HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-00668
\.
\l
~
It'
~
"
()
~
~
,
i
-,
~
~,
q:
"\J
-
~
'-
-3
c....,""':
> ,.,.',
.:;}~:\ :
'" .~
::<;:
"':':l~"
....,,~'r I
:;:.h',
";.~ 'f
.,:;~
,:'3~1
f~j
:,.,~
:;il
)5}~\
'2~
"'~~
!;~
\~j
.)ill
;.~,!}~;
:~
,;\??
!~~i~
'~'ii'"
':~:~ii~
'/~'
c.:l~
'"t~
_-<~V~{
'::;;~~;:
,~.<l.t;
',~
'....,'0'
'/-,':~ '
, .~~~,
, .):~J
"'j"""'''''I'",.,
. '"
'.':".\
,
~H
;- _:f;~
j
I
}
J
J
/
/
//
I
;
!
r
....
~
-
.
..5
-
~
0..
~
"
. "
~
~,
~.;' ..
i;;',:,:'
~,'
'<(.
_....4'..,.'
.--
HAROLD a. IRWIN, III, EaQ
ATTORNEY ID NO. Zl120
:II EAaT HIOH aTREET
CARLlaLE PA 17013
(717) 2U aOlo
ATTORNEY FOR PLAINTIFF
LINDA R. WICKARD .nd
CALVIN L. WICKARD,
PI.lntlffs
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
VS.
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
: NO. 91 . ~ CIVIL TERM
JOHN SHOEMAKER .nd
BARRY E. JACKSON,
Defend.nta
: IN ASSUMPSIT
PRAECIPE FOR WRIT OF SUMMONS
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Please enter my appearance on behalf of the plaintiffs and issue a writ of
summons upon the defendants, The defendants are as follows:
JOHN SHOEMAKER
184 Big Spring Terrace
Newville, PA 17241
j
February 4. 1998
BARRY E. JACKSON
615 Ml. Rock Road
""""lila, PA ~~
HAROLD S. IRWIN. III
Attorney for Plaintiffs
..,
,
!
35 East High Street
Carlisle. PA 17013
(717) 243-6090
Supreme Court 1.0. NO. 29920
!,
,.....
-
(") <0 0
~ ~,) +q
'"T1 ,.,
'~l~''j rq ,-
-;j:!1
ftt [I):... ::0 ",-
[ ::~~(f I .'"11'11
<lCJ ~
~ t:i C'; , ..' ') :S
',':"J'-
""1) ., "J
.'--r
',,) _..
-, '-.,.C")
~ ):... 01 ~.J ~:)rn
0 .. =.,
, . -'.
f2 :) :") ~'l~
~ ...t =<
U1
~
i'~:'_,
U
\
i'
t
)
),
.-',;
1['"
, .
P','~
If "
j,:
.)"
i I
,
, ,
.."
I ~
:z'
,
,
'I,
)
, ~
,
,
, -nW::t: n D:l<..o nl:'" ,
, I",
, ~1llU11ll .... III 0 III ....
, ....11 11 < 11 ::r ....::l I':'
,
, ~l-'tIlO .... 11 ::l < p.
, -.....QJ..... I-' '< ....Ill
, r ,0\
, en en 0, en ::l ,0\ 1
I NI-'rt :J>o tIl::r :<J ,<Xl
,
>' ""Ill en 0 . 0 I:'" In
g w. :z:. rt III
, .... .... <..03 ~ ~ '....
J oo.'tllCH 0 51 III III ~ ...' '<
~:J>o::r~ ::l 0.... ....0 I....
....Ill o .... II-'
0.... en.... I' 5' 0011 ....Ill 11-3
~rt::l , 0 III 11
011' 'I:'" ::l III 11 P. ,Ill
....Ill 'Ill ::l P. I~
WIllH I~ P. III
rtH , ::l
, SO
H I P.
, r
,
,
,
!
j
."~.
.
\:
,
IlAI\RY A. KRON'J:HAL, ESQUIRE
Pa. Supr~ Court 1.0. No. 55672
REYNOLDS , HAVAS
101 Pine Str_t
Poat Office Box 932
Harriaburg, Pennay1vania 17108-0932
,I
~ i
.
Ii
Telephone:
rax:
(717) 236-3200
[717) 236-6863
Attorney for Defendant:
IlAI\RY JACKSON
"
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN L. WICKARD,
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 98-668 CIVIL TERM
~
v.
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON,
Defendants
.
.
PRAECIPE TO ENTER APPEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY OF CUMBERLAND COUNTY:
Kindly enter my appearance as counsel for Defendant,
Barry E. Jackson.
REYNOLDS & HAVAS
A Professio al corporation
DATE: 3/,/9~
By:
Att
KRONTHAL
ey I. D. #55672
Attorneys for Defendant,
BARRY E. JACKSON
101 pine Street
Post Office Box
Harrisburg, PA
(717) 236-3200
932
17108-0932
.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I HEREBY CERTIFY that I have served a true and correct
copy of the foregoing document upon all counsel and parties of
record this , '~ay of ~,,~ , 1998, by placing
the same in the United states First Class Mail, postage prepaid,
at Harrisburg, Pennsylvania, addressed as follows:
Harold S. Irwin, III, Esquire
35 East High street
CarliSle, PA 17013
John Shoemaker
184 Big Spring Terrace
Newville, Pennsylvania 17241
~,~~
Debora L. Hamm
"
.)
"
\(
'!
.-
"
0 ..D P
C', :;.;) .,
c.~~}J :-!: ,I
. ~1pJ
:-J
In
, " i","' 11:+)
..:' "}(~
,\ '''j'.
0.." ~. -n
I':;:U
,,' ~/C)
'C~ i;y cj;f!
.- . :'.'l =t:J
", ~.!.]
(., -<
,;5
.;,
~:
,:'/
"J
;,i
.-T
Ai;
';1-
'~~r
,t.,
~~~:
':'{
.....1
.
'-~
,~1f
-*
'~
"
,
',Ii !",.,T
l..t.~ ( ; ~ .., i.
:,:L
: ')",'1
I ,!I>..
CA'.JE no: ; J::.,. :>'. H: 01.:' I.' !~
CrJi'Il'i'Jliln'F.^LTli C,IF PEIIIl:'::;YL\'j\til:'\:
COWITY 'JF C UiIL'CHl.A!il'
~'~r;,I} R ~~.i.r.![-'.~i... ET Ai '_,___..
V~) .
S110~!IAf\ER JOliN ET I\L
ROBERT L, FIW~~:-;R.
5heLlf1 or til2put)' SIV21~ii.t 01
CUMBERLAIID CQunty, rc'nn5i.l....<.....n~tJ, ....ho IH..irlg duly :;;""'(ll'n ,Jccordin~l
to la'., sa)'s, U", within Wlil.I_E:!F :;~U~IlI'Jr::;_._,___
upon _$f18E~ltili.[::R JOIl1/
dE':fendant, ::'It 143'2>:00 HOURS, on lh(:, 28th.. do)" l.Jf F'?UrlIQ.rV
'WaG ~L"r vL'd
t h~..:.l
1998 "t
184 BIG SPRING TERRACE
lIEWVILLE, PA._l'L::;'i)
__, ClJIIBEHLMlIJ
County, P,,'nflc'ylvaniCl, by Inn.;i",] tc JGAlI SIWEI'IAEEI':, PERS01/ III
CHARGE
~ true and attest0d copy of thl~ WRror 01; SUM~:~:S
and ;;1.1.:. the S;JlnE;' tim..::,' dir...:'ctill'.J 1I1-..:.'_1': '.1tt(.:nlicdl tu thQ contents thl:.~l'.;;>of.
Shoriff"s Cost~:
Dr,)cl:t?l int:l
Servicsl -
A!fid<Jvil
Surch:;1!.UE'
~;o ~~_..C?~~
F:: J t I Cl rll a :":1.:-.::rrI;~;::~llf~TI-i 1
1;'),00
7. ~l~l
. Gel
6.00
:;'"J1-:-:lTlii..i"\OLLI ~'. II\'n'~j'l
CJ~ "':1':'/1="-:)5,//~ ~
by -~~-Fs~;LL~
S\o,'Ol'n ;':'iIld ~'>Ub8'::Tibt:-..:d to v.;:'Ifor-~;.;;' ill.:':"
tins __.:Jt.!!;. day 0:,1 J~-'I_____
19 9~_ A. [I,
__Cl _Q '}.ll_..oi,T'>-:-~~_-____
-~ ...(.J'.'_lfl'~II.c.ll/
fI..:.IO..:.
y~-\,:t:.':::t;;:,
;',,;/
.
',' 11 . I '{'~' I ~. I
,I, '1, ~..IJ,::..~,~~l1:~
'. . ,-' ,",~",;.'.,1.iP'
. ,,;}:, Jt:;;V~!Pfj:~
,I' ~, J,,/,'hll~~''::I'~~
" ! I ~'\" ~:, -I. .t\"~~ "
," . 1'-' ',~ :,<". i,!'I'~V:I'
,. . '", \':1 1'1..-,~ 1i~~~iI:'
; " "~to l ....;~ If '1~"~~,'J'W:i( 1
. . \ .. ..,\ I 1\ .,,~(;J J ,
" ,"<,' i "':(1,~1\;;r'l~1 '
".\ ';. ',,:: 1 ,~ "?:'J1II..f.;..~tr.
, t. ,'., .'1 .'.,-'" t' ~,"?.'\
. " \r ",. \ .>) c""dUi\'~".,\~ ;.
" ';' ',.'(.\d ,..il'.',~t/>I.~:..;a~liJ~~~t'(,
. [, ." ''7,...... ;r'I.'.{I'~/j"'.l(r* ~,"",
.,', ',' ~",; t' .,t .I,'~'" l<f';;i~/,{r~'1:". "
'. " ,,' ~ 'i :" " ,..,~ '~" .t:J~ti'
'" \ ' " '. ' l' '" ' .'.. l.t~\,.~~'t-J:r:(.~ ~
"; > _ ~ ,. ,I :'j;;<'~l.::~~tl*'"
'. ' . I." I, ~ .Ii . 0 I, ,.::1., 1'.,
, J, " ,".'':- ',' ..: .,:.""::'\ '{ ~'"r t:
" '_ "., f.o :.:,.' ",(j",l' ," ,. r~~)""':.J'.1!IJ
. "" 'f (or 'r ", ~ .j II fr(t:" k'O 't'~r,p;
, , ,~~,.I f,.-," I 1 '~!'''';.i1\f'1''''~~?'! . ~
, '\~ , .~' "~' 1',_ ':':. (tTi""::U' 'Ni::1
'" /, "",...,~, ""'(' ,'1>..1(, _.'t~!'f4,
, " ,t, t "~ ",......, f' ~.1.... "I
. "<"'~I'_"(~':::!1:~!~'?l;&'
~ ,,'.,.' '"1\.~.., ,1,'1 ~f;-'~.. ,,~..."l (
., ,,' , I'~ <: . 'J, j. ')'1 ., I \. '-:,JI,;.'
. . . ,'l.. " .:',,'~ "1 r .~ t.'~t
, ,,,: ~ , '.. ,....1.' i '''''1'-" l,.{,,:>..''i
,I ,,' '-. ". l, " ). 1~, \:: _'--..~~::,~~ (,
~, ',' , .t,~,,:t~,) ~:} , ~ ,J:'lt;f~.1l'i-~i~: '..'
"", \,1 ,"~~I .".....,l/~.'\i,,\'~.
:..' ~ ~. ).;>;~rL,'. '"'"~.I;c'rJ~'r~l'
" """ I' " {.. +. If.... 11~,
, ,~', ",.!. ~.:; -,'~!'I";' .....Il!f:,..'"
" " ", ~ ..:," ,,( .t:j'''o':'''r ,,~~ ,;J.:,t:.
'': , . ',\;"/:\1 ':" 'r~J l..\~\}.:.:i!J'ri>'~~,I",
. ..~ '- :'4 r '_I ~.:~~~~\~..:}iy.;,:;;':;..'.t;~l"Ei!'~Io~ I: '
> ~..., .' . ;\'~J,~~t: I'"..l/:l.f",.~l:'{~'~~;~i.r.
-', "l~'"\ ~llr'\"J~.....;~t,?1:JJ1", -~
) " "..j',,;:,"""':'~"I,,l':t \~":4il':/#'I;'r...'
,.:...". b,/> Jr. ~..1~,F:<:'~I;;1..t"t.~~~'",
,,'\ 1"'}';"""<JiJ.II,,;,'1,;(f;1:-:'A:t~ ,'t:
tJ!n>. <I.'. ,~.\I"'.:',II'!\r":;~"I,.,;,N~'''''''I~'''' ,:7
6<o:'l>"J.tp. l{?,: . -, ~'\ J \: ,','.;;Ij-V".......', I' ~
,~?~w>y'! ,:,;",'!C:?:",P,::~.;~,'il~,;',~:~>::",~; ::'.' \ ,~ ".' . . ,..,",. .',', : I ~ , ~, , < ~ I. :':I~;~~l: _i~,,~~~-r",~li i3~ '
--f: l ff . . ,"~' ,I',~, "'/., ~~.~.~.,::'; ,.....f.~...4"ll
"",":(:',' 1~1~";('Y"Y':!'" ,~" ~}J~~"":":.' .' . <"~;". '-~':Jl.J"'.!;&\;:;I,:.;~'j..h!/-,
,1 !''v_. fi,'1;f.':":-~~o(V'''-''' ".;~fl"",., . ,l'~.'l',',~ ",'...". _ ' ".'r*;.),t~)!.>:~I"if"t
, .~, .!':...J.f"f"".."~~,.I.',~,;,:, :..,., ,.."-,.,,, ',~". '\"""";~J~I"I'."'l
:""!'. ".'~" '^J~< >, \'~' _ '. ..,1 . . "; (.;"""'_I",.;:(,,~"\".!"":~,:l"~"l').'"
, "..".,f!'.~lt",',r, ,.,,",' ...,:,~,:. .--:.,' '.," ' .' .,.1., J ,'W<.h\ !i~.
f';'1"p,' ~Il^;',.-",,,l'" '_ ,d. ."~'i .r".:"., q 'r_.:.~, "\:.?>\."..~.'.\hp-""~l:t,~( 1.~"',:'
,.Iit, ,.'-N., ",\,,!,;?\, r.i~' 'l~,,' :'.', ',: '.:' ,: .~ I " '~~'::" . . " " '. ,. ",'" ,( ',' ';. (: ""~ {,t' ft. ,tt.r~l'1f..q,;}:..'+'l
""m ,\'- I ",','.'.', ",'"., ',.., ,.)'(~'~"""""""'t""~;'""'{'~"""l~l"
'~l"" .), !" hI" " . "':~' ",' :"':"\:" I - l '"" 1'..,;
~:::v'" Af':ll..?>~,':.:'.,.'~.':',':' " . . .p;,. .-".',..,", ... I"'~' '\"I"L"tr~~'l"'.';
~:rl::' 'i.f'''11'"I'1,~\t'~, ~l',' ';'1 ". ',._:1 :,',\ - 'i.' ""~,I' '.~:'."'I~;:\'" ")\1JY:t;,1:.tf~'~jJr'
l',f "',""",~.,'.,''','',' ",,'>," .. ' ".,. "~ ".'o""'"'f.ii'.'
'J ~~. 'l : :: ,'~,''>'' ,~,-,'. ~ '~"/j .,:!.,,'/~;~,....... .,..to-
'\ ':" v.~I..i";"\\;""~'j\I(;,;.,I.";, ,. "'" ' J.'.'" .. ." "'!...:....r..,,' ,~. )"IA\H,!~l ~~.,
. f~ ~J.tN/l :t;.!;;:;;(~";~.\::.~.~~,<,,.,;~,~..,:.I_~'><" " '. .~ . ,., ',' . -,' . i:~:~- ' .1:."'~\~a'~U':}'~~'"
lI<,\;f'~~ 'i!jf, ,">',1>',' ;ir;J:ib':'."'.";';C'-""=''''::::';::''' " ," ' " '"'R)' "~., ,d llti,I.IiJI
tyJ' ~{~l':: '.f''f/1f, ~!,'.~._l''''; ,fJ..:.:.'~",'~".": .,"~:',,:/""',: ",' , '... ~', . .,.';;.~ "},:~,,' .~,:' JJ:'; .ii-:"r,..~
If't:. . {I "'1~'{ij,~ ~.:t";'i"':'1\:",vcir;.,~.,t~';.,.,:':.':',"', ".'" .'~ 1'\ '. .'\",,/ P '"'r~~::t..~J
. '1;.;1' ",' t.~~ Zl~t';''''~~ l~~--;;;"Y:'--':~;;'::':;''-''~o- ",':;~\.., .;',;.' ., " .:, .',..' " - ! "~'" !'i....~1 ''oJ'.". 1..'
