The URL can be used to link to this page

Home My WebLink About97-06665 ~-,-' 1'_1 NOTICE " ~, "I l', " r /II I J I I I ?, , , , , ' " You lmvc bccn 5ucd ill court. If you wi5b to dcfcnd IIgah15tlhc c1l1lms 5cl forth inthc li)lIowing pagcs, you mU5t lllkc aCllon withintwclllY (20) daY5 aftcr thi5 compltlintand noticc arc 5crvcd, by cntcring a wriltcnappCa\'llllCC pcr5011ally or by altol'l1cy und nllng in writing with thc court your dcfcll5cs OJ' obJcctlons to Ihc c1ahm 5Ct Ibrth IlgalnM you, You arc warncd that If you fail to do 50 thc ca5C may procccd without you and a Judgmcnt I11I1Y bc cntcrcd ugllln5t you hy lhc court without furthcr noticc for any 111l'ncy cllllmcd In thc compluillllll' 101' any othcr c1uim l)l' rclief rcquc51cd by thc plllintlff. You mllY 105c moncy 01' propcrty 01' othcr rights important to you, YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE, IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP, Cumbcrland County Court AdministralOr Cumbcrlllad Coullly Counhou5c Onc Courthou5c Squarc, 4tb Floor Car1l51c, PA 17013 (717) 697-0371 A VISO Lc han dcmandado a u5tcd cn la corte, Si u5tcd defcnder5c dc c5las demanda5 expuC5tas en law pagina5 siguicntcs, ustcd tienc vcintc (20) dia5 dc phlzo al partir de la fccha de la demanda y la notilicaclon, Hacc flllta 115cnUII' una comparcncia cscrila 0 en pcr50na 0 con un abogado y cntrcgar a la cortc cn forma c5crita 5U5 d,:fen5as 0 SU5 objcclones a la5 demandas en contra dc su pcr50na, SCII avisado quc si ustcd no se dcfiendc, ia corte tomara medidas y puede continuer ia dcmanda cn contra suya sin prcvio aviso 0 notil1cacion, Adema5, ia corte puede decodor a favor del demandantc y rcquicrc que ustcd cumpla con lodas law provisiones de esta demanda, Usted pucde pcrdcr dincro 0 sus propicdadcs u otros derechos importantes para uSlcd, LLEVE EST A DEMANDA A UN ABOGADO INMEDlATAMENTE, SI NO TIENE ABOGADO 0 SI NO TIENE ELDlNERO SUFlCIENTE DE PAGAR TAL SERVICO, V A Y A EN PERSONA 0 LLAME POR TELEFONO A LA OFICINA CUY A D1RECCION SE ENCUENTRA ESCRITA ABAJO PARA A VERIGUAR DONDE SE PUEDE CONSEGUIR ASISTENCIA LEGAL. Cumbcrland County Court Administrator Cumbcrland Coullly Courthouse One Courthouse Square, 4th Floor Carlisle, PA 17013 (717) 697-0371 " ,', c.oMe.l,.A.L~i.,[ Phlhlllff~, hy ami through thclr allOI'l1CYS, Morgan & Morgan, P,C" herchy cmnpluln against ()cfendunts and uver a~ follows: (, Plaintiffs ure adalt Indlvlduuls and hashuud and wlfc, rcsldlng at thc ahove addres~, 2, Defendlllll, Glalll Food Slores [nc" Is a husiness OI'gunizutlon with a principIII place of huslness ut the ahove addrcss, 3, Defendullt, Doevllle Limited Partncrship, is a business organization with a sole general panner locatcd at Fawn Corporation, RD /II, Box [54, Gardners, PA [7324, 4, Defendllnt, John L. Ruhcnstcin, is an adult individual who is the president of Fawn Corporation with a principal plllce of hus Iness at the IIhove address, 5, Defendllnt, E.D Real Estate, [ne, is II husiness organizlltion with an agent accepting service, located at CT Corp, Systcm, [635 Mllrkct Strcct, Philadclphla, PA 19[03, 6 Dcfendalll, Michacl B, SlOncr, Inc, Is a husincss organization with a principal place of husiness at the above addrcss, 7, On or about January 16, 1996, Carol Miller was a business invitee of Giant Food Store and was in the process of walking beside her pllrked vehicle in the parking lot of Giant Food Store, when she was caused to slip and fall as a result of a patch of ice located on the passenger's side of her vehicle, 8, As a result of the slip and lilli, Carol Miller suffered severe and disabling injuries, including hut not limited to, injuries to her nr:rves, bones, muscles, joints and fascia, pain and suffering, mental and emotional distress, some or all of which arc or may he continuing in nature, 19, At ulltlmes material hereto, Defendant ucted indlvidually, llr through its agems, servams and/or employees within the course and scope of their Hgency or employmcnt. 20, At ulltimcs matcrial hcrcto, Defcndlllltowl1l:d, posscsscd and/lll' controllcd thc parking lotlocatcd in front of Giant Storc 1160 at 5301 Simpson Fcny Road, Mcchanicsburg, PA 17055, 21. Plaintiff's inJul'ics and damagcs arc duc tothc ncgllgcncc, carclcssness and rccklcssness of the Defendant, including but not IImitcd to: A, Allowing a dangerous condition to exist with respect to the parking lot where it knew or should havc known patrons would be walking; B, Failing to warn p(~rsons such as Plaintiff of an unreasonable risk of harm presented by the dangcrous condition of thc parking lot; C, Failing to removc snow and icc from thc parking lot; D, Failing to rcpair, maintain, inspcct and c:olllrollhe parking lot; E, Failing to arrangc for competent or qualit1ed snow and ice removal services; F, Failing to ensure the removal of slippery substances from the parking lot; G, Failing to arrange for salting or cindcring of said parking lot; H, Failing to providc IIdequatc lighting of the parking lot. " COI/NTry CAROl. MII,LER v, Eon REAI.I.iliTATE, INC, through 9 us If fully sct forth III Icngth, 22, Jllulnllfflncor(lol'lllcS hcrcln hy rclcrcncc thc ullcgullons of (lul'UgrU(lhs I 23, At ull tllllcs Illulcrlul hcrcw, Dctcndunt uctcd lndlvlduully, or thl'Ough Its ugcnts, scrVUIllS lind/or cmployccs within thc coursc und