HomeMy WebLinkAbout97-06169
.
.~
q
"
~
.~
b
~
I
" :
~'\
'~ \
,~ '
d
,
, ,
"~
~
,
,
, ,
.....
;,t _
.~
..
c:J1 I
~
~
...,
~
a-
~
'I
n. ii,!
11:1:\1'1"
','I
i':
,'ii[.,
-j
Ii ",
; i~
I!'~
"I
'I
''1
"
"
,
I,
d
1;\
'! -)
"
~~~~ ~. 'X~~, ~.qui~,
Xde~titioatio~ ~o. 76717
O"JlO~~X Am> I\~~OCX"T~~ I JI. O.
1711 ~o~t~ 'ro~t ~t~eet
ijarri_burg, JlI\ 171Q2
(717) 9Q1-!l796
"'XCH~~lI~ 'RY
7251 U>>io~ Pepa_it Road
Hummel_town, pl\ 17Q36
v.
O>>~~O~~T "'O'l.'OR Pxvx~xon or TH~
qmnm~~ ~OTOR~ CORPORATXOn
0/0 CT corporatio~
1635 ~ar~et ~trQet
ppiladelphia, PA 191Q3
Attor~ey tor Plai~titt
,
,
,
I
I
,
,
,
,
I
,
,
,
OOlm'!.' 0Ji' OOmfO~ /ll~.AI'J
COtOO'Y 0' Ol1ml~R~ANP
Jlllllm$Y~VAifJ:A
oJ:vn OO~P~I\XN'l'
~AW PXVXSXon
no. t)'7~ tRl(P9dthl~
lI.oncJLm.J:llrllm
You have hooll nuod 111 oou~t, II you Wlnh to d.rond .U.III"\ tho olollllp P.t lo~tll In the 10lloWli'll
~noop you llIu.t t.k. aotloll "Ithi" tW.lJty I~O) dllY. alt.~ t Ii. complnillt alld 1I0tic~ .~e .e~Vod, ~y
l\t.'1119 . W~ltt.1I .proa,a,\o. p.o,.onallY 0' ~y atto~II.~ .lId liUI\U in w<lt11J9 \lit, the CoUtt yqu
.,O!'... o~ ohi.ctioll. to t '0 cl~iln. lI.t Iq,th ao.li,.t ou, You at. w.rn.d th.t I you ~.1l to do
no t 10 OllllO may llJ:oceed W~l: loUt aU a ,d j\J.dijment mB>, 0 <<mtol:tOd uaihl t oU p t II court. without
lu.'t ,e, notice 10' allY 11I0)\.1' ol.rllled in t1,. comPlnl'lt o. lor any USIO' cl.l~ 0' ~eU.I ~equ..t.d hI'
tho 'lolhtlll, you mAy lou. mOIl.y or p,op.,ty 6. Otle. .IOI\t. impo.tallt to you,
YOu I"OUJ,D TN<. TIIII MU~ TO YOU~ ~.~"T OllC.. I' YOU pO lI0T IIAV. " ~.~ O~ CNmOT ,...,O/Ul O~,
OQ TO O~ T.~nIIOIlJ TII. o,ne. u.r ,O~T" UJ,OW TO 'I/IP OUT WJl.~. YlJU elllf Q.r ~.Qr.l. ".~~.
e1tm~ .'gIm!:YII~~o~n~~lm~~~.
IT I UTAA~O. '
eU'I"~ CO., CO~THOUU
r.~~ ~"~~'71~.2t~.g.0
AVl/l.Q
f,.o hill\ dem,mult.do 4 unted Qll 14 co~tq, 131 unted qUiet:B d\lfe~ld~l:BQ de !!JotaD do BQt:OJf demand""
..p,I..tan all.. Eagtll.. .tol,I.llt.., uetod tie". veint. 12.} d a. d. pl.io al pa~tl. d. ia looh. d.
111 dlltmBndB ia lot HeBo ell. Haclt tnltll "DentRl: un~ cOlnp,1l:e~loilt. eDQ'rlta 0 on. PltrQo>>Fl 0 QOj1. un
AbogadQ y e tug r n la corto ''I' fOt:mB BI3CJ:itA DUd rJehnono .0 1l41J objeciqnOB " In demalldllJt i>>
OOlltto. dlt QU berDona, Sea avisado QUe 111 \Hlt:f;Id no 1)0 defiende, 10 Qo~t:Q l:oma):'B m8didil:f: y. PUtt' ..
cOllthlusr Is a.lna"d. .11 contra auya .ill p..vio avlao 0 lIotUloaclo/l, /Id.~s., I. cort. bue e ij.old r
nfavor d~l d~T8nda>>t:e y requierq qUe Uuted cUlIlbln con tod41J laB ~;n'ovlf,1ione.D de oDta deman A, Ust:ed
pUlldlJ );loJ;der d nero 0 DUB );lrol'iedodUIJ U oQtroQ LiQuchofJ impOl:tBntfJlJ para UQted, '
~~.". Ilr" P1m " UlI NlOaMO llIIl.PI~~.t ~I HO TIfo. NlOE 0 U NO ~11Il!lI .~ PIIlJlll)
eurxc2111T. P. , r"x. URVlalO, V".,,, . lOll. ~Lm. ~ ~ TaU, 0" L10 OPlCIH" OIlY" ll2~.COIOII
01 I"CtJIIITIlA UC~ r" ~I\JQ ~NlI\ "V.~IaUN< . U ~ .P. COKU aUIR ~ U'IIllClt. ~.cw..
~.~ ~.,.~~ I\lIP IH'a~rIOK I.~VIC.
COuaT lIDKIlfUr O.
CUHB.~~ OOUHT~ uaTHOUII
eNl~U~1 , 17013
UU~m)lf.1 '71 -2'0,62.0 '
. '
B~~ ". 'X~~, ~~qui~e
Xd.pti~io~tio~ Woo 75717
aA~OZZX ~ ABBOaXAT.a, ~.a.
1711 >>o~tb 'ront Bt~eet
ij~~~i.bu~qL ~A 171Q~
(717) 9Ql-5795
Atto~ney ~or ~lainti~~
HIOIJ.~~~ ,/ty
7251 ~iop pe~o.it /toad
ijumme 1. tow>>, ~A 17036
,
,
,
,
,
I
,
,
,
I
,
,
,
OXVXL OOH~~AIwr
LAW PXVIllXO/i'
~O. '11.(, Ii, 1 (!II.~I 0'-
OO~T OF OOMMO~ ~~.All
OOunTY 0' O~.~~ANP
~.Jfflll'J~VANXA
v.
alJ~VRO~ST ~OTOR PXVIllIO~ 0' THM
G.>>.~ ~OTO/tll OORPO~TXO~
0/0 aT Oorpo~atio~
163B Harket Bt~eet
pbilade1pbia, ~A 19103
QQlfP1.lAJ:1fI
1. Plaintiff, Michelle Pry/ is an adult individual citizen
and legal resident of the Commonwealth Of Pennsylvania, residing
at 7251 Union Peposit, HulnmelstoWl1, Pennsylvania 17036,
:2,' Pefendant / Chevrolet Motor Pivision of the CleneX'al
Motors Corporation' (hereinafter referX'ed to as "General Motors"),
is a business coX'poration qualified to do business in the
commonwealth of PennsylvanIa, and can be served c/o c'r
'Corporation, 1635 Market Streett Philadelphia, P~ 19103,
D/l.OKGROT.1NP
3. On or about ,June 11/ 1996, Plaintiff purchased a new
1.996 Chevrolet Truck G Van/ manufactured and warranted by
De fendant /
bea):'ing
the
Vehicle
Identification
Number
1GCHG39K9TF109630.
The vehicle was purchased in the state of
,
Pennsylvania and is registered in the commonwealth of
. ,
L'ennayl vania.
1\ , 'l'he purchane Jildce of the vehiole, inoludina
regiatJ:llt,1.on charges, document fees, salol3 tax, finanoe and l:lanlt
chnrge/il pllt, excludip\il other oollateral oharses not aped fied, yet
dl~fined Py the Magntlson-Moss /i'ederal /l'rade Comlllial9.lon Improvement
",ot, totaled 11\0l:e than $:2:2,000,00 A tl:ue and OOl:reot oopyof the
Salelil Agl:eel11ent il3 attaohed hel:eto, made a part hereof and marlted
as Iilxhibit 111\."
5, Plaintiff averl3 that as a l:esUlt of the ineffective
l:epail: attemptl3 madlj1 py Defendant and its authodzed dealer, the
vehiole cannot be used fOl: the purposes irtended l:ly Plaintiff at
the time of aoquisition, as l3uch, th,e vehicle h worthleaa,
6. In considel:ation for the pUl:chase of the above vehiole,
Defendant Genel:al Motol:s issued to Plaintiff aevel:al wl:itten
warranties, inoluding a thl:ee(3) year, thil:ty-a.lx thouaand
(36,000) mile wal:l:anty, as well as other standal:d warl:anties fully
outlined in the wal:l:anty boo)det, deli vel:ed at time of sale.
7. Plaintiff hUll delivel:ed the non-oonforl11ifjg vehiole to
an autlJod.zed sel:vioe and l:epail: facility of the manufaot,ul:er on
numeroull occasions. Aftel: a reaso11al:lle number of attempts, the
manufactul:el: was unable to l:epail: the non-conformi ties,
a, Tbe first l:epail: attempt il.!l beHeved to have ocou;rrep.
on 01: before August 11\ I 1996, when the vehicle' a odbn\eterread
3 I 060 miles. On that date, repair attempts W~re made to the
9. 'l'he f.llJoond reh?ail:" attempt ia pelieved to have Qooul:"r.ed
on or pefore October. 21, 1996, when thq vehiole'f.l odometer. showed
5,504 miles. 010 that date, rerair at temrta were made to the
vphiole'a detective pralt~fl, whioh were 10cl<1ng U)? on the road.
'rhe vehicle Was also sel.'viced fOI:" front end alignment. 1\11'10,
repair attempts were made to' the vehiole's defeotive rear tail
lam)? 'rhe vehiole waa servioed for an oil and filter change. 1\
true and oorreot copy ot the repair invoioe summary if.! attaohed
hereto, made a part hereof and Il\ar~ed EJxhibit lIe."
J' I'
vehicle'a deteotive h'ont and side mirrors. I\t this time/ the
vehiole Wlif.l I'le~'viced for an oil nnd eiltf;lr cllallgf;l. 1\ trUe and
con-oot oopy qf' the ~'e)?air invoice aumll1u):'y ia attaclhed hel:"eto,
made a part hel:"eof and ma):'jtsd n:xhibit 1113."
I'
10, The tnil:"d repah: attelllpt ia believed to have ocourred
on 01:" betol:"e Peoember. 12/ 1996, when the vehiole I s odometer ahowed
8,758 milea, On that date I repair attem)?ta were made again to the
vehicle's detective bl:"akes. The brake light a Wel:"e on oontinuously
and the bl:"akes were looking up again on the road. ,'I'he vehiole waa
serviced again for its defective right side mil:"l;'ol:" , The vehiole
was also ohecked for rear end noise uj;lon aooeleration, The
,:,ehicile was serviced for a window/body panel leak and for an oil
and filter change. 1\ true and correot copy of the repair invoioe
summary is attaohed hereto, made a part hereof and marked EJxhibit
,I
"01"
11, The fourth repair' attempt ia believed to have oocurred on
I
'I
II
. '
Ot' lJeCot'e MiJro/1 'I, 1997, when t.he vehiclelu odometer Ilhowed 14,111
mUes. On that date, t'epair attempts were made to the vehicle's
r,leCactive radio. Also, one wheel cover wap sel'vJ.ced. '1'he vehicle
Wllll sflrvioed Cor an oil and Ciltel' change. A trUe and oorr,ect oopY
is att!johed hereto, made a part hel'eof and marJ{ed IJlxhibit IIJJ), /I
14,
subjact
In addition, Plaintiff avers her vehicle haa been
to additional repair attempts for defects and/or non-
12. l\ fifth repair attempt is believed to have ocourred on
or before March 24, 1997, when the vehicle' p odometer shOWed
14,751 miles, On that date, r.epair attempts were made again to the
vehicle I s defective ,radio, The vehicle was servioed ~or a lolown
lighter/dome fuse, TnE! vehicle's engine was running rough and it
had a hard to start condition, l\ tr.Ue and correct oopy of the
r.epair invoice !Iummary is attached hereto, made a part hereof and
marked Exhibit 1\1i'. /I
"
,
13, l\ sixth repair attempt is belJ.eved to have ocourred on or
before September 10, 1997, when the vehicle's odometer showed
26,124 milE!s. On that date, repair attempts were again made to
the vehiole'S lorakes, The sensor was replaced and Wiring ~nd/or
the connector was found defective. The vehicle was again serviced
Cor the window leak prololem. A trUe and correct copy Of the
repair invoice !Iummary is attached hereto, made a part hereo/: an~
marked Exhibit 1\0."
. I ,I
confo):'mitiel3 and/o):' aondit.ionu fC)r whLch tho deale):' did not;
mainti'lin reco):'da.
15, Plaintiff fu):'ther avera that aho haa ):'eaorted to Better
BllaLneas Bureau's I\uto LilJO I\rbitration J;l):'ogram (Blla Auto Linel,
J;ldor to fiUng the within comJ;llaint as required by the Magnuson"
Moss I\ct. 1\ true and correct copy qf the BllB'S rej ection letter
is attached hereto, made a part. hereof and marl<ed 613 E:xhibit \l1i.1I
ootlm' I
~QnvQOn.MOBB CLAIM
16. Plaintiff herebY incorporates ~ara<;JraJ;lhs 1 through 15
by reference as if set for.th at length herein.
17, J?laintiff is a "Consumer" as defined by 15 U.S.C,
~2301 (3) .
18. Defendant is a IIWarrantorll olS defined by 15 U. S. C.
~2301 (5) .
19. By the ter.ms of the eXJ;lress written warranties referred
to in this Complaint, Defendant General Motora agreed to perform
effective war):'anty repairs at no charge for parts and/o):' labor,
20. Defendant General Motors' authorized service faoilities
have made attempts on several occasions to cOl]1ply witl1. the terms
of its express and imJ;llied warranties, however/such repair
attempts have been ineffective.
"
21. An a di recto and proximate remll t of Pefendant' J'l failure
to comply with the eXp~'IlJHJ wdtten warrantieJ'l and implied
,wan:anti,es, Plaintiff hal'! J'luffe~'ed damages and/ ~n acoordance witn
15 V.S.C. /i231Q(d) 0) / Plaintiff iJ'l entitled to ):J):ing suit for
suon damageJ'l and other. l,egal and equitable relief,
22. Title 15 V.S.C. provideSJ
If a conJ'lUmer finally prevails on an action
brought under paragraph (1) of thiJ'l
J'lllbJ'leotion/ he may be allowed by the oourt to
recover aJ'l part of the judgment a sum equal
to the amount of aggregate amount of costJ'l
and expenJ'les (including attorney feeJ'l based
upon actual time expended), determined by tne
court to have been reasonably incurred by the
Plaintiff for, or in connection 'with tne
oommenoement and prosecution of suon action,
unless the court, in itJ'l diJ'lcretion shall
determine that suoh an award of attorney's
fees would be inappropriate.
23. Plaintiff avers that upon sucoeJ'lsfully prevailing upon
the Magmlson-Moasclaim herein, all reasonable attorney fees are
recoverable and are demanded agaillst Defendant.
V/HElRE:FORE, Plaintiff respectfully demands judgment in her
favor and against Defendant in an amount equal to the purchase
price of the subj ect vehicle / plus all available collateral
charges and attorney fees.
COUNT II
UNIfORM COMMERCIAL CODm
24. Plaint! f f hereby incorporates paragraphs 1 through 23
, ,
I
I
'/
by ~'eferenGe as if set forth at longth herein.
215. 'rhe defects and 110n-confot'mitias existing within the
vehicle constitute a breach of contractual and ptatutory
oblil3ationp of Defendant, including but not limited to the
foJ.1owing J
a. J;;xpreS/9 Warranty,
I:l. Implied Warranty Of Merchantal:li lity, and
c. Implied Warranty of Fitness ror A Particular
Purpose.
26, rhe purposes for Which Plaintiff purchased thi/9 vehicle
inclUde but are not limited to her personal, family and household
use,
27. At the time of this purchase and at all times
subaequent thereto, Plaintiff hall justJ,fiably relied upon
Defendant's expresa warranties and implied warranties of Htne/9s
for
particular
and
implied
warranties
of
purpose
a
merchantability.
28, At the time of the purchase and at all times subsequent
thereto, Defendant was aware Plaintiff was relying upon
Defendant's express and implied warranties, obligations, and
representations with regard to the subject vehicle.
29. Plaintiff has incurred damages as a direct and
,
,proximate result of the breach and failure of Pefendant to honor
its express and implied warranties.
'/'
I I ,I
30, Suoh damageil include, but are not limited to, ehe
/?urchafle /?dcfj of the vehicle pluil all collateral chargeil,
including attorney feeil and cOiltil, ail well ail other expenileil, the
full extent of whioh are not yet 'mown,
WHS~SJi'ORr.;, plaintiff reilpectfully demandil judgment in hex'
favo~ and against Pefendant, in an amount equal to the purchase
price of the subjeot vehicle, plus all available oollateral
oharge~ and attorney fees,
OOom' HI
Qn,AIR TRAD~ PRAoTIomp ~ oO~~UMmR PROTmOTION a~AIN
31, Plaintiff hereby incorporates paragraphs 1 through 30
by referenoe as if set forth at length herein,
32, Seotion 1961 "If :JjJe Penl1sylv<lnia ~utomopile Lemon ~aW,
provides that a violation of its provisions is also a v~olation of
,
'the Unfair Trade Praotices and COQ~umer ProteotioQ Law,
33, In addition, the Unfair Trade Practioes and Consumer
Protection Law defines unfair methods of oompetition to inolUde
the following f
(xiv) , Failing to oomply with the terms of
any written guarantee or warranty g.i.ve,n to
the buyer at, prior to, or after a oontraot
for the purchase of goods or servioes is
made.
34. Plaintiff believes, and therefore avers, that the
reckless, wanton and willful failure of Pefendant to
oomply with the terms of the written warranties
., ;
, '
, ,
constitutes an unfair method of competition,
35, Seotion 201-9.2(ai' of tho Unfair /rrllde Practicel'J and
Consul1ler Protection Lp.w, authoriiilos the Court, in its disoretion,
to award up to three (3) timea the actual damages sUlltained tor
violations of the net.
WHIilRlilFORS, rlaintiff respectfully demands judgment in her
favor and against Pefendant in an amount equal to three (3) times
,the purchase price of the s~lloj ect vehicle, plus all availalole
collater.al charges and attorney fees.
,j
a.'o'~,~, ,.'~ATSSI P.O.
aYI /S~(~. ~MAN' S~QUIRS
nttomhey for plaintift
1711 North Front Street
Harl'ispUrS, pn 17102
(717) 901-5795
II I'
v ~ R X , X a A T X 0 ~
I, Miohelle 'ry, verify that I am the Plaintiff in thi~
aotion and that the I'ltatements made in the foregoing Comj;llaint are
true and ooJ:t'eot to the best of my ImoWledge, information, and
be~ iee.
I understand that any false statements made herein aj:'e
subjeot to the j;lenalties of 16 Pa, C,S, 94904 relating to unsworn
falsification to authorities,
~
I /}'/ ( 1/ / / Cj/
--I-I~'~v::-.,fU-, ell (,.-z ? V
Miohelle Fry cj1
" I ,.
~AKU1~ ~. fX~~, ~.quire
XdllntiU.oal:io~ ~o. 757 J, 7
OA~OZZX Aijp A~~qOIAT.~, P.O.
1711 ~ortb front ~treet
>>a~ri.bur9L PA 17102
(711) 901-5795
/'JXCJ"JIl~~. II/ty
7251 unio~ Papo.it /toad
HUlIlIlIehl:own, PA 17036
v.
Attorpey for Plaiptiff
I
, OOQRT 011 OOl'JHO~' P~~A~
I OO~Y Of O~.~~Aijp
, P.~~Y~VANXA
,
I
I
I
I OIVIu OOHP~AXNT
I
, ~AW PXVX~XOH
,
,
I li'0.
JURY ~RIAL DEMANQ
O>>.~OH.T /'JOTOR PIVI~XOli' or TijJll
GSnERAL /'JOTO/t~ aORPOItATIOH
0/0 aT Oorporatiop
1635 Hark,t ~l:r..1:
Phil.d.lp~ia, PA 191Q3
TO THE; CLE;RI< Of COURT I
,
~laint~ff he~eby demands a trial by ju~y in the above-
captioned matter,
,I
"
I
,}I
OAPOZZI AND A~~OOX~T~~, P.O.
/' ,; /
/::/<:./ .if.;' ,
...----/ , , ,~/ '
/' /,~,/.',
BYI ,".', '__
,'SJ\MU);)J:, B ,"").\'INE;MAN I J;)SQUIRE
Atto~ney for ~laintiff
1711 North Front Street
Ha~riaburg, ~A 17102
(717) 901-5795
'.'1""--"
......<;0
Lawrence
"P I
....
UHmmlt
CAU,I",II(i1,OI't)MI
lJM>'" 1<10/1 flNll
,lIP, ,\ l. 10
11/10111I 7011'O~Il<l GeeD
IIllljf PIIl"JrINll
III "11'1,1 I{ I '!'Y
li11l111' ,
f J'III\II,jf' iii III,I~I:"'I' /lI.l/ld
i'lIl !"~n
11I" ';'11 ,11'1\ ~"I
I ::~:; I II
\11
1111 'I I/;r
lWIII'1 PAC/'^' '"
,II
I nl III
.
!'A1tl I hi AI Alii
INll
PlIltlll
litH.
"11/;1
I Alii ",: '11111I111
"
I
"
oFIWICI; CONTn/lCT
1")11:
I'/U I,
.
LI IIliCL^IM~11 01 WMII^NI~n '
~lIllliIJUI'"IlII,^r \'0111 ~' ~~'L~'l Oi'lliUm ~15CI'IM m ~""';tH/IU, "I'ill
~IIJle$ 1J1l1~Pll .INellJ t) ANY 1'~lIiU ,\)1 tANh \.'J ~l!'lt;tl'" ~DIUtY llfJltJ~n~
n I ".21l1'CIILM/P.I/III'OIf, m III~ YIjI/'~1JI11 I 'h~lrMI '''''''~ I/QI',~" ~~IY OJl'I'"
Ilh.lH t 'MHilj~i; "OIl IIMJllIty I ,utjN~{;"llltl Willi lItl,: ,.f,l ()~ n.,
~ll1cLI' t>~/I'I '" 1111"f1P,,~ ~~~VIII~~ III WI~"L ur '01' 'N '" M1w,luNI rll ""Ii
otjtll.Al; IlJn W ~ IJOCL,/.,IH;~ m.rt1omuu to Mil WH~rl 'Il~ YIHjICl~ II; I)~\ Iv/;,lI'l)
r)""BIt)" I
JIll' ~~Olljll YUllf':~~ 15 l\OlU 'AtS 16" WIt/lOUT A~Y W"'IIt\,'ltil) IIHII"I 1;).pnIHlli 1;11
I~WLI~I)' 11W I'lJIlC'IAUIH1 'hll~ 11P."'1 ni~ ~IHlllI{ Ullll~NtU: O/' 'I~P,Alllltll\ nil l'tHlI1I!'Ctll"1
~UYnu"r(;18111'" "IIEbl'fHLY 1:~lbl 1"11 HI^t t~,..y ncr.:UI\lH fll': vl'lllIll
.,'l'
'''IN 'Ii 1:'.--' 1
---~-~~
I
.'.,111
,,I,
I)I.:l',;I': ~ q",:I ,llll .' t .. '1(1/ L.i:,
r,;lj~ lll/ilUn l.i1l1t,,\'IIII~ )C
Ulllw !JIll 1I.llhHII ";11 ,'mlllllUl' III ~.i 11111,'111\ 11'1' 11111 Ill'rllm (llItl' lIl,1 1117i1''- 11l111J 11I11 P'IlH III
plllllNl!I .1e)IVIlI). Ihll /lUI"I,ll Ill" .,1 .1I1~ ~I 111111 nlll I,'tll)'," II iii 1111' IIltlllll UI ~,lIl'll ;.. 11\01111'
l't ,. rl'III' P.. ,/111., III II 'Inllll> 1I111'n,,11 ,,' . 1"1 '11..'011< 1"'1,111'11 \/,111
rfl)iIIwl"f/ 11\)1111,," IInlllll I)' Itl!. ll.ulullllIllll!hlllllr limit J/lII 1I""II,m 1r''''II' 01 Um hhnvll lIh1rlll
1:11I'1>. ....-._lIIOI:'lhl~ll,llrl', _f
L;l,I.hHIUH~I~.
