Loading...
HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-06133?RNNIYWAI1111 )VOICIAa 011?RIC? NOTICE OF APP1Ak fRQM DISTRICT JUSTICg 4UDQm1jJT COMMO"PkNA1No I I L?L•??LGt . ^I? NOTIC[ OF APPAL Notice b given that the appellant hot filed In the above Court of eonin"I Pleas on oppeol horn the (udgmmml re0deled by the Dstrlrt hellcat on 014 dote and In the cote mentioned below -? --- _ . Wm or AM I Fmttl O/f Rt?fi?u7Ftf _7__ _ .P /' G>?!? (11Y l 7-f -r-'A'y nom V* Of oc GAVA "0 71 Cy 19 d .... WA aYA4-m7AMMB) 97 /M a 0, It A11751114119 N ,e?a,-;. p TNS a<k wl a signs O LY when 1 1t notation h required miler Pa R CP,IN Na II 1 llulit Was CLAIMANT (so0 at R.C,P,,I P• No, NI TNs tke of Appeal, when received by the D old Justice, will operole as o 1ODl f 0) In aCtlar) llalala Ul hlal 411811Ca, ha MUST SLIPERSEDEAS to the Judgment for possession In Ihit cola FILD' A CQMPLAINT Wllhlr) Iwanly (20) clays affor -- -u7rruiFrnr o7?T eiliuy >'ti ry iiy filloT his NQTICF ql AMEAL, PRAICIP[ TO [NT'Ik ROO TO liki COMp-LAINT A -b RUL TO SILL __._.- (This soctloo of lam to bo Usad ONLY whoa alw1faat was PFFFNf)ANT (SIM P), ff,C.P,,IfR Na. 100117) In aclim hofao Ulnhlr:t 'blsffca I NOT USED, dolacl) !roan copy of notlco of oppool it) 0a naval ulxv) aWWolloa), PKA[CIP[t To Prothonotary (jxkY/?rn r9 Q/u fet r?r. Z Enw We upon r?.G_al^_?Ya?? d file o cnmplalnl In IMs ophed _ / MYIU ry{iwIFnNXI ?? (Common Not No !f (Q / .15 ulLx ____ ) wIINn twenty (70) days ofWservlce of rule or suffer entry of judgrtuml of non pro? r /1 !$IIJIIM,XII r!/ nr.?MMnll ,11 1NX eleaXrw I// egseM RUI [1 To da// Ca r/aN LTAI/MdN /uh NO, ? ?sNe ?, f or V'q rln ' ?"' (1) You are nollfled that a rule Is hereby entered upon you to file a complaint In this appeal wllhht twenty (20) days after the dote of servke of tills rule upon you by personal service or by cerllRed or reglstomd mall. (2) If you do not file a complaint within Ihls Iimt, a JUDGMENT Of NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU. (S) The doh of Wvke Of INNS rule If service wqt by mail IS the date of molll Doh; sNlnnr r /1/ 1sMh, AM 312-M COURT TILE TO 13E PILED WITH Pnoi IIONOIAlly a PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND RULE TO FILE COMPLAINT f This proof of service h1 UST 0C rflFD WITHIN TFN ( Ill) UA YI> ATTFIi lump Iho nuhca of appall Chuck oppllcebllr fluxes) COMMONWOLTH OF PENNSYLYANIA COUNTY CF I sa AFFIDAVIT( I hereby eWanr or alflnn that I serval Q a copy of the Notice of Appeal, Common Plena Nv.- -------------..__. , upon the District Justice designated therein on (oafs of service) , lq_? Q by personal sorvico Q by (curtllied) (ruglatered) hall, sundor's receipt attached hereto, and upon tho appellee, (nanle).__.- .---• on 10____0 by pVrsonat service Q by (corllhod) (rugistorod) mall, sundur's receipt attached hereto Q slid further that Iserved the Pole to Fill) it Complaint accnmpanyhlgthe abovnNotice of Appeal bponthe oppelles(s)IQ whom file Rule was addressed oil _ _-.----, io__, Cl by parsunal sorvico Q by Icurtified) (rogistarod) mall, sender's receipt attached hereto SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND SUBSCRIBED BEFORE ME THIS -DAY OF --,1g-.-- sigealer0 Of offloal 001010 venom 41110ove was made rare of ofllolal my eommisslon oxillres on IQ-, Slonorura at offloor ij2 cr1 E 1 , N Q, r., r F, T r. F1 ? c h w 1+' COMMONWEALTH Q1 PkliNBYLVANIA q 7 - G 13 3 ?vr.wwr.wnnN 09-3-05 WNIm1. Hm RONALD R. K1•AIR #4*m 507 N. YORK ST. NRCHANICSHURG, PA rwp w. (717)766-4576 17045-0000 NOTICE OF?Iv?GiMENTITRANSCRIPT eeLAINTIFF MIMEUUwaEEu (HARRY GARMAN/OARMAN PLUMBING i HTN4 199 NOORRDALE ROAD CARIIISI.RN PA 17013 DEFENDANT; vs, MIME IM AGM11 60 IAR109be NARY -I 1451 I.UTZTOWM ROAD BOILING SPRINGSN PA 17007 L_ -J DNo.03 9/26/97 MARY EXPE I 1481 LUTZTOWN ROAD BOILING SPRINGSr PA 17007 THIS IS TO NOTIFY YOU THATi Judgment, _FO_ R RLAINTIFF D Judgment wee entered for (Name) BARgy 13A13MAN/naUAN PJAIM11INt3_i_._.__ _ © Judgment was entered against: (Name) _akTnP +, MARY In the amount or $ r. 3 o o s n on: 11 Damages Will be assessed on: [J This case dismissed without prejudice. E] Levy Is stayed for days or E] generally stayed, El Objection to levy has been Pled and hearing will be held: (DAteofJudgment) _JU/24197 (Data & Time) _ Amount of Judgment b? Judgment Coate Interest on Judgment {. Attorney Foos ZTOTAL { Place: I Time: ANY PARTY HAS +ia OF APPEAL WIT y MUy?SMT?INCLUD i (FI ? i iii I' oytl(y I7,1 this Ii "t%%PPEAL WITHIN 00 DAYS AFTER THE ENTRY OF JUDGMENT BY FILING A NOTICE 'ROTHONOTARY/CLIMRF THE COUR;OF COMMON PLEAS, CIVIL DIVISION. YOU , ?CI? TN?S NOriti¢t? d JUDO AEOI *WSCRIPT FORM WITH YOUR NOTICE OF APPEAL'" ?,;y.M. / , T , DleUfot JUetlde M1y1 , J MI, ,, 1 an correct 4bpy o twre ^tp? +salsinlirnJbe judgment, ;-- r--T?? '? g---. • DistrIck Justice a-t My commission expires first Monday of January, 2 AOPO3i"7 SEAL i i, I? X 454 741) 547 UB poolol sorvlco- ?eC4IPt for Cettlfled fulell o Ipso nca cavamgga pravldod. D nol solo Inlomsllonslrlo?ee foe m ?ldo,re-4 M, 0 poelope $ Cameadfee Bpadd Dogymy Fos Hasltlded Celvary Fos alum ????? blwwiny to Ra< ?? Date A TOTAL -' a 8 F 7 oaIm ar ele /INNITIVANIA NOTICI OF APPIAI, *V O 20MM011?LIM FHQM )VOICIAS plSillcl DISTRICT 14STICI 11.)DOMINT COMMON PS1AeNw NOTICE OF APPEAL Notke Is Given that the appellant has filed In ilia above Court of Common Pinar an uppeoi tran Ilia lWomont rendered by Ilia District Justlce on the date and In the case nwnlionad below HW OF 4- Lr. Z• 'fro _G..1YJ _ D /U-.2 Corr ?