1''-:'fJ' ~:I' "~" l'\';::'J(,r" ::;t:~f.~~lr,i<,~.,..':':'..'l~...::":,,,' "',i ',.<.r. '~"','i "r':.l,,:,'.,\~~.~~' '~':':"'tt' I'.~'
J. .. !~,,,. r"r.r~(;J.l ~""""""""'Ir'''''''''~'''''\' . ,'j , ,J ~~.k~l':'"
l ~ "~:; ~~:: :("fJ';/:..::/ rl',~:')-:,.:~~{-,-:-.'r~:":~l.~({":'::~~:"~'.~'''''' ..' .:,,', . ,,~:"' ..,"r"'_' '~':-;a'4'Z~ C'
g;~ ."fill \;.:;tl'/'~<!d,lL:': ""';-;' to\' , ' .. " ,,", .,'" :",." ",., '1"",,:~2 ~!;!!'~t~
I~iti~ ~i'1~~ ~~~,.,:;~7.~" ~~>\:'!,_~,:t:~~~~':~';,"J~~",:~, ~;,~{......,':'. ' , . : ", ,,",:' ::~'; ~ \:~ {:::.'.' ~~i,t..-f::'Z:"~'1 ~K'
';l;,'IJ~ ~,,~ ,,~~V "', ">',,,""...', ",' '.i'~ """';"\:'~:'i,~:.:,~I;!:i,l'd'~:
~~~~. il!'~il\A .,~J,,~;.\l~~ r,~~,;(}{:,;>\';cjJP.;,;'; ~,'::: ,: " '. '..,'.: ,"':/,~I;:'.)J;;',t1:,! :\~ oil!!
t-;: ,rti,*'jJ.'J:&'i.t!~1;~f:.'''1.'J.' ;:I:~t.!)~,I;J!,'~~ \"'; ~. 'cO ,::. ;0, '," .",,'- ,,"r'-'_r1"~S:-""" 'i-a:f'C~Ofi
\~t~~t. : ~~~~~1~i?!~~:';1~f~~:'~ ','~~{::~J',~ ~~..d:':-::'l:} ,J;; "~". ~. , : ': ..::~.,/~i~<~.\o)~' "i,~ I f'~<'Ift{t~~5'
~"'f>l.~"'J;~. ..:si'4J{<m;'!<1Jo ~-?'>.J.fr:<;.1",' J'" ,"',: .t. ":;:'~+" ' .; '. . I .. .' I" 'i~ ,,,-:..--1,, ~~;.-!" .,o"~~:T,,,;t.~.~
'.mf.1~~l'i.'.fl.'" il',"'::ol:>'~-\:.\."j"~,, "...... :l,,~: 'i''' "- " ,.,' 't, " . j -~', ~:,{ ~~ '.JI~.~".~;'i) L~f"
~;:!i:3..)J:~' ~il(f ~~...'~'~:rJ;.w;' ":, .0([1":..' ';\,.'.~.,l f,,' . ~ .+." ',r,. '" ',' "" :':',1-\',; ., ')'if.tv,\~"Q.t~(f
,~/iJ"'~~, "'rEr~l&!fi'e':i;;,,;:'~i ": ,}:': ...';;",':'; ,t, ~, : '.: .' " , .. . '. '" ':, ,:,'f', :~1t,.)'P;;f1i",Y'I;~'
,ii~"':~"'{f.' .. '..".'....~,"r't.Hi: i?,;";~~"'(~~t'\.),,." ~J ' .,' -:, . ," '( 'I \'<:"'~~r,t. ~'I'~>>
)tN.t!, "~''''l'l::' I" ~'n ,'lA"" ~ 1. ~ ';" "1. :",,',~ \~i .' J ,~" ,/".~. ,t' ~ :.ff':!....l.I.I!~Jt;l:,t:~
..;.,r1'?j oti:f.."'..'...I";,}......tI,.\\;:l'J'.~-J\'"~ , ' . ,...' ' .' "," "~~' 1";.1'. "'I .tIt d. I-:'~~n"i:q
flIt~~JJi'hj'1'1>t';.',~:itr1..;\"~f.".:'.,-;;,~.;t€:';;"~ ,..; ,'~ ~, f,:, .'.\ ..' : t". ,~.I,,~,( 'r"i7i."'f\'i.'~:'f!,;'l''':{f!~
); .....d~~..~" '~'...'.A1',,'~. "1,;" '~' I '-' /,", .,,;~, ",' ' ~ "~ ,1.",' , j~, 'l"~, }':rr. ..;ll.l.>:r.'v,. ...~
:..,.' ~~~ , ('f:~~7Sr'~~' ':::t\~~~'t. '.t.l!,':'~"f-,I\;IV.'~;~t:;t;~ I ~.' ,;,.~.',...,' ~ .'')'}.; . " ,'. ,I' '".. .fl.,..",.. H,t "'.l~'V:'{.jf: '~'
'''', "., 1a:"'" ,. i"~tt, ~,i1 ~ "P>!:"i' ''''.; . ,.:.' I ,~ ,..'" '.', .' , . ' .' (', ~'" ': r.t';:,,:';i/~:;~-.':' J1q;j'.\tlt:~,f.-t\~Qr ~l~ '
~~~1f' iV~~:1"t~ '" '~':J. .,.$ :.:-;.m 'J,:Jt."\S', j:.,/;:':J-;, , "', "J ,(,:,:~',~' .~.:~' . , ' ,...,'"t ..J,:.k,'fl'.,O,~~,~oz;: p'!5,~\!-lrf:;
..... .JJ~{Jt '.rF""",.~t. .,~.~.,"j""~..rij,.'f:< 'l~"'" ,...~,... '. :'\' I.J, >, ~l t." ), ,'~l"4'tt1'
tmt~}fr'f;1;~~~t~.~:iUt~~~J~~1fi:f~\~J.~:!.:~I;~ '~-j.::;;~:.I:~~ ;.:,) ~., .,(, .f ~_, ',\' ; '~':';' '~" .; ~:;/':>:;i ./)i'::':> ::>" ;;~,:.,:;\;);:;:\)'~:;:~H~!;':, !f~~)~!i,;<il;:;.Ji~;.. ,,~~ ~ . J
.{!rr.-i.~'.1:~' ;~~r.i.-:.'k.~Z!,J "".~~{~_ .."..,,1' '_' ':.\.1".1 ..." ,>~, .' '. ;'\"...",'"", '.' '", "': :,'~;;......"..:,<r':~';;l!,~\").;'::/.~~.'~;.v::f!:lr:{~\~#~l:;:~!~J:iM~t,Cj~~~~,~~.~.
~'f!>~,.i~ ..."~":'~{,.,,.. !.!'i!'~'~ 1 ,. ""l"'~". .~, I ~'." ". .,: ~ "'I,;..,_;,r.,::~""",,~,,-;:"I,;..,.,..-..:4,~..,-\if'!;"'~'\'5'if";f",..""."~(j> "'~;\
~\4~~~~~~~~l1}~~~:J:~iq;?'~f':!~";';';~';"\":' ',' ':', , '", .:- ",';,<: ,\ " ,,:;",,; i', ';~;'.;\:~'ii;f!(;,j':;'P;:;\~I;i,i,i5~;?J~Z,;[ij.')it('~Mq;!,"f,,~< ,'~' ,
,~S15"'-t;ii~'~~~1i~'Y:\~~:Q {,;. '1;~;i):':_,:'~"'" : i ;,' ;:':.' ,". :,'..~.,... '~'..".~" ,-: ".;~ ":"i, (' (' '"0 ":~7: ~,~.~t~:;::' ~"';:~~):..~~:".~~~ ';'.:j~;~,' .~., ~':
,,,,~~";'V,,i'i,v_~jf,""'i ::j"",,';"" ....,'.,..", " :"- ....',:, ',;;: "'i" :'!'<:~."'q2~C.iJ(~~~ .
fo..r:-Y,';i~t.t:~(),~~),:;.~:.,'!i~';:..:'.,...-lt ..... " .~. .1':;'\/ ,::;'{ "'.~, ,...~.".I..'r:;J'." .....11"(:;,. .-~=':"'~(:{L. ..';Ii,
~jJ,~lii.~~~.(~~("5~iJrF.rHfr;- :,'; l.]:'.~.: ."~';;:' ',1 I '..' : '~' ;J'~~:, 'J:..-.' y. -,;:~ ....~'.:5:}:...'I'/.r.:~~~.Uh ;,~.; .
:~~.. :,\'*~\:t.-.."....},~.'\'i}";'~ ,:;I;'~ (~~ . ;.1_. . . I~'..>'. .' ~.~.~t'l" '....-.t'J.r--l~y'l:.'XlttJJ)"1
\\ii'''''i.i~~~'~:'~~'i.F.:~'\:':'''';''';;'.' '" ,::, ; '" ' ';, ';, ":,';::/-;~S"i ", ;;~~i' i::I":{:;',{ (:>~{',"~(ri')
....t!'r:,~t:i,Ut:!.::.Ji~t.;tt;~\\',~;L..."t _,' 'I' ',-', ~~'l ,,"' ""," ".:", :.::' "",~,'\\W;.)'~'.rJ.......:-7~;~;':""(.; t
~'~~,~J~!.:'}i:'i,,'r'f~);!li,'-;;:'1,':' ; I.,.> ': '. .' _"~",' '!. ~ '" .. ., " ,'.',., I' .' ,'.-," : " " f''." .,~~. . t1:.~. ,'/.''..,~,:\. 'l.':;.-=,,:?, r'-:~'~, .'f,.:f
~1.i:-;''CI<\I'(*,!''''''''''J' ~.,.' ....,.\ ",~;' ~"'...-:" ......I".~~~~J..."lH:.,
~);r.- ~:'f.;r;:;1t.\f~~+!~'?!: 'I~',l'~;'_, .!' I' ,'. ' .:y" .'- '. . " ," ~ '. ..;\ ,'i' \:: ~;. ~:;. I .~",,:\;....i~'J'r:'.::<-.,,-.:J~~'#~~"~i;~~
',V"- r.o---, ""A))" ~ ,t-o "..' , ,~.' ' . '" .:<;" ,J'-'l '1 ,. ' I.) '" '-1 '~;1;~!' (C','ilf'
.....'i..y.:'.i-;i~g,.*/"ljff;.};~. :"~:j .,'" ~. .~. ",. .... -,~,"""..."j ',\:,,'....'r~"'''\o .;fJ;r':'(''<j:....~o,).... 'E:t::.;1::7"c.-
~i~f:./~~*~f"<tjj~~~~;i.tj.~l':~, ;;.(.: J '. .. -' ( ., I' :~;_: ~;,'",. :' ",: ~ ';i.~ '.~~~~, , ;'~'Jl~:~~~\,{;:~~t(~7:J~~;f:$P.t!hP&,tf~':
I'....S'(:M )./'/';."""'_' : ,', '/' ',~.,' \ ",.., '~" ",,'",':,.;(-.,.~,'}r''''' ~Yi\'<l1l.,:;.<~"frl
,~'::,~~",'\'~l;'"";V'" " , "', "~", ""V\ .._.".~~al.~.::t\tei"1 '~'I,'~(~;'llt,,)
~,~"'.:....~"..IN:,~t,':' ",)..:.' . "', ~" ,,'. :'; j. "'. ',~""~"'II"'~I".'J'.'~J"';.J.J.l""l"l....-r....tfo"t}i: 1~<"t'l
;;1"'F.':'~"'l ~~;,', "j.',: .,'/', . '.:.,' ,.' . ", ""Yi~ i"I'~I';'I;'''''''~'~'i-','..:-f.:;:;v.f,f~)~;~,tY1Jf.
\."~lt;':l:.~':t!Jr""1 :'..,f ....~;I., " I' " ",."~,,:..,,....:'t,..,}~,1.'1-,::'/i'{:-."!.'FY-''''t~ljo:t;.
;'~~"';"'~"~r.. ~{<1' ~~~ :':');1.,;,:' .; . .' ; IO~':':, ~ ' " ) '.' . rr.' '.,J'" . ~:' ,:,';' ~,~,/!:t::~\~'r''1,~vr..w;fl:t:ti:P:
~~,~'.7"~',t.'.I...tl~':i!\~:~;: ,'\1 ::.'~"":h;. .:.1....'. I ~",', ' " .' I .. ': i _ . ,,'.... ~}:.:.:: ~ f--j,:,..) '(~1.~~~Y::'-:'jl~!1J ~,,~~:r,~?-.
,{f'r-~'\,'I":rt.\!,Zftr:~'I;..';,~,-J"''''' :'-".~.:),.,,: ' . ',~' . ,," '. ..'~' ' !~J . ";' :~'.:\',:'tl"')/'-:;'h;'';~if~v.~5~r:t;j.r '.:&.V \
~,., ~: tt:".,..c...... 1_.'.... I ' '1 ... ;.., '.' (;' ~'{"'k'~ ...,....
...... ,j'\~,( ."","~;.~~"r ""'.,, ..... '.\~: ,~, ' ~ '. ...'.' ''''lh~~'l"r-I'''':''t,....~).,..,;,,,~..~'1
to (-'-"k~~ ........ ~'t I ) ;,', .',' "".' . ; .. '- '-!'...r ";.{I\ \fl'''' ,..~' r'h,...;I~.)\ 'I
',!.;.~~,,'h'::.:;~;~::','::'''i''''' \ ~:. ~< 'j' ,~.' "."'., "," .. ,.1). ',', ,:--. '-,' ,-....,' J "'r'. ..}~htt'!."~~:!J~~t-;"'j;JI1> .
"i::;,.t~:.:!I.'-k:;.j,....',~? _~) ,\-. ' ,,'l' " '/.: ,'~'~t.' ''''\if'.'';~::;r;'I!''fl..<:~,....td'
"~'I:~Ji.l'll~'1jf'I'l.$)'1;"~\"'l'''r,'.),~,\.,..,, : _ , ...,'..01 .. .'\,'-,'~ .{',....~,~(.,. \'.:::gtt~~}"\~~''''~C-::'~j.;
"~.tJ.~,'7fr~'f"..'-'I~I'~::' ,"'''. .', " '.'. ~,.~. "., t,;.', \' "'l'-"~~!f:;-;1-)
r '. !1...)t:f'.>f.7:.,~., ~.~f{~~;r'!:'\:;"/f'; .'~~: >',.: :~ " .: . . . ~ ,I " " . ~ '. :l.'.;r: . . \:. -; :','\:..:, l)l':.!}'I:,',7!/~im~..4--{~
y~' >.".-:~,...~:(.,-,;l",.-:.."", ~ ._1_ ~'~, I . . . I'. r... '..' A ,I. ,,,- ..'t)\"'ll, ,,'~'I~~. '..
'~'1~i,:~:~/l:rj~;j~~,:~m,.:..'~~t0;W6':(i!~J.~.~~?,.~'~>,::;',r:,. \~.:, I ~ ,'~; ..-:\-<;~.~.,:~\ J', ~\~~<"~':'I;':,:;;~~f~r,Slt(~t;ft\;~$} i~
'M\1i,'..",..""~.,"~ "",e, 'j"" ". ...' ",,' . c"",";'" , ""';..:!;'li).'v.:o;,t
~{,t1ill~~1.i~~1~~t~:~~t\i~~i~'~H~~~(~t0~; t::"::',;., ':,' ;':: ,f, ':, :"'~:..:: ',,:l:::~:'l.rf{(':':!"f~~ ~-:,~':.l:~:~~jil_~;J}t&1.!Jti~~'~ti~~1'
....._..........,;;,_,.' .~ ,~,I'" ....-., ' '. ,." ~cv 'v. , 'I, ""1. t,r,\. ~ . <, """,,~,',__ij;P J~ r,
,. '.~.' - .' ,~ J. "" ,..-\. ,~~,,;""S_)-'.:U'&'llJYJ,'.~"1 '\;t\i!:.i
. .',. " " .:., \ qqJ,,:--:!~r',:t;'::;'~lb';~\''i~1'-
f ,~,,;,1}: ~'l\ljh'Vr "
"'..-.1'\.....,
\'.'
';:~' :
.-
I.')
.'
, ,
~::"'>~
,'/!'
,/
:....
....
'I;
.:.
"
".,:
,-....
,~
I''',;'''':''
"
'i'.;':".,
".:;
,n
".""
.,
':'.
" ~ . ~
. ~ .' ': '.
,I..
,.,' ,-,' ""
"
"1,
'":',:'(i I
".:':'
"~I,
TI/OMA~, mOMAS & I/AFlR llI'
Dougl.u II, M.lre."o, hlIUI""
3115 North Fronl SIro.'
P,O. lIox 999
I/arrlsburg, I'A 17108-0999
(717) 255-7238
(717) 237.7105 (Fax)
LINDA R, WICKARD and CALVIN L.
WICKARD
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND CO, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiffs
NO. 98-668
vs,
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants
"
. ""':,', '" "', "", '" -" '" ,
",..""..", --, .. -'.. ,-',",', '-'..,',.
NOTICE OF INTENT. TO SERVE, SUBPOENAS
TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS AND THINGS FOR
DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.21 ' " '
. ....',',"--...';..'.-..'...-"',,-,..,..-,',.
',...'.."..',.. ..,'..,.
',.. .. --, '..'..'...
'........','.'.', '..,....
..:..,',..,,,..,',-----..,,....-...
"",.,...."..". -"
-;'.,',-,..,',;..