II ~lllll:IUh'ulllll~ "II/elltlbl' nUlIlllIIllllll1lt 'Illrhll III 111~lIl'lillvllI) IJI 1111/ Wllldu, 111111111,/1/. lI~lIlpl
I\KI)jmltlth/llhvtlw,~III'l.liilll.PIIJIJI 1II/IIllIl,h.llhlllllli IlllllhltlU~
, UldIH~'" '\l)lilh~ 1I1:~UI)~h"'llllh rl) Ihb PU<)yll C 11111111
ClIthmllU l61 Hlllunl X .._...~ ~..
Purchn,or nu,o/1I1 "HlI IlIln 111111" IlIcludul; 1111 ullllO IU/IIIU "nd ':U/lllllIUI" oil
bUIll UIII /,It,:U lUll' JJfYlllf\1J ~jrJlJ hU/oo/,'ItHU lhlll mdm CIIIIL:IJIIJ ilmJ liLll~lJ'UOd;'1) ;!
lIt1y ')/11,)' !IUIIlll/MIlI nnrl ~Ii nl thl) flll~n Im/ll,,1 \;U/IIjllllinu 1111) CtllllphJl11 nllll
o,ellllll,V n ~11I","IIU,'III,",' ,IIIU ','iIII'" '" ,lu,uullllmllUlllll/lu "I mn ',u,~,I',j~'I, '~IIU',i
co,u,o" ho",~V' f/llo "'!,5! ,Ah/)III,I!') ~V.cUl.'"1 ~IMIIIU u!)lll II~enplu~" !no
~~,n'P!, ,Ul./!I! UUI'PllludIU)!!u'OllllllIY9; 1"111,11111 hllVUI mlly c,lnen,' 'hI! :1 "'AIlIII.
~'!!IIIcl II11~!I"U!Y!"..'.' .I.ull, ',ol"nd .II'V IIll1u..~,'!'u!U,IU"!ilPI .'1, ",I!',?PY-"!Jiln-"'iAiiu];6'W'liii'f,-j
cUllilnel n'o''''" hy Oil o~lhorllu" dUlllu, ,up/oou'IIOII," ~y ,,!Vln,) Wflllllll Lnlll
iifij)~9,11';;nl)h91!!)II'lIi"I;i'i)io'/hj'lll!I, Plllchnnul IlVhls 'O,UOIIIIUII 01 illls 'n1~UI
Oe~IIO\'lludguo Ihol hll ho, rond 110 IU/IIl' .lIld COlldlllllllU "lid hn' rocolved n t rorAL 1I0WN '/AYMf.NT III' J)
Irun copy ollhl' Oldo" A UNI'AIU IlAlANCf.or CA6111'1IIl)f.11 .. ,II
~)%~~~"~{~Y,.~;R,~~gEtt~pA;m~'!_,,!,.~z'l!,,,
'CCaPfan ""I' ~,' . - ..~.. "'f ' U/lJ'('" .', I ", ,
~:"".__..,_~.I!.J .. 1m,,1 , ~,."ni)fii~Jrll'""i~T'!II!lf'h':-',:~'~::' ..
; , . ,GO JlIAO'~AL 6TMf,M 'NT
Th. In/c:umoUon you IUtl) on I ~lnlJUW hmn h>r Ihl~ yuhl~hj III plllt 1)1 lI\fl5 t:onhnr.1: ,nhm
1,,\11111'/\1(:1
q, . I
I"
'''1'
'. ".,
, I'.'
I^.
'.."11.1\1
111'1, hI
l>l)~,IIMI tllMly H.f
,,!!I}~iI_ '
llej'/I!II: hl)}j'!)il'l- 'i'ii'Li~ .
',,\'!,,\ '1"',';'1'1' L';,;I,'
11()""'l-r.:J\IiIIPIUCfllrllvt!tH"ll
I'A II/If. rAX
. .ji~lu6inA',i(m--'.--
L, lilli,,,, ..'
..- --,., h~
1':.Alill
11I)W~1
'lil'I'MUil
.
Ill'I'I)!;ll fl/jllillllll
l ~ III ~ I . t i I
.~.-.~.-
..'.....-.
,1')'\", ,I
,', j~i\"Jh'
-.... -'
'..A'il'IINI1HI'lfll)'
.~ \, .: \,.; t \
/,,1)\1,
,"HI. III
,(, .1,1'1 HI
I
,
\,
'I', I.;
PLAINTIF~'8
EXHIBIT
~
11'11;
.........--
II' II,
tjl ii,
un~ conllllr)! p,oYJalonl lit Ih. conl,.cl 01 ~"I'
H ... .......:.~ ~ . - - -,
No. 7570106
..
,...... ','
...,'.---.
CO'I\J"CIJi:~r
~
__ MI('II~',.I~
I' umU -
t HOI" "', ~~mJ'~lIuw-~rP~ II ,IU WUIi~ foIl()V', i '" "oc1<TiPto ~,6i:i< lij CI,lJ~~
' m" WiLL UilU~IlI~ X4':WH:.!\'J! I CO~~ ' , '
JO~.t.~HAH/~IJIWIWII ~ aUj~\'OIl8"ij> .' 'jJWHU IH COMMoJ1L, "
~'O k~rMWiU~W~IO 1I11~~. a! " U d ~~it~(l~~fllii'Bh',~WfJ:~~)rr~l~f'~
HOli' ~ IIliV'"ICLJiIAUiWjUIJ!/IliU,Clie~ IIIIUU~OC~ 0 ,lfU~OC~laClliC~'U,COMl>llli ~umloClI/Oj1~~V,/l. .,
~ Q,-, 0 ~~~'lmKw.ta'~'k{ra~~~~~~ O~II'tf:,~Yill OQO /1~ IlL:'
II J,iili/olli IfON~~~N' " ,
\'jl/1NINU ~ WAtCOI~~i Mmll a)!liMiNI~~N<i \'llIJ u.IIl.O./OIIIlMlALliU 10 \'001'
I ~af III ) ,JQI'ot.\ 01' II I~Yif.CL!IN.OIW~l1cltMHUOII" "
, I . .., ,
o IUI \IiN D~", ~ N IJiH, C IIC~ Wi O^,
M I'UI iJ'H'!OI.D111 Wi
~ ulllm er~1lT
ell' UI~" liP CIIV
MN<i 01' Villleli lIilllO.. \'IH , ~1I129l.1
1lO0V 1\'I'l!IUOIUOlJ, l~~,for " ilil1l5,jiif\li],iCLi .
ill """aiHDil1 10 W"OO~iNiO 0
vn HO
\'18 NO
V
CII\'
UI^,'
.
. .
'"
lIP
,,' ;',~t' '\
/."\-,",:',"-"""1
IWllfil1
/,
U
mlll/Ili
f'W;.c'IIIHI
..t,' ;,", \\,
~>f ~. 0,
d,.
.rR!/oI,/'I>llJ
~Z illUlY!L
~ n>tfn,;;,r".
CJc~f'.A cw I"UYlOl.IliLY IU~\Jkl)'\A'i
d~i~lI1.n ~ h.P\.N:'~.H. 0' ''\.~I,
, OllWll/ill'lliNlVl'l."f"^,i ' ,.,,, ' "
d~~~r~"9'PL~II'~J1'L~,~UI~tor "t- ' lJ:~ :,;' .............
'RWOH'OA,R.~."'.u. ':;~. ~, "-. """"lv<~...""I'(.JW,!",",~
.,~ OUIOUH OWIC~O '~-:~UHi~~?~~'iI'Hb41:1lI
, OT: "" E En ECE EO" block 10 ehoc,o IIcol olul. I 0
VIti' ., J , ,'"
I
1~~~~.i~~2QS .
"
. ,
A'j.l.1
lUeUI~
t.:i~, ~1I0N
"
~
~
I S
j .
~ A
L
'I".'
tf.lf: ION!! ~u I r.
" y~or rOgl"ltullOl' docomlnll oro 1101
lUCC 'Md WI I111l 60 d~yu, ploooo cOlllnc
f'lllll oot. .. ,
I
MIS SINO'" NUMS''''
\
, APPLICANT'S COpy /TEMPORA"V
.
1oI1M1I1I1 NNlt /.ill)~hflllt&ij
i I 111111'" I
1lOAN111111Y..
'igl~~~Q_gJSU~9~~~'
" " IIIllllI1 1,1 I'll; >I I ,Ii'
, I \'II'IIILi_~J I WIiJ.- I'll ' ,~ /',',!",-,/": LL......
W;IIII. rill
1 '" '
JiliN! iliklilllll'rNmr-.-.---:.'..-" -,-,,-..-- ---'-..--.-'-----
L WCf IMlUAlL YM19! CIIMl9L ~moun' fln.Mlld ola. a a
<0110 YOUI ,,,lor "'1"/11"" 0"01111 IlIlou,' ilii<ii4" "II ""1" 'i>l ~I""/' ,I ",,,,~.,y.;;;;,., "'"'''' I" ~I ., I ~h!n you n >>~lv'!!llnOlltlavVO~~~'av~' uall~ you Will
I I'" blhlil 11I1I1/Il4' II PII"'"II II ""No IU y 'Ii ~ II I ~nl , I
Iqu 11. I 01 I ,,1 Ilul Percunl.
_,.__'-_.___ % '_--1ll;." ," ____ !..........:JJ.:.J!IL___'-___,__ '~WJ.~ U~' r:~tI1:~~;;kIWI; ICCOVIII
Vllllbll ,lllel filII olllluul po/call logo 1010 llIay Iilclom dUIIIIg Iho IUIIlI 0' I~III/Olllocllonll: IlIu IV' I, (Indl~)
chollglll, Wu will odd IllIalgln 0' _~I.j.L-Io 1hlll1do~ valuo, Thl lallIVIII,chlllg1 monlhlv on II1tU,.1 dlY 0' I~I monlh, rhl 'lit Will nlVl1 III ~Ighll 1~ln Ihl
IIJII"IlIU/Illnto ollilwod by low, olld il '1111I IIvvur bo IlIil 1/1011.._1:11.11____, AI1~ 1I11111U61 /0111 IlIclmol will rUlulIl1I mll/O povmuIll1 III Iho 101110 III1I1UIII, ror E~lllIpIU,
II UUI UIIII WUi IUI ,6,Q00 0115% IUI 4U II1UIII1I5 olld 1110 Al1l1uIII PIIIClllllo~1I nolo Iilclmod l!Y.~% IIllr 0110 001, UIO 101111 01 OU 1001\ would Il1clmo b IWOIII01JlIII,
Your unibi, 0/ PIYII"'I'I ""Jmoui1iOJ1l.YmlntIW~iilpl~mlntl ~'ii 'ijUI - --. Plopllly 1/l1U/'/lO,! OU llIay 0 n PlOP' Y IlouriOclliiiirl"
PaVlllonl ' 'I'd, t/';' I'" 'f> I, I d, ''''''I' ' ! I" ", 0, l1yono you WOllt 110115 ooo,plabll to Ilia credit Un191), II
8chldulo I, '1,,':1. IJ I I' I" .. I ,I"ll '.i" "' ',' I yob gOllllo InlUloncl "Oll) the credit unloll you 1'1111 pay
Will bo: , fl,,1
BlrUlllVI Collolvlol 50 curing 011101 loono 1'11111 Iho %dlt union Ihe goOd I or
1'111 0150 50CUlO 11115 loon, YoU 010 glYlng 0 leoullly Inle~ult proplrtv being mUU Olhel
III youl 5110rOl olld/or IlOpOlll1 Inlllu olodll union; o/Id olclloiod: (Oescribu
Lall c~IIglI II you, paymont ISlO"dOYI or 1l)0lo pOll doo, you 1'111 e chalged 0 010 'el equo 10 % 01
oUr Ichodulod poymolll, '
I . .. oUI 00 reo oou l"iiIilor In Iddlllonl) Inlolmlllon I ou non I mlO, I IU In 10 IIqU I
i ;y!J ~~j ',___~_/~~_'..L,_'" 'l~_..L_m_,A,2~~~~M'0 $ ....---
A11!00nl 'T ,ro
I PlldtQ I'.~ ,.'11, TOO 1..,"I:JI,J~1 \llh11j dll'. q 111,i1
I OlhOlD on $ , ,ro
I YourDoholl' ",,,' ro I',YI'" 1111' , To
lOG CONTINUIO ON AmnDI UIOI ~II 0 e I goYlme I e aWl 0
I r~a 'olloWlng porogroph oppllu only It Ihll II a yorlable roll loan I Thllnlllol 1010 01 Inloresl II N n~ 'Ill, .
Inl""II Inlololl 1'1111 bo chalgod 110m IlIe dolo 01 Ihll loon unlll you 1I0ye paid 1'11101 you OWl undor Ihll AgrDcllIonl, rho Intorell 1010 IllubloCllo C~ll1gl 11101101'11:
r "1110 .,- c!J.l-~--____.______.~_________.._____.._,__" '.- lIndu~) challgUI, Wo 1'1111 odd 0 mOlgl11 01 I J ' ,,} , 10 lhe )ndO yalUl,
I rhe 1010 1'1111 cllango llIol1ll1ly 0111110 II/51 daY 0' 1110 monlh, TlIB rolo Wlllnoyo/ bo hlgllor lllolllllu n~axllllUIll /010 ollowod by loW, and II will nover blloli 111011 ~:..--,
I l:!1y Inleloll rala IlIorOODoi Will rOlult In Inoro paYllIonl1 of Iho oonlo BII10UIIl, . ' ,
I I Plomllllo PlY I Yoo PIOII\IDO 10' pay , . ",'" I ',I' 101110 r.rndllllnlon plllllnlol051 or, IlIe onpold bolollCO 01 ' .,.. ..,.,.,,., % por YDOI
.JuJ!!!Jy}l!U9U 01'10 1100 boun ropold, __
Co)llOl)cn COIIII You plomlDe 10 poV 011 CODtl 01 colluclll1g 1110 omounl you 01'10 ondol 11111 agloement Including court c051e and Imonablo attorneYI fan, up to 20%
1.MD;!p01 and 111101011, ____
I 8aaurllY Olll,edl __________ MODEL IEM 10 NUMaER
I Ild',lilJI,I'f (,:\\1 ~",I''.(lIH'il':,':',
I
rll!PAlp
clltll8i ,
,.....--
TYPI
YM.UI
11,1'111,/'.,1,'111
II/ II'!,;,:,',
, I,' ,.1
011111 (1IIICrlb.ll
Yoo PiOJgo 8110100"-"---' .,,- -------u----hA;~I--ii-uh','n----' '$__.___..____~h__ Accl. N
andlo, 0lP05111 _oL__..~....... ________,_______,... . ,__, __."-'--____
BIGNA TUllEr II yoll ouroo 10 /JIoko and bo boond by 1110 1111mB 01 11115 Noln and 50cullly AgruolllolIlllglI bUlOW, 1/ YOII olIC 1101 a bOllowa/ bUI 011 OWIIBf 01 1M collalers/
'I lor IIIIS 10<1/1, sl(/II/J/lloW unci cl/uck 1/10 bOK lor "Ow"e,' 01 CollI/lorn/': Oy doll/II $0 YOII 011100 01l1Y 10 tho to""s ollhl Secorrty AII/eement,
C~UTlolIllT Is IMPORTA~r nt~T YOU r~oROUOHLY RIAO THIS CO'jf~~VT mOR_ YOU ItOIl Ir.
e - - - 81 -'-'-1,'- ,,/1110wn81 01 coIlBIBral,~~~.~r"'~~n a B,O"O~~
1',1,'1
~~p,8r $
ill,l
: ,~',\,."" To 1.1'''11.111 1"I"Ui,II,.,ll : ...'..' ~o
11I1 $ '",' ~~ I,!!, I ili' $ T~
~r CQHJlNOIO ON ~mllU' IIPI I Thll Nolo 1,1 goyorned by Ul' ',wl 0' P/I
! vlng pmg,oph opplles ol1ly II 1111111 0 yol1oblo lalo 10111: Tllo Inlllal 1010 01 Inlor05111 ..m~\-_......%,
, 111101011 will bo cholgod 11011I 1110 dolo ollhlllooll olllll yoo 110YO pold wllol yoo oWO olldol Ihll Au,OOI)IOI)I. Tho Inlololl 1010 II loblocllo chol1go u lollows:
~,__.__.,_._._________________,._m'_..._____ (li1d0~1 challQPi, Wo Will add a lJlorgll) 01 .J.iJ..u._ 10 tho Inds~ vsloo,
1111 cllollgo IJllllilhly olllho II/il day 011110 1II01)Ih, Tho (oto Wlllllnyo, bo hlghnl Ihalllho 1II0~llJIoIII 1110 allowod by law, olld II 1'111I llOYD' bo 1058ll1all ~.l__,__, '
III IDle III0rmOl Will rOloltlll ~lJIonll 01 ho IOllla Oll1oont, ,
'10 p~Y' YOo lJ/olIIllO Io'pay $ "., I '. ','" 10 Iho Clodll olllon jlluolirt~'UQI ~r,lho ollPold bolollco 01 ", '",' .,...,.,,, , , % pel YOlI..
'..Y.!1JL9.\Y!1'u bevl) 1P>>J!!.rj, _
I QUill Yoo prollllso 10 pay oil cosls 01 collocllng tho omoUnl YOo oWO ondol II11s ogloolllonllnclodll1g cootl coill ond I8Dlonoblo allornoYI 1m, op to 20'l\l
I/Id IlllolISI,
91l!J~L~____...._.____._,__.._J!!l.O[\- --'ViM JDHVMDfII IYPI y~UI
/ :,,' 1,1)\,1 J'
l'"t,I,1 t. '.: II.~r)JH'.d ',',I',fl
11,1 III "
II 111/1",' I
I ~.' d
.','.:\
IlcrlboL..,~__,,_ ._,___.."_____..",..,_ ,_ ,_,_ ".. '.,
10 6hDIOi S Accl. N $
Ipollls 01 .........._""--,...~____ "..'~_._
lj~~1 I~OO og'oo 10 mo~o OlibO boond b~ Iho 10~111 ollhll NOlo olld 60cu,lly Agreelllonl/IUII bolow,,, you 1/' not, bo,mw'r bU!,n own'r o/!h' coll'tl/'/
'on, slpn ,low ,,,~ c/lock the 0)( lor "f} nor 01 ollo,,,,r! Ry I/O/liP so yo~, ,preo olllY to tllO lorms 0/ Iho SecU'i~ ~pr"m'n '
i IT I~ 1 ~QIITMT TH~T YO Tijo~OUO ,~y II. II THII OO/lTII~OT ~~fQ/l1 YIIU IloH IT,
It " 10 BOl/OWOI2LIOw"er 01 Collolo/al (oilior Hili! I BOl/OWOI) 1fai8
"'~~ ~
I ,( U 15f~L
[J Ow 01 01 Colllolol ( I 01 Iho 0 IIoworl ol/owor now"" 01 Col 01011/ 101 or t In a BOl/owoll Oslo
W UMI
.
AceL N
hi d.y or dlsobllllY,
"Yoor" mOBnS l~o mombor sn~ Iho 101111 inlured 01 'PPj Isbl,l, ,odlt InsuII"ce II ~Ol~~"rll".1IOl ".~ Iud., '0 obllln III" ,..., You m,y
i Insum ol.YOYI cholco, You a," apP~lng ,t,o tho 60clely 01 credlllnsOlal1CO or yoor 10'", yay egroelo pay the premlom ch.srgos S~OWI1 b.loW, '''',HI liT
) S ~ LlO~TIO/j If IT OONTAln~ AN BLA~~ IP e~B, ~ I 'PPllnl o,n I vo j Ind will nol ~, u... In . oon',,1 " .11 bl'nk Ipm. h.~. ~o, bltll
I, lr~, m'!JIbar hit 1101 ,Igned en ..Isd Ihe ~ppnaa~onl end" ,110 ~PPllo."on hit nol bltn wllnllled. Tho I.lloWll1g slalolllenls mede by yoo oro
1II0lls ol1d oro Iruo \0 Iho ball 01 yoor ~"owlodgo and ballot: ,
OIlIOIT LI'~ I/lBUIIANOE ' ,,--- ...------ .cIlIDI' DIB~BI~iTY ,"BUIIAHO~
ndol ago 65 (J,Yos ON~ '"';jz J .cy Ol1lhls doto, oro yoo prosollUy acllvoly at wor~ and regvlarly performlng all or Iha
, -~{ (. ...., ~(...I-c-ionl olual dollolofo galnluloccuplllol1 a IJIlnllllUIIl or 26 houraaWOBk? ;,OYol ONo
II no, why 11011...__
foliilTniU"a ICQ'UO"OWI/I jij"1j'""",,. , Q" ,"dll . "~,,,glll "lOciii,j]'Dii'i
--.-....,..,-,.-.. ..~..., ..............',..,,-,_..._-,-,_..- .., , 'r);ii
i;; yO~ ~ndor l'''Q;il5?''C] YOI ?I ~ Nq. e "~" " '" . (,)
.v..,_'.....J,""I~"'_\.,,,f~..II Q, , __-B_, '7[,-:_/' ." //.J
d~DlUllIlll-"tlllu t . '.. f.::P- -f-'1fa1'
Wljj.iiJi&-.......... -.-. .. ...-... ~4.__ ------.........- Oall
/liiiiliC,ii;-Y-,J .~.lij-Jo8i;n.l;j';loiiiit-orlur-. ..
I .meUD
Idll Lifo
III LUo
I IOPA
11000111 01 Lool1
\ I '
'II
liji:i:O'-liJd',y-'Ii'ltll~Ii~-ldl'y .1 ~llU t1~Mi.u .ji, il.me'"s/IIU) '..
YOI
No
_,_......__ COVERAGE mEmO
,_......._,. Crodll OIBoblllly
Ai'i' BII<),<)7M PA
Monthly'-'-"-' --rBriilii"-Cortiiicalo
PaymonVBol1ollt III Monthl
YUI
No
--. -".---
_-L
II1IUIII1CO Chorgo
ef/OCIlYO Dalo
o Cartllloate
Dele 01 Bltlh
Mo, Day Yr,
,
"11/'I11n.nli)~N, PA 110:N,
I U
, "'9M,j
I' ,
. h~Il?~oM",n~:-"--'''Lii;i:-:-i ,- I 11,11 'I' ;!j', ,.. JL:,l:i('a'ii~:) ,."._'.. ..,...
, 11~iHlII Pll ~ht UI~ r 111~1/1 I~Ut! !;H!rlill~'i ~H/lII:U J LAlCfjHS,
(' litj ~NfJ 1'7 AI I I UIl r ~ ~I< A71~ i 1/ I 'I~ ~ rillE .'llCIlHIIll:
V ILl.. /All Li\l: j lJ [II Hi,:rl"jHWEll 111l:/1 M r,(I~ THin .
f) VlO'
LI /'Il'.III' //1-1/11111111' III/lVII,I" nllll! 1:,111;1(11) ""(IUI, /IIII~" 1\11/
I' I In~ A III iiI.' 1111 J'I/llltILlI/J'.
