitioner's knowledge or consent.
7. It is believed that Respondent is removing marital
property from the marital residence for purposes of keeping same
from Petitioner and/or selling same.
8. The actions by Respondent as set forth in Paragraph 6
and 7, above, are intentional and designed to ensure Respondent
will have access, use and possession of certain marital property
to the exclusion of Petitioner.
9. Enjoining Respondent from removing any articles of
marital property from the marital residence will maintain the
status quo during the pendency of the divorce action and preolude
Respondent from improperly dissipating marital assets..
WHEREFORE, Petitioner Joanne E. Roberts requests this Court
to:
LAW O"ICt:.
SNEL8AKER.
BRENNEMAN
a SPARE
B.
A. issue an Interim Order ordering and directing that
Respondent shall not remove any marital property,
including, but not limited to, furniShings,
antiques and collectibles from the marital
residence without further Order of Court;
issue a Rule upon Respondent to show cause, it any
there should be, why the relief requested in this
Petition should not be granted; and
-2-
C. Order and direct such further and other relief which
this Court in its discretion deems just and
appropriate.
Date: October 31, 1997
Respectfully Submitted,
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN & SPARE, P. C.
I ./a U~..
By: ~J1
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire
44 W. Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
(717) 697-8528
Attorneys for Plaintiff/Petitioner
Joanne E. Roberts
-3-
(b) Provide approximate date when discovery will be
complete and indicate what action is being taken
to complete discovery,
If informatIon Is nQt receIved by Def~ndant by March I, 2000
a PetItIon to Compel the Answers to the InterrogatorIes and a
request for counsel fees wIll be flied.
...:it I~ .2 re-tJ
TE
NOTE:
PRETRIAL DIRECTIVES WILL NOT BE ISSUED FOR THE
FILING OF PRETRIAL STATEMENTS UNTIL COUNSEL HAVE
CERTIFIED THAT DISCOVERY IS COMPLETE, OR OTHERWISE
AT THE MASTER'S DISCRETION.
AFTER RECEIVING THIS DOCUMENT FROM BOTH COUNSEL
OR A PARTY TO THE ACTION, IF NOT REPRESENTED BY
COUNSEL, INDICATING THAT DISCOVERY IS NOT
COMPLETE, THE DIRECTIVE FOR FILING OF PRETRIAL
STATEMENTS WILL BE ISSUED AT THE MASTER'S
DISCRETION. HOWEVER, IF BOTH COUNSEL, OR A
PARTY NOT REPRESENTED, CERTIFY THAT DISCOVERY
IS COMPLETE, A DIRECTIVE TO FILE PRETRIAL
STATEMENTS WILL BE ISSUED IMMEDIATELY,
THE CERTIFICATION DOCUMENT SHOULD BE RETURNED
TO THE MASTER'S OFFICE WITHIN TWO (2) WEEKS OF
THE DATE SHOWN ON THE DOCUMENT.
.
..
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
PlaintilT
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL VANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LA W
v.
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
NO. 97-5994 CIVIL TERM
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, this 30iLday of March, 2000, upon consideration of Defendant's
Pe1ition for Contempt lor Failure To Complete Interrogatories, a Rule is hereby issued
upon Plaintiff to show cause why she should not be required to answer Defendant's
interrogatories.
RULE RETURNABLE within 20 days of service,
BY THE COURT,
Keith O. Brenneman, Esq.
44 West Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
Attorney for Plaintiff
1
'L
'Y Ol~. ','''' ~
~o
\,,,0
'5 ~ l':J
~~
f:2
;::::
"U~;.
en\"
,h.le:
6>'0"
~6 ~
~;n :.i:
a:-; I") too)
~c ..
~ too)
-< (,,)
Judith A. Calkin, Esq.
2201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, P A 17110
Attorney for Defendant
:rc
CJ 0
CJ ~1'1
.....
.~
,.
:\"
,1)
t:J
'-1
;\~~~
....1-11
-,,0
i~q,
~~':
Oi!i..:,'"
;3~?t;<;
~
~~ .... S!
t~ ~ ~ ~~; /
rgffi ~ I
ffi 0 ~j"J ~
'" .... u
~p.. '" t:l ~Q>! ~
I-< or< III ...
o . ..... ..., 0 ~,,~~ I ~ ~
~~ g <II t:l <II c:: '"
~] I-< .. I
el~ t:l ~I;g g
.... 0
1-<8 U o:lP< o:l'" or<
lil lil ....
~~ .... 'r< Ci<iiil
'" .... r
'" . . .. ;:l il
'" lol ,.J '" -, ..
I . ~
" ; en ~
~~ '" >
.
~u 0 lil
:z: ..,
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 CIVIL TERM
JOANNE E. ROBERTS, :
Plaintiff/Respondent:
RONALD L. ROBERTS, :
Defendant/Petitioner:
CIVIL ACTION-LAW
IN DIVORCB
ORDER
I.
AND NOW this
day of
,2000, a hearing on
the within Petition for Contempt for Failure to Complete
Interrogatories is scheduled for
, 2000 at
m. 0 I clock in courtroom 1/
, Cumberland County Courthouse,
Carlisle, Pennsylvania.
J.
vs.
IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS
CUMBBRLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994 CIVIL TBRM
CIVIL ACTION-LAW
IN DIVORCB
JOANNE B. ROBBRTS, :
Plaintiff/Respondent:
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant/Petitioner:
PETITION FOR CONTEMn FOR FAILURE
TO COMPLETE INTERROGATORIES
AND NOW comes Defendant/Petitioner, Ronald L. Roberts,
by and through his attorney, Judith A. Calkin, Bsquire and in
support of his petition avers as follows:
1. Defendant/Petitioner, RONALD L. ROBBRTS, is an adult
individual residing at 400 High Street, Apt. 1, West Fairview,
Pennsylvania.
2. Plaintiff/Respondent is JOANNE B. ROBERTS, an adult
individual residing at 10 Worth Road, Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania.
3. petitioner and Respondent were married on June 21,
1969 and separated in 1997.
4. Respondent filed for a divorce to the above-captioned
number on October 2B, 1997.
5. Respondent handled the financial matters during the
marriage, and Petitioner had limited knowledge of the parties'
assets.
6. On June 1B, 199B, Respondent was served with a set
of interrogatories.
7. Although some information requested in said
interrogatories was received substantial amounts of information
have not been received, although numerous requests have been made.
B. The parties have been separated in excess of two (2)
years and in order tl) prepare for a Master's hearing it is
necessary for Respondent to complete the interrogatories that she
has had since June, 199B.
9. Petitioner's attorney's fees in pursing this matter
are anticipated to be $450.00.
WHBRBFORS, Petitioner respectfully requests that:
a. Petitioner be required to answer the
interrogatories;
b. petitioner be held in contempt and directed to
pay Respondent his reasonable attorney's fees.