scopc of lhclr ugtHlcy 01' employmelll, 24, Alull times Illutcr;nl hcrcto, Dcfcndulll owncd, posscsscd und/or controllcd thc pnrklng lot locntcd in front of Giulll Store 1160 nt 530 r Silllpson Fcrry Rond, Mcchnnicsburg, PA, 25, Plaintiff's Injurics nnd dlllllngcs nrc duc to lhc ncgligcncc, curclcssncss nnd rccklessncss of thc Dcfendnnt, including bUI nOI limited to: A, Allowing n dnngcrous condition to exisl Wilh respect to the parking lot whcre it knew or should have known patrons would be walking; B, Failing to wal'l1 pcrsons such ns Plnintiff of an unrcasonnble risk of harm presented by the dangerous condition of the parking lot; C, Failing to remove snow and ice from the parking lot; D, Fniling to repair, maintain, inspect and control the parking lot; E, Fniling to arrange for cOlllpetcnt or qualified snow nnd ice rcmoval scrvices; F, Flllllng 1,0 cn~urc Ihc rCllloval of ~lIppcry ~lIh~lanCc~ fl'lllll lhc parking Ill!; G, Failing 10 arrange for sailing or clndcring of said parkllllllol; F, Failing to provide IIdcllualc lighting of Ihc pllrklllg lot. WHEREFORE, Plaintiffs dellland Judgmcnt agaln~t DcI' cllll II Il! , Individually, Jointly and/or scvcmlly, In IIn amOlllll in cxccss of $25 ,000,00, cxdu~ivc of inlcrcsl, costs and dclay dalllagc~, COUNT V CAROL MILLElLv, MICI1L\ELJL->o'i'ru.tlliJUlli:... 26, Plaillllff Incorporatcs hcrcin by rcfcrcncc thc allcgations of paragraphs I through 8 as If fully ~et forlh at Icngth, 27, At alltlmcs IIIl1tcdal hercto, Dcfendant actcd individually, or through its agents, servants and/or employecs within tbc coursc and scope of thclr agcncy or cmploymcnt. 28, It is bclievcd and therefore avcrrcd lbat at alltimcs matcrial hcrcto, Mi<:hael B, SlOncr, Inc, WIIS undcr contract with Giant Food Storcs, lnc" Doeville Limited Partnership and/or E,D, Relll Estate, Inc, to rcmovc snow IInd icc fromthc pllrking lot of Store 1160 located at 5301 Simpson Ferry Road, Mccbanicsburg, PA, 29, Plaintiff's injuries and damages are duc to thc nc,gligcncc, carelcssness and recklessness of the Dcfendant, including but not limited to: A, Allowing a dangerous condition 10 cxist with rcspectto thc parking lot whcrc it knew or should havc known patrons would bc walking; 33, A~ II rcsult of ellrol Mlllct"s Injuries IInd danlllges, clluscd hy Dclendanls, indlvldulllly, jollllly IInd/ot' Ileverlllly, hushaJllI PlainlllT hils suffcred IUld will contlnuc 10 suffer the loss of society, comfOl't, services, IIsslstllnce IInd cunsul'llum of his wife, WHEREFORE, PllIlllliff delllllJllls judgment against Delendlllll, individually, jointly and/OI' scvct'lIl1y, inanllmoulllln excess of $25,000,00, cxclusivc of coSlS and delay damages, COUNT VlIl RQ.NALll..MILLEJ~ v, JOliN L. RUBENSTEIN 34, Plaintiff Incorponues hct'cin by rclerence the allegations of paragraphs I through 9, as if fully set forth in lenglh, 3:5, As a n:sull of Carol Miller's injuries and damages, caused by Defendal1ls, individually, jointly and/or severally, husband Plaintiff has suffered and will continue 10 suffer the loss of society, comfort, services, assistance and consortium of his wife, WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgmel1l against Delendant, individually, jointly and/or severally, in an amount in excess of $25,000,00, exclusive of eosts and delay damages, COUNT IX RONALD MILLER v, RoD REAl. ESTATE, lli.C. 36, Plaintiff incorporales het'ein by reference the IIl1egations of paragraphs \ through 9, as if fully set forlh atlenglh, 37, As urcsult of Cuml MlIlcr's injurlcs uml dUlllugcs, cuuscd hy Dcfcndunls, Indivlduully, Jointly und/lu' scvcl'lllly, hushund Pluintiff IHIS suffcrcd und will contlnuc to suffcr 11\1: loss of NoclelY, cOllllilrt, scrvlces, usslsluncc und consortium of his wifc, WIIElWFOlm, Phlintllf delllunds judglllcnlugnlnst Defcndulll, Indlvlduully, joll1lly uud/or scvcl'lllly, In un IlInount In cxccss of $25,000,00, excluslvc of costs uud dcluy dUlllllgcS, Cill.!.NLX RONALD MILLER v, MICHAEL B, STONER, INC, 38, Plaintiff Incorpol'lltcs hcrcln hy rcfcrcncc thc ullcgations of paragrnphs I through 9, as If fully sct tiJrth at Icngth, 39, As u rcsult of Carol Millcr's injurics and dalllagcs, caused by Defendants, individually, jointly and/or severally, husband Plalllliff has suffered and will continuc to suffer the loss of society, comfort, services, assistancc and consorlium of his wife, WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgmentagainsl Defendant, individually, jointly and/or severally, in an amount in exccss of $25,000,00, cxclusive of costs and delay damages, MORGAN & MORGAN, P,C, By DATED: December L' 1997 ~ Meli, sa Merrills ivera, Esquire Allorneys for Plaintiffs, Carol and Ronald Miller CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE I. Nichole L, Mycrs. IlI1allthorizcd agcm of Marlson, Dcurdorn; Williams & Olto. hcrcby cCl11fy that a copy of thc forcgolng Pracclpc was scrved lhls date by dcposltlng samc In thc Posl Ollice [II Carllslc, I' A. Hrst class mail, postage prepaid, addrcssed as ti.lllows: Melissa MerrillS Rivera, Esquire MORGAN & MORGAN, p,C, 120 South Strcet Harrisburg. pA 17101-1210 Docvillc limited Partnership and Fawn Corporation RD III, Boy, 154 Gardncrs. pA 17324 John L Rubenstein Fawn Corporation RD III, Box 154 Gardners. PA 17324 E-D Real Estate, Inc, c/o CT Corp, System 1635 Market Street Philadelphia.PA 19103 Michael B. Stoner. Inc, 5 19 Hogestown Road Mechanicsburg, pA 17055 MARTSON. DEARDORFF, WILLIAMS & OTTO By if;;' nl YI /1/, id " ' Nlchole L. Myers t! Ten East High Street Carlisle, P A 17013 (717) 243-3341 Dated: December 16. 