'1't@_"lllY""""WII'lIII'.II"""IJHH;I/l/'llllll"" "'INII,.rlll.;/"
. t.~ ,.tH60I:\M1LiTl'1111.11:JIJ 1..Il
' " -".....,.- ,'''- , .111/1 II I '1"111 1~Illil"
...,' - ..,",..," ,'~. ,~., ..,... -~'.~ ..', '!!l~_L~_r~!~~,.l.~~I!~ ~ I'MI/Il
.m :'i :1't';V,' /\,IInHlnllllme 1m! TIll 0./:)11 I I I:Illiilll,,\,l
/1/1 I II M II<llll" )\.It I,ll Ilr
IIIrI w ~ hill lJ~Nu ~ '1'1 11/111//1 ~ T 1O11l HI MI./IJUI f./w
"
"~,i)'li- , '''IllY ,.,. NLJM 1JI::Il , , ..:, m:fJCrUI'llli/l "-Jii~""--~'rUW ~~hf~-
. ,
oIi)lJ U 2 III II\L 1/Ill1I1/ ~ 1'1\1111)
",'1If
'" ---
','
~0
awrence
~hevrolet · Geo. Oldsmobile-
lj/I46 ~~ALISLE PI/<E P,o, sox 610 phQne 766.02~4
MECHANICSSUAG, PA 17066 "
, ,
I
! I
,
..
t
rlll;1II1,~ II 'II\'
.'
1~~11I 11H1I1tI 1I1'1'I/fil I IIIII\Il
'~ '
"
. ... -....,.........,. .'._,... ......., ".. ,,- - .,.- .
Ij.ll ,Ii, ,\ 11111 '1'1,11/1 .." __.. , _ _. .. ' , ,
,IUO II I 1.1), ~ 11i11)IJWIl~HI;1I I'lIl1i11l UII.
- /
'MW~jj j"" ":IIliI.'~ljl"',iij"Bljtl~Ij,\I'JmN(iij~,II'
. .............,.,
,~
-." .... ... _..._....-._.~....._---,~;..~.
WU OWRilNTUU ~R selW~u WOiK ~OR 81)
rlArs 0/1 4,OOQ ILUS ~ "tftev R OOMI8
r.'f1ST, IF OUR RUP IR OR ~,W:O. ~1jJ "AILS
Wu,~~'Wt~T T,\ll~O~/1 I' Wd ~wQ~lr~ PA"Tg"~~
LLAIIOR, II' uls 0 PA TSlu ~Al.L~D1JO
AbO" I IOU D Oft "I PO
/lepLAO~~NT ~~I THOS~ I' Tft S PI' IG~~T
UI'", >>/~Ht~I""'~'ff~ !l~IIl'/~~/lMJff//IIl
II
/1
-"-,....,..I~ -....-I _...../
Il III "II '" I'.
II --J
"
,
Ij
I I
.
"
, O'lti~/'"I'1~
.,
~ .,
ll.l4
, ?',;n
",,,,,. t.iJ.
111..,1:,
....-. ,..'.-...
WIIHI/MlI I'
, ,-.. ..~ .1_
O.C)o
, :: .Q.,oo\
., '''''.; ". . ., ,~
, I,
.15,1'5"
~,~()
\
',.tJ.9b ,
. . , ,.!l~. '15
", . 'iOO lUlU I \ '
, rell Ill. . om,
"..-"taltllllllL till' . '" _",
'UII\I " MU1l:
I ilmpnW1iliAlIY' iii/ill'-Oll 'i;I'I~~IlI~' ....... ,." ,'.. .;'" ,
IlrAlll' '-.., , ,.,'...... ._.. '.., ......" ........., .....,.,.
I nIANI< YlIII, 111m 'hIIIJl(lJ ellil,l (Ji1l1i, I Ill~ nl IU: I I ~m
, L A I.j II J, II I: , I: II I' V II II L i: I.
I) Ill:NV' L:L ollm 1;1\11 111/ TIll/ell. WI: 1I111'1: I'll 11fC I'll
... ........"',~ .
Pl.AIHTIFF'8
, EXHIBIT
--B-_
'1-I,ltll . II, ,.
.~ ~...".," -.~....,~
, .'
"
"
,- ...-....-.., .
1111.\1 I,An"I/..
jr:Jl~t aO\)l~ r:
o II I,ll..
\'/I.A. Aldl:...
*"....,1
~ '-At ",... '-'............., '"
.' Chevrolet. Geo. Oldsmobile
6446 CARL.ISL.E PI)<E p,O. BOX 610 P~(me 7~~.Q284 ·
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17065 " ,
IlIUI<IIJIP'~~1
-'
"""I'IMIIlM/lljilQ
D
/I
D UI
/I
,J
,"~I
U'
, .
,,,
'" 'I '
-
I'l II II II II II I H,r
1'.Ibl,l\ l)tllllll 1111'11111 I 1/1111I1
111111111'111111'111. l'iI INII,
I
4,1 -!'InJ '
.
\J~'"11111)~1:~'i~W 'Mil I' IIi/II' ijlll'l I1Y:1 IllllIlI II l'l'\(\)1 1 "I
AIIII L I~III B MI; II All 111[1111'. /IIIMIi tI IIIL:I< ), AI 111'111'.
I:II!)I :) 11I11~1I!/) I" Il~' II: 1'1 ~\l ll'I.I:11 \111111('1' I'll." 111:1:1' \II' Ilia I
I ~lJ [,1M . ft~fJ ~ ~ II l) I'Al '/) lilt I Hrl I\',l Al 111l CI'
'. II'; 11'1: '\0 I I'flj' I filllW!1 jl'll WIJ. Illl J n I 11,1) 11\11: 1 III MIlII\
, 110 I I I 1':111 t U AI1I\ IHI LII .11 (111111 J.
I'A\/II) II n JI)tllJ~UP/ ' .." ' ,..' '1)I':!llJljll'IlPU' ....' . . IJ~II 1'1/11:1:'
.JIll II 1 1 ,,1,0,1117(, IHlCIO< 4..)~1
, "lllJ II l nil AI.. PAil PI
."'!" " ,.~,~:t... , ,',:,':~'" '" ' ';'IlI~:II.'~'l:lil,:~~l;\hiJrl'l: 'Ii~~~~" ..'
"II:' ()1lW 1111 UIlII "1I1 \1\1111 1I111H11 ll(:II(lI)l1hl
I:\'!i'IIII'11f'l '\lllJ Ill'l'l ,Iii, I.IIPI" 1:1I1\I}llltl, 11111111'11, f 1 (I)'I~II(Ji,
, Ull'il\~ \lIhllkA~II:1J ,lnlli'ilt'dIIM(\lIrlt ddllllV~1 ~I Mt 1I1;\li Illi 1111,
II l\lll:r
111111'1,111 1111111111 HIII/'IIII/VIII'I' (111111 1:111 ':'1111 1IIIIII.lI, 1111 Ill, Mil
FIlii A IP \11'1 IlrIL, 1'1'1\ 'Illl II.
I"llllli IllY 11'IHII1PlIl'" . IJI l'lII/ll'l 11111
,1111" ',' I 1,1':1111)114' Iii 111111,1):11,
, IJHII 1'I/lr:I'
III
,'"1' II ;> IlllAI I'Mdtl
011111 ii,',' 1111111.. I.AIIIIII ~ l'AllllI
O,\)I) 111:11(11) 11\)/
. ... ,.'
.JII :1 /'/l':V'/W(ln~ ,WAlIIl lilHl I II I'! I 1/ CAlI 1l1~"111
, IlI'II/1 1I11~IIINIY ':x Ie Hill' 1:1\1l WillI
AI, I CAl 1\1 Nil l:IIA 1111 Iii 1:111111 III
"'l\lllll tHY, n' IIIJI1ll1'll'" 111111'1/11'1 II III
.
dllli "
0/1111 II I) I'IIIAI
'l!1:IIW)CJt'ii
IIllill'IW:i"
OJ IIIIAl '1\1<)[1
1,I\lJIIII ~ l'Allm
.., .
I
I
I
I
/ i'
I
I
'\
J Itlllll C
II 11111 11l1l:1II1
III II
1l11'1 tI,I\IIIL,
II) 111.1111' 11111
111111 I'1l11:1
IIIIM l'Alllll
) '(I 1111
III Y
011111 II 4
"lilI M ~ IlIIAI
0.:10 HIIII(fJ) cH'1
PLAINTiff".,
exHIBIT
C
---.
i . I
,
. ,
IIN Ifill
,. " ' ,~ '. ,. . ... . . ,
,III bl1lIl:V/INII:lr.1, PI~I!l(lh I Arl'tl .
I,ll (,1\ 1.11 r j'~li 1I\1,ANI
, 1'1 "I 111111 I tI'iIIllt
) HI q
, I.llll.l'T 111I1.1 A111'
I
,,,,,
1,1,111,1)t-iM,
, M1bU
WilllIIIIIII)
WIIIIII~!I>~
, .
O,I)t)
..
11.14
(,' II
,'. I
11),4h
0.\11)
\1.00
, "~ ~,?~)
0.00
().()O ,
0.00
..',...,_ ,_w
AHHIIHIY
~GZ)
awrence
Chevrolet. Geo · Oldsmobile
6445 CARLI6LE PIKE p,O. BOX 610 Phone 766-0284
MECHANlC6BURG, PA 17055 ' ,
I'lJ111111' Ii I II)'
i',!!',lA 1IIIIInl 1111'1]1111 1'(111\11
11111'11111111111./11. /'/\ lil):lfI
-
Il\liJljl ~ "1'/111 ," ,.,... -.,... '" ,." ,
,III ,1,111';1:\1, IIIEI;I~UII1/II1J!II'IWIIIIII iItllllll
nllIl1ll"HO
~ 'III I mINl'I~11;W
1111 II'IHII'IIIW'
1'(lIllii
111111:1/11'111111
, ..,
~ ;11!'ij'J~ t"II'I"1IIJ(~c)QI;rJlilli~~i't'lir-,~~;; .-.:'. ..-- "
.111 I h.ll 'j/\II ~
, I H \! 1.1) 1M IIllillJl.//1J'i'jI:1l I'll) I'll/I I)ll, tI
111111111' ,
1./1 1'I1A/1I1 Villi. 11111/ Vii' 11I;/lI:IIIIIIIi'II/I, 1111/11" I 1:1 !tUi
,
I i\ 1./ Iii III: I' I; III 'I Ii III I I'
111 IiLI/VlI:!, YIIIIII I:'\I~ 1)1/ flilll:!l. 1./1. IUII'I' 1'0 111;1: Villi
MIAIII III 1'111' 1111/1111:
~'Pygu~~~~!! o;J~I'./)ffiV~~~.H~iK ~'iJM:g
rRV'6ffMO~":~lr. o~ I~ nJ~~~LlI
.rL PI't IT ,W.. 0' 2 G~ mTa ~<<:&l
~Qon, IF USID "~'lT51,. ~~~L~~"U5
loAQOR laINc~UDID NiD TH Ta '0 '~IlT
".PLACIMINT MI THOU F T/1 a PI' I R,
U""'I~mllll'M"NIHQ ""I '"I~I'M~II/N<l
Q
n
Q UI ,.i, II
11
(,,',11,:1
/1):)/'16
I ,'1/) I,U:IIOI) Il:j','
"IA/I/lMlry
"1'0 I ""filL'
,', II 1M l'IIInl)
I,M/lllt ~ /'MUU
lI,nl'
(1.1/1)
.~... .. ,I'.'... ~.,. "
.. .. . .
"I III II
') ,11111" II 1111 M
..'l..'.."....l.
.,,-,. ... ..,-.-..----.w.."__~~~.~_~t-~_~....
, .. - I, '" , " , , , ~~~n~I!F
b.llt)l) ~1I~1I
1011\l nOli b.b~
................ " "" , ..
.
1111/\ 1,/\/""1" ".14
I' f/\ I'~ I,q . /.:H
1',\ Ii III J I'. CI'I'~
'I /\ 11111.11" b.~l
I /\, '1m:... lh'\
II A lAX.,. . 1.4
11111\1 III VI II 1;/ , jlh~ :"1'1
~J
/-1~;~
l/ ().~
,.., .
, i
......r:7\
~~
awrence
Chevrolet · Geo. Oldsmobile
lj'I45 CARLISLE PIKE P,O, BOX 510 P,",cme 766.Q204
MECHANICSBURG PA 17055
.
WP OIlMWITPS iR SSRVIOS WlfI FOR IIQ
~~\r Inll~~p ,1~H8l1 MH~~g !fN~~~~3
W ,l]O'l!;l"L BSlI ICS WJ '~GlH r PSRIO~
l.Ato~, I~ '~s~:;e~AWr8 ARE G~~' ~t'l:,~o
LASORIS INeLIIPSO ANO THS TER S FOR 'ART
flSI'l.AOSMSNT AflB THOSS OF rH SIIPPLI R,
U/Il<J PIPHt ~I~~HIH~ 1I~1 "'l~ ~1~~HIN<l
II
R
II .>>
fl
_I .--JJJ '
'Il ~Il
/31 --1>>'
11/1
)J1'II~FlIII'II~H, 1"/\ I/C):lil
" ,""'M/I
11,11!IM
(,,'4!,:1
.
Jl~11I1 I II '//)'
~'", 1/\ 1111 Pili 1111'1)111 I 1'111.111
.b/ll
1\)11111 K I'?'IIII . "...., ",.,..
ij .." Ihllll IIIFI,I~nll1/1jlJ!il'IWIIIIII IIH1111I
[1Il'IW' ~l'111l1l1nH
/\Illllj I II 1111 pm
III \' II' IUI111iFII
1.11/ II ':/1(1) I t:J"
WA/l/'lf\ttr Y
'Will
111111:1111'111111
oIi11l II
') 011111 II (, 101/'11
litO I PI/Ii:I'
.., 111I1\1 1'/111[\)
1,/\111111 ~ ,','*HI
. .".
lil!'~' , , ~ 1,111'1 'I )111 ,;MO~I;PI1IH:illlM~Nr-j;l;i; ...---,-_., '
Illl 1 !, .'1 II 1\ i'I ~
HIll ',I I ,I) 11M 1Il1l1llWrll'tll:i1 Mil Pill 1111. ~
...'.'..... "
,
1),IIC)
0.\1\1
,/ '. ,,'~.., " '
._"...'__,~_'" ,,__.6""'_ ...._... ~_~.,.....,.....
. ~ "" ." .
h, ~'Jl)()
~II~H I
IIII/\l. '11011
, ~~~~~l:~I
b,b~
'ill III il,..,
I IItr./IH rllll. 1/1111 VI\IIIIII Lilli ""'11 ". 1111' 1111 , I: I Ii'l'"
I 1\ W II I II I: I I; II I IJ 1/ II I I I'
11 1\!'IIVil:i YilIIII 1:;\1'1 1111 [1/111:1<. Wi: 11111'1 iii ill:1 YllII
I ,"IA II'l III 1111 111I1111i:
'"'''' ., .r......"....
JIIIA I,AI"II', , 1\.14
. l'lrA '0 1111.. ,li~1
I I" Ii 11111,
III /\ 11,11.11.,
II" A 1'111,1:, ..
111/\ I f\X"., lI.l,
., ,...'
1111/\1 IIIVIIII;I . Nj.:l'I
I i/J'/;1/ jf/
(~~~y
I:II!III'II'II " !II ntlA 1111/1
.'
&,)~
,.-1 ~~-~2Y\}\
\ ,. , ~"-J
\,; l.,
, .
.111 :.1 1411V~ Il"~r.~~Hmll
~~~~hW'cnrjlll1l~~~r PtWIJ
flAlml ., .UTY'. 'fr NlIMPlill'" ..... ,.. "'llpll~lm'IllIt!, .....,.:iQ~'~., OT~~~l ~~~y~' 0.00
~O/l II G TOTM, LA/lOll & PAIlTa O.OQ
.. ,..~,~ ""~ . .,.~. .... .,.".~.,.......'. ......._... .."..., _..... ,,__ ,........__...,..........._...... _.".,...... _.__....._ __.............._....... 0... _"..........,.. .....'. ....~'...., ... ............,.._..........
.J" 4 09C:VI. ~U~f<E!l lltlInS! ".()O H.IlU<B)lle7 WMIWm
Alla BkFlU~ ,,12HT aw~ Rtl ~N8 STAYS UN rOl~ fl W/iOLE nFlv IH
M~~l~ili ~ (~OIDgaNm:c~B" 1~ U~IIICI t.: 1ll'l"rlJ tlnlllO/l
rlll.un"llly.:;'n'~llIMlJ/:I'l..'..'..'m' ,...Ptllt;H'lf'rp)t~,,~ "'JOD~4'T~~~[ ~m~" O.QO
,lOl' II 4 TorM. I,AlIOR & pwrs 0.<)0
. ........."..... "" ...,...., .,......._..., ........."............_. '0 ,. '. ..,..."...,....._...... ..... 'n _.. ..... ...,"'......'.. .........,.."..,..,.........
JII 5 m:Vl GUUrfi"EI"lUijA,~~E~~a~IN UfiTU tnT~N~l~lfCl.E AT J)~T~6~~a)mf,,1tl wmANTY
OlJJ)l. ,r Hl C 1m "Ii FOR EPII n II T tlo W HWO
m',tlc IrJiIlU: Will BOllY 11101' I R Dill! J'AI'Wl. 1.1' I'
f'AJ/Trl" -. 'Im. '.-FI'''Nlll'Illl::JI''''.. ....,,,,,-llf.fJCIW'rlllt!,, '. '...."...,......, ,,'
6445 CARLISLe Pll<~ p.o. BOX 1110
MECHANIOSBUAG PA 170611
u '"
/I
'III
"
p~Q"e 766-0284
I,
.
Mlr.lIl'U /l I'I/Y
, 12~IIlIlHI~H IJgl'lI11l! fiollP
. IIIJI11'1r1 IHlIWN. rA 170:M
, ,"" '1/,4'1
,111/'11,
h~'Jl~1i () ~ cC~Nl.U2~'I- ~ft~,:" iit~:~~~" 8 ~t' r tt tt~~j/t;;ij~~ ~~~~fJ l [I' ;.r~/i~~~~,' ; ~~ 'j ~'~~~~f,~r; " ,on'"
lJ' UCLf !Jilt) IitflMI1 m" ~ECllHRrcHWI) HI l:lllJfll ,.Oll ~H1H
g,mc
'tO r:\.r.r.ll I"lE,llUE!lI~1l OERVIClE. M.lIll I:/llCI<r1l IlOnl'll. Ill.! rn. Alrl
r I . r :rl IINI) fir r T rlE I"rlPitil/rll'. '
PA'llfJ".' ",...ul'Y--,.fl...NlJl'IllJ;:R--~--.,.,..._.,.,. -J)EllornrTlOII" .' ""..' " ..', ..1!t1lT rJnll~E-
~OJl II I I '4~~~Q. OIL FLrn I.O~6 . , ?~1
, ' , JOU II I TOIIIL rAf/Ta
0Ull ij I TUIAL LFlllUR & "FlRIB
........_.. ,,'.." .,... .,.~,....~, ._.,'..~... ......_........._..._.......__.".._... "..'" ,.. ,,,.,,. ,.. ,._., . ,. ..._.. ....__.....~....., 0 """0" .. .. ,.,.' ,. ,_ +.
O.:lO n.()/j(6)11~1
~~ ~ ~"CV~ U~O~T IlIBr~~~~~RTe~a6rc UIHl'EH
RE~Oij~ ~U/~11R & milT FILl. P(iO,'El.llriV
f'ARHI". .".. ,1l/Y,.'..fp.HUI1DER..".,.....,.... ....~r.E1CNlrr ION'" ,...,-,...,..,IouT. 2-'i~~~1. my~-
>l1I,1 N ~ /[1111I I.MII]Jl ~ "FlliTS
". ..
rn:lIl1l) 11'.1/
utn 11)1
.J1l11 II
dllll II e. III I AI..
..., "....,......,...,.,.,...., ........-..Qi;:r~~' i!tUTtII l' 'n';Jlc'u;"illh
l':NP,~ IQt ON AGeE ,E!-IM lllN .
I PLAIHTlfl"8
. .~XHI~I,t
. J:).~
,
111I
ll"~
7.. :'Jt
~.~
11l.4b
~A~jiAN)Y
Q.OO
O.O!>
O.l/O
<l.. <lc~
c~ .Oc)
n,,, . -,,,.
~'I.Il;) "
l).l,lL) CA/1LISLJ,: PIKE P,O, 130X (j 10
MECHANICS13l..'RG, PA t 7Q6/3
'/ ,
.)
"
~Qno 766.0264 _,L'" ",,'
.... ~..~_ill'- ji/l_n._'~"~"
.
ll~mt) I
I: l)llq
Ijllll.
....------...- l~1iTIJili~~ir-~-+-liiiTi;f.r)ji').....>-.-'..-..I>>rl[~tir'u i:l~~~.--- -'_.~--~
-)Tmil;irtiflMi5ITfX''''.L-- - -.--.- ___._1-.-__..__.. ... illiiy-~TIY IJ~" l~
" ,
----.------.-- "imTifj;Tm~TI It.O
II I '1 .,. :1
.=~~_:~=-J-I~~l ~0 ___.~~-=_ n-lr~~l1--=
IHijW 'I' 'I~ -.--
I III
rTfljii------
f ~ II)
Vl~.-..___Lltiij1ijIOH~_._~~_= --~---'-"-'--"-"
",J,
.,.'
,'II I
'"
'I,
II ill, II . I
! I 11>11'1111 I,'
I',
i'I.;II
j ~
1111
I,'
11.'llil' ,I
/11lj.'L'III Ilt.",1
, "
ill
Ii
1111"1111 I;
I:, . ,1'1 \
II I, ,
It'I,I,11
.
, "
"
(", :!
Illd I
lij ,-III " 'ill III' 1'1'
I I II II II I 111\' III, Illl!: I, "~I 'II iI.1I111 1\"'1
1111 Il'llol('!, Inn I I ! Ii II.' I " II'
, I,
, '
l'III'1
,f'I.,I.
I: f I P
\1', 1,;11
"Ii: t I
',/,\11
"I'll
, 'I
,
"
.,
Ii ,;
"
'II 1,'1 ,Ii
_" I
"III
.
"
','
"
1/ '
j'll
'I
'Ill I'r" I',
.j il ,,_
dl-
'11111
1'1'
"
"
"
,
III'
.,Irq,
I':;il'
'i'l
" '
','
I,i -,'r
-..
lj';IJlkl.')
i. rii; '~l~jl-'-"
lllti,;Tfi'ft:iiiTii"
'iI1)IIljl:liD/I);..11'
,
I'.
1111';")II:!
'. ..'...:,oil.ii.~'..iWIM ~~Ar~.
./11/1 M ~ TO 1/11 I.I\PO/I ,.. ''MITS
. t, ,_ ~. "." ". ... _", '.'N ...."..__.. '......_.~..,..,.._,..., _..... ,...._._". ~_ .._ ..,.. _ ,w""" ,,~........ ..,...._.......... ~".." ... ....' ....... ., ,- "........... ,. .... .........,' ....-_ ...... -,'
.111 ;) 16liVl JlJl~P.~H~IVLU liN I nil TECI!' G" t ~,7
~l~W;r:3r'n[jp ICA~A ,Pr:NJ Ell
['/\Inti ',..OTY' 'fr./llll'lpl:Il" ...... ,........p~S[)fIlJ'nuN. ..,.. ..,.....jtjij'j,.' .i'T~~~[ ~~/8~'
~Oll M II fUl/\I, l/\lmll ~ PMITEl
" .,., ...... ,. .'....."_....,,'......., .........._.",.. r""."'" ..-_..'.... .' . """.', ............_...,. - .'.... '..,....'