Defendant, John Shoemaker, intends to serve subpoenas identical to the ones that are
attached to this notice, You have twenty (20) days from the date listed below in which to file of
record and serve upon the undersigned an objection to the subpoena. If no objedion is made, the
subpoena will be served.
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER LLP
Date: December 16, 1998
By.~9~
DOUGl B. W; CEllO, ESQUIRE
Attorney for Defendant
,
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
Plaintiffs
vs
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO, 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
, Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009,22
TO: Custodian of Records,Carllsle Hospital, 245 Parker Street, PO Box 310,Carllsle PA 17013
(Name of Person or Entity)
Within tvJenty (20) days oltor service of thIs subpoona, you aro ordered by tho court to produce the following documonts or things:
All medical reporls, treatment notes, test resulls, correspondence, etc, for treatment rendered on
behalf of Linda R. Wickard, d/o/b: 1/16/44
.1 THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LlP, 305 N. Fronl Street, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
(Address)
You may deliver or malllogible copies of tho documonls or produce Ihlngs requested by Ihls subpoena, logother with the certificate of
compl/ance, to tho party making this toquesl at the address IIslod abovo. You have tho right 10 seek. In advance, tho reasonable cost of
preparing the copies or producing tho things sought.
If you faU 10 produce 11'10 documents or things required by this subpoena. withIn tw9nty (20) days after its service, the party serving thIs subpoena
may seek a court order compelling you to comply with il.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOLLOWING PERSON:
NAME: Douolas B, Marcello. Esoulre
ADORESS 305 N, Front Street. POB 999
Harrisburo, PA 17108
TELEPHONE, (717)237.7141
SUPREME COURT 10 No: 36S10
ATTORNEY FOR, Defendant Shoemaker
Prolhonot:uy/Clerk, Civil Division
Deputy
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Courl
,
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
Plalnllffs
vs
NO, 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22
TO: Custodian of Records,Erie Insurance Group, 100 Erie Insurance PI.. Erie. PA 16530
(Name or Porson or Entity)
Within twenty (20) days after service ollhls subpoena, you aro orderod by tho court to produco tho following documonts or things:
All claim files Including applications for benefits, medical reports, treatment notes, test results, correspondence, elc. for
rendered on behalf of Linda R. Wickard, d/o/b: 1/16/44, polley no. Qll.1504184H
.1 THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP, 305 N. Front Street, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
(Addross)
You may doliver or mall legible coplas of the documonts or produco Ihlngs roquostod by this subpoena, togothor with tho cortificate of
compliance, to the party making this roquest at tho address listed abovo. You have tho right 10 sook, In advanco, tho reasonable eost of
proparlng the copies or producIng the things sought.
If you filii to produco tho documents or things required by this subpoena, within twenty (20) dllYs after lis sorvlce, the party serving this subpoena
may seek a court ordor compelling you to comply with it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOLLOWING PERSON:
NAME: Douoias B, Marcello. Esouire
ADORESS 305 N. Front Street. POB 999
Harrisburo. PA 17108
TELEPHONE: f717l237.7141
SUPREME COURTlO No: 36510
ATTORNEY FOR: Defendant Shoemaker
Prothonotary/Clork. Civil Division
Deputy
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Court
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
Plalnllffs
vs
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO. 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22
TO: Custodian of Records, Blue Mountain Anesthesia Associates
(Name of Person or Entity)
Within twenty (20) days aner service of this subpoenll, you are ordered by the court 10 produce the following documents or things:
All medical reports, trealment notes, test results, correspondence, elc, for treatment rendered on
behalf of Linda R. Wickard, d/o/b: 1/16/44
01 THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP, 305 N. Front Slreet, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
(Address)
You mOly deliver or mall legible copies of tho documents or produce things requested by this subpoena, together with tho cortificato of
compliance, 10 the party milking this request at the address listed above, You have the right to seek, in advance, tho reasonable cost of
prepnring tho copIes or producing tho things sought.
If you fall to produco (he documents or things required by this subpoena, within twenty (20) days aftor Its sorvlce, tho party serving this subpoena
may seek a court order compelling you to comply with it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOLLOWING PERSON:
NAME, DouQlas B, Marcello, Esoulre
AOORESS 305 N, Front Street. POB 999
Harrisburo. PA 17108
TELEPHONE: (717)237.7141
SUPREME COURT 10 No: 36510
ATTORNEY FOR, Defendant Shoemaker
Prothonotary/Clork, Civil DivisIon
o.puty
DATE: 12116/98
Seal of the Court
.:==-_..,~
, ","'\ff~ (f~~li,.t!l,/ " \'\ ',.! 1!lr
" "jL',,~\, 'l~;.{~ ;:<-" ;''l.'I;'
l: .: r.... ~I, )1, ~~:-"Jl_y:"r'" \ .,<,
, '~, \ '.,"',' - "'A''''",..~}/~IJ.
.,' ,.' 'l' ,'.' ", :l~f.~:r~
'I>' :,'1,,'.; ~'. I '~,~'iN:,llif/fi
" It..... ":;';'L4.;:.~"t.\~~)
.'),,> .', \ ..: ,4;'? "t~\:~~~!
, ~ _ ._~il.ti':):..~:~,n.~
......:....
Douglas B. Marcello, Esquire
305 North Front Street
P.O. Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108.{)999
(7m 255-7238
(7m 237.7105 (Fax)
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN L. WICKARD
IN 1111 COUIU OJ COMMON I'IIAS
CUMIII,HI ANI> COlIN I V, l'INNSVl.VANIA
Plaintiffs
NO, '11I.(,r.1I
v.
CIVil, ACIION -lAW
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRV E. JACKSON
JUHV IHIAI. I>IMANl>m
Defendants
" ""..","
,,,:;,::,::,:':;;:':::""'-'"
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICI:
AND NOW, this 16th day of Deccmber, 19911, I, IlARIIARA A, ONORATO, a l.cgal Assistant
at the law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafcr, l.l.P hereby certify Ihat I S(!I1t il true ",ul correct copy of
the foregoing Interrogatories Directed to Plilinliff Lindil Wick,lrd by plilcing a copy of the same in the
United States Mail, first class, postage prcpaid, to the following:
Harold S. Irwin, Esquire
Suites 201/202 Hitner House
35 E. High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Mr, Barry Jackson
615 Mt. Rock Road
Newville, PA 17241
JJWLMk Q. f)~Jt I It-
Ililrbilra A, Onorato
l.egill Assislilnt
Date: December 16, 1998
-----~
" 'j'" "'" . "t "'fi~'
".-, ',..'. ;\',:~,:~, "-"~~, J~Jl%' .ll~ .;.
, "'" '"'',''11''';<;''' ~~' ,
, .' ":' .:~> ~:",,':.', '~'~f.' I'" ,
~e'J.t-"r.-;I'I;~iV,'::'~~>- '...
,.. ','J,','.1i' 'J"'}-'" 1',' "
l'''l},''''}I:.,>$~lJl~1,i' '.
. ,--'-.'"
.'.-',
,..-,:
" ,j::;,,!,j~r;;,~i!l~1!'~~,
" ":','.'" ,:,.-,'\<i"d:,' j,'[',.I,!,{'I',i
" ::;.::~'_'..~.:;;;',\>, ~,;ji'4i/:\.}/1~;;','['lt..,
,'C',-'H ""'-~!1);')'I:"1 '
""":''-'>_.' t'~':"i:~!{;'1{,.;\!,iX, }
;,,," ::",,~:".~j!~:UU~};~~:J.i
.-:'.; ,"
"',
~~c
to;'
"
OIlU"'" D, M.n:cUII. EIl,ul..
305 Nllrth Frunt Stn'"
P,O. Bllx 999
lIorli.hulll, PA 171I1H-l~)99
(7t71255.71JH
(717) 237.71115 (Faxl
LINDA R, WICKARD and
CALVIN L. WICKARD
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMIIERLAND CO, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiffs
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
No: 98-6311 L.I",Y
v.
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants
,'. ';::':::'~'::':):>::::
.',.,""','.-'-'-',,,.,'.."....'..
..,..--,..,......,,','
,',-:,.-:'"'.:..,,'.-,..,.-,,..'..
.,',.,.",-;'."
, , , , , CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this 16th day of December, 199B, I, BARBARA A. ONORATO, a Legal Assistant
at the law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer UP, hereby certify that I sent a true and correct copy of
the foregoing Interrogatories to Defendant by placing a copy of the same in the United States Mail,
first class, postage prepaid, to the following:
Harold S. Irwin, Esquire
Suite 201/202 Hitner House
35 S. High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Barry Kronthal, Esquire
Reynolds & Havas
101 Pine Street
Harrisburg, PA 1710B
,!Fl,II&lI"
:"-",,1 .
~
-~~ !
iii' ·
~.~~ tt
{~~1r "
:,Wi
,f;q~l '
:;1\!1~~
t%,~t'
rii~{!
}~.'):.\~
~,:p?{
E~I~
\;;,~~!{
}j~;;tl
~'.tl'~!fu~
'lAiPi~
)~.t""!
"~~~I~
I!t.-.;;&,
_'n;:i~i}~
~ ~~j;,~
. ,~~--..~~~~Ul.>1;;a'4~Auo.~~:~~u~~.r~~!'"".'l'tt."~I?'<'~ ~~~~:,:.<.!,'tia
" , i ;','::..,.;~:::{",;-}::;;:)::\\'i~.:r';:;{!!.:-~:[ri~:{i{,!~:tJ:~~~
~().~
Barbara A. Onorato
Legal Assistant
Date: December 17, 1998
24
~!o,'1':"'-"l~I' ....'l'~ ,~'" " '
~-flilft\I\:'!.i}i. ~:"'~'t....'~ ~1! '.'''-.'.~'t ,
"~"tr,i."''-,'',.',~'.r-''_."".~: ..'
j,t, ~lhq,rl~'C''<'.-:.;''')' ~'''' ,\,\
<< I..... 'tl J'1".1 ";''''''' \ r . ,
~,~ .it':t\{.:,- :'.~""(~"~"'" .
~~-~!;,''ioJ'\",'f\~,~'~.' 1.1~,\. ,.'"
'I~' 'y'II"~J.',t". ~ ~( ." II', '
~ \.., ~ '.1 !o. . '. ' . ~. .
.. ~,,'H'I).!,,"I...."':~ ')... :-', . '
;,: ~il':.'" ji....ll,~.v..r. ).>: ...~
,ijI,',b'I"'<t");! ,,' to. >,W ,I' 1. "
,f:~",">:.~~.\~\,.:\'~;, ~f'('JI:~)(.~\:""~,, '
1!:.:l.,.:""J,~"";"'~"1>A ,'\'" :)' ,
Inllm"." *IIU"'no""'."r..
DIIUA'.' R MarceUn, [IIlulre
JII~ Nllrth Fnlhl SInd
P,O, Do. 999
IlIrrhhulllo PA 17111H-Il'J99
(717) 1~S-72JH
(117) 1J7-71115 (FR')
, ,
. ',~;--=:.
"'"I
.','
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN L. WICKARD
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND CO, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 98-liBI t..~
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E,JACKSON
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants
'-"-..'
,- " ,'" ','" ,
,,' ,- "" -- '" '.
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE '
AND NOW, this 17h day of December, 1998, I, BARBARA A. ONORATO, a legal Assistant
at the law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer llP, hereby certify that I sent a true and correct copy of
the Plaintiff's Request for Production of Documents Directed to Defendant by placing a copy of the
!JuJ~O~
BARBARA A, ONORATO
legal Assistant
'I" '
~,
~.~
~~~
,,'i~,rA
;~~i'l;l
'1".0 ~'~',.
l~" -~
~.~.~
'~~~
~:,'i!l"
Qt~~!~~
"~ 'n
".,"Ii."'!<'
.., ,'Ji
\:'v".-g
r'~'ll'i
,':.:1f"1.-;.'
j\',,'~;V
,ii,','~'lI!'.i~"
~_ .!":'
!", ,.
'!-l;' :
tt..~ ~_
,,;~~Iil~
li,....'t;iJ..
';.;;;tl~
;~~~ ;
l'.;~':i,l
:r:.~\~'>.:l.'
';"n:{tC-'
:?t:~V~1
:;',",'l'~~~
,,;:,;,/,.J~
q',!'J
,."J;1'.
["""'"
.','r:, ~
!":-.,:-..1:S
1':O?";:5
,..,...'.'.,
::;~]~~~ti
"",:,i"!"
!,;:,{,~~~!;;,~
I : -,' ~?"'1
---~Ii;~ll
same in the United States Mail, first class, postage prepaid, to the following:
Harold S. Irwin, Esquire
Suites 201/202 Hitner House
35 S. High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Barry Kronthal, Esquire
Reynolds & Havas
101 Pine Street
Harrisburg, PA 17108
LINDA R. WICKARD and CALVIN L
WICKARD,
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
NO, 98-668
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
v.
JOHN SHOEMAKER and BARRY
JACKSON,
Defendants
PRAECIPE FOR RULE TO FILE A COMPLAINT
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Please issue a Rule upon Plaintiffs to file a Complaint within twenty (20) days or
suffer judgement non pros.
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP
Do as B. rcello, Esquire
3 North Front Street
Post Office Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108.0999
(717) 255-7238
RULE
A Rule is hereby issued upon Plaintiff to file a Complaint within twenty days or
suffer judgment non pros.
pro\:onotary
Ijtr-I-A-
Gl-Gtv~ t?"
f~
'/ c f1
IJ JJ-'1 J
.....
tJ
G~
-or,j
rnp"':
- , " ~
f~; ~~ :~
i.~,:
:1::(1
:::~~:
0,:\
-<
~t')
c;:)
CJ
rq
C-,
",
C..J
o
-n
::rI
,'--r1
'~~I!2P
':1
(~~ t )
:f~~-l
',:?r;)
(:)1"
-,I
.".
'n
~
.",
:.:?
",
CO
,'~
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
NO, 98.668
CIVIL ACTION -LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
LINDA R. WICKARD and CALVIN L
WICKARD,
v,
JOHN SHOEMAKER and BARRY
JACKSON,
Defendants
PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF APPEARANCE
TO THE PROTHONOTARY:
Please enter my appearance on behalf of Defendant, John Shoemaker in the
above-captioned matter.
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP
By: \
Do glas
305 N rant Street
Post Office Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108.0999
(717) 255.7238
I,
i
i
!
!
I
I
I,
!
I
-
,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
1"' L
AND NOW, this I~, /' I day of December, 1998, I, Cynthia D. Byrd,
"
secretary In the law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer, hereby certify that I sent a true
and correct copy of the foregoing document to the following counsel of record, by
placing a copy of same In the United States, first class mall, postage pre-paid,
addressed as follows:
Harold S, Irwin, 11f, Esquire
Hitner House, Suite 201 and 202
35 East High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
(), ./\ fl .
t\ j')J~/J--rU ,1
Cyn la D, Byrd
TI/O^,^S, "'O^,^S III I/^" R II"
DOI'IlI,.. II. M,uccllo, h'llll",
305 North T,olll SI,ccl
",0, 110. 999
I/,ltTlllllOll, "^ 17100.{J999
(717) 255.7230
(717) 23707105 (r...)
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
PI.linliffs
NO 98-668
v.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E.JACKSON
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants
CERTIFICATE
PREREQUISITE TO SERVICE OF SUBPOENAS
DISCOVERY PURSUANno RULE 4009.22
As a prerequisite to service of subpoenas for documents and things pursuant to Rule
4009.22, Defendant, John Shoemaker ertifies that:
(1) A notice of intent to serve the subpoena with a copy of the subpoenas attached thereto
was mailed or delivered to each party at least tw~nty days prior to the date on which the subpoena is
sought to be served.
(2) A copy of the notice of intent, including the proposed subpoena, is attached to this
certificate.
(3) Harold Irwin, Attorney for Plaintiff, has waived the 20-day rule, and
(4) The subpoenas which will be served are identical to the subpoena which are attached
to the notice of intent to serve the subpoena.
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAfER UP
Dale: December 21, 1998
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiffs
NO, 98.668
VS.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOI-IN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY JACKSON
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendant
, CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE "
AND NOW, this 21ST day of December, 199B, I, BARBARA A. ONORATO, a Legal Assistant
at the law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer LLP, hereby certify that I sent a true and correct copy of
the foregoing document by placing a copy of the same in the United States Mail, first class, postage
prepaid, to the folloWing:
Harold Irwin, Esquire
Hitner House-Suites 201/202
35 S. High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Barry Kronthal, Esquire
REYNOLDS & HAVAS
101 Pine Street
Harrisburg, PA 1710B
/J/~IA () IA~A-d-
Barbara A. Onorato
Legal Assistant
Date: December 21,1998
'"'
6l\
fe'" '
TIlOMAS, TII0MAS & IlArcR Ill'
Dougl.ts O. Molrccllo, [lItulrc
305 North Fronl Slrcct
1'.0, 00. 999
Harrlsburg,l'A 17100.0999
(7m 255-7230
(7m 237.7105 (F,lK)
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN L. WICKARD
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT Of COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 911-668
VS.