1997 '(;3 ',C) '''u ~ roo , u', :,l,i i-' ., n M 1\ . lJ~ "Co :r: ,~~ I ~' ( ...' f1:~' (,),. ',~I :.j ~r, N ' ,'~f.l L(: J'" I .. to \~ -' ~;1 (~1 u.;ll' .' , '1:~,l.14 "" roO, -. :.i \5 co 0' 0 I 'HllhlMIAHtld Mill It 11I1 HO-M." I 111m 1'lulr'lllll)r".I/~ ''''11)1'1-.1 jllllll,1 IIUt)~"I)llf" It 1'1-.1 \If/,illll'l CAROL MILLER nnd RONALD MILLER h/w, IN TilE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA Plnlnlill); v, GIANT FOOD STORES, INC, DOEVILLE: LIMITED PARTNERSIIIP, if Dclnwnre CIVIL ACTION-LAW Limited Pnrtnershlp nnd FAWN NO, 97.6(,()5 Civil Term CORPORATION, as the sole Generul Partner, JOI'IN L. RUBENSTEIN, Individually nnd In his cnpncity ns President of FAWN CORPORATION, E-D REAL ESTATE. INC. c/o CT CORP, SYSTEM IInd MICHAEL 8, STONER, INC., Dclcndllnls JlIRY TRIAL OF TWEL VE DEMANDED 1>F.I1ENI>ANT GIANT 11001) ST()(~ES. INc.'S ANSWER ,WITII NI<:W MATTER ANI> CROSSCLAIM TO l'I.AINTII1I1S' COMI'I.AINT TO: CAROL MILLER, and RONALD MILLER, Plaintills, and their IIttorney, MELISSA MERRITTS RIVERA, ESQUIRE AND E-D REAL ESTATE, INC., c/o CT CORPORATION SYSTEM AND MICHAEL B, STONER, INc:., Delcndllnt, and his att01'l1ey, DREW 1', GANNON, ESQUIRE YOU ARE HEREBY NOTIFIEb TO FILE A WRITTEN RESPONSE TO THE ENCLOSED NEW MATTER WITHIN TWENTY (20) DAYS FROM SER VICE HEREOF OR A JUDGMENT MAY BE ENTERED AGAINST YOU, \, Admitted based on information received, 2, Admitted, 3-6, Admitted bllsed on information received, 7, Aller reasonable investigation, the answenng Defendant is without knowledge or information sullicient to lImn a belief as to the truth or llllsity of the IIverments contained in this parugraph, The averments arc therefore deemed denied and proof is demanded, 8-9, Denied plll'sllantto Pa, R.C,P, I029(e), COlJNTI Cnl'lll Mlllel' v, Glnnt Fnnd Sllll'es. Inc, 10, Thc Ilvcrlllcnts of' plll'l\grnphs 1.<) of' this Answcr IIrc hcrcby incOI'pol'l\tcd by rclcrcllcc. 11.12, Allcr rCllsllllllhlc invcstigntlon, thc nnswcring Dclcndllnt is without knowlcdgc or inll1rnHltion sullicicnt to I\lI'IlllI hclicf' liS to thc truth or lillsity of' thc IIvcnllcnts contnlncd In this plll'll!lrnph, Thc IIvcrmcnts IIrc thcrcfl1rc dccmcd dcnlcd nnd proof'ls dClllandcd, 13, Dcnicd, To thc contrnry, thc answcrlng Dclcndnnt was not ncgllglmt, rccklcss or cnrelcss By WIlY of flmhcr I'csponsc. it Is dcnlcd thlltthe IInswcring Dclcndalll A. Allowcd a dangcrous condition to cxist with rcspcctto thc parking lot whcrc they knew patrons would bc wlllking; B, failcd to warn pers1ms such as Plaintiff of an unrcasonablc risk of harm prcsented by the dangcrous condition of' thc parking lot; C. Failed torclllovc snow and ice f'romthe p.\I'klng lot; D, fllilcd to repair, maintain. Inspcctand controlthc Pllrking lot; E, Failed to arl'llngc for competcnt or qualified snow IInd ice rcmoval; F, Failed to insure the rellloval of slippery substances from thc pllrking lot; G, Failed to lII'rangc for salting or cindering of said parking lot; H, i~ailcd to provide adcquatc lighting oflhe parking lot; WHEREFORE. Defendant Giant Food Stores, Inc, dcmands judgment in its favor and dismissal of Plaintiffs' COlllplaint with prejudice, COt/NT II .c.w:ol Miller v. Do~ville Limited Partnel'sh!l) II ()elllwlll'e Lilllit~ll Pllrtnershil) 1II111 Fawn Corpol'lltions the Snle Genel'lll Pllrtnel' 14, The averments of' pal'llgraphs 1-13 of this Answer are hereby incorporated 'by reference, 15-17, The averments of these parugraphs refer to II party other than the answering Defendant and therefore no responsc Is required, To the extent a response may be deellled required, these averments are denied, WHEREFORE, Dclcndunt Giunt Food Storcs, Inc, dcmunds judgmcnt In ils Iilvor und dismissulof I'lulntll11;' Complulnl with prcjudicc COlINT III elll'ol MilicI' v, ,John L. nuhensleln 18, Thc uvcrmcnts of pllrugmphs 1-17 of Ihis Answcr urc hcrcby incorpomtcd by reference, 19.21. Thc uvcnnclllS of thcsc pumgmphs rclcr 10 II puny othcr Ihun Ihc unswcrlng Delcndmll and therelllrc no rcsponsc is requircd, To thc extclll a rcsponse mllY be dccmcd rC1luircd, these IIvermcllls urc dcnied, WHEREFORE. Dclcndant Giunt Food Slorcs, Inc. dcmands judgmcnt in ils 11Ivor lllld dismissal of Plaintill1;' Complaint with prejudicc, COllNT IV e"l'ol MilicI' v, E-I) Rcnl Estlltc. Inc, 22, The avcrmcnts of paragrllphs 1-21 of this Answcr lire hcrcby incorporatcd by refercnce, 23-25, Thc avermcnls of thesc paragraphs refer to II party othcr thlln thc 1I11swcring Delcndllnt and thcrelnre no rcsponse is required, To the exlenta rcsponse may bc deemcd required, these averments are dcnied, WHEREFORE, Delcndant Gillnt Food Storcs, Ine, demands judgmcnt in its lllvor and dismissal of Plaintill1;' Complaint with prejudice, COllNT V Cal'Ol MilleI' v. Michllclll. StoneI'. Inc. 26, The averments of paragraphs 1-25 of this Answer are hereby incorporated by retcrence, 27.29, The IIverments of these paragraphs refer to II party other thlln the answering DtJlcndant and therefore no response is required, To the extentarcsponse may be deemed required, these averments