-n?nirtA??.?nrn•.r, tit 2 Pon z1fJif e /?? u / y (Se-w, , CY 19 n 0 Cv p?G/- p7 ,ltily LT 19- _-_?• _ ? _ J be signed ONLY w an this rwtallar h rsquha? ur>c?nr Pu R CA.1P, an This Notice of Appeal, when received by ilia District Justica, will operate as a S PERSEDEAS to the Judgment far possession In this case ,G "ALP If appollant was CLAIMANT (see Po, B.C,P,JP, No. 1001(6) In action before District Justice, he MUST FILE A COMPLAINT wlthln twenty (20) days alter -- filing his NOTICE of APPEAL. IN t71NN/IV??-?- P•(tAEf~IPO TO LNTRR RU I TO FILE COMPkAINT AND RUIE TO F111.1 MIS sectkrn of femt to be used ONLY what sppollnnf was DEFENDANT (sue N, n.C,P.JP. No. 1001(7) In action before District Justice. IF NOT USED, detach front copy of notice of ni tooal to bo served ufwn appolloo). PRAICIPII To Prothonotary IV c. rJ' Ga rilrn y ,. GnY"9ra 01 Enw rule upon l/ F 2 --1• r n oppellee(sJ' to file o complaint in INS appeal ?" / 1 n Nmsr ul IVYwrhnYnJ (Carman ftleaS Na - rn L 1 within twenty (40) days oil service of rule or suffer entry of Judgment of rm pros. n ? er r n sieraava of aW7elae ar tie of" of 000 RULM To rt// C4 o?/An), nV Ain atr./ r• )Prellensl• J? 9/- 66 `?/ Nerno el Grp AWs) (I) You are notified that a rule Is hemby entered upon you to Rio a ea olnt in this appeal within twenty (20) days ofw Ihe'dote of service of INs rule upon you by personal servke or by cot, Red or registered mall. (2) 0 you do not Rle a complaint within this time, a JUDGMENT Of NON PROS WILL BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU, (0) The date of service of this rule If service was by mall Is The data of moill Dee fan, 5 19_14 /din nc?? ? /?, • wu' ,. ' sww" or na p" AM a 10.64 COURT FILE PROOF OF SERVICE OF NOTICE OF APPEAL AND HUH TO FILE COMPLAINT Il I rhls proof of sefviae AMU HE Flub W) I'HIN I EN 110) 0A YS AF If It hhpu Me notice of appoalChuch applrcahlo holies) COMMgNWRALTN Of PIN144YLYANIA I COUNTYQI' cc Nc et,^r&!_kLt----...._ is ). AFFIDAVIT: I hereby swear or affirm that I served 1 GE a copy of the No11cg91 Aypsuh Cupmnon F'la?is No, Upon the District Justice dsslonated thergln or) Idele al sq/vice) !? Q.?.r_? by personal service 0 by (curtlflgd) (roglelored) mall, sepdar'e, receipt attached hereto, and upon thu appalleo, InomoJ ?_, on lq-,_....G by personal service [1 by (curllllad) Uoulstured) mall, sender's recalpt allachod hpre)q. f and lurthur that{ served the Polo to File a Complaint accompnnyloo hruabove Notice of Appeal Upon lhooppallea(s)Iew)ionl the Rule was addressed on - /?r_, 199 7, C1 by personal survlceDd by Icnrtlllod) (roglslored) mall, sender's recalpt attached hereto. SWORN (AFFIRMED) AND 8U08CRIBED BEFOPE ME THIS PAY OF l?Yi ?r7 ?2 Cam, ,? I/ ZZI-4 ?)w "7" SJgf1aIN/C el0lll?nl pl Nlun of ol!!a/el a?lofa whanVll/floovil walmag0 My valnmloolon on l IA ?L, j ? ti;. r 1I.dial lrli%7 ? ? ?i fJ „ r hY 'i P)I 11'1 MV I r HARRY CARMAN, t/o/d/h/a t IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF GARMAN PLUMBING & HEA'T'ING, t CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PLAINTIFF t 197 - 6133 CIVIL. Vol MARY HEIDEL, DEFENDANT i CIVIL. ACTION - LAW NQTICETQ DEFEND You have been sued In court, if you wish to defend against the claims act forth in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint, order and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing In writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that If you fall to do so the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the court without fbrther money claimed In the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the plaImIlP. You may lose money or property or other rights Important to you, YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER, OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Court Administrator Cuptberland County Courthouse I Courthouse Square Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 (717) 240-6200 AIUSrigllswith Disabilities Act of 1990 The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County is required by law to comply with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990, For information about accessible facilities aid reasonable accommodations available to disabled Individuals having business before the court, please contact our office. All arrangements must be mode at least 72 hours prior to any hearing or business before the court. You must attend the scheduled conference or hearing. BARRY GARMANp t/a/d/b/a CARMAN PLUMBING & HEATING, PLAINTIFF V11 MARY BEIDEL, DEFENDANT t IN TIE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF t CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA 1 t 97 - 4133 t t CIVIL ACTION - LAW t t COMPLAINT' AND NOW, this I8th day of November 1997 comes the Plaintiff, BARRY GARMAN, by his attorneys, Irwin, McKnight & Hughes and make the following complaint against the defendant, MARY BEIDEL, as follows. 