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Defendants
CERTIFICATEQFSERVICE'
AND NOW, this 16th day of December, 1998, I, BARBARA A. ONORATO, a paralegal in
the law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer LlP, hereby certify that I sent a true and correct copy of the
foregoing document by pl,,':ing a copy of the same in the United States Mail, first class, postage
I
,
I
prepaid, to the fol/owing:
J
i
Harold S. Irwin, Esquire
Hitner House
Suites 201/202
35 S. High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
I
,
l~
(
Mr, Barry Jackson
615 Mt. Rock Road
Newville, PA 17241
Dale: December 16, 1998
Barbara A. Onorato
Legal Assistant
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
LINDA R. WICKARD ond
CALVIN WICKARD
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
Plolntlffs
vs
NO. 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009.22
TO: Custodian of Records, Dr. Daniel Hely, Orthopaedic Suregons of Carlisle
(Name of Porson or Enlity)
Within twenty (20) d3ys aner service of this subpoena, you IIro ordered by the court to produco tho following documents or things:
All medical reports, treatment notes, test results, correspondence, etc. for treatment rendered on
behalf of Linda R. Wickard, d/o/b: 1/16/44
.t THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, llP, 305 N. Front Street, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
(Address)
You may deliver or mail legible copies of the documents or produce things requested by this subpoena, together with the certifICate of
compllanco, to tho party making this request at the addross listed above. You havo the right 10 seek, In advanco, the reasonable cost of
preparing tho copIes 01 producing tho thIngs sought.
If you fall to produce tho documents or things required by this subpoena, within twenty (20) days aftor its servico, tho party serving this subpoena
may seek a court ordor compelling you to comply with it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOllOWING PERSON:
NAME: Douolas B, Marcello. ESQuire
AOORESS 305 N, Front Street. POB 999
Harrisbum, PA 17108
TELEPHONE: (717) 237.7141
SUPREME COURT 10 No: 36510
ATTORNEY FOR: Defendant Shoemaker
Prothonotary/Clerk, Civil DivisIon
Deputy
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Court
I
i
I
I
~
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
Plalnllffs
vs
CIVil ACTION. LAW
NO, 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009,22
TO: Custodian of Records,Belvedere Medical Center, 850 Walnut Bottom Road. Calisle PA 17013
(Namo of Person or Entity)
Within twenty (20) days anor service of this subpoona, you are ordered by tho court to produco tho (ollowing documents or things;
All medical reports, treatment noles, test resulls, correspondence, etc, for trealment rendered on
behalf of Linda R. Wickard, dlo/b: 1/16/44
at THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, llP, 305 N. Front Slreet, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
(Address)
1
I
,
I
You may dol/vor or mail legible copies of lhl) documents or produco things roquested by this subpoena, together with tho certificate of
compllanco, to tho party making this request ill tho nddress listed abovo. You have tho right to soek, In advance. tho roasonablo cost of
prepnring tho copies or producing tho things sought.
Iryou fall to prOduce tho documenls 01 Ihhl9S requIred by this subpoena, within twenty (20) dilYs after its service, the party serving this subpoena
may seek a court ordor compelling you (0 comply with it.
!
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOllOWING PERSON:
NAME, Doualas B, Marcello. Esauire
AOORESS 305 N, Front Streel. POB 999
Harrisbum. PA 17108
TELEPHONE: (717) 237.7141
SUPREME COURT 10 No: 36510
ATTORNEY FOR, Defendanl Shoemaker
Prothonotary/Clerk, Civil Division
Deputy
,
I' (
I
I
,
"
'I
,
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Court
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLA.ND
LINDA R. WICKARD nnd
CALVIN WICKARD
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
Plnlnllffs
vs
NO, 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER nnd
BARRY E, JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009,22
TO: Custodian of Records,Carlisle Imaging Associats, 245 Parker Street, PO Box 310, Carlisle PA 17013
(Nama 0' Person Of Enllty)
Within twenty (20) days anor seIVlce 0' this subpoena, you ore ordorod by tho court to produco tho following documents or things:
All medical reports, treatment notes, test results, correspondence, etc, for treatmenl rendered on
behalf of Linda R. Wickard, d/o/b: 1/16/44
ot THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, llP, 305 N. Front Street, POB 999, Hanisburg, PA 17108
(Addross)
You may deliver or mall legible copies of the documents or produco things requested by lhis subpoon3, togothor with tho cortirlCato of
compflanco, to tho party making this request al tho addll'$S listed abovo. You have the right to soek, in advance, tho reasonable cost of
preparing tho copies or producing tho things sought.
If you fail to produco tho documonts or things required by this subpoena, within twenty (20) days aftor its servlco, the party serving this subpoona
may seek a court order compolllng you to compty with it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOllOWING PERSON:
NAME' Doualas B, Marcello. Esouire
AOORESS 305 N, Front Street. POB 999
Hanisburo. PA 17108
TELEPHONE: f7171 237-7141
SUPREME COURTlO No: 36S10
ATrORNEY FOR: Defendant Shoemaker
Prothonol.uyfClork, Civil Division
I
o,pUIy
.,
i
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Court
, ,
, '
:~ .''',"
'"'
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
PlalnUrrs
vs
CIVIL ACTION. LAW
NO. 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E, JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009,22
TO: Custodian of Records.Erie Insurance Group, 100 Erie Insurance PI., Erie, PA 16530
(Name of Person or Entity)
WithIn twenty (20) days 3nOl servlco of this subpoena, you 3ro ordered by tho court to produce the following documents or things:
All claim files including applications for benefits, medical reports, treatment notes, test results, correspondence, elc. for
rendered on behalf of Linda R. Wickard, d/o/b: 1/16/44, polley no. Q11.1504184H
.1 THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP, 305 N, Fronl Street, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
'\
,
I
(Address)
You may doUvor or mail legible copies of tho documnnts or produco things requestod by this subpoena. together with tho certiflCato of
compliance, to tho piuty making thls request .at tho address listed nbovo. You have tho right to seek, In adVilnco, tho reasonable cost of
preparing tho coplos or producing tho things sought.
If you (all to produco tho documents or things required by this subpoena, within twonty (20) days aner lis sorvico, lho party sorvlng this subpoena
may seok a court order compolling you to comply W'ilh it.
i
,
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOLLOWING PERSON:
NAME: Douqlas B, Marcello, Esquire
AOORESS 305 N, Front Streel. POB 999
Harrisbum. PA 17108
TELEPHONE: (7171 237.7141
SUPREME COURT 10 No: 36510
ATTORNEY FOR: Defendant Shoemaker
Prothonotary/Clark, Civil Division
Deputy
I
I
l
,
r [
I
I
1\
i
i
,
I
I
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Court
\
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLA.ND
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
PlalnUfls
vs
NO. 98-668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009,22
TO: Custodian of Records, Blue Mountain Anesthesia Associates
(Nama of Person or Entity)
Wlthln twenty (20) days aftor service of this subpoena, you are ordered by tho court 10 produce tho following docum~nls or things:
All medical reports, treatment notes, test results, correspondence, etc. for treatment rendered on
behalf of Linda R. Wickard, d1o/b: 1/16/44
.t THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP, 305 N. Front Street, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
(Address)
You may deliver or mail legible copies of tho documents or produce things requested by this subpoena, together with the certirlCato of
compliance, 10 tho party making this request at tho address listed abovo. You have tho right 10 seek. In advance, tho reasonable cost of
preparing tho copies or producing tho things sought
If you fall to produce the documents or things required by this subpoena, within twenty (20) days after its service, tho party serving this subpoena
may seek a court ordor compelllng you 10 comply Ydth it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOLLOWING PERSON:
NAME: Douolas B, Marcello. Esouire
AOORESS 305 N, Front Street. POB 999
Harrisbum. PA 17108
TELEPHONE: f717) 237-7141
SUPREME COURT ID No: 36510
ATTORNEY FOR, Defendant Shoemaker
Prothonotary/Clerk, Civil Division
Oeputy
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Court
COMMONWEALTH OF PENNSYLVANIA
COUNTY OF CUMBERLAND
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN WICKARD
CIVIL ACTION -LAW
Plalnllffs
vs
NO. 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
Defendants
SUBPOENA TO PRODUCE DOCUMENTS OR THINGS
FOR DISCOVERY PURSUANT TO RULE 4009,22
TO: Custodian of Records, Dr. Arun Kapor, Carlisle Pain Center
(Name of Person or Entity)
Within twenty (20) days aner seMce of this subpoena, you are ordered by tho court 10 produco tho following documents or things:
All medical reporls, treatment notes, test results, correspondence, elc, for treatment rendered on
behalf of Linda R. Wickard, dJo/b: 1/16/44
01 THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP, 305 N. Front Street, POB 999, Harrisburg, PA 17108
(Address)
You may deliver or mail legible copies of tho documents or produco things requested by this subpoena, together with tho certificate of
compllanco, to tho party making this request at the address listed abovo. You have tho right to seek, in adv:mco, the reasonable cost of
preparing tho copIes or producing the things sought.
If you fall to produce th" documents or things required by this subpoena. within twenty (20) d3YS al'tor its servlco, tho party serving this subpoena
may seek D court order compelling you to comply.,...;th it.
THIS SUBPOENA WAS ISSUED AT THE REQUEST OF THE FOLLOWING PERSON:
NAME: Douolas B, Marcello. Esquire
AOORESS 305 N, Front Slreel. POB 999
Harrisburtl. PA 17108
TELEPHONE: (717) 237-7141
SUPREME COURT '0 No, 36510
ATTORNEY FOR: Defendant Shoemaker
Prolhonotary/Clerk, Civil Division
Deputy
DATE: 12/16/98
Seal of the Court
;i
"
.'"
;/:
:~
OJ . ,
"
"
4. Please state whether you have lost any time from your business or occupation since the
accident of February 5, 1996, and if so, please state:
(a) the cause of such loss of time;
(b) the number of days lost and the dates;
(c) the amount of any wages or income loss; and
(d) the name and address of the person, firm, company or association who maintains a
record listing your attendance at or absence from said work.
ANSWER:
February 6, went to Carlisle Hospital ER for thumb injury.
Carlisle Hospital, 246 Parker Street, Carlisle PA 17013
5. Are you now receiving or have you ever received any disability pension, income or
insurance, or any worker's compensation from any agency, company, person, corporation, state or
government agency, and if so, state:
(a) The nature of such payment;
(b) the dates you received such income;
(c) for what injuries or disability did you receive it and how such injury
or disability occurred; and
(d) by whom paid;
(e) whether or not you now have any present disability as a result of such
injuries or disability, and;
(f) if so, the nature and extent of such disability.
ANSWER:
NO.
~ . .
~ " ..
8, Have you ever suffered any injuries in any accident during the ten (to) year period prior to
the accident which is the subject of this litigation l If so, state for each injury or accident:
(a) the date and place of such injury;
(b) a detailed description of all injuries you received;
(c) the name and address of any hospilals rendering treatment;
(d) the names and addresses of all physicians, surgeons or other medical
praditioner rendering treatment;
(e) the nature and extent of recovery and, if any permanent disability was suffered,
the nature and extent of the permanent disability, and
(f) If you were compensated in any manner for any such injury, state the names and
addresses of each and every person or organization paying such compensation and
the amount thereof;
ANSWER:
No.
~ ~ "'" .
. "
11, State whether you have made any written or recorded statements regarding the accident of
February 5, 1996, and if so, please slate:
(al the name and address of the person or persons 10 whom such statement
was made;
(b) the dates such statemenlS were made;
(c) the form of the statement, whether written, oral, by recording device, or to
a stenographer;
(d) whether such statemenlS, if written, were signed; and
(e) the name and address of the person presently having custody of such statement.
ANSWER:
Feb 5 - and later - PA State Police. Written.
To my attorney, Harold Irwin - He took notes and someone typed
them up for me to sign.
12. Please Slate the full name and last known address of f?Very witness known to you or to your
attorneys who have any knowledge regarding the facts and circumstances surrounding the accident of
your accident of February 5, 1996.
ANSWER:
Barry E. JaCkson,?
State Policeman who came to investigate the accident.
Paramedic from Newville Hose Co.#l, who talked to me after accident.
13, Please give the name and address of each physician, ch iropractor, or other medical
practitioner who has examined and/or treated you as a result of the accident or for the injuries alleged
in your complaint, and please state with regard to each such physician or medical practitioner;
(aJ the first date on which you were examined and/or treated by each;
(bl the number of occasions you were examined or treated by each;
(c) the last date on which you were examined and/or treated by each; and
(d) the nature of the treatment rendered by each,
ANSWER
See attached.
.'
. '
~
. '.
ANSWER 13, continued.
I....;;~:~,~()(!)(,j) 9..1..4 C,,\m...I::,;I...E .l:I'I,)OHIO (.;BSDGt:i :1. '.>96();',~()6 I;<:l :I.'1';>6{);~<)"~
1...,;r,:~6() ;1'1 ""I. ~I:I. IMI'I.J:l:i:L. I'" H"-'..Y I'll) :L \JIJ6()~';~:L~) '1:0 :I. 9';>.!,();'~:l:;;
L..;;:U~Il,f, .I, '7 . ()", CAI'(L..I: ::;U,i: .1:1'11:,13 :l.1'1I:i 1::-'!:j~:)OG~:) t (j.I1"lo;!,O~::l'l t<:l :l \;Hy (~)() ~~:1. 7
l... \?,t)(!)I!)':)~:; ;';; ::\ .. ~:l() tiEL. VEOI:::r:(E l'IEf).l:I,:f,L. t:;OI'(I"l.lI:;:I~TIi:JI'1 :I. \'Jl':)(!)()4~:I. '7 t,;, :I. \:,J<Y'!'()4:::J. '7
L. I?,.~ ~'~::I. ::'il:J ,;)'.::..41.) '::"11,; 1:;,I'IIi:I'::l.!I:',"II.; ( fii'H'(:'i.l:I::.I:,""'l:ii .I. ';;'\:'>6',)~';:Ob t<:, :I. \;>'l(!)()~';:()l)
I...\/';J~';: /~;: 1 .;)/..41;' 1IIl.WI 1"'I"h"~II":I~h',1 ; I , 1.1'11;... .I. \;"/ ,:)O~~~::i~') b;) I. '}'/C)()~;:~'::I{)
l... ',ZIt; J t~) ~:~l;J.;; ,;:::\" l. t;~ ()(,,"II.i::,I... I' HEL.:- I-IV 1.9\;i\::.O:;;J.~:: 'to :J. "))'.;>,;)",l.;-}l~;:
..
I... ';J'i'HI~)~)::S I. .I. ~;i .. '~:: ;; C,:'.h:I...J.::jI...E II'..:,,:,,!. ::::,J... 1.'="'/,:)0:;:06 t(:) .I.';/'l ;,'.):,::1. '/
111(),;';~;~/6::) ~~::\.. :I.':;: (MI'I !. I::.!... ,,;' 1'11:'.1...( IYID :I. ~"';(!)();J,~';: ~:l t<:) J. 'I'J"~)()':):i:::;
1'l:l::\(hM:$ 4(.~ .. 'I'J 1..1:1'11>1" I'~ Wll.:I(")t,W :L ~;"(..;)b()~:::1. '1 tCJ l';>'y6c),',::J.7
1'1 J. r:\()().;, ::\ ~::~"'" l~: !:l!.,:L.VI:,:O".m,: l'II;:D.l:I:;,<;!.., l.;m~I"CmAT,rl.lI" :L ').l9 ~!.()~;)~~ ::\ tl:, :l9j)f.)()~':;~'~::,
1'120';>O,fJ ~ ~::::' ..l~~ l-J1::L.VEVEI':Ii:: 1'II:d)I: C;,,)!... CIJI'~I:i'lJl'~A r:r llI'l l''''\TI.)()~:\:C::~I.~ t<:l :1. 'i'(;>t.)()~;,l~'~t.~
l'I:'1:J. 660;1 2?'j'1.~.. :LI.~ ~H..I::XAI'IDEI:~ !:)I';'''~.['''G RI.~HA/o.I :L '1"y6()~:)2'y t'J :t (;J(Y6()c)~::B
~1340:',\fJ6 t:U:l:C:::.. ~:::c::: .<)'-1,,:;(,,\1'11>1:::1': ~;F'I': 1.1'11<) I'(E:HAH :J. 9"C,O';1();'~ t,:) :1. '1'1~~()7:J.6
1'1:)4?~);I. IJ ~':):':)(.~.. m;;; I)LEX,",I'IDI::i'( :'jf"'I'~,[I'IU f~I:.HAI:l :I. 9';>6()7;~~':j t.':l 1 "'1o()BO~J
1'1'12() 1 " ~,\ :l ';>:L . ()';1 AU::XAI'lm",: ~;;r;"I:;:J:I'IG l':EHAI:I :L 9<;60B()';> tCJ l'~')>6()lH.;,
I'H:I:l7:::7:$ "~::'" .J.:~ tl/::I.. VEDI::r:~E I'IE:O,J:GAL C(Jf(I:i'rlHA T:r ON 1 '1'16 H)02 t.rJ 1')>'1.;,1002
M:H '7~;'74 mI. 1<1 CAI:(I..:r SL/;: 1:1'IAGIIoIG ASBOC!:i 1.9<;6100'7 tCJ 1. 'Y'16 :[()07
l'I:H77UI 3'70.6<) GAI':I...I:SI...E: H(lSPITi\l.. :L'1'i'6:L007 t,~ :l'jl'16:LOO7
1151.'77:1.8 2~;..1~~ !:tEI.. VEI>I::HI,,: l'IE.o:l:CAL. c;Of(POFO:A T ION :L'19,Sl()U. t.<:l :l ';>'16:WU.