,I" 4 Q9CIJ~ A~a p.JlA~Wtfc'I~~~ S99E~ un ~N8 ~tnw ON ~o~Q ATbfl~t~) ~~r M
~~~hRi~ e 'tch 8BNm:c~oR 16 UltllCIX Ilf'I"CIl tJl:NliO/'l
PABlO "lln";:n'NU",J':I~"'.'" '''PtnCHII'rllltl ~O~" ~'T~~~[ ~m~
~1'Ifi M 4 rOJM tAILOR a [Wlrs
, ,..,.._".......".,...'.'_'M'~.'...,..'...._".;,..._'.....,..........._.... ...,..,.,.,.__..'....M'....'... .,."... """,~'-'M
,IN ~j m:Vl 1lI.A~1l ~IJ~I( ~NI[~I n:efj(O)l1~7
lm~l~~Ert,)r;lllgiJll!A/~rtU~lflAWf\ AY' IW!.lft\lJ~U' ~r,r. n n' HI
11f,OCllnJlJU, !.I1T11 JJUlJY tltlOl' nm tliItJ I'AlWL It AI(
['AIITU' ,lilY, ,.",'NlJI'IWII' "... ""liftJCIIII'IlIlN' '.. :J[iit~ ~'T\m[ r.~IIY~'
.JOll H ~ TOTAL 1.1\J1I111 ~ PAJlTa
.. "_.I"."................"~,.,._..,......_..'M"._...........'.. ..,. ."~'...."_....,'".~,,... ."..,......"...-. ,.,
.IN I"QH:V~lJrFFlltllv StH~ICE JlEI\~ tlU'F UNlTUI nCH(f3) 1116
nUflTUrr::R B!gT6B.JlE~ l::NJJ M.\lIBE ON I\Cr.El.l:RATlIlN
, nn~U:RatllltAJl ti~m: ir.NTlAL... '
I r,1l\: ~I. ,.om; ..rr-~~g!~j;.--._- -"-tijli; !':!!!". . - .._h.~" IT I"l~!;
, .. ~." I~' ..tH1 ';".'. .......,1 'IOW"...
, '1I1./11I'1t( BflII.lN. 1'/\ f 7()~11,
, u
'" '" 'If,~'1
~,~IIIIJ/l1~r:wnlb!'II'Ntll. 'lI~i)U~tI~' iil\"; 'tl.II,~i:,/, ;;lll~'\l:IiAtJl"'" IIIMll!i!lili{I/~['lIIILlI,
1;1'1:1 fill' 1'llL M,. I'Ll/"Ill, 1:11'1'11 rill' JIII~ t , [1\: l'II'utilllil.
V;jl:l.' I/ll ml\ew/I 111, 1/11;11/'1/'11111I'11 nllnNM /'1m HII
,iVl '
go f'I,~Il:1l /,1~(/Ul:aT~1I [W[IVIr:I'" /\IlIil 1:1111:1(1/1 Ilrmnl, lill TII, /\lll
r I.,:ri /'INIl firr 1m!: I"m,rHillrw,
f'/'IllHI"'" .....un-..'fIl./'jU/'lI3F./'l.----.........,,' ....PUlllJlIPnO/l.. .,...... ,. ",. , .. ,", ,,,..11111 J P/'l!CE"
IIOlJ MIl M:ltJ:lll~ OB. fL JJl 1,0:#, ,1'.3'
, , ' '.... .lOll H I TQI/'IL r/'lJlTB
,lUll M I T01/1L' L~lJlJJl t PAJlHl
, . ,. ....,..-......"........-'... "'---."'''.'''' ..'.".........
O,:'ul H.ClH6) "/II
,
.. .,,, . ,. " .. ,,-... .... .... .' .. ~ ".-.....,.. ....... -.......... - ...~ ....." ". . '.
~ij " \!Iof:vl r;~n:/'lllIR TllIl'I l/tj lJ'!1 1
gl~~\l !lIB~ lPlR/'lllll L1jUOr.
RE~O~~ ~llr.r(llll & INtlrl\u. "Iml'l::l LIlY
P/'l/'l J lI'" ,'.. ,II n.... Ff'.NUI'I/lJ:Il.......... '" ,., "/lr:lIr./l /.I" lUll
I'/\1I1: 1 01' 2
r.cON r !NUI.1l tIN Nn T PAtlEJ
.' _..- ,.'" ",... . .,' , ~. .. ... '
I
\;
11.14
f..,Ji
..7.:Jl
11l.4r:5
,,'. '...........,.....
l.IA/'l'I~N1Y
Q.QO
.'. ,
l.I/'I/lIl/ltHY
Q.OO
Q.()O
.,.,.,.,....
I.IMII'/I\/IlY
~Y,2J
19.11
1 e.t 2l! H';"
. ,
....... . - ~~--~...,
,Chevrolet · Geo. Oldsmobile
6445 CARLISLE PIKE P,O, sox ,510 "hone 766.Q284
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
Jill ~_
"~It
LJI 'lIt
~~IJl~f',)'il e~l~ini' ':. 'i olli' , i'iit', "~:JI'IUt - ~NI'~I" 1[~I'lliIIH III,
Y~i'bjW ~W\~t~p 2t r,t,' \iU: \/11 ~,r~1WI~'II' 11111/'t dl,r' 't.~m~Wi"
0, t~ O/lU hE/lCll~~ If ' Rl'i.CLl1 ~tllJl:oJl I tll IIVIiI. l' 0(1 1111:1
g. l~: ~ .
(,I f'~'r(11 /II:oUI.OII'I) [(/:itVU:l, /lI.SIJ ClIlllIClIIIiOBlfi. 11I1 In. 1\111
r I ,I f i A j~ tin T Ii: , if'til)lIM ,
f'filll~U1Y'fI'N~gft~"...,. "B~llUltmnlln, -, " ,....UlHf /,1i,ICL'
-III!. ~ ,:. '. ,1 ,..~ '... ~._ ,,~..... }~ fl)VJ :.U,JL ,. "\"",n' 1 'Torl\l'rA~t~lp ;'" .,~~~~
,.,.
"till" 1 ItlIAI. 1,(lJIIW ~ I'A/iIO
.... ......... ,
1/tIlItH' r~ ell ((j ) I ) HI
fl(lUI,f; ItmlJJ ~lfll)ll/lj
.
l
IIII il:)/II" I JlIlj
. """""'mJj~I~_
II
fI
II 1I1
fI
.
,
"
,
\ '~
" .
, \ ' ~
,
~
..iIlJ ']
{"":' '
,\,," ~
{I ' ·
.."7'~
rII qtn I II I'IIY
milA 'Hili III m,"l)11I r lilJ/l/!
/IUMI1l.lflTlIWH. l'A l/q:~^
'" 1,4')
,~
, , ,
.
.11I :! :'I~I :V/llAjJ~(J IIMll(),
'UUIUM~li ~)1IlTV.II, IADln
/Ir)mr;/lI(~U'1
I'AI~ iii ' III Y , ~'I' IIlIII/II.I'
.I" I lol:Vi
, IIHI'I'Illm
I,JlIII II ;, '111M, 'M/ill
., f .JiH~ H 'i IllIAI I AlII II I t' I'MIII)
1.1,1,(1' j 111'1I1. 'bll~IUW,lblkl'WJlII I I:llyl'fj 1/)\1';""1111 " ,,~Ii'iW ~(ilt I Mill!
~tl)' ~ ,
tHe A ,.t. ~Jwrl. Cl)VI.r~ "
II I Y ''I'' tUI~~EI/' ' '1II,i)ui~r; I ~ 1111 . ' -'1/111 rill CL'
I ,11>110):) UP I,M f"lW,fj
,\ oIlIIi H :,1 ,11l1A! I"M'lTn
,I(l~ "I IIIIAI I. Mil It/ /, !"Alnu
... ,.. .,..... ,
f'AIll U
,Ji)IJ " :,1
,..
:Ir)~ t /' lillf'~I: &Ui,iI1 'ill)oi)~J;f;Hi:ii' MilT flri Ii u',' Q
.
" ,hOC) '/UlH I
1111/\1
nOli
"
'"I' '~I~~I~
, ,
"
... .'
I
/174~:J
11,) ~
lIJ.'lb
0.1)1)
0,0'1
1),1)1)
t.lA/IIWII,
~W~'ll\tl IV
. 0.00.
O.OQ
_.....,..,..~".",.., '
15.~O \
~.M
UIlNMI.NIII' I
AU Ii ,
...' f ~ ~ .. ,
~
PLAINTIFJ:'8 t
~ EXHIBIT /, *
I "
-~
, ,
,
..,,'"
awrence
Chevrolet · Geo ~ Oldsmobile .
~4:~~t~~:~~~~~A~~'~OX 510 P~on. 766.Q284
IWI d~ ~III 14,1
c
,ll.bl)
,~'I 11/111'1</11 VANIJI'
IJ~ lJ 'I l< .,' 1 I 'l 0' /. Ii II
/11 Gill I I Ii IllY
/,!blf\ IJNIIIN 1111'111111 1/II/llJ
IIIJ111'III '" III\Itl. 1'/) lilll/,
, ".,.1>44
I'IH/lUI
~I 1111\t1l( YlJII. IJII.I'I VAI.III::P 1;lJ!ITUI'1I.[i. I' III~ nUll': I rtlO
I AUI'IIIWI I:III"JIIIIII:I IlI'lHIIIIIJI'lIilIJl r
II) 1,1:11'/11'1 \'111111 Ir-ll< lill ,tHIGH, ~r 11111'1, 1111,11 )1111
1\11,,) I II II~ 1111 Iii 111111
('
'f.f'l '-' f
'V ' \ '1 '
,/( ", ""..
1:IJIJ1i1l11,JI flU III1H',
W~ OO~AN'T" ~A BI'W~CI WOAt< ,OA ~
III YB OA 4, IllB JICHIV A COMI
~A~,IF OO/l~P IR OR ICJ~IIIlT F~l
OlUtl BIA ICI WI I~ mrr PIA'
I' " IT FAil OF CO, p~ TB
lAllOA, , UBID P~ATB MI ~~T~~I~ 0
lAllOA IB I C U 10 NlO THe TI/I ,OA AT
RIPI.ACe~~T ~AI THOBI OF TH B~PPLI ~,
UlWl. 0"111 ~'~H/HG "~' '~'>P/Il~HlH<l
D
II
II l~
A
t",
J
l~
.
IQ~/'II
IUf'll. l.l\lJl!lI..
fs At, PAIHll .
'A, qUIlLf. i .
I /I 1I11i.n..
11'JIA M :'11;,.,
11111\ II\~..,.
IUIIII I~NlIll;L J
\
,\
,
14MU4
'" 4~,l'
"
,
11,14
7, ~.I1
Q .\)~l
~:~~
,~tj ,ull
,..._..... - .. . ~... ., ,... . ,'..., I ... ...... '. .
,r.;:"~
" '"
" /i} , )
, r"" \i~)-
. ~~'\ . ,
.1 "
;:.', il:. ~1C1~
',I \j
('
\').,
"
- ~~.... , .. ..,........ -'-\./. .'"'IUl:l......U,..,..~
e445 (!)AR~ISLE PIKE p/O'IBOX 510 ...iCjl>ti"t66.0:$4
HANI'bSBU G PA'l 066 ,.." I'
.
/1 I
a ~ t \
/l
"
,~
.
,
,
(
I
I I MMI 4/1~I.lr,
\
IIIII1/'II:L:ilillm. /'A 1 Nil,
I
'),1, 'IIIH
n.ElI6MJ4'1
M4~:)
Mll;IIlU II rflY ,
/;'bll\ tlN1LIN Ill'l)nll rmfl/J
.. . " "
, I~'IIII. !,\~'lII'tl ,..,'" ...,....,........, ... , , ......~"..,,'" ,... ........,
,', I 1),,1 l 'jjH!lI~wL'.~n~~ol~glc:rAN'W'ijJ It.;I(II~lJWi IUI~i~iI JWU~f)m~rtm I
c~~' 1:1/ !!~fi~Fn.l. 'I) ~y <14 tllJAln a '
/ nI'.In 'rALt,,~ lfLJM. At/II tl~:lI/lIJi U/lIf'(~' lllMn,'" illt~ ~t>vLI, "
!i'1I1i)'!)" ; lJ/yt".rr-NLJ'1.f./i+LJ.J..J..:.. .,1" 'IIPII;'I:I I'!'llIN .' .. "lll'>I>1 1"Ht.;("
r, '_11111 H 1 flIT 111_ 'AliTa,
.
,JIIU H I '''lilL LAUOIi r- 1'/lInlJ
"":;'I')r.I~Vl .. ~IJ~I'~~~~I~}~~i~~6hi 'I;ULJO;t';- ~UM;'t;;;~:,;' IIJ~~~U~ui I j ;;1
lUll NU" pO,fxCA,E
","'.. .".
I'flln~;'1""""'IlJY",-:~(,..~ljM/lrR:, "-'ULU~I"llUN ":"'-:io/, Ii ;;'''iW,tU 1:~,Wb
" I
"III' H ;, '111M LI\III1// r, "/\IIIH
, , . .
1 1.I:lIc /,;) II ~4
,.,
'~
" ,
'I' .,
, ~~I;MHr
I' I I
I
"
0,1)1)
Q.Oo
. .....-... ..'-~..'"
C),Il!)
",
~II :,1 1I11;VI >>OIJY ELE~)JHII:AI IINlllil ,
llUli I '111LI' (:)'/ AH,O,I..lI1/m/UlIllI'lI 1'1I1l!: Iii i1WN
llrll N I /Ill .
, \
/'llllI:;", '''(II Y,H',Nl//'1IJIH,........ .",..,,,-..jII.II!;I;J I'IIIIN '..."
' , ,I ,1I1l1 n
" .
\ 'Ni' H 8 1'lI1"'.
f' . . . ..., '...,.....~."..h '''''' n.. .... " ,,, ,.......,....., .., . , _I.... .....". _0-. "'1. ...._ . ". '. ,.
,m 4 ~/'icVI , /lUcf:aqOlm:c; II/II /III O. i'() .Hoelle a) ,,~"
1;I,JtJ rllMLH HE illllclHij I I/LF'I,/ll:1. M 100 I Nil 111\1110 II Illl rl
'iHom .,'
11:j''lI\CI:JI I<NUO '
,
"', "(Hy,' .f'I',NIII1111.11..,. "IIHII.:IIII'111I11 litH I "IlII;(
4 I 11,1) ,!I)b:,14 \' IIIH 11m '1.101:.;' ,
· ,JlIU H 4 I U I III F'IIII III
. , dUU'''~ ~ IIJ1 tt l.1I1J0I1 1\ PArdo
,I~~;-o~i(:v~; " 'H~;~ 1:~3~11~~~li~g~~FDiii~;~Jmg; L.IJw.i--::" j:l:'~'tla);l~. ---.,'" ""'"
, ,
l'Altlo' ,..., lilY 'n>.NI1I1flrcl/......--_..._...'~....IlEac:l/lf'''Utl,
........__.,.0-..,
.. ,.
,
0,00
0.011
I),!)II
,
.. l/I!', 1'11/1:/:'
I '0 I I\!, I 'Al1I!J
I.,\//l)fl r- "III/H)
(/,01)
11,()O
~I\"'TMNI)
pllll/II
! /,u ,t
I,
I
I
WARJ/AN I Y
o.<)Q
().oo '
'O.QC)
I'
i:lII11'lilllli '
IINIIr.:11i Jll/l.l' h t.j,\ II ,/ I ,~,
", ,
PLAINTIFF'S
EXHIBIT
r
, II/H I "1111;[-
, dUllll ", 111M I"/\I!ffi'
, .
.
"1111 It ~ Willi, IMIlI/! /, I'IlIIN'!
,. .. .
.' ,
O.O()
II. Ill)
,. ..,.
, "
..
~
;
,
,
,
f
\
.I~ I
1:IH,l./: fl n~y ,
't)lll lIHllltl IJI,I'l)lIJl 111)/111
IMNJ, I tiIl.I!.IH. I'll 1/1)~JI,
"",,''''/I,H
,
, 4 I "
/lul. ~d)2r~/!'" ........".."................"", " ,...'....."".., " ....., ,
I I). '~HllI'~~IlEi?e~~al~~IOr/'l~lIillij)H;lllJt!MI:It.IU,~iNJ~ JWUl\nmnfNr' I "I
Cff{rw,:r' ~fi~r u.r '" ~y q4 Ul/A/II a ',\ ' ,I . I
, , m:ln~rALt ~ lfl/~ /'I~IJ fI~:III/11i li'~!fIlJ-a. m,l)~'/,l'." Q)~ ~~"I, ...
1m).., :; ",( '~.I."HlJ~.I'.H+L"...t..J..:...I.. '1I~'ICi!lI~rIlJN ' ......'.. "Il/HI 1"I~~I;r"
, .)fl/J ~ I rUJIII" 'A/I'rO'
, .)1111" I IlllflL LMJu/1 ~ !'flllIl!
I . " " . "''\'' .. I....~ ._... ".......,. .. . ~ . .. . ,_ . ......".. , . ,., . _,., . ,........"
;~ 1);.I;Vl ~11l)1l111"r'~I,~l4lK',~Mh 1/lJIMI I l:tlMtlt;H~HII III lS~IHU/llb4
/llU H f pu"r,clI Ii ,
"1ltJ,........OTY'...FP~ijM~E/l,, '" ,. ... lJl.tJ4/i11'11l)/I ,..~,........,.... '....liNn 1'/ill:l.
1,' ",,' , I, >In>>" :> nllM, '1\111 I ,
.
, ,11)/1 /! 2 ro r /'IL LMHlII K I'IlII/H
,",."". "~_.._...~.......'........,..........,............_.....,.......". .,,'~....~ .....,..-.... .,..., .., .. ..... ......., 'H ..... ....... .....,
:) lIICV7. PR~Y E~"t.:TRIGA~ lJHlIlIl ;' 11;1;11([;) n~4
UUlHlJM~ll I III EEl ,L,lllltrEIUml/'l1' Fll1l~ ~lIllm , ",
III U NIlT Of .
I \
' 'IJ '" ", '(11 Y 'n"/llIMIJl:N ,,,,"'-_..,, "..--Jl',l:lIUI/JI' llllN '....,.. " "'lJljll "Iii 1:/: '
, ~ ,\ JI)/,l":) 101111, I''/\I'i/!!
" .
\ . Ill}' " ~3 /l)) Ill, 1,lIlJl)l'~ ~ rWi)!i
"':-.""I'~ "...........,. . ..~ ...........-.......-.....,..-.... . ... "... .., ,.,. ... ... ...... ... . . _N .J.'........ ." .. .... ....__ .... ..,._ ,
4 3'n:vz M;CWliI'UIHl,(' 11/111 I J (). i'lI 1l-. r:lll II) 1\ ;?'l
I:'/Ijli}rll N Ilflll1l1nln .. 111.1"11Ai:1 11lt'IIIltlll /1,111111 Illllill
1'\[1" ~
lc-'AI:I,IJ 1l/lljU
. I
PI ""..-rJl'y'...'n../ulMI'~JI".,.".. ,--" "'.. "UHI\II/lI'lllIll ' ,......, 111I111'//11;(
" i I 1/,O;!I)b:,14 ,~ UlJ'l IlH'l.bll,' , liAR/~i\HIY
hiiVi' - . ..- .... i.,;",i~Ei~--~jii; ;;:;~:I;JItl1;;;1t--;!;:::,'~;;:): . . .. .-..::::
fiY~'~~I'c~NR~" RE. 1I1J6 I.IJ!.I
\ ' ,
ll".....IJI'Yn'.NlIMm,I"I."..._....~,...-.._....Iit::ElClm'rl'ml, "''''''" II/HI f'IIICf;", '
. ,. .JCHl /I I) II I AI, I"Akra ,
"illl" ~ Willi, [,>1111111 I, I'AJI~~ 11.1)0
" ......_,..,... . " . '.,. ..
"" I
.'
, ,
~~Iwm
" I
\
O.l)ll
0.(1)
............... .....j.
1).111)
'\
0.\111
\
O.l)l)
I),l)!/
0.00
c).oo
, ..
W,1)IIWIII
0.00
'.'r" ....
,. '..."..""". ...,........
'!(i(! bHI.~>> !.IfIll 411 t,
"H ..,...,~_.. ,..,._...,...j"". .....
, .'
".........,
...
"
I'
"
....i
I '
I'
, '
,
, ,
, .'
"
I
I
I
I
II
'I
" i
Ilj;]
, ,
~'"
awrence
Chevrolet · Geo. Oldsmobile ·
6445 OARLISLE piKE, P.O, BOX 510 Phone 766 0284
MECHANICSBURG PA 17055 '1-
lfJ/" I,.
'.J
HtL:III,1l 111m
I','hl 1\ IJtlIl)~1 IIIJ'lJlIll 1/111\11
JlIllIl n ,.. ' ..........
Ill: ilIANI( YIIl1. lJllI<, VIII,lIl:;1l ClIQlllI'ILII. i III< mil C I Hili
I flWIWNr:1: I:lIfVI/UI.LT..I!r:O',lJlllHMIl,IIU
HI 'iliV 11:( 1lllJll 1:1111 lITI Tllllel(. ,WI. /111/1'1'. jI,I,\,I.L, \Ill)
AIJf\lN IN, Ill~ i'l/Tllm:
.'
~'-
l
.
Q
II
Q III
II
~~ygU~~~TM!MI/lm~~~M~~ ~'ifM13
rJIIST, IF oUIlmp IR OR '~Er,IIiT FAILS
WE,tto~rt~T Ilf~E~C~F Wd ~ol~ ,,1 !r:R~'IfB
LADOII, IF USElI PMlTS ~E ~~r~E~'"Ho
IA80AI6 INCLlJPED Alill TH Till S FOR 'AIIT
REPLACe/.lENT ARE THOSE F IH ~UPPLI R,
ilW<iUI~l)lll''''''NINQ "ll"'I'~ N'IjIj
I
1111 I.ll Ill' .
,I
I
I
I
.1
lIJII\L 11111l)~,.
" At 1'1\1<1 I .
I)'" \il)lIl. I.
10 II 0 0.0..
IflT 1\ 1'11,)1:. . ,
1 III AI. lAX.'".
1IIIIll (tlVlllt.J:.
~l)::13
( .~3
.(11)
o .Ol~
O.l!\)
I
,
'.
"
-
,I '.
" 117 ~UU hUU4 ~h
I'IlU
l'IN,\II)J I'll' ~
t, 8atU
..., G..
SERVICE
INVOICE
'uruiSCHIVAO OLl.l1 00.
..hii "..',..'"
"' ,. milt
I"
reO,I,U, "'''"QOOO
~O. 110360 PAT~/rIM. I~I 9/Q9/1997 ~Il~
SAt prWIP MAATI>>
JlfIC/J11.lI/I It ,,~y
~~~7 Qal1a~ay d~1ve
~B~STOWH ~A 17036
(717) 5li6-9li44 (717) 0639-5771,
,
nrm'I'I'I,.," OLl'l'.
por. cotmT,
9/10/1997 1:1'141
1 PAOli I 1
05
lGCHG39RST,lQ96JO
lpe6 CHBVJOx.Br r. V~ WHIT"
li:NtJI N'1rI l/oe e,7rNS X.IC,NO, Y?'.~~65
MIJ,/lS IN/OlM'
~(jl~4 1
:16):14
ItA?'.,
...~.........~....~.................-........_--..--_.--.,.. ._._-~------._._._-~.
X.Iff/il 1
Olffl/!R STATIlS ABlI X.Il.l/n' IS ON
CO~B8 a5La'L37 SrOR/lp, T~ST /l.AJb~eIIlP ~/ilHSO~,
Ji'O~ IlI11XSl'JIItCII lUJAxmros /fOT CO*6SCT. R~n>(,ACIl
~=, =~:.P~~~sb~~T ,~rx.~~T~r.o~P~=iP:+' ~~g~.~~~~
TU/lOUGU WI~. AT Cl00 OO~CTO~, ~AI~, INSU~A~
l\NP RepOSITION '/.'0 PlUJVI~ ~ROM >>~lNG ON T~S.
RIIPAI~ l WI/lI~G ANP/OR CO~CTOR . /lB/lATIl ~I.x.OCr. "~ING
o/;1COPB I H6035 SALII 'l'Y~1I I WJ\llllAm....
JJ~Il' ,50 OTff HRSI 2,10
~~I~Y TIICH, 175
WW ~ART". 1
rc, n
TIcn CO/olMI
~TS
l'I1!SC I"P IlI'Y PRICli SAI.II 'I'YP/il
~4203876 SSNSO~ Y 1 w~y WTV
-~"---~------_.._~..-.._-....-...-...-----~----_.__..-----..-------.---..-....."