1, Plaintiff, BARRY GARMAN, Is an adult Individual residing at trading and doing business as Garman Plumbing & Heating, 199 Mooredale Roads Carlisle, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania 17013, 2, Defendant, MARY BEIDEL, Is an adult individual residing at 1481 Lutztown Road, Bolling Springs, Pennsylvania 17007. 3, 1! The plaintiff discussed with the defendant entering Into a contract for the renovation of a bathroom at the defendant's residence as well as the rerouting of a sewer line to a second bathroom In the middle of May of 1997, 2 T 4. Th9 defendant hired the, plain?Ilfht mid May of 1997, 5, The plaintiff began his work on June 27, 1997) and completed the work as required by the defendant on July 9 and July 10, 1997, b, The defendant agreed to pay the plaintiff for his time and Twenty ($20.00) Dollars per hour In addition to the cost of materials used on the job, 7 On August 1, 1997, the plaintiffbilled the defendant for his work, a copy of which is marked Exhibit "A," s, The defendant relbsed to pay said bill and requested an Itemization of time and materials. That bill was the resubmitted on September 11, 1997, in the amount of One Thousand Three Hundred Thirty Four mid 01/100 (510334,01) Dollars, A copy of said bill is marked as Exhibit "13" and attached to the Complaint. 9 The defendant has refused to pay any portion of the plaintiffa bill for the work he performed. 3 10, The plahufff Is entitled 10 Interest on the outstanding balance duo for the work he perfonned for the defendant at the rate of 1,5% per month on the outstanding balance, WHEREFORE, the PlabriilT demands judgmcnt In the amount of Qne Thousand Three Hundred Thirty Four and 01/100 ($1,334,01) Dollars with interest at 1.5% per month plus costs of thlo action, IRWIN,1N1cKNIGUT & HUGHES By: ' More A. McK 60 W t Pom" tree' Carlisl ,Penns Ivarda 1701 Suprenne Court No. 76 Counsel for PisintifT', Barry Garman Date; November 18, 1997 ?.3h ,' 4 ; ,:;!I I I I Mi 1 I, 1 I I I I EXHIBIT "A" I GAR AN PLUMBING AND HEATING y 9ARRY0,OANMAN PNON1 199 MOOR1DAl1 ROAD (111) 243.4207 CARl1311, PA 11013 Glilupwl a __ Y -• I ' .. .. .. _. _. _ 1. _... -friMl,__ UI Ai_411 I6 __..i IMnUlll -_..--_. _-!:!1..1'.1,i1.__.1??_/..?.LL•?i_u;_-?A?__L1..S11t:1,.1 _.___. ?._. _._._ t _-.._..-L.r.l,.•_!r?__+-1__4'31 J.r?._;?f,.ls?_.__...-•--- - -- • , II I ' Soles Tax I Total I t y 1i.' EXHIBIT "B" in i GARMAN PLUMBING AND HEATING BARRY D. GARMAN PHONE 199 MOORIDALI ROAD (711) 243.4202 CARLISLE, PA 11013 ?r ME 2 ,. 4'' 4 ?. ? y" srYS" 1 y ? Cuv?t+r / .. Y x 9 r?-?.t 9o / Sat ? 2???vr / ,2 x 1 Ila 11-t WA Ovs I" 1.Qa I If,, pvc. ?yt°a p I/ C. P Vt- Tak& ta,E 97 /YS z. o b ?9s tis7 11 40. SO p .s? r6.z? ???: x.14.90 Tal''? L2?, u?, fib', t)p l I rh /o / ((a• vj _ o9b. Zo d , uq ! 7 s^ 5, 60 6,8 t . 9L H? ? 7 ? ¦ } ?vq so, J °I 2 MMf !. ?/ti I,rs. E{ c?, 4 1-0,w ? I rn? 5 y/y lff >< 't.o. Diu ? 115, v-o ?`?"t Io L ,,w 1/?1r?4u1,X touo 3ua,u.? i ' 1'D fR.9• ? ? sS, vU ?r91+r,.9•. 8 ? 7? 4a° it c, t k, 2. Z 1% 77QA?°r /./S- G A, .t, )o a x n t n-.a 2.n1' z_ dr C"e?u A30 ? IQ 3x 3A Ir, 7- 45" 3,ao / I p L 4r Fr 4-0 3 ?9?w7{[ 4 9s 3, 9p / 3 x t wya 9, ?u i? r" sr POW / f 3 / 1 ???. flMµ? Yr° 9 Y6, 9. 4?, Pve- ??lorn1 / nS' I, 4S 4oh / t l.s?l S'Pfl I 3F door ?.ts 2.91 -lot, 1.49 ' J y 4 n; ? ?6 U,,?Lu/ArmF.?{' NA?IK 7.?uj•'U ,C S I'?, v p ' l Z. X It) 1 7 xy )t$ / Orb r y x a sr....??P?`I w??J rn 99 ' / Y x 8 ?,.? u??• 10.61 44kA 3!IL Is ,r Li?w• I I ? ,;1 I F9sy rnA 'S_ ,?7 9y. 9/ /0s; ao J 99 9/ zQZ.91 ??7.91 The foregoing Complaint Is based upon information which has been gathered by my counsel me in the preparation of this action. I have read the statements made In this document, and It Is true and correct to the beat of my knowledge, htforntation and belief. I understand that false statements herein made are subject to the penalties of 18 pa.C.S.A, Section 4904, relating to unswom falsification to authorities, -?1ru?A1?RR G?----- Aatet Nov I t 91997 i MTIVIOATLItip xv 1, Marcus A. McKnight, 111, Esquire, hereby certify that on this date a true and correct copy of the Complaint was served by first class United States mall, postage paid ht Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013, upon the following; Mary Beidel 1481 Lutztown road Bolling Springs, PA 17007 IRWIN, McKNIGHT & HUGHES Date; November 18, 1997 By, ' Marius A. McK lip ,111, 60 est Pomfret et Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17015 (717) 249-2353 Supreme Court LD, No. 25476 Attorney for Plaintiff', Barry Garman ?A, 1 ? I I 1 ? ?. ?. i i i ? ? - ["1 ?? uD r,7 i. ?.', '-a ? i? ..,. ?, ! ? .. ?„ '? ,, ? },;? ". ? , ;.r. :i`? .: r, •, s;??j i „? ;. ,c- '-?'. -i-r I i I 4 If j I I r, -It l 4 {1{ t I iI I ' la.l I I t?.4 ?. i114i Ii JIU.? ( y ( ' { 1 11 (, 1' Y ,I r4 ( l I I r ? ' I I ..r 1. I 1 y S ) ? ,1 ?. Ig ?ll''r in r illl -?I' , d1, 1 1' I I I I II I tl 11',111 I I' 'r.I „' Ir I I I I', ,lyi 17 ` I ''r 1 1 I , '. I 1 'I .'1 1 ,5i,1 r l a r..?