HomeMy WebLinkAbout98-00684
/
~
N
.
~
~
""
,~
"
~
"
/
),
(
~
~
-
.
.
.:1
~
~
~
~
.
~
~
)[N THE COURT OlP COMLlVllON JPJLEAS OF
CUMl)I~ERJLAND COUl'\!,']['Y', PENNSYLV AN][A
CHARLES M. FOGARTY.
PI4intiff
CIVlL ACTION - LAW
NO. 9 f- bPi G'IJ\ l ~rLi>1
Vs.
GAL~~Y, INC..
Defen,14nt
NOTICE
YOU HAVE BEEN SUED IN COURT. If you wish to .Iefend 4g4inst thc c14ims
set forth in thc following p4ges, you must t4kc 4ction within twenty (20) d4Ys 4ftcr this
Compl4int 4nd Notice 4re scrved, ~y entering 4 wri((en 41'I,e4r4nce l,crsOll4l1y or ~y 4((orncy 4nd
filing in writing with the Cou~your dcfenscs or o~jcctions to thc claims sct ford, 4gainst you.
You 4re w4rm,,1 that if you f4il to ,10 so thc "asc m4Y l,ro"ee.1 without you and 4 ju.lgment m4Y
~c cntered 4g4inst you ~y thc Courl without furlhcr notice for 4ny moncy c14imcd in the Pctition
or for 4ny othcr c14im or rclicf ""'Jucstc.! ~y Pc(itioncr, You 1l14Y losc money or property or other
rights import4nt to you,
YOU SHOULD T A1Iill THIS PAPER TO YOUR LA WYER AT ONCE. IF YOU
DO NOT HAVE A LA VVYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR
TELEPHONE nm OFFICE SET FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE
YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
COURT ADMINiSTRATOR
Third Floor
CUIl1~crl4nd County Court Housc
Carlisle, PA 17013
Telephonc: (717) 240-6200
][N Tlf-j[g COURT OJ[? COM]o/1l0N PJL][~:AS OF
OUMBER1LANJ(J> COONT'Y, lPENNSYLV AN1[A
CHARLES 1\1. FOGARTY,
Plainliff
crvu.. ACTION - LAW
NO, 9'- t,Rtf' e"uc'(~'~
v.,
GALA.."\.T, INC.,
Defellllanl
COMlJeJLA][NT'
1. Plainliff iH an a,lult illllividual reHiding at 6Jl7 GutHhall Road, Boiling SI.ringH,
Cumberland Counl)', PennH).I,'ania Jl7007.
2, Defmulanl iH a PCllIlHyl,'ania corporalion will, rrgiHlcl'l,.) officeH at POHI Officc Box
693, Ncw Cumberland, Cumberland Counl)', PcnnHyl,'ania 17070.
3. On or ahout Fchcua!'). Jl, [997, Plainliff waH re'lucHte<! to I.crform litlc rCHcarch
for thc Dcfcndanl upon thc l.remiseH 10calc,1 in Middlc Paxton TownHhil" Daul.hin County,
Pcnnsyh.ania, identified as Daul.hin Counly TAX 1\1al'l.ing Parcel No. .;I3-000.08Jl.
.;I, TI", nalure of Ihc work involved was 10 dclcrminc Ihc accuracy of informalion
concerning A 8UM"CY of t.he suhjC(:t .>>rCluisC8 through VArious ri"hiR of A(ljoininr. l"lIlIl OWU"I'R.
5. On or ahoul AI.ril 3, 1997, Plainliff coml.lcl.,.( thc work and l.rovi,I",1 all
information to the D"fmlllant. '1'1", total (:OHt of t1", work JI"rforme<l was $Jl,36.;1.75,
h. Aflc'" AllI.il 3, 1")")7, till' )).,fl'1I11AIII "I"IUI'HIc..1 PIAillciff III """,( with till'
D.,f",,,IAIIC AII,I till' D"f,'IIIIAIIC'H HUI""')'m' tll ,'xl,l"ill till' titl,. ""H"AI."h AII.IIIII MAY H, 11)97, thAt
1II""lillg WAH Clllllpl"Ic,,1 Al till' .'xp"nH" of all a.I,litiollal IWII (2) hOlll'H of till,,' I'm' All AII,litiollAI
chAl'g" of $120,00. D"fm"IAllt Ht"t,,"1 Aft"" thiH lII"ding d", wOI'I, waH "llIl1!lI."h"IIHiv" AIIII thAt
A d",,,k for d", wlll.k woulll 1,,, forwal'.I".1.