X.INI 2 Olffllllt STAT/iS DIUVIiIM POOR LBM<S 'AT VlIm' WINnOW
TlIIcn COMHI AI.XONiD/ ~UB8P AND CLlIANIP ~ArHs~sTRIP,
\'IATIR TIST, 01<.
It.PAIR 1 WBATJJBRSTRIP - Ax.I~ O~ RIPLACI 'ltom' DOOR v~.
OPCOP~' C1Q41 BALli Typal WAR~
1JIUl, .so
PRI~Y TlleUI 117
--..~._-------.......-.--------_.--.._-----.--..._-.-.---...----..-.-- --.----..-.
X.XHII 3 OI'/mlR ST1\Tli8 WINPIlUIIX.D Llf\J<S 'AT TOP lIlJn ~OIUtJlR
Tlcn COMM I NO !:.BAltS roum:> AT ItINPsarllt,p,
NOTI, WI~SHIliLP BRoKSN UPON ARRIVAL 9.~.97,
a'PAIR 1 NO CHARG~
OPCOPBI NO BALS 1'V~B, CVSTQMBR PAY
PRIMARY TiCHI' 117
Fel 3/'t.
,,1)1)
--...__.---.~----.-"-...-._--------_._"-.-.--.---._-.---_._.._____'._M ......~._
.."VICID...AATMIHTI
~r~~t~~:::H::~*~E~ I, p~~;rr'e},'
....-.. ' ~'Ll
,IN! , --. -- .O;miR. STATis .PASS. DOoR. snip - cOLi:a;rs .WATiR. MOo -. MOo. --... M.. ~ . "
\,
In'V
W'l'Y
, !
/Ie" COHM,
.
,C:, :II<
~,
WIII~i 'r/J13T1 IlJiMOVII Jm1J11l pOOll I\.CC"'IHI PN'I'/IJi XN-
$1 lIlfl"1j.j 'l',U1/1 TO (Jl)~P. 1'I1\.'r'/l~ Jm'O pItAI>>L xii
I~ POOIl, S.AL J.OI'/~/t sc/tB1'/ nOJill/1. l'I"r'llll ~'/Isr I
OK,
.~I\XJIt 1 TIU,.. ASS",,~~y, Jl'P-Om;' POQl\ . Fl"~ Oil Il..~x..w/l IU lJJIT ,
Peop., CHU SAlili 1V~., l'IAAIll\ll'1.''l
~1I1 ,JO
RIMAR'l TJlon, 117
l'/'J'V
~..-"~....._........~-----~..._-........................_.~--.._....__.,..--.~...
IS1ON/i1l Ii IQN"?It1M
, , ,
.'
ClIS'l'OM/i1l 'rOTM "',',
',011
'.
"
"1IV~. D."~"TM.Nre
CM . lOW, & /lllllton $,.~m '34.....A
Tflucl( . C.me,on & PlIXlonllll..t. RORoQO<l4
COLONI~P~, A~gQu"n ~\.lI 114'''''''
! If
i-I
"
,
; 'I'
W:J ff. "pII"" DI "_/IItfll \lit. 1...11I,1/:
.. ''''''!IIn ,", mt/hPII ~n. 10.... ~ ,___11IbIe III. "rNlIllo/!, D/ '1rJIl~~ JII!)' /Ill
""iIIllllll.lItl4I.~II.1I W"lalltll'
HilI' mMC^>>i~
01
, ,
/'Cllall flrlin~tQn , loaneS7 11: 07
TOIMrs, M~o~ella fry P/Q C~p~~Z1 A~~uo1~t~a
PM!! .'S
COMPA" { r
J\~~~tfflX
!'PO' I H'J'flII\JMIRlY
TD"I 717 a,! '3Q6
lXT, I, ~'n HI ~ ~~I ~ 7
[]JJ t. n~H1AI. .1IIlI,1II~ 1.."",,/111' '" 11lI1olI1Il'IIn; '''toIlIl
Il ",. lIo~~llloII. 1011",.'I!, 'In '''111111'1.','' II/llllr Ihr I'A 11'1"'/' 1,/. hUYl' IIQ'I I'r'" 11"1,
~~ II.oll.'"~ l~r llr"/I"~l l'm'>llll"" ",,>j ""1'11/' I' III '"III'r ,I; n/I~~ "'I III" ~"llIrll'
Iv_d, III<' I,ll r"IIl",dl' Ih'll II,.. ''''''~I''II",hlll'll 'II III, '''''11''"1111 /I'" III"II'~'I
rnull ",' ".""11" ~."r Pn" II'II'! 'd'U 111.1 'lilY "'4""1 "tllll'llIlI >j/'I""I,
'I) Il,. .11~..d ~rlllill',"" ," 1Ir111 ""'I",d", /1"1' I"",
~~rr,,"L . rI~41'I'h...,
I) 110/1. nf I'll" ~"II~"I ~I'nhll"'. III'''''~ JlII"ilI,iI"
I~~", VllJ41', or ~~lnl) "I llil" WIII'I,',
ul' I II" "'''11',/14'1'' 'Iorl ~/I,'IoI
.','M '"11/ ~I/ I I'''I'U I, ",.
'I
~, ~:"1:::r.:~ ~~11IIt btyOllll MlIm\III WIll l/ld 1II1r,I/lll."a1" ."~ tJIdu.n
"or m~70^~1l\
0,
~)' ~ ~~ /lOI ~ ~'" oolallltl.., IncIftl!III 0/111/811 UIA' Wit"
,~.....,- OIl w.. ""'rMfI~ '" A,..,
~QI' m~7C1^al,11
.... Q~'~'~'-~~M^!'..('" ,
..,.". ,..1 I 1\ ...t...__
IIU. 'J II ~l
ClII. -
........
........
...-
~----
,
DIIt
---
u
, ....IW~I.-.
.""..,..C_II.....__...,~ W.
_111I'
;1 '
i \
PLAINTIFF'S
I-L.'
, ,
, .
,
, .'caIlJl f>l"li>>.ton . ./OS/lliIEl7 11; 37
~iHra. "ao~~11e rrv o/u C~p022i Aeaool~tee
PM!! "s
r:OHPMIVi
"i.~tFA~
/'lO' I HW'O~'/l;IY
TE~I 117 ;,~ 930.
cc;r. ~. ~'n W~ A~I P G
lJJ .. 1/11 pmi/I!lIllIllIIlm 1,.IllIHlIllI"IIIi)1ll1f q, /'/11I11 "1'/1111' ~~., Ill. Ill" "mcm ItW
! "" _ h~ flIlI.L I.... mil,
"'"" .~." '''' '-. IIltI ..', Milt "",ltlIWIII1Il.
"QI.ll Oil LIi. ~'I>.I, O'd"I'1 0,1'111'''/1'') I,~ I Ii,' ,."", "~'I'l', 11>,'" "II ;,~ 1111 . ,\lid
orllh!",,, w.,. .VII,I..'1 III 'HI'I'I' 1"'11' IIi,"I 1."'1'. II' 1"11' III" "I"'~I 'II' '111'11""
pl'lIh/r/ll WII. 1I.~ur ""III'/I,.d I'" ^"Y "I "," 111'11111, lII'flr"',
II, II'M ..,...." ",*",pl'", /lII~ ..'" ""'." /lII, ".., "11 Ii'" _.:1_"'" QYI/'GlIm- (1"'1IlI1I/~
,,~mlll~O,.,. pj.... .~,...I~ 11\. J.-III~.I,ij~jlOlIlllIt IIQII"""",~
"01' M'j'I,'(IAnl,N
('/'". .1.lur','~ P""'I'II" 1.11' hI" /lI'" 1'1'/'" 1""1 .)
/fJ
~~, t....". II""'..L _ltd 10, ~.;.. or ,tpl-''''IIIII.r II"," 11I.11I1
.....,. ~ lht ,,"'1I1rn~ IIW. P~... '~,*In lilt lacl.lhl"\IIlPlIIt IhII ~.",
I) 111. nulllli~" ,,' r"p~JI 111<"'/1111 'I" "IIY 11,,,..1>11"1' II'lllp"II;III~11I1 rlr"~
, 1111\ m~', l~. P'I'I"j"\II"I" I " I' ""'''11I,.,1>11' ,\"",111'" pr r' ,,,d, 'ill rlllll ~
\I~~"r llit ~h hl10l' 1,111.
II "~" rll~'IJMltvu IU~HI .11 d'YH 11'11' VI'I,;,' I" ~I'1i /1111 1II,I"r\lIl'l' In!' "II'"
Ih. ."r~rll pl'I'~I''!'lH .".., '1"/ '"HI II,,, I'h 1'''''''1 11111 "'~II'n'IIIIII" 1111111,,"11
,,,t rcp~i'rhuo.
i
i
t
I
,
"....... .....-'-Iw
'1"''''"~..hIt._~"".~~A
........
I
I
I
I
:
I
I
I
I'
I
,
, .
. CDaD Arli>>.t,m ,IQ!l/lea7 H' 07
'tolMre, M~r.hltlh' rry IJ/I) t:",po;::.:1 "ijijOIJUt"'~
'\1 "')tf,,~
, I"ll'
PAQ/! e
r;OHPAlj V I
~. I' ~riJ"\j)~lllJl'
IW:,' l1'fN.i'>i:JIJII'
l):;I~ If. IW'r 1'1 ,',llo' ,..
Ill,
,'" IAllH IIIt11lt11l hi lII. ".. ""~ ..,."..." I' t/ U.. dill. 01 Ul. ~..Il,.11/I1Itt iItI... In ~
~I~ .btYl~ .... ..,.,1lIt ~ I~~' ~ " . ...,'" '" lhl \ltIIllllt'l w..lt/l,lllll' Y/6~'IIM"""
~w...1MiHtI 141 _ "'U~ ~~ ~ ~I iJ",.,11Nbll I ij" ~I"il'illt""'loI, III 111. ~1oI" l-l n. .~.. ~
..",....,. '., I., ,,~Illll, M'''''' n".,.'lo~ tit ~"""IIe,, ~11l!t I'tW""
"""t ~'llt~ I~ "," ",,' 1IlI~1 r'lW "/111141,1,",
"rl~*"") ~'I""'I 1'111",\111111'" II vl'lilrll' III "d~ 1'11/1111111"11 ~II" II/Jr 111m)
"'ll''', VII."I,' III 1''''11'1' "'If ~"J'i",JI,"' ~I'II','I \01111) lilY /II Iii
~ m)I'ijl UI ~''''I'' '
,,?hll'II III 'rill. r"9~.c1 "r"'111I11 .).1"'1'" ,'11"1' 11)" '"11'11'''' "1"",'11"" "II"'? ,,"1,1"1.',
'\'~hlr/l m ~~rIlUj ~U~ 6 '"11', '~II'" "1"'PI"'c1 MI,~IIM.),y. I1," 1I/'~"I'IIlI"'IIIII"j"
~1Ii'1I ~.,\ II'tJII/'I'1 , ~'" II "I """,~I'''II'II'\ ,1,'rI"'I '
'rrl~,.,,'M ull~l~ ~III '11.1 I "JI' ,"","', "I '''''11'1: "W 1"",'1111111"111 '("111111"'111" Itllll
1,1i~",""r' ","IIL' \11111 11,1. 1'1'1'11"''''11 II u,',' IUIl'.~' 111"" lit I," nr 1ll'IdHIIIl'
nl \"," yl'll!r' ",
ltJ
~ IE, _'''''illi, l ~~ ~=r, "'Sill """, lilt" _/Iho """'1"""-" ill"""'"
, 1 ala ""1Ilhtr I~t ,u// , I"'ltlt u.., _., ,j/~ III lit. ...
... ' "" llltlll I t\of"''' yell",," . , .
"~'d UPQII 1/11' V<I\I~I' "'"1,,',111"1 "II n'l 1)', '17\ Ill' ~"ll UI, II"~, 1'11'111'''11 /'l'Ii~jr
.~LU~II\' I ql' I ~"'" . I liLi'rt Iir"!IJr'II'\, J I 1111/""'''" I 111I1 "~II" 'I( II"'~I 11'II'llill
P1.~I~Ill' '"b~I'III'~1 y I"'lilll. i11r ""'. V'" ", "I "111 Ilt.y ,"I I,ill Vrh!I'I",
"
,
-'-1lI~_1...
"...""....~........".......,_ hI ,......... V~
.......,
, ,
, ,
, '(;Dab "rUn.ton
.TOIHr~, Hlb~l#lhl
,/QElllElEl7 11 I 07
fry DIu CapO~2& AUUuU1atl#u
P,\QI! '/Ej
COMPIIIIY I
JH.IJt/'''X
---...
, ti".'
1'7VI' " ~'l:!VMlfrI'
1U:I' f'j'r.t'l',f'~
lll:I~ if, l'l'ff' (~I'JIi'1f
liJ, ~ 1'I....1II1)V".~~. U,. "IlII'IIJlIIIHII~g ~UIII IIQ,lClllltiQ" 1I1~ 111. PlJlblll1ll lie. In
_Iiln 41t1l1l1i1Yt "'1'1_ oorrtli.. 111/1 /!It dII. DI ,lIe "tll'WIlII
~,ob/"I HI ~L'JIIII'I"nI1411 I.', m' ""1""1 "H"IIII '11'1' l'II"I"~I'r'I' '~I'IIlI~'I'~ ,\
IIIHIIt~~'''" UI' 1i~"lI: -VI,
rrobll,_ '6) Q'ltrllv~ '"41~ 1111' 1""'11 "'I'II'n'~ 'IY ""r'm""I," ~II"I/, "" 110'
ri,HL'/II',', ,,,., '"'~1i1 UI "'111""" '11'1 "II 11'/,11'1' ~i,
III')
II) ., .,'" ,,_. IIIII,tIII lH'*lemt "'1'1 NOr _HI! ",,"'"'' 0111" 4,1. III I~' "'1lIt~.1
"ul' U,; '! 'DUI'."LIY" "'"' I""kllll' ,III,' wi"dllw,
!'rll~ ~~ U ~,'~rl'I'LIYI' 111111, '"l'" II"~J'IJ'. "y~I"II'
',n r,~' " 'n',"'!!I" .1,,111 I..d, ",I'd""IIIII'1
"" nil' U ~or "lid 11111111 ,
,
~, "'-' .~IIIt.. .,.,..I.lIlIIlPOl\I", ~ij' ",/lOIlIIIIIl 'M'1II1 p~ IIIIM '" ....lIIllltl
--,. notbtt~~"lI/~. "'0/"" ""'rtnvl
,..,ro(411). ,1.1 II/v ~U~I"'''''I '" ,,'.'Ii",,/,y III "" 1/11'1"'1'1101" "'I IIU-II"I';,
ili. .iIHk.d III"~'."'~ 'I, !" 'I, ,,,,Ii ~!I "U~, "" 1"'1'1' "111'1,,'1..,1,
......hr~....
.'...~"'C_.............. .10..,..... vA
-...
, '
, I
. 'qpnp Arliolton Oa/1ijij7 11:07
'~IHrl, Ml~h~11~ 'r~ 0 0 Capu~~l AUijUU1~tUij
PAOI! ,a
COMP/llI'Il
IIl..llt,r...~
___---.-m ........,,_,._,
1""
~~U1' " r'~l\I.I'~)~'"
I\:J;I' ,),;,.v::.~~
lXI', II, 1'1';" tll'~4' Ii'
+
Rf~IO~1 '011 J)le'I'ON
OUIIO",." -JUlJl.\'.4J.'i..I!JJ., ,
01' . I"'
II'"~ ,'I
1\11~ .',_fJJ.lli~!U.___
.1II,"",,-WlJ.W!l;:.tll.r/UH: 1(1 ~"/.I.1I/1
Uta."
I'~""'I-IP
",...! "."r...__,...........'""'.
,
ltJ 1'" W/OA,..,.,...~~~. 1/'" "..IIlIIIIII /1.. ~lIlulll Iii. IlIlllIWInu ~IQl/IIr/lI
.~ h',,,~ ljI,""I~11
I"Q~~ ~1I.\.t '~l' 11/111 11l1I~1"1' .1111' ..,"~',~'
rQ~ III ~ '""Ul'V~ ~1iI1"llIrll Ir"I/i,r, ~~~It'I' "
r~\I. rl'l~ ~ ~'~II~jV," ~Ql'r ,",11 I>r 1"1 II I!I 1111' (,lL'!' "/"1\'11111'>1)
r~h r~ f4 ~~.IIlIlJ flllllil','"11 '
rQD ,,1 U I'''' 'II~ 11111,1'
I'ob in,1I >ullll/v. II~I"
III ~~~ "'"" hll ..a1I"I~lJ'Il ~'DlII"" !thu" . ,.1'" ~, "041"1 , .boV~'
,*II to /'!I I, br III '" II AhHI' ~""/lIf . d...,.,
hlOllu, It:Tr '"~r."u~",jrr, /,~ 'IP'IIl"l"
,,) III"'". t"UrNlrrl:/"'vr.,,rl, ~/tl 1I1~9'i. i/ol'III!'
.~) a 1)~Ir,". l~r~I'U' tllrvrn1rl, III Ihll;,'/h. II! ;q,Qr,
.~rWI\t~ tjl"~I'r""I, (II 1~~DIi. 1,/' I~ Ur,
HI ,rm:t. I,II'\I.)'.~..~ v~r")I""'111I '''''1'.'''1'''''''' "llY 11'11111/ 1I,1i1'/~'
h 111~r. ,N~rrllf,'l!iI'VI'n'rl. ~/tl 'hilt""" ''''il.'lr,
;~ I'mr. ,,/ur~rrl' ,'I"'VI'n'r'. II/II 1~~OII, 1/11 'II' ,
U II,"'," Lllrrl\'" rll'U, ~/1l 1fII,1~I/. /IjH1l/"" 11'1~""",,1 "" 'l'I'i!'~', Il/llIMI~~9>
[JJ ""~liflt '" _MIl 011I11/ "/'I11jf ~_.. '/Ie 1II,1t"" pjobltm, W.,.
lIll..,..,.lI/ ,,"", ~ 'Ilt ",,!WltoIU,.,.., lit .....'" IIIl' IllIl~_loItll)l ,...ll_ -11"
~' I 4.~ (~/P '~3VI)) .~) Iillli'~/I !rl/l) 'I)I)'",~)
fJ I' 4..~. rNII lbl/,'Ofth IU"Ili) ji,) I "'IY (~/11I'.)9'1)
~OM~ II,> J "'~. I~/t) IlIh~~. h IIII'~~">
., ''''loIIuWIll9 .."", II/Ill)I.",..,.w...., .."IIlt_ ~; III '~"It~ 11I1.,. ""~I
~rDbl," '\!."lIlnr, 1'1'"'11' ,,'"
"111111/111I'6 ~ql~r\lv<' 1'lIdl"
-.--.----
"'-....,....,.\-,...
....."'''''CMoIDI''''".......''''" l'rl,""', v.
....,,,.
(
, '
, ,
I
I
I
I
",
, ,QUOD ^rU'lIrtQn .J/QElllaS7 H' 07
~IMre, N&bhell~ fry G/~ C~pul~1 A~ij~c&ate~
~ I H~~O'KJ",V
at-
....." M)tll~l\~ I'I~
'Ill!,1 117 ;~~ S:ll~
*~&. D.-OJ'
,
-
___1_____
~r 'l\JlM1,.,." (lIIMnnl,." ~01'()~ III v I ~ 11I1L____,.__
Minh".. l'ryl,.
...11I.
Cl,tVlo I,ll llo~or
r.i'''r~h~~' ,:I"~
roultome~IJ'1 ,...Ilbr ..._..!!l~1 ~ L II~ ij I)
..,".....
.
PAQ/! 'ij
COMPMY I
l\1lrhtl"^H
D':T, G, tn7 Ul3~ ~11 "D
~".., UI,VP7I,JU,,"
,
,
~'VI~'n" I. t,'II"~I',II'"'' lIlY I'I'IIIIII",II'IIIIY I..
V ~II; ~ I r ,
.......--......, ~.V.NN,<'...".
..."...It\W\., ....._.I.~._..I.......~_.........
, 'I
.,.c-...................
.....
PilIAtI_.!'!,' '),\,,1
1"-
....1 _
Pille,
".._.........\,....._ , ."d
, ,
.....-.-.--
I'
, .
. 'CDPD M'Un.tl)n
'~I~r~, Mtbhelle fry
Ililhtl'I\X
d OanGfJ7 H, 07
o/Q CapQ~~t AijijoG1~teb
Pl'm: '-'fl
CONPi\l.Yt
+ AlI'J'() ','N'~- ~,---_,_
(\(JCllW"M\Cl~ (m ~v.Jl';O'n()!': (>/" P/WJHI()l'i
I).tel
(J~I/qmell
~~.I"o"l
W,.ll"i"
(Jilt :>lulllllclI
I Qfl)9f97
Mlu/ltlle Fry e/o CI.po~~l & i\lIoc!nel
C/,"v/Vlo/ Mow Oil'lll""
1;01 Pi\ Igo~~j'}~qrfWMjl)
CIlWNZR4l
~I~ulo'cu 'I Ihe t\rl/ll,.tlml UUCIIIQII I" yUill me, We h"pc ;'lill IIIIVC Ihl'I'u ,hc elJi'nl ,//'II,C HHH tl~II' 'u<l ,he
Vl1'"lltc", a/bl,I1I/UI<t) I" be luJllrgelOm Ullu we II'''' I"~I you wlll/lp.! Ihe doelllm) CIIII~tlAh'c HI ull e,mcemcu,
P'..",e CIII III ~fYl)\1 hlAve auy 'lUCt,Ir~I" U!xllll ,he 0.1".,,111/1,
OOMPJ..~TIi: 'fHli: "'OJ,.J,.Q\V/l'<.l i\NP liIETUI(N IT '1'(.) us IMMJ::LlJNrw..Y
NOlel YQllr l'allll/ll 10 retllm ",1, mini within I.day' .hll' /1c oon.llderelJ p rC,looll,m o/' the d,:ohlon, Y<M ml~' WIlli It'
relUIJlI~1l fl/rm Ill" t'cmlllod ",aU III CllI YOllloalo Ipoo,al~lt 10 cOllltrlll /IlOOIJll ufYQllr "MIIOU Iii"" "Y the /lUll,
rIme cheol\; I/no Qf dill fQ"owlnll'
__ I Accf;rT TIiE: ARBITM,/,/ON DJ;:q~rOJ'l, , 11'I~crlJ"I<l "Ih Ip~U'"1
· ",<I ')II!III~II/I ~1I11", l"l9IHy '~Il,,,LlI,,."lu,llll> )"I~"~ci~~lllllll"LI,
· I. tQQ, will be lel!lllly "elmd, wbh:h mCllllllllivc ~Jl'llY ,MillO Ill" the bUlln"u III ~ou" <lIlIlIlY <lI.lm ll'~t
11I111 whblplbe 1<l0p" IIrlll}' ,,~ltr~IIQIII)cll,lllll, 11111011 tl,o hu.hle~~ Mil III pe,rQml .00111'111111 ") tile
AtbllllllOl" l/eol,lol),
_ I Rl'.:Jf;OT TIiE: ARBITRATION PIWI~ION, IIl/idcI",,)d lh" mO'''I'
.' I /lI'Y pllllue olllcr ica.I remedlel UI\UCI 11.10 01 Ii:do,Il1 l.wl
· de~lldlns <In rel/elUl 01 IUIC Ilw, ,be decllln>> lIlay be hmul/ur.el/ A' evl~e>>ce hy !lIe "l Ibe hll~b10" In allY
olvll coUrt Aodon reJIlIlllllIII .ny mAiler clIIIJ1dered ill t/lll Illbilllui<m beannYI
· 'be bllllll..1I will I1Ql be ohlll\lll<lu tu pOI'fnrm IllY p.rtllf rhul/<lol.lnlll.llu,
· rbll will e!ld BcUel I3Ullnm Burelu lnnllvcmellrln my OIlC,
Ollllllmrr Sillna'Qret _
, Par"l ,
[for BlIa u.., I/nly, Fon<l <lor retumed .nd prc~"mcd reJ~olo<lt
ClOO\\l'"" Ill,... a.1.rCCl, AI:".,"", V^ um ..---..--PiOiiiliOO:1liJi"il------------'--'---'--'---'--iw7QiJi'I,97l1Q
. .