_ 11 l' 'r I iil' I Il r .. p ,v 1,is , { Vr I. " I 'I r , I r,l It ly110 f. f I ' I 1` r Ir 1 I , I I ?I ,( ?I Ij?? I,L} ,+ 1 1, I'. II I,1 I ` f151?1(I II , }i +4 irk", .f .l' t y' 1 ( , ( 'III , I I 1 Y, I I !,r 5 I IrLI F. .yN V1 r 11 'I' S 11 1 11 -`.,m a?'i I ry r t it -' r , I r .1 , I I ' i 1 ? ' I nl 1 I 1 ,+ 1? 511' ?/It ?15?°I if }. 166 I ' 1 I I r I , 1 I?? d t {r , 15 r .I I ' , 1 1 'i 1 II?,'1, I ?5 !p ? 1 "I1? Y ,5 ?I ' ?Ir 'I rl I 1 l , 1 ,11 , I I?.'?fl I 1{ I " ffr }} I ' 6 II, t ( I I , _51 + IIlf 1 {Il y? 111 r 5'? r„ ? +I ? I r 1 ? ' 1 , r, 1 ,1 Y 1 1 ,li+ .I. - r rl yl l 1, I) , ?" I` 1 1(' li II 1" r,l It 53.t 5' I 1( u i 1 ' ' I f ,1 r 14}'`?`?F ' 5}f( 11 ' III „ r II ) , II I y j1 I? , a f .1 !{'If I7 It rl 1. a II - 1 1 •III 14{ }t51T, } 11 f {1«f5'. it p l ,yf ,II1!{L5 ' 114 Ida ?„ ' I ''I r f.?r{r ?''t.5 ?:7 ftr,gll If is 1'{. I? .I{rl '1{z)?11 e?,lt ?f V. , j P )?I W l -III l5. 4, i Ilrl Ij '( rl, ' 1 ? I- I II ,I , II iII ', y115/9 5 ,1. fr 1, 1 1, I i+ 1 1 r, t III I '''1'?1-?fh?l?jj' ,,.?{IF 1'13' fil 111+, y I'. ' ,i '., ( 1 I r I I11 a i;jr 1??1'1 of r 1 , I II r :1 z 11 1y Yl II ? t y?` 5 I) II ? I a r 1, }I! ?,I I I ,l I i ( In 115, I ? ,?l,l??r}??I?S/?9 I I1 'I? 1? I 11 ?? ' '1' '' ' ?. l ''6 115r ,I ?d(rY 5,5 ,r I tltl If ? ( ,?, ? , r' rr I y ... I s ^? I n''y ?'lrrll? {1 u4??A?' ? ,.II FI I II ', I 11 54h1 1' l'tu ?r'I,u 5tt rt.'. I tl`'F 1 III II '1 It •I It?ll}', ,ir 1. 1111 r'1ii ???14:}u ; 1'rl I u }' I I 1 n I r 1 I I 1 , ?? ? 5?,y (i , 1 1I 1 , ,' ! ' ' , i I?4r ,Ir17y)l,}5„ i r' '.5 1 h 1 1 ,l 1 r I? I ({II,I r, ) r{)i 11r?5 1511y. 111 ', ., I'. 1,?-rIII r' 1 11'? r_IJ1560{'(}} 4?1},?yt ?. I rl ?'il{ I 'I (?. q , , I , 1'I„ ? 1 41 , 1 it r15? ??didl?Y 1 r C ? ?I ?f , r g I .II ? I? I , 1 I 1 I I '1? ?I a Jyl'-1, [,, 1??,? yy} 11 F, 1-.'I i ' ,1' I 1, II 1Y11 fll?pI?`?l ' II y f ?;I r I -I I ?! II t h41M?rK Sil r'11 1;_ i + I -i ,? r r fl I lr 11}t GA{II ?,'1 1?1''? II? I'I 1 11 ,.,1 +S??If ly1 'r , I ,, 5 I'} r!}? 17} I?,,, II . rj 41 'I ie 1 ,` s 657 ? ' I(,4! j71 III ! , , (T(f4 u 1 ' r ''I' ' 1 , I \ 't I _ ?, ? d ,1 ?) 1 1' 1 1 " A I ?'A l tt l}5 I I 1 1 ,?5?? t { I f"?41 1 y,a I' I ,,, ? 1 i - } 15 , 1 li I I 1 r: II r, 4} ? ,115 1,}(I IA1 iy?l 1 1'.,11 AI I'j1 I-. I'.r r :?jS l n ? II 11 '?Y{y' yS I('.w Il ?.ne r 1' . ' I I I 1,. 11 , 1 15. ' I///f//I AIi r //•?f/l?{i/i/ ?.`, i.?II/(?/fir} ? I BARRY CARMAN, t/s/d/q/a CARMAN PLUMBING & HEATING, PLAINTIFF MARY BEIDEL, DEFENDANT TQi MARY BEIPEL 1401 LUTZTOWN ROAD BOILING SPRINGS, PA 17007 Date of Notlcet October 30, 2000 I IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF t CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA t t 97.4133 CIVIL TERM t t CIVIL ACTION - LAW IMPORTANT NOTICE YOU ARE IN DEFAULT BECAU&E YOU "AVE FAILED TO ENTER A WRITTEN APPEARANCE PERSONALLY OR BY ATTORNEY ? AND FILE IN WRITING WITH THE COURT YOUR DEFENSES OR OBJECTIONS TO THE CLAIMS SET FORTH AGAINST YOU, UNLESS YOU ACT WITHIN TEN (10) DAYS FROM THE DATE OF THIS NOTICE, A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU WITHOUT A HEARING AND YOU MAY LOSE YOUR PROPERTY OR OTHER IMPORTANT RIGHTS, YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS NOTICE TO A LAWYER AT ONCE, F YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE'FQLLOWING OFFICE TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP. Cumberland County Bat' Association 2 Liberty Avenue Carlisle, Pennsylvania 17013 (717) 249-3166 (800) 990.9108 Attu The Court of Common Pleas of Cumberland County Is required by low to connply with the Americans with Disabilities Act of 1990. Por bnfornation about accessible facilities and reasonable accommodations available to disabled Individuals laving business before the court, Please contact our office, All arrongunnents must be made at least 72 hours prior to oily bearing or business bcf ore the court, You must attend the scheduled conference or hearing, IRWIN, McKNIGIIT & HUGHES C? ,- Nrcu I III; Req. S erne Court Lp, No. 25476 t) West Pon" el Street Carlisle, Pennsylvania 7013 Attorney for Plaintiff cc, Jacqueline M. Verney, Esq. b, M 47 v ; ,, X '? 4? i jl?ll = VI'?1 IYi 4II)?VI ? Onln II'/?i I/? ? Iltlll V?I'1 P.1IIII? ? . 11 'il l?+?IN?II -? I1? n' I uni,.,v? ? n ? r r i t? tl ?.' ?,i?' i . ?.. ? I it 11 ? ? ? ? I ?