M:H 7720 1~7. ::u C,')/'(I...:I: :iiL.E: n/r')GII'IG A!:iSOCS :1. '1'16:1.0:L6 ttJ :1. ';>'16:l<):L,S
l'I:'~~:I..:lI.Jl 2~5.. :J.~~ .t;tli"_ VI=:J)EI:~Iii: 11EI).I:(;;I)L CClI'(I::'()f~A T I (m :1, '1'1,~:l.O;~;~ to :1. 9\;>6:J.()~:~2
1'1~':'~:1.~~(;>::1 ~)I.... '7'1 W,"'I_I'Il.JT BOTrl:JI"1 H(-HHOLDl3Y :r. 'j."J6:r.02~~ tc~ :1. '1';>6 :L02;~
1'l60~)\;)t3,!) ~:I.):1. .. t.~::l I'IGI'I 1:;'I"U;:',I;~I"I(.~IC Y :t :[1,/(:: " 1.9')>60;:;;~6 tCl :1.';>961:1.()6
rI606')>~1f.l ~~.. 5.1. I'IGI'I 1"H(-\I'(I'lliGY " ING" :r. 99'.~)()~~2c) tC:l :L '.i,H)) b ()~'~~~f.)
1~16(;'..!)99() 1 <;;;;" '7'1 CAI'U.. ,I: SU:: HOSI":rTAI.. l.'y9~):/'(>:L6 tCJ 1';>96:1.016
M6()6'1')>;~ 7cl..:;::\ BEI..VI::I>Ef(E I'IEIHCAI.. COI'(I"" :I.'1'j16:1.0:~0 te~ 1';>9~,:LO;:;O
'16()6'19;:; 2~; ..12 BEl. VJ::I>EI':E 11E1>.1:CI)L. CClI':POI':A T I (JI'! 1. 9''>';.:/, :l ():L to :L9'16:1.:l();l
M606';>9:, 61.87 AI_EXA"'DEI:( SF'I=\::rI'IG r~EHAB I. '196:L:1.1:;; t(~ :1. <;96 1:l :1,:$
1606997 101. 9() AI_EXAI'IDEI'( SI"RII'IO I'(EHAB :1.990,11.21. tel 1'1';>611.~:1
116<)'7()OO ~,(, ..1"'. AL.EXArII>EI;: SI"fUNO REHAB :J.~;)1i'6:I.:I.2::\ t'J :L(;>96:1.:L~'~::,
'191~\1~;7 1.1.~3.. 7,!> ALEXi~I'IDE:I:~ ~)I"I::::J:I'IG 1'~Iii:HAB 1 ~;>'Pf.)l~;:():2 tCl :J. 99c):t 20lJ
rl'1 1 ~i 1 'I<) 14;:;.76 ALlii:;(.'~I'JI)I::I'~ :iil"'l"::l:I'1I;) I':I::HAB 19'Pf.)1~~()r; tel :l.9t,.:JiJ:L:;~1:1.
1'i';~:I.;:;84 ll.~~).. 7~') ',)L'=:Xf,I'IJ.>E:I::; ~il::HI.I'IU I'O:EHAB I. 99,;'):L ~:~ J. rJ tCI .L cy'Y":>:1. ~:~ 1. €J
"'06:;;t.~~~9 ;l4~1..:2() "',I..E:<,')I"DIii:F~ ~iil:;'I'::./, "'I:) f(I:.HAJ:< .I, ';",/():J.().;, t() :I. 'P')>/O:I.()l:l
"()~~()n;6 1 ,q ::\ .. ~~() (.)I..I:"X."lI'IDEI'( ~i)I"F:n/l:J l':E:HI-'lB 1. ')>')>'7().I. :L;;; '1:'J 1.'1'P'70:l..I. ::\
107'I'7:n lt~~1. '7-!) Al.I::Xf)/"OEI'~ :,iPl'::l:I'IG HEH(.)J:< :I. 'j>')>;10120 tel J. (~'?'7f,) 1 ~~2
'I07'D'8<) 1'13.76 AI_EXAI"OIii:I'~ !,iPl:::II'IG I':E:HAI:< :L <j>';>'7<):L27 to :L'1')>'70./.29
N()7'178:L :1.1.13. '7.S r-,L.I:":X I'.~ID ,::1;: !:iI"RII'11J I':EI-/r"lf.' :L 'Y'i"70;W::; 'tc, :1. '1';>I'O;'~<)f.,
1:L39::\3t.J '71.~18 AL.EXAI'II>EF( Sr::-I:;~:r Nei l':EHAf.t :1. 9'P'IO;~1 '7 'tel :1. '1';>'/02:l '7
":l.;1c, ~i~113 :l'I;:;.'76 AI...E:X(.',I"OE:I'~ ~;PfUI'IG I'(EHAI:< :L ')>'i"7();'~:L<> 'tel :L('()>/'()2:r.~~
\1:3:L:t::\tJ9 ;T7 . 913 BI::L. V,":!)I:::FO:E I'II".!).I: Cf~1.. (;lJl~I"'ClI'((.) T:r UI'I ,l \;J\.j?O~:'()('" tc, :L '.'<;7() :',\()9
'lq.'L J.~~S;j(? :L:)~~ .. '7 ~;.l ElI...UE "IUUI'lr.'Hi'I (-)f'IE::;n'II"::iiIA (.~1:3S(JC .. :I. ']:'\:i/(6) 'I. I:) b:l .I. 9'1 /()6:J.~1
'1';~:L ,f) ();':J ~) :1.1 ~:\.. 'ref) /'1131'1 I"HI)f;:I'It<'j',;, " 1.1~11.; ., :/. ';J9'/()~:l.l.r., tCI :I. 99?() ::l:c'::B
'1'!:I.,SO;:;7 9~:, It (:J(,~ l':'I...UE "II.lUI'I(','HI'1 (.',I'IE::; I HE~;./:A 1;')~H;)()C .. 1 ~,;'\;'/()(:>()6 ,(:,:, :r.99;"Of.)()~)
'1'1160'1<> .;):C:~~:~ .. <):L BI_UE l'IUUI'IJ','),I:i'1 ,<)/'IE~; J'Hf.i:SI!-) ABS()C .. .I. \;)'iI'?()~l:L-!J tel :1. \jl9'IO ~:l~~2
14:L6()'ll :';)';~:;"" :1.1 l~iH~L ,L SU" HW,w.l: ('1.)1... 1',910::\.1.6 to 1 ":;'('i :;o()~l:L(!)
'1'11';'<)1.1'1 :L<)7.IH C,<\I'(LISI_E HU~:;I",( J',<~L ,L 9\~'10:;"~~2 tCl :1, 'Y'.:,) '10 :~l~'~~~
1513'1 ~\'1'1 1.66.6:;\ CI.\I'~L I lill..I:: HOSI"',/: rl~1... 1'1'1'706<M tCJ ,l'1'Y7()6()1.,
/::\1:11.15')>6 2()6 .. :':~t.J CAI':LHiLE HI~l:;F' J: rill... :J. 9 ,;>'7 ()6HI tel :J. '19';10<f.:l.l~
.. ,
4 t, I
. '
14, Please state whether any other claims and/or lawsuits have been filed in a court of law
resulting from the accident of February 5, 1996, and if so, please state:
(a) The names and addresses of the parties involved;
(b) when, by date, the action and/or lawsuit was filed; and
(c) the County where the lawsuit was filed,
ANSWER:
No.
15. Please state whether or not any of the physicians listed in the answer to Interrogatory No.13
recommended or prescribed therapy as treatment for the alleged injuries sustained and, if so, for each
physician who recommended therapy please state:
(a) his or her name;
(b) the name and address of the person administering the therapy;
(c) the nature of the therapy administered;
(d) the area or areas of the body which were so treated;
(e) the dates on which such therapy treatments were administered; and
(f) the total charges made in connection with the therapy.
ANSWER:
Dr. Kretzing, family doctor, referred me to Alexander Springs
Rehab. Therapists were Shelly Bitner and Marsha Diller. Stretching
and working with the muscles and nerves in right arm and shoulder area.
. ,,-
.. .
.... It ,
ANSWER: 15 Continued:
Alexander Springs Rehab Physical Therapy Treatment
Dates:
Costs:
3/29/96 - 6/28/96
7/02/96.7/16/96
7/23/96 - 8/06/96
8/09/96 . 8/16/96
11/13/96. 11/13/96
11/21/96 - 11/21/96
11/25/96 . 1/25/96
12/02/96 - 12/04/96
12/09/96. 12/11/96
12/16/96. 12/18/96
1/06/97 - 1/08/97
1/13/97 - 1/15/97
1/20/97 . 1/22/97
1/27/97 - 1/29/97
2/03/97 - 2/06/97
2/10/97 - 2/12/97
2/17/97 - 2117/97
$2,794.14
$ 482,22
$ 334.83
$ 191.07
$ 61.87
$ 101.98
$ 59,14
$ 143.76
$ 143,76
$ 143.76
$ 145.20
$ 145,20
$ 143.76
$ 143.76
$ 143.76
$ 143.76
$ 71.88
Total:
$5,393.85
.. .
... '. :
16. Immediately following the accident of February 5, 1996, were you treated by any hospital
emergency room facility for said accident and, if not, why not. If your answer is in the affirmative
please state the name of the hospital, address and date of treatment.
~
The morning after,I went to the Carlisle Hospital ER. A few days
after that, I wnt to a Saturday morning "First come, First served"doctor
visit to my family doctor. I could not get a regular appointment - none
were available. I met with Dr. Ketzing.
17. Please state the entire amount of property damages to the vehicle you were operating at the
time of your accident on February 5, 1996, and whether those damages were repaired, and if 50, the
full amount of the costs of the repairs and the name of the repair facility.
ANSWER:
Damages were over the book value, so they totaled our car and
the other two as well.
It was $1,200 or $1,300 they paid for the car.
18. Please state if there was a police accident report prepared following the accident of February
5, 1996 and if 50, please attach a copy of the report on said accident to these Answers to
Interrogatories,
ANSWEIt:
Yes.
19. Have you, as a result of the alleged injuries sustained on February 5, 1996, worn any type of
brace, corset, cervical collar, support or any type of orthopedic appliance, and if 50, state;
(a) the name of the doctor or chiropractor or other medical practitioner
who fitted or prescribed said appliance;
(b) describe the appliance and state its cost;
(c) when did you start wearing said appliance;
(d) when did you stop wearing said appliance; and
(e) was said appliance worn constantly or intermittently during the foregoing
period, and, if both, state the period in which it was worn constantly.
ANSWER:
Yes, for a thumb injury - a splint and wrap aroung thumb and two
fingers. The ER doctor put it on until I could get an appointment with
Dr. Healy. I wore a splint all the time, except for bathing, for 7 or
8 weeks.
~ ,
.. '.
. '
:
20, Please list the name, address, specialty and reason for consulting any and all physicians who
had occasion to examine andlor treat you during the two-year period immediately preceding the date
of the accident which is the subject of this litigation, and give the approximate date on which you
were examined and/or treated by each,
ANSWER:
Family doctor - probably for poison ivy.
21, With regard to the accident and alleged injuries which you alleged to have suffered as a result
of the accident of February 5, 1996, please state:
(a) the nature and frequency of any present complaints resulting from said accident/and
or injury;
(b) the nature and extent of any disability;
(c) describe in detail the location of the pain you suffer and the duration and intensity
of such pain; and
(d) whether or not you suffer any restraint of your nonnal activities due to the aforesaid
injuries;
ANSWE~ There is constant pain in right clavical area and top, back of
right shoulder. Intense burning under right upper arm. I have finally
ten some relief (only since 6/98 visit to pain Clinic) by a combination
of medication and trigger point injections. I still have trouble lifting
things since the accident. I am right handed. Any constant activity with
my right arm aggrevates the pain. I still have trouble hanging out the
laundry, getting things off of shelves, pulling files from drawers, holding
my granddaughter, grocery shapping is still hard to do, vacuuming carpets,
*Continued below*. ." k dId I
22, l'lease deSCribe the type of vehicle by stating Its ma e, mo e, year an co or, you were
driving at the time of your accident of February 5, 1996.
ANSWER:
1980 Ford Fairmont - white with red vinyl roof and red interior.
* (continued) hanging curtains, washing window3and walls really makes my
right side (arm/shoulder) hurt. I have found that I can function if I
maintain the pain clinic visists. The doctor tried another medication
this summer and the pain carne back full blown like right after the
accident.
.
. 'I I
.
.. "
.
.
,
.
23. If you are covered by any type of insurance, including any excess or umbrella Insurance, that
might be applicable to the Incident In this matter, state the following with respect to each such policy;
(a) the name of the insurance carrier which Issued the policy;
(b) the name Insured under each policy and the policy number of each
policy;
(c) the type(s) and effective date(s) of each policy;
(d) the amount of coverage provided.
(e) each exclusion, if any, in the policy which is applicable to any claim thereunder and
any reasons, If any, why you or the carrier claim the exclusion is applicable.
ANSWER:
Blue Cross - Plan 366
Blue Shield - Plan 866
BC/BS - $250 deductable, next $750 is a 80/20 split.
Calvin Wickard - QACI66-32-4289
.j.
t. ACCIDEUl
OAft
II,~~C .I!//=.~.. -..-
l' '~L _.J~~:~
l' OlD '/E111:'... ~"vE 10 BE. nEI,lOvED
JAQU;TIlt. SoCEf,E'
UNIT t
. .. '. ,., I~'J'~" "
O()016~~#4l<',"';';':, ~ ,'"
COMMONWEAL TH'OF PENNSYL VANIA
POLICE ACCIDENT,REPOR'T' i '
AEPORTABLE B:rNON. AEPOATAlILI 0:' , ,
.. R ~i # ACCI' ...QC;ATION': , ~,
20 COU.lHY ,._ ,. \ Cqll.E
(}JMQl~!:!!!.di '__ .' _AL--..-
21, "~~:;~'1.l" -12~ r- ~ J COO.1.
_ _,__~_O tur~__.-. .~_!.-
PRINCIPAL ROADWA Y INFDRMA TION
---t---:-"-;-
", r '
4 TYtE- 0 )(I'lAcC'S. .J...' ,
tUOHWAV _1':: CON1ROl 'I
, INTERSECTING ROAD:
26 nOUIENO-OR -r-:-,----. ~1.---.....-. ,'..,.
_ smEET NAME -r- ~_~Rw._,....___ '
iT sPttO 28 TVPf .. J,r) I ACCfftG ,'. . ,
LIMIT S- HIOHW~__~!!!..q~.J S~'.,;;
IF NOT A T INTERSECTION: ',ill,;'
iO"cnoss STREET on -----.....- .. .-. --- ,::::.,
SEOMENT MARKEn . "1 r.~
3i"o'lRiclToN'- -IU.DI8TAr;r"t----. ~.... ...-. .-.. ~. .~..
FROM SITE N SEW _ fROMSIlE I n _...!!I .(;"11\'1
33 DISTANCE WAS 0' 0 II .~..
MEAtURED ESTlMA1EO
"ii)COP~~fRUCTION S mAFriC-PRiN~-i;j.1i!iiSECTiNo .
'.' tONE CONlnOL ['.',., ['7'"J
DEVOCE ,9.J ~
',':1...;::1 . ..... '. ..
,"l!f""'~ i(\:':r~;(,,"': ',i\ ,~I
31 1i~^It. Jh LL:(iAlLY Y N 31. IltO I~' ;;- li,. ~~E
. PAnKtD' DD PLA1'L~rQ Z:3,<.J.S",___.. . t:ti.__
39 PA TITLE OR
.. OUf.OF,STATEVIN 41p.-I?7;i071'10L ---
40 OWNER
. 8A"''''KY E"<&h!.~ ::iA~~O~~___._-
4t OWPlER "-
4DJRESS ul~;:: ;"'c;t;.!:..Au.. .----
42 CITY,lTAn
.__ .~....:~.., ,,~t~~:'. 6If1rf&~~Z.,/~~(1~~._._.. ....:,~~:~~.