, .
" . COOO I>rl1nltoJO dOE//leS? 11: IJ?
''1'011>11'1:1, MU:llltlllt1 fry U/'J C/l./I~\:(:.It AijijtlUl.lHljl1
J\1.ntJ'^~
PAUl.: .:e
c:ONPA/1 Y I
+ ^IJ'J'C) I,INI~
OrlQIlC, 'I, 1'/97
/WI uQ7 171) I " nl"V?7~2H~2 iltl> eli, CUI~rn~ & ^~~,,~IW'lJ' In nlle.,ll'_' MllIllI I ~\'I~lom
M,~, .\ll"h""" I'I)' ul" (~pun' Ik ^"""d~Il"
1711 Nml,li 1"1'/1,'51,
Jl.nilbu,*, l-'A I? IQ~
Uu.1' M,o.I"!)' ~/'I CaV'I"zl & ,l.",,,,ncol
~I'clqocd 10 th~ ~/!lhl.,uro p,.,MQI/ ~'Id IWJJ",~/~" fHtiilll/ Ih, Y<llll ~~IIe. 'n," lIl\ll ,\lITO I.I:-m JIm,,, m'lIl ,,,,,,Iv,,
IlIe ~Cjl/lplll'C.J ,'rr'/wir:,/flt!fII!/'" /inr"l III "'/1 "meOI '," IUlel th~'II. duy~ num III" ,lwl" "r'l,i. It,,,,,,, ,'""wll/II "'1
III~i1lh"I.',
~bll"'JQ'o hi llIlUI\lI'l'O "'NI!:,III m'W,," 'he" duulllllnA, lulle h'I" IIcU"'1II1 ull kfllll ~",I <lljl,I,"hJ<lliluUllft
1'l""'"0 10 ~ ralt ~lId jlln .Joolalu'"
If~'uu h.ve allY Gl,eld?O. .b<lu, Ihe declolu" UI If we m.y hr. flf lervlce m )'011, p'~4AC roelliu In ".1111" '"
1IOI/,'155,5'OQ,
ISlncerely.
Jcmnlf", RflWI...,.., EXlcnalflll 52~
'4100\111." ,iiiil~, ,,"I.'C~, ^,',I~'IllIl.. VA liIOI-- ---'---'~;jir,(),ili:liiiti-'-"" ....,._, ,.._....._--'_..--..--f~.,.97{1Q ...
~" .
,I ",
1".,.,
"
. .
, calif! Mllnllh'/llI/Of1/IAWf II. 37
fOl~ra, Miohelle fry 0/'\ C&P02~j AeQOG1~te6
~'Ol
FHxll1
l'~'OIl\ I
OQt 09 I
PNJF 'II
COM\'1,lliYI
'Illlhll'''~
Mr~, Miohelle ,ry 0/0 CJpO~~1 _~,.ociat..
1717~lHln
J"lmif.,,~' Jl.cI11o~'
l~ 9'1
R,' (~aV97~"B~2
Tilt. a 1 P'\II'lW I ~
"
(
(,
"
',I
'..... ..' .t ,.
'.
~: ..:1' '.
c'" r, ~
!~\ ,
.. ~ ' ,t' .......
N
r.,J .),1.. ~1 ....... \()
... I) :1'
...
r,l, u.. ')'1 ~ ~
~ . i 'p ; "'~:I
(of I .l'" +:
If\'! ;.0' 1;1' ~~ \
',,'rfl
f!.' I',J ~ ,I r:_ ~
;.I:
~ J" J ~~) ~
C1'
~
" ,
Ii,'
f,,'
;!.,
'I,'
I
I
\
'. . ..
, , '
,~ '\
I '
~.....)
-~
I
I
I
I
I
i
I
I
,
I
1
I
'"
IN THE oolJ~T of cOMMoN PLJ:AS OF CUM/3E~LAND COUNTY, PENNSYlVANIA
MlcHEtLE FRY,
, Plaintiff.
OIVll - LAW DIVISION
No. 97-6169 Civil Term
PRAl:OIPI: fOR l:NTRY Of
APP~ARANo~
vs.
CHEVROLI:T MOTO~ DIVISION
OF THE GENE1~AL MOTO~S
Co~poRAnoN,
Flied on Behalf of Defendant, Chevrolet
Motor Division of the General Motors
Corporation
counsel 0' Record for this Party:
CONSTANTINE J, PABSODELI6, ESQ.
PA. 1.0, #65872
JEFFREY COHEN, ESQ.
PA, 1.0, #76512
MEYE~, DA~RAGH, /3UO/<lE~,
/3E/3ENE/< & EeK
Firm No, 198
2000 Frlok /3ulldlng
Plttspurgh, PA 15219-6194
Telephone No.: (412) 261-6600
Fa.x No,: (412) 471-2754
Defendant,
"3....no' I
f
i
"
IN THE COLJ~T OF COMMON PLEAS Of CUMBI::f~LAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
MICHELLE FRY,
Plaintiff,
CIVIL - LAW DIVISIoN
No, 97-6169 Civil Term
vs,
CHEVROLET MOTOR DIVISION
of THE GENERAL MOTORS
CORPORATION,
Defendant.
~B..~..IABAtiQg
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Kindly enter our appearanoe on behalf of CHEVROl-ET MOTOR DIVISION OF.
THE GENERAL MOTORS CORPORATION, Defendant in the above-oaptloned oaoe,
RespeotfullY submitted,
MEYER, DARRAGH, BUcKLER,
BEBENEK & EcK
4ir" ,VL
By' , ,
CON T T, E~, PASSODELIS, ESO,
JEFfREY COHEN, ESO, '
Counsel for Oefendant, CHEVROl-l:T
MOTOR DIVISION Of' THE GENERAL
MOTORS CORPORATION
P3....IW' ,
'.
eBQ.Qf..OugBY.m
I here~y certify that I am this day serving the foregoing P~M:C'P~ fO~ l!NTRY
Of APPl!ARANOE upon the persons and In the mannlilr Indloated ~oloW:
~fl~'y"'U&.,..F.II'iI"GIULM.illl~~.!lmJ..uJ.Q]lgWJi:
Samuel B, Fineman, J:squlre
CAPOZZI AND ASSOCIATJ:S, p,c,
~ 711 North Front Street
Harrls~um, PA 17102
(COll/1sel fOf P/BI/1flffl
pated: November :2~, 1997
Mr:YER, DARRAGH, BUcKLER,
BEBENEI< & ECI<
/'~' ,i/
By: ",t ., 1,1 ,-;/L--
ONS TI J, PASSODJ;:L1S, J;:SQ,
. JEFFRE CHEN, J;:SQ.
Counsel fOf Defendant, CHJ:VROLET '
MOTOR DIVISION OF THl: GENJ:RAL
,MoToRs CORPORATION
113~"OO~ I
"
i:: '1'1 .,
~\.
i "
Pi'
I' ~ ' .,.,
~..) !
I"
"I' ,
I " ,I:
., l"
I "
LI" t-, d
u r.i~
,~
.,,-, '
I
~
I
" "",
rVi\ I
I\,l.ClIlL II, Hl^Kl~ hq,
I)/(!/ ; '//'/- r) ']/1'7
f
',I
CM/()ZZ1 fr ASIiOC1A'1JS, p,c.
MI'lnWI/6 M ',,111/
1111 ~orUi Inlnll~III' lI'tmburJ, ,~ 1110/
rlltphm (/Ill m,4101 · III (7111 HHIOI .loucGlplJlnllnl,co,"
SAMlJl,I,III'1NI:MAN
\
lllll'''"~1 1717) 'lill'~7l)~
llllll'llIllHHKllJMONI't\ 1,,\\ (717) J,I,I..IIII,1
I
, I
"
I
(
I
r "
,.
tI
\
"
(' Al'IIUII\N~)/~~S:~'!!.~[l:,~!.P, (~_..,...,....._
_. __~~ J:~ !.l.~I~.)~~Ll!~~'",. _ _ ._.______...__....___
1711 NIHII/I 1'1111"'1 SHill'
IIAI''''III'III', 1'1 "" 1 ',"1,\ 171i1l
'I'
. ,
I" i
'-"
f
it
I
i i:
".-
"
'!
.,.. .
I
~i
nelo..__ ,.. "-'.., '. Ho~r.. '" _",..
1b ,....,__,......, ...._'..'.._........__.........,,__..,. '...._........",'
M '.. W:tj;O~,~2~~~~O_UT
0/ ..,,_..~'" ":",,,:. !1:1jJiJ;;.:;.:;"
~::'l0,:.::;::......_ _.... ;~::,:~~:~;{~;~~;~ ..,..":'..,
11110 honed Rol~"'od cell Lilli Poe 0
Ploeuo Coli WOB In lOeB 600 Me
ell elll Will ol~m lOR I
/"
f' ,
',I
\
el~.. ~~7Zd..~,=S1f3..-:~__iii2' -.=
"-.... ,'--,.._-,---,---,-----..,-2L14 '
~~~~~-P;.t~jfT---
f'Jiff1!P~-~
61 nld_
"
")~VOAY Aooll00A No, '/21l!
,",
1 \,'
I
I
f
,I
11\
I ,\
"
,
~14; \V1lh A..",II<I ~I
"
'.
'I
,
t! 'I
r
1'1
,,,;--'.' ,
Dala ,
".'uu, Hour ___""
TO"UWHILEUYOUWEREfou'r
.., ,7' t,,p:-:~
M,
l.;:l.:.Y;':!j'~-.",
? liLt,.". ".._
?] "I
" ,.1',",""1,." ,...r.-:.12.,( ~
~"';:(/ ,,' --..
" " -,'-../
01,
PhQn!) .,._I~~.<:l~.l~
"AX ._ r.!~~.~_l~.'
Tale honad
plaasa Call
Will Cal A Rln
M~,s~~Q,L
. .!~l,~!!~! '.
Ralurnlld Coli
Was In
Will Autum
Lall Pac~a Q
Plaaua Baa MQ
1111 orlanl
\
III n.d _~_____,____
"',Amw ~EOIlOEIl No, ~rUQa (i) M".. Willi ""/elon P'II"
,
I'
.-
;.-..t.,....:...,.~._ _
..".,/
i
I
~
f
~h.-..-
I
".' , \
. ... r....'..- .~. ~:;'. ,~. '-'.. ,'_. t.--..
O.k".
.. .'Ii '.
.........
Indicat~ trial counsel for other parties if known.
2000 Frick Building, ~ittsburgh,~A 15219-6194
.1A f ft'AY
~QhAr'.
,
F!Ac;Jlli l"A
'I
}!B~!i~rJU:91UJ1}}11mLSM!U:'9JL!J~J!1~11
(M\.mt l.Jo typl.lwdlloll IIIld Hutlllittuu in dupHctltcl)
'/Q 'mE; PIP1'II~Yl'(IIlY 01" CUMUf:'ll/IN.J mU1'm
Plctlull lillt tho t'Cll.l'lI'IimJ CIlHQI
(Chock one)
( x
tor ~l)JlY It'ial lit tl1Q noxt tOJ:lIl ot civil CClUl:'t.
tor tr.illl without II jury.
------------------------------------~----
C/\P1'ION 01" CASJ;;
(orUre caption nlJst be stated in fUll)
(chcck Qno)
( x) civil /lOtion - JAw
( {\Ppofll tJ:'Olll l\I:bitration
Miohelle Fry
(other)
(Plaint iff)
vs.
Chevrolet Division of the
Qereral Motors Corporstion
'rha trial Hst will be called on
lInd
.1"t:}~ 9r 1Q96
(Defendant)
'1'rillls COImlllflce on.1111 y f>, 1 Q9R
Pretrials Will be held on JUne 17" 1996
(ariefs are due 5 days before pretrials.)
('1'110 party listing this case for trial shall
provide fortllwitn a copy of the praecj.pe to
1111 counsel, pursuant to local ~le 214.1.)
vs.
I'lo. 6169
Indicate the attorney wno will try case
Civil 19 Q7
for. tile party who files t/')ia praecipe,
Samuel B. Finemaq.EsQuire,t711 N. Front St.,HnrriBburq, PA 17102
,/'
.",/ ./
"
'/
Patel
~!~1);f
/~'. .-
Signed!. --;;-' /' 5'
Print Narm. Samuel B. Flneman,E,quire,
'1~is case is ready for trial.
Mtorney for.
~laintiff
"
r -. ....
IN r.-.
., t,'#
O.j ~ ';;;".1,'
&f~ 'J ".
:x: ..' =1'
"J ~. '~I ~j
~I!I " I.,.
"r it. I.)
.... "i lil~~
LJ I ~ i;.]I.~
,., ;:1
~1 ffi :3
..
\
\
1111, II
, I, I "lid;
Jil)l III 111111il',
'A'>! 11'11 1 "/ ')'1", I
IIIIII"II\II-'AI 'II I "I 'I,/Irl "I '1/\11 Ii',
,,1'111', Iii-' 111'1111," till I
I')i)' /"11 JI,I,:! I,!,;
V!I.
IJWV)lI)!,Vl I'L"JI.IIi !';')',
F ,nl'!!!I.~liL.JSJ 1,/'1:,,',.
!"hlilJ 1.'-', \illl') IJr-1lrlll dill'!, 11'1,11)11"1 ill::r!11Idl.lll,J
I,,) j"w, liilY", IIi,,1 1)1' ''',l'j" " '/11.1,'1"111 I~"","II '111,1 111'1'.111 Y \," I',lil' WLlellill
ll'IIIIl}1j dl:l 1'1.11\1111111.,
'-U 'vi II.
h IJ l. Wdr,l IlIldh 11..' t.n
1,1:11::;)1.1:-.1
,,:m;YJll,IJ,J;1 J'Jl)lDIL)lJY.l~:J'JfI, 1))-'
'I'JI!:: ill';!H',/if!), I'!rJrl!J!~;; '1l)!j'IJ/I,\J'JIi/J
T/l':'JlI___, III hll' IFILI1WI"\o"
PJI.!I,i\Pr;J,P!J!A I,""lll.y,
II JjJ I':WH')' II J)f[
Ih.J 1.lhnl..l I" r:) I" 1 1
r'r,>1I1H.1Y ItJiHI 1,0},
d81.1111,1'.",d I h,,' I,Ii"1 1,\ t "r
t.o 'W'I'm I,hl' wi HI In )jUlI'"h
\....
IJI'I ..J1!,IY
_~~Hl./. 1'1.'::.1U.
j IIJli u' r LI;I~J W<l1i 1.11 I'l:lrJl,l1 pl. ut
till} l]1~tr}chFld l'I}I~Urn frulII
")LI Ji\/.!J,;!'!'JlJIi
1.:'Jl)1I1. ~/, IJt:.'IIIHJY I 'Jon!.'),
nod"" Ie III\)
!Jllle of 1,;o)lIlIl,y
:Jl)l":horLJ~}
l.1"1plll:i,~"! Phi I,ll 1:'1)
IfJ.'l)ljJ
'..1, In,l
:~. ~')11l
':1/\,/,1,)
')f17';1~0 ',~M'I)::;,:J ,', A',~,']I'
(i'J'j / :' I / I 'J',)(I
~.il) oill,'lW,') l~ ,...;/ . ~ ~
~-!/ .--,/' .--::/,
" '~?~r~/'t'?'6'~I,'~r~"'~-
1\. 1ifl t.ltllll I; \ t Ill"', 1 III r I J
>
:::JhlE,IJ"1 it' I;~ 1-: 0 l'.1 t',l-j I
:;.iw(}rn und nllbl?ll:~l-J.br~d 1;'1 b(.Jlllll~; 1111-'
I: h I. n,.,-1.lJL ,ill Y '} I 'f~~~:-c,,,,.._,
() ~ (
1. ',' ,"' J..!1..__ ^, IJ.
C)b"/tL ";\ -.\.~"". " Clip'll
" , ,_...,~!..,/r'I\,........I'"
I'" I). 1.)lliJ '}I.
'H~"'"'''' "~rLl"N - ILlMMClNliIlOMPJ..IlINT
{'~~l../
FrJ
CO/,\'-'QH f'L.~M HO, '17 r:,/(' 1
CCllIN TV COIII' r
V~fl~IJ' Ufl/ol, lij
Ot.V rO Irt (hv In)", 1'10, (illtll ,~
P I V tJ r fk ,&"'" /'tl" 1,,.1 Cd!"
(I ~ (, r ~) 0 PelendQnt
\~(nt...1 ~ j
BE/WJ::P ANP MADE KNOWN TO -_~._.,_______,___,______ ua-OelellQQnt CQmpQIlY
~y hQndlllg II hue and oUested copy 01 the within SummQns/Compllllnt, Issued In the opove coplloned moiler
on --/J.J})---I..:l-,,------_ / 19_U__ ,llt -1"';~L o'cloc~, -fL_M" f;,B.T.lP,S,T,
llt _ 1~3r 11).A!.:LCz.L-----.7---,~--,---,---.u. , In the County QI Ph~'lldelphIQ,
Blllte 01 Pennsylvonlo, 10 __f1JJ1.v '-~.fv' _____________ .____
o 0) the ololeBold delendont, pelBonolly I
o (2) all odult mempel 01 the lamlly 01 said delendllnl, with whom said delendallt lesldes, who IItQled lhal
hlB/hel ,elotlonshlp to said delendllnlls IhQt 01
o (3) an adult person III cholge 01 delendllnt's lesldellcel the sold odult pOison hov~ng leluud, UpOIl ,,,-
guest/ tQ give his/hili name ond ,elaUolIBhlp to sold delendontl
,0 (4) thll mllnQqol/c1er~ of the ploce 01 lodging In which sold delendont lesldesl
a (5) agent or pelBon lor the lime being In cholge 01 delelldalll/B oHlae or USUQI plQce 01 puslneu.
o (6) the __________ and olllcel 01 Bold delendant CompanYI
JQH~ 0. 13"11II1'1, SIJerW
So AnBwels/
~ <. \J / L 4~yr,___
By I, ". '~_(dditki-'!-.IW':...~__tt.j&.;{( ~~ ,
/ f)"llI/ly ,~r"/i(1
,
11"111"1,,, iiM71
iH 1111: 1..11HI~ III ~_I'"III'111 '~ll~ III LLIIIIII"'II,lI~" ~""HI'.'" '1II1'il.,IIII,1
Mio/)ollll l"ry
l',
,..
Chavr:'Cllot: Motqr UI,vJlli<1Il <It' '1'11<1 tJolll1rill Moton> CorporuU'Hl
!'ill, 1)7-616') CLvil '1"HIII l~_
tI~\y!N'IV. 7i lU'J7
J1t}i Illde p~II,1l
1")_. J SlIf.IUff Of Cl'i\lllf.RU:'iP COL'~T)', P,\ dl) bmb~' d~pullu Ih~ SlmlfT~r
COUII~ I,} m~ur~ Ihll Will. Ihll ~~JluruI"ln b~111~ mllJ~ 1I1llld I~qllm oou rlil( orlh~ PlolorlfT.
,~::'i' ,I...'''>>;:'
~l: ~/. ~.' '."
'f' ~ ,,,.,,...,......<' (.~.,f:.i.,-',~.
SlmlfTorCUl1lburlllnJ Couol'), PII,
'.
Aft1du vir 01' Seryl~e
l'iow,
1IIIbln
opop
Dl
b~' bllndloi 10
prtuted topy or th~ ollw1oul
Ihe tOOleOI! Ibur~or,
19
.111
o'tlo~!,
S" DOlllirl.
Shirlrr or
C"Oryl'),PO,
I
I
,
I
I
J
'I
(:1
COSTS
S\\oro ood loil,~rlhid il.r'Jri
mt 1i)ll dll~ or 1')__
--
SERVICE
i\IILE,\GE
AfFlP\\lT
S
s
,\1. fir' ~U Ihi
,"
o 'rOe ood
GOU moui hO'llln 10
.....
"
'"
0\'
~
--....:;:
/)
(""-.
\'t
:....
.'
MIOIIJ,:;LLJ.\ [''WI',
Plnintitt
,HB
HI /1'HV: COUll'I' 0';' cOMMON /lLJ.\MI aii'
cUMU~RL^Nn COUNTY, PJ,:;NNUYLV^NI^
C LV U. ^C/I'IOI'l - I,M~
v.
CHJ.\VJlOLJ.\'l' MO'I'Oll PIVHlIOI'/
or 'l'''1'l OENJ,:;JlM.. MO'l'OIli:l
COR~ORlI'l' IoN I
petondnllt
97-6169 CIVIL TEllM
eJ1li'=:J!.HJ.^L,_g.QUJ:Ji;llEtJ~E
^ pro-tdill 1I0nloronoe in tllrJ i,I)NvrJ-onptionad
case was held in the chilmIJors at JlIdqe Oler on Wednesday,
June 17, 199B, Prosont on l~ollilH Qt thrJ Pin inti t't' wore
Raohel H. Meaker, BsqllirrJ and i:lnmuol D. Fineman, J,:;squire,
~rasent (by telephol1o pllrsUill1t to pormission of the court)
wa. Jeffrey Cohen, J,';squiro, on !Jehnlt ot the Defendant,
/l'lIia ill iln illltion under the Mugnuson-Moss
rederal Trade commission Wurrnnty Improvement ^ct, the
~enneylvania Uniform Commeroinl Code, nl1d the ~ennsylvania
Unfair Trnde prnctices and Cel1SUmor Protection Law arising
out of plaintiff's purohnse ot a new, allegedly ddfective,
1996 Chevrolet van from a Chovrolet dealer in Mechaniosburg,
,cumperlal1d county, POIHHJylval1ia.
'l'his wi 11 I->e a jury trinl in Which each side
will havo four peremptory clHlllongos for n total of eight.
The estimated duratiol1 of triill is two duYs,
Counsel are directed to fllrnish to the Court
at least three dnys prior to the com~cl1ccmcnt of the trial
.'
.
term preliminary ~eqUe~ted points ~or oharge with re"peot to
statutory rules QPplica~l~ to the anse on liability, meaSUre
at damages, and other permissible rolie~, with speoitic
oit/ltlons to tho statutory soctions involvod, l"3Y t~~e same
time, ooUnsel aro directod to supply the Court with
preliminary propo~ed vordict slips,
counsel are in agreoment that the issue ot
whether damages should ~a incroasod ~oyond a jury's verdiot
unde~ the Pennsylvaniu Unfair Trade Praotices and consumer
Proteotion LaW is to be rosolved by the trial jUdge
tolloWing the trial, as is the issue of Whether attorney'S
tees should be aWarded under any of Plaintiff'S olaims.
.With respect to sottlement negotiations,
oounsel naVe indicated that t~let:e is (It least a possllJility
ot settlement at this point,
By tho court,
,
/J
i\
SAMU~L B, FINEMAN, ESQUIRE
RACHEL If. MEAKER, ESQU I1U:;
CAPOZZI AND ASSOCIATES, P.c,
1711 North Front street
Ha~ris~urg, PA 17102
JEFFREY COllEN, fl~QUIRE
~EYER, DARRAGH, BUCKLER,
BEl,BflNEK & ECK, P.L.L,C.
2000 Frio~ BUilding
P~tts~urgh, PA 15219-G19~
)' ,,' /
,I if.',/ [;,; "
(
, /j
,','/.,1
i '..
JI!, ~\J.
Court Administrato~
Ilkt
. ,
"O~A.U> lv-.o-~I
U \ 2.:; \ qe; - I-It'f
,~,
'- l'::l ',.
l''', I ,-
r:' ..
11)', .:,';
, 11. .:.. " I
Ii ~ \.-
~ ,I ,
," ,
"
111' ,
iJ , r 1,'1
" I,).