•I,? .u 1 III t r tr. l ) ' J ? ai .q tJl i IIARRV CARMAN, t/a/d/b/a t IN '1711? COURT OF COMMON I'LEAS OF GARMAN PI,UMIIING dk t CUMDERl,AND COUN'1'VoIlENNSYL,VANIA IlEATINC, t 1'labntiff t 97.6133 CIVIL TERM t V. t CIVIL. ACTION-LAW t MARV 1114,3 )1?la, t Defendpnt I NOTICE TO PLEAD 'I'Q, Marcus A. McKnf ght,111, Esquire 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, PA 17013 You are hereby notified that you have twenty (20) Jays In which to plead to the enclosed Answer and Counterclaim ofu Default Judgment may be entered against you, pate. 1I-13-61) k cg Ihne M Verney, Esquire #23F67 aA South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 243-9190 HARRY GARNIAN,1/u/d/h/u GARMAN I'L,UNJUING & IIIA'I'ING, I'luh?Uff V, MARY 111,d111a,, De1'endanl IN'l'llE COURT OP COMMON PIXAN OF CUMIII?R1,AND COUN'I'Y,PI?NNSVJ1NANIA 97.4133 CIVIL, Th:ItM CIVIL, AC'T'ION - LAW li2hW!''r,NDAN'T'I ANSWER ANI) COUN'I'h, tC AIM 1.3, Admitted, 4, Admitted In part rind denied In part, It Is admitted that Defendant verbally hired Plaintiff as u plumber to perform certain work at her home, At the tine of hire, the parties did not discuss connract terns, or at hourly rate. By way of turthcr upswer, Plaintiff Indicated duripg the mecthng In n1W May, 1997 that his brother, Brian was to perform the carpentry work at the Ionic; and that Don Westbrook would perform the excavating, 5, Admitted In part and denied In part, It Is admitted that Plui tiffbegan to work on the project on Junc 27, 1997, It Is denied that Plaintiff ever completcd the work, By way of further atswer, Plaintiff failed to complete the following work In u workmanlike manner a. fulled to remove'the cc 111119 pipe complctclyt b, failed to construct the commode platform to the specified six (G) Itches; a tailed to cover holes that he mudc; d, failed to center the bathtub; c. failed to anchor tub pipes; I" Culled to level the vanity top; g, fulled to strop tite pipes under the copmiode; It, fulled to seal cbtder blocks; 1, fulled to provide it cleat out; J, lulled to remove cunt pipe It wood thereby preventing hole lion) being sealed; k. !'ailed w remove old sewer line, [i, Denied, The parties never reached un agreement as to the hourly rates to be charged, 7. Admitted, U. Admitted In part and denied In part, Defendant admits t?)at Plaintiff submitted u bill it) Defendmu in the amount ot'1;1,33A,01, Delcndunt denies tint the work perforated by Plaintiff Is valued at that anwam and further denies the number of hours that Plaintiff alleges he and his personnel worked and that the hourly rate ehurged was ever agreed to, 91 Denied, Defendant is willing to pay Plaintiff a reasonable amount for the work he performed, but not the amount requested, 10. Denied, The parties did not enter Into u contract whereby u monthly Interest amount was to be Charged, WHEREFORE, Del'Opdant requests that Judgment be entered for the Defendant and Plaintiff's complaint be dismissed, COUNTERCLAIM I I ,I 1'1111 '?Ih 11, 'I'be answers to ptn'ugruphs 1.10 bereurme Incorporutcd by M. erencc us if the sume were more lolly net 1'arth Lit loath jivrOn, 12, As it result of the unworkmwilike manner lit which the Plaintiff perl'ormed the work, pel'endunt Incurred additiopul costs to repair and complete the project In the amount of$475,00. A copy of the bill is attached hereto us [ixhlblt "A" W1WRIE-FORF, pcrendunt demands judgment It) the amount or$475,00. Reppccttltlly submitted, pate, u q Il,,.c (/?^? - equ no M, verncy, )Esquire #231c? 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717)243.9190 Attorney for Retepdupt ' t K,Ql ?N I verlly that the sunements made In the w1thht Answer nod C'ounwrcluhn are true and correct to the best of Iny knowledge, hUurmution and bellel'. I understand that lillse nuuements horeln are made subject to the penalties of 18 Nu, C, S,A, § 4904 relating to unsworn Jbisilicatiop to nuthoritles. II Putedt /, . I/ . ) Mw' 13e1? L' 1 La- 'I s a ?I RIDSR'S CUSTOM WOODW, ONO C?L?J\? OUfl??, Ca/pent + Cabinetmaking L J ?. 9) Wlee Lane Bolling eprlnge, PA 17007 (. zrI m A-'I'mo' q 17 (717)950.3414 TO M Q- - 44 wig1 _1ZD, TORMS: ?WxN?k ?ry> ? J ?? -?iliplDl ?111'Tp'Y''+??GC• IMII I?}un[lUJll LU?f1NY1,M? I I CAY WORK I I CONTRACT I I EXTRA MI IM,WWII ?- 1+:A1Nl???? vI 11 MATRRMh ?? ?? . D lAj ? Coups ?,? O, a 47 't S PRI i.1 L CE o AM04 Et- T PRACRIPTION OF WORK ??vFlGu?et w4-re C sY7?M?.??u F>c?o?e AJ? rxw e- N H 6 j'b Ai*gt WA'/Frc C am- ?S1!R? 9kA4 MML1M?rT3 j 0& R I!+6 ?'at V pi" Y uJOov ei PA J & ?& - cu ?- a ca?r- MIS a$ L'I Ise, L TOTAL OTHER LABOR "Re. R??n AMOU t(T ,, DAT•DUMI4YI /D ' TOTAL MATERIALS TOTAL LABOR TOTAL MATERIALS 7 TOTAL OTHER Work ordered by SlpnNurn C TAX ,IrlWy.cAgN Jp.n••nm.nay.agNWialdup.wY.D.knD.nwmA, ^- - TOTAL ?- " i I hereby uertll'y 111111 u p-ue and correct copy ol'Ihe luregoiog Answer and Counterclaim Was served on the lullowbtg persons by Orst cluss US Mull, postage propuld op the date htdicuted; Marcus A, McKolght, III, Gsyuirc 00 West P0111(•et Street Carlisle, PA 17013 Date: Uucy hic M. Verney, Gsyuire 11237 44 South Ilanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717)243.9100 Attorney I'or child (,I I: I' I 1.. :. i. is I11:? I I 1/ ' , , d t, h i r II' , I II ?1r 1' 1 ? ?' ` l,(, I I r , ( r ?l? I 11 X11 . 1 ? '?? 1 P' ; 1 l 1:1111,, r L Ir II t t IF 111 I ? y - 1 I rl 11 ?I I'. I 1 I I 1 , til ?:?R'T , 1 1 '_ r lr J1 1, s? I I 1, 1 t 1 ( I i I , (fir,{ i r•. '?a ? ti14 r ' F 5 1 I II 1 I ilk I I i 1. I 1 r: I I { I I i q}I't\, I 1'I 1 f? IAr'j 1 I 1 I,{ ' ( i if ?1 IN 4 ,ti' nl"t 71 a 11 1 11 7 1 1 I ! 117 i { {iit(?14y{??p' ,1;k,f},111 ' I,i `i 1'ikl I } I- II 1 I I ?I 1 I ?:r {tl'?',{,, '?,,I ' p/t tti?i'44}I )',}' 1 ?ir j}t I+r 11' lr 12 f I f , AI ,, . r' 4 f f ? ?' ?.? l???tl?i''!}l?, ?nilr+r ?11 ? :'h I rf' I I I I 11 ?I rltr)i 1r ? l§/l?r ?4 fllr? A I , 41 Alk 1 it I ; q •I .C li 1.7 a H15 ???11 1i????' 