Respectfully submitted:
ith A. Cal n, Bsquire
y for Defendant/Petitioner
2201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(717) 23B-2312)
commonwealth of Pennsylvania:
County of Dauphin
I,
Judith
A.
Calkin,
Bsquire,
attorney
for
Defendant/Petitioner verify that the statements made in this
Contempt Petition are true and correct. I understand that false
statements herein are made subject to the penalties of 1B Pa.C.S.
Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsification to authorities.
Date:
Sworn and Subscribed
before me this 23 day
~~
Notary Public
NOTARIAL SEAL
ELLEN ROSENBLOOM. Notary Public
CItY 01 HaniIIIUra, Daupl1ln County
t4 Comrnlaalon E'x r81 MI 8, 2003
CJIJtTIJ'ICATB or UJtVICJI
I, Judith A. Calkin, Esquire, do hereby certify that a
true and correct copy of the petition for Contempt was served by
U.S. postal delivery, regular delivery &. certified mail from
Harrisburg, PA, postage-prepaid to the following person:
Keith O. Brenneman, Esquire
44 West Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
Dated: 3/23/00
~'t:J 71<(~
~
vs.
IN THB COURT OF COMMON PLBAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 97-5994
CIVIL ACTION-IN DIVORCB
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
PO-TRIAL STATEMENT
OF RONALD L. ROBBRTS
Defendant, by his attorney, Judith A. Calkin, Esquire
files this pre-trial statement in accordance with Pa.R.C.P.
1920.33 (b) .
1. Marital Assets: See Inventory and Appraisement and
attached list.
2. Bxoert Witnesses: None at present.
3. Other Witnesses: None at present.
4. Bxhibits:
a. Pay stubs.
b. Appraisal of real estate.
c. Appraisals of pensions.
d. Verifications of other marital assets.
5. Income Information:
See Income and Expense
Statement.
6. Exoense Information: See Income and Bxpense
Statement.
7. Pension Infolmation:
Attach to Inventory and
Appraisal.
ii
B. Counsel Fees: Defendant is not requesting counsel
fees.
9. Tanqible Personal PrODertv : See list and pictures
attached to Inventory and Appraisement.
The parties acquired hundreds of collectibles and
antiques. It would be prohibitively expensive to appraise them.
Husband proposes they be put up for auction. Either could bed on
any of the items and divide the proceeds.
10. ProDosed Resolution: The parties were married on
June 29, 1969 and separated in 1997. They have two adult children.
Husband works for the Commonwealth and grosses $31,915.00 per year.
Wife is employed full time and it is estimated that she makes
approximat'_ly $17,000.00 per year with an additional part time
income of several thousand dollars. The major items of marital
property are valued at $607,227.00. Husband proposes a 50/50
division of these assets. If husband received his pension
($233,249.00) and approximately $70,000.00 in additional assets
this would leave wife with the bulk of the liquid assets--many of
which can be income generating. If she chose to remain in the
marital home, she would have not only the home, but approximately
$135,113.00 in additional assets which could generate enough income
to make her yearly income as much as her husbands. As a
consequence, there should be no alimony award.
Respectfully submitted
t ;J()j"
ith A. Cal n, Bsquire
torney for Defendant
2201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(717) 23B-2312
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICB
I, Judith A. Calkin, Bsquire, do hereby certify that I
servtad a copy of the Pre-Trial Statement upon the Plaintiff I s
Attorney by U.S. mail, to the foll~wing person:
Keith Brenneman, Esquire
44 West Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
Dated:
~/Jd/rtJ
udith A. a kin, Bsquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
2201 North Second Street
Harrisburg, PA 17110
(717) 23B-2312
MAJOR ASSETS
Home equity
$9B,500.00
. 37,000.00
111,251.24
B9,223.14
3,000.00
4,000.00
5,530.21
5,70B.01
31,521.93
9,712.21
3,931.44
16,046.01
15,BB9.02
14,389.98
13,OOl.lB
233,249.00
4,497.07
$607,227.30
Land
PNC shares-Date of Separation
Value 3/31/00
CD's .
(Two accounts no value received)
Cash value of life insurance polices
Husband's pension
Wife's pension
TOTAL
JDANNE E. RDBERTS,
PlaintitT
(111 OJjCSZ~
IN THE CDURT DF CDMMDN PLEAS DF
CUMBERLAND CDUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
NO. 97.5994
RDNALD L. RDBERTS,
Defendant
CIVIL ACTIDN - IN DIVDRCE
PLAINTIFF'S PRETRIAL STATEMENT PURSUANT TO. PaRCP 1920.33IbJ
TO.: E. Robert Elicker, II, Divorce Master
Plaintiff Joanne E. Roberts, by her attorneys, Snelbaker, Brenneman & Spare, P. C.,
submits this Pretrial Statement in accordance with PaR.CP. InO.33(b) and at the direction of
the Divorce Master as follows
.A BACKGRDUND
This divorce action was initiated by Plaintiff Joanne E. Roberts on Dctober 29, 1997.
The parties were married on June 2 I, 1969 in Perry County, Pennsylvania. They were separated
November 28, 1997 when Defendant Ronald L. Roberts left the marital home.
The parties have two adult children of their marriage. Plaintiff is 61 years of age with a
birth date of April 18, 1939 Defendant is 59 years of age with a birth date of December 12,
1940.
PlaintitTis a high school graduate who works full-time as a cook through a food service
company, U.S. Dining S~rvices, that provides cafeteria service at the PHI CD building. She
started working full-time in 1990. Previously, she worked only part-time jobs after having
LAW OFFICES
SNELBAKER.
BRENNEMAN
a SPARE
children. In 1994 she suffered a stroke. She was able to return to work as a cook part-time in
1996.
Defendant has been employed by the Commonwealth of Pennsylvania for in excess of
thirty years. His current employment status is unknown. Both PlaintitT and Defendant have had
in the past additional minimal income from other sources of employment.
During tile course of the parties' marriage up to 1990, Husband was a chronic alcoholic
Wife single-handedly raised the parties' two children and made all contributions as II
homemaker. Due solely to her efforts and thrift, there exist various assets that Husband was not
able to expend over the 23 year period that he was drinking.
B. STATEMENT PURSUANT TO. Pa.R.C.P. 1920.33(bl.
The following corresponds to the paragraphs ofPa.R.C.P. 1920.33(b) setting forth the
content of the Pretrial Statement:
I. Marital Assets.
Various marital and non-marital assets with their values are identified on the document
attached hereto and incorporated by reference herein as "Exhibit A".
a. Marital Residence. The parties are the owners of a house located at 10 North Road,
Mechanicsburg, which they acquired in 1969. The house has been occupied by PlaintitT since
the parties' separation in November, 1997. Defendant's appraiser has established a value on the
property ofSI ]4,000.00. Plaintiff reserves the right to appraise the marital residence,
b. Fowler's Hollow, Perry County Property. The parties are the owners of an
unimproved tract of land in Perry County consisting of approximately 25.46 acres, having
received the property from Plaintiff's mother in 1980. The appraised value is S37,500.OO.