are dcnied, WHEREFORE, Detcndant Giant Food Storcs, Inc. demands judgment in its favor and dismissal of Plaintitli;' Complllint with prejudicc, COIlNT VI l{ollllld MHI~I' v, Gllllltllool1 StOl'CS. IlIe, 30 Thc nvcl'lnenl~ of pnmgl'llph~ \.:.!9 of thi~ AII~wcr nn: hcrcby incorporntcd by reference, 31, Dcnicd pur~unnttol'n, R,C,I', 1029(c). WHEREFORE. Defcndant Ginnt Food Storc~. Inc, dClllnnds judgmcnt in its lilVor nnd disllli~snl of Plaintlll's' COlllplnint with prcjudice, COllNT VII l{ollllld Miller v. lloevllle Lh>>ited PIII'tllershil' 111111 FIIWII Corporlltioll liS the Sole Gellerllll'lIl'tller 32, The avcrments of pamgraphs 1.31 of this Answcr lire hcrcby incorporatcd by rcfercncc, 33, Thc avcrmcnts of thcsc plll'llgl'llphs rcfer to a party other than thc an~wcring Delcndantand therd(lre no rcsponse is required, To the extcnt a response may be deemed required. these averments are dcnied, WHEREFORE. Defcndant Giant Food Stores. [nc, demands judgment in its favor and dismissal of Plaintitl:~' Complaint with prejudice, COIlNT VIII Itollllld Miller v. .Johll 1.. n,lIhcllstelll 34, The averments of paragraphs 1-33 of this Answer are hereby illcorporatcd by reference, 35, The averments of these paragraphs refer to a party othcr than the an~wering DetcndaJ1land theretore no response is required, To thc extent a response may be dccmcd requil'ed, thesc avcrments are dcnied, WHEREFORE, Defendant Giant Food Storcs, Inc, demands judgment in its f.wor and dismissal of Plaintitl's' Complaint with prejudic<l. COUNT IX Itollllltl Miller v. I~.U nelll Eslllle. IIII', ]c) The IIVCl'll1enls of plll'llgrllphs I.] 5 of Ihls Answer lire hereby IncorpoTllled by rclcrcncc, ]7, The IIvermenls of lhese plll'llgl'llphs relcr to II puny other thun the unswerlng Delcndllnlllnd therelllre no re~ponse is required. To the tlxtenta response nHlY be deemed required, lhese uVCl'ments ure denied WIIEREFORE, Delcndunt Giunt Food Stores, I11C, demuuds judgmcnt in its Iilvor ulld dismisslllofPluintitl~' Complllint with prcjudice, COIINT X Itollllld Millel' v. Mlchllel IJ, SIOller, IIII'. ]8, The IIvermenlS of pUl'IIgrnphs 1.]7 of this Answer IIrc hereby incorporulcd by reference, ]<), Thc averments of these pllragl'llphs refcr to II pany other thall the IInswering [)elcndllnlllnd therelbre no respollle is required, To the extent II response may bc deemed requircd, these IIverments arc denied, WHEREFORE, [)elcndlllll Giant Food Stores, Inc, demands judgmcnt in its f1\Vor and dismissalofPlaintitls' Complaint with prejudice, NEW MATTER 40. Thc averments of paragraphs 1-.1 8 of this Answer arc hcrcby incorporated by refcrence, 41, The IIccident was caused by the contributory comparative negligence of the Plaintill'. 42, Plllintitl's recovery is barred by her voluntary assumption of the risk. NEW MATTER 1'lJnSlJANT TO I'll. It.C.I'. 2252(d) ~;illllt 1100d Stores. IIII'. v. Uoeville.1Jwited 1'lIrtnershil" ,John L. Rnbenstein E.D (telll Estllte, IIII'. IInd Mil;hllcl n. Stonel:..1w:.. 4.1, The averments of Plllilllitl's Compluint, which averments have been specitically <kmied, arc hereby iucorporaled by rctcrence Illr the limited purpose of this crossclaim, cunclusiuns uf Iuw 'II' IIICIIU which nu responsc is ncccssury: tuthc cXlcntlhulUI'CSpUnse Is decmcd ncccssul'Y, lhc uvcnncnls nrc dellied pursuunllo Rulc 102lJ(c) ufthc I'cnnsylvuniu Rulcs ufCivllpf(lccdurc, Ill' WllY uf fUl'lhcr uuswcr, SIOIlCI' hcrcby Incul'pumlcs by rcfcl'cncc us lhuugh fully s,:t timh hCl'ein pllrngrnphs 40 througll 45 uf Ncw Mullcl' hCl'einalkl', 10-25, l'ul'lIgmphs 10 Ihf(lugh 25 or Pluintin:s' Cumplllintmc dll'ccted lu Dclendunts othcr than Sluncl'. IInd Ihcrclill'c no I'CSpOIlSC is I'cquircd, TUlhc cXlcnllhlltul'csponsc is dccmcd ncccssury, thc uvcl'mcnls arc dcnicd pursullntlo Rulc 102lJ(e) ofthc I'ennsylvllnia Rulcs ufCivil Proccdurc, Ill' way or flll'lher answcr, Sloncl' hercby incorporates by relercnce as tbough rully sellilrth hcrcin parngmphs 40 lhrough 45 of New Maller hcreinalier. 26, No respunsc rcquired, 27, Thc IIvcrmenls or parllgmph 27 ur I'lainlifls' Complaint arc wncluslons or law or IIl<:tto which no rcsponsc Is nccessmy: 10 Ihc exlcnllhat a responsc is dccmcd nccessary. without tilrthcr idcntlliclltion or thc agcnls, scrvllnls, and/or cmployccs mcnlluncd ill pmagrnph 27 or Pllllntiffs' Complalnl, It is spceilkally dcnied that SloneI' was IIctlng individually or lhrough his agcnts. scrvllnls ur cmployccs and striCI pf(lof thercuf Is dcmanded atlrial. 2H, Admillcd in part: dcnied In pm!. It is IIdmitlcd only lhlll 1I1lhe timc oflhc incidcnl dcscribcd inPlllintllls' Complllinl Sloncr \VIIS undcl' wnlraet with (Jianl Food Slorcs. fne, to salt porllons ufthe parking lut ufStorc No, 60 localcd lit 5301 Simpsun Ferry RUlld. Mcchllllicsburg, PA, It Is spccilically denicd thai Stoncr was undcr cuntract with \)ucvillc l.imltcd Parlnership and/or E-\) Rcal Esllltc, Inc.. and stricl prour lhcrcur is dcnulIldcd IIttrilll. Any inlerencc thllt 2 Stoncr's conlruct with Giunt Food Storcs, tnc, involvcd thc rcmovul of ull snow ond Icc IhlllllllC cntirc purking lot ofthc prcmiscs in qucstionls spceillcully dcnicd. und slrlct pl'lloflhcrcof is dcmundcd uttl'iill. By wuy of furthcr unswcr, Sloncr hcrcby incorporntcs by rcl~rcncc us though fully scll<lrth hcrein purugrnphs ,10 through ,15 of Ncw