HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-00013
""'1"
~
\."
.w
..
-t'
4.-
~
,.
~
J
.ct.
-
U
.0
.,
'"
cr
'to
-
-
/
-
~
., ~
'j
',-
n
~
'"
.~
-
.
.
.,:)
-
. <:J
.
Johnson, Duffie, Stewnrt & Weidner
By: David J. Lnnzn
1.0. No, 55782
301 Mnrket Street
P. O. Box 109
Lcmoyne, Pcnnsylvania 17043-0109
(717) 761-4540
Attorneys for Plnintiff
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO, gjf- 13 CIVIL TERM
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
Plaintiff
v,
ROBERT V. GOTHIER
and ANVI CORPORATION,
Individually and Ud/b/a
DE-ANN a/kla DE-ANN CORPORATION,
Defendants
NOTICE TO DEFEND
To the Defendants:
You have been sued In court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the following pages,
you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint and notice are served, by entering a written
appearance personally or by attomey and filing In writing with the court your defense or objections to the
claims set forth against you. You are warned that If you fail to do so the case may proceed without you and a
judgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any money claimed in the
complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiff, You may lose money or property or other
rights important to you,
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT HAVE A
LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO
FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Court Administrator
Cumberland County Court House
1 Courthouse Square
Carlisle. Pennsylvania 17013
Telephone: (717) 240-6200
COUNT I
Breach of Contract
5, Plaintiff Incorporates the averments of paragraphs 1 through 4 as If fully set forth herein,
6. At various dates from 1987 through July, 1996, Plaintiff and Defendants entered Into various
agreements whereby Plaintiff agreed to provide and Defendants agreed to pay for engineering services and
general consulting In conjunction with Defendants' Manada Creek Mobile Home Park project. One such
agreement Is attached hereto as Exhibit "A,"
7, Plaintiff has fully performed all of Its obligations under the aforesaid agreements,
8, Plaintiff has Invoiced Defendants in the amount of $68,520.45 for the aforesaid products and
services, True and correct copies of the aforesaid invoices are attached hereto as Exhibit "8,"
9, Defendants have paid oniy $58,305,67 and have failed to pay the remaining balance of
$10,214.78 or any part thereof.
10, Plaintiff is entitled to judgment In the amount of $11,099.99, calculated as follows:
Unpaid principal
Interest at 6% per annum
from July 31,1996 thru December 31,1997
Total:
$10,214.78
$ 885.21
$11,099,99
J
11,
Plaintiff has demanded the aforesaid sums from Defendants but Defendants have refused and
I
neglected and continue to refuse and neglect to pay the same or any part thereof,
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendants in the amount of $11,099.99, together ~
with costs and interest from December 31, 1997.
COUNT"
In Quantum Meruit
12. Plaintiff incorporates the averments of paragraphs 1 through 11 as if fully set forth herein,
\
13. Plaintiff fully performed engineering services and general consulting services for Defendants
pursuant to Defendants' request.
14. Plaintiff conferred a material benefit upon Defendants upon the promise of Defendants to pay
the reasonable value of Plaintiffs services,
15, Defendants authorized all work performed by Plaintiff,
16. Plaintiff expected remuneration from Defendants at the time of the performance,
17. Defendants were aware that Plaintiff expected payment for Plaintiffs services.
18. Despite demand by Plaintiff for payment for Plaintiffs services payment has not been received,
19. Defendants' failure to make payment resulted In Defendants' unjust enrichment.
20, The value of the aforesaid services (less payments madn) equals $11,099.99 (piUS costs and
Interest) as set forth on Plaintiffs Invoices,
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands judgment against Defendants In the amount of $11,099,99, together
with costs and Interest from December 31,1997,
COUNT III
21. Plaintiff incorporates the averments of paragraphs 1 through 20 as If fully set forth herein,
22, Defendants owe Plaintiff the amount of $11,099,99 for services performed (including interest
and costs) In accordance with a book account, a true and correct copy of which is attached hereto as Exhibits
"A" and "8,"
23. Plaintiff has demanded the total amount due,
24, Defendants have refused and neglected and stili refuse and neglect to pay the same or any
part thereof,
WHEREFORE, Plaintiff demands Judgmenl against Defendants In the amount of $11,099.99, Including
Interest from December 31, 1997 and costs.
Respectfully submitted,
JOHNSON, DUFFIE, STEWART & WEIDNER
BY:
~!L
David J, Lanza
:102514
j
,
,.