LAW O'fICES
5NELSAI<ER.
BRENNEMAN
a SPARE
-2-
c. Household Goods, Furnishings, Miscellaneous Tangible Personal Property.
There has been no agreement to divide the household marital goods and furnishings.
Plaintiff reserves the right to have the items inventoried and appraised. Those items which
Plaintiff contends are non-marital and owned by her are noted on the listing attached hereto and
incorporated by reference herein as "Exhibit B".
d. Motor Vehicles. There are three vehicles which are marital propeny. One, a Saturn,
was used by Plaintiff and titled in her name. That vehicle was totaled in an automobile accident
in 1998 and insurance proceeds used to pay the lien holder. Two other vehicles have been in the
possession of Defendant. One was believed to have been sold by Defendant.
e. Checking, Savings and Olher Accounts. The parties had three joint accounts
containing a minimal balance as of th~ date of separation. The other various acco~nts that
existed at the time of the panies' separation are noted on Exhibit A
f. Marital Debt. There were three marital loan obligations. Two loans were PNC Bank
loans secured by the marital residence. Three months after separation, the primary mortgage
loan to PNC Bank had a principal balance of$19,592.00. The second mortgage to PNC Bank
had a principal balance of $1,367.00. Plaintiff paid these loans on a monthly basis. The third
loan secured by the Saturn automobile was paid in full from the insurance proceeds after the
-3-
vehicle was totaled.
II. NDN-MARIT AL ASSETS.
The non-marital assets are identified on Exhibits A and B. In addition, the variouslif.'t
lAW OFFICES
SNELBAKEA
B~ENNE,",.N
&: SPAR~
insurance policies and certificates of deposit that are not titled in Defendant's name as noted in
6, Inheritance Tax Return for the Estate of Gladys K. Gutshall.
7, Plaintiff's 1999 Income Tax Return.
8, Plaintill" s Income and Expense Statement.
9. All documents provided by Defendant in discovery.
10. Video tape of the parties' personal property.
PlaintitT reserves the right to supplement this list of exhibits as needed as documents
become available to her prior to hearing.
VI. PLAINTIFF'S INCDME.
A representative statement of PlaintitT' s income from employment is attached hereto and
incorporated herein as "Exhibit C". See the Income and Expense Statement ofPlaintitrto be
submitted in this action for identification of any additional income.
VII. PLAINTIFF'S EXPENSES.
For a statement ofPlaintitT's expenses, see the Income and Expense Statement Which will
be submitted in this matter.
VIII. RETlREMENTIPENSIDN BENEFITS.
Defendant is vested in a retirement benefit provided by the Commonwealth of
LAW OFFICES
SNELBAKER.
BRENNEMAN
a: SPARE
-5-
Pennsylvania State Employees' Retirement System. Plaintiff reserves the right to value
Defendant's retirement benefit as necessary.
Plaintiff participates in an employee savings retirement plan through her employer.
Information concerning that benelit is noted on Exhibit A.
IX. CDUNSEL FEES
A current statement of Plaintiff's counsel fees incurred in this matter will be provided.
X. TANGIBLE PERSDNAL PRDPERTY.
See Section I.c., above.
XI. MARITAL DEBT
See Section I. f, above.
Xll. PRDPDSED RESDLUTIDN DF ECDNDMIC ISSUES.
Plaintiff will accept sixty-live percent of the panies' marital assets together with monthly
alimony to be paid for an indefinite period of time.
Respectfully Submitted,
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN & SPARE, P. C.
,4~/.JU'~
BY:
Keith D. Brenneman, Esquire
44 W. Main Street
Mechanicsburg, PA 17055
(717) 697-8528
Attorneys for Plaintiff
Joanne E. Roberts
ti
LAW OFFICES
SNElBA.I<EA.
BRENNEMAN
8r SPARE
Date: July 7, 2000
-6.
I~ ~ !
Ii Ul l!jl~1
f jl !l !jJ~" if
!Iii JI"CO ~ siHs
I H f"11
I u"t I) . i
d~
f If ~IU~
." "
.. 2 c ~ ~ ~ po
~..c
! l J/ - .. eiB ~il
. c c: (! ~.c . ...
n ; .~ ~H~
BN~ -UBSI
(J)~...J ~!!!!~ ~."dl;l ~
8_
<( ~~
~ Z 'N ~ !!
on . ~ ~
1 f"f 0
z z
u ~
U -
8 .. " ;:; OIl "
~ 1E l:l ::l ;;; - '"
.. - "
j ~ re- ~ ,.: ~ - ~ l;i ,.: .,; ~
'" ;0 '" r--
iB <D - '" " .,;
~ ~ en ~ &i on on ~ ~ .0
l;l - ;;;
~ ;;; - .. ... ;;; ;;;
z ...~
j ~ .D U ." Ii -' co
8 8 .. " 1E N ;:; ::l ;;; - OIl "
~ '"
~ ~ .. 0 - r-- ~
,d ~ 0;- ~ ,.: ~ - ~ l;i ,.: .,;
~B '" ;0 '" I::
.; ,.: <D - '" .,;
~i - l:l 1! en ~ &i on .0 ~ ~ .0
;;; :: .. " l;l ;;; ;;; ;;; ;;;
...~ (J) ..
>Jl " ~ ~ .D U .,; Ii -' co
~~
8 8
dl~ ~
!f~a ~ III ~
~ ~ t
!I~ ~ iSt
.. " l:i .. ~ .. ~
01 ! ~ s:& I
, 11
..,
Q.
i ~ ~
~ Ii .. j ~
c ~ ..
.. ~ :Ii ~
- :& 0 ~
Ii z
c ~
..
:&
~ 11 ,., ,.,
~ ~ ~ c
0
! l! u I- ~
J: h ~ "
.. ~l! ~ '"
l! 11 ~ ~ ~
i .. ~~ ~.8
" ~~
'C ~a:
J: ~ .. .D
i ~ c ~:g 8
c 0 h
a: 0 E B cc!;
~ B E E c - -
a: S 8 e ~~ " c
" ~ ~ .... N ~ '" 1!:t'"
11 eo (J) ~ ~ .., ~ ::! .... ll.@ H!
J: 0( ~ - ..
I . , IE~ .. '" N ~ !it
H z " ~,., N N l:l ~N
.l! (J) 0 - ~ 0
'" '"
8- ..i 0; 0; 0; N N Ii r-
a:c (J) ~ a~ z z .. H
H c ..
ll.tB a1 5l 0 0 0 0 0 0 0
'" >-~ z z z z z z z
~<l:~ u .0
Z ~ l ~ .D u .,; Ii - .. ~ll.