'i ??Ifn"}r. J?'?SI }11'I 7!'??}l;l,?Slr l,j 1 I I? I, 7 I, I.-'. ' ?Ir r )11'i'1 ?rp(? ? A r ( WI. r } It r J;) I , r,l III 1 ,'. r ?,lIFI,,1(K7i P }?.211ir ,411! n llTill t t' ,?r a II 1 ,.,-1 r It vi ??} .7 Ytp?`f p-it IV?1111 i11?II1 ??1}I,IrI { I ?.I I , -?I I I r A 111{III III 'llil?? ?r? t.. ?', 5rq f I illt ?}' }I 1,?! 1} '1-II '1 r I lid ' ',1 I ? I Ir I r ? Ar ?r??r r-. [[ , Is irT °.lfV?i k". aAlily4 !i? , ,\II !'?f} Ile Ilr }, ?i1 11 In 1 I I'' i!'r r I (1i,114ri 14q Y A{?????1}?'?? ?}i1A?I FrV1?{I,tl} Ir A11 ?14111I ?,I l?rlll } ?7 1 I r i rl I ' ' ' 1 ' 1 r !r } ?r , 4., 7 r' I A1?1k, }?tFl ii/(' ?NI i t A r I,li I r.r 7 I I r j '`' II r I) 'P(44 } ll } k t?tl I il,I r?), 1 1 ' .. I 1 I I 1 ? '; 1 1 IvIV t'i:i ?1?+ \ ?iS?({j r y?sfi ?v}t,'A?1 ,}1) I sl I ?? ! 111 , I I e n ! I ', I I ?? I I'1{r,rl 1?1 '},A?vj ?,??`iPPI?? , { ???? }y r t tl ,ti it I ?? 1 s I qq? t ? i I ?' IJ I f r ll ;N I I F f Il??tII II,I}„ n f i !'?Il ,rr l "?I IY ?II a ,1 ' - 1 - (`, I I III: 111',1}{?y{F?T-ir r?rfr? I ??F}?ArT?I if °I+Iv} 1 61i? ''I li r Ilu ' I q 'j I ( I i i F , 11i, PT'-t)st'i?" 14 A' I 4`I r r t t a -' II , } l " ,. ' I , 4 r, , .Ili SI I \EI i ?t ))n? { ,F i 1 1 t f It f 11+ , ?.? I vP" t ' I ? y ., I r I' ? ?1 I!{jll j3 }!iA 1 f? +i ?(ji{tl{ !?' ' I 11' ! , I I , 11 , rAI}I 74q?(? i 1 1r 1 ?) Il lllr j ?'.I Illt? 1?;11t1'Yr(?ii J1CY1 ?. II?,J7 1{ IFI , 4 1 11 l ?r'' , I 1 II.F r'f'IIAA,,U/11 ?'1?t,{' i7., A \ j {v , p { F. , l l }4 ' f I I , 1 11.'1 1 I. I 1 I 1 ;i! ,11' ul 1111 l,l y 1 Y, ,rr?a F{ '?t 'F x }1 a111 'I ' \, ? r' r I` ( -.l I)1t?'?1 P Irj ?(t??jr(t(4lir?re l+l-'??A r ill{? 4 ri 1 .,I 1 ! ll r ' i 1 1:} ' 1 I ?r, ? ,1? ??I??y 1'}x Ill,fl I ? II I I I ' ' F ??j i t1i:, t ? r l t i F I JI I I ill`. 1 1±1 it f ll?l?'1 1? r i "+? fl t'1r I-I IFrli } ', ,I '- V 11 I'1f1AiG t:?,lt i llpt 1 I a n11 7r 11 '{ 1A ?'? ? II l ,,, I , I I , , Ilr I} + ' ?p I (j ?'f1tt+ }11Etti ?f'II 1! -`r I ,I} '' 11 I, I , ' ' r 11 Ili 1' lH it IAf lA r,}f1 ??111 Itb} ?'t Y?1A? 1 Illk A( ?i ! I 11 I ' 1 1 1 I r ', r l I' /1 Ck1 It H( I? 1 I; k „ I - 1 II Y \ 1 i? p l f? l r I t? l, k' I i l' , I( I , r I 1, t1 ,! 1. ?l;l +? r?{1 ?i11' ?r f' tl ' .I? I 1 { ???ur?h r rl_?A ?, \??, 1_Ir I'r / 't I. I I I I'?. I I I r I(1 ? INI{i / v\t' 'r r l '1 ?4 I: I I 4 1 r GA h ?41'f??!'??'?4?Ij?r}jl pllhl I I. , i n ' I _ ?? + ? A, Ill Aj IMF/yj) I llr? 7 {. Ill, ,.j I I II ,Pl ?{f???t?il? ? ,S?N,tY{1o??7A li,,{ll , , I , I I I 4, q nik t?t;?' 'R y?I 'V nA. .. . 1.. .(IMIAII: ??} \T IA4'},;4 `,,'?11'? R y, BARRY GARMAN, t/o/d/b/s t IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF GARMAN PLUMBING & HEATING, t CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PLAINTIFF t t 97 - 6133 CIVIL Vol t t CIVIL, ACTION - LAW MARY BEIDEL, DEFENDANT AND NOW, this 12th day of December 2000 comes the defendants by its attorneys, Irwin, McKnight & Hughes, and makes the following Answer to Counterclaim; III The averments of fact contained in paragraph one (1) through ten (10) of the Counterclaim are hereby incorporated by reference and are made a part of this Answer, 12, The averments of fact contained In paragraph twelve (12) of the Complaint are opegifleally denied, On the contrary, the workmanship performed by the plaintit)', Barry Oarmun, was more than satisfactory, The plaintiff did not complete the work due to the defendant's failure to pay for the work he had already performed, The defendant was only billed for the work he had performed, WHEREFORri, the Counterclaim of the defendant, Mary peldel, should be dismissed by the court and judgment entered In favor of the plaintiff, Barry Gannon, in the anount of Qpe Thousand Three Hundred Thirty Nino and 5011 Q0 (51,339,50) Dollars with interest as permitted by law and the costs of this actiop. Respectfully submitted, IRWIN, MCKNIGHT & HVGIIES By. Marc s eKulght, Esquire 6Q West mlket Strcet carlisle, pen (717) 249.2353 Supreme court LID, No, 25476 Attorney for plaintiffs Dater peeember 12, 2000 ¦ ,' 1 The foregoing Answer to Counterclaim is bused upon information which bus been gathered by counsel and myself in the preparation of this action, I have read the statements made in this document and they are true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information and belief, I understand that false statements herelp made are subject to the penalties of 18 Pa, C,S,A. Section 4904, relating to unswom falsification to authorities, A?,HARRIRARMA~?N ?~ Date: / ?. BARRY GARMAN, t/a/d/b/a t IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CARMAN PLUMBING & IIEATING, I CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PLAINTIFF t t 97 - 6133 CIVIL. vo, t t CIVIL. ACTION - LAW MARY BEII)EL, t DEFENDANT t CEUIFICATE QFrSERVICE I, Marcus A, McKnight, 111, Esquire, hereby certify that a copy of attached Answer with Counterclaim was served upon the following by depositing a true and correct copy of the same In the United States mail, First Class, postage prepaid In Carlisle, Pennsylvania, on the date referenced below and addressed as follows: Jacqueline M, Verney, Esquire 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 IRWIN$ McKNIGHT & HUGHES By: Macuu A, MeK t,11 quire 60 West Pomfret reet Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 249-2353 Supreme Court I,I), No. 25476 Datet December 18, 2000 i I i I i I I I ' 6J? • I ' I I I I I ? I i vl ?, wi Cr i!1?1, 1.1 I.11 I 4 it J. 1 ? , .. 