~
"EXHIBIT AU
..
717691 7654 P.002
~@lEawlEIID
NO'I 1 5 1995
J. Mlchaul Brill 80 AssDclates
Consulting Engineers
nUG-22-1997(FRI) 11:06 J. MICHnEL BRILL
J. MICHAEl BRILL. ASIOCIATU, INC.
PROFESSIONAL SERVICES
SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORIZATION
DATE: November 9. 1 995
JMB PROJECT NAME
JMB PROJECT"
Menade Creek Mobile Homo Perk
110
SUPPLEMENTAL AUTHORIZATION NUMBER 01
In accordance with verbal authorization on th9 above roferenced project. b9tween the Parties
desIgnated below, J. Michael Brill and Associat9s, Inc., Is hereby authorized to:
XX Proceed with Additional EngIneering Services
Procged with AdditIonal Surveving Services
Proceed with Revised Scope of Services
JM8#
OIl\! Fill::
CI OUT FilE
[JDAT,l.F:LE
COPY TO
Incur Reimbursable Expenses
As Follows:
Perform additional enalneerlna services which include revlslna the loeation of the water main Bnd
rat.fals. on the Sanit2!lrv and Wilt... Service ImDrovements Plan Sheet as Der a drawina cro\1ided bv
the clienT. Work is necess~lrv for Annual Water ReDort.
Compensation shall be adjusted as follows:
Perform fer a Lumo Sum Fee of $500.00 and invoice under Phase 901 - Suoolemental Authorization
01.
Upon return of a fully execUted authgrizatign. this service shall becgme pan: of the Agreement
identified above.
APPROVED BY:
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES. INC.
APPROVED BY:
~~
z -"':i
Signature
tf:.~~
gnature
J"S ~ "0
:VI n
o PROPOSAL
J!! AGREEM!:NT
- "-
J. Michael Brill. P.E..P.L.S.. President
NamelTltle
.,.... ...,..
Namerritle
COpy TO
11- 1-1 S-
'"0y~ -
Date
Date
c=
!
I
.'
--
"
"EXHIBIT B"
......
J. MICHAEL BRILL 8. ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
/
, ,
J
M
B
INVOICE
SUITE 112. 5010 RITTER ROAD
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055,4828
(717) 691,0200
FAX (717) 691.7654
DeAnn Corporation
1000 North Front Street, Sulle 240
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
Attention: Robert Golhler
Cuslomer No:
Date:
Page:
Invoice No:
114
7/31/96
1
116070101
Professional Services Rendered From 7/1/9510 7/31/96
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK
BASIC SERVICES
Public Waler Related Work:
DEP . Public Waler Supply Report - 2.5 Hours
General Consunlng - 1,5 Hours
Project Management - 0.5 Hours
SecretarlaVAdmlnlstraUon Work - 1,0 Hours
VENDORlEMPLOYEE REIMBURSABLES
Mileage
Reproduction
Miscellaneous
Mailing/Handling
187,50
112.50
47,50
35,00
10,70
28,00
6,:30
W
TOTAL NEW BILLING
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BILLING
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
$429.12
$9,785,66
S10.21.t.7B
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
J
M
B
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
INVOICE
SUITE 112, 5010 RITTER ROAD
MECHANICS BURG, PA 17055.4626
(717) 691.0200
FAX (717) 691.7654
DeAnn Corporation
1000 North Front Stroot, Sune 240
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
Attention: Robert Gothler
114
6130/96
1
96060101
Customer No:
Date:
Page:
Invoice No:
Professional Services Rendered From 4/1/95 to 6130/96
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK
BASIC SERVICES
PUblic Waler Related Work:
Various trips to SUe for Meter Readings. 4.5 Hours
DEP . Public WAter Supply Report. 7,5 Hours
General Consulting with Park MaJnlenance Man & Others - 2.0 Hours
Project Management- 0,5 Hours
SecrelarlaVAdmlnlstration Work. 1,0 Hours
270,00
510,00
150.00
47,50
35,00
VENDORlEMPLOYEE REIMBURSABLES
Mileage
Reproduction
Miscellaneous
Mailing/Handling
43,20
25,00
10.50
~
TOTAL NEW BILLING
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BIWNG
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
$1,094.40
$8,691.28
59,786.66
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
, '
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS ,~
J
M
B
INVOICE
SUITE 112, 5010 RITIER ROAD
MECHANICSBURG. PA 17055
(717) 691.0200
FAX- (717) 69107654
DeAnn Corporation
431 Wren Court
MechanlcsburD. PA 17055
Attention: Robert Golhler
Customer No:
Date:
Page:
InvoIce No:
114
3/31/95
1
95030101
Professional Services Rendered From 3/1/95 to 3/31/95
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK
BASIC SERVICES
San~ory Sewer Related Work:
Meeting. & S~e VI.1ts - 3,0 Houre
Intercfflce Review cI Plane - 0,5 Hours
General Consulting with Cllenl, GflOoTechnlcal Engineer and Others. 1,0 Hour.