.' 0 a: Q.
-
N
....
o
o-l
III
Dl
III
Po
-
I(
Eo<
H
III
B
J ~ ~
~ ~
1; ~
"
J J
~ '.!; ~ ~ ~ ~ ~ ~
~ z
8 8 .... ~ ~
0
0 ~ ~ .... a '"
.~ m .... ~ ~
... :;j
0 :;i ~ ~
0- 0 :l 0
J .. ~
c:
... ... ... ;:, ;:,
8 8 .... ~ ~
0
liB ~ ~ .... ~ '" ~ l" ..
m ....
... :;j \
~[ a ~ ~ .. c: I"
... ... ... ~ '5
>.ll ;:,
,
H)
sL
<.);(0
,,~
!5
~
5 -~
c:
..
=l' ~ ~ 3 .~ 3 3 3 ~ 3 3
0 52
0 c: c: c: c: c: ' c: c:
Z .. .. .. .. .. .. .. ~ .. 0 .. ..
- 2 2 2 2 2 2 2 2~ ::I 2
li ."
1: 0
.. ..
2
."
c:
~ '2 '2
! " " " ~ ~ ~
~ .!! .., ~ .., .., J: ~ i
~ ~ ~ ~ S ~ ~ '2
.. J: J:
.!!
~
c 51 Om
~ .... '" -~
~ '" ~ B:!l 11
~ !! -::l -'" - 0 10 ~:: -'2 S
~i.., f!~ " 0_ 0.... ~Z .. ..
~~ B- B'" ~~ h c:
a: ~~ ~6 Be J!~ B~
0 ;:''' ~L '" 0 "... Ui
~ .... a.g' ep; ep; , 0. E .il,r
B ~o:;l ~~ <(N i
il ;; ~o ~ 0 z 0 .. ~ .. ~ e
'2s'" ~ .. 5 u.. F 0
j ~BC;; <.?'" ~~ ~~ z q ~
~~N Ho ~E~ t ~~ ~ - l' ~2
o -
oelS oj'9 ~! o .. Jl6' ~8. ~ ~ ~ ~~
;:,8. ~ 5.... <.)
<.)~8 u ~~ ~ ~
~~j .. 0 .3 a..!! !!~ <.)~ ~n.~ ii~
o z EO. zu.... ZlllN Z 31
.. ~ ci! w ... u: 0- n. 2 0.
-
N
....
o
N
41
0\
"'
r:lo
-
0<
Eo<
.....
III
B
"
j ~r." ,.,
t-~1-\
1J ,.
Anawor to Inlarrasatory 8:
NON-MARITAL PRDPERTY
Livinll Room
Piano
Gone/wind light (red)
6 boxes
Some glassware in china closets
Wooden bushel
Dolls
Wicker rocker
Wicker carriage
Iron bulldog
Milk can
Familv Room
Baseball, football, bird cards
Football s
Baseballs
Sheep foot.tool
Rocking horse
2 door stops
, .~ Snowmen
Parrot bookends
Book
, . '- Salt and pepper sets
"
Kitchen
Dog set
Santa bird ornaments
Kitten Pitcher
Salt and pepper set
Cookie jar on counter
Gold swan
EXHIBIT B
-~:~: :~b::::: - ~g~g~~E - ROBERTS - - - - -- - - - - ~:~ -~~rba:: '~~~~~;~~Egy~~~~;~~;~~~~ ar 412
SSN... ..... 188-32-4350 Payroll for. 14/2000
Exemptions: FED 01 Married Payroll in.. 14/2000
Exemptions: PA 00 Married Cost Center: 6551
I Exemptions: PBU500 Single Pay area.... FD Field Group 4
-............................................................................................................................................... --...........................
I Check date Check number Chk amount. Grols Taxel DEDS I
04/05/2000 6237259 239.97 . 290.00 - 50.03 - 0.00
.---- -- -.... ..-....... ----.. -------- -....... --- ---.. ---......... .------_.. ........ -- ---- ----------.... --..
GROSS Rate Number Amount YTD
1001 Base Pay-Field non-salary 7.25 40.00 290.00 3,794.00
1007 Holiday Pay - Hours 226.00
1020 Overtime-1.5xRate 59.84
Total Earnings 290.00 4,079.84
-------..-----------------------------------------..-------------------------------
TAXES Amount YTD
Federal FED
1401 TX Withholding Tax 16.82 239.43
/403 TX EE Social Security Tax 17.98 252.95
/405 TX EE Medicare Tax 4.21 59.16
State PA
1401 TX Withholding Tax 8.12 114.24
City PBU5
/~01 TX Withholding Tax 2.90 40.80
1451 TX EE Occupation Tax 5.00
Total Taxes 50.03 711.58
-.......-----------------------------------------------------------------------------
l'IlI.tclor!lelOllClMld'......"'OMOIIC.__GIlMft'l....~
EXIIIBIT C
\1
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I, KEITH D. BRENNEMAN, ESQUIRE, hereby certify that I have on the below date,
caused a true and correct copy oflhe foregoing Pretrial Memorandum to be served upon the
person and in the manner indicated below:
FIRST CLASS MAIL. PDST AGE PREPAID. ADDRESSED AS FDLLDWS:
Judith A. Calkin, Esquire
2201 N. Second Street
Harrisburg. P A 17 I 10
Keith 0., Brenneman. Esquire
SNELBAKER, BRENNEMAN & SPARE, P. C.
44 W. Main Streel
p, D. Box 318
Mechanicsburg. PA 17055
(717) 697.8528
Attorneys for PlaintitT
Date: July 7, 2000
~ 8(1- L/.~'
, -'I
"
V---'
d
fl ~1iI[__~'\.4..A-V',.-.
Ie" w),j7...J .
J l ......1,. /'
- v'/ .I~/ """''''4. ."
, -. ~~.' )
.' J /
/~ '.,. J Il.4.",;" {' ..
r: :- -'
I
('-",---
'.Alj~.
I'
,. .
f, 1
/ t"^~_v~
(./'1.((.1
'l(2AH'
i. ~~ ~A.............
~~Ak-.
1I/''"l.(1';
)up NJt;.1
~
II/, !'\ 1:1 /.
~ .11'.,I\w-v.J,J;.Or#/...-{,d...._lj{"A~. fIr). )""/'1'- ~ '-.J~t)4/ Il)(lq('r7
j /'''''1-' I .
L...,..,.,... . , '~A
~~J.t J... 7.-{!..> /..,,,.
.\ I ,I I f .J.
r< " r",. I' '.'" '. It ..Lc.....t /I~
( I / ',-.