1 ?1 ? ? "T 1 1 ? 1 UARRV GARMAN,1/u/d/INu t IN TIPP', COURT OF COMMON 1'1.[:AS O GARMAN MUMIIING 44111?ATING, t CUMIII?R11AN1) COUNTV,1'1';NNSV1,VANIA PLAINIIIF c t 97.4133 CIVIL, val t t CIVII, ACTION - L,AW MARV 1)kaA1,l„ t IMITINDANT t FTATE-ML,NTQI? IN'ITNTIQN 'I'Q PROCI:m) Tnc 'N'hc cunrt u1 Cglnnup? I'leua of Cumhcrlund cnuuty uud Curtly It. VouK, Nrothuuuturyc The Pluhrtlff, Burry Gunnar, Intends to proceed with the above-euptloned mutter, IRWIN Bye ultht,111, I~ 00 West Pomfret Street Curpsle, Pennsylvania 17013 Supreme Court Ia No, 25470 Counsel for Plubrtllt', Burry Gorman Dow October 24, 200:3 ?? i Murc ra AI McIC W rr ? •••? •. ? i{iviY.'r1L}',M DARRV GARMAN, t/a/d/h/a t IN 'I'Ill? COURT' OIr COMMON PLEAS c)F - GARMAN PI,UMIIING & IIk:A'I'ING, t CUMI03111 AND COUN'I'V9 I%NNNVI,VANIA PLAINTIFIF t t 47 - 6133 CIVIL Vs, t t CIVIL, ACTION - LAW MARV IIVII ELF t UVIFIENI)AN'I' t CERTIFICATE qr SERVICE I, Marcus A, McKnight, III, Esquire, hereby certify that u copy of attached document was served upon the lollowhtg by depuniting u true and correct copy of lbe same In the United States mull, First Class, postage prepaid In Carlisle, Pennsylvania, on the date relvrcttced below and addressed as IbIlows; Jacqueline M, Verney, Pscl, 44 South Hanover Street Carlisle, PA 17013 IRWIN & McICNIGI)' 13y. areas A. eKrtight, III, squire 00 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 249.2353 Supreme Court LID. No. 25476 Date: October 27, 2003 2 i 11 i 33j r m AS OF CASE# 16-A3-A006 1197- 0133 HAS BEEN SCANNED. ALL EARLIER FILINGS TO THIS CASE HAVE BEEN MICROFILMED. BARRY GARMAN, t/a/d/b/a GARMAN PLUMBING & HEATING, Plaintiff vs MARY BEIDEL, Defendant Case No. 1997-6133 Statement of Intention to Proceed To the Court: THE PLAINTIFF intends to proceed with thelbove captioned matter. Print Name MARCUS A. McKNIGHT, III Sign Name Date: OCTOBER 23, 2006 Attorney for Explanatory Comment The Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has promulgated new Rule of Civil Procedure 230.2 governing the termination of inactive cases and amended Rule of Judicial Administration 1901, Two aspects of the recommendation merit comment. 1. Rule of civil Procedure New Rule of Civil Procedure 230.2 has been promulgated to govern the termination of inactive cases within the scope of the Pennsylvania Rules of Civil Procedure. The termination of these cases for inactivity was previously governed by Rule of Judicial Administration 1901 and local rules promulgated pursuant to it. New Rule 230.2 is tailored to the needs of civil actions. It provides a complete procedure and a uniform statewide practice, preempting local rules. This rule was promulgated in response to the decision of the Supreme Court in Shop v. Eagle, 551 Pa. 360,710 A.2d 1104 (1998) in which the court held that "prejudice to the defendant as a result of delay in prosecution is required before a case may be dismissed pursuant to local rules implementing Rule of Judicial Administration 1901." Rule of Judicial Administration 1901(b) has been amended to accommodate the new rule of civil procedure. The general policy of the prompt disposition of matters set forth in subdivision (a) of that rule continues to be applicable. 11 Inactive Cases The purpose of Rule 230.2 is to eliminate inactive cases from the judicial system. The process is initiated by the court. After giving notice of intent to terminate an action for inactivity, the course of the procedure is with the parties. If the parties do not wish to pursue the case, they will take no action and "the Prothonotary shall enter an order as of course terminating the matter with prejudice for failure to prosecute." If a party wishes to pursue the matter, he or she will file a notice of intention to proceed and the action shali continue. a. Where the action has been terminated If the action is terminated when a party believes that it should not have been terminated, that party may proceed under Rule230(d) for relief from the order of termination. An example of such an occurrence might be the termination of a viable action when the aggrieved party did not receive the notice of intent to terminate and thus did not timely file the notice of intention to proceed. The timing of the filing of the petition to reinstate the action is important. If the petition is filed within thirty days of the entry of the order of termination on the docket, subdivision (d)(2) provides that the court must grant the petition and reinstate the action. If the petition is filed later than the thirty-day period, subdivision (d)(3) requires that the plaintiff must make a show in to the court that the petition was promptly filed and that there is a reasonable explanation or legitimate excuse both for the failure to file