Projocl Managemanl . 0,5 Hours
Preparing Correspondence.. 0.5 Hours
Secretarial/Administration Work - 1,0 Houra
$225,00
37,50
7S,OO
45,00
27,50
35,00
Public Water Related Work:
CER - Public Wtller Supply Emerceney Plan - I,S Hours
CER.Publk: Wtller Supply Repor!. 2.0 Hours
General Consulting w~h Cllenl & Othere - 0,5 Hours
Project Management. 0.5 Hours
Secretarial/Admlnlslrtlllon Work - 1,0 Hours
82.50
150,00
37,SO
45,00
35,00
VENDOR/EMPLOYEE REIMBURSABLES
Mileage
Reproduction
Mlecellaneous
Mailing/Handling
TOTAL NEW BILUNG
20,80
8,40
4,98
1.42
C 5830,80
58,691.28
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BILUNG
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
; 59.521.86
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
, ,
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
J
M
B
INVOICE
SUITE 112, 5010 RITTER ROAD
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
(717) 691.0200
FAX- (717) 691-7654
DeAnn Corporation
431 Wren Court
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
Attention: Robert Gothler
Customer No:
Dale:
Page:
Invoice No:
114
2/28/95
1
95020102
Professional Services Rendered From 12/1/94 to 2/28195
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK
BASIC SEnVICES
slInnlll}' Sewer Reletod Work:
Meeting. & Sne Visits - 2.5 Hours
Interoffice Review of Plan. . 0,5 Hours
General Ccnsul1lng wnh Client, Outchland OffIcial., and Olhers _ O,7S Hou..
Project Monegement - 0.5 Hours
Preparing Correspondence.. 1.0 Hours
SecretorlollAdmlnlstretlon Work - 1,0 Hours
5187,50
37,50
58.25
45,00
75,00
35,00
Public Weter Reletod Work:
Various lrlp.to Sne for Meter Re.dlng. . 5,5 Hours
OER.Publlc Weter Supply Report - 7,5 Hour.
General Ccnsulllng wllh Client & Others. 1,0 Hours
Project Monegement - 0.5 Hours
SecretorlollAdmlnlstrellon Work - 1,0 Hours
348,75
510,00
7S,OO
4S,OO
35,00
VENDOR/EMPLOYEE REIMSURSABLES
Mlle.ge
Reproduction
Miscellaneous
Melllng/Handllng
17,04
23,79
9,34
3.98
TOTAL NEW BILUNG
51.504,15
$11,187.11
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BILUNG
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
$12,891.28
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
.j
I
, "
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
SUITE 112, 5010 RITIER ROAD
MECHANICS BURG. PA 17055
(717) 691.0200
FAX. (717) 691.7654
114
11/30/94
1
94110100
J
M
B
INVOICE
DeAnn Corporation
431 Wren Court
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
Attenllon: Robert Gothler
Customer No:
Date:
Page:
InvoIce No:
ProfessIonal Services Rendered From 11/1/94 to 11/30/94
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBilE HOME PARK
BASIC SERVICES
Sanitary Sewer Releled Work:
MIscellon8DIJs Revisions to Pions. 3,50 Hours
Meeting. & Coordlnellon with Geotechnical Engineer. 1,0 Hours
General Consulting ond Coordlnellng wKh Client, Contrector
and Othen . 2.25 Hours
Project Monegement . 0,5 Hours
Preporing Minute. ond Other Correspondence. 0.75 Hours
Socrotoriol/Admlnlslrellon Work. 0,50 Houre
$140,00
70,00
1&5,00
42.50
52.50
17,50
VENDOR/EMPLOYEE REIMBURSABLES
MII...ge
Reproduc1lon
Mlsc,1I1sn80ul
Melling/Handling
19,20
336,31
6.75
4,17
TOTAL NEW BIWNG
SII55,93
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BIWNG
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
510,331.16
511,187.11
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
. .'