....f.., ". ....... v.-L.t.f. ; -'-11 ~ ..'~ I
<;r,/"t t... ~ ~..I;;,4I.L^Ifl
lb.,......;) (/...-'. "~
/,v-
~~ - Ul, &~.Jv-~
Nt{ /ft'wr:U, r /I n., vo ~ ~I' \ h
Il~ 'tGt A /J).
'f /vdd,-,c....., .
O"~...,('c\.-'<<..-.... ......
,..,ft.I", I
~.
l..t~
If ~
I~~,'{ /:Jut..... _ S;^'"-......I~JJlrl 11'(.17 P'lLllA-I., -
/.L.J1J. J I..... ..,pt'I},'1 tJ/.,lttl ./'t'I.".( II '.s-,f.... I'&C\--.;,rc..
c..- .... . .,,.Jt. \ 1+
~..)c._- ~ ~"1~
11: U~ 1.1-, c., ! -,. -~. '(;'; "'t .. <c' fl ::.. q tf7, .r
"uA v""'-M.:l.J., ll',! ,.,', "L...{q \l'!
''1,-:,~ ;\.iJ I V, ,,0.. 'II '[V.,;J-
. \
J. \. .1. L...uJ,tL ^-'>..I)."..............
I~~
ct,...", .
w..d.....I...
()~J-.J r'...').. .
. ; .'......11..J
vh<<.t....".. ,t.__
.--
., \
I' t' -..-..... '-~j
..",...... i...... \~
,\ l~ 1
I ,V L , ~ " .
J
r~'\ L.' ,..1,
, '1. I~ 'f - i_
I ..
1:4-<, t'J 1
10,- , 'i ~ _
I
~. -
-) i~. ....
,. . J -:-,
,"l'~'" 'I.'" f
"
I'i \:1 /., "'I-
1-- I' I . I
1- (.,.^/;e~., ,.\. , ,. . t'( ,. ..
1.-5 -I..,n/\~,
)~(L.\~" I ,'" ...../., ~......_. j j
,)
. ~_.i'~'1.1 H<- ,
/'i ,-:. ~
'J'iA.J... -
" "I } i ,1) I j,' j "I !. J 'J
~~ Gu.rv- c . ", ...~ e.' r'1,i-V,I,H,) (j (-'yojA, ('11 ~~
I" t'l I I '"..".,. . ;"1 " . V
1.1 .,~. j". , 'I,
-~Q~"",-_,\ I ,,",,~.v~}f1.:J 1.1 ,l
" ci
-I /! I" 1
I...... 'U'j :.JI /-.v,.(,,_,~tl l~t/\...
\ ~.. tt~ , Cjd L.t I..",,~ tVV"'..-L.;';I"'~~
't."':''ft'....." . I" I
. t '\, '" V ',\i
'/41 '. C~<!
t( r.'.r F<L.
---! l1"'<l. j't"
~(.\
O~)",\.,.qa/' L~'l.d. d";/d,,..
?f.X.. .rLv_.n -A.",,,... ,', ! "/,,.
7... 1/'.1' .J- . cu.."'; ~! (''''10. '~.t.\.lV~{
,
vw-v. ~ f'~ LA '~,t\"~"~"'jlLq... . ~~ /tJ)WA .~~J
. , .,., t. '(.,! J) 1 I/" I
.J'If '" ''-.' I ' >,' .1 I. './J ...l).. r u"" {"";'..._
Ir"'/~
\,\.\ ~ ~ .-.
L~.......,. A~'1i' i.J l,Joi/_. Y1 ((9 7, 61.._._..,
"_..--".._._.._-~-------
.
--
JOANNE E. ROBERTS,
Plaintiff
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
vs.
NO. 97 - 5994 CIVIL
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant
IN DIVORCE
ORDER OF COURT
.
AND NOW, this ,.jI.J day of A~U;A1dJ.AJ
2000, the parties and counsel having entered into an
agreement and stipulation resolving the economic issues on
December 2l, 2000, the date set for a Master's hearing,
the agreement and stipulation having been transcribed, and
subsequently signed by the parties and counsel, the
appointment of the Master is vacated, and counsel can
conclude the proceedings by the filing of a praecipe to
transmit the record with the affidavits of consent of the
parties so that a final decree in divorce can be entered.
BY THE COURT,
.J.
cc:
Keith O. Brenneman
Attorney for Plaintiff
~
_~ ~ 00
l~ \ra:~~*
I
Judith A. Calkin
Attorney for Defendant
~..)
r ",' ,
f .
_..1
t."
,
.~.
,:!~:.
I'
"
'I
~ ;
JOANNE E. ROBERTS, IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
Plaintiff CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Vs. NO. 97 - 5994 CIVIL
RONALD L. ROBERTS,
Defendant IN DIVORCE
THE MASTER: Today is Thursday, December 21,
2000.
This is the date set for a Master's hearing in the
above captioned divorce proceedings.
Present in the hearing room are the
Plaintiff, Joanne E. Roberts, and her counsel Keith O.
Brenneman, and the Defendant, Ronald L. Roberts, and his
counsel Judith A. Calkin.
This action was commenced by the filing of a
divorce complaint on October 29, 1997, raising grounds for
divorce of irretrievable breakdown of the marriage.
Counsel
are going to provide the Master later this morning with signed
affidavits of consent and waivers of notice of intention to
request entry of divorce decree so that the divorce can be
concluded under Section 3301(c) of the Domestic Relations
Code.
The Master's office will file the affidavits and
waivers.
The complaint also raised the economic claims
of equitable distribution, alimony, alimony pendente lite, and
counsel fees and expenses.
The parties were married on June 2l, 1969,
and separated November 28, 1997.
There are two natural
children of the parties, both of whom are emancipated.
The Master has been advised that after
negotiations this morning th~ parties have reached an
agreement with respect to all of the outstanding economic
issues. An agreement is going to be placed on the record in
the presence of the partLes. The agreement as placed on the
record will be considered the substantive agreement of the
parties not subject to any changes or modifications except for
correction of typographical errors which may be made during
the transcription. The parties and counsel will return later
this morning to review the draft of the agreement for
typographical errors and make any corrections as necessary.
After the agreement has been corrected for typographical
errors the parties and counsel will affix their signatures.
The signatures of the parties will simply be an affirmation of
the terms of settlement as placed on the record at this time.
When the parties leave the hearing room they will be bound by
the terms of settlement irrespective of whether or not they
subsequently sign the agreement.
After the Master has been provided a
completed agreement, he will prepare an order vacating his
appointment and counsel will then be in position to file a
praecipe transmitting the record to the Court requesting a
final decree in divorce. Mr. Brenneman.
MR. BRENNEMAN: Thank you, Mr. Elicker. The
of the wife shall be considered the wife's property and all
other items in husband's possession shall be considered the
husband's property.
3. In addition to those items that I mentioned, wife is
retaining separately appraised personal property in the amount
of $3,165.00.