4G IN'-." 1" MOllh. IHC'I' _ 1"6 IU~ I
y~...!LQ..,UI.!~,U _'!!!~,' ''!'~'L .,I,Tf.!;'tl1Y..-.-. ' ,~JlII.._,.,r.J. u~...Q,
411, YEHICLl:: 411BO:" 48 SPECIAL ~YEtttr.L':
OW~E.J., . !!.':~ _.:S::~._ ... USA~o.. O\",~I'SIt~: ..L_
~2 TRAVEL ,.- ~I"'UAL IMPACT 51 VEHICLE ') i: THAVEL "
SPEED _~. __ _ !*.Q!!lL_I._ ._.. .~ SlATUS --i- SPEJ.I?.._...(.;L
I PRCSENCE .. g~~~~'ON I ~~~~~,~~" I ,~~}~=~V;c"NCC" .. g~\;~r;'ON
q ~ ., S~'" .. un,.En . .' "~f
~?.J.lIQ ,.__.._'_" €tl, .. !.!I!~'"E'L.:'1,Qy~,."c.:.'L_...,...--- ..l?E_.__
'!Ill Ufll'.ER
Q}.IAI W .":'HaEb1J!!!:L~ __.._ ' ..' _~^ELZJl}N1Y. Euli.r:..'!i~_J.}:)!.!)C50tJ._.. .. ..-.......
!lIJ ['lfllVLR
ADORESS :>, ,~t:&<~:C rLo, /8':1. ...~'!!'.!!lli- U~_l!'l;:..,'j'a{.~,t?(). ' ,-_. .... ....-.\
00 CITY. STAlE c.';! r,lfv. SlATE
lZlPCOOE &,:>.-q 17i!,,{/.... ' , ,,,..,.. ..,U!~_I.IE...,Y,rU"',.,?f1._L(<:,'1I~---..,.-..,.-.-.]
It. SEX 82. DAlE OF Cd rll Uf !1 .. nl SFlI ,A;! ('IMe O~ ,.. 1. r.3 Ph~I~(; ,.. "
BIRTH 0, /./7 7/7 ,'G..')SC\) ,VI '11111T11 1.I",8/",)~ 7/"7l7~' ill,J"
04. . VEH. M DIVER 56 ORlYfll (H CfJMM vEt1 If,!. 11l11\,f;H 11;(, I)nl~l:I' I
..,~ARR:R CL~'~ '=,.__'~~:'~ _ .,'..___ ' 51 ~P.i,;iif- : ,C~^,~!, ,_..::~,t,:. "....~~..~, :' .-::'.'.=:':\'
ee CARRIER .. URc":juliEfi-~--"
ADDRESS ADnntSS
..CITY,STATE -.....-'-.... .., ,.,. .. i.iiCiiY'i,mE .....-' ...'..' '.....'.-'-..j
& ZIPCODE & 11"(('lDE I
7OUSOOT' -IiCCi....--...--.-..'IPuc;......- . 7Oii~b;;"i..... . '-llr.co".--- -.-..1iIUC;...'.....'-...--..\
2~~FIU . 3~~~~~;;-"''''''"' .~.ovwn.'.' . ~2'i~~;~::I~" ..--' ~~~~~G,~~~_..-.- .njl;i1'Ii,\.;n -'...--......
n NO OF 6 HAlAI1DOU5 . --, 17-iiHf,.-\SE "Qf'iiiiMA.l. 1~ IloUF---.' - (ftJiiAURth>US. __m nAEili-sE Ufuulib1~l
AXLES MA1ER1ALS y LJ N lJ UN~. w "xLliS ... hllT[n.M,S 't' l J N U UNK W
AA~,,'I921 -, ----- --'16895i 7 - ,-'- _.-;;;,~'-:C .--,... --CiiifliiirORl,iiiiiiii,,',;8t.Fm
'.-:'0'
"J/A
\
",
,
.'
\~
,.
I'
"
...
2Z ROUTE NO, OR
SlREET NAME
23, SPEED
L1MIl
. .
yl2a NO
12. NUMBER. "::)
0" Ut;lfS..._W_
i6 PnlV. f'IlOP. 0
ACCIOruT '(
17. VEHICLE DAMAGE
o ' NOt~[ UNIT I
1.UGHT
2. MoorRATE
3 ' SEVERE
UN112
[i]
[1]
N3I
UNIT 2
111 Pl:.NNDOT
:::.:.~:..~~6..~
"
"
"
,.t.,
,
~ ADOAf..1 ", . ,
I .(,"
I
.. IJ."
.
').
"
II, DlAQRAM I
.,
'..' ,.IINCI5E'Nf,: J{.J..~~-1'1!J.i!__.,..__
IACCIDENT DATE: ~:7_~ '''.il,:
" , 171, NIPclIlnIHo '1011 AQlNCV
,'.;.
I ",MEDICAL 'ACllITY
I 1'1( 0 ~"''''D-'~ ,
.:,
.,
"f~'
, , .~., H
,
, ' ,
-
..
,
Q
NAIIE
I .1-,J....J:_ ..,!-,_
'"
-,- .-.-
--.. --. .--
..-1--, ..- ...'..
-- ...- ....
-'':'1-..'1-''0'--
-'--
"
;\
-\
,
;:?(
'"
,1 '
~
-r ~.
I'
IDu_11OH 0 @WIA1lCAD
--0
. "
I"
~
" ,
t..;", ""
l:.:. ... "'4frtSYLVAHlA IQtOOL O&ITNCT
)ll, .. (P N'I'UCAIl.Il
"':~;.
~ ,'.j ~ .
....................;....................1'...........'. .'
~ ... .
"
'1,
.. DllCfWlTIOH OP OAWcGID PROPERTY
i
j"
................ .........'........ ....'....-........... '......,....." ....... ....
" ..
"
~.
~
'!,
r:.
OWNI/I
NlllAflll
... ..,.....",...... ......................
..
"
,
f'
- ' '
17, NAllAAn,c 'IDENlIFY PREClPlTA1INQ EVEN11, CAUSAnON IAC10~S. SEOUENCES OF ~VENT, S, WITNEIS S1~1EMEIITS, IoND PROVIDE AllOIT1ClNAL-'--
OETM.B I..~ IHSURAHCIlINFORMATK)N AND LOCATtON OF TOWED VEHIClES tF kNCW.N
,-
-
,1.,
;~.
__: " ,.._,?"A .. -...--:> A,.. r,l/E ''J:~C}''J o;okJr'h6 ArA;:>p';'o,ii 'S~~
Ur .;"..r".\ ~dAr "'~'d .v~ ,) T',,,,-r rAIO rw2sLr~"-.:Jr- "'/.!'II' .H(. H~ ~g..L.__
A.,~ ~ ~ tl'" .I ~~t..J~rH~,./lA1 ~~r 1(i~~2lL.&n~\ __
-r2h. ~..1"" .. - III? --,.."" ,',"101"',' J "..:LC->~~APA~ ..-......,
.~.r . . 'iKA1'.111; "'". "-~M/ ,cr r..........,El,: .:...z:c.:.Y.,.wA..Li:<!.cL..&'L.~_~_,_
. ..-. -.... .......-;\I:..,,~-~.. .~,,?~^, ,5H~ '<J~_C/.oJ&..;'1!5'.t:.J:).f.:Ndn:l/-J:'g;ltJ;r.r()U 'ii!:(L.._
- - ,..~. A . ;:::r,~ Ru~ ~vr,jE.,Lu.('!Ir..;:;:../!>.I,Ll{Il.-:>./i:':,.l~!;;.,_'Uff..fJ1.TLLQ.F_._-
""'... - .V
..-.. . ...... ,. , .... -.... . ,...... ..-..-.-.-.--,-.----
<p"7. "',., ~ ~'BZi.ELTC.~Un. ',_r!-f.ul~,tJr,J a~j(;.:;/'i''.J,....... ....... ....--...,......--
,.'
t
"
~
"
INSUFWiCE
lHFOAMAnoN
U~IT
COMP
y-.-
- -It.;siJiii\'tic'f'' CO,,orM;'
INroIIM^TION
.. .. ~ jjrili -..... PO~Ii,;\'
2 "0
PHO"l:-
f~,..,(.c___, ,_,
~~y Q;I-,~- ~,,"',"
NAME
ea 1=:-- -, .., -"-' ...-
wm<ESSES .....E
".n..... ._,_..., .._...._
^PU"l-~S
'.ii'i'DiIFSf. _..
.- ,-- .--..-...-. .....-...-piiONE'......
. '.f' t. eg, VtOLATlON~ INDIC^tED
11(1 '3Et~1I0N NllMArn$ tONL Y IF r.ll\nOEOI
Ie rile
UNI!:I
Jif)/oIc _'''_''
,-, .. . ..d.... ..-..--.-.... _....... ....._--.-'-ocf
,- .... ..-_... .. -...-----.--- .....1]'0-
~2'n"E l\Hf:,ULtS r-IN' 1-ST
"-""tl:!U \;..-, ~_.J \J ~ 94 INvtSTIc.\lION
o nFrlla CClMPLE11!'
O,..._.Qbo UlIII \U bi:l I/O [)
. ,_ ..__._._... .__. .....__.,......__w.w_ _.___._....__-:'.::.
UNI' 2
~1 )PROPAOLf
>0./ USE
\ON"! 0
('f2)IVPF ~~'A(:SUI tS ~Nn 1[<1
" lEFil 1-' ~,.
_q. _ L. ~::::- qOf;r:,"~~~ UI~' ~
1689518
,11ll'nOlMltU:
\- uFiI;
.4.04SI11V21
rAOE' _~L.
ClHTl!n IllllllXlllWAY ,^rtTY
. .. ,
, .. ,
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify thllt I 11m this dllY serving II copy of the foregoing document upon the
person(s) IInd in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the requirements of the
Pennsylvania Rules for Civil Procedure, my depositing a copy of the same in the United States
Mail, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, First Class Mail, postage prepaid, as follows:
DOUGLAS B. MARCELLO, ESQUIRE
THOMAS THOMAS & HAFER, LLP
305 NORTH FRONT STREET
P.O.BOX 999
HARRISBURG PA 17108.999
Date: ~~
Attorney for Plaintiff,
Linda R. Wickard
.. .
, ,
.
.
>- \11 r
':~ ~':
j:~:
r-' -"
lJJ ,; ;
( ) ~;.
(".( .',.
'-'
" ,..
Ci!
c..~;) L1
UJ'
~".I "..
ITl\ " '-,
-;t ~ ';;,L
t.,. - . ;..,'
". cr' ~'~J
. 0 0" U
LINDA R. WICKARD .nd
CALVIN L. WICKARD,
PI.lntHfs
: IN THE COUItT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBEItLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA
,. !
,
,
.
.
I
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
v.
.
.
: NO. II .111 CIVIL TERM
JOHN SHOEMAKER .nd
BARRY E. JACKSON,
Defend.nts
:
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
.
.
COMPLAINT
,
NOW come the plaintiffs, by their attorney, Harold S. Irwin, III, Esquire, and file
this compiaint against the defendants, representing as follows:
1. The plaintiffs, Linda R Wickard and Calvin L. Wickard, husband and wife,
are adult individuals residing at 799 Burgners Road, Carlisle, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania, 17013.
1
,
\
,
I
2. The defendant, John W. Shoemaker, is an adult individual whose last
known address is Big Spring Terrace, Lot 184, Newville, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania 17241,
i
,
,
3. The defendant, Barry E. Jackson, is an adult individual whose last known
address is 615 Ml. Rock Road, Newville, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17241.
4. On or about February 5, 1996, Plaintiff Linda Wickard was operating her
1980 Ford Fairmont and was lawfully stopped at a stop sign on the western corner of
the intersection Oak Flat Road and Route 233, near Newville, Pennsylvania.
5. Defendant Shoemaker was operating a 1994 Ford Escort and was
traveling north on 233 approaching the intersection of 233 and Oak Flat Road.
6. Defendant Jackson was operating a 1995 GMC Jimmy and was traveling
south on 233, approaching the intersection of 233 and Oak Flat Road..
"
I
I I
7. Defendant Shoemaker failed to yield to oncoming traffic and turned left at
the intersection into the path of Defendant Jackson, resulting in a collision between
defendants' vehicles.
,-f,
8, The force of the Impact caused defendant Shoemaker's vehicle to collide
with the driver's side of plaintiffs' vehicle, A copy of the Pennsylvania State Police
accident report Is Incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof and
attached as plaintiffs' Exhibit "A",
COUNT I
LINDA R, WICKARD v. JOHN W. SHOEMAKER and BARRY E. JACKSON
9. The averments of plaintiffs' complaint, paragraphs one through eight
inclusive, are incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth at length,
10, The accident and resulting losses, injuries and damages were directly
and proximately caused by the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and Jackson,
including but not limited to:
a. the negligence of Defendant Shoemaker in failing to yield to oncoming
traffic and failing to keep his vehicle under control.
b. the negligence of Defendant Jackson in failing to keep his vehicle
under control and failing to exercise reasonable care to avoid colliding with Defendant
Shoemaker's vehicle.
11. As a direct result of negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and Jackson
and the collision as aforesaid, Plaintiff Linda Wickard suffered property damages to her
vehicle requiring it to be totaled.
12. As a direct result of the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and
Jackson and the collision as aforesaid, Plaintiff Linda Wickard suffered severe
personal injuries, including a cervical strain with nerve root irritation, a fracture of her
left thumb, injury to her right sternoclavicular joint, soft tissue injury to her right arm,
fibromyalgia and related medical problems.
13, As a direct result of the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and
Jackson, the collision as aforesaid and the personal injuries sustained thereby, Plaintiff
Linda Wickard incurred medical expenses which have exceeded $10,000.00 to date
and which are continuing.
14. As a direct result of the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and
Jackson, the collision as aforesaid and the personal injuries sustained thereby, Plaintiff
Linda Wickard suffered and will continue to suffer physical pain and suffering, mental
anguish, emotional distress and the loss of life's pleasures.
',' 11',"
", '~. ,:t.
v~ \:, ';)/A
",. '.
'. ",~,':.to..,.,~~\( 'OJ . II l.~~''''' I,. ~.,;""'~.f' j'l . .....);"!.. I . ",....~. ..t,'
..,,~ ",~, '.:' O()0162""'~ .:-'.d/ ,I ;:'~l,~ ':':,I;'ij.1' ,,'/
m':';'~~~MONW,~iTH;;l;r~~~~l:V~NI;t, '
".. .'" ',POLICE ACCIDENT,'REPORr,I ';"',
I. , 'lIIfOflTABL. ,~NON ' AEI'OATAI'i'C!]I'. 1" !f,,"
W ~I It:
10 CO~::ftJl"~dl__ . !,-'j~. ._
11,MU"'CI!,~I~),~O r --,.C~~
~_.___ ~__,__. ..!.:.2J';'r.._
PRINCIPAL ROAOWA Y INFORMA TlON
22 nouTE NO- OR . ---;---;-.
STREET NAUE 3- ----
2J SPEEO 4 TYPE !t ACCHIiS
LIMIT HIOHWAV 0 .-aN!!!f!. ;J_
INTERSECTING ROAD:
~G_~.~~i:r"~.:1: -r-!/,; _/OAk_~--;:' !&_~~.~~.~~~__
a1 !;J'EtO ~~ 18 TYP~ ~ 'l'J "c.:Cf!JG J '
t.lMlf ~ HIOHWAf comnOL ,~.
----,. '-' .
IF NOT A T INTERSECT/ON:
\: -:."-'-.W:.i:,'
. '.. ,.. ';'4'
,,~IUfrIT
OATC
II. TiMi1.t ll. NUMBER ':)
OA' I OF u..HO ____
I), . K,~.rr; _.,114' IN I}J~.".O,' . liP,iiYiiiujp 0
.LL. L--L.. ACCIOEUf.,
,.. 010 VI'1A.'.. ~ ~_~E TO If. nEJ.IOIiED I'. VEHICLE DAlMOE
'ROM ':'ht.: ~E~(' O. NONC UNIT I
yNIT , UNII 2 I . LIOHT
2. UOOCRATE
:I ' SEVEnE UNIT 2
19 PENNDOT .
N,liJ
W
rz-I 1')CON~rAUCTION
L~. . 'ONE
N8I'- .
:]0 'CilO!lS SfREET on
'iEOMENT MAnKEn
ii'OIAEt:iTON'-:-N
FAa,", SITE S
3:] OIS T ANCE WAS
---'--........
.....!!I
v~ NO
[Q]
'~1~~:..;:.
Jh Lt;(jAU.Y Y N 37. "EO. 'F,'" <J
. ., PAnKED' DO PUI'E tJ, -,y, Z'3,u.:;r,__..
:]') PA TITLE OR
_" Q!!f,OF,STATEVIN 4./~</?7;;t:;7801 _
40 OWNER
_ 6A>.--KY ~~~.:;;;'cl<!.o~~__,.__
410WflER
'. ,^ " .LJ/. ~ J _ 'O~RESS ~1 '<:" ^-Or. ;o!oC'" .;:."..-
. I w- -.:.,... .-'. 'U CITY',ITATI! .sK.-.I.:.A ~U
....-... ,., ~~i~o~_tV.(1Yf6t~~._',70(1.~~ ._,.,.:,:':~~.~~:
1'1 MlIlJh. lNOT _ 140Il.s..:.. I
._I!)lll.' ''!~L ~.r"-T 1Y.._._., ,Jll!_~CJ.. u~!!,Q,
49 VEHICLE oUldOl'" 45 SPECIAL .9 Vl!ttlt:L':
OWNEAS',!!? ,j.. . !:!!:~ _.:J:(.,_ ... USAOE Q. ow_r;r,sH!r._.L_
.r- W INITIAL IMPACT 51 VEHICLE" t THAVEL d.t!"