7, On or "hout JUII" 16, 1997, d,,, D"f,,".lant paill to the Plaintiff the sum of
$500,00 alld Defendant i11lli"ated to the Plaintiff that the halan"e of the hilling would he paid
when the ullllerlyillg tide issues we,'e ,'esolve.1.
8, The work l.erform,,"1 hy the Plaintiff for the Def.",dant was not conting,,"t in any
way and the Plaintiff is therefore owed the total sum of $984,75, together with interest through
June 16, 1997,
9, Plaintiff made due demand upon the Defendant, howev"l', the Defendant has failed
'W]!-1ER1EFORE, d,,, Plaintiff dema11lls judglllent against the Defellllant fOl' the total
j
\
I
t
and refused to pay the halallce owed,
amount of $98-1.75, together with interest from June 16, 1
Rollel't G. Ra ehad" ESlluil'e
1. D, #19255
107 Locust Sheet
J-JarrishUl.g, PA 17101
(717) 234.6655
,.
1Yl,,'if). 11.111 lilt' Hll1l"IlI,'nlH 1lI1I,1.. in IhiH COlll1.lllinl Ill'" Il'u" 1111I1 ,,,,,.,...d, 11IJul""HIII.ul
11.111 fllIH" HIIII"m..nIH lu,,'..;n II"" mllll.. Huhjed 10 II... 1''''lIIlIi''H of 18 PII,C,S. 1} -19().1,...llIlinl\ 10
unH"'...'n flllHificlllion 10 lIutlull'iti"H,
Dille.
/O//Cl/97
/ /
~~-
Chll,.]"H N1. FOglIl'ty?
j/
'.
. ,
f:j~
~~
~ ~
~ ~
.f
Bb
% s:p-
. .
: r~ -~
~r .
;0 :
~ :~'" i
0:' :
~zi ~~
. ,-j
)>~o~
;0", ~
~\ '
"'6Q.
~ ~ ~
I(?
~ 0 ~
() () ()
I
~C/)r.
j~
r-. ....:1 .-:1
;- (:) -i'1
.."
~. 1
-1"
r,,: .
.'-J
"}3
(:", ~ (:)
J.'l
'-'-' ."\ ~~l
-ol J
_ ~jlll
...;1
....... ') :~:?
(..) -....
e
..",
. .
'. .
~.; ~
~;cs; :
~~z:
;g ~ -l :W
0: ;0;'
-l: IT':
I:~Z:
?~..' ~:
o >;__
I '-,
), m'D
~ .....
~: ~
t:
\~ :
I,
V
. ...
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL DIVISION
CHARLES M, FOGARTY,
VS,
NO. 98-684 CIVIL TERM
GALAXY, INC.
PRAECIPE FOR ENTRY OF JUDGEMENT
To: Prothonotary
Kindly enter judgement in favor of Plaintiff and against Defendant in the
amount of $984,75, in accordance with the Award of ArbitratoIE' entered March
10, 1999.
Dated: April 12, 1999
/J~]
/ '
t.f d- ~ yfv/'
{,(f/(~, .. ~ y(
Robert G. Radebach, Esquire
1.D. # 19255
107 Locust Street
Harrisburg, PA 17101
(717) 234-6655
Attorney for Plaintiff
'.
.