MIIllcr hcrcinul\cr, 29, Thc avcrmcnts of purugraph 29 of Plainllffs' ('omplllint urc cllllclusions of luw 01' lilctlo which nf.lrcsponsc is ncccssary: tolhc cslcnllhal u rcsponsc Is dccmcd ncccssary, thc avcrmcnts IIrc dcnicd pursuant to Rulc I 029(c) of lhc Pcnnsytvllnia Rulcs of CivilProccdurc, By way of furthcr IInswcr, Sloncr hcrcby incorpornlcs by rc1crcncc as lhough fully set I<lrth hcrein paragraphs 40 througb 45 ofNcw Mallcr hcrcinul\cr, 30-37, Paragrnphs 30 through 37 arc dircctcd 10 Dc1~ndants othcr lhlln Stoncr IInd tbcrcforc no rcsponsc is rcquircd, To thc cstcllllbatarcsponsc is dccmcd ncccssury, thc aVCI'l1Jl'.nts ofpuragl'llphs 30 through 37 urc dcnicd pursullntto Rulc 1029(e) oflhc Pcnnsylvania Rulcs of Civil Proccdurc, By WilY of flll'ther IInswcr, Sloncr hcrcby incorporlllcs by rclcrcncc liS though fully sct forth hcrein pllragmphs 40 through 45 of Ncw Mallcr bcrcinul\cr. 38, No rcsponsc rcquircd, 39, Thc IIVCl'll1l:nts contllincd in pllragmph 39 ofPlainlifls' Complaintlll'c conclusions of law or filctlo which no rcsponsc is ncccssllry: to tbc cstcntthatarcsponsc is dccmcd ncccssary, thc avcrmcnts lIrc dcnicd pursullnllo Rulc 1029(c) ofthc Pcnnsylvania Rulcs of Civil Proccdurc, By way of furthcr IInswcr, Stoncr hcrcby incorporatcs by rclcrcncc as though fully scl forth hcrein paragmphs 40 through 45 of Ncw Mallcr hcrcinal\cr. 3 WIIF.IU~FOlm, Dcfcndunt, Michuelll, Sloncl', Inc.. dcmunds judl:\l1Icntln its JIIVOI' und ugulnstl'lulntlffs und lhutl'laintllfs' Complulllt bc dismisscd with pl'cjudicc und costs oflhls uction, NEW MATTEl{ 40, Tbc uvcnncnls sct fill,th inl'luintiffs' ('ol1lpluint litil to stutc u c1uim or cuusc of uclion ul:\uinst StOIlCI' upon which relicI' l1Iay bc gl'llnlcd, 41, If I'luintiffs suffcrcd injury or dal1lugc as ul'csult ofthc IIclions or inuctlons of individuals 01' cntltics, as ullcgcd inl'llIinlins' ('ol1lpluint. such actions 01' inactions WCI'C of individuals or cntitics othcl' than Stoucr, its agcnts. sCl'vants. 01' cmployccs, and OVCI' whom Stoncr ncithcr cxcrclscd nor had lhc ril:\hlnor duty to cxcrcisc control, and lill' whosc actions 01' inactions Stoncr is not rcsponsiblc 01' othcl'wisc Icgally liablc, 42, Any c1l1im or CIIUSC ofuction liS sct forth in PlalntiI'Js' Complaint Is barrcd by thc opcration of the contributory/comparativc ncgligcnce of Plaintiffs liS l1Iay bc developcd during discovery, It is spccilically avcl'rcd that Plaintiff. Carol MilicI', had u duty to ussurc her own safety by reasonable conduct and Ihal she cither did not Iii II us arcsult of any condition of thc parking lot or fell as a result of her own brellch of duty, 43, Any c1ail1l or causc of action as sct forth in Plaintills' Complaint is barred by the operation of Plaintiffs' assul1lption of a known risk as may bc developed dming discovery, Plaintiffs voluntarily parked their car in aloclltion thatl1luy or I1IUY not bave bcen icy, and thcreforc chose to cncounter U potcntilllly dangerous condition upon exiting their vehicle, It is 4 furlhel' uwrreu Ihull'lulntit'l: Cllrol MIlicI', Illuy huw Im:vlously wulked ovcr Ihe Sllllle porllon of puwnlenlonlhe dllY of her IIl1eged Injury, IInu wus IhercJilre uWllre of uny ullegeu conulllons on lhe puvcmenl, yel chose 10 encounter lhe Cllnullions ill spite of olher oplions, 44, Any c1ailllor Clluse of IIctlonl'Ulseu Inl'llIintit'ls' COlllpllllnt is hurred hy the upplicuble StntUtl~ oflllllltlltions, Including spccilicully, hul not II III I led to,uny c1uilllor cuUse of ucllon which, by rcuson of luck of spccilicily of plcudlng, Is nOI directly or specilkully sellill'lh in lhe lunguuge of I'llIintit'ls' COlllplulnl, but which I'llIintllI~ seck tOl'Uise ul II luter lillle by Ihrther UmClllJment, c1ulming 10 have prcservcd such c1l1im or cuuse of ucllol1 withinl'llIintiffs' Compluinl, 45, At all times maleriul hereto, Stoner acted with all reusonuble care uud due diligence in perlill'lnlng its dUlies under ilS contract Wilh Glunt. Oenernl slippery conditions prevailed thl'Oughoullhe comnlllnity utthe lime of the uccident. Further, lhe snow und ice had notlill'll1ed hills and ridges, and the snow und ice were not allowcd to remain for an unrcasonable lcngth of time, WHEI{EFORE, Delcndanl, Michllcl 8, Stoner, fne" demands judgmcnt in its lilVor and against Plaintit'ls and that Plaintit'ls' Complaint be dismissed with prejudice and costs of this action, 5 :>0- r- [?:; !i1 tr. 1-> .. "; ~~ N l~) ;~i :'T: (')..':t ., '-~ ,... 1..... '.". ,,~ ~ <Xl ~0 ."" tE~~ "" ~.r ~ ...~ x: '. ~ (0 a 0' ... " RIJA~:l{f(~J'J'fI,C:i' ! 'li'{i'M;~I''- ;,I;!/i}{:!f'c;"'" I' I' h_li,~"i:III,"~':'/?" :,/.- II 'f11<l{'I':';'':!.: i". ~1::{J:~!':j" :i;f~?:' ':'<. ',' v. j /:! ;~' 'trJ i " ,,'I' 'I i JX?l:'/. 1,,1" ,I 'I ~1,~lU' :i\jA('/',,'; .,;,', ' it I.f/'}l '! . rq I{"J /,~L' " II " III '/ >>/(r'II/,II,I, "i~' ",";'/// I11, .,', Itf"'> I II" ~111'111,/1'11 Ill, ~", IF, f , ~~' 11' . [1./ ' J"",{ll-ll' 1,11,' 'I' //,/'51/1,1'1 "Irllft/tlll'!', /; ! II 'lr 'f,/I;' ,,1.-.' ' f.l((.v;"~'lj" /(,' II' Ilflll\I'II";~/ If<! f 're' 1 ,At' 111'1 'il I ' >- 1:J}~V/tl~:II.I, ?t1. II I , : /, to'::: . ':/,',\t:f'I;' ,." '~,', g , '''i'''''I'' I" ':Jl lfi'~)"i;' ifl':t!' 'I;:fol\;r'~/I '. ~ i+",SI~" Ii. tn .~ ,filzt' ~'JWr'{;\1:1!J:;?i;'/ ll1 ,:",~4~ 'i~'~? "I ./'1 l ;1:" I ' '1<1/'/"(."" 