SPEED;;2_ "altIT I . 'iTArUS -,-' SPEED ~~-
S DRIVER ,- .- - ~VCt1ICl.e- .,-'--- ~7)~ .- !IS UAlVF,,,-_.n-
CONDITION onADIEm . rRE5ENCe CONOIrlON
q 7 S1 S~Jl' ~6 nRIVER . ~,7 'jun:
_"EA ,,~ _ . "elL.... .. !iU~'~'L21'.Q!lI!i'.""G.:a_._.... . .l?E.-...
M. DRIVER lid_ l)JlIVER
NAIll! W. "'JlOI''''I'lK,~ __ ,._,"..' _~~Li3~&a.E:V.(j?.."!.E_:[)l!.!~^-'---, ,.".--..,-
M. ORIVER 51 oOlVER I
ADORESS ::>'. ,;'F'M',q,:e ,.{.a(.t8~.. ..~~!lill-",,%_l!1! -,j'~s.,L , --,_. .-.. ..._--\
eo. CITY. STAlE GO elf"', STATE
I ZIPCOOE t1z., =>,A I '?~~ ,_,. , "". '_" .... ZIPCOOE N.E,^!.v,ra€.J,<?f)_L2(:.&f~/__._, '---"-'-'1
61.8 n. DAlE OF 7 191 PlI Ufo ~ ... III Sf,X_ M O.\TEO" / ~ J ~ ~,Ph~I~e. "''':k]''
lATH '/ I. I " "(..>' )$'\) ,VI Ulnru './.f..'~!~',J 7/"J, 7~-' 1e' ~ J
V ~ H," gL~~._... eo ~A~v:..:I, .._' .. ,n .~ ~Q.~~;.z ,r:~ ~~I.~~,n ,. " J~~.~'.~".. _........ ...-..!
'J.CAnRIER 51. CARnIen 4__..______..._ .._.'R_. ._._.. .... .... ...--4....1,
IMI CAAfUER - --. ..- dii'C~lRiE~.'
ADDRESS AoonESS
n CITY. STATE -"-.- -, - ..-. ~ -.. - .-- Iiii' CiiV. 5WE- . .....- -" --..... ...... - ...... .'.-'-..i
I Z1PCOOE & Zl"COOE '
7OUSDOT' ICC.-.------fPuc;.....- . ... 1OU~5i};..---' -'-'If.C-;'---'-''--. i~rrc;.."....._..,---t
J CARGO --.- ...-. .. . . ~-rivwn'-, .. - i2)'vbt .---. .--.- K?3\~\iiG(r .----.. -'174' n\\'iri --.--......1
00'1' TYPE ' curWl(l DODY ,yre I
8 UAZA"OOUS ..- ;niEL~~SE Q!.IIAZ M".c 1S ria OF --- ~l' to r;A7.iJ\ii\)us --.-- niiEiJ.tsE W:!to\! 'iai~1
MATERIALS Vb! N U YNK U AXL!!S IIIITEn'/.LS y LJ PI: U IJNK U
--'- --'1689'51"7' ,_.- --;;;'~'=C' .__.n' --cENi.iirORlliiiilwAy'imN
,.", '1"'~Lr,1 '{I. ,;;f.,..: .~J.i4~"I:; l'J
~ If '..'1 ."~""I~I.', .~~.ilf'I"t .
'. 'I .' ,"~
'~'I\:.,'
j "
., '
INCIDENfi: ..
ACCIDENT DATE: '.'
'I " "., ~,-.. :~I"~""J ,;., "'" .
~""'-AOORI";." ",,!' \'~"lI:'~:1.t.. ~.J"'!"
,I' .~ ~*i~t ..\. ,r,t,"
':'.
i,
"
. ,Ii',
,',",">
. ,
.'r:
h,',.
, "
,
('
r:;"1 'r.::. r.::1 II, D1AlII\AM
~ E/WfATHlRLQj',. ,,.
"
IUfvrACI~:' :! "'. ::'\..'
" LLJ :,' N(.J..r(l( ,,,,,,".10 "
.., PE"N5YL..,.tASCHOOI. D18mOCT ,~ j:lFf'llI)<, I M't. '
IIF Al'l'UCA8LE)
",Ill
..IlIKRIPT Qf llAMAQIg PROPERTY
<J:?
" '
"
':
,,,",
\ "}0I0.
-:;i~
{>J:.t HlDNtI
. . "~
z;
. t.'
ill ,;'i,'~'
~.- 2 ~ '1
I': -
' "" ......"" gruP~ ; ,,~a13 :
i ;):;6,.) : ,II ;
,..:::t~ !,\(~J !
....,.............;.......,....,........ ......,..........,.. .I.J.~...."".~....:..........;'.....,.".."....,..
: '.' .'. ~ ~,". '. -j :~:
WI. _TMI.IOIIHTIfY PNC1I'fTATINQ EVENTI. CAUSATION FACTORS, SEauENCES OF E\'l!NTI, WITNESS STATEMEHTI, AHO PIlOVIllE'AllDIIlONAL "
. -:.,. INPORMAnoH AND LOCATlOH OF TONED VEHlCl'S IF K, ..' e.,
,I J" , .... ,
';i,' ' 'ttYr/r~.& A/tJ;?n.I &rJ ~;<>~~.5', t/....~,.. 2
,.. ,
.rJAU\ ,lAlTr ~-J"')
ulLir _~.M;:J:J'i \ J;:;r.,....,!C e;n,~ ,)~.
= /
..) ,~
.".
p -...
7".;;
'~j,\:.~
~~,
:ii~~':
'"
~.,\
-,
~~ /;-;-r 7i~L>>'AI ~;-{_r.:..ts:?_;7.IF Kr'F..rtr__
J?rGH'7 ~1>);l.tJ~' I }/<<r r .. ~/(iJ~1~"~ ;-.....-n-/!t._
~.,...,.rA' Jt!/{t.A/.. r'7:\." /fJ., ,.xeA1 ~.';::!r'.It'Hj _22lE:
;- III ~ i.L.EJj_:joaJrN "1\l.Z%'-.1!QL~ ~ i~rro::...", __
d.t:" 01>" ~z:e;x....y.;r~6.LJ____.._.._.___....
~LMI....A Cflo,rn .~~.!:..r-H~,(.~-r~.!'_(U.t...~d4!:..-hfi..Jl..,. "'!:::L.?..fLh. i!r:'3S-
u ~#.. ""',1&~, c:~u .("l.~C;,,.,J~"'.z:. Z"bi;,.J",d?:.,z:~..E~..t!lJt!!.:L
-w. ~,~_zu.,)IW..~,i.:n:."dJJ:D.:J2E,l'~,'-~?.iiJ.J:- :.-1"" ~
r;o",7. ,
'---.--....,-.-- _.-, ... IN u',^NCif.COMPAf~'--. ---..---;.------'-..-
'i.JtANrA ~;:,~~ j.~:J.. .~'J. ,Cc). }~qf1~T!Q!!. __~T~3'~~~~~i:.?~.,._,~~~..(U
, Utllr PULlCV, ";.... . l
" , NO 1'>,-( Q
,
-
.-.w""
It..k 7"HC
lNBUAANCI
LNFonMATION
UNIT
I
COMPANY
.
...nunE!iS
..,
WITNESSeS
. .^OOilE~.S-._. . -... .. -- '......... PHONE I
OU 500110" """""51""' ;~r ::;^~~;Ell' -"'~~~,"~~~~;~:~.
00
--... .',. ..... ._--'_.........._,.,....1.; 0-
!J IlF',tILI'i ~lll fl'mf n IllVl:~UOArrO'"
%t::,J r,rrUI]I! COM~LEl1n
0, 'i.'.J 'Jl/K Y.~ D<'I NO L:.l
"miiiiiiOR tMiiW;,;i'IAPm
..,. :.'. 81t
INO A fU
~~~~,:.. ,I':: rt!.~'~ i;Z.:~~..N', (~I'""-
UNIT ~ _ .,t~tJAJl
D"'I.l'''rll'\Olf
".1_- II;"
,j"7irt 0
l.. ,,' _..
M,ot~lt~~1
o
\1','1""1'
" 'II:~I
J "
~II' Jllf'iULI..
I
I 0,
I
\11 }1'1l1.1/\^IU t;
1mI'
i'>d"'O Ir'B
, '1"l'rtl'iF _.._ 0,
. ro.O(, .1 IJtjt( UlM?
1'689517
LINDA R. WICKARD and CALVIN L
WICKARD,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 98-668
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
Plaintiffs
v,
JOHN SHOEMAKER and BARRY
JACKSON,
Defendants
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in
the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this Notice, New Matter
and Cross Claim are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attorney and filing
in writing with this Court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are
warned that if you fail to do so, the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered
against you by the Court without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any
other claim or relief requested by the Plaintiffs. You may lose money or property or other rights
important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT
HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET HELP.
Cumberland County Bar Association
2 Liberty Avenue
Carlisle, PA 17013
(717) 249-3166
THOMAS, THOMAS & HAFER, LLP
By: ~~qUire
305 North Front Street
Post Office Box 999
Harrisburg, PA 17108.0999
(717) 255.7238
i
I
I
I
I
r
"
~ .'....
-,
7, Denied, The averments of paragraph 7 state a conclusion of law to which
no responsive pleading is required. In the alternative, the averments of paragraph 7 are
denied pursuant to Pa,R.C,p. Rule 1029(e).
8, Denied, The averments of paragraph 8 state a conclusion of law to which
no responsive pleading is required, In the alternative, the averments of paragraph 8 are
denied pursuant to Pa.R.C.P, Rule 1029(e). It is further averred that the Pennsylvania
State Police Report is inadmissible. In the further alternative, as Plaintiff has failed to
designate or specifically aver the facts set forth to which a response is required, to the
extent, any is, with regard to the police report, Answering Defendant is without any
belief so as to be able to respond, thus the averments are denied and proof is
demanded at time of trial.
9. Answering Defendant incorporates the averments of paragraphs 1 through
8 as if set forth in full.
10. Denied, The averments of paragraph 10 are denied pursuant to
Pa.R.C.p. Rule 1029(e).
11. Denied. Any and all allegations of negligence on the part of Answering
Defendant is denied and proof is demanded at time oftrial. Answering Defendant is
without information or belief as to the truth of the balance of the averments of paragraph
11, hence they are denied and proof is demanded at time of trial.
12. Denied, Any and all allegations of negligence on the part of Answering
Defendant is denied and proof is demanded at time of trial. Answering Defendant is
without information or belief as to the truth of the balance of the averments of paragraph
11, hence they are denied and proof is demanded at time of trial.
13, Denied. Any and all allegations of negligence on the part of Answering
Defendant are denied and proof is demanded at time of trial. Answering Defendant is
without information or belief as to the truth of the balance of the averments of paragraph
13, hence they are denied and proof Is demanded at lime of trial.
14, Denied. Any and all allegations of negligence on the part of Answering
Defendant is denied and proof is demanded at lime of trial. Answering Defendant is
without information or belief as to the truth of the balance of the averments of paragraph
14, hence they are denied and proof is demanded at time of trial.
COUNT II
CALVIN L. WICKARD v. JOHN W. SHOEMAKER and BARRY E. JACKSON
15, The averments of paragraph 1 through 14 are incorporated herein and
made a part hereof as if set forth In full.
16. Denied, Answering Defendant is without information or belief as to the
truth of the averments of paragraph 16, hence it is denied and proof is demanded at
time of trial.
17. Any and all allegations of negligence of Answering Defendant are denied,
Answering Defendant is without information as to the truth of the balance of the
averments of paragraph 17, and proof is demanded at time of trial.
NEW MATTER
18. Some or all of Plaintiffs' claims may be barred by the applicable statute of
limitations.
19. Some or all of Plaintiffs' claims may be barred by Plaintiffs' assumption of
risk,
VERIFICATION
I, John Shoemaker, verify that the foregoing action and that the attached document is
based upon the Information which has been gathered by me, my counsel and/or others on my
behalf in preparation of this lawsuit. The language of the document is that of counsel and is not
mine. I have read the document, and to the extent that it Is based upon information which I
have given to my counsel, it Is true and correct to the best of my knowledge, information, and
belief. To the extent that the contents of the document are that of counsel, I have relied upon
counsel In making this Verification.
I understand that intentional false statements herein are made subject to the penalties of
18 Pa. C.S. 94904 relating to unsworn falsifications made to authorities.
Date:r;;:;;J? 0; /; '1<11
/
Q~ ~~~a ~QJ,/
{7 JOHN S OEMAKER .
....'
/'
BARRY A. KROH'rHAL, J:SQUIRJ:
Pa. Supr~ Court I.D. No. 55672
RJ:YNOLDS " HAVAS
101 Pine Str_t
Poat Orrice Box g32
Harriaburg, Pennay1vania 17108-0g32
~.l~hon.:
I'ax:
[717] 236-3200
[717] 236-6863
Attorney rOE oarandant:
BARRY JACKSON
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN L. WICKARD,
Plaintiffs
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
NO. 98-668 CIVIL TERM
v.
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON,
Defendants
:
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
PRELIMINARY OBJECTIONS OP DEPENDANT, BARRY E. JACKSON
TO THB COMPLAINT OP PLAINTIPPS,
LINDA R. WICKARD and CALVIN L. WICKARD
.\
.
I
i
,
AND NOW, comes Defendant, Barry E. Jackson ("Mr.
JaCkson"), by and through his counsel Reynolds & Havas, a
Professional Corporation, and hereby files these Preliminary
Objections to the Complaint of Plaintiffs, Linda R. Wickard and
Calvin L. Wickard (collectively referred to as "Plaintiffs"),
averring the following in support thereof:
1. This action was commenced by Writ of Summons on or
if t
,
i':,
l
r
I'
,
! '
about February 4, 1998.
2. Pursuant to a RUle to File Complaint, Plaintiffs
filed their Complaint and served it upon Mr. Jackson's counsel by
letter dated January 28, 1999. A copy of the transmittal letter
r'
',,',,<
\,','
I""
and complaint are attached hereto, made a part hereof and marked
as Exhibit "A".
3. Pat R.C.P. No. 1028(a) (2) and (3) states that:
(a) Preliminary objections may be filed by any
party to any pleading and are limited to the
following grounds.
(2) inclusion of scandalous or impertinent
matter;
(3) insufficient specificity in a pleading.
4. As discussed in greater detail below, Plaintiffs'
complaint is insufficiently specific and contains impertinent
matter. Therefore, Mr. Jackson now timely files the instant
Preliminary Objections, pursuant to Rules 1028(a) (2) and (3).
I. Preliminary objection for Insufficient specificity in .
Pleading. Pursuant to Pat R.C.P. No. 1028Ia)13).
5. The averments contained in Paragraph 1 through 4
inclusive hereof are incorporated by reference herein as if set
forth in their entirety.
6. In their Complaint, Plaintiffs allege that this
automobile accident resulted when Defendant, John Shoemaker
negligently turned left directly in front of Mr. Jackson's
vehicle, which in turn, caused Mr. Shoemaker's vehicle to collide
with the vehicle being operated by Plaintiff, Linda Wickard
(paragraphs 7 and 8 of the complaint).
2
7. Nevertheless, in their Complaint, Plaintiffs' sole
allegation of negligence against Mr. Jackson, is as follows:
The accident and resulting losses, injuries
and damages were directly and proximately
caused by the negligence of Defendants
Shoemaker and Jackson, includina but not
limited to:
.
(b) The negligence of Defendant Jackson in
failing to keep his vehicle under control and
failing to exercise reasonable care to avoid
colliding with Defendant Shoemaker's vehicle.
(Paragraph lO(b) of Plaintiffs' Complaint) (emphasis added).
8. Pat R.C.P. No. 1019 requires that a plaintiff must
allege his claim of negligence with factual specificity.
9. The foregoing averments constitute non-specific
general allegations of negligence and fail to comply with the
factual specificity requirements of Rules 1019(a) and 1028(a) (3).
8. The general boilerplate allegations contained in
the aforementioned paragraphs do not provide Mr. Jackson with
notice of the manner in which he negligently failed to exercise
the reasonable care required of an automobile operator.
10. In fact, Plaintiffs use of the phrase "including
but not limited to
. . .
" clearly establishes that Plaintiffs
have not met their burden of setting forth all allegations of
negligence against Mr. Jackson and as such, that phrase must also
be stricken.
3
11. If the allegations set forth above are allowed to
remain in Plaintiffs' Complaint, Plaintiffs may have the
opportunity to amend their Complaint to introduce new theories of
negligence after the applicable statute of limitations has
expired, which would obviously be prejUdicial to Mr. Jackson.
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Barry Jackson respectfully
requests that this Honorable Court issue an Order striking the
phrase "including but not limited to . . ." in Paragraph 10 of
the Complaint of Plaintiffs, Linda R. Wickard and Calvin L.
Wickard, along with Paragraph 10(b) , for failure to comply with
the factual specificity requirements of Pat R.C.P. Nos. l019(a)
and 1028 (a) (3) .