4. The real estate jointly owned by the parties consists
of a home and land in Cumberland County. Husband agrees to
provide a special warranty deed to wife conveying his right,
title, ~nd interest in that property within thirty days of
today's date, Wife agrees within the same time period to
provide an indemnification to husband with respect to the
present mortgage obligation on that property.
5. Also within thirty days of today's date husband agrees
to provide to wife a special warranty deed conveying his
right, title, and interest to the parties' vacant property in
Perry County.
6. Wife shall retain the following items of personal
property and investments:
The PNC stock;
the New York life insurance policies;
the Nationwide tax free income fund;
the Nationwide non-qualified annuity;
the two Bank of Landisburg CDs;
and her. Compass Group savings retirement plan benefit.
7. Husband assumes the obligation to pay the balance due
on a joint credit card debt.
8. Each party waives any claim that they have for counsel
fees and costs in this action.
9. Wife also waives her claim for alimony.
10. Except as herein otherwise provided, each party may
dispose of his or her property in any way and each party
hereby waives and relinquishes any and all rights he or she
may now have or hereafter acquire under the present or future
laws of any jurisdiction to share in the property or the
estate of the other as a result of the marital relationship
including without limitation, statutory allowance, widow's
allowance, right of intestacy, right to take against the will
of the other, and right to act as administrator or executor in
the other's estate. Each will at the request of the other
execute, acknowledge, and deliver any and all instruments
which may be necessary or advisable to carry into effect this
mutual waiver and relinquishment of all such interest, rights,
and claims.
THE MASTER: Mrs. Roberts, have you been
present while your attorney Mr. Brenneman recited the
agreement on the record?
MRS. ROBERTS: Yes.
THE MASTER: Do you understand the terms of
the agreement?
MRS. ROBERTS: Yes.
THE MASTER: Do you have any questions about
it?
MRS. ROBERTS: No.
THE MASTER: And you are satisfied to enter
in to this agreement to resolve all of the outstanding
economic issues in this case?
MRS. ROBERTS: Yes.
THE MASTER: You understand that when you
leave the hearing room today, even though the agreement has
not been signed, you are bound by the terms of this
settlement?
MRS. ROBERTS: Yes.
THE MASTER: Mr. Roberts, you have heard the
questions that I have asked your wife. Have you been here
during the recitation of the agreement on the record?
MR. ROBERTS: Yes, sir.
THE MASTER: Do you understand the agreement?
MR. ROBERTS: Yes, sir.
THE MASTER: Do you have any questions about
it?
MR. ROBERTS: No, sir.
THE MASTER: Are you satisfied that this
agreement will resolve all of the outstanding economic issues
J.n this case?
MR. ROBERTS: Yes, sir.
THE MASTER: And do you understand that when
you leave the hearing room you are bound by the terms of this
agreement even though you have not subsequently signed the
agreement?
MR. ROBERTS: Yes, sir.
I acknowledge that I have read the above
stipulation and agreement, that I understand the terms of
settlement as set forth herein, and that by signing below I
ratify and affirm the agreement previously made and intend to
bind myself to the settlement as a contract obligating myself
to the terms of settlement and subjecting myself to the
methods and procedures of enforcement which may be imposed by
law and in particular Section 3105 of the Domestic Relations
Code.
WITNESS:
DATE: OE:ct.'Jo.II3l:n ;) I, :2 "., tI
1fh~~
J r~..-.
... "/.-11.."
.Joanne E.
I" (_.
. .r ,... " ~~ . ~
. (,"" "
Roberts ~
Keith O. Brenneman
Attorney for Plaintiff
"
J ..' t l. 'j
It. " .U I' Jf.(~h,;;.:..
Ronald L. Roberts
ith A. Calkin
torney for Defendant
.\
ORDER/NOTICE TO WITHHOLD INCOME FOR SUPPORT
State Commonwealth of Penmylvaola
Co.lCity/Di51, of CUMBBRl.J\ND
Date of Order/Notice 02/05/01
Court/Cale Number (~e Addendum for cale summary)
fmployerlWilhkolder's fedt'roll [IN NumhN
COMMONWEALTH OF PA
[mployer^Vithholdrr'~ NoIml'
C/O PAYROLL OPBRATIONS
l:mployerlWilhholcwr'fo Atldn.u
PO BOX 9006
HARRISBURG PA 17105-8006
IIC.T. '17-5994 CIVIl.
PfoCSF.5 418100010
DR272JO
o Origin.ll {)rd('r/Nulke
o Aml'ntlc.d OrdN/NoUc.p
@ I ermlnolte Order/Nulke
IRf:ROBBRTS, RONALD L.
I [m'llu'(l'I"JObliKur's NoIml' II oJ"l, first, Mil
I 206-32-2353
I Imployt'e/Ohllgur's SuciJI S('curlly Numb(.,
I 6623100024
I l mplnYL'l'/Ohligur's C,lW hlt'nUriN
I (SI. AJd.nwm for pL.lnr/H twm,..uocM,.d with nl.' OIIlftulun,nf)
) Cu\lutli.lIllJfenl's Notmr. U.ul, lint, Ml)
I
~e Addendum for dependent names and birth dates associated with cases on allachment.
ORDER INFORMA TION: Thllll ao Order/Notice to Withhold Income for Suppor! based upon an order for supporl
from CUMBBRIJ\ND County, Commonwealth of Pennsylvania. By law, you are required to deductthele
amounts from the above.named employee'slobligor's Income until further notice even if the Order/Notice 15 not
Issued by your State.
$ 0.00 per month in current support
$ 0.00 per month In past.due suppor! Arrears 12 weeks or greaterl Oyes ~ no
$ 0 . 00 per month In medical supporl
$ 0 . 00 per month for genetic tesl costs
$ per month in other (specify)
for a total of $ 0.00 per month to be forwarded to payee below.
You do not have to vary your pay cycle to be In compliance with Ihe suppor! order. If your pay cycle does nOI match
Ihe ordered support payment cycle, use the following to determine how much to withhold:
$ 0 .00 per weekly pay period.
$ 0.00 per biweekly pay period (every Iwo weeks). . (,
$ 0.00 per semimonthly pay period (twice a month). y
$ 0 00 per monthly pay period. J.I . I- \ (..(1/
REMITTANCE INFORMA TlON: I .\,1")
You must begin withholding no later than the first pay period occurring ten of Ihis
Order/Notice, Send payment within seven (7) working days of the paydate. Iitled to
deduct a fee to defray the cOSI of withholding. Refer to Ihe laws governing for the
the allowable amount. The total withheld amount, and your fee, cannOI ex . .' .... cOI'I.lluyee'S/ obligor's
aggregate disposable weekly earnings. For the purpose of the limitation on withholding, Ihe following Information Is
needed (See '9 on pg, 2),
If remitting by EFl/EDI, please call Pennsylvania State Collections and Disbursement Unit (SCDU) Employer
Customer Service at 1.877.676.9580 for Instructions.