1)\"1"""'" ",~'I >:~;~:I~,~ ) 'Jft I: I I , It;I~J,li--1',;," .~~ 1m 0 j'i I -/;,fi, /.',,-', I ~~, ; ,,' - ,. ":f'Jrf,~II/', 1./ " j" 'i ",.:1i ;~"i '. ". - c- '. ) .", ,-- ~{;~'i/fl;}~;dJ{rJ:';'-" ' hJ! ' d//'"i".,/: 111'_ "1,1, ';1/ ':, "i .. , , , 'I " , , ,',I ;. . , , , , I 'i' " ., , /-/ , ,',I '.' , " '" . / " , '/ " , 1 'i' , , , , , " ,'I I " I, " , , , " ,';I l': I I;",!, I',', , " "; 1 ';4 ., ~" ': '.. '~4'1 '''", 'I ..:' I:/" ~. I 'I " , , , . 'j -I, I" I " , ' " , I " Id (II "1 I' " " ".',' , , ','I' , " ,i'I"" ;.';',: , '" '.'11, ': ii" 'I " i " " , " , ')'t: . , , ~,. I , " .' . . , , ,,. ,i' ,:';, II , ,i,' "I, " j' '.. " ?," ,'1 ',. " ~",; I:; ~ , -, ,.. t~1 ~ :1 u(l r ~.. I' """, I r f', ~ ...,. ., 1,"'\ 'f.") '.(1 I J~II.. C") :,. , 1- ,~,' IT~ 1'1 c.: : , ~ -I i 'I J . . . >)1..1- ,... - " " II,,' c<'l :';i , (,,) 0" 0 , . IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY MILLER 6t MILLER Vs. GIANT FOOD, ET AL NO. 97-6665 CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SEIWICE OF A Sl.I81'OENA PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 As a prerequisite to service of a subpoena(s) for documents and things pursuant to Rule 4009.22 GEORGE FALLER, ESQUIRE certifies that: 1. A Notice of Intent to Serve the Subpoena (a) with a copy of the subpoena (a) attached thereto was mailed or delivered to each party at leaat twenty daya prior to the date on which the subpoena(s) ia sought to be served, 2. A copy of the Notice of Intent, including the proposed subpoena(s) is attached to this certificate, 3. No objection to the subpoena(s) has been received, and 4. The Ilubpoena (s) which will be served is identical to the subpoena(s) which is attached to the Notice of Intent to Serve the Subpoena (s) . Date: 3/30/98 ~~~ ( ".. '- \ , fj" .~~ ,,) \ Pile .. "2389".2 ..,,~ '..,.._, GEORGE FALLER, ESQUIRE 10 E HIGH ST CARLISLE, PA 17013 215..243-3341 ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT INQUIRIES SHOULD BE ADDRESSED TOs MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, INC. 4940 DISSTON STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19135 (215) 335-4907 By: Jacquelino Mumper IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY MILLER 6< MILLER Vr3. GIANT FOOD, ET AL No. 9'16665 TO; MELISSA RIVERA, ESQ NOTICE OF INTENT TO SERVE A SU8POENA TO PIWDUCE DOCUMENTS AND THINGS FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.21 DEFENDANT intends to serve a subpoena(s) identical to the one(s) attached to this notice. You have twenty (20) days from the date listed below in which to file of record and serve upon the undersigned an objection to the subpoena. If no objection is made the subpoena may be served. Date: 3/9/98 GEORGE FALLER, ESQUIRE 10 E HIGH ST CARLISLE, PA 1'1013 ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT INQUIRIES SHOULD BE ADDRESSED TOI MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, INC. 4940 DISSTON STREET PHIl..ADELPHIA, PA 19135 (215) 335-4907 By: Jacqueline Mumper Enc(s) : Copy of subpoena(s) Counsel return card File II: M238946 <X>>M:NtEIWn1 ~ PI'JHMNAHIA <XXJIfl'Y OF C1I4I3ERlAM> 976665 File No. HILLI!R ... HILLER VS. GIANT FOOD, I!T AL t ,..,1"1", SWPOENA TO PR<:O.a 00Cl..tENTS 00 THI~ FOR DISOOVERY ~SlJANT TO IM.E 4009..t.U TO: HEALTH SOUTH REHAB (Heme of Person Of' Ent ity) WIthin tW\'lf1ty (20) dIlys after service of this 1I~. you are ordered by the OOII't to prodJce the following docunenh or things! ..SEE ATTACHI!D ADDENDUM.. at -MRDreltU-bBGAtr-RBPROllUCTIOblS TIlle- 4Q40 nrSSTON ST PHIT..A PA 19135 (Ackhss) You may deliver or mail legible copililS of the docunents or Pf"oc1lce things requosted hI thIs subpoena, together with the certifIcate of OCJl1)1iance, to the party making thl1 request at the adO-ess listed lIbove. You hsve the riltit to seek in edvance the rea~h cost of pr89arlng the copIes Of' prodJcing the thIngs sought. I f you fall to produce the docunents Of' thIngs required by thIs subpoena wIthIn twenty (20) days after Its servlce, the party serving thIs s~ may seek s court ordQ<' cx.rrpelling you to carply with it. THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSlEO AT TlE REQUEST ~ TlE F<UCWING PERSON: NAI'E: GEORGE FALLER JR, 8SO_ AOOflESSI --lO III IIIGII &T CARLISLE PA 17013 (215) 335-3212 TELEPH:lNE: S\JPREI'E exulT I D . 49 813 ATTOANEY FOOl 15mNDAli'l' OATE:~~~: tm Sea I of the Cotrt -- BY TlE exulT: 1 ~R. Prothonotary/Clerk .~ I DIvis Ion \.;..DQ. [) m~l'I\a1() ~ Deputy (Eff. 1/91) ~I 01' PNHiYLVNUA <XXM'Y OF C1.Mll'JUNI> -- 976665 File No. MILLER , MILLErt VB. GIANT FOOD, ET AL SWf'OENA TO PR<O..q! 0<:X:U-EJml 00 TH IIQS fQlLP I S(X)VEflY,.,MSIJN(J' TO R\.ILE 4009. 22 TO: CENTRAL MED EQUIPMENT CO - (NlIITIll 0'; Person or Ent ity) Within twenty (20) days after service of this Ill.bpoena, yoo ere ordered by the court to produce the following doo..mont~ or things: **SEE ATTACHED ADDENDUM** at ---HEfH-cld:r-bBGAL REPRODIJC'rIO~" TN!" 4Q4.