II. Preliminary Objection for Scandalous and Impertinent Matter
and rncludina. Pursuant to Pa. R.C.p. No. 1028Ia)12).
12. The averments contained in Paragraph 1 through 11
inclusive hereof are incorporated by reference herein as if set
forth in their entirety.
13. In Paragraph 8 of their Complaint, Plaintiffs
allege the following:
8. The force of the impact caused defendant
Shoemaker's vehicle to collide with the
driver's side of plaintiff's vehiCle. A copy
of the Pennsylvania State P?llce accident
re~ort is incornorated h~~ein bv refe~~nce
and made a cart hereof ~ng ~tt~h~Q ~s
plaintiffs' E~hibit "A".
(Paragraph 8 of Plaintiffs' Complaint) (emphasis added).
4
14. As alleged by Plaintiffs, attached as Exhibit "A"
to Plaintiffs' Complaint, is a copy of the pennsylvania state
Police Accident Report with regard to the subject incident.
15. Impertinent matter is matter which is irrelevant
to the material issues of the case and which, whether proven or
not, or whether admitted or denied, can have no influence in the
decision on the case.
16. The Pennsylvania state Police Trooper who prepared
the accident report attached to Plaintiffs' Complaint as Exhibit
"A" was not a witness to the motor vehicle accident. Therefore,
the accident report is inadmissible heresay.
16. Accordingly, the Police Accident Report
constitutes impertinent matter and must be stricken from the
Complaint.
WHEREFORE, Defendant, Barry Jackson respectfully
requests that this Honorable Court issue an Order striking any
references in paragraph 8 of Plaintiffs' Complaint to the
5
r,
LINDA R. WICKARD and CALVIN L. : IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
WICKARD, : CUMBERLAND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA
Plaintiffs : CIVIL ACTION _ LAW
V. : No: 98.668
JOHN SHOEMAKER and BARRY E. : JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
JACKSON,
Defendants
NOTICE
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth
in the following pages, you must take action within twenty (20) days after this complaint
and notice are served, by entering a written appearance personally or by an attorney
and filing in writing with the court your defenses or objections to the claims set forth
against you, You are warned that if you fail to do so the case may proceed without you
and a jUdgment may be entered against you by the court without further notice for any
money claimed in the complaint or for any other claim or relief requested by the
plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LAWYER, OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE
THE OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL
HELP.
COURT ADMINISTRATOR
FOURTH FLOOR
CUMBERLAND COUNTY COURTHOUSE
CARLISLE, PA 17013
(717) 240-6100, EXT. 6200
T,r.: il: .....0'"''-' FR
'-... ..., r-, OM RECORD
Iq r"J!mjl)n~' i>irf.~:eO(, I hl'jf( Un!o ."'t In\, "'~d
"n" "/1.":1 (0.1' . . 0).. I, "=-11
o 11.. ; 1\1 "'t.~, (JI 'i.:'J ,.. 'iI!M' Jll'''~(,U'' ,; ~
TI,;s. .:J. J' ~ ..... ..'-~!'" \,/a .:::,j~, {"a.
. _UaY ""~'''I''''''''/~1 19 79
~ L'tl (.t.. ?~I.' . I'"
,/ ,. ....~... '\A./J.4.
PrIJthonorary
. . .. . ...___~U
LINDA II. WICKARD .nd
CALVIN L. WICKARD,
Plaintiffs
: IN THI! COURT OF COMMON PLI!AlI OF
: CUMBEIU.AND COUNTY PENNSYLVANIA
Y.
: CIVIL ACTION. LAW
JOHN SHOEMAKER .nd
BAIIRY E. .lACKSON,
Defendants
: NO. II . III CIVIL TERM
.
.
: JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
.
.
COMPLAINT
NOW come the plaintiffs, by their attorney, Harold S. Irwin, III, Esquire, and file
this complaint against the defendants, representing as follows:
1, The plaintiffs, Linda R. Wickard and Calvin L. Wickard, husband and wife,
are adult individuals residing at 799 Burgners Road, Carlisle, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania, 17013,
2, The defendant, John W, Shoemaker, is an adult individual whose last
known address is Big Spring Terrace, Lot 184, Newville, Cumberland County,
Pennsylvania 17241.
3, The defendant, Barry E. Jackson, is an adult individual whose last known
address is 615 Ml. Rock Road, Newville, Cumberland County, Pennsylvania, 17241.
4, On or about February 5, 1996, Plaintiff Linda Wickard was operating her
1980 Ford Fairmont and was lawfully stopped at a stop sign on the western corner of
the intersection Oak Flat Road and Route 233, near Newville, Pennsylvania,
5. Defendant Shoemaker was operating a 1994 Ford Escort and was
traveling north on 233 approaching the intersection of 233 and Oak Flat Road,
6, Defendant Jackson was operating a 1995 GMC Jimmy and was traveling
south on 233, approaching the intersection of 233 and Oak Flat Road..
7, Defendant Shoemaker failed to yield to oncoming traffic and turned left at
the intersection into the path of Defendant Jackson, resulting in a collision between
defendants' vehicles.
..~,..
~
.~
8. The force of the impact caused defendant Shoemaker's vehicle to collide
with the driver's side of plaintiffs' vehicle. A copy of the Pennsylvania Slate Police
accident report is incorporated herein by reference and made a part hereof and
attached as plaintiffs' Exhibit "A",
COUNT I
LINDA R. WICKARD v. JOHN W. SHOEMAKER and BARRY E. JACKSON
9. The averments of plaintiffs' complaint, paragraphs one through eight
inclusive, are incorporated herein by reference as if fully set forth at length,
10. The accident and resulting losses, injuries and damages were directly
and proximately caused by the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and Jackson,
inClUding but not limited to:
a, the negligence of Defendant Shoemaker in failing to yield to oncoming
traffic and failing to keep his vehicle under control.
b, the negligence of Defendant Jackson in failing to keep his vehicle
under control and failing to exercise reasonable care to avoid colliding with Defendant
Shoemaker's vehicle.
11. As a direct result of negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and Jackson
and the collision as aforesaid, Plaintiff Linda Wickard suffered property damages to her
vehicle requiring it to be totaled,
I
,
I
i
12, As a direct result of the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and
Jackson and the collision as aforesaid, Plaintiff Linda Wickard suffered severe
personal injuries, inClUding a cervical strain with nerve root irritation, a fracture of her
left thumb, injury to her right sternoclavicular joint, soft tissue injury to her right arm,
fibromyalgia and related medical problems,
13, As a direct result of the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and
Jackson, the collision as aforesaid and the personal injuries sustained thereby, Plaintiff
Linda Wickard incurred medical expenses which have exceeded $10,000.00 to date
and which are continuing,
I
I
I
,
L
I,
, ,
} I
14. As a direct result of the negligence of Defendants Shoemaker and
Jackson, the collision as aforesaid and the personal injuries sustained thereby, Plaintiff
Linda Wickard suffered and will continue to suffer physical pain and suffering, mental
anguish, emotional distress and the loss of life's pleasures,
,
"
"
,.
,
I'
,
~
I ~ ..'..,.,
...~ ..
tJ/A
. ,.~' ~, ""1\"r- '," . ~I t'''.".,. ~. ..;~ 1~ ", ' 1'( ~~ fIl,. " '':f,.~ ' . .1'
., .~ ..... ;' O()Ol'62'"" '~'~~I ~~I.', .,': !.,~,. " I
m ':'~~~MONWiA:;H;;';rNNS~i:VAi'A:':
. ........ ..POLlCBACCIDENT:RBPORf'." '~".
" . 1lU00TAILI,BrNOH 'R!~TAI':i:C:I"';" 't,.."
I . Qc:: TION ,\\
20 CO If ...ui..li __ . ).. c~ .
J1, "UN'CIP~I~ ,. ~ '" --,,~
I.~~~~O'~ ~~~
. PRINCIPAL ROADWA Y INFORMA TioN
22 ROUT' NC. OR" t
STAEET NAUI ..- . p
"SPeED · TYP! - 0 l!l'lM:C~S' . ':..1..
LIMIT HIQHWAY l,,:"::CONfROL
INTERSECTING ROAD:
26 ROUI! NC. OR -~----'---;-----:
SlAEOTNA..!"'-" 'L..5J!11s_~,:>" -'-"--
aT 5f1EED ~ ~ ~. TYpe 0 I "CCUG -,
\.11041' .;1 HIOHWA1- _e.!!!.q~.J_. {I" ,i
IF NOT A T INTERSECTION: ;,-";
'" CUCSS SlR!1T OR - ------.'..-
litaMENT MARKEn
iT.OIRECTION N
FRD" SIT! S E
~3 DISTANCE WAS
.,
.,.
'.AlXIOf,rlf
DATE
11. TlMt. '..I' . 11. NUMDlR .s
DAy'_. . ,-!..I.E . .... ...9!:Ji!i!l~
la.' Kl~t;r; Ii. 'INI}lAF.U l~ pnl"'. .."up 0
J.J.... __I L ..._ ' A&:CIDEtn ., .---!:!
II. DCVl"'A....~ ~~! TO II nlMOvED 11. YEHICLE DAMAOE
'ROM TilL j!;!fr4I!' 0 . NONE YPiIT I
UNIT t UNIT a I . L10HT
a . MODeM TE
~. SEVERe
Y~ NO
W
Q~I
j;)CCN~rRUCTlON
'-' O:CNE
W pa. ~~9J~'~~f;'-~"~' ,. ~T" ...-, ::. .':
MeASURED 0 ESTIMATEU 0 --
- -.---
, TRAFfiC PRINCIPAl.. III1CRSECTINO
g~~~~CL [oJ r~J
UNIT a
. .1.:',~ .. ,..,..,. "" .
, .,,.,,,...~ \<:,,;,,'~'~,>!.. ., " '
,,, LLllALL Y Y N 3/, nEa ,,,,...... tJ lil, \it~.
PAR'~D' Cl D PLA!! -!lcoQ 2.'3 Q.~. ___" ,_.I::f.1_
:I'l PA TITI..! OR
OUT,OF,STATEVlN "I~",??;;.t:;7.RO/_
co OWNER
,? _ i'lA"WY E"~~ JACI<!f.OLI __"_
41 OWNER ... '- .' .. .
',_ r' "DORESS tJ~ I\)~C~U_..
43' ~IT'i.lJTAre:
.... -.., ." ~~1~D.~_ dI.f~Yf6~~~._l~(!.~'._ _~':~':.~~~-:"
40 'N~ 1'1 MOOh INO! _ I 'G IUS I
y ...!LO u~~LJ ._'\!1'!.' IY!~'J.. ';,l'.!!:'4.'tY.._.--. ~Y~_~CI... UM.Q.
4i VEHICI..(! / ."ldOl" ~SPECI"" c9 VEttlr.L':
OWNERStllP _.. . !:!!~~ _s.G.. _.--!~USA(\E Q___ oWJ,jf:~__L_
!la TRAVEL _ 8'Ulfl^LIMPACT t'5I)VEHICLE ,... K~THAVEI.. .".~
SPEED _~.._ _ p.Q!llL_L_ __' ~ill!.!!!.-0 sPE..EJ?____7_~..
!is g~~g~ION I ~~~~lgl~~1T I 1,~~J~:~V:eRNCE'- SS ~~~~~ION J
q 7 ~I Sl~ll; !If!, ()f1IVER , ,~:- 'j1~rF.
" ~ _.€IJ...... _. !!.u~'!!.'L.2~.Q!:I!I..'"f'Cla_._..n _..L~_-j'
~d unlvER
fA) , <')/tJI"MAKEi?- __._..._. _~~L-i3/!~,E.v.<i.?..~e_;L)).~^",---. .....--,..
!l~VnIVER I
AOORESS ',), :7:'~",,"'u~c,.{.aT dJ~., ..~!!PAESS '-'l$'_~!_.:i'~5.,L. --.-.--.. ----,1
ea. CITY. STATE GO ';11'(, STATE I
...:ZIPCOOE n.DAT'CF /ft., ':>"j 17_~~"pi'."f." '.,-:' Ai ~::'CCDE .f{{f,;'K!'a~r,~...!:..(,:;'Irt;'Phl\oiC--;:---:-~'l
BIRTH a, 1/1' 7,7'7;:,' )$(\) IV1 l1ln1ll './t.d:!/",J~ 1{7'"7J"~" 1C],J I
Y : H" g~~_.___ 60 ~A~V:":I..._.._ ._. . .~ ~'tr.~~ lr,~ ~~'.~t~'._ .. J.~_~';;' -..-. ..... ...-..... ...-..:
:. :::::: _ __._ _ :: ~;.:::;-_. ___ ,___ __._ .n....__ ...._.. .........--..,-\
ADDRESS ADlmess , -..- -.. --... .
19 CITY. STATE -"- -- -' - ..... '. . ... .-- . tIq' CiiY. i1ffiE- ,. -, "'--'-'-1
7O~::TO~E 1CC'-'---"--'..fPUC; ....- ... ;o~~~;.c~~.. -'-~IC:C"'---'_.--' ~~uc;.....u._..,---i
2 ~~F1~. J g~~r;~;'-'- ....- .. . . "'-IlVwO' . . ,i)~~;\,~~-' "--}jh~r~~~----- "'1'7i?t\\';n -----~....\
.. ~Lg 0 :;:.~~'~~~~S __ ~= nn~tr~~'~ZN~'b ",~_~L~t_.-~.'_f.::;~~~~~~:"'=~- 77 ~tfS~_e5.~~~l
"~SlI/921 168951 7 PAr.E .L_ CE~mn rOR IIIUIIWAVR^1'E'lY
Nl8I
I
'1
I.
, I
I
I
!
!-...
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
I hereby certify that I am this day serving a copy of the foregoing document upon
the person(s) and in the manner indicated below, which service satisfies the
requirements of the Pennsylvania Rules for Civil Procedure, my depositing a copy of
the same in the United States Mail, Carlisle, Pennsylvania, First Class Mail, postage
prepaid, as follows:
JOHN SHOEMAKER c/o
Douglas B. Marcello, Esquire
305 North Front Street
6th Floor
P,O, Box 999
Harrisburg PA, 17108-0999
BARRY E, JACKSON c/o
Barry A. Kronthal, Esquire
Reynolds & Havas
101 Pine Street
P,O. Box 932
Harrisburg, PA 17108
DATE: January 28.199'
LAW OFFICES OF HAROLD S. IRWIN, III
By: ~~Z-
JOHN J. BARANSKI, JR.
35 EAST HIGH STREET
CARLISLE, PA 17013
(717) 241-2312
Attorney for Plaintiffs
:',
l,
.
() \!:l 0
c: '-0 .,.,
:::". -., =jJ .
""tl{l; P1
nlrn ;;0 fli ::g
1:~;;? ~3~
(:~I ";-.. -.l
-"..a::' (.)
C:..CJ ~ :'J~J
2':: :.-) (~ :tl
./-::() -. J,,~
,..
~""l':: ~ ~
Z ~ ~
3 N
,
,',
..
, . ~ " '.
TIIOMAS, maMAS & tiMER W'
OnuHI.n U. MtUcellu, [!I{lulrl'
J()5 Nurth Fronl Slrel't
1',0. Un" 999
fj,ml.hurl\. PA 17101J.l1999
(717) 255,7230
(717) 237.7105 (f,,,1
LINDA R. WICKARD and
CALVIN L. WICKARD
Plaintiffs
vs
JOHN SHOEMAKER and
BARRY E. JACKSON
Defendants
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND CO, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NO: 98-668
JURY TRIAL DEMANDED
CERTIFICATE OF SERVICE
AND NOW, this 20th day of April, 1999, I, BARBARA A, ONORATO, a Legal Assistant at the
law firm of Thomas, Thomas & Hafer, LLP hereby certify that I sent a true and correct copy of the
foregoing Interrogatories Directed to Plaintiffs by placing a copy of the same in the United States
Mail, first class, postage prepaid, to the following:
Harold Irwin, Esquire
35 E, High Street
Carlisle, PA 17013
Barry Kronthal, Esquire
REYNOLDS & HAVAS
101 Pine Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
Date: April 20, 1999
~O.~
Barbara A. Onorato
Legal Assistant
,J~i~~t(~iij'x~i~t~l~;:,~:~:;ft{":,;,::':~'i'.'.;," '.' '. .
,....
8"'0""
~ -:', '. . '.',~:: : ~_:, ~. ,
'M' ~
}/
:r;l~ "
':lj,~,' -.'
~~{~.'
:!~1"~1
'''''i@
....\....;/<;i,;.::.,:,]P',-{"S'~!;i,;:,.iWi~i1{~'~tm~\~:~i;$~*;~:;~f&~ty>>~~t~t,~i
"
('") I.D .~
So; I.D
"'U f1j "- ....
r:= -,-
ri';:!J
~YJ :c: -"hi
I
-,::<;: 0:> 236
cn';7
~i5 -I_r-
~ 25:i:l
~(") ::c -.0
::;8 lO orn
.. -I
~ .:=> ~
~--:'_.'_"-..,.,;.,",.