C") \D 0
~ t ~ ~ ~; \,Q "Tl
,. "" "J
~ "('r.t.! -" ~~; :n
n-lrn :;:t'
~ ;-':::.:I, r-
.,'\?
i;j~; I" ;'1')-
~ ",
~ ~ \ r;: ~) ~(J
-0 " :II
~ ~; ("'J ::<. i ')-'
....(')
~ ) ~::; (:-~ ~ "-irn
~ .. I~- ~::I
~ .... 0 ?iJ
~ 'I' =<
~
"
r:"4r(,d: c--;r 1ft, /-"'t!J~;";r,l;-y
...., , .
/ 7~i,,;I,.,q
I~.
6",(L4XV /A/t".
,
iJrI:;,;,I..., t
We do solemnly swear (or affirm)
the Constitution of the United States
wealth and that we will discharge the
)
)
1
)
)~
)
)
In The Court of Cornmon Pleas of
Cumberland County, ?enns~lvania
9,)" r;.o -
~lo. .. 6.'1'1 ,d/~l- 19
OATH
./
that we will supporc, obey and defend
and the Constitutioo of this Common-
ducies of ur office ith fidelity.
~, .' / ~' . ~t2tJt.t
a r.nan
~\A~.W~
,
11.;/a-k /1) IlIAt'/J-'
AWAPJJ!
We, the undersigned arbitrators, having been duly appointed and sworn
(or affirmed), make the following award:
(Note: If damages for delay are awarqed, they shall be
separately stated.)
0{" Ttt:. p7k,-r:h17
*'11 m,:c/.-IY ~ ....1iI,"'. d'"
- yJt, /"/t-.., ~ 6f.d .:-...i::H....:.Y /~
~t,j"rj- 6?ua*''''...G.C....
t!'.k...-.
7f'. ,tUJ
;..~>t-...,.~.
applicable. )
Arbitrator, dissents. (Insert name i:
d~~e jJ .ia6lt~
uL- . -. .I ().... ~hair:nan
~ r,~C). Mtf(h..,
J o~u.:>
-/fh,j; /I) 4t~r"'JIJ-' / ,
'(HJ .)5.. ,.,.,
NOTICS OF ENTRY OF AWAPJJ
, 19..i2...., at I~, P. .li., the above
nocice thereof given by mail co the
Date of Hearing:
..:S- J:: 'i' ,9
,3'-?- Yj'
Date of Award:
Now, the /0 ~ day of \.../~L(..,,-,-,.......
award was entered upon che dockec and
parties or their attorneys_
Arbitrators' compensation to be
paid upon appeal:
$ ,)to,a;)
By:
(1 _. /J;{;,
" 'Q'" K' b''J'. ?tb';~~notary
I;', C ~i~~&':'
I Deputy
C")
c:
::~:
Uf"o,
D.I/;
..-:.. -",
~~--:C:
~~:..
~_lr.)
'-,.
].~ {D'
'3
'-D
l()
:1::
.~';..
" "
".
o
"n
:.~!
.i:.:J
,--
ro:,rn
,,0
-, .
.=J ~?
f ";:r!
::':,~ )
,-, II
'-.
:.:.:1
,-
:.1J
-<
<::I
~?
",.
r;:}
--
l.
I
~
\
..
""
t:\
r.
t.
~
f
i.:J b-'1'1 /!ku:",t (lO'
CHARLES M, FOGARTY,
Plaint if f
IN 'fHE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v,
NO. 98-684
CIVIL
GALAXY, INC"
Defendant
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
NOTICE OF HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the undersigned Board of
Arbitrators, appointed by the Court in the above-captioned
case, will sit for the purpose of their appointment at the Law
Offices of Marlin R. McCaleb, 219 East Main Street,
Mechanicsburg, Pennsylvania, on Monday, March 8, 1999, at 9:30
o'clock A,M" at which time and place you may appear with your
respective clients and your witnesses to present such evidence
and testimony as you may have in the case,
Keirsten W. Davidson, Esquire
Mark W. Allshouse, Esquire
BY:~~
Marlin R. McCaleb, Chairman
Board of Arbitrators
February 8, 1999
TO: Robert G. Radebach, Esquire
(Attorney for Plaintiff)
Thomas p, Gacki, Esquire
(Attorney for Defendant)
LAW ClITICI:~;
MARLIN It Mc:CAtI!U
Richard J. pierce
Court Administrator
"
"
,
'.