, ,. ,I
V (I~ I
I, ll' ( )
IN THl:: cOllRT OF cOMMoN PLl::A6 Of ClIMBERLAND COllNTY,
PENNSYlVANIA
MIOHELLE FRY,
Plaintiff,
CIVIL. LAW DIVISION
No, 97.6169 CiVil Term
vs,
OHEVROLET MOTOR DIVIS/oN
Of GENERAL MOTORS
CORPORATioN,
Defencjant,
M~SW/!~ A~P N/!W MATTe~
Flied on Sehalf of Defendant,
CHEVROLET MOTOR DIVIS/ON of
GENERAL MOTORS OORPoRATloN
counsel of Recorcj for thIs PartYI
CONSTANTINE ~, PASSODEL/S, ESQ,
PA, J,D, #65672
JEfFREY OOHEN, ESQ,
PA, I.D, #76512
MEYER, DARRAGH, BUCKLER,
sesENEK & ECK, P,~,L,C,
~Irm No, 196
2000 Frlc~ SulldlnQ
Plllsburgh, PA 15219-6194
TelePhone No,: (412) 261-6600
Fax No,: (412) 471-2754 .
JURY TRlAI. PEMANDED
PUllIIl
" l'
I I!
I ",'
'.11
IN THE COURT of COMMON PLEAG OF ClIMBERLANO COllNTY,
PENNSYlVANIA
MICHEL~E FRY,
PlaIntiff,
CIVIL - LAW DIVISION
No, 97-6169 Civil Term
vs,
JlIRY TRIAL DEMANDED
CHEVROLET MOTOR DIVISION
Of GENERAL MOToRS
CORPORATION:
,
'.
Defendant,
~w.
AND NOW oomes the Defendant, CHEVRo~ET MOTOR DIVISION Of G~NERAL
MOTORS CORPORATION, by Its attorneys, MEYER, DARRAGH, BUCKLER, B~aENEK
& ECK, P,L,L,C" and nles tne within answer to the plaIntiff's oomplalnt and new matter:
1, After reasonable Investigation the defendant avers that it Is WIthout
,
~nowledge or Information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments set
forth Inparagrapn 1 of the plaIntiff's oomplalnt.
2, Admitted,
G, After reasonable Investigation the defendant avers that It Is without
~nowledge or Information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments set
forth In paragraph G of the plaintiff's oomplalnt.
P38t1I"
4. After reosonaple Investlgatlon the defendant avera that It IB without
I<nowledge or Information sumolentto form a Pellef as to the truth of the averments set
forth In paragraph 4 of the plaintiff's oomplalnt.
6, The avermentB Bet forth In paragraph 6 of the plaintiff's oomplalnt oonstltute
oonoluslons of ,,ow to Whloh no rasponslve pleadIng Is required,
6, The averment,B set forth In paraQraph 6 of the plaintiff's oomplalnt oonstltute
oonoluslonB of law to Whloh no responsive pleading Is required,
7. The ,avorments set forth In paraQraph 7 of the plaintiff's complaint OO/1stltute
oono)uslons of law to whloh no responsive pleading Is required,
B, After reasonable Investigation tho defendant averB that It Is without
I<nowledge or Information sumolent to form a belief as to the truth .of the averments set
forth In paragraph B of the plaintiff'S oomplalnt.
1/, After reasonable Investlgallon the defendant avers that It Is without
I<nowledge or Information sumolentto form a belief as to the truth of the averments set
forth In paragraph 9 of the plaintiff's complaint,
10, After reasonable Investigation the defendant avers that It Is without
I<nowledge or Information sufficient, to form a belief as to the truth of the averments sel
forth In paragraph ,10 of the plaintiff's oomplalnt.
PIIl7UII
11, After rellson.able Invelltl9atlon the defenqant avers that It Is without
knowledQe or Information sufflolent to form a belief as to the truth of the averments Bet
forth In para9raph 11 of the pllllntlffll compl,lllnt.
12, After reasonable Investl9atlon the defendant avers that It Is without
knowledge or Information lIufflclent to form a belief as tq the truth of the averments lIet
forth In para9raph 12 of the plaintiff's complaInt.
,
P38I/11 t
3
13. After reasonable Investl9atlon the defendant avers that It Is without
knowledge or Information sufficient to form a belief as to the truth of the averments set.
forth In pars9raptJ 13 of tho plaintiff's oomplalnt.
14, The averments set forth In para9raph 14 of the plaintiff's complaint
oonstltute conclusions of law tq wh.loh no responsive pleadln9 Is required.
15, The averments set forth In para9raph 15 of the plaintiff's complaint
oonstltute ooncluslons of law to whloh no responsive pleadln9 Is required. To the extent
that a re~ponslve pleadln9 Is required to para9raph 15 of the plaintiff's complaint, sold
para9raph Is denied,
COUNT'
MAGNUSON-MoSS cl.~'M
16, The defendant hereby Inoorporates by reference paragraphll 1-16 of It~
answar to the plaintiffs oomplalnt as It more fully set forth at length herein,
17, The averments Ilet forth In paragraph 17 of the plalnllffs complaint
oonstltute conoluslons of law to which no responsive pleadlnQ Is re~ulred,
18, The averments set forth In parag,'aph 18 of the plalnllffs complaint
oonstltute conoluslons of law to which no responsive pleadlnQ Is required.
19, The IIverments set forth In paragraph 19 of the plalnllffs oomplalnt
oonstltute conclusions of law to which no responsive pleadlnQ Is required,
20, The avermenta set forth In paragraph 20 of the plalnllffs oomplalnt
constlllJte conclusions of law to whlcll no reaponslve pleading Is required,
21. The avermenta set forth In paraqraph 21 of the plalnllffs oomplalnt
, conslltute conclusions of law to which no reaponslVe ?Ieadl~gl$ required,
22. The averments set forth In paragraph 22 of Ihe plalntlffll complaint
conslltute conoluslons of law to which no reaponslve pleading Is required.
Pltl7lll
4
23, The averments set forth In parllQrap/1 23 of the plalntlfrs oomplalnt
oonstlMe ooncluslons of law to Which no responsive pleadlnQ Is required,
WHEREFORE, the defendant, Chevrolet Motor Division of General Motors
Corporallon, respeotfully demands that judgment be entered In lis favor,
OOlJNT "
lJN'PORM OOMMJ:RO'M.. OOPl:
24, The defendant hereby Inoorporates by referenoe paraQraphs 1.23 of Its
answer to the plaintiffs oomplalnt as if more fully set forth at length ~ereln,
26, The averments set forth In paragraph 26 of the plaIntiff's oqmplalnt
oonstlMe oonoluslons of law to w~loh no responsive pleading !s requIred,
'I
,
26. After reasonable investigation the defendant avers that It Is without
~noW'edge or Ihformatlon suffiolent to form a ~eHef as to the truth of the aVerments set
forth In paragraph 26 of the plaintiffs oomplalnt.
27. The averments sat forth In paragraph 27 of the plaintiffs oomplalnt
oonstltute ooncluslons of law to Whloh no responsive pleading Is required,
. 28. The averments set forth In paragraph 28 of the plaintiffs complaint
opnstltute ooncluslons of law to Whloh no responsive pleading Is required,
Plal/g'l
6
;29, The averments Slit forth In paragraph 29 of the plaintiffs oomplalnt
oonstltute ooncluslons of law tQ Vihlch no rl'llIponslVQ pleading Is required,
130, The averments set forth In paragraph 130 of the plaIntiff's oomplalnt
oon"tIIutll ooncluslons of law to which no responsive plf/adlng Is required,
WHEREfORE. the defendant, Ohevrolat Motor Dlvllllon of General Motors
oorporatlon, respootfully demands that judgment be entered In Its faVor and against the
plalnllff,
OOUNT '"
UNfAIR TRAOl! PRAOTIOl:S AND OONSUMJ:R PRoTJ:oTION OLAIM
131, The defendant hereby Inoorporates by reference paragraphs 1.130 of Its
answer to the plaintiff's complaint as If more fully set forth at length herein,
32, The averments set forth In paragraph 32 of the plaintiff's oomplalnt
constitute ooncluslons of law to which no responsive pleading Is required,
313, The avermants set forth In paragraph 133 of the plaintiff's complaint
constitute ooncluslons of law to which no responsive pleading Is required,
34, The averments set forth In ,paragraph 34 of the plaintiff's oomplalnt
oonstltute ooncluslons of law to which no responsive pleading Is required,
. PJeI7Gl1 6
'f"~ . I
35, The averments set forth In paragraph 35 of the plaintiffs complaInt
constitute ooncluslon~ of law to WhIch no responsive pleading Is reqLjlred,
WHEREFORE, the defendant, Chevrolet Motor Division of General Motors
corporation, respeptfLJlly demands that jUdgment be entered In Its favor and against the
plaintiff,
.jll~Y TR'M. OaMANOaO
P3117011
7
NJ:!W MA TT/:ll
36, The plaintiff has failed to Ilet forth a oaulle of acllon upon Whloh relief can
~e granted,
37, The pl~lntiff has failed to give reasonable notloe to the defendant and has
failed to afford the defen.dant the reasona~le opportunity to oure any allesed de'eot
whloh Is the su~jeot of the plalnllffll complaInt.
3B, I' the Ilubject vehlole wallllold by the defendant, Ilald vehlole was free from
defeots and/or non-oonformltlell at the time of sale,
39, The plalnllffs claim Is barred by the applloable Statute of limitations.
40, If the llubJect vehlole wall delivered by the defendant, an express new
vehlole limited warranty was offered relallve to the su~ject vehlole and Is speolnoallY
limited by the terms thereof.
41. The oondltlons as oomplalned of by thE! plalnllff relative to the subJeot
vehIcle were the result of actions or negllgenoe, abulle, mlllulle, Improper Ulle, and/or
Improper malntenanoa by the plaintiff or othar personll or entities for whom this
defendant hall no legal responsibility,
42, Any non-oonformltles of ~hlch the plaintiff complains have been oured,
r
P3l11Q1 I
B
o"t'."'-- ,l.
4G, Th~ plaintiffs olaims are barred In whole or in part or are limited by the
pl,aintlffs LJseof Ihe vehicle whlory Is nol In the ordInary ~nd/or Intended LJse of said
yehlole,
44, The plalnllffs damages are barred and/or limited by plaintiffs failure to
mlllyate damages as required by law,
46, The plaIntiff did not presonlthe subjeot vehiole for repair at an authorized
servloe faoUlty of this defendant dLJrlny the term of the new vehlole limited warranty,
Whioh was provided to the plaintiff at the lime of purohase,
46, In so far as the plaintiff seeks reoovery for any alleyed breach of an Implied
warranty, said warranties have been limited or excluded under the new vehlole limited
,
warranty offered by General Motors.
47, This defendant reserves the rlyhtto add additional defendants Whloh may,
present themselves throuyh the oourse of dlsoovery.
48, To the extent that the plainllffs seek reoovery for any oonsequentlal
damages, reoovery for sold damages Is exoluded under the terms and conditions of the
now vehlo'e limited warranty offered by General Motors,
P3e1781 t
9
r,r,
WHEREfORE, the defendant, Chevrolet Motor Division of General MO,tors
Oorporat/on, respec;tfuHy demands that jUdgment be entered In Its favor Elnd against tho
plaintiff,
JU~Y TRIAl- pe"'M~PJ!!P
Dated! ~une:f!L, 1996
ay:
o TA T J, PASSODELIS, ESQ,
JE fRE CHEN, ESQ,
Counsal for befendant, o~tEVROLET
MOTOR DIVISION of GENERAL. MOTORS
OORPoRATION
(
PHIIII.1
10
, '
,1,'1
.,1
I i I
, ..I
MEYER, DARRAGH, aUcKLER,
BEBENEK & ECK, P,L,l.C,
eB.Q.Qfj)f.UBYJ.Q.E
I hereby oertlfy that I am this day servlnQ the fore[joln[j ANSWE~ ANO New
MATTe~ upon the person Bnd In the manner Indloated below:
~~rl$t.Class Mall. adqresseq..D.l9JJ.gyJJ:
Samuel B, Fineman, Esquire
Capozzi and Assoolates, p.e,
1711 North Front Street
Harrlsbur[j, PA 17102
[Cotlnsel for plain/1m
Dated: June ~ 1998
PlOI7i1 ,
YJmJfJMtJ.QN
I, ~~, ~'w.- _' have re~d the foragolng ANsWeR ~N~
NJ:W MATTl:R, The statemants therein are oorreot to the best of my personal
knowledge or Information and belief,
This statement and verlnoatlon Is made Bubject to the penalties of 18
pa,Cons,Stal.Ann, ij 4904 relallng to unsworn folslncotlon to authorllles, Which provides
that If , make knowingly false averments, I may be subjeotto orlmlnal panallles.
Pated: June 1.1J , 199B
............... ~.
'I
P,3817GII
il
"
"
" ",
,
lll'
"
I
(
I
I. "
I
II, , ,\
"
U ~p , I
I
I
I
I
j'
CAPOZZI & ASSOCIATES, P.C.
AttfJ",'Ys ~t L~w
"" No/lll '/'!/lll,,"l · ",,"!bu,,. ,~ mOl. JIl'plion. (/11) m.f,Ol · ,.. (/11) llI.f'O)
~Hcm:~,~,~: "IY I (:( lIlT (W C( IlL'.:AI;
~'M'lllff, I ClJMIJI':'{~,ANJ) (.'()lJNl'V
I '11':NNNY~.v ANIA
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
I
....-.,..
'-.
V,
QVII, ACTION -1,AW
,
qIJWIU)J..I~'" I\m'l'()ll mVIN'ON
OF TIlE GEN~:llAJ.. MOTOllN
C()ll"()'IA'J"ON,
N().'n.(,J69
IM~"lhml.
CJ!AE.gl!JUQ..llJNC9NJ'J~lIJ':, NF:T'IU: ANI) J:;IDl
'I'll Ihcl'rlllhlllllllurYi
Kllldly murk IhcllhLlW'CUpllLlIlCd mollCI' sell lcd, dlscllllllllucd und cllded per ul!rcemCIJ\
hCIWCClllhc pllrlles, IIlUddllloll, pleusc rCIUI'JlOJ)C (I) 1lJ'lhelhrcc (3) sUpplied cl)ples llmc ulld dUlc
slumped Illlhc cllclLlscd sell~llddrcssed. POMUI!C puld cllwJ()PC,
RcspcclI'ully suhmlllcd,
/' ').'
,r ./ I
/'~/
. .'" /
~ / -- ..
, '~j-> ../
~l)uul 13, FI~I1l11Il, Esqulrc
I,D, NI), 75717
AlILlnlCY Illr PIlllnllll'
Duledl 6'/J/1~,
,':.. l'::. ,
.'~ r:"
Ib ~J
h I~: , d~
III.:,' r
, ,.
I:It , ... ~
J .
;',1 r,), ,."',
1 ' I i
'."1 "" I
/'1' , !"l I
II' ! " I
I , 11(1,)
.. , IlL
I . n;~ ,i
r .1
l:" ';,l
..
'.,.., ,~
~ ....
,
'i'I' , II
M~),PR' PAn/lAGH . UUC"J,~q( · Hnll\N~::" & ll,C/<
,'\ ""{t )1'1'~i41()N,\I I II\IITHIII MIIIII ) ':' ','.J 1','\"")
,t r ~1)OI) r,o,'" 111.111.1 )IN', , PII'L"Il. N'"I. 1'\,\ I :',/1 'I.,,, '1'1' (,II,: I .!II 1 II,,{)'.\ , 1',\ Xi (0) 1:1) ,1f'1 ;!;'i',1
1 ,~,~(,~. ~ "
/'Ll'i\.""",,,,,.
,lmJl~\' C'WN
,\l1l'rn~y."\H,M\\
IIJJI"q I.ll"', 1'11)01 "'~I m""H
1.'IIIIIIIII~~r'.'~1 1'I)h'IIr,\)/II~"b~'~lIm
flLi:: NO, GM.ml(l2~1'1
JlJllfJ 111, IOfHl
Lawrence e, Welker, Prothonotary
Courthouse, 0110 COll/'lhoUaa Squore
Corllsle, PA 17013
rtEI Mlchlll/ll fry v. CIl"vrolqt Motor Lllvlt>lon qt (,o/lllrol
Motors corporlltlcll1
No. 97-6169 Civil Term (Cumhurlond C:OllllIY)
Dear Mr, Welker:
-I.,/).f~
Enclosed please Ond the Pre- Trlol Stotomont 10 be "ied on brohal' ot defendant.
CIlElYrolat Motor DiVision of General Motors Corporation, regardinf) ti10 above-captioned
malter,
I have alao eneloGed an additional copy of II1ll Pre. Trial Stalelllt1nt Which I ask thai
you dale stamp and return to 111fl In tilfl self.addressod, slmnpod envelope provided for
your convenlent:c,
If YOlllJave any que51lcnR /'l'lgardlng tllI~ malter, please do not hesitate to call,
.'CllIo
J:::nclosuro
0<'''. ~
cc: .JUdgl) .1. Wesley Oler, ,Ir (VIII r:llc~'m'IQ Olllyl
-Samuel 0. FinemAn, !;:sqlllrl;l (V/.1 hl,~r.i/lI,I," WIf.t U S Maill
'I~O~U'1
r'rrn,lILIIICIL P/\ , ('II,\I<tl~.tll,"', \V\' I (lfll'l'.,'''!.I,. PA . ,\lll'II',\ 11,\ I j\ll'l,,;-\'.,"r, 1\,,', \.\'\'
"
, ,"
IN THE COllRT OF CQMMqN Pl.I:AS OF CLJMBERl/\NU CQUNTY,
PENNSYI.VANIA
,
MiCHELLE fRY,
PlaIntiff,
CIVIL - LAW DIVISION
No 97-6'169 Civil Term
Va,
CHEVROLET MOTOR DIVISION
Or: GENERAL MOTORS
COHPORATION,
PfUHRIAl. 6T A n:MeNT
Defendant.
l'lled on Bellolf of DG/l3Ildlllll,
CIIEVROLET MOTOR DIVISION of
GENE:r{/lL MOTORS CORPORATION
CounGel of Rncord for tills Party: '
CONSTANTINE J P/lSSODELIS, ESQ,
rA, IJJ, nG5872
JFFFREY COHt:N, ESQ.
rA, 10, H713512
MEYE~, DARRAGH, BUCKLER,
BEBENEK & EeK, P,L,L,C,
I'irrn No 190
2000 F rick Building
PillHbur[.)h, P^152 19-6191\
)'f;llf;lphone No: (1\ 12) 261.6600
rllX No (1\12) 1\71-2761\
JURY TRIAL DEMANDEO
'l~'.'c) I
! lip
:,\ I'
,.
t..,
'"
IN THE COURT OF COMMoN PU'AS OF Cl!MllI;HI.ANl'J COUNTY,
I'ENNt;YI.VANIA
MICHEllE FRY,
CIVIL, L;\IN UIVIf-lION
Plaintiff,
No, U7.ljllH) Civil Term
vs,
OHEVROLET MOTOR mVlslaN
c>r GENERAL MOTOR!:;
CORPORATION:
,lImy THIAl. IJIfMANOEO
DerencJonl
eBe.mlAlIHATEMliNI
I, NARRATIVE STAWYlf.JU
The plalnllff Is sl'lGklno rflllflr \frldar the MagnusQn-MOBB Fflderal Trodfl
Commission Warranty ImprovGlI1ont Act, Ill'! PaIHIsy1vl:1nltl Uniform Com/llflrolal Coda,
and the Pennsylvania Unfair Tmde fJractlcas ,wI ConSUI1101' Pmlactlon law, The
,
plalntlN illlegos thot on or about Jlme 11.1096, sl1ft p11rr.hOliiJd n new CheY/olel van
Subsequent to tho p1lrcha8fl of Ihe van, she ollerjes vllrlOlJ8 dClffl(lte, lhe mosl significant
of whlclllnvolvlls cJllfacllve antl.lock brakos (wJ W,jltJr ItJHk~ ThE.' plnlntlff flllogolllhat
after numerOl/s ropalr altfln\pls by VrJrlous servlcl~ fi)Cilltlos of Gf.lIlt3rnl Motors, the vehicle
remains In a cJefecllve cOlldlllnn, Till! datf:lndtlnl [llIeg86 thot it Is clIrnmtly IH1Abll) to
dupllclltG any deracls or which the plaintiff GOlllploins,
II: DAMA..(31;S
Not rilppl/(:Lible.
":UI_I'If..11
/IP' '"
,
.
III. WJrJ:l!Uu~..e.a .
1, ./0/1/1 Wnhsh1r
2, OS610lllllQd fllfjr1wmtntlvf.l qf l.aWffi/ll:l) Gilllvrold
G, Ol!lslunll1eQ rl'lflrllaenllllll!~' or EMllff Cllevrolat
4, Any 1111'1 all wllneaaall IcJontlfklcl In tilo plalnllH'a prli.trllll statnmant.
IV, f-~rJJ.EUr13
1- MlInll'~lctllfl/f'e NoW VolllelL? 1.1/1111011 Wlllfflnty.
;l, P\jrol1nse eOlltar,;1.
(j, Repplr order dpted I\UglJst 1 ,I 1 HflG ,frolll Lowral1ce Cllevrol~l,
4, Repair order elated October 3, 1 DOll frolll LliwranclI Cllavrolet
0, Repair order elated October 26, 1996 frolll Lawrence ChewQlet,
6, Repnlf oreler dilled Decernbo, 11, I fH1G 'rol11 Lflwronco ClloVfolet,
7, !-lapplr oreler dilled Murch 7, 1997 tram Lnwrel1ca CllevroJot
0, Repplr order daled Morch 24, '1997 frolll L;)wrOI1C,l ClwvrQlal.
9, Ropnlr ordor dall!ld Soplc.rhtw 17, 1007 (rom CII1'ly Roe,
10, i'll/pair order daled Septembe, 10, 19\17 from 8ulliff Chevrolet
11, Repair order dated October 2, 1997 from Sutliff Chevrolet.
12, ,{epelr order deted October 0, 1997 frolll Gtllllff Chavrolet,
13, Ropair Or(1l1r dated NOl!llmbijr I:!, HIm (W,II Sullltl CIHlYrolel
14, !-leI-air order dnled JlInlJnrylG, 1990 from Lawrence Cl1evrol~t
15, Roralr onlor dallld J(~ml~HY :JO, 188~ Irolll D~111i1f C~If.lvrrJlf.lt
10, Hapnlr order dnte!J Marcil G, 19.90 frol1\ (,ullif! Clwvrolol
17, Expert report of John Wet)!;ti//'
II;1n~M,' I
'"''
"
, '
"
HI, PhlJIOIl'llph~ or ~llbjl}d Vt1hlcla
19, Depolllllon lr~nscrlpl or Mir.l)rJllt1 Fry,
20, DepQsltlon transcript 01 .John Wlilh~lor,
V, F~m;BJJ3j;P-QBI
Attached,
VI. STlP~LATIONS
The parties will likely stlplllata to tt\fJ allll1m/1l1clty of >III r<-lpfllr ordl'lrs
VII. fJr:mJJJ.Q1'J,6J..Jk:lE.QJ3MhJJ pl'J
The d&fendant Is unaware or any additionAl Inrormatlon Whlc:11 tlw CQllrt mllY
require,
Dated: JLJne .\(p _ , Hl98
fl).Hl~:11 :3
,
'''1'
"
.
flRqgE-.m:.Jlf;J"j YJ.~.f.
I hllrllby carllry thflll./rll thin (jay urnvl/l\j tile.! 'C)p!)~ol/l~J '~IU:..n~IAL STATJ!Mf.:NT
upon Ihlt perean anelln the lIl~nnrJr IlIdlwtllr/ holQW
fJOrYIOl) bv E!I,cslmJllU'IWULSL..EJ[!JJ:.Qjg.6~ ~MIJ,I"JI5J.91SL~}i!;J~).JJJll9lI.9WI\:
Samuel tl. Flrlll/llon, f-t>qlllre
Capo;!;!1 ~nd Ae6ool~l\OS, P,C
1711 North Frrml street
Horrlsburq, PA 17102
(CO/.Jns(!Illor plclltWn
MEYER, DARRAGH, BUCKLeR,
8EBENEK & ECK, P,l.,L,C
Pated: June ~_, 1\106
....