(L,nrSSTON ST PHILA PU913~___ (Aderess) You may del iver or mail legib Ie copies of the docunents or produce things requested hI this s\.bpo(lno, together with the certificate of COllJliance, to the party making thl: request at the add--ess Iist.ed above. You have the right to seek in advance the res"Onabll cost of pre<)aring the copies or producing the things sought. I f you fai I to produce the docunents or things required by this subpoena within twenty (20) days after its servlce, the party serving this slbpoena may seek a court ordeo' carpe 11 1119 you to CCIl1> Iy with it. THIS ~NA WAS ISSlEO AT TK: RECU;:ST Of' nE FOLLQl/ING PERSON: ~: GEORGE FALLER JR, ESQ .tOORESSI 10 B IIIGH ST _CARLISLE PA 17013 ll:LEPH:lNE: (215) 335-1TIT su>R&E exun 10 II 49813 ATiORNEY FOO: DEFENDANT DATE:-IY\OAc.hb I 'Cj9R Sea I of the Colrt BY TK: o::un: ('Lt~ R. ~ Prothonotary/Oln, ivil Division \ LAn D ~\'J\.O\A ~ Deputy (Eff. 7/97) ~, \,0 ,.- i:': ~.~ III ~ ('I' n""I' L'.. (,),' ',',I C:" 1 ~J' , " k" " f' ol;': I c- U ';i ,_I l."'l.::l-MlNWEi\L'l'fl OF Pl'lINS,{LV/\NI^ cr.l.Jm"{ l)~' ClJMllEmNlD Carol and Ronald Mlt ler, husbolnd and wi fo, rIa lnUEE,; Fi I,~ No. 97-6665 V. Giant Food St"ros, Inc., Nlchael 13. Stoner, Inc., et al., l)Ofendant,; SUE!p<~€N~ TO PRq;:U::t: C<.O.M:fIT;) CR THI~ Eel'< 0 I SCOV~RY PUHSlJANT TO r,UL~ JOOS, 24. TO: Dr. Stanley Goldman, '1700 Union I)oposit Road, Hilrrisburg, P^ 17111 (Nane of Perscn or Entity) Within twenty (20) days after service of this subJ:oena, 'fCU are crdered by the court tc prodLlce the fa llcwing doct..ments or th ings: A copy oE any and all records relating to the care and treatment of Plaintiff, Carol J. Miller, DOD: 11/12/41, including, but not 1 imited to, office chart entries, telephone messages, correspOtldenC(1, memorandums, laboratory nlPorts, l10SPltal UTIfr,llarqe sununaries, con"\,Il;dtlull~7 1 crtpLlulI". at Hartman & Miller, P.C" 126-1.8 Walnu~~et, Harr sburg, PA 17101 (Address) You may deliver or mail legible copies of the Cocunents or produ{';c things recLlestec.~' th i s sub~cer\a, together wi t!l the cert i f i cate or com Ii ance. to the party mak ing th '! reeuest at the address 1 isted, aI::<lve. You have thl! right to seel, in ad'/Mce the reasor,abl. cost: of preoaring the ccpies or pl'oducing the things sought. If yeu fail (20) days after corpe 11 ins you to to produce the docunents or its serv~.:p., the party comly with it. things recuired by this scbpoena within t"''!nt', :;erv In\i th j s subl=oe'1a may se\!k a court c,rdf!r TH I S SU8PCEtlA WAS I SSUED AT tHE RECL'EST C1" THE FCLLCW I fIG PERSCN: NN"'E: Drew p, Gannon, Esqu i re , Hartman bo MiuldL, [' ,c. ACCRESS: 126-128 Walnut Street Harrisburg, PA 17101 TELEPt-I:NE: (717) 232-3046 SUFREM:; COJRT lOll 7'1680 AITCflNEY rCA: Defendant. Michnel D. Stoner, Inc. ~"'~ L~, }!lil proth~arY vrUP ) , OiViSl~n 1'/ ut~ (Eff. 7/9;) IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF CUMBE;RLAND COUNTY MILLER Vs. GIANT l"OOD NO. 976665 CERTIFICATE PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF A SUBPOENA PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22 As a prerequisite to service of a subpoena(s) for documents and things pursuant to Rule 4009.22 GEORGE FALLER, ESQUIRE certifies that: 1. A Notice of Intent to Serve the subpoena(s) with a copy of the subpoena(s) attached thereto was mailed or delivered to each party at least twenty days prior to the date on which the Bubpoena(s) is sought to be served, 2. A copy of the Notice of Intent, including the proposed subpoena(s) is attached to this certificate, 3. No objection to the subpoena(s) has been received, and 4, The Bubpoena(s) which will be served is identical to the subpoena(s) which is attached to the Notice of Intent to Serve the Subpoena(s) . Date: 5/4/98 C'c- , \\ 1 "(' . )\!- . "" frF '" ft?J1 File II: M240312-05 . (,,()J GEORGE FALLER, ESQUIRE 10 E HIGH ST CARLISLE, PA 17013 215-243-3341 ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT INQUIRIBS SHOULD BB ADDRBSSBD TOI MEDICAL LEGAL REPRODUCTIONS, INC. 4940 DISSTON STREET PHILADELPHIA PA 19135 (215) 335-4907 By: Jacqueline Mumper a:HO/WFAI.ll1t OF PaHNL~ axJNl"l OF ClJMBl']U.AND 976665 MILT"ER & MILLER VS. GIANT FOOD Fi Ie No. (' ~ r; I! ~NA TO PR<:OX:E ~S OR lHlNQS ~ PUlSUANT TO ~~ 4009.22 DR STANLEY GOLDMAN TOr ---memeorPerson- or Ent i ty) Within twenty (20) days after service of this subpoena, you are ordered by the court to prodJce thl) following docunentl'\ or thingsl ..S.~~TJlCIUro 1I.nnlj;I:IDIIM** MEDICAL Lt;l.;I\J.. KIlo~l\ODllCTIONS INC 49 HI DI "STON ST at PliTT 11. PA lQ135 (Addt"ess) You may deliver or mail legible copies of the docunents or produce things requested h, this subfXlerul., together with the certificate of oc:rrpliance, to the party making thi( request at the address listed above. You have the right to seek in advance the rea,onabh cost of preoaring the copies or producing the things sought. I f you fai I to produce the docunents or things required by this subpoena within twenty (20) days after its serv~ce. the party serving this subpoena may soek a court ordel' oc:rrpelling you to oc:rrply with it. THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF mE FOLLONING PERSONr NN'Er GEORGE B FALLER JR ESQ ADDRESS I ] 0 " 1-1 T (:1-1 !,;T CARLISLE PA 17013 (~15, "3~~-'-- TELEPH:lNE I SU'REl'E cx:on 10 ~~._ ATTORNEY FOR,_,__ DATEI_L.l.,QJ q. I'1H _____ -Se41 of the Court BY THE CXlURT I Lud.A f2. e~ """ " Prothonotary I ef-k , Civi I _~.. {2 'fit., frJ,,~_ Division Deputy (Eff. 1/91) I ,. cnKlNWFAIJnt 01" pmNSYLVANIA CXXJm"l OF oJHBE]UJ\ND 976665 File No. MILLER & MILLER VS. GIANT FOOD SUBPOENA TO PROOU:E DQCl..tENTS OR TH I NGS FOR 0 I SCO\IERY PUlSUANT TO R!.!I.