Make Remittance Payable to: PA SCDU
Send check to: Pennsylvania SCDU, P.O. Box 69112, Harrisburg, Pa 17106.9112
IN ADDITION, 'A YMENTS MUST INCLUDE THE DEFENDANT'S NAME AND THE 'ACSES MEMIEft ID (mown
above as the Employee/Obl/Bor's Case Idenllller) OR SOCIAL SECURITY NUMIER IN ORDER TO IE 'ftOCESSED.
DO NOT SEND CASH IY MAIL.
t'&~ [;.!', "J1_~n
~
."
Date of Order:
FebnlllCV 5, 2001
Service Type M
Jt
Form EN-0l8
Worker 10 21005
OM8I'ttJ.;u"'lJ.Ql\
1_IHI.ltlllfl[1..t.:lllll.1HI
.,
ORDER/NOTICE TO WITHHOLD INCOME FOR SUPPORT
State Commonwealth of penn.ylvanla
CoJCity/Disl. of CUMBERLAND
Date of Order/Nolice 02/05/01
Court/Case Number fSee Addendum for case summary)
00, 97-~ CML
PKSES 418100010
00272lO
o ()filllnoll (JrtJl',lNolkc
o Anll'ndt'd Ortj(.,lNullu-
(8) lermirwle (Jf(tl'r/Noli(~
EmployerlWilhholdcr's feuer,1I [IN Number
COMMONWEALTH OF PA
tmployerlWilhholtfer's NoIme
C/O PAYROLL OPERATIONS
E mployerlWilhholtfer', Adoress
PO BOX 8006
HARRISBURG PA 17105-8006
I Rf: ROBERTS , RONALD L,
) EmplnyeeJObligur's NoIme II oIsl, fiht. Mil
I
I
J
I
J
I
J
206-)2-2353
[mpluYfOeJObligu,', Sor,i..1 Ser.uriry Num~'
6U31000H
[mllloyeelObligu,', Col~ Identifier
($" Addtnwm Iw ,w/ntlH Mme. ."ocMtHl wi'" ('.... 011 .".dun.llt)
CustodiAl PoIlent', NoImt" ll,ul, I irsl, Mil
See Addendum for dependent ""mes and birth dates associated with cases on attachment,
ORDER INFORlvtA TlON: This is an Order/Notice 10 Withhold Income for Support based upon an order for support
from CUMBERLAND County, Commonweallh of Pennsylvania. By law, you are required to deducllhese
amounls from the above.named employee'sfobligor's i~come until furlher nolice even if the Order/Nolice Is not
issued by your State.
So. 00 per month in current support
So. 00 per monlh in past-due support Arrears 12 weeks or greaterl Oyes (g) no
S 0 .00 per monlh in medical supporl
S 0 . 00 per month for genelic test costs
S per month in other (specify)
for a total of So. 00 per month to be forwarded to payee below.
You do not have 10 vary your pay cycle to be in compliance with the support order. If your pay cycle does not malch
the ordered support paymenl cycle, use the following to determine how much to withhold:
S 0 . 00 per weekly pay period.
S 0 00 per biweekly pay period (every Iwo weeks).
S 0 . 00 per semimonthly pay period (twice a month).
S 0 00 per monthly pay period.
REMITTANCE INFORMATION:
You must begin withholding no later than Ihe first pay period occurring ten (10) working days afler the dale of Ihls
Order/Nolice. Send payment within seven m working days of the paydate/dale of withholding. You are entitled to
deduct a fee to defray the COSI of withholding. Refer to the laws governing the work state of your employee for Ihe
Ihe allowable amounl. The total withheld amount, and your fee, cannol exceed 55% of the employee'sf obligor's
aggregate disposable weekly earnings. For the purpose of the limitation on withholding, the following informalion is
needed (See *9 on pg. 2).
If remitting by EHIEDI, please call Pennsylvania State Collections and Disbursement Unit (SCDU) Employer
Customer Service at 1.877-676.9580 for inslruct;ons.
Make Remitlance Payable to: PA SCDU
Send check to: Pennsylvania SCDU, P.O. Box 69112, Harrisburg, Pa 17106.9112
IN ADDI1ION, 'AYMENTS MUST INCLUDE THE DlFENDANT'S NAME AND THE 'ACSES MEMBEIID (shown
above as the Employee/Obl/aor's Case Identifier) 01 SOCIAL SECUIlITY NUMBEIIN OIDEIl TO BE 1Il0CESSED.
DO NOT SEND CASH BY MAIL.
~
'} <,{...
~
Date of Order: Febnlllry 5. 2001
BY THE COURT:
Service Type M
Form EN-D28
Worker ID 21005
O...IS....LOIJ1U-oU
I.J)lI~.~'n D4l1' I "ci)!'!;O
.,
ADDITIONAL INFORMATION TO EMPLOYERS AND OTHER WITHHOLDERS
o If checked you .He required to providl!" copy of this form 10 your employt'c.
1. Priority: Withholding under this Ordi?r/Nolin~ hdS priority uver .1Oy other IllgJI proress under StJle IdW dgJinsllhl1' Sdme income.
Feder..1 tdX levies in effecl befow rec_eipl of lhis order hJW priority. If there Jm fcderdllJx levit~s in C(fcct plcdse conlJr:t the requesting
dgency listed Ill"low.
2. Combining PoIymenB: Yuu r.m comhim~ withheld .tnlOunls from mom Ihd" one employee/ubligor's income in iI single payment
to edch agency requesting withholding. You musl, however, SClklrdtely identify the portion of the single J>dyment Ihal is altribulilble 10
edch employee/obligor.
3.. -Reporti~~PaydatelDate of Withholdinll'-Ynttmmt report the paydaleJdate ofwithholdingwher,.,ending-~payment;-The-
pa,d'loId>to of withholding-;,.thedateon-whidumount....'withheld /rom theemplnyt'e"....ge<: You must comply wilh Ihe Idw of Ihe
stolte of (he employee'slobligo,'s principal plolce of employment with respect 10 the time periods within which you must implement the
withholding order clod forwllrd the support P<lyml!Ots.
4.. Employee/Obligor with Multiple Suppon Holdings: If Ihere is more Ihdn one Order/Nolice 10 Withhold Income (or SuppM
dgdin.t this employee/obligor dnd yoo dre undble 10 honor dll sopport Order/Nolice. due to Federdl 0' S'dle withholding limil., yoo musl
follow Ihe Idw o( Ihe .Idle o( employee's/obligor's princip.ll pldce o( employment. You must honor dll Orders/Nolice. 10 the gredtesl
exlent possible. (See '9 below)
5. Termindlion Nolificdlion: You musl promplly nOlify Ihe RequeSling ^gency when Ihe employee/obligor i. no longer working for
you. Please provide Ihe inlorm.tlion requested and return a copy of this OrderlNatice to the ^genc.y identified below.