vs.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
CHARLES M. FOGARTY,
plaintiff
GALAXY, INC.,
NO. 98-684
Defendant
NOTICE OF HEARING BY BOARD OF ARBITRATORS
You are hereby notified that the undersigned Arbitrators
appointed by the Court in the above-captioned matter will meet
for the purpose of their appointment on Wednesda~, January 27,
1999 at 10:00 a.m. in the Hearing Room, 2" . floor, Old
Cumberland county Courthouse, carlisle, Pennsylvania 'at which
time and place you may appear and be heard togeth with your
witne.,e, and coun,el if you '0 de,i e. ~
Murrel R. Walters, III, Esqu re, Cha~rman
Keirsten (Walsh) Davidson, Esquire
Scott D. Moore, Esq./Mark Allshouse, Esq.
By:
cc: Robert G. Radebach, Esquire
Attorney for Plaintiff
Thomas P. Gacki, Esquire
Attorney for Defendant
Court Administrator
Cumberland county Courthouse
Carlisle, PA 17013
"
,
,
I
I" :' ,C,;
,~,~.
/)11, '.'
~y
-0 \)
It r-
>- -l:;\ 0
o. ~ QJ
~ c"': \) IX,
1-
UJQ cO =:1...- ~ ":t-
0-'- O~
J:1:P .- C)~~ \'
(3f~' .~ ..-)-"
I C; "'J >>! "'-3 '>-.. -.It
an,. ;;0(1)
LLJC. N ..)% r--.. -D.
_11.1 U U.:;;. ~ ~
u:: '1' tl.J ! I.ltj] '\(')
f.: a (Qu- I<') Cl
u.. -" :tt: ~
co :~
0 C'l U
>- t-. ~
9? lr.
l-" .<:
UIQ c;, f~~~I:
0(: :c
p.:~ C- . ::.:
'..!-I
0(-:. ("'J >'(/1
6~ C'J ::1 ~;:
~L1' W ~t ifj
u:: -..
r- l..LJ j;.io...
C;, "'=
lJ.. co :'1
0 a' U
CHARLES M. FOGARTY
Plaintill'
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS
CUMBERLAND COUNTY,
!'ENNSYL VANIA
v.
CIVIL ACTlON--LAW
GALAXY, INC.
Defendant
FILE NO. 98-684
NOTICE TO DEFEND AND CLAIM RIGHTS
You have been sued in court. If you wish to defend against the claims set forth in the
following pages, you must take action within twcnty (20) daysafter this Complaint and Notice arc
served, by entering a written appearance personally or by attomcy and filing in writing with the Court
your defenses or objections to the claims set forth against you. You are warned that if you fail to do
so, the case may proceed without you and a judgment may be entered against you by the Court
without further notice for any money claimed in the Complaint or for any other claim or relief
requested by the Plaintiff. You may lose money or property or other rights important to you.
YOU SHOULD TAKE THIS PAPER TO YOUR LAWYER AT ONCE. IF YOU DO NOT
HAVE A LAWYER OR CANNOT AFFORD ONE, GO TO OR TELEPHONE THE OFFICE SET
FORTH BELOW TO FIND OUT WHERE YOU CAN GET LEGAL HELP.
Lawyer Referral Service of the
Cumbcrland County Bar Association
2 Libcrty Place
Carlisle, PA
717-249-3166
,~
A VISO
USTED HA SIDO DEMANDADOIA EN CORTE. Si usted desea defenderse de las
demandas que se present an mas adelante en las siguientes paginns, debe tomar accion dentro de los
proximos veinte (20) dias despues dc la nOlificacion dc est a Demandn y A viso radicando
personal mente 0 por medio de un nbogado una compareccncia escrita y radicando en In Corte por
., ....., .-,'
"
.. . \ -..~
II. Thcre was ncver any agrcemcnt betwccn the parties lor payment for Plaintill's scrvices;
Dcfcndant pcrformcd thc work withollt cven disclIssing the work with Delcndant.