~ I I ! I ~ TRISTAN ASSOCS TOI (NMlol of Person or Ent 1ty)-' Within twenty (20) dllYs lifter service of this subpoena, you are ordered by the court to produce the following clocunont~ or things: ..SBS ATT~GHEP ADDiND~- ~~ sm PUT'", na 'Q',~ MEDICAL LEGAL KEPlrouuC'lIOI1S Ilk----.,-""."r".-~~.~.. . n..... "'- , at ___ (Address) You may deliver or IMil legible copies of the docunents or produce things requested to', this subpoena, together with the certificate of camliance, to the party making thl! request at the address listed above. You have the right to seek in advance the rea~onab1E cost of preoaring the copies or producing the things sought. If you fail to produce the docunents or things required by this subpoena within twent) (20) days after its serv~ce. the party serving this subpoena may seek e court a-de" c::arpe lllng you to CQll) Iy with it. THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT nE REQUEST OF nE FOLLallNO PERSON: NA/'E: GEORGE B FALLER JR ESQ ADORESS: U).. Ii: H yr." !:'I' CARLISLE PA 17013 IH:>) 335-3212 TELEPH:::NE: SU'REM?: CXUlT ATTORNEY FOR: 49613 10 8U!NDAM'l' DATE: O/a" p q I q t, f S 1 of the Court BY THE eXUH: C...x....7? ,e~-\.;J=,:..-- Prothonotary/C) k.}Civil Division ~_~u- C /h~ Deputy (Eft. 1/97) ADDENDUM TO SUBPOENA MILLER Va. No. 976665 GIANT FOOD CUSTODIAN OF RECORDS FORI TRISTAN ASSOCS RECORDS FOR SERVICES PROVIDED, BILLING FOR SAME INCL W/O LIMITATION ALL ADMISSION/DISCHARGE SUMMARIES, RESULTS OF TESTS OR STUDIES, OPERATIVE NOTES, CONSULTS, REFERRALS, FORMS, REPORTS, CORRESP AND MEMORANDA, ETC. EXCLUDING ACTUAL FILMS AND ROUTINE NURSES NOTES. PERTAINING TOl NAME: CAROL MILLER ADDRESS: 1055 NANROC DR MECHANICSBURG PA DATE OF BIRTH: 11/12/41 SSAN: 206324412 MEDICAL BILLING REQUESTED CERTIFIED PHOTOCOPIES OF THE RECORDS WILL BE ACCEPTED IN LIEU OF YOUR PERSONAL APPEARANCE. County of: CUMBERLAND MLR File #: M240312-04 ',lll:ldl,I' I": 1"lldl 1'.1,'1 i( II 1\1\ l';A~~jE nUt )')'1,/ ',II_"!I,') I: CIJI1N'INWlilll,TII I'll-' l'I-.lIll','!I.VMII II, CUlHlT'! 1iF' 1IJI'IIWlil.MIII I1LLLlJU:.I\J!.'!L..Y r ,AI, V~:; . 9LMJLDAI!I .'i'J:i.)I'.I~~L,III' ,J,T .11/, _,h'J;;~:iLE.L~jJJ.'}J.\ "" .......,....._.'_ CUNl1EI(LAND 1;"IJnt,y, 1"'.'IIl'Il,yJ.vlln,ol, t.o ll1\l, 13"YS, 1:1l(' 10i IUllI'I rJ.~!:I'.lf,:I-; up 0 n ,Jil.1iJ'iL..EJI!/[L. : ; '[~mY~ '.....,__...". ,.. , :'jlJ,-' J I I. t. I) J Ilt:'pIJ I,' : IlLj 111. .;)1- W II f) 1)(.' 11 HJ t j IJ .l Y ; J.... t) I II ,j I.": () I d 1 n',J iIIUJ'A!J'H'LII I liT ",Ulll li','J'/I...d 1,11\.' dE\fendnn t:, ;j to _..tJ.L~)J:1. IfIJur,'.:;, (ll, 1.I\I~' L~1U!. ILlY 01 t!':.!:i1ilIL'.:-1 --_.' 1 'J2Z. ;, \ _uL\:1 ~lJJ.AWJLiJJ,l/Im,J.~!J-:L., CARLISLE PA 1701J '___r___~__'_.U_'H"__~__'________", . _.._......___. ,..,' ','lf1 j,I)':lil..J!JII' ...-.' County, 1"?nn~Jyl'/I;III'", flY 11I'trldlil!1 1 'J J.tJ;:IL~~!J'IY..LI\"I)J..J.._J:lI, 'JLA}!li,l:;" ILEA D q:illJJeill...,......"mm'... "._,....,... o l.rup. ::Hld utIJ':.lf,,'d 'cop>, oj I'l", ti'ITrq.,I\r/.lI,..I.,~JM.J'Lj\UJJ and at: tlH: i.:1alllF' t,ll!1l~1 dllllf~t'.lflcJ ~Lu:.~ at:I'J...ntllJll tfl l~t\l::' l'I)r1tl_'f1I:~j thl:'l",?')f. SherLff's Cr);3l::.:1: Docket.lrHl SerVlce . Affidavit. SUl"char\)p (,. It) f/) , J. 1 ill . VI(/) .:. ""1 .../? ,,pi ././:4 :.i" '"r~*'~~ R', .'.TllIJ'rl't;.i-~i'-T\TTI'i-I:';-~ --"Srt'c'r'7'i."rr-- --. ':;11'.10 'fIIH,CiMI .', 1'lr1HI.,MI I()'-) / ::~::,I 1 'VI H by ./' J, / ~ / ,/ '/t?t :',,' ;::,;[.' ./., ~r .v-:cl.l V,.., .. , - f'-- .... "'- ..", '.. L;' It'r'fllJ'ty ..JfllJ'I I t / (/ Swarrl anrl ~3\JbGr:~r-LI)I~lj tlJ IJ("1111'() thi:;: _~..:?~.~~ d~l}' l'Jt ~.~ l':I.9X A, [I, c;~~f~<':rG7,H2f~l<('("'-'r.,. IYM r I) \. 1':lrJl I - ,J I Y 1111,' IHIEr"""'1 RII1'URI'I - IUMMOI'II!CQM"I..I"I'IT {/(IIL/ !/I() /L'I / COMMON PL.EAS NO. COUNTY COUJ~T c; 7 G C, (;,.{ VERSUS TERM, 19 r -fJ I~~ I 6ljJ,~ c/u (-r Ccvj'" NO. (-" '17,) J~,-) SERVED AND MADE KNOWN TO _J~~i~1,'~ o Defendant lB-Defendant Company by handing a true and attested copy of the wllhln Summons/Complaint, issued in the above captioned matler an __~,c Llfi-----, 19 __1~2._ ,at q. j (', o'clock, -LL M., E.S.T.lD.S.T. at ~- (YL4/ her .-1"..---------- __ , in the County of Philadelphia, State of Pennsylvania, to --.. ~ -,-p~r;f'':::!':'::--------'----'-' o (1) the aforesaid de!endant, personally; o (2) an adult member a/the family of said defendant, with wham said defendant resides, who stated that his/her relationship to said defendant is that 0/ o (3) an adult person In charge of defendant's residence; the said adult person having refused, upon re- quest, to give his/her name and relationship to said defendant; o (4) the manager/clerk 0/ the place of lodging in which said defendant resides; ~ (5) agent or person lor the time being in charge of de/endant's ollice or usual place 0/ business. o (6) the and officer of said defendant Company; Sa Answers, JOHN D. GRlleN, Sherlll By: aJ~~_li(L.1,y..l{::~:...~i/.l.c:-:Vl-u-.:/.~. I' 1l,-II/t1y .111""/1 0 I }':~R (Rlt~. IJ,fHl ':" 'I.Co' !'..',I ,( 'I" 'Il \,P N , )-, , ><r ::t:: ell ~, I"i' 'i " ! I :\' , 'I ,I'i ~, :;J~ 8f.1 o ~~ 'rf;i21"1' OJ'' S-. ~; $0 :pP- t :] H;!, ~" I, , , I, " d t, " q , I , " I' 1 '" , ;1 " , , 'i 'I, , ., " , " I';' " ,i., Lj ~ ,I 8 ,~~ a' :,1, " l ~ . ~' I I' 'd ''I 'J , I I I P: .! , , " ~ Ii ' ~ ~ 'C' " - '-" ',"1', I;" "