J FJASSODEI..IS, ESQ
HEN, ESQ,
"]"II~flJ, I
~h-t:,'-;'!\J "
'I,,' , I
p't.dl-i:1:.:
I
.
,,,..,
CAPOZZI & ASSOCIATES, P,C'I~ ~UN 0 81~98
Attorneys M Lpw p,.'
l7Il "otth lronl SlIttl' Harrilbu,.. p~ I/lQJ · J~lphont (m) 1Il-4101 "~ (117) JIHIQI
\
"
. ,
.. .
I '
i" I '
. ,
f
r-
;..~"'.~ ~;~Ir-a;'- ~':':""""':.
'_.-,,,. ,
-,,, '
,
\ 1,1
. >>
~q ,!.'~I.l
!
.,
\
"
'I
SAMlWI.Il, FJNJo:MAN, II.HYlllr~
Id~'lllnllullolI I'll), 75717
CAPOZZI AN/) MiSOCIA'/Hi, p,c,
171 1 Nl)rlh Fmpl Slr~~t
J/ur,'/Kbury, P A J71l)2
(7/ 7) I)t)l.s 71/5
AIlI'm~YN '''r l'lul/l''''
JWClJ~~M;~; IIJ{Y
l'IIlI,,'''''
....._...____n_'....__..__..________._._.,___.___ _.. ..._........ _.." .,_~_..u....__....._.._n_.....
I IN Tm( cqlllt'I' ()/" C()MMON I'I,MS
I C1JMIJIo:IU,ANll ['()lINrY
I l'I,;NNNn,VANIA
I
I
I cI VI I, AC'J'lON - I,A W
I
I
I
I NO,9HlCI'l
v.
. q,f,VIUIJ.,I('I' M()T()lt mVISI()N
Of 1"1": C,f,NJi:ltAJ., M()'J'()lUi
e()JU/OM'l'I()N,
,,~
Plulntl,r s~~~s r~lI~r ulld~r thn:~ s~purut~ ulld dlstl'\~tcuus.~s llI' uclllllllll comlC~tlll/l with
/lcr purchuse Ill' u 191/6 ChllVrol~1 (j VUII Iruck Ihull Pcl~ndullt's Ulllhl)rl:t.~d deuler, l.uWJ'lIlllle
Chevrolet II) Mellhulllcsbllrg, P A, CmUlI , Is buscd llP()/l Thl.! MUYl)usl)ll-MllSS Fl.!dernl TrUlj~
COn)111133jl)l) Wurrunty 'lIllJl'OV~IJ)~lIt AliI, IS LJ,S,C, * 2301l.!t SIlY', Cllulllllls bused UPO') 1M
PlIlmsylvul)lu LJnl/hm) ~JI)llJ)lIrclul Cl)d.;, 13 p,S, * IIOJ cl sey,. ulld Count III Is busl.!d upon 1M
&lm,W~hILJnlhlr Trll~1.! Pructlces lInd ('onslllll~I' ProtectillltL!lli:, 73 I',S, ~ 201-\ el sey,
Th~ purchusl.! prlcl.! of IllI.! whlllll.!. Including r~glslrutll)l) chnrg~s. dl)IIUmenl l\:es, sui liS IllX,
nmmc~ churges und IIcellse I\:es, bllt cxc\lldlllg other lIolluMulll\lllrges und dumuges I.!yuuled $24,
S74,20,
Arbltruthmln this CUSIlIlLll) b~ bypussl.!d dll~ II) ClIlllberhllld Cuunty LUlllll Rule l301-1,
. which Kills Ihll urbltrutlon thrcshold lit $25,000, In Ihe IlIslunt lIuse the IUllllunt III c\lJltl'llwrsy Ihr
lIxeulIdij $25,l)l)I),l)l) wheJl the IIm,)UJlI ellllmed lIJ1ulJr ("lUIll Ilij uwurded, lIJ1d 1I110/'llIJYK' '~IJK llru
udded nJll//o,' the IIddltl'l/lnl truh)1J dumn/,!IJK ll/ldllrlhlJ elillmij ijllt ,i,l/'tl) 1/1 l'mmllllilrlJ udded,
~l,
l)JI or UhUlll June II, 1'/%, PlulntH), Pllrehuijed II 11IJW u 19% Chev''l)lel (/ VUJl IhJlII
nejimuulll'a uUlhurl~lJu IWW cur deullJr, hellrh)/,! V1Jhlclll IdeJ)lHjeullo/l Ilumber
I (Ie, ICl391\.'ITF 1l)'/(131), The Wlllelll Wlll! purchuslIu unu I'cglslllred II) lhe CUlmlll)Jlweullh ur
jlull'lsylvulllu, Huld V1Jhlcle hus exhlhlllld ~IUJ1ler')lIS delilels ShlCIl 11111 lime of purehuse, IIll
rel~rllJlclJd III the repulr orders til/' the V1Jhlele, 'l'IllIprlmury 1l11JHOnlilnnltlIJs with this V1Jhlele
Includel del~etlw mln'lll's, del\:cllw UlJlllue~ brukes, JuslldlllUlld stull cUlldltloll, WUllJr leuks, Ul)d
I"ur IJIlU Ilulse, The Jblh)whJg pruvldlls u hrlef ehru/1,)luBY of repulrsl 8/14/'16 (uel\:eIIVIJ mlJ1QI's);
1 ()103/lJ6 (del~ctIVIJ ul)llluck brul<es, l'uslldle Ulld slull, WUler leuk, uIIBnllle/ll)t 10/2~/96 (delcellve
u)\llloe~ brn~es)\ 12/11/'/6 (uel~etlw mlrr% ullllluek hruklJs, wull:r leuk, reur eJ)d Jllllsu)1 3/7/'/7
(delcetlve rudlo, wheel cuverll 3/24/97 (del~cllVIJ dlpSIIIl~ "'rUCkel, 011 pressure guul!,e, rOUllh nm
wltll IUJlI!, ,crunk): WIOI'l7 (del~etlvll Ullllluek h,.ukes, wuler leuk )t 10/02/97 (hmke rolllrS Ulld
beurIIlBS); H)108/'/7 ( WUler leuk, deleellve puwcr door loc~s); 11/12/97 (Ilolse ullel\ lront wheel)
Ul)U 1/30/98( tupplng III rlghll\'olll whllel),
A.
A lrue uJld Clllrecl ehroJlI)II)gy uf rep!llr ullempls lilr which Plulnllll' hus records Is sel Iqrth
il,lllulnllll's Exhlhllllsl,
n.
I. IllIr~hIl5~ l'rl~'1l
?
'J'/IU purchasc prluu I)flhu whlclu llllulud $24,5H.2()f 'J!)1lnuludlll~ ull UI)lIulcrul uhur~us,
2. (:1"'/Ilur~' ql~r~uHI
~. '"IUruHll
"Iulnllll' ululms Illcurrcd I)mmuu uhurl!us ulld L!lhur dl)uuJlwntud ulllluturul ullurlluB UB will bu
uslubllshud ut Irlul, "I uddllllln, "'ulllllll' uluhllS Inulduntul dumu~uH Huull us II)SI WUllcs, und
rr.:1I11bursumulll,i.lr rumul wlllelus,
c, ~):W Yt:m~'W.LM1:nm w AI!MN'J'lWh ~ n:AIt'~o.O(II' MJJ&!i.
pu/endunl Issucd scwrul wrluun wurrllmlus ,ill' IlIu vehicle ul Ihe lime of slllef which It
rclers III us ll'IIJmltud Ncw Vclllcle WUITllI)tyi,. p/1)vldln~ "humpur 10 bumper" CL)vern~e '':Irde'ects
1lI1d/or nOJl-cLlll,i.,mllllus durlll!! thc nrBI 3 yellrs lIndh>r 36,000 mllu purlod lIncr lll:tual retail
delivery, Only nL1l'J\llll weur uJld leurf lIbuBuf nellluut und modll!cutl'l/l were clleluded 'rom
coyerullu. /lIs uJldlspulcd thlll wllrrumy w\)rk wus ncwr declhwd by II qICyrQlcl duuler bl1lled UpOI'
II Wurrl1Jlty ellcluslllll. It Is lllso undlspulud IlIut rllulllle muhllel\unee wus perlilnned hI uceordllllce
with the mllllu/ltcturer's !!uldelllles, It Is lllsll uverrud thllll}cJendUll\ Is In possusslon of n coPY of
suld warrunty und Is rr.:quuslud 10 produeu sume Ii.)r 11'1111.
3
(
I'
\
m, "I~INql'M, INN1WN (w ','Mm.n'\' AN,. 'MMAliJ':/oI
A, MA(iJljllNqN-Ml/N~ tlillEJlMt 'I'I!AW;: COMM'N~Jq", WAll'lt\NT~
Co lint I l)fllw ("Imr'nhll nll<:u<:s n vh,)nl/')Il'Jftlw MnWUJJi9J1::M!ltiJLWlIl1llll.lY.&!, Till) AI;I
<:r<:nl<:s jUl'lsdl<:II\l1l ,i>/, prlvlll<: <:nUS<:H ,)1' n<:lhm "In nllY Cl'll/'I')f <:llllJr<:l<:nl jllrlsdl<:ll'm 1/1 nil>' Hlull)
or Ihl) lJlSIl'lcl 'If ('"llImblu," (15 lUl,e, !i2310(d)<I)(A)), Tlw MnWJ1lli\Jll:M.YJlJl Wn/Tn/l ;.&.lIs
hll<:/ld<:d 10 <:Ild <:<:rluln ubusl)s l'lll!urJII)I! <:Ol)sll/JI<:r pr,)dUcl wnmllll/<:s ulld pl'llvld<:s 'ill' ,'<:<:,)wl')' LJf
Ih<: <:1)SI ,)1' Ih<: Iloods pUI'<:llllS<:d rlus Ulh)l'n<:y's f<:cs, cosls und <:xp<:ns<:s, ~c v, VolksWij.l/.!lli..!l1'
6JnJ:J:knJl, <lU),l'll, 94-(.'V-4404. Dlu<:,\ J,),
Ills w<:ll <:slubllshcd lhllllh<: Illw II) b<: llppll<:d h) Ilw M1!JIJlll~.M()ss Act Is billlcd ~PQn
Sllll<: luw, 'lu1cl)u v, R<:4nlll/llh)11l<:s,Il)<:" 748 F,2d 10.58 (51h ell', 1984H l'Iovos<:1 v. N9)jhw~
txfol'Jr Cllr C'lI'p.. 4(1) F,Supp, 541 (N,P, N,Y. 1(78), An unulysls of Ih<: luwbc:ulns with U11
l)VUIUUllu'l of Plulnlllrs clulm pllrsUlll\1 to uppllcublc slul<: law, which III Ihls cusc, would be lhe
Ullllimn COll)I)Wlul Cudc alld Ille 111llhlr Trlld<: /1rl\Cllc<:1L!lJl!l',Cunsumel' I'rulC:clloll LllW. Thl)
M.l!.ll)lUsun.Muss pruI<:cllon nlsu <:xc<:<:ds Slllll) IllW III c<:rtuln WllYS, FLJr eXlllllpl<:, hllplled
Wlll'l'llllll<:s muy /lot be dls<:lnlmcd Ib" lh<: <:llllre teon ul' u wrhl<:ll wllrrUllly If the /JIullulilclurer Qr
supplier provld<:H II wrlll<:1l WalTllllly, Ihuugll the wurrullly Issued may ull<:mpllo do so, (15 V.S,C.
!i231)8(ll)), In Y.!llil.Y1'll v. Ford Motor c;oll'o., 433 A,2d 801, 180 N,J, Super, 45 (1981), Ihe
New Jcrsey Superior Court lllluly,.;ed the blelld betwecll Slllll) luw uud till) MU~llusoll.Moss Ael BS
,()UOWSI
The Mllllllusull-Moss WUl'l'llnIY-F<:d<:l'lIl Trude Commission
Improwm<:llt A<:I. supru, wus lldopt<:d on JUllunry 4, 1975, 88 Slut
2183, Its pUrpose Wlls 10 Illukc 'Wllmllltles Oil <:[)l)sulllerproducls
~
II, lJ
I lC
~nlhrcc~lblc,' NI)tc, 7 lhU/Iocm.('umdcn I"J, 3711 (/1)7(1), Th~ Act
~nhullcc~ tlw clm~umc,J~ PI)~llllm by ulll,wlnu rCCIIWI,>, und~r u
wurrullly JICt without rcgurd h) llrlvhy 1'1' contruct hclwcc/) Ihe
cL)ll~umer und wurrullll)r, hy pNh bltl/ll,~ lhc dl~c'ujm~r III' hJ)pH~d
wurruntl~~ In u wrlll~'1 wurrullly, und 11Y ~nlurgh)g th~ rcm~dle~
uvulluhle h) u con~umer iiI/' breuch 1'1' wurrUlllY. Jllcludlng the uwurd
of Ull1mwy '\:e~, Id, The requlrcmentl)/, privity of eontruct helW~cn
thc clm~u/)wr und Ih~ WUrl'untll/' hll~ bc~n renmwd hy u~~urlllg
Cl)J)~umer~ u remedy ugulllst ull wurrllnlllrs 1)1' u p/'llduct, Y.l:JillJJJl.Y.
"'Iml MI)IOr..Q)JlIP!illY, fulllLO, 433 A.~d 808,
Plulnllll' ~ee~~ rccllwry und~r M1l1lJl\lJill!l:Mwm ulld coneurr~lll stule cluhllS setli,)rlh ubow.
Cllunt II Ill' tbe Complulnt uHcge~ brcuch of wUlrulllY In uccordullc~ with th~ lJ,li"mn
~l]ml))e/):Iul Codll us udoP1Cd III P~nnsylvunlu,
mulmll)' hus uss~rled vurlous ~uU~es u/' u~llolll'lr breuch of wUrrUt)ty und, us UIl ~Iemem of
recowry. scek to obtuhl I)lhcr dumuBe~ Illcurr~d us u r~sult ufth~ ulleBed breuch, The o~lly purpose
ofthe lJ)llllulullturees New Vehicle limited Wurrunty Is 10 provide rerulrs lilr the vehicle. In tills
cuse, the wurrulllY lulled I,n hs essc/lllul pUrpo~e, Ullllilnll COllllllerclul Code. ~2719(b) provldes~
Whcre clrculll5tunce~ cuU~e UlI e;>(cluslvc or Ihl1lted remcdy to lull of
It~ essentlul purpose, rcmcdy muy bc hud ,us provldcd Il\ lhls tltlc, 13
ru, C.S, ~2719(b),
In nccordunce with thc JJulfon)1 Cl)I)llllCrcl~, eonscqucllllul dUl))ugcs urc subject to
,
rccovery, Scctlon 72 H provldesl
(c) Incldcl\IUI Ulld COllscque'lllul PUlllUBcS, hI u prop~r cus~, WlY
Incldcl\tul Wl~ cOllselJucllllul dUI11UBCS ul\der *2715 (reluthlB to
Incldcmul und COl\scque/ltlul dUI11UBeS of buyer) IllUY ulso be
recowred, 13/'11, C,S, *~714(c),
5
I
II,
Sucllll" 2715 Ill' :rJJdJJllJnmU:!Jm!ll.!lJ~nLuI!J.!I UI"IWH reellwl'Y j,m "UIl)' u<)J))l)Jur.:lnl/y
runHlmuhlu Chur~uH, UXpllllHllH llrllUmmlsshms In llllJlllUllllllll with 1l/)~lllhJij llllWr"l (2715(u)-(2))
IInd ",,,uIlY Illhlll' rlluNlmuhlllllxpllllilllncldllllllll dllluy <)1' lllhcr hrcllllh," (2715(11)(3)),
C, lJN'~AI't "'lt~J)Jo: 111{ACT,q:~ ~IS'~ CO~"l/l\j~:I~ J',u~n':~;nl)N q,AI~1
Sccllo/) 21)1.2(4)(xlv) del1ll11S unlulr <II' dllllllptlVC ncts Illlncludc lullllllllll cllmp)y wltll the
lenJJS Ill' UJJY wrlthm llllurulllcc or WU1'rU/lly, Hecll<m 201.2(4)(xvl) pruvldl:s lilr u vllJ)ullllll 1t'lhe
llJunulactur.:rl
"mukes repulrs, hllpruvemcllls IJr repluccmenls lln lunlllhlt:. reul ill'
personul prllperty, 1)1' U "ulure or LJuulhy 11l'~rlor 10 or below lhe
stuJJdurd oflhul nllrwd hJ In wrlthlll,"
hi,
OeJimdunl'ij Jallure IIJ elllJJply with the lerms of Its wrltleJJ wurrUIlIIl:s Cllllslltules Ill) w)jillr
mClhod ot' compelltloll, To wIll (I) dill wumuJly wus bruuelledl ul)d (2) Ihe I'Cpulrs mude to Ow
vehlele were hclow Ihe slulldurd ugruud III In writing (I.e, the New Vehicle I-Imllud WurrBllly
promise IIJ repulr dejecls IllllJuterluls uod workmullshlp),
Thu fucls sUlTOUlldhllllhis cuse eSlubllsll u eleur vlolutloJJ llfthe JlenllsylvuJJlu Un/illr 'frodc
Act. ulld Ull such, plullllltTwHl seck Ull uddltionul uwurdof up III thrce lImes the uetunl dU!llulles
Incurred upon suceesslul result In this euse,
IV.
I, I\busel Plulllllll's vehicle wus nol subjeello ubuse,
2, Ne~l.,ell PllliJJtlll's vehicle wus '101 subjectlllllegleel.
3, MlliJlllcUIIl)l11 Plnhlllll's vehicle W,ls nllt subjectlllllluterlul modll1eutloll,
6
4, t'imJ:S!))}J91'JIlJjYJ)!)UilJUblJJJJlJuJJmlluJJJmmll /I IN ~I~ur IhUllh~ dl:'~~ls cumpluln~d
III' Cl)JISlhlll~ u "d~'~~1 Ill' ~lI/ldllhm" whl~h NubsllllllluHy Impulr lh~ USI:. yuhll: und/I)r sUl~ly uf u
mul/lr w)lkll:,
Simply put, J>~limdulll's ulllll:lpUI~d dl:'~ns~s Ul'~ n~llh~r ~'r~dlbll:, nl)1' l!1'uund~d In jiM,
v. >>'I'J'N'~~~ L.W:1
l, P'ul/llIn; MI~lwHI: FI'Y
2, UnITY WUl!~r, H~pl:l'l,
J, Eml~ JUl:Ilby
4, Ju~k 81l:WUl1
5, MI~Il~HI: CuHhlS
6, Rob~rl Su'uywolf
7, AllY ulld ull WIIIlI:SSI:~ Idl:'Jlill~d Ill' 1:1l1l~d by O~'~lldul)I hll:luding lis e~perts.
CorpUI'Ule r~l:prl:s~ntuli ws uud/or Oeul~r Pl:rsulluel,
V/,~t
I, Should Plnllllill' preyuH. she will sl:ek u dis~rellonul'Y uwurd Ill' ultomcys' '~es Ulld costs
undcr Thc MUlJ.nllSl1l1.MoNS WurrunlY .6J;J. Ulld will pl:lllilllllhl: CoUrt lhr SUIllI:,
2, Should Plulntl/)' prcvuH on Ihc UlldcrlyllIg ~luhllS, Ihc 1Il1der~IBned will seek a
dlseretiollUI')' uwurd of up II) Ihrec lhlles Ihe dUlllugcs reeowr~d, pursuunt 10 PC/llIsylyunlu's Unfair
Trude Pruellecs A~l und CUlIsulllcr Prul~~lIl)l) l.uw 73 Pu, C,8, * 1961. UpOIl Pelhlollto Ihe Court,
7
VI'.
I, "lllllllln'~ ~llavl l)J)~ dllY,
2, Pvlimdllllt'~ ~1l~~1 ll,w.hlllf dllY,
vm, lOOJJJlll!J./iIl
"I, MUllulu~tur~r~ VNW'V~~ WrlUVll wurrullty (II) bv ~urpHvd by PvlimdulIl)
P2. purvhll~v C()ntru~t
P3, l.uIIIl pl)~UmVllls
P4. 1{~J1ulr Ordvr dUlvd AUl!ust 14, 1996 1111111 J.uwrUllUU CI1UVroJUt,
PS. HUJ1ulr Ordur dUlud O~lubur 3. 1996 Ihlln J.llWrUlluu Chuvrolut,
P6, HUJ1ulr Ordur dulud (Mubur 2H. 1996 Ihmll.uwrulluu Chuvrolul
P7, Hupulr Ordur dlllud lJuuumbur II, 1996 Ii'om I.uwrullcu Chvvrolet
PH, HCJ1ulr Order dilled Mllruh 7. 1997 from I.uwrellue Chevrolet
P9, HCJ1ulr Ordcr dlllcd Murch 24. 1997 Ih1m l.uwrence Chevrolet
PIO, Repulr Order dUlvd SVJ1lember 17. 19971h>m Cl'llly Rowe
P II. Rvpulr Order dilled Suptvl)lber 10, 1997 !rom SUlH 11' ChevNlvt
P12, Repulr Ordvr dUlcd Octuber 2, 1997 Irom SutHll'Chvvrolet
PI3, Repulr Order dUled OClober 8. 1997 111m) SUlllff Chuvrolel
P14. Repulr Ordur dUled Nllvcmber 12, 1997 Ihlln SUtlll1' Chevrolet
PIS, Repulr Ordvr dUlvd JUllllUI)' 16, 1998 Irom Lllwrellue Chuvrolet lor Chcvrolet
Illspectloll.
8
9
I'll), J~~pulr ()rLJ~r LJIII~LJ JUllUIII')' 311. 1l)'IH Ihlm HU1H/rl'h~vrul~1
1'/7, J~~pulr()!,LJ~rLJul~LJ MIII'~JI (" 1l)'IH Ihml HUllllrCh~VI'o'~1
PI H, J(XP~I'I 1~l!J1orl ofJIulT)' Yl!lIijl!r
1'1'/, curl'l~ulum Vhll~ ofJIlln)' WIIIJ,~1'
1'2(1. T~~lml~1I1 H~l'vl~~ lluH~IIJl~ 1~~u~LJ b)' l'h~VJ'"I~llhut r~Jul~ to thl! ~ubJ~~t whlclll'&
~lm~Cm~,
Plulmln' cxr~~t~ J>cl\mLJunt l'hryKlcr II) ~tlpululC tl) Ihllllllml~&lbIHI)' of ull CXlllblts, .1'III'm.
SIlW Jixhlblt~ "P2!)", PJulnlln'~ Jix.hlblt "P2()"I~ uLJml~~lblc hllllOU~~ T~~hnlcul Scrvl~~ lluHctln& lII'C
tlllllollllllllll to port)' IIdml~sllm~ of dcli:ct b)' Ihll "lonulil~lurcr, As II rll~ult, thll)' ~hQuld be
,
Udllll~~lb'c, pI'IlHUIIlIIll! uuthc/ltlclt)'.
"
,
l
\ .
,x,
H~IIII:")l:nt 1l~l/.lltllltlllIlH hllw h~~1l 1Il\~III,lll:J lhrl)lIl/.hl)lll lhu ~IIH~, wllh lh~ I'UrtIUH hl:lllll
ulluh/1: III 1Il/.IW II'lll /lIIIIUlIlly 1Il/.IW,,11II: Uml)Ulll,
x, ~:()Nq.IJ/i,q~1
Plu'"II/1' l'l!H/ll:l:l/ully rl:qlll:H1H IhuI jIlJUI))~/l1 b~ ~nl~rI:J III h~r jilVIlr UIlJ 'IUnIIlHI P~limdlllll
UH H~l liml, IW/'IIln.
C^,'OZZI & AsSOqi,\"'r.rs, 1',C,
/'/ ~
I) ./'(., / '
fYI~" _
Smllul:l H. FIIJeJ)lnn, L\Hqulrl:
J,P, NIl 75m
171 I North From SIJ'I1I:I
IInrrlHhljru, l'A 17102
Attl)m~YH lhr Jllnllllll)',
MI~hI:IlI: Fry
" )
pnlcdt f.';' J' .,-1.('
.' ..
10