12. Delcndant can thcrcfore be liablc to Plaintil1' for, at most, thc normal and customary
charge for work of thc type performcd.
13. The work performed was a titlc search, the customary charge for which does not exceed
$145.00.
14. Defendant paid the $500.00 under pressurc from PlaintitTand in an etTort to avoid a
dispute, and not as a reflection of the true value of the services I cndered.
15. Defendant is therefore entitled to a refund of$355.00 from PlaintitT.
WHEREFORE, Defcndant dcmands judgment against PlaintitT for $355.00, together with
interest and costs.
Respectfully Submitted,
3;1 )-/q~
~~~~
Thomas P. Gacki
Atty. \.D. #44864
4775 Linglestown Road, Suite 200
Harrisburg, P A 17112
(717) 671-1958
ATTORNEY FOR DEFENDANT
!
,
;/'
I'i.
1 '::;
.,
VERI FICA nON
DATE: 10..-15'- "J/?
h/ll-
I verilY that the statements made in the foregoing document are true and correct to the best of
. . .
my knowledge, information, and belief. I understand that false statements herein are made subject
to the penalties of 18 Pa.C.S. Section 4904, relating to unsworn falsifications to authorities.
{
(
.
;;
"
~
.;
.,
:1-
!;
{
',':
.~.
][N THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYL V ANKA
CML DMSXON
CHARLES M. FOGARTY,
VS.
9f'
NO. fW-684 CIVIL TERM
GALAXY, INC.
REPLY
10, No ..nswel' is necessary to this ..verment.
11. Denied, On the cont.....ry, Defendant requested that Plaintiff I.reform the
services ..nd ..fter tile work was completed the Defend..nt ..greed to I,ay for nil of tho
work which w..s I,reformed. Stnct proof of the ..vermont is hereby dcm..ndo.i.
12. Denied. On the contrary, The scope of the work involved relluired Ii
suhstantial ..mount of l'ese..rch to ..nswer tide lluestions of the l4Iuls own ell hy
Defenclllnt wllicll wel'e die Hubiee( of die (ide work. Tile hilling whioh iH (he Huhiec( uf
(his lIe(iou WIlS Il nurllllllllllCll'ClIsunllble ohllrge for dle edenHive nllture of the WOl,k.
Strie( proof of the IIvel'lIIent is llercb,. delllllnded.
13. Denied, On tile oontrlll7, the tide resell1'Oll work Ilreformed I,y Plaintiff
Ilt DefeJllbnt's recluest WIlS subsfautillUy more work thlln IIn ordUlllI7 IlbstTlld of tide.
Striot proof of the averment is hereby demanded.
14, Denied, On dle contrlll7. Plaintiff avers that Defend4Ut agreed to pay the
toiallllUount of Plllintiff s bill without question. Plllintiff further avers that Ilt no time
did the Plaintiff subied the DefencLw.t to 4Uy pressure, unclue intel'fel'enoe, 01' dispute
as to the edent, necessity. 01' value of the services rendered, Strict proof of the
Ilvel'D1ent is hereby deJllanded,
15. Denied. On the oontrlll7, Plaintiff avers that DefencLw.t owes the Lal4Uoe
of the Lill as prayed fOl' in tile Complaint, Striot proof of the avel'lUent is hereLy
delUanded.
( ',J.' I.~
:.:0 411
."~ "'.
." ' .~ ',.i~
; l: ,-
,,1\
1'...) ,0
U', , .' tL)
.,..1 ':"~ :\,j
~ (.)
( , :.:~ cjrn
, I ,.1
-"
." :0
....1
-: 1:;J '-<;
I
"
,
,
......
~ ."
0 ,= 0
<c,.
~~") .... .."
-~ ."
" C~
'~J :7'> 0;:0
~.'..I '''''(1.;
N 00
or: ..,,~
.... (JJ<
-C =rn
=>: mO
u> ;:0
nl 'c.C .."