WITHHOLDER'S 10: nn na90
EMPLOYEE'S108LIGOR'S N^M(: ROB3RTS. RONALD L.
EMPLOYEE'S ~SE IDENTIFIER: 6U3100024 D^TE OF SEP^~T10N:
LAST KNOWN HOME ^OORESS:
NEW EMPLOYER'S N^ME/^OORESS:
6. Lump Sum Pdymenls: You mdY be ,equired to report dnd wilhhold (rnm lump .um pdymenlS such as bonuse., commissions, or
severance poly. If you have any questions IIbout lump sum payments, conlacllhe person or authority below.
7. Lidbility: I( you (dillo wilhhold income dS Ihe O,der/Nolice directs, you dre Iidble (or bolh the accumuldled amounl you should
hdve wilhheld from Ihe employee/obligor's income dnd other pendltie. .el by Penn.ylvdnid SIdle IdW. Pennsylvanid StdtP. Idw governs
unless the obligor is employed in dnolher Sidle. in which Cdse Ihe Idw of Ihe SIdle in which he or she i. employed governs.
8. Anli.<fiscrimination: You are subject to a fine determined under Slale law for discharging an employee/obligor (rom
employmenl, refusing 10 employ, or tlking di.ciplindry dClion dgdinsldny employee/obligor becduse o( d support withholding.
Pennsylvania State law governs unless Ihe abligor is employed in another Stdle, in which Cdse Ihe law o( the State in which he or she is
employed governs.
9.. Wilhholding LimilS: You mdY nol wilhhold more Ihdn Ihe lesser of: lllhe amounts dllowed by the Federdl Consumer Credit
Prolection ^ct (1 5 U.s.c. 51673 (h)!; 0' 2) Ihe dmounlS dllowed by the Sidle of Ihe employee's/obligo,'s p,incip.ll pldce of employmenl,
The Federdllimil applies 10 Ihe dggregdle disposdble weekly edmings l^OWE). AOWE is the nel income left dher mdking manddtory
deduclions such as: State, Federdl, local taxes; SodOlI Securily taxes; and Medicare taxes.
10.
"NOTE: I( you or your agenl are served with a copy o( this order in the state that issued the order, you are to follow the
law o( Ihe state that issued Ihis order wilh respect to these items,
Requesting Agency:
DOMESTIC RELATIONS SECTION
P.O. BOX 320
CARLISLE PA 17013
I( you or your employee/obligor have any questions,
contact WAGE ATTACHMENT UNIT
by telephone at (717) 24()'6225 or
by FAX at (717) 24()'624B or
by Internet @
Page 2 of 2
Form EN-028
Worker 10 21005
serv:ce Type M
eM8 '-0.:0910.015"
(rp,rotllOllo..ll': lJIJI~O
-l-t
ADDENDUM
Summary of Cases on Attachment
Defendant/Obligor: RObERTS, RONALD L.
PACSES Case Number 411100010
Plainlifl Name
JOANNE E. ROBERTS
~ Allachment Amount
97-5994 $ 0.00
Chlld!ren)'s Name(s):
DOB
PACSES Case Numher
Pldinliff Name
Docket Allaehment Amoum
$ 0.00
Child!ren)'s Name!s):
Olf checked, you are required to enroll the child(ren)
idenlified above In any health In,uranee coverage available
Ihrough Ihe employee'slobllgor', employment.
D08
Oil checked, you are required to enroll the child(ren)
Idenlified above In any health in,urance coverage available
through Ihe employee'slobllgor', employment
~S Case Number
Plainlif( Name
~ Attachment Amount
$ 0.00
Child!ren)'s Name!,):
PACSES Case Number
Plalnlifl Name
008
~ Allaehment Amount
$ 0.00
Chlld(ren)', Name(,):
DOB
o If checked, you are required to enroll the child!ren)
identified above in any health insurance coverage available
through Ihe employee'slobllgor', employment
;.:--.-~'~i<:1_._f~
o II checked, you are required 10 enrolllhe chlld(ren)
Identified above In any health in,urance coverage avall.1ble
Ihrou8h Ihe employee'slobligor', employment
PACSES Case Number
PI.inliff Name
~ Attachment Amount
$ 0.00
Child(ren)', Namefs):
008
PACSES ease Number
Plainlifl Name
Docket Allachment Amount
$ 0.00
Child(ren)', Name!s):
o If checked, you are required 10 enroll Ihe chlld(ren)
idenlified above In any health Insurance coverage available
through Ihe employee'slobllgor', employment
o II checked, you are required to enrolllhe chlld(
Idenlified above in any heallh Insurance coverage av
Ihrough the employee'slobllgo,', employment
Addendum
Service Type M
0'-\81\0.:0970-4.1154
hrlll.lliotlll4ll': llfJ1~O
Form EN-028
Worker 10 2100S
',- t.: I ,"-.
. i ,-
) .-
. ;';.:1
, :-::i
, " ."'J
<
" i,1
l_ .. i'~
.,..';
-')
~-:j U
"
-/
In the Court of Common "lelL' of CIIMII.:RI.ANU County, l'ennsylvanla
O()~ml>"IC RU.ATIONS NY.Cl'ION
JOANNR B. ROBBRTS ) 1)II,;kcl Numhcr 97-5994
Pluhlllff )
VI. ) ,,^CSIiS eu"" Numhc:r 419100010/027210
RONALD L. ROBBRTS )
Defcnd.nl ) Olhcr Slulc ID Numhcr
ORDER
AND NOW, 10 wit, on this
5TII DAY OP PBBRUARY. ~001 IT IS HEREBY
DRDERED that the AI'I. Ilrder In this case be 0 Vacalcd or (i)Suspended or
OTermlnated without prejudice or 0 Termll1alcd and Vacaled,
effective JANUARY 19, ~OOO ,due to:
A OBCRBB IN DIVORCB, THBRB IS NO BALANCB DUB TIIB PLAINTIFP.
, \)
,~,.,
\ ",
(y\lt
BY TilE COURT:
XCi plalnllff
:Iefenlant
Jlltlth Calkin, P.llI]\llre
Keith nrelllll'lMn, P.8q\llIe
., '''' r!"l
.. ..~._. ..~-* ~
,-/l/c,
III
JUDGE
(
,
\. .
Scrvkc TyI'C M
Form OE.304
Worker ID H005
'- c:.:, ~
''r, lr.
'-;,..0
, '::j
-. .),<>;
.. .:;~
, '.
~:":" . -(j")
I .::;....
'., I"'-~
. '-ji'u
J.;,,/
l.. .i.1rl.
.
, '.:i
.:.:> U