'J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
\1
,
,
J
M
B
SUITE 112, 5010 RITTER ROAD
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
(717) 691-0200
FAX. (717) 691.7654
INVOICE
DeAnn Corporation
431 Wren Court
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
Attention: Robert Gothler
Customer No:
Date:
Page:
Invoice No:
114
10/31/94
1
94010101
Professional Services Rendered From 10/1/94 to 10/31/94
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK
BASIC SERVICES
Senltary Sewer Relded Work:
Research ftems@ Clients Request .1,75 Houns
Meetings & Coordlnollon wfth Geotochnlcal Engineer. 2.0 Hours
Field SUNoy Locollons lor Boring. 3,0 Hours
General Consuftlng end Coordlnollng with Client. DER OlIIclals,
Conlreclor and Others . 3,25 Hours
proJoc1 Msnegemonl . O.S Hours
Preparing Minutes end Other Correspondence - 2.50 Hours
SocretarteIJAdmlnlstrollon Work. 1,50 Hours
$122.50
140,00
285,00
232.50
42.50
175,00
49,50
VENDOR/EMPLOYEE REIMBURSABLES
Mlleege
Reprocluc1lon
Miscellaneous
Malllng/Hendllng
18,00
8.50
4,50
1,87
$1,080,47
TOTAL NEW DIWNG
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BIWNG
$9,250.71
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
$10,331.18
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
J
M
B
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
INVOICE
SUITE 112. 5010 RITTER ROAD
MECHANICSBURG. PA 17055
(717) 691.0200
FAX. (717) 691-7654
DeAnn Corporation
431 Wren Court
Mechanlcsburg, PA 17055
Attention: Robert Gothler
Customer No:
Date:
Page:
InvoIce No:
114
9/30/94
1
94090100
Professional ServIces Rendered From 8/01/94 to 9/30/94
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK
BASIC SERVICES
SanKary Sewer Releled WCllc:
DER . NPDES PermK AppllcelJon Pelt II .10,25 HOI"e
Interoffice Rovlew of Agreement. 1.0 Houtll
Engineers Conotructlon Cost EotImele . 4,50 Houri
General Consulting and Coordlnel/ng with Client. DER Off1clal..
Municipal Engineer, County Con.arvel/on District otfIclel. Munlclpol otf1clel.,
Contractor end Others. 4,5 Hours
Project Menegement - 1.0 HOUri
Preporlng Minutes and Other Correspondence - 3,00 HOUri
SecreterlellAdmlnlstrollon Work. 4,75 Hour.
$717.50
70,00
315,00
330,00
85,00
155,00
158,7S
VENDOR/EMPLOYEE REIMBURSABLES
Mlle.ge
Reproduction
Miscellaneous
MoIllng/Handllng
10,50
358.58
5,38
1,93
TOTAL NEW BILUNG
$2,207,114
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BIWNG
$7.04:1,07
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
$9,250,71
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
,_....,
. .
,
J. MICHAEL BRILL & ASSOCIATES, INC.
CONSULTING ENGINEERS
J
M
B
SUITE 112, 50 I 0 RITTER ROAD
MECHANICSBURG, PA 17055
(717) 691.0200
FAX. (717) 69\07654
INVOICE
DeAnn Corporation
431 Wren Court
Mechanlcsburg. PA 17055
Attention: Robert Gothler
Customer No:
Dale:
Page:
Invoice No:
114
7130/94
1
94070100
Professional Services Rendered From 7/01/94 to 7/31/94
JOB NO: 110
JOB DESCRIPTION: MANADA CREEK MOBILE HOME PARK
BASIC SERVICES
SanKary Sower RellIlod Work:
SKe Plan. Oeslgn & Dralllng . 7,0 Hour.
SanKsry Sewer Design & Draltlng .11,5 Hour.
SElSC Plsn-Ilraltlng .2.5 Hours
MI.e, Info, & Detail. Sheet. Design & Dralllng . 12.0 Heurs
Ouantlty Tskeotl. . 2.5 Hour.
Englnsers Construcllon Cost Estlmllle . 8,50 Hour.