,=> ~
'~
:",
.'
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, lPENNSYJL VANIA
CHARLES M. FOGARTY,
Plaintiff
CIVIL ACfION - LAW
NO. 98-684 CIVIL TERM
v.,
GAL~'\."Y, INC.,
Defendant
... ......
.-.. ,- .
-.... ....... ".. ...... ... """
PlRAIEC[PE TO lREnNST A TIE COMPLAlINT
To the Prothonotary I
Kindly reinstate the complaint in the action ahove captioned.
.. .-.._... .~.._....._.__.
.... ...
lR crt G.lRadchach
lOatedl Septemher 30, R 998
IN T:I-:m: COURT OF C01\1Uo/j(ON PIL"EAS OF
CUMmKRLAND COUNTY, j[J>ENNSYJL V ANJ[A
CHARLES M. FOGARTY,
Plain(iff
CIVIL ACTION - LAW
v..
GALAXY, INC"
NO, 98-684 CIVIL TERM
DcfclUlan(
1'0 the Prothonotary:
][jndly rcinstate thc complaint in thc action above captioned.
R.obert G. lRadebach
lDated March 1L 7, 11998
\G)
0 _0 ~
c 0)
;:04' ::T. ~~
'T3f.ij :,:.
ml" :;0
Z:.r)
;;.::r- jl
(j)~"'''' \.0
~7. 0
....0 :E! '7t
~" 2~
>8 ~ ~
~ N ~
CHARLES M. FOGARTY,
Plaintiff
v,
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
GALAXY, INC"
Civil Action - Law
Defendant
No,: 98-684
AND NOW,
1-
this L
ORDER
D. Moore, Esquire as an arbitrator in the above-captioned matter.
ORDERED that Mark W. Allshouse, Esquire is substituted for Scott
day of January, 1999, it is hereby
J.
n ,0 0
f: v::l '"
'- '-J
"'r:! 00. -.1..."
nl.~'_1 .-." ,'I~
:;-:~::I -~
%C' N '::~6
(n.,-: ,';
-< ,. :-.-1(. .
r::u ~ -~:~-J
:;.::("" ~~(~
:~ ) Om
."CI ~~
.>c: '='
/.- :::> ~
=3. (~ -<.
IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
CHARLES M. FOGARTY,
VS.
NO. 98-684 CIVIL TERM
GALAXY, INC.
CIVIL DIVISION
PRAECIPE TO SATISFY JUDGMENT
To the Prothonotary
Kindly mark the judgment in the above captioned action satisfied and
discontinued. /d_
Dated: June 28, 1999
Robert G. Rade ach
AUorney for Plaintiff
912 NorLh River Road
Halifax, P A 17032
CHARLES M. FOGARTY
: IN THE COURT OF COMMON PLEAS OF
: CUMBERLAND COUNTY, PENNSYLVANIA
v.
: NO. 98-684 CIVIL
GALAXY, INC.
IN RE: APPOINTMENT OF ARBITRATORS
ORDER OF COURT
AND NOW, January 26, 1999, the appointment of Murrel Walters III,
Esquire, as chairman of the arbitration panel in the above-captioned case is
vacated, and Marlin McCaleb, Esquire, is appointed in his stead.
By the Court,
P.J.
Marlin McCaleb, Esquire - C!..~ ~t. 1/:1.3/91.
Chairman.><l.'P'
Court Administrator
:ss9
Ii
II
I, ..;;'/'
,...
,-:.
~.~.
";.,:,.
...~
(,..
~.
';;;1)-;1;
\.. ~
,_J ..~
~")~~
;',01"
'" \\,..
,;'?\.-:''':
-~.~
"()
c.f'
c.
'I"~
I
I....
Id'
~!...'" .
;
~
.;l
~
t(.
....\4
y."""
,-..
\l.-'
.~".
_r.C,
\.1_'1'.
".:")\<
~'
(.:.
..(\.
::AC'. .
c....\.-.
\-
\_t..
o
--
-c:.