the notice of intention to proceed prior to the entry of the order of termination on the docket and for the failure to file the petition within the thirty-day period under subdivision (d)(2). B. Where the action has not been terminated An action which has not been terminated but which continues upon the filing of a notice of intention to proceed may have been the subject of inordinate delay. In such an instance, the aggrieved party may pursue the remedy of a common law non pros which exits independently of termination under Rule 230.2. Fq- r 4 ?u BARRY GARMAN, t/a/d/b/a : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF GARMAN PLUMBING & HEATING, : CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA PLAINTIFF : VS. MARY BEIDEL, : 97 - 6133 CIVIL : CIVIL ACTION - LAW STATEMENT OF INTENTION TO PROCEED TO THE COURT: Plaintiff intends to proceed with the above-captioned matter. Respectfully submitted, IRWIN & M#KNIGHT. P.C. By: Supreme Court I.II -.o: 25476 60 West Pomfret Street Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 249-2353 Date: October 27, 2009 ILTED-ORICE OF MOTHONOTARY 2009 OCT 27 PM 2: 48 CUM . _. UJUNTY PFNNXVANIA, Harry Garman, t/d/b/a Garman Plumbing & Heating ------ ?'laintiff Case No. 1.997 - 6l .33 Civil vs -_ _ _ -- t~ .? N CJ -q Beidel Mary --- -Q3 N ,..t ~ - - - Defendant d P ~OC3 Z~ {~ ~ , ~ r*3r-, - rocee Statement of Intention to z~ --t or-;..4 D ~~~ ~ ~ 1 o the Court: ~~ ~~ 'o ~ ~~..." -fin, ~ intends bo proceed ith the ab e captin The Plaintiff ~ att~p x~ r-~r-z, _ -__ __ - / ~ ~~ _. ca ~ ~. :~ J }Tint NameMarcus A. McKnight III I_ __ Sign Name - _ __ __ _ C Date: October 26, 2012 Attorney for _I'lantiff _ _ ___ _ ____ _ __ Explanatory Comment the Supreme Court of Pennsylvania has promulgated new Rule of Civil Procedure 230..2 governing t he tcnnina tion of ~nacti~e cases and arnended Rule of Judicial Administration 1901. Two aspects of the recommendation merit ~~omment i. Kole e~lcivil Procedure New Rule of Civil Procedure 230.2 has been promulgated to govern the termination of inactive cases within the ,cope of the Pennsyhiania Rules of Civil Procedure. The termination of these cases for inactivity ~+-as previously eoverned by Rule of Judicial Administration 1901 and local rules promulgated pursuant to it. New Rule 230.2 is tailored to the needs of civil actions. It provides a complete procedure and a uniform statewide practice.. preempting local rules. phis rule was promulgated in response to the decision of the Supreme Court in Shop r~. Eagle. 551 Pa. 3bd),710 A.2d 1104 (1998) in which the court held that "prejudice to the defendant as a result of delay in prosecution is rcyuired before a case may be dismissed pursuant to local rules implementing Rule of Judicial Administration 1901.~~ Rule of Judicial Administration ]901(b) has been amended to accommodate the new rule of civil procedure. hhe general policy of the prompt disposition of matters set forth in subdivision la) of that rule continues to he applicable. II Inactive ('uses The purpose of Rule 230.2 is to eliminate inactive cases from the judicial system. hhe process is initiiated by the court. ~\tter giving notice of intent to terminate an action for inactivity, the course of the procedure is with the parties. I P the parties do not wish to pursue the case, they will take no action and "the Prothonotary shall enter an order as of course terminating the matter with prejudice for failure to prosecute." If a pam wishes to pursue the matter- h~• or she will illc a notice of intention to proceed and the action shall continue. j. If'he~~e the uctiorz has been terminated If the action is terminated when a party believes that it should not have been terminated, that party nr<ry proceed under Ku1e230(d) for relief from the order of termination. An example of such an occurrence might be the termination .,f a ~iabie action when the aggrieved party did not receive the notice of intent to terminate and thus did not timely file the notice of intention to proceed. l~he timing of the filing of the petition to reinstate the action is important. If the petition is tiled within d~~irty days of the enU~~ of the order of termination on the docket, subdivision (d)(2) provides that the court must grant the petition and reinstate the action. if the petition is filed later than the thirty-day period, subdivision (d)(3) requires that the plaintiff must make a showing to the court that the petition was promptly fled and that there is a reasonable csplanation or legitimate excuse both for the failure to file the notice of intention to proceed prior to the enm of ~~ihe order of termination on the docket and for the failure to file the petition within the thirty-day period under subdivision (d)(2). 13. N'hc~re the actron l:as not been terminated An action which has not been terminated but which continues upon the tiling of a notice of intention «~ ~:~rocccd may have heen the subject of inordinate delay. In such an instance, the aggrieved party may pursue the rrmrd~~ oh a conun~,n law non pros which exits independently of termination under Rulc 230.2.