Gen.ral Consulting snd Coor<llnstlng wKh Client. Municipal Englnser,
Municipal OfIIcIol., Contrac!er and Others. 1,5 Hours
Project Msnagement . 2.0 Hour.
Preparing Minutes end Other Cone.pondenee . 3.25 Hour.
Secrotariel/Admlnlstrstlon Work. 1,5 Hour.
$282.50
555,00
93,75
720,00
160,00
595,00
112.50
170.00
227,50
52.50
VENDOR/EMPLOYEE REIMBURSABLES
Mlle.ge
Reproduction
Miscellaneous
Mailing/Handling
3,00
139,20
10,34
6,59
TOTAL NEW BILUNG
$3.107.88
513,935.19
TOTAL UNPAID PREVIOUS BILUNG
TOTAL AMOUNT DUE
517 ,043.07
PAYABLE UPON RECEIPT
THANK YOU
~
iT. <::J \9 ~
~ ~
~ In
~o ..
r M ::.'~ k:.
Q :r- O:-oS \
l..)~p ~
~~ a.. c,;:
(~~~ <::l
N ~;- G.i P Al ~ \Cl
~LL I .J;" --
u:~~ -. I.'c2 N V'"'l
,-
r- "'" lUI::J G
-, :...;!o... Ir'
~ co :3 Q ri ....3-
@) en u ~eD~
.... . ~
,
SHERIFF'S R~TURH - R~GULAR
CASE NO: 1998-00013 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
BRILL J MICHAEL & ASSOCIATES
VS.
GOTHIER ROBERT W ET AL
MICHEL E. BARRICK
CUMBERLAND County. Pennsylvania. who
to law, says, the within COMPLAINT
. Sheriff or Deputy Sheriff of
being duly sworn according
was served
upon GOTHIER ROBERT V the
defendant, at 1510:00 HOURS, on the 8th day of January
19~ at 1000 NORTH FRON STREET SUITE 240
WORMLEYSBURG, PA 17043 . CUMBERLAND
County, Pennsylvania, by handing to BARBARA SWIEKERT BOOKKEEPER
AND PERSON IN CHARGE
a true and attested copy of the COMPLAINT
and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof.
Sheriff's Costs:
Docketing
Service
Affidavit
Surcharge
5.00
.00
.00
2.00
So answers: I ~ ~:
~t"?<';-""'r~< ..~~.<-,
-, ~:.,< .'1" .-...........
I
H. I homas 1\1J.ne, ::iherJ.11
$8.00 JOHNSON DUFFIE STEWART WEIDNER
0l/09/~:98 . 7 ~ .~
~4e~
sw~rn and~subscribeQd to before
thJ.s 9- day of ~'=tl.....
I
19 CJi A. D.
()1.4~ () ')]W~, J 0=
'-jl I 'iiro'tho-no{aryt7
me
. '.
SIIERI FF" S RETURN - REGULAR
CASE NO: 1998-00013 P
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA:
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
BRILL J MICHAEL & ASSOCIATES
VS.
GOTHIER ROBERT W ET AL
MICHAEL E. BARRICK . Sherizf or Deputy Sherizz oz
CUMBERLAND County, Pennsylvania, who being duly sworn according
to law, says, the within COMPLAINT was served
upon ANVI CORPORATION TIDIBIA DE- ANN A/I{/A DE-ANN CORPORATION the
dezendant, at 1510:00 flOURS, on the 8th day of January
1998 at 1000 N FRONT STREET SUITE 240
WORMLEYSBURG. PA 17043
. CUMBERLAND
by handing to BARBARA SWEIKERT BOOKKEEPER
County, Pennsylvania,
AND PERSON IN CHARGE
a true and attested copy of the COMPLAINT
and at the same time directing Her attention to the contents thereof.
Sherifz's Costs:
Docketing
Service
Affidavit
Surcharge
18.00
9.92
,00
2.00
So answers: ~" /./..:~~
....-::~."....,,'1f ...";,,, ..' ....
'I" .........;_._._.;'..~.L4' ~':. ...: ........-'" .....~
.
H. I homas Kl~ne, ::;her~11
S2~.~2 JOHNSON DUFFIE STEWART WEIDNER
01/09/1998
by
Sworn and sUbscrib~~to bezore
() I#~ 1
this , - day of .....
I? I I
19 7~ A.D.
C)"1'-'- Q. ~I-'''O